This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit sbarrettbar.substack.com/subscribe
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Hillary is going to, there are words one could say, demotic Anglo-Saxon words. Let's use the phrase tell me off for not having done enough work on the list.
SPEAKER_01And I haven't done enough work on the list. So I do need to get to the list. But at least we've got our Q&A and then we can have a nice weekend and then we can kick off next week. I have been inundated with media requests, a lot of which I've had to turn down. It's now coalescing into the idea that I'll do an hour on Tuesday for talk. um half an hour on wednesday morning for mike graham and then an hour um or possibly half an hour which would suit me better but and maybe
an hour on wednesday
SPEAKER_01for talk again um The media is always changing. They are constantly changing their formats. So we'll just bear with me. Denise is back. And I want to know Denise's story of how she got back because this sounds amazing. It sounds like Denise beat the system, which is fabulous because we all need to know how to beat the system. And it's just lovely to have Denise here. Hillary's here. Debbie's here. Catman's here. But Denise, you are undoubtedly the star of the week without question.
SPEAKER_01How did you beat the system? How did you get around it? And I had to go to a very secure office block this morning where they gave me a pass. And then when I popped out to grab something, for lunch i forgot it um because i that's what i do and then i got back into the very secure allegedly very secure building by just being very polite and nice saying thank you to the receptionist didn't even mention that i
wasn't showing my pass just chatted briefly and walked through security because we can get through
SPEAKER_01things can't we denise and we need to know your tale In fact, Denise, if you want to write me a long note on what you did, I'll post it as an article just in praise of Denise, hopefully to encourage the others and so that the community can feel that we absolutely can get things done. We can get things done. We are not powerless. They love to imply that you're powerless. Again, always think of them like, you know,
SPEAKER_01that adult who hasn't got any sweets come Halloween, who's hiding behind the sofa when the call has come, when the doorbell goes, hoping that everyone will go away. If you go away, you don't get anything. But they are scared of us, as they should be. We must go on this. Well done, Captain. All power to everybody who does anything. Good to see Jane. Good to see Elizabeth and William. And another Jane. Loads of Janes. We're drowning in Janes.
SPEAKER_01I usually drown in Davids. That's usually the problem I have. In fact... a big proportion of the lawyers who i actually trust like and respect are called david a disturbing amount of them are called david there's a really far too many davids um going on um sarah jane oh you're so you're another jane are you sarah uh jordan has joined jordan had a question so we'll get to that um post it on the lovelies chat just keep fighting everyone we can win well no
because i might lose it there denise so put it put it in a dm and then i will literally put it in an article i'll top it and tailor it and give it like a picture and you know tell me what um headline you want or i'll do a headline if you want let's get this message really out there and then it can be a Substack article free free to readSubstack
SPEAKER_01article um of what you did and how you beat the system with all credit to you and you could be named or not named depending what what you want it is because you're the hero okay so but i genuinely think an article and then i will tweet that article and we'll it will it will tumble if we just put it in chat i'm worried it'll get lost i think it's too important to go there uh angelique is here uh we're just all glad to have Denise back. If only we could have Petronella back.
If only her husband would leave her alone for five minutes so that we could have
SPEAKER_01Petronella back. But we are the lovelies and we are glad to be together. If you're one of my free subscribers and you're new to all this, this is how we treat each other. We respect each other. We know each other's names. We like each other. We look out for each other. We look after each other. I tease Hillary sometimes. Hillary then does all the work. It's great. We are a community. This isn't really about me. There's quite enough things about me in the media and in social media.
This is more about having a corner of the internet where decent people can come together and
SPEAKER_01talk and support each other. And that's what we do here. That's part of it. Everyone who joins the paid subscribers is a lovely. I'm a lovely. We are all equal in loveliness. The only one of us who has a title is Hillary, who is officially secretary of the list or great keeper of the list. um and the list is the list of things i'm supposed to do which i still haven't got around to um believe me the list of things i'm supposed to do in this house is twice as long but there we are um
I mean, being on Mike Graham at 7am is really pushing my organisational skills.
SPEAKER_01You know, I have to get a small child up. I have to get myself washed, my hair washed. I have to get the dogs out and in again. I have to get the dogs docile. I have to feed said small child, get a portion of fruit or veg into said small child because I'm obsessive and do a million and one things and then go on Mike and say something interesting. And, you know, in theory, prepare for Mike, which is... There's no real time for that. And then I have to, you know, just run around again to try and get the small person out. But it is mad.
SPEAKER_01I keep those face-to-face. I was asked to go on the media. I can't remember which channel it was now. tomorrow at 7.30am. And I just replied, I am knackered. I need to sleep in. And I'd like to just, this is a weekend with small person, which are always the much more valuable weekends. My dad's going to come over We'll do the Sunday lunch at the place we always go, which knows us, has lovely people. One of the, we chat, I chat to everyone.
SPEAKER_01This is where sheltered railways really made a massive mistake. I get on with people. I like people. I chat to people. So obviously we know all the waiters because we chat to them. And one of the waiters, um or the or the the the ladies there's the ladies and men i don't know what the who cares uh anyway obviously it's a big pub and so there's lots of stuff and they're all lovely but one of them has a baby girl he has a little baby girl and i love babies i don't care whether it's a baby girl or baby boy i just love them um
so i get updates sometimes we get pictures we talk about what it was like because i
SPEAKER_01remember what it was like um so stressful um so that's the weekend and then next week i actually have to do something or hillary is going to beat me bloody um and that's not gonna no one's gonna enjoy that um so we must get more done um and we will get things done on the list but that's just to explain to free subscribers what we are and what we're doing again we are a special corner of the internet where lovely people come together and support each other that's what we are um
SPEAKER_01Lots of chat.
SPEAKER_00Everybody's talking.
SPEAKER_01Dogs are so much. I love dogs. I love my dogs. I think obviously you love your dogs more. God, dogs are so much... You compare it to a cat, it's unbelievable. A cat is just basically a houseguest who looks after themselves. Hillary is promising not to bat on me, which is great, but I must do the list. I really must do the list. At least two things. Let's get two things off the list in the coming week. Right, I've titled this about Starmer and his betrayal of our veterans,
SPEAKER_01because I really worry that people are missing the depth of this. Not only did he voluntarily take a case to persecute a veteran. That's okay. We barristers have to take cases to do things, whether they like it or not. Unless we're not paid. He wasn't paid. So he chose to try and persecute veterans, and they completely failed. And so he just made a man's life hell for years,
SPEAKER_01lots and lots of unnecessary stress, and he's doing it for free. He's volunteering to do this. And because we are self-employed, and there are only so many hours in every day, and only so many court appearances that you can possibly attend to, courts have holidays and rest periods, or at least the court's they do so there's only so many days so you he's literally he not only did that he gave away money so he lost out on earning tens of thousands of pounds which as far as i'm concerned is a donation to the idea that you persecute
our veterans now i think certainly all of us here because we're lovelies will just think that's horrific you know i can't tell you how many remembrance services and remembrance sundays i've done and gone to and you and you stand there and you solemnly think
SPEAKER_01about those service men and women who lost their lives. You know, I can't believe how many died in all of our wars. The idea that you would persecute our veterans strikes me as utterly sinister. It's evil. It's perverse. And to volunteer money and time to do it... i simply think starmer is is a very very bad person i think he's evil i think he's demented i have nothing in common with him um i don't ever want
to meet him if i did meet him i don't think i'd say anything polite um i have nothing but contempt
SPEAKER_01for him and lord herm is exactly the same and i'm very sorry to say The vast majority of the human rights lawyers are exactly like this. And because of the human rights lawyers and the strength it has upon the concept of being a barrister or the concept of being a lawyer, almost every young lawyer to be now writes, I want to be a human rights lawyer. it has an utterly corrosive effect on both professions. Both barristers and solicitors are utterly eaten inside by this cancer,
which is determined to do vile things and simply has no moral compass at all and
SPEAKER_01nothing I can equate to or be like. And I am very, very proud i'm proud that i am that i got to be a barrister and i wasn't i am a barrister and i practiced in the high court and i got to address the court of appeal um i'm very proud though to have let my practicing certificate lapse and to no longer be amongst them on a daily basis i i'm not sure given the state that they are in that um that would be a very nice place to be at all um
there are elements
SPEAKER_01to that but um Yeah, we're just, we're going to find a new path. We're going to, we're going to fix the country. Right. Waffle, waffle, waffle, Stephen. 20 minutes. Jordan has the first question because I actually spotted it, Hillary, although I spotted that you spotted that I might not have spotted it. And therefore you picked it up. But Jordan said, wanted to ask a question, back during Brexit, there was a massive to-do with the Henry VIII clauses. Why was that a massive problem? Okay, so Henry VIII clauses are a type of what we call delegated
legislation.
SPEAKER_01It's about giving a power to a minister to do something. They are part of the paradox of the left. So in theory, and what you mean by why was it a massive to-do is because the left got really hissy about it. And there's something called the Hanson Society, which is almost entirely captured by the left. It's still quite useful. It's still quite good on parliamentary procedure, but it is left-wing. There's no point denying these things. I'm fed up denying these things anymore. And the Hansard Society back in, oh,
SPEAKER_01God, I'm old, but I think it's 2014, something like that, published a very long report, it's almost book length, on a delegated legislation. And Henry VIII's powers give the minister the ability to make a statutory instrument which changes an act of parliament. Now, it's all perfectly lawful as far as I'm concerned, all perfectly constitutional. But they got into a massive to-do about it because they don't want ministers to wield that much power. They'd rather have, or they say they'd rather have parliamentary accountability.
They often bang on about this when there's a prospect of a right-wing government. They really want ministers accountable to parliament when there's a danger of a
SPEAKER_01right-wing government. I've not seen any complaints about Henry VIII powers under a left-wing government. Just so you know, just for your radar. They're not necessarily a problem. They are part of our constitution. But the other irony, Jordan, I'd flag, is that Henry VIII clauses and delegated legislation empowering ministers... is entirely down to the EU. So that's how the EU drafts it. Like or dislike the EU, I don't really take a position on it. But I do think it's quite funny that a lot of the people who
are very pro-EU, allegedly, hate the way that the eu makes law but the eu every time and because it and in its defense because it's legislating for 28 member states then 27 member states now it just passes laws that usually say the minister shall have the power to do this the ministers will do this and then it hold it hopes to hold governments to account the eu is is structured um legally on the idea that everybody will have a president and
SPEAKER_01That's one of the ways we just don't really fit with it. That doesn't really work. And therefore, through the president, to whom all the ministers are accountable, the EU can hold a nation-state accountable. It's much easier for the EU to have a personal conversation with the president about, oh, we don't think your ministers implemented... this stuff on energy policy than it is to have a conversation with us because we're like oh well but parliament doesn't you know we're just a different system and this is just how they operate but the greatest irony is that all the people who whined
most about henry the eighth clauses all support the eu um which is the greatest
SPEAKER_01source of henry the eighth powers um in the last 30 years i think there was a time there's a speech god this is testing my memory but i think lord judge when he was um lord chief justice gave a speech in 2010 saying that 120 um new henry the eighth clause powers had been made in the preceding parliament um but they were all 99.9 percent of them would be eu based and lord judge would be a firm remainer because he is
SPEAKER_01In fact, the entire crossbench peers are. They're not independent. They're a political party. They're the pro-EU, pro-status quo, pro-blob party. If you want to look at the House of Lords, you find it really weird. There's Labour, Conservative, Lib Dem peers, and then there's this thing called the crossbench, which wouldn't let people like Claire Fox and Kate Howard, name's gone, that you know I adore her, um wouldn't let them join um because they're not because
they're anti-eu that it's just a pro-eu party inside our second house that nobody ever pays any attention to anyway oh arrogant's here good to see i found i found arrogant on twitter today if i find any lovely any lovely get to follow back on twitter because that's just how
SPEAKER_01we work that's how we roll And I found Aragon today. Or at least I think I found Aragon today. Let's see if Aragon says, Stephen, I don't Twitter. That's very embarrassing. Anyway, Jordan, right, that's that question then. Samantha, question for Friday. Samantha, does the FC301148 really state... What is the FC301148? I literally Googled it and all I could find was...
property listings in florida i don't think whatever the fc whoever said and this is one of the and i'm not embarrassing um samantha because she's a lovely and we adore her um but i we just all need to be aware that there are people on the internet who
SPEAKER_01say really weird things about the constitution and And I think we should have this golden rule, which is by almost do what Samantha doesn't ask me, because I will not lie to you about what the Constitution is. And we'll get back to that. That's another point that's going to come up later. But also just have some skepticism. If it's too good to be true, if it sounds fantastic about the Constitution, it's probably wrong. Probably wrong. I don't know what FC loads of numbers is or is purporting to be. I would bet you money it's a charlatan, probably on YouTube.
SPEAKER_01who's going around spreading some nonsense like the Freeman of the Land, that's also nonsense, and the other people who say simple nonsense about the Constitution. I'm this close to falling out with Andy the Gabby Cabby because I don't lie on the Constitution. It's really important that I don't. It's really important that I get it right. Anyway, hopefully, Samantha, that is enough for you. Kate complained about Mukund Krishna, The head of the police federation,
SPEAKER_01who has been found to have acted unlawfully in sacking two people. I think the most important thing about the story is why the hell does the head of a public sector body earn £700,000? Kay doesn't really... Kay, I think, is baffled by the whole thing, so it doesn't... Asked a specific question. But I would suggest that's the more important one. He claims to represent more than 130,000 serving police officers. I mean, this is unions for you. This is unionism. When I was a young man in our first year, we all went down to watch the Oxford and Cambridge boat race.
SPEAKER_01And one of our friends, his parents, had a flat in the Barbican. So we all stayed there, like about 18 of us in a flat. So, you know, we're young people, that's what happened. And we were just one floor below the top. And so it was like, oh, who lives in the penthouse? It's like, oh, Arthur Scargill. The left is often just away. um was it sorry this is regards andy cabby post seems sorry
what she said no don't don't worry i'm just andy's just a bit too enthusiastic about the constitution it really can't do magic um but anyway arthur scargo was in the top of that block um i find it ridiculous that somebody in charge of the police federation which is a i'm
SPEAKER_01going to start using this phrase non-jobs for non-entities Now, you're going to see that a lot. I'm just going to keep saying non-jobs for non-entities, because at the moment, our entire society, its only purpose is not to provide health care, not to provide education, certainly not to provide policing, not to provide defence, not to have a border. The only purpose of our country, which is a very wealthy country, is to provide non-jobs for for non-entities and that's something that i'm going to keep pushing and you're going to keep me hearing me say and you know the the
establishment will hate it but let's face it they already hate me i have nothing to lose and i just want to have my own self-respect um hillary's happy with good oh denise had to deal with after
SPEAKER_01scargill back in the day he was an unbecoming discourteous man Well, the types of people who finch and half-inch loads of public money usually are. I always defend people on the left who I adore, and from that period, I always had the deepest respect for Tony Benn. Far better man than Arthur Scargill ever was. Mick says, my question, isn't donations to a party a conflict? I'd be more than happy for parties to be solely tax-funded,
SPEAKER_01with set limits for various things for a party to operate. Would you, Mick? So what we do is we don't traditionally allow that because much of how our system is built is to prevent socialism. Okay? you have political parties funded by the state. And by the way, this story sort of, I could have made, there was a leak about Liz Kendall selling a dinner with Liz Kendall or something for like 30,000 pounds. And that was, you know,
a tweet sent out and I could have gone, oh, this is awful.
SPEAKER_01And I just went, I looked at it and went, if we're going to have privately funded political parties, That's how they raise money. But that's fine, as long as they're not giving peerages or saying to people, I'll make this law or that law. As long as it's just come and have a selfie with an exclusive and an hour-long dinner. I really don't have a problem with that, Mick, because the alternative... is state-funded political parties, which will inevitably mean that the Labour Party will have all their supporters in
SPEAKER_01charge of that, which inevitably means there will be dirty tricks and shenanigans. We're already seeing the way that the left are willing to, how far they are willing to go. And I think it's a really bad idea. I also don't really want a hard-working taxpayer's money spent on political parties. As far as I'm concerned, our constitution is so old that we predate political parties. Political parties are really just for the administrative purposes of the House of Commons, to prove which person can command the confidence of the House.
I have no real interest in political parties, and I've moved one recently.
SPEAKER_01But none of them has a right to exist. None of them has a right to live forever. None of them has a right, as far as I'm concerned, to public funds at all, apart from all the other dangers and risks. They're just what they are. Come or go. They are what they are. I'm not pledging to fight and die for a political party. That's where I think we need to change this stuff. I think we need to end sectarianism in politics and the extremists that's going on. And I think that will happen because the party I've joined looks as though it's trying to reach across quite broad,
SPEAKER_01quite broadly. And there might be all sorts of people who end up in it. And as long as they're good people, I'll be glad. You know, I make it very clear that I adore Claire Fox and think the absolute world of her. Obviously, we don't agree on a lot, but that doesn't mean I don't think the world of her. We can bring good people together. We fought the last war as a coalition. People forget this. Anyway, good question, Megan. Where are we? Martin, can Starmer be prosecuted for treason? Now,
SPEAKER_01Martin, we don't want to go too far down this trap because we don't want Starmer able to say that things were said on social media and in the media that means that no trial against him can go ahead. It's really important to not give Keir Starmer any defence. So all we're going to say, Martin, is that I think various potential events and activities will need future investigation. And I think this is a government that will see investigations in future.
SPEAKER_01I do not wish to prejudice any trial against any of them. They are all innocent until proven guilty. And I'm not even calling for prosecutions. I'll just call for investigations. But let's see, Martin, because I think that's where we are. Charlie, don't you ever get tired of the so-called unwritten constitution where Parliament can basically do whatever it likes on a Tuesday afternoon and call it democracy? Wouldn't we be a hell of a better off with a nice, clear, written-down constitution? Now, I think Hillary answered this partially for you, Charlie, which is that we can't have a written constitution.
SPEAKER_01So I don't like one. I wouldn't want one. And we can go through what I see as the negatives of one, which is a lot of what happens in America using courts and judges as though they're some sort of magically independent creatures who can make political decisions, all of which I don't like. But ultimately, we can't have a constitution because the only way we could create a constitution would be by act of parliament.
SPEAKER_00And the future parliament could destroy it. The only constitution we have is Mount Doom,
SPEAKER_01where anything can be forged and anything can be destroyed. It's beautifully simple. I don't get fed up of it because I think it forces us to grow up. And I think we're in a period where we're going to be forced to grow up again because we've been far too asleep and far too childish for far too long. This is our democracy. We have to take part in it. That's why I'm very proud of Denise and others who organise. You've got to talk to your neighbours. You've got to know who your MP is. You've got to know who your councillor is. You've got to get numbers.
SPEAKER_01You've got to write to them. You've got to make them afraid of you. You've got to intervene. The answer is not, oh, some lawyer will save me. A judge will come. No. It's never the answer because that person, when push comes to shove, you won't be able to trust them. And all on that, I only raised Lord Justice Bean on the Epping Bell Hotel case, which I think is absolutely shameful, ridiculous. I think it's the reasonings of a, at best, brain damaged toddler.
But I note that he was head of the Fabian Society and therefore not merely because
SPEAKER_01he's not intelligent enough to have heard the case, I don't think you should have heard the case. And you just can't trust judges. When push comes to shove, it'll be somebody who's on the side of the baddies. In Hitler's Germany, they didn't need to recruit new judges when they switched from the Weimar Republic to Nazi Germany. They sacked the Jewish ones, obviously, because they're evil. But... The others just carried on working, carried on doing their stuff.
SPEAKER_01They didn't need to suddenly recruit or create lawyers. Lawyers are not inherently good people. I mean, I've had to deal with this for a very long time because I think I am a nice person. I don't think I'm a nice person when I do law because law isn't nice or bad inherently. It's just law. And you can have good and bad legal systems. So, Charlie, I don't get fed up of the so-called unwritten constitution because... I think it makes us into grown-up and useful members of society.
I think you can say for 30 years we've been sleeping, but I think push is coming to shove. John says, should the next advanced UK or reform, let's be more honest, Tom,
SPEAKER_01Government, cancel any and all quangos. Yes. That was an easy one, John, wasn't it? And I'm not being flippant. Of course they should. Quangos and this entire system is a way of taking power out of Parliament, bleeding the lava out of Mount Doom and putting it in places where you can't see it being used by people you don't know who are unaccountable yet seem to cost an awful lot of money. Get rid of it all. Get rid of it all. Get rid of it all. Syset. Good day, Stephen and fellow lovelies. tuesday 27th january was holocaust memorial day modern
historians agree and si goes on to recount the details of the genocide which is appalling but the largest group was jewish and the bbc and apparently three separate other broadcasters oh no in three separate broadcasts the bbc quoted the six million figure but removed the
SPEAKER_01reference to jewish And Cy asks, do I think that the BBC is institutionally racist? Yes, I do. I think it's unavoidable now. And I think if we had any sense and the next government, I urge simply send it. I don't need an inquiry. Just send in a task force and sack a lot of people and hire people who aren't racist or just get rid of the BBC. And I'm 50-50 on either of those right now. Makosh, hi, Stephen. Do you know if there's any attempts or preparations made to rid the legal profession of activist lawyers?
SPEAKER_01No, there isn't, Makosh, and it's just getting worse. It's absolutely outrageous. He thinks, Makos says, the purpose of my law degree is to turn me into an ideologue. I know. I know. And that's what they've done. They've made the law so complicated that if you were polite and kind, you'd actually say it's verging on impossible to learn law now. It's just so impenetrably hard. There are times when I just read, I'm reading something and I can't work out what the hell it means.
because they've just perverted law as some sort of fetishistic sort of attack on it
SPEAKER_01to make it just drown in words. It's drowning in words. It's unbelievable. I had to look at a system of codified rules, and I looked at 10 of them that were written in about 1992. And they took up less than a page. And then I looked at the same 10 rules now, and they ran for eight pages. When I talk about this stuff, it's the sheer physicality of it.
SPEAKER_01So I think the first step is they make law almost impossible to learn. And then they give students an easy off-ramp, which is if you become an activist. If you say, all I care about is human rights law and... in Gaza, then you're okay and you're allowed a job. And that's utterly perverse. It destroys the system. It's cheating on those kids. It's betraying them. And it's just bad. But that's where we are now. We're in a socialist system and it's evil. I can still remember six years ago thinking,
SPEAKER_01Stephen, you can't say it's a socialist system because everybody will call you mad. Nobody's calling me mad now because we're in a socialist system. The question is, how do we get out of it? Si, and forgive me, Stephen, for I'm about to say, because he's doing a second question. He said that we cannot wield the ring, but out of curiosity, is the term gammon a derogatory reference based on personal skin colour? I think it's racism. But again, we're in a socialism where they want two-tiered outcomes. It's not by accident. It's by design. It's how they fetishistically get off on it,
but it's also how they prove that they're in power.
SPEAKER_01They want you to not be able to complain about gammon and And they want to be able to be racist themselves. I'm terribly sure, but I think the N-word is racist no matter who says it. That's a really important point. And they try and say, no, the N-word is not racist if certain people say it. No, that is inconsistent application of rules. That is two-tier justice. That is not on. We must go back to single application of rules. But as you know, and as I teased,
I'd probably just get rid of all racial-based laws anyway because we're not racist.
SPEAKER_01And the way we deal with, if anybody actually was a racist, the way that we deal with it is morally in society by damning them. And, you know, absolutely cascading them, getting Hillary to clip them around the ear. We don't need all these laws. We actually deal with stuff as grown-ups ourselves. And that's what I'd much rather see. Mag says, Hi, Stephen and the Lovelies. I just read MPs back in the Assisted Dying are preparing to use the Parliament Act. Can they do this? So, Mags, I'm afraid I had to say constitutionally they can. Good news.
SPEAKER_01The government whip, the chief whip in the House of Lords has confirmed that they're not going to do it. But constitutionally, I have to be honest, okay? I don't have the luxury of selling you some nonsense like a bunch of made-up letters and numbers or some sort of magic thing that's in the constitution. I have to tell you the truth. And I was sat there all this morning thinking, somebody's going to ask me, aren't they? Somebody's going to ask me. And I did get asked by an ex-MP, and I was just like, I have to tell the truth. And I think it's morally reprehensible to firstly pretend that this isn't
SPEAKER_01government policy because it clearly is government policy. So to call it a private member's bill and make sure it gets less scrutiny, which is the result, is inherently dishonest. I think that's morally reprehensible. I still think that's lawful. Things can be morally reprehensible, but still lawful. That's why law is not inherently good. And if the government wanted to pick this bill up, it'd have to become government business in the next session. in the next session, because I don't think people are aware enough of parliament that whilst we have a
SPEAKER_01general election to a general election, we then have sessions of parliament inside that period. Roughly a year, and they don't sit for a whole one. Think of it like a school year, but that's a session. And so in the next session, the government could bring it back. They'd have to bring it back in exactly the same form um it's in there are provisions to amend it but broadly speaking i don't think there is scope for massive amendment um one parliamentary clerk who i think overstepped their position i think it was a parliamentary clerk
i might be defaming the parliamentary clerks anyway somebody suggested that there was scope for lots of
SPEAKER_01amendments that's not my reading of the act but um The government, most importantly, so I think they could do that. I think it would be morally reprehensible if they did it. Most importantly, the government chief whippers said they're not going to do it. And he is actually a vaguely, he's a good man. He's one of the good ones in Labour. And I think the Labour Party have realised that this is incredibly stupid and is going to destroy them. There's just a few fanatics, including the Prime Minister and Lord Faulkner and Kim Ledbetter and some other of
SPEAKER_01the madder Fabians who are desperate to get this through. They're going to fail, thank God, and thank God for the hard work of the members of the House of Lords. And then mags, while they could use the Parliament Act, I don't think they're going to or that they should. Kay is here. Yay. Did Kay miss Kay's own question?
SPEAKER_00I think Kate. Oh, Markos says, could the fact that some advocating using the ECHR to go after soldiers in a book edited by the disgrace bring him down?
SPEAKER_01Yes. But, um, yes. I mean, it's absolutely disgraceful. And then the parliament, uh, number 10 put out a message that, Keir Starmer had never worked with Phil Shiner. That's a very technical position because Keir Starmer's DPP is bringing prosecutions. And that's, therefore, he's not really, he's never going to be working with the CPS. But Shiner was absolutely at the heart of pursuing what we now know to be fraudulent claims against soldiers in Iraq. So the Labour government will both illegally send soldiers off
to fight and die in
SPEAKER_01Iraq and then illegally prosecute them. That's who socialists are. That's it. As far as I can tell, they're just after the cash. That's all they want. Just public money. Snuffle, snuffle, snuffle. Sickening. Anyway, the lovely Denise, who is our shining star, says, after raising Mary Hill with my councillor, BTCO, I finally own to step back. So we talked about this. I'm so pleased. Yes. And I did actually cover it. I remembered it. I put it in the notes just in case I forgot it.
SPEAKER_01And Denise is going to tell us how she won. And we're going to know. uh martin uh this wonderful on questions rescued by hillary a question rescued by hillary is one that does not go in the official thread please put questions in the official thread it say it makes my life easier and it makes hillary's life easier um but hillary is marvelous at rescuing questions for martin she says is the government forcing people into contracts with third party software providers making touch digital software illegal Governing and stressing fines if you don't enter into these contracts,
SPEAKER_01which I believe is illegal under UK law. No, it's not illegal, provided it's got a statutory basis, Martin. The government can do anything. Again, this is back to the fact we need to go back to a much more mature understanding of morals and what the government should do and really stop worrying about the law. The law can be changed to be whatever any government wants it to be. Therefore, the question is not, is murdering firstborn sons illegal if the law says it's legal it's legal the question is
is murdering for firstborn sons so morally reprehensible that we're going to do it and actually take political activity and grow up in and be and own our society we must own our country it is ours um uh right john says thank you stevens greases all the lovely i'm sure this has been covered before but the home office in spite of its basis for
SPEAKER_01some prosecutions against legal immigrants Is there nothing that can be done? And he wants to personally prosecute the Home Secretary for letting in illegal migrants. I need to think about this more broadly. I've often said crown immunity, but I think we're getting to a point where we probably are going to have to do something. about the failings of the Home Secretary. I don't want to go into too much detail and successive Home Secretaries or Home Secretary, because again, I don't want to give any of the defence that a trial against
them has been
SPEAKER_01pre-prejudiced. But again, John, I think that's one of the ones we need to look into. wendy steven do you anticipate a successful delay on the building of the mega spy embassy i don't really wendy because the entire process was exhausted and then the government um went around that and i'm not sure where anybody goes um i'd the embassy and again we don't look to law the embassy should not have been built and i'm afraid the conservative party should not have sold them the land in 2018 but
SPEAKER_01the labor party should definitely not have given them permission Both are bad.
SPEAKER_00Uniparty bad. And finally, you're all arranging a meetup, aren't you?
SPEAKER_01Bless you. We need to have, one day we'll have our party. Which for free subscribers is literally, that's not a political party. We literally want to have a party. Like a party party with nipples. Stuff would be great. Fine, we always save Hillary till last. Um, so it is Hillary. Uh, ministers are preparing new legislation that would allow Britain to prescribe Islam as a revolutionary guard. Um, Do they need legislation with this?
SPEAKER_01No, Hillary, I think that's just journalists not understanding. And the legislation already exists. The Home Secretary just makes an order. It's really easy to do. I don't know why they're making such a faff about, I'll have to prepare it. Oh, you might have to do some typing, love. Oh, well, get on it. Typey, signy, stampy, go. You mean you could do it in 20 minutes, Hillary? They're just making a rigmarole out of it because they don't want to prescribe Iran's Revolutionary Guard because they're on the side of Iran's Revolutionary Guard,
SPEAKER_01because they're communists and wrong-uns together. Right. Hillary wishes me a good week and doesn't tell me up. Out of curiosity about the sophistication of AI's understanding of UK constitutional law, I asked AI. Oh, no, Hillary, you didn't. Do not ask. Stop asking Tamagotchi's legal questions. Stop it. Sorry, Hillary, that must have been somebody else. But I've got to your AI question. It just all got bundled up as you.
SPEAKER_01What are the advantages and disadvantages of an uncodified constitution? It told me these things. Is it correct? Yeah. The advantage of an uncodified constitution in the UK include flexibility and adaptability, allowing it to evolve with changing societal values. That's okay. It's a bit vague, but sure.
SPEAKER_00Disadvantages include potential for ambiguity. Why would there be less ambiguity in an uncodified constitution?
SPEAKER_01There's plenty of ambiguity in the American constitution. They fight over it like cats and dogs all the time. vulnerability to manipulation don't get that as there is no single document outlining the rules or what so we're so stupid that we can't look at three documents or however many it is um ai is is a waste of time it's rapidly morphing into everybody's favorite um plodder at university who's destined for a two-two um where it says on this hand that and on this on the other hand that and then goes
which I used to mark exam scripts for both a university of repute and as an
SPEAKER_01external examiner for a university of an awful lot less repute. And I hated essays that just went, on the one hand, this, on the other hand, that. And that's what Grok and AI is morphing into because it's not artificial intelligence. Intelligence is a gift from God. They can't create it in a laboratory. They can fake it. They can lie. They can create fraud that looks like it's intelligence. And it's like, well done. But it's not intelligent. It's not intelligent. It's not consciousness.
SPEAKER_01Question two from Hillary. A Muslim activist convicted for his role in armed terrorist park is seating election. I know. Should convicted terrorists be stopped from standing as candidates for parliament? We do have rules about criminality in parliament. I was going to look it up. It's not actually parliament he's standing for. It's the council. But I still think that there are rules that he may well be in breach of. I think for local elections, I would. I probably wouldn't have that rule for MPs. Just because if a criminal tries to stand to be an MP,
I think it's more important that we notice that something's going deeply wrong in
SPEAKER_01our society. Can existing legislation do this or be updated to do this? Yes, existing legislation can do both. They can always get rid of it later on. And I'm pretty sure there is existing legislation about councillors. So I don't really understand what's going on with it. But that does strike me as an absolute disgrace. Right. I've waffled way too long. Does anybody... Hugh Grok, he said, I use Grok to make rude images of the Prime Minister. There's nothing wrong with using Grok for certain things.
SPEAKER_01Just don't ask it law, or you'll just get the Plotter 2-2 answer. You know, you just don't, on the one hand, this, on the other hand. It's just no good. Right, sectarianism is a danger. Yes, it is, Hillary. Yes, it is. CJA has joined just as we are finishing. So poor CJA, but they will be available on Catch Up. I hope everybody goes and has an absolutely fantastic weekend. I'm going to go down and watch more Simpsons with small person.
This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit sbarrettbar.substack.com/subscribe
This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit sbarrettbar.substack.com/subscribe
This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit sbarrettbar.substack.com/subscribe
Thank you Lillie Jones, Hilary more than one question, Jane Noble Knight, Denise Hall, SARA L 🇬🇧, and many others for tuning into my live video! Join me for my next live video in the app. This is a public episode. If...
This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit sbarrettbar.substack.com/subscribe