Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Amazed and Perplexed

Amazed and Perplexed artwork

Does God Allow Sin in Certain Circumstances? (1 Samuel 19:9-16)

Nov 6, 202243 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Send us Fan Mail 𝐃𝐨𝐞𝐬 𝐆𝐨𝐝 𝐀𝐥𝐥𝐨𝐰 𝐒𝐢𝐧 𝐢𝐧 𝐂𝐞𝐫𝐭𝐚𝐢𝐧 𝐂𝐢𝐫𝐜𝐮𝐦𝐬𝐭𝐚𝐧𝐜𝐞𝐬? (𝟏 𝐒𝐚𝐦𝐮𝐞𝐥 𝟏𝟗:𝟗-𝟏𝟔) Today we answer a listener-submitted question about whether God is okay with sin in certain circumstances. Thank you to Johnathan Odle for the question! Website: http://amazedandperplexed.com Contact: amazedandperplexed@gmail.com Music by: Heavensense https://soundcloud.com/hvnsen

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_02Hello, my name is Connor, and I'm Jason, and you are listening to the Amaze and Perplex Podcast. So we all have seen a TV show or movie where somebody needs to sneak out or somebody needs to go, a kid needs to sneak out, a teenager needs to sneak out, and so they leave like a basketball under their under their uh blankets on their pillow with like some I don't know uh with pillows making it look like a body.

SPEAKER_02Right. Uh has there ever been a situation for you, Jason, where you did something to that effect where you tried to deceive somebody to pretend like you were sleeping or that you uh were at when you were actually somewhere else or doing something else?

SPEAKER_00Hmm. I cannot remember doing the fake like the Ferris Bueller or if you're from a different generation, like Escape from Alcatraz, because it's the same thing there, you know, more technology with Ferris, where you leave a body in a bed, um, or a fake body. I have both true stories. Right. Yeah. That's true. We'll talk later. But anyway, the um the dynamic of sneaking out, I I have done, and I I just bring it up I because my parents, we moved into this house before I was a teenager, right when I was a teenager.

SPEAKER_00Uh and I don't think they intended to do this, but the window right in front of my room were these huge bushes that were man, if you did not make that jump, you were hurting. I mean, it would scratch your skin up. And uh, and I think I only tried it one time, and man, even with a good leap, it caught like the back of my legs. Man, it scratched them up. Um, and so it was a natural deterrent. So, to parents out there, I would say you need to do some planting uh of uh very gruesome things for the very reason of what we're talking about.

SPEAKER_02I want to teach uh I want to teach a uh a parenting class which is all just preventive shrubbery. Yeah, I think that's right. Don't pay attention to your children. As long as you plant the right, plant the right foliage, you will be okay. That's right. So I I do you do you have a story? I I do have a semi kind of similar story. Um and it is uh so I don't know about you, but I assume a good portion of our listenership struggles with the phenomenon of having their phone before they go to bed. Um are you do you have a good habit or practice around that, like like looking at your phone before you go to bed, like putting up I have a bad practice.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, I have a horrible practice, and I've tried at different points, like leave my phone in a different room, but then I always have my justifications, and eventually it just always it never works out in the end. So for me, um, I remember this started at a very early age for me, like maybe around like eight years old. Um and we did not have cell phones back then, or I did not have a cell phone back then. Um, but what I did have was a portable DVD player, and I was a massive nerd, Jason. And um, I mean, like when I say massive nerd, like my whole personality was Harry Potter. Uh, and that was just that was who Connor Bryant was. Uh, and so I got the uh fourth uh the Gobble to Fire movie, um, and my my family got it, and I stole it from our family DVD uh tower thing, which is so funny, you don't see those nowadays.

SPEAKER_02Everyone, everyone used to have a DVD tower. That's right. You know, you used to judge that was the first thing I looked at when people when I went to people's houses, how big their DVD towers were, and and I would compare my family and oh, we're better off than you. We have we have Ferris Bueller, uh, you know, special edition with commentary from now. I'm just kidding. Um so I but like I stole it from them and I saw my brother's portable DVD player and I would take it up to my room. And before this, I have no recollection of ever fighting sleep or ever trying to like ever staying up and looking at screen. Um, but for several nights in a row, I'm like ninth grade, not ninth grade, I'm probably like nine years old, like in fourth grade.

SPEAKER_02I am staying up for like nights on end, re-watching this movie over and over again, just because I have to stare at the screen. And I have done that a thousand times since. Um, but it's so funny for me. I have this pivotal moment in my life where I remember I had really good sleep habits, I didn't do this horrible thing, and I have pretty much done it every night since then, unless I'm just completely exhausted and there's no cell phone reception wherever I happen to be.

SPEAKER_00So that that's my story. So the reason uh we started with sharing those stories about our odd sleeping habits or not sleeping habits uh is because we're gonna be referencing a story in the Old Testament today that that kind of is the climac point uh of that story. The text we're focusing on today is in response to a question from Jonathan Odal. Uh Jonathan is a uh former student of mine and uh a guy that I I love that guy. Uh so he's asking about uh an event that occurred in 1 Samuel chapter 19.

unknownUh-huh.

SPEAKER_00Uh and so we want to process that today. We're gonna uh kind of shift it in this way. We will process what amazes us and what perplexes us. And then after that, if there's anything that we feel is left over about his question, we'll come back and uh and address that. Uh but context here is David is in Saul's life. Uh we're in again first first Samuel uh 19, and we're gonna begin in verse nine. And Saul has already felt the the temptation and the sense of competition with David, uh, but something pivotal happens in verse nine.

SPEAKER_00It says, But an evil spirit from the Lord came on Saul as he was sitting in his house with his spear in his hand. While David was playing the lyre, Saul tried to pin him to the wall with his spear, but David eluded him as Saul drove the spear into the wall. That night David made good his escape. Saul sent men to David's house to watch it and to kill him in the morning, but Michael, David's wife, warned him, If you don't run for your life tonight, tomorrow you'll be killed. So Michael let David down through a window, and he fled and escaped. Then Michael took an idol and laid it on the bed, covered it, covering it with a garment, and putting some goat's hair at the head.

SPEAKER_00When Saul sent them in to capture David, Michael said, He is ill. Then Saul sent the men back to see David and told them, Bring him up to me in his bed, so that I may kill him. But when the men entered, there was the idol in the bed, and at the head was the same goat's hair. So the question that we're processing today from you know our listener is uh stated this way David's wife puts an idol in David's bed and then lies to the guards, telling them that David is sick, so that David won't be killed. This is no small idol. It is big enough that the guards thought it was David.

SPEAKER_00Why did God allow or not condemn David for having a household idol, or Michael for lying? Uh and then that raises a question, too, that's similar in the next chapter, Jonathan and David make a plan to lie to Saul in order to save David again, and this was clearly a premeditated lie. And so the question is, why is this not corrected or even why does it not even come up this idea? And I think we could find this in multiple places clearly.

SPEAKER_02And our listener will say that later on, you know, it seems that God allows sin. He this is how our listener would phrase it. Uh God allows sin in certain situations but not others, um, and was very kind and would love to hear our thoughts on that. And so that is a very interesting jumping off place of there are times, right, where God or a prophet or Jesus or somebody will say what you're doing is bad, stop it. And there are other times where it's like, man, there is remarkable silence on this. Um, and so how do you process um especially something like this? This seems to, you know, this is a big deal.

SPEAKER_02Because I think when the when I'd ever when I'd read it, maybe the last time I read it, I didn't pick up on on how big a deal um the fact that it is an idol uh is and what that says about uh Saul's household and what that says about even David. Um and so how do you process when there's not this uh there when how do you process when it seems like there should how do you process when it seems like God should be jumping into the story here to correct, but it doesn't happen.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, that's that's really good. I was hoping you go first so I'd have an answer. You told me you told me you had an answer.

SPEAKER_02I wasn't gonna I wasn't gonna hear it until we recorded.

SPEAKER_00That's right. Yeah, I was joking, I think. But let's let's say I did have an answer. What would that sound like? So okay, so the way I think about this is number one, here's my bias. My bias is God is good, my bias is God is love, uh, and everything that love is. So that would include being just and merciful, which in human hands that feels almost contradictory. How are you just and merciful? And so there's a complexity there that even when I try to be unbiased, I still steer. So I'm just owning that that I'm always looking for how's God the good guy in the story, you know?

SPEAKER_00Um, so I'm I'm open to criticism uh regarding that. Um so the the other part is if if I'm talking to someone and I realize they are much more intelligent than I am, and this happens sadly frequently, um, I I it doesn't mean I have to drop out of the conversation, and especially if it's in some area that they have enormous education or experience in, and I have very little, I will tend to defer. Yeah, it's just natural. I I think most people would, and it doesn't mean that they're perfect, but it does mean that they probably have a wider breadth than the article I read, you know, on BuzzFeed.

SPEAKER_02So well, if you saw a video on TikTok on it, then it would be uh that would that would equate to whatever PhD or whatever. That's exactly right. I don't know.

SPEAKER_00I'm 15 TikToks away from my master's degree uh in this subject.

SPEAKER_02But anyway, so I was listening to his I was listening to a podcast the other day where it talked about like this this crazy doctor in the 1900s that he didn't finish his bachelor's and went on to like a three month a three-month course to get his uh his uh doctorate or whatever for for uh medicine. And I thought, man, I would have loved to be um I would have loved to be an academic in the 1900s. Can you imagine it's a three-month course for like the highest level of your field?

SPEAKER_00So, anyways, a lot of it was probably trial and error, like, ooh, that guy didn't make it.

SPEAKER_02I think most of it was error. I think most of it was like, no, I think I think this lead's gonna work out one day. So, anyways, you were talking about let me redirect you, you were talking about on when you're talking to somebody who has more expert in a field and you feel this need to defer often.

SPEAKER_00Right, exactly. So, when when I'm trying to determine why did God do or not do something, I have to acknowledge if if you believe the God of the Bible and that he's all knowing and all-seeing and outside of time and has purposes that we couldn't imagine, that that's a factor. You know, that's a factor. And I see it in Jesus. Why is Jesus not correcting the sin in the world? I mean, if you really walk with Jesus, just you know, be over his shoulder in the gospels. And we've covered this so much in Amazon Perplexed, that it's like, why are you not correcting the racism, the sexism, the oppression?

SPEAKER_02The I mean yeah, and that's so much more jarring because it's like literally God is jumping off the page into the story, yeah, and you don't see the correction. Whereas as here, there's also it's a reporting of what happened, right? It's like, you know, it's a reporting of it's it's not directly, oh, I mean, God is in the story, right? But God is not the active physical character in this story here.

SPEAKER_00That's right. And and the the real impact on that is there's no there's no perfect person in the story. Whereas with Jesus, there's a perfect person in the story, and then you're watching, how does perfection, because this is the question, I think, how does perfection deal with imperfection? And this question is not simply academic because it it applies to how is God working with me right now? Because I haven't I don't own an idol, because you've got two issues that that that our reader brings up, or our listener brings up, and one issue is why do they have idols at all? Saul is supposed to be a man of God, and David is married to Michael at this point, and he's a man of God, a man after God's own heart, and yet why is there an idol here in the first place?

SPEAKER_00And then number two, this lying that no one corrects. And I think it's I think it's a great question, both okay, can we get some sense of it, but also how does God deal with my lying? How does God deal with my um idol worship? You know? And so and so those that that frames it for me in that regard. I haven't answered anything yet, I understand, but I'm just framing that question.

SPEAKER_02And and I would even I would even maybe put a little bit more meat on the bone, because so you get in the situation here where it's like it's it's David's going to die if this doesn't happen. Now you could maybe like find something else that wasn't idol. Maybe it was maybe it was so bang bang that it was just that closest thing, and you know, and so I mean she had the idol, so it that that's not the issue. Um so you have I think you have two elements at uh at play here. Um if if David does not run away, if there's not this lie, if there's not this hiding, then David will David will be killed, and that's bad.

SPEAKER_02Being killed is bad, being murdered is bad. Um but then you you get to the old test, you get but then you get to the new testament and you have you have Jesus saying things that are pretty pretty radically pacifists, and you know, turning the other cheek to your enemy, um, and not striking out, um, and allow even himself, you know, allowing himself to be arrested and allowing himself um all these different things. And so how do we process because like I would lie, so you know, you get to the big questions of like of people who hid Jews in Nazi Germany. I think unquestionably, fantastic thing. Do it a hundred times, lie as much as you can to the Nazis about where the Jewish people you are hiding.

SPEAKER_02But when it comes to ourselves, or when it comes to like like you know, um our own personal, you know, nobody else is in trouble but uh but ourselves, like it would seem to me that Jesus would advocate for um for for nonviolence or non-design or uh non-design, but then Jesus is very shrewd sometimes. I I don't know. There's a lot of there's a lot going into this conversation.

SPEAKER_00You know what you just said about him advocating pacifist mode, and he did. And if you if you're confused about well, wait a minute, he turned the table and he I think people hold the view that he's beating people. Number one, one time. Uh number two, he's not beating people, he's driving animals with the whip. Because sometimes you just get this picture like he's just insane. He's very controlled, it was a pre-meditated meditated action, and he's he's proving a point. Um, but yeah, the vast majority of everything he does is very pacifistic. Um, and the irony to that, and uh it didn't pop in my head till you were talking, is that if somebody said, Hey, you need to be to a Jewish man at Jesus' time, you need to be a leader, like David was a leader.

SPEAKER_00David murdered people. I mean, not just in combat. There were people that were already captured that he murdered. Um, and so he just it's interesting how, and the whole point I'm the even I'm referencing that again is the idea of this huge shift in expectation. God sets the whole Old Testament about conquering, and and either you're conquering the land or you're trying to get out from being conquered. That's pretty much the story uh of the vast majority of the Old Testament. And so, and of course, they were oppressed, the people in Jesus' time.

SPEAKER_00So that was such a shift in expectation, and that's what this story is back in 1 Samuel. It's a shift in expectation because, like, number one, they shouldn't have had an idol, uh, and we, you know, why why shouldn't they? Well, because they had the law, and the law said no other gods and no idol. You know, I mean, this is not like some obscure passage we're running up against, and then he and then this idea of being a person of honesty and integrity, uh, something that we would say that's a that's a function of justice or a way of applying justice. And so, what's the reason why? Okay, so here's my first stab, uh, and then I expect you to make this look good after I get done, Connor.

SPEAKER_00Okay. So um I'm ready. You're ready. So so then you'll have the real right answer. Okay. There is a fallacy of believing that when God is in somebody's life, the way he makes you holy is he makes you completely moral. And until you're completely moral, he really can't work with you. And this is exposing yet one more time throughout the whole of the Old Testament, and we get glimpses of this in the New Testament, we just have a lot less narrative of the fact that God solely worked with people that were super flawed.

SPEAKER_00I believe if David was tuned in to God in the way that that that even we are, maybe, you know. And he could see the full revelation of who Jesus is. Yeah, and so that's a huge deficit to his view, and that's a great point. Like he didn't even have the law necessarily handy to him, you know. Well, and if he had the law, I don't know if he had Genesis, he might have had Leviticus or aspects of that, but but I don't know. Maybe we could find that out, but I don't I don't know. But he certainly didn't have what we have. And so he is living in a way that number one was corollary with everyone else.

SPEAKER_00So I'm just dealing with the lying part right now, and then I'll get to the idol part in just a second. But but the the key here isn't so much what what David did, it's how God lives with his people and their sin. Um, and so I guess it does apply to the idol, the idol dynamic. I mean, how many idols do I presently possess that I'm just gonna own I idolize football? You know, I love watching the NFL. And I will I will be in church about to preach, and I think to myself, just full candor here, I'll think to myself, I need to hurry up because I really want to get back for the noon game.

SPEAKER_00You know, I have those thoughts. That's completely unreasonable. I just watch soccer uh during church. During church, that's good. If I could just figure out a way to do that, but anyway, I I have idols all over. Now, when you ask me, Jason, should you, I would say no. I may even be taking action against, but in in the middle of a death, life and death situation, I don't know the corollary to using my idol to support my life, but uh but I would. And and the thing is, I think there's a fallacy that, well, God wouldn't work with you if you're if you're connected with some sin.

SPEAKER_00And I'm like, God only works with us when we're connected with sin. In other words, if he was waiting for us to be uh perfect, you know, and see we think the physical idol is so much worse than the fact that I'm materialistic or I'm a glutton or I'm a whatever, you know, I I I love you know looking at the opposite sex or whatever it is that we idolize, and and we're like, no, the physical idol in many cases probably had less of a hold on them than they did on us. No, not in all cases. You know, in some cases those idols really consumed, especially when they were under stress.

SPEAKER_00But but this is the nature of how a perfect God works with actual human beings, is he doesn't make them clean up everything before he works with them. And his correction is usually, and maybe this is a whole second point, it's usually very slow.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, that's really good. And and I think for me, the very convicting aspect is our idea, our idea usually of what that big sin would be or that big idol, that unapproachable thing is usually God doesn't feel the same way about those things. You know, for me, like, you know, I love you, Jason, I love doing this, but if you went out and murdered somebody, I would probably like, well, I probably I can still talk to Jason. I probably need to stop working with Jason. I probably am gonna like, you know, put a put a pause to the podcast, or you know, that's the line you're drawing. Murder. Okay, two murders, two murders.

SPEAKER_02No, but but but even to that extreme, we have um, we all have that line for for what we think. And usually that line is just past where we would go, where it's like, okay, God will work with me up to this point, but man, anything past that, and you know, like that just seems like too much. Um, and I think your point is so is so important about um about what we think is a bigger idol and what we think are our bigger problems. And and I think honestly, in the old testament, there's plenty of evidence that the problem with the idols, it's not the fact that it would, they were, you know, just stone, it's also what they represented and what what and how it how it played out in their life.

SPEAKER_02But what you said is so important um about how God works with people. And I think I talked about that in our in our kind of like coming back episode after you're sabbatical. Um, when you look at the old testament and you see the progression of God's people, it just becomes so abundant how scandalously patient God is. Um, how scandalously patient he is, not just with individuals, which he absolutely is, but with uh his people as a whole. And so we get that's how we get to the point where like I talked a little bit before about how Abraham is like, hey, not sacrificing children, that's a big deal.

SPEAKER_02That's good, you know, that that's some fantastic progress. And even when you get to the point of David, you get to hear, okay, what would even even even Christian nations 500 years ago, you have a deranged king, um, and you are the next in line to inherit that throne. What did 99.9% of people do in that situation who find themselves as heir to the throne with a crazy king? You kill him, you kill the king so that you can do the right thing, so you can have your place, you can have your power. Um, and and and I could even make a moral argument that it's bad that God just continues to allow Saul to be king when he is clearly so off course.

SPEAKER_02We could have that conversation another day. That's another good conversation. But I do think it's important the God, David is doing something here that is so completely different and foreign to the way things were done then, and even necessarily to how things are done now, because the way the world operates until like the way the world would operate until that point is well, the natural thing is you kill him because he he tried to kill you and you would be a better king, and so why wouldn't you kill him? Like that would be the that would be what would be going on in my mind if I was David.

SPEAKER_02Okay, Saul just tried to kill me, I will make a much better king than he is. Why wouldn't I kill him? And so in this story, God is making slow progress and saying, no, the way you get to better government, the way you get to be better people, is not by making these more, like not maybe making these massive moral sacrifices. I'm okay with taking the step here of you are not going to kill the person so you can have their power. That's the that's the that's the step that I want you to take in this moment, David.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, and so so let's apply it to I'll I'll take this on me. I was raised in violence, okay? And so when when somebody got mad, they were hitting you, you know. So I marry my wife and I'm committed not to hit her, and I am doing fabulous because I'm only exploding, like verbally. And it's like, oh wait, that's not of God either, but that's part of my growth, you know. So it doesn't mean that it's okay that I exploded, but it also needs to be put in the proper perspective that that's progress.

SPEAKER_02I mean that that's more progress than basically however many thousands of years you think humans have existed for your line, for your ancestors. There might be like five other generations in the past 200 generations that accomplish what you accomplished. And part of that is built on how the small steps that were taken um through your grand your great great great great grandparents and your parents and you eventually you know being able to make that step and make that progress. Um and again, I could make the moral argument, man, that's so slow, but that's just the nature of what it is to work with humans is that we don't make progress in we don't make these massive jumps, we make these slow progresses, and then you look around and it's amazing.

SPEAKER_02It's horrible the way women have been treated for all of history. Um and it's horrible that the way husbands have treated their wives, and it's it still happens. I don't want to pretend that it's not, but the fact that the expectation for for a woman to not be hit is a massive, it's it's that's that's a complete change from how it was 50 years ago, and that's horrific, and that's the bare minimum now, which is good, but man, I think we often forget. Um yeah, I I I want to I wanna I want to transition back to what you were talking about. I think we often forget um uh of of of how long it takes to change and how um how hard that process is.

SPEAKER_02And and yeah, so i I I I could keep going forward, but go ahead.

SPEAKER_00No, well well, and and so it's this idea, and I want to be super clear. I think David could and and it's hard for us to get in this emotional state, but just uh you you'd you'd said this, I'm just gonna return to this. So you're sitting there, and in theory, I don't know if it says this, but David's playing music. That's a whole purpose for his existence here or his presence in Saul's, you know, room, his throne room, I suppose, and Saul throws a spear at him. So I don't know how many of our listeners uh have ever been like this person tried to kill me.

SPEAKER_00So the you know, the guy takes a shot at you, you know, he's got a gun and takes a shot at you, and you escape and you know he's coming after you. You know, I think David, especially once we know the history that comes after this, that he will not lay a hand on Saul, even when Saul is vulnerable. I mean, imagine if you have in your life, and maybe some of our listeners do, a person that tried to kill you. Not somebody you don't like or somebody that's rude. Like, I still hold grudges over people who offended me, you know, much less, you know, pull out a spear and chuck it at me.

SPEAKER_00And so this just happened, and so it is way dialing it down not to kill him back, as it were, you know. So that's a great point that you make. I do think that that there are tons of stories that the Bible can't tell because the people didn't respond in the fullness of faith and purity. I want to be really clear on this. That's good. And we made this point in the New Testament study. It's like, wouldn't it be a beautiful story that the apostles are watching Jesus sleep and the storm is going on, and they're just sitting there meditating because they know God will save them.

SPEAKER_00And then they all go under, and now we have the story in the Bible of how people breathed underwater. You know, we don't have that story because they didn't demonstrate that faith or whatever, because Jesus would have got them through it, you know? And and this is the point, God meets us where we are. But I do believe that David could have said, you know what? I'm just gonna sit here and pray. And if if Saul comes after me, you know, what would we have the story about Saul at two feet chucking spears at him and they don't hit? You know, it's like, what in the world just happened there, you know? And and I mean, I've seen I've seen live video of people shooting at people at two feet and not hitting them.

SPEAKER_02So I'm like, we see, we see like this bed that cannot be moved from the room, and we see, you know, like you see a door that cannot be open. I mean, like the the the amount the endless creative ways that that God would have come through in this, could have come through in this situation.

SPEAKER_00And and that's the point. So I think I should aspire to, because to me, it's we don't do amazed and perplexed to say, amazed and perplexed to say, um, wow, we figured this out. We do this to help us to see God anew so that we can say, okay, what is God telling me today? If we for me, I have no interest in doing some kind of academic discussion. I'm saying, how does this actually apply to me today? And what it what it says to me is God will work with whatever I give him. As long as I'm after his heart, and I will say again, I've said many times, David didn't have God's heart at all, ever.

SPEAKER_00Maybe momentarily. He was after it. And that matters to God. And it allowed him to cover up a ton of David's sin. God's love covered over so much of David's sin that he was not held accountable for and was not punished for. But when it was to God's purposes, God would bring punishment, i.e. Bathsheba, or when he did the census, or any number of things that he does get punished for. But there is a ton of stuff he did not get punished for, and God was working with the reality of him. In other words, you know, I was raised, man, situational ethics do not exist.

SPEAKER_00In other words, you always do the same thing every time. And I'm like, that's great. Except Jesus didn't. I mean, we have to own the fact that Jesus did things different all the time. Yeah, you know, and because it's Jesus, maybe we don't question it, but when we talk about, okay, I want to be Jesus and in my world today, or I want Jesus to shine through me, that should bring it's gonna look different all the time. Yeah, and Jesus in you is gonna look different than Jesus in me.

SPEAKER_02And so you said something earlier. So when we look, David not killing Saul, David not retaliating, David not David not, you know, giving an eye for an eye in this situation is a glimpse of a part of Jesus. It's not the pure manifestation of the goodness and the purity of Christ, but it is a part of the goodness of God. Like there is that the goodness of God is shining through in David in that moment. Um and so we see um not the fullness, but we do see a part of it shining through. Then we get to the New Testament and we see the fullness of the goodness of God shining to a broken world in broken situations, and so we see how it keeps playing out in different ways, where we see when we when we see Jesus walking um through the New Testament, we see how his pull, it's like a gravitational pull, and it's it's causing all these weird orbits and it's causing all these um these these weird anomalies and these things that we aren't sure why they happen or why he's doing it in this specific way or why he's acting in this specific way.

SPEAKER_02Um and I and I the the and the thing we have to believe because we believe Jesus is God and He's good, is that the goodness of Jesus is not changing, but the way evil, the way his goodness is encountering evil, um, is is is warping and changing. Um and so yeah, I I man there this I I love I love this discussion because I just think it's it's so um it's so massive and it's so good. Yeah, so I just think it's I think it's really important that we remind ourselves when we're reading the Old Testament and the New Testament, um, that that the absence of the perfect figure in the story has a massive um has a mash uh has a massive change on how that story would play out.

SPEAKER_02And in the same way in the New Testament, we see um when the perfect figure encounters the world, when the perfect figure invades the world, that um the different kinds of evil that he faces or the different kinds of hardships that he faces are going to change um how that love and that evil and that hardness come up and and butt up against each other.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, that's that's really, really good. And I think that would bring me a lot, a lot more peace. I would experience more of the fruit of the spirit of peace if I keep that in the forefront of my mind. Is that in the in the application of that perfect person wants to live in me, that the spirit of God that few possessed in the old testament, some did, you know. And at this case, we're talking about Saul, he replaced the spirit of God, which he initially put on Saul, allowing him to prophesy and and and do other things that has been removed, and now he's got the spirit of we haven't even brought up the spirit of the demon, you know, his spirit of evil that God sent.

SPEAKER_00It's like, hold up, you know. Um and that's a whole nother discussion, but but it it actually fits to the point of exactly what you're saying. This is what it looks like for a perfect God not to eradicate evil, yeah, but to work with it for his purposes, and and that's it's almost how do I say this? I don't think I can think about it right. It's almost like if you're trying to the our our your house is flooded, and you're trying to clean it off, you're sponging it or vacuuming it or whatever while it's still flooding.

SPEAKER_00You would say, No, we have to stop the flooding, then we do the cleaning, and God's like, no, no, I'll do the cleaning while it's flooding. That's the whole wheat in the tears parable. It's like, no, I'm not gonna remove it, I'm gonna wait till the end. You're like, well, it'd be much easier, and that's the servant's point. And the way we feel like remove it all.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, and the way we feel about it oftentimes is like it's not that God's trying to remove it, it's like God's doorknob polishing over there. And I'm like, no, like the house is flooding and you're polishing the doorknob.

SPEAKER_00You were missing the point, God.

SPEAKER_02In reality, we're not seeing the full picture. So I have a I think a pretty good example. My daughter, um, she'll she'll be two in December, which is crazy. I know it's crazy. Uh, she's had sensory issues for most of her young life to this point, and so we have struggled mightily when it comes to food for her. Like, I mean, just battles upon battles. Like, I think there was a period of time where we are probably spending, I don't know, like four hours a day trying to feed her because it was just it was misery. And so we've we were able to get her some um OT and we started developing these new techniques, and so we're now at the point where she will sit with us at the table and most nights eat her meal.

SPEAKER_02And that, if we could have told like four months ago, Connor Hannah, we would have been like perfect, fantastic. She's getting calories, she's eating, you know, what we put in front of her for the most part. This isn't fantastic, this is a miracle. And you would be right, like that would be so exciting, but she is she's still chucking her fork at the at the ground, or even sometimes in our direction, um, which is incredibly bad. It's not bad to try to impale your, you know, I don't know. She's not trying to do that. It's not it's it's bad. And and as as many times as we've, as many techniques, and as consistent as we have been with it, she is still has um still has this will to keep going her own way.

SPEAKER_02And there's a part of me that when every time she chucks it to the floor, and we have to do this whole song and dance um to help her learn help her teach her how to not do this, that this is bad. I just go, this is the worst thing ever. She just keeps chucking things at the floor. This is this is so bad. But in the context of the growth that she's had and even where she started and the problems that she had initially, it's like, man, I so quickly forget the progress that has come up before now, and all I can focus on is the unaddressed issue of the chucking of the fork. And I think we do that all the time with God.

SPEAKER_02I think God takes us and and and and pulls us and grows us into new areas and pulls and grows other people in our lives into new areas, and it's amazing, and it brings us so much peace and it brings us um closer to him. And there's the metaphorical, you know, chucking of the fork or not responding in the perfect way to somebody trying to kill you in David's situation. Um and even though we know it's like, oh, an almost two-year-old is throwing their silver on the floor, big deal, or oh, David in in a in a moment of panic decides that he's going to allow, you know, himself to be lied about and an idol to be used for his escape.

SPEAKER_02You're like, okay, big deal. Like, I imagine that might be David's conversation to us, like, yeah, I was about to die. I like make that decision in the moment, make that decision in the moment when the king of your country decides he wants you dead, make a decision to to to fully um to fully live, you know, maybe the mindset that we might think Jesus has. And and that would be a very, very fair challenge.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, and and this is the key, and this is the challenge I think, depending on how you were raised. If you were raised that that and the the fact is it doesn't match reality, but when you get together at your churches uh or in your communities and talk and say, no, you should just always do the right, right thing, and then you can't even process like Holocaust questions, you know, would you would you have housed, you know, uh, you know, Jewish people, because it's like, oh, we can't even think about this. There's just one right answer. And if that's what the Bible taught, there's just one right answer, then okay, you know, well, we we're gonna figure this out.

SPEAKER_00But the fact of the matter is, God works in reality that we are affected by evil, and he works with anybody that will is willing to work with him. He starts with where you are. There's never a time when he's like, you gotta get here. I mean, think about the examples of this, and once you start thinking about it, they're everywhere. Elisha heals Naaman, and Naaman says, Hey, uh, will you forgive me because I'm gonna be bowing down to an idol for the rest of my life because of my job and my position? And Elisha's like, sure. Like, it's not like, sure, like, what in the world?

SPEAKER_00No, you know, I mean, it's just that's crazy talk. You know, I obviously idols have come up, and and Jacob's, what's it, um Rachel, steals Laban's, her dad's household idols, and he he brings, he's gonna kill them all, you know, and can't find it, you know. I mean, idols are all over the place, and God works to it until the people's heart are totally devoted to the idols. You know, by the time God's condemning idol worship in almost every setting in the Old Testament, they've been doing it a long time. Yeah. And they have totally forgotten him. So the existence of the idol wasn't really the main deal.

SPEAKER_00And again, I'm not saying that's it, it would be best to remove all idols. Let's be super clear on that. The point is God works with who you really are, not who you should be. Yeah, and and that's true of every single person, including the apostles, including everybody. Yeah.

SPEAKER_02And I think it's important to just make the distinction, to make the uh to make at least on my end, very clear that God, God is, in my opinion, the God revealed in Jesus Christ, is always going to honor our attempts to save innocent life that is especially done by nonviolent means. So for me, I I think that's one of those things that like, you know, it's not even a quibble for me of like, oh, somebody was rescuing, you know, thousands of condemned Jews from the Holocaust. I'm like, yeah, no, those innocent lives that were nonviolently saved.

SPEAKER_02I completely believe that the father is is excited and happy about that situation. God's not looking down and quibbling, well, well, you could have done here, or you could have not told that fib. Or I even heard this crazy story of this guy. Um, I was listening to this podcast, and it was this guy, he um he was in, I think he was in Belarus, and it was in the time of um of uh it was in the in the time of Nazi Germany where they're fine, they're rounding up a lot of the um a lot of the maybe it was Budapest, I can't remember which one is one of the one of the B B European cities. I wish I could have anyway.

SPEAKER_02Um and it's this guy who say he was a he was just a random like uh Czech, oh not Czech, he's some some some uh ambassador that was basically just decided I'm gonna go and save lives. And basically what he did, he was a confidence man, he would just walk up to Nazi officials and be like, those Jews are uh Swiss uh citizens, you can't take them. And he would just be so confident, he would just be so bold and confident in his lies that most of the time the the Nazis would be like, oh okay, you you seem like you uh you have you know what you're talking about.

SPEAKER_02Take we're gonna kill them, but you can take them now because they're your citizens. And I think to something like that, a story like that, yeah, we can be like, well, the more, you know, the moral we shouldn't lie, and all he had to practice his line to get good at it and all this sort of. But I think unequivocally, Jesus would be like, good job. And I don't know if this guy was a Christian or not, but good job. I think good job in specifically this an era, good job, my faithful servant, because you protected innocence and you protected goodness and life, and you were a source.

SPEAKER_00I don't know what light this would shed on it, but I'd be interested to go back and listen to our podcast we did on Luke 16 of the parable of the shrewd manager, uh, because you have a similar situation. And he's he's talking about that's that the parable's talking about him saving his own life. And yeah, maybe he cheated himself only, you know, by taking out his wage, however, you see that. And again, I can't even remember what we concluded or if there was a conclusion. But I do think this is Jesus sharing a story about somebody, and what one person could look at as dishonest, he's labeling as shrewd.

SPEAKER_00And and I think that's the point in all of our lives. Am I trying to see it from God's perspective, even if I think I already know? Because there are tons of things in history where people felt like, I know this is true, you know, things like slavery, that I know there was a contingency of people that wouldn't have stood up for like an a master, you know, abusing their slave, but they're like, well, it's just the world we live in. We have there are people that have slaves, even if I don't have slaves, you know. Whereas today we'd be like, no, we have to eradicate that. Like if I knew there was somebody, I know there's there's obviously sex slavery is a huge issue, but I I don't know how to I can support agencies, but I don't know where that is, you know.

SPEAKER_00But if I did, if you told me, hey Jason, that lady is is being, you know, especially if they're a minor, you know, I I would I would take risk there, you know what I mean? But I don't. But there was a time in our culture where people just like me were like, well, it's just the way of the world, you know, and who am I to stop that? Now I think they should have made a better decision. But were they saved? Or specifically were they lost because they didn't die eradicating slavery, you know? And and this is the thing is this is going on right now. Their injustice is going on right now that I'm clueless as to how to stop, and even if I should, whereas 20 years or 100 years from now, they will judge me on that, and then and I could look forward if I knew what they did and I could judge them on that.

SPEAKER_00This is the point, is is it God sees the heart of the person within the reality of their life context, and he says, Are you willing to work with me on this? You know, and and that to me is the takeaway. Like I could look at this, and I think it's reasonable to look at this and say, Wait, we have idol worship and lying going on here, and I don't deny that. And I think God would say, You could do better, you know. But you could also look at it as look at God's compassion and his mercy and the fact he's taking David from where he is. Then I say, look at God's compassion for Jason.

SPEAKER_00Look at look at I rarely talk about myself in third person, but uh but but it's that idea of all my sinfulness, all the better choices I could be making, and God's like, Yeah, are you with me? Let's go.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, man, I I I love I love this conversation and I think it's so important. And I think it's I think it's a a very important reminder that you brought out that uh there are there are real things today that we are that we should maybe we might be should be able to see, or things that we see that we don't think are as big a deal or that we don't take as much action as future you know versions of of Amazon Perplex or Connor, you know, and Jason might see and go, how could they not have done that? Um and obviously, like when I when somebody points out something horrific to me, I want to, I want to help, like I want to donate to agencies, I want to be a part of the problem of writing injustice.

SPEAKER_02Um, but the almost certainty is that as we make this, as God slowly marches us forward and and crafts us more into the image of Christ, and as God marches us forward and as he makes us more into the image um of all of who we were always intended to be, we become more and more aware of how far away we are. We become more and more aware of of how much we don't line up, how much we haven't done. Um, and so where before, you know, I I hope for David's sake that he recognized in this moment, man, I didn't, I didn't give an eye for an eye.

SPEAKER_02I did something good here. My hope would be in my situation when I, you know, if I'm in David's place here, that I would be able to rejoice in the moment for not repaying evil with evil and doing something and breaking a cycle here, but then down the road being like, okay, but I could have done this better, and I could I could do this better in the future, and I can work on this. Um, and I think that would be my encouragement through through this episode one. Um, yes, could David have done things differently? Probably. Is there a more perfect way to do things that God would have preferred? Um, absolutely.

SPEAKER_02But I also don't think God's like, well, you only got 50% credit. So, you know, I that no, I I think God would want David to be pleased. Hey, like you, you, you, you made progress. You were committed to goodness um in a new way, not in the full way that I want you to be, but you were committed to goodness in a new and special way. And so um, that would be my encouragement um for myself, honestly, um, is one don't be don't be satisfied with not just killing your enemy, um, but also don't be necessarily um down on yourself or down on God because he's slowly taking these steps beside you.

SPEAKER_00Thank you so much for listening and thank you so much for the questions. And I would say keep them coming, not because we have the answers, but it gives us the opportunity to stretch and iron sharpening iron and that whole thing. Because that's what we want from this podcast is people to hear it and ask better questions and think uh and ask God, hey, make this clearer for me because the word is living and active, and we want to constantly be surprised by the amazing and perplexing things that come up grace, peace, and love.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. How We Think About Marriage(Matthew 19:1-12)

    Nov 8, 202634 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail 𝐇𝐨𝐰 𝐖𝐞 𝐓𝐡𝐢𝐧𝐤 𝐀𝐛𝐨𝐮𝐭 𝐌𝐚𝐫𝐫𝐢𝐚𝐠𝐞(𝐌𝐚𝐭𝐭𝐡𝐞𝐰 𝟏𝟗:𝟏-𝟏𝟐) Contact: amazedandperplexed@gmail.com Music by: Heavensense https://soundcloud.com/hvnsen

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. The Unmerciful Servant(Matthew 18:21-35)

    Oct 4, 202632 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail 𝐓𝐡𝐞 𝐔𝐧𝐦𝐞𝐫𝐜𝐢𝐟𝐮𝐥 𝐒𝐞𝐫𝐯𝐚𝐧𝐭(𝐌𝐚𝐭𝐭𝐡𝐞𝐰 𝟏𝟖:𝟐𝟏-𝟑𝟓) This episode sits with Jesus' parable of the unmerciful servant, unpacking the ancient debtor's world behind the story and the...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Hearing as a Community(Matthew 18:18-20)

    Sep 27, 202627 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail 𝐇𝐞𝐚𝐫𝐢𝐧𝐠 𝐚𝐬 𝐚 𝐂𝐨𝐦𝐦𝐮𝐧𝐢𝐭𝐲(𝐌𝐚𝐭𝐭𝐡𝐞𝐰 𝟏𝟖:𝟏𝟖-𝟐𝟎) Jesus makes a bold, almost startling promise: where two or three gather in his name, he's there, and whatever they agree on will...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. A People of Repentance and Forgiveness(Matthew 18:15-17)

    Sep 20, 202649 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail 𝐀 𝐏𝐞𝐨𝐩𝐥𝐞 𝐨𝐟 𝐑𝐞𝐩𝐞𝐧𝐭𝐚𝐧𝐜𝐞 𝐚𝐧𝐝 𝐅𝐨𝐫𝐠𝐢𝐯𝐞𝐧𝐞𝐬𝐬(𝐌𝐚𝐭𝐭𝐡𝐞𝐰 𝟏𝟖:𝟏𝟓-𝟏𝟕) This episode digs into dealing with Sin in the church. We discuss why the gentle, small first...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. The Rich Man and Lazarus(Luke 16:19-31)

    Sep 13, 202634 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail 𝐓𝐡𝐞 𝐑𝐢𝐜𝐡 𝐌𝐚𝐧 𝐚𝐧𝐝 𝐋𝐚𝐳𝐚𝐫𝐮𝐬(𝐋𝐮𝐤𝐞 𝟏𝟔:𝟏𝟗-𝟑𝟏) This episode dives into the strikingly detailed story of the rich man and Lazarus in Luke 16. The discussion explores what it means...

    Credit the people on this episode