Hey, thanks for reading Public Sphere! I’m sending this video out to everyone because I want it to have the maximum possible reach. But this work is sustained with the help of paid subscribers. If you can spare $1.34 per week - the annualized cost of a paid subscription - then I would really appreciate your support. You can upgrade below. The frontline town of Oleshky has been under Russian occupation since 2022. Now, a humanitarian catastrophe is unfolding. According to Ukrainian authorities, about 2,000 people out of a pre-war population of about 24,000 remain in the town in the south of Ukraine. The inhabitants lack access to clean drinking water, food, and electricity: according to Ukrainian Foreign Minister Andriy Sybiha, some people have been reduced to eating grass to sustain themselves. Lacking food deliveries since May, on Sept. 27, local Ukrainian authorities released video showing the transport of nearly 4,000 kg of food to the town with drones. However, Russian forces try to prevent aid delivery by shooting down these drones, confiscating and reselling provisions, and detaining residents who manage to get their hands on these packages. It’s a terrible situation that forces Ukrainians to become prisoners in their own homes amid constant shelling. Journalist Emmanuelle Chaze joined me discuss the situation. She is a Kyiv-based reporter working as a correspondent mainly for Ouest-France, RFI and France24. She is also the author of the Substack newsletter A View from Ukraine. She wrote about the situation in Oleshky below. Please listen, watch, or read the transcript of the video above. Restacks also help me reach more readers. This Substack is sustained with the support of readers, viewers, and listeners like you. This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit www.worlddisorder.io/subscribe
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_00Hi, I'm Luke Johnson, and welcome to the Public Sphere newsletter. A humanitarian catastrophe is unfolding in the frontline town of Aleshky in Russian-occupied Ukraine. According to Ukrainian authorities, about 2,000 According to Ukrainian Foreign Minister Andrei Sibha, some people have been reduced to eating grass for food.
SPEAKER_00Ukrainian forces recently released video showing transport of nearly 4,000 kilograms of food to the town with drones, but Russian forces actively try to prevent This drone delivery by shooting down the drones, confiscating or reselling provisions and detaining residents who receive these humanitarian aid packages. It's really a terrible situation that forces Ukrainians to become prisoners. I'm pleased to welcome Emmanuelle Shays here to discuss this situation.
SPEAKER_00She's a Kiev-based journalist working as a correspondent mainly for West France, RFI, and France 24. She is also the author of a Substack newsletter, A View from Ukraine, which I highly recommend. Welcome, Emmanuelle.
SPEAKER_02Thanks, Luke, and thanks to everyone who's joining us right now.
SPEAKER_00So I think many viewers and readers of my newsletter follow the war in Ukraine, but they probably haven't, many of them have not heard of the town of Oleski. Can you describe it?
SPEAKER_02Absolutely. So if you see, if you have in mind a map of Ukraine, you will see the region of Kherson. Some of you might know that it is partially, partly occupied, that it had been partially liberated back in November 2020. But there's still a part of the region that remains under occupation, and mainly within the Dnipro plains, that is where Oleski is, on the side of the Dnipro opposite to the city of Kherson itself. It means that Oleski is within the reach of Ukrainian fire,
SPEAKER_02which explains also why Ukraine was able to deliver those food parcels You've just mentioned, but also that the people who stay, who remain in Oleski, and we're talking about in the cities of 2,000 people out of the 24,000 pre-full-scale invasion. And if we count the survivors, It's around 6,000 people that remain in the area. It means that those people are trapped between the fires and they are effectively under Russian occupation with all that it entails in terms of sanitary situation
SPEAKER_02and humanitarian situation, which we will probably talk about.
SPEAKER_00Sure. So let's rewind a bit and talk about Eleshki since the full-scale invasion. So it was captured really a few days after, or in the opening, really 72 hours, I believe, after the Russia launched its full-scale invasion in 2022, and then some other things happened since. Can you describe the humanitarian crisis as it's been going on since the full-scale invasion?
SPEAKER_02Absolutely. So we are talking about the situation right now because the humanitarian crisis has been increasing over the past few weeks, the past few months. But in fact, if you look back Even to 2023, the situation was already catastrophic at Oleski. You might remember when the Karhovka Dam was blown up by Russian forces, there was a huge flood all across southern Ukraine. You might remember those videos of people on the roof of their houses calling for help.
SPEAKER_02And those are pictures from Oleski itself. It means that The city was already heavily damaged. There was no sporadic access to electricity. The sanitary conditions are also very dire in terms of access to drinking water, clean water, clear water, and access to roads. Since the spring, access to food deliveries has dramatically decreased.
SPEAKER_02In fact, we have the head of the military region, the military administration, sorry, of Oleski, who has said that the last food delivery in Oleski dates back in May this year. And ever since, no food has reached, at least on the Ukrainian side. Has been able to reach the inhabitants, the residents of some 2,000 people who remain in Oleski itself.
SPEAKER_00Okay. And why hasn't food been able to reach there since May? What changed?
SPEAKER_02Well, because this is a red zone. This is essentially a zone where you will have heavy bombardments and, of course, heavy civilians as well. You have drones, you have artillery, you have glide bombs. The road access is either hindered or non-existent.
SPEAKER_02The last, sorry, a few hours, the European Union has also said that it was trying to access Oleski to provide humanitarian relief. But this is still an ongoing process. And so far, with every day passing, the situation is more dire for people there.
SPEAKER_00Okay. And is Russia providing any humanitarian aid or access?
SPEAKER_02So Russia has said that it was looking into the situation. Why? Because Oleschke has reached international headlines and Russia, when it comes to occupied territory, wants to present, you know, an image of a A very normal city where Russia is rebuilding, where people are happy to live under Russian rule. But we know from the Ukrainian side that this is all but a lie because people who are resistant to the illegal occupying forces, they are being silenced.
SPEAKER_02They are silenced in the way that they are deprived of. The basic human rights, such as access to a passport of healthcare, access to education, access to some goods as well. And that isn't the best case scenario. In the worst case scenario, and that happens quite often, people are brought in to detention centers, to filtration camps, to To be questioned, to be tortured, to be raped as well. We have a lot of testimonies on Russian violence occurring against Ukraine
SPEAKER_02in occupied territories. That's not just in Oleski. But that explains why Russia wants to sell this image of everything is in order, everything is going well in occupied territories. But if you look at testimonies from Ukrainians who managed to escape from those territories, it is very far from being the case.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I mean, in occupied Mariupol, which is the only major city that Ukraine could not hold in the full-scale invasion, you know, Russia has been You know, building condominiums or really expropriating people's apartments and portraying this as kind of a paradise by the sea, you know, when that's really far from the case. But I want to zoom out more broadly to just what happens when Russia occupies the territory.
SPEAKER_00That many people do not know this because information is essentially very difficult, if not impossible, and of course incredibly dangerous to get out.
SPEAKER_02Absolutely. So you mentioned Mariupol. It's really interesting to see what has been happening in that city. It has been occupied since the spring of 2022. There you know that even humanitarian corridors had been bombed by the Russian troops. Our civilians were trying to make their way out of this city. Ever since, it's been very difficult to obtain information as to the well-being of Ukrainians still in the city.
SPEAKER_02What Russia has been doing since 2022 is first erasing traces of war crimes. For example, they had bombed this theater in Mariupol, killing more than 600 people, including many children. There was a sign reading children in front of Mariupol that people could read from the sky. Were they to drop a bomb in the vicinity? And they did right on the theater. So first off, Russia rebuilt this theater and played Russian authors in that city of Mariupol,
SPEAKER_02which is a Ukrainian city. And at least for Ukrainians, they still see Mariupol as their own city. The second thing that Russia will be doing, and it has been doing so consistently, not just since 2014, also in Crimea, but throughout history, it will bring... Russian settlers within the city, it will sell houses which have owners, Ukrainian owners, but owners might have died, they might have fled, they might be here in Ukraine,
SPEAKER_02they might be in Europe, and they will install those settlers in Ukrainian territories. Almost five years after the full-scale invasion, almost five years after the occupation of Mariupol, you will find more Russian settlers, Russian-speaking people there. And in a way, Russia, in that way, justifies its invasion, justifies its occupation by saying to the world, look, there are Russians there and they are happy to be here.
SPEAKER_00Right. I mean, of course, all of this is completely illegal under international law. But I wanted to also ask, what happens to Ukrainians who stay behind? Like, how do they get food or if they need medication? What's life like that trying to obtain everyday goods?
SPEAKER_02So, also I have to say, you know, being in Ukraine, the sources I have for occupied territories are the, you know, personal contacts with people whose family has been left behind. For example, people who have We have a mother in Mariupol, an aunt who's staying in Perdiansk in Melitopol, all those places where it's very difficult to get out. In the case of Mariupol, for example, people, if they want to get They will have to show support to the occupier or at least at
SPEAKER_02the very least be very silent about any sympathy they might have for Ukraine. They will have to cut ties effectively with their relatives here because it's increasingly difficult to communicate. Most of the, for example, apps like WhatsApp, etc., are not available in occupied territories for And any sense of being resistant to the occupation might earn Ukrainians serious reprisals from the Russian occupier.
SPEAKER_02We see also what Russia is doing with the youth is going to schools to try and develop a patriotic sentiment from children, Ukrainian children, by teaching them in Russian, by rewriting history books, of course, to the advantage of The Russian narrative when it comes to history by erasing, in effect, every trace of Ukrainian culture, Ukrainian language, Ukrainian history, and try to demographically change this region, linguistically change this region,
SPEAKER_02and of course, just try to erase any form of resistance.
SPEAKER_00And you said something interesting. So is WhatsApp not available in these Ukrainian regions that are occupied by Russia because WhatsApp is largely not available in Russia because of internet censorship and these occupied towns are on the Russian mobile networks?
SPEAKER_02Absolutely. So the goal also will be to break every link with Ukraine, with territorial Ukraine, with free Ukraine. And you will see also a divide, you know, growing. Within families, you have families who are here in Kyiv, who are elsewhere in Ukraine, who are trying to reach out to relatives. But it's also very dangerous because if your conversations are intercepted and you're being critical against the occupying regime,
SPEAKER_02then this can also earn you a trip to the filtration camp, a trip to a torture chamber. And people are really worried. You know, living in a state of great stress, and that's also the case for the residents in Oleski.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, so can we talk about what happens, you mentioned filtration camps, and can we talk about what happens if you, despite heavy around-the-clock bombardment, try to leave and somehow manage to make it to a slightly safer area?
SPEAKER_02So the way out for people who live in occupied territories would be first to go to the territory of the Russian Federation, right? So in order to do so, they have to go through filtration camps. And not everyone will be allowed to get within the Russian Federation territory, especially if they are considered as resistant to the occupier. There are some ways of, though, with people, you know, we have those reports of, for example, children who have returned from occupied territories,
SPEAKER_02but they are not just crossing the border. For example, the Dnipro River between Oleski and Kherson, that will be Way too easy. And in fact, they do have to go within the territory of the Russian Federation. In order to do so, they have to go to those filtration camps where they undergo a lot of interrogations, sometimes for several days, sometimes they're sent back home, sometimes they have to go back several times. And more often than not, they leave With almost no personal belongings, you know, they leave everything behind.
SPEAKER_02A lot of people also stay, and I quite like to highlight this fact, sometimes people just stay home because they know they cannot, you know, persuade their grandfather, their grandmother, their aunts to come with them. Others also don't want to leave because they want to bring the cats and they're not sure that at a checkpoint, at a given checkpoint, they will be able to bring their pets. And once they've passed this filtration camp, they can go if they have the financial means, if they have the passport. They can go to the territory of the Russian Federation and then begins an odyssey,
SPEAKER_02I would say, to go to a neighboring country and then try and reach Ukraine. But it's also another difficult task when you have no passport left.
SPEAKER_00Right. Um, and what happened, you know, there, there's like lots of reports. Like I can imagine if you're, if you're a young man, like if you're at one of these filtration camps, you might get conscripted into the army. And certainly if you're a woman, um, sexual violence is possible. Right.
SPEAKER_02Absolutely. So there are interesting points you're making now. I've talked recently to a young man who had escaped occupied territory. He is from Luhansk. He grew up under occupation. And then quickly before he turned 18, he tried to leave Luhansk itself because he knew he was coming at an age where it would be highly possible that he would be mobilized and mobilized within The Russian army to fight against Ukraine.
SPEAKER_02And for years, since 2014, he has always known that he wanted to go back to, you know, free Ukraine. He had self-taught Ukrainian to himself. He managed to, that way I was describing earlier, to reach the Ukrainian territory. But he was talking about how, as a Ukrainian, he was always, you know, the victim of bullying when he was at school, when school kids would be punished if they sang Ukrainian songs and that kind
SPEAKER_02of thing. And you've mentioned the fate also of, you know, Women, young women, and also actually women of all ages and paths of life. And you mentioned the fact that rape is happening also in occupied territory. It's not solely testimonies coming from women. There's also a culture of raping under torture, men who are brought in for interrogation. And that's something that has been documented by Human rights groups,
SPEAKER_02NGOs, working here in Ukraine. And the challenge also there is that there's this feeling of shame from people who have been victims of those war crimes. And more often than not, they don't dare to talk about it. But if you look at the pattern of occupation, the centers of detention across the front line, and we're talking about a big front line, it's more than 1,000 kilometers away. Well, such centers exist and so do those practices.
SPEAKER_00Okay. Moving back to Leshky a bit, what are some of the parallels in Ukrainian history to, I mean, forced starvation, you want to talk about it?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, I think it's important to keep in mind just how traumatic it is for Ukrainians to hear about fellow Ukrainians being subjected to, you know, a humanitarian crisis such as what we see in Oleski and not just in Oleski as we've just mentioned. We're almost a century after the Holodomor, this famine orchestrated by Stalin during the collectivization in Ukraine in 1932-1933.
SPEAKER_02Ukrainians, and especially the ruble population, were subjected to impossible-to-fill demands of giving to Moscow all the grain that they were producing, enormous quantities of grain they were producing. In certain regions of Ukraine, such as the Kharkiv area, the Kyiv area, One in four Ukrainians died during the Holodomor, so died of starvation during that time. And so many people died that even today it's very difficult to know exactly how many.
SPEAKER_02The consensus, I think, conservative estimates are around 4 million people who died. And this, you know, induced a trauma that can still be felt in today's Ukrainian society because every family or nearly every family of Ukrainians Has a story to share about the Holodomor, about a grandmother who witnessed half of her family, if not all her family, dying. When you're invited within a Ukrainian family, you will see that there's a profusion of food on the table,
SPEAKER_02that the basement is filled with preserves. And as anecdotal as it can appear, you know, this is not per chance. It is because people here are really, really afraid that such famine could happen again. And as early as 2022, when Russia was occupying part of Chernyiv region and parts of Kiev region, we saw the same pattern that is happening right now in Olochki, reappearing with people, you know,
SPEAKER_02being deprived of food, being You know, forbidden to access shops or any food, you know, reserves there might be because Russia does still use food as a weapon of war.
SPEAKER_00Right, and it's forcing people to get Russian passports to, you know, access food. And then it says, well, okay, these territories are Russian, because Russians are living here. But that's obviously, like, the propaganda lie behind all this. I wanted to ask, you mentioned that Russia had... Yeah.
SPEAKER_02So that's what the Ukrainian authorities are hoping for. We've heard quite strong words from Foreign Minister Andrei Sibiya, who called for partners of Ukraine to react. And he also, you could feel that he was, you know, under pressure Also, when he said that partners should not only give declarations of attention or just, you know, sharing the deep concern, because to date, deep concern don't stop bombs and it also doesn't feed an empty stomach. And I live there under bombs and I can tell you that it doesn't.
SPEAKER_02Intercept anything. So he called for partners to be a bit more effective and so did the Ombudsman for Human Rights, Mitro Lubinets, who also said that so far the international response had been ineffective when it comes to Oleski. Now we've had a response from the European Union saying that indeed it was concerned and that indeed it was trying to reach out You know, some kind of solution in which Oleski itself is humanitarian aid.
SPEAKER_02And in the meantime, we've seen an answer from the Ukrainian army. So, of course, it's also a communication operation to see that they are not abandoning Ukrainian compatriots on the front line. They've announced that they've dropped four tons of humanitarian aid on the city in several locations. But there's several, you know, interrogations as to Whether food has been indeed delivered to people, and also reports by the army itself that in fact the occupying troops,
SPEAKER_02the illegally occupying troops of Russia in Uleski had seized those parcels, that they were keeping the parcels for themselves, they were destroying them, they were reselling them, and also they were arresting people who had managed, residents who had managed to put their hands on their parcels and Yeah.
SPEAKER_00And I wanted to ask you, you live in Kiev and you mentioned that, you know, you're living under bombs and those have increased during to the daytime in recent weeks. So I just wanted to ask how you and your friends have been holding up.
SPEAKER_02So, funnily, you know, your standards to answer these questions, they lower every day when you're in Ukraine. For example, earlier I was texting a friend and she was asking the same question. I said, how are you? And I just told her, well, you know, I'm alive. And that's already a win. It very much feels like we are in a huge game of cat and mouse with Russia trying to You know, terrorize people in the capital, really demoralize people in Kyiv.
SPEAKER_02There's 3 million people. There's a lot of people who are considering, you know, trying to spend some time outside, but also outside of Kyiv doesn't feel safe because the region is also bombed. There's a lot of people who really are hoping for interceptor means to reach the Ukrainian air defense. We've seen the past I think a few hours, the past few days, that there's been some interceptions, especially of jet-powered drones, the ones that are, you know, doing quite a lot of damage. But the past few weeks have been really horrific,
SPEAKER_02to be honest, also with a lot of destruction on civilian infrastructure, on, you know, food warehouses with, again, you know, the fear of lacking food at any point, which is not the case right now, even if you can see some empty shelves in supermarkets, but there's that fear. That the situation might worsen. Of course, there's been strikes on pharmaceutical warehouses. So there's a fear that there will not be enough medicine for people who have treatments to follow. Yesterday, we've seen the Academy of Sciences being destroyed with people dying there.
SPEAKER_02So a strike against civilians, a strike against knowledge as well, a strike against the hospital yesterday as well. So it's a reality that just doesn't feel... Well, thanks so much for your reporting, and everybody should read and subscribe to your sub-stack. It's called A View from Ukraine, and a link will be available in the post. So thank you again.
SPEAKER_01Thank you. Thanks for your interest in Ukraine and talk to you soon.
Hi subscribers, I recorded a short video reacting to the U.S. midterms, where Democrats won control of the House and Senate in a landslide. In the run-up to the elections, U.S. President Donald Trump waged an...
Hi Subscribers, Earlier today, I spoke with Mark Goldberg at Global Dispatches about Donald Trump’s pivot towards Russia and the throttling of Elon Musk’s Starshield inside Ukraine. You can watch the episode above,...
How did Hitler dismantle Germany’s democratic government in less than eight weeks? Historian Timothy Ryback offers some answers. He is the author of a new book, 53 Days: How Hitler Dismantled a Democracy. Ryback, who...
Since Russia launched its full-scale invasion of Ukraine in 2022, it has been globally isolated by international sanctions, and Russian leader Vladimir Putin has had his travel severely curtailed by an arrest warrant...
Elon Musk, Mark Zuckerberg, and Jared Kushner are household names in the United States. Journalist and author Casey Michel describes them as part of a new oligarchy in the United States, aligned with President Donald...