Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in
M

Mandy MatneyUnclaimed

She chased a boat crash her editors wanted dropped and helped bring down a legal dynasty, now she hunts corruption on True Sunlight

3PodCred credits

3 Feed-stated

Counts Verified and Feed-stated credits: what a show's own feed states, or a confirmation backs. See the record

  • Host

Claim this profile+ Add a creditIs this you? Claiming needs a free account. You sign in or join, then come straight back here.

This is not me · Request removal

+ FollowConnectMessageShare

This profile is unclaimed. PodSubs built it from public show feeds and credits. The person it is about has not reviewed it yet.

About this profile

Profile
Unclaimed
Shows now
3

About

In the small hours of February 24, 2019, a boat carrying six young people slammed into bridge pilings near Parris Island, South Carolina. Mallory Beach, 19, was thrown into the dark water and did not come home. The driver was Paul Murdaugh, 19, youngest son of a powerful local legal family.

Read more

Matney was the breaking news editor at The Island Packet, and tips reached her almost at once. Sources warned her that if reporters did not stay on the story, the family would cover it up like everything else. Something in her clicked. She stayed.

Matney grew up in Kansas, watching Dateline and 20/20 beside her mother and following the O.J. Simpson case as a kindergartner. She graduated from the University of Kansas journalism school in 2012, then took a graduation trip to Hilton Head, where she picked up the local paper and thought it a nice place to work, alligators and all. Her first newspaper jobs, in Waynesville, Missouri, and Danville, Illinois, she has called soul-sucking, and she cried often. In March 2016 she landed at The Island Packet at last.

The boat crash became her story, and her bosses did not want it. She remembers a March 2019 meeting where her boss said he was sick of the boat crash stories, even though they drew more readers than anything else in the paper. That year she was demoted to reporter despite leading the newsroom in page views. In her memoir, an editor she calls Charles Gardiner responded to her obtaining key files on Stephen Smith's unsolved 2015 death by asking what she had done to get them. She kept reporting anyway, alongside fellow journalist Liz Farrell. In January 2020 she left for FITSNews, a South Carolina news site that promised her the one thing the Packet never had. Free rein.

At FITSNews she was first to say openly that three deaths sat in the Murdaugh family's shadow. Mallory Beach. Gloria Satterfield, the family housekeeper, dead after a fall at their home. And Stephen Smith, a 19-year-old nursing student found dead on a Hampton County road in 2015, his investigation file mentioning the Murdaugh name 40 times. She published the official case file on the boat crash and broke news of the reopened Satterfield investigation.

On June 7, 2021, Maggie Murdaugh and her son Paul were shot dead at the family's hunting estate. Matney has said her life turned upside down that day. Two weeks later she and her boyfriend, David Moses, started a podcast at their kitchen table, their rescue dog, Luna, underfoot, Moses teaching himself audio editing on free software. The first episode of the Murdaugh Murders Podcast was called South Carolina's Chappaquiddick. By the ninth episode it was the number one podcast on Apple, which later named it the number one podcast in the world for 2021. The Washington Post credited the show with introducing the public to the Murdaugh family.

The attention cut both ways. Alex Murdaugh's lead defense lawyer, Dick Harpootlian, mocked her by name before a courtroom gallery. Strangers online attacked her voice and her looks. A message from a friend of Buster Murdaugh that she read as a threat made her stop posting her whereabouts in real time. The work ground her down, and she has written openly about depression. Her older brother died suddenly when she was seven, and she sees her own mother, she has said, in grieving mothers like Sandy Smith.

In March 2023 a jury convicted Alex Murdaugh of the murders, and he was sentenced to life in prison. That May, after 93 episodes, they relaunched the Murdaugh Murders Podcast as True Sunlight, with a wider scope. Their second show, Cup of Justice, with attorney Eric Bland, had debuted at number one that January. Matney's memoir, Blood on Their Hands, written with Carolyn Murnick, became a bestseller. She now runs Luna Shark, the company she built with Moses, her husband since 2022. In October 2025, Hulu premiered Murdaugh: Death in the Family, a scripted series based on her podcast, with Matney as executive producer and Brittany Snow playing her.

Her work has drawn legal fire as well as abuse. A defamation suit over her earlier reporting on a University of South Carolina professor was dismissed in 2023. In 2026, lawyers for convenience store owner Greg Parker subpoenaed her as a non-party witness in the Beach family's civil case against him, over a leaked mediation video containing police photos of Mallory Beach's body. A judge ruled the state reporters shield law did not excuse her from testifying. Matney said she felt unsafe at the office where the deposition was set, and on March 27, 2026, she waited at her own lawyer's office a short walk away. She was deposed eleven days later. In July 2026 the judge held her in contempt, finding she had willfully disregarded the subpoena, and ordered her to pay $176,500, a $5,000 fine plus $171,500 in the other side's legal fees. She appealed to the state court of appeals.

The Murdaugh story is not finished, and neither is she. In 2026 the state supreme court overturned the conviction and granted Alex Murdaugh a new trial, and Matney and Farrell were back covering the fight weekly. She still shows up for the families who trusted her when nobody else would listen. In July 2025 she led a walk in Hampton in Stephen Smith's memory that raised money for his scholarship and investigation funds. Her mission has not changed since the kitchen table days. Give a voice to the voiceless, expose the truth wherever it leads, and get the story straight. Her sign-off to listeners doubles as instructions. Stay pesky. Stay in the sunlight.

Sources: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mandy_Matney · theguardian.com · bookpage.com · scpress.org · thecinemaholic.com · girltalkhq.com · kansan.com

As a guest

Mandy hosts Cup Of Justice and Murdaugh Murders Podcast and 1 other show.

Written by PodSubs from Mandy's credits.

PodCred record

PodCred is the verified record of where Mandy has worked and appeared. These credits come from the shows' own feeds and wait for people who were there to confirm them.

Worked with Mandy on a show? This is where you give them credit.

+ Add a credit

Shows they work on now

3 shows

  • Cup Of Justice
    Co-host Feed-stated
  • Murdaugh Murders Podcast
    Host Feed-stated
  • True Sunlight
    Host Feed-stated

Is an appearance missing?

People get invited back because someone remembered they were great. If you heard this person on a show and it is not listed here, add it. Your memory might be the reason they get their next invitation.

No account needed. Anyone can give a credit.

Add an appearanceHow PodCred works

Experience, education, skills, and recommendations start empty. They fill in when Mandy claims this profile.

Recommendations

ReceivedGiven

No recommendations for Mandy yet.

Recommendations open once Mandy claims the profile.

Activity

0 followers

PostsCommentsImages

No posts yet. Posts Mandy shares on PodSubs, and what Mandy publishes on Substack, YouTube and elsewhere, will show here.

Recent episodes

From the shows they work on now

10 episodes
  • “Finally..." Weldon Boyd and Bradley Williams Charged with Murder for Killing Scott Spivey (173pt1)

    True Sunlight

    Nov 19, 202656 minAudio

    On Part One of True Sunlight #173, Investigative Journalists Mandy Matney and Liz Farrell have BREAKING NEWS. Just as they finished recording this episode, the Horry County Grand Jury signed true bills indicting Weldon...

  • COJ #204 - Strategery: Noah Pines on the Team Murdaugh Hail Mary, the PowerPoint & the Quietest Hearing Yet

    Cup Of Justice

    Nov 17, 20261 hr 4 minAudio

    Liz Farrell⁠⁠ is back from Iceland Noir, so she and ⁠⁠Mandy Matney ⁠can welcome back attorney Noah Pines to decode the quietest Murdaugh hearing yet - starting with his theory on why it was so calm: “I think Jim...

  • Tombstone Pals & Paper Trails: Were Greg Alexander, Randy & the PMPED Boys Circling Wagons? (172pt2)

    True Sunlight

    Nov 15, 202654 minAudio

    On Part Two of True Sunlight #172, Investigative Journalist Mandy Matney and Producer David Moses first look at Friday’s Murdaugh hearing which was arguably the calmest yet - and the scariest. Judge McCaslin took the...

  • 74 Subpoenas & $6 Million Missing In Murdaugh Money: Inside Operation Lowcountry Boil (172pt1)

    True Sunlight

    Nov 12, 202657 minAudio

    Note: Eve Fleming and Jean Fowlkes have not been accused of any wrongdoing. Liz is on a much-deserved vacation, so it's Mandy and David - just like the early MMP days - digging into the juiciest exhibit Dick and Jim...

  • COJ #203 - Pressure Makes Mistakes: Ret. Detective Steve Remick on What SLED Agent Owen’s Notes Mean In the Murdaugh Case

    Cup Of Justice

    Nov 10, 20261 hr 3 minAudio

    Investigative journalists ⁠⁠Mandy Matney and ⁠Liz Farrell⁠⁠ welcome 28-year retired law enforcement officer Lt. Steve Remick - 28 years in Virginia law enforcement, now teaching at George Mason - joins Mandy and Liz to...

  • How Serious Are Alex Murdaugh’s Claims of Misconduct by SLED and Attorney General Alan Wilson’s Office? (171pt2)

    True Sunlight

    Nov 9, 202635 minAudio

    In Part Two, Investigative Journalists Mandy Matney and Liz Farrell break down Team Murdaugh's three big accusations: that Agent David Owen lied to the grand juries, that the AG's office misused the state grand jury to...

  • Team Murdaugh’s Hail-Mary Motion Reveals Juicy Insider Details Of Murder Investigation (171pt1)

    True Sunlight

    Nov 5, 20261 hr 6 minAudio

    While I breathe, I freaking hope: South Carolina just elected its first woman to the U.S. Senate - and Mandy’s got her spark back. A much needed spark at that, because on the eve of Halloween, attorneys Dick Harpootlian...

  • COJ #202 - ‘My Client Is Justice’: Mandy Powers Norrell on Prosecuting DV & the Laws That Trap Women

    Cup Of Justice

    Nov 3, 202658 minAudio

    Investigative journalists ⁠⁠Mandy Matney and ⁠Liz Farrell⁠⁠ welcome back attorney Mandy Powers Norrell for an episode that opens in 1925 - when women were jailed for wearing pants, by an officer named Police Chief...

  • The Audacity of ‘The Gilleyship’: Christa’s Parents Fight for Custody of Grandchildren and File Lawsuit (170)

    True Sunlight

    Oct 29, 20261 hr 1 minAudio

    Part One of One (👻Because🧙Happy Halloween! 🎃)Investigative journalists Mandy Matney and Liz Farrell give massive update on the Christa Bauer Gilley case and Lee Gilley’s Big 'Flee' to Italy. On today’s episode, Mandy...

  • COJ #201 - Lying About A Lie Detector? Team Murdaugh’s Round 2 Strategy Collapses With Attorney Noah Pines

    Cup Of Justice

    Oct 27, 202656 minAudio

    Investigative journalists ⁠⁠Mandy Matney and ⁠Liz Farrell⁠⁠ and Atlanta attorney Noah Pines break down the hearing that reset the Murdaugh retrial. First: why motions to compel barely exist in criminal court - the state...

Showing 5 of 10
Report this profile