Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

We Saw the Devil: A True Crime Podcast

We Saw the Devil: A True Crime Podcast artwork

Matthew Farwell Trial, Lori Vallow Appeal, Lindsay Clancy Retrial & Olney House of Horrors

Nov 4, 20261 hr 33 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

The red wave died on a truck stop bathroom floor, I was spectacularly wrong about Michigan, and Matthew Farwell’s defense spent two days trying to snap the prosecution’s case over a hyoid bone. Also, Lori Vallow is back, because that woman will outlive us all out of pure spite. IN THIS EPISODE Election Fallout: Democrats took the House and the Senate, flipping Texas, North Carolina, South Carolina, Ohio, Kansas and Iowa. Kansas! A Democrat! First time since 1932! I gloat, I mourn Ken Paxton (I do not), and I unveil the agenda: litter boxes in every classroom, mandatory trans for your Uncle Gary, and drag story hour on Fox and Friends. Plus a public apology to Abdul El-Sayed, who I swore up and down was going to lose. Never let me near a betting app. Matthew Farwell Trial, Nov. 2-3: The defense came for Dr. William Smock with a battering ram. Kentucky’s own chief medical examiner on what Smock does and doesn’t do, a hyoid bone specialist in a full-blown rematch with him, a pattern expert on the strap clasp, a DNA expert describing a ligature allegedly crumpled into plastic like a gym sock and never compared to the twin brother, and the FBI’s own bone expert, called by the defense, not the government. The judge told two experts “you may be losing the jury here,” which is federal for “shut up, juror seven is drooling.” Closings Friday. Farwell has pleaded not guilty and is presumed innocent. Lori Vallow Daybell: The reason this podcast exists is asking the Idaho Supreme Court for a do-over, arguing she was robbed of her lawyer, a man who also represented her co-defendant. One justice called him a “loose cannon, bull in a china shop, run amok.” Three metaphors, one question. And she’s willing to risk the death penalty coming back to get there. Lindsay Clancy: Prosecutors want round two but won’t say on what charges. Double jeopardy, the holdout juror, a gag order fight, and Kevin Reddington telling a sitting judge “you’re not going to stop me.” I break down every charge and option on the table and tell you exactly why retrying her is a colossal waste of Massachusetts’ money. Plus a Florida woman charged with secretly recording Patrick Clancy’s father for Instagram content. Leave that family alone. The Olney House: No new evidence, just the most unhinged paper trail I’ve read all year. R.C. Horsch’s family promising a judge “no recurrence of illegal activity,” a cooperation deal that shaved years off a 20-year mandatory minimum and charged nobody, a missing woman who once spoke for him in court, and a “letter from the mayor” telling cops not to arrest him that nobody can find. Eugene Horsch faces federal firearms and false-credential charges, is not charged in connection with the missing women, and is presumed innocent. RESOURCES There is no 24-hour wait to report someone missing. Do it now. NamUs: namus.nij.ojp.gov 988 Suicide and Crisis Lifeline: call or text 988 SOURCES Boston Globe, NBC Boston, Boston.com, MassLive, Enterprise News, CBS Boston, East Idaho News, AP, The Blaze, Men’s Journal, ABA Journal, Philadelphia Inquirer, 6abc, Fox 29, NBC Philadelphia, CBS Philadelphia, CBS News, NPR, Al Jazeera. Full links and transcript at wesawthedevil.com COME YELL WITH ME Patreon: We Saw the Devil (the unfiltered, off-the-leash version) Instagram: @wesawthedevilpodcast and @robin_wstd Threads: @wesawthedevilpodcast TikTok: @wesawthedeviltruecrime X: @wesawthedevil Facebook: wesawthedevil Transcripts: wesawthedevil.com Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/we-saw-the-devil-a-true-crime-podcast--4433638/support. Website: http://www.wesawthedevil.com Patreon: http://www.patreon.com/wesawthedevil Robin's Instagram: http://www.instagram.com/robin_wstd Twitter: http://www.twitter.com/WeSawtheDevil Instagram: http://www.instagram.com/wesawthedevilpodcast TikTok: tiktok.com/@wesawthedeviltruecrime Threads: http://www.threads.com/wesawthedevilpodcast All links: Linktree

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Speaker 1So there's a bone in your neck about the size of a wishbone. It's shaped like a horseshoe. It floats. It isn't attached to any other bone in your body. And right now, in a federal courtroom in Boston, it is the single most important object in the entire Matthew Farwell trial. And it's called the hyoid. Go ahead. You can actually touch your throat right under your jaw. If you swallow, it's that little thing that you feel. You can feel it move. That's what we're talking about. Sandra Birchmore's hyoid was broken. Everyone on both sides, everyone agrees

Speaker 1with that. The right horn, there was a single fracture, no healing, no old injury. It broke around the time that she died. And again, none of that is in dispute. What is in dispute is what actually broke it. The government's star medical witness stood in front of the jury last week and told them that a 23-year-old woman found in a partial seated hanging should not have a broken hyoid. Young hyoids are flexible. They bend. They don't snap from a doorknob and a duffel bag strap. So if it snapped,

Speaker 1someone had to have snapped it. Thus, homicide. And this week, the defense marched in a chief medical examiner, a forensic anthropologist who literally studies hyoid bones for a living, a forensic science professor, a DNA expert, as well as a former FBI anthropologist. And every single one of them came to say some version of the same thing. that it's not that simple. And the man who told you it was, Dr. Smock? Let's talk about him. So, we have two days of testimony. We have a bone the size of a wishbone. We

Speaker 1have a strap which, according to the defense, got crumpled into a plastic bag like leftover takeout trash. We have a federal judge telling a prosecutor and defense expert to stop talking over each other. It's wild. And the defense is actually expected to rest today. Closings are slated for Friday. And then it goes right to the jury where 12 people are going to decide whether a broken bone means a man is a murderer. I'm Robin. You're listening to We Saw the Devil. We have a lot to get into, guys. We're going to be talking about, obviously, the Matthew Farwell trial,

Speaker 1the Lori Vallow case update because there was a hearing, the Lindsay Clancy trial. Is she going to be retried? And then I do have a very special little minor update on the Only House news out of Pennsylvania. Let's get into it. Hello everyone and welcome back to We

Speaker 1Saw the Devil. Again, I'm Robin. I've had exactly zero sleep and I am probably three gallons into coffee at this point, but I am so freaking happy. Unless you've been living under a rock, you're probably aware that the Democrats took both the House and the Senate. They needed a net gain of four Senate seats and they actually flipped Texas, North Carolina, South Carolina, Ohio, Kansas, and Iowa. They held Georgia. They won Michigan. It is absolutely insane. The exact size of the majorities is still being counted,

Speaker 1but both chambers, they were already called the House, both chambers are projected solidly blue. And I want to talk about the losers, okay? Because I'm going to be completely honest with you, I have waited two years to be this fucking petty, all right? If this isn't for you, fast forward about two minutes. But Ken Paxton, Texas, lost a statewide race to a seminary student. Ken Paxton survived an impeachment in and securities fraud indictment. But what finally took him out, y'all, was James Tallarico. It was just

Speaker 1win after win after win after win. And I mean, Trump told the whole, he spent the whole week telling everyone to vote like he was on the ballot. And you know what? They did. That is the problem, sir. Rest in pieces to the red wave. It died the way it lived, like loud, sweaty, gross, and, you know, forever lying about the support size. And because I do have integrity, y'all, and because I will never hear the end of it from some people in my DMs over this, I do owe you a correction, all right? Do owe you a correction. I have a listener, and she pointed that out as well, and not upset, okay? I was wrong.

Speaker 1I was dead fucking wrong. On a previous episode, when I briefly pivoted the podcast to politics, I told you with my whole chest that the Abdul El-Sayed, that he was going to lose Michigan. I was sure of it, right? I was down for my weather forecast. And then obviously last night, even after Haley Stevens said, right? The original Michigan Democrat. She crossed the aisle to support Mike Rogers, the Republican. Everyone, it just enraged everyone, you know? Even

Speaker 1Associated Press called it. And so I am currently eating my words with a little side of crow and a very celebratory glass of wine, all right? But I was wrong. I thought for sure we were going to see an even harder pivot to the right. I thought that Michigan was a lost cause. And, man, I just, I'm smiling ear to ear today. I feel like I can breathe, but if you want to know my personal opinion, which obviously doesn't amount to much because I thought that that was going to be a loss, I feel like the

Speaker 1Democratic leadership, the DNC, the higher-ups in the party, I feel like they need to see what the American people want and get in fucking gear and actually listen instead of, you know, because, again, they, you know, are all for their corporate overlords and some for AIPAC and... I don't know. I feel like I can breathe maybe one or two clicks better right now, but I am absolutely thrilled. Okay. So I do what I want to talk about because I'm already seeing the meltdowns on every platform is I want to talk to you. Okay. Here's what we're doing first. Okay.

Speaker 1My fellow liberals. I want litter boxes in every classroom in America. Okay. I want them federally funded. I want us to get the good shit. I want the clumping, unscented, eco-friendly because that's who we are as Democrats. All right. Well, I mean, technically the kids are now. I want Chuck Schumer to personally, personally drive to Costco, get a flatbed full of tidy cats or whatever. I want Hakeem Jeffries to go to the parking lot, handing them out, right? Like little scoops or communion wafers. I don't even care

Speaker 1because everybody's trans now, right? Mandatory, mandatory. Your Uncle Gary or whoever, Cletus, you know, the cousin with the lifted trucks, the Freedom Eagle stickers, all of that. We're going to get him a new name. We're going to get him a skincare routine. We're going to get him a group of lesbians and a group chat where he can find emotional support. And, you know, he's going to drink water and go to therapy. Pronouns. I want pronouns everywhere. I want rainbow flags on every single pickup truck. I want

Speaker 1drag story hour on Fox and Friends every single fucking morning. Okay? And, you know, for those of you who need it spelled out, the litter box thing was a fucking hoax. It never actually happened. Okay, that has been debunked a thousand times over. No one is coming to turn anybody trans. No one wants your gender, cletus, whatever it is. And just, whew. But I joke, okay? But here's what I actually want you guys to take from last night. For two years,

Speaker 1a lot of us have been scared. Scared for our marriages. Scared for our bodies, especially women. Our trans friends, our neighbors, education. environment, prices. I know so many people who are Republican who voted Democrat because they lost their health care or they have a special needs child that was on multiple services and lost them. I know so many families who have been personally impacted. And what a lot of people don't realize, and I don't typically do the mail call on this show, is I can, you know, unless stated otherwise, I keep

Speaker 1all correspondence with me private, but I've had so many Republicans reach out and say, you know, my life is ruined because Republicans, you know, got rid of or voted out this state program, you know, or federal funding or Trump did this or whatever. I know that's what we've all been trying to say that so many people voted Democrat. And I'm just like, I'm so proud of the country right now. I know that it's going to not, that's not going to last for a very long time, but, In any case, I feel like I can breathe just a little bit more easily today. So that's that. Let's

Speaker 1go ahead and get back into the reason that we are all actually here, okay? And this is going to be an update episode. It is going to be a full one. I have two days now of the Matthew Farwell trial. And that's going to be the longest part of the show, okay? Because again, the defense case is part of the trial that... I feel like a lot of people skim, but I find it really, really, really interesting because we're getting down to, guys, like I said in the intro, this case is going to be likely determined by expert witnesses on this hyoid bone. All right?

Speaker 1Then I'm going to go into the Lindsay Clancy case because she was back in Plymouth. The courtroom got super, super loud. Lori Vallow was back in court, which if you've been here since the beginning, you know this is a very personal development for this podcast. And then I'm going to end up with the Olney House update in Philadelphia, where I'm going to be completely transparent. There's no new evidence necessarily in the active case, but the family members and the court documents and a paper trail, that's all produced some of the weirdest shit I have seen so

Speaker 1far this year. Okay, so again, I'm calling this new segment the Commonwealth Docket Forecast because I swear to God, I pretty much It's funny that I'm going to be moving to Massachusetts. I feel it's almost like a harbinger of whatever is to come because I think it's funny that I'm actively moving to Massachusetts in a couple months. And for some reason, all of the cases are currently happening there. But finally, guys, just a quick housekeeping. Again, you're listening to We Saw the Devil. My name is Robin. Thank you for listening. You all look beautiful today. Extra beautiful today, by the way. It is a good day.

Speaker 1But if you want to follow the podcast, you can do so. The website is wesawthedevil.com. From there, you can find links to all of the social media platforms that it's on the patreon as well for five dollars a month you get ad free episodes i do have another patreon episode coming i just put one out over the weekend and also the again the social platforms but also the like 20 or so platforms where you can listen i'm not just on spotify i'm not just on itunes i am everywhere I don't think that sounded as ominous as I intended, but alas, I tried. So, again, let's

Speaker 1get into Matthew Farwell, because that is why we are here. I'm not going to give you a refresher on the Matthew Farwell trial. I want to know what you guys prefer. Because I cover some of these trials in such an in-depth way, right? But I do do kind of a summary in the beginning of every episode. And I feel like people who tune in don't really... necessarily need the full introduction to the case every episode, but I want to make sure that anybody who comes in in the middle understand what's going on. I'm not going to do

Speaker 1that today, but please, if you were living for it, please shoot me an email at info. We sell the double. Okay. So more trial starting on Monday. And again, I just want to kind of summarize that the government's theory is in this case is that Matthew Farwell met Sandra Birchmore when she was a kid. She was in the police explorers program, a youth program where he was, he was an instructor and prosecutors say that he groomed her and that he first had sex with her when she was 15 and he was 27. So the big twist that

Speaker 1we're starting to see finally come out is that DNA, you know, Sandra Birchmore was pregnant when she passed. Now, the big twist is for the DNA, and it basically later showed that Farwell was not the father. The father is a man by the name of Jason Picard. He's an army recruiter. He testified earlier in this trial. And both sides believe that Sanderov actually did believe that Farwell was the father. The government says that Matthew Farwell believed this as well. So the defense says that he was confident that he wasn't and that he told her that.

Speaker 1The defense theory in all of this, just to recap, is that Sandra Birchmore had a history of mental health struggles. A documented, sad, horrible history of mental health struggles. That Matthew Farwell went to her apartment to end the relationship, and after he left, she took her own life. Matthew Farwell's lawyers have basically conceded that, yes, he was having an affair. They said that in the opening, that he made mistakes. But what they're obviously denying is that he murdered her. Now, The part that makes this particular case

Speaker 1just weird as hell is that the state medical examiner originally ruled Sandra's death a suicide. That ruling was a huge part of why the Norfolk County District Attorney's Office never actually charged anyone. And then three years later, the feds come in, Farwell's indicted. And a key piece of that indictment came from the outside medical expert, Dr. William Smock. Smock looked at the evidence and said, yep, homicide. And in April of this year, more than a year after the federal charges, the state medical examiner's office changed its

Speaker 1ruling on manner of death from suicide to undetermined. So the prosecution, keep that in mind, the prosecution rested last week. And I covered all of that, okay, including Dr. Smock's testimony. Don't forget, too, that Matthew Farwell's twin brother, Billy Farwell, who also testified under immunity, he testified that he also had a sexual relationship with Sandra. The medical examiner who did the original autopsy also went on the stand. So last Thursday and Friday, the defense team started its case, right?

Speaker 1It's starting its defense with Sandra's former boyfriend, as well as the forensic psychiatrist who testified about suicide risk. And this week, the defense came for the forensics with a goddamn hammer. All right. So what they're doing is kind of going against and combating the prosecution's witnesses. for the forensics. Because here's the thing, y'all, that you have to understand about this trial. Everything the jury has heard about the grooming, about the texts between Matthew and Sandra, about affairs, about

Speaker 1Farwell being allegedly a child predator, you know, none of that by itself actually answers the question that they've been tasked to answer. Did Sandra Birchmore die via suicide or did someone kill her? And that question, you know, it's going to be fought in the medical report. And again, it involves a bone, a duffel bag strap, and then also a mark on her chest. So that's where the defense has gone. This is what they're trying to attack

Speaker 1head on, straight, right? Straight at the highway bone, straight at the forensic expert for the prosecution. So Monday, we had about six hours of testimony. We had three defense witnesses and one single target. And that target, before we get to them, I do want to kind of bring up Dr. William Smock again, particularly who he is and what he told the jury. Smock is a physician out of Louisville, Kentucky. He's board certified in emergency medicine. He did forensic fellowship training and he directs a clinical forensic

Speaker 1medicine program connected to the Louisville police. He is a very, very, very experienced courtroom witness. If his name does ring a bell for you, he testified in the Derek Chauvin trial. Again, Derek Chauvin was the shitbag police officer that knelt on the neck of George Floyd. I think we all remember the aftermath of that. He is, by every account I've read, and I'm referring to Dr. Smock, a fantastic theatrical presenter. So last week he had the jurors in his case

Speaker 1touching their own throats, you know, feel for your own hyoid bones. He's a performer. And I mean that not necessarily as an insult, but just as a description of who he is. Juries love, love someone who is animated, you know, physical, things like that. The man is basically a walking TED talk. But what he is not, y'all, is a board certified forensic pathologist. That is a very, very specific, specific medical credential. It's the credential that medical examiners hold. And so the defense spent a lot of

Speaker 1last week's cross on the fact that he does not possess that credential. And then they also spent Monday on it as well. And Smock's entire opinion was this. He said that the hyoid bones in young people are not fused. Again, they're flexible. And he went through and he went through it and basically said, no, she was the victim of a homicidal act. The scene had been altered to make it appear. And he's using her weight in terms of it was a seated hanging, her hyoid bone could have

Speaker 1withstood a lot more weight, so no. That was the wall, okay? Well, Monday, the defense team brought in their rebuttal to that. Witness number one was Dr. William Ralston. He's the chief medical examiner of Kentucky. And think about how petty, how petty and gorgeous this particular move is. Y'all, this is why I love court so much, because it's so dramatic. The defense goes to Smock's home state, and brings in the top medical examiner in Kentucky to talk about him, not

Speaker 1about Sandra, about Dr. William Smock. And Ralston didn't even read the Sandra Birchmore case materials, okay? He has no fucking idea what even happened. That wasn't his job on this stand. His entire job was to talk about who Dr. Smock is professionally. Ralston said that he'd known Dr. Smock for decades, And he testified that the only time Dr. Smock did autopsy work with the Kentucky Medical Examiner's Office was back in the 1980s. And even then, Smock was

Speaker 1just a lowly lab tech. And since then, according to Dr. Ralston, Dr. Smock's work with that office has been more or less treating the medical examiners themselves when they get exposed to something toxic, not the important role as a forensic expert. He certainly hasn't been performing autopsies. And this actually does matter, you guys, because Smock told the jury that he'd worked as an assistant medical examiner in Kentucky. Ralston took the job in 2016 and said, essentially, whatever Smock's title was

Speaker 1before me, his duties definitely didn't include autopsies. So he is putting down his, Smock's supposed qualifications. On cross, the prosecution asked Ralston a question, trying to make him appear like a man who was jealous or had a grudge, you know, that he'd been at odds with Smock before in criminal cases. And Ralston just said, certainly. So you can kind of read that in a couple ways. You know, the prosecution wants the jury to hear that these two men have beef. They don't like each other to begin with.

Speaker 1So take Ralston with a grain of salt. The defense side wants to hear the chief medical examiner of Kentucky has disagreed with this guy in multiple cases more than once. Okay. When the chief medical examiner, guys, of a state walks into a courtroom in another state to say, hey, that man doesn't have the qualifications that you think it does. That is a professional credentialed professional going on the record. Right. Like that's the medical examiner version of standing up in

Speaker 1a wedding during the speak now or forever hold your peace. And someone magically standing up out of nowhere and being like, absolutely the fuck not. I digress, though. That was the point of Dr. Ralston. I have no idea how the jury is going to actually process that or if that's going to have anything to do with their decision. Now, witness number two was Dr. Heather Gardner. and she's a forensic anthropologist. And this is the one that I am personally paying a little bit more attention to, and I want you to pay more attention to it as well, because this is the witness who matters most on the

Speaker 1actual science that we're looking at in this case. Garvin is a board-certified forensic anthropologist as well as an anatomy professor in Des Moines at Des Moines University. Her specialty is bones, okay? Specifically, she studies hyoid bones. She reviewed the Birchmore materials, and she was not there to talk about Smock's resume, all right? She was there to talk about Dr. Smock's conclusions after she reviewed the actual physical evidence as a specialist. And here's a detail that I

Speaker 1just fucking love. This is not the first time that Heather Garvin and William Smock have been on opposite sides regarding a hyoid bone. In 2022 in Ohio, there was a murder trial over the death of a woman named Emily Noble. And Dr. Smock was the prosecution's star witness. He testified that her hyoid fracture came from strangulation, not hanging. And then Garvin actually testified for the defense. the jury ended up acquitting. And afterwards, when NBC Dateline looked at

Speaker 1the case, Garvin said out loud that he, that Dr. Smock did not understand, quote, fracture biomechanics. So if you're in it for the drama, Monday was functionally a rematch between Garvin and Smock. Smock versus Garvin. Round two, hyoid edition, all right? Now, Garvin spent a long time on direct. She got up off the witness stand to point at anatomical diagrams. She walked the jury through the structures of the neck. She walked them through study after study after

Speaker 1study on hyoid fractures and hangings. And her headline, if we just want to cut to the chase, was that the literature does not support Smock's conclusion. Her own words, quote, this fracture is documented in hangings and strangulations. It's not specific to either. And she said that hyoid fracture rates in the research are highly variable. A hyoid fracture shouldn't be used in isolation to decide how someone died. And then she kind of did the actual math in front

Speaker 1of the jury, which mad respect. Researchers estimate that a seated hanging can put somewhere between 17 and 32 percent of a person's body weight on the ligature. Sandra's reported weight was 161 pounds. So Garvin calculated somewhere around 28 to 52 pounds of force on that duffel bag strap. And her math holds, all right? So compare that to how much force it takes to break a hyoid. Garvin

Speaker 1pointed to a 2013 study that found an average of about 6.8 pounds of force was enough to fracture the bone. Again, 6.8 pounds. That is probably less force than I used to open a jar of pickles. And she said that the same study didn't find a difference between fused and unfused bones in how much weight and force it took. So you see what she's doing. Smock is all like a young, flexible, early 20s hyoid bone can't break in a seated hanging

Speaker 1because there just simply isn't enough force. And Garvin is like, bitch please, a seated hanging on a woman this size could put several times the force needed to break a hyoid on that strap. And the research doesn't show that young bones need dramatically more force. She said that hyoid bones can fracture any time there's external force applied to them whether fused or unfused. So we have two completely, we have two experts with completely different conclusions here. All right.

Speaker 1So are people going to go with Dr. Smock? Or are people going to go with the two higher credentialed specialists who say that he is absolutely incorrect and that it is absolutely possible for a seated hanging to do this? So at the end of direct, the defense asked her the money question. Is there anything about this fracture that tells you whether this was a suicidal hanging or not? And she said, Looking at the fracture and the anatomy, there is nothing that points to either suicide or murder. That there's nothing there screaming out one or the other

Speaker 1to her. Okay? That's the defense in pretty much like one sentence, right? Is that the bone, which again is the most important piece of evidence that we pretty much have here, can't tell you what it is. Which is obviously not ideal for either side. Okay? But then we went into cross. And the prosecution, I have to say, I believe that they did a pretty decent job here. They pressed Garvin on which studies she included in her presentation and which ones she left out. And Garvin acknowledged that hyoid fractures happen at a higher frequency in strangulation cases than in hangings. Again, they did get Garvin to

Speaker 1acknowledge that hyoid fractures happen at a higher rate in strangulations than in hangings. And she acknowledged that nothing about the fracture ruled out strangulation. She just said that she couldn't determine what kind of trauma caused it. So, Point one. All right. And then the big one here. The prosecution also asked, hey, Dr. Garvin, in all the literature that you have reviewed, did you find a single case of a person under 30 or under 40 even with a

Speaker 1fractured hyoid in a seated hanging? She could not point to a single similar case. OK, her answer was kind of like, well, the studies don't break down the data that finely. Some look at seeded hangings, some look at age, some look at strangulations. We just we don't report every single individual factor in the study. You know, so no, I don't know of any. And you can't just pull out that exact specific combination. Now, that is a real answer. All right. And it is it is scientifically honest, I believe.

Speaker 1I mean, I have no no background knowledge to back that up, but I do believe that she is being honest there. absence of evidence that something happens in just like a very, very small specific scenario is not evidence that it can't happen, right? It's just not. And Garvin has said exactly that before about Dr. Smock's reasoning of like, hey, no, I find this highly unlikely based on everything that I've fucking seen, but crazy shit can happen. I mean, that's more or less kind of what she's saying. So which one is going to stick for the jury? Honestly, I think that that depends on whether the jury trusts The

Speaker 1woman who studies hyoids for a living, a very high credential and respected woman who studies hyoid bones for a living. Or, you know, Dr. Smock, who made them touch their own throats to feel the hyoid bone. But I don't know. I really do not have a guess on that at the moment. Now, the next witness is Dr. Alicia McCarthy, and she is a forensic science professor. She teaches forensic science at the Thomas College of Maine, and her expertise is pattern analysis. She was there for the chest. Now,

Speaker 1if we remember, Smock said that there was a patterned injury on Sandra's chest that matched the lobster claw clasp on the duffel bag strap. And so he used that clay mold demonstration that I mentioned an episode or two ago to show how that got pushed into and molded into Sandra Birchmore's chest. Well, the prosecution's logic is that if the clasp left an imprint on her chest, that that suggests force or a struggle. You know, a strap being used as a weapon, a strangulation, rather than one

Speaker 1that she tied herself and committed suicide with. So Dr. McCarthy went after the photographs first. She said that a lot of the autopsy photos weren't examination quality. She even pulled the metadata of the photo of the chest injury and said, bitch, this is taken with a wide angle lens. You know, it creates inherent distortion in the photo. And then the FBI's photo of the clasp itself, it was taken with a zoom lens. So you have a distorted picture of the wound itself, and then you have a differently also distorted picture of the object. All right. And

Speaker 1then trying to have specialists and all of these well-credentialed, important people trying to compare them. You know, it's kind of like, holding up a Funhaus mirror selfie next to a zoomed-in Zillow listing and then calling, you know, trying to bounce and, you know, compare the two. In any case, Dr. McCarthy, in discussing the clay mold, she said that the method was unusual and that she wasn't sure of its usefulness. And her entire bottom line on whether the clasp even

Speaker 1makes a difference is that, hey, y'all, this is inconclusive. You know, there are similarities, there are differences. And she said very openly that she's on the fence about this. She just said that the evidence wasn't the best because of how it was photographed originally. Okay. And that's what Monday was. The defense didn't try to prove that Sandra died by suicide. And I want to make that explicitly clear. The entire thing is like, I think a lot of people in this trial, you know, would assume that the

Speaker 1defense's entire purpose is to prove that Sandra killed herself. Okay. Okay. They did that, but in a roundabout way. They tried to prove that the government's expert couldn't prove that she didn't. And then they tried to make the jury question whether Dr. Smock is even qualified enough to speak to this. Now, the jury went home after Dr. McCarthy, and before they left, the defense told the court that it actually expected to rest on Wednesday. So that was Monday. Let's move on

Speaker 1to yesterday, November 3rd. And it was dramatic. It started with the fire alarm. The Mowgli courthouse was evacuated. Fire department, they came, checked it out. Everybody got back inside by about 8 a.m. The jury came in at 9.07. And then there was a full day of what a local station called technical and dense testimony. I'm going to make it less dense for you, and I'm not going to get into the weeds, all right? I will do my best. But there was a lot of information yesterday on more on the technical side. So witness number one was Dr. Marr,

Speaker 1we can call him Max, Noradine. And he's a DNA specialist, specifically a molecular geneticist. All right. Bright man. His background is forensic DNA, serology. He runs a consulting company. And he reviewed six reports produced in this case between 2021 and this year. And all of them were about how the Massachusetts State Police Crime Lab collected and analyzed the evidence. And he started with a lesson and he doubled down on this. And I'm going to give you a really

Speaker 1quick brief on this. And that is about DNA transfer. This man was displeased with this DNA transfer. I think everyone is aware, right? DNA goes from point A to point B. You touch a doorknob, your DNA is on that doorknob. And then if someone comes in behind you and touches that, congratulations, your DNA is on that doorknob. You know, that's just how it works. Every time you go out in public, you are picking up a shit ton of other people's DNA. Okay. Evidence touches evidence, right, in criminal cases or crime, and the DNA still continues moving.

Speaker 1That happens before a crime lab technician or whoever comes in and swabs a single thing. So we have single source versus mixture. Sometimes a sample has one person's DNA, right? You can say who it is and exclude everyone else. A mixture is when there's DNA from multiple people in a single sample. That is very, very normal. Happens every day, all the time. And the key sentence there, though, is DNA testing can tell you who is in the mixture. It can't tell you how it got there. It can't

Speaker 1tell you when. It can't tell you whether they touched it or if it was just transferred. So keep that in mind. Because the main question starting out here is the ligature. That duffel bag strap that was around Sandra's neck. Noradine said that from its condition, it looked like it had been packaged in plastic. Now, biological evidence is supposed to go in paper because why? Paper breathes. And this strap wasn't even just in plastic. He said it was basically crumpled into a big ball. It was folded over

Speaker 1on itself. Different parts of the strap pressed against other parts of the strap, which if you remember my lesson from about 20 seconds ago on the doorknob, that is a beautiful little recipe for DNA being moved from one part of a strap to another. The single most important piece of evidence, in a death investigation. And according to his testimony, it got balled up like a used cum sock and just shoved in a plastic bag. Are you shitting me? He also flagged other moments where the transfer

Speaker 1could have happened as well, like when the strap came off of her neck at the scene, when her clothes were removed before the autopsy. They showed the jury a photo of a bag with Sandra's underwear in it at the medical examiner's office, and it was sitting by her feet. In every single instance, or every single one of those instances, y'all, that is a place where DNA can move and be transferred. Now, I did learn something yesterday, okay? He testified that the ligature itself was never tested beyond just being swabbed for skin cells. Okay? All right. But what did the swab show?

Speaker 1The lab found DNA from four people on that strap. And that's working from the assumption that Sandra was one of them, right? The breakdown was about 90% Sandra, about 5% Matthew Farwell, and the last 5% was split between two unknown people. Now, earlier in the trial, the head of the state police crime lab's DNA unit, they were testifying for the prosecution, told the jury that it was 6.2 trillion times more likely that Matthew Farwell contributed to that mixture than he didn't. Trillion with the T. She also

Speaker 1ran a separate kind of test that only looks at male DNA and found that it was 158 times more likely that Matthew Farwell or a paternal relative was in it than a random person. Bing, bing, bing, bing, bing. Paternal relative. So remember that phrase, okay? Because Matthew Farwell, again, for those in the back, has a twin brother, a fraternal twin. That's Billy Farwell. And Billy Farwell has already testified in this trial that he also had a sexual

Speaker 1relationship with Sandra. Fraternal twins share the DNA the way that any siblings do. But this particular testing on male DNA follows the male line only. The Y chromosome passed from father to son, right? And brothers generally carry the same Y profile. So on this particular test, Matthew and Billy Farwell can look the exact same because they're, again, twin brothers. They're both Stoughton cops. They have matching Y chromosomes. You know, apparently they just really, the Stoughton Police Department just really bought a buy one, get one free special

Speaker 1on bullshit here. But Nora Dean testified that the state police never compared Billy Farwell's DNA profile in this testing. The defense attorney, Kimberly Stevens, asked him directly, well, was Billy's DNA tested as one of the contributors to the ligature? His DNA was not tested, y'all. So the defense team, their argument is shaping up like this. Okay, no, no, no, guys. You've got a strap packed wrong. You have crumpled up DNA that can migrate with, you know, small male contribution that the lab says is Farwell or a relative. But

Speaker 1the lab never ruled out the male relative who also had a sexual relationship with her. That's where the defense is going to be coming from. You know, how do you even know it's me if it could also potentially be my brother and you never tested for that? Now, Nordian went even further on this. He... said that, you know, it's called the YSTR, the YSTR test, is the one that tests for male lineage. And the lab identified Farwell as the major contributor among at least four men. And Nordin said that he couldn't find anything in the lab

Speaker 1file that supported their conclusion. He said that he saw no evidence that the lab had validated the procedure that it used to interpret four different men's DNA. And his line, which I think is the most quoted line of the entire day, was, the lab interpreted a mixture they should not have. So he's fully, for those who might not understand the gravity of that, that is a defense expert telling a federal jury that a state crime lab basically came to a conclusion that science could not support. Okay,

Speaker 1that was a big swing. So here's the problem for the defense, right? Nora Dean didn't offer his own competing interpretation with the defense witnesses. He criticized their method, right? He showed up, he shit-talked everybody else's you know, ideas, but he didn't provide his own. He didn't give the jury an alternative solution or an alternative answer. Okay. And from, I think what we all are aware of, if you watch true crime, juries like some sort of alternative theory

Speaker 1to go along with it. And Nourdine agreed with the lab on a bunch of things, though, okay? Don't think that he just came in just shitting all over the chessboard like a pigeon. He agreed that Farwell was excluded as a contributor to DNA under Sandra's fingernails. That is, in fact, a point for the defense, by the way. Because if someone strangles you, you kind of expect the victim to fight back, right? Fingernail scrapings, and it was stated in the trial, are the number one place where you would look for DNA from the attacker under the fingernails, especially in strangulations. He also agreed that there were sperm

Speaker 1cells found in Sandra's underwear in two separate stains and that the two likely contributors to one of those stains were Farwell and Jason Pickard. He also told the jury that doing laundry can redistribute sperm onto other clothing, which is another way of saying, hey, DNA on clothing, it doesn't tell you when it happened. He went one step further, okay? He said that he thought Pickard's DNA was consistent with DNA from an oral swab taken from Sandra. Not sperm,

Speaker 1but DNA picked up while analysts were looking for sperm cells. Get my drift there. And then came the cross, and it got heated. The prosecutor in this case is the assistant U.S. attorney, Elizabeth Riley. She went after Nouradine's credentials first. She got him to acknowledge that he's not a forensic DNA analyst. She made the point that the state police crime lab is accredited, whereas he is not, which is kind of a super little polite way of saying, where's

Speaker 1your little certificate, sweetie? You know, like it definitely did not help. Then she went at the substance of all of this. Nora Dean's whole critique leaned on the idea that the lab just assumed that Sandra was a contributor. And then they built everything and all of their findings from that. And Riley disputed that. Her position was that, hey, the lab didn't just assume that. it recalculated its entire basic findings. And then she kind of made the government's version of what the numbers are. She said, hey, set

Speaker 1the female DNA aside. Sandra's 90% is Sandra's 90%, right? Of course her DNA is all over the fucking strap found around her own nag. But look at what's left. Of the remaining DNA, Farwell's profile accounts for half of it. He's not a trace on this strap, y'all. He is the biggest contributor left after Sandra. And Nora Dean responded to this and he said, more or less, well, that's an interesting way to look at it. And then he also told her he disagreed with how the lab interpreted

Speaker 1the mixture. Earlier, he pushed back on Dr. Riley calling Farwell the, quote, next highest profile on the ligature at all. He said that it was a trace sample. Okay, so there we have it. We have the same strap, the same percentages. The government says, nah, second biggest contributor. Half of what's there isn't even hers. The defense team says 5%, We have a trace. It was packed wrong. It was possibly transferred. It was never compared to, you know, Matthew's twin brother, Billy. And somewhere in all of this, right,

Speaker 1these two people started talking over each other. Judge Casper had to step in and had to remind them not to talk over each other because obviously we are all adults here. At one point, and I laughed, I laughed out loud when I heard this, is that she said at one point they started going over each other so much. She was like, she stopped them and was like, you may be losing the jury here in terms of translation. That is both of you shut the fuck up. All right. Other than that, there, there was an actual fight about the underwear and how it was handled. DNA transfer, all that. Both sides tried to get his take on it. And

Speaker 1then we had witness number two, and that is Dr. Angie Christensen, the FBI's bone expert. And again, I was fascinated by this one. And I think it's strategically, I find it to be really interesting, a really interesting witness that the defense has called. So Dr. Christensen is a forensic anthropologist with a PhD. She worked for the FBI directly until last year. She's retired now. And she wasn't hired by the defense to look at this case. She was asked by the FBI. The government's own investigators asked

Speaker 1her to assess Sandra's, you guessed it, the hyoid bone. So she wrote a report for the FBI out of Boston. She was also in direct communication with Dr. Smock. And then the government didn't even call her. The defense did. Right. Like that's the kind of that shittery sometimes that we see in trials. And think about the strategy here, y'all. The defense is showing the jury that the FBI had its own forensic anthropologist. Look at this bone. And the prosecution chose a different expert to put on the stand.

Speaker 1An implication here, y'all, that the defense very much seems to be pushing is that the government set aside an expert whose findings didn't help it. So here's what she said. She examined the hyoid using CT scanning, and she found a single fracture on the right side. The bone, again, was unfused. There were no signs of healing, so it wasn't an old injury. The fracture was pretty apparent, and it was in the spot where hyoid bones most commonly break. She said that she talked to Dr. Smock about it because he'd been involved in removing the bone and that he also identified it as perimortem, meaning it happened around

Speaker 1the time of death. And then the defense's key points here, okay? That there is no established amount of force that's known to be required to break a hyoid. Nobody can tell you it takes, you know, 13 pounds of pressure and a seated hanging only produces... Nine. And yes, based on the literature, hyoid fractures are less common in younger people than in older people. Less common, but not impossible. On Cross, Riley did the same thing that she did with Garvin. She got Christensen to agree that the studies she reviewed

Speaker 1didn't contain a single example of a young person fracturing a hyoid in a seated hanging. Then we went to redirect. Joanne Daly said, a defense attorney got her to agree to the shape of it all, which is that strangulation is the most common cause of hyoid fractures. But again, it can happen in suicidal hangings. Okay. So that's the hyoid after two full days of testimony, pretty much on it. And every single expert agrees that the bone is fucking broken. All right. Every single expert agrees that breaks like this

Speaker 1are more common in strangulation. Everyone says that, you know, agrees that it can happen in a hanging as well. It's, We do not have a final all encompassing answer here. All right. Two full days of this. And it's kind of like pick your fighter. Who fucking knows? That is the reasonable doubt fight that the defense team is looking there. The highway for them is going to they're really going to be pushing. Well, not going to be. They are that that is a reasonable doubt item. So let's discuss

Speaker 1what the jury is actually going to be deciding. So today, on Wednesday, the defense is likely, well, they are expected to call its last two witnesses on the docket. And again, it's now one o'clock. I've been so busy today. I've been doing this episode in pieces. I do not know what has happened today in trial so far. I will do an update episode on this tomorrow, but I just wanted to at least cover Monday and Tuesday. So today, first up should have been Dr. Thomas Andrew, and he's a forensic pathologist and the former chief medical examiner of New Hampshire. Watch him, okay? Like, well, listen to the

Speaker 1transcripts of it. Because so far, the defense's medical attack on Dr. Smock has come from a chief medical examiner who didn't even review the case. It came from anthropologists, from pattern experts. Dr. Andrew is a board-certified forensic pathologist, the exact credential that Dr. Smock does not have. And I would expect him to be kind of the one who, you know, stands up and is like, here's how I would rule this stuff. Here's why I would rule it this way. That is the very closest thing that the defense has to a direct rebuttal to Dr. Smock. The

Speaker 1second one up is going to be Daniel Loper. He's a digital forensics expert. And we don't know exactly what he's going to cover yet. I'm not going to even venture a guess. But a digital evidence, you know, specialist, especially with this case, obviously it's going to include phone data, text, timing, you know, any sort of geo hits and whatnot of where he was at that particular time, right? After that, the defense is going to rest. Thursday, tomorrow, there will be no court. Friday, we'll have closing arguments. And Judge

Speaker 1Kasper has actually already told the jury to plan to be in court from nine to five. Because again, Friday is the day she expects them to get And at least from right now, it very much looks like Matthew Farwell is not going to be testifying. He's not on the defense's witness list. Obviously, that's his right. The jury will be told that they cannot hold it against him. And obviously, they are not supposed to. A defendant doesn't have to be the one to prove anything. The government, as we all know, the government is the one that has to prove everything. So what is the jury actually

Speaker 1deciding then? Well, obviously, count one, killing a witness or victim. To convict, the government has to prove that Farwell killed Sandra Birchmore and that he did it to prevent her from communicating with law enforcement about a federal offense. And obviously, the federal offense here is his alleged sexual exploitation of her when she was a child. So, two questions. Did he kill her? And if he did, was it to keep her quiet? Count two, the death of the unborn child.

Speaker 1That one basically, you know, rises and falls with the first question. If he killed Sandra, the death of her pregnancy clearly follows. If the jury convicts, Farwell faces life in federal prison. And I guess, as always, without being asked, I'm going to give you my own, I guess, thoughts and feelings on where I think it's going to go. The defense has had a couple good days, like two days to be exact. Dr. Garvin was strong. Christensen is

Speaker 1definitely a problem for the government, not necessarily because of what she said, but because of who asked her to look at it all in the first place. The you may be losing the jury was an absolute gift to the defense because the defense's whole strategy is confusing everyone. And a confused jury obviously is one that has a higher potential for doubt. But here's what the experts, the defense experts at least, here's what they didn't do. Not a single one of them said that this was a suicide.

Speaker 1Not a single one of them said that the bone proves that there was a hanging either. Their message, again, has just been, the bone doesn't tell you. We can't choose. So... you know, if you look at everything that the trial has covered so far, the jury is going to be forced because they don't have an easy answer with the hyoid. They're going to be forced to go back to the relationship, the text, the lobby video of Farwell, you know, at her building that night. And then the government, right, says that this man took great pains to hide this particular affair more than he did with any of the others.

Speaker 1We have a twin brother testifying against him. And the jury has to take a look at all of this evidence and ask, okay, well, without the hyoid bone, being for sure a conclusion, what does the rest of this tell us? That's where this case is going to be decided. It's not going to be in the scientific weeds, not the anthropology. It's basically going to be whether 12 people believe that the hyoid bone is the only piece of evidence pointing at murder or just one element of a couple. Okay,

Speaker 1and as we all know, whatever they decide, I'm going to be here for it. But that's it for the Matthew Farwell case today, guys. Well, not today. That is it. All that I'm covering in this episode. Court is currently ongoing as I'm recording this. And so later this evening, I will give you an update on today just to do a double check in to see if the defense rested. But now on to something and someone that I never thought I never thought I would utter this name again. And if you've been around the podcast or you've covered me for a long time, you know, OK, You know,

Speaker 1you know that this podcast was born out of the Lori Vallow case. She is, in a very real sense, the only reason that this show exists. Every single podcaster has an origin story, all villain origin, whatever. And some people get into true crime because of a documentary or because of a book and all of that. I got into it because a woman who believed that she was an exalted goddess sent to lead the 144,000 through the apocalypse decided that her children were zombies. I mean, we all have to start somewhere, I guess. Heinous, heinous case.

Speaker 1And it was a wild way to jumpstart and understand true crime. That is for sure. And this week, she was back in court, because of course she is. Now, don't forget, for those of you who are not familiar, Lori Vallow, after she married Chad Daybell, her name became Lori Vallow Daybell. She spent years telling people that she was a translated being who couldn't die. And she was right about exactly one piece of that, which is something in this story is immortal, okay? And it's apparently going to be her court calendar, because it will not fucking stop.

Speaker 1The apocalypse, obviously, I mean, unfortunately, in my opinion, never showed up. But her hearings are eternal. Okay, Lori, like, Habibi, you are not a goddess. But on Monday, the Idaho Supreme Court heard oral arguments on Lori's appeal of her convictions. And these were back in 2023. And quick reminder of what those were for the gallery over there, right? Murder and conspiracy to commit murder in the deaths of her children, 7-year-old J.J. Vallow and 16-year-old Tylee Ryan. Conspiracy to murder Tammy Daybell, who was the wife of Chad Daybell, whom

Speaker 1Lori married about two weeks after Tammy died. And then grand theft of Social Security benefits, because obviously when you're planning the end of the world, you still need to collect your kids' checks, right? Well, she got multiple life sentences in Idaho. And then in 2025, she was convicted in Arizona of conspiring to kill her former husband, Charles Vallow, who was shot and killed in her home, and of also conspiring to kill her niece's ex-husband, Brandon Boudreau. He was shot at and survived. And I believe that Brandon just did a podcast episode or started his own podcast.

Speaker 1I don't know. I saw a news. article on it. And to be honest, I have tried purposely to stay out of Lori Vallow updates until this one. She got two more life sentences there and they have been ordered to run after the Idaho one. So Chad Daybell was also convicted. He was convicted in 2024 and sentenced to death. And he's currently appealing that. So Lori is asking the Idaho Supreme Court to throw out all of her convictions and give her a new trial. Her main argument for this is that she says she was denied her Sixth

Speaker 1Amendment right to the lawyer of her choice. All right. Buckle the fuck up, friends, because let me tell you about the lawyer of her choice. Okay. His name is Mark Means. And early in the case, Means was representing Lori. And Means was also, depending on who you ask and what day it is, representing Chad Daybell, her co-defendant. Right. In the same murders. That's like your husband hiring the same divorce lawyer. Okay. But I digress. While Lori was officially found incompetent to stand trial, because she was in

Speaker 1the beginning, right, and then she had therapy and all of that, her case was on hold. So Means, during that, Means was filing documents with the court, including sworn statements from Lori. The trial judge disqualified him over conflict of interest. Now, Lori's appellate lawyer, Craig Durham, argued that the judge got it wrong, that the Sixth Amendment requires an actual conflict of interest, not just a simple hypothetical one. that there was no evidence that Chad shared confidential information with Mark Means, you know, that Mark Means was hired mostly to handle

Speaker 1just the media, that Chad had waived the conflict, that Lori never got a voice in any of the decisions because she was incompetent at the time. He called it a flawed process that produced a flawed result. He admitted that the joint representation was unorthodox and also incredibly ill-advised, and that Means' filings were very unorthodox themselves, But he argued that the court overstated the problem and could have done something a little bit less drastic than barring him. Right. So, like, say, for example, appointing conflict counsel or just ordering Mark needs

Speaker 1to stop filing things. That's all it would have taken. Now, one of the justices, Gregory Moeller, asked the question that kind of like we were all asking. Right. What is a judge supposed to do when a defendant's attorney is and I'm quoting the justice directly here, quote, a loose cannon bull in a China shop run amok. I mean, three metaphors in one question. Good for you. The state side came from Assistant Attorney General Jeff Nye, and he pointed out that Mark Means had publicly declared that he represented Chad. That when police served the search warrant on

Speaker 1Chad's property, you know, the one where they found JJ entirely deceased, Chad's first phone call was to Mark Means. That in a jail call, Chad said that they'd consolidated to one attorney for reasons of confidentiality, which kind of answers the question, right, of, whether confidential information was involved in this. And don't forget, Chad was paying Lori's legal fees. And then he gave the line that basically just summarizes this entire shit show. He said, quote, nothing that happened here is normal, but that doesn't mean there was an error.

Speaker 1Embroider that shit on a pillow. Okay. Put it on the pillow and put it on the couch of this entire case because yes. But in a dark way, I kind of laugh at this because Justice Cynthia Meyer asked Durham a very, very, very pointed question. Hey, if we reverse this conviction, doesn't that potentially put the death penalty back on the table? Because prosecutors originally sought the death penalty against Lori, right? Do you guys remember that? Before the trial judge took it off the table for her.

Speaker 1And Durham said that there are several strong arguments why that couldn't happen, but that Lori is aware of the risks and is choosing to proceed anyway. So what that means, in plain English, is that Lori Vallow is gambling her life on a do-over. I mean, honestly, y'all, that tracks if you know anything about this bitch. But this is a woman who thought that she lived multiple past lives, right? What's one more? Roll of the dice. It's not necessarily an appeal. It's just this woman just... Never mind. Y'all get it. The irony, though, is that Lori is arguing

Speaker 1that her right to choose her own lawyer was so sacred that violating it requires a whole new trial. And lest we not forget, this is the same Lori Vallow who in Arizona chose to represent herself. So she values her right to counsel so much that she'll go to the state Supreme Court over it. And she values the actual counsel so little that she'll drop them and just do it her damn self. Just wild. Now, her appeal also raises a you know, what we call speedy trial claim.

Speaker 1And there are arguments that she was deprived of counsel at some pre-trial hearings, that she should have been present for hearings held while she was incompetent, that the jury shouldn't have heard about uncharged acts in Arizona. Those weren't argued in depth on Monday, but they have been brought up. The court also heard about an hour of argument and took it under advisement. There's no ruling yet, no timeline, you know, she was arrested originally back in 2020 and here six and a half years later, she's back in a courtroom still asking for a couple more chances. And

Speaker 1it's just absolutely wild. All right. Like, thank you, Lori. Thank you, Lori. I never thought I would have to talk to you again. You absolute apocalypse brain book of revelations, fanfic writing, crazy bitch. Like you are the reason the show is possible. Okay. Please stay in prison until the actual end in times. But that's it for the Lori Vallow case, guys. I will absolutely, give you the update once that does come down, once that is made known. And then I also do want to talk about Lindsay Clancy, all right? Because she was also back in Plymouth Superior

Speaker 1Court on Monday. It has officially been 60 days, 60 days since Judge William Sullivan declared a mistrial. And on Monday, for the first time, the prosecution finally said out loud that it does, in fact, intend to try her again. So... let's just get the information out of the way. And then I'm going to tell you exactly what I think because I'm pissed. All right. I mean, even the blue, blue cocky that happened last night could not make me any less pissed about the Lindsay Clancy case. So quick reset.

Speaker 1All right. Everyone knows Lindsay Clancy trial. I'm not going to summarize it again. I've done enough episodes on it. Listen to a previous one or Google is your friend. But we're talking Monday, right? This week. So Monday, there were three big motions on the table, plus the question of a retrial date. And let's go through one at a time. First is the motion. The first motion. The defense wants the case thrown out entirely. Double jeopardy. This is the argument from Martin Weinberg. He's the appellate heavyweight that Lindsay Clancy brought in after the mistrial. If that name sounds familiar, he's the lawyer who argued double jeopardy

Speaker 1for ding-a-ding-ding-ding-ding. Yes, Karen Reed. incestuous law community in Massachusetts. But his argument is that Judge Sullivan declared a mistrial without what the law calls manifest necessity. During deliberations, the jury foreperson sent out notes saying that the holdout juror wasn't following the judge's instructions on reasonable doubt. We remember that, right? Well, Weinberg says that before ending the trial, the judge had to dig in, question the jurors individually, figure out whether

Speaker 1that one juror was actually deliberating in good faith, and if not, replace him with an alternate. Because he didn't, because the judge did not do this, Weinberg says that the mistrial was unnecessary and trying her again would put her in jeopardy twice. And Judge Sullivan immediately pushed back from the bench. Didn't I bring the jurors in and ask them about following my instructions? And yes, he did. He did question each juror at sidebar about whether they could follow the law. And Weinberg's answer to this was that, well,

Speaker 1asking all 12, hey, can you follow the law, isn't enough. That doesn't tell you if one of them isn't, if you're just getting a simple yes or no answer. And I have to say, I agree. Now, the prosecutor, Jennifer Sprague, she had the line of the day. She said that the record was clear that this juror, quote, did not refuse to deliberate on He refused to agree. Now, honestly, all right, on the law, that is a very, very strong line. Judges are not allowed to go digging into how a juror is thinking just because the other 11

Speaker 1don't like his answer. That is the whole damn point of a jury, all right? Sullivan reserved his decision here, so we don't know what's going to happen there. I mean, I do agree with Weinberg, but I don't think it's going to go in his direction, right? Now, motion two. the holdout jurors records. And this is where it got loud. Okay. Kevin Reddington, who Lindsay Clancy's trial lawyer, he wants the court to preserve and let him get into the holdout jurors confidential questionnaire, right? Not only that, but his phone records,

Speaker 1other court records, Reddington alleged in court that the juror wasn't honest on his jury questionnaire. He alleged that the juror didn't disclose a past abuse prevention order against him or his arrest from back in 2021. He also alleged the juror was scrolling on his phone during deliberations, which was heavily reported. And, I mean, big caveat here, right? These are obviously allegations from the defense attorney. They have not been proven yet. You know, no court has made any finding on them yet. And the judge already refused an evidentiary hearing on this a couple weeks ago. And

Speaker 1the juror's own lawyer was in court this Monday saying that her client followed the rules. And then Reddington, mid-argument, said the juror's name out loud in open court. And then the exchange went a little something like this. Judge Sullivan said, I'm going to stop you right there, Reddington. You're not going to stop me, Judge Sullivan. I am. Ladies and gentlemen, Kevin Reddington told a sitting Superior Court judge on the record, you're not going to stop me.

Speaker 1I have watched a lot of courtroom footage in my life, and I have rarely seen a man so committed to his little act, his little bit here. All right? He... just chef's kiss. Okay. Now Sullivan's point though. Okay. Let me discuss was that there was no need to bring out the juror's name. The questionnaire is confidential under Massachusetts law. And Reddington's response was like, yo, the juror's name is already all over the fucking news and the internet because he's out there giving interviews. He's quote, got more FaceTime

Speaker 1than I do. Direct quote from Sullivan, which, or sorry, Reddington, um, you know, which coming from Reddington is kind of a hell of a burn. The man has been everywhere. Um, But the juror's name, we call him the asshole juror, all right? I don't care if that hurts anyone's feelings. Everything I have learned about this man has been awful and against my will, so whatever. But his lawyer, her name is Heather O'Connor, argued that he is being targeted because he disagreed with the other 11 jurors. And she said that if the court lets the defense investigate him,

Speaker 1the message to every single future juror in Massachusetts is basically, hey, you must agree with the majority or you might get investigated and blown up in public. Now, Prosecutor Sprague asked the judge to deny the motion on its face because once you start investigating one juror's private conduct and deliberations, you open the door to what? Doing it to anybody else or all of them. And I will say this, okay? I have real problems with how that holdout juror handled himself during the trial and after the trial. I mean,

Speaker 1we've heard from the other jurors and talked about his behavior. I mean, he should never have been chosen. I did multiple episodes on this. But the people arguing that you can't put a juror under a microscope for voting the wrong way, like they are right about that, right? It's wrong when it's a holdout for conviction. It's wrong when it's a holdout for acquittal. The door swings both ways. So I don't know how this is going to happen, but I don't think anything at the end of the day is going to come from this juror. I think that they are just going to speed, just going to decide to go ahead and try and try her again. Now,

Speaker 1motion three. The prosecution wants a gag order on Reddington. Sprague accused Reddington of making calculated public statements to shape public opinion and taint a future jury pool. She pointed to his comments about the holdout juror, about his relationship with Lizzie Clancy, and my personal favorite, his public floating of a presidential pardon. A presidential pardon for state murder charges in Massachusetts. Like, Kevin, sweetheart. Like, as everyone knows, everybody,

Speaker 1you know, lost their shit after he's a lawyer. He should understand a president can only pardon federal crimes. Yes. And he is aware of that. All right. It's just getting it into the news. Reddington is good at grabbing headlines and saying insane shit that gets press. All right. So Laura McConnell argued against the gag order for the defense. Her point was that Lindsay Clancy hasn't given interviews. Reddington is her voice. If you gag him, then you've gagged her.

Speaker 1That is also under advisement currently. But then the retrial date, okay? And Sprague said for the very first time out loud, quote, this would be a retrial. But she wouldn't say on what charges. She said the Commonwealth hasn't even decided yet what it would look like, and she didn't want to set a trial date until the judge rules on pending motions. And Reddington, bless his little soul, he lost a little bit of his shit, okay? You know, why don't we know, he said, if the next trial is, first-degree murder or

Speaker 1a lesser charge or no charge at all. He said he needs to know logistically whether he's defending a triple first-degree homicide or something else entirely. He called Judge Sullivan's upcoming retirement the elephant in the room, and Sullivan faces mandatory retirement next June, so Sullivan's going to be out by next summer. And Reddington said that he wants Sullivan to be the trial judge. You know, he wants it this spring, and he's not going to have this woman still incarcerated for the next one, two, or three years. So, Sullivan said that he's leaning toward a March trial date

Speaker 1as a realistic date. And that's a possible date, right? Like not a set one, but possible. So in any case, they are back on November 16th, which is what, 12 days from now. And he is expected to deal with all of these motions, maybe even set a schedule. So again, set a reminder, November 16th, we should have some answers here. Now, one thing I do want to cover is what charges could Lindsay Clancy charge actually face? Like, what's the reality that we're looking here, okay? Here are the options on the table and what each one would mean. Option one,

Speaker 1we could retry her exactly as charged. Again, that's three counts of first-degree murder. In Massachusetts, a first-degree murder conviction is a mandatory life sentence without parole. And here's a detail that actually, I mean, it very much does matter. In Massachusetts, you cannot waive a jury on a first-degree murder charge. So this is a jury trial no matter what. same experts, same psychiatrists, same evidence. The jury pool has now been marinating in this case for over a year. Okay.

Speaker 1Lest we not forget the amount of impact that this case had on every single social media platform in the degree. I remember one day, I think it was on threads or something and well on Twitter slash X, Lindsey Clancy was training every single day throughout the entirety of the trial. That was like a top hashtag. And then also on threads. I think I looked one day at how many posts or threads were written about it. And it was like 182,000 from 24 hours of people talking about this case. So

Speaker 1my entire point here is where the fuck are they going to find a non-tainted jury pool or someone who hasn't already made up their mind in this when like every household in America has been discussing this? Now, option two, we can drop it to second degree murder and second degree murder in mass still carries life, but with parole eligibility. The Commonwealth would essentially be conceding that she didn't act within the deliberate premeditation that they argued the first go around. And here's why the defense might like this option. Once

Speaker 1first degree is off the table. Lindsay could choose a bench trial instead of a jury, which is exactly why Reddington keeps saying that he wants Judge Sullivan. Judge Sullivan sat through every single minute of the first trial. Sullivan heard every expert, every witness, everything. And Sullivan is the one who said that the case had enough evidence to go to a jury. But he's also watched 11 of 12 jurors land on not criminally responsible. Option three, manslaughter.

Speaker 1Up to 20 years in state prison, This would basically be the prosecution saying, yeah, she killed them, but without malice. And it's the kind of charge that becomes a plea deal conversation. Personally, I don't see that happening. Option four, we have an agreed disposition. The Commonwealth of Mass basically stops fighting the insanity question. a judge enters a finding of not criminally responsible, and then Clancy goes into the custody of the Department of Mental Health under a civil commitment statute where she is evaluated, then committed, then she'll

Speaker 1be reviewed periodically. She can be held for as long as she's considered dangerous because of mental illness, which, I mean, for someone who's killed three children during a psychotic episode, could very well be for the rest of her life. People here are not guilty by the reason of insanity and think that that immediately means that the court doors open and they you know, skip out like um nicole kidman after her divorce from the divorce from tom cruise remember those pictures her hands up in the air and she's just kind of like skipping down the road that's how people think when people get off for not reason

Speaker 1you know not guilty reason of insanity no that is not how it works she could still potentially be there the rest of her life it just depends now what i think I don't think Lindsay Clancy should be retried at all. And I'm not saying that because I don't think what happened to Cora Dawson and Callen matters. It's the only thing that matters in this entire case. But I am saying it because a retrial doesn't do anything for them. This is going... If you live in Massachusetts, you should be fucking pissed that this is even an option on the table. This is going to cost millions

Speaker 1of dollars to the Commonwealth of Massachusetts. And an enormous amount of money to accomplish what? Lindsay Clancy is in a goddamn wheelchair. She is clearly not going to be popping out kids with anybody else anytime soon. Like, my God. And think about also what a retrial actually is. 11 of 12 people sat through six weeks of evidence and decided that she was not criminally responsible. A retrial isn't the state discovering brand new evidence like, oh, shit, look what we just found. It's the state going shopping for

Speaker 112 people who agree with the one. And again, think about who pays for this. Second jury pool, hundreds of people, they're pulled out of their lives. You know, I've already talked about the finances of all of this, but we have weeks of a superior court courtroom. We have court officers and sheriffs and clerks, the team of prosecutors from a district attorney's office, nonetheless, right? That also has other cases, other victims, other families, expert witnesses on both sides, forensic psychiatrists. Also, by the way, they don't testify for free. They are

Speaker 1heavily credentialed and charge a premium rate. Also, the judge is retiring in June. And then also, whatever the verdict is, years and years and years of appeals. Again, all paid for by Massachusetts taxpayers. And like I just said, y'all, the part that just really grinds my gears is that Lindsay Clancy isn't going anywhere. And I don't mean that, I mean that figuratively and literally, I guess. Like, she's paralyzed. She is in a state psychiatric hospital right now. under the Commonwealth's care, on the Commonwealth's dime, if she's convicted,

Speaker 1the state pays to hold her in a prison. If she's found not criminally responsible, the state pays to hold her in a psychiatric facility. Either way, she's going to be in a state building being paid for. The state will be paying. She's not walking out of it because she can't. The only thing that a second trial is going to decide is which building it's going to take place in. That's it. And what it says on the door and what the charges will be. Massachusetts is going to spend April fortune in taxpayer money to argue that.

Speaker 1And then meanwhile, look at what this case has done to everyone around it. After the mistrial, Patrick Clancy, obviously the father, the children's father, said that through his, he said it through his lawyers, that he hoped to avoid a retrial. The man who lost all three of his children, that's who doesn't want to go through this again. And his family is getting dragged anyway because of picmiches and the true crime community all over the internet trying to come up with these batshit insane conspiracy theories. Which brings me to this, all right? I don't know if you guys heard, but a Florida woman named Shauna Gramko, who's

Speaker 146 years old, she lives in Sanford, Florida, has been charged with felony unlawful wiretapping in Massachusetts. Police say that back in August during the trial, she called Christopher Clancy, who's Patrick's father, and he was a witness in the case. And she recorded him without his knowledge and posted the audio on Instagram. According to the police report, the clip opens with her telling viewers that Patrick's phone number came out at trial and that somebody decided just to give him a call. Christopher Clancy told the police that he doesn't remember knowingly talking to anyone about those topics on

Speaker 1the phone, that he never agreed to be recorded. And by the way, Massachusetts is an all party consent state. So if you record someone without their permission, bitch, you just copped a felony. Now, Grimko has been charged. She hasn't been arraigned yet. She's due in court later this month. She's, you know, I have to do the preface of she's presumed innocent until proven guilty, all that. But according to reporting, she's kept posting since the charge. Y'all, she keeps posting. She said that they just want to silence her. And instead,

Speaker 1her voice got amplified. Ma'am, ma'am, the only thing getting amplified is your legal bill here, all right? Because you are putting yourself into a world of shit. Reporting also says that her account repeatedly pushed the narrative and theory that Patrick Clancy was somehow responsible for the kid's death. And I'm going to say this and probably more clearly than I've ever said anything in my entire life on this show. That theory is bullshit. All right. There is absolutely no real evidence. Lindsay Clancy's own defense never disputed that she killed the children. Patrick Clancy came home to that, came home to that. Now, I don't, I mean, people

Speaker 1want to talk about that he was an absent father, possibly he was cheating, he wasn't helpful to Lindsay, he didn't really throw his weight around the house or with the kids. None of that is relevant, all right? The bottom line is that we know what happened the night that the children died. We know exactly what happened. That is not in dispute. So any person still pushing that bullshit theory is literally just harassing Patrick Clancy, a grieving father, trying to farm engagement or something else. I'm just, I'd

Speaker 1be over that shit. But so that is what a jury, you know, pool retrial would draw from, right? We have not only that, but like Nancy Mace, the bad shit insane congresswoman, right? She publicly called for Lindsay Clancy to be executed, executed in a state that doesn't have the death penalty. I mean, that's pretty much on par for Nancy Mace. But Nancy Mace looked at Massachusetts law, saw no death penalty and was like, don't worry, I'll bring my own. Sit down, shut the fuck up. Now, let me give you the other side really quickly so you

Speaker 1have it. The Commonwealth's position. All right. We're talking about the state here. And you're going to see this in columns this week, most likely as well, is that three children were killed. A jury never reached a verdict and that justice for the kids requires the state to try it. There is a real argument, y'all, that if you let an 11 to 1 hang decide the case, that you're letting the jury's majority overrule the law that requires a unanimous verdict. I understand that argument. I don't think it's insane. I don't think it's crazy. I just think that it loses to reality. You know what I mean? Because every single possible outcome of a second trial is going to

Speaker 1end with this woman in state custody, some type, prison or mental health facility, for a very, very long time, possibly forever. The children are gone. Sad but true. And they aren't helped by a second, you know, trial of their deaths being picked apart on a live stream. There are better ways to spend that money in Plymouth County that would actually better off its citizens. So resolve it. Make an agreed disposition. Get it done before the judge retires. OK,

Speaker 1stop the fucking circus. I am begging all of you. But in any case, that is coming on November 16th. And I will obviously be hot on that update there. Now, last piece here, guys, and I wanna just really quickly brief on the Olney house. Again, as I stated earlier, there is no new evidence, just a lot of very, very, very strange shit happening. So let's finally pivot away from Massachusetts, my future home, and let's go to Philadelphia. So I'm

Speaker 1not gonna, I think everybody at this point knows what the Olney house includes, right? So lest we not forget that inside the home They found hard drives with more than a million photos and videos. Police say there's a video of R.C. Horsch apparently strangling a woman, possibly to death. They believe it is. And they say that images show several women alive in the house and then appearing dead. Several missing women have been tied to the house. Police believe that five of them died or were killed inside the home. They've identified 58 people so far from the

Speaker 1digital files from hundreds. And police say that most of them are alive. Police and the FBI wrapped up a three-week search of the property last week. And again, let me scream this from the rooftops. No human remains have been found. They're currently waiting on test results from various areas around the inside of the home that they have swamped. So the son, Eugene Horsch, is currently in federal custody on federal charges involving firearms, the fake federal credentials. He has not been charged with anything connected to the missing women.

Speaker 1His lawyer has said that he didn't even know what was going on in the basement and that they're currently negotiating with the U.S. Attorney's Office. There has not been a trial for him yet, and that is currently where we are there. So no new physical evidence this week, but what we got instead was paper, court records being unsealed at the request of the Philadelphia Inquirer, and a trail of letters and testimony from R.C. Horsh's family and the people who lived around him, okay? And frankly, to be perfectly honest, it is the most unhinged fucking collection

Speaker 1of character references I have ever read in my entire life. In my entire life. I mean, they quite literally read y'all like five stars. You know, R.C. Horsch, I give him five stars. Very repentant. Very nice. Would absolutely counterfeit with again. But that's literally how these read. So let's start in 1985. R.C. Horsch had been the federal government's problem child since the Nixon administration. In 1974, the Secret Service actually arrested him for counterfeit $ 10 bills. He spent

Speaker 1two years in prison. In 1977, the DEA raided a garage in Huntington Park and found what they said was a meth lab. He'd been buying lab chemicals under the name Richard Harris. And instead of facing that case, he hauled ass. First California, then went to New Zealand. And in New Zealand, he worked as a chemist under a fake identity, Mr. Stanley Stokowski. And that definitely sounds, you know, fake as fuck. But that is where he met his wife, Anna. Now, they married in 1980 and they had a son. You

Speaker 1guessed it, baby Eugene. They had Eugene the next year. He ended up getting caught in Orlando because, of course, it was Florida. He got caught in 1984, and he pleaded guilty to manufacturing meth. And before sentencing, the family wrote to the judge. And his father, Raymond Horsh Sr., wrote that they were a close-knit, law-abiding, religious family, and, quote, our only son has been the first ever to tarnish our family. He told the judge that his son was truly repentant. His wife, Anna, wrote that she could assure

Speaker 1the court that there would be no recurrence of illegal activity. No recurrence of illegal activity from R.C. Horsch. Okay. And then R.C. wrote his own letter, praying for a punishment that would spare his wife and child and what small future they had left. Right? There was also a psychological eval that was done in 1985 at the public defender's request. It took four hours, and it kind of reads like the opening of some sort of crime drama. The psychologist described him as highly intelligent, suspicious, and controlling. He told

Speaker 1her he couldn't answer questions honestly. He told her he was suspicious of her. He told her that he couldn't stand being out of control. His IQ tested at 140. He'd held more than 20 jobs in 20 years, including... chemist computer analyst photographer when the psychologist asked for his three wishes he said not to go to jail and to be with his family to live as a hermit and deal with society only on his own terms and then third to understand quantum physics better wish number two is just you know like an incel dating profile bio

Speaker 1like for real though so chemistry computers photography a retired FBI profiler who grew up just a couple blocks from that house, and Olney looked at the list and pointed out that, you know, that's everything that investigators are digging through in the house right now. Chemistry, computers, photography. Like, that sums up the case, and that's been his primary interest since the 80s. The psychologist remended supervised probation and wrote that more prison might just make him more hostile. And he got a few years, got like two or three years, and he was out by 1987. So, we're making the jump from 1987 to 2009. In March of 2009, R.C.

Speaker 1Horsch was arrested in Kensington. He was accused of trying to lure a nine-year-old girl into his Jeep. Inside the Jeep, police reported binoculars, a long photo lens, and a condom. He was convicted of a misdemeanor in 2010 and then got a new trial. And when the trial didn't come back to testify a second time, the charges were withdrawn. And his record was expunged. That same summer, a woman staying in his house in Chalfont in Bucks County called

Speaker 1911 about a possible burglar. Police didn't find a burglar, but they did find the 455 marijuana plants in the basement and two sawed-off shotguns. Federal case, it was. And as a felon with guns and a massive grow operation, he faced a mandatory sentence of 20 years. He got four and a half. Four and a half fucking years. But because R.C. Horsch became a cooperating witness for the federal government, they, you know, it's because he became a

Speaker 1witness that he was given so many chances, you guys. He gave prosecutors information about child prostitution, about cocaine and marijuana trafficking, about fraud rings. Prosecutors described his information as truthful and reliable. And in the same record say it wasn't sufficient to prosecute anyone. Investigators couldn't even identify the targets connected to the alleged child sex crimes because of how guarded R.C. Horsch's contact was with them. So essentially what happened is that the government gave a man, R.C. Horsch,

Speaker 1who was, again, accused of trying to lure a child into his car and also had a condom. They gave him an enormous sentencing break in exchange for information about child prostitution. And his information led to absolutely nothing and fucking no one in absolute zilch. Not a single human being was charged or even investigated. No one, not a single person. What are we even doing? The federal prosecutor fighting to keep part of that file seal said, and I find this almost poetic in its bluntness, Raymond Horsch is dead. Yes. Like his point though, was that the

Speaker 1fact of, The R.C. Horse's cooperation, none of this shit needs to be hidden anymore. The man dead. But he's still fighting to keep the details of what Horse told them sealed. And I want to know why. Now, Nicole Fasaro's cousin, his name is Jonathan Halloran-Corin, called that sentence absolutely insane. And keep in mind that Nicole Fasaro is one of the missing women. Investigators say that she's the woman in the video who was murdered. And her cousin said that You know, he could have been in jail and Nicole would still be alive. And that is true, right?

Speaker 1Had R.C. Horsch been in jail, Nicole Fasaro could potentially still be alive in this story. That is who this paper trail and why this information coming out, even though to us, it doesn't seem like it's a terrible big deal of him being a witness, but it actually could potentially have hurt people. So some other stuff new from this week here. The transcript from his 2012 sentencing came out on Tuesday. Now, in it, his lawyer, a man by the name of Jerome Brown, the same lawyer who now represents Eugene, okay, he's, this is a better call

Speaker 1Saul type of situation here. He told the federal judge that R.C. Horsch had been working on a documentary about prostitution and heroin addiction in Kensington. And that Horsch even had a letter from Mayor John Street saying, essentially, hey, don't arrest him. He's doing something good here. He's a letter, y'all. from the mayor of Philadelphia, telling cops not to arrest R.C. Horsch. A literal hall pass. Like, R.C. Horsch was a seventh grader who needed to piss during the middle of a class. Right? No.

Speaker 1He was a grown-ass man who was into horrible, insane things. Now, no one has actually seen this letter. The inquirer, who's been hot on this case, I know it's so bizarre to say that out loud, the inquirer hasn't reviewed it. And Mayor Street didn't respond to the inquiry about it either. But his son, who is State Senator Sharif Street, said that it was out of character for his father and said of R.C. Horsch, quote, it sounds like he made up a fake letter. Which, considering this man, you know,

Speaker 1forged passports, IDs, he actually forged money as well, counterfeiting. Like, obviously his son got pulled over with a fake federal badge. I would say that, you know, history could be repeating itself. I'd say that that is a fair assumption, potentially. But Philadelphia police say that they do not issue letters like that to filmmakers. So they don't understand why that would have happened. But I mean, if he was a federal witness or who knows. But the creepy part is that a former Philadelphia prosecutor told the paper that she remembers

Speaker 1a different lawyer for Horsch presenting a similar letter, like an actual physical letter that she saw with her own peepers. at his 2010 sentencing in the child luring case. Something presented is coming from someone high up in city hall or the police department. And it was to be shown to cops if he ever got stopped in Kensington. She said that it was handed to the judge and relied on for sentencing. That record is now expunged and sealed. The inquirer does have a hearing on November 10th to try to get it reopened. So we have six more

Speaker 1days before the inquirer tries to take a stab at it. So either way, The mayor of Philadelphia wrote a hall pass for a violent criminal and pornographer or R.C. Horsch forged one and walked it into a court and a judge believed it. Honestly, I don't know which one is more impressive and I don't know which one is worse. OK, so either way, someone screwed this up in a spectacular fucking fashion. But I also do want to talk about something that made me a really bit sad is that is at the 2012 sentencing, a woman stood up to

Speaker 1speak for him. It was his then ex-wife, Amy McHale. And she told the judge that she'd been a paralegal for five years. She said that he took her in. He encouraged her to get help for her addictions. He helped her get into Pierce College. He supported her in every single way that he could. She said that he'd seen him help other girls in her position and that sometimes girls would come and stay. Well, Amy McHale went missing in 2016. Her family says that she was last seen at that house. She's one of the seven women

Speaker 1In 2016, Horsch made a film called Deleted Scenes, a serial killer's video journal. A South Jersey woman who researches missing people for families found a very distressing photo of Amy in a review of that film in 2024. That's two years, guys, before the federal probe. And she sent it to Amy's daughter. And then she sent it to the Philadelphia police. She says that a detective told her that R.C. Horsch's work was fiction and and that he could have just photographed Amy as a model. No search

Speaker 1warrant came out of that. So a woman made the complaint, sent it to police before the federal probe even started here, and police are like, nah, that's fiction. A woman that CBS Philadelphia is calling Jane Doe told them that she met Arcee and Eugene both in Camden in 2013. that she did drugs with him at the Chew Avenue house, that she blacked out and woke up with Arcee standing over her taking pictures. She says she had to lie her way out of the building and that in 2014,

Speaker 1when she was arrested for prostitution by an undercover officer, she told him about two men hurting women. She says he didn't write it down. He didn't believe her. She told him that a lot of women didn't bother reporting it because they figured no one would believe them. And that officer said, She had the name. They were able to trace it and they found the officer and the officer did not respond to CBS. So just to tie this up here, guys, federal prosecutors called R.C. Horsch credible. A judge apparently accepted a letter that nobody can find,

Speaker 1that nobody knows that even really exists. And the woman who well, I can't say woman, the women who came forward over the last 20 years and said these men are fucking dangerous. They were told that it was fictional or it was art. So again, we are still waiting on that to come back. But that is the episode for today, guys. Again, Matthew Farwell's defense is set to rest today. I will have an update episode on that tomorrow, just in case something crazy happens. We have closings on Friday. And when that jury goes out, y'all, you'll hear about it right here. I'm very, very interested to see what

Speaker 1the jury is going to do with that hyoid bone. Because again, as I said earlier, you know, that leaves doubt. If we don't have a definitive answer to how that hyoid bone broke, everything else, I mean, there's a lot of doubt. Like there really could potentially be. I mean, obviously women, we all know, you know, or assume, I can't say that we know, but you get my drift, right? Like I think that based on their conversations, based on the timing, based on things that we've seen, based on him wearing the mask, we can reasonably come to a

Speaker 1conclusion that he probably did it. But the jury has to also come to that conclusion. But is there doubt? So I don't know, but we will see. And then again, Lindsay Clancy will be back on the 16th. Lori Vallow is waiting on the Idaho Supreme Court, which I'm sure she is totally handling with calm and no prophecy whatsoever. I wonder if Chad still comes to visit her in her cell via projection. I don't know. But then lastly, Philadelphia, the next hearing is November 10th, which is going to

Speaker 1determine whether the child luring file gets unsealed for the public. Also that letter apparently from the mayor, if it exists, it's finally going to see daylight and that is going to be a very big deal. So, Beyond that, guys, if you want any extra episodes, you want ad-free episodes, Patreon is just $ 5 a month, unlimited ad-free episodes, and then also occasional Patreon-only episodes, you can find that on Patreon at wesawthedevil, wesawthedevil.com, and wesawthedevilpodcast for Instagram, for the

Speaker 1official show page, robin _ _ wstd if you want to follow me personally, the food that I eat, the pets that I have, the wife that I hang out with. On threads, it's wesawthedevilpodcast. On x slash Twitter, it's wesawthedevil. Facebook, We saw the devil as well. And then lastly, TikTok is we saw the devil. True crime. For those of you who are the same political persuasion as me, enjoy your blue hangover babies. Okay. Make sure you stay hydrated. Try not to have too much sex. Take care of yourselves. Like it is a glorious day. All right. For other

Speaker 1people who don't like it, I guess. you need to get busy. Okay. Pick your gender, pick the color of your litter box. Like how many abortions do you want to get this week? These are the important questions that we need to figure out. All right. So you're in my thoughts though, but that's all for today, guys. Again, thank you for listening again. If you want to reach out, if you have a case request, if you have a correction, a question, you want to tell me how awful I am. You can do that. You can email info at we saw the double.com. I've been incredibly busy the last couple of weeks, as I mentioned on the patron only episode, but,

Speaker 1I will be getting back to people who have reached out. But you can always reach out to me there. That's it for today, y'all. Until next crime.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. KJ Biermann and Kim Zolciak: Raised on Bravo, Charged as an Adult

    Nov 19, 20261 hr 41 minAudio

    KJ Biermann, the 15-year-old son of Kim Zolciak and former Falcons linebacker Kroy Biermann, is charged with seven felonies in Fulton County, Georgia. Prosecutors say he sexually assaulted a classmate at an Alpharetta...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. The Do-Over: Why Massachusetts Is Retrying Lindsay Clancy (And Should They?)

    Nov 18, 20261 hr 5 minAudio

    Eleven of twelve jurors were ready to find Lindsay Clancy not guilty by reason of insanity. In Massachusetts, the state has to prove a defendant was sane. It didn’t. So the Plymouth County DA is trying her again: same...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. The Internet Thinks You’re Guilty: Charlie Kirk, The Idaho 4, Lindsay Clancy & the Boston Bombing

    Nov 14, 20261 hr 35 minAudio

    Internet sleuths, TikTok true crime, and Reddit "detectives" keep naming the wrong person, and innocent people pay for it. Robin goes scorched earth on the mob, from the Boston Marathon bombing to the Idaho murders, the...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Mica Miller: "Dismissed Without Prejudice" (Part Two)

    Nov 12, 202644 minAudio

    March 11, 2024. In a single day, Mica Miller found a deflation device in her tire, was followed to a gas station and then a car dealership, got calls from numbers she’d already blocked, told an officer she was afraid...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Roundup: Matthew Farwell Convicted, Russell Brand Sentenced & Sonia Exelby’s Trial Begins

    Nov 11, 20261 hr 21 minAudio

    Russell Brand is going to prison, Lindsay Clancy is going back to trial, and a former cop is finally a convicted killer. Then the full story of Sonia Exelby, before her trial and before the internet can get it wrong...

    Credit the people on this episode