Sometimes the most unlikely people become heroes. Neapolitan history is full of such characters, from Masaniello to Maradonna, who just end up being the right person at the right time. This month’s podcast is about a man who found his true calling during the Second World War. Enzo Stimolo, like all Neapolitan heroes, started out as a fairly shady character before finding a brief moment of true glory - and then (probably) meeting a sticky end. This is the story of how it all happened. Enjoy! Aftermath by Keith Lowe is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber. This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit keithlowe.substack.com/subscribe
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_00Every year, at the end of September, my thoughts return to Naples. I actually often think of this city because it's a part of me, I suppose. I used to go there as a child, I fell in love with it as a teenager, and I eventually wrote a book about it. But I think about it at this time of year particularly because this was the time of year when the people here rose up as one against the Germans in 1943 and threw them out of the city. Naples was actually the first city in the whole of occupied Europe to rebel against
SPEAKER_00the Germans. Perhaps, I suppose, with the exception of maybe the Warsaw Ghetto Uprising in Poland, but unlike that uprising, the people of Naples were successful. In the space of just four days, they fought off the Germans and won. Most British and American histories of the war say that the Allies liberated Naples, but they didn't. Naples liberated themselves. So today... I want to tell you the story of one of the big characters of this uprising.
SPEAKER_00His name was Enzo Stimolo. And he was, well, I mean, he was one of those people who kind of seems set to be a loser in life, but who during wartime suddenly finds a place in the history books. He wasn't an army man, wasn't a politician or a community leader or anything like that. He was just... Well, actually, he was a petty criminal who spent most of his life in and out of prison. And yet he was also incredibly brave and quite inspirational and has
SPEAKER_00since become something of a legend in Naples. That's the thing about war, I think. It makes heroes out of the most unexpected people. So I want to tell you about Enzo Stimolo. But first, a little bit of background. In the summer of 1943... Naples was full of Germans. There's nothing particularly surprising about this. Italy and Germany were allies at the time. And so the Germans were here to help with the Italian war effort, exactly as the Americans were in Britain to do to help the British and so on.
SPEAKER_00But in September 1943, all of that changed because the Italians suddenly announced an armistice with the Brits and the Americans. Effectively, they're leaving the Germans in the lurch here. This armistice is announced on the radio on the 8th of September, just hours before the Brits and Americans launched their attack on the beaches of Salerno in southern Italy. Now, the Germans, as you can expect, were absolutely incensed at this betrayal and immediately set
SPEAKER_00about getting their revenge. The first thing they did was to attack all of the Italian army installations, police stations and so on, and take control of them. They disarmed all of the Italian soldiers, sent them all home, and anybody who resisted was immediately executed. Unfortunately, in Naples, lots of these officers did resist them, these soldiers. Some of the police forces also resisted. Some of the customs officers, well, they got punished for it.
SPEAKER_00The Germans eventually overpowered them all, but instead of taking them prisoner, they lined them up against the wall and shot them. And there are massacre sites all over the city, particularly down near the university and the port. Right, so the next thing the Germans did, they've taken control. Well, now they systematically set about destroying the city. They blow up what was left of the port. They blow up the factories. They blow up the power plants and the telephone exchanges and all the hotels along
SPEAKER_00the seafront and so on. It's basically a scorched earth policy. The Germans want to stop anything useful from falling into the hands of the Allies, so they're going to destroy everything they can. But to be honest, they did go far beyond what was strictly necessary. So, for example, they set fire to the university. Why? Who knows? They put time bombs in the post office. I mean, there's no military reason for doing this.
SPEAKER_00All it did was sow terror amongst the civilian population. So they were absolutely brutal. Anything that could be taken away with them, of course, was stolen. So they stripped the entire city of all its food supplies. They took all the cars and the trucks and the bicycles, any kind of transport. And once they'd taken all that they could, well, then they started rounding up men and taking them too. They wanted slave labourers, people who could help them build a massive defensive line around Monte Cassino.
SPEAKER_00So they kidnapped every man they could find in Naples and turned them into slaves. That's actually the word they used at the time, slaves. It's in all the documents and war diaries. Now, naturally, the people of Naples did not take this lying down. You know, as long as the Germans are just destroying buildings, they're willing to stand back and let it happen because they're afraid. But when they start taking the men away, well, they figured they probably had nothing left to lose.
SPEAKER_00So on the 27th of September, 1943, the entire city rose up to fight. This is not just the army now and the police and so on. This is everyone. Shopkeepers, school teachers, carpenters, labourers, you name it. Even women and children joined in. But these people need leaders. And so in this sort of melee of people rising up, a few natural leaders come to the fore. And one of them was our hero Enzo Stimulo.
SPEAKER_00Now at the time when this uprising was first brewing, Stimulo was hiding out on a farm in the Vomero district of Naples. There are about 200 young men hiding in this farm. All of them are just trying to avoid being rounded up by the Germans. Right from the beginning, Stimula established a kind of leadership position amongst all these men. Partly because he had a kind of natural authority about him. But partly also because he told them that he was an army captain.
SPEAKER_00Stimula was not an army captain. I mean, he had been in the army once upon a time. Certainly not as a captain. He was just an ordinary soldier. In fact, he hated the army. Stimlo, it has to be said, was used to being in prison. In fact, he had been in and out of prison repeatedly ever since he was a teenager.
SPEAKER_00He was probably what you'd call a habitual criminal. A little bit of theft here, a little bit of fraud, quite a lot of hot-headed mischief. So, yeah, until now I suppose he wasn't really the sort of person you'd look up to really. But nobody here in this farm knew that. So they took him at his word and they accepted him as their captain because he was, as I said, a kind of natural leader.
SPEAKER_00Anyway, on this night, the night of the 27th of September, Stimolo decided that they needed to get themselves some weapons. So he dressed up as a police officer. He's not averse to impersonating police officers either. And he gets a cart and he takes it up to the castle on the top of the hill, the Castel San Elmo. He knew that there was an old army barracks up there, which he figured probably still had some weapons in it. And indeed he was right,
SPEAKER_00it did have weapons in it, mostly old weapons, rifles from the 1890s, things like that, but also, importantly, lots of ammunition. So he takes this cart up there and he manages to get hold of all these old weapons and bring them back to the farm. The next morning, under Stimolo's leadership, 200 men took to the streets of Womero and fought a running battle against German troops. This battle lasted all day. And then all of the next day as well.
SPEAKER_00This was really serious for the Germans. It took them completely by surprise. They had stuff to do here. There's still a lot of demolition work they're trying to do. And of course they're supposed to be rounding up these men as slave labourers to take up north. The last thing they need is a full-blown insurrection on their hands. I'm not going to go into all the ins and outs of the battle itself. I don't really have time for that. But I will tell you about one particular episode. Because this ended up being pivotal to the whole story.
SPEAKER_00In this part of Naples, Womero, there is a sports stadium. It's still there today. And this sports stadium became one of the most important sites of the insurrection. Because one of the German officers... It was a major called Hugo Sagao. He had taken 47 hostages and holed himself up in this stadium. The Italians, under Stimulo, had surrounded this place. Every time one of the Germans showed his face at the entrance, they shot at him.
SPEAKER_00And so you've got this kind of siege situation starting. Now this is serious for Sagao and his men, because they need to get out of there. They know the Allies are on their way. If they stay too long, they're going to get captured. They're going to get carted off to a POW camp. So all the Italians really need to do is to keep them holed up and wait for the Allies. But things are a little bit desperate for the Italians too because they quickly started to run out of ammunition. And plus, there was, of course, the problem of the hostages.
SPEAKER_00Enzo Stimulow had already seen exactly how brutal the Germans could be. So we just wanted to get these hostages out alive. So this game of cat and mouse ensues between Stimulow and his men on one side and Sagal and his men on the inside. And after a couple of days, finally, this German commander, Sagal, he starts getting really worried. So he comes out waving a white flag. And suggesting a parley with Stimler.
SPEAKER_00So Enzo Stimler steps down and talks to him and he makes the German an offer. What he basically says is that if the Germans release all their hostages, he would allow them to leave unharmed. But he didn't just want this particular small group of Germans to go. He wants the entire German regiment to leave the city. He wants everyone out. Sagal says, This is ridiculous. There are hundreds of German soldiers here. Just in this part of Naples alone, there are hundreds more on their way, retreating from Salerno.
SPEAKER_00We're the ones in power here. But Stimular says, You're not the ones in control. We are. We have 3,000 partisans just in Vomero. 3,000 men who can hold off the Germans indefinitely. So do the sensible thing and take my offer. Of course, Enzo Stimulot is bluffing here. He doesn't have 3,000 men. He has barely enough men to hold down this siege. And he's rapidly running out of ammunition.
SPEAKER_00But remember, Stimulot is a professional gunman. And, which shouldn't be taken for granted, he's a Neapolitan. And Neapolitans know how to blag their way through any situation, let me tell you. So, eventually... Major Sagal agrees to his terms. He says, okay, I will surrender all the hostages and we'll leave the city. But first of all, he needs authorisation from the main German commander,
SPEAKER_00the big commander, the colonel. He's a guy called Walter Scholl. His headquarters is about half a mile away in the Hotel Parker. So Stimulot and Sagal leave their subordinates to carry on glaring down their rifle barrels at one another. And they get in a car together and they drive down to the Hotel Parker to speak to the main guy, Colonel Scholl. Honestly, this whole story is like something out of a movie. On the one hand, you've got this German major with a highly trained company of soldiers.
SPEAKER_00And on the other side, you've got this chancer, this ex-criminal posing as a captain. And yet it's the chancer who wins the day. They go to the German headquarters. They get here about nine o'clock at night on the 30th of September, and they're served tea by a waiter in white gloves. And Stimulo negotiates for the evacuation of the German army from Naples. After an hour or two, this big commander, Colonel Scholl, finally agrees to Stimulo's demands.
SPEAKER_00Now, I don't want to romanticise this too much because, of course, the Germans needed to get out here quickly anyway. Because by this point the Allies are only a day away. But nevertheless it was Enzo Stimler who negotiated for the liberation of Naples and he succeeded. The Germans agreed to leave without killing anyone and Stimler agreed to tell his men to let them go without firing on them. And so the next morning the Germans left and Naples was free.
SPEAKER_00Now, for years, nobody really knew about this story, apart from the people who witnessed it. But then in the 1950s, a journalist, a guy called Aldo De Iacco, he wrote this book about the uprising, which became a bestseller in Naples. And then a film director got hold of the story, Nanny Loy, his name was, made a famous Italian film called Le Quattro Giornate di Napoli, Four Days of Naples. And the main hero of this film is Enzo Stimolo, the man who saved the city.
SPEAKER_00Unfortunately, by this point, Enzo Stimulor is no longer there to enjoy his notoriety. Because, well, after this uprising was over, Stimulor joined the Allies. He became a spy for the Americans. He joined the OSS, went behind enemy lines in northern Italy. And for the next year, he was sending the Americans all kinds of intelligence reports. He's a really important spy for them. But then in October 1944, a year after the uprising, he just disappears.
SPEAKER_00To this day, nobody knows what happened to him. The Americans, the OSS, assumed that he must have been caught by the Germans at some point and executed. In fact, this is what they told his family after the war. The Italian government also spent a good deal of time looking for him, couldn't find him, and eventually declared him legally dead at the beginning of 1947. Then there were various other people who tried to find him. An Italian historian called Gaetano Barbarulo.
SPEAKER_00He tried to track him down, find out what happened to him. Never really found anything definitive. The assumption is that he must have been caught by the Germans as a spy, under a false name probably, and was executed. And then his body was probably dumped somewhere. If he was using a false name, then there's really no way of tracing him. It's a sort of sad end, really, for a very brave man, if it's true. But the problem is we don't know whether it's true.
SPEAKER_00Perhaps something else happened. If he was living under a false name, perhaps he simply chose to disappear, lived out the rest of his life in northern Italy, posing as maybe he was a major this time, or a colonel, or maybe a prince. Or maybe he left Italy altogether, got on a boat perhaps, went off to live in the USA. There are endless possibilities. Most of them pretty unlikely, it has to be said, but then Enzo Stimullo was a pretty unlikely kind of man.
SPEAKER_00We'll never really know. But what we do know is that in Neapolitan history, he has become a legend. To this day he's still remembered as the man who saved the city from the Germans in 1943. It hardly matters whether this is true or not because, well, as Stimula proved when he led his men into battle during the uprising, sometimes it's not the truth that matters. Sometimes all you need is a little bit of faith and a little bit of swagger.
This month’s podcast is the story of a boy who lived in a DP camp in 1945, and played with the explosives he found in the woods… This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get...
A story about a girl at Auschwitz in a little red coat, as told to me by one of the Eichmann prosecutors. As broadcast on my Substack channel, keithlowe.substack.com This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss...
I first released this podcast back in June to my paid subscribers only. It originally held the title “Flashbacks: The Toxic Burden of Memory in Israel”. Given the ongoing conflict in Gaza, this week I am releasing it...