This week we're getting moooooody - moodboards, that is! First we talk David's new iOS app Archiv, which lets you photograph and catalogue what's around you. Then we wade into the thorny world of design inspiration, copying, and downright plagiarism, vague posting without credit, and the blurry line between inspiration and theft. We tackle wether moodboards are lazy shortcuts, explore why learning through mimicking great work actually teaches you something real, trace David’s design awakening to his discovery of the Bauhaus, and ask: how much of design is just remixing culture anyway? We talk about having our own work ripped off, the commercial stakes of credit, and how to know when copying crosses from homage to wholesale theft. David McGillivray is a designer and creative director in upstate New York, designing for early stage tech companies through his own practice. He also co-founded Offhours and runs Corners, an art and design store in the Catskills. Jacob Heftmann is a Los Angeles-based surfer and graphic designer. He is currently the Design Director at Grilli Type. Previously he was on the faculty at Parsons and founded XXIX and Index in New York City. Artwork by Pablo Delcan Music by Mondo Boys Artwork typeface; GT Standard Mono by Grilli Type www.worksbutmakesnoises.com
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
DavidYou are listening to What But Make Noises. Jacob. Hey man.
JacobWe're back.
DavidWe're back.
JacobI'm riding the high of our last episode. I loved it. I thought our guest was great.
DavidEste, yeah. Yeah, she was great. If you haven't listened to that one, uh, listeners, you should. She's great.
JacobLeft feeling more calm after that. Which I can't tell about most experiences.
DavidJust in just most experiences in life. Yeah. Or most pop podcast experiences.
JacobIn my limited podcast experience, I actually feel pretty good after this, but she was uh see of calm. Yeah, she was. She was.
DavidYou're just used to me and my chaotic chaotic uh end of week energy. Um what's what's going on, man? How's your week been?
JacobIt's been pretty good, pretty typical. We did a little um Apple store run yesterday to pick up a new laptop for Gabrielle, so that was a wow experience, yeah.
DavidNice. Yeah. Um what would she go with?
JacobShe got a little 15-inch MacBook Air, nice little computer. Nice. They're good now. The air's the air's a yeah, nice. I'm envious of how light that thing is. We had a funny like which color is to choose, and then they're all basically like silver. You're like squinting, you're like, I guess that silver one.
DavidThat's so funny. I was I was saying, I know we we started last episode talking about Apple stuff. Um I was saying my sister bought one of the the MacBook Neos that comes in a bunch of colours, and um I was dying because the the text thread was like, she's like, What colour should I get? I'm like, you've got to get silver. It's like the classic Mac colour, it's timeless, it's timeless, works in all scenarios, professionally respected, you know, still looks nice.
DavidFast forward to her getting like the neon green one. No, well, no, but no, the funny part was she just she just texted back. I ordered the dark grey one, they call it indigo. And I was like, You mean the blue one? Hence it being called indigo. The clue, the clue's in the name. She's like, oh, it looked grey. I'm like, yes, but it's also literally called literally called indigo.
DavidYeah. But to be fair, it looks uh in person, it look it looks good, it doesn't look too blue. The only thing I don't like about that one is it has grey keys. There's just zero contrast. Um there's just zero contrast between the the shell colour and the keys. Not zero, but just like a bad level of contrast, you know? It's two grey keys. Two matching is the worst, yeah. Yeah, yeah, yeah.
JacobAnyway, anyway. Um we did that, mission accomplished. Um I don't know, caught up on some podcasts. Normal week. Normal, designing some websites. Yeah. How about you?
DavidWhat's going on over there? Um, I had to go in the city for a few days um for a couple things. Uh it was insanely hot, 95 degrees, just wild, unbearable. I saw that's pretty wild. Yeah, it was like we arrived on Sunday and it was like sun and and left on um Thursday, but yeah, Sunday to Wednesday was like heat warning, heat warning. It's just yeah, it was a lot. It was a lot. It's too much for May.
DavidUm it's too much for me. I'm not used to it. Upstate it's 10 degrees cooler consistently, which in the winter is rough, but in the summer it means you basically get perfect temperature. It like doesn't it get it gets occasionally gets a you know mid 80s, but you yeah, 95, all that concrete, oof. Um I I've recalibrated to upstate, so my system's uh it's not what it used to be, you know. It's not as robust anymore.
DavidCan't take those sharks. Can't can't. Can't walk walk walking places. I got the subway. I was like, dear god, what is this? Like what um anyway, yeah. So you know, it's it's always fun to have a little little um little uh trip to the city. But um other than that, you know what? I've been working on this week, which has been super fun. A new app I've been building. I got really into it. It's an iOS app. It's called Archive Without the E.
DavidActually, I was consulting your name, some names, actually, wasn't I? That's what I went with. Archive without the E. I was super helpful, right? I was like, I like all of them. Honestly, the ideal response. Normally I show Rebecca a list of things, she's like, I hate all of them. So it's honestly refreshing to good. You got your yin and your yang. Now you need someone with some natural like help forward, right? Um but it it's it's fun. It's so it started out, I had this idea, I don't know where it came from, but I was just thinking it'd be really cool to have like a digital rock collection.
DavidJust a little app on my phone, which just had a you know a collection of rocks that I I rocks that I'd seen out in the world, I've been walking, and we're like, that's a cool rock, took a picture, and maybe you know, the app would tell me like what type of rock it's from, like how old it could be, what area I don't know, something like that. Maybe give it a name, you know, and I just have a little collection of all the like Joe, like the rock Joe. The rock Joe?
JacobLike name, like name it. Yeah.
DavidOh, yeah. Like the app you could name it in. Yeah, I like that. I like that a lot. Ron, Fred, you know? Yeah, just like a bunch of guys.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, okay.
DavidRock band.
unknownSorry.
DavidAnyway, that's where the idea started. I was like, oh, that's fun. I should make that. Then I then I was like, it took me a few minutes, then I was like, oh, I guess I could capture other things that aren't rocks too, I guess. I was like, that could be a cool thing for nature. And then a few minutes later, again I'm slow, I was like, I guess it could be anything, it like anything anyone wants to collect. I was like, that's kind of fun, you know. And so that's essentially what it is. We you you you take a picture of something, it it doesn't actually just knock out the background, it re-renders the whole thing, cleans it up, changes the position of the the core object so you can see it a little bit more clearly, evens out the lighting, adds a little positional lighting effect.
DavidBasically, it re-renders it with the guidance of create a archival-like photograph of this object. Um, so it makes everything look really crisp, bumps the contrast a little bit and bumps the you know, sharpens it a little bit, makes objects look really like they've been shot in a photo studio, but they still look like the original, they just look like a cleaner, clearer, slightly better lit if it needs it. If you take a picture of a piece of art, it's on the wall and you're at a crazy angle, it m you know makes it flat on and clean and clear and straightens it.
DavidSame with books and things like that. I've been taking photos of everything. Yeah, it's cool. It it and then what it also does is it also identifies, adds a whole provenance sheet where where it was taken, time of day, what what the weather was like, you know, all that kind of stuff, the the neighbourhood, the street, and then it identifies what it is. And if it's a piece of art or a design object, I basically have the Google Google Lens API hooked up, and it it it identifies it and then writes about it, who the who the artist or designer was, the name of that particular thing.
DavidIt's cool. I've been I was walking around the city, I was taking pictures of like fire hydrants, like crazy New York City fire hydrants with all these graffiti stickers over. That's cool. Looks looks sick. The idea of that isolated in a you know in an archival style. It looks sick. Um super cool. And even just like technical, like there were weird kind of mechanical outlets on the side of these big buildings in Chelsea. I was taking pictures of, and it's just like, you know, um, like really high-end, like fire hydrant sprinkler, like mechanical setups on the side of these buildings, but it it tells you what it is and identifies it.
SPEAKER_02Oh, no, really. Wow, huh?
DavidThere's a really cool like 30-foot Buddha statue they put installed on the high line, and I was like, Well, that's crazy. Took a picture, tells you the artist is, tells you the the name of the art, all that kind of stuff. Yeah, it's it's it's been really fun playing with it, getting like getting it to figure that provenance out. I tried a few different things, and then yeah, Google Google Lens is the best for identifying things, but it like cross-references it all. It it looks like a really simple app, and it is, which is actually what makes it so fun.
DavidUm, but like it's actually quite technical. It makes like a whole capture docket where it it has weighted evidence around what it thinks the object is and provides them, you know, this like s puts the evidence forward for like the AI models to like judge what it thinks is most accurate and then write it all out. Yeah, it's kind of it's kind of cool, it's kind of fun. That's very cool. Have you stumped it? Uh at the moment it's pretty good. I haven't haven't I mean it doesn't go super technical, like it didn't tell me the manufacturer of the like the fire hydrants.
DavidThere were there was one I was pretty impressed by I did like a cone. There was a cone with a bunch of stuff, I don't know, like there was some kind of official sticker, and it identified the towing company whose stickers it was on the on the cone. I'm like, that's pretty well. But yeah, I mean you know, it can't get that crazy. Although I I mean this blew my mind. We were at this there's a fried chicken place in um in Manhattan, I guess it's like flat iron-ish area, Kokodac, amazing fried chicken, it's all gluten-free, but it just it's one of those places that happens to be gluten-free, but it it tastes amazing.
DavidAnd um, I was showing this dinner, I was showing a friend the app, and they were like, try it, do it now. I'm like, on what? They're like, on the chicken. I'm like, okay. So I towed up a bit of fried chicken, took a picture of it, it it re-rendered it beautifully, looked delicious. Does it take your hand out? It took my hand out, rendered it all perfectly, got all the details as it existed on the fried chicken, but made it beautifully lit, look super looked amazing. And it but it somehow managed to, off of images from a Reddit thread, it identified the restaurant we were in.
DavidOh wow, huh. And I was literally just holding it above a table and there was a bunch of blurry bowls and food in the background. I wouldn't, if you'd showed me that picture, I wouldn't have been able to tell you where it was from. And I'd been to that restaurant like five times. Um that kind of blew me away. And I shouldn't mind, I was like, wait, I knew the restaurant. And if I looked at the picture, they're like, what? How is that even so it has good days and bad days, but when it has good days, it feels it feels super magical. Do you know what I mean?
JacobYeah, yeah, I can imagine. Does it know to take out your hand, or does that some did you kind of brief it all in?
DavidLike square image, square art and remove hands and yeah, it's got a pretty comprehensive like specific prompt of how to render the images to get this specific kind of style. Which again, you look at it first glance, you might be like, oh, you're just knocking out the background. Then you but you can feel it just looks really good. But then you look again, you're like, wait, yeah, no, it looks it looks it's not just like one of these cheap knockground backout things.
DavidSo just all of the images have like a really nice quality to them.
JacobI love the origin story of the rock collection. I I'm a I'm a rock lover. Also, it'd be great if it was like really only for rocks, and it would like, no, that's not a rock, we're not gonna upload this.
SPEAKER_02Rocks only, please.
DavidUm I was yeah, I was showing a friend, he was like, Wait, you made the hot dog, not hot dog app from Silicon Valley. You would see that amazing, that's great. There's a the you know, the the guy makes the app and he's like demoing it. He's like, and it correctly identifies this. And he shows a hot dog and it's like hot dog, and and then and then he holds up something else, and you you think it's gonna identify the next object, instead it just says, not hot dog.
JacobThat's great. I forgot that. We're it we're at a perfect moment for that show to come back, I think.
DavidOh, dude, the absolute most perfect moment. It was so prof prophetic in with all the AI stuff as well. Yeah. You look now, it's like, wow, this is one still absolutely holds up comedically, and two ahead of its time, if anything, in terms of subject matter. I think we need it.
JacobYeah. Yeah. Okay, so when do I get the link to uh test this little little guy?
DavidYou know what? I got I mean, I mean, maybe today. I got I've got a slightly older version. I got test flight up and running. I gotta upload a new build. The bottleneck is just waiting for Apple to prove it, but they seem with test flights, they seem a little looser than the you know Facebook App Store stuff, so it should be pretty quick. But yeah, I'm gonna.
JacobLet me ask you, can I dig in a little bit further? I want to know um what's what's the uh model here? Are we going free? Oh.
DavidUm I mean this is just a test flight, so yeah. Uh right now, but you've submitted it, right? Uh it's a test flight. But I understand it's like yeah, yeah, yeah. No, no, no. I think because of what's involved in it, there like It's tricky. There are costs. I'm trying to make it as simple as possible. Like, so I think what I want to put out is a you can bring your own API key. Okay. Um have a security.
DavidBut there are other things there are there is another service, for example, like the Google Lens API, which is a separate thing, which is paid for, but that's a that's gonna be a terrible product experience. If I'm like, just sign up for your own Google Lens API key. So I'm gonna take that cost. I think I want to have it so that there is an experience you can have where you bring your own API key, but it's potentially a better experience if you just want to sign up for this account and pay X amount of money a month to the app.
DavidThat's a good idea. It'll it'll do it'll do everything, it will do it, it'll there'll be maybe a couple different tiers. Because also, like even processing the images, yeah. Um, in theory, there's a you know, yeah. Uh there's a cheaper version which does it in batches. If you're prepared to wait, you can do it in batches. But if you want it quicker, you know, there's there's all that kind of stuff. That's cool.
JacobI like that model of BY BYO API key or paid in terms of that's cool. Yeah, I like it.
DavidYeah, uh yeah, it makes sense. Um I think it's a nice way to start off, but I I I can see a lot of people just being like, when you compare it all, I can't, you know, if you if you if you just pay to cover cover the costs, all of it will be a bit of a better experience. You know, there are just other things that I can I can do. I can do better if you're able to if you're prepared to like cover the costs rather than like, well, you can do that, but you'll need you know four separate API keys and like four separate subscriptions to a very specific thing that you'll probably never use again, other than this weird like archival app so anyway.
DavidBut um I love it. Yeah, it's fun. I've shown it to a to a bunch of friends and everyone's like, wait, I need this. This is super fun. I want this. Like everyone has their own weird niche thing they want to use it for, you know. Is there gonna be a future feed view? Other people read quite yeah, yeah. I've I can yeah, I think it'll be super fun. Definitely want to do that. Not right now it's all local, which is one arrays I'm able to start off lean and and and you know, keep it simple. But I definitely I wanna I'm gonna add the ability for people to like publish their c their collections as websites, you know, so you can just press a button in the app and it'll have a standalone website of your collection.
DavidYou can share it. It'd be cool, like a gallery view of a collection.
JacobI could put my like raw collection on a little pedestal and it would yeah, yeah, yeah.
DavidExactly. Exactly.
JacobYeah, this isn't a video enabled podcast, so you'll just have to imagine the hand gestures that went along with that sound effect for for the listeners.
DavidDynamic hand swiping from Jacob. Um anyway, that's what I've been up to. Yeah, it's it's pretty fun. I'll um if if anyone listening wants the uh wants to get on the test flight, um feel free to feel free to DM me on uh DM me on Twitter. I think there's there are there are links in this in the show notes. But yeah, um we'd love to get some testers that'll plug. Yeah, that sounds fun.
JacobUh I got a great message from a friend this week. It was like, you know the worst part about all of this like homebrew software craze is all of the people asking you to test their apps. I got a good laugh out of that. I was like, it's so true. I've gotten so many of those. I'm like, by the way, do you want to test my app?
DavidOh man. Yeah, yeah. There's a lot of apps. What else is on your mind? Um, well, you know what? Yeah, I was saying I wanted to say I wanted to dig in dig in with you this week. Um something I've been seeing a lot of recently, which is interesting, is people posting people posting online, posting design online. Vague posting design online. So, you know, just being like super clean lines always make a difference, or like some like vague thing, and then posting one image of a design or a video of a design or a few images of of design, like shots of design, interface design, product, whatever.
DavidAnd then everyone's like, Well, this is great, and they're like, Thanks, dude, thanks, thanks. And then someone will be like, Hey, this is my work, what the hell are you doing? And I've seen I've seen a bunch of people just like on crusades calling out all these people, like, hey, this isn't yours, I know it's not, it's Sansa's, give credit or delete it, you know. And it's just this there's just this wave of people just vague posting design and just taking credit for it, which just seems like on so many levels, such a wild thing to do.
DavidThat is an insane behavior. It is insane behavior when I I struck my mind goes to who's the imagine being that person in the world. Imagine being like, I'm just gonna I'm gonna take this design. I'm like, more important than anything is that people think I'm a good designer, even if it means I'm getting credit for someone else's work and that I get more followers. Like, imagine that being so important that you you just sit there and you you you know, you ever think about that? Like sometimes when you're like, oh, that's crazy, that person got murdered, and then you you think through you're like logical leap.
DavidYou think through like the steps, imagine you think through the steps, you're like, wow, you know, this premeditated murder, they really had to be like, Yeah, I'm gonna get this poison and I'm gonna hide it in their drink. And I like there's so many steps involved in this nefarious act that you're just gonna be backed out. There's exactly there's so many places your mind could have been like, Wait, what am I doing? This is crazy, stop this, but it it's that kind of vibe, you know? But anyway, it got me on the thinking on the subject of like copying, plagiarism, mimicking, and it's such a like weird, interesting grey area in the world of design.
DavidSo, yeah, I think it's a fun one to to to dig in on. It's a it's a juicy one. I'll kick off where I'm more my mind's in where my mind went in with this, is because some things are black and white, right? Like that people doing that is is that's I would say unequivocally bad. You shouldn't take for credit for other people's work. That's just steal, that's literally stealing. The weird thing is that as they say, nothing is original, everything's been done before. And it and like most of design is um is to a large degree, you could argue, just synthesizing references or other things and like recombining them in new configurations, which is kind of weird as like a profession, right?
DavidI don't know.
JacobYeah. I blanked out for a moment because I just was thinking back to all these experiences I've had where like this is such a foreign idea to me that you would post someone else's work. I mean, also for me, just out of sheer like laziness, like I I don't like posting my own work. It feels very like tedious. Like, why would I bother posting someone else's work? But I've had this experience many times where where people have been like, oh, I saw that thing you posted. That's really cool. Did you work on it? And I'm like, wait, what?
JacobLike, I mean, I I I know that I'm guilty of not being great at social media. I post stuff. I don't give a lot of context, like if a project launches and I was involved in it or something, and I don't really like I'm not like a caption guy. I don't like write anything, I just like repost. Fine. Ultimate, ultimate vague, vague poster. Yeah, but but to me, it's never occurred to me that I would do that for something that I didn't make. So when people are like, oh, that was cool. Did you make that? I'm like, wait, what? Like what? I didn't know I needed to be explicit about the fact that I had made the thing that I posted on my thing, but I guess now I'm like, how naive am I?
JacobOr I don't know. But yeah, I just had a dawned on me.
DavidI don't know. In this age, you kind of do need to be explicit. I feel like just because no one reads anything, no one like I'm like, new work. Like Yeah, maybe so. Um lesson learned.
JacobYeah, that's funny.
DavidYeah. Um especially now. Yeah.
JacobYeah, I mean, true. I think it's getting harder and harder to figure out what, you know, authorship is like more more difficult to ascertain than ever, probably. So yeah, it's a good, it's a good I mean, dude, there's a lot there, obviously. I've thought about this plenty. I've had some weird experiences throughout the years. So I've had many moments to reflect on such matters. Yeah, it's interesting because I feel like we talked about this before.
DavidI mean, mood boards are mood boards the most widely accepted. I mean, I consider it in some ways a grey area, most widely accepted co-opting of other people's work in service of your own work, like most direct co-opting of someone else's work to create your work. You know, you're literally capturing other people's work. I've seen all sorts of mood boards. I spent most of my career having a certain perception of what mood boards were. Um, for a lot of the time, my perception was that they were more abstract, and I I I don't I've basically ne I don't create mood boards generally as a as a designer.
DavidUm, but then I've I mean I've seen in more recent years mood boards from agencies and things like that, and they're way more closer to we'll make work that looks like this. Yes. Um versus then they're not they're less mood boards, they're more design, precise design references. For me, mood boards, the word mood is key. It's like the general's tone, the general like vibe is like this snippet of like this one typeface I found, or like this colour, or this photo of this like rug I saw in a hotel lobby, you know, versus the like this logo, this brand, this thing, like very cohesive design snippets.
DavidYeah. Oh man. How does it make how's that how does that make you feel, Jacob? Is it in the room with you now?
JacobI'm trying to like regulate my response levels. This is a top. I mean I feel like anyone who knows me is like, oh god, don't get them started. No, no, no. I mean, we banned them in the studio because I just find it to be where like laziness meets uncreativity. I just, I'm like, I just find the references also to be so boring and obvious.
JacobI'm like, you you just opened Instagram. Like, I mean, I think part of it is like is the the format, is like, okay, we'll talk about the format. And then part of it is like what goes into a mood board. And I find like they're sort of separate discussions. Like, you call it a mood board, but you show me like, I'm really interested in black holes, and you teach me about black holes, and it's in the format of like what we'd consider a mood board. I'm like, I'm in. I don't care what you're I just tell me about black holes. I'm here to learn. If you show me like the same format, but a bunch of images that you found of other graphic design done in the past couple of years, I don't care.
JacobI'm checking out, you know? And so what a mood board is is obviously like pretty broad, but I find the general practice is basically like sort of an exercise in like laziness and not creativity, and just it's it's sad, you know. I I guess I feel like there's an infinite number of ways to combine images, type, space, did I say color, and like ideas? And I don't I just find it a bizarre starting point for someone who wants to be creative.
JacobI mean, I have like a whole other side of like, you know, this conversation about copying that's probably a lot more generous, you know, because I get I get the other angle on it too, but but mood board specifically, I think is like I think they're weak.
DavidYeah, it's interesting. I mean, I I my question to you is I'm gonna answer my own question to you and then let you answer my question. I you know, I think most designers that use mood boards would say, well, it's the quickest, most efficient way of getting client by in an alignment between the the design provider and the client on a direction without doing a bunch of design. It's like, well, we're gonna kind of go in this direction, or we're gonna kind of go in this direction, or this dire, you know, and the client can look at it and be like, yes, we like that direction.
DavidStraight away you have directional alignment without, you know, you've sourced images but you're not doing design. I've like I said, I've never done that in my design practice. I actually just I just do the smallest footprint, but smallest legible footprint that gives a visual indication of design route with original design. I will normally just do like depending on the project, I would often do like a home page hero and like here are like anywhere between two and five directions, depending on you know, it's all creative, I don't set a number of directions.
DavidUh, you know, I'm like, here are the different directions, and if and and in this little vignette, they can get a sense of how all these components might come together for this brand or you know, for this particular direction. And I've just always just done that, and then they pick they they they're like, okay, we like this, we like this, so we can we of course add this into this. And although there might be some burn burn through in the design that doesn't get used, um I find that I found that I never I kind of never been like none of these directions are right, you know, and I've never needed a mood board to get to that point, and then I've already got a starting point that I then build off of and flesh it out and and not or more often than not, a lot of the core stuff is like exactly right and exactly what they want.
DavidHow how have you historically gone around getting that alignment in an efficient efficient way, or just straight to design, or is there another another trick or step?
JacobYeah. I think that's an excellent question. I feel like that approach makes sense if you've made maybe a bunch of other previous decisions that force you into the position where you have to show like swipe. And I feel like if you start with aesthetics, you're never gonna get to a place where you have a substantive solution to a problem. And I feel like the mood board is like bypassing all of the work required to create substance and going to an aesthetic exercise.
JacobAnd I don't think good design or good ideas or problem solving is an aesthetic exercise. I think it's a conceptual exercise. So if you've gone through this whole conceptual exercise of solving the problem and explaining the problem and how to solve the problem and the parameters of the like problem space or solution space, the aesthetic outcome at the end almost is like inconsequential in a way, which I might sound like crazy for a designer to say, but I feel like if you've really defined like here's what we're solving, either the solution is so clear at the end that it like transcends aesthetics, kind of, and it's just correct, or it doesn't even matter actually what the treatment is because you've found something like much more important and true and everlasting.
JacobAnd then to just treat it as like, here's a mood board, it's just like window dressing. And I think it really devalues what design actually is and meant to do.
DavidThat makes sense. But I would argue you can there are there are infinite ways to solve um like the same problem, effectively. Like you could if you if you're if you're like, okay, we've gone through all this strategic work and we've reached a point where where, you know, here's the problem statement, here's here's gonna be our strategic approach to to solving that, and design is gonna be one of the tools that helps manifest that solution out into a into into the tangible world, right?
DavidAs a brand and a website and all these other touch points. The way that can manifest visually, say, say, say, say there's there's five five ingredients, and those, those are those are the things that have to be in this for this to make sense, and they have to fall in a certain way for it to solve correctly. There's still maybe like a thousand permutations of the way those things could be executed that are all in theory right, but we're all humans, and the people that are running that organization might still have certain preferences that are maybe more nuanced, more subtle, that then there might be certain directions where they hate this what the way the ingredients land in this way this direction, but love the way they land in this direction, but both technically solve the problem.
DavidDo you know what I mean?
JacobYeah. Yeah. I mean, I guess I'll just give you a maybe a more straightforward answer to your question, which is like I would just make the work myself. You know, and I would show three different ideas. I'm not like maybe they were more original or maybe they were less original. I'm not vouching that they were the first time anyone's ever done that solution, but I would definitely create it myself and I would show the work and I also learn how to. I think that really teaches you how to work quickly, how to show things of very high value and not get stuck in things of very low.
JacobI I see designers, one of the biggest things I see junior and mid-level designers do is waste their time on things that aren't important. And you can make a couple small quick moves that are extremely impactful. And I think that's a super good lesson to learn. And I did that through always having to do my own work to show sort of like, you know, here's the five worlds we're gonna explore. And I made all five of them. And sure, you throw four out, but also at the end of the day, it's like, I love to design things. This is what I want to do. And so I spent five, I spent my time doing five different directions from scratch.
JacobAnd like I think if your process can't support that, I don't think the answer is necessarily to like, oh, work faster, make mood boards. I think it's to maybe ask, like, how do I change my process to support a more creative practice? So that would be not a super short, but shorter answer.
DavidAnd then No, I mean, yeah, we have the same answer, basically. Yeah, I did this, I've done the same thing. I I I make I make my my version and and what it also I I know you have a second part to answer, which I want to hear. I was just gonna say, I think what it also, to your point, you g you focus on the most important things, and it's a it's a good practice to to get into as a as a designer, and you get fast and good at making things that communicate the most important information about that work, which I think is which I think is, yeah, as you say, uh it makes a ton of sense.
DavidAnd you also get to I I yeah, I think I I would imagine there's probably been more disappointment and misalignment created from mood boards in the history of mood boards versus the opposite in a lot of ways. That's always been my concern about mood boards as well, is like if you're showing a logo, it's like it's really hard. Then that logo is in the client's head. And that's someone else's logo, and that's a specific execution. I think if you're making it, you have full control over all of that nuance, and you have full control over everything that's being communicated, everything that's being shared.
DavidSo there's no miscommunication, there's no like, oh, but I liked that other thing. It's like, well, that other thing already exists, so we can't use that other thing because that's someone else's thing. Whereas if you're making it, you can ensure it's original, you can ensure it's well, original is a tricky word, but you can ensure it's you know made from scratch and it's ownable by your client. Um, that's like guaranteed when you do it yourself, right?
JacobYeah. Yeah, I've also been in some weird situations where like there have been mood boards floating around and there's sort of like the level that they set of like here's what we're aspiring to, and it happens to be like a 10-year-old brand that's invested millions of dollars in perfecting what you're looking at right now, and it's on this mood board, and then there's this immediate assumption of like, oh, we'll come out with something like that fully mature at the end of this six-week process, which is like it's setting up sort of a weird expectation that's really fairly unachievable.
JacobUm, you're kind of looking at the end result of a long process and maturation, whereas we're in maybe the first meeting where we've ever even like talked about this, right? So there's that disconnect. And I think there's also this funny like thing that's happening in that process where the person making the mood board is probably going to some references that they really love, and they're probably some like incredibly talented people and some incredibly successful projects, and they have, you know, and then there's like this immediate assumption, like there's this leap of like, I could just be Carol Martins all of a sudden because I've like referenced it, you know, and you're like, Yeah, yeah, no, you could copy Carol Martin's at best in the in the way that this process is set up, but you're not gonna just like leapfrog that to that level just because you've clipped the images, you know, like there's still the like you have to be skilled enough to execute what's been put forward, which I think is like it's a huge thing for a designer to actually like close the gap between your sort of like taste level and your actual like technical ability.
JacobIt's not just snapping your fingers. Yeah, yeah. So I think that also doesn't really get talked about. Is like at the end of the day, you'll still have to like execute that vision somehow. Even if it is derivative, it can also be very difficult to pull that off, you know? Totally, totally.
DavidYeah, and yeah, if you're sh if you're if you skip that mood board phase and just show your own work, you haven't you're not setting yourself up to fall short of those.
JacobI'll show I'll keep their expectations tempered by showing my own work. This is about the general world that you're gonna get.
DavidYeah, it's not it's not getting any better than this, buddy. This is it. This is the ceiling, this is as good as it gets. Yep, just to be clear. I just want to level with you. Yeah. Um, I think it's there's some truth in that for sure. It it's funny though. Because it's kind of a it's a funny practice, right? I just wonder if it's like if it's become acceptable because essentially in the in in a lot of ways the art of design, the practice of design, should I say, is is is like an is kind of this collaging at another level, right?
DavidWhat I was kind of touching on earlier. It is this essentially a synthesis of references, synthesis of different things that you are essentially trying to reconstitute into a composition which feels original is a crude distillation, but something that uh solves the problem, answers the answers the brief, also looks good, feels good, feels appropriate, and sits in the cultural landscape in an appropriate way.
DavidUm but it you know it's like mood boarding is like a it's a very literal collaging, and then the next step is is like slightly more abstracted version of that, but you're still you're still pulling pieces and references from everywhere. So I I I guess what I'm kind of trying to get at is I wonder if that's why mood boarding even exists, right? It's like we're gonna start at a high level where we're very literally pulling things from people, and then we're gonna kind of pull things from people but in a less visible way, you know, a less direct way, where maybe you can't you can't track where this reference is directly from, but like, you know, it's all kind of been done before, and you know, I'm pulling this from here and this from there, this from two years ago, this from 20 years ago, and and so forth.
JacobYeah. And I think that that's actually it an important aspect of graphic design in the sense that it operates through semiotics and messaging and expectation and things. And actually borrowing from culture is super important, is sometimes in making your message more clearly understood. You know, I think when we say like work needs to be creative, I guess that's sort of on the surface always taken to be true. But in reality, maybe it's not the most important aspect of a project.
JacobYou know, like I always ask clients at the beginning of projects, I don't do a lot of branding anymore, but I would ask what's more important, fitting in or standing out. Because in some industries or for some businesses, actually being seen as like part of a peer group or trustworthy or reputable or on par with, you know, like is more important than creating a distinct vision and borrowing from existing visual culture sometimes can be utilized as a tool to actually like establish that, not as a bad not as copying, but as like signaling, you know?
JacobFor yeah, yeah, for yeah.
DavidIntegrating into culture, using existing cultural cues to signal emotional reactions and responses that you're actively looking to create in your audience. Yeah, totally, totally. Yeah, it's funny, it makes me think like when I did my little stint at Parsons teaching, the thing one thing that really stood out to me was um how little it felt like the students really um were aware of contemporary the contemporary cultural landscape in a visual context, you know.
DavidThey would make things that were totally original, um, but I mean, one, sure, they're still honing their craft, so they the you know, the executional quality wasn't there, but they also just looked so alien. Um, you know, and and I would just I would say to people, okay, you have there's a brief here, there's something you're trying to achieve. Um, what you've made is original, but not in a good way, you know. It it has no cultural or emotional kind of touch points.
DavidYes, great work. Has no touch points, so so it's not resonating in any way with me and won't resonate with people because it is it's alien, it's this foreign thing, and it's not I I think you can only do that if you are truly a high artist in a very specific sense. Can you create something? I mean, creating something truly original is is almost impossible anyway. Um probably outside the bridge a lot of the time. Yeah, yeah. Um but so yeah, I just think that's it.
DavidIt made me think of that. It's it's interesting. It's just I would tell I would tell them, I was like, you need to look at more around you, you need to look at more design, you need to look at more visual things, you need to look at the world around you, you need to absorb it, you need to consciously observe it. And when you see something where where you think, oh, that feels really good, or oh, I like that made me feel this way. Observe how, why, what's the construction, what's the references. You know, yeah. Some students were using, you know, they they were designing something and and they would use colour and they were using black and red in a very specific way.
DavidI'm like, black and red has a very strong connotation. Yeah. And it it's not appropriate for what you've told me you're trying to achieve, you know. Yeah. Things like that. Yeah, it's it's so funny.
JacobYeah. I, you know, Bob Gill is my idol, and his design is really, it has a lot of humor in it. And I feel like good design works in the level of a joke where like the funniest jokes are ones where we're like, I've been in that situation. I recognize, you know, I get that, right? You know, and I feel like there needs to be that same like, oh yeah, I've seen, you know, that makes me think of this. Yeah. I underst I understand. I understand.
DavidAnd it's on a subconscious level, right? Totally. Yes. It has to be on the subconscious too. Yeah, it can't be, it can't be too overt. It's parallels with like product design here in terms of like, you know, UI UX precedent, you know, you suddenly, you know, there's a reason why there are certain paradigms which catch on and people start using them because they're good, they're intuitive, and and and they get enough, they get enough exposure that the broader audience has seen this before, understands it, and there you go. You know, you you leverage these paradigms, these UI paradigms, these software design paradigms.
Davidparadigms, um, where you can, because you know people are going to understand them, right?
JacobYeah. Yeah. Yeah. And I think part of that is also understanding like where you have room to be unique or creative or original and where you have where where's not like the time or place to experiment or even put your time or energy. It's not just not worth it. And I I mean I'm the worst at that. I'm like every single part of this every page of this website has to be weird. I've definitely done myself in with that one.
DavidNo, I I like that. I think it's a good point. I think that is where in contemporary design that is where the artful part is knowing where to b where and how to balance the um parts that are going to resonate or are understandable. Dare I say legible for want of a you know better VC favourite word right now where parts are going to be legible to the audience and where where they need to be legible and you shouldn't reinvent the wheel and where you where where there's room to to push it.
DavidI mean I I think largely that's the real craft and the way you in finding that balance um making something which feels fresh feels like oh I haven't haven't seen that done that in that way before but in this the way it's delivered I understand it and it makes sense and it works and it's usable and it does what it needs to do. Yeah. Which is hard.
JacobIt is yeah I used to really struggle with that like I'd have what I thought was like a good idea and it's like you only need to do it once but you feel like it's such a good idea you want to make sure that the audience gets it so you kind of keep doing it and then at that point you're like oh no no like too much take it back.
DavidYeah it's funny I mean when I was a design student I remember me and my kind of little cohort of of friends in our class that kind of you know were on the same wavelength we all kind of had the same feeling I think which was the work isn't good unless it's totally original which is so misguided but understandable looking back you know year one graphic design you know yeah yeah I remember you know there was someone in my class who I'd be working on certain and they'd at the time it felt maybe it was passive aggressive at the time it felt passive aggressive but also it felt intentionally malicious.
DavidBut I don't actually looking back I don't think it was at all you know they were c I remember them coming up to me um and they would do they would do it a lot but I really think they were just trying to engage and they would come up and say oh like that's really interesting you know what really reminds me of this and reference another piece of design and I'd be like great well fuck thanks for ruining it now I gotta start again you know which is so funny because that's just not how how any of it how any vineyard it works you know as we've yeah we've been breaking down but it just reminded me reminds me of that it was just I was just on such a quest to I thought being a true creative true designer meant designing yeah designing things no one had ever seen before which is just not not how it works.
DavidAnd I only found out just by just just through time.
JacobNo one ever sat me down was like hey you know that's not how any of this works yeah but but I do think it's good to retain a little bit of that feeling of like when I sit down to a new project I want to make it the best I can and part of that is like something that hasn't been done before. You know I think whether it's practical or achievable or appropriate or whatever is a separate sort of like conversation you need to have next but I think to start with like I really want to do something that's unique and my own I think is like a really valuable thing to retain in your practice.
DavidSo no 100% 100% um I think it also I think kind of this all kind of also spiders out for me around there there's there's a there's a license in design I think to borrow to reference to collage and I think it's interesting it feels like this operates at all these different levels. And like the most obvious one and the earliest one for me at least is kind of copying mimicking other existing design is is how I learn to design as a as a student as a design student.
DavidI I kind of try to make things that look competent until we learned about the Bauhaus one day in class and I was like holy shit this is this is this is it. This is beautiful this is design this is what good design looks like to me you know I I it just resonated with me so deeply and then then like 8 VO and just like you know all of the just that world of kind of Swiss Swiss and German you know um John Tischold that whole world of Germ German and Swiss graphic design grids typography all of that and then I was just like it was just such a come to Jesus moment I was like wow yeah I like hearing about the moment that yeah the light like the like I don't know that clicked for you or whatever.
JacobYeah that's cool.
DavidIt just it just felt it deep it just deeply resonated with my personality there's a there's a for me you know I'm a I'm a Virgo I'm an Enneogram type one there's a lot that's just very like clean pure there's a lot of truth you know I'm all about trying to find the truth and communicate in a very direct and truthful way. Like language is very important to me being very as precise as possible to kind of articulate what I'm trying to communicate you know and for me this just um personified all of those qualities and it just full body resonating with me.
DavidAnd knowing you I can see that it makes sense yeah and and I try to just incorporate it into my my work or I try to I try to make work that behaved like way and it starts and it it starts out very superficial right I'm using Helvetica. And but what but I think a really interesting thing happens as you start to mimic this work you learn how it's made you uh learn why it's made you learn how it operates you learn kind of it's like a reverse engineering that happens that through that process you end up learning a lot more about that you know that type of design that style design that approach to design and you kind of through you just you just learn the nuts and bolts of it and through doing that you also learn about what those pioneers of that design I think were trying to do as well simultaneously through that practice.
JacobYeah. I think the other thing that what you're saying made made me think about is like the same action sort of like um contextualized in a different way can have a totally different meaning. I guess what I'm saying is what I mean is if you're like I was really inspired by this and I wanted to explore further how this type of design works people would be like that's really interesting that's cool. Tell me more about that and if you try and hide that and you try and get away with it and the outcome's exactly the same but people are kind of on to it, they're like that's weird, right?
JacobYou know so I guess I guess if you're just kind of like owning your sources and like doing it as an homage or like I don't know not an homage maybe that's too literal or too close but like you know I think just like citing your sources basically is what I'm saying or giving credit is like a huge way to sort of acknowledge like yeah it's not totally original and that's why it's that's actually it's appropriate for this project or whatever. Here's why rather than like trying to do the sneaky weird thing and get away with it, then you're gonna get busted, right? So it's a little bit less about maybe the work outcome than sort of the intention you go in with if that makes sense, you know?
JacobTotally.
DavidNo, totally I I think it's in that's also an interesting topic as well because I think I feel like there's almost like a statute of limitations with references where if you're if you're if you're referencing some design that was done six 12 months ago you can't you you can't get away with it. It's like oh the rebrand that that that so and so just did six months ago you know but if you're referencing yeah the Bauhaus you know just for example if you're referencing something done 10 20 30 40 50 years ago that's almost seen as culture it's almost seen as a refined you know informed intelligent academic approach to design because you know your history you know your sources but yeah but there's a cut-off point and there's a blurry cut-off point where if it's totally too recent because if it at that point that all that stuff kind of just enters the canon and it's just you know yeah like you say public domain almost yeah which is I think it's kind of funny so you can think about that.
DavidIt's like visual infrastructure.
JacobYeah it's true.
DavidI also just feel like there's a bit more you know obviously depending on like how deep a cut you're going for but there's a little bit more it shows me that you're more maybe more curious or you worked a little harder to research, you spent more time digging you know like that's really interesting rather than like I don't you just opened Instagram is not like I'm not convinced, you know like I saw this like a gallery website or something or yeah I guess it signals if it's a more historical reference it signals rigor in your process in in in a sense as well as as well as a you know a whiff of like academia or academic approach.
JacobI could see the argument like oh you're more online you're more cultural aware but like I don't know that just doesn't really hit for me. I think I think like the subtext of this is also just like being really gracious about crediting people when credit is due. You know like we worked on a project that another studio who I really liked had had done the work first and I knew like the original work that we were going to like take and you know um expand into like other surfaces. And I emailed them and I was like hey you know I love your work I love what you've done we're gonna try and like stay really true to the spirit you've imbued already I'm gonna send you the work please give us feedback you know like and I was just really up front and we've credited them always with like the original concepting you know and I think that I my intention was just to acknowledge that like not all of it was ours.
JacobUm I've been on the other side of that and I've seen this a lot in like actually some of the more popular right now studios I see projects and I'm like this launched four years ago and looks very similar and it's called like a rebrand or a refresh and it's not that different and you didn't even acknowledge the original work, it's not a good look, you know? And I just think there's a basic level of respect due if you're going to refine other people's work for whatever reason because you know that's the client's brand or because you were inspired by it or whatever.
JacobI think you got to acknowledge it's not that hard.
DavidSo and I think I think one of the reasons why you know we kind of started this conversation talking about credits, right? Talking about not crediting I think one of the what one of the reasons why it's kind of loaded and i it does feel important, it has weight to it is because ultimately design is a commercial discipline right there's you know they all these are all kind of commercial activities that overlap and intertwine and so if you're not cr you're not crediting it's it's I mean you know morally obviously mm dubious and more than dubious but you know it there's there's there's hard repercussions to claiming credit to another person's design because it's it's work they were paid to do and it's work that they then that they use to get more work.
DavidI think interestingly that also kind of dovetails back into what we were just talking about around you know um you can get away with a more historical reference I think partly also why you can get away with that is because that work falls out of a commercially competitive space right um you know Jan T Shawd isn't gonna like send me an email like dude you use the same grid as me what the hell do you know I mean whereas like you know if you're ripping on work about the game 12 months ago like you know that's a that's potentially another per that's another professional commercial designer potentially somewhat competitive or operating in the same space as you um and and that's a that's a problem right yeah yeah yeah I mean that happened to me I I there's definitely situations where I've seen things that I felt were inspired and I don't really that doesn't bother me you know I'm like that's hard to prove visual cultures you know like whatever it might be it might not be but there have been many situations where because a brand launches and then hires or whatever the work was claimed by others and that's the only really situation of copying where I get like riled up you're not you're not bothered if you're not bothered if you see work that feels like super heavily influenced by by your work.
DavidLike too you know when you know it's a little too close to the bone.
JacobI mean I've defin there was there was a website that had even like our email link in it still you know because it was like not just copied but like duplicated.
DavidI mean that's the next level that's next level that's next level that's just that's that's that's almost a different thing.
JacobThat's almost a different thing yeah no I mean I think early early on I think it bothered me but I think it was a little bit more maybe related to my like personally only I'll only speak for myself but m related maybe to my insecurity of just like oh is this threatening my ability to get work or whatever you know and then once I got a little bit more confident further along in my career it's not bot you know I was kind of like I'm already on I did that a year ago. I'm on to the next thing you're copying what I used to do you know and it ceased to bother me you know so it was just like more of me growing I think than yeah I don't know had to let it go.
DavidYeah you gotta you know you gotta take it as a compliment I think um there are times easier said than done for sure yeah it is because it I think when it bugs me to be totally candid is the stuff that of mine that kind of gets ripped is the stuff where I'm like I really thought about that and I took I took an opinionated approach on doing a certain thing. Yeah or I work I worked to to take an approach which felt very fresh to me very original to me actually I I've not seen this thing done like this and that's the stuff that gets ripped.
DavidAnd so that's I mean I mean it makes sense that it is because other people are like oh I've not seen that done like that. That's cool. Maybe I'm just gonna do that. That's but it's it's a compliment but it's also like goddamn like now this person is just doing this thing and people that don't know the original reference or haven't seen my work you know they're just they're looking at this person's work and and being like oh that's a really cool way to do that. And honestly even I mean even if there's a credit it's like yes there's a even if there's some in some way a credit or an inspiration it's a little bit like well maybe you know you tweet out the credit credit once but you know that website's gonna live for multiple years and and and you've you've ripped off what my work and and I I don't know that's it's the game.
DavidIt's the game. I don't want to sound too bitter about it. But yeah definitely sometimes I I struggle a little bit where I'm just like goddamn well you know what I I really put effort in and and and made this something fresh and you've wholesale ripped it. Influence is a different thing. When you people wholesale rip I'm a little bit I'm a little bit more bitter about it to be totally honest. But to your point the healthiest attitude is well you know I'm gonna go on to the next thing ne the next thing and I'm gonna reinvent this now and you know what they say you know if someone if you're copying or you're looking to your competitors they're always going to be one you know you're always gonna be one step behind them, you know?
JacobYeah. Yeah. And just to be clear, that's what I aspire to but I definitely I mean I I think and I definitely have had situations more like what you're talking about where it feels like you know we were a small studio and that happened with studios that were much bigger and didn't really need to like steal you know steal from us. And and I was like you're getting paid probably much more you're getting very successful off of like the work that we had done and that feels bad because it feels unfair you know and I think it was a bit of like an eye-opener to for me in the sense of like I guess I can really empathize much more after those experiences with someone who feels like oh my work is getting ingested by this language model.
JacobYou know I think like it's if you're not if you haven't been in that situation it's hard to understand how like intellectual property is ownable and stealing it can be theft. But it really does feel invasive when something that you spent a lot of your time and energy making is taken for others to profit off of. And I think that's how I you know like I I definitely feel that I'm not immune to that no way that's very hurtful.
DavidYeah I totally totally have you I've I've had this many times like a surprising amount of times I've I've spoken to designers in my network in my world and they'll say you know maybe I'm meeting them for the first time and they'll be like oh hey you know I really like your work you know oh you know yeah we you your stuff ends up on our mood boards all the time and I'm like I know you mean that as a compliment but it makes I feel really weird about that like you know is this something you've experienced?
JacobI don't know I just find that a bit peculiar of a thing to say many, many times. You know and I don't want that to sound egotistical but I've had that experience so many times and I have the same thought I'm like I don't know if I don't know if I know you mean that in the best intentions but I don't know if that makes me feel good. You know I I had one very like distinct experience with that where it was that was sort of like the preface to the conversation and then there was like a studio tour that followed and there was a lot of oh we're working on a project and it's in the same space as this thing that you did that we really liked and then the work was posted on the walls like what they had been working on and I was like oh no oh no you can't do that oh my gosh that is what was very uncomfortable yeah yeah it happens but I don't know that one I feel like I'm like there's a lot of ways that this idea could die before it actually before I have to be stressed or worried about it.
JacobBefore I have to kill it. Yeah exactly we'll let the client do the dirty work first.
DavidHopefully it'll die in one of these other natural ways that designs get killed before I have to bring out the machete. Exactly yeah that's very funny. It's funny it's just such a yeah it is the more you think about it it's just it's all just a very murky world of like references in one way or another and like every part of design is is is some reference cut up, remixed reconstituted referenced in different ways, you know like you know and then we're we're making things that that are reconstitutions of other things that then you know this fresh reconstitution then gets referenced by someone else and put in a mood board and then reconstituted or it's yeah it's a funny it's a funny old profession is design it is yeah yeah it's tough to navigate you know I mean to me it all feels quite intuitive but yeah you kind of have to navigate it intuitively like this feels too close this feels this feels wrong and even just respond like responding to other people working with your work it's like at what point do I you know say something um what point do I not at what point is it just part of the game you know yeah um all right ma'am well yeah that was kind of a fun juicy one to sink into I think a lot of people are curious about navigating that yeah it's fun I could riff hopefully I don't get too it's a topic I get fired I mean oof I get fired up sometimes.
JacobLike oh I could tell I could tell I think the computer died because I was getting a little hot.
DavidAlright brother well thanks for listening all you have been listening to the one and only works but makes noises the original the um with original cover off from Pablo del Canal music by the one and only on the boys see y'all next time
Everyone creative person has been in the Valley, the miserable stretch in a project where nothing works. In this episode, we talk about some of the tricks we use to get to the other side: sleep, sneak attacks, talking...
Jacob’s back from Indonesia and Japan to find that David didn’t, in fact, burn the house down. We compare two very different product launches - Apple’s new HomeView and Tesla’s dream car (if you're a 12-year-old boy)....
This week, Jacob’s somewhere in rural Singapore (I think?), so David sits down with Nick Pattison, founder of Primary Studio, to trace his path from Pentagram and Milton Glaser’s studio to building a productized design...
This week, we talk about the lost art of *not* selling out, whether or not to turn an idea into a business (plus David's released the beta of his app Archiv), and the forgotten 95% that goes into releasing a product. We...
Recording from an NYC visit (David) and peak California beach season (Jacob), this week we dig into the design portfolio and how to present yourself effectively - whether you’re at the beginning of your career or...