Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Who Ordered the Pie? | Classic Rock Music History & Cocktails

Who Ordered the Pie? | Classic Rock Music History & Cocktails artwork

Episode 48: Right Song, Wrong Timing | The Power Pop Pioneers

Sep 25, 202622 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Send us Fan Mail Before Cheap Trick, The Cars, The Knack and the power pop bands that followed, a handful of artists were already combining loud guitars, huge hooks and ’60s-inspired harmonies into something that would help define the genre. In this installment of “Right Song, Wrong Timing,” Christopher goes back to the power pop pioneers who had the songs and the sound, but ran into bad timing, record label problems, changing musical trends and some truly bizarre twists of fate. This episode features Big Star’s “September Gurls,” The Raspberries’ “Overnight Sensation (Hit Record),” Dwight Twilley Band’s “I’m on Fire,” The Rubinoos’ “I Wanna Be Your Boyfriend,” and The Real Kids’ “All Kindsa Girls.” Along the way, you’ll hear how Alex Chilton and Big Star became one of rock’s most influential cult bands, how Eric Carmen blended Beatles melodies, Beach Boys harmonies and the power of The Who, how “Jaws” helped derail Dwight Twilley’s follow-up to a Top 20 hit, why The Rubinoos played “Sugar, Sugar” to a Jefferson Starship crowd, and how a French music journalist helped The Real Kids make their first record. The story also crosses paths with The Ramones, Tom Petty, John Lennon, Jonathan Richman and more as we trace the roots of the sound that became power pop. Then it’s time to turn down the guitars, open the bar, and mix this episode’s featured cocktail, “The Overnight Sensation.” If you love classic rock, power pop, ’70s rock, Big Star, The Raspberries, music history and the stories behind the songs, this episode is for you. Support the show Who Ordered the Pie? a music history podcast with custom cocktail pairings. Show notes, recipes, and extras: WhoOrderedThePie.com Follow: Apple Podcasts • Spotify • YouTube • Instagram

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_00We've talked about Power Pop before, the hooks, the guitars, the harmonies, and the bands that kept the three-minute pop song alive. But today we're going back to the Pioneers. Before bands like Cheap Trick, The Knack and The Romantics made that sound easier to recognize, other bands were already building the blueprint. They worshipped the 60s, helped create a sound for the 80s, and somehow got stranded in between. Today we're talking about a masterpiece buried by a collapsing record company, a band that rebelled against progressive rock, put on matching white suits, and somehow ended up looking like the world's coolest wedding band, a hit single whose follow-up was derailed by a movie about a shark, and a band that played Sugar Sugar for a Jefferson Starship crowd and had fruit thrown at them.

SPEAKER_00They had the songs, they had the hooks, they had the sound. Only one thing they didn't have was the luck. Today we've got another installment of Right Song Wrong Timing. These are the PowerPop Pioneers.

SPEAKER_00Just listen to that guitar. It sounds like sunlight coming through a cheap car radio. If you wanted to design the perfect PowerPop band, you'd probably start with Big Star. Great songs that sounded immediate but never disposable. Records that could be bright and infectious one moment, and strangely melancholy the next. And somehow, one of the most influential rock bands of the 70s couldn't sell records. To understand why, we need to go to Memphis, Tennessee.

SPEAKER_00This was the home of Stax Records, one of the greatest soul labels of the 1960s and 70s. Otis writing, Isaac Hayes, Booker T, and the MGs. But over at Arden Studios, Chris Bell, Andy Hummel, and Jodie Stevens were making a very different kind of noise. Then Alex Chilton came along, and Chilton had already been famous. And that's a 16-year-old Alex Chilton singing the letter, a number one hit in 1967 by the Box Tops.

SPEAKER_00But a few years later, he wanted something different. So he joined Bell, Hummel, and Stevens, and now he had two very different creative forces in the same band. First, there's Chris Bell, who's obsessed with the studio and the sound of British pop. Then Alex Chilton, who already experienced something that none of the others had, a number one record. Together, they became Big Star. And by the way, that name came from a grocery store across the street from them in Arden, Big Star, which, considering what happened next, may be one of the more optimistic band names in rock history. Their debut was called Number One Record.

SPEAKER_00Again, optimism, but the music backed it up.

unknownSome of the boys got it bad. Some of the boys got it bad.

SPEAKER_00Bell and Childen share the love of the Beatles and the British invasion, but they were never trying to recreate the 60s. They took those melodies, the harmonies, and ringing guitars and made them sound like something distinctively their own. The songs could be bright and intimate, but then there was always something underneath it that was underlying. A little loneliness, a little sadness. Something that kept all that beautiful pop from ever sounding quite as simple as it first appeared. Number one record came out in 1972.

SPEAKER_00The reviews were good, the distribution was not. Arden depended on Stax to get the album into stores, and Stax was developing serious business problems, so Big Star found itself in an almost impossible situation. They made the record, critics liked the record, and people were asking more about the record. Small problem, nobody could buy the record. Number one, sold fewer than 10,000 copies. Chris Bell was devastated and left the band. For most groups, that would have probably been the end. But Big Star made another album.

SPEAKER_00Chilton, Hummel, and Stevens returned to Arden and made Radio City. And on that album was a two-minute and 41-second song called September Girls. John Fry, who owned Arden Studios and engineered the record, thought this might finally be the one. It's short, intimate, chiming guitars and a melody that gets there almost immediately. This thing was built for radio. Unfortunately, while Big Star was making one of their best records, the business around it was falling apart.

SPEAKER_00The problem with Stacks had only gotten worse. Marketing and promotions were breaking down, and Columbia, which was handling Stax distribution, did very little with Radio City. Once again, good luck finding it. September Girls didn't become the hit that John Fry thought it could be, but something strange happened afterward. The records wouldn't go away. Musicians started finding them. REM became devotees, the replacements wrote a song called Alex Chilton, and the Bengals recorded September Girls.

SPEAKER_00And eventually Cheap Trick would record Big Stars in the street for that 70s show. Big Star couldn't get its records into enough stores in the 70s, but eventually its sound ended up everywhere. The record didn't fail, the machinery around it did. Our next band had almost the opposite problem. They could get hits, John Lennon was paying attention, and somehow they still couldn't make it last.

SPEAKER_00Longer songs, longer solos, longer hair. Carmen wanted the opposite: short songs, big choruses, beach boy harmonies, and loud guitars. Hear those opening vocals? That Beach Boy sound was intentional. Carmen wanted the melodies of the Beatles, the harmonies of the Beach Boys, and the power of the Who. That was a blueprint for the Raspberries. Even the name Raspberries was supposed to be rebellious. Carmen said that they were essentially blowing a raspberry at the progressive rock establishment.

SPEAKER_00Capital Records apparently heard fruit. Then there was the close. Carmen wanted the band to look completely different from all those guys in denim and long hair and beards. So the raspberries wore matching suits, eventually white suits, very white suits. They were trying to rebel against the bloated progressive rock scene. Somehow they ended up looking like entertainment at a very expensive wedding. And underneath those suits was a band that could seriously rock.

SPEAKER_00And just in case anybody missed the point, hit record was in parentheses after that. The song is literally about wanting to hear your record coming out of a radio. And Carmen and a producer Jimmy Lerner actually built that idea into the production. At one point, the record collapses down into the sound of a little radio, then it explodes back in the full stereo.

SPEAKER_00They weren't just thinking about what a hit record felt like. According to Carmen, Lennon kept poking his head into the studio. And at one point, Lennon needed hand claps for Nielsen's loop-de-loop. So he recruited Carmen and drummer Mike McBride. Imagine that.

SPEAKER_00You're trying to make your next hit record. John Lennon walks through the door and asks if you can clap. I'd probably say yes. Producer Jimmy Leonard later told Carmen that Lennon walked in while they were mixing down Overnight Sensation and loved what he heard. So now one of the Beatles thinks your new record is great. You gotta be thinking this is it. And Overnight Sensation did become a hit. It reached number 18.

SPEAKER_00But the album starting over stalled at number 143. Within months, the Raspberries were finished, which makes the song strangely perfect. They got what they were asking for: a hit record, just not their career that was supposed to come with it. Our next band has an even crueler experience. They released their first national single, and it went to number 16. They had a follow-up ready, and then Steven Spielberg made a movie about a shark.

SPEAKER_00Dwight Twilley and Phil Seymour met in Tustin in 1967 at a movie theater. They were both there to see a hard day's night. They loved the Beatles, but they were also obsessed with that old Sun Record sound, Elvis, Jerry Lee Lewis, Carl Perkins. They wanted British invasion melodies, but with that raw Memphis feel. Eventually, they made their way to Los Angeles and signed with Shelter Records, and another young songwriter from the Tolson scene was there as well, Tom Petty.

SPEAKER_00Petty and Twelly became friends and labelmates. Phil Seymour later sang backing vocals on American Girl, Breakdown, and Tom Petty played guitar in Twelly's Looking for the Magic. These guys were coming up together, but Twelly got the first hit. I'm on Fire reached number 16 in 1975. First national single, Top 20. Not a bad way to start. Unfortunately, starting wasn't the problem. Shelter needed a follow-up, and the Dwight Twille band had one ready.

SPEAKER_00It was called Shark. And then Jaws happened. Spielberg's movie became a phenomenon. Suddenly sharks were everywhere. And according to Twille, Shelter worried that releasing Shark would make it look like the band was trying to cash in on the movie. So they didn't release it. Think about that. Your first single goes top 20. You've got a follow-up ready, and Steven Spielberg accidentally wrecks your release schedule. That's some kind of elite-level bad timing.

SPEAKER_00Then Shelter itself ran into major corporate and distribution problems. The band's debut album got caught in the middle. By the time the album sincerely finally appeared in 1976, roughly a year and a half had passed since the single I'm on fire. And pop music, that's an eternity. Meanwhile, Twilly's friend Tom Petty was working on his own debut. And according to Twilly, he heard an early version of Breakdown. Near the fade, Mike Campbell played this little guitar figure.

SPEAKER_00Twilly heard it and told Petty, That's your hook. Twilly remembered Petty recognizing it immediately. The band went back into the studio, and that figure became the central part of the arrangement. Breakdown became Tom Petty and the Heartbreaker's first charting single. There's something bittersweet about that. Dwight Twilley could hear a hit. He knew exactly what the hook sounded like, and he had already written one himself. Sometimes careers just turn on moments.

SPEAKER_00A follow-up comes out while everybody remembers your name, or a giant mechanical shark swims straight through your release schedule. Our next band had a different problem. They were making bright, unapologetic pop in Berkeley, California. And one night they played Sugar Sugar to a Jefferson Starship crowd. That went about as well as you're imagining.

SPEAKER_00The Rubinuus were not interested in being cool, which unfortunately was happening during a period when everybody was extremely interested in being cool. John Rubin and Tommy Dunbar loved the Beatles, the Beach Boys, the Hollies, the Kinks, and old top 40 records. They didn't set out to create something called Power Pop. They just wanted to make the kind of records that they loved.

unknownSo far, we just read.

SPEAKER_00In early 70s Berkeley, that made them outsiders. And nothing demonstrates that better than a show in Winterland in 1974. The Rubenus were on the Bill with Jefferson Starship and another barrier band called Earthquake. And there was actually a family connection. Earthquake's guitarist Robbie Dunbar was Tommy Dunbar's older brother. The Rubenus had been spending years opening shows for them around Berkeley, but this was Winterland, big rock crowd. And the Rubenus, well, they decided this would be an excellent time to play Sugar Sugar.

SPEAKER_00And because Winterland had a big video screen above the stage, thousands of Jefferson Starship fans got a giant view of the whole thing. The crowd started booing, the Ruben news kept going, and eventually people started throwing things, including bananas from the concession stand. By the end, there were banana peels all over the stage. Playing Sugar Sugar for a Jefferson Starship crowd was either fearless or a serious misreading of the room. When John Rubin came off stage, promoter Bill Graham was furious, but Grace Lick found Ruben backstage, gave him a hug, and essentially told him not to worry about it. Well, at least somebody in Jefferson Starship appreciated what they were trying to do.

SPEAKER_00But the Rubinous weren't kidding. They truly loved great pop songs. That eventually got them signed the Berserkly Records. Their version of I think We're Alone Now reached the Billboard Hot 100 and got them onto American Bandstand. Then came the song that really captured what they were all about: I Wanna Be Your Boyfriend. There is nowhere for this song to hide. The title is the hook, the hook is the chorus, the harmonies are enormous.

SPEAKER_00It sounds designed to blast out of an AM stereo. There's just one problem. This wasn't 1965. Disco was enormous, Punkett arrived, New Wave was coming, and Arena Rock was filling stadiums. And then here comes the Rubenews with a completely sincere song about wanting to be your boyfriend. No irony, no menace, no eight-minute guitar solo. Just pop. And interestingly, just two years earlier, the Ramones had released a completely different song with the same exact title.

SPEAKER_00Now remember, we've talked about this before. You can't capride a song title. Underneath all that leather and distortion, the Ramones loved 60s pop too. The difference was how they packaged it. The Rubenus sounded like they could have come straight out of an AM radio back in 1965. The Ramones took some of those same popped instincts, turned up the guitars, and suddenly it was punk.

SPEAKER_00The Rubenu's record got more attention overseas, but America mostly passed. The world around the Rubenus changed. They didn't. They stuck with the hooks, the harmonies, and those big bright guitars. And before long, that sound would have a name, PowerPop. Our final band takes us to Boston, Massachusetts.

SPEAKER_00John Felice had played in an early version of The Modern Lovers with Jonathan Richmond, but the two were heading in very different directions. Richmond was tripping things down. Felice had a Les Ball, 100-watt marshall, and absolutely no interest in being quiet. Eventually, Felice formed the Real Kids. They played Chuckberry style rock and roll with British invasion melodies and garage rock energy. Then Punk happened. And because the real kids played short, loud songs and clubs filled with kids, people called them punk, Felice never really agreed.

SPEAKER_00Punk just showed up, looked around, and apparently claimed them. But before the Real Kids even had an album, somebody heard something in them. His name was Philip Garnier. Garnier was a French journalist writing for Rock and Folk magazine. He saw the Real Kids play in New York, and he went to Boston specifically to see them again. And he liked what he had heard enough to help arrange for a French label called Sponge Records to release a single.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Episode 53: Out on Their Own | Part One: The Ones Who Made It

    Nov 20, 202624 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail What happens when you're part of one of the biggest bands in the world, and decide to strike out on your own? Does fame guarantee success? Or is there something about the chemistry of a band that even...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Episode 52: Songs You Endure | Part Two | Halloween Special

    Oct 25, 202627 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail Episode 52: Songs You Endure | Part Two | Halloween Special Some songs give you chills. Others make you wish you'd never pressed play. Last Halloween, we explored 5 songs that took us into the darker...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Episode 51: When Soul Got Fuzzy | R&B with the Guitar Turned Up

    Oct 16, 202617 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail Episode 51: When Soul Got Fuzzy: R&B with the Guitar Turned Up Motown had a sound of its own. Then fuzz guitar started cutting through the polished soul, adding a rougher, louder edge. In this episode,...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Episode 50: Something Strange in the Speakers: Creepy Sounds and Studio Legends

    Oct 9, 202624 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail Have you ever heard something in a song that made you stop, back it up, and wonder, “What the hell was that?” This week on “Who Ordered the Pie?” we’re exploring the creepy sounds and studio legends...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Episode 49: A Life in Records | 1 Year of Who Ordered the Pie?

    Oct 2, 202617 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail 1 year. A lot of music. And a wife whose suggestion to start a podcast turned out to be an excellent delegation strategy. For this anniversary episode of “Who Ordered the Pie?” I’m sharing how a...

    Credit the people on this episode