In this episode of War Against Weeds, Tommy Butts is joined by Joe Ikley (North Dakota State University) and Tom Barber (University of Arkansas) to discuss how fall-applied herbicides fit into weed management programs across very different environments. The conversation covers glyphosate-resistant Italian ryegrass, kochia, wild oat, and waterhemp, with a focus on herbicide timing, residual activity, and product selection. They also discuss research findings, farmer adoption of fall programs, and explore how cover crops, crop rotation, and weather impact herbicide performance. Transcript: https://app.box.com/s/odey5jljte1aewvjyrflj1f30365le6y
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Tommy Butts: Welcome back to the War Against Weeds podcast. My name is Tommy Butts. I'm an extension weed scientist with Purdue University, and today I have the privilege of being joined by mr. Joe Ikley from North Dakota State University, as well as Dr. Tom Barber down at the University of Arkansas, and we are going to talk about some fall applied herbicides and attacking those various things, various weeds that we have out there. So, before we get too far down into that topic, Joe, Tom,
you want to say hi, introduce yourselves. Anything along those lines? Joe Ikley: Yeah, I can go first since I'm I'm a dual role citizen today. So our administrators say we should do more with less these days. So I am co-host and an interviewee today. So no need for much of a further introduction for myself. Just yeah, up at NDSU, weeds are still a problem. Tom Barber: Oh well, that's that's good and nice job security, right? Joe Ikley: Oh yeah, plenty of that. Tom Barber: Weeds are a problem. They need weed scientists, I
guess. So, well, hello everybody. I'm Tom Barber, Extension Weed Sinus from the University of Arkansas. I've been on the podcast a couple of times, I think so. I don't know if you need any more introduction than that, Tommy. But I'm good with I'm good with leaving it right there. Tommy Butts: Sounds good. You don't need any introduction, right, Tom? You are the Tom Barber. Tom Barber: That's whatever. Yeah, whatever that means. That and $5 won't buy you a happy meal at McDonald's. So
Tommy Butts: All right. Well, so to kick off the podcast, I figured we'd just kind of since we we've got stark environments right between you two the the white north up there by Joe who maybe has snow already who knows and then the hot humid south down there by you Tom who you just said it was you know cool today being under 100. I figured we could just start off with each one of you maybe telling us where fall applied herbicides are kind of fitting and like what weeds you're targeting. So
I'll just I'll throw it to you first, Tom, because I figured the fall applied residuals and herbicides have really started more in the south and they've started making their way more north. But maybe if you want to start and just give us a little insight, you know what's being used, why, what weeds you're targeting, kind of thing. Tom Barber: Yeah, and so Tommy, you know down here, I'll just throw the mid south in as a whole. A lot of this really started probably in in Mississippi, I'll say many years ago, and it all revolves around glyphosate-resistant Italian
ryegrass. At least that's when it started. With Roundup not working on our ryegrass populations in the spring, they're really hard to kill with with other chemicals. And just throwing a select or or something in the tank sometimes doesn't always work out when we're talking about burn down in March, and so the the drive for those fall applications is probably really ryegrass. At least it is. I know in Arkansas and probably most of the mid south, Italian ryegrass has just
blown up. As you know, when you were here, I mean it was becoming a major problem several years ago, and so you know, I'll say for the last 10 years we've been dealing with it significantly, probably a little earlier than that. But currently, from north to south, there's really no difference. Raw grass is going to be there when we get done, and we're in a position where the last several years we've got our crops planted pretty early, and so assuming harvest goes well,
we're harvesting beans and corn and rice, all of it right now. We look to get done in a timely fashion, you know, barring any environmental catastrophes, so hurricanes or other things, and so we'll have a lot of time when that ground's just laying out there wide open. Once these temperatures start fluctuating, we'll start seeing germination. And so, because of the resistance issues, the best methods we have for control is
by not allowing it to come up in the fall and early spring. And I don't know. I don't want to talk too much here on this topic right away, anyway. But one thing we're seeing, so I did my master's project in ryegrass about I don't know 30 years ago, and back then we used to get one great big flush in the fall, and if you could go out there and take care of that flush with disc in or tillage or Roundup or something, you really got on top of it, and you didn't have to deal with a lot to wait maybe
one more in the spring. But now we're seeing I don't know as many or five or six flushes, probably more in the spring, starting in January, depending on the temperatures and the temperature fluctuation, all the way through. April. I mean, again, depending on temperatures, so it's a little different animal. It's adapted a little bit to our farming practices, our typical farming practices, and so we're we're trying to approach it in a little different fashion. But that's why it started with those Italian ryegrass populations.
Tommy Butts: I'll circle back to your comments there too about the like the spring emergence and then some of these fall applications. But Joe, do you want to quick give a brief update on like North Dakota and what y'all are targeting and things like that? Joe Ikley: Yes, we don't have ryegrass, or I guess I should say I we confirmed our first population this year about a week after I was on another podcast and said I don't have rye grass, I got some pictures. So we've we got one population that I know of. So ours is kind of a whole different mindset. I
guess if you want to go all the way back through history land, I mean we we have done fall applications for Canada thistle, foxtail barleys are important perennial grass up here that we get better control of that in the fall with glyphosate, but that's not what we typically discuss with fall applications. So there's it's really two different mindsets, and for some people, it's unfortunately a balancing act for both. So we have several no-till producers, and and we do want that fall application of just like a glyphosate 2,4-D. Take out some
marestail, narrowleaf hawksbeard is another aster we have. So some of those winter annual weeds, we have some of that. Those guys also have winter annual bromes. Would be our our overwintering grass of of challenge, and we have some applications going out for those as well. But the the vast majority of the acres, I'll just do the majority, maybe not the vast majority, of the acres. We've been going with fall applications for 10-15, or years or longer now, and a lot of that is to target our spring annual weeds or summer annual weeds
that emerge early. So it really started with a heavy emphasis of flumioxazin in the fall to catch early emerging kochia, and why flumioxazin ? Well, for us, it was effective at the time, and it's a relatively insoluble herbicide, and so our goal was to kind of get something like that out in the fall, catch the winter precipitation to help activate it, and it's going to work a little bit better in that case, and our springs can rain can be so variable. Some of those less soluble herbicides we
just found have worked better in the fall than in the spring, when we kind kind of get the whole winter to collect some precipitation. Now, if kochia has long been the target, then as we got resistance to flumioxazin, we have been looking at other things, and some one the focus was pyroxasulfone. Out of the group 15 s are probably our least soluble one. So looking at that in the fall for kochia, then also realizing well that's also a pretty decent wild oat product, but we can often not get good wild oat control in the
spring with pyroxasulfone, but we see much better results in the fall. And so, the last couple years, it's been kind of a heavy focus on using the fall or residual, if you want to use the main name brand. But we're about to have 30 or 40 name brands on the shelf here. So then, last year, the question came up: All right, I'm doing it for my kochia, my wild oat. I'm going to have my fall there. What can I expect on waterhemp? And my answer at that time was, I really don't know. We have no
data, so I can give you a guess, and we'll get into this later. But my guess would have been wrong. So really, it's allowed these residual herbicides to target our summer annual weeds. Is is kind of the how we focus on it a lot, but we still do have these acres. We we catch our winter annual grasses and focus on the perennials as well. Tommy Butts: So just why we're on that topic, and this will tie
Joe Ikley: Yep. So historically, we will go. We'll say sometime in October is, and it's always a moving scale up here because we want to get it as close to ground freeze up as possible. Some years that might be mid October, some years a little bit later. So it can be a bit of a balancing act of when we can get that out. And our main goal is there there is to get it out in the fall, late enough in the fall, so we don't have any degradation. But of course, we can't apply it to frozen soil. So you know maybe right before a big snowstorm or something is
when we're targeting in mid October to late October to make that application. In the spring, then again, always varies by year, but I'll say April is probably the average time that kochia and wild oat will start to emerge. Warm spring, it might be March. A late spring, it might be May. We've had springs where we still have snow cover until the early part of May, so we'll just say on average April, and then to to set the stage later for waterhemp, our waterhemp starts about the middle part of May, and like everyone else's waterhemp, we
still have germination going now into late August. Tommy Butts: Okay, so Tom, then just to come back to you with your timescales, you know, when are you typically seeing guys apply fall herbicides, or when are you recommending for those? And then you mentioned kind of these new flushes that might be January, February. Have you seen that these fall applied residuals are helping with those flushes? Are they played out? You know what's that timeline and and residual kind of look like for y'all down there? Tom Barber: Well, I think so. The timeline is somewhere
between october 15 and november 15 on on average. I mean, it can change. Last October, we didn't get hardly any rain at all, so we were like, just don't put it out. Let's just wait till we get some moisture, and we may be there again. I don't know. So on average, I try to shoot for November one. That's statewide. That you know, that's a big paintbrush. It doesn't always work that way. But you know how long they work, and and the timing really depends on whichever one you select. You
know, for us, for again, our target is rye grass. Now, there's some other things we can go after, but the big one is rye grass for us, and especially on fields that we're planting are going to be put in an early season crop like rice or corn, especially a grass crop, right? And so, we definitely want those fields void of any ryegrass when we drop the planter in there in in March, so we're gonna try to use something that's gonna last
you know long enough to get us through that March window. The group 15 s for rye grass work fairly good. There is a pecking into Tom's comments too, with like the January February order in those. The peroxisulphone or zidua is germinating ryegrass and stuff. Can you put more of a timescale probably the best of the group 15 s for ryegrass, and then but on what you were just talking about, Joe. Like, so when are you trying to, especially kochia, since you said you've been doing this forever, right? When was that typical fall s-metolachlor, you know, at a pint and a half or something, usually gets used the most because of price, and then we application going out, and when was your early germinating kochia that you were talking about? throw valor in there because why not? It's two bucks, so and it picks up all the other things, and so if but if we just went
we'll have several people try four ounces of valor because it's so cheap okay and that will you know honestly it's pretty good on rye grass till you get to about January and then we start to lose it if we've had enough rain and so it but it will hold everything else Broadleaf wise, you know, through March, and so four ounces of Valor is really good and really cheap, unless your main target is ryegrass. And so for us, and so you know, if we put that Valor, Duel or Valor,
s-metolachlor combo out mid October, and we use the right rates, and we get the right moisture. We can that will last us till you know through March anyway, usually. But the one I like the best is Command Clomazone. It's got great activity on ryegrass, even if the ryegrass is up. We seem to get some reach back with clomazone. The problem with that is it's going to be a little more expensive than the Valor,
s-metolachlor combo. You know, some crops like corn we we need to watch out, and maybe cotton. Although I haven't seen that much issue planting cotton behind that, but you just kind of have to know what you're rotating to, and sometimes that's the biggest question because nobody knows until March. Tommy Butts: Yeah, just to circle back to the ryegrass problem too. I know there's been multiple. I think you were on a podcast in the past with War Against Weeds talking about the ryegrass situation too. But just to emphasize that point, like
you mentioned, trying to get ahead of the thing, especially in the grass crops, rice and corn, because essentially once those crops are up, I mean, do you have any options in rice and corn whatsoever to try and get rid of ryegrass? Then Tom Barber: it's very difficult. the The glyphosate resistance, the ALS resistance, is widespread. We just did a great big screening study. Finally, finalized that one up. We do have some populations that are clethodim resistant, but the problem with clethodim or select anyway is the plant backs to
corn and rice, and so you kind of have to have a good game plan in place if you're going to use that. You got to use it early, and it doesn't work that great when it's cold outside. So, you know, paraquats are option unfortunately right now that we have if it's up. With all the issues we hear nationally about paraquat, I don't know how long that one's going to continue to be an option. So we definitely, but that timing is critical, like you say, Tommy. I mean, because if it gets up out of the ground, we that's one. Reason I like command a lot is because if
it's small raw grass and we have moisture, we can get some reach back on it and it will help control. So, Tommy Butts: just speaking of command, I think this ties into my next question a little bit too, and then we can I'll throw it to you then after this too, Joe. But rates that you're using, right? So rates for command. We're talking about pyroxasulfone too, the Valor component. How is that working with label restrictions on you know season use limits? So I
guess this multi-fold question here. You know, when do those seasons run? Right, is it calendar year? Is it you know fall to spring, that kind of stuff. Are you running into label restrictions? And I mentioned command, like when you were talking about that, because I know when I was down there, right? That's a massive one for rice production that we want in season. And so, if we start using it in the fall, is it going to be issues then the following spring? Because we're going to run up against season use limits. So I'll start with you on that, Tom, and then I'll throw it to you, Joe, too. If y'all are running into any issues there,
Tom Barber: so yeah, so especially on command, you know, Tommy, we as you've been down here, you know, I mean, we get I think 34 ounces of command. You have to keep me honest on that. I can't remember off top of my head, but it's something like that. Tommy Butts: That sounds right. It's been a couple years, but that sounds right. Yeah, Tom Barber: and so it can be a problem. When does it start? When when do the use patterns start? I don't know. That may be a gray area. I don't know that the labels completely spell that out every time. Just says per season. Well, you know, I guess
a season is I consider a season probably starting in the spring and ended in in the fall. I don't know, but but everybody's going to have probably a definition of that. So we do have to be careful, and you know, on some of our lighter soils, generally is where we're going to have a tremendous amount of ryegrass anyway. So we can use a lighter rate to help us get away from some of those season limits. And with Valor, we've shifted to like in our soybeans, we have made a shift to where we're using a lot of Group 15 Metro using combos pre,
so like a boundary or generic form thereof, right? And so, you know, Valor, we're trying to move in that fall or spring burn down window because I really like if we're you know just going to lay out a program here. I really like using two ounces in the fall and coming back with an early burn down sometime in February with two more ounces, and that gets into helping us with some of our spring weeds that Joe was talking about earlier. But you know, getting trying to get two applications
out, especially if the if it's bare ground, you know, good luck. We have hard enough time getting one residual application out. So, but I don't want to skip too far ahead there. But timing is a big deal. Selection is a big deal, and and you know, with weeds like ryegrass, where there's not that many options to control, we need to try to time it where, you know, perfect world. We spray it, then it rains, and then we don't have any up when all that happens. So, yeah, Joe Ikley: you know, rate for us has always been kind of a big
deal because one of the programs or one of the goals of the program historically would be let's put on our our fall flueoxes and our fall valor, and I want rotational flexibility because sometimes it's like, well, by the time we get to planting season, our corners out the window just because of how late it got. What can I go to next? So we generally have erred on the side of a lower rate, so two to three ounces of valor, for instance. We can we've gone as high as four in the fall in the past, but that does lock you into certain crops, and that
hasn't been too big of an issue coming back in the spring because we've then switched to sulf entry zone in the spring. More water soluble, generally a little bit better on kochia, you know, year over year than than flumioxazin would be, and that has led to questions in the past because I overload my PPOs, and we have not seen that on some of our minor crops. So going with the fall Valor Spring Spartan type of program that has led to good kochia control in the past without that crop injury that we might have been concerned about. Now two different products, so
that kind of gets around that labeling standpoint. As we've shifted to group 15. This has opened up a whole can of worms, question wise, as we're doing fall pyrox. So, okay, what if I use my maximum labeled rate in the fall? Can I then use a different group 15 at a maximum labeled rate in the spring? And of course, we're just kind of breaking into this pyroxasulfone maximum rate. So, no one wants to ask questions about that. They want to ask the next question that we don't have funding for yet to to look at is how these these discussions
always go. But you know, for the seasonal use limit, and this this has come into play as we looked more at pyroxasulfone and I'm just going to stick with the Zidual label because I know those rates off the top of my head. So for soybean, for instance, it's six and a half ounces in a calendar year. And I asked, "What is a calendar year? Because if I apply in fall of 2025, and then 2026 is a new calendar year. Local interpretation, at least, was a 12 month a 12 month window from
your first application, so if I make six and a half ounces, if I apply that november 1, I really can't apply any more until november 2, the following year. So that that's that was a local interpretation that I got on that, and and so we've been working within kind of those constraints. Rate has been a challenge in Pyrox. I mean, we we don't like to spend a lot of money in this geography, especially in the fall. So historically, it's been a little bit more expensive product. So if we want three and a quarter ounces fluid residuals, kind of
the standard rate, we can get some folks up to four in the fall. We've tried six and a half. To no surprise, the higher the rates, the better the weed control in the spring. But it has become a cost question in the past, and with the price point coming down now, that we expect we might see more folks go with a higher rate. So some of the things we started messing around this year for the waterhemp question specifically was using that maximum labeled rate, but breaking it out across seasons. So we looked at three and a quarter in the fall, three
and a quarter at soybean planting, or four in the fall versus two and a half at soybean planting. So a couple different ways to get to that six and a half ounce maximum seasonal limit. That that's kind of where we've shifted towards waterhemp with some pretty interesting results, but I'd say historically three and a three and a quarter to four is kind of a goal in the fall to help get that early flush of kochia and wild oat and or wild oat, and then if we needed to save the rest for in crop for whatever other weeds we might be going after, right? So
we do that fall historically for those early season weeds, but we still have pigweeds and and green foxtail to contend with in crops. So that's kind of been the historical look at it, breaking it out to target different weed species. Now we've kind of shifted towards a whole program for waterhemp was our current research question. Tommy Butts: I want to follow up on one thing before I'll come back to the water hemp thing too, Joe. But one thing I want to follow up on what you just said there. You mentioned like the cost, right? And then trying and getting guys to do certain things. Since you've had fall applications more consistent for
like 15 years, do you have a relatively large current adoption where guys are doing fall applied herbicides already? Like, is that a relatively high percentage of your folks that are doing that? Joe Ikley: Yeah, I don't know if I can throw a real good percentage at it, but I can tell you when it doesn't work. So my percentage of phone calls go high. So there's there's enough people that have done it on it, and especially the 2022 and 23 when we were first getting Group 14 resistant kochia, and the the
fall the fall flue oxygen that was not controlling that kochia, those phone calls really started rolling in. It's one of those things. That's when you kind of learn how high the adoption really is. I just I cannot put a number on it. It's been higher in no till areas further west, which is also an overlap with our kochia areas, wild oats were kind of regionalized in pockets, and we can tell the people that are using those, and and that's also you can tell the years it doesn't work. That's not a resistance thing, but I should have probably stated from the
beginning for kochia and wild oats, it's always kind of been a this is a starting point. You know, some years you might get 90 plus percent control. Some years it's 60. It always depends on the winter how it shakes out and things like that. So it was never expected to be a complete program, but the years it doesn't work quite as well. We we recognize that by the phone calls that roll in. So enough people that the phone line lights up in the spring. Tommy Butts: Yeah, I'd throw the same question then to you, Tom, because I know when I was down there, you know, the ryegrass
was was starting to really pick up, but trying to convince folks of doing fall applications when they thought they were done and having it added at expense in a certain year was a tough sell. So, has that changed at all in the past couple years? You know, are more guys adopting it? Are more guys open to it now? What's that looking like down there for you? Tom Barber: Well, I think we were generally increasing every year, you know, and so we we've had quite a few move to that. I had from an education standpoint, an outreach
component. We made a big push. We had a couple of webinars last fall to try to encourage people. Of course, it was a terrible fall to encourage growers to do that because they just came off of one of the worst economical years that they had had in you know recent memory, and so it was very hard to convince them to do it. We may have lost some ground. This past season, because of that, but those that did it on some acres tell me they wish they'd have done it on every acre. And you know, for
us, so the ryegrass issue is kind of unique because if you don't have a you know farm wide yet, what it does is it starts from the ditches and then it kind of moves in. And as long as we can, we had several folks. I had to talk to several growers that were just ringing around the fields, either a couple of airplane passes or a couple of you know ground rig sprayer passes, just to to protect against that encroachment from the edge of the field. And so, if you catch it early enough,
you you don't have to spend a tremendous amount of money going after rye grass just by doing that. You can really reduce the numbers. So I think it you know people want to do it, encouraging themselves to do it after harvest is a little more difficult. But we have had a tremendous adoption. And again, when when you do it, and if you put the right mix out, and you can get your ground ready after harvest, put this out, pin it on the mix, you can drop the corn planter in there in march, 1 of
March, and not do anything else. And so that you know that's pretty cheap weed control. When you talk about all the different mixtures we have to put out in the spring for our variety of winter annuals that we have. So Tommy Butts: that might be a good little transition point here too to actually talk about. I know you've hinted at it a couple times here, Joe, but and maybe I'll start with you because I know you've got some stuff, and then I'll ask you the same question, Tom. But with these fall apps, or maybe even like the sequentials, like you were talking a little bit about,
Tom. If there's if there's some potential there, are you seeing that these what I'll call you know off season applications are they working on some of these summer annual things then too? Are they at least giving us some advantage or some head start there? So you know, like you mentioned, kochia for you, Joe, maybe Palmer for you, Tom. When we get to you, that kind of thing. Are you guys seeing any advantage? Joe Ikley: Well, so I'm gonna. We've got one year of data with waterhemp, and I'm gonna put this in perspective. It's been a drought because I will probably. Well, I will be sharing this
data all winter, which means we'll probably be very wet next year, and it won't work as well, but we we still have plots here at the end of August where I can go out and look, and our soybeans never canopied because of the of the drought. But if I go with like that three and a quarter ounce of of residual in the fall, pyrox in the fall, it a looks better than a spring application at planting because we had fall by itself, spring by itself, and then the program together, I called it
overlapping residuals northern style. So rather than do the at planting end crop, let's do a fall at planting type of overlapping residual. Some of those overlapping residual plots, whether it was three and a quarter followed by three and a quarter, or four followed by two and a half, are still to this day greater than 95% control waterhemp. Now we've had four inches of rain since planting, maybe an inch before that, and it's always hard to account for our winter moisture.
It depends on where the snow is actually at when it melts, and then we get some rainfall along the way. But in that kind of dry environment, I was kind of honestly, I was blown away by how well it worked. We're really all we did was October 27 application of Pyrox, and then a may 22, and we're gonna unless we get some typhoon coming from somewhere, gonna be basically at harvest in 10 days or so with that level of control. Now, a wet year, I'm not gonna expect that high because we're gonna
get more degradation, more chances for water hemp to emerge. But within the the constraints of the the testing this year, it's worked very well on on a weed that we know emerges all year in this geography as well, or at least all all summer until sometime in late September. Tommy Butts: I mean that's impressive. That's crazy. But Tom, are you you know seeing anything along those lines with some of the summer annual stuff? Tom Barber: Probably nothing that good. We have done a little work where we're looking at fall only versus fall only followed
by spring applied versus just a typical spring burn down, and so typically for us the weeds we're going to have in the field, the first ones out of the ground from a summer annual standpoint, is rhizome Johnson grass, yellow nutsedge, and barnyard grass, some general you know annual grasses, pigweed. Our Palmer typically doesn't just hit the ground running until the end of april, 1 part of May, and most of our residuals are played out
by Palmer. One thing that we've noticed going to the you know a based fall residual or fall and spring is it's basically a release program for yellow nutsedge. Joe, I don't know if y'all have yellow nutsedge in up there where you're at, but you know that most people will see a green tinge across the field, and they just think that's grass, and they'll go out there, and it's not grass; it's yellow nutsedge. And so, Johnson grass, yellow nutsedge, those are both up when we're planting. And so,
we haven't seen a tremendous impact on any of the rhizome Johnson grass stuff yet. We've got to get that's one of our big up and coming weed is resistant Johnson grass, and we're gonna we're gonna have to make a shift to really focus on that one in the future. But with yellow nutsedge, if you just put four ounces of otter in the fall or two ounces, and then two ounces with your burn down in the spring, it'll be completely clean. You know, maybe some Johnson grass out there, but also yellow nutsedge will be everywhere. That can be a problem for us early season competition, especially in
cotton, and so it can be a problem in every crop. But we have some tools that we can use in those others that we don't have in cotton. So I recommend if we're going to move to a valor-based program, we have to have the esmatola chlor in there. Command is not great on yellow nutsedge either. That's one that it misses. And so, with the combination, or at least coming back and using an s-metolachlor in an early burn down, really helps us. It's not perfect on yellow nutsedge, but
it really knocks that population down. And so, but it will be a solid map with just a valor-only based program, and so that's not good, right? But you know, we we do see some benefit, I think, on some of our early emerging annual grasses, barnyard grass, broadly single grass, you know, crabgrass, Bermuda grass. Interestingly enough, where I get a lot of calls on Bermuda grass again, creeping in from the edges, and it's very hard to kill with any of the herbicides we have available. But by using
these fall residuals, we have really knocked that population down in a field that I thought we were just going to turn into a hay meadow or something because of all the Bermuda grass out there. So it's really helped us kind of knock those populations in the head a little bit, but for pigweed, unfortunately, I don't think it's going to be enough. I mean, we may get a very early initial flush if the temperatures warm up enough to have it germinate, but it's going to have to happen in March. If it doesn't happen in March, we're going to miss it.
Tommy Butts: Just as a side note, from a weed scientist perspective, if I take my extension cap off, I kind of miss the sedges a little bit from being down there. They were always kind of a fun weed to deal with. So I will also say, I will also say too, I'd echo your Johnson grass comment. I hear that more and more, not only like me in Indiana, but from other states too. Like that seems to be popping up a whole lot more across the country, even in the past few years. So
yeah, that seems like it's making a pretty strong comeback in some form or fashion. But Joe Ikley: you want to get a little jealous of the North. We have one confirmed sledging of Johnson grass in history, and it did not overwinter. Tommy Butts: That's excellent. Tom Barber: Yeah, I don't know. I don't know what we're going to do. I mean, it really is a. It's an increasing problem. I mean, you drive down any of the main roads just through our the Delta region, you'll see it pretty much everywhere, and all we can
do is burn it back and beat it back, and it just seems to keep coming. So, job security, job security, yeah. Tommy Butts: So I think kind of roughly the last thing, last couple things I wanted to just hit on quick, and we can wrap up the the show for today, but one thing is, I wanted to just ask both of y'all if you had any, essentially your your final recommendations, right? That you wanted to to pass out with fall applications. You know, are you typically recommending a tank mix with a post herbicide too, right? To try and catch any
initial flushes. Like I'm especially thinking the ryegrass down south, right? Like you throw in paraquat with the residual to try and knock down any potential emergence, plus get the residual. And the second part of this, as far as recommendation goes, are y'all recommending anything along the lines of like trying to use these residuals in conjunction with, say, cover crops? Right, because I know in some areas, if we leave the ground bare all winter because we apply a fall herbicide, like that's bad news bears for erosion or other things. So, I guess it's kind of a twofold question there. Just
kind of what your recommendations are as far as tank mixes and trying to pair it, you know, with anything else that might help for erosion or extra weed control. So, Tom, I think I'll throw it to you first if you want to take that away. Okay. Tom Barber: That was that was a lot of different points to cover, so don't let me get too long winded. You're welcome. But let me start with the let me start with the erosion concern, I guess. And so you know, if we're going after raw grass, so we've talked about combinations, got through talking about a lot of combinations, take out everything. If we just use a
group 15 at at the ryegrass rate is what I'll call it. We have a lot of other things come up, and so generally erosion in those like Mayweed will be one of the first things out of the ground. It seems to be like we're if we're just using group 15 s, we'll transition to having a lot of mayweed in that in that field over the winter or primrose or something else, and so we, you know, it's when we throw the valor in there that we get pretty much bare earth all winter long, and some like that,
some don't. It it does bring a you know an interesting issue with erosion if if we get a lot of rainfall. But now, what what what else? Tell me where else I didn't write all these talking points down. Tommy Butts: Well, so while you're on that topic, right? Are you recommending integrating it with cover crops and stuff, whether it's for erosion or for like ryegrass control or sweep, right? Tom Barber: As you know, when we were down here, we were doing when you were down here, we were doing a lot of work with cover crops. We still are. I mean, cover crops for us makes a lot of sense. Not that every everybody's not transitioning to
do it, but it does make a lot of sense from a pigweed control standpoint, from a conservation standpoint, water infiltration, and now with you know with the ESA and the herbicide labelings, you get extra points for being in a cover crop system, and for us that means a lot, but it is difficult managing ryegrass in a cover crop. We, a lot of people do blends, as you know, Tommy. We recommend a lot of cereal rye or wheat notes just because it's
easy to establish and it's fairly easy to terminate. At least cereal rye is, and so we've done some work with cereal rye, actually using a reduced rate of flumioxazin and if you hold your mouth right, you won't get any injury, and you'll get great ryegrass control early. I mean, for two weeks anyway, or three weeks, and that's really all we need because once that cereal rye takes off, we have a lot of competition with ryegrass there, and we can come back. We've looked, we've done work to
look at Group Fifteens. All of them post about two to three leaf cereal rye. Some cause more stunting than others, but none have completely taking out taking out a cereal rye stand. I will say so. It is it will stunt and it will reduce growth for a few weeks. Then it seems to kick back off. But if you want to try to control the ryegrass component in a cover crop, you know it's going to be you're going to have to have a little luck at the end of the day, or you're going to have some rye
grass. That's all they're into it. But you know, generally as we move forward, cover crops are getting a lot more attention with with the issues we're you know we're having in the environment we're living in with with herbicide labeling and everything else. So, Joe Ikley: Joe, I'd kick it to you then too. Like any you know along those lines, right? Like the erosion or cover crops or integrating this kind of stuff is. Do y'all have a fit with any of that, or how are you recommending around some of that stuff? So we have some of that, and and we we have played around
with cereal rye, let it come up to one or two leaf, and then do your your fall application. Kind of the goal there is to let not let the rye get too big, so more that herbicide hits the surface, and so then it's working in conjunction when the rye takes off in the spring. That has worked better than than either practiced alone, either herbicide or or cover crop. We get into this this kind of fun situation, and to extrapolate, I know earlier Tom said we always follow the label, and what can happen up here is sometimes it may start as a as a rye cover
crop, but then it looks good in the spring, so that's now the cash crop for the year. Or we go the other way. We started with the cash crop that looks like crap in the spring. Now it's just a cover crop and treat it however I want to. So that's one of the things with our our markets up here, we we kind of have a market for all sorts of crops like that, and so we don't want to do that in the case where we are taking that to grain yield because then you know the risk having some residues in there and all the other fun stuff with with those
off label applications. But when it is a true cover crop situation, the the combination has worked, and and probably one of the other things, if I circle back to one of those points that was in the questions you were asking, is how how we put it all together. That's where it does get more complex. I think you know a lot of my answers so far have been pretty. You know, here's here's this combination how it's worked on our driver weeds historically. I can tell you my Pyrox. If I would have shifted it 100 feet to the north, I would have been on a
ragweed patch, and it would have been a very poor result. And so, kind of mixing all these things together, at the end of the day, a lot of our focus is on the driver weeds: kochia, waterhemp, wild oat, but we've got all the other ones that can still be problematic and varies by geography, so you know. If I think, well, you know, what does the future look like of some of this work? We've done some mixtures in the fall. It's like a valor residual mixture in the fall, and and that, of course, will look better. But then it was, you know, how much? Where
do we want to spend our money? I guess is the ultimate question. And so maybe in the future we're doing one of those actives in the fall. We'll say it's pyroxasulfone. Then you come back with your full Monty of three active ingredients at planting. You just have to watch your rate to make sure you don't exceed the seasonal limit of what you put on in the fall to help round out the weed control program. The other just interesting balancing act we have is our dry climate. If I could have a crystal ball and weather, well, I wouldn't be
here. I'd be somewhere with a lot more money in general. But when it comes to herbicide applications, we we have years, especially the further west you go, the drier it gets. Where we've got some data, where a mid-September application looks better on kochia in the spring than a late October, because what happened between mid-September mid-October moisture caught some moisture, and then no moisture all winter. So in that case, the earlier application worked, but then again, we don't typically recommend that because we don't
want to have that pyrox or whatever herbicide degrade in the fall, we want kind of the maximum available in the spring, which I guess I didn't tease out further than enough. Yeah, up here we freeze in the winter, and so we we don't have degradation when the ground is frozen, and that's usually we'll just say on average November through March will have frozen grounds. That's four months of really no degradation. Tommy Butts: That's better than I was expecting. I figured you were going to tell me august 31 is first freeze, and then you're you know
Joe Ikley: well that can happen, Tommy. We did have a frost a week or two ago somewhere out west, so we've had frost in August, and a dry year like this, I wouldn't be surprised if we have a widespread frost sometime mid-September coming up. But truly, ground ground gets below 32 degrees and stays below 32. That's what we're talking with frozen ground all winter. That that can be about a four-month window on average. Some years it is longer. Some years we get two feet of snow and the ground doesn't freeze because we got that nice blanket all all year, so it's frozen above ground for the whole time.
But the ground itself is not frozen. Now we're not getting much degradation when the ground's 33 degrees for four months, but we can't say it's frozen with none, and and so that's kind of why we we wait for that late part in the fall to not have degradation during the whole frozen month, and then in theory, when when biology resumes in the spring up here, then we have most of that herbicide residual waiting there for the weeds. Tommy Butts: Awesome. Well, I think that's about all the questions I had for y'all. I was going to just say first of all,
thank you for joining and discussing this topic today. Before we completely finish, though, do y'all have any last remaining thoughts, comments, you know, recommendations that you want to throw out there for you know the various areas, or even some of us in the middle of the country, what we should be preparing for? Tom Barber: Well, Tommy, you're right there in the middle, so I mean, I don't know what what what do you have? I, you know, for us, this this fall residual thing again, it's mainly for ryegrass, and the biggest question we have is, what are we
planting next year? And if we can answer that, then I can help them make a program around that. So many of them don't know until it's time to put the planter in the ground, and so in that case, you know, Valor gets a lot of recommendation just because we can pretty much go to anything when we apply it in the fall. At least anything that we plant, we have to be careful on the group 15 s, especially Zidua dual, that we're not going to go to rice the next year because our zidua rate basically is limited
on if we're in a rice rotation or not. That three and a quarter ounces. Well, I think we're 12 months out on rice, so we can't use any of those in the fall and come back and plant rice. So, if we can figure out what we're going to plant, we can develop a pretty good program for fall residuals and residuals and spring burn down. If not, then Valor, it is, and we just will deal with whatever escapes we have. I guess with the post-emergence, hopefully, and burn down before planting. So,
anyway, what are y'all seeing there in Indiana, man? Tommy Butts: Well, so I think we're like we. In the middle of the country, I think we're in the middle of the roads, like with what both of y'all are discussing. So it's kind of nice to hear both sides, because essentially, you know, one of the questions actually Joe and I have talked about this, right? You know, how far south would something like that work, where you apply residual in the fall or kind of more in the winter? Can it carry over into some of this spring waterhemp control at all, like where's that breaking point as you move south? So
we're hopefully going to work on that a little bit here moving forward. If if we're below that cutoff, or if we still get an advantage from that, because we just don't know in Indiana per se with some of the Group Fifteens. I know there's been some other work with like the PPOs and things in the past, but not necessarily the Group Fifteens. I do also know then, similar to you, Tom, we've got ryegrass that I keep getting more and more phone calls on. So it's moving north. You must have made a trip up here at some point, didn't tell me, and emptied your pockets. So, but we've got more and more calls on
that popping up. I know Alyssa in Ohio State says the same thing, and so I've been starting to tell some guys like if you're in bad problems, the way to approach it is fall applications, right? Get ahead of it. Like if you can get ahead of it, you're much better off than trying to be reactive in the spring. So we're we're kind of in that middle ground right now. I'd say is where we're starting to realize we might need to do some fall apps for rye grass, and we want to see where we might fit in for some of these spring, summer, annual things too, if we'd have any advantage there. But Joe, you
got any final comments, recommendations? Joe Ikley: Yeah, I was gonna say I think up here we're going to just see these fall applications continue to increase, and we we still have some that are in the camp of I'm done spraying, and the last thing you really want to do is clean out a sprayer in a snowstorm, so there's there's some folks who you know have parked the sprayer long ago for that reason, but when we look at just logistics across our sequence, I mean, we've got like a four or five month growing season. We're always chasing winter on one side or the other. Just depends on how the year
shakes out, but if we have our crops start coming off in late July, early August, and then we've kind of have this four-month harvest campaign, where in the morning we we can maybe go out and spray a field or two along the way, especially as we get later into the fall. Versus in the spring, we're planting 20 million acres and hopefully a four-week window, and it's usually windy, and then we miss the pre-herbicide application, so I think we'll continue to increase, and that's one of the reasons that we we are looking at. And we start
small with single actives, work up to tank mixes. Can we can we almost move on some of these acres that spring residual to the fall up here, because the wind will be blown in the spring, and on this year is a perfect example. Some years we plant corn or soybean; it takes three weeks to come up. It just happens. But then this year we got hot the end of May, and we had beans out of the ground in five days, like the rest of the country can have. In that case, we missed our pre-window. So if we didn't have that fall app, then now we go to some some
other chemistry that well, we're look. We're talking residuals again for a reason. So, so I think we'll continue to increase, and I encourage folks to continue to do that. And you know, hopefully, if if some this early research on these fall apps for our summer annual weeds later into the year continues to hold out, I do think I see some of our residuals shifting more in the fall than in that at planting timing. Tommy Butts: Well, it's never ending joy in weed science. I'd say we always have something new and exciting that we got to work
on. So, silver linings for weed scientists. Joe Ikley: No silver bullets, but silver linings. Tom Barber: To say I was working on pigweed 30 years ago, and I'm still working on pigweed, so I don't know. Probably means I just suck as a weed side. We're not seems like we're getting further behind every year. Tommy Butts: Yeah. All right. Well, I think we can wrap up from there, gentlemen. Thank you so much for for joining us. I appreciate your insights and and just the the good discussion. So, with that, thank you for joining us, and thank you to all
the listeners out there on the War Against Weeds podcast. And we'll see again on the next go around. We'd also like to extend a thank you to the North Central IPM Center for their continued support of this ongoing podcast series, as well as our partners at the Crop Protection Network, and finally, I'd like to say thank you to all of our listeners, and please tune in next time for the next War Against Weeds podcast. Thank you.
What happens when weed science meets economics? In this episode, Tommy and Sarah sit down with and Dr. Chad Fiechter, an Ag Economist at Purdue Universtiy to discuss everything from fertilizer prices and financing costs...
For years, Group 15 herbicides have been a cornerstone of waterhemp management, but new research from Illinois suggests their effectiveness may be eroding. Aaron Hager and Pat Tranel join the show to discuss the...
On this episode of War Against Weeds, Joe Ikley and Sarah Ganske are joined by Meaghan Anderson and Wesley Everman from Iowa State University to discuss the emergence of Asian copperleaf, an invasive weed that is...
In this episode of the War Against Weeds podcast, Tommy and Sarah are joined by Stanley Culpepper, Bill Chism, and Elizabeth Burns Thompson to discuss how herbicide regulations, Endangered Species Act (ESA)...
In this episode of War Against Weeds, hosts Sarah Ganske and Alyssa Essman are joined by Purdue University weed scientist Dr. Bryan Young and Bayer Crop Science technical product lead Dr. Kati Price to discuss...