This week we’re covering the effect of backpacks or rucksacks, or knapsacks, on the body. Dr. Bayan Aghdasi is an orthopaedic surgeon based in California specializing in spine surgery. He completed his medical training at Loyola University Chicago, followed by residency at the University of Virginia. Dr. Aghdasi further honed his expertise with a spine surgery fellowship at Johns Hopkins University, focussing on complex spinal pathologies and advanced surgical techniques. With more than a decade of experience, he provides expert, patient-focused care for a wide range of spine conditions, including degenerative spine disorders, herniated discs, spinal deformities, and trauma-related injuries. He helps patients understand their diagnoses and treatment options while developing individualised plans that balance safety, effectiveness, and long-term outcomes. He prioritises prevention through lifestyle, including nutrition, exercise, and holistic well-being, and, when surgery is necessary, he selects the least invasive option to restore function. To get in touch with the podcast with comments, guest ideas, or for advertising/sponsorship opportunities, email us at jim@walkingpost.com
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Hello, I'm Jim Cornall and this is the walkingpost .com podcast. Walkingpost .com is the news website dedicated to walking with all the latest on gear, books, trails, fitness, health, festivals, events and more. This podcast is number 62 and it's going live on October the 2nd. And just when I thought I'd got rid of my cold, I have another.
Now I just need someone to blame for it. The nights are getting longer now, so day hikes are now shorter, and soon will be really short. I hadn't realised moving up to Scotland made such a difference in daylight hours. Obviously the further north you go you get closer and closer to that months -long winter situation, but here on the shortest day we get about five and a half hours of sunlight, if it's not raining. We did
manage between colds and rainstorms to get out for a 13 mile hike on Saturday and to do some filming, but it was all pretty much the same scenery, so there's only so much you can film. Lots of fungi, or whatever pronunciation you care to choose, and we, well, my son, saw a red squirrel while I was busy looking at the map. If a UFO passed over our heads, I'd be taking a photo of a flower. For the first time we took some of those gel packs with us for energy. Still
not sure if they made a difference. So let's just move on and take a look at October the 2nd. It's World Smile Day. If you can find something to smile about. Obviously it's better to be optimistic, but when you read the news there's not a lot to smile about in there. It's Kids Music Day. My 14 year old son took a quiz online that told you your musical age based on what kind of music you listened to. He seemed a bit surprised and maybe a bit proud when it said that his listening
age was 80. Afterwards I took it as well and mine was 92. At which point, if I'm still around, I'll likely be deaf anyway and not listening to music. But why listening to music from the 60s and before makes you old, I have no idea. It's International Day of Non -violence. World leaders, please take note. It's Guardian Angel Day, and I don't think it means the baseball teams, the Guardians and the Angels. I think my Guardian Angel is on vacation. And another
interesting one, it's Name Your Car Day. It's a bit odd because if you do name your car, you probably do it when you get it, not wait until October the 2nd. I've had lots of cars over the years and I think the only one I ever named was the first one. And that's only because the license plate started with TWB, so I called it Tub. And as it was a Citroen 2CV, it did look like an upturned Tub. Other than that, I've never named a car. But if you do, I'd love to hear your names for them. Other than the profanities that you
call it when it won't start. For events, it's the day in 1766 that the Nottingham cheese riot broke out because of the rise in the cost of cheese. I wonder if times have repeated themselves. Here we are in 2026 and everything has gone up, and the size of food packaging has gone down. No riots though, thankfully. although I don't read the Nottingham newspaper. For births, Richard III, Gandhi, Groucho Marx, Sting, Mike Rutherford
from Genesis, I actually recognised quite a lot of names on the very long list this week. Right, last time on the podcast we talked about hiking in and visiting Antarctica with Amanda Hunter, the operations manager of Terra Nova Expeditions. This time we're talking backpacks or rucksacks or knapsacks or whatever you want to call them, but not about brands or how they are made. A few weeks ago I read an article about how backpacks can cause damage, especially in younger children.
Obviously that doesn't apply to all backpacks and it also doesn't apply in all cases, but when our son first started at high school or secondary school his backpack weighed about as much as two small vehicles and the school doesn't have lockers. So no wonder he was exhausted and sore every night. So we are talking about the best practices for carrying them and what damage they can do if not worn or carried properly or if they're overloaded with an expert, Dr. Bayan
Aghdasi, an orthopedic surgeon based in California who specializes in spine surgery. And just to be clear, this is not a conversation about whether you should carry a backpack. Almost everyone does, and I will keep carrying mine. After all, you need one. I'd be lost without mine, and it doesn't even feel like a proper hike without one. This is more about what happens when a pack is too heavy or worn the wrong way, and what to watch for. But before we get going, if you
do have news, guest ideas, or even subjects to cover, or comments, or if you want to advertise, please get in touch at walkingpost .com or you can just email me at jim. at walkingpost .com. Right, backpacks. I think I have about six of them and I can honestly say I've never really
had one that I love everything about. I've definitely had ones that an hour into the walk I've wanted to throw off a cliff into whatever sea I'm walking alongside but I'm not about to litter and also I want to keep the stuff that's inside it. The main reason was both of those packs were massively uncomfortable and actually after a while started to hurt. So what is the best way to carry one and what damage can they do? How much weight should you carry? I don't know the answer to
these, so this week on the podcast we have a conversation with someone who does know what the problems are, because he's an expert in the field. Dr. Bayan Aghdasi is an orthopedic surgeon specializing in spine surgery. So let's get right to it. Hi, Dr. Aghdasi. It's so good to have you on the podcast today. I'm really looking forward to learning about backpacks. Maybe to start, you could give us a little bit of background on your background. I practice spine surgery.
I'm a board certified orthopedic spine surgeon. I was trained in orthopedic surgery on the East Coast. My undergraduate studies were at UCLA and my spine surgery training was at Johns Hopkins University. I've been in private practice six years now. I kind of specialized more into the minimally invasive, reconstructive forms of spine surgery, which are ways of doing more advanced surgeries through smaller and less invasive incisions.
I use advanced robotics and navigation softwares and techniques to get that job done. I've done maybe, I don't know, several thousand minimally invasive spine surgeries in my years and happy to kind of reflect on those with you to figure out how to avoid getting into the operating room, right? How to keep people's necks and backs healthy for as long as possible. Sure. Is the field of
medicine that you work in, does that change very much? Does it evolve over time or is it pretty much? what you learned years ago is still the way that it's done. Well, I'm sure a great majority of the principles remain the same, although it is perhaps the most liquid and fluid branch of orthopedics, primarily because of the complexity of the spine, such that the science of surgery
on the spine is nowhere near its maturity, as opposed to hand surgery with trigger fingers or carpal tunnel or even joint replacement surgery that has been around in its current form for 30 plus years with very little change to those procedures. Spine surgery has undergone a rapid evolution over the past, I don't know, 10 years, 20 years. It continues essentially to rapidly evolve. Different approaches, front, side, back,
different techniques. open versus less invasive versus ultra minimally invasive robotics navigation and arguments around all of those different decisions so there is no clear true standard of care around these finer points about the techniques so it actually remains in a very fluid state and I would say it'll take another 50 to a hundred years to reach full maturity the way other branches of medicine are really set in stone, really.
Right. And before we actually get onto backpacks, I was just wondering, as you were saying that, are lifestyle changes altering the physiology of the body? Is the back changing? People are more sedentary than they ever were. They're not outside walking as much. Are there changes that you're seeing over time? Yeah, absolutely. There's been quite a bit. I could take a look at a patient's x -ray and MRI. and tell you a great many things about them, not just genetics and what their
body shape and form is like, not just obesity, but also wear and tear phenomena, mechanical, chronic degenerative changes, and even metabolic stressors like things related to lifestyle, what their diet has been like, what their exercise regimen has been like. and what kind of substances they've been using, alcohol or nicotine. Even those produce effects to the internal structure of your body that are long standing. And so I
think, yeah, we can tell a lot about the modern population and how our lifestyles are impacting our musculoskeletal health. Today, kids especially, but adults as well. A lot of people carry backpacks. Is that generally safe? Yeah, good question. I think, and this is kind of my opinion to some extent. It's an expert opinion, but an opinion nonetheless. My impression is backpacks are safe up to a point. And in reflecting on your questions,
I suspect it has to do with a threshold of weight. It also has to do with how you carry the backpack. But I think the biggest issue is relative to your body size. How big is the backpack? And if it's something that you could sling over your arms and ideally carry on both shoulders to distribute the load evenly and not create asymmetrical biomechanical imbalance, which can accelerate wear and tear or exacerbate nerve root tension symptoms. I
think if that weight is low enough where you can wear it and not feel fatigued or aches or pains in that body part for hour after hour, meaning if it's really light, I think that's safe. I think a backpack worn on both shoulders that's really light, that's worn kind of high and tight, so it's kind of sitting up on your back and not necessarily pulling you down or back, kind of distributing its load over many
different vertebrae. And if it's quite light, I think that's a perfectly safe thing to do. I don't foresee that ever being a significant cause of disease or problems. You mentioned the asymmetry earlier. So I guess then distribution would fall under that. Yeah. So much of the time, I guess in the 1980s, we used to say like the cool kids would carry their backpack on one shoulder. Right. And I think there is a certain convenience
to doing that. But certainly. When you do that, you asymmetrically load the shoulder girdle, the spine, the hips, the lumbar vertebrae, and you can propagate a pretty significant imbalance and create unilateral symptoms much more quickly because you're concentrating the load onto not just the anatomy, not just the focal points of the anatomy, but also on leverage asymmetry.
So you can, you know, you've got the whole shoulder girdle, let's say, eight or nine inches off from the midline. And all of a sudden you're applying all that weight to one point, and you're going to drift the whole spine into one direction, and then compensatory adaptations down below and above in the other direction. And so I think asymmetry drives it, drives problems, load drives problems, and Yeah, and also duration, how long you're going to keep those two factors in place.
So those three things, I think potentially over a lifetime would significantly shorten the lifespan of some of your vertebrae. Do you see injuries caused by backpacks and can that end up being permanent? You know, probably not like an acute injury, like we think of a fracture or a dislocation, but over the lifetime of usage of your arms and legs, I think the majority of the diseases that
we treat are in fact degenerative disease types, meaning they come about after years and decades of wear and tear. So yeah, I'm sure the backpack plays a significant role. I mean, it's one of the biggest things we do is we wear, we carry things with us, right? And so wear and tear is the greatest source of disease in the spine. carrying things is probably one of the major contributors to that. So even though there's no studies that I'm aware of quantifying that
problem, I'd be shocked if it wasn't a major contributor. Right. Associated with that, are there warning signs that people can take note of when they're feeling something in their back? Yeah, I think if you wear the backpack and within five or 10, 15 minutes, you start to have aches and pains and need to change sides or take it off I think that's too heavy and if you're wearing it on one side and you're noticing you have to
switch sides or keep switching back and forth then I think you're not you're not wearing it properly you're not putting it on both shoulders and strapping it tight so it it rides high and spreads its weight over your back as opposed to kind of just yanking on on your shoulder blades back and so yeah if you're starting to have aches and pains You're using unilateral or bad habits. The load is too much and causing you discomfort in a short time period. Those are all signs that you're probably not doing yourself any favors
long term. Are you seeing more issues with things like this? Because there are like a hundred different kinds of backpacks. Now, when I was a kid, there was a backpack and now they have backpacks with frames and there's backpacks with vents in them and different sizes. Yeah, that's a good point. And there's probably more research to be done, certainly on my end, to really pin down whether these commercial adaptations are actually significantly
modifying the general risk, the style, if it can sit up higher, if it's more square and projects further away from the body, or if it can be kind of flatter and sit more on your skin. Like you said, the vents or the frames. I'm not aware of any research that meaningfully differentiates those particular adaptations. Now, I know the roller bag where you kind of roll it on the ground behind you, that obviously is going to be better for your spine, but it doesn't look very cool
and it's not very user friendly for hiking or camping or, you know, or just going in between university classes up and down stairs. You know, that can be a problem. So I'm not aware of an adaptation directly to the backpack itself, which would significantly alter the natural history of of loading the spine. Other kind of connected to that, too, is are there any recommendations or limits according to age? Because obviously
10 year old doesn't have the same capacity as a 40 year old and also their body is still developing. Are there recommendations for capacity for weight for different ages or different heights? I think very young kids who have still not gone through puberty that are still going through their growth phases. And those are the ones that we tend to saddle with backpacks full of textbooks, unfortunately, right? There is a law called Wolf's Law. that
states that bones will adapt to pressures. And so if you put a lot of weight through a bone, it actually will adapt and kind of shorten to accommodate or not grow as much if it's trying to grow to accommodate that load. And so just like if you wear really tight shoes as you're growing, your feet might be restricted in terms of their size. If our eight year olds and 10 year olds are carrying, you know, 45 pounds, of textbooks on their backs all day and going
from class to class, you know, 10 periods a day at school. I think that's going to significantly impact their development and could cause sometimes chronic issues. So I think prepubescent children should be cautious and avoid avoid those three things I mentioned earlier. And then also, as we age, our bones become softer. So especially females of fair skin over the age of 40. who are slender, I think that those are the categories of people more susceptible to osteoporosis. And
so those are the ones who will also be more susceptible or prone to hip fractures or fragility fractures. And if you're loading their spines and they step awkward or step off a curb wrong, the risk of a fragility fracture in that population due to a loaded spine from a heavy backpack is also an increased risk. So at the extremes of youth and fragility, there is downsides to chronic
shoulder based loading. And how about posture? Because clearly it changes posture a little. Are there, do you recommend to people specific postures, whether it's with or without a backpack? Yeah, absolutely. I think the healthiest posture is one where You kind of stand square and upright without slouching and keeping your shoulders low and back. That's kind of a position of readiness for your body to respond to physical stressors,
whether it's, you know, athletic or environmental. And so we can't all walk around looking like a bodybuilder, but you can be conscious of not slouching. not keeping your head position down as you type or you work on, look at our phones all the time. Those are all common errors that exacerbate and accelerate the hunching over that inevitably happens to all human beings as we age, especially the elderly fair skinned females
that I mentioned earlier who suffer from disproportionately from osteoporosis end up developing these hunchback, very painful postures. And so, yeah. slowing that process down by maintaining upright shoulders back daily routines can be life -saving in the long term. Can it also affect other parts of the body like hips and thighs and legs? Very directly in fact sometimes if you create enough
wear and tear through the spine whether it be from mechanical sources or metabolic stressors or sometimes obesity or nicotine you actually degenerate the discs to the point where the vertebrae collapse and pinch onto the nerves, the nerves that are exiting at each spinal segment. And those nerves go to all your organs and your arms and legs and bowel and bladder. Eventually, if you degenerate your neck or your back far enough into your 60s or 70s, those nerves will actually
cause weakness and dysfunction. You'll start to get numbness and tingling and balance issues in your arms and legs. You may find it hard to walk, you know, be limited to shorter and shorter distances. And eventually people go from a cane to a walker to a wheelchair, oftentimes because of spinal degeneration. So, yeah, it has the potential to affect your whole body. Are there any recommendations that you have for people? You mentioned those three things earlier, like
are there any things people can do to help themselves when it comes to carrying on their backs? I think a regular routine of resistance training exercise is really important. It's the low chronic loads that are degenerating more than the acute controlled muscular exercise that is really healthy. So instead of carrying something for you know, many, many hours, what you can do, I would prioritize
three or four times weekly, 45 minutes of high intensity resistance training exercise. That's gonna build up skeletal muscle, decrease adiposity or fat, and make you more resilient to whatever tasks of carrying that you need to do. You'll feel more up to doing those tasks, more apt to executing them without incurring more wear and tear. if you're fit and lean and healthy. So I think exercise is a great way to slow down
the wear and tear process. And how about for back injuries? Obviously, they're all different. But if somebody has fatigue or issues caused by a backpack, is it just a case of resting or carry less? So what are you thinking there? Yeah, I think in the more immediate time frame, you know, preventing the offending behavior and modifying it, decreasing load, increasing symmetry, decreasing
duration is the obvious short -term stopgap. But ultimately, you need to figure out what's going on. Is it mechanical axial pain? Is it radiating periscapular nerve pain or sciatic pain down the legs? And then that would be diagnosed with x -rays and an MRI. And so, you know, getting to the bottom of exactly what's going on and how bad it is. Is it just a nuisance or is it quality of life? Is it interfering with your
quality of life on a regular basis? And is it actually resulting in weakness or dysfunction? Or are you avoiding certain activities because of it? So there's a spectrum of disease there, but I would say get checked out by a doctor. Don't be afraid of imaging. MRIs have no radiation. X -rays have very low dose radiation so they're not really considered a risk factor. I would say get checked out sooner than later so we can diagnose it and if there's nothing wrong then we'll keep carrying backpacks. A really informative
conversation there. And I've already decided my strategy for distributing the load better the next time we go out filming. My son can carry it all. I'm just kidding for those who were taking it seriously and about to send me a nasty email. And a couple of things worth keeping in mind from that. Dr. Aghdasi did say that this is his expert opinion and that he isn't aware of any studies that put a number on how much backpacks contribute to long -term back problems. Maybe
there's an opportunity there for a study. The points about wear and tear are general risks over a lifetime and not really a prediction for anyone who carries a pack on a walk. On kids, since weight came up, guidance does vary a little bit, but the figure that you'll most often see is that a child's pack shouldn't be any more than 10 to 15 percent of their body weight. So for a child who weighs 60 pounds or 27 kilos roughly that's about 6 to 9 pounds or 2 .7 to
4 kilos. The 45 pounds that Dr Aghdasi mentioned there was just an extreme example and there are resources online that can give you tips on packing a backpack both for children as well as adults. The practical takeaways were, I guess, wear it on both shoulders, keep it snug and riding high, watch the weight and the weight distribution. And if you're getting aches within the first few minutes, or you have to keep switching things around, then that's probably a sign that something
needs changing. And if the pain persists or worsens, then do get it checked sooner rather than later. Advice that I need to start heeding. There are times when I know that I'm going to be taking the backpack off a few times and so I'll carry it on one shoulder for a while. And yes, it does start to hurt right away. And there are also times that I add things in that I don't need. So it could definitely be a bit lighter or maybe even a lot lighter. Do I really need to carry
five different tripods? My son is shaking his head right now. I know, I probably don't need the 1 meter AND the 3 meter sticks. And two lights, and 48 cables. And two extra sets of microphones, just in case. Never mind a suitcase, I think I should call my backpack the just in case. If you do have news or suggestions for podcast guests, please do get in touch through Jim at walkingpost .com We are always looking for guests, whether it's about a new trail, new book, a walking festival,
or someone who has done an amazing, unusual or interesting walk somewhere. So I hope you enjoyed this week's walkingpost .com podcast and I hope that you have a great week ahead, hopefully with a walk somewhere, with or without a backpack. Until next time, happy trails! is an Ayr Coastal Media Limited production.
Fewer than 130,000 travellers make it to Antarctica each year. A new company, Terra Nova Expeditions, is taking a slightly different approach to taking travellers to the continent. With a boat limited to fewer than 100...
Julia Hartley is the founder of Guided Outdoor Adventures. The company is organising the first Cheshire Walking Festival on Saturday, 3 April 2027, based at The De Trafford Arms in Alderley Edge. The day will feature 10...
This week on the podcast we have a conversation with author and traveller Walter G Meyer, who we caught up with while on a trip in Colombia. Meyer worked for two summers in Grand Teton National Park and for one summer...
This week on the podcast we have a conversation with Jo McGowan business improvement district Manager for Dorking, in Surrey, which hosts a walking festival from 19 to 27 September. This year’s event, the second,...
This week on the podcast we have a conversation with Geraldine McFaul, from Glasgow, who spent six months walking from her home to Rome, a journey of around 2,000 miles. There were two rules - no backpack, and no Alps....