Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Yarn Library

Yarn Library artwork

S3 E12 Knitting: More Questions Than Answers

Nov 16, 202626 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

I started this series of Yarn Library wanting to understand more about knitting and the people who make it their living. After all those conversations, I think I have more questions than answers. We want detailed patterns, but also independent knitters. We want affordable patterns, but properly paid designers. We want knitting to be inclusive, but no single pattern can fit everybody perfectly. In this solo finale, I reflect on the ideas that have stayed with me and how they’re changing my thinking about designing, teaching and making a living from knitting. There’s plenty I haven’t worked out, and I’d love to hear what you think. Questions, thoughts or suggestions for future guests? Email podcast@cleevelyknits.com. Follow Yarn Library wherever you listen, and if you’ve enjoyed the series, please leave a rating or review. Thank you for listening, and happy knitting.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_00We want more detailed patterns, and yet we also want more independent knitters. We want cheaper patterns, and yet we also want to make sure designers are paid properly. We want knitting to be inclusive, but by definition, no pattern can ever fit everyone perfectly. We want creativity, but increasingly we allow social media to define what actually gets made and what we're interested in. Over the last few months, I've talked to some extraordinary people on this podcast, trying to further my understanding of the knitting world and everything in it. Rather than finding answers to my questions, I think I've been left with more questions that I want to dig further into than I've got answers.

SPEAKER_00And indeed, this podcast was meant to be a way for me to address all of the nuance, which we just can't get into on the snapshot little tidbits of information we get on social media. So I'm left now in a reflective position wanting to talk to you more about everything that I've heard over the last 10 or so episodes. And I want to tell you where my thoughts are at and give you something to think about in terms of how we build this season going forwards. Are we making knitting too easy? Now, this is a really interesting question for me that's come up repeatedly in different ways with people like Patty Lyons, Chantal Miyagishima, Zandy Peters have all expressed views in different ways on that fundamental question of what should a pattern contain.

SPEAKER_00There's a huge drive in the pattern design world to transition from a world where we had patterns explained in a kind of coded dense language into a very fulsome explanation of exactly how to make what you've got in front of you. Now I've experienced this myself because when I've created designs, and I'm thinking particularly about my Talker's hat, the one with the spiral on it, and Dominique, which is this um beautiful big uh design with the shading on it, those designs for me actually condensed down to a really tiny size in my notebook.

SPEAKER_00But when it came to being able to explain them to basically any knitter, I went into pages and pages of explanations and diagrams so that they were as approachable as possible. Now, some knitters really appreciate that, but some don't. And that doesn't work for some people. And as Patty pointed out, I'm going to quote here from the episode, by trying to merge a knitting class and a pattern, you get a diluted version of each thing. And that made me think a lot about what I'm trying to do when I do create a design and when I do communicate it.

SPEAKER_00Who am I trying to help? Because it's a problem. If you want to make a brilliant knitting pattern for an advanced knitter, actually what you need to do is maybe present more of the puzzle. And that's something Zandy Peters talked a lot about that you sometimes are creating a puzzle, you have puzzle solvers in knitters. Some people, on the other hand, need the encouragement and want to be shown step by step. And I just think that's really interesting, and it probably comes down to a bit of a choice by a designer about who they're trying to help the most.

SPEAKER_00But it is interesting to me as a as someone experimenting with design about how involved you get in that process of trying to help other people's education. Now I've really taken that on board in terms of trying to build my own understanding about what I should be doing to help people. I'm currently working on a design which I don't know how to describe this, it is complicated. There is absolutely no question that what I'm working on is a hard thing.

SPEAKER_00So it's a design that I struggled with for a couple of months in terms of articulating exactly how I wanted it to be. It's got 24 different cable stitches used within it, and a bunch of other things as well. And I am halfway through making it and I have made so many mistakes, which because it's a sample, I have to go back and correct. Now, the thing is, as a pattern, I fully intend to release that, hopefully, as a hard pattern.

SPEAKER_00I'm gonna take a step away from what I've done historically where I try and explain everything to everyone, and this is just something which I'm gonna accept is a hard thing to make, and therefore I want to make it difficult and a puzzle for people to be able to make. And I'm really interested to see how that goes. I'm interested whether people buy it, whether they can make it, whether they choose to make it. But, you know, for me, this is all experimentation and it's all learning, so I'm really interested in the feedback of that. Now, I'm only halfway through it and I'm loving it because it's such a challenge, but I can't wait to see how that does get consumed by people as a result.

SPEAKER_00And there was another piece of information in there which I thought was really interesting from um Chantal and Anna, if you've listened to those episodes, but both of them alluded to this idea that actually you may not even know the mistakes that you're making or may not know the techniques that you want to um look up if you're looking for things online. And that's an interesting idea about well, if you don't even know what's wrong, are you better going to a class on something rather than buying a pattern and expecting all of the information in the pattern to be within there?

SPEAKER_00And that's challenging, but there's something potentially useful in there, which is if the pattern does at least list every technique and skill that's used within the pattern, then that does at least give you somewhere to go to YouTube and be able to look up those techniques. And I find that an interesting idea that maybe you need to bundle together this little knowledge package which says, well, if you need to look up any of these things, these are the search terms to use, and maybe help designers not have to go to the effort of creating all the videos and tutorials and trying to create a full class out of every knitting pattern that they also create.

SPEAKER_00And I think it's fundamentally a difficult question. Do you want every knit to be able to understand every pattern? Or is the whole point that actually you create this wide variety of patterns and that everyone gets to choose their own designers, their own styles, and all the rest of it? It's an interesting question, and it leaves me also with the question that Zandy Peters proposed right at the beginning of this series, which is the weird thing about patterns is that when you're buying a pattern, you're never buying what you're going to learn from. You only buy from a picture of a finished object.

SPEAKER_00And I think that's a such a difficult tension to manage. The second big issue that I think is worth addressing that's come up time and time again, is about how we value creative work. Now, creative work is obviously undervalued. That is hardly unique to knitting. It's within writing, it's within art, anywhere you want to go in the world, creativity is typically undervalued. And I know there's also a well-trodden argument about, well, where work has been done because it's been majority women that have produced, that is a classic way in which things get undervalued.

SPEAKER_00I've got another point that I want to make about why things are undervalued. But another thing is a structural change which comes back to pattern design about how patterns are expected to do so much more than they used to. So Patty Lyons, who has long experience in the knitting industry, has talked to me about how, well, when you get a hat pattern now, people expect to see it test knitted. And I've had this experience too. When I've published patterns without test knits, people say, Oh, I would have bought this, but there isn't a test knit for it.

SPEAKER_00I can't see evidence of it. Now, the thing is when you've got a hat pattern or something that doesn't need multiple sizes, it used to be that you'd never have that expectation. So it's a weird thing that social media has done to create this expectation that hats and scarves and gloves and everything, as well as garments, get what's called fully test knitted. Now, a full test knit has also grown in what people would expect. So traditionally, if you went back 30 years and you picked a jumper out of a magazine, that would have been test knitted, but possibly on only one or maybe a second size, and everything else was graded from that single pattern.

SPEAKER_00Whereas now a designer is expected to create the design and pattern, but then also coordinate a test knit. Now you may think a test knit doesn't take, you know, well, a designer doesn't have to make anything, but I promise you it takes a long, long time to work through a test knit because you have to find test knitters, it adds time to the process of creating a design, which it is time that you're not making money by selling the pattern, and then you have to have all of this coordination and feedback with so many different people.

SPEAKER_00Yes, it doesn't take hundreds of hours, but it's definitely tens of hours, and if you add that to something like a hat or a scarf, well, that's a lot of extra resource that you're asking designers to put in. It's a weird feature of modern patterns which didn't used to be around. And I think social media's got a lot to answer for there in terms of creating that increased expectation. Now, I also like what Zandy Peters has talked about, and I think Patty as well, that actually we should be talking about preview knitting and getting people involved in doing preview knits rather than test knitting.

SPEAKER_00Because also, if I create a hat, I know that the hat design works. It doesn't need to be tested to prove that it works. Yes, there might be some readability issues, but I use two editors, for example, to be able to go through that. I go use a tech editor and I use a words editor to make sure that the copy all works. So you shouldn't really be asking your test knitters to do that. It's more about previewing the design. And I think that's an interesting terminology, which also I'm going to try and adopt going forwards. But here's the thing I think not enough people are talking about, which I really want to do research into.

SPEAKER_00I think there are two big reasons why patterns aren't priced properly for designers. And I'm not able to prove them because I haven't done enough research on it, but I want you to go away and think about it. I'd love to know your thoughts in the comments here, and I really want to find someone who can help me just do this as a piece of research. I suspect patterns are structurally priced incorrectly. I think I think there is a long history of patterns being listed for sale and then not being increased in price.

SPEAKER_00That's one issue. The second one is free patterns. Now, the issue is as a pattern designer, you don't want to increase your prices. It's a difficult thing. No one wants to increase their prices. I've got a very commercial background and I've worked in consumer brands. I know about how you increase prices. Best practice when you're dealing with direct consumer businesses is to increase prices regularly by very small amounts. Now, supermarkets take this to an extreme. They will fluctuate prices every week.

SPEAKER_00But as a brand working in a direct consumer area, what you'd be expecting to do is increase prices one, two, or even four times a year, a very small amount that keeps pace with inflation. Now it's important to do not year to year, that doesn't make so much of a difference, but over a period like 10 years, well, if you haven't increased your prices, because your wage bill will have gone up and your costs will have gone up, actually your headline price will be below the inflation expected value.

SPEAKER_00So the problem there, I think, is that when you're in a very small business, firstly, it's scary to increase your prices, and it's also a pain. I don't want to go into my patterns and say, oh, every six months I've got to adjust them up by 5p. That doesn't work. But secondly, I don't really have the confidence as an individual person to just go and put up the prices, and I think that's probably a big issue with patent designers. I started to have a look at this and I looked at some of the big designers like Stephen West.

SPEAKER_00And actually, his prices have slightly increased on shawls where I could find evidence how they were listed in 2009. They haven't kept pace with inflation. Now, my suspicion is that for most designers, patterns haven't kept pace with inflation over a long period, and the result of that is that in real terms, patterns are getting cheaper and cheaper over time. When you combine that with the pressure of free patterns, then I think you've got a real problem. Free patterns are released by designers partly because some designers don't want the faff of having to deal with payments and taking money, and they just want to put something out there without having the pressure, that's fine.

SPEAKER_00And some designers want to put patterns out there for free so that they demonstrate how they write patterns. Again, I totally understand both of those. But the difficulty is as a designer, you're then going across that barrier of, well, this isn't a free version, it's a premium version, and so you've got to then argue why it is paid. And I think where you're providing value against something that's free, it's really difficult to demonstrate that additional value. And I think if you've got that price moving further and further away from free, that's even higher pressure.

SPEAKER_00So I don't really know who has to change there. I don't know whether it's designers that need to be more confident to increase their prices. I don't know whether Ravelry, as an example, should automatically always increase prices on behalf of all designers. I don't know whether designers should stop listing things for free. But it makes the argument about, well, why are patterns undervalued really complicated. The next issue I want to talk about is how inclusive can knitting patterns really be.

SPEAKER_00Now, I'm going to talk a little bit about size inclusivity, but realistically, there are broader problems with inclusivity in the knitting world. Both how do you treat left-handed knitters, people with different knitting styles, as well as people with different learning preferences. There are so many issues bundled up there that I think that's worth a whole episode some other time. But I want to specifically talk about size inclusivity because it's really on my mind, because I want to design a cardigan, and it's kind of the size inclusivity argument is really putting me off actually making it.

SPEAKER_00So I guess the important thing here is to start with the fact that size doesn't equal shape. Now that's something that a number of designers have talked to me about, and what was really interesting is that there's a bunch of people here that I've talked to on this podcast who've got what considered normal bodies, but I mean goodness what knows what normal is, but there's nothing that you would walk past these people in the street and think, gosh, that's such a peculiar shape, and yet every single person has got parts of their body where they say, Well, when I knit this kind of garment, this bit doesn't fit me properly.

SPEAKER_00And this comes back to, well, when you're trying to make something size inclusive, which is a really hard thing to do in itself anyway, you're then still not making it actually fit everyone. And then you get into the question of, well, if you're trying to make something fit everyone, you go back to what I said about, well, you have to teach lessons or you have to have extra parts of a pattern to say, well, with this part of your body, you might need to do this extra shaping. And you create all of those extra cues for people to say, well, this is how you might make it fit.

SPEAKER_00Now, if we go back to the argument about advanced knitters, well, they just know that. They know that they've got a wider back, or that they know that they've got a different shaped bust, or waist, or arm length, or arm thickness, all of those things, and advanced knitters should just know that, then you don't create the prompts. But on the other hand, that makes it less approachable for everyone who doesn't know exactly when the trigger might be to include bust darting as an example. And that's something as well that Arina Shah also commented on: that what lengths do you actually go to if you want to make something totally inclusive and totally work for anything, for anything and everyone?

SPEAKER_00And that becomes a really difficult, really difficult problem to solve, and in fact, goes so far that it makes it pretty impossible to make such a thing as a universal pattern. Now, Zandy made a fantastic observation here about we started talking about Apple pilots, or potato pilots, I think it was, where the OXO good grips came up with a they were trying to make something more inclusive for universal design. So a tool which has got a much wider grip to be able to hold on to.

SPEAKER_00Yes, it makes it easier for people who struggle with their grip. But it turns out it's just better for everyone. Now, I think the knitting world is still waiting for that aha moment of the OXO good grips, where it can truly say this is the way you do it that makes it universally appealing for everyone and work for everyone. At the moment, it feels very much like there are too many bits of, well, you need to know about this for this kind of shaping or this for the other kind of shaping. And there isn't that way of saying, well, this is how it works for absolutely everyone.

SPEAKER_00And it's something then I struggle with when I come back to the idea of creating my own clothing design to publish, and it's absolutely a reason why I won't publish my quite well-known cable jumper that I wear a lot, is that I don't want to create something that is exclusive to a few people, but on the other hand, making it inclusive to everyone is something that is still, I feel, beyond my capabilities. I guess the question that you get left with there is, does a knitting pattern need to serve everyone?

SPEAKER_00Or do we need to live in a world where we accept that not everything works for everyone, and therefore we celebrate the individuality of each pattern and each niche for its own thing? What happens when your knitting hobby becomes work? Well that's something which I and other designers have struggled with. Melanie Berg put it very succinctly. When you turn your hobby into a job, you need to find another hobby. Jane Abraham told me it stripped the joy out of doing it because it felt like you were a production line, and she was referring there to knitting samples for her shop.

SPEAKER_00And it's something I experience a lot as well. One of the things that I've really struggled with is trying to keep on top of social media and the presence that you start creating. At the time of recording, I've got about 330,000 followers across platform. And when you think about that in terms of expectations of content and so on, it's very easy to get in your own head about, well, I need to produce something now for the sake of producing it. And that takes you a very, very long way away from trying to create the things purely because you are passionate about it. Something I've worked really hard on this year is actually trying to step away from social media and all of those expectations and just focus on things that I want to do for joy, for the sake of joy.

SPEAKER_00And I think that's me trying to protect what's partly still a hobby for me, which is the knitting of the social media, although it is increasingly something that I want to be doing as my full-time professional career. Because the problem is that when knitting, when your hobby does become work, it does become increasingly draining, it does become more difficult, and you don't have that place where you have that outlet. Now, I will say one of the things that has brought me the most joy in the last couple of months is this exceptionally hard knitting pattern that I've been working on.

SPEAKER_00It's hard for me. I don't know, maybe you'll find it easy to knit, but for me it's really, really challenging. And it's a reminder for me that actually putting aside all of the other world's concerns about what makes what constitutes a good pattern and doing something that is just something I'm passionate about is hopefully a place that makes me at least happy and fulfilled. One of the most extreme examples, I think, that I've managed to turn knitting as a hobby, which should sound like so much fun for me, into a really intense amount of work is running the knitting retreats that I do.

SPEAKER_00If you don't know, I run make a getaway retreats, and they're the most fabulous holidays for people. Creating spaces for three, four, five days for people to come away and knit together and learn together. It's a wonderful, wonderful experience. And I am so jealous of everyone that comes on these retreats because I have to run around and do the teaching and making sure that everyone is happy and fulfilled and having a wonderful time. I'm playing host. So I don't really get to experience them. Again, I've taken something which could be pure joy and hobby, and I've turned it into full-time work for me.

SPEAKER_00Brilliant, good job, Adam. But just going back for a second, talking about the interviewees that I've spoken to, so Charlotte Stone, for example, who's created so many wonderful soccer patterns, Stone Knits, if you're familiar with the social media account. Charlotte was talking about how expectations are so high because once you've created a single pattern which hundreds or thousands of people buy, the expectations on social media are that you're just going to produce another and another and another. And that's trapping both from a creative perspective that it squashes you into a confined space because you have to create something in these dimensions, which is, say, a sock, and it's also difficult because then when you don't produce your next big viral hit, that also makes you feel like a failure as someone that's living in the eye of the public in that respect.

SPEAKER_00And I think that's something which is really difficult to understand from outside because also people don't see your failures by definition. When something doesn't go viral, when something doesn't take off, when a pattern doesn't sell, it's never seen anywhere. And so the only person that's left actually understanding those failures is really you as the designer or a content creator. And that's a painful and isolating and lonely place to be. What I see is that the people who are able to continue to progress through that difficult phase and that they keep putting stuff out there, they keep going, well, those are the successful pattern writers that we know and that become part of.

SPEAKER_00The scene of who makes great knitting patterns. And that brings me on to the question of why we actually knit. And that's a question which is addressed by, not directly, I haven't asked people that question in so many words, but I feel like there are so many different reasons for the designers that I've talked to that they do actually knit. A lot of people, it starts out as something that, well, you're brought up in that way. You'll get taught to do it, and you do it as a child and you never really question it. A lot of people, as an adult, it's something that we rely on as a way of calming ourselves or a hobby that we find rewarding.

SPEAKER_00Certainly, there are people like Irena Shah who talked about the connection that it brings her with people who used to knit with her or for her and brings her together with history. And Alex Byrd talks about how she wants to keep the tradition of Estonian knitting alive and how she also wants to make sure that it is kept pace with contemporary design processes. And the wonderful thing about knitting is that it creates this sense of accomplishment as you go through the process of making something. You don't have to feel accomplishment when you finish the object, you get the sense of accomplishment when you change colour or when you move on to a different technique or when you finish a cable.

SPEAKER_00There are so many points at which you get that little hit of, yeah, I did something great. And that goes back to what Anna O'Leary talked about in terms of adults choosing to learn. It's something that children do all of the time. And it's so wonderful about being a child. You get to do all of that learning. It's structured into what you do. But as an adult, you need to find ways where you can participate in playful activities where you get to learn from what you're doing and you get that sense of satisfaction as you progress. I think that's one of the reasons why I do love teaching adults as well, is because adults really, really crave that, but don't always know that that's how beneficial it's going to be to learn something new.

SPEAKER_00And when you do get to teach someone that new thing, you get such a big rush of that person feeling that sense of achievement. And I absolutely love that. And I think that's something why the teachers that I've talked to as well creating an environment for a few hours where you're creating the expectation that you're going to sit down, you're going to be protected from the outside world, and you're going to be forced to learn this technique whether you like it or not. I think that's a really great place to be. And just reflecting again on what Charlotte said, I don't think there can be much wrong in knitting.

SPEAKER_00It's a hobby as well. And it's so true. And I really hope that you are someone that participates in knitting and feels that there isn't much wrong. I will certainly say that when you're online and you create social media accounts, there are people out there who are perfectly happy to criticize a lot. But knitting should be joyful. It should be something playful and rewarding. And I really hope it is for you. And I think rather than making a discussion about agreeing on the right way to knit, it's more about preserving space for people to approach knitting in their own way, in a way that works for them.

SPEAKER_00Anyway, I really hope this has given you food for thought. This is going to be my last episode before Christmas, because in the run-up to Christmas, I'm afraid I just have too much on my plate. I'm really passionate about continuing my journey of learning in the knitting world. I really want to continue this podcast in the new year. If you have suggestions as to people you'd like to see interviewed on the podcast or you want to be on here yourself, just drop me an email, podcast at clevelynits.com. I promise I read every email that I get. I don't necessarily get to reply to everyone, but please do, if you've got suggestions, please do write them in.

SPEAKER_00If you haven't already subscribed to the channel, drop me a follow, and I'd love to know what you thought of this episode in particular. Let me know in the comments. Thank you for listening. Happy knitting. Thank you so much for listening to this episode of Yarn Library. If you've enjoyed the conversation, please do follow or subscribe wherever you listen to your podcasts. And if you have a moment to leave a rating or review, it genuinely helps more people discover the show. If you have a question, comment, or idea for a future episode, someone you would want to hear me interview, email me at podcast at cleavelynits.com. And if you'd like to see this conversation or watch some of my longer form videos, head to Clevelandits on YouTube.

SPEAKER_00I'll be back very soon with another episode. Until then, thank you for listening and happy knitting.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. S3 E11: The Yarn Shop Dream: What Comes Next? | Jane Abraham

    Nov 2, 202652 minAudio

    To avoid travelling to London to buy beautiful yarn, Jane Abraham opened a yarn shop in Cornwall. A perfectly reasonable solution, if you ask me. Jane runs Stitches & Cream in Falmouth and is also known as The Cornish...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. S3 E10: Creativity, Colourwork and 144 Squares with Annah O'Leary

    Oct 19, 202646 minAudio

    What would you do if you were feeling anxious and needed a small, manageable project? If you're Annah O'Leary, apparently the answer is to design an enormous blanket made from 144 colourwork squares. Even though you've...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. S3 E9 What Knitting Patterns Can’t Teach You with Patty Lyons

    Oct 5, 20261 hrAudio

    What can a knitting pattern teach you, and what can only be learned by understanding your own knitting? Patty Lyons joins me for a frank, funny and thought-provoking conversation about the skills that exist beyond the...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. S3 E8: It’s Not Brain Surgery, with Charlotte Stone

    Sep 21, 202656 minAudio

    This week, I’m joined by Charlotte Stone, better known as StoneKnits, the designer and author whose wonderfully playful colourwork socks have become instantly recognisable. Charlotte didn’t set out with a strategy to...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. S3 E7: A Blind Date with Your Yarn, with Melanie Berg

    Sep 7, 20261 hr 2 minAudio

    This week, I’m joined by Melanie Berg, the knitwear designer behind Mairlynd. I first met Melanie when I accidentally attended one of her shawl-design classes entirely in German. Thanks to Google Translate, I managed to...

    Credit the people on this episode