You’re a business owner or a creator with something real to sell, and your Substack is growing but the income isn’t following, this post is for you. Most people publish on Substack and quietly wait to get paid. They show up, they post, they pile more behind the paywall, and they hope the money follows the effort. It rarely does, and the reason usually isn’t the writing. Here’s what you’ll walk away with: A clear picture of why publishing and selling are two different jobs, and the specific habits that turn a growing list into actual income. The short version: Stop treating Substack like a place to post, and start treating it like a place to sell. Substack isn’t another feed to dump content into The first mistake is treating Substack like every other platform. People come over, dump the same repurposed content they post everywhere else, and wait for it to turn into something. It doesn’t, because Substack rewards a different thing. Not the 3-second hook, not the aesthetics, not the trend of the week. It rewards substance: The actual quality and depth of what you’re saying. Think of it like a restaurant. People will stand in line for the hot new place once. But if the service is cold and the food is forgettable, they’re not coming back. Your publication works the same way. The first post might get a look. The 10th is what decides whether anyone stays. This is also why Substack suits people who don’t want to live and die by visuals. In Kelly’s case, the appeal is not wanting to still be doing a photo shoot every other day at 60 just to stay relevant. You get paid for your ideas here, not your feed. And piling more content behind the paywall isn’t the answer either. People don’t upgrade for more of the same. They upgrade for something they actually want that they can’t get on the free side. So the real work splits in two: Building an offer worth paying for, and getting good at selling it. Your readers don’t know what you sell, and that’s your problem to fix That second job, selling, starts with an uncomfortable truth. If you surveyed 1,000 of your subscribers right now, most of them couldn’t tell you what your paid tier includes. They saw your offer once, maybe, the day they subscribed. Months later, they’ve forgotten it exists. That’s not their failing. It’s yours to fix, and it’s fixable. People subscribed because they’re interested in what you do. So remind them, directly and often, that there’s a next step. A simple message in the chat or a DM does more than another broadcast: Thanks for being here. Did you know we include this and this in the paid tier? Worth a look if it’s useful to you. It feels like blasphemy to a lot of creators. Then half the replies come back as some version of “I didn’t even know you offered that, I’m in.” The pattern underneath is boring and true: The more often you make the offer, the more sales you make. Whatever outcome you want in the business, you have to do the behavior that produces it. If you want sales every day, make offers every day. But knowing you should convert free readers to paid is the easy part. Knowing which move to make, for the specific subscriber in front of you, is the hard part. Our Free-to-Paid Playbook is packed with 100+ tested strategies for turning free readers into paying members, sorted by subscriber stage, so you find the right one in minutes. Sell like the sales math is real, not like selling is rude The thing that stops most people isn’t strategy. It’s discomfort. They hold back because they don’t want to be salesy, don’t want to bother anyone, don’t want to be too much. So they make an offer once, hear nothing, decide it didn’t work, and go quiet. But your belief about selling drives how you sell. If selling feels like taking, you’ll do it apologetically and rarely. If you understand that selling is how the person with the answer reaches the person who needs it, you’ll do it like it matters. And the math isn’t on the side of the timid. People rarely buy on the first ask. Most sales happen after several follow-ups, not the opening message, because people buy from whoever is top of mind when they’re finally ready. The creators who win aren’t louder. They’re just still there at the point most people quit. That takes patience. Anything that compounds, an audience, a reputation, a business, gets built over months and years, not days and weeks. And the ones chasing an overnight win from a viral note tend to attract the wrong people anyway, the kind who don’t buy and don’t stay. Turn selling into a system, not a scramble Making offers every day sounds exhausting. It isn’t, once you stop reinventing it. The move is a monthly campaign. Give people a real reason to act now: A defined window, a specific thing they can get for a limited time. Human nature doesn’t change, and when there’s a genuine reason to buy now, more people buy now. A monthly workshop is a clean example. Announce the topic at the start of the month. Build a little anticipation in the days before. Run it. Then offer the recording. That’s a full campaign you can repeat every month without inventing a new sales strategy each time. And the busier you are, the more a repeatable system beats chasing a new tactic every few weeks. Build the engine so it isn’t all riding on you The last piece is leverage, because you can’t be the whole machine forever. Start with an inventory of what you already have: The masterclasses, podcasts, webinars, and trainings sitting in your archive. That back catalog is raw material. With AI tools and a clear process, one person can turn it into hundreds of notes and a queue of articles scheduled well in advance. But don’t just hand it all to someone and walk away. The creators who get burned are the ones who delegate a platform they don’t understand themselves. Learn how it works first, build the system, then bring a team member into it alongside you so you’re both working from the same playbook. Delegation without a system is just outsourcing your confusion. That’s the whole shift, from publishing and hoping to running an actual business on top of your publication. If you’re ready to turn your Substack into real income and not just a growing list, that’s the work we do inside the Substack Accelerator. It’s direct coaching from the Write • Build • Scale team, built around one outcome: Becoming a Substack Bestseller and building a real business on top of your publication. This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit writebuildscale.substack.com/subscribe
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_02We are live. Hello, everyone, and welcome to today's session. Hopefully, Kelly, this is what you bring to the platform, so I'm really excited to get your perspective on, in my opinion, how to use Substack a little differently than what people are probably most used to hearing on the platform. Yeah. I'm just hearing my own echo. Do you hear me all right? Yeah. You sound good on myself.
SPEAKER_02Perfect. Kelly, I actually want to dive straight in. You came to Substack with a background of sales, how to sell, how to build offers, how to build a thriving business, right? So you came with a successful business. What did you see inSubstack that actually made you want to
SPEAKER_01jump in? So many things. I think first of all, the people that tend to spend time on Substack Are people that are craving connection, community, and depth. And it was very evident as soon as we came over here that the caliber of people here Is very different, for example, than the caliber of people that are really spending time on like Instagram and some of these other platforms. So I would say there's a culture of Substack that I think is really attractive,
SPEAKER_01especially if you are a service-based business owner and you really value connection, community, depth. You have work that you want to share with people that are actually craving more meaningful conversations. Those were some of the things that stood out to us right away.
SPEAKER_02And I mean, you had your business all set up, you had your offers, everything, your systems, your team. When you look at what you're doing on Substack now and also what you see people doing, what stood out to you in terms of what didn't directly transfer from other platforms that you've been using before? On the strategy part, on the monetization part, you already talked about culture and community, but are there any other things that
SPEAKER_01really stood out and surprised you? Well, I mean, I think Substack provides a lot of advantages for business owners that want to grow their businesses, especially if they have a small team. So the fact that you can do in-app purchases, a lot of people don't realize the significance of that. If you look at consumer behavior and how much people have shifted all of their buying, for example, to places like Amazon or places that they already have themselves auto-logged in, that is literally dictating where and how people are spending their money.
SPEAKER_01And the fact that you can have multiple offers built into the Substack platform and people don't need to leave in order to access them, that's tapping into the cultural zeitgeist in a way that other social media platforms aren't, which creates a huge advantage for any business owner that actually creates community and a following here on Substack. So that was a really big thing. I mean, obviously, there's many components of The distinctions between Substack and the other platforms
SPEAKER_01and why it's such a superior place for business owners. But I think the in-app monetization is huge. And I think also we're in a very special moment right now. And a lot of people don't realize the significance of this moment. There aren't ads on Substack yet. People don't realize how much things will change here when that happens and how right now is a literal goldmine because Substack currently makes money when you make money.
SPEAKER_01Their whole platform is currently optimized to promote and help people grow that are getting paid subscribers. And so I keep trying to explain to business owners that this is like a moment. It's a moment that's not going to last. And so business owners should really be taking advantage of this because right now all of Substack's interests are our interests.
SPEAKER_02When you try to explain that to, and let's talk about established business owners who have offers, who maybe have audiences elsewhere, What are some of the common misconceptions and mistakes you're seeing right now? Because, I mean, I've seen so much in terms of also just a misunderstanding of how the platform should be used and what the strengths and advantages are, which I think is for a large part also because all the other channels we are used to are They just became very similar to each other, right?
SPEAKER_02All with the link in bio and link in first comment and just the way you drive engagement and clicks to external sites with the hope that people will sign up and eventually purchase. Yeah.
SPEAKER_01I think there's a lot of mistakes that people are making when they come over the platform and you can see it, right? So there's a lot of people that are like, oh, I'm going to get on Substack. And so all they do is start dumping content on Substack the way that they did on the other platforms. It's kind of exactly what you just said. They think of it as like another social media platform. So they come, they dump a bunch of repurposed content and they hope that that's going to like turn into something. And I think it's really important to understand that you should have like a completely different approach,
SPEAKER_01mentality, and philosophy in the way that you're showing up on Substack to really make it work for you. And so I would say do not come and just dump content here the way that you would on another platform. You see a lot of big influencers doing this right now. They're like, I'm going to get on Substack, right? So they just take the same content that they're putting other places. They dump it here. It's not going to go anywhere, right? That's number one. Number two, a lot of people, of course, first heard about Substack as a publication and newsletter platform.
SPEAKER_01So they think if I just publish once a week, you know, that in and of itself is going to grow me this, you know, big paid audience and business. And it's more than that. It is about community. It is about the relationship between what you're doing with notes and with your paid articles. It is about, for us, like, we do a lot of campaigns, so those campaigns are really, really important. I think that a lot of people put on the other side of their paywall just more content. And they hope that people will just pay for more content.
SPEAKER_01And I think that you have to be a bit more strategic than that in understanding what your audience is truly craving and what they would pay to upgrade to access on the other side of that paywall instead of just kind of like more of the same, you know?
SPEAKER_02And I view it as those two big pillars, really, right? You have the offer side, exactly what you just described, like people don't want to pay to get more content or more of the same in that sense. So you really have to get a deep understanding for the audience and what you can do for them. And then the second part of that game is, how do I sell? Like, how do I make sure people want to pay for it, whether it is the paid tier Or anything that comes after the paid tier.
SPEAKER_02Have you spotted anything there when it comes to Substack in particular in terms of what makes it easier to sell your paid tier? Do you have a philosophy, a framework, or even the mindset shifts it requires in order to sell more confidently and comfortably?
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Well, I think, you know, the first thing I would say just overall since I teach sales for a living and my channel is called The Sacred Art of Selling, right? I think your belief set around selling always drives your behavior. And what I always tell people about sales in general is selling is your opportunity to unlock someone else's dream. And selling is your opportunity to be a maximizer of human potential. You literally have the information and transformation that could change someone's life.
SPEAKER_01And a lot of people, they'll do something once or twice and then they'll say, oh, that didn't work. And they move on. And so I always say it's so important to understand just basic sales statistics. Basic sales statistics. They are law. They're not going to change, right? On average, people say no three times before they say yes. On average, 85% of sales happen in the 9th to 12th follow-up, right? People buy based on top-of-mind awareness, which means one of the last three people that followed up with them.
SPEAKER_01No one wants to accept these things. No. They're real. They're real, right? And so I think for a lot of business owners, number one, they hold back from selling because they're like, I don't want to bother people. I don't want to be salesy. I don't want to be too much. I don't want to be in front of people, right? And then I think on the other side, there's just a lack of patience overall. Overall, right? And this is not just specific to Substack. I think that with anything that you're going to do that's going to be excellent and going to be lasting and something that's going to compound and scale over time,
SPEAKER_01you have to be willing to do it consistently for months and years, not days and weeks. And I think that's a huge gap that I see with people. You know, when they approach Substack, it's like everyone wants that overnight success. And there's a lot of things that you can do to have success really quickly. But you also have to be willing to put in the reps. And I think that a lot of people hesitate around that.
SPEAKER_02I love how you stated that so clearly. It's something I try to communicate in so many different forms all the time, and I think the misconception also stems from There's so many people just posting about how quickly they have grown and how they went viral with a node, etc. And of course, you could go viral with a very random node, just like you can go viral with random content on other channels. But that's not a strategy.
SPEAKER_02That's not something that you want to base an entire business on and build offers around and build an audience around, an audience of people who see you, who trust you, who want to buy from you over and over again. I feel like sometimes the job really also is to step back and take a realistic approach to growth because if you were to open a restaurant, you wouldn't just start cooking and expect people to line up. Take any business,
SPEAKER_02as simple as it is, a daily business that you engage with in your day-to-day life, It does take time and patience to build anything that is worthwhile. And I'm also looking at careers like you don't become a doctor or a lawyer or anything overnight. And this type of career takes a lot of patience. And I love how you've mapped that out.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. And let's go back to the restaurant for a second because I love that you use that example. The thing that you have to remember about a restaurant is if you go to this new restaurant that's hot in town and you, you know, stand in line, you make a reservation, you sit down at the restaurant, the service is terrible and the food is forgettable, are you going back? And that's what a lot of people don't realize about Substack. Substack is not Instagram. Substack is not about your three-second hook. Substack is not about your unhinged moment. It's not about who has the best aesthetics.
SPEAKER_01Substack is actually about the substance Substance of what you're doing. And so it's about putting effort and time into high-quality articles and notes that actually land and make an impact and building a culture and a community of people that are invested in what you're doing. And, you know, obviously, you know, we've had clients that we've been able to take through our Substack process that generated like over $10,000 almost immediately only
SPEAKER_01because They were already doing the work other places. They already had an audience. They already were able to take the momentum of what they were doing in their business and simply apply it to Substack. So some people will have faster success because of the business they've already built. But I think what a lot of people don't realize about Substack is it's such a gift that like we didn't have coming up. And I tell people like if I was starting a business today, I would absolutely start with Substack because the gift is that you get to use your brain to And you get to create think pieces and high quality content
SPEAKER_01that people will actually pay to access versus on all the other platforms. It's so algorithm driven. It's so trend driven. I always say to people like, I don't want to be 60 years old doing a photo shoot every other day, being on camera, doing video every other day. So I think the patience to build Substack the right way where it's not hinging on a It's not hinging on visuals. It's not hinging on trends and fads.
SPEAKER_01I think people really underestimate how valuable that is and how important it is to be willing to do the slow burn to build the audience, to build the community. Because you have to look down the line and say, do you want to have to build like this or do you want to get to build like this? And I think that's something that a lot of people aren't, like, necessarily connecting the dots on yet.
SPEAKER_02And you know what? Looking at it exactly in terms of where would you start building your business if you started today, another thing that is Just crucial for me is if I were starting today, the primary reason I would choose Substack is because it gives you the option to experiment. I started with long-form writing. I started by writing on Medium and I did almost only that for years, which meant I had no chance to basically sprinkle in cute photos or a short video
SPEAKER_02because it was a long-form writing platform, which I know is unusual for most creators. But I now get to leverage video on Substack. I did some really short form kind of mini vlogs earlier this year. Now I started doing all the vlogs of my trips. I'm terrible at it. I'm just getting started. I learned so much. But it's the fun part of you try a note, you try a deep dive article that could be 5000 words if you just have enough to say you can do a video, you can do a stream.
SPEAKER_02And if you are getting started and the key, the glue to everything you do is the message, you can experiment, you can have fun with all those different formats. And that's such a joy. Not just because of the experimentation, but also because you can then leverage all those assets in other places if you want to. A large chunk of my posts basically start as a YouTube script. I record the video, then the video becomes a Substack post embedded with the direct YouTube video.
SPEAKER_02So many other formats that you can just play around with. And I think that is vastly underestimated as well.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, for sure. For sure. And I think, you know, to your point, I think a lot of people, their first impression of Substack is that it's so like you have to be a writer or you have to be really strong as a writer in order to have success with the platform. When in reality, Substack has done such a great job of giving the tools to repurpose your content. You can start with whatever original form that you're the strongest at, and then you can use the tools within the platform to then have it be delivered in whatever way.
SPEAKER_01I mean, I keep saying to people, like, listen, the capabilities alone that are naturally built into Substack – Yeah. What works for you isn't necessarily going to work for me and so on and so forth. I think there are key principles.
SPEAKER_01And that's what we teach our students and our clients. There are key principles that we know this works, right? But ultimately, your audience is going to connect with you, your message, your philosophy, your core values, your convictions. And so making sure that those things are coming through Is the most important element of being able to be sustainable. You want to be able to sustain relationship, not just have momentary attention. And you mentioned something earlier about going viral.
SPEAKER_01And what a lot of people don't recognize about going viral is that most of the people that you attract in viral moments, they're not your ideal clients. They're not actually even positively supporting or engaging on your account. A lot of it is extremely dark, extremely negative. A lot of people go through a lot after those things happen. So I just think our culture many times like almost encourages or incentivizes us to follow the wrong things or to pursue the wrong things. When in reality, it's like it's those building blocks of relationship.
SPEAKER_01And relationships are one of the only things in business that compound. They're one of the only things in relationship that relationships multiply. They compound. People tell people about you. And Substack even gives the tools for people to, like, gift your membership or, you know, do a trial or whatever the case. I think it's just there's so many ways to build on this. But I think patience
SPEAKER_00is so key.
SPEAKER_02And to what you said about relationships, I also see people underestimating still that you are building your email list here, which is the strongest form of the technical aspect of a relationship you can have with someone. I have so many creators I love and sometimes I just realize, wait, I haven't seen anything from them for a while, whether it's on Instagram or YouTube. And when I am subscribed to someone's newsletter, it doesn't have to be on Substack,
SPEAKER_02but that's the surest way I know I am going to stay up to date and I'm going to hear from them. And that's a very untypical behavior, but I love reading newsletters. It's one of my favorite things to nerd. But people really underestimate that. Yes, there's the emotional component, but also if people don't hear from you enough times, they will forget about you because everyone is busy. Everyone is bombarded with content, with ads on other channels as you've talked about before.
SPEAKER_02And I actually want to do a quick shift to something else you have mentioned. You talk a lot about systemizing, about being a solo founder, but not being entirely founder dependent. Now, let's take the case of someone, and this is like a lot of our clients right now are at this stage, for example, where they have 60, 70, 80 paid subscribers. Their publication is solid.
SPEAKER_02They have a clear offer that is converting. They know they will be a bestseller soon. They're already building up the next offers in the letter. That will make sense. But they're also in a stage where They might still have their jobs that they don't want to quit. They have other responsibilities. They're busy people. And so the question is, what can I systemize? What can I maybe hire someone for? If you imagine that type of solo founder who has basically done the groundwork
SPEAKER_02and now they're at the stage where simple shifts can make a significant difference. What would you tell them? I know it's very dependent on the case, but what are some foundations?
SPEAKER_01No, I mean, listen, our whole subset was basically built by our marketing team. We went from like zero to 100K plus in sales and seven months of monetization. And really that was driven by my team. And so you absolutely can have someone on your team. I always say like the first thing I think you should do when you're looking to accelerate growth on Substack is do an inventory of your assets of the long-form content that you already have. Masterclasses, podcasts, webinars, really high-value trainings or teachings or coaching sessions that you've done.
SPEAKER_01And get that asset inventory done so that a team member can then use clawed skills and can use AI tools to actually take your original content, pull out hundreds of notes. Notes can be scheduled in advance. They can write articles in advance. All of these things can be systematized and can be led by your team. I always tell people, like, you know, we have a challenge that's kicking off in a couple weeks. We're taking people through building their subsect system.
SPEAKER_01And I told everyone that's joining us, I said, bring a team member with you. A lot of people make the mistake, though. They want to just delegate it out to a team. They have no idea what's going on. There's no process in place. There's no system. And then they're like, same as every other platform. They're frustrated because they're throwing a bunch of stuff on the platform, but it's not actually working, right? So I think that you have to invest in learning the platform, Your original
SPEAKER_01content, your original IP, big ideas, all of that. I think it's about organizing, having systems. And also, to the point that you just shared about, you said a lot of your clients right now, they have a small number of subscribers, but they're by themselves. They still have their job. They're trying to figure out leverage. That's where I think having a monthly campaign strategy is really powerful and really effective.
SPEAKER_01And that's what we teach our students because When you have a monthly campaign, there is a specific reason to buy now. There is a time-sensitive, and this is the thing, and this goes back to what I said earlier about those sales statistics. So many times as entrepreneurs, we want to, like, not believe or we want to ignore things that are human nature. Human nature is that when you give people a reason to buy now, they're going to buy now. When you give people something that has a reason that there's scarcity and urgency
SPEAKER_01because there's a defined timeline, there's a certain quantity, there's a certain thing that they can access for a limited period of time, you're going to see a massive surge in those results. And I think a lot of times people are just like this. So, yeah.
SPEAKER_01I think those three things. Invest side-by-side with your team. Bring a team member along the journey with you so that both you and them understand how to use the platform effectively. Systematize the asset inventory that you have and leverage AI to be able to allow you to pre-schedule notes and to pre-write articles and have things lined up into the future. And then leverage a monthly campaign strategy to get those big spikes in the paid subscribers coming in.
SPEAKER_02I love… So much of what you said, and I had to love. I also saw Rachel in the comments, who I had a one-on-one call with just yesterday, who's at that exact point, right? And I love what you said in terms of as entrepreneurs, we often don't want to do the obvious things. And I think it's even, I think the human nature part of it often is also just thinking that Something about the way I do things is so special that the foundations and the stuff that works in sales… We all do it.
SPEAKER_02We all do it. We all do it. Sometimes you're right with that. Sometimes you might see a strategy, a pattern, and it might be genuinely off and you might be right, but oftentimes it's worth at least giving it a shot. I remember the first time I ran a webinar, and I ran it as a live stream in a Facebook group. Back then, I was learning a lot from Russell Brunson from ClickFunnels, and they have a very step-by-step approach to So that it sounded more like me.
SPEAKER_02And then I could make tweaks and then I like 10 webinars into it. I knew now there's like now there's room and there's the confidence that I can learn from someone again and install what works for them and what their best practices are. So yeah, that's, that's, I think, again, you said it, it's human nature thinking that something about the way you do things is different and you cannot sell, you cannot be salesy. But at the same time, these monthly campaigns that you mentioned, so powerful.
SPEAKER_02And I think people don't Acknowledge that it's an easier way to grow as well. When you have a system that you just rinse and repeat, it makes things easier. And that's also something I discussed with someone just yesterday. She's doing monthly workshops, for example. If you do a monthly workshop for your paid members, it's perfect. Every month you can create a campaign around that workshop, right? You announce the topic of the workshop at the beginning of the month. A couple days before you can build up hype,
SPEAKER_02you can build anticipation, you run the workshop, then there's the recording. It makes things so much easier. And honestly, the busier you are, the easier it is to run on a system like this versus constantly reinventing a new campaign or a new sales strategy and trying a dozen different things every single year.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_02I saw one question in the chat that is completely different, but it's something that I think that often leads to a lot of follow ups and kind of mindset shifts as well. So I'd love to hear your perspective. I love to hear how you respond to that particular question. It's about the length of an article to get paid. So the question is, is it up to the person how much value they are going to put into every single piece? Can it be a one minute read or should it be at least a 10 minute read?
SPEAKER_01I, yeah, I think that's a great question. And to me, it's as long as it takes for you to convey the value and the transformation. And I think that also means that sometimes your article is a one minute read. And sometimes your article is a five minute read. And sometimes your article is a 10 minute read, I would not like I always tell my clients, I feel like the moment that things become robotic, that's when they lose the energetic charge that is going to transform. So I wouldn't try to design your articles to be a very specific length.
SPEAKER_01I would try to design your articles to lead people through a mindset shift, a transformation, a belief transfer that's going to get them to take action. And I think my personal perspective is that That can range and that can be different week to week. You don't need to make that like overly managed to the point that you're trying to make an article length instead of focusing on what is the outcome of the belief transformation that needs to happen in this article, right?
SPEAKER_02Mm-hmm. I always love to compare that to any other medium, essentially, whether it's a book, a movie, a song. You don't dislike a movie just because it's too long or a book. If you give up on a book, it's not because it's too long per se, it's too long for what it is. Yes, yes. And as creators, I feel like we often, like in the beginning, we try to make up those rules for ourselves to have boundaries
SPEAKER_01to operate. Because it feels safe. It's like we feel safe, right, in those rules. But the rules aren't what's going to make it good, right?
SPEAKER_02I also think maybe that pattern or that Those questions come from a time where you know on Instagram you would see perfect feeds and there is like on Twitter this is the ideal length and on LinkedIn this is exactly the formula to post etc but That's exactly why people are enjoying Substack right now, that sometimes those are the stuff that works and does really well and connects is kind of out of the box. And that's your opportunity to have a little bit more fun with content
SPEAKER_02and play around, given that your focus is exactly like you said, Kelly, how do I actually make a difference for the reader, right?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, exactly.
SPEAKER_02There's another question from Venice saying what's a good frequency? Daily, weekly, monthly articles and how many times is ideal to post on notes? Do you have And any additional answers that you want to give on that?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I mean, we've seen one free article a week, one paid resource, you know, a week. Again, instead of giving yourself overly rigid rules in terms of production, think about what can I commit to and do exceptionally well and then build on that, right? So if you're executing and you feel like you're doing exceptionally well with the quality of what you're doing, Then maybe you want to test the waters on increasing it. Maybe you start with one note a day.
SPEAKER_01Then maybe you go to two. Then you go to three, and so on and so forth. I think you also have to pay attention to what works for you. There are top paid people in Substack that do one note a day. There are top paid people in Substack that do five notes a day. It's your community. It's your vision. It's your brand. But what I would say is, I think it's much better to start off with a cadence that you can commit to and follow through on and build on it than like go crazy right up front and then be like, this is crazy.
SPEAKER_01I can't do this. And then you just stop. And that's what a lot of people end up doing with a lot of things in business, right? So make it sustainable, commit to what you can actually do and follow through on and then go from there.
SPEAKER_02I think there's also so much relief in allowing yourself not to stick to a structure that is so rigid and saying that I have to show up two times per week with articles, life gets busy, you skip one, you feel terrible, you have immense pressure to create your next piece. And nobody is rewarding you for sticking to that structure. The algorithm isn't and your audience isn't. In the best case,
SPEAKER_02your audience expects you and they miss you if you don't show up, but nobody rewards you or punishes you for the amount of times you show up. Yeah, yeah. When we circle back to the topic of sales to wrap things up, we've already been into it for half an hour, and I'd love to wrap up with something practical for the audience that is listening. When you look at an entrepreneur who has offers,
SPEAKER_02services, and they are trying to leverage Substack with a paid tier, but primarily the goal of driving more sales for what they've already built outside. What are some best practices that you would recommend? How do you think about the funnel when it's running through Substack?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, absolutely. Well, I mean, I think every creator that wants to do something real with Substack should try to get on the bestseller list in their space because that is going to get Substack to start promoting you and give you the discoverability to build your top of funnel, right? So the top of funnel is discoverability, which is why doing joint live streams, doing joint articles, getting on the bestseller list, you know, focusing on those things is going to build your audience. And then what's the middle of the funnel?
SPEAKER_00The middle of the funnel is relationship and nurture.
SPEAKER_01So what can you do to nurture those people that are already subscribed to your free tier on your channel? You can be in DMs with them. You can use the chat feature. You can post notes consistently. You can engage on their content. So those basic fundamentals of just being connected, being human, adding value for people, that's going to nurture people. That's going to get people to want to stick around and stay and be open to what you have to sell. And then the bottom of the funnel, which is the hardest for people, which is make offers every day.
SPEAKER_01Make offers every day. So if you want sales every day in your business, you should be making offers every day in your business. So top of funnel, discoverability, middle of funnel, nurture, bottom of funnel, conversion, making sure that there's something happening for you in the business every day, top, middle, and bottom. And then you always have a funnel to close and grow.
SPEAKER_02What could making an offer every day look like on Substack?
SPEAKER_01Yes. So remember that people are coming to subscribe to your channel because they're interested in the thing that you're sharing about and you're learning. And just because people see like one time when they subscribe to you the first time what your offers are, that doesn't mean that like Down the road, months later, they even know what your paid tiers are or what your offers are. So that's where I think using the chat feature, using DMs, and actually saying like, hey, so-and-so, thanks so much for being a part of my world here on Substack.
SPEAKER_01I'm so happy to have you as a free subscriber. Did you know that we include this, this, and this in our paid tier? Have you considered joining us? And I know that feels like blasphemy for a lot of people. But a lot of people will be like, oh, I didn't even know you offered that. Yes, I am interested in ABCXYZ. Thanks so much. I'm going to go ahead and upgrade. It's shocking what happens when you make more offers, more people are going to say yes. And whatever outcome you want to see in the business every single day, you have to do the behavior that correlates with that outcome.
SPEAKER_02It's so funny to see how when you break things down, it does go back to the basics all the time, right? The more times you mention your offer, the more sales you will make. Given that the foundation makes sense, you have an offer that people want to pay for. And the offer actually also works for people. So you have testimonials. It's this whole cycle over and over again. But it's funny how true it is. And also going back to Rachel, who is in the chat,
SPEAKER_02I had that And that's something that every business owner has to take responsibility for.
SPEAKER_01If you went and surveyed a thousand of your subscribers and they don't know what your paid tier is, that's your problem. And that's your problem to solve, right? Because if your people aren't even aware of They don't even know what you offer. Then they're not even being given the chance to say, yes, I am interested. No, I'm not interested. They aren't even aware that there even was an offer. There's plenty of people on Substack that they're not even using paid tiers or anything like that. So I think it's just asking yourself, what is my job as a business owner?
SPEAKER_01It's to create awareness of the transformation that I offer that more people can have success, more people can get results as a result of consuming my work. You know, taking action and being able to follow the frameworks, the formulas, the results that you help people to get.
SPEAKER_02Exactly. And again, it goes back to the fact that if you are your own boss, you might love what you do and you might not be the best at sales and marketing. Yes, you might not want to think of yourself as someone who has to go out and sell. But if you want to keep doing the thing, if you want to help more people have a greater impact, that is part of your job. And it's actually the most important part of your job because you probably already are really good at what you do and what you teach. You probably have years, decades of experience with that.
SPEAKER_02You have the results, you have the client voices. But you also have to get that other thing down. And in my experience, a huge part of that is the mindset. It's the confidence. And it's feeling great about showing that amazing thing that you created, whether that's your paid tier or a $50 template or a $5,000 coaching program that you're promoting. Yeah. And I think we can all be excited to have so many little opportunities to plant the seeds and do that through Substack now that all these features exist.
SPEAKER_00Exactly.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I think that's a great way to wrap it up. They're making it easy for us. All I can say to everyone watching is there's never been a place that has made it easier for you, and there's never been a time. That it's going to be the opportunity that it is right now on Substack. Once this moment is gone, this moment is gone. And so I would just encourage everyone to put your best foot forward. Give yourself the best shot at success.
SPEAKER_01You don't have to figure it out on your own. Obviously, people like you teach people this. People like me teach people this. There's people out there doing this every single day. No one is like, Out in the middle of the ocean with no like access to support or information. But I think that if you are either a business owner, an aspiring one, or a creator that wants a place where you can actually get paid for your big ideas, for your IP, for your frameworks, and you want something that's going to be more sustainable long term, like it's here, you just have to be willing to do the work.
SPEAKER_02Beautiful. Wonderful ending to so many wonderful insights. Thank you so much, Kelly, for taking time, for sharing what you have experienced on the platform over the last months. And yeah, thank you all for joining us and staying and have an amazing day on Substack. Continue growing and let's connect. Thank you for all the great stuff you put out there, Kelly, and we'll hear from each other soon. Yes, you too. Thank you so much for
If you started your Substack today, your first 30 days would end right before 2027. And most new creators spend that first month on the wrong things: designing a publication logo, rewriting their first article for the...
We recently sat down with Virgil Brewster, a member of our Substack Accelerator, to unpack how he turned a brand-new publication into a source of real clients in a matter of weeks. Full disclosure: Virgil has spent over...
The creators who grow their paid subscribers fastest aren’t the ones promoting the hardest. They’re the ones promoting at the right moments, in the right places, with the fewest reasons for a reader to say no. In this...
https://www.substackcoaching.com/ou’re a teacher or coach and aren’t sure how Substack could fit into your existing business or ecosystem, this conversation is for you. We started working with Katarzyna Ciszewska 🇮🇹...
If Substack has started to feel like too much- all the live streams, podcasts, videos, and automations- and you can’t give it the hours you’d like, this post is for you. You don’t need any of that to keep growing. You...