I first released this podcast back in June to my paid subscribers only. It originally held the title “Flashbacks: The Toxic Burden of Memory in Israel”. Given the ongoing conflict in Gaza, this week I am releasing it more generally, because even if a peace deal is struck, this tragedy is not going away any time soon. This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit keithlowe.substack.com/subscribe
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Over the past year and a half, I've been watching the war in Gaza with great sadness.
SPEAKER_00What's happening there is such a tragedy. I have family in Israel and they, like me, keep asking why. How on earth did we get to the point where both sides seem to be following a path of perpetual war? I have no answers to this. All I can do is to offer you a story. It's the story of an Israeli novelist called Aharon Appelfeld. When I was researching my book on how World War II changed the world,
SPEAKER_00I went to Jerusalem specifically to interview Mr Appelfeld. He was an incredible man, gentle, passionate, very softly spoken. The conversation that I had with him was one of the most compelling conversations I think I've ever had. Anyhow, this is the story that he told me, which might shed some kind of light on the current conflict, at least from an Israeli point of view. Aharon Appelfeld was born in 1932 in the city of Cernovitz,
SPEAKER_00in the northern borderlands of Romania. He was originally given the name Ervin, a good German name, although everybody knew that his family was Jewish. When the German army swept through Romania in 1941, he was just nine years old. He was staying in his grandparents' house in the Carpathian Mountains when he suddenly heard shooting. He called out for his parents, but then there was more shooting and he realised it was coming from inside the
SPEAKER_00house. So he jumped out of the window and went and hid in the cornfield outside. From where he was hiding, he could hear his mother screaming. The Nazis were in his house, they murdered his mother and his grandmother, but there was nothing he could do about it. At some point during that day, his father came back, came and found him, and they went home together to Chernowitz. But being Jews, of course, they were then forced into a ghetto.
SPEAKER_00After a few months, they were put into cattle trugs, and expelled to Transnistria and finally forced marched to a makeshift concentration camp in Ukraine. This forced march he remembers as yet another extremely traumatic event. It was the end of autumn and for two weeks they marched through mud and torrential rain. I was lucky, he told me. My father was strong and he carried me on his shoulders. Most children and old people died along the way.
SPEAKER_00At the concentration camp, he was separated from his father, who was sent off, sent away to work with all the other men somewhere else. After a few days on his own, he looked around himself and realised that the only people who had been left behind were the weak and the dying. He understood instinctively that if he stayed here, he would never survive. So he took a chance. He slipped under the fence and ran away.
SPEAKER_00The first place that he hid was in the forest. He lived for a while by eating rotting apples and berries, but when the rains became worse and the nights got longer, he realised that he had to find shelter. So he began knocking on doors in the villages, asking for work, but nobody wanted to take in a nine-year-old boy of dubious origins. Eventually, a woman took pity on him and let him in.
SPEAKER_00She turned out to be the local prostitute. All through that winter, he worked as her servant, milking the cow, cleaning her hut, going to the local village to buy food for her and her clients. And in the evenings, he would watch her drink vodka, service the local peasants and then fight with them when they refused to pay. I only ever finished grade one at school, he told me. That was grade two.
SPEAKER_00Then one day, one of her clients accused him of being a Jew. "'What are you doing here, you bloody Jew?' he said. At that moment, he knew that it was time to move on. So he ran away to the forest again, where he found refuge with a gang of thieves.' For a while he stayed with them and helped them to steal horses. He was small so they could post him through the window of a stable and then he would drop down and open the doors for them.
But soon the thieves also began to ask questions of him, so he moved on once again.
SPEAKER_00For two years this short, undernourished child moved from place to place, surviving on little more than his wits and sheer luck. Eventually, in 1944, the Red Army swept through the Ukraine and Appelfeld got swept along with them. He persuaded a supply unit to give him work as a kitchen boy and watched as they made their way from village to village, raping and killing as they went. At the end of the war, he found his way into a displaced persons camp.
He was adopted by some Jewish soldiers who smuggled him across the Mediterranean to Haifa.
SPEAKER_00But even now, he was still only 13 years old. Aharon Appelfeld relived these experiences over and over again throughout his life. When I met him in 2016, he told me that he still had flashbacks, sometimes a sudden noise or that the feeling of damp shoes would awaken a sudden burst of inexplicable fear within him. Sometimes he had nightmares or woke up in the middle of the night feeling
SPEAKER_00ravenously hungry, just like he felt during the war. When he first came to Israel, these things were not viewed with much sympathy. The sabras on the kibbutz that first took him in didn't want him to be a victim. They wanted him to be tough, strong, heroic, just like them. They wanted him to forget his past, erase it, build a new life on its ruins. They made him change his name from Ervin to Aharon, a nice Hebrew name.
SPEAKER_00They stopped him from speaking in German or Ukrainian or Russian, all of the language that had kept him alive in Europe, and they made him speak Hebrew instead. He tried his best to forget his past and move on, but the nightmares kept coming. All my experience in Europe became like a cellar, he told me. A dark cellar buried deep inside me. You do not need to be Freud to understand that such a cellar is
a dangerous thing.
SPEAKER_00What saved him, he said, was learning to write fiction. Other people just went crazy, he told me, but I was lucky. I was a writer. And if you've ever read any of Aharon Appelfeld's novels, you will find them peppered with stories about prostitutes and orphans and gangs of thieves, all of whom are based upon the people he met during the war. He recycled the events of his childhood again and again and again, not because he wanted to,
SPEAKER_00but because he had to, because there was no escaping his past. Now, Stories like this, when there are enough of them, have a communal effect on society. Israel saw a massive influx of people just like Aharon Appelfeld after the war. In the space of just a few years, nearly three quarters of a million foreign Jews arrived, more than doubling the country's population.
SPEAKER_00In Israel, they call it the cloudburst, The influx of people was so huge and so sudden that Israel changed almost overnight from being a nation of heroes and pioneers to being a nation of refugees and victims. Now, imagine what it must have been like for all of those refugees. They've just fled persecution in Europe and the Middle East and come to a country that's supposed to be a safe haven for them.
SPEAKER_00But Israel isn't a safe haven. The first thing that happened when Israel became a country in 1948 was a massive war, both a civil war and a war against its neighbours. Aaron Appelfeld put it thus. In Europe, there was a war with a lot of killing. Now in Israel, there was a war with a lot of killing. In the mind of a refugee, What was the difference between this and the horrors of the
Second World War?
SPEAKER_00Now, if the violence had ended in 1948, then perhaps Israel might have had the chance to become a normal country, whatever that is. But it didn't end then. Israel has been at war with its neighbours in every decade since. There's no sense of safety in Israel. Life in Israel is a permanent war. That was one of the first things that Appelfeld said to me when I interviewed him. Life is a permanent war.
SPEAKER_00Is it any wonder then that, just as Aharon Appelfeld had flashbacks to the Second World War, so too does his country. Every time that Israel goes to war, the whole community becomes immersed in memories of the Holocaust. during the Sinai War, the Six-Day War, the Yom Kippur War. All of these were accompanied by an atmosphere of existential panic. In 1982,
Menachem Begin justified his invasion of Lebanon by saying that the alternative to
SPEAKER_00this operation is Treblinka. Even today, Benjamin Netanyahu is constantly telling his people that they are about to be annihilated. We can argue about how much of this is just political rhetoric, but we can't argue with the very real fears that lie behind it. Just as Aharon Appelfeld recycled his past again and again and again, so Israel as a nation does the same.
The Holocaust is always there, in the background, whether they like it or not. It's not only Israel that experiences communal flashbacks to the war like this.
SPEAKER_00Of course not. Lots of other countries do the same. Russia, Poland, France, China, South Korea, the Philippines. I mean, every country that was devastated by the war has had these communal flashbacks. My book, The Fear and the Freedom, is all about these flashbacks and how they've affected every country in the world, including those that were seemingly far away from the fighting. And yet, Israel remains a special case.
Because of all the nations in the world, Israel is the one that has never been able to move on. There's a common saying that those who forget the past are condemned to repeat it.
SPEAKER_00But I think also the flip side is quite true. Those who remember the past too much are also condemned to repeat it. We need to remember the past, like Appelfeld did, in order to process it. But we also need to find a way to let the past go. If we can't let it go, all we do is relive it again and again in a constant loop.
SPEAKER_00The people of Israel have never been allowed to move on. Their nation has been repeatedly attacked by their neighbours, most recently in the terrorist attacks of October 7th, 2023. but they have also been subject to a barrage of memory from their own politicians. The invocation never to forget the Holocaust has been relentless over the past half century or so. Nobody has done this more than the current Prime Minister,
SPEAKER_00Benjamin Netanyahu, who invokes the Second World War in almost every major speech that he gives. It's 1938, he's fond of saying, and Iran is Germany. But it's not 1938, and Iran is not Germany, neither is Palestine. Sometimes I wonder if politicians like Netanyahu are treating the past not as a lesson, but as a template to They invoke the past so much that they find themselves falling
into its traps and
SPEAKER_00keep making the same mistakes again and again and again. Aharon Appelfeld died in 2018. His passing is symbolic of the passing of the whole of that generation. Very soon there will be no one left who can relate their direct experiences of the Holocaust. But the memories will not die with them. For better or worse, Israel has been left with their legacy.
SPEAKER_00In this part of the world, life is, indeed, a permanent war.
Sometimes the most unlikely people become heroes. Neapolitan history is full of such characters, from Masaniello to Maradonna, who just end up being the right person at the right time. This month’s podcast is about a...
This month’s podcast is the story of a boy who lived in a DP camp in 1945, and played with the explosives he found in the woods… This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get...
A story about a girl at Auschwitz in a little red coat, as told to me by one of the Eichmann prosecutors. As broadcast on my Substack channel, keithlowe.substack.com This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss...