Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Week in Business

Week in Business artwork

Why we're all going to be poorer for longer after the Budget

Oct 29, 202611 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

We might have been promised a 'do no harm' Budget, but the Chancellor's plans could well - in fact - do quite a lot of harm. Christian May explains the grim implications of tax hikes, failure to cut spending, and decisions kicked into the long grass. Week in Business is also available in video format here.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_00Oh, we are so screwed. Sorry to kick off on that note, but there's no other way to put it. Welcome to the week in business and what a week it's been. We're going to talk about the budget, obviously, and we're going to talk about it in three ways. We'll look at the politics, the economics, and the policies. Let's start with the politics of it. Contrast, if you will, yesterday's thin gruel of a budget statement with the Prime Minister's lofty rhetoric and vision for a revolution, for changing, ripping up 40 years of economic consensus, rewiring the state.

SPEAKER_00I don't agree with that plan, but it was the plan he set out. What we got yesterday was the sort of budget Rachel Reeves would have delivered had she run out of money. She had run out of money, so what I mean is had she realized that she'd run out of money. Overall, taxes increased by about seven billion quid. That obviously follows the 70 billion quid a year tax increases from Rachel Reeves. So as I've previously said, the Chancellor was hemmed in by that economic reality and the political reality of Labour's manifesto.

SPEAKER_00So it was in the end a very strange event. The Chancellor did his best to try to stitch together a coherent narrative about breathing space and helping out here and helping out there. But it was a holding statement. And holding for what? What are we waiting for, if not a general election? The policy side of things was all over the shop, really. Over a hundred individual measures. Minute tinkering, little drops of a million pounds here for that, and two million pounds here for that.

SPEAKER_00Everything from tweaking the rules around the financing of company cars to yet more ISA reform to money to counter misogyny in the workplace, to various little schemes and reliefs and levies and new quangos and uh new rules here and there. It was a lot of tinkering. The big items, of course, was a hundred quid for everyone, every household at least, um, which will be about a quarter of the amount by which energy bills will rise next year. That's going to cost a couple of billion quid.

SPEAKER_00Paid for largely by a so-called one-off raid on the banking sector. Perhaps we'll come back to that. Also, tax tweaks, tax increases for landlords. Uh, that's the move that everybody who knows anything about this has said will further deter landlords from having rental properties on the market. So that's not going to be good for renters. So the politics I found very unusual. Uh, the Chancellor doing his best to present a coherent narrative, albeit boxed in by context, history, and indeed foundational economics.

SPEAKER_00So let's look at the economics of this. Our front page today described it as a little box of horrors, and that refers really to the OBR analysis in the red box as much as it does the policies that were announced. That analysis is quite breathtakingly grim. Just look at next year. Growth forecast for next year of 1%, at a time when inflation is forecast to peak at 4%, averaging, according to the OBR, about 3.5%, 3.75% throughout the year.

SPEAKER_00There's a word for that. It's stagflation, a stagnant economy, higher inflation. And the consequences of that, according to the OBR's analysis of the state of our economy and the budget itself, is that they expect no growth in household earnings in 2027-2028. They expect a near-term hit to living standards. The think tank world analysts and economists chewing over the budget details today as we speak.

SPEAKER_00The Resolution Foundation, the left-of-center think tank, has said that average income will be a thousand pounds a year lower by the end of this parliament than it was at the start of it. We are going to endure another lost decade. From the pandemic to the end of this parliament, we are stagnant, we are hanging on. There will be no meaningful improvement in our earnings or our household income or even disposable income taking into account inflation.

SPEAKER_00That 1% growth rate is a tragedy. The OBR also helpfully looked at a number of other areas of government policy. They cast their eye over the Employment Rights Act. That old friend, remember that, for the first time. We had been saying for a long time that the cumulative impact of all that new employment rights legislation will be very bad. The OBR has now looked at it and concluded that it will, uh, taken together, constitute a net negative hit to the economy.

SPEAKER_00Well done. Well done, government. They also looked at house building and said that the cumulative impact of government policy on the house building sector will mean they haven't got a hope in hell of meeting their house building targets. Little wonder that house builder share prices have slumped. That is another spectacular victory of Whitehall, Westminster, and the government. And as it comes to the tax on the banking sector, some people might feel they dodged a bit of a bullet given that the uh 3% increase in the additional corporation tax surcharge on banks is meant to be temporary, just 15 months.

SPEAKER_00Um but income tax was meant to be temporary, by the way. Um the problem that I have with that policy is that it's capricious. It it's it's it's it's taxation on a whim. It does not allow for planning, it creates uncertainty, it bakes uncertainty into the tax regime of the most important part of our economy. You might not like that, but it's it's basically true. Um that's a real problem. Um, it's going to cost banks 100, 120, 150 million pounds a year.

SPEAKER_00Um, and businesses, of course, don't pay taxes, people do, so customers ultimately. But the Chancellor needed to find a little bit of money. He dodged a bullet in the bond markets. He did, as he said, stick to the fiscal rules. Uh, he had a good line about his fiscal headroom. He said that's what it's there for. Use it when you need it, build it back up when you don't. So he's taken that headroom down from 20 odd billion to 15 billion. And the bond markets have said, okay, for now, but it's for now because the devil in the detail, the government's entire uh spreadsheet only makes sense if you allow for the extraordinary assumptions on cuts to public spending penciled in for 2028 and beyond.

SPEAKER_00Now cast your mind back to what happened when a Labor government tried to shave uh five billion quid off a 300 billion pound welfare bill. Labour MPs said no, not going to happen. The idea that they will tolerate what they call austerity imposed on the unprotected government departments uh towards the back end of this year, possibly in an election year, is for the birds. Now that's not a trick unique to this Chancellor or this government. It's what all Chancellors do. They make the numbers add up by baking in these hypothetical spending cuts towards the end of the forecast period.

SPEAKER_00But it's a sham, it's a nonsense. It makes a mockery uh of current government policy when the whole thing is built on uh these ropey, shaky foundations of future policy decisions that just aren't going to happen. I mentioned welfare, that's forecast to rise from about£350 billion a year to£430 billion a year by the end of this parliament, uh, and another£25 billion a year. £25 billion a year additional on that if the rate of um uh the personal independent payment scheme continues to grow in the rate that it currently is growing.

SPEAKER_00So welfare is up, borrowing is set to increase every year over the forecast period, unemployment is forecast to climb north of 5% next year. I'm trying to find a silver lining, and I can't. Uh this is the worst uh economic forecast position since Labour came to power. They did not touch any of the big ticket items that need to be dealt with. Uh, I mean, we are well beyond uh trying to restore some credibility by increasing the fiscal headroom by a few billion here, a few billion there.

SPEAKER_00We are in a situation that requires urgent and permanent reductions in government expenditure, not least on the welfare bill. And I'll end with an observation on welfare because there are two ways to come at this. There's what they call the labour way, which is that you reduce the bill by encouraging and training and getting people back into work, and particularly young people back into work, and you know, obviously there's something in that. There is another way, which is to say that the welfare system is too generous, it is a disincentive to work in the first place, and that it has to come down.

SPEAKER_00And whether you're gonna take the axe to those personal independence payments, or indeed uh the motability scheme or the triple lock, um, it has to happen. And while we're at it, I'm afraid you can't stop there. You're gonna have to take a serious look at the provision of health care in this country and who pays for it. We are in very, very serious economic conditions indeed. This was a budget that kicked everything down the road. Somebody else's problem, a problem for another day, it's our problem right now. It's really very serious indeed.

SPEAKER_00So I'm afraid I had no good news to come out of this budget. Um, it was, as I say, a combination of deferring and delaying and ignoring the big things, tinkering around the edges, squeezing a bit more money here and there in order to bung every household 100 quid next year. Uh, the Chancellor calls that breathing space. I say it feels like we're being strangled. I'm gonna leave it there. I'm sorry I can't cheer you up. That's it from me this week.

SPEAKER_00Uh stay in the know and up to date with the City AM app and on cityam.com. I'll see you next week, and who knows what we'll be talking about then.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Why a Taiwan-China crisis would blow up the world economy

    Nov 19, 202611 minAudio

    Taiwan is a remarkable success story, and a major component of our global tech architecture. But, with the geopolitical threat placed on the territory by China, it is difficult to overstate the economic catastrophe that...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Why this year's John Lewis advert is a FLOP

    Nov 5, 20267 minAudio

    For more than a decade, the John Lewis Christmas advert has been viewed as the moment the festive season truly begins. But this year's ad revealed a creative weakness at the heart of the embattled retailer. City AM...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Why making it easier to quit will boost the UK economy

    Oct 9, 20268 minAudio

    Andy Burnham might be about to do something really smart, and good for growth. Something that should have been done a while ago, and businesses agree. City AM Editor-in-Chief discusses exactly this in this episode of...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Burnham, a debt crisis and why higher taxes are coming

    Sep 3, 20269 minAudio

    Financial alarm bells are ringing but Andy Burnham doesn't seem to have noticed. Christian May explains what this means for Westminster, the markets, interest rates - and your tax bill. Week in Business is also...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Who is - and isn't - advising Andy Burnham on the economy

    Aug 6, 20267 minAudio

    Andy Burnham’s allies boasted that highly-regarded economists had been lured as advisers. City AM Editor in Chief Christian May and Economics and Politics Reporter Mauricio Alencar discuss the non-appointments of some...

    Credit the people on this episode