Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Always Hangry

Always Hangry artwork

Cheap Turkeys, Thanksgiving Myths & the Butterball Talk-Line

Nov 17, 202630 minAudio

Thanksgiving dinner for 10 for under $80? George Duran and Karla Walsh dig into why turkey is so cheap right now. A new Wells Fargo analysis says the classic meal costs a little less than last year, Lidl sold turkey for a quarter a pound in 2025, and stores are happy to lose money on the bird if you buy everything else from them. Karla also comes clean: the food writer has her Thanksgiving catered. Then the myths. Do you really need to baste? Is white meat healthier? Should you wash your turkey (78% of people do)? And can you trust that little pop-up timer? Plus a round of Foul or Fiction, where Karla has to guess which turkey recipes are real: Mountain Dew-brined, glitter-coated, reheated in the dishwasher, or stuffed with Munchkins and served with coffee gravy. Finally, George calls in to Nicole Johnson, director of the Butterball Turkey Talk-Line. She explains how the hotline works, what to do with a frozen turkey on Thanksgiving morning, the microwave turkey trend, and her mom's secret stuffing ingredient. Then she takes George's questions about butter, in-laws and a 25-pound turkey for four people. Need help this Thanksgiving? Call the Butterball Turkey Talk-Line at 1-800-BUTTERBALL or visit butterball.com. Key Takeaways Thanksgiving dinner got a little cheaper. Wells Fargo puts a traditional dinner for 10 at $78.93, down 0.4% from last year. Turkey is down 0.5%, cranberries 6.6% and frozen vegetables 4.2%; pumpkin pie and gravy mix went up. Turkey is a loss leader. Stores price the bird low to win your whole Thanksgiving basket, which matters this year: in a Harris Poll for Instacart, 74% of Americans said they worry about grocery costs affecting Thanksgiving, and half said turkey is one thing they won't cut back on. Everyone buys a thermometer at the last minute. On Instacart, whole turkeys ran 1,651% above their usual share in Thanksgiving week 2025, and food thermometers jumped more than 3,500% on Thanksgiving Day itself. George owns eight. The meal deals are real. Amazon has a $25 Thanksgiving meal built around an 8-pound Butterball, and Walmart's $35 basket feeds 10 with 26 items. Turkey has rarely been cheaper. Adjusted for inflation, turkey in the 1930s through the 1950s cost several times what it does now. Lidl sold whole turkeys for 25 cents a pound in 2025 with its app. Skip the constant basting. Opening the oven costs heat; George dry-brines instead. Dark meat isn't the villain. It has more vitamins and minerals than white meat; it's just a bit fattier. Don't wash the turkey, or at least be careful. Food safety agencies say washing spreads germs. Karla notes the habit has deep cultural roots for some families; if you do it, avoid splashing and wash your hands well. Don't trust the pop-up timer alone. It pops when a small piece of metal alloy melts, at about 180°F, which is well past the 165°F a turkey needs. Check with a real thermometer. Thawing is the #1 question at Butterball. In a cold-water bath, a 12-pound turkey takes about six hours. Stuffing cooked inside the bird should reach 165°F in the center. There's no butter in a Butterball. The turkeys are pre-brined. Yes, you can microwave a turkey if it's small enough. It won't brown, but it can save the day if the oven breaks. Save the giblets. Nicole's mom chops cooked giblets into her stuffing; George calls them concentrated turkey flavor. When the mother-in-law insists on eight hours: gift her a thermometer and have a good gravy recipe ready. "The mother-in-law is going to win." Hosts want help but don’t ask. Butterball conducted a survery that 85% of Thanksgiving hosts prefer guests to offer help, but only 38% actually ask them to pitch in. People & Companies Mentioned George Duran: host, Always Hangry; chef and TV personality Karla Walsh: food and wellness writer, Level One Sommelier; recurring Always Hangry co-host Nicole Johnson: director, Butterball Turkey Talk-Line; registered dietitian, with the Talk-Line since 2001 Butterball: Turkey Talk-Line (Naperville, Ill.; open Nov. 2 to Dec. 24), Butterball University, Butterball Buddy Butterball Buddy: Butterball’s answer to getting guests to assist, so hosts are not overwhelmed. It's turkey-shaped gadget guests pass around that hands out chores like pouring drinks or helping clean up. The Butterball Buddy is free, but limited in supply, especially around the holiday. Wells Fargo Agri-Food Institute: annual Thanksgiving food cost report Instacart / The Harris Poll: Thanksgiving shopping data and survey Amazon (Amazon Grocery), Walmart, Lidl: Thanksgiving meal deals and turkey prices Costco, McDonald's: mentioned by Karla (rotisserie chicken, Big Mac meal) The Washington Post: cited by George for a 1934 suggestion to serve ham or rib roast instead of turkey (unverified, see checklist) Paula Deen: hit by a tossed ham at an Atlanta charity food drive in 2009 Farm Sanctuary: runs the Adopt a Turkey Project ($35 symbolic adoption) CDC: source of the 78% turkey-washing figure (2020 survey) Kansas State University: cited by George on pop-up timers Reynolds Wrap / Reynolds Kitchens: Mountain Dew, glitter, mac and cheese, dill pickle, 24K truffle, caviar and pasta chip turkey recipes Time: covered a viral Flamin' Hot Cheetos turkey video (2019) CBS Texas / Bear Creek Smokehouse: dishwasher-reheated smoked turkey Boston Magazine / Unwholesome Foods: the TurDunkin' (Coolatta-brined, Munchkin-stuffed turkey) Brands named in the game: Mountain Dew, Froot Loops, Flamin' Hot Cheetos, Nutella, Dunkin', Red Hots, SpaghettiOs Links Guest Butterball Turkey Talk-Line: https://www.butterball.com, 1-800-BUTTERBALL (1-800-288-8372) Mentioned Amazon $25 Thanksgiving Meal: https://www.amazon.com/ThanksgivingMeal Walmart Holiday Meal Basket: https://www.walmart.com/HolidaySavingsBasket Farm Sanctuary Adopt a Turkey: https://shop.farmsanctuary.org/category/Adopt-A-Turkey-Project Always Hangry Website: https://alwayshangrypodcast.com Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/AlwaysHangryPodcast YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@AlwaysHangryPodcast TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@AlwaysHangryPodcast

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

GEORGE DURAN: You write for all these food magazines and you cater your Thanksgiving?! KARLA WALSH: I know how to make all the dishes. GEORGE DURAN: Yeah. I know how to do open-heart surgery, I just choose not to do it. KARLA WALSH: [giggles] GEORGE DURAN: Welcome to the Always Hangry podcast, where we break down the way we eat. The good, the bad, and the completely ridiculous. I'm your host, George Duran. On today's show, we're talking Thanksgiving why turkeys are so cheap. And is Thanksgiving dinner actually getting less expensive? Plus, we'll be busting some of the biggest Thanksgiving food myths.

And later on, we're talking turkey. We've got an expert from the Butterball turkey talk line sharing some of the craziest Thanksgiving emergencies they've handled. Were putting their turkey saving skills to the ultimate test. Joining me now is the only person I know who can find a turkey for 25 cents a pound and still complain that it's overpriced, the deliciously witty Karla Walsh. KARLA WALSH: Goodness, George. I feel pegged. I. Luckily, I haven't had to shop for a turkey in a little while. That's like, outsourced to someone else these past few years.

So I don't even know what the going rate is of a turkey unless I'm writing about it. For a trend story about comparing year over year,. GEORGE DURAN: What do you think is the average price for Thanksgiving dinner for 10 today? KARLA WALSH: Okay, 2026, 10 people? I'll say $150. GEORGE DURAN: Well, it's actually cheaper, believe it or not. KARLA WALSH: Really? GEORGE DURAN: A new Wells Fargo analysis puts a Thanksgiving dinner for 10 at $78.93. KARLA WALSH: What? I was so off. Wait, that is a steal.

That's, like, cheaper than a Big Mac meal at McDonald's. GEORGE DURAN: Yeah, and crazy enough, it's been going down in price. It went down 0.4% from last year. Turkey prices are going down 0.5%. Cranberries, 6.6%, frozen vegetables 4.2%. And the only things that are going up in price are pumpkin pie and gravy mix. KARLA WALSH: Okay, can you make this make sense for me, George? Is this, like, a loss leader category that the grocery stores just, like, eat the difference on? Like, Costco's rotisserie chicken in hopes that

you'll buy all of your other groceries for the week, it's Christmas there. GEORGE DURAN: That's absolutely right. A Harris poll conducted in September for Instacart found 74% are concerned about rising grocery costs affecting Thanksgiving, while 50% say turkey is one item they refuse to cut back on regardless of the price. People are worried about the prices going up, but Thanksgiving, apparently the prices are falling. KARLA WALSH: This is wild, because overall food year over year, costs are going through the roof. So if they can earn your loyalty from that for

the rest of the year, that's actually really smart. GEORGE DURAN: Maybe we should make Thanksgiving every Friday. KARLA WALSH: Would you get sick of it? GEORGE DURAN: I mean, yes, of course. I mean, turkey every Friday. I don't know. I like the fish every Friday already. And it's Vegetarian Mondays. Is that what it is? KARLA WALSH: Meatless Mondays? Yes,. GEORGE DURAN: Meatless Mondays. And then the Taco Tuesdays. KARLA WALSH: Turkey Thursday. GEORGE DURAN: No, no. All the days of the week have already been taken. Don't bring me turkey. And man, who's gonna cook that turkey? You're not cooking it. KARLA WALSH: Right.

We actually get our whole Thanksgiving, or pretty much all of it, catered. GEORGE DURAN: Wait, wait, wait, wait, wait. You write for all of these food magazines and you cater your Thanksgiving? KARLA WALSH: I have zero shame about this. So by the time Thanksgiving rolls around. I've been writing about it since, like, July, so I am, like, over it. And I really would, like, prefer. Let's just get sushi or pizza or something. I don't want to talk about turkey or pie again. And we would rather spend time catching up, playing board games, doing crafts than, you know, stressing over cooking.

So we go to, like, a local, I think it's like catering company, and pick it up. My mom brings her signature pumpkin pie. I bring wine and bread, and we're all set. GEORGE DURAN: Promise me you'll never invite me over for Thanksgiving. KARLA WALSH: I cooked Christmas last year, if that counts. GEORGE DURAN: No, it doesn't. KARLA WALSH: No,. GEORGE DURAN: It does not. KARLA WALSH: I know how to make all of the dishes. I can make them. GEORGE DURAN: Yeah. And I can do open heart surgery. I just don't choose to do it. KARLA WALSH: Good. Okay, tell me about your Thanksgiving prep. Do you have like a whole, like, month long strategy of shopping, prepping, freezing?

GEORGE DURAN: It starts about a month and a half before Thanksgiving. Everybody has something specific that they want for Thanksgiving. And so I've made it the rule that everyone gets one item. One. That's it. KARLA WALSH: Okay, I need to know, George, what's yours? Like? Only one can stay. GEORGE DURAN: I want to order in Thanksgiving. KARLA WALSH: I see you've seen the light. GEORGE DURAN: In 2025, Instacart found that Turkey's share of purchased items surged 1,651% above its usual level. During Thanksgiving week, people are buying more than ever.

But the most messed up thing is that food thermometer purchasing at the Last minute spiked 3,500% on Thanksgiving Day itself. KARLA WALSH: I think it's smart. GEORGE DURAN: I'm sorry, if you're cooking Thanksgiving meal every year, how do you not already have a thermometer? KARLA WALSH: Right? GEORGE DURAN: Ask me how many thermometers I have at home. KARLA WALSH: How many thermometers? GEORGE DURAN: Eight. I have eight thermometers. Meat thermometers. KARLA WALSH: So not everyone has eight. So maybe they, like, had one and, like, it broke. GEORGE DURAN: Call me. I'll. I'll give you one. It's not a problem. KARLA WALSH: Okay. George will put his number in the show notes.

GEORGE DURAN: I will not. Speaking of deals, there are some insane Thanksgiving meal deals out there. Today Amazon has an entire Thanksgiving dinner for 24. KARLA WALSH: Wait, how many people? GEORGE DURAN: It's for a family of six. KARLA WALSH: Shut up. GEORGE DURAN: It's a Thanksgiving meal bundle featuring an eight pound turkey, sides and dessert, ingredients. KARLA WALSH: Remarkably cheap. GEORGE DURAN: Walmart also has something a Thanksgiving meal for 10 people for $35. The bundle has 26 items, including a Butterball turkey, mashed potatoes, stuffing, cranberry sauce, creamy

casserole, potato casserole, rolls, and pumpkin pie ingredients. KARLA WALSH: I mean, you mentioned a Butterball brings up the turkey hotline. Have you ever called George? GEORGE DURAN: I have never called and secretly I would like to be an operator at the Butterball Turkey. KARLA WALSH: I think you'd be such a good host for the calls. You'd have answers for everything. Yes. GEORGE DURAN: Well, we're going to talk to the Butterball turkey talk line representative at the end of the show and I will ask for that. By the way, can you guess which decade turkey was the cheapest per pound?

KARLA WALSH: Are we talking inflation relative? GEORGE DURAN: Yes,. KARLA WALSH: In today's dollars. Let's say 1980. GEORGE DURAN: It's this decade right now. KARLA WALSH: This is wild. GEORGE DURAN: In the 1930s, 40s and 50s, turkey was between seven and eight dollars a pound in today's money. And last year, Lidl, the supermarket chain, was selling turkey at 25 cents a pound. KARLA WALSH: This is bananas. GEORGE DURAN: Cheaper than bananas, by the way. In 1934, the Washington Post suggested serving ham or standing rib roast as a cheaper alternative to turkey. They lure you in with the price of the cheap or free turkey, practically.

So you can buy all the side dish ingredients for more money. KARLA WALSH: Yeah, side dish and then some, because you're probably hosting people throughout the weekend. GEORGE DURAN: And I wouldn't recommend a ham either because it can physically hurt you. KARLA WALSH: Physically? GEORGE DURAN: Yeah. Don't you remember in 2009, just three days before Thanksgiving, a charity food distribution event in Atlanta? Paula Deen was there helping unload donated hams when a volunteer accidentally threw one back at her, striking her square in the face. KARLA WALSH: My God. Threw a ham at her. Oh. There are better ways to resolve disagreements.

I mean, I know she said some things, but. GEORGE DURAN: Have you not seen the video? KARLA WALSH: No. GEORGE DURAN: She got knocked out. KARLA WALSH: Oh, no. So at least it wasn't on purpose. GEORGE DURAN: She was fine afterwards, by the way. And she joked about the incident. She said, I haven't met a ham that couldn't stop me yet. In 2021, a California auto parts salvage company came up with what might be the worst Thanksgiving marketing campaign imaginable. You buy auto part, and then you get to chase a live turkey around the junkyard, and if you catch it, you take it home for 25 cents. KARLA WALSH: Oh, my God. So it was like a rodeo.

GEORGE DURAN: Animal Control Authority stopped the promotion, and before it started, they almost had criminal charges against them, and now they were stuck with 320 live turkeys. KARLA WALSH: There's a lot of steps that they're skipping throughout this process. GEORGE DURAN: By the way, those turkeys, they ended up going to adopt a turkey program. Do you know what that is? KARLA WALSH: Oh, I love that. No. Educate me. GEORGE DURAN: The Adopt a Turkey project is a Thanksgiving tradition run by Farm Sanctuary. Instead of buying a turkey to eat for Thanksgiving, you can symbolically adopt one and help support its care. You get to know your turkey, including its name, photo, personality.

Your donation pays for the food, shelter, veterinary care, and the turkey stays alive. It lives at the sanctuary instead of ending up at someone's Thanksgiving table. KARLA WALSH: You know how when you fly on a plane, you can, like, offset the carbon emissions? Do they have, like, turkey offsets? Like, we're adding one to our table, we're adding two to our table. I'm going to adopt two turkeys or something like that. GEORGE DURAN: And just like the carbon offset, I think this is a scam. KARLA WALSH: Tell me how you really feel, George. GEORGE DURAN: Like a horse. I understand. A dog, of course. A turkey. KARLA WALSH: Yeah.

It's just ethically tricky. GEORGE DURAN: I'm going to start a salmon sanctuary and just ask people to send me money. KARLA WALSH: Amazing. I would love to get photos of your salmon. GEORGE DURAN: I'll just send the same photo to everybody, and they'll have no idea. So you're telling me that if I showed up to your dinner party and there's no turkey, instead you. You've given 35 bucks, by the way, to save a turkey's life, and instead you're serving tofurkey. KARLA WALSH: No, what I'm saying is if you could still eat a turkey, but then just adopt a turkey and even it out. That's how offsets work. GEORGE DURAN: Oh, so you're killing the turkey's brother or sister?

KARLA WALSH: Well, I mean, it's coming to net zero, so it's better than negative one. GEORGE DURAN: All right, when we come back, we're busting some of the biggest Thanksgiving food myths and playing a Game of Foul or fiction? And later on, we're calling the Butterball Turkey talk line. To find out if there's any turkey disaster they can't fix. Don't go anywhere. All right. We're back with Karla Walsh. Karla, here are some Thanksgiving myths that we can talk about. Turkey needs constant basting.

KARLA WALSH: No, no. Because you shouldn't be opening your oven door that often. GEORGE DURAN: The better method, dry brine in advance. And that's what I do. I dry brine my turkey. KARLA WALSH: Perfect. GEORGE DURAN: White meat is healthier than dark meat. KARLA WALSH: I think that they both have qualities, but there's a lot more micronutrients, vitamins, and minerals in the dark meat. Right. It's just a little fattier. GEORGE DURAN: Damn, you're such a nutritionist. Nerd. Thanksgiving myth number three. Wash your turkey before you cook it. KARLA WALSH: No. But I have written stories about how this really has cultural ties to people that mean a lot.

So do whatever is comfortable for your family, but just be very careful not to splatter the the meat juices and wash your hands very, very well before and after. And you're saying? GEORGE DURAN: Absolutely. A 2020 US consumer survey cited by the CDC found that 78% of participants reported washing or rinsing turkey before cooking it. That's insane. KARLA WALSH: I learned a lot from a food historian that I interviewed that it has a lot of ties into people who like, had worked in slavery situations and they were giving food, given food from their masters.

And so they weren't sure or like if they could trust it or if it was safe or how clean it was. And so like, it has these really deep roots for people. GEORGE DURAN: That's fascinating. I didn't know about that. KARLA WALSH: I know, I know. I've learned so much working on that story. GEORGE DURAN: Myth number four, you can trust the little pop up turkey timer. Kansas State University explains that properly manufactured pop up timers can be accurate within 1 to 2 degrees Fahrenheit. But their placement matters. And you should still verify the bird with a conventional thermometer. The pop up timer is almost like a joke.

KARLA WALSH: Does anybody actually trust that? I thought it was just kind of for looks. GEORGE DURAN: You go to the butcher and like make sure it has a pop up timer. I'm not buying it otherwise. So how does the pop up timer work? Do you know? KARLA WALSH: No. Is it like a pressure or something? Like moisture levels? GEORGE DURAN: Inside the plastic housing there is a spring loaded stem. It's held down by a little bit of a metal alloy that can melt with heat. And as the turkey cooks, the heat travels through the timer's housing and warms the metal. At 180 degrees Fahrenheit.

The alloy melts and releases the stem. And then out pops this plastic stem, signaling that the turkey has reached the timer's trigger temperature. KARLA WALSH: Is nobody worried about this? In this age when we're talking about, like, microwaving things in plastic and using plastic utensils, like,. GEORGE DURAN: It's too late. There's so much plastic in us, what does it matter if you put a little pop up in there? I think my biggest gripe is that it's popping up at 180 degrees Fahrenheit. And if you serve me a turkey breast that has been cooked to 180 degrees Fahrenheit, I will leave the table.

Okay, we're gonna play a little game. It's called Foul or Fiction. KARLA WALSH: If history teaches me anything, I'm really bad at your games, George. GEORGE DURAN: That's why it's so much fun to do it with you. I'll tell you a method of cooking turkey, and you need to tell me if someone actually cooked it this way and developed a recipe for it or. Or if I just made it up. KARLA WALSH: Got it. GEORGE DURAN: Mountain Dew Turkey Turkey brined overnight in Mountain Dew water salt and then roast it. KARLA WALSH: Yep. I'm going to say they've done that. GEORGE DURAN: Hell yeah, they have. Reynolds Wrap has created that recipe. And, boy, these guys are proud of it, too.

KARLA WALSH: I see the connection where they went down this road. I just don't know if I fully agree with them. Brining it. GEORGE DURAN: Cool. You can have my share. KARLA WALSH: Deal. GEORGE DURAN: Froot Loops Turkey. Turkey basted with melted grape jelly and coated in crushed Froot Loops. KARLA WALSH: I hope that's not true. No, they haven't done that. GEORGE DURAN: They haven't done that. No. Flaming hot Cheetos turkey. KARLA WALSH: 100%. GEORGE DURAN: In fact, they have. In 2019, there was a very viral video covered by Time magazine about it. Nutella turkey Turkey slathered in Nutella and coated with crushed pretzels.

KARLA WALSH: No,. GEORGE DURAN: No, I made that up. You're good. Phew. You're getting good at this. KARLA WALSH: Yes. GEORGE DURAN: Dill pickle turkey Turkey brined in pickle juice, rubbed with dill pickle butter and served with pickle gravy. KARLA WALSH: 100%. That has to be true. People love pickle. Everything. GEORGE DURAN: That's true. Reynolds Wrap invented it this year. Dishwasher turkey. An already cooked packaged smoked turkey reheated in a dishwasher. KARLA WALSH: Oh, I think I have heard about this. Yes. I'm gonna say that actually happened. GEORGE DURAN: It did happen.

CBS Texas covered it. Of course. Texas Glitter Turkey Turkey roasted and finished with edible pink glitter. KARLA WALSH: Mm. I'm gonna say. Ooh, I wish it wasn't True. But I think that it is. GEORGE DURAN: They sure did. KARLA WALSH: Yes. Okay. I'm, like, batting 100. GEORGE DURAN: Yeah. Reynolds Wrap in 2018 made this garbage can turkey Turkey cooked outdoors beneath an upside down metal trash and heated with charcoal. KARLA WALSH: I'm gonna say somebody did that. GEORGE DURAN: Sure did.

KARLA WALSH: I hope it was a new trash can. GEORGE DURAN: I hope so too. Cotton candy Turkey Turkey wrapped in cotton candy and roasted until the sugar melts into a glaze. KARLA WALSH: I know that cannot be true. GEORGE DURAN: It is not true. But my kids would love it. How about this? Dunkin Donuts Turkey Turkey brined and Dunkin Coolattas stuffed with munchkins and served with coffee gravy. KARLA WALSH: No, that can't be true. GEORGE DURAN: It is true. KARLA WALSH: No, it was doing so well.

GEORGE DURAN: Boston magazine had a recipe for TurDunkin. KARLA WALSH: Oh, clever. GEORGE DURAN: No, this is not clever. This is disgusting. Mac and cheese Turkey Turkey rubbed with powdered macaroni and cheese seasoning and served with macaroni and cheese. KARLA WALSH: Yeah, I bet that totally exists. GEORGE DURAN: That's another Reynolds recipe. See? How about this one? Red Hots Turkey Turkey injected with cherry cola and blended cinnamon Red Hots candies. KARLA WALSH: Oh, please say this isn't true. I hate Red Hots. GEORGE DURAN: This is not true. KARLA WALSH: Ugh. Good.

Red Hots and Fireball are like two of the worst things to ever happen to this planet. GEORGE DURAN: 24 Karat Gold Turkey roasted turkey decorated with black truffles and edible 24 karat gold. KARLA WALSH: Yes, I'm saying that that does exist, but I don't think it would be at today's prices that we were talking about earlier. GEORGE DURAN: Yes, it does exist. Reynold's Wrap invented it again. How about this one? Caviar turkey Turkey served with black caviar, creme fraiche and potato chips. KARLA WALSH: Totally. I bet this absolutely exists. GEORGE DURAN: Sure does.

Pasta chip turkey turkey coated with parmesan cheese and crunchy pasta chips. KARLA WALSH: I would say yes, I think that does exist. But why don't we just use potato chips? GEORGE DURAN: I don't know. Because Reynolds Wrap wants to get that shock value, so. Yes, it's real. KARLA WALSH: Okay. Yes, keep going, Reynolds. They have all the ideas. GEORGE DURAN: And finally, SpaghettiOs Turkey marinated in ranch dressing and stuffed with canned Spaghettios. Come on, get this right, Karla,. KARLA WALSH: You. GEORGE DURAN: Got this. KARLA WALSH: I'm gonna say this does not exist.

GEORGE DURAN: Correct. It does not exist. I made that one up. KARLA WALSH: Yes. I only missed one. I think this time that's a new record for me. I usually am, like, less than 50%. GEORGE DURAN: But also, you're covering a lot of these news stories, aren't you? KARLA WALSH: Not so much about Wacky turkeys. GEORGE DURAN: Okay. All right, Karla, thanks so much for joining us. We look forward to the next time. KARLA WALSH: Such a treat, George. Thanks again for having me. GEORGE DURAN: All right, when we come back, we're talking turkey with Nicole Johnson from the famous Butterball turkey talk line. She's heard just about every Thanksgiving disaster imaginable.

But is she ready for my questions? Stick around. Welcome back. Our guest today has been talking Turkey for over 20 years. She started at the Butterball turkey talk line while studying nutrition and dietetics, and 22 seasons later, she's heard just about every turkey disaster imaginable. Joining us today is Nicole Johnson, director of the legendary Butterball turkey talk line. Nicole, thanks so much for being on the show. NICOLE JOHNSON: George, thanks for having us. And thanks for talking turkey with us today. We appreciate it. GEORGE DURAN: How does one become the director of the Butterball turkey talk line?

NICOLE JOHNSON: Well, like you said, I have over 20 seasons under my belt. This is a seasonal position for all of us. But when we're looking for a turkey talk line expert, we look for someone who has a food passion. They love to help consumers, but from an education standpoint, they'll have a culinary degree. We have a lot of registered dietitians, food stylists, food scientists, culinary instructors, you name it. We all bring a little something different to the table. And we all work Thanksgiving week.

And yes, we all do work Thanksgiving day. GEORGE DURAN: So is there, like, command central, like, you know, you have all these, like, operators working together in the office, or can they just take the call from home? NICOLE JOHNSON: You know, the last several years, we have offered both. You can work here in the Naperville, Illinois, office, or we do have remote work from home, home options, which is nice as well. We have nearly 60 men and women that are manning the phones, email, chat, text, and of course, we're on social media as well.

GEORGE DURAN: That's crazy. And so when does this start exactly? When does. When do the doors open? When I can start calling into the turkey hotline? NICOLE JOHNSON: Yeah, the first Monday of November. So this year was November 2nd. We're open the weekend before Thanksgiving. We're open all of Thanksgiving week, Thanksgiving Day, of course, and then Christmas Eve is the last day of operation. So December 24th. GEORGE DURAN: So this is not just for Thanksgiving. NICOLE JOHNSON: No, Thanksgiving is our busiest time. But we get a lot of tricky questions leading up to the Christmas holiday as well. GEORGE DURAN: Yeah.

So there is such a thing. I read there's a Butterball University. Is there like a final exam that you have to take and how does that work? Is there really a physical university? NICOLE JOHNSON: Yeah, so we do. We call it Butterball University or Butterball U. Um, and we teach all of our new incoming freshmen, years one and two, everything they need to know about a Butterball turkey. Everything from A to Z. And I tell you what, George, I've sat through that training many, many times. And I always walk away saying to myself, you know, just when I thought I knew it all, I walk away with just a little something extra.

So it's a wonderful training. GEORGE DURAN: So what do you tell someone who has a frozen turkey on Thanksgiving morning? NICOLE JOHNSON: Well, we ask them what size turkey it is. GEORGE DURAN: Okay. NICOLE JOHNSON: If it's a 12 pound turkey and they're calling us early enough and we are open as early as 6am Central, a 12 pound turkey is going to take six hours using that cold water bath. If they can even start to thaw the turkey using that cold water bath a couple hours. Give it a little bit of a jump start, if you will. That's ideal. But regardless, if you have a fully thawed turkey, you know, partially frozen, which is not totally ideal, you

do want to use your meat thermometer to check for doneness. GEORGE DURAN: But you're not just answering questions about turkey, right? NICOLE JOHNSON: Well, that the thawing is certainly our number one question. How to roast, how to test for doneness. Those are the most popular questions. But you're right, sometimes we get questions on a side dish. GEORGE DURAN: Yeah, but I can't call in for like stock advice or dating advice or anything like that. NICOLE JOHNSON: Well, I'm not one to talk on the stocks or dating advice, but we certainly try to help you with cooking related questions and making your Thanksgiving memorable.

GEORGE DURAN: And nothing about how to deal with your in laws during Thanksgiving. There's gotta be some other help that you can give us. NICOLE JOHNSON: Well, we've gotten a couple phone calls like that. You know, you always know it's gonna be interesting when you answer the phone call. Thanks for calling Butterball Turkey talk line. Nicole speaking. How can I help you? And you're on speakerphone. And right then and there, you know, there might be a crowd full of people. Maybe it's a husband and wife, you know, kind of bickering, who's right, who's wrong. So a lot of times we're the ones that will give the right answer. GEORGE DURAN: Are you then not cooking Thanksgiving meal every year because you're too busy answering calls?

NICOLE JOHNSON: Well, for the most part I do, I work alongside my 60 experts here. I'm here 6am to 6pm Central waiting for your, your phone call. But what's nice about the talk line is we Want to make sure that we are serving and nourishing and hydrating all of us who are taking phone calls so we have our own little Friendsgiving here. GEORGE DURAN: I love it. I love it. Is there the weirdest place that someone's cook their turkey that you've heard of? NICOLE JOHNSON: I think the ones that really stand out to me are the college students.

A couple years ago, there was a big social media kind of frenzy. People were wanting to cook their turkey in the microwave. And believe it or not, so long as it's small enough, you can. It's a tedious process. It's more of a moisty cook method. So you may not necessarily get that beautiful golden brown that we would in the oven, but you can prepare your turkey in the microwave. PEOPLE CHUCKLE but if they find out that their oven is broken the day of and they don't have, you know, an outdoor grill or they don't have a neighbor that they can borrow their oven, sometimes the microwave is, might be the only, the only solution.

GEORGE DURAN: What, what do I need to do to get on the turkey talk line? Because it sounds like it's the perfect job for me. And honestly, I would do it for turkey. I wouldn't do it for, for money. I would do it in exchange for some turkey. NICOLE JOHNSON: Well, you have to have a food, nutrition or dietetic background and you have to love helping people. You have to love helping consumers. And George, you gotta give me at least eight or nine hours of your time on Thanksgiving Day. GEORGE DURAN: Have you guys ever thought about doing keeping this all year long for all kinds of foods? NICOLE JOHNSON: I would absolutely love that.

I think it would really be a lot of fun. I mean, we, to your point, Butterball is the trusted resource, you know, particularly when it comes to turkey. So we would love that. GEORGE DURAN: And you're not hanging up on people because they haven't purchased a Butterball turkey, right? NICOLE JOHNSON: Absolutely not. And I will tell you, the callers over the years, they're almost sheepish at first. I don't have a Butterball turkey. Can you still help me? Absolutely. I'm not the expert on X, Y and Z brand, but let me see what I can do for you. GEORGE DURAN: Amazing. Do you have any generational advice that has been passed down from your parents, grandparents to you? NICOLE JOHNSON: Well, because I have worked here at the Talk line for 20 plus years.

My folks always host Thanksgiving for my four kids. And the big question is to stuff or not to stuff. And it's about family tradition. Right. And so my mom growing up has always stuffed our turkey. We just wanna make sure if you wanna stuff your turkey? Of course, you're using that meat thermometer to test for doneness. The stuffing's gonna register 165 in the center of the stuffing when your turkey is done. GEORGE DURAN: Okay, and your favorite stuffing, what would that be? NICOLE JOHNSON: Oh, well, I'm gonna give away my mom's secret, but she actually cooks up the giblets and chops them very finely and puts it into her stuffing, and she is certain that's what gives it its flavor.

And let me tell you, George, I didn't know that for so many years until I started working here. And I was telling my mom that we were learning about the giblets, and she said, well, Nicole, I have to tell you something. Come to find out. That's what she's been doing. It's delicious. GEORGE DURAN: It's amazing how many people throw away their giblets because they're scared of it. They think it's some, like, weird organ. It is like, concentrated turkey flavor, especially if you, like, fry it or saute it. The giblets are all the flavors in the giblets. For some reason,. NICOLE JOHNSON: My mom agrees. She certainly does. Yes. GEORGE DURAN: I recently received something called the Butterball diploma, buddy.

It's like this device. Can you tell me what. What am I supposed to do with this? NICOLE JOHNSON: So Butterball conducted a survey, and they found that it's wonderful to hear. 85% of cooks still plan on having Thanksgiving, but that same percentage of hosts find it daunting. But they don't want to ask others for help. But it's a lot of stress, so it's okay to ask for help. So Butterball created the first of its kind retro notification device. It's turkey shaped, and it's adorable because it's a great way for

the host, for us that are taking on so much to pass on to their guests. And it's four actionable time frames. And it will say, help the host pour drinks, greet the hosts at the door, help with cleanup. It's a wonderful way to get everybody involved. And it's just another way that Butterball is really bringing more to the table. It's sort of an extension, if you will, of our advice of the talk line. GEORGE DURAN: Is there an instruction for mowing the lawn, perhaps? NICOLE JOHNSON: Now you're talking.

Now you're talking. I need to ask my sons to go and do that. GEORGE DURAN: All right, So I want to pretend I'm calling you with a few questions, and I want you to answer the call, and then I'm going to ask you all these questions and see how well, you can answer them for me. You ready? NICOLE JOHNSON: Let's do it. Thanks for calling Butterball Turkey Talk Line. Nicole speaking. How can I help you? GEORGE DURAN: Hi, Nicole. How much butter is too much butter for Thanksgiving? And at what point does the turkey officially become a butter delivery system? NICOLE JOHNSON: Oh, goodness. Well, I will tell you that yes, the Butterball turkey does have Butterball in the name.

But there's actually no butter in the Butterball turkey. It has been pre brined for enhanced juiciness and tenderness. So if you want to use butter, you can, but it's not required. GEORGE DURAN: Another question for you. My brother in law is allergic to poultry but insists on sitting next to the Butterball turkey. How far away should I seat him? And does the turkey need to wear a mask? NICOLE JOHNSON: Oh, my goodness. Well, I tell you, there's a lot of dietary restrictions out there. Best for him to consult with his doctor. But he can certainly give us a call at 1-800-Butterball and we can talk him through anything. GEORGE DURAN: I love it.

My mother in law insists on cooking the turkey for eight hours because that's how her mother did it. How do I tell her she's wrong without ruining Thanksgiving or my marriage? NICOLE JOHNSON: Now that's a tough one. GEORGE DURAN: I stumped you. Finally,. NICOLE JOHNSON: You may be able to gift your mother in law a thermometer and tell her you certainly don't want to overcook the turkey. You don't want a dry turkey. But George, if you're a smart man, the mother in law is going to win. You may need a good gravy recipe to help with that. Dry. GEORGE DURAN: Turkey. I like that. All right. I accidentally bought a 25 pound turkey, but there are only four of us for Thanksgiving.

How many days can I serve leftovers before it legally qualifies as psychological torture? NICOLE JOHNSON: A 25 pound turkey is music to my ears because who doesn't love the leftovers? Two to three days in the refrigerator. And for longer storage, let's put it in the freezer for two months. GEORGE DURAN: Okay. Sounds like you're very opinionated about turkey. I like that. Nicole, finally, my wife wants to deep fry the turkey, my father in law wants to smoke it, and my mother in law insists on roasting it. Can I cut the turkey into three pieces or should I just call a divorce attorney? NICOLE JOHNSON: Well, I'm not sure about the attorney, but my advice would

be those are three wonderful cook methods and I would purchase three turkeys. And if you give us a call, we can talk you through deep frying, open pan and smoking. We have advice for all of that. Certainly give us a call. GEORGE DURAN: I love it. Boy, you have an answer for everything, and I love that you're doing this. But you probably never get tired of talking turkey, right? NICOLE JOHNSON: No, I don't. And a lot of people will say, you've been there for 20 years. What keeps you here? First and foremost, I love the iconic brand. I also love the team that we have behind us. Some of these folks are some of my best friends

and friendships that we're about talking 20 years. So it's a wonderful position, to your point. And we, we do love talking turkey. GEORGE DURAN: Well, thank you, Nicole, so much for being here. We really appreciate it. I can't wait to call into the talk line and hopefully get you again. NICOLE JOHNSON: All right, George, thanks for talking turkey. Happy Thanksgiving. GEORGE DURAN: Thank you, Nicole Johnson, director of the legendary Butterball turkey talk line. And if you need a little turkey emergency assistance this Thanksgiving, you can call 1-800-butterball or visit butterball.com for all the questions, tips, and tricks you need to save your holiday feast.

That's it for today's show. Tune in next week for another Thanksgiving episode packed with more food, fun, and plenty of surprises. And don't forget to subscribe. Follow us on social media and check out alwayshangrypodcast.com for more. I'm George Duran. Until next time, stay hungry.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Brian Frange Ranks Your Apples (Sorry, Fuji)

    Nov 10, 202630 minAudio

    Episode Description Why does every apple you ate as a kid taste like "coffee grounds in a leather glove"? With Thanksgiving pies around the corner, George Duran sits down with comedian Brian Frange, the self-proclaimed...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Air Fryers Gone Wild! (And Thanksgiving in a War Zone)

    Nov 3, 202629 minAudio

    Seventy-one percent of American homes now have an air fryer. George Duran owns three - one of them for the beach, powered by a generator. Delish food editor Taylor Ann Spencer bought hers during the pandemic only to...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Razor Blades in Apples, Candy Corn Conundrum & Pumpkin Spice Everything

    Oct 28, 202629 minAudio

    Has anyone ever actually found a razor blade in a Halloween apple? George Duran and food and wellness writer Karla Walsh dig into America's favorite Halloween scare: where the razor-blade apple hoax stories came from...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. '90s Diet Disasters, Cabbage Soup & Asian Food Beyond Takeout

    Oct 20, 202629 minAudio

    Remember when eggs were the enemy, jelly beans were a "fat-free snack," and a seven-day diet told you to eat eight bananas and drink eight glasses of skim milk in one day? George Duran and food and wellness writer Karla...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Side Dish: Pistachio Secrets from Nichols Farms' Jeff Nichols

    Oct 13, 202613 minAudio

    Side Dish is a little different from our regular episodes: no co-host, no rants, no games - just one focused conversation with someone who really knows their food. For the full Always Hangry experience, check out our...

    Credit the people on this episode