Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Wine with Meg + Mel

Wine with Meg + Mel artwork

Why Is the Wine Industry Losing Good People? Women in Wine on Careers, AI and the Future of Wine

Sep 25, 20261 hr 30 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Send us Fan Mail Wine is a “sexy” industry right up until you see what the hours, expectations, and unspoken rules do to the people who make it. We’re joined by three powerhouse voices from very different corners of wine: Jess Clark from Dexter Wines with deep production experience, Imogen Gardner, Public Affairs Director at Treasury Wine Estates, and Jill Boyer from Adelaide University, teaching and shaping the next generation of wine professionals. We talk about the quiet talent drain: why a 50 50 split at the start of wine degrees can later turn into a sharp drop-off in leadership, and why people often leave without making a sound. From harvest and spray season workloads to the “martyr mentality”, we unpack what drives burnout and what actually helps retention: better planning, realistic rostering, clear communication, fair compensation, and workplace psychological safety. We also dig into the “sexy job tax” and how glamour can hide underpayment, overwork, and boundaries that get trampled. Then we go wide on the future of the Australian wine industry: GLP-1 drugs like Ozempic and Mounjaro, changing health trends, and why “drinking less but better” could be an opportunity rather than a threat. Imogen explains how nutritional labelling and kilojoules can build consumer trust, and we explore AI in wine, from vineyard sensing and forecasting to label compliance, plus the risk that AI erodes entry-level training if leaders aren’t intentional. We finish with the practical reality of pregnancy, parental leave, and returning to work in production roles, and why flexible work, cross-skilling, and job design keep knowledge in the business. If you care about sustainable wine careers, better workplace culture, and the long-term health of Australian viticulture and winemaking, hit subscribe, share this with a wine mate, and leave us a review. Follow us on instagram @winewithmegandmel and TikTok! @winewithmegmel

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_03Hi, and welcome to Wine with Meg and Mel. We are here to help you navigate the world of wine. I'm Mel Gilchrist, and today I am joined by three pretty amazing people in the industry. We were all part of a panel as part of the Women in Wine Symposium, which happened recently, and there was just so much knowledge and experience on this panel that I just wanted to keep some of the conversation rolling. I want you guys, our listeners, to be able to hear from them because they had some pretty interesting things to say and answer some of the questions that we didn't get to on the day.

SPEAKER_03So who we have today? We have Jess Clark, she's with Dexter Wines and has an extensive background in production. We have Imogen Gardner, she's with Treasury Wine Estates as Public Affairs Director, and Jill Boyer, so she's with Adelaide University, where she's teaching the next generation of our wine industry. So as you are going to hear, they have really broad and interesting backgrounds. They bring some really great dances on different issues and opportunities, and we're going to have some really in-depth chat.

SPEAKER_03So this is going to include issues in the wine industry, why are we losing good people and what can we do to make the industry attract the best people that we can? GLP1s and nutritional labelling. So, how can weight loss drugs and being made to put nutritional labels on products be a good or a bad thing for the industry? We talk about AI, what are the implications, what are the opportunities, and also parenthood, pregnancy, leave, and whether we should advocate for ourselves as women in the industry or whether it sets us back.

SPEAKER_03So there's a whole lot of content here. If you are interested in a particular topic, the chapter markers are going to be there so you can skip to whatever interests you most. But otherwise, I really hope you enjoy it. As always, we want to hear from you, so make sure you are messaging us. I have no doubt that there will be some sort of follow-up episode with Meg. And I want to I want to bring all your opinions to the table as well. So make sure you shoot us a message. Enjoy. Okay, so thank you so much for being here. Let's start with you, Jill.

SPEAKER_03Can you take me through a bit about yourself? Just reintroduce yourself because we're gonna have people listening as well who weren't there on the day. So take me through a bit about yourself and what you're passionate about in the industry.

SPEAKER_00Sure. Easy. I um I love this panel and I engineered the panel because it very much mirrors my own kind of personal path and my personal career, which is more like squiggly lines than straight ones. So I started in in Food and Wine publishing. I worked for a magazine called Food and Wine in New York for about six years. And as part of what I was doing at the magazine, I spent about half my time in Sonoma and Napa. So when it was time to leave New York, and when it was time to leave to head back to the West Coast, which is where I was from, I moved to Napa and I got on my hands and knees and I begged a wine maker for a vintage position.

SPEAKER_00I had no business working a vintage because I because I was very corporate, worked in an office my whole life, never had put a pair of boots on, and I still pestered him until he gave me a job. And then Ann absolutely fell head over heels with production. I thought it was the best thing I'd ever done. It was exciting, it was energizing, it was exhausting, it was science, it was art, it was conversation, it was everything that I had dreamed. And I worked for an amazing winemaker, his name's Gary Brookman, and he let me into so many more areas of the winery than I deserve to be in, now, knowing what I know now.

SPEAKER_00After that, I moved to Australia. I had planned to be here for about a year. I was gonna go back to the winery and work for Gary. And then life happened, and I ended up staying quite a bit longer. I've been here now about 20, 20, almost 25 years, and I wound myself through through kind of marketing and sales and bits and pieces of production along the way, and then returned to the master's at the University of Adelaide, which is now Adelaide University, and completed my master's and then ended up staying here at the university.

SPEAKER_00And so that's been since about 2014, 2015, and I have forged my way through academia and teaching and absolutely love the education component. So I have a kind of very diverse background and have been able to use just about everything that I ever worked in across education and now heading into research as well. So I I put this panel together to illustrate to everyone that there's no linear pathway, no matter which aspect of our wine community that you want to enter into, and that just about everything that you touch through your career will add to who we are as an industry.

SPEAKER_00So that's just um.

SPEAKER_03I know, I love it, and it's such a cool lens that you bring as well. We've just had Imogen join as well. Thank you so much, Imogen. We're just doing intros at this point, so it's a great time to join. We'll jump to you first, Jess. What do you want to just give an intro to yourself and what are you passionate about in the industry? Okay, I'll get to the question in a second.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, so I actually finished school and I did an engineering degree first. I wasn't very good at it, and then I didn't love it. And I worked for a while as an engineer, and again, I wasn't very good at it, and I didn't love it. And so I took some time off and did a harvest at Brown, what was Brown Brothers and is now Brown Family Wine Group, where all good wine breakers go to start their careers. And then and I loved it, I just loved it. I thought it was the best thing ever. And at the time Catherine Brown was there as well, and she said to me, Oh, if you like vintage, they do this in the northern hemisphere as well.

SPEAKER_02And I was like, Oh, do they? And she she was like, Yes, Jess, because like there's it's summer in the other half of the world, the other half of the year. And I was like, funny that like it just finally clicked it, and I was like, I think I want to go do that, anyways. Like long story short, I ended up doing that and going overseas and coming back, and I worked on the peninsula where I met my father-in-law, who I work for now, and then I went to Adelaide Uni and did a master's, which is where I met Jill.

SPEAKER_02Jill and I were in the same cohort together, which is just so coincidental and absolutely fantastic. We just had this cohort that was full of incredible people. We were we had this tiny cohort of only about seven people doing the masters, and they were all just the coolest people in the world. We were just so lucky. You get good years, you get bad years. We just happened to get a good one. And then I won a scholarship and went over to Germany, and then I and worked over there doing harvest, and then I worked as a similar for a heliskin company for a while, which was really fun because I didn't I could ski, but not really.

SPEAKER_02So I got to serve really nice wines to some very, very wealthy Americans. And then I ended up staying on and going to the US, staying on there, finishing my masters at UC Davis, which I loved, had such a good time, stayed on for another year to work over there, and then came back and started working at Tapanappa with Brian Crozer, who had really mentored me through the whole thing. And then during that time I went and did three harvests over in France, in the Rhone and Alsace, and then with my partner Tim at Dujac.

SPEAKER_02And then we moved to the O Valley together, and I did six years at Giant Steps, which was really fun. Had a couple of kiddies and then started working for Dexter for my father-in-law, which hilariously I'd met who I'd met in my second vintage at Stonia's. It's weird how things just come around. And then I recently started teaching at Melbourne University as well, doing the wine science course. As you'll said, not a non-linear path, but it seems to have all worked out one way or the other, even though at times it has been a little bit kerfuffled.

SPEAKER_03Yeah, no, awesome. Thanks, Jess. And oh my god, there's so much that I can't wait to talk to you about. Umogene, I'm so glad you were able to jump on because you're so interesting. Would you mind doing an intro? And what are you passionate about in mind?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, of course. Hi, everyone, thank you, and apologies for being a bit late. We were just saying goodbye to an industry stalwart, a chap here who basically set up the whole pinfold sales team back in 1979. And wow, we call him the mayor of Melbourne. There's not a person in this industry that this man doesn't know, or it's a bit of a cheeky lunch there, so thank you. I am Imogen, I am the director of public affairs for Treasury Wine Estate. So we deal in policy, government relations, any of the boring stuff, the legislation that no one wants to be involved in.

SPEAKER_01That's my bag. I started my career off in hospitality, working in restaurants, working my way up through supervisor to manager, and that's where I really found my love for wine. Ended up setting up a meeting with a local merchant and saying, I want to do this. What should I do? And he said, Go and do a vintage in Australia. So, quite the point that Jess just made in regards to, oh, there is a whole other summer, the other side when it's terrify thrashing down with rain over here, head on over and learn about wine.

SPEAKER_01I ended up uh working in two restaurants, both in Brisbane and Perth, under two incredible someliers and coning my skills there before deciding that Australia wasn't quite enough for me at that point, and I needed to go back and finish my degree. So I headed back, finished off a politics and international relations course, and then ended up in Westminster. So headed off and got my job as a parliamentary assistant to an MP at the time.

SPEAKER_01And as I said before, piggybacked off his wonderful career to get to the point of chief of staff to George Eustace when he was Secretary of State for Environment. So within that portfolio, we had all of the Brexit debacle, free trade agreements with Australia, debating policy with the Australian diplomats over wine legislation, over duty agreements and veterinary policy to antibiotics with piglets. So it's been a very specific.

SPEAKER_01Very specific, my gosh. And that was interesting trying when I headed across to Treasury Wine Estates and walked through the threshold of the Australian embassy. I wasn't sure if I was going to be shooed out of there, but they did eventually welcome me with um bigs. And then worked for Treasury within our London office, so heading up Amir with the policy head on. And then I was very fortunate to be across in Melbourne a couple of years ago. And as my boss was leaving, I had the opportunity to put my name forward for the global role.

SPEAKER_01And so started on this journey to head across to Australia. And Mal, I didn't tell you this on the panel the other day, but my sister and I, she's in New Zealand, she headed across and was helping me prep for the global job. And we were driving the Great Ocean Road in a camper van, of course, as the English people love to do. And we ended up just back to back binging all of your podcasts before my interview. Oh mainly, I have you and Meg to thank.

SPEAKER_01So oh my gosh, I just like it's so nice every time I hear someone like, but like someone like you as well. That's so nice. You've got to know everything in this role, but thank you very much. You definitely gave me a lot of insightful information into the industry at that point. Since that, I've just been heads into all of the happenings in the Australian wine industry, as well as the kind of global portfolio. So, of course, treasury with our main areas of production, obviously, China, America, France, Italy, and of course, our home country and most important country being Australia.

SPEAKER_01And that's been an incredible journey, amazing. It was an honor to be part of the conversation the other day with these incredible people on this panel as well, just to celebrate the wonderful field that the wine industry allows us to indulge ourselves in. And so I'm I wear my hat of the AGW board member as well. We've we do some really cool stuff as well as influencing some of the other areas in other regionals. We may have seen the announcement made by the Premier Melanaskus today with the South Australia update.

SPEAKER_01So 180 million wine package for the industry, which is fantastic. Yep. So big piece of work we've all been leaning into. It's just incredible to see that someone's listening. And yeah, that's awesome.

SPEAKER_03Oh, that's brilliant. And it's like there is such a range of expertise and background and experience here. A lot of these topics, and we have 20 questions, so I don't think we're even going to get through them all, but we're gonna try really hard. But on a panel, you only have a certain amount of time, and so one goes to one person or whatever. But I think just our range of what we have here is gonna be really interesting to bring to each of these. So it'd be really cool if we could all jump in. Jill, you had a really nice framing to the way that you said you see people at the start of their career, and it's 50-50 men and women.

SPEAKER_03And to to be clear, we probably had a a lens of women in wine, but I think everything that we have to discuss here goes well beyond that. But it starts off that you see these people coming through and learning about wine, and then what do you see happen?

SPEAKER_00That's a great way to start because we really I'm on the board of Australian Women in Wine as well, which I didn't happen to add in. What we're doing both in the symposium and into the future needs to benefit and lift all of industry and not just women. There were jobs that came up in industry, people would tap me on the shoulder and say, Hey, why aren't you applying for that? And I knew that they wouldn't hire me because I had young kids. I feel strongly about adapting how we think and how we work and our perspectives in production to make room for everyone.

SPEAKER_00So we just need to have conversations about how that can look and how it can work and how it's economically viable. I see these young women at the start of their careers in their early 20s, mean maybe 30s, and I just want to open up pathways for them. So that 17% into kind of leadership positions in winemaking and 13% in viticulture.

SPEAKER_03And so how many in terms of getting the degree, how many, what is the gender split of entering university degrees in wine?

SPEAKER_00It's roughly 50-50. And I see these incredibly bright, enthusiastic, passionate, curious, intelligent women. And I want to make sure that they have the skills and tools and that the industry is prepared to make a space for them.

SPEAKER_03And then there's also a wider thing beyond women, right, that we have just people generally dropping out of the industry because it feels too tough. Is that what you're saying?

SPEAKER_00Yeah, we see that. And I think one of the things I said was that that it's quiet. There's no noise when they leave and transition into other industries. Do so quietly. So you may not even kind of notice unless you actually stand up and look around. That's what I'd also like to change that that they feel that they have the kind of agency and voice that they feel strong enough to make some noise.

SPEAKER_03And Jess and Imogen, I'm gonna ask you separately because you're in such different parts of the industry. But Jess, let's start with you. What are the issues that you see from your side that might be causing people to want to leave the industry?

SPEAKER_02So the biggest one I see is ours, but if you just rewind a little bit, we probably just need to be really clear. Some people who start the master's or diploma at have no intention of doing production. Some people who do that degree are just like, I just wanted to come and learn about winemaking, but my intention is to go on to wine marketing. So when we use these percentages of graduating to ending up in the industry, what we're really focusing on is the fact that for some reason the male to female split ends up being incredibly jarred later on.

SPEAKER_02But in general, the thing that I see the most that drives people out, in and I've only been in the industry for sort of 14, 15 years. So again, I've my experience is very current and recent. So before anyone who counts hours jumps down my neck, just this is me and my truth. Yeah. But the thing I just really see is the hours. So I we didn't get to explain this on Tuesday, but when you start in production, and by production, I just want to define that as we when we say production, what we mean is either wine making in a winery cellar, or we're talking about being in a vineyard, and that could be like on foot or in a tractor or on a lawnmower or whatever.

SPEAKER_02But what we call production is the process from the growing, say in the vineyard to the making in the winery through to bottling. Anything beyond that is we wouldn't really refer to as production. And during the production season, there's two really key times that can traditionally elongate the hours of the day. In the vineyard, it's called the growing or spray season. So it's when it starts about now during the year when the for argument's sake, when the buds start to burst, the leaves start to come out, and the vine starts to grow in its foliage stage.

SPEAKER_02That goes through until they set their grapes, the grapes were raised, and then we tick. But during that time, before the nets go on, there's this whole period where the vineyard, the viticulturists and the vineyard team are in charge of basically how well that vineyard is going to produce grapes throughout the season. And everything they do is so important because it literally determines the harvest, which then determines how much wine you'll make, which then determines how much wine you can sell, which then determines how much money that business can make. So it all goes back to the vineyard, and they have this really small period of time, and unfortunately, there's a really tight period of time in December, Jan.

SPEAKER_02It always falls over Christmas, which is the suckiest thing ever.

SPEAKER_04Yeah.

SPEAKER_02Where they have to get certain sprays on and they have to get certain practices done. I can't, I don't want to get really geeky and go into fruit seeding and shoot feeding. And I don't know all the things I have to have, but I'll just tell you that's a really critical time in Australia, especially the last five years. We've had this insane period of over that time where we've had some very interesting rain events where vineyard teams have had to be out there spraying from sunrise to sunset to try and save the grapes so that we actually have a harvest so that they can actually sell wine.

SPEAKER_02So during that time, like a lot of friends in the vineyard, and they'll often be on a spray cart from sunrise to sunset. That because of a rain event or whatever, it sometimes means that has to happen on a weekend. It's over Christmas and New Year.

SPEAKER_03Suck. Oh yeah, that does suck. And the Northern Hemisphere figured it out a bit better, didn't they? Yeah.

SPEAKER_02Exactly. So it's just and a lot of people will argue it's just gotta be done and it's just that it's just the time the grapes can't grow themselves, can't spread themselves. That's my best impression of the great martyr that I always refer to. Yeah, cool. However, I got a lot of friends with really bad backs from sitting in tractors with shitty suspensions for hours and hours. As of when you're a female as well, let me just give you some really nasty facts. A lot of tractors are made for men, height-wise and body-wise.

SPEAKER_02As a female, when you're sitting in the tractor, you're not the same height, so you're sitting way forward like this. So you're back here. Oh my gosh, of course.

SPEAKER_03I've never thought about that.

SPEAKER_02They all have safety mechanisms where if your bum and your weight is not on the tractor doesn't move, which is a great safety mechanism. What if you weigh 55 kilos? Oh yeah. You're sitting like this to try and get your no one can see me because it's a podcast, but I'm just gonna tell you, you're trying to move your weight in such ways so that the tractor, the tractor thinks that you're there, the tractor thinks you're on it. Because if the tractor thinks your bum's not on the seat, it'll stop going. So there's just so many so again, that's just a sucky, that's rare, and there are lots of companies that then modify their tractors and accommodate that.

SPEAKER_02But I'm just saying there's a few things. This is a woman in my podcast. I'm just saying there's a few things that really negatively and the vineyard, there are just some gross parts of the vineyards. Whenever I'm in a vineyard, I always see that there's one portal toilet for an entire team of pickers and a team to use. Sometimes, if you're lucky, they'll have a sanitary bin. Often they don't. There's horror stories about people having to change sanitary items in the middle of a row, halfway down on picking day. And you're like, how could that be that? And whenever you tell that story, people say that can't possibly be true.

SPEAKER_02Happened to me last week. Okay, and like it's just quite it's just quite interesting. Anyway, I'm I don't want to I don't want to go on a whinge mission because I just think that's it's really, as I say, it's not gonna be it's really unhelpful. But anyway, back to the question. I just find people say, Oh, the vineyard, the vineyard's tough. Yeah, cool, it's tough. But I see the hours really driving people out of it. There's quite a few people recently that have left fit of culture who are such hyper-intelligent, fantastic people, really innovative, and could have used those brains, those brains, those amazing brains, and all that knowledge they have, working towards better fit of culture in Australia, especially with these really tough growing seasons.

SPEAKER_02It's only getting tougher and tougher. But because of the hours, the lack of respect for their boundaries and time, they left. Regardless of whether they have a family or not, they left. And it sucks because Spin Sin's catching up to them. They're like, Oh, I love having Christmas and New Year's with my family. I love being able to have the summer. And I'm like, oh, it just sucks that you left because of that and that you're seeing such a better balance of life now. Because what if their experience had been more staffing, more tractors, maybe some backup support from a contractor like the PBC or one of those?

SPEAKER_02What if their experience had been fantastic organization and then financial compensation and leaf compensation to make them feel valued and like their time was worth it? And yes, they had to work hard, but it was okay because their time was worth it. As soon as, in all cases, I find as soon as someone's time or expectation of time and compensation are out of balance, that's and they're not people that don't feel valued. And as soon as someone doesn't feel valued, they're out. So I'm never one to say those hours, the total of hours can't be and shouldn't be done, because that's incorrect.

SPEAKER_02There are certain things that have to be done in this business in production to get grapes and get wine into a bottle at the end. However, how we do it and how we get there in terms of staffing, rostering, organization, time off so that employees in the end feel valued and compensated will really change the outcome of someone's feeling at the end of a growing season. And if they're in that growing season feeling valued, hot tip is signing up for the next one. So if they don't, yeah.

SPEAKER_03I think you just listed a few things like more people and more tractors and maybe more compensation and stuff like this. From the reality, and maybe from a lens of a small business, because I know that maybe bigness, bigger businesses and bigger corporates are gonna have an easier time making that happen. From uh the perspective of a small business and from uh really thinking about logistics and reality point of view, how easy do you think that is in practice?

SPEAKER_02Yeah, so obviously for smaller business, it is a little bit harder, as in there's literally less people in the business. Yeah, fun. But there are some fantastic examples. It's really interesting. Just because you're small, it doesn't mean I would say this, just because you're a small business, it doesn't mean you have to do every single thing. Yeah. So small businesses, you don't necessarily have to employ extra full-time people. You just need to plan really well and call on those people when you need to for a day or two days or three days. This is crazy. But like, do you need to be doing okay?

SPEAKER_02Here's an example. Do you need to be doing the books every Monday, especially during harvest, or can we farm that out to an accountant just for that harvest period? I think about queerly down the road from us, they do I think it's 20 SKUs, but they do quite a bit. They keep to a 40-hour week, there's three of them. If they can do it, we could all do it. Small businesses are really difficult. And I just want to say that from the outside because dollar redues in are literally into the family's business account. If they're not going in, they're not there. Dollary dues out are normally literally coming from a family account.

SPEAKER_02I need to acknowledge small family business, it's really difficult. But with planning and forethink, like forward thinking, there are certain things you can take out along the way that you don't need to do. So I'm not saying that doesn't need to be done. I'm just saying you don't have to do it all. And it's the same small business or bigness business in wineries. We see the same thing. We see these really elongated hours of 14, 16 hours a day. And you could be doing that for three to four weeks straight, which is awful.

SPEAKER_02And I'm pretty sure illegal. And we've seen people burn out at the end. I just can't tell you how many times I see the winemaker get the flu at the end of harvest.

SPEAKER_03Or they all get all sick at the end. But there's a weird patting yourself on the back about it as well, though, right?

SPEAKER_02It is such an Australian thing. Yeah. Everyone's like, I worked this many hours, and they're expecting a pat on the back. And like, as I said on Tuesday, when somebody came to me and was like, I've done 70 hours this week, but I used to be like, Wow, you are so dedicated to your business, you must be amazing at what you do. And now, having worked in the industry for a while, I hear people say that I'm like, Oh my god, you must be the most unorganized micromanager in the world. You sound awful.

SPEAKER_03I think that's definitely from your side, the hours and stuff are absolutely crazier. And there's so much more I want to get into on that because once you start folding in motherhood and all these other things, it's but it's just such a beast.

SPEAKER_02But yeah, I think it's a really this sounds awful. And I it's I almost don't want to say this, but I think it's a really dirty side of the wine industry that people don't realize, yeah, especially if you're in the office end, that yeah, the hours I don't think it's well understood. No, I'm not sure it's totally understood that the hours of production can get this out of hand and that it really affects people's lives. But I and I need to put a few caveats there that it's not every winery, it's not every business. There is no way treasury lets me.

SPEAKER_04Yeah, we should be clear about that. But there's a little clear thing.

SPEAKER_02I need to be exceptionally clear. I'm only talking from my personal experience and only talking from the experience of friends who have left the wine industry due to hours.

SPEAKER_00Can I come around and because one of the things that we were going to do was follow up on the questions that we didn't get to. It runs this thread. And I think it I think it works both for you, Jess, from lived experience and image, and perhaps from a policy perspective and maybe how it's handled at Treasury. But one of the questions that and is it okay if I run forward this, Mel, is how do we best address appropriate compensation for overtime hours for full-time staff who obviously don't receive any overtime pay, especially if they're working for one of those wine makers who still retains that martyr mentality and expects to care everyone to be there with him or her, especially if we hope to retain people for an extensive long-term career.

SPEAKER_00Essentially, if you're a junior level employee and you're working with someone who wants to work those 12, 14, 16-hour days for an extended period of time, and then you're not compensating that permanent employee because you're just expecting they're going to be with you there for the passion of it, and they're giving up times with family and friends or themselves to try and meet your expectations. What are your thoughts there?

SPEAKER_00And how do we address that?

SPEAKER_02Can I just do a quick explainer? So for anyone listening that is like, what do you mean? How could your casual be paid more than your winemaker? That doesn't make sense. So for anyone listening that just doesn't quite understand that, so this isn't unique to the wine industry, this is in other industries as well. You have a full-time team that works throughout the year. Often that'll be a couple in the winery and a couple in the vineyard, and then you're full-time as well that work throughout the year. You take a full-time salary, which is however much a year.

SPEAKER_02In your contract, there'll be something written about reasonable overtime. And that's to take into account a wine dinner on a Wednesday, or maybe you have to do wine club on a Saturday, or as we talked about earlier, it's spray season and the best time to do it, the only time you can get access to a tractor happens to be on a Saturday. And so you don't get paid time and a half for your Saturday time, or you don't get paid overtime if you have to if you're working at nighttime or anything like that as a permanent employee. If you were a casual, like working in cellar door, if you're a casual working vintage or in the in the winery or the vineyard, you're normally on an hourly wage.

SPEAKER_02And then as soon as you go over your look, I don't know how much it is, you'd have to look at for spare work. But let's say as soon as you go over your eight hours, you go into time and a half, I think it is. And then as soon as you go over that, you go into double time. If you're on a Saturday, it's time and a half. If you're on a Sunday, it's double time. And that's for any sort of casuals, like whether you're picking or whatever. That's why not many people pick on a Sunday. So what Jill was talking about is at the end of a week, you can often, like you're adding it all up, and at the end of the week, the paycheck for a casual that's working harvest can often be larger than the permanent staff.

SPEAKER_02A casual seller hand who's been hired just for harvest, can their paycheck might be higher than the full-time seller hand because the full-time seller hand's on the wage and the casual seller hand is on hourly but has gone over time. Does that make sense? So you can see how that's happened. So Jill's question is for the permanent seller hand who feels like they've been a bit stinged here, like how is Joe Blow, who just rocked in and is only here for six weeks on a higher weekly wage than me when I've been here for four years and I've been training and I'm doing all the stuff and I'm managing him, but how is how are they being paid more than me?

SPEAKER_02I can see again.

SPEAKER_03How does that because I've seen that managed is people who are in those type jobs get like six-week annual leave instead of four? Is that the kind of thing you've seen, or are there other approaches? Or is it or do they just lose out?

SPEAKER_02Yeah, that's Jill's question is basically well, not Jill's question, someone who submitted it to Jill, is how do you manage that so that again you don't end up with staff that are aggrieved at the end and then they leave? Maybe they're saying something, maybe they just leave, which would suck.

SPEAKER_00And perhaps they don't have the agency, perhaps they don't have the agency to say to the the senior winemaker, the head winemaker, this is not equitable, this is not, this is not fair. And I'm I'm losing out here on on pay for passion. Yeah, and because a few things we're in a cost of living crisis and people need the money in their pocket.

SPEAKER_02Yeah. So there's a few things I would say there. The first one would be you should always obviously and I'm gonna it's it's obvious what I'm gonna say, you shouldn't get yourself trying to try not to get yourself into that situation. And I say that by with by planning starting correctly, you should try never to get into a situation where your overtime, your casual overtime is being paid more than your permanence. I however, and if you're interviewing for a role, a permanent role like that, one of the questions I would be asking is how do you manage your hours over harvest so that they're reasonable and equitable for everyone?

SPEAKER_02Because just remember, the thing we're trying to prevent at the end is someone feeling undervalued. If someone feels undervalued, they leave. So you just that's what we're trying to prevent. So prevention is always the best thing. If you can prevent yourself getting into that situation with staffing an organization, fantastic. If you ask correct in correct questions in the interview and you trust the person that you're working for, you won't get into that situation. However, there are times when you do, and this is when like a lot of people are gonna jump down my neck and say, Oh, but it's just times when you have things happen and the press breaks and blah, blah. Yeah, okay, I get it, I get it, I get it, I get it.

SPEAKER_02I worked 2016 as well. 2016 was an insane harvest where all the grapes had to come in basically two weeks because a series of a perfect storm of ripening and rain. And so I'll just tell you, like, as using 2016 as an example, everything had to be harvested really quickly. And it was obvious that was going to happen. So if I was in a leadership role and I ran into a situation like that where there was no getting around it, I can't madly hire stuff now with two days to go until I'm about to try and get 400 ton in the door in two weeks, it's not gonna happen.

SPEAKER_02You're not gonna be able to find that stuff. You've done everything you can, but the weather's just worked against you, and now you're here. So, what are you gonna do? There are some really key things, like key strings that I would pull on immediately, which is pulling stuff from other parts of the business, like seller door, like marketing. You can train them to wash floors and bins. They don't have to be on forklift, they don't have to be doing anything dangerous, they don't have to be making press cuts, but they could be delivering stuff and they could be washing bins and they could be doing stuff that's really you can train for.

SPEAKER_03Can you train quick enough when that happens? Or do you think businesses need to be organized enough to be training these people in advance so that no gal, can you use a garden hose?

SPEAKER_02Cool, you can wash a bin. So there's just a little thing. The other thing is you can sit down with those permanent staff. Say you have five or six of them, you can sit down and you can communicate really strongly. You can communicate the situation and be like, we are gonna run into this situation. There's nothing we can do. We've tried everything, but we're here now. What are we gonna do? Talk to them, see if they have ideas. My ideas would be look, it's gonna be really tough two weeks. This is what we're running in for, but we're gonna compensate you with extra leave at the end.

SPEAKER_02It's two wineries I know of in the Yarrow Valley that do this, where they're like, look, it's tough. It's gonna be this tough couple of weeks. We're giving you an extra week of leave. It's not coming out of your annual leave, you're just getting it, it's our gift to you. You're getting an extra week of leave. Love that. That's amazing because then it doesn't financially take away from the business as in you're not paying out more money. The other thing is looking at a hectic two weeks, you've probably budgeted for six to eight weeks of casual labor, like staff without. Now you're looking down the barrel of maybe only needing them for three or four.

SPEAKER_02So you might have a little bit of extra money laying around. I'd be saying to those casual staff, Imogen, you're on 1.0, I know, but for the next two weeks, you're on 1.2. Because it's going to be really difficult and I need you to do extra hours. Are you going to be okay with that extra 1.2? Or would you prefer the extra week of leave? You might even give it to them as an option.

SPEAKER_01Some people are really motivated. Especially with Australian holiday, definitely. I'll take the leave. Exactly.

SPEAKER_02Some people are really motivated by money, others are motivated by time, and it depends where you are in your life and what your values are and what you need at that time. But if you communicate the situation, and I think like in all back to what I said about preventing it, again, it's a communication issue. If you didn't ask the questions, if it wasn't communicated, if this is a surprise to you, you've got that you're in a situation. And as Jill said, sometimes you don't always feel like you can communicate those issues upwards.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, I was just gonna say that. Do you think you're talking about so emotionally intelligent leadership here who is planning ahead and thinking about it? When in reality, I think where people find themselves, it's just this expectation. You work here and you're lucky enough to work for me at my, you know, five winery, where you can go down the road and work for somebody and make lesser wine, but you work for me, so this is how it is. Take it or leave it.

SPEAKER_03Yeah, my friend has a theory that she calls it the sexy job tax. And she's like, entertainment. We heard about the screen industry who are like TV and stuff, entertainment. She used to work at VRC, they're like Vic Racing, and she said the amount of stuff like she had to go to every race day, she had to dress and match the members at every day and be in a hat. And not only was she compensated less than other industries, but that time and all those extra expenses weren't compensated. And the there's something like being in a cool industry, you get less.

SPEAKER_01But there's definitely something about that, I think, just to jump around. And again, it's very different because we talk about the office and then we talk about production, we talk about the vineyards as well. But even if I just put a political lens or even in the position I'm in now, like I'm never at home, especially since moving here. I'm never at home. I will count how many times I sleep in my own bed every month, and it's not that much. It's definitely not worth my rent. And it's incredible, but you've still got to be, you've still got to look the part, you've got to speak the part, you've got to turn up, you've got to be with certain parts of the industry, you've got to you've got to match the men, you've got to be there, you've got to be strong, and you've got to keep on going till 2 a.m.

SPEAKER_01in the morning sometimes. And that that's been through my political career. We learnt to drink and stand up till two in Westminster, and then it still plays a big part in here. And the sexy job tax is definitely something that I resonate with. I think that's a really powerful phrase, and you need to give your friend a pat on the back or at least a commission every time we use that now. Yeah.

SPEAKER_03And I think like we've been talking a lot about compensation and hours and stuff, but it must be deeper than that. And Imogen, I'm so interested to hear from you, particularly because there has been a couple of like significant registration registration resignations recently. Stuff like so it's not just people in production or people in winemaking. We've had the Australian Grape and Wine CEO resign after eight years. We've had their AWRI managing director step down.

SPEAKER_03His he was there for seven years. So is there anything that you're seeing through your lens of the industry as well that's contributing to people just not sticking around?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, really good question. And to Mark and Lee, we love you and we wish you all the best on your next adventures. There are two chaps who have given their all to the industry. And I don't want to speak on either of their behalfs, but they carry a massive weight. The leader of an industry association, you've got a membership that is full of all different categories and makeup of the wine industry. You've got to split yourself across all of those different categories, and you've got to meet each other and show that there's worth in that membership.

SPEAKER_01And you go towards, you look at Canberra and you go in with cap in hand, saying the industry. I know we've said we don't want to keep saying the industry is in an area of strife, but there are pockets of the industry that are doing really well, and there are other pockets that are in dire need of support. And so you go to Canberra and you shuffle the tin and you say, look, this is effective policy that could support transition. For example, I've noted the Premier Melanaskis' announcements this morning, and the they've signed off on concessional loans.

SPEAKER_01And what that does is that provides a bit of grace and a bit of dignity for people who are in huge amounts of debt or who feel trapped and they've got no way to exit or transition to a different to a different farming practice. People like Lee and Markin is right with AWRI, they carry a lot of weight on their shoulders. And I think the solutions, we haven't always been concise enough about what the industry does need to help solve this crisis.

SPEAKER_01We look at what happened with the trading conflicts a couple of years before. I'll be diplomatic about this part. And you looked at a sudden market that was just entirely closed off overnight and what that meant, and where that was the responsibilities of the government at the time and of diplomatic relations, but what that impact had on the current state has been tremendous. And we as an industry haven't recovered from that point.

SPEAKER_01And when you go through such insane, intricate, challenging moments like that, it takes something out of you. And I think when you don't have the solutions, or necessarily when your tank is empty, to excuse the pun, then it's time for you to crack on up to the next one and bring a bit more energy in. So I think we're coming to a position where we know how to solve some of the issues, also how to deal with some of the small issues, like the CCA post, for example, massive environmental concern.

SPEAKER_01And it's just needing a little bit of government intervention and engagement on that front to say, look, here's the infrastructure for waste disposals to do this safely, and it not to cost you a dollar per square meter, which could be huge potentially on someone who necessarily isn't afloat with their finances at this point in time. And these people have been working so hard to get these kind of policies enacted, and sometimes you win and sometimes you don't, but those losses are huge, and I think that's why they're they've had their time.

SPEAKER_03It feels like this is becoming this so this is South Australian specific, what came out today, is it? Yeah. So it's only in one state, and it feels late. We've been in strife for a really long time. Do you have any insight in why governments aren't helping?

SPEAKER_01Yeah. There's a general assumption that it is a private business, that it is not a that we are a commodity as a wine industry. And the question is whether or not it is the government's responsibility to intervene in private business in such a way. But you then compare that with its look at SA specifically, it's the fifth largest export that you have globally. Australia is known as this whole huge market and it's renowned for its wine.

SPEAKER_01You look at every single free trade agreement in the world that Australia puts forward, there's a bottle of insert round Australian wine on the table on the negotiation standpoint. We always joke about it, it's diplomacy in a glass because it opens doors, and it is the sexy element to part of it I spoke of earlier about. Veterinary practices. Definitely when you're talking about pharmaceuticals, it's a lot sexier to talk about wine and those kinds of concerns. So there's this balance between the two.

SPEAKER_01The problem is there probably has been parts of the industry who didn't want to wake up and see that the market was shifting and haven't kept up to measure with the consumption levels. And of course, you just look at the heritage and the relationship that we have with wine in this country, and you have such an amazing sense of history, skill that goes into it.

SPEAKER_01It's so difficult to then say, what I've been doing for years may not be working anymore, and I don't know what else to move to. And potentially there isn't the financial backbone within your own balance, uh bank balance in order to make that transition. It's the generational side of it, I think is so challenging, which is why with wine it's so much more than just shifting categories. But yeah, Imagine is really interesting what you say.

SPEAKER_02It is really hard to say we might have got it wrong and we need to change. It's that's really difficult. That is a really as an individual, as a company, and as a as a government, it's suicidal to say we got it wrong and we need to change. That's a really difficult thing to do.

SPEAKER_00Particularly in an industry that works on such long time frames. Exactly. You're looking at growth, you know, years and years of time frames in order to change production. So it doesn't shift on a dime. Now, arguably, what happened in the past with trade was was very abrupt. So it didn't really, there was no lead time to shift there. But consumer habits and changing of habits, that has been a slow burn. That didn't happen overnight the way the other things have. So, but it's just very hard to react quickly in this industry when you know the uncomfortable truth is the biggest danger of businesses.

SPEAKER_00That's the way we've always done it. Because you're not looking at innovation, you're not looking at change, you're not looking, you're not looking at other things around you and what's encroaching on your space. And, you know, look at the if you look at the different drinks that are rapidly entering the market from people who are very flexible in what they can do and put out, there's you know, those challenges, and we are up against all of those things all of the time.

SPEAKER_01Look at the baseline point of just different formats, and you're competing against that. We're still stuck with a 750 mil double thick, heavy bottle that we're handing around, and we've made amazing strides in terms of the the tetra packs, and you look at what we're sending to the Nordic markets, it's a completely different proposition. And yet you're competing with the RTD market or different wine brands which have entered with a 187mm proposition that you can slide straight into your handbag, and that's very different.

SPEAKER_01But again, that that's this question of are we gonna stick doing what we've always done, or can we move the times? And that's it's a real quandary. And some people have the skills to do it and some people don't.

SPEAKER_03It's the passion, it's so much passion in wine, and it's like when Cabernet started going out of favor and people started drinking more Pinot, so many people just didn't want to believe it and kept growing Cabernet and said, but Cabernet is really good, but it's the best, but Cabernet is so good, and now we have so much Cabernet.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, drink more Pinot, people.

SPEAKER_03Okay, okay, let's look at something totally different. Let's go left field because I would have loved to talk about this one on the day, but it's so different. We lightly touched on GLP ones and health trends. Where do we see wine in the next two years with a focus on health and sugars and how do we maintain our consumers? So, GLP ones are things like the weight kind of regulators like Ozempic or Monjaro and stuff that have become really big in the last few years. And what's been interesting to see is the restaurant industry has had to respond really quickly because what it means is people are eating less, and especially in America and stuff, where this is much more established, a lot more people are on it, places like LA apparently, the restaurant scene has completely changed.

SPEAKER_03And something that I don't think is spoken about enough is that it changes people's habits with wine as well. About half of people who are on it report that they drink less, that they might have one glass instead of three. So it also has the opportunity to impact what's happening. Imogen, I'm actually really interested. Is there something on your radar?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, absolutely. We do quite a lot of work with the Portman Group, which is a regulatory body in the UK that I'm a council member of. And then, of course, just the kind of academic research papers that we work with, IARD and ABA on this front as well, just out of interest. GLP ones, it's as you say, it's had a huge impact on the whole of the food and drinks industry, and it will continue to do so. I think it's one of those things that wave the kind of the calm down flag that I don't think we're getting away with it because I think what it actually does is it just supports this idea that we are generally drinking less, but we're drinking better.

SPEAKER_01And from a responsible consumption lens, I think it's so much better that we're actually saying, okay, so I'm really gonna slow down, I'm gonna enjoy a couple of glasses of wine rather than just smash it back. And of course, it's not just wine, it's the way that people are taking cocktails or they're drinking fizzy drinks or the rest of it. It does just change that mentality around it. The evidence itself doesn't necessarily suggest that it's such a huge impact, but it does suggest that, of course, just when it's taken with increased exercise and awareness, which I think is what drives a lot of the change, as well as just the jabs, it will of course have an overall effect when the world is going that way.

SPEAKER_01What I find really interesting though is that in certain studies, I think it was a study in 2025 where like a randomized trial of 48 different adults who had high levels of alcohol harm, actually they used it then as the GLP1s as an injection to then reduce their addiction. So you're seeing it being used in forms of alcohol recovery treatment as well as drug treatment recovery, which look if that helps helps with impulsivity.

SPEAKER_01Impulsivity, so it impacts that kind of the pleasure cortex as well, and it's fantastic. So, in terms of that, if we can utilize it and it drives better behaviour, less high harm, risky levels of drinking, which just to clarify are on the down and the decline anyway, yeah, then I think it's a wonderful thing. So we're not facing extinction by the injection pen. If anything, it's we're just facing another force pushing consumption towards less better and more intentional, and that can only be a better thing.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, also I've got friends who have been on the jabbo's and they're still having a cheeky couple of glasses of wine and having a great time. So anecdotal as opposed to academic, but that's what matters. You just call them the Jabos, El Jabbo is what I call them. Yes, that is so funny. The Jabbo.

SPEAKER_00That is exactly what we say, the jabs as well.

SPEAKER_03You've been in Australia for long enough, I think. If you're starting to call it a jabbo. You're a true Australia.

SPEAKER_02It's such a it's a great take image, imagery, and I really didn't know about I didn't know that they were using GLP1s to help recovery and addiction. It's quite interesting because I feel like everyone loves a whinge. Everyone loves a whinge about export, everyone loves the whinge about the growing season, everyone loves a whinge about apparently the Gen Zs are drinking, aren't drinking very much. As we've recently discovered, massive study came out incorrect, and now people are jabbing, the jabbo's are coming, and you know, now we're gonna drink less.

SPEAKER_02Everyone loves a whinge. It's so interesting because I saw it as actu maybe this is just because I'm born with an optimistic hat. I saw it as an opportunity, as in drink less crap. Eat less, yeah, crap. Yeah, being more intentional. And I'm obviously being entirely selfish and self-serving when I say this as a premium Chardonnay and Pinot Bob producer, but eat better and drink my Chardonnay with it.

SPEAKER_02Stop drinking the five dollar crap, stop eating the absolute crap two-minute noodles because my Chardonnay doesn't go with them. Go and get some go and get some good food. Exactly, exactly. And when people are freaking out about the kilojoules being printed on the label, like guys, oh my god, Imogen, was that a fight?

SPEAKER_03Did you fight that?

SPEAKER_02Oh really? Okay, Imogen's nodding for anyone who can't see it. She's nodding as if she does, but it's for interesting. Again, I see it as an opportunity because I would love for a consumer to stop talking to me about how much sugar and calories there are in wine. I'd love to be able to print it on the bottle, and so somebody can know how many calories there are in a glass of wine. And then when they go to McDonald's, look how much how many calories there are in a small chips, and you'll very quickly do the math and know that they should be drinking half a bottle of my wine and not eating the small chips from McDonald's.

SPEAKER_02I would can you explain what this is? What are we talking about?

SPEAKER_01There has been imposed by Fasan's, so Food and Standards, Australia and New Zealand, um, piece of legislation that was introduced, which basically requires the kilojoules on every label of an alcoholic beverage. Initially, conversations were happening globally, so from a global standpoint. So, of course, you've got the World Wine Trade Group, you've got for sans, you've got the OIV, you've got IARD, you've got every other thrower stakeholder nonsense in there having these conversations going, this is too much, this is atrocious, just as what happened with the kilajoules that you've got on a menu with food in restaurants.

SPEAKER_01And then actually, there was a real conversation that developed from it. So, initial kind of standpoint going, oh, you're taking up the real estate on the label, you're putting it on with insert the other kind of label, you're taking away the romance of wine. And realistically, we were like, this is a great way for transparency for the consumer to understand exactly what is on the label, putting in their bodies, what the level of consumption is. So it goes along with the units, with the ABV, and then what your calorie consumption is.

SPEAKER_01So we actually, as Treasury Wine Estates, made a bold commitment in 2023 that everything by 2025, excluding a 175 milliliter bottle, would have kilojoules on there in markets where it was illegal to do so. Just to clarify, in some global markets, it's actually illegal to put anything on an alcoholic bottle because then you were making a health claim. Let's just do it, let's set the standard. And then, of course, that happens in different governments around the world now where they're doing it.

SPEAKER_01But Jess, I agree. Just to stop you from being bothered all the time about it, but also in the end, it's individual responsibility. You can be engaged, you can understand, you can be educated, you can look at it and go, I'm gonna make that choice. Just to say someone sent me a meme the other day, and a uh glass of was 99 calories and the chips were 137, and she was like, I know which one I'm gonna have. And I have to say I agree.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, exactly. And I just again, it's a chance for education of consumers. It's by the way, whenever someone argues about it takes up too much space on the label, it's like a one centimeter QR code. It's so small, like when you're especially when you're exporting to the UK or somewhere like that, and it's an opt-in. You are asking your customers for consent to opt in to the ingredients and the kilojoules and everything else involved in that bottle of wine. It's also a massive opportunity for education because you can put all those things on and you can put you can do the QR code and the kilojoules and the ingredients.

SPEAKER_02You can also link to some other things like your website. Yeah, there is a chance to wage a game, exactly. Like it's true.

SPEAKER_03I think a lot of people think that wine is worse or at least more colorific than it is. Yeah, it's I'm not necessarily viewing it as the worst thing either. I personally, as a marketer, I'm a little bit annoyed about the less space because that with the full nutritional label does give me less words, but I'm not annoyed enough to cry about it.

SPEAKER_02I just but it's also not just you, it's not one particular we're all in the same boat, everyone.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. Change change is going to be constant. We are going to be, we're gonna be, we're gonna be facing change all the time. And it's the approach that we take and the perspective that we take and the mindset to it. So this change is happening. We accept it, we accept that there's also opportunities in it, that there's education, and then we implement it and move on and yep, not not not drop down to the whinge level.

SPEAKER_03I love that point. It's when you fall down the stairs drunk, you don't get hurt because you're all floppy and you don't resist it.

SPEAKER_01Exactly.

SPEAKER_03I do not condone being drunk and handling stairs.

SPEAKER_00So again, I'm gonna agree with Jess wholeheartedly that and Imogen that we just we take the kind of optimistic approach and we say, where are the opportunities in this? So it's again, it's change happens. Change is coming because that is gonna be a constant, and it's the mindset and our approach towards it that dictates our response. And then those to the people that we want to engage with and buy our wine. Awesome.

SPEAKER_03We don't have too much time left, but there's two more questions I want to get to. So let's try and get through them. Are you kidding? Out of 40 questions, we got to four. I know, but it's been such a good discussion. I decided to let's go quality over quantity. But it's two more I want to get to, and they're so different. So, first let's go talk about AI and then let's finish up with support for new mums and particularly interested just in how that works when you're lack in production. But AI, we did get a couple of questions with AI. One of them is like, how's it being applied in the industry?

SPEAKER_03Is it a good thing basically? Do we like AI? And then the other question came from such a different perspective, and it was like, how do we stop AI from taking over? How do we keep jobs? I don't know. Someone jump in whoever wants to answer first. Like, how are you viewing AI? Do you think the industry is it? Yeah, maybe Jill, actually, we start with you. That's because what are you teaching? Are you starting to teach AI?

SPEAKER_00We teach I the way that we're approaching what I'm approaching AI in the minute in education is that it's it's gonna be, it's absolutely 100% going to be a constant in my future, right? And it's just gonna get better and better. So how I design assessment in what I teach has to be more personal, has to be smarter. I think there's so many opportunities to upskill. And I, in my 50s, have written four or five apps now, two of which, one of which I use for teaching, one of which I've is now industry-facing to help connect.

SPEAKER_00I've just skilled up and used available resources, and there are so, so many that we can use. The way I talk to students about it is that music and videos and reels, they are that are a big part of their lives. They can recognize AI in those, right? So they can see through the noise, AI reels, and they look quite sloppy, they look quite generic. I think that we will never lose the personal aspect.

SPEAKER_00And I actually think there is a push away from, and I think you see it in even big brands like Nike, people are moving to other brands that fill voids that have a personal, feel like a more personal connection. And I think that only again is an opportunity that we build on those personal connections and who we are, who's behind the wine, who's making it. And and then people will gravitate towards that because we will see through the AI noise to what is real.

SPEAKER_00Jess, Imujum, what's your take?

SPEAKER_01I think it's AI is going to be an absolute revolution for the industry, certainly from a from a from a larger business perspective, what we're dealing with now in Treasury. It's using it as well for the industry for checking to actually see what's in ground from a satellite, drone, sensor data element, identifying water stress in certain areas, disease, canopy variation, and then you look at then our supply chain, you can streamline and really precisely attack disruption planning, demand forecasting, and then even just engaging with the consumer.

SPEAKER_01You've got more tailored recommendations that come through, customer service support in the right space. That's not really one of my favorite ones, I think. But you're seeing all of these kind of progress that's actually happening, and it could be fantastic, and it's helping certain areas of the industry already. But I take your point, Jill. I think with everything in AI, we've got to take it almost with a grain of salt. Dear King Charles is currently hosting a AI summit at the moment in Balmoral in Scotland, with some of the keenest minds to discuss the concerns in AI.

SPEAKER_01And I think we've just got to be aware that we still cast our eye across it, but it's such a tool that we can use to harness everything from our day-to-day in this industry. We've got to embrace it.

SPEAKER_03That's like the cutest thing ever. I can imagine him being the kind of person that can't even figure out how to turn on a phone.

SPEAKER_01He's so cool. I'm I know that sounds like I'm just saying, he's amazing. He was one of the four, the forefront climate change voices. Started speaking about it very early on to his detriment when he was discounted. So this is I love that he's jumped on the bandwagon of AI and is actually he's got the power to call some of the most important people in the world into his castle to have a conversation about it.

SPEAKER_03Wow. Yes. Do you yeah?

SPEAKER_02I I'm really keen to hear Mel from a marketing point of view. Because I think if someone's worried about AI taking their job, they're probably in that marketing sphere. Because AI isn't taking my job unless they it suddenly develops a tongue, brain cells, and the ability to communicate what a wine tastes like into work. I'm I'm not terribly worried about that. And AI, in terms of taking jobs for us, it's taking a lot of real crappy jobs I don't want to do.

SPEAKER_02So, as an example, which Imogen just touched on, I can walk every row of that vineyard if I want to. It's gonna take me a very long time. And by the way, what I'm about to say is I don't have the ability to do this. But if I won the lottery tomorrow, I could go out and get a drone that would map the vineyard, would figure out, take photos, take a bazillion photos, find out where the dead or red leaves are, map the vineyard, tell me where there's potential disease and water stretch. That program that those photos could go into a program that could then write me an irrigation and fertigation program within rows, within drippers, if necessary, to tell me what to spray when, how.

SPEAKER_02So that's an example of it taking something that I don't want to do. I just want to be really clear. Dexterwise does not have a drone or the ability to do that. We didn't win the lottery yesterday. But that's an example of it doing another example. Is like when I went to giant steps, we did a lot of export and we had so many back labels. And it would take us days to check every single back label for the UK, for Denmark, but again, could all those labels be uploaded into a little AI program? And then could every Wine Australia export guide be uploaded into the same program?

SPEAKER_02And could the AI tool check my labels against the guidelines and rules? As Imogen said, you never trust it completely. You still use your own eyeballs and your own brain, but could it flag the things that would take me a large amount of time? Or in the winery, you can see you can put into programs like grapes in dates, all historical data, and it can map out where it thinks you're gonna have sort of bottlenecks in terms of tonnages into tanks.

SPEAKER_03So you can't see jobs being lost in production, you can only see efficiencies to be made, which can help with this whole I don't I don't want to say that because don't come at me with the bots, but I don't want to say I'm not saying job losses anyway.

SPEAKER_02And I'm not saying no, I'm just saying I think it could be used for certain efficiencies to do some jobs that we really don't want to do anymore.

SPEAKER_00So I mean it absolutely can. And the thing is it's it so it shifts. So it it just like every innovation that we have experienced in the past in our lifetimes, from calculators to computers, there was always there's always a subset of voices and noise that are raising alarm bells that we're gonna lose a part of our humanity as a part of that. So we're not gonna be able to. Absolutely. You can look at calculators, oh, no one's ever to do mental math anymore.

SPEAKER_00We are always going to be in a state of And that's kind of part of the human condition and the uncomfortable aspects of that change.

SPEAKER_03I think that to what you said, Jess, about where there is potential for job loss, I can see some really clear potential. And that is grads and interns. That is the main thing I think about because when I know my first job's out of uni and I know all my internships, I did first drafts for people. I did a lot of first drafts. And what does my first drafts now? AI cannot do my job for me 100% not. And I'm still definitely a better writer than it. I'm still more strategic than it, Phil, but it can do my first drafts, which is all the stuff that I did straight out of uni.

SPEAKER_03And I think that, I think we just might see less companies giving that kind of first step in that more creative space. How do young people get that first step if there's less entry-level positions?

SPEAKER_01I totally agree with you on that front. And I think that's a key part in all of the conversations that are happening globally. And something that I've certainly seen within kind of entry roles within my team as well, is you've got you can utilize AI and you can bang out a briefing and you can talk about this, that, and the other, and rundown of a piece of legislation you've got to send off to the the chief exec's office, and this is what the understanding is. But you still have to be able to train your AI, your agents, all of them that you use, you still need the skills and the critical thinking and the analysis in order to train it to do it on your behalf anyway.

SPEAKER_01And I think that's the part and parcel that we lose along the way with this conversation of AI. I think it still takes the time and the energy for you to sit down and train it to do exactly how you want and to analyze, like we would do. And that's my fear. It's that little pocket from your point, Mel, where you're saying you don't get that baseline training or the shame of writing a speech and getting it wrong and going back and doing a third or fourth or fifth draft because you're missing out on those learning abilities.

SPEAKER_01So I think it's not a snowball effect, but it is shifting and it's moving quite quickly. And we've just got to be aware. And I think there are elements that within business, and we've talked, we've spoken so much about mentorship and shadowing when we're at the symposium on Tuesday about bringing the youth and bringing the younger generation along for the ride and letting them show the amazing work that we get to do further down career paths. And that's a key point. We've got a responsibility as business leaders, as mentors, as grafters, to make sure that you still give those opportunities and you don't just cut straight from the bottom.

SPEAKER_03All right.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, that gives me the heebjeeb is what you just said, Mel, that which is I'm sorry, I'm this sounds so silly, like how naive of me. But that you just said the drafters and the idea generation is what goes. Because does that make us this is way by the way, too meta for the this podcast. But does that make us less creative as an industry and a society and a world? Yes.

SPEAKER_02If we're no longer having to create wild and crazy and sometimes admirable ideas to yet to sell our wine if AI is coming up with the ideas and the first draft competitive, if everyone gets less creative to be competitive in the industry, you need to learn how to outsmart AI.

SPEAKER_03So it's I don't know, humanity could go to a cool place. We'll see.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, maybe we become more creative because it isn't a great generation.

SPEAKER_03I want to move away from it though, because we have one last thing and I want to get it in before we have to finish up here. So I want to direct it mainly to you, Jess, because I know and I think that like from a corporate type perspective, I work in an office and so it's probably not going to be too different from other offices. I don't think the wine industry, people who work in like marketing or something, find too much difference when it comes to pregnancy and parenthood. I think my in fact, because I work for a corporate, I think I've had compared to other people I've spoken to, a much better experience.

SPEAKER_03I've had a lot of flexibility. I've had maternity leave offered and all these things. But flexibility and all the things that are offered don't necessarily work. You can't work from home. You I'm I had this vision before when you were talking about the there's only one toilet. And I was like, what if someone had to pump? Where would someone pump in a vineyard? So can you just talk about what you've seen and what you think needs to happen in terms of pregnancy and parenthood in production?

SPEAKER_02Yeah, this is a really interesting one. It's one that's really changed as well in the last, even in the last five years. If you're asking me who's had kids in the last five years in production, it would be my experience, I imagine, would be incredibly different to someone who had children in production even 10 years ago. And there are some companies out there that are doing the most amazing work with women returning to work. I'm just, I'm on the Moin Peninsula, obviously, and Stonias has got this incredible system where they've got their viticulturist and their vineyard team and their female, and they're all returning to work with a bit because they've all had kitties.

SPEAKER_02And I love that, and I love seeing the practicality of it. But there's no denying if you work in production, it is quite physical. There's already going to be a conflict there between physicality of production and having children. So there's just there's you can already see there's gonna be friction, it's how you remove those frictions, right? There's always also this friction that obviously there's alcohol in our industry, and pregnancy and alcohol create another friction. So there's a few things there. In terms, five years ago, when I was thinking about having kitties and I talked to my friends who are the same age, they will all said the same thing, which is you must go work for Treasury or Endeavour or Perno or one of those, because the big guys always look after you.

SPEAKER_02Because they have policies and they have things around this, and I'm sure Image can talk about I'm sure, I don't know, but I'm sure Treasury has a very set out this is maternity, this is paternity leave. We don't even call it maternity leave, but what we call paternity leave. This is what we don't even call them mums and dads, we call them primary and secondary carers. And our government, thank you, Albo has done some absolutely amazing things between my first and second second pregnancy. Maternity leave and cover completely change. They've just recently introduced super payments, which I didn't get with my kiddos, but fantastic to everyone else going forward, they're gonna get super.

SPEAKER_02I see our government changing as well, and I think that's gonna change a lot of what our industry does as well, as In Majin can talk to. It starts from the top, and you start from legislation, you work your way back down into privatized industries, and that's how it's always worked traditionally. So I can only talk from my experience. I had two kitties while I was working in production, and there is the physicality did become hard, like walking up and down catwalks and lifting and all that sort of stuff. And I went into it was a very naive thing that I was like, I'll be back in the city.

SPEAKER_02Catwalks are those things in the air. Sorry, by the way, the physicality was hard, but I just really changed my role and I deliberately took on a lot of admin stuff towards the end. I had a lovely 2RC, and we just we did this thing called, yeah, what Gail had a web for cross-skilling and and we trained each other up. So I took a lot of their uh admin, a lot of their rostering, a lot of the labels, a lot of the export, a lot of the reading, and they could run back the tartaric up to the catwalk. So we cross-skilled so that also then when I stepped out, he was able to take a lot of that load.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, and if I needed to work, if I could, and then I could take a lot of on the tool on the seat stuff and he could do a lot of on the tool stuff. So there is ways to manage it, and we just did it that way, and we were very practical about it. Um in terms of when you return, you legally you get a year, and the government says that a job people have to keep your job for a year. Yeah. And when you return to the exact the wording is you return to the exact role that you left. If for some reason you cannot do that role, the company has to offer you something alternative.

SPEAKER_02But that alternative role you may or may not like.

SPEAKER_03But the alternate role should be at the same seniority level and at the same pace, shouldn't it?

SPEAKER_02Yeah, it's all lined out on fair work, it's very clear and very specific. But it can be in a different department, it can be the problem being like your priorities change in that time. And so that doesn't matter if you're male or female, if the priorities change in that time. And so you may not want to return. Even if you could, you might not want to return full time. And then you've just got to assess your priorities. I think as a company though, and this this kind of goes back to again when we were talking about the hours and satisfaction versus compensations and being valued, you want to retain your staff and the knowledge that they have.

SPEAKER_02A lot of these people that will go on paternity leave have worked for you for a long time, and the knowledge that they have acquired during that time, they know about row four that has the dodgy dripper, they know about the password to the Y in Australia account for the marketing doesn't always work. And then nobody knows that. The knowledge they have, you want to keep them as long as you can. Do you know how much it costs to rehire someone? Oh just to just just you know, someone earning, just as a ballpark figure, someone earning 100 grand a year to rehire is$14,000 just to rehire.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, as in that, and that's a stat that's online, it's$14,000 to rehire someone just to do onboarding to train them up to do it. Is so expensive to rehire. So if you can keep someone as an employee, even if you keep them part-time, you're doing way better than having to rehire someone. Also, if you keep them, but you have to hire a second person to help them out, that per the original person can train the second person. So again, you're doing a cost saving in all these situations. What I the argument I always hear is, oh, but it's the cost. It's the cost of that person going on leave, it's the cost of that person giving them desk time rather than tools time.

SPEAKER_02It's the cost, it's the cost. You know what's really expensive? Losing someone and rehiring. That is the most expensive thing that can happen. And everyone is different, and your return to the work will look really different. The baseline problem I see is communication. You always need to have that open line of communication. It needs to be received as well. And you might need to adapt your business to accommodate that person. But at the end of the day, keeping that person is always better than having them leave because their hours couldn't be accommodated, or they didn't feel like they were being accommodated back into the business because for whatever reason.

SPEAKER_02But the other thing that I think is really key to talk about here is when we talk about taking leave, like paternity leave or something like that, leave doesn't always have to be for kidding's. There are a whole lot of other reasons people take leave. There are, and I really found this out on Tuesday, part of the networking part of the Australian the Women in Wine Symposium, which I really recommend everyone go to for the content and also for the networking, because having the really honest chats was fantastic. Because a lot of people said, I want to take leave because I'm feeling I'm having all these problems because of menopause.

SPEAKER_02And I was like, great, well, you should be able to take leave for that. Or someone else having a bit of a mental health crisis, they should be able to take leave for that. And or just crazy idea, but someone's done and just wants a break in their life. It's crazy where you have this weird 40 or 50 year career where you're just expected to work Monday to Friday for 50 years. Who's to say that person does not want six months off?

SPEAKER_04Cool.

SPEAKER_02They don't need to have a baby. It's it's I've got to be really careful what I say here because I'm gonna have a bunch of feminists jump down my neck, but having a baby is a terrific excuse to take a year off. I love it. I've done it twice and I've loved it because I got to have a whole year out where I didn't have to work in production, but I didn't have to work, and I didn't have to talk about why I don't. I really needed a break. I've been doing it for 15 years. It was a great time to take off, but you shouldn't have to have a baby to do that.

SPEAKER_02And I talked about in the symposium how Tim schedules into his calendar for the entire team.

SPEAKER_04Yeah.

SPEAKER_02This is when I have kinda three-year-old kinda footy clinic, this is when I have drop offs, this is when I have pickups, but someone else should also be able to schedule into the calendar. 3 p.m. Thursday, I've got therapy. 4 p.m. I've got the dentist, and I'm not working Friday because I've had a really rough week and I'm taking the time off, mental health day. But it should be able to be scheduled in as easily as pickup or drop-off for kids. I just want to be really careful and inclusive when we talk about leaves. Maternity leaves paternity leave, sorry, is really important.

SPEAKER_02And I think as always, we need to make people taking that leave and also returning from work really important. But that leave should be for any reason. And if you are being a really good leader and you are communicating that crazy word, you will know when people need leave and you should be supporting them. Because I see so many people leaving due to the hours, but I see so many people leaving because they're not being accommodated in their return.

SPEAKER_03Yeah.

SPEAKER_02So two problems there.

SPEAKER_03The menopause thing that you said, I actually got thinking the other day, and I'm going down a full path that I would love. I would actually love it if someone contradicted what I said, because I think that's a really valid point in the opposite. But I said the other day that I, with my pregnancy, with my first one, I just fought through it and I was throwing up in the bathroom three times a day, and I was so sick, and it wasn't very productive, it wasn't good for anyone. But in this one, I just spoke to my boss early.

SPEAKER_03We figured out shorter hours, we figured out flexibility, more work from home, and that kind of thing. And there's two schools of thought. And what I, from my perspective, that's good, and that's good to encourage, and that's good that people should be able to stand up for themselves and advocate for what they need, and particularly women in all these phases of life that we go through, like pregnancy and menopause and things that are really specific to us. But then I was thinking about why that doesn't happen in the first place, and I was like, because the generation of feminists before us probably fought really hard to be seen as no different from a man.

SPEAKER_03So I would actually love your thoughts on this. If we start putting up too much of a fuss and saying we need all these concessions for things like pregnancy and menopause and periods, are we undoing some of the work that was done?

SPEAKER_02No, women's problems are not women's problems. Women's problems are everyone's problems. Every single person. Whether you're male, female, or non-binary, don't identify. If you're a human, female problems are your problem. Straight up. And again, I want to be really clear when I was talking about taking leave, that it's men and women.

SPEAKER_03Yeah.

SPEAKER_02Men or people that don't identify as women have as have problems as well. Or no, sorry, problems, that's an awful word. I shouldn't say that. Have reasons that they would need to take leave. And they should be supported in taking that leave, no matter what the issue is. And again, it goes back to communication. You just raised the point that you were able to communicate with your with your upper being that you're having a hard time and that you might need to adjust. And as Jill said earlier, sometimes that communication upwards is really, really difficult and you don't feel like you're in a safe place.

SPEAKER_02And what Gail talked to is psychological safety within the workplace and the ability to communicate upwards will always give you a better result. If you think about what we're aiming to do at the end of the day, I would say every one business everywhere in the world is trying to make better wine. How do you make the best wine? You get the best people. How do you get the best people? You offer the safest and best workplace possible. How do you keep those people? You keep them valued. You make sure that their compensation and the expectation match each other, that they feel valued, and that they want to stay forever.

SPEAKER_00I think that I think one of the points that resonated was the capacity for part-time work and job sharing. I think there was a lot of questions in the panel before us around that. I think we have one of the most well-trained workforces in viticulture and analogy in any country in the world. We would be right up there per capita for how many well-educated people we have who are probably very likely to look for those roles. And that again, I think that spans across genders.

SPEAKER_01I think to your point, Mel, I think it's really interesting. And I keep having quite a lot of conversations with male friends about this as well. So it's definitely an interesting concept. We could probably just do a whole podcast specifically on that, or at least have a bottle of all of our wines sitting around the table and just go hell to leather for it. But I think it's very interesting because education is a massive part of it, but it's still doing it in a diplomatic way where you kind of don't feel like you're throwing everything too much and it's still palatable for the opposite sex to understand.

SPEAKER_01And I hate that I'm saying that out of my own mouth now. I hate it. But there's an element of it where we have just come on, everyone, understand that things are different for us and that we've got way more pain and pressure and children and menopause and childbirth periods and everything on top. Yeah. And we just crack on and we're dealing with it. But I think through pieces of education and campaigning for, let's just say for endometriosis, like the understanding that's happened around that within the workplace, I think is fantastic.

SPEAKER_01If you look at the understanding of that being a serious health matter and needing to have surgery or extra doctor's appointments, that's a massive change factor that I think has been negotiated very well. I look at China. China have a really interesting way of looking at periods. It's okay, you can have the days off. You're on your period, you can be left. Don't worry if you're running at half mast.

SPEAKER_01We will leave you, we will respect you, go home, go early. Even to the point where recently I read an article and it was talking about a major gym chain in China acknowledging that women's women's membership would run on 35-day cycles. So it would allow for those days where a woman wouldn't go when she was on her period.

SPEAKER_03Oh my god.

SPEAKER_01And I'm like, that's China. And so I think there's I think there's massive strides. I think there's a lot of understanding, and I think it goes both ways because we speak about women, but we also now, when we go back to the paternity conversation where men can have their time with a child, it's a mutual understanding that we are nuanced beings within our gender and we need allowance for that. So I think with respect and education, it's the right way to do it.

SPEAKER_01And I think we will continue to make strives in the right way. And I would say, in certain circumstances when there's a real barrier that we're met with, possibly by the opposite sex, there's got to be another way in which we can handle those conversations or handle that understanding.

SPEAKER_03Yeah, it is it's weird because it would feel like such a win. Stuff like the the period thing that you just said in China and supporting flexible hours in pregnancy and more work from home and this and stuff. And like it's it's just biologically true that women go through more stuff than men. But if you are then a hirer who is looking at I've two equal, unpaid people in front of me, but one I can see foresee is gonna have all these more issues in the future and that I'm gonna have to accommodate, but this one isn't. What does that do for equality?

SPEAKER_01I don't think we're gonna fix it, but it's I had a friend the other day who went for a job interview, and this was in not in Australia, but in a very neighboring country, and she is 35. And the question was, even though it's illegal, do you have or do you intend to have children?

SPEAKER_02Oh yeah, I've been asked that.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. Oh my god, I've never been asked that by an employer. Oh my god, opportunity employer.

SPEAKER_02And that's it, isn't it? Yeah, I was asked that, but again, opportunity hat on. I thought if I answer yes and you don't give me the job, yeah, I don't know why you didn't give me the job. It's not gonna look good for you. If I answer no, you know, lie, oh god, get the job, I'm still gonna go ahead and have kids. I don't see really a lose-lose here. Either I've got something to hang over your head, or I'm going ahead. It's quite interesting that yeah, I've been asked that though. Like at the oh my god, you could do a whole podcast on illegal and dumb stuff you've been asked.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, you know, no, I think again, just back to leave is leave, return is return. Everyone should be able to take leave for whatever reasons necessary, and we should support people to do that. We've gone from generations of women being like, please let me into the wine industry. I'm here, I'm here, please let me in. To please let me in, and now I'd like to have kids, to please let me in, I've had my kids, now I'm going through menopause. There's all these different generations going through, and now I'm going to please let me in, I'd like to have kids, I'm going through menopause, I need to look after my parents because I have an aging population in terms of my parents, and I need to take carers' leave.

SPEAKER_02We have this whole thing, we're having a very large shift generationally within Australia. I saw today, for the first time ever, there's more people over 100 than ever else in the world. We're going through a situation where people are about to take a large amount of leave from their jobs to look after older generations, whether they are parents or not, just carers in general. So leave is leave. We need to support everyone to be able to take the leave that is necessary to be able to stay in their jobs and maintain a sustainable career, no matter what that leave is.

SPEAKER_03Hey, Imogen, can you please work on this with the government that we mandate that men have to be in charge of that caring for the older generations because there's a certain amount of stuff that women don't have control over that we need to take leave for pregnancy and stuff. I think that we should put the boys down for that one so that we don't have to take even more time off work.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, just start writing the exposure draft. Well, that's fine. We'll do that. Yeah. You'll still you'll get that to the right people for me. Yeah, we'll do that. Yeah. Thank you.

SPEAKER_03Thank you for listening. We've gone, we've done so long here, but it's just been the best conversation. I've enjoyed hearing your perspectives and takes, and you're all such interesting women. So thank you so much for coming on board and today and being able to unpack so much more. I I think it was just so worthwhile. Well, right. Yeah, that would be email.

SPEAKER_02That was great. I can't believe we got to 40 out of 4 out of 40 questions. And it would have been really interesting to hear Meg's take on that as well, because she is someone that has gone through the whole thing as well, from production to marketing to consulting to the whole work she's done with Kirchhoff.

SPEAKER_03She is definitely going to listen to this episode and then come in with a list of things that she wants to say. I have no doubt. Thank you so much. Everyone listening, send us in your thoughts. Oh my god, we want to hear your opinions. I might even do like a little follow up of opinions because just there's just been so much covered today. If you send them to me, I will absolutely direct them to the right people as well. If you want to talk to these guys or get a message to them, but we're gonna wrap it up. Thank you so much for joining.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Wine News: Falling Export Numbers On Australian Wine, New State Funding And What It Means, Plus The New Michelin Grape Scale

    Nov 18, 202643 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail A 7% drop in Australian wine exports doesn’t sound huge until you put it next to the reality of a small local market and a massive national crush. We dig into what’s driving the latest numbers,...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Fiano, Can We Change Meg's Mind?

    Nov 11, 202625 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail Get down Dan's and taste along with us, these were stunning. We taste Fiano across Italy and Australia and realise we’ve been underrating just how complex, food-friendly and age-worthy the grape can be....

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Does price matter when buying rosé wine? We're blown away putting it to the test.

    Nov 5, 202623 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail We thought this would be a neat little rosé experiment. Instead, it turned into a reality check about how we buy wine, how we judge “quality”, and how quickly our brains fill in the blanks when we see a...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Wine News: The Return Of Family Owned Wineries, Endeavour Agree To Transparent Labeling Rules and A Wine Heist In The Italian Countryside

    Oct 28, 202647 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail A lot can change in the wine world while you’re away, and coming back to the headlines can feel like whiplash. We’re unpacking the big Australian wine industry moves that sit behind the bottles you see...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. From QR Codes to Ice in Rosé: Opinions from Sommelier and Wine Communicator Cyndal Petty

    Oct 23, 202637 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail Wine can be the most welcoming drink on the table, and somehow we’ve also managed to make it intimidating. We’re joined by Western Australia’s Cyndal Petty, a wine communicator with a deep hospitality...

    Credit the people on this episode