Content note: This conversation talks openly about abuse, addiction, a death by overdose, and suicide, including the caller’s own history with suicidal thoughts and attempts. Nothing is described in graphic detail. If you’re struggling, you can call or text 988, the Suicide & Crisis Lifeline, any time (US). The caller also talks about Alternatives to Suicide (Alt2Su), peer-led, non-clinical groups where people can talk openly about suicidal thoughts with others who’ve lived with them too. After their oldest brother died of an overdose, the caller and their oldest sister could say something to each other that nobody else in the family would: they were relieved. He had hurt the caller, and he’d gone on to hurt others in the family. Now it wasn’t happening anymore. Whenever they tried to say that around the adults in the family, they got the same answer every time: we can’t talk about that, because he’s dead. “I’m just trying to speak the truth,” the caller says. The call opens with what happens when we die. The caller thinks there’s probably nothing, an everlasting nothingness, and that comforts them. Not knowing for sure comforts them too. They talk about their own history with suicidal thoughts, how hard it’s been to say any of it in a therapist’s chair, and the peer support groups that finally gave them a place to say it. Grieving their brother has been the most complicated loss of their life. They’re grieving a relationship they never would have had, and they’re still asking how much space he should get at all. His addiction has made them more careful with their own recovery: “That’s like the only thing I got from him.” They can still say he deserved help he never got. The night before their sister called with the news, they dreamed about him and drew what they saw the next morning. The week he died, they asked for a sign in blue. A blue bus they’d never seen before showed up on their route every morning that week. They don’t believe in any of it, but “if something were to make me believe in it, maybe it would be that.” In this conversation: Why the idea of nothing after death comforts the caller Being afraid to be fully honest in a therapist’s chair Alternatives to Suicide (Alt2Su) and non-clinical peer support “Don’t speak ill of the dead,” and families that won’t make room for the truth Relief, then guilt, then shame about the guilt Why carrying someone with you can mean carrying the pain too Compassion for someone without letting them off the hook A dream, a drawing, and a blue bus Memorializing people by doing the things they loved Why the best memories are usually the small ones Book recommendation: Broke: Patients Talk about Money with Their Doctor by Michael Stein. See the full list of Anonymous Book Recommendations here. Video Episode: If you'd like to watch this conversation instead of just listening, you can find the video version on YouTube. About When We Die Talks: When We Die Talks is a podcast built around anonymous conversations about death, loss, and how contemplating mortality shapes the way we live. If you’re new here, start with the Episode Guide. It’s designed to help you find conversations that match where you’re at - curiosity, grief, hesitation, or openness. Stay Connected 🌐 Website: whenwedietalks.com 📰 Substack: When We Die Talks 📸 Instagram: @whenwedietalks ▶️ YouTube: When We Die Talks ✉️ Email: zach@whenwedietalks.com Want to share your thoughts? Leave a voicemail at 971-328-0864 and share what you believe happens when we die. Messages may be featured in a future episode. If you’d like to have a full conversation, you can apply to be an anonymous caller at whenwedietalks.com.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_01My oldest sister has acted as like the matriarch of our family in a lot of ways. And all of us, younger siblings, lean and rely on her in a lot of ways. And I think with her being able to be so honest about some of the let's call it hurt.
SPEAKER_03Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Some of the hurt that has happened with my brother. And sometimes it has felt like I am the only person besides her who will actually say what happened and will actually say that was shitty and that shouldn't be okay. And just because this person is gone doesn't mean that the impact of those actions is lessened in any way.
SPEAKER_02What do you think happens when we die? And from there, the conversation goes in completely unexpected directions. Some speak with certainty, others with doubt, some are still trying to make sense of it all. I'm Zach Ansel, and this is When We Die Talks, a podcast about death, meaning, and how that shapes the way we live. This podcast was born from my own fears around death and the need to talk about. Thank you for being a part of this conversation. I'm glad you're here. Hey, welcome back or welcome here if this is your first time.
SPEAKER_02We've officially made it through all the milestones and anniversaries, at least until next year. I know you're all sick of hearing me talk about them, so this week we're back to what you expect week in and week out from the show. Anonymous calls. When this week's caller found out their oldest brother had died, the first thing they felt was relief. He'd been one of the biggest sources of pain in their life, and he'd hurt other people in the family too. So when he was gone, there was one thought they kept on having. He can't do this to anyone anymore. And for about a year after that, they felt lighter than they had in a long time.
SPEAKER_02Like they'd been handed their life back. Then the guilt came in. How can they feel relief when their brother is dead? And on top of that, they felt ashamed for feeling guilty at all. Even though all those feelings were theirs and they had every reason to have them. In their family, there hasn't been much room for any of it either. You don't speak ill of the dead, even if all you want to tell is the truth about what you're feeling. This week they get to tell it. Before we jump in, this call talks openly about abuse, addiction, a death by overdose, and suicide. Nothing in any sort of extreme detail, but I wanted you to be informed.
SPEAKER_02It's heavy, but there's a lot of warmth in the conversation. And as it often happens, there's laughter too. If today isn't the right day for you to listen, that's okay. Come back whenever you're ready. Let's get into the call. I hope you enjoy.
SPEAKER_01Hello?
SPEAKER_02Hey, how's it going?
SPEAKER_01Hi, I'm good. How are you? Can you hear me all right?
SPEAKER_02I can hear you all I can hear you all right. And I am doing good as well.
SPEAKER_05Yay!
SPEAKER_02I don't know why that was such a tongue twister. I hope that's not like a precursor for the rest of the call that I'm just not gonna be able to speak very well. Fingers crossed, I don't ruin this experience for you.
SPEAKER_01No, it's already great because I know you're a real human.
SPEAKER_02Doesn't it feel strange to have to say something like that nowadays, in a way, like surrounded by so much that is not real, that just having a conversation with another human is like a relief, even though we're gonna talk about something heavy?
SPEAKER_00Absolutely.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, strange times. But I guess that actually sets up how I like to start these calls, as I alluded to a little bit. This is a conversation a lot of people don't like to have. People don't like to talk about death. And then you're also signing up to talk to a stranger, a real human, but a stranger, for approximately an hour. So I guess I'd love to know maybe briefly why you even wanted to have this conversation.
SPEAKER_01I think we don't talk about death enough. It's this thing that hangs over all of us all the time, no matter what we do. And it feels silly to me to reject that like inevitability. And I feel empowered talking about death in a lot of ways. And with a stranger, obviously, it adds a layer of oh, this is a little scary. But I think it's good to be uncomfortable and manage that and be like, man, why did that make me uncomfortable?
SPEAKER_01And go from there. And I tell you what, this probably couldn't be that much more uncomfortable, but that's pretty cool about it because it affords this like level of vulnerability that I think we don't like allow ourselves to access.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. Absolutely. I'm very grateful that you were willing to trust me and to have this conversation, and I'm excited to dive into it. But before we do that, I would love to maybe get to know you a little bit. And obviously, we're keeping the anonymity and everything so you feel comfortable sharing what you want to share. So I keep it pretty simple, although it's very clunky. I haven't found a good way to ask it since I've changed it a little bit. So I like to know the state that you're calling from, and then maybe like the state that you grew up in, or where you would call your like childhood home.
SPEAKER_02I think both of those kind of give an idea of I don't know how you how your ideas were formed to some extent. And then the other question is what's your favorite book and why?
SPEAKER_01Awesome. All right, so I know it's an easy question, but complicated to answer. I currently live in Connecticut. I moved here about six years ago from the southern Appalachian Mountains in North Carolina. And I was born in Medford, Oregon and was back and forth.
SPEAKER_02I'm in Portland, Oregon, so not too far.
SPEAKER_01Oh, how about that? That's cool. Yes, I didn't really grow up in Medford or anything, but from like age zero to seven, I was between Medford and California, between my two parents.
SPEAKER_04Okay.
SPEAKER_01And but I spent like my formative years in Southern Appalachia, and I thank you for asking this question because I wholly agree. That has definitely colored my whole perspective on a lot of things.
SPEAKER_02I guess you're like, I don't know, bicostal kind of. I don't know if that's maybe the right phrase, but that you have experiences from both ends or both sides.
SPEAKER_00Totally.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. And then your favorite book. Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Let's see. Ah, that's fluctuated throughout my life. Currently, I would say my favorite book is this book called Broke. It is a these little anecdotes that this doctor took from his patients talking about money in on the table. And it's like kind of a short read, but it feels really resonant in a lot of ways. So I've read it so many times in the last couple of years. And why?
SPEAKER_01Because yeah, it I grew up really poor, and one, I guess, institution that I would go into that always felt like disarming, and what the heck am I supposed to do here? Is a doctor's author.
SPEAKER_04Oh, yeah.
SPEAKER_01And it feels so like there's no space there to really talk about okay, I'm stressed, I have all these things going on. And actually, my financial stability and my quality of life is highly affected. And it feels like that's important to talk about in a doctor's office because that's your care and you're a little person, you're not just a body. Yeah.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. Yeah, that's awesome. I not awesome. Like, I love that this book. There's so many things when I on these calls where I'm like, oh shit. I hope that doesn't come off the wrong way. But just like that, there is this book, that there is this kind of resource that you found that kind of unlocked some of those things for you and allowed you to think and know and maybe some of it just noticed some of those things. I'm sure you already noticed already being in those situations, but maybe it gave you a perspective or like more information on kind of those. I don't know, that behavior sounds like a weird way of phrasing it, but that those insights.
SPEAKER_01I read that book and I'm like, oh, that's I feel like I'm reading an anecdote from like a family member or like from myself. So yeah, I really like that one.
SPEAKER_02That's awesome. I have a a giant book list of all the book recommendations from all the anonymous callers. There are just so many random books, and that's why I love it. And I think it's an interesting question to ask people because some people do listen to the podcast before they come on, but a lot of people don't, and or even some that do forget that I'm gonna ask that question and are geared toward okay, death questions. Okay, I'm ready for this. And then it's like favorite book, and it's oh shit. I don't know what to say now. I did not plan for this. So I feel like it's but I think it speaks to who you are to some extent.
SPEAKER_02And I think we got to know you a little bit through your book recommendation. So thank you for for adding that to the crazy, ever-growing list of book recommendations.
SPEAKER_00Thank you for listening.
SPEAKER_02Now we can jump into the heart of the conversation. And I just based off your application, I think we're gonna go a lot of different directions, but we will start with the big question of what do you think happens when we die?
SPEAKER_01I've had so many different theories throughout my life, and I think I've gleaned a lot of things through those things like reincarnation and there being like an idea of heaven or whatever. Ultimately, I gleaned, okay, I should be a good person. But I think the thing that brings me the most comfort is like feeling like there's nothing, and it's just this everlasting nothingness. Oh, we're not gonna get along just kidding, just kidding, just kidding.
SPEAKER_01I I would hope that's what it would be, but realistically speaking, I have no idea. And I also take the most comfort in knowing that I do not know, and anytime I get in a state where I'm like, this has gotta be it, I immediately question myself and I'm like, why do I feel so sure about this like intangible thing that you know? So I have no idea. Yes, like there's no way to know for me personally.
SPEAKER_01I envy people who have a solid answer for that. Oh, totally. Me too.
SPEAKER_02I'm right there with you in a minute.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, like something rooted in faith, or I'm like, wow, that must be so nice to have that to hold on to. Um but I will say, like the whole whatever darkness or whatever is has been like a kind of positive to hold on to because of that. Okay, that's cool. At the end of it all, it's nothing. That's cool, none of this matters, or maybe it all matters so much until it doesn't anymore.
SPEAKER_01And like I can take a lot of comfort in either one of those things, and also comfort in knowing that I don't have any clue.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. I so there I joked with you earlier because my kind of belief all along going into this project, and I say this over and over again, so I probably need to stop saying it, or but I I also feel like I need to clue the caller into who they're talking to to some extent. My belief has also been that kind of nothing happens. But I'm on the opposite end of the extra where that has terrified me and freaked me out, so much so that I started a project and have talked to tons and tons of strangers about this topic.
SPEAKER_02So maybe I think I'm just gonna keep it very broad and ask why it feels like this comforting thing to you.
SPEAKER_01Hmm. I think from a young age I was ripped of like any autonomy. And I think also from a young age, I realized that one of the only things I will ever have control over is like my own mortality. And I think like there have been a lot of situations in my life where the idea of okay, if this stuff is so bad that it is so detrimental to my life and my well-being and my ability to function after this thing, I can always die.
SPEAKER_01And I think like uh I've also struggled with like suicidal ideation and suicidal thoughts and attempts throughout my life. And I've recently gotten to a place where talking about this thing and being able to like put words to it and be like, hey, sometimes when I go into a rough situation, my like way to get through that situation is knowing that I could end it all at the end, and I didn't, and I'm here and I'm and I still chose to live.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, but just it's sometimes this weird translation between, okay, I'm actively living my life right now, but I know I could end it if I don't want to be here anymore, has oddly empowered me to do a lot of things that I don't think I would have otherwise. So I think like death and like the idea of there being nothing, like I grew up in such a chaotic environment. I feel like that like stronghold of being like, ah, I actually still have all the power in this situation, even when I feel like I don't.
SPEAKER_01And I think that is like where the main comfort in it is substantiated for sure.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, it's that's definitely an interesting dance to navigate, right? That yeah, that living, but also knowing that you have some control. I guess the other thing that and I don't want to mess with this, this system that you have, but what about where it's not in your control? How does that play into kind of your is that not something that is it to some extent like then it that it is what it is? Is that part of the kind of thought there or you don't think about it?
SPEAKER_02Because I the one thing that I always say, and I say this too much too, and I say it to my friends a lot, and I think it freaks them out a lot, I could, after we get done with this call, when I'm driving to the grocery store, could get hit and killed. Like that could happen. We don't have total control, but I do get what you're saying about there is this kind of, hey, you know, if I wanna I wanna tap out, I can. But what about the parts where that's not an option? Um, and it's just chance, circumstance, whatever.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, great question. I think that even within that, I take a little bit of comfort because I'm like, okay, at the end of the day, I've loved, I've lived, I've had wonderful experiences. If I die tomorrow against my control, then okay.
SPEAKER_03Nothing you can do about it.
SPEAKER_01Exactly. And I think like what that does for me is just compels me to just live a life every day that I'm like, I'm okay with dying today. Yeah. And I think like another thing that kind of I want to mention, there are these support groups called alt to sue, and it's alternative to suicide.
SPEAKER_02Oh, interesting. I've never heard of this.
SPEAKER_01It's honestly changed my life because it's a space where it's facilitated by peers who relate to you, and it's a non-clinical setting, and you're not going to be at the mercy of like some practitioner if you mention having suicidal thoughts or because that's always alarm bells with anything.
SPEAKER_02It's like, okay, now we need to we need intervention, and it's that's not necessarily helpful. And I don't know. This I don't want I feel like I've had my moments where just yeah, it would be easier to just be done. And it feels like anytime I try to communicate that to someone else, I don't know if it really comes across, but I'm like, I always feel like I have to start with this is not a cry for help. It's that weird, again, that weird dance of I want to express that I'm not doing well.
SPEAKER_02And like there are moments where it feels like this would be easier to just, I don't know, just be done. But I want you to know that I'm not I don't necessarily have plans to do that. And that feels like a really weird conversation. And I think that's why this conversation that we're having right now is very important, because I think a lot of people don't know that there is a I guess there's a gradient, maybe. It's not so black and white. And so I get what you're saying.
SPEAKER_02With if you I remember with my therapists at moments where it's oh yeah, if you said it wasn't quite said this way, but it's like if you say something about self-harm, then then there needs to be some sort of intervention or there's alarm bells are going. I did sorry, I went off on a tangent, but I totally get what you're saying there.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, no less than that. It is, and I feel like a lot of times a clinical environment takes away the nuance of that whole of life and death. And it is really detrimental to feel stifled in being able to talk about those things.
SPEAKER_04Yeah.
SPEAKER_01So yeah, I think I get I relate a lot to where you're saying I felt so often in the therapist's chair being like, oh God, should I say something about yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_02You get that like okay, if I say something now about this, then the whole dynamic changes. This whole thing is different than how I need it to be or want it to be. And yeah, should I be fully honest right now? Yeah, that's really interesting. Um, I feel like I I took over and went off on some weird tangent of my own. But yeah, it's there are often times where I talk to people on here where it's like, Hey, am I allowed to talk about suicide?
SPEAKER_02And I'm like, hey, yeah, I think that's the problem, is that we feel like we have to ask permission. I have friends who have kids that were like, Oh yeah, they have suicidal ideation, and and it's just that I don't want to I don't want this to come off in a certain way, but I think it's a lot more normal than people believe it to be. And I think because we don't have these conversations, it's we don't talk about death and then we really don't talk about suicide. And I feel like that is detrimental to so many people and points to what things look like in our culture where we just shove that aside, or not necessarily shove it aside, but just try to hide it.
SPEAKER_02But I think it's important to talk about this stuff.
SPEAKER_01I agree. It's also weird how in our culture, like American cool, death is not a celebration, oftentimes. Yeah, a mourning, it's grief, it's obviously yeah, it's all of those things, but uh, I'm so much more like oh, it feels so much better to be like, yay, this person loved all of these things, so let's do some of these things that they love.
SPEAKER_04Yeah.
SPEAKER_01To memorialize them. And yeah, and suicide is it's always so interesting to me how it's always been a comfort for me in a weird way.
SPEAKER_02Obviously, my relationship with it has developed into a much healthier one as I've gotten older, but and you've had, like you said, you have had resources that cultivate doesn't seem the right word, but like it's cultivated like a a healthier relationship with it, maybe. I don't know.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, purely simply, purely and simply because I just got to say what I was thinking and not be.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, absolutely.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, I'm so glad that you told me about yeah, I've never heard about Alt Suit. I'm definitely gonna do some research on that. I'm I would say in some ways I'm surprised that I haven't heard about it, but then I'm also like, I'm also not that surprised based off of what we just said.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, totally. Yeah, I work in a peer support work, so honestly, a lot of resources and things that I have came directly from like taking that course and getting that certification because I didn't know anything about it either before I took that. But yeah, it's changed so much for me. Yeah, even my like willingness to talk about it because I'm like, oh, it's even like hard to be like, oh, is this even a safe person to say this to?
SPEAKER_01Because are you like a mandated reporter or it's a terrible thing to say, but hey, are you trying are you trustworthy?
SPEAKER_02You're gonna go you're going to the cops. Come on, let me know. I need to know. You have to tell me if you're a nerd. I think that's one of the rules.
SPEAKER_01Seriously. That also makes me think about obviously the state of the world and stuff, and like people have a lot of issues with a lot of things going on, and it's very hard for a lot of people. So we should be able to talk about wanting to die about it sometimes. Yeah.
SPEAKER_02Absolutely. It's again, I think we've I don't want to go over and over again, but I think again, it's so much more normal than I think we give credit to. And yeah, I'm glad that you and I are having this conversation because hopefully that normal I am such a small fish, but hopefully maybe someone hears this and it it makes them feel not so alone in it. Because I think that's part of it too, is the isolation that comes from not being able to talk about it.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, absolutely.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. I don't necessarily want to this is this feels like a aggressive left turn from one hard topic to another hard topic. But I'd be remiss if I didn't ask you if you wanted to talk about what you mentioned in your application, and I don't expect you to remember, but you talked about losing your brother.
unknownYeah.
SPEAKER_02So is that something you're willing to talk about or do you want to avoid?
SPEAKER_01Oh, I would love to talk about it. And I will never avoid it.
SPEAKER_02I just don't always want to make sure I give the option that once once they're on the phone and it's like if this doesn't feel like a safe space or something where it's oh hold on. No, I don't want to talk. I want to make sure that people have the ability to say, eh, you know what? I know I wrote that. I'm not going to hold you to it.
SPEAKER_01So yeah, I appreciate that a lot. No, I would love to talk about it because honestly, it feels like a hard left, but it really entwines a lot with what we're talking about.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, I'm sure. I didn't want to make that connection. I figured you might make it, but I did not want to be the one that like connected dots.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, no problem. Yeah, I'll connect all the dots. My oldest brother uh a couple years ago died of an overdose, and I've had a a lot of addiction and stuff in my own life and throughout my family. And sometimes with that, my parents are also party to that. It comes with a really chaotic upbringing. And my brother was actually like a huge source of abuse for me.
SPEAKER_01And when he died, I felt guilty for how relieved I felt because I was like, wow, he can never do this to another person. And also, I recognized that year after he had died. I felt like I had this newfound sense of life. And I was like, wow, I'm not like burdened by this idea of maybe the potential of having a relationship with this person or how they may show up in my life in ways that I'm not super okay with.
SPEAKER_01I don't have to worry about any of that anymore. And it made me feel this immense guilt within that grief. Cause still that's a sibling, that's the yeah, uh who can ultimately one of the only person in the whole only people in the entire world who can actually relate to like our experiences growing up. Yeah.
SPEAKER_02Can I ask a quick question? Sorry.
SPEAKER_01Sure thing, yeah.
SPEAKER_02So you said this brother was a source of abuse for you. Was it also for other members in your family? Because I would assume if it was just directed towards you, then there's also that complication of that dynamic between you and your brother was completely different than it was with other people in your family. And so while you're having this uh complicated grief and maybe some guilt, other family members are having completely different experiences. And obviously everybody's having their own experience.
SPEAKER_02But I could see how that could isolate you even more and make kind of grieving in community, in the familial community, more challenging. Did that make sense?
SPEAKER_00Oh yeah.
SPEAKER_01That makes that hits the nail on the head because I'm my oldest. So unfortunately, he did go on to abuse a lot of other people within my family unit.
SPEAKER_03Okay.
SPEAKER_01Funnily enough, like the adults in my life, like my grandmother and like my dad and stuff, even though like my oldest sister and I have acknowledged, hey, we're relieved because now we know that these things aren't happening anymore. It was like we can't talk about that because she's dead. And like that, I definitely have experienced that inability to relate with my family.
SPEAKER_02There's that, um it's there's a different way of saying this, but it's the only way that's coming to mind. But it's like we have this way of like looking at people who have died at like through rose-colored glasses, like looking at them as the best version of themselves and forgetting about all I think that's something that happens often that we feel like we have we can't. It's that whole thing of don't speak ill of the dead. And so, yeah, that's you have that complication going in there or added.
SPEAKER_01Totally. And it's it is totally added in there. And it's I'm not trying to speak ill of anything, I'm just trying to speak the truth. I'm trying to be honest, and it just so happens about your experience. Right. And it just so happens that like the truth of it is it's really tumultuous and it's really gritty and it's not fun to hear. And um, of course, when we're in a state of being like, Man, this person is dead and I'm sad and I miss them. Of course, we don't want to acknowledge this, that, or the other that maybe they did wrong.
SPEAKER_01And not that I think like someone should die and we should be like, vilify this person. Yeah.
unknownRight?
SPEAKER_02Is it like I agree? I'm not trying to say that they should die. That is not what I'm saying. Like, it's that caveat that we have to throw in there because it's like, no, it's not saying that I wish that they would die. It's that this relationship was complicated and I have complicated feelings around it. Sorry, it's it's just one of those other things that we have built into this culture that we have to like add that addendum, which it feels like we shouldn't have to.
SPEAKER_01I agree, yeah. And I think I I loathe that addendum so much because like through this process, so I think it's about three years now since it it's gonna be his like death anniversary in September, and this call is actually timed so interestingly because always about a month before it comes up on that, a lot of things kick up for me with processing that like all over again and thinking about it, and within that is like this idea of he's not here anymore, he can't hurt me.
SPEAKER_01But it's funny to me that like for the year after he died, I had no, I like truly cannot think of feeling like I wanted to die. I felt really empowered to live. And now that year had passed, it's been a couple years now, and I noticed this uptick in like those thoughts and things within myself around the time of his death, because it is going to be like a process of grief and a process of understanding why it feels the way that it does to me for a long time to come.
SPEAKER_04Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Um and I think that it's always a surprise to me of about around this time how I'm like, whoa, I'm starting to feel some things, like some more guilt, some more like some some shame of even being guilty, feeling guilty about it, because like, why should I feel guilty about feeling the way that I do about anything? Those are my feelings. But yeah, it's been I think the hardest death for me to process in my life, as far as like the emotional complexity of it.
SPEAKER_01I've had friends die and it's been so much more straightforward because it's so much less complex.
SPEAKER_02It's just this like I think like a more understandable and like maybe regulated feeling of loss than it is when you're trying to straightforward in a weird way, although that's not the it's definitely not the right word because it's still complicated and messy, but it has more I would assume it has more of a directionality of there's just this love for this person. And obviously there's still complications with relationships, right? But there's more of this like love and that kind of grief.
SPEAKER_02But you, like you said just now, like there's the guilt, the shame, like all these other elements that are coming in with your brother that just I'm sure it's like uh I don't know, putting getting put on like the tumble cycle or something in the washer or the dryer or whichever one does the tumble cycle.
SPEAKER_01Absolutely, yeah. I wish it was like so that's my brother, I loved him, I missed him. Uh, but it's not at all. And so yeah, I that's definitely I think been a thing that I've really only been to talk, been able to talk about in any real way without feeling like I need to pull back on certain things. My sister is the only other person being able to talk about this with.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, that was actually one of the questions that I jotted down is how you've been processing the grief. And then the the secondary question was like, is your sister in alignment? Are you two able to kind of bond? And that sounds now I'm having to make my own caveat, right? That sounds shitty, but like you and your sister bonding over this. But I think that is that's what's happening.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, it really is. And unfortunately, my oldest sister has acted as like the matriarch of our family in a lot of ways, and all of us younger siblings lean and rely on her in a lot of ways. And I think with her being able to be so honest about some of the I don't want to call it hatred, uh let's call it hurt. Yeah, some of the hurt that has happened with my brother, and sometimes it is felt like I am the only person besides her who will actually say what happened and will actually say that was shitty and that shouldn't be okay.
SPEAKER_01And just because this person is gone doesn't mean that the impact of those actions is lessened in any way. And I think that's another thing with like his death that is also difficult is I mentioned that feeling of like kind of ease and like comfortability after he had died and feeling like a year without thinking about wanting to die, and then it's wait, he's gone, but actually the impact of all that he did is still there and is everlasting and is going to be now processed within this new found, newer found grief, and that has been so rough because with what kind of space sometimes it feels like I'm doing myself the biggest disservice ever to process like grieving a relationship with him that I ultimately never would have had, but am hopeful that maybe it could have turned into if we could have had this, that, or the other conversation.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, and that has been a weird thing to experience, I think, feeling like I need to give my space my myself the space for this, but also how much space should I give to this? Because realistically I like don't really want to give him the time of day.
SPEAKER_03Yeah.
SPEAKER_01And yeah, my sister understands that. And I think in like with my own personal processing of it, I make a lot of art, and that has been, I think, like the most profound thing for me. Also, oddly enough, I had I don't know, I don't I really have no belief system as far as like spirituality and stuff. I would like to, and there have been times in my life where I felt like I have, but at this point, I'm like, I don't really have that.
SPEAKER_02That's a next year project.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, we'll figure that out. But when he died, the night before I got my sister is the one who called me and told me, and the night before I got that phone call, I had this dream of my brother in this subway station against the wall, and there was like just this soul, this something coming out of him, and there was like this substance in front of him, and that was like the dream. And I drew a picture of that the next morning, and then shortly after that, my sister called me and told me what had happened and said he overdosed in a train station.
SPEAKER_01Oh and I was like, Whoa, that's so weird. I don't really believe in any of this shit, but also if something were to make me believe in it, maybe it would be that. I don't know. And also that I remember the week that he died, I was like, if I don't know, if you're there, I don't know, show me like blue, show me like blue things. I don't know. And that week, I every day I went to work, there was this blue bus that I had never seen before, and I have taken that route for years.
SPEAKER_01And there was this blue bus every single morning for that week that was on my route, and I was like, this is weird, but I still don't feel like I believe in like anything. I don't know.
SPEAKER_02I can acknowledge like the coincidence of it and lean into that side of it, that it's more of a coincidence versus a happening, but maybe it sounds like there's like a slight like one or two percent chance that it's like maybe that meant something, but still kind of holding on to like, you know what? Blue is a common color. So that's I get that. I get that. I think it's easy to talk about a lot how I think the way that we're raised now too in this in in the United States, and it's not just the United States, but very science and fact, although I think facts are a weird thing now for some weird reason.
SPEAKER_02I don't know if anybody knows what a fact fact is anymore.
SPEAKER_05I know.
SPEAKER_02But we have that kind of I think we have that kind of built into us, and so if there's no proof, right, that blue bust was something. And so then we can lean on to like the scientific, hey, you know, probably just a coincidence. I think that's what we've gotten drawn into and not saying that's good or bad. I think it's just what's happened over the last couple of decades. It's probably not just the last couple of decades, but but more focused on that side of things versus going to church and having that faith in religion like we were talking about very early on in the call.
SPEAKER_02So I think you know, I'm I'm very similar, right? It's very skeptical, but I definitely have things where it's like, I don't really know how to explain that. And so it's almost like I put it on like a mental shelf. Maybe I'll consider that later. Not sure, not certain, but I'm still gonna stay skeptical over here and say that nothing happened.
SPEAKER_01Yes. Anytime I'm too stringently, okay, this is it. Like I mentioned this earlier when I was like, I don't know, I had to was going through my thing in the past with like reincarnation in heaven and blah, blah, blah. Anytime, even with my own skepticism, anytime I'm like, this isn't true, like, there's no way. I'm like, okay, but I don't actually know anything. Yeah.
SPEAKER_02And you just get into that cycle. I don't know if you do that, but then I just spin in circles. Wait, what are we doing over here? We've just been arguing with ourselves for like an hour and gotten nowhere, just gotten more and more confused.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I still relate to that a lot. Yeah.
SPEAKER_02The other thing that you brought up, taking it back a couple of steps, that, and I'm trying to this happens every now and then. I can't read my handwriting. You were talking about how or I guess the way that I maybe introduced it is we have this idea, or there's this common idea, I'd say, that people talk about that when people die, we carry them on within us, that there's we carry on their story, their memory, their legacy. And it's interesting because I've definitely had conversations with other people about kind of this topic, complicated grief, but never to this extent.
SPEAKER_02And I never have made that connection of, yeah, that doesn't just mean the good. You know, oh, we don't just carry on the legacy of, oh, this person was so kind and loving. We also have relationships with people that, like you're talking about, that are complicated and difficult. And some of what we get we carry on is that pain and that suffering. And navigating that, that's a really interesting, yeah, a really interesting I don't want to say play, but like an interesting shift on that conversation that we hear all the time.
SPEAKER_02And I think it's because we don't talk about death, we don't talk about grief, and so then we have these platitudes, but we don't really understand that they how broad that they can be. And so saying something like, Oh yeah, their memory carries on, it's yeah, for me, that's not a good thing. There's parts of this memory that I wish wasn't here because it's this is more complicated than that.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Even to the extent that like if something reminds me of him, or I'm like, I want, I'm like, oh, that thing reminds me of him. I'm gonna put that in like a less thene place of my house. And it's funny, like one of the things that I can relate with almost every single one of my family members on is addiction. And with him, of course, ultimately, his addiction is what killed him, and it has been like profoundly impactful on my own recovery.
SPEAKER_02Oh, yeah. Um sure.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, because I'm just like, I don't if I die, sure, but at the I don't wanna. I don't wanna. Yeah, I don't wanna die that way if I do, but I'd rather not. And has just made me a lot more given me this awareness of oh, okay, you know what? I I still do have a lot of these tendencies and things, and when I feel those things, it reminds me of him and makes me not want to engage with him.
SPEAKER_03Yeah.
SPEAKER_01And that's been like I'm really grateful for that in a really weird way.
SPEAKER_02Again, the complicated nature of the relationship in grief, right?
SPEAKER_01It I think that's like the only thing I got for him. Yeah, or got from him, yeah, was in his death.
SPEAKER_03Hey, we'll take what we can get from him.
SPEAKER_01My um I will, please, seriously. Yeah, but that that's been such a weird thing, and it's still a weird thing, even though it's been a few years, and I know that it will probably be a weird thing for probably the rest of my life in some ways, and that's that's okay. Yeah.
SPEAKER_02Um I'm sure it'll morph and change in different ways, and yeah, it'll continue to be it.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_02Have you And oh what? You go ahead. You go ahead if you had something.
SPEAKER_01I was gonna say, and at the end of the day, it also sure, he did a lot of crappy things and all of that. At the end of the day, with like particularly addiction and whatever, there were a lot of interventions and a lot of things that could have helped him that he didn't have access to, and like it also allows me to acknowledge that in a different way and be like, hey, even if I think someone's shitty, that doesn't take away from the fact that I still think they deserved to be able to explore better outcomes.
SPEAKER_02Totally. Yeah, that's a yeah, that's another one I think, and this is just in the context of not even someone dying. I guess it's you're not really talking about dying, it's more about the the difficult nature of your brother. But we all have difficult people in our lives, and some more or less difficult, and it is that like recognition that there's a reason for it, but that doesn't absolve it. And I think sometimes we hold that oh if I can say, oh yeah, if he would have gotten this intervention and this and that and these things happened, then maybe he could have been different.
SPEAKER_02You're not saying that you and I'm not a therapist, so I cover my my glean on on reading and my own my own work, but you're not also saying that like and you're absolved of your behavior towards me. It's just that I can acknowledge to some extent why you were the person that you were and how I wished you were able to get help. But I think sometimes we feel like we need to hold that grudge and be like, I'm not allowing them off the hook by saying that they could have had these things and that might have made things better.
SPEAKER_02I feel like we we dig our heels in sometimes. And it sounds like um, you know, I I feel again, not a therapist, but it sounds like what you're saying there is like very healthy of hey, I can recognize that he needed help and wasn't able to get it, and I wish that he was would have been able to. And and I think then going back to your earlier statement, then maybe we could have had a different relationship.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, that's totally how I feel about it. Definitely doesn't take away from anything he did, but of course, I understand that maybe given handed a different life on a silver platter, it could have been a lot different. But that's not the reality of it. And I think I am like not a grudge holder very much i yeah, anyways. And this like whole process of exploring this grief surrounding him has reaffirmed that in me. And I'm like, Yeah, I can Maybe be forgiving to like my own detriment at times.
SPEAKER_01But I think I'd rather be like, okay, you know what? Whatever. I just want to understand you. Feels better for me than being like, screw you, you suck. Like you ruined my life.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, absolutely. So I'm gonna so I ha I usually have one question that I ask at the end, but when I'm talking to people who are grieving someone, I usually ask another question before I get to that last question. So I guess the penultimate question. But I think because of the nature of this conversation, I'm gonna shift it a little bit for you. Because what I would normally ask is, what's your favorite memory of your brother? And I guess you could answer that if that's something that feels like it's worthwhile. I would, and I guess I'm putting my own kind of judgment in here, is it doesn't feel like that's something that's that adds to this conversation to some extent.
SPEAKER_02And so the the question that I would ask instead, maybe, and you're whichever one you want to answer is fine. Or if you don't want to answer either of them, that's fine. But I was thinking maybe you could tell me your favorite memory of your sister.
SPEAKER_01I love that. Thank you. Yeah, I truly do not have a lot of good memories with my brother, so it would be really hard to reach into my memory bank.
SPEAKER_03Yeah.
SPEAKER_01My sister, gosh, that's hard in a different way because I have good ones with her. Yeah. But I think one of my main ones is I think I was in elementary school and she's five years older than me. Oh my god, no, I wasn't. I had because she was already driving at the time. So oh wow.
SPEAKER_02I was gonna say, if you're in elementary school and she was driving, this is a completely different story. This is not where I thought this was going. It's like you guys carry you stole your parents' car when she was 12, you were seven, and when you were riding. It's not where I thought this was gonna go, but okay, I'm down with it. Let's see her.
SPEAKER_01I honestly would not put it faster, but it's funny actually to think I was way older than I thought I was in this memory because I'm like, that's so silly. But I guess yeah, I must have been like 11 or 12, sitting in her lap, and she was letting me like control the wheel of her car while we were on our way to get ice cream, and she just used to drive me around in her car and we listened to music, and she it felt like this escaped that we both desperately needed away from the home.
SPEAKER_01And I will always I love those memories with her. They're some of the best of my whole life. Just it's so simple, but like the feeling that I got from it, and like the conversations we were able to have, like I still reference them to this day and think about wow, that really impacted me.
SPEAKER_02Really beautiful.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, that's probably thank you.
SPEAKER_02And I think you also nailed it like it's so simple. And I think often we think about how everything needs to be so grand and so perfect, and like all these things to be the best memory, especially in the world that we live in. It's oh, for it to be the best memory, it's gotta be Instagrammable. Or I guess maybe that's showing my age. I guess it may be TikTokable. Yeah, then that probably shows that shows my age even more because I don't think I'm 38. I'm not that old, but yeah, I don't think TikTokable is a is a phrase that anybody's using, but I think I'm gonna start saying it because I like people thinking I'm about 80 years old.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, use it.
SPEAKER_02But yeah, we have this idea that like those best memories with people, friends, family, parents, whoever it is, that to some extent it's gotta be this grand thing. But sometimes it's just so simple. I was on a a meditation retreat a couple months ago, and I was like during one of the breaks, they're like, Oh yeah, just go for a walk or and go lay down. And so I just laid down in this like grass and was like looking up at these trees, and I went to sit up and I had all this like grass in my hair, and as I was like brushing it off, I had this like memory of my sister and I rolling down like the hill outside my grandpa's house as kids, and I was like, I don't know if I've ever actually remembered this.
SPEAKER_02I remember it happening, but I don't know if I've ever in my life been brought back to that moment, and it was just so it was really visceral and it was really powerful. And it was also like I remember being so happy, and all we were doing is rolling down and not a very big hill. Like it was this is not some like epic hill or anything. This very small hill, and there's gra like there's nothing that special about it, but it was like my sister and I just like goofing around. And yeah, I think you nailed it with it's it is those simple things, it's not the those grand trips can be amazing and all that, but those little moments are really special.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, yeah, they're everything. Yeah, the big moments are made up from the little ones.
SPEAKER_02Totally, totally. Maybe that'll lead into this last question. This is a question that I ask all the callers, and we spend roughly about an hour talking about death, although they're in this last moment we got to talk about life a little bit, and that's what this question's about. So, what's one thing you still want to experience in this lifetime?
SPEAKER_01One thing, let's see. I think the one thing I want to experience is instability. I think, yeah, this stuff has been so unstable and rocky for so long, even in my adulthood. I'm 30 now, and I still feel this intense instability all the time within my life, and I would love to experience just what it is like to just feel stable and whatever, even defining that for myself.
SPEAKER_01That's what I think it probably starts with defining whatever that means for myself.
SPEAKER_02I was just gonna ask you that question, so I'm now I'm not gonna make you answer it because it's up to give me to sit with that.
SPEAKER_00I'm not sure.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, but I also love the way that I also took that as you were explaining it. You took this really big exhale, and it's like that, that's it, right? That's what you want to be able to do is just take a really big exhale in life and say, I'm good. I'm good right here, right now. Of course, that needs that's still very uh theoretical in ways, but yeah, I think that's I think that's a wonderful answer. And I say this to everyone I talk to because I do want to stay in touch with people.
SPEAKER_02I want to hear, like, I care about the callers that I talk to. I feel like we build this like really deep connection in an hour and talk about these really heavy things. When you find that stability or before, definitely let me know. Definitely stay in touch. I want to hear, I want to hear more about how things are going. But I do want to thank you so much for being willing to do this in the first place. For being honest up front, I think maybe some of these other people lie to me and say that, oh, it's so great talking to a stranger. I love that you're actually like, hey, you know, it's kind of nerve-wracking to talk to a stranger.
SPEAKER_02So I'm glad that you overcame that anxiety and sat down with me and talked about some really deeply personal things. Like, I don't take that lightly, and I just want you to know that I'm grateful for you, to you, however you're supposed to phrase that.
SPEAKER_01Thank you. Thank you for providing this like really brave space to be able to talk about these things. I appreciate that.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, I'm glad. And like I said, definitely stay in touch. Yeah, and I hope you have a good rest of your day.
SPEAKER_00Thank you. You too.
SPEAKER_02All right, take care.
SPEAKER_00Take care.
unknownBye.
SPEAKER_00Bye-bye.
SPEAKER_02Their brother is gone, but what he did didn't go with him. They still move anything that reminds them of him to a part of the house where they won't have to see it. They're still figuring out how much space he should hold. And even so, they can say he deserved a chance at a better life. They said they've never been one to hold the grudge. They just wanted to understand. Some of us are carrying someone we never got to grieve out loud. Whatever you feel about them, whether it's relief or anger or love or all of it at once, those feelings are yours. You're allowed to have them.
SPEAKER_02It's been a weird couple of weeks for me. Coming back from a meditation retreat always throws me a little. I always think I'm gonna get home and do all these things and be productive. And as usual, I came back with zero energy and completely destabilized. I always have this idea that it's gonna be total relaxation, but honestly, it's a lot of work. If you follow the project on Instagram, you probably notice how quiet I've been. Things should be back to normal this week. I also took a break from doing calls for a while, and I've gotten back into doing them the past few days. It's wild how much I get from them.
SPEAKER_02I can feel how much happier I am through the day compared to when I'm only focused on the behind-the-scenes stuff. It's a good reminder to keep doing this and to keep finding ways to have these conversations with more and more people. This week I'm headed to the NWEL conference. I'm looking forward to seeing a lot of friends I've made over the years to this work. If you're going to be there, let me know. And I know it sounds crazy, but we're already at that time of year where the holidays mean podcast breaks. Next week is the last episode of November, and then there'll be three more in December before we close out the year. More soon. I'll see you next week.
SPEAKER_02When we die, talks exist because people have stories worth telling. And most of them never get told in a way that lasts. Mostone is my attempt to do something about that. It actually started with a guest from the show, and after his interview, he told me how much it meant to have something he could share with the people in his life. So he didn't have to keep repeating himself, and so nothing got lost over time. I couldn't stop thinking about how many people have a version of that. Honestly, all of us do. All of us have a life worth capturing, and people who love us and would give anything to hear told.
SPEAKER_02Demostheny is a guided conversation with me where we capture someone's life in their own words, where they come from, what made them who they are, and the stories they want people they love to know. The recording is yours, private, personal, something you can share with anyone you want. If someone came to mind just now, even if it was yourself, that's probably worth paying attention to. You can learn more at Numostony.com. That's N-E-M-O-S-E-N-E.com.
SPEAKER_02Thanks for listening to this episode of When We Dietalks. These conversations don't offer answers, but they do open space. Space to reflect, to feel less alone, and maybe to see things a little bit differently than before. If you'd like to explore your own beliefs out loud, you can apply to be an anonymous caller at WhenWedietalks.com. And if a full call feels like too much, the voicemail is always open. Leave a message at 971-328-0864 and share whatever death has stirred in your life.
SPEAKER_02Listener support truly helps keep this project going. If you'd like to support the podcast, you'll find a link in the show notes. And as always, please like, share, and follow. Every bit makes a difference. Until next time, have a good life.
A quick update on why there's no new episode this week. I was at End Well in LA when I got a call that Jackson was having a seizure, which kicked off a pretty wild five and a half hours of getting home. He's doing...
Content note: One voicemail near the end describes being shot and a near-death experience, with some strong language. The episode also talks about pet loss and euthanasia. Three years ago, this project started with a...
Content Note: This episode includes a brief mention of suicidal thoughts in childhood. This caller pictures death as floating in a dark bathroom lit only by a nightlight, so comfortable you forget where your skin starts...
Months into a stay at a rehab hospital, with both arms and both legs broken, the caller found out the crystal they always carried in their pocket had been sitting in their bedside drawer the whole time. They couldn’t...
The caller was five or six when they started lying awake at night, scared of death. What frightened them was the idea of not existing at all. That wasn't something a kid could bring up to adults, so they mostly thought...