Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Always Hangry

Always Hangry artwork

Razor Blades in Apples, Candy Corn Conundrum & Pumpkin Spice Everything

Oct 28, 202629 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Has anyone ever actually found a razor blade in a Halloween apple? George Duran and food and wellness writer Karla Walsh dig into America's favorite Halloween scare: where the razor-blade apple hoax stories came from and why an apple is a terrible place to hide a blade anyway. Plus the cases that were real: a California dentist who handed out candy-coated laxatives, and a Long Island woman who gave dog biscuits and ant poison to teens she thought were too old to trick-or-treat. Then it's "Treat or Trash?": Sour candy in a toy toilet with a plunger? (Real.) Candy scabs inside a fake bandage? (Real.) Liquid candy in a urine-sample cup? (Sadly, real.) Pickled eyeballs and used-tissue chews? (George made those up.) After the break: candy corn. Karla is fully Team Candy Corn; George thinks it's sweet, chewy wax and has receipts. They cover how it started as "Chicken Feed," the wax and glaze that give it that shine, Brach's new candy corn perfume, and a candy corn round of Treat or Trash where hot dog, hamburger, green bean and roasted turkey flavors all turn out to be real. In the second half, creative director and Creative Briefs host Jon Racinskas explains how pumpkin spice went from spice trade to pumpkin pie to Starbucks' 2003 latte, why "manufactured scarcity" keeps us coming back every fall, and which pumpkin spice products, from Spam to scented trash bags, have gone too far. Plus his pick for the next seasonal obsession. Key Takeaways The razor-blade apple is mostly myth. Sociologist Joel Best (University of Delaware) has tracked "Halloween sadism" reports since the 1980s and found no substantiated case of a child killed or seriously injured by a stranger's tampered treat. Most reports he followed up were hoaxes. The scare had a paper trail. Razor-blade reports spread in the late 1960s, and a 1970 New York Times piece, "Those Treats May Be Tricks," warned that the apple from a kindly neighbor might hide a blade. Apples are a bad hiding place. George's case: a cut apple browns fast, a slit big enough for a blade can't be hidden, and the fruit would be visibly off by the time it got home. Real tampering was rare and strange. In 1959 a California dentist, Dr. William Shyne, handed out about 450 candy-coated laxatives; around 30 kids got sick. In 1964, Helen Pfeil of Long Island gave out steel wool, dog biscuits and ant poison to teens she considered too old for trick-or-treating. George hands out instant ramen as a Halloween treat. He says he's the most popular house on the block. Gross candy is a real category. Kidsmania's Sour Flush (sour powder in a toy toilet with a candy plunger), Flix Candy's Box of Boogers and Lick Your Wounds candy scabs are all real. Candy corn started as "Chicken Feed." It's credited to George Renninger of Philadelphia's Wunderle Candy Company in the 1880s; the Goelitz company, now Jelly Belly, began making it in 1898. Yes, it's waxy. Candy corn gets its shine from a confectioner's glaze (shellac), and some recipes use carnauba wax. Candy corn now comes as perfume. Brach's released Ode to Candy Corn, a $22 limited-edition fragrance with vanilla, spun sugar and honey notes, in fall 2026. It sold out fast. Yes, these flavors are real. Brach's Turkey Dinner mix (2020) had roasted turkey, stuffing, green beans, cranberry sauce, ginger glazed carrot and sweet potato pie; its Tailgate mix (2022) added hot dog and hamburger. Pumpkin spice is four spices. Cinnamon, nutmeg, ginger and cloves. McCormick sold the blend as pumpkin pie spice in 1934; Starbucks launched the pumpkin spice latte in 2003. Scarcity is the strategy for seasonal pumpkin spiced flavors. Jon's take: a PSL in June wouldn't sell, because the appeal is nostalgia tied to a season. Warmth matters. Jon thinks pumpkin spice products that last are warm and multisensory, which is why he doesn't expect the Slurpee version to stick. Pumpkin spice has gone everywhere. Spam (2019), Nissin Cup Noodles (2021), Hatfield bacon, Pringles (2012), Kraft Mac & Cheese (2020), 7-Eleven's Slurpee (2024), Hefty trash bags, cat litter, deodorant, Dawn dish spray and Trader Joe's hummus. What's next? Jon's bets: a spring lavender latte, and "deep fried" as a flavor, pointing to Oreo's new Deep Fried cookie. People & Companies Mentioned George Duran - Host, Always Hangry; chef and TV personality Karla Walsh - Food and wellness writer, Level One Sommelier; recurring Always Hangry co-host Jon Racinskas - Creative director and filmmaker; host of the YouTube channel Creative Briefs Joel Best - Sociologist, University of Delaware; leading researcher on Halloween candy-tampering myths The New York Times - Published "Those Treats May Be Tricks" (October 1970) Dr. William Shyne - California dentist who handed out laxatives to trick-or-treaters in 1959 Helen Pfeil - Long Island woman behind the 1964 steel wool and ant poison incident Jelly Belly - Maker of the vomit-flavored jelly bean (formerly the Goelitz Confectionery Company) Kidsmania - Sour Flush candy Flix Candy - Box of Boogers Lick Your Wounds - Candy scabs in refillable bandages Bon Appétit - Cited by George for a 2013 gross-candy roundup (unverified - see checklist) Wunderle Candy Company / George Renninger - Credited with inventing candy corn Brach's (Ferrara) - Candy corn maker; Ode to Candy Corn perfume, Turkey Dinner and Tailgate candy corn Walgreens - Exclusive retailer of Brach's novelty candy corn mixes American Chemical Society - Source George cites on candy corn's glaze McCormick - Released pumpkin pie spice in 1934 Starbucks - Pumpkin spice latte (2003) Hormel (Spam), Nissin (Cup Noodles), Hatfield, Pringles, Kraft, 7-Eleven - Pumpkin spice food products Hefty, Special Kitty, Native, Dawn - Pumpkin spice trash bags, cat litter, deodorant and dish spray Trader Joe's - Pumpkin spice hummus Oreo - Chicken & Waffles and Deep Fried limited-edition cookies Links Guests Jon Racinskas - jonracinskas.com, https://www.instagram.com/jonracinskas/, Creative Briefs on https://www.youtube.com/@Creative_Briefs Always Hangry Website - https://alwayshangrypodcast.com Instagram - https://www.instagram.com/AlwaysHangryPodcast YouTube - https://www.youtube.com/@AlwaysHangryPodcast TikTok - https://www.tiktok.com/@AlwaysHangryPodcast

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Real or fake formula? P. Yellow lemonade flavored sour liquid candy packaged to resemble a urine sample collected at a doctor's office. Gross. No, that's fake. It's real. No. Who. Why does this exist? George? Welcome to the Always Hangry Podcast, where we break down the way we eat. The good, the bad, and the completely ridiculous. I'm your host, George Duran. Today we're unwrapping some of Halloween's sweetest secrets, from tainted apples to candy corn that taste like

candles. And later on, we're diving into the pumpkin spice craze. How it took over America, why we're obsessed with it, and whether we've finally taken it too far. Joining me now is the only person who brings a snorkel to Bob for Apples, the delightfully spooky Karla Walsh. I mean, honestly, I wouldn't put it past me. You got to be prepared for everything. George. Have you ever bopped for apples? I think when I was a little kid. Yeah. I don't see anyone do that anymore. I know. What. What made that stop. Should we bring it back?

I think kids were probably drowning. Oh, I. I mean, I hope not. Well, the secret to bobbing for apples, that because the apples float, you have to push the apple down into the water until it hits the bottom of the container, and then you can grasp it with your teeth. You can't just grasp it from the tip of the water. Yeah, yeah, that does sound kind of dangerous. But speaking of apples, do you remember the whole thing about razor blades and apples? Yes. Was that true? Yeah. Well, for decades, American parents warned children that a stranger might put a razor blade inside their Halloween apple. Years after research, there's still no substantiated case

of a child being killed or injured by this. Wow. Do we know where this rumor got started? Well, in 1968, a Toronto TV news broadcast aired footage of local police displaying apples with razor blades and poisoned candy reportedly turned in by trick or treaters. And then in the 70s, the New York Times published a sensational article titled, those Treats May be tricks, warning parents that the plump red apple that your kid gets from a kindly old woman down the block may have a razor blade hidden inside. What the hell's wrong with

us? I have. I have so many questions. A, who was handing out apples on Halloween? And like, B, like, where did these rumors begin? This is so, so wild. There has been zero recorded evidence of a child ever being killed or seriously injured by a random stranger hiding a razor blade or poison in a Halloween treat. So it is not true. It's complete myth. So you are the parent in this conversation. I would love to know. Do you sort through your kids Halloween candy before they eat it?

Yeah, so I can eat the good stuff and they can have the crap waxy candy instead. What do you steal? Anything. Peanut butter. But that's because also my youngest kid is allergic to peanut butter. But it's kind of an excuse too. Yeah, yeah. I mean, safety first. Yeah, okay, sure, whatever. I want the peanut butter. Dr. Joel Best, a sociologist and criminal justice professor at the University of Delaware, found that the vast majority of reports were hoaxes about the razor blades. Children seeking attention from anxious parents would stick a sewing pin or blade into

a candy bar and claim they found it. When pressed by police, almost all of them admitted it was a joke. Wow. That's not funny. Those kids deserve the razor blade in their apple. Yeah, these kids are seeking attention. That's it. Wow. Here is the reason why razor blazing apple are pretty much impossible or impractical, I should say oxidation. Apples are highly susceptible to rapid oxidation. The moment an apple skin is punctured and the flesh is exposed to air, the enzymatic browning process begins.

It would start rotting right away if you put a razor blade in there. Yeah. Or at least getting visibly brown. You know, as we've all seen when we have cut slices of apple out for snacking. Absolutely. Visibility is another reason to embed a standard double edged razor blade, someone would have to make a deep, wide slit into the core of the fruit. This cut cannot be seamlessly closed or concealed. Like how do you stick a double edged razor blade into an apple? Like with pliers. And how do you even do that? Yeah, it would be extremely like an engineering feat to make

that happen. And again, I go back to who is handing out apples on Halloween. And then there's deterioration. By the time the apple sits in a giveaway bowl and handed to a child, bounced around in a trick or treat bag, it was finally brought home and it was pretty much starting to rot. You can instantly tell if this apple, there's something wrong with it. Yeah, I came up with a candied apple treat one time that had the whole razor blade theme to it. And what I did was I made these like cookies that were shaped as razor blades. You dip the apple in the caramel and then I made

a slit in the apple and kind of pushed in this cookie that looked like a razor blade into the side of the apple and served it like that. Okay. I hope you were serving this to adults with like a sign. No, it was kind of fun and dark humor. And people loved it because they could eat candy apples with a cookie that was razor blade shaped. You're making the narrative your own, George. That's creative. But no doubt if somebody were to give me an apple for Halloween, I would just chuck it right back up there. Front window. No, George, you cannot give apples for Halloween. Nobody, no kid wants

apples for Halloween. Oh, gosh. You know what I give out for Halloween? What's that? Packets of ramen. No way. Every year I give up packets of ramen and I am the most popular house on the block here. Yeah, I was gonna say that's a hit. It's dirt cheap and it's ramen and it's something that's not sweet. Parents love it. Kids love it even more. Yeah, I mean, that's like a good post trick or treating meal. Honestly, this is what's really happened for in terms of tampering for food. In 1959, a California dentist actually gave kids laxatives. William V. Syine distributed approximately 450

candy coated laxatives to trick or treaters. Around 30 children became ill. Why would you do that? In 1964, Helen Pfeil from Long island handed out items including steel wool dog biscuits and clearly marked poisonous ant traps to children she thought were too old to be trick or treating. Oh my gosh, that is awful. I'm not joking to you. I get a lot of adults trick or treating in my neighborhood. All I can think in my head is like, man, you're too old for this. Get the hell out of here. But I still give it

to them. I don't say anything but to give them ant traps and dog biscuits. That makes me sad. That lady is a party pooper. Trick or treating is not for adults. I'm sorry, I'm a zero judgment zone. If you want to come knock on my door, that's okay. Okay, we're going to play a game called treat or trash. Okay, I'll figure it out as we go along. Yes, I'm ready. The way it works is very simple. I'm going to tell you the name of some outrageous candies and you have to tell me if they are real candy treats or if I invented them. Okay, I'm ready. Barf jelly beans, Real or fake?

That I believe was part of the Harry Potter jelly belly series. I'm going to say real. That's correct. These jelly beans deliberately flavored to taste like actual vomit. Made by jelly belly. Come on, people. Again, why are we doing this to ourselves? Next, one zombie toenail clippings fake or real? That has to be fake. These tiny, sour, yellowish candy shards are packed inside a plastic nail clipper dispenser. Oh, gross. And they're fake. Ah, good. I was just like, this cannot be real. Who would pay

good money for that? All right, how about this one? Belly button lint. Fake gray cotton candy that resembles belly button fuzz with a sour blue raspberry center. I'm gonna say that's fake. That is fake. I made. Yeah, yeah. Sour flush. A miniature plastic toilet filled with sour candy powder. You dip a candy plunger into the bowl and lick it. Oh, I think that's real. It's like a fun dip, but like in a playful package. I'm gonna say real. That's totally real. It's made by Kids Mania. And my kids love it.

Love it. How about this one? Pickled eyeballs. Gummy eyeballs with a liquid dill pickle flavor center that bursts when bitten. Okay, well, I mean, pickle everything is out there, so I'm gonna say that has to be real. That is not real. Darn, that was a good made up one. George Box of boogers. Sour gummy boogers and flavors including Snotermelon Slime Apple and Sour Green Boogie. I'm gonna say that's real. Kids love a booger joke. Yeah. Flixcandi made this. It's real. All right. Denture chews.

Pink bubblegum pieces that unfold into a full set of edible dentures. That is so fake. That is fake. Formula P. Yellow lemonade flavored sour liquid candy packaged to resemble a urine sample collected at a doctor's office. Gross. No, that's fake. It's real. No. Who. Why does this exist? George, it's made by. Can you imagine that? Yellow lemonade flavored sour liquid candy packaged to resemble a urine sample. Yep.

No, I can't imagine that. Why? Why? Why does this need to exist? Just put it in a regular bottle. That's really gross. Sewer sludge, slurps, chocolate syrup, and tiny plastic drain pipes designed to look like sewage being squeezed into your mouth. Oh, my gosh. Well, on the heels of that, I'm gonna say that has to be real, even though I want it to be fake. We're gonna stop at poop. This is fake. Okay, okay. Well, that's where the line is then, George. Candy urine, totally fine. Candy poop. Eh, I don't know. Pick

and lick Earwax. An oversized edible cotton swab that you dip in earwax colored candy powder. Oh, gross. Now I'm on the Fence. Because we had the toilet plunger, which was also okay. Oh. Oh. I'm, like, right in the middle. I'm gonna say it's fake. It's real. No. Oh, I'm so bad at. Yeah. In 2013, Bon Appetit had a roundup of disgusting Halloween candy, and they featured the Pick and lick earwax. Oh, my gosh. I wonder how many of these still exist of the ones

that are actually real. Toe jam taffy striped taffy combining sweet blueberry and pungent blue cheese flavors. Oh, gross. Did not really need that in my life. I'm gonna say fake. It is fake. I made that one up. Yes. I mean, blue cheese flavored. Gross. Lick your wounds. Candy scabs. Fake adhesive bandages that open to reveal edible pressed sugar candy scabs. Oh, I'm gonna have nightmares. George, that has to be fake. It's real.

No. Oh, my word. Who is thinking this is a good idea? When they're like these? Brainstorm. Meaning, Just imagine sitting there. I know. We need edible scabs made by Cap. Candy, a division of Hasbro. Of course, this is in 2006. You could refill the bandages with more candy scabs if you wanted. I don't. Next up, use tissue chews. Wadded up raspberry taffy with a gooey lemon center made to resemble a used tissue. Come on. I'm going to say fake.

Gosh, you know me so well. It is fake. Finally got one right. But we should invent these used tissue chews. That would be amazing. Oh, my gosh. I mean, like, isn't that, like, every grandma, like, has, like, the used tissues, like, up their sleeve or something, and. It comes in the box of Kleenex, you know, that little square box, and you pull it out and you eat it as you go. I think we need to take a nausea break here, right? Yes, please. I could use a deep breath.

Okay, when we come back, we're talking corn. Candy corn, of course. And later, how did pumpkin spice go from a simple seasonal flavor to full blown national obsession? We're talking to an expert who'll help us make sense of America's pumpkin spice madness. Stick around. All right, we're back with Karla Walsh on this always hangry Halloween special. Do you like candy corn, Karla? I am fully team candy corn. Specifically, if I could choose, I want those Mallow pumpkins because it's like candy corn, but

larger. I want it all. It's straight sugar to my veins. But isn't it, like, super waxy? And it has a weird Chew right? Yes. That's part of the appeal. In the 1880s, George Renninger, a candy maker working at the Wunderle Candy Company in Philadelphia, wanted to capitalize on America's agricultural culture with an innovative three colored candy shaped like a kernel of corn. And then in 1898, the Goelitz Confectionery Company, which eventually became Jelly Belly, began making candy corn. And that helped turn

it into a national product. The candy was sold under the name chicken feed. How do you feel about candy corn, George? I hate it. It's just wax, Sweet, chewy wax that it just doesn't even melt in your mouth. Like that's not worth the calories. It's not. I'll take your candy corn. I do feel like that's one of the more polarizing Halloween candies. That's for sure. Yeah. You know what I like using candy corn for? What's that? I take a hot glue gun and I take a small little white pumpkin and I hot glue all the candy corn around it, facing out the point

facing out. And it looks like pinhead almost. But with candy corn, it's adorable. And then you throw it in the garbage where it belongs. You like it for crafts. Have you seen those recipes where they melt it down and make it kind of like a homemade butterfinger? Oh my gosh, no. I mean, no. Why would you do that? I mean, because butterfingers are delicious and maybe these are the. For the people who don't like candy corn so they can turn it into something else. Okay. Straight in the garbage. Do you know how they're made? No. Fill me in.

Yeah. Originally, workers heated a sugar based mixture, then hand poured the colors in separate stages into kernel shaped molds in starch trays. But today, producing them with a machine called a Mogul, it can create around 8,000 to 15,000 pieces of candy corn per minute. Wow, that is so much more efficient. That would take forever to do individually, but if memory serves, it's been a while since I've had a candy corn. Main ingredients of candy corn, sugar, corn syrup, of course, dextrose, honey, and texturizers. According to the American

Chemical Society, manufacturers polish candy corn with a shellac based coating to give it that glossy appearance. Some candy corn formulations also use carnauba wax, a natural wax derived from the Brazilian palm leaves. I knew it. They were using wax in that. Yeah, it's like the jelly bean coating too. They spin them in like a little. I watched many an episode of Unwrapped back in the day. Do you remember the last time you ate one. Oh, it's probably been like a decade. It's been a. If you find a little jar somewhere that's offering, you don't even put one in your mouth to kind of like, taste it and be like,

I know. I need to get back to it, because maybe it's like one of those things. I tried some, like, Hostess snack cake recently. I was like, wow, the formula has changed. Or my palate has changed. Here are some of the weirder shapes that they've made candy corn out of. The pumpkin jack O Lanterns. Like you said, the little pumpkin ones, they've made a acorn shaped candy corn. Bats, black cats, witches, witches on broomstick, skulls, crossbones, owls, corn cobs, sheaves of wheat, jugs, Santa Claus, snowmen, and Christmas trees, all made out of the worst candy on earth.

You're like, the corn was enough. And now we have all of these iterations. What are you doing? You want to ruin Christmas also? Come on now. In September of this year, Brach's launched Ode to candy corn, a $22 limited edition perfume with notes of vanilla, spun sugar, and honey. Oh, my gosh. That has to just be like one of those shticks, you know, like marketing departments getting a little too creative. I went online to find one to buy one for $22. They're sold out everywhere. But I did find one on eBay for $899.

Oh, come on. I could think of many other uses of $900 that I would prefer. Yes. Buy candy corn and throw it into. The river for the good of the collective. Yes. All right, we're going to play another game of treat or trash Candy corn edition. You ready for this one? I'm ready. Here are some of the flavors that candy corns were made into. Or not. You have to tell me which one's real and which one is fake. That I made up. Okay. I'm going to predict that I'm going to be terrible at this. French onion soup. Candy corn.

Oh, that has to be fake. Yeah, it's fake. Of course it's fake. I was trying to throw you off. Hot dog. Candy corn. I'm gonna say that is real. That is real. And yeah, that's right. Part of Brach's tailgate candy corn collection. Coffee. Candy corn. I'm gonna say that's real. People love coffee. Yeah, it is real. That makes sense. Of course. It tastes like a latte with wax in it. Everything I've ever wanted. Mashed potatoes and gravy. Candy corn. I'm gonna say that's real. Seasonal.

Yes, it's fake. However, Walgreens confirmed that Brach's actually experimented with a mashed potato flavor candy corn, but couldn't get the flavor right, so it was never made. And that's why they're not broke. Pickle juice, candy corn. Okay, on the heels of last time, I'm going to say that this is fake, and then I'm going to be wrong. But it's fake. It's fake. That's right. Phew. Green bean candy corn. I'm gonna say fake. It's real. That's right. One of the six original Thanksgiving

dinner flavors by Brach's. Yes. Somebody intentionally made a vegetable flavored Halloween candy. Wow. So did they, like, have a Thanksgiving mix that was, like, all of the dinner in one bag? Yep. Including ginger glazed carrots. Oh, wow. What about this one? Ranch dressing. Candy corn. Ooh. As a Midwesterner, I'm really on the fence about this because we have ranch everything here. Also. I'm gonna say fake. Yeah, it's fake. That's right. And what about cheeseburger with bacon candy corn? Is that real or fake?

I'm gonna say real. That's fake. Come on. I made that one up. That's an easy one. Sweet potato pie, candy corn. That's real. Of course it is. One of the original Thanksgiving flavors. Like we discussed before. Stuffing, candy corn. That would be really hard to recreate because there's a lot of flavors going on in that. I'm gonna say fake. It's real. Ah. Part of that same mix. That's right. Brach's is trying to do anything we can to ruin Thanksgiving. Hamburger, candy corn. Fake.

That's real. Okay, we just had, like, a cheeseburger with bacon, and that was fake. Come on. Sold in the same tailgate collection as the hot dog. That's right. Ketchup and mustard, candy corn. I'm gonna say real. I guess now in that same package. Man, I'm just throwing you off here. It's fake. Told you I was going to be bad at this game. Roasted turkey, candy corn. Real. Of course it's real. There's Thanksgiving. You can't have Thanksgiving candy corn without roasted turkey. Flavored candy corn. I still don't want it to be real. It doesn't need to exist.

But yeah, I bet you my kids would eat that over the roasted turkey too. That waxy texture is just so appetizing. And finally, macaroni and cheese. Candy corn. If Mac and cheese can be ice cream, it can be candy corn. It's real. That's fake. I made that up. Ah, darn it. I feel like Mac and cheese has been a lot of different things, so why not candy corn at this point? Thanks so much for joining us on this Halloween candy adventure, Karla. Anything you want from this show that we discussed, I'll send it to you for Halloween. What do you think? Anything that you like.

Ooh, I want that caramel apple razor cookie treat. Yes. Next time I come to town. Yes. I like your dark side, Karla. That's awesome. How about you? What can I bring in exchange? Definitely not candy corn. Just anything but candy corn. How about that? Perfect. Sold. Thanks so much for being on the show, Karla. Thank you so much for having me, George.

Up next, we're talking to branding expert Jon Racinskas to find out how pumpkin spice became America's biggest fall obsession and why we keep falling for it year after year right after this. Welcome back. If you've ever wondered how pumpkin spice went from a simple spice blend to a full blown American obsession, you're in luck. Joining us today is Jon Racinskas, creative director, filmmaker, host of the YouTube channel Creative Briefs, and perhaps most importantly, a proud dues paying member of the pumpkin spice

latte army. Jon, welcome to the show. Oh, hi, George. Thanks so much for having me. Jon, first of all, pumpkin spice, how on earth did this become so popular? Where did it all start? Its origins are ancient. Actually, around the 8th century. We're looking at the height of the spice root. And pumpkin spice is a blend of four really important spices to the spice trade. It's simply cinnamon, nutmeg, ginger, and cloves. You know, this

had traded for centuries, and eventually it found its way into American kitchens where it became the unofficial flavor of fall because we started blending it into pumpkin puree and making the ubiquitous Thanksgiving pumpkin pie. Yeah, but we've taken it to a whole different level this day and age. Right. Like, this is not just pumpkin pie anymore. So in 1934, McCormick releases that blend as pumpkin pie spice. And in 2003, a little coffee company out of Seattle takes that

spice blend, throws it in with some milk, and makes the pumpkin spice latte. And here we are 23 years later, still talking about it. There's actually a significant psychological component at play here. I assume this really made it big for Starbucks. Right. And they don't call it like the fall harvest latte. They're calling it pumpkin spice latte. Clearly, there's no pumpkin flavor in there, but it's the spices that you use for pumpkin pieces. Right. I mean, I like where you're going with fall harvest. But

pumpkin spice, those two words are shortcut to nostalgia. Right? This is the flavor of fall, and this predates, you know, Starbucks by a century. And it's almost like Starbucks is like the king of pumpkin spice today. Right? Right. That is the brilliance of Starbucks. And the pumpkin spice latte. Right. We call this manufactured scarcity. They could sell you a pumpkin spice latte in June, but you're not gonna want it. It has meaning and nostalgia attached to it, and that

is only applicable at certain times of year. Do you think there's another spice or flavor that is like this? You know, as I was preparing for this, I was thinking about what could the next pumpkin spice latte be? And I think it's the lavender latte in spring. Right? Come on, think about it. Right? First warm day of spring, lavender cups come out. Four weeks only, and then it's gone. See you next year. And you think people want to drink soap flavored lattes out there?

No. I personally love a good lavender latte almost as much as I love a pumpkin spice latte. Really? There's nothing like pumpkin spice. Nothing. There's really not. It is tying into memory. If you think about that pumpkin pie spice, it conjures up memories of. Of Thanksgiving tables and people that are now long gone. Right. You are paying a premium to tap into this shared nostalgia, and people are willing to pay for it. And that's why, you know, we're seeing

the explosion of pumpkin spice everything. It's because it works. We have taken pumpkin spice to a whole different level, and I started digging deep and finding out some of the pumpkin spice flavors that we've integrated in our foods. So here are some of the crazier products we've sold in the US with pumpkin spice flavor. You ready? I'm ready. Let's do it. Pumpkin Spice spam. In 2019, Hormel came out with a pumpkin spice flavored Spam. That seems like an act of desperation, Right? Would you eat

regular Spam pumpkin spice? Sure. Let's give it a shot. Yeah. Nissin, which is that noodle company, they come up with pumpkin spice cup noodles. Wow. It is one of the more bizarre ones I've seen. Yes. Yeah. Pumpkin spice bacon by Hatfield. Ooh. I could totally buy into that, right? Yeah, totally. Because you do like brown sugar and there's like, these warm spices. Why not, right? Oh, yeah, yeah, yeah. No, it's. It's perfect for it. In 2012, Pringles came out with a pumpkin spice. Pringle chip. Yep.

Okay. Pringles of course. Kraft Foods came up with a pumpkin spice Mac and cheese in 2020. Have you tried it? I will not. It's an experience and didn't hate it. Oh, that's not a positive thing to say. I didn't hate it. Well, because it's pumpkin spice everything. The bar is kind of low. Yeah. And then finally in 2024, 7 11, of course, came up with a pumpkin spice Slurpee. Pumpkin spice latte is a multisensory experience. And its

warmth, I think, is an essential part of a pumpkin spice product that lasts. It has to have a certain multisensory blend. And I don't believe the Slurpee is going to last because it's missing one of those critical components. Well, tell me if some of these non edible pumpkin spice items would, would tickle you. Pumpkin spice trash bags. Hefty sold cinnamon pumpkin spice scented garbage bags in 2023. It sold out in 90 minutes when they released it.

Would you, wouldn't you want your trash can to smell inviting? I guess. Yeah. It to smell like a pumpkin spice latte that's been spilled in the streets of New York City. Sure. Better than the average trash bag left on the streets of New York City. Special Kitty has sold pumpkin spice scented cat litter at Walmart. Do you really want to tempt people with, you know, such delightful flavors on cat litter? Native offered a pumpkin spice latte scented deodorant.

I've seen that. And finally, Dawn released a limited edition pumpkin spice power wash that spray. The power wash spray and pumpkin spice smell. Wait, you're washing your dishes and then you're going to eat something off of it and it smells like pumpkin spice. That's a little bizarre. Yeah. And I think it's, it's, it's, it's sort of defeating the purpose of cleaning your plates. A few pumpkin spice latte seasons ago, Trader Joe's introduced pumpkin spice hummus. I mean, there's chocolate hummus, so I guess why not pumpkin

spice hummus, Right. You know, hummus is a savory food. Right. This is a savory spice blend. It works. What is the next pumpkin spice phenomenon? I think Oreo is great at pointing out where trends could go. So Oreo is releasing all of these limited edition flavors. I don't know if you've tried any of them. There's chicken and waffles. Don't recommend. Oh, God. But one that I would is their deep fried Oreo flavor. Oreo. And it is, for me, it is the flavor of the state fair and the

fact that Oreo is tapping into that might be meaningful. Maybe the flavor of summer is deep fried. I don't know. Can't imagine what that would be like. I mean, this really just shows how hard a job it is being over in the marketing team over at Starbucks, right? Because they're look, you know, they're looking for the next pumpkin spice latte. And so they're floating a whole bunch of really terrible ideas right now. And I'm sure the flavor of deep fried has come up in conversation. Oh, my gosh. Jon Ruscinskas, thank you so much for being on the

show and giving us this insight on pumpkin spice. Thanks so much. I appreciate it. Thanks for having me. And you can learn more about jon@jonracinskas.com, follow him on Instagram on https://www.instagram.com/jonracinskas/ and check out his YouTube channel, Creative Briefs https://www.youtube.com/@Creative_Briefs. That's it for today's show. Make sure you follow us on Spotify, Apple Podcasts or wherever you get your podcasts. And don't forget to follow us on Instagram, TikTok and Facebook at Always Hangry Podcast. And Visit us at alwayshangrypodcast.com for more episodes and all things Always Hangry. Until next time, I'm George

Duran. Stay hungry.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Cheap Turkeys, Thanksgiving Myths & the Butterball Talk-Line

    Nov 17, 202630 minAudio

    Thanksgiving dinner for 10 for under $80? George Duran and Karla Walsh dig into why turkey is so cheap right now. A new Wells Fargo analysis says the classic meal costs a little less than last year, Lidl sold turkey for...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Brian Frange Ranks Your Apples (Sorry, Fuji)

    Nov 10, 202630 minAudio

    Episode Description Why does every apple you ate as a kid taste like "coffee grounds in a leather glove"? With Thanksgiving pies around the corner, George Duran sits down with comedian Brian Frange, the self-proclaimed...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Air Fryers Gone Wild! (And Thanksgiving in a War Zone)

    Nov 3, 202629 minAudio

    Seventy-one percent of American homes now have an air fryer. George Duran owns three - one of them for the beach, powered by a generator. Delish food editor Taylor Ann Spencer bought hers during the pandemic only to...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. '90s Diet Disasters, Cabbage Soup & Asian Food Beyond Takeout

    Oct 20, 202629 minAudio

    Remember when eggs were the enemy, jelly beans were a "fat-free snack," and a seven-day diet told you to eat eight bananas and drink eight glasses of skim milk in one day? George Duran and food and wellness writer Karla...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Side Dish: Pistachio Secrets from Nichols Farms' Jeff Nichols

    Oct 13, 202613 minAudio

    Side Dish is a little different from our regular episodes: no co-host, no rants, no games - just one focused conversation with someone who really knows their food. For the full Always Hangry experience, check out our...

    Credit the people on this episode