Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in
P

Payne LindseyUnclaimed

He could not afford to film the documentary, so he recorded a podcast at home, and Up and Vanished helped crack an eleven-year-old cold case

3PodCred credits

3 Feed-stated

Counts Verified and Feed-stated credits: what a show's own feed states, or a confirmation backs. See the record

  • Host

Claim this profile+ Add a creditIs this you? Claiming needs a free account. You sign in or join, then come straight back here.

This is not me · Request removal

+ FollowConnectMessageShare

This profile is unclaimed. PodSubs built it from public show feeds and credits. The person it is about has not reviewed it yet.

About this profile

Profile
Unclaimed
Shows now
3

About

In February 2017, Georgia investigators arrested two men in the disappearance of Tara Grinstead, a former beauty queen and high school teacher who had vanished from her home in Ocilla eleven years earlier. The pressure that helped break the case open did not come from a newsroom or a police department.

Read more

It came from a podcast recorded at home by a filmmaker in his late twenties who had never investigated anything, with a microphone that cost about a hundred dollars.

Payne Lindsey was born and raised in Kennesaw, Georgia. He got his first video camera at ten and wanted to direct feature films. As a young man he directed local television commercials and music videos around Atlanta, and he sang lead in a band called Right Side of the Tree. He attended college on and off for a few years and hated school. At twenty-three, his father cut him off, and Lindsey got serious about making videos for a living. He shot a thirteen-minute documentary about strangers he met on a cross-country road trip. The work was real, but it was commercials and other people's songs, and he wanted a story of his own.

In December 2015 he watched Making a Murderer on Netflix and felt its pull. He went looking for a case in his home state and found Grinstead's. She had disappeared in October 2005, and her case had grown into the largest missing person investigation in Georgia history. His grandmother lived in Tifton, not far from Ocilla. Lindsey planned a documentary film, then did the math and saw he could not afford to travel and film the interviews. He has said he realized he could produce a podcast at home in his boxers. So he did.

He had no access to police files and no training as an investigator. He read old news articles and dug through online forums hunting for leads. Then he did the thing that made the show different. He investigated in public, releasing episodes week by week as the work happened, saying plainly what he knew and what he did not. People in and around Ocilla started calling with tips. Within twelve months Up and Vanished had passed fifty million downloads, and a case that had sat quiet for a decade was back in the national news. Lindsey quit everything else and podcasted full time.

In February 2017, the Georgia Bureau of Investigation arrested Ryan Duke, a former student of Grinstead's, and his friend Bo Dukes. New witnesses had come forward as the town talked again, and journalists credited the podcast's attention with moving a case that had been stuck for eleven years.

The legal ending was harder than the podcast ending. At Ryan Duke's trial in 2022, Duke recanted the confession he had given investigators and testified that Bo Dukes had killed her. The jury acquitted him of murder and convicted him only of concealing her death. Bo Dukes was convicted of concealing the death and related charges and sentenced to twenty-five years across his cases. No one has been convicted of killing Tara Grinstead. Lindsey and his team went back to Ocilla and covered the trial episode by episode.

The success became a company. With his friend and business partner Donald Albright, Lindsey co-founded Tenderfoot TV in Atlanta, and Up and Vanished became a television docu-series on Oxygen. In early 2018 he launched Atlanta Monster, about the Atlanta child murders of 1979 to 1981, in which more than twenty-five victims were killed in his home city. He had never heard of the case until Albright told him about it. The show passed seventy million downloads. Tenderfoot went on to make To Live and Die in L.A., Culpable, and Somebody, and by June 2019 the company's podcasts had passed four hundred million downloads. In the fall of 2019 Lindsey launched Radio Rental, true scary stories told by the people who lived them, framed as tapes from a fictional video store whose clerk is played by Rainn Wilson. Wilson had found Lindsey by tweeting that he loved Atlanta Monster.

The later seasons took him farther from home, toward cases the system had left behind. Season two followed Kristal Reisinger, a young mother who vanished from Crestone, Colorado, in 2016, and it debuted at number one on Apple Podcasts. Season three covered Ashley Loring Heavyrunner, a twenty-year-old Indigenous woman who disappeared from the Blackfeet Indian Reservation in Montana in 2017, and Tenderfoot offered a fifty thousand dollar reward for information in her case. For season four, which he called In the Midnight Sun, he spent the better part of a year in Nome, Alaska, investigating the 2020 disappearance of Florence Okpealuk, an Alaska Native woman last seen on West Beach, at times working undercover. The season widened into an account of missing and murdered Indigenous people across Alaska.

He has widened his own range too. In 2023 he hosted High Strange, a limited series asking what the military's UFO footage actually shows, and he launched Talking to Death, a weekly talk show where the investigator runs the conversation instead of chasing it. His younger brother, Mason, works as a producer at Tenderfoot.

The through line of the work is plain. A kid from Kennesaw who got a camera at ten wanted to make movies. The movie he could not afford became a podcast, and the podcast became a public investigation, one week and one phone call at a time, aimed at people the official record had stopped looking for. Tara Grinstead's case still has no murder conviction, and Lindsey still takes cases that may never close. He starts with a name the world has stopped saying, and he does not stop saying it.

Sources: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Payne_Lindsey · dewexpo.com · crimecon2024.sched.com · season1.upandvanished.com · upandvanished.com · podcastrex.com · pg.ubook.com · podsubs.com/search

As a guest

Payne hosts Atlanta Monster and Talking to Death with Payne Lindsey and 1 other show.

Written by PodSubs from Payne's credits.

PodCred record

PodCred is the verified record of where Payne has worked and appeared. These credits come from the shows' own feeds and wait for people who were there to confirm them.

Worked with Payne on a show? This is where you give them credit.

+ Add a credit

Shows they work on now

3 shows

  • Atlanta Monster
    Host Feed-stated
  • Talking to Death with Payne Lindsey
    Host Feed-stated
  • Up and Vanished
    Host Feed-stated

Is an appearance missing?

People get invited back because someone remembered they were great. If you heard this person on a show and it is not listed here, add it. Your memory might be the reason they get their next invitation.

No account needed. Anyone can give a credit.

Add an appearanceHow PodCred works

Experience, education, skills, and recommendations start empty. They fill in when Payne claims this profile.

Recommendations

ReceivedGiven

No recommendations for Payne yet.

Recommendations open once Payne claims the profile.

Activity

0 followers

PostsCommentsImages

No posts yet. Posts Payne shares on PodSubs, and what Payne publishes on Substack, YouTube and elsewhere, will show here.

Recent episodes

From the shows they work on now

10 episodes
  • RedHanded - David “D4vd” Burke - Part One: The Killing of Celeste Rivas Hernandez

    Up and Vanished

    Oct 20, 202614 minAudio

    Today, we are sharing part one of a two-part series from the award-winning true crime podcast RedHanded, hosted by Suruthi Bala and Hannah Maguire. RedHanded is the UK's #1 True Crime podcast, covering everything from...

  • 28 | Prepare for Landing: Part 2 (Season Finale)

    Up and Vanished

    Sep 8, 202652 minAudio

    Ten years after Joseph Balderas disappeared, the details still don’t add up. In the Season 4 finale, Payne examines shifting accounts, missing evidence, and critical gaps in the original investigation. A trail of old...

    • Apple Podcasts
  • 27 | Prepare for Landing: Part 1

    Up and Vanished

    Sep 1, 202643 minAudio

    Ten years after Joseph disappeared from Nome, Alaska, new evidence rewrites the story of his final weekend. Join our Discord: https://discord.gg/upandvanished

    • Apple Podcasts
  • Friendly Universe | High Strange Season 2

    Up and Vanished

    May 5, 202644 minAudio

    From the creator of Up and Vanished, Payne Lindsey returns with a new season of High Strange. To get you ready, we're dropping the full first episode of Season 2 right here in the Up and Vanished feed. Scientists,...

  • Where Things Stand in Up and Vanished

    Up and Vanished

    Feb 11, 20268 minAudio

    There has been meaningful movement behind the scenes in Up and Vanished. Because of the serious and legal nature of what is unfolding, we are being deliberate with the next update. More is coming soon. In the meantime,...

  • 26 | This is the Captain Speaking

    Up and Vanished

    Jan 31, 202641 minAudio

    For the entire season, a few voices have been conspicuously absent; never speaking with Up and Vanished. In this final episode, we present a recording that changes everything. For the first time, we hear directly from...

    • Apple Podcasts
  • 25 | Final Boarding Call

    Up and Vanished

    Jan 16, 202652 minAudio

    After months of investigating the disappearance of Joseph Balderas in Nome, Alaska, Payne Lindsey presents a comprehensive examination of everything that doesn't add up. In this penultimate episode, we systematically...

    • Apple Podcasts
  • Inside the Investigation with Payne Lindsey, Dennis Cooper, and Kyle Tekiela

    Up and Vanished

    Nov 24, 202523 minAudio

    Have you ever wondered what happens off mic in an investigative podcast? Join Payne Lindsey (Up and Vanished), Dennis Cooper (Culpable), and Kyle Tekiela (Crook County) for a candid look inside making a hit series. Hear...

  • Up and Vanished Weekly | VANISHED: Denise Griffin

    Up and Vanished

    Oct 15, 202538 minAudio

    When New York State Troopers embarked on a high speed chase on Monday June 28, 1993, they did not foresee the scene they would soon stumble upon. Inside the vehicle they discovered the decomposing body of a woman. After...

  • Up and Vanished Weekly | VANISHED: Richard Cox

    Up and Vanished

    Oct 8, 202551 minAudio

    When 21 year old Richard Cox - a cadet at West Point Military Academy - missed evening curfew on Saturday, January 14th, 1950, his roommates quickly became concerned. As authorities began investigating, their interest...

Showing 5 of 10
Report this profile