Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Write • Build • Scale Podcast

Write • Build • Scale Podcast artwork

Nobody Told Me These 5 Things When I Started on Substack

Sep 28, 202625 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

We’ve been on Substack for 2 years now, and a lot of what we believed at the start turned out to be wrong. Recently, a business coach about to join the platform asked us what we wish we’d known 2 years ago. Here are the 5 answers, the things we’d tell our day-one selves, so you can skip straight past the mistakes most beginners make on the platform. 1. Substack is not a writing platform, it’s a relationship platform When we joined, we thought Substack was about great writing. We’d come from platforms where long-form writing was the whole game, so we assumed we’d have to become excellent writers to make it here. That was wrong. If you want to build an audience here, free or paid, the skill that matters most isn’t writing. It’s relationship building. Writing is just the tool that opens the door. Notes especially get people to notice you. But where they actually connect with you is somewhere else: In live streams, in videos, in the messages you send back and forth. That’s why you don’t have to be a brilliant long-form writer to do well here. Short-form is far more forgiving, built on hooks and templates, and it does the job of getting the right people into the room. Since we started, the platform has added live streaming, podcasts, and video, so there’s more than ever to build those relationships with. If we’d understood that on day one, we’d have approached the whole thing differently. 2. Paid subscribers matter, but not for the reason you think When we started, we thought the whole point was to rack up as many paid subscribers as possible. Here’s what changed our minds: Paid subscriptions make up less than 5% of our annual revenue. Everything else- the digital products, courses, coaching, communities, and collaborations- sits on top of that. So paid subscribers aren’t the prize. But they’re still worth chasing, for two reasons that have nothing to do with that 5%. The first is proof. Getting to 100 paid subscribers earns you the Bestseller badge, and on Substack that badge is real. On other platforms you can just buy the checkmark, so it signals nothing. Here, a badge means real people are paying real money, and that pulls others in. It’s the same reason a line out the door makes you want to see what the fuss is about. The second is signal. A paid subscriber has raised their hand. When someone pays to subscribe to us, they’re telling us they’re serious about building and growing on Substack, serious enough to put money behind it. That makes them your warmest possible lead. So get to that first bestseller badge to build the trust, then build the real business on top of it. 3. The connection here is unlike anywhere else, which makes it its own category Our view of what Substack even is kept changing. First it looked like a writing platform. Then a writing platform with social features. Now we’d put it in a category of its own, because of the quality of the connections you can build here. Think about the older social platforms for a second. They’re crowded with ads, clickbait, and endless reels, and a lot of people are quietly sick of them. Substack is quieter, and it’s built for going deeper. Here’s a test: Message someone you’ve been talking to on Substack, and chances are high they’ll reply. Now try to remember the last genuinely meaningful conversation you had in someone’s Instagram DMs. For most people, it’s been a while. That depth is the whole reason live streams work so well. Every time we go live and invite people to reach out about something they’re stuck on, someone does, and a real conversation starts. That rarely happens on the platforms people are leaving. 4. Use Substack with a plan for where it actually leads This one took us the longest to see: Substack works best when it fits into the bigger picture. When we started, we assumed everyone came here to grow an audience and turn on paid subscriptions. But after working with a lot of serious entrepreneurs, we’ve learned that the ones who win the biggest treat Substack as a means to something specific. They know exactly why they’re here: To win members for a community, to land a book deal, to get booked on stages, to find one-on-one coaching clients, to start a mastermind. For a creator or an operator, Substack is one of the best places going to generate real deal flow. One person we started working with recently came in with exactly that clarity. He didn’t want to grow a list for its own sake; he wanted to shortcut his path to revenue, and within his first month he was closing real business straight out of DM conversations. Not because of a viral post but because he knew what he wanted the platform to do for him. Those conversations are where a surprising amount of real business happens, and they’re also where most creators freeze. The Substack DM Playbook gives you the templates to start real conversations that go somewhere, so your deal flow doesn’t depend on guessing what to say. 5. Consistency beats brilliance, every time The last one is the one we’d tattoo on our day-one selves: Consistency beats brilliance. When we started, every note was a lottery ticket, written in the hope that this would be the one to go viral and change everything. It never really happened. We have notes with thousands of likes, but never one of those explosive, list-doubling viral hits. And still, we grew from zero to over 55,000 subscribers, purely by showing up. More than 400 days in a row, at least one note every single day, often 3 or 4. That’s the trade most people get the wrong way around. Going viral is a lottery ticket. Consistency, on the other hand, is building a foundation. And a foundation attracts the right people: The ones who found you because you kept showing up with something useful, not because a single note happened to blow up. Viral subscribers mostly don’t care about you, the same way readers you pay to acquire tend to convert worse than the ones who arrive organically. So the person to bet on isn’t the one who posts 50 notes in a single day and then goes quiet for a week. It’s the one who shows up every day for 50 days. Pick a cadence you can actually hold, and hold it. Those are the 5 reminders to keep in mind: Build relationships over writing, treat paid as proof and signal, go deep where others stay shallow, work with a plan, and let consistency do the heavy lifting. Every one of them took us the better part of 2 years to learn the slow way. If you already run a business or a coaching practice and you’d rather not spend your own 2 years figuring Substack out by trial and error, that’s exactly what we built the Substack Accelerator for. It’s direct coaching from the Write • Build • Scale team, applied to your specific publication, so you skip the guesswork and move straight to what works. It’s application-based, because we only take people we’re confident we can get there. If that sounds like you, apply here: substackcoaching.com This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit writebuildscale.substack.com/subscribe

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_01Today I want to talk a little bit about the things that I wish I'd known earlier. We are on Substack for two years and today I will share everything that I wish I'd known from two years ago when I joined the platform. How did I come up with this idea? Just how all my other ideas come up with through simple conversations. I'm joining a mastermind in Ibiza in about a month from now. And as service of this mastermind, it's also coming with a digital community.

SPEAKER_01And Patrick, the founder of the mastermind, is very keen in connecting other people with each other. The cool thing is he already connected me with a guy from Germany, an amazing entrepreneur who just left his startup that he grown from the beginning and is now becoming a business coach. This guy is called Simon and Simon is now starting on Substack in The niche of being an online business coach for people from Germany because he's also creating German speaking content.

SPEAKER_01And I was on a call with him. We exchanged some thoughts. He shared some tips with me about running ads and how he's running his business. And that's always what I love to learn from others. But then he also asked me the following question. Hey Philip, I'm starting on Substack now. What are the things that you wish you would have known two years ago? And it really struck me as A cool question because a lot of things have changed over the last two years, not only on the side of Substack, like what features they have and how to approach it

SPEAKER_01and what strategies work nowadays, but also like how I am as a person, how I am treating opportunities and lots and lots of other things. So I've created a short list or basically I looked at the transcript that are things that I've shared with him and I now want to share some of those things with you. The first thing is Substack is all about relationships. I thought when I joined Substack, Substack is about great writing.

SPEAKER_01Sinem and I and also Yare, we used to write on a platform like Medium So I was really a little bit skeptical about Substack because I thought, yeah, okay, this is just another writing platform and I need to become really good at writing in order to make it on that platform. After the first couple of days on the platform, two things have been completely clear. Number one, I do not enjoy long-form writing, so that's what my two co-founders are doing.

SPEAKER_01Second, though, I enjoy writing short-form because that is something where you can work a lot with templates, where it's a lot about hooks, and that's just simpler than long-form writing. So that was something that I really enjoyed and that I jumped into, and it was amazing. And nevertheless, my thought right from day one on Substack that I need to become a good writer in order to make it on Substack was completely wrong. I strongly believe nowadays that if you want to build an audience on Substack,

SPEAKER_01no matter if it's free or paid, if you want to thrive on the platform, you need to be really good at relationship building, not at writing. Writing is just a tool that helps you build relationships. Writing gets people into your door, especially notes, but where they really connect with you is through live streams, through something like this, through videos, through sending messages. So Substack is not a writing platform. When I joined it two years ago, I really thought it is another writing platform.

SPEAKER_01But since then, they rolled out so many more features like live streaming. Now we're doing a podcast. We're posting videos. So there's so much more that we can do nowadays. So that was probably the first thing that I would have loved to know two years ago already because I would have right from day one approached Substack very differently. I see a message in the chat from Andy K saying, I just started six months ago and got to 1K. Congratulations on that.

SPEAKER_01The first 1,000 subscribers are by far the hardest. I bet you it will not take you six months, not even close to that, to go from 1,000 to 2,000. And I invite you, whenever you reach 2,000 subscribers, feel free to reach out to me and let me know how long it took you. Or if you want to get in touch right away, you can also do that.

SPEAKER_00I see you're still here in the chat. Thank you so much for being here.

SPEAKER_01If you have any questions, also open invitation for everyone else. I have some time today to answer some questions. Just throw things at me at the chat and I'm happy to go into detail on those things. In the meantime, I want to take a look The second thing here on my notes and it's something that I've shared with this business coach because he wants obviously to use Substack to grow his business and he asked me about the value of free subscribers

SPEAKER_01and paid subscribers and I I really thought when I joined Substack two years ago that it's all about getting as much paid subscribers as possible. What I learned and what I know nowadays is that paid subscribers make up not even 5% of the annual revenue that we Everything else is on top of that. It's through digital products, through courses, through coaching, through communities, through collaborations. Even sometimes affiliate marketing makes up almost as much as the paid subscription

SPEAKER_01for a specific amount of people. So this is something else that I would have loved to know. I was so focused on getting paid subscriber, paid subscriber. And to be honest, the biggest benefit of the paid subscribers are twofold. First of all, Getting to 100. Subscribers and getting this first bestseller batch is amazing. It's a milestone that you're looking for and it is a milestone that allows you to be more recognized on the platform because no matter where you post, you stand out and people really trust you.

SPEAKER_01If you take a look at other platforms, those batches like on Meta or on X, you can buy them, which basically means everyone could have them if they want. Therefore, there's not really A lot of benefit in it, in my opinion. On Substack, if I see a paid subscriber, I instantly know this person has 100 or even 1,000 people who are paying for it and therefore there's so much more value to it. Because let's be completely honest, why do so many people buy the new iPhone?

SPEAKER_01Because they see lines of hundreds of thousands of people lining up also wanting to buy it. So that is something That I want you to keep in mind. So as for the bestseller badge, it's really important to get it so that you get more recognition on the platform. The second thing is, and that's important if you're a coach, if you're a consultant, if you're an expert, if you're selling digital courses, I would always treat The paid subscribers is some kind of an arm raiser.

SPEAKER_01So in our case, if you are subscribed to Write • Build • Scale and you become a paid subscriber, you are telling us you are interested, not just a bit, but quite a lot because otherwise you wouldn't spend money on it, to become a Bestseller on Substack, Build a Business on Substack, or Grow Your Online Business. This basically indicates to us that you are interested and you've already invested money in us. So therefore, we treat this as an arm raiser saying, hey, this person is raising their arm. So to sum up, in the beginning, I really thought it's all about getting paid subscribers.

SPEAKER_01Now, two years later, I know paid subscribers are important. You want to have them because only if you are making money on Substack, Substack is also making money. Therefore, I would always encourage people to at least get to the first or if possible to the second bestseller batch to build the trust, but then monetize on top of that. Okay, let me quickly check what's going on. Coach Kerb is saying, since I've leaned into my sports content on Substack two days ago,

SPEAKER_01my subscribers count has grown from 27 to 50 people. That's amazing, Coach Kerb. The beginning is always the hardest. I would really encourage you to right now pay close attention to who those people are, why they subscribed. If you find the time, send them all a personalized message, reaching out to them, saying something like, hey, thank you so much for becoming a paid subscriber. I'm curious what made you subscribe. What kind of content do you expect?

SPEAKER_01Just start a meaningful conversation. Don't try to pitch them something right away because you are still at the initial stage of your Substack. There it's really important for you to find out why someone wants to subscribe to you. Once you're getting hundreds of subscribers You will have already figured out why someone subscribed to you. But nevertheless, those 10 plus people that subscribe to you every single day are an amazing source for you to figure out what you can do or should do with your publication.

SPEAKER_01I'm a big believer in building in public and I always tell my clients, please build products that other people really want to have. So therefore, really make sure to get in a conversation with them. And last but not least, congratulations on getting started and congrats on your first 50 subscribers. Soon you will be at 100, then you will be at 1,000 and I assume by then you will also already have your first paid subscribers. Andika is saying, I totally agree, Coach Kerb.

SPEAKER_01Choosing to focus on one topic plus showing up weekly helped me a lot. I absolutely agree. You can either choose on one topic, on one super specific target audience group, Or on one transformation. Those are the three ways to niche down and you need to pick one of them. Most people go with topic. I also know a lot of publications, for example, on publication that focuses on students of a huge US university. They can then write about multiple topics, but they write only for the students of this university.

SPEAKER_01And the third one, that's the one most overlooked. And most of the time, this works for those people that cannot find a niche, and that's focusing on your reader's transformation. So for example, we with Write Build Scale, we focus on our reader's transformation. We help them go from new on Substack, not knowing what to do, to building an audience on Substack and monetizing on Substack and on top of it, because we want to help our people build digital thriving businesses.

SPEAKER_01What else do we have here in the chat? Coach Kerb is saying, it's been amazing. I had no idea where so many sports creators are on here. Yeah, there are lots and lots of sports creators on here. And I can tell you, there are even more readers on there. So for example, if you take a look at everything that I post on Substack, You will not assume that I'm into sports a lot. I mean, if you see me on the live streams, you see that I have all those signed jerseys that I collect, sports memorabilia. You might also hear me talk about that I'm training for an ultra race, which is 100%.

SPEAKER_01You will get a little bit of a better understanding of those things. But I can already tell you there are some really amazing publications on Substack in the running niche, in the football niche. And I don't know into what kind of sports you are into, but there are lots and lots of amazing people on here. And also oftentimes you don't see it on a profile, but those people are also interested in sports. Andy again is saying, I share a recipe, activity, and product recommendation around being a 90s mom.

SPEAKER_01I'm the 90s mom on Substack. I love it. I love that you found your niche and I'm 100% sure that a lot of people can resonate to this. And you're also a paid subscriber to Write • Build • Scale. Woohoo. Thank you so much for that. Those of you who are not yet paid subscribers to Write • Build • Scale and want to become one, take a look at our publication. We're currently running a special promotion where you can be able to become a paid subscriber for the entire year for only $24.

SPEAKER_01So in my opinion, that's a no-brainer because if you want to grow on Substack and you invest $24 in our content, there is no way in hell that you are not going to benefit from it. Okay, what else do we have? QuietAfterNoise is saying, I used to chase followers on X and Facebook. After a triple near-death experience in one evening, I deleted the apps and started writing on Substack just from Within 60 days,

SPEAKER_01my free subscribers jumped from zero to nearly 1,000. Congratulations on your success on Substack and also my point of view, congratulations on leaving access. I strongly believe those are the, like I love to call them, legacy social medias. Legacy social media means people are already sick and tired of them. No one, in my opinion,Substack really enjoys those platforms anymore.

SPEAKER_01There are too many ads. There is too much clickbait. Those reels are so annoying and Substack is just a quieter place where you can really go in deeper with conversations. Everyone who wants to challenge me on that, I give you an example. Pick someone who's here in the chat and send them a direct message. Chances are so high that the people are responding to you. On the other hand, pick someone on Instagram. I do not remember when I had the last time a really meaningful conversation on Instagram.

SPEAKER_01That's also the reason why I'm such a big fan of Substack. And this is the perfect bridge to the third thing that I told this person on the call about what I think is Different on Substack nowadays than what I thought it is two years ago. Two years ago, I thought Substack is the next online writing platform. Then I thought it's the next online writing platform with social media aspects. Now I think it stands in its own category because the quality of connections

SPEAKER_01that I have built on this platform and that you can also build here on Substack is unbelievable. So there's really a huge difference between the amount of Meaningful conversations that I had on other platforms compared to what I've already had here on Substack. And that's also why I love to do those live streams. Every single time when I do a live stream, I invite people to send me a message if they want to talk about a specific topic where they think I can help them.

SPEAKER_01And every single time someone reaches out to me and I get feedback, I get input, I start conversations. For example, it's September. And I love to do Substack September. So meaning every September, I do something special here on Substack. First September, we kicked Substack off. Last September, we focused a lot on growth because it was our one-year anniversary. And this year in September, We said, hey, you know what? I want to go live every single day. And I started doing this.

SPEAKER_01I invited other people to also do a challenge for September or to also go live every single day. And one of our students, Sarah Stone, she instantly created a posting saying she thinks it's a cool idea. She wants to do this. She's also going live every single day. And two days ago, we did a live stream together. So that is the idea of Not only do you want to keep yourself accountable, but you also want to inspire others to do something amazing here on Substack.

SPEAKER_01Give me a second to quickly follow up on the chat, take a sip, and then I continue with the next point of things that I wish

SPEAKER_00I'd known two years ago about Substack.

SPEAKER_01One thing that was not clear to me two years ago is that on Substack, it's the most efficient way for you to use it when you have a plan where it should lead. And I'm not only meaning your activity on Substack, but the bigger picture for it. When we first started on Substack, we thought that people want to build an audience on Substack, want to become bestsellers, want to monetize through Substack. Now that we've Worked with so many amazing six-, seven-, and even eight-figure entrepreneurs.

SPEAKER_01We've learned that those people that see the best success from Substack are the ones that have a clear game plan in place, that exactly know, I want to be on Substack. Because it helps me win members for my community, get me in front of publishers that I can land a book deal with, get me to speak on stages, helps me find people that I can one-on-one coach or even found a mastermind. So really, once again, two years ago, I really thought everyone's coming to Substack wanting to grow an audience

SPEAKER_01and monetize through the paid subscription. What it really is all about here on Substack, if you're a creator or if you're an operator, it's an amazing opportunity to generate some deal flow, to build cool and amazing things that people can really relate to. For example, here in the chat I see the ADHD weasel. It's an amazing account. I have a call with one of the founders or the person running it right after this live stream. We already had a chat earlier this week and he's also not only interested

SPEAKER_01in building on Substack but also building on top of it. So you see, I'm not the only person that wants to do this. And earlier today, for example, I had a call with Virgil. Many of you might know him. He already is an owner of the Two Comma Club. Not the Two Comma Club Awards, but the Two Comma X Awards. Basically, he got rewarded for making over $10 million with his product in revenue. And I've chatted with him and he told me that he joined our program a month ago.

SPEAKER_01And he already made $12,000 through Substack, just through DM conversations, which is, in my opinion, absolutely amazing. But you need to know what to do. He had a clear plan why he came to Substack. He said, hey, I want to shortcut my journey as much as possible. Guys, please help me. How can I do this? We started working with him and he's already seeing amazing results. Yeah, just because he had a clear plan of what he wants to do.

SPEAKER_01Okay, I think now I'm down to four things that I wish I'd known two years ago when I joined Substack. And I have one more to pick. I have all my notes from the call here. And I think the last one that I really want to share Consistency beats brilliance. What do I mean by that? When I joined Substack, I was writing note after note after note and my goal was always, hey, maybe one day I can have this note that can go viral and I can suddenly grow my audience.

SPEAKER_01Honestly speaking, I haven't really gone viral. I mean, I have a couple of notes that have thousands of likes and comments, but not like one of those ultra-viral notes that get people 10 or 20,000 email subscribers or something like that. Nevertheless, I've been able to grow my audience from 0 to 55,000 people. Because I was consistent. And I strongly believe consistency beats trying to go viral on Substack every single time. For me, it's like trying to build a foundation for your business compared with trying to win

SPEAKER_01the lottery. I do not believe in the lottery. That's why I'm not playing this. If I want to have an adrenaline rush, I do my own sports or maybe I do some sports betting just for fun. But I do not believe in the lottery. If you take a look at numbers, it's not possible to really make sustainable money from the lottery because the odds are stacked against you. And that's how I approached Substack right from day one. It's not about going viral. It's about being consistent. I think yesterday Aurel sent out a message saying that WriteStack has now a tracker

SPEAKER_01with how many days in a row you've published just through WriteStack. And I am at, I think, 440 days. For the last 440 days, every single day, at least one note. In my case, most of the time, three or even four notes a day went live through WriteStack. And I strongly believe that this is so much more valuable to me than just going viral once. Here's why. When you build a consistent audience by consistently showing up and consistently providing value, you are attracting the right people.

SPEAKER_01Because here on this live stream, there are over 90 people here now. And I know that there are only the people that really care about what I'm doing because I never went viral. On the other hand, if your new account, no one knows what you're talking about, you suddenly go viral and you have thousands of subscribers. Those subscribers do not really care about what you are doing. Because they just subscribed because of a viral note. So we've always seen this. It's similar to when you run a funnel. You will always have better results with people that you attract organically compared to people where you attract them

SPEAKER_01through advertising dollars. So I would really invite you to keep this in mind. Substack is all about consistency. And that's also the idea of Substack September. That's why I'm trying to force myself to go live every single day. I've completely performed the entire week. Let's see, now Saturday and Sunday is coming, plus it's the first, the one-year anniversary of Sinem and My Wedding, which also does not really make it easier in order to find time to go live. But hey, maybe I find the spot,

SPEAKER_01maybe I do it just five minutes, maybe I fill the challenge and I just continue on Monday. It doesn't really matter. The important thing is that you try, that you show up, and that you take it seriously. So those have been all the five things that I wish I'd known when I joined Substack two years ago. Now quickly take a look at the chat before signing off so that all of your comments are answered. Andy is saying consistency is huge. Just wrote a note about how taking action and motion.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, absolutely agree with this. There's this quote basically saying, I do not fear the person that works out like crazy for 50 hours in a row. I fear the person that works out 50 days in a row. And that's absolutely true for Substack as well. There's no sense in posting 50 notes on one day and then missing three days in a row. Just make sure to show up, be consistent, and it's quite easy on Substack if you use a tool like WriteStack, for example.

SPEAKER_01Turning Pain into Power says, glad to catch this. Thank you so much for the kind words. We might even turn this into a post so that you can rewatch the rest if you missed something. Learn English with Joe says, happy anniversary, guys. Yeah, thank you so much. Appreciate that. That being said, I have to prepare for a call that I have in 15 minutes. Thank you so much, everyone, for joining in. I wish you an amazing Friday. And if you have any thoughts about Substack, feel free to send me a message. I'm happy to respond to you, challenge your ideas, or just have a casual conversation with you.

SPEAKER_01Have an amazing day.

SPEAKER_00Talk soon. Bye, everyone.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. What I'd Do in My First 30 Days on Substack

    Nov 18, 202640 minAudio

    If you started your Substack today, your first 30 days would end right before 2027. And most new creators spend that first month on the wrong things: designing a publication logo, rewriting their first article for the...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. How This Creator Made $12k on Substack Within 30 Days

    Oct 26, 202652 minAudio

    We recently sat down with Virgil Brewster, a member of our Substack Accelerator, to unpack how he turned a brand-new publication into a source of real clients in a matter of weeks. Full disclosure: Virgil has spent over...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. 3 Substack Strategies to Gain Paid Subscribers

    Oct 23, 202635 minAudio

    The creators who grow their paid subscribers fastest aren’t the ones promoting the hardest. They’re the ones promoting at the right moments, in the right places, with the fewest reasons for a reader to say no. In this...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. She became a Substack Bestseller with a TINY audience

    Oct 21, 202636 minAudio

    https://www.substackcoaching.com/ou’re a teacher or coach and aren’t sure how Substack could fit into your existing business or ecosystem, this conversation is for you. We started working with Katarzyna Ciszewska 🇮🇹...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. 3 Things I’d NEVER Skip on Substack

    Oct 14, 202615 minAudio

    If Substack has started to feel like too much- all the live streams, podcasts, videos, and automations- and you can’t give it the hours you’d like, this post is for you. You don’t need any of that to keep growing. You...

    Credit the people on this episode