Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Write • Build • Scale Podcast

Write • Build • Scale Podcast artwork

Stop Building a Following: Build the 1 Audience No Algorithm Can Take From You

Oct 12, 20261 hr 6 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

There are really only 3 ways anyone becomes an overnight success: The first is nepotism, the door that opens because of who your family is. The second is a lucky break, the moment someone powerful decides you’re next. Both are real, and neither is available on demand. The third is distribution: The slow, email-by-email way you build an audience that’s actually yours. It’s the only one of the three you can choose, and it’s the one nobody can take away from you. That’s the real difference between buying attention and building it. You can buy reach, and it’s fast, but it evaporates the moment you stop paying, and you never owned the people it reached. When you build it, it takes far longer, but every subscriber is a person who chose you, on a list you can take anywhere. Building has leverage. Buying is a rental. Everything you don’t own is rented land Here’s what “yours” actually means, and why it matters so much: Over 10 years ago, Philip Hofmacher taught hundreds of thousands of students on Skillshare. Thousands of people logged in and loved his work every day until the platform changed its entire model, and overnight he had no way to reach a single one of them, because he’d never collected their emails. All that audience was gone because it was never really his. That’s the trap of every rented platform: Your followers live behind an algorithm that can change the rules whenever it likes. An email list is different: It lands directly in someone’s inbox, and it moves with you no matter what any platform does. This is why one email is worth roughly 10 followers. It’s also why, if you’re starting on Substack and you have no audience anywhere else, you’re luckier than you know: Substack builds an owned list for you by default, while every other platform hands you followers you can’t keep. So the move on any platform is the same: start collecting emails as early as you possibly can. Put something out, give people a reason to subscribe, and build the one audience nobody can take. An owned list converts into almost anything Your owned list converts into whatever you decide to do next. A creator with a modest email list of just a few thousand people can launch a product and watch it sell out in hours, because those subscribers actually open, trust, and act. The same list is what opens doors in publishing. In Laila’s case, when she told a book agent she wanted a Big Five book deal and pointed to her large social following, the agent waved it off: What you need is an email list. Editors love Substack right now precisely because readers there convert into book buyers at a rate a social following rarely matches. The bigger and more engaged your list, the more doors open, whether the one you want is a book, a product, or a business. A follower count flatters your ego. An owned list pays your bills. Turn on paid early, and sell the HOW Once you have people on a list, the simplest way to turn it into revenue is your paid tier, and most people set it up backwards. First, turn paid on early, even before you have anything behind it. Skip pledges, which are a confusing halfway step, and just switch on a paid tier as a simple way for people to support your work. There’s a quiet psychology to it: People hate having something free taken away, so if paid is an option from the start, and later comes with more, you’re playing a smarter game than the creator who suddenly slaps up a paywall. Second, don’t paywall your reading. Your articles stay free, because free is what earns trust and reach. What goes behind the paywall is the how: The templates, the prompts, the action guides, the implementation tools that turn your ideas into a result. Give the information away, and sell the speed. People don’t pay to read what they could already read for free, they pay for the shortcut to actually doing it. A handful of genuinely strong assets in a vault, clearly worth more than the price, can carry an entire paid tier. Getting that mix right- what stays free, what earns the upgrade, and how to sell it without feeling gross- is the whole skill. Our Free-to-Paid Playbook hands you 100+ tested strategies for turning free readers into paying members, sorted by subscriber stage, so you always know the next move. Even a huge audience still has to sell Here’s the part nobody tells you: Going paid doesn’t mean people throw their wallets at you, no matter how big your list is. In Laila’s case, with a large, established audience, turning on paid meant selling all over again, figuring out how to differentiate, what to offer, what actually converts. That’s not a sign anything’s wrong. It’s just the work. And the work is the whole thing. The same day we talked through the idea of building a paid vault, she went away and built the entire thing from scratch overnight, while raising 3 kids. That is exactly why she has the audience she has. Because overnight success is a story people tell after the fact. Behind almost every one of those stories is someone who showed up long before it worked. It took real persistence, dozens and dozens of published pieces, before things clicked for us, too. You don’t get a shot at being seen if you never show up to take it. Every piece you publish grows your luck surface area, one more chance at the thing that finally lands. Nobody starts publishing and has readers come running. You build it yourself, one piece and one email at a time. So build the list, own it, and turn it into something real. That’s the difference between a big following and an actual business. If you’ve already built genuine expertise, and you want Substack to carry it further, into authority, a real audience, and income, that’s what we do with creators inside the Substack Accelerator. It’s direct coaching from the Write • Build • Scale team, applied to your specific publication and your specific work, built around turning what you know into a real business and getting you to Bestseller. It’s application-based, because we only take people we’re confident we can get there. If that sounds like you, apply here: substackcoaching.com This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit writebuildscale.substack.com/subscribe

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_00Hello and welcome, everyone. We were just talking about how excited we are about this session, honestly. I think we have a lot of ground to cover. Laila, first of all, thank you so much for taking time and being here today. I will dive straight in. I'm big time fangirling. When I first came across your content, I was trying to think about it, but I think it was a newsletter that isn't even on Substack. Someone linked to one of your articles. I clicked on it. I was like, oh, Substack.

SPEAKER_00And then I saw you have over 140,000 subscribers, which was just like the second layer of impression. But first, the content I saw was just really cool. You're kicking ass. You have kids. Kind of the woman who basically says no excuses. And I'm so excited to hear more about your story and share your perspective with our viewers, with your viewers. So let's

SPEAKER_01do this. How are you doing? Good. Thank you for having me. Honestly, I had the same reaction. You reached out to me. We got on like a Zoom and we connected and then I just binged everything you've written. And I was like, whoa. And like literally I have a whole Google Doc of all the things I have to do to like make my Substack more marketable. So I joined Substack. My backstory is I actually am an operator. I co-founded a tech company over a decade ago at this point. And we built last mile logistics distribution software. It is very different from what I write about. But I learned a lot.

SPEAKER_01And my first day on the job, I was a C-suite, which meant I was part of the 7% of minority C-suite in the United States, right? Minority female C-suite, that is. So it's just, I had access in a way that maybe a lot of women don't have access, and women aren't minorities, but often have. I met a book agent three years ago, maybe four years ago, three years.

SPEAKER_01And I knew I wanted to write a book. I had a Substack at that point. It wasn't that exciting. It was like business advice and there were very short articles. I was semi-consistent. And I said to her, imagine I came to you in three years and what would make me like non-negotiable talent? And she goes, you need an email list. I was like, but I have a social media following. She's like, I don't care. You need an email list. I'm like, tell me more. And she said, I'm going to tell you, this is not the only way, but I'm going to tell you the easiest way to write a book if you want to do a big five commercial book. I said, what is it? She said,

SPEAKER_01and anybody in this room, if that's your ambition and you don't have these numbers, do not let this dissuade you. I just did a Substack Live with a guy named Scott Kern who just had a book published from Simon & Schuster that's a USA Today bestseller. And in the whole live, he's like, I don't have a following. I don't want a following. I hate having a following. So this is not the only way, but I will tell you my way. So she said 25,000 emails minimum by 50,000. Doors are open all over, 100,000 emails. Nobody's going to, everybody, you're going to have a ton of editors to choose from in the publishing world for Big Five. And that was my ambition.

SPEAKER_01So I locked in. And when I locked in, Substack was locking in. So we kind of rode each other's waves, quite honestly. Like I think the algorithm at that point was trying to push people to build the brand. And I was very noticeably for probably on the developer side, bringing people in from Instagram. I have these very regular CTAs where I'm like, hey, you know, You wanna read the Substack? Comment this and go to my Substack. So I was constantly importing emails and like really locked in on Substack. And that's my backstory of how I got here today, Sinem.

SPEAKER_00I have a very specific question. Yeah. Because that's still in your mind, right? The book and it's still something you have, you're pursuing. Do you think that Open rates, click rates, is that something the publishers are looking at as well, or is it really list size?

SPEAKER_01This is such a good question because I have social media content as well, and a few years ago at some point, somebody told me, So my social media is all about growth and productivity and business. And even if you're not in business, just growing, becoming better. That is what I'm obsessed with. And I write about it. And so my social media is similar. I was talking to this social media manager. And by the way, I need to put this context in the foreground.

SPEAKER_01At that point, like in 2020, there were as many business bestsellers by men named John as all women combined. So women are not seen, even though we're half the population, we're not necessarily seen as business experts in the commercial realm, right? So I meet with this manager and I'm telling her my mom's just diagnosed with cancer. I'm sorry I'm late. Like, you know, I'm kind of all over the place. And she goes, oh, cancer. Have you ever thought about like supplements? Like we can totally pitch you to supplement companies and to pitch content for them and, you know, make social media content. And I remember at that moment I was like, A, I'm not working with this woman.

SPEAKER_01B, This is all she could see me as. Somebody who's not even in science selling supplements to women who are maybe in a scared place who might also have relatives with cancer. Supplements are great and fine, but I'm not a doctor. I'm not a nutritionist. I have no expertise. And she can't even see me for being a founder that's raised $75 million from venture capital. And I remember at that moment, it became really clear to me a few things.

SPEAKER_00You have to tell your own story, even in metrics,

SPEAKER_01and you have to shape the story based on what you want. So I'm sure some editors care about click rates. I keep a separate document at all times, and Substack gives you this really cool metric of reads, and I care about that more than click rates. I care about that more than open rate because Sinem, you can tell me if I'm wrong, but I think Substack's open rates are inherently lower. When I was a smaller When I had like 3,000, I had like 70% open rate. Now it's inherently smaller.

SPEAKER_01But I have a consistent amount of reads, you know, 50 or 60,000 per article when I publish it. I'm not sure. So those are the numbers that I'm keeping because at the end of the day, the point of metrics is to sell a story. And the story is usually a conversion story.

SPEAKER_00Thank you so much for giving us the full background. When... And I think that's the perfect segue, but when we talked about doing this live, you also mapped out really beautifully how there's two ways to get distribution and attention, right? You either buy it, quick way, you buy the attention, the visibility, or you build it, which is the slower way. The more sustainable way that it can be because people trust you, because people see you over a longer period,

SPEAKER_00both have pros and cons, both have their places in maybe different stages of a business, in different scenarios. How are you looking at it now that you have built such a large audience and you have basically the next steps in your mind now when it comes to the monetization part of your Substack?

SPEAKER_01So listen, building your own audience has leverage, right? Like you said, you can either build your audience or you can buy it. And the thing about building is it takes forever. I knew I wanted to write a book. I didn't know how to do it. But I was like, I'm going to start building my email list. I spoke to a friend a year ago who has like 300, 400,000 followers on social. And she was like, I kind of want to think about business. Never done this. I was like, I don't care what you want to do. Build an email list. Today, she has 3,000 emails. She launched a hijab. It sold out in 10 hours because of her email list with a brand. A brand reached out to her. She launched it. 3,000 pieces sold out in 10 hours because of her email list.

SPEAKER_01And now she's launching a digital course, got 800 interested people because of her email list, right? So this is a story of just ownership, right? Ownership of distribution. Now, when I decided I want – and I always knew, like, my big thing is access. I put a lot of information out there. The idea is that somebody reads it, learns, and has expansion in their life in some way. And so I was like, okay, everything's going to be free. Everything's going to be free. I'm going to make my money off the book. And then I started to realize something. I told you, I'm writing this, like, Substack algorithm, the Substack Wave, and Substack's getting bigger.

SPEAKER_01But Substack is a business, and it's a very smart business and one of my favorite social media sites. And I started to realize, hold on, I'm falling behind. I'll never get the bestseller title, which has clout, right? I'll never get any sort of checkmark, which has clout. And there were events happening in LA, New York, wherever, where they were inviting Substack bestsellers. So now your social network is expanding. And I was like, man, I got to play this game. And I want to tell a conversion story to my editors that I'm going to sell my book proposal to, ideally to create a So I

SPEAKER_01went and paid very recently. And me and you started talking about that, Sinem, because it's very different. I assumed I'd go paid and people would just be, you know, just throwing their wallets at me. That's not what happened. So anybody here who has a following smaller than 145,000 subscribers, you should rest very assured. That's not what happened. And I was like, it's sales again.

SPEAKER_00I have to sell again.

SPEAKER_01And that's kind of where I am now, right? It's like, okay, how do I differentiate? How do I sell? And you give so many phenomenal tips about that.

SPEAKER_00Thank you so much. I think the first part of what you said is really the interesting bit here, because we work with a lot of creators who are in the very early stages as well, right? Who just, like Substack is the first place where they are publishing. And then when you hear about becoming a Bestseller and charging $5, $10 for your subscription, that sounds very attractive. But when we then talk to people like you, people who have audiences, who have established coaching businesses, consulting firms, the conversation suddenly is okay. Well,

SPEAKER_00do I still need to chase the bestseller thing or can I just leverage it for reach and visibility? And yes, even if you're very clear on the fact that having, let's say, 150 paid subscribers is just kind of something you have to check off your to-do list to get the little badge next to your name, it is something you should do because Substack is a business. Substack makes money when you make money. Yeah, no surprise that there is going to be some benefit to people who actually get paid

SPEAKER_00through the platform. The events are a great point. That's really interesting too in terms of different locations in New York, in LA, there are lots of Substackers. So even though you have like 144,000 subscribers, you might not be on the invite list because They might not be looking at free subscribers. If they would, they would see you, but they might be looking at the bestseller list. To be fair, it's different in other locations, right? We've been at the event in Berlin last week where I talked to many creators who have

SPEAKER_00a couple hundred subscribers. They've been there because they've been on Substack for a while. They are doing meetups, so it's a very different conversation. Where you are and the circles you are playing in obviously matter and create a different barrier. But again, I know I told you this on our first call, but I think it's an absolute no-brainer for you. Yes, the first transition period, it's not people throwing their wallets at you. You'll get the bestseller badge very soon.

SPEAKER_00I'm confident about that with what you've built so far. That's a very tiny step in your journey, but a very exciting one because I think it's making that switch and telling people, hey, there is something more, right? Right. And, you know, I have

SPEAKER_01to, right? The thing is, like I said, there was many business bestsellers by men named John is all women combined, Muslim women in hijab. If I had to guess. And I know a hella smart Muslim businesswoman in a hijab, right, to speak for my own community. So I have two questions for you, Sinem. The first one is, everybody's here. Do you recommend, you know, and I've heard you guys say don't turn on paid until you have the value you've locked in what you're going to do. Do you recommend people turn on pledging? If you were talking to Layla with 500 subs, 1,000 subs.

SPEAKER_01Would you tell me to have turned on pledging or paid? What's the guide there? That's question number one. Question number two, once you're done with that, is you talk about launches, transitions. I would love to hear about the phases of growth as soon as somebody does turn on paid.

SPEAKER_00Pledges, no. Pledges are a really weird thing on Substack. You turn on a pledge, and basically if someone opts in for the pledge, they are saying, if you turn on the paid tier, I'm part of your paid subscription. So instead of turning on pledges, we recommend turning on the paid tier right away, even if you don't, like even if you say there is nothing behind the paywall yet, you just, if you want to pay, it's kind of supporting my work. Smart. I wish I did that. Everybody listen. Smart.

SPEAKER_00Then on, you mean the stages in terms of paid subscribers?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, yeah, yeah. Like when somebody turns it on, what do you notice is the first stage? I'd imagine there's some level of hesitancy, maybe embarrassment, cringe, like, okay, what am I going to offer as the first thing? Some level of figuring out, is it live or is it, you know, downloadable content? Like what is the life cycle you see when people go from like,

SPEAKER_00this is cringy, I hate this, to like, no, this is successful. Yeah, oftentimes, you know what a weird barrier to a lot of people is also? I need to figure out the cadence, the schedule. Am I doing one free, one paid per week or one piece every week and it's free, free, free? It doesn't really matter, honestly. Yes, if you can pull it off, do one free, one paid a week. If you can't do that, just don't do it. The quality matters a lot more than quantity in that sense because people often look

SPEAKER_00at our publication and they're like, oh, you're publishing three long-form posts a week. Yeah, but we're also three people. We do a ton of live streams. Most of our content on Substack isn't originally written for Substack anymore. All of my YouTube videos go out as Substack posts. If you're starting from scratch, you shouldn't aim to publish three long-form posts.

SPEAKER_01So go ahead. So I have a question. You talked about your lives, and I know a lot of them got us emails. You talked about YouTube. You talked about three posts a day. My fear, and this is a very intimate chat of nearly 200 people, okay? So we're just going to be very vulnerable here, and anybody who listens to it after this. My fear is I overdo it, right? And so the question becomes, is sending an email a day too much? Like, how do you kind of get through that? How do you assess it? I'd imagine you're probably sending out five, six emails, which is funny because I read your stuff and I've never thought, wow, this is too many emails, which might answer the question I'm asking.

SPEAKER_01But, you know, what's the right amount there?

SPEAKER_00Did I say day? I meant three a week. I'm sorry if I say day.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, but you said three a week. Does that include your lives and your YouTubes?

SPEAKER_00Is that all of it? Directly through Substack, we send three posts per week. But for example, it depends on how you count it, right? People also get a notification email when we go live, like we just did for this one. In total, we also have a kid on list. We send at least four emails per week. So, Kit 4,Substack 3, Live Notifications,

SPEAKER_01another 3.

SPEAKER_00Okay, Kit 1. Kit Minimum 1, unless we have a launch going on, then it could be a lot more. Okay, let me circle back to your main question, actually, the whole cringe and being afraid of overdoing it. When I started sending newsletters in 2020, I think when I was done writing an email, it took me two more hours to go over it and to basically find the courage to send it out. I had maybe a few hundred people on that list, but it felt so intimidating to send an email to someone's inbox.

SPEAKER_00It took me years to basically realize, It doesn't matter. People sign up to receive those emails. If they don't like it, there's one button and you're gone. If it's too much, it's too much. You can unsubscribe. You can always check the page. I don't know. Set a reminder on your to-do list to go back to our publication every 10 days and look for the content you like. It's in every reader's responsibility to kind of manage how you want to use Every creator's content. I'm someone I love receiving.

SPEAKER_00I love reading newsletters. So for me, it's been a long journey to get confident in sending. But the reality is that the amount of content we push out is not what most people should aim for. And even you now, I think in your stage, you don't have to prove yourself through the volume at all. So I think in your case, it's really like, I mean, you already sent me the vault that you've created, which is a key asset of becoming a paid subscriber,

SPEAKER_00but I think people overdo and overthink the whole cadence and schedule thing. It's great to know that on a certain rhythm you are showing up, but that's not how you grow, right? You don't grow because every week at the top of the hour, at the same hour, you send out an email.

SPEAKER_01You know, it's so funny because, so me and Sinem were talking about The Bolt and I was asking her like, you know, what could I potentially offer? And something she'd said is, you do, I do a lot of my content is, you know… Articles that talk about how comfort effectively is getting in your way and how to grow and how to effectively grow your opportunity. And she was saying one thing you could do is build implementation tools during the live and during your pieces. And at the end of the piece, you offer the implementation tools and that's what's gated. That's what's behind the paywall. So you're selling the how, right? So that was one strategy that you'd offer to me.

SPEAKER_01Sinem, what are the most successful strategies you've seen for somebody who, like me, who likes to write? And I want people to read what I'm writing, right? Not just people who like pay. And I need reach. I need and I want reach because I'm writing a book. I'm in the process of this, getting a book deal so I can write a book. What are the various ways people can go paid and still successfully get that badge?

SPEAKER_00Make the paid, like the add-on, make very clear that you don't have to pay to read the content. The content stays accessible for most people still, but paid is a premium level of access. Paid is not access to read your stuff in that sense. And you can have a very successful paid tier with a handful of really strong assets. If you are good at what you do and you have tremendous value in the form of templates,

SPEAKER_00prompts, action guides, whatever it is, write fancy names for different niches. But if you have a handful of them behind your paid tier and you can communicate their value clearly, even if you have a paywall in a post, the whole reading part can be free and then you do a paywall and you're like, here's the PDF.

SPEAKER_01And you tell people, you said very clearly, so like you're welcome, you're about, it's like you will get all the content for free. If you want to implement it, here's an option, but my content will always remain accessible. Are you like straightforward about that or are you kind of a little tricky?

SPEAKER_00We don't mention it explicitly because in our content it's very straightforward often because a lot of the free stuff that we have on our publication now is also video. So you see, for example, it's a video embedded from, like it's just a YouTube embed or live streams like this one or live streams we do with our clients. So it is very clearly either it is a full free thing or if it is a paid vault post, I will say at the top,

SPEAKER_00the whole post is free to read, but our paid members at the bottom will get a link to download, access, whatever.

SPEAKER_01That's so good. That's so good. I think that somebody just wrote, give info for free, sell speed. I love that because you're right. People do buy the transformation. And I've seen your vault, Sinem, and it's well worth whatever you charge per year. I mean, I could spend a day on that and make that money back and all the things I would implement just in your vault on how to be a Substack success.

SPEAKER_00But let me actually add something to the conversation. You mentioned we talked about the vaults in our call. And the funny thing is we had to call my time in the evening. And then I went to sleep. And when I woke up, You had built your own vault from scratch. You texted me like, hey, look what I did. You're a mom of three kids. This is not something that a lot of people would do. And I think that is just something to point out here. I think there is a lot of

SPEAKER_00Yeah, a lot of wrong expectations also in the world of being a creator because you see all these success stories that look like an overnight success and you just also told us how you wrote Substack's Wave to a certain extent. But you don't get a shot at being seen if you don't show up in the first place. If you had published two articles and logged out, You wouldn't have been able to attract and reach those 144,000 people who are on your list now. It is like this whole idea of,

SPEAKER_00you know, growing your luck surface area and just showing up more often, taking more shots. It is a big part of the game. And when we talk about an idea and then, you know, I don't know, 12 hours later, you sent me a link to a whole like mega volt that looks kick ass. Well, yeah, that is part of the reason why you have That many subscribers and why,

SPEAKER_01yeah, I do believe you will get any book deal that you want, obviously. Yes, I definitely hyper fixated. I had the time of my life. And actually my last article, I did exactly what you said. All the content was free. And then in the bottom, I was like, you want to do this? Pay me. Like, you know, we need to keep this moving, right? Like, we need to ultimately turn this into a business and show publishers, no, even though I'm not a guy named John and lots of love to the Johns in the audience, you guys are great and very good at business, but there is many business bestsellers by men named John is all women combined. And even though I'm a woman and my name is not John, I could still sell a book and people will still buy from me, right?

SPEAKER_01And so, you know, you said something earlier I want to tug on. You said turn on your paid early, even if it's just like, hey, buy me a coffee. I think that It's worth diving into. What I would do if I was listening to this live and not on it is I would go down a rabbit hole on the psychology of buying. My hunch is people hate having something free taken away from them. And so if you start with some expectation of like, I'm kind of doing you a favor by giving you this for free, at some point, you know, the paid is always an option. And at some point, the paid might come with more stuff. You're probably playing a little bit of a smarter psychological game.

SPEAKER_01And there's like, you know, 200 people here. If anybody knows the science of that, please feel free to share in the chat. Okay. So I want to share something else. I talked to a friend this weekend. We were on stage. We're on a panel. Her name is Lena with Love, Lena. Big influencer, 3 million followers, started a clothing company last year or the year before or the year before that. And I was like, you know, what would you have done differently? And she said, I would have started my email list a lot earlier. She has a YouTube of over a million and Instagram of over a million. And she's like, I would have started it earlier.

SPEAKER_01And I recall hearing that from the Atomic Habits guy too, James Clear. He was in a podcast and somebody said, would you trade your email list for Kim Kardashian's following? And it's in the tens of millions. And he's like, absolutely not. Absolutely not. And so there is a lot of value to having people's emails, which is obviously clear to everybody here. But the point that we're bringing is if you don't put information forward and shoot your shot, you're never going to get those emails. And emails can convert to any sort of business. Somebody talked about loss aversion psychology. I cannot wait to hyperfixate on that as soon as this is done.

SPEAKER_01Writing that down.

SPEAKER_00The part about the email list is actually the whole reason we built our business the way we did is my husband was on Skillshare, one of the very early teachers on Skillshare, I believe 2012. He had hundreds of thousands of students in courses on so many random topics. He told me just last week he had a course on how to travel across Europe on a low budget, for example, and he recorded that when he was in Berlin the first time.

SPEAKER_00Very weird, like recorded on his iPhone. Hundreds of thousands of students who logged into his courses. He made decent money on Skillshare. Then Skillshare changed the model. He had hundreds of thousands of people watching his courses, loving his stuff. He had no way to reach them. No. Because you didn't have email access. Painful. He started doing it on Udemy. But when I started writing about personal development and my articles started

SPEAKER_00to get traction, he was like, we need to set up an email list. And I'm like, what will we do? What's the purpose? It's like, it doesn't matter, we'll figure it out, but we are going to start an email list, put a freebie, and just collect emails. Okay, let's do it. And then I wrote about personal growth for two years, two and a half years, before I gave a single piece of writing advice. I was reaching up to half a million readers through my content before I started writing about This is how you might start to write

SPEAKER_00and reach your own audience. But then as soon as I started giving writing advice, I started the second list because that's the foundation of everything we did and teach. And I thinkSubstack is Changing the whole conversation there. People are aware of that now. And there is the fact that if you start on Substack and you don't have a reach anywhere else, you have no idea how privileged you are to be building subscribers here instead of followers on any other channel that just are...

SPEAKER_00It doesn't matter how many of them you have, but it's rented land. It's not your place that you can take anywhere else.

SPEAKER_01So I'm going to tell you two things. First of all, I had an editor reach out to me from a big five publishing house who's like, hey, love your work. Who do you want to write a book? Let's talk. So when I was chatting with her, she said, Substack is hot right now. Like editors love Substack because there's very high conversion from Substack readers to book readers. If you're in the chat, And you follow Sinem or you follow me and we wrote a book. Just give a little heart if you would buy it. My hunch is if you're giving us an hour on a Wednesday morning to listen to a C-Gap, you would really spend five hours listening to the best insights we've ever thought

SPEAKER_01of, you know, over our whole lives pretty much, right? So you can just reinforce that idea if it's the correct one. And so somebody asked, at what audience size would you start an email list? I have like 80,000 or something Instagram subscribers. I did the math once when my Substack was 3,000. My conversion was similar across my 80,000 Instagram and my 3,000 email list.

SPEAKER_00And there's math to prove that. You need to, like, I mean, on Substack, it's not a question. You start building your list right away. That's the big pro of the platform that works. We're all on now, but if you're anywhere else, you need to start your list as soon as possible. If you were starting to create content on YouTube, you need to have your CTA and you need to start your list as soon as possible. Part of the reason Substack is hot is because it makes it easy for people to build their lists. I love KIT.

SPEAKER_00I run the business on both Substack and KIT, but... I'm not a tech girly, right? So it took me a while to get familiar with a proper email service provider in the days. And I do understand why people get intimidated by that.

SPEAKER_01On Substack, everything is very straightforward. It's straightforward. My tech stack is different, right? You do Substack and Kit. I do Substack, Flowdesk, and Kajabi. And this is outside of my business. This is like my personal brand because I have a business. It's separate. So the Kajabi, I have digital courses and I sell them there, right? And I tell everybody in my welcome emails on Substack, you will be added to my other email list. Opt out now or opt out at any point. And when people unsubscribe, I say, you are on my other email list. Opt out now or email me back and I'll make sure you're removed from there as well.

SPEAKER_00And so

SPEAKER_01between all these other tools, you can actually expand the list and turn it into a sustainable business, which is really great. But that's all to say that somebody who's intimidated and says, I don't have a social media following, I'm not starting an email list, I think one email is worth 10 followers. If one person in this chat follows you, it's worth 10 followers, truly. And there are metrics behind that to prove that you could build a sustainable business over email in a way that would be much more challenging over Instagram or especially over TikTok where the algorithm changes every time I sneeze.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, absolutely. What are some of the things you have in mind to build for your paid tiers specifically that we could talk about?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, great, great point. So for anybody who doesn't know me, I write… Long-form articles on growth about twice a month. And they're articles that will help you really tackle your biggest demons, why your anger is sabotaging your success, why your comfort zone is shrinking if you're not pushing it. And I spend a lot of time in these articles, and I absolutely love them. And ultimately, what I write about is capacity. How do you build your capacity? I'm a mom. As Sinem noted, people always ask me, how do you do it all? And the answer is like, I don't do it all, but I do what I have capacity to do.

SPEAKER_01And people are born with different baselines for capacity. Based on your surroundings, what you told was possible, but your brain is plastic. You could push that, right? And ultimately, it hinges on your emotional regulation. If you're an extremely angry person, you will really struggle to continue to work on a project because everything you do, a third of it sucks, a third of it's awesome, a third of it's boring. If you're angry, what are you going to do in that third that sucks? You're going to get in your own way. So I write about all that. So I started to do implementation tools in my lives and in my articles Where,

SPEAKER_00you know, for example, my last article is all

SPEAKER_01about the story you tell yourself. This is actually a really cool and off topic. I would always say if you want to have confidence, do the reps, do the reps, do the reps. In fact, I might even tell you in this talk, oh, you want to be good at Substack? We talked about this. Leila, you were consistent. You kept writing. Okay, that builds the skill. That does not build confidence. What builds confidence is the story after the article goes out. Is it my open rate sucks? Nobody likes me. I'm not good at this or is it… I kind of need to tweak my titles. I kind of need to do this. I kind of need that. And that will determine whether or not you have confidence. So in my last article, I built a whole toolkit based off of science.

SPEAKER_01I'm not a scientist or neuroscientist. So based off of other people's science on how to really get ahead of your story so you can reach self-actualization. And I put that behind the paywall. And then everything I built tools for, Sinem, to your advice, I put in a vault. And the vault says, okay, you want to learn how to be confident? This is what you do. You want seven strategies to get ahead at work? This is what you do. And that's for paid subs. I don't have the evidence to tell you what's working or not yet. I'm tracking it very closely. I very recently went paid. So I'm seeing what converts, what doesn't convert.

SPEAKER_01And it's painful. It's really painful because it's sales now. I went from just ideating to sales. And I want that to be very clear here. Nobody, very few people are one-hit wonders. And actually, I'm going to take a step back. Really, any wonder became a wonder in one of three ways. One, nepotism. Their dad went to Harvard, bought a building, so they got into Harvard. Now they're the CEO of a bank. Number two, FOMO, right? The starlet who worked at Denny's. I'm in Los Angeles. This happens all the time. Gets a lead role with Timothee Chalamet. Now everybody wants to hang out with her because she's going to be it soon.

SPEAKER_01And three, distribution. And that's the slow Painful, email-by-email way that you build who you are and you tell the world, I can sell it. And distribution is slow. It is slow, right? Somebody mentioned you give information for free, you pay for speed. Ideally, what I shouldn't be doing, honestly, is paying somebody like Sinem to help me speed up the paid tier in conversion. And she has a lot of resources that provide them, but that's where I am in my journey, Sinem.

SPEAKER_00I think what you pointed out last is just something, again, a lot of people overlook as well. It's so easy to look at someone like you and go like, oh, she's so lucky, she has so much reach, so many followers, and it all looks so easy to her, right? And I would love to circle back to what you said about like before and I know the person you were referring to was actually John Brosio. I saw his name in the chat. He's one of the good Johns. But before we went live, I told you I was thinking of what to say, what not to say.

SPEAKER_00But let's be honest, it is harder to get that reach and the distribution when people cannot even pronounce your name. You talked about how it's harder for women in so many different fields. It is not easier for women to be seen online when you're creating content. And it is harder if, again, people cannot pronounce your name and there's unfamiliarity. And when you look at your notes feed and you see all these, I don't know, English, US names that you're just familiar with,

SPEAKER_00it is easier for these people to Be seen as credible. So when you see someone like Lila, and I don't say this often, but also when you see someone like me, it does take many extra steps in between to be seen and to be recognized when you have a name that you've probably never heard before. And I think that is often not acknowledged either. People so often are like, oh, I've published five notes and I didn't get any likes. This doesn't work.

SPEAKER_00You would be surprised by how often people get discouraged and they haven't done the bare minimum. I showed up for 150 long-form articles on Medium before it clicked, before I understood what to do differently. That was also my fault. I was not doing a great job, frankly. But still, it does take so much more perseverance and consistency and Really just putting in the wraps and the work. And of course, it depends on where you start. If you had a career in marketing, you're going to be so many miles ahead of me who started having no experience

SPEAKER_00with all of that. We all come from different backgrounds. Nevertheless, it does take the showing up. It does take the shots. You don't know what's going to work and what's not. Nobody goes out there, starts to publish content, and people just come running to you and loving your stuff.

SPEAKER_01No, no, you have to do it yourself. And if you have a, you know, a name that's different, Sinem, you have an accent. People will be less likely in the United States to think you're credible. And I'm going to tell you the science behind it. It's not me being mean. My parents have accents, right? When people look at somebody, they judge you on two axes, competence and warmth. It's called the stereotype content model. It's written by a lady named Suzanne Fisk, a bunch of different researchers. And the idea is they look at somebody like me, somebody like you, they say, how competent is she and how warm is she? When somebody hears an accent, Some accents from some parts of the world. You know, the assumption is maybe she's not that competent.

SPEAKER_01But Sinem looks warm. She's pretty. Like, okay, so she's not... She's not competent, but she's warm, so I'm going to treat her a certain way. And that certain way isn't the type of way you treat somebody who you're going to buy knowledge from, right? Somebody might look at me, maybe not in a hot pink car job, maybe if I looked a little more scary today, and say, okay, she's neither competent nor warm, because I've heard stereotypes about Muslims my whole life, and she's probably violent, and she's probably dumb, and she probably gets abused by her husband. None of that is true, right? But the point is, it comes with serious impacts in terms of your reach

SPEAKER_01and how quick people are willing to believe you. And so that's very, very true and very worth pointing out now. Are either of us victims? No. It means we just have to do it ourselves. No, but it's worth pointing

SPEAKER_00it out. We just have to do it ourselves. Yeah. Because it's, I mean, you would be surprised how often I, like, I've had comments, people saying, like, well, yeah, you've got an audience, but yeah, you've got a pretty face. I'm like, that's the least, like, the last thing I've That has ever attracted anyone to my kind of content, like my content. And everything that you could watch on YouTube is so boring. It's not something you watch for fun, right? Obviously. But people love to degrade women. They love to degrade women that seem different to what they're used to.

SPEAKER_00And if you're watching this and you're like, I'm not sure if this is going to be worth it. It's hard. I need to publish on notes every day. That takes up so much time. Well, it's really, I think the key question always is, how bad do you want it? And why do you want it? If you've got the why nailed down, it's like, I've had a coaching session a couple of weeks ago as well. And the question was basically like, What did you do when you were not seeing the signals and you had to push through and you were not sure if it's going to work and if it's just even going to work in

SPEAKER_00the long run? And honestly, what I was telling myself, and I was 20, 21 when I started publishing content, but I was like, There are a million examples of people who get paid to share their knowledge online. Like I was seeing all these people back then on Medium, right, making a ton of money through the partner program, selling courses, doing their programs and stuff. And I was looking up to them. But I was thinking to myself, honestly, what they do looks really cool. I would love to do that for a living.

SPEAKER_00Why shouldn't I be able to replicate it? It's all there. It's all visible, right? It's not like you're building some hyper complex tech company. Yes, there is tactics and strategies and mechanisms to build a content business and an educational business the way we have. A lot of the stuff, you can see it. You can click through our publication. You can sign up for our funnels. You will receive the emails and the follow-ups. Obviously, people do that.

SPEAKER_00They do funnel hacking. But that was what kept me going, was just seeing other people are doing it and knowing that there's always room for one more person on top.

SPEAKER_01Definitely. Definitely. You know, so Jackie just made a few really good comments. Jeff is also talking about unfamiliar names or accents. One thing I want to point out is that when people can't control you, they control the image of you, right? They try to control your image. And so when you're putting the content out yourself and you're representing yourself with integrity 10 toes deep, there's not a whole lot of space for people to write your narrative. And so I think it's cool. I think that 10 years ago, me and Sinem would not have 220 people who showed up at 10am on a Wednesday to listen to us talk about how to be successful. Quite frankly, it would have been a lot harder to do that.

SPEAKER_01And it was very easy for us to do this and get you all here. So Sinem, you talked about funnel hacking. I want you, I'm a business leader before I'm a writer. I want you to talk about Substack as a hobby versus Substack as a business and give a few strategies for people who want to turn Substack into a business. What are the things you see, whether it's, you know, funnel hacking? I don't know if it's necessary consistency. You said it's continuation rather than consistency and making sure you constantly are going back to that point. Tell me, you know, give me your best tips for somebody who wants to go from

SPEAKER_00recreational writer to like that girl. Favorite topic. Before we went on, I just recorded three YouTube videos on the topic. I'm locked, Angel. Jump in. Substack is a hobby. You write because you love writing. You publish. Some people see it. Some people like it. You are happy about every conversation you have. Substack is a business. You design your Substack as an important part of the funnel. It doesn't need to be an important part in the beginning,

SPEAKER_00but it does make sense because it is a very powerful step that for a lot of founders, coaches, consultants, experts, it makes sense to lock in now. Because as you said, you can get more reach for free here than you can get anywhere else right now. And it just makes sense if you are here now to just use that. It's not going to stay that way forever. Make use of the opportunity that is here now. Depending on how you have designed your business and offers, you basically want your content to be leading people down a funnel all the time.

SPEAKER_00You don't need to wait for a launch. You don't need to do a campaign to do that. You can do it in every single article that you do. It's hard on notes. The purpose of your notes is to gain visibility, drive strangers to your profile and publication, and to gain more subscribers, and to be on top of mind with the subscribers you already have. But everything you do on your publication, and can also be your subscriber chat if you have one and that is already active, Should guide people towards the next step in your funnel, whatever that looks like.

SPEAKER_00For us and for a lot of our clients who are coaches and consultants, it's, for example, it's an application form. It's a strategy call that people book to see if you're a fit to work together. For our lower ticket offers, we send them directly to a sales page as well. We have products that are $27, $47, template packs, et cetera, on Gumroad. We just link directly to them. And you have so many opportunities to streamline that on Substack now. You can create templates for those pitches inside your articles.

SPEAKER_00Tell me more. Tell me more. I didn't know about this. You have the option when you are in the editor, you can create a template. It's on the right-hand side at the top of the editor. Just click on template. You can create a template that is literally a CTA. And then, depending on how you create your content, you just say, oh, I talked about this topic, I have this CTA for whatever, freebie, paid product, call to action to book a call to go down the application funnel.

SPEAKER_00And you want to be doing that all the time. And with a large audience, honestly, Like you as the creator, you will feel like you are repeating yourself all the time. But that's what you should be doing because some of your key messages are the reason why people are here and why people stay. I always like to compare this to our favorite musicians, right? If I go to a concert, yes, I might want to hear some songs from the new album, but I also want to hear the bangers that are maybe like 10 years old. So true. Like that's what I come for.

SPEAKER_01And the whole audience does. Everybody was crazy when like, you know, that song comes on. Sinem, this is so freaking valuable. This is so freaking valuable. So what I heard from you so far was if you want to go from Substack as a fun hobbyist to Substack as a business, you have to create your CTAs to whatever it is. It's your upsell, it's your digital product, it's your pay tier, and you need to be constantly mentioning it in your chat and your articles. Use notes to build community, I believe is what you heard, not to sell. Is that correct?

SPEAKER_00Reach. It's more visibility and reach. Notes, not that much of a community element.

SPEAKER_01Okay. You guys had a YouTube where you talked about 4-7-11. I believe it was Philip who talked about this. Is this ringing a bell?

SPEAKER_00Mm-hmm.

SPEAKER_01So you talked about the amount of times you have to see somebody online through different channels and different frequencies, I think. Forms of media, yeah. Can you tell us about that? Because that actually blew me away because I was like, oh, maybe I'm not that cringy because like, yeah, this makes sense.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. Let me actually pull it up because I… I don't know what the exact kind of formula was, but actually Philip mapped it out in a live stream basically saying these are the numbers and then I did a video saying the numbers don't matter as much. Okay, so give us your POV. We don't need mine. The POV is actually very basic. People need to see you and hear from you multiple times until they are ready to make a decision and that decision is basically a conversion decision.

SPEAKER_00You need to get them to subscribe rather You need to make that decision very simple and quick. That's happening in an instant usually, the subscribe. But once somebody is subscribed, they need to see you and hear from you very often. And there are always exceptions to the rules. We have clients who watch one video and they're like, I want to work with you and here's 10 grand and help me do my Substack.

SPEAKER_00But we also have clients and I love, like, that's the nerdy part about having access to so much data on Kit, for example. I have people on my list who have been reading my stuff. They've been with me since Medium. And they went through, I don't know, 25 product launches with me. They never bought anything. And now they say, now I'm ready to work with you. And that took like, I don't know, 250 years. But usually you need at least a couple of times of showing up

SPEAKER_00in somebody's email inbox, and ideally also in different formats and ways. Honestly, you can read five articles that I've written, but if you just spend 45 minutes with us, You know me pretty well. You get my energy. You either want to stay connected or not. If that resonates, cool. You're going to check out some of my stuff on the publication. You're going to see if any of our products or services are fit for you. You're going to stay subscribed and just follow the journey.

SPEAKER_00Or you found out, I don't know, I don't want to learn from two weird women who are like, I'm moving on. Give me the John and James.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. That's so interesting. And you know, in enterprise software, it's actually similar. It is seven touches. You need to make seven touches before somebody knows you exist and starts considering, you know, I'm an enterprise software founder for anybody who's joined before they consider buying from you. Sinem, something really interesting here. And I think we both Yeah.

SPEAKER_01Reels, TikToks, you know, articles. That was easy. Like, whatever. You just constantly get these dopamine hits. People tell you're amazing. And now I have metrics attached to my name, right? It's like, can I actually convert people? I'd love to hear about the journey you've seen there and, you know, takeaways for anybody who's going from, like, you know, selling something to selling themselves and how they should think about it and any hints or tips there for somebody going through that transition.

SPEAKER_00It's a confidence game. That's all it is. And I think the more confident you are about whatever it is that you are asking to get paid for, the easier it is to Feel good about yourself. When I know that my course, my coaching is kick-ass, it is easier to tell people, hey, you might want to check this out. Yeah. That's the whole point when it comes to the sales part. And for the paid tier, that's actually the part where it's really easy on Substack, right? When you're aiming to become a bestseller,

SPEAKER_00for example, you are typically not asking people for a whole lot, right? You typically ask for $100 on your annual tier. You might discount, it might be significantly lower, but that's the price range we are talking about. For anyone who has something worth sharing with other people, you can give someone an enormous amount of value that absolutely exceeds the expectations. Yep. Yep.

SPEAKER_00Yep. And whenever you are sharing knowledge, that should be so easy to do. It's very different when you are writing fiction or you're an artist.

SPEAKER_00That's a whole different conversation. But if your stuff is knowledge and experience and your story, and you want to help others by sharing what you have learned and what you know, You can pack thousands of dollars worth of value into your paid subscription, which then makes it very easy to show up and say, hey, here's a five-day promo period. I'm going to send out 10 emails. If you want it, you get it. If you don't want it, well, you have to just ignore these emails for a while and then you'll still be on

SPEAKER_00the list and receive the value for free anyway on all

SPEAKER_01the free articles. Do your emails, your promo emails for Substack come within Substack or do you send them on Kit? If we promote the paid tier, we do it via Substack. Interesting. This is so good. Okay, so guys, this is so full of information. If you came late, like, restart. Go listen to it. I'm sure it'll be on your page, right, Sinem, so people can listen to it. And what we're talking about is ultimately turning your brain into knowledge and how people don't pay for information, but they pay for transformation. And transformation is big. It's huge.

SPEAKER_01Honestly, I don't do one-on-ones because I don't make enough money on them. It doesn't make sense to charge somebody $300, $400, $500 and spend my whole day doing that. And so I've totally canceled the idea of one-on-ones, right? But unless I'm doing it for a friend and it's not going to go to my heart or an acquaintance or whatever. But suddenly for a hundred something dollars a year, somebody has access to all these things in these lives where I'm kind of giving too much of myself. So you're right, right? In a universe where I won't even entertain the thought of a one-on-one because it just doesn't make sense in terms of my calendar. So you're right. People do pay for that transformation.

SPEAKER_01They will pay for access. Let's get to questions. We have 10 minutes left, and I saw some really good questions, starting with one that we'd spoken about a bit earlier around notes and whether notes reach your subscribers or new subscribers more, Sinem. What do you think?

SPEAKER_00Both. It's a mix, but you want to leverage both ends. So you want to think of notes as your opportunity to just show up more often, to have more touch points with the people who are already subscribed. Some of your notes will drive subscriptions and will bring strangers into your world. That's big That's why I recommend using very different formats as well. Be experimental with notes.

SPEAKER_00If a note flops, you've lost nothing, right? If you spend 10 minutes on a note, 15 minutes a note, that's probably the max anyone ever spends on an individual note. So what? Just give it a shot. Whenever you have an idea, no matter how cringe or weird it might seem, you don't know. Especially with short-form content, the stuff that sticks and travels far is not always predictable, especially on Notes, because Notes as a feature is still very, very young.

SPEAKER_00It hasn't existed like three years ago.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, yeah. And you know, like the rule that I love is if you're going to try something, do it 100 times before you come to conclusions, right? So I'm going to send out 100 different opportunities for people to upgrade their self-stack with me before I come to any conclusions because that kind of gives you a good understanding of what people want, where the market is, and it forces you not to take it personally and turn it into a numbers game. Somebody asked about How authors and speakers are using Substack, whether it's for sales or for building followers. Sinem, I'd love to know through people you've coached. Chris, my personal answer as a speaker and aspiring author is reach.

SPEAKER_01I want people to trust my voice because that's what will convert them into. I need editing houses and agents and everybody to know that I can attract people to my words and my voice. So for me, it's more like building followers matters a lot. Believe you me, the second I get that book deal, you guys will never stop hearing about book conversion. So I think it could be depending on your strategy and where you are used for both. Sinem, what do you see?

SPEAKER_00It's also, yeah, like, authority, reach, trust, all of that. And you can look at Substack as, like, a home base you're building. You don't need to give up, like, anything that you've ever built, right? And a lot of our clients, they have their websites. Their websites are pinned in their navigation bars. But still, it's… Especially because Substack is hot. When people come in here and they see that you've got a proper page, you have your content up, and you are just showing up with your message and presenting it in an attractive way, that's just giving you a head start.

SPEAKER_00And I think people really underestimate how much you can leverage multimedia on Substack because it has started as a writing platform. People think, I can only fully leverage the platform if I write. As I said, a lot of our content nowadays is basically the videos, is the conversations, and that's not because we are too lazy to write, but because it is easier to build a connection by speaking to you, by being on video, and by showing that, you know, yes,

SPEAKER_00a lot of other people are saying similar things, but this is our perspective, this is the way we do it, and this is not copy-pasted advice, especially in our space, right? Left and right, people start to talk about how to grow on Substack who have barely, I don't know, a few hundred, a few thousand subscribers.

SPEAKER_01You know what's funny is the way I listen to Substack mostly is audio. Put a heart in the chat if you're like that too. I don't know if for minority or majority, but I do a lot of audio Substack. So the day that I binged on you, And, you know, your Substack, I was just listening. I listened for five or six hours that whole day. And it was YouTube's and it was like Substack's audio feature or whatever. And I actually like the YouTubes more, even though it was my same use of Substack because it was like your voice. And I listened to your Substack lives. I went crazy on the Substack lives. The audio one that was not alive, which was the bomb and everybody has to listen to, I think it's posted on your page.

SPEAKER_01It's like 200 tips. What's the title? You effectively give like 200 tips for everything on Substack ever. Yo, that was so good. And it was so clearly not like internet slop. It was so clearly from experience. I like kept taking notes frantically on my phone because I'm like walking and I'm like, oh my gosh, do this, do that. So good. But I agree that multimedia reaches people. People are starting to engage with this differently. Some are here for the reading. Some listen to reading. So it's listening. And you know, all these things might engage different people.

SPEAKER_00You can pick your favorite media, right? If you love to write, then focus on the writing as something that makes you happy, but you can still do a voiceover. We have clients now who do the writing, but then they read out their own articles, which is a massive personal touch that you're giving people if you read your own article. With lives and podcasts, it's your way to really Really accelerate the whole journey because it is hard

SPEAKER_00to build trust just over

SPEAKER_01text alone right now. Yep, yep. I started recently doing voiceover. Anybody who's considered doing that, the first one took me like 40 minutes. Now I pretty much have like four errors per recording, which is awesome. And I used Descript. I'm not sponsored by them. For the love of God, they need to start sponsoring me. Phenomenal. I love them too. Phenomenal. You just record into it. I have a good microphone, which helps.

SPEAKER_00You guys might be able to see it.

SPEAKER_01And then you edit it like a Google Doc. And so I literally will have it remove all my spaces and my ums. I'll give it studio sound. I edit it like a Google Doc. I throw my intro and outro in and I export it. And now it's like a 20-minute, including the recording, probably a 30-minute process. And so – Somebody asked a question about Substack as a business being for products within Substack or outside of Substack. Me and Sinem, I'll let you answer in a second, Sinem. For me, it's regardless. If you want to use Substack to make a living, whether it's through your paid subs or other products, that's like using Substack as a business with CTAs and with funnels.

SPEAKER_01Sinem, would you agree?

SPEAKER_00Yeah, absolutely. I mean, if you are here because you feel like Substack is your infrastructure, you don't want to do any sales marketing whatsoever, then yeah, you're welcome to just Do everything on Substack. If you're coming here from the perspective of a business owner, a founder, and you want to leverage the platform to just be one part of your ecosystem, even if it's a very crucial part, maybe for several years, we'll all see where the journey goes. It does make sense to make sure that it's one part of the ecosystem

SPEAKER_00and it just makes sense with A lot of other moving aspects in your business.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, yeah, yeah. We have a few more minutes. We'll take these questions. Squeeze anything in the chat. We'll see if we could take it as well. There's one around promoting my enterprise software.

SPEAKER_00I actually don't do that onSubstack

SPEAKER_01or on my socials because we have a very specific buyer. It is a owner or a VP-level operations role in a company that owns a private fleet. So, like, you know, there's 250 people here. I doubt anybody has that title. If you do, like, Let's Talk yesterday. So there's no overlap, but they also have different goals, right? My business's goal is revenue. We have very different email lists, very different marketing strategies. We've hit our revenue goals. We're profitable. We're doing our thing there. We go to trade shows. Then I have my personal brand with different goals. It's writing the book and being the thought leader.

SPEAKER_01Somebody said, complete newbie here, exploring the idea of starting a Substack. Does it make sense to write more personal notes or write on the topic relevant to the product you're building and plan to launch or both at the same time? Sinem, tell me about that. Do people love personality here?

SPEAKER_00Yeah, absolutely. Mix it up, especially in notes. Again, notes are very fast-paced. They are easy. Just do your personal quirky notes on the go whenever something comes to your mind when you take a photo with your phone. You don't have to hold back. And I would even say, whenever it makes sense, bring that personality to your long-form writing as well. You really need to be aware of how much we are competing with just AI-generated content as well.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, non-humans. People will stay with you for you. Yes, it's your content, but you want people to have a connection to you as the writer as well. If you can do that with more personal content, you have an advantage there.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, I think so too. And I kind of go back and forth. Like I have the advantage of having maybe less skin in the game because I really write as like a side hustle and it's fine. So I'll randomly post something about, you know, my kid telling me hilarious things and then I'll post something about, you know, what I do and what I want to teach. And I think it creates a little bit more of connection, which is always great. So, so good. Every, thank you. Every shares how to grow on Substack, but if you have a strategy for convert, engaging to convert. So he wants to talk about engaging people to convert them to clients.

SPEAKER_01Sinem, do we want to end at 11 in a minute on the dot? Do you want to do more minutes? How are you feeling? I am good. I have extra time if you do, too. I do, too. Let's go. So somebody wants to know how to convert. • Engaged people into customers. I'll tell you my answer. I'd love to hear yours. My answer is you got to ask and you got to tell them how you're going to change them. You can't expect, you can't do what I did and just turn on paid and be like, people are going to love me and people do love me, but they don't want to pay for me, right? I have to tell them what I'm going to do for them, how I'm going to do it and I have to repeat it a million times.

SPEAKER_01Would you agree with that approach, Sinem?

SPEAKER_00Yeah, definitely agree. And I mean, the rest really depends on what does your Business and funnel look like right now. I was just scrolling up because Chris left a comment very early on and he said, I'm always looking for new ideas to help my clients, nonfiction authors, grow revenue from their book expertise and life experiences. So Chris, I believe you have offers that are basically battle-tested, right? So whether it's coaching, consulting, courses, community,

SPEAKER_00you want to make sure that you direct people to those offers that you already have. The steps you take on Substack and what you build on Substack shouldn't be a whole separate thing. It should fuel your business and the ones that already exist. And another thing people really underestimate is Substack doesn't penalize you for linking in your articles right now, right? I wouldn't use links a lot in Notes. Notes that use links don't go very far,

SPEAKER_00but in your articles, you can send people to your pages, and that is a huge asset. Maybe we do get penalized for it sometime. Maybe it's going to be done differently in the future. But right now, that's perfect. When you have your offers, you just need to make sure that your content, your packaging is sending the right people to the right places. You just have more visibility for the offers you've probably spent years designing in the backend anyway.

SPEAKER_00Mm-hmm. It's so interesting.

SPEAKER_01Jeff is asking about comparing this to Substack newsletters to promote business and other business models. Some people argue for us to use lead magnets with online landing pages to get email addresses, then regularly send entertaining marketing emails to people on the list. So one thing I do. Always on Instagram, if you follow me on Instagram, you know this, every single one of mySubstack turns into a carousel that explains a lot the article and says comment blank to join, you know, my newsletter. I also have a Flowdesk. And if I have a digital product, or if I'm going to launch a digital product, Flowdesk gives you like this landing page where you can get people's email.

SPEAKER_01And you can literally say, you know, join, I'm going to launch this thing, give me your email, yada, yada, yada. If you're asking a question that is that sophisticated, Jeff, my hunch is you also need an email list that can segment people based on why they came to you so you can determine what you need to send them, whether it's information or products, because segmented email lists have the highest open rate. I'm doing an ad with Flowdesk right now. I'm like... They break down what's working. And segmentation will always do better than non-segmented lists.

SPEAKER_01You'll have more clicks. You'll have more opens. And with a question like that, it is highly likely that you need an audience that is segmented.

SPEAKER_00And also, it's less of this or that. A lot of people who have spent a lot of time on other platforms, they look at Substack as this evil thing that is now coming and everyone wants Substack attention. It can work together. As I said, I have my list on Kit, you have yours on Flowdesk. Substack is not taking anything away from that. It's just making it easier to reach more people and to convert more people. You can also use a very simplified version of the whole lead magnet and landing page

SPEAKER_00with Substack, but it's not really what the platform is built for. So just like Lila said, it's If you have the infrastructure in the backend, you have your email service provider, it's very likely going to make sense to keep that infrastructure and just, you know, put fuel, put gas on the fire with Substack. Yeah, I agree. This was awesome.

SPEAKER_01My parting words, listen, everybody's here because some of you have done it and some of you really want to do it so you're overstudying what to do before you do it. Every year, Three dozen people come to me and say, Leila, I want to write a book. I want to write a Substack. I want to start a business. I want to start a podcast. I want to blah, blah, blah, blah, blah. And I swear to you, I say this all the time because these are my metrics. One in every 10 does it. The other nine keep planning. They get nervous. They get in their own way. They might pay for the consultants and the landing pages and the flow desks and whatever, and they just don't do it. So if you're here and you haven't done it,

SPEAKER_01really the only takeaway from this whole thing is just do it. It's going to suck. Most of it will suck. Like I said, the rule of thirds, 33% awesome, 33% boring, 33% absolutely sucks. So 66% of it will mostly suck. And I'm telling you right now, I'm not a wunderkind, you know, I'm used Austrian for you, Sinem, of Substack. Like I turn on paid and you guys aren't throwing your money at me. It sucks, right? Most things suck. And that's the reality of building any business. So my encouragement to you is embrace that it sucks and just do it.

SPEAKER_00See the fun of it. See it as an opportunity that I always think to myself, like, I don't know, my parents didn't have the opportunity to just, you know, do funny stuff on their computers and get paid for it or just sit at home and work from home and do cool things. So I take that as a privilege as it is. I mean, You might not have the easiest start. Most of us don't, to be fair, but have fun with it and appreciate the opportunity. Appreciate that we're living in a pretty fantastic time

SPEAKER_00to have all these opportunities in the first place.

SPEAKER_01Go do cool shit.

SPEAKER_00Thank you so much, Laila. I'd love to do a round two, so I'll keep pinging you. I'll be on top of what you're doing. You ping me whenever you need something and I can't wait to get the recording out to everyone. Thank you. Thank you, everybody, for joining

SPEAKER_01as well.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. What I'd Do in My First 30 Days on Substack

    Nov 18, 202640 minAudio

    If you started your Substack today, your first 30 days would end right before 2027. And most new creators spend that first month on the wrong things: designing a publication logo, rewriting their first article for the...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. How This Creator Made $12k on Substack Within 30 Days

    Oct 26, 202652 minAudio

    We recently sat down with Virgil Brewster, a member of our Substack Accelerator, to unpack how he turned a brand-new publication into a source of real clients in a matter of weeks. Full disclosure: Virgil has spent over...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. 3 Substack Strategies to Gain Paid Subscribers

    Oct 23, 202635 minAudio

    The creators who grow their paid subscribers fastest aren’t the ones promoting the hardest. They’re the ones promoting at the right moments, in the right places, with the fewest reasons for a reader to say no. In this...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. She became a Substack Bestseller with a TINY audience

    Oct 21, 202636 minAudio

    https://www.substackcoaching.com/ou’re a teacher or coach and aren’t sure how Substack could fit into your existing business or ecosystem, this conversation is for you. We started working with Katarzyna Ciszewska 🇮🇹...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. 3 Things I’d NEVER Skip on Substack

    Oct 14, 202615 minAudio

    If Substack has started to feel like too much- all the live streams, podcasts, videos, and automations- and you can’t give it the hours you’d like, this post is for you. You don’t need any of that to keep growing. You...

    Credit the people on this episode