Movement veterans Bill McKibben and Jamie Henn have been thinking about where climate activism goes from here. They argue for a new focus on celebrating and accelerating the miraculous global boom in solar power. We get into what it looks like to fight for building stuff, how to win the online information war for clean energy, and why the sun offers not just cheaper power, but a form of liberation. This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit www.volts.wtf/subscribe
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
hello everyone this is volts for august 20th 2025 what does clean energy activism
SPEAKER_03look like i'm your host david roberts We live in difficult and confusing times, to say the least. Perhaps no group is as confused or faces as many difficulties as climate activists. The clean energy provisions in the Inflation Reduction Act, which the climate movement had only ambivalently embraced, are now mostly gone. The wind and solar parts in particular have disappeared and renewable energy is
SPEAKER_03under direct ongoing fire from the Trump administration. The situation is dire. Where does climate activism go from here? Bill McKibben, the man more responsible than any other single human being for the birth and development of the U.S. climate movement, has some ideas. He thinks people need to get excited about the sun, specifically the miraculous profusion of solar power across the globe, which is outpacing even the most ludicrously optimistic forecasts.
SPEAKER_03What would activism in service of the sun look like? And is the climate movement capable of evolving? To help think through these problems, McKibben is teaming up again with his old partner in crime, Jamie Henn, with whom he founded the climate organization 350.org. They are pushing a new project called Sunday, which we are going to get into. I will not endeavor to cover their full resumes, which are long and distinguished. I will just say that McKibben's latest book is called Here Comes the Sun,
SPEAKER_03A Last Chance for the Climate and a Fresh Chance for Civilization. which is pretty self-explanatory. And he's running the Third Act Network, designed to mobilize activism among the 55 and older crowd. Hen, meanwhile, is running Fossil Free Media, a nonprofit communications lab that he founded. I am excited to have both of them with me today to discuss what it might look like to rally activists in favor of building stuff.
All right then, with no further ado, Bill McKibben, Jamie Hinn, welcome to Volts.
SPEAKER_03Thank you so much for coming. It's great to be here.
SPEAKER_00Good to be with you, old friend.
SPEAKER_03I was looking back. I can't believe neither of you, I think, have ever been on the pod, which is bizarre to me since we go way back. So it's great to talk to you. I have a million things I want to get into, but Bill, I wanted to start with a question for you, kind of a big, heavy question. So from the time I got engaged with climate change, basically, I think back to the early 2000s, it was basically like you and Al Gore had And the theory of the case was always some version of fossil
fuel incumbents are
SPEAKER_03powerful and have politics kind of locked up, politicians kind of locked up. The only counterbalance to that, the only force capable of overcoming that is people, so the prescription for the climate movement is to build something analogous to the civil rights movement, i.e. a volunteer-based bottom-up people's movement that would get out on the streets and force change.
SPEAKER_03That has always been the theory of the case, sort of in the background. 20 years have passed, you have had, I think, miraculous ability to turn people out, turn tens of thousands, hundreds of thousands of people out. People got out on the street, but it just didn't... I mean, tell me if you think I'm wrong, but it just seems like the... The cultural atmosphere, the media atmosphere, something it just didn't catch on like the people. It turns out like it only matters if the people who decide what matters decide that
SPEAKER_03it matters and they didn't want it to matter. So it ended up not mattering. And I don't know how to get above or around that. But basically, this is a long winded way of trying to ask you, is that still your basic theory of the case that that is what we need?
SPEAKER_00Yes. And it has mattered tremendously in the past. I mean, the reason that we have a Paris climate agreement that got lots and lots and lots of countries around the world working on climate change was because we had a big, broad-based global movement. And Jamie and I and our colleagues like Mae Boovie, who helped start that at 350.org, have great pride, I think, in that work, work which continues to this day to stand up to the fossil fuel industry.
But the prospect for standing up to the fossil fuel industry is different now than
SPEAKER_00it was 20 years ago, and for a simple reason. All the time since I wrote The End of Nature back in the 1980s up to about three or four years ago, the essential problem here was that fossil fuel was cheap and clean energy was expensive. And that made it structurally extremely difficult to make progress because fossil fuel was pretty much synonymous with the economy. That's now flipped.
We live on a planet where the cheapest way to make energy is to point a sheet of
SPEAKER_00glass at the sun. And in some ways, that really does change everything, or at least it could. It's an epochal moment for human civilization that allows us to think very directly about ending the human habit of setting things on fire. If you think I'm cognizant of that, well, the fossil fuel industry is at least as cognizant of it. They're probably well aware that, say, California, fourth largest economy in the world,
is using 40% less natural gas this summer to generate electricity than they did two years ago because they've put up so many solar panels and so many batteries. And that explains the fight back that we're now seeing across our society.
SPEAKER_00And it's why we have to continue engaging in this fight. The other reason we have to continue engaging and mobilizing is because there's this deep time element here, David, as you know. If we weren't operating under the specter of rapid, rapid, rapid climate change, then the fact that it might take 20 or 30 years for us to change over to wind and sun would be annoying and expensive and so on,
SPEAKER_00but it wouldn't be quite the crisis that it is. The problem is that if it takes us 20 or 30 years to really make this transition, then the planet that we run on sun and wind is going to be a broken planet. And that's what the news from the jet stream and the Gulf Stream and the moisture content of the atmosphere and on and on and on is now telling us in the starkest possible ways.
SPEAKER_03One way you could put it is, and I talk about this with students a lot when I talk about sort of the history of my involvement with this, is like, as you say, the first 10 years of engaging with climate is, you know, solutions were mostly theoretical, mostly far out, you know, required a heavy dose of altruism to get over the top. So you're pushing a boulder uphill, basically. And now, if I'm reading you right, basically, your idea is the boulder has crested the hills, rolling downhill, and we just need to make it roll faster.
SPEAKER_00It's very well put. And the first step of doing that, I think, is the kind of work that we're doing at Sunday or that I'm trying to do with this book, which is just get across to people the new world in which we live. We have called this stuff alternative energy for 40 years. Yeah. And that has its effect. That's the corner of our brain in which it ends up. But it's not alternative energy. 95% of new generated capacity around the world and in this
country last year was
SPEAKER_00clean, renewable energy. The shorthand I've been using is You know, we're kind of used to thinking about it as the whole foods of energy. It's nice but pricey. Actually, it's the Costco of energy. It's cheap. It's available in bulk. It's on the shelf, ready to go if we choose to use it. And as I say, the fossil fuel industry and Energy Secretary Wright and everybody else is just as cognizant of that as I am. They're just fighting desperately to try and keep people from making this
SPEAKER_00liberating realization.
SPEAKER_03Tell us then briefly, what is Sunday? Is it a day? Is it a movement? Is it an organization? Is it a theme? What's the idea?
SPEAKER_00Jamie, over to you. You're in charge here.
SPEAKER_01Well, I'll take a stab at it. Well, Sunday itself is a day of action, and it's a day of action to really celebrate the progress we've made on clean energy and then go out and fight for more. And so we're organizing hundreds of events across the United States for September 21st, which happens to be the fall equinox, and also the weekend before the U.N. General Assembly and Climate Week in New York. So a chance to kind of focus public attention around these issues. But the goal of Sunday is to do a few big things, a few big goals.
One is to really kickstart more of a movement on the ground that can get folks
SPEAKER_01involved in the work of deploying clean energy, something we'll talk more about. Second, as Bill said, is to really be an excuse for a lot of communications. We've used days of action like this in the past to try and do mass public education around different concepts, whether it's what's needed for climate or the threat of fossil fuels, and in this case, just the huge advances. that have taken place in clean energy and really drives through a few key messages that this is now the cheapest form of power on the planet, that it's generating huge amounts of jobs, that we can move forward with it in big,
SPEAKER_01miraculous ways. And then finally is the day of action itself. This is a chance for folks locally to do a whole host of work. that can help move things forward, whether that's advocating at the local level to speed up permitting for solar and batteries, whether that's advocating at a school to get solar on the rooftop, or just doing a heat pump tour as well. I want to get into these local examples, what concretely what it is people might do.
SPEAKER_03But I guess it's at the very least, I was sort of trying to get at this with Bill, like you're trying to educate people about something they're not aware of. It's just a lot more fun to do that when the news that they're not aware of is an incredibly good thing happening rather than the world falling apart, which they weren't aware of. I imagine their ears are more open to this latter message.
SPEAKER_01Mm-hmm. And I think that's still true in some cases. So we tested a bunch of content that said, big oil is holding back your clean energy. Big oil is standing with the solar. Trump doesn't want you to have it. And honestly, the response that we got from folks mostly online was, I don't want to hear this stuff.
SPEAKER_01I'm already depressed. I already know that things are bad. I don't need more content of this. People scrolled right on by. The thing that actually engaged people was the facts that Bill was laying out about clean energy. The idea that actually 90%, 96% of the new electricity installed was solar, winded batteries, that this was now the cheapest form of power on the planet. People just have no idea, and they say that in the comments, and then they share the video to educate their friends. I think, as you said, they're... Not all good news is viral. I mean, bad news travels fast, too.
But this is an area where I think we have incredibly exciting news on our side that
SPEAKER_01we can be getting out to the public in different ways. And frankly, we just haven't done a good enough job as a movement to do that so far. So you have this day and you have these local organizations doing things on this day.
SPEAKER_03Is there meant to be sort of infrastructure that comes out of it? In other words, is there an ongoing organization coming out of this or what's meant to be the long term play?
SPEAKER_01That's what really excites me about this process. We sort of like to say days of action in some ways are an excuse to do a lot of good organizing and communications. And it's like throwing a rock in a pond. You get a great big splash, which is exciting and important. We want news coverage on September 21st. But it's really the ripples that spread that help build a movement. And so our take is having talked with folks across the clean energy space for the last six months or a year and been mulling on this for years before that, and frankly, talking to a lot of folks who've been on Volts,
is that there's an incredible amount of good work happening at the local level. There are important organizations out there like Greenlight America and Permit
SPEAKER_01Power and Climate Cabinet and Lead Locally who are doing elections, but all of them don't have the air cover that they need, aren't getting the attention that they desire online, and don't have the big base to back them up. We have two people showing up at a local hearing to advocate for a clean energy project instead of 100. The petition to support offshore wind has 1,000 signatures instead of 10,000. And so what we're thinking through is how can we use something like Sunday to bring together a big coalition of groups across the movement and from
different places as
SPEAKER_01well. And we can talk more about the kind of interesting coalition of groups that do this work. But it's not just Sierra Club. It's also the YIMBY crowd that wants to build housing with solar on it. And could we create that air work and that air cover and really build more of a large mass movement that can back up the 10,000 local fights that we need to have to really deploy clean energy at scale?
SPEAKER_03Well, here we're getting into the meat and potatoes of it, Jamie, which is, as you know, because you've probably heard me rant about it no fewer than several dozen times, I think it all comes back to the information environment. This is my ongoing obsession. I talk about it all the time. And this seems like I'll just use as an example, the fact that you've got artificial intelligence, which is being hyped and invested in so wildly beyond what it
has demonstrated it
SPEAKER_03can actually do, you know, and this national blanket of hype about it. Meanwhile, there's this literal miracle happening around solar power, which is, I think, going to be much more transformative for humanity in the long term And you can't get people to freaking talk about it. You can't get people to point at it and go, wow, that's amazing. Like they make excuses for it or they like, you know, there's caveats or it's not a real thing. It's baffling to me. And to me, that comes down to basically the information environment.
SPEAKER_03You know, the right dominates the information environment. They don't want that story spreading and connecting together. So it doesn't. So this all gets back to, I'd love to hear your diagnosis, Jamie, because your whole thing is studying the information environment and thinking about how to navigate within it. Where do you see clean energy right now in the information environment? I mean, it kind of looks to me like it's getting beat up, but like, what's your diagnosis for currently how clean energy is doing
in the information
SPEAKER_03war that's going on out there? I'd say we're losing.
SPEAKER_01I'll expand. Yeah.
And I think that we need to do a much better job of basically getting into those feeds and winning the meme wars that are constantly taking place out there.
SPEAKER_01As you said, there's a lot of disinformation at play. The typical NGO or foundation response is to write a report about disinformation. But of course, reports on disinformation don't actually help stop disinformation. You have to be willing to get pretty messy. Perhaps at some point, the sheer tonnage of white papers will simply overwhelm. It'll break through. Like the gray goo they're always talking about. But I'll say, what gives me hope is that I think that clean energy is perfectly positioned to do this type of marketing. modern-day,
SPEAKER_01creative, multi-channel communications work because it has all the key elements, right? There's a big global threat, which I think is still an important part of the story. There's the conspiracy element of the fossil fuel industry holding back the solution for so long. There's the lifestyle element of people actually want to get good stuff, and you'll be amazed anytime you go on YouTube and It seems like 90% of the content is about reviewing cars or reviewing stuff for your home. Unboxing stuff. Yeah, unbox your solar panel.
And that's a wedge for a lot of audiences that we need to be moving around these issues.
SPEAKER_01If you're worried about dyes in your food, just wait until you hear about what's in your gas stove. You thought seed oils were bad. Yeah, just wait until you hear about the 21 toxins in natural gas. Before we hopped on the phone here, I went on YouTube and saw the thing that gave me great hope was there was basically a tech creator who has 17 million followers who's doing a review where he's putting balcony solar or these plug-in solar panels that you can do on
his roof in Utah,
SPEAKER_01the one state where you can actually do that now. And he's ranting to his followers about how cool this is and why doesn't your state have it and this is illegal other places but I'm doing it here in Utah now. And he codes as a totally kind of right-wing dad, not a kind of activist. That's what's exciting to me about this space. That said, we have to actually have strategies to invest in it, to build it, and to fight it out.
SPEAKER_03I couldn't agree more that the raw material is there. This is a technological miracle happening under the nose of a culture that claims to be fascinated by technological miracles. And he's ignoring this one, more or less. And so this is what I mean. Like, the raw material is there. But as far as I can tell, in these meme wars, out on YouTube, on TikTok, you know, what's getting passed around Facebook groups, we're just nowhere. And I don't want to be unfair about this, but tell me if I'm wrong.
I don't see anyone, much less a lot of people, I don't see anyone doing it.
SPEAKER_00David, this is starting, hopefully, to change. And it's interesting to kind of watch. You know, I wrote this new book that's coming out and I did a big excerpt from it for The New Yorker, which went, you know, modestly viral in the way of these things. And the response that's been to me most interesting is coming from many, many of our colleagues in the environmental and even the clean energy movement. And they are like, I had no idea about how fast this had come.
SPEAKER_00This was still stuck in that other corner of my brain. I did not know that the Chinese were currently putting up three gigawatts of solar panels a day, which, you know, I mean, we can have a long discussion about, you know, nameplate capacity and things, but you can roughly translate that into a couple of coal-fired power plants a day worth of solar panels in China. People get very excited when you show them what's happening in other countries. It was something that both you and I have written about is this
miracle in Pakistan.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. And if you just show people the TikTok videos with the kind of Hindustani music in the background – that people used in order to figure out how to install the equivalent of half the country's national electric grid in eight months in solar panels on the rooftop. People get very excited about that. For me, this is a remarkably strange moment because from my point of view, almost everything that's happening on planet Earth is terrible right now.
SPEAKER_00There are one bad big thing after another. Yeah. And yet, you know, we're trying to bring the news here of the one big good thing that's happening on the planet.
SPEAKER_02You've just described my whole career in a nutshell. There you are. And I think the other thing that's going to happen as we get this discussion going is that people are going to figure out that there are more than technical and
SPEAKER_00utilitarian reasons to love this transition. So if you go to the sunday.earth website, one of the things you'll notice is how beautiful it is. And that's intentional because consciously and even subconsciously, I think we want to get across the idea that this is a potentially beautiful moment. That a planet whose geopolitics has been racked for decades by essentially fights over who controls access to oil and gas now has the possibility
of running on
SPEAKER_00something that's available to everyone, everywhere, all the time. Even human beings are going to struggle to figure out how to fight a war over sunshine. And once that sinks in, people are like— Oh, Bill, you sweet summer child.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. There will be deaths over solar panels before the year is out.
SPEAKER_00You know, along those lines, one of my favorite stories of the year was this interview with the biggest energy provider in Ukraine. And he was like, yeah, you know, when the Russians take out one of my thermal power plants, one of my coal-fired power plants, whatever, takes me like months to get the thing back online. But when they take out one of my solar farms, it's like four or five days, you know, I've got a bunch of panels in the warehouse. I just slap them in the broken ones and we're good to go.
SPEAKER_03Yes, yes. There's so much narrative material here that has been unused. It's somewhat baffling to me. So, Jamie, back to you. I want to ask, there's sort of two things going on here, and I'm curious which you are pursuing more, which you're preferring. One is just telling the story here that we're talking about, you know, like... Like Bill says, there is a miracle happening, and even people in our own industry don't fully get it. I mean, it's legitimately hard to keep up.
SPEAKER_03It's legitimately hard to track. Like, if you tuned out for eight months, Pakistan transformed its electricity system. Yeah. Getting the news out is one thing. That's an information game, and I'm curious how you want to go about that. But then the other side of this is activism not meant to raise awareness or all that kind of stuff, but actually accomplish things at the local level. So like, you know, get a group of people together to go to the PUC meeting, to get the PUC to reject a rate increase,
SPEAKER_03something like that. So there's sort of two ways this can go. One is the information warfare. One is the actual guerrilla activism. And it's this latter thing that has really got me excited because, you know, like when you got all those groups together in the distributed climate protest, sort of the point was the people being there. Do you know what I mean? Like the story was, it happened. And if you can't get mainstream media to tell that story, then, you know, nothing comes out of it. But if you get a bunch of groups together who are actually doing conversation,
SPEAKER_03concrete things at the local level, then even if you can't get mainstream media to tell the larger story, the things get done, right? So how much of this are you thinking about as an information warfare thing? And how much of this is like actual guerrilla activism at the local level meant to win local fights?
SPEAKER_01I think I'm going to cheat by saying both. But I think for a specific reason, actually, which is that I think the two are really intimately connected. And I think it's important to see the ways that they are, because I think that we make mistakes as a community sometimes, and I maybe extrapolate to the Democratic Party, of feeling like we do these things in a vacuum. You know, we do all of our communications work over here with its big ag budgets. And then we leave the messy work of movement building and activism up to those wacky kids over in the corner and hope that they figure it out.
SPEAKER_03No, no, we wait for them to do something. Then we write in and tell them. Then we critique them from the sidelines. The way they did it was wrong.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, the way you did this was wrong. You're doing it wrong again. Yes, and I'm sure we'll get some of that. People are welcome to send that in in the comments on this podcast. Yeah. But look, I've always been impressed by the ability of distributed organizing to do both at once, to both drive a narrative and get people to pay attention to something, but to also really make concrete change at the local level. And I think take some of the past campaigns that we've worked on. You know, fossil fuel divestment is maybe a good example where that
concept of divesting
SPEAKER_01money from fossil fuels, you know, a few people were talking about it. Students at Swarthmore College had kind of pioneered a campaign like that to tackle mountaintop removal mining and the investments that Swarthmore had in it. But it really hadn't spread beyond that. We were then able to partner with groups and young people across the country and turn that into a huge cause and public debate. And both worked together because we were doing both pieces of it. On the one hand, equipping young people with the tools they needed to figure out how do I organize
SPEAKER_01on my campus to apply pressure to my administration to divest? How do I learn about this issue? What's the checklist of steps I need to take? But then also saying, hey, post about it online. Share what you're doing, make videos, do stunts, drive this in the media, write op-eds for your local paper, start kind of driving this debate. And lo and behold, that sort of expanded out there from there. And I think that it went in lots of different directions, not just about fossil fuel divestment campaigns, but really about the entire role of finance in climate that now is a huge area of
SPEAKER_01work. And I won't claim that we were the only player there. If anything, we saw a trend in a narrative developing and jumped on it, just like I think we're doing here today. And so when I think about the challenges we've talked about on clean energy, the communications work and the work that needs to happen at the local level to change permitting decisions or get towns to adopt solar app, I think the two go hand in hand. Because what we want is much more conversation online that, of course, we can do some of that paying for it. And we need to be investing far more resources in content
creators and our own channels and
SPEAKER_01smart, paid media. But ultimately, what we want is thousands of people every single day making videos like that one I mentioned about how cool the solar panels on their roof are. Because that's not just important because you see your neighbor, but that's how the algorithm works. You need lots of people posting. You can't just buy one post and hope it goes viral. Yeah, you need the peer-to-peer. You need that peer-to-peer. We want to be on Nextdoor.
SPEAKER_03We want to be posting. They've shown that you can force that. You can construct that, too.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, and the right invests in this. I think it's important they do so. I'd say the two work in hand, and we can talk more about the organizing work in a minute or two, but I've been pleasantly surprised as kind of an activist organizer to say, wait a second, there are a lot of levers that we could be pulling at the local level where folks with a little bit more knowledge and a few more tools in their tool belt can really make a big difference.
SPEAKER_00And some of that work is now well underway. Jamie gave some of the groups that were, you know, Greenlight and Permit Power and things that are already doing it. And I can tell you from our work at Third Act, you know, we've mobilized a lot of older Americans who turn out to be a very good, you know, we always insist that young people... Yeah.
SPEAKER_00Who else, who's going to sit there, you know, Wednesday, Thursday, all day in some anonymous state office building someplace except lobbyists? Well, it turns out that, you know, if you've got your basket of knitting or your crossword puzzle book or something and a few of your colleagues from Third Act, then you will sit there and you will start to master this stuff. And pretty soon you're making a difference. But those efforts become much easier when there's a kind of a halo of engaged, fun,
interesting activism around them of the kind that things like Sunday provide. Then they become less boring, more musical, more artistic, more everything.
SPEAKER_03Well, let's go through a few more examples because I think one of the things I would like for people to get out of this, one of the things I would like to get out of this is a little bit more concrete sense of when we say we're going to mobilize local groups to do clean energy activism, we're Specifically, what does that mean? And I have a few specific questions about it. So one is about PUCs, which, Bill, you've already gone straight to because you know my love language. Obviously, monitoring and hassling PUCs is a huge opportunity here,
SPEAKER_03which doesn't take that many people to do it. But so what are some of the others? And I'm thinking here specifically about... A lot of these fights take place in rural areas. And as we all know, rural areas in the U.S. are, by and large, completely captured by, immersed in right-wing media. And that's where all these crazy Facebook memes about wind turbine cancer and everything are spreading. So, like, what would it look like to mobilize against that, for instance?
SPEAKER_03Like, What does mobilizing people in favor of clean energy look like?
SPEAKER_00Well, let me give a few examples. I just wrote this big piece for Mother Jones that just looked at the rooftop part of this. It turns out that there, the problems may be deepest, not in red states, but in blue cities and towns. And they stem mostly from this Baroque and Byzantine permitting system. that often means it takes many months between you making the phone call to someone to get solar panels on your roof and they're providing power. And that's the reason that rooftop solar costs three times as
much here as it does
SPEAKER_00in Australia or the EU. We can change that.
SPEAKER_02The story you told in that piece of the, I forget what country it is, but the person's like, hey, I want to get solar.
SPEAKER_00So they go to vacation to Spain. They're staying with friends.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, Spain. You just go to Home Depot like, I want that one. And then they come put it on your house.
SPEAKER_00Three days later, they're making power. Yeah. Which is how it should be. Yes. It's not like we're, you know, installing a nuclear reactor on your roof.
SPEAKER_02I know. It's like this should be as easy as putting a refrigerator in your kitchen. Yeah.
SPEAKER_00And that's how we should talk about it. But that's going to take some work, you know, maybe even especially in blue cities and states. On a larger level in rural America, I think that one of the ways around it, I think you had, did you have Doug Lewin on from Texas? Yes. Yes. You know, what happened in Texas this spring was really interesting to me. And he's a great reporter, and I've been following it with great interest. You know, the fossil fuel industry was lined up to try and really decimate the Texas
SPEAKER_00renewable miracle. And they had all this stuff that was just crazy. I mean, basically, some of it amounted to kind of DEI for natural gas, you know, put in five megawatts of solar and we're going to make you put in five megawatts of natural gas. Yeah. Well, as I understand his reporting, the reason that most of the worst of that failed was because people kept showing up from rural parts of Texas in Austin to testify and saying, guys, this is how we pay for our school system. This is what keeps the old folks home in business.
As someone who's lived my whole life on dirt roads in either both red and blue
SPEAKER_00parts of rural America, there's a different set of arguments that work well. Jamie was talking about the guy in Utah with his balcony solar. I know a lot of people for whom their home is their castle, which they are completely prepared to defend with their AR-15. And if they have solar panels on their roof, then they really are the kind of independent soul that they're sort of imagining themselves to be. And that's one good place to begin.
SPEAKER_00I was talking with, as I was writing that piece for Mother Jones, with all these guys at Conservatives for Clean Energy down in the Southeast, they were a big part of the force that got Ron DeSantis to not to put the kibosh on local solar. And at least in the rooftops, Florida is now starting to show up as a real player in this game.
SPEAKER_03Georgia, too. Rooftop solar spreading in Georgia like wildfire. People don't know that either.
SPEAKER_00So it's not impossible. It's difficult because all the obvious players, you know, the Koch Network, Americans for Prosperity, whatever, are at work full time spreading misinformation and scare stories and on and on and on. And they've had some success. Something like 15% of counties in the US are now off limits. But when you get out in those places, you find that often the biggest advocates for putting up solar farms are farmers
who realize that this is a stable source of income and one that's increasingly
SPEAKER_00compatible with a lot of other things. One of the great talking points and beautiful stories that capture people's imagination and that we should be talking a lot more about are agrivoltaics. You know, the notion that you can do two things in one place and that on an overheating world, shade is a really precious commodity that we now have a new and interesting way to provide. Those are really good stories. You know, depends who your audience is. I told someone the other day about these new trials in France
that demonstrated that yields of wine grapes went up 60 percent in fields with solar panels. And they were suddenly very attentive to the, you know, I'm a beer guy, so what do I know?
SPEAKER_00But go where people's interest leads you. Well, I mean, the whole weed industry is just sitting there waiting to be transformed by solar.
SPEAKER_03Hey there, everybody. Don't worry. I'm not going to tell you about a new mattress or push a credit card on you. This isn't an ad. There are no ads on Volts. It is supported entirely by listeners like you. If you'll indulge me for a second, I'd like to ask for your support. I started Volts because we're all surrounded by depressing news about climate change and misinformation about clean energy. And it's never been more important to share the stories of the real people on the ground doing the real work of transition and all the ingenuity
and courage and
SPEAKER_03public spirit they are bringing to it. People are hungry to hear these stories, to learn from and find inspiration in them. I've heard from people who change majors or careers after hearing episodes of Volts. People using it in classrooms, community groups, even state legislators who have passed bills inspired by specific episodes. Sharing these stories matters. It makes a difference. If you have found value in it and want to help me continue doing it, I hope you will join the community of paid subscribers at volts.wtf.
SPEAKER_03It's about the cost of a cup of coffee a month. If you don't like subscriptions, you can make a one-time contribution, leave a review on Apple or Spotify, or just tell a friend about volts. I am grateful for any and all support. If you're already a paid subscriber, thank you. And now back to the show. Well, I mean, the whole weed industry is just sitting there waiting to be transformed by solar.
SPEAKER_00The fact that we grow that stuff indoors drives me out of my mind. I know. I mean, they call it weed for a reason, and it's absurd that we're using huge amounts of energy. See, there's something for every audience, Dave.
SPEAKER_01That's the thing that excites us about this.
SPEAKER_03I think probably what a lot of the audience is thinking right now, what I'm thinking right now is these all sound like great things to do. There's something cosmically ludicrous about the fact that the two of you are trying to engineer this nationwide communications and activism mobilization effort using your freaking email, you know, and like a buck 50 or... Where is all the green money? Where is all the money? What is it doing? Like billions of dollars are floating around.
SPEAKER_03Green philanthropy, billions. What is it doing? It would take like, honestly, like a buck 50 to hire just like a dozen kids and just say kids. Go be on TikTok and talk about clean energy. That's it. Just tell them, go. You can pay a minimum wage, for Christ's sake. Like, I could practically fund that. Where is the green money?
SPEAKER_01Well, let me know if you find it. I think it's a good question. I think there's a more serious answer, which is that, as I said earlier in the conversation, I think that philanthropy and the larger movement have approached this as mostly an advocacy fight. We're going to run big-dollar ads to impress Democrats. We're going to change minds. We're going to persuade people. And we'll convince Democratic politicians or Senator Schumer
that there's enough money behind this fight that he can pass a bill and expend that political capital.
SPEAKER_01And again, to some extent, that worked. I mean, we got the Inflation Reduction Act done. The problem with that approach is that you leave out this whole other piece. So when I then heard people kind of afterwards saying, why don't people know about the Inflation Reduction Act? Or, you know, why are people not in the streets defending this and highlighting projects? One, I mean, we named it the Inflation Reduction Act,
SPEAKER_02which is, you know, just again, still blows my mind. Let's point the finger at the jagoff who's responsible for that.
SPEAKER_01Exactly. And second, you know, we ran a communication strategy that was basically purely aimed at D.C. and not at mobilizing the American public.
SPEAKER_03And so I think that— But can I just pause here and say, just for the record, because people are constantly saying this, but like you say, it was D.C.-focused— Elite focused. And it worked. It convinced the D.C. elite. It convinced the Democratic elite. And they put in a lot of work and expended a lot of political capital to produce an amazingly ambitious bill. So like people crap on that strategy. But like. worked pretty well that's why i sort of say that it's i think there's a complete justification to it and again i think people did an amazing job
and and i'll just say you know i'm in a lot of signal threads and groups of people who worked tirelessly to try and go after the big beautiful bill and i think we're doing all the great work that needed to be done of getting local op-eds written etc that said it's still not enough and so to your point of where people could invest more
SPEAKER_01I think we need to get into the organizing effort to then go out and change the laws that are holding that back in 49 other states. That's the infrastructure that we're trying to build.
SPEAKER_01We're talking with a lot of people. We're trying to build that out collaboratively. We would love to talk to funders who are interested in doing it. My pitch would be that it is cheaper. You're getting way more bang for your buck when you're helping advertise a product via a YouTube video, collect that data for that person and help solve the customer acquisition issue that the industry has. engage that person in local political work so that they can plug in to change regulations to help speed up all of this work. And then, as Bill said, give them a community of people who they can keep organizing
with so that they're more likely to go to additional hearings and comment on Nextdoor and get in all the
SPEAKER_01different places online and Reddit threads, et cetera, where we need to do this. So I just think that we haven't invested in that at scale in the ways that we need to.
SPEAKER_03We haven't invested in it at all.
SPEAKER_01I was being polite, you know?
SPEAKER_03It's wild. We haven't invested in it at all. And we're still cranking out these white papers, still cranking out sort of like politely worded press releases that are emailed to the proper list of journalists at the Washington Post. Just like we're fighting this war that like ended years ago. And there's this ongoing guerrilla fight in the streets of the internet that we're just not engaged in at all. It's shocking to me that no one in the green philanthropy world has done what seems to me very basic, low-hanging fruit harvesting here.
SPEAKER_00David, people should take a clue from the last part of this. You're right that the Inflation Reduction Act... had some elite inside DC, you know, organizing at the end there to put it across the finish line. But the reason that there was even a possibility was because of big scaled activism, you know, Greta's moment, and then followed in this country by the incredible work of the Sunrise Movement. people who had by and large come out of the fossil fuel divestment campaigns, but who figured out how to capture people's imagination.
SPEAKER_00People forget now, but in the 2020 Democratic primaries, climate was polling as the number one issue. And that's why Joe Biden, I mean, you know, that's why Joe Biden had Varshini Prakash on his transition committee, the head of the Sunrise Movement, you know, making sure that we got something that turned into the IRA eventually.
SPEAKER_03Of course, the entire Democratic establishment has decided, the entire elite centrist establishment has decided that that, the one period of time where Democrats actually got feisty and ambitious, that was where we went wrong. Yeah. It was the climate activism and the race activism and the gender activism. That is what they think is the problem.
SPEAKER_00They're going to get mom-donied now, so. Yeah,
SPEAKER_01I mean, that's, Dave, as you remember, I mean, that's the beauty of having a career of being, you know, told that we're radical, silly activists on the margins and doing it wrong, is that you sort of get used to not listening to those people. And, you know, it always sticks in my head of – You know, when Bill and I were, along with Jane Klebb, who's now working on rural clean energy, of all things, Jane, who is a key player in the fight against Keystone XL, you know, when we did those first sit-ins at the White House in 2011, there was a poll of energy insiders in D.C., and I think 97% of them said that the pipeline would be built
by the end of the
SPEAKER_01year. And of course, you know, I think Trump is still now committing to build it, last I checked. The communication environment has evolved now in notable ways that we're all sort of watching.
SPEAKER_03And we know that the sort of coin of the realm now is attention. Like, no one has to pay attention to you. If you issue a press release, no one has to care. Like, so everything now is about grabbing attention. And what I see is not just that the sort of big money, big establishment people on the left... Don't seem to get that. Don't seem to do it. It's that any group on the left that does sort of figure it out and does do something that actually disrupts and draws attention,
SPEAKER_03they get scolded. by all the rest of the people on the left. In other words, it's like the left is not just like trying to sprout flowers. It's chopping down anyone that sticks their head up. They're like, ooh, that might offend the sensibilities of the 52-year-old white guy mechanic in Erie, Pennsylvania, our perfect swing voter guy. He might not like that. Therefore, no one can do it. So it's not just that we're not doing it. It's that we're... It almost seems like actively discouraging it,
so I'm glad you're ignoring those people.
SPEAKER_01I mean, what I would say, again, to kind of the good news is that where we are doing it, it's going really well. And so I do want to shout out folks like Action for the Climate Emergency that works with young people around the country. Climate Power has been doing far more social content and has a creator program. And it's working. I mean, the metrics are great. It reaches people. The posts get lots of like. I think the challenge is it's still a drop in the bucket compared to the infrastructure that they have on the right. And so we know this can work. We do have to make sure it's connected to the activism piece of it because we don't
SPEAKER_01want to just be, you know, communicating to people and then leaving them there. We want to get their email and make sure they can go to a permitting hearing. Well, because the jobs went to Republican districts that will build political support on its own, as someone sort of slightly in the business of building political support,
SPEAKER_01that's never how it happens. You actually have to get out and organize.
SPEAKER_03They want to be insiders. They want to be bipartisan. They want to be lobbyists in the room with all the other big boy lobbyists. And they just don't see that they're getting their ass kicked. They are in a guerrilla fight and they've got to fight that way. I think one place where that needs to become clearer is for the clean energy
SPEAKER_00industry itself to take a little more active role. Yes. They've tried very hard to walk both sides of this politically over the years and, you know, willing to defend the production tax credit even at the cost of lots of bad environmental policy, whatever. I think by now it should be pretty clear to them that they have no friends on the right-wing side of the aisle, and they might as well square up and do some politicking themselves. Like, they just all got together and voted unanimously to crush your
industry with a boot.
SPEAKER_03Like, if that doesn't send the signal,
SPEAKER_00Bill,
SPEAKER_03if they don't hear that, what more evidence, I mean. Well, happily, a few of them are now throwing in with Sunday, and that's good.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_03So let's talk about the sort of big intellectual, if you want to call it that, big intellectual movement on the right, right now. Well, there's a couple going on. There's the YIMBY movement, which is very interesting to me for a bunch of reasons, kind of has developed somewhat outside the usual left-right battlefield and is, unlike a lot of other social movements, is just like winning, winning over and over again. There's that, and then there's the abundance thing,
SPEAKER_03the abundance push, the abundance idea, which is related to Yimby but not overlapping. So what you guys are talking about here, marshalling climate activists in favor of building stuff, in favor of building clean energy, in favor of removing permitting barriers and removing bureaucratic barriers and removing regulations that slow these things down and all this stuff, that is the same kind of thing that the abundance people do. are talking about, and similar to what the YIMBY people are talking about.
SPEAKER_03So I'm just curious how you see this new push in the climate area, how you see it relating to those other things that are going on. Do you see those as fellow travelers, as competitors? How should we think about this? Well, let's talk about the YIMBY one because I feel like that's an easy one.
SPEAKER_01You know, I think we really want to work closely and we've reached out to various YIMBY groups and they're getting involved in Sunday and we're talking about how to build affordable housing and clean energy. And obviously the two go hand in hand in a lot of different places. Now, as many commentators have noted, there are some, you know, old school, nimby environmentalists who don't want to see affordable housing where they lived. And so, you know, I think that the movement is diverse and those are people that we would push to say, hey, look, We get where you're coming from, but this is a priority.
SPEAKER_01It needs to happen. And the benefits outweigh the potential harms that are on the ground. And it's important to just remember the environmental movement slash climate movement slash energy movement is an incredibly diverse array of groups even within itself. You know, you have old school environmentalists. You have young clean energy campaigners. You have old clean energy campaigners and young NIMBYs. You know, it doesn't always cut along the same lines. And so I think it's easy for the press and for commentators to paint with a broad brush and say climate activists don't like this or they don't support that,
SPEAKER_01when in fact are probably factions and diversity within that crowd. But would you say that you feel some responsibility to try to advocate for YIMBY
SPEAKER_03within the environmental movement?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, absolutely. You are trying to change that. Yeah, and I think, you know, Bill can speak to this more because he's written some great pieces, you know, really encouraging environmentalists to kind of understand the importance of moving forward on clean energy projects. I'll just touch on abundance quickly before handing it over to Bill. I think we really need a clean energy abundance movement. You know, I read Ezra and Derek's book. I think there's a lot in there, most of it, that I really agree with. And I think when you read the actual book, it's all about clean energy and science research and all of that.
SPEAKER_02That's a minority strategy.
SPEAKER_01Actually reading the book is a— Actually reading the book. I'd recommend it. And Ezra, I think Ezra or Derek, both of them, I guess, right at the beginning, saying, look, we're going to go pick on left-wing cities because we think that progressives are the only ones who will listen to us. And Republicans might not engage in this debate, so we'll make it all about going after— which I think is maybe a slightly cynical PR strategy, but there's a kernel of truth in that. Look at its success. My challenge would be, I think that we want an abundance of good things.
SPEAKER_01We want an abundance of clean energy. We want an abundance of healthy food. We want an abundance of social justice. I don't think we want an abundance of new fossil fuel projects and pollution and childhood asthma. You know, there's an abundance of TikTok videos online. I don't think anybody feels like that's made our attention better. And so I think we just have to be a little bit clearer of we want good things, not bad things. And the challenge of abundance, of course, is that it's been hijacked by a lot or it's being attempted to be hijacked by a lot of right wing groups that have for a long time pushed a
deregulation agenda that's meant to hand more power over to corporations to do whatever they want to.
SPEAKER_01And in the case of climate, often fossil fuel companies who want to build more fossil fuel infrastructure. So, you know, when it comes down to the exact permitting bill fight in Congress that may play out, we'll have to see. And we may have to make tough choices about how much it will benefit clean energy over fossil fuels. But I think that's a conversation that we're really willing to have and want to debate with people, but debate in good faith. And I think that the more that commentators can kind of engage in it like that and think about wait a second, do we really need to be getting rid of NEPA to put solar panels
on a rooftop?
SPEAKER_01That doesn't make sense. I think that we can have that conversation as we go. And we'd love for people in the abundant space to get more involved in the real work of organizing to cut red tape that's standing in the way of things like rooftop solar and batteries.
SPEAKER_00And this is one reason why it's really important to to keep the climate part of this conversation really engaged, because that is the deep, deep underlying threat to our civilizations. And so we're not in a position of just being able to say, we're in favor of building any damn thing in the world. We need to be building the things that help us get out of the greatest crisis we've ever faced. Now, I've written a series of pieces now,
SPEAKER_00sort of trying to persuade people like me, which is to say, old white guys, to stop suing to block things that they don't want to look at. And I think that's really important. I think it's highly irresponsible at this point to be saying that build that solar farm somewhere else. I don't want to look at it. And I think that's a key part of this kind of, you know, there's a kind of moral cast than there should be to this Yimby idea. And I think that the sheer fact of the abundance of solar
energy, the fact that it
SPEAKER_00falls in volumes far greater than we could ever make use of, is maybe the most beautiful fact about the world we live in right now. But none of that gives us permission to throw people under the bus who are fighting hard to preserve history. their place from real and toxic threats and so on and so forth. That's the reason we do this work is to try and build a world that doesn't have that stuff in it. So for me, you know, there's a political dimension to this abundance debate,
SPEAKER_00but there's also just the sheer fact of abundance. That's why I like the sun, which already gives us, David, I mean, just think about it for a minute. The sun gives us warmth, it gives us light, it gives us photosynthesis, and it's now willing to give us all the power we could ever need. That's so mind-blowing and so liberating and so beautiful that hopefully we can figure out how to use that to start and kind of shift
SPEAKER_00some of the tired axes of our political debate.
SPEAKER_03Well, I want to push you both on a few more specific areas of contention, because when I threw this out on social media, this is what people want to hear about. So I do see the overlap with abundance. It's quite obvious. And I think you're both right to say, have said in other places, that Green groups, despite the frickin' ludicrous stereotypes about them that still dominate mainstream media, have actually been pro-clean energy for a long time and have been fighting and organizing for clean energy for a long time.
SPEAKER_03They were abundance, solar abundance, before it was cool. So there is a lot of overlap, and I think the Yimby thing fits squarely in there. But... There are points of contention, and these are points of contention, I think, not just with the abundance thing, but with some larger, more powerful democratic groups. One is, which you've both sort of touched on, is that the abundance people are explicitly pro-fossil fuel development. They basically say the U.S. 's own emissions – are relatively meaningless in the larger scheme of things.
SPEAKER_03The U.S. just needs to be creating and driving down the price of clean technologies and exporting them. And until that happens, people should be running on clean U.S. natural gas rather than whatever the dirty coal, et cetera, et cetera. You know all the arguments, basically. But, like, they are very pro-fossil fuel products. Do you think that that's just an unbridgeable chasm here? I mean, this seems like something that you can't talk your way around. It's a fundamental break between the two groups. I just think it's nonsense because the economics are so far
removed from what that is.
SPEAKER_00The Chinese are now setting the pace of energy economics in this world. They're demonstrating that the only way that you're going to get to be a player in the world going forward is if you can produce lots of low cost energy, which means energy from the sun and wind and batteries. Natural gas is just not only a climate wrecker, but it's also just an outmoded old technology now that can't really compete with what we can do. And if you have any doubts about that,
just watch in the next year as what happens in China starts to reverberate around
SPEAKER_00the globe. If you look at things like car sales data from around the world now, the entire Global South, their vehicle fleet's going to come from China, and they're going to be electric, and they're not going to be using U.S. oil or anybody else's. And on and on and on across a wide range, if we have any serious pretension to making America an important part of the world economy, then we're going to do this. We're going to have to do this.
SPEAKER_00The alternative is to decide, and I think this is really sort of close to Trump's heart, is to decide that 15 years from now, America is going to be the global museum for internal combustion, where people from other countries who can wangle a tourist visa come to see what the world looked like back in the olden days, you know?
SPEAKER_03Well, let me push you a little bit on that, on one specific thing then. As we speak, two of the groups that you helped start, 350 and Third Act, are, as we speak, fighting against the revival of nuclear power in New York State. This seems like a lot of abundance people, I think, view this as unforgivable hypocrisy. They say, you want us... To be building this, you say the trade-offs are worth it.
SPEAKER_03You say the climate is a crisis. You say the climate matters more than anything else. And you say you want abundance and you say you want building and you say you want to pro-clean energy. And here you are out fighting carbon-free energy. How do you think about that, Bill? From my point of view, the other thing I want along with all of that is mathematics.
SPEAKER_00And in fact, I think Third Act Upstate New York is not so much opposing Governor Hochul's plan for a nuclear power plant as just pointing out that the New York state had promised to build 15 gigs worth of clean energy and that the cost of building one gig of that in nuclear power is probably the equivalent of of what you'd spend to build 15 gigs of solar and wind, and that you'd get it built three, four, five, six, seven times as fast.
SPEAKER_00I don't think anybody has, I don't know anybody left who has any, you know, spends their time worrying that much about the consequences of nuclear power, because compared to the consequences of an overheated world, we can probably deal with it. I think people are just doing the math and figuring out that it does not make a lot of sense to spend your money here right now. That's what I was saying before about Costco. You know, if people want to keep trying to shop at the most expensive
boutique, then OK. But really, in a realistic world, you go buy what's cheap, available and ready to go. Well, let's talk about one other critique, and maybe, Jamie, you can weigh in on this one.
SPEAKER_03One other big part of the Abundance book, which you, unlike most people, read, is a critique of, and here I'm air-quoting, The Groups. So the idea here among abundance people is that they are these professionalized nonprofit groups that are run basically by young people who are far to the left, not only of the median American voter, but of the median Democratic voter.
Basically, these nonprofit activist groups have been captured by young lefties.
SPEAKER_03They are then lobbying Democratic politicians, pushing and forcing Democratic politicians to take positions that place them outside the mainstream. And so this critique gets... It's focused a lot on racial stuff, on gender stuff, on social stuff, but it does hit climate too. So the idea is like, you guys thunder out of the gate with the Green New Deal, which sounded great among all the young lefties who developed it.
SPEAKER_03But then it's introduced to the American mainstream. They recoil in horror. Fox characterizes it as banning cows and banning cars. And basically, Democratic politicians are stuck in a bind. Either they do what the groups want them to do, And if they don't do what the groups want them to do, they get beat up, they get spent against, they get lobbied against, or they do what the broad public wants them to do, in which case the groups beat up on them. So green groups are part of this critique.
And I just wonder what you thought about that aspect of the critique and how you, whether you have any criticism or self-criticism of how nonprofits have engaged in
SPEAKER_03this fight.
SPEAKER_01Well, I think that there's a lack of understanding maybe of how kind of politics really works in some of these critiques, or at least a kind of sense of like that there can't be a really productive give and take. And so I hate to give credit to the right on things like this. And I'm not one of those liberals who thinks they do everything right, because I think that the right has its whole own huge problems and challenges. But you see on the right a real understanding of how they can They mobilize their fringe, their base, and then move things into the political mainstream.
And so you don't see Donald Trump and folks sort of critiquing their fringe pieces.
SPEAKER_01Sometimes it blows up in their face, like around Epstein or things. But they have sort of an ecosystem there that understands how to take ideas... from their base, digest them, and then use them to really expand their political power. The left is terrible at this. You know, my experience of D.C. politicians, and maybe it's the groups that I'm coming into the door with, but tends to be that they're incredibly fearful of doing anything that would be exciting and mean. and get out there and embrace these issues. I mean, people like Zoran are the great exception,
SPEAKER_01which is why he gets so much attention at this moment. I don't think you see lots of Democratic politicians out there, you know, pushing exciting radical concepts to engage the American public. Quite the opposite, in fact. And so I think... Look, you asked for self-critique. Of course. I think there are demands that activists have put forward that didn't meet the moment, that aren't popular, that won't translate well into the immediate electoral space. I tend to give activists a bit more leeway on that because I think it's not always the role of an activist on the ground to...
SPEAKER_01be keeping electoral math of the moment in mind. I think that if you looked back at past social movements in America and chastised the civil rights movement for doing things that were unpopular, we wouldn't be where we are today. So I think it's really the role of the grassroots to push and to try and expand that Overton window. But it seems like something that's happened is the internet has kind of flattened everything.
SPEAKER_03So everybody's just a voice on your screen. Do you know what I mean? So activists are a voice on your screen. Democratic politicians are a voice on your screen. The idea that they have separate roles, that they're allowed to take different strategies. You know what I mean? Everybody is treated as though they are an official spokesperson for all of the left at all times, which is just like... You've got to have division of labor. You've got to have some people pushing and some people doing other stuff. The internet has just made everybody in the same pool.
And it's really screwed up that dynamic in ways that I can't really capture.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, and so I think people have to be a little more comfortable with the messiness of that and know how to work with it. And know how to take the best pieces of an idea that appeals to you, that you think you can use in your district, and go out and run with it. And as always, kind of keep the focus on the opposition as well. Again, you used the Green New Deal piece of it. We were always sort of amazed that Fox News saw the power of the idea, but MSNBC never did.
SPEAKER_02They get it immediately.
SPEAKER_01Fox got it immediately. And they understand the importance of fighting over these things. And I think the answer is not to never say something compelling again. That's not going to work out well for us. The answer is to figure out how do we fight for it more effectively. And I think that goes to a lot of what we've been talking about today.
SPEAKER_03Well, yeah, it's the information. I mean, not to get back to the information environment, but I think a lot about the New Green Deal episode because when it was introduced, there were some specifics attached, but nobody really officially... There was no official version of it. No one really owned it. There was just a lot of... It was just a fertile idea. It was a fertile platform on which you could have built almost anything. So a smart political party would have said, look, here's this incredibly fertile idea that is like a container.
SPEAKER_03We can put whatever we want in it. It's a marketing vehicle that already is potent, already is powerful, already catches the imagination. We can just put whatever we want in this container and And let that be the flag. If we don't like the radical stuff, if we don't like the jobs guarantee or whatever the hell piece of it we decide we don't like, just ignore it. Just drop it. You know what I mean? That's what they do with the radical ideas on their side. They don't go debating them and... In Washington Post op-eds,
they just ignore those parts and let them drift away.
SPEAKER_03Just like put whatever agenda you want behind this. But like instead, because it drew attention, it drew Fox attention. Fox poisoned it. And because Fox poisoned it, now the whole left is like, oh, well, it's poisoned. We got to stay away from it. I'm just like, you guys, they're just going to do that over and over again.
SPEAKER_01To bring us up to the moment we find ourselves in now, it's the right and Trump and Republicans who are way out of line with the American people. If you go look at polling, the vast majority of the public supports clean energy. They want more clean energy jobs. They want to see these investments in America. They don't want more fossil fuels. And so I think that we have to really embrace that. There's a kind of self-flagellation on the left of nobody likes us,
SPEAKER_00nobody agrees with us,
SPEAKER_01so we're not going to talk confidently about these issues. This is a moment to go to absolute battle with the other side and blame them for the rising electricity prices. Facts are on our side, but I think the narrative is on our side as well. And we need to be confident going out there and doing that and be a little less fearful of our own shadow, but a little bit more creative about how we get the message out there.
SPEAKER_00Amen. The polling shows that people love the sun and that solar energy is powerful and pulls beautifully across partisan lines. This is one of the places to make this stand. And that's why we're doing it.
SPEAKER_03One thing that really grabbed me in your Rolling Stone piece, I guess I don't mind the idea of abundance. I don't mind the whole abundance push. There's something to it. I don't know how it is as a slogan or whatever, but the idea that government should provide for people is great. I'm all for that. But you use a word toward the end of your Rolling Stone piece that just, to me, is much more fertile, much more sort of intriguing. And that word is liberation. which I think has some of the same implications,
SPEAKER_03but also some more, packs a little bit more in there. So maybe by way of taking us out, just talk a little bit about what you mean when you say... And you sort of gestured at this before, you know, there's more to this than just the economics, the physics of providing power. There's more to solar power than just different electrons. There's something beyond that. So maybe by way of concluding, talk a little bit about what you mean by liberation.
SPEAKER_00Absolutely. We've been locked in an energy system since the Industrial Revolution that was all about centralization. Energy came from a few big facilities and was piped down the line to us and we took it and that was that. And it was controlled by people who controlled those relatively rare and scarce deposits of fossil fuel around the world. But that's not necessary anymore. In 1954, people invented this solar cell in Bell Labs in New Jersey
And it turns out that it's able to directly translate the power of the sun,
SPEAKER_00those billions of hydrogen into helium reactions every second, and make that useful power for all of us. And it liberates us from dependence on those oil companies and all the other parts of that structure, because all of a sudden we can produce on our own homes or locally in our own states, the stuff that we need. It liberates us from the incredible threats that we're now
facing and that darken
SPEAKER_00our world all the time, the threat of climate change above all. And it sends us up into a kind of, well, a kind of sunny upland, you know? Energy from heaven, not from hell. When I borrowed the title for this book from George Harrison, I'd always loved that song, Here Comes the Sun. Abbey Road was the first record album I bought with my own money at the age of So that's up, by the way, a high bar to begin with.
SPEAKER_02Truly. But I didn't know that Here Comes the Sun was the most popular song in the Beatles
SPEAKER_00catalog, at least if you go by streaming on Spotify. Hmm. Twice as popular as Hey Jude or Let It Be. And I think it's because there's something so optimistic and gentle about that song. So pregnant with the possibility of a very different world that we could wake up to where... the systems and structures that have governed our lives begin to melt away a little bit.
SPEAKER_00Look, we live on a planet haunted by climate change, and we live on a planet made grotesque by the inequality that we see around us. The biggest structural change that we could make easily and immediately that would do at least something about both those crises is to switch from fossil fuel to energy from the sun. That's the one big good thing happening on planet Earth.
SPEAKER_03I probably should end there for poetic reasons, but I remembered one other point I wanted to cover, which is just I think a lot of people, when they hear, this will free us from dependence on the people sitting on the oil, they think, well, won't it then make us dependent on the people sitting on, you know, lithium? Or silicon? No, because, I mean, this is a good point to make, because it really makes this point more real.
SPEAKER_00There is no such thing as a free lunch. There's only more expensive and less expensive lunches, OK? And so there's very real costs that go with mining lithium, say. And we need to do what we can to make sure that it's done as humanely and environmentally soundly as possible. But when the minute you start thinking about this switch, you understand how huge it is. If you go mine some lithium and you stick it in a battery, then it sits there doing its thing for the next 25 years.
SPEAKER_00If the battery is eventually outmoded, we now can cost-effectively recycle the lithium and start again.
SPEAKER_03You do not have to keep feeding lithium into it. If you go mine coal, you set it on fire and you have to mine some more tomorrow. Yes, this is such a crucial point. You only have to pull the minerals out of the earth once.
SPEAKER_00Once. A boatload of solar panels will provide, over its lifetime, about 500 times as much energy as a boatload of coal. If you let that sink into your consciousness, then you begin to understand the possibilities of the world ahead.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, because I really think the vision of a closed loop material cycle is kind of the final piece of the puzzle here. Do you know what I mean? Like, once you get that in your head, you're like, oh, I can actually start to imagine humanity living on Earth. Yeah. In a way that's not eating our seed corn. Do you know what I mean? In a way that's not sort of like burning down a fuse. In a way that's sustainable and like the original.
David Roberts, this is the place where your nerdy soul meets your rock music soul, man.
SPEAKER_00And you have the final epiphany that gets you where we need to go.
SPEAKER_03Yes. All the energy we need falling on us from the sky, all the minerals we need to harvest that energy already dug up. We're just recycling them over and over and over again. And then we're stopping the vast systematic plundering of the earth for fossil fuels that we have been doing for hundreds of years. It sounds so sci-fi that people are not letting it sink in and really into their hearts, but that world is in sight. It's just over the horizon. It's a real possibility.
SPEAKER_01Sunday, baby. Sunday. Yeah, I was going to say, Bill, as a good organizer, we'll end with the ask, which is, that's the world we're trying to kind of give a sneak preview of. on Sunday, on September 21st. So listeners can help go to the website and organize events or attend events. There are already some solar-powered, battery-powered rock concerts in the works, but we need many, many more. We have a great artistic ambassador, Antonique Smith, a singer who's going to be singing Here Comes the Sun, has been doing that around the country. So lots of fun to be had. And I will say it really is fun.
SPEAKER_01I've been in this work now for a couple decades, not nearly as long as Bill, but I'm doing my best to catch up. What keeps me going is that the activism piece of this is actually super fun to go out there and cause some trouble and get these ideas out and actually get our hands dirty making some change in our communities and not just talking about it from the sidelines. We're eager to recruit folks into that fight and partner with people too because our approach has always been this has to be a movement of hundreds and hundreds of groups. We're not trying to set up, you know,
SPEAKER_01the one new organization, but really empower all of us to go out there and do the work together.
SPEAKER_03All right, guys, that's a great place to quit. It's beautiful. It's just nice that after years and years of saying, we're doomed, we're doomed, please pay attention to how doomed we are. It's like the cavalry is coming. And we get to be the ones to tell people that the cavalry is coming. It's like, what a fun twist of fate.
SPEAKER_00Here comes the sun.
SPEAKER_03Thank you for all your work over the years. Thank you for this. And good luck with this going forward. Thank you, Dave. Onwards.
SPEAKER_00Take care, man. And thank you so much for all your education.
SPEAKER_03Thank you for listening to Volts. It takes a village to make this podcast work. Shout out especially to my super producer, Kyle McDonald, who makes me and my guests sound smart every week. and it is all supported entirely by listeners like you. So if you value conversations like this, please consider joining our community of paid subscribers at volts.wtf, or leaving a nice review, or telling a friend about volts, or all three.
SPEAKER_03Thanks so much, and I'll see you next time.
This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit www.volts.wtf/subscribe When people push for better data centers, they picture hyperscalers - Amazon,...
This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit www.volts.wtf/subscribe America’s first big wave of solar power installations, built between 15 and...
This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit www.volts.wtf/subscribe The Senate’s bipartisan permitting bill got a manager’s amendment last week -...
This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit www.volts.wtf/subscribe Last week’s election was a blue wave all the way down the ballot: Democrats...
This is a free preview of a paid episode. To hear more, visit www.volts.wtf Volts published eight conversations in October, which is a lot for anyone to listen to. We’ve rounded up the highlights into less than an hour....