Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Volts

Volts artwork

The case for using prices rather than VPPs to coordinate distributed energy

May 8, 20261 hr 30 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit www.volts.wtf/subscribe Most people think that coordinating the behavior of thousands of distributed energy resources requires some kind of third-party middleman, like an aggregator managing a VPP. My guest today, veteran research scientist Bruce Nordman, believes there’s a better way: dynamic, time- and location-specific retail prices, communicated directly to consumer devices, which would cut out the middleman and leave more value with customers.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_01Hello everyone, this is Volts for May 8, 2026. The case for using prices rather than VPPs to coordinate distributed energy. I'm your host, David Roberts. The electricity grid has more and more participants. There are increasing numbers of small distributed energy resources, or DERs, Solar panels, home batteries,

SPEAKER_01EVs, EV chargers, hot water heaters, commercial and residential HVAC systems, and on and on, that need to be coordinated to work as efficiently as possible for the good of the grid as a whole. But how should they be coordinated? One answer, which I have discussed many times here on Volts, is what are called virtual power plants, or VPPs. This involves a single aggregator, usually but not always, a private party,

SPEAKER_01contracting with dozens, hundreds, or thousands of distributed energy device owners agreeing to control and coordinate their device's behavior, monetize the flexibility, and share the value with the owners. My guest today, Bruce Nordman, spent nearly four decades as a research scientist at Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory working at the intersection of network technology and energy systems and he thinks VPPs are the wrong answer not because they don't work they do

but because the gap they're exploiting between the real-time locational value of electricity and the

SPEAKER_01flat time invariant rates actually charged to customers shouldn't exist If retail electricity prices actually reflected real-time value, there would be nothing to arbitrage. The flexibility value currently being split with aggregators would just stay with customers, captured automatically by their own devices, without any private third party reaching in their home to do it.

SPEAKER_01The technologies needed to do this, basically a central price server to send the price signal and devices capable of responding to it, have become cost-effective on a mass scale in recent years, and there are limited experiments underway in some places running things this way. In this conversation, Nordman and I dig into it pretty deeply. Okay, very deeply. This is an intensely wonky discussion,

SPEAKER_01more technical than most of what happens here on Volts, but if you are a real head and you want to understand how to actually get the most out of distributed energy resources, I think it is ultimately fascinating and worth it. with no further ado Bruce Nordman welcome to Volts thank you so much for coming well thank you this is a lot Bruce and I've been thinking about

how to ease into it

SPEAKER_01so kind of where I want to start is at the big abstract level so like when you first approached me with this you're like let's use prices instead of VPPs I had in mind like oh like you're gonna like design some novel tariff for PJM or something something like that but this is much bigger than that this is a sort of ground up new vision for how electricity works. So it's a little bit more to get into. And part of the big vision here is similar to Jonas,

SPEAKER_01who we talked to a couple of weeks ago, Jonas Bergeson, in that this is about transitioning the electricity industry from the old unitary model to a networked system that's what I talked with Jonas about this is I think an excellent adjunct to that or your sequel or I don't know exactly what you'd call it but like you're involved in broadly speaking the same project so you write that the telephone system

and the electricity grid were invented roughly the same time, roughly the same place.

SPEAKER_01So they are interesting kind of analogs to track. And as listeners know, at this point, we covered it a little bit on the Jonas Pod, the telephone system has now entirely been transformed into a The internet and this involved as I said going from a unitary system to what's called a networked system and the electricity grid notably has not and so one of the things I want to talk about starting up front is some of

the aspects of what it means to go from a unitary to a networked system and then so we can look at sort of

SPEAKER_01how the internet did it and how the electricity grid has not done it You have this chart here of qualities of a unitary system and qualities of a network system. A lot of this, I think, people understand intuitively. So you're going from a centralized system to a distributed system. You're going from a largely analog system to a largely digital system. but here's one that I want to look at because I think it's important for understanding the electricity grid and why it's such a problem

one of the things that the telephone system did is go from a tightly coupled systems to loosely coupled so just briefly and keep in mind briefly because we've got a lot of

SPEAKER_01territory to cover just briefly talk about what it means for systems to be tightly coupled or loosely coupled. And maybe tell us how it is that the internet is loosely coupled and then contrast that to tightly coupled systems in the utility grid.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. So on the telephone system, when I was a child, if I picked up the phone and called my grandmother, a circuit was set up and there was a continuous flow of data at a constant data rate between the two ends of the system over one specific circuit and even if Owen was talking it was there one thing which enables things to be loosely coupled is storage on the internet you can connect links of different communication technologies that run at different speeds because you can store and

forward packets which sort of accounts for the fact that things are running on different technologies and different speeds so for communication storage changed

SPEAKER_00everything Yeah, one of the themes here,

SPEAKER_01and I might as well just put an exclamation point on it now, is normal people, even people who think about electricity, I don't think anybody has fully absorbed electricity. What a big deal it is to go from a system with no storage to a system with storage. It just fundamentally changes the architectural possibilities. It's more fundamental than people appreciate, I think. So give me an example of a tightly coupled system.

SPEAKER_00Well, like the old phone system was tightly coupled where everything was interconnected and really the old electricity grid was where every customer site was just part of the grid. It didn't have any really functional identity. It couldn't operate separately. So the grid ended at every end use device.

SPEAKER_01So for every customer to be part of one big pool, that means if I pull on anything in the customer site, it affects everything because everything is part of the same system. Everybody's coupled together. and so loosely coupled means that you get some distinction right functional distinction between these systems such that they can operate somewhat in isolation without affecting one another is that fair absolutely and part of this is the the

AC frequency of 60 Hertz as we use is part of what enforces this in that really

SPEAKER_00things are all very interconnected and all the load affects the frequency So one advantage of having loosely coupled systems as opposed to tightly coupled systems. A tightly coupled system, as I said, if you pull on one string, you affect everything. Basically, you can't fiddle with the machine without fiddling with the whole thing.

SPEAKER_01But if you have loosely coupled systems, you can innovate and change and evolve the systems separately and independently.

SPEAKER_00Exactly.

SPEAKER_01And that, I think, enables much faster evolution and expansion and scope. And the one underneath that on the list, I think, is similar and related. So entangled technologies versus isolated technologies. Similar sort of concept, right?

SPEAKER_00Exactly. And this is where the internet technology example is highly informative, where the architecture of the system does this isolating of complexity so that, as you say, systems can evolve separately. So ideally, the technology inside of a customer's site can evolve separately. from the technology on the grid and you can minimize the point of interaction between them.

SPEAKER_01Right. And so the reason I think that the telephone system was able to make this leap, like one of the reasons you point out is that we were able to build the new system basically alongside the old system. And like for a while we had the two systems going and then we sort of eased our way from the one to the other.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, so originally internet communications went over phone lines with dial-up modems, and then we flipped it so that with voice over IP, the phone calls went over the internet lines. There's a similar sort of transition from where we are to where we want to be.

SPEAKER_01Right. You know, what I'm trying to get at here is one of the reasons that the electricity system has not been able to make this similar transition is that you can't really do what you did with the telephones. You cannot build the new system alongside the old system. It is all one big system and you can't, what's the analogy, rebuilding the plane in flight type of thing. So that just makes it trickier. I would actually push back on that and this sort of gets back to some of the earlier points you made about the podcast with Jonas about his

approach to networking electricity and mine on the internet there is the wide area network and there's the local area network the local area network is what's inside of each customer site whether it's your house or an office building or a factory and then you've got the modem and router at that boundary and then the wide area network is

SPEAKER_00everything else and there's technologies that only exist inside of LANs and there's technologies that only exist inside of the wide area network and then of course there's things like the internet protocol and some other ones that exist in both. So we talk about entangled technologies versus isolated technologies and that's a great example I think the WAN and the LAN like you can fiddle with WANs technology wide area networks you can fiddle with local area technology and you don't

SPEAKER_01implicate the one and the other. You can work on them separately, which enables rapid innovation. So as a final thing, transitioning from the unitary to the network system, and this is, I think, both the most important one and the most difficult for people to wrap their heads around, is going from a deterministic system to a non-deterministic system. What's funny is the reason the telephone people didn't invent the internet was is that they were running a deterministic system and they were

convinced that only a deterministic system could work they could not imagine how a non-deterministic system could do the communications work that telephones did and of course they were wrong people came along did it and they faded into history like dinosaurs now we're in an electricity basically the exact same exact parallel situation which is right

SPEAKER_01now the people running it are running a deterministic system and they are convinced that only a deterministic system can work and they cannot imagine how a non-deterministic system could work so just tell us what is a deterministic system and what is a non-deterministic system So a deterministic system is where you you plan out everything in advance and then

SPEAKER_00you just operate according to your plan, right? Airplanes used to do that. They used to file flight plans with the FAA They said exactly the route that we're going to fly and they had to adhere to that unless they got permission to fly differently So that the FAA would always knew what they were going to do and then maybe a decade ago I don't remember exactly when the FAA cited, you know Other than these military areas where you're supposed to stay out of fly wherever you want and we just transition from a deterministic system to a non-deterministic one and

SPEAKER_00it still works. And you can imagine if you ran the old airplane system why that notion would freak

SPEAKER_01you the hell out. If you are used to working with deterministic systems the idea that all the planes are going to run themselves their own direction and you're just going to coordinate on the fly sounds crazy. And yet it works.

SPEAKER_00Railroads conventionally are quite deterministic, particularly before where you plan out where the trains are going to be so that they don't run into each other. That's certainly quite important. Whereas car traffic is non-deterministic. When you start driving someplace, you don't tell somebody in advance exactly the route and timing that you're going to take. You kind of make it up on the fly by observing the traffic, maybe seeing what Google Maps says and such.

SPEAKER_01Yes. To our point here, the communication system, the internet has become non-deterministic. So as you said, on the telephone system, if I pick up a line, connect to another person, that is a particular physical circuit that the data is traveling to and from. That's not how the internet works. And I don't think necessarily that people know this. It's worth describing briefly. Like if you send a packet of information out onto the internet, it is not the same. There's not a set path that that packet goes along to,

to its destination.

SPEAKER_01So what happens and how does it, how do we make it work?

SPEAKER_00Yeah, so packets for the same chunk of data, whether it's an email or some streaming video, different packets in that, and there's going to be an enormous number of these packets, are going to take different paths and arrive at different times, and they are reassembled at the end. And if any of them don't arrive, there's ways to retransmit them with TCP to make the whole system work. And to your point about the phone company being blind to this, multiple people went to Bell Labs in the 1950s and said, hey, there's this new thing called packet switching.

SPEAKER_00We think it's the future of communications. And the smart engineer said, yeah, we know that cannot possibly work. And there are people who say it is impossible for a utility to charge a good retail price. And of course, they are wrong also. It is possible for utilities to charge good and better retail prices. They just choose not to. So to your point about deterministic, the wholesale system for electricity has always been deterministic. And my guess is always will be because that's how wholesale markets work.

SPEAKER_00But retail electricity has never been deterministic. People are trying to force it to be through things like VPPs, but that's not necessary in general for balancing supply and demand. Now, deterministic operation is necessary for addressing distribution system capacity issues, which is its own separate topic that I assume will come up later. But that operates at a totally different scale of a few customers at a time versus millions of customers at a time. and so the two mechanisms operate in parallel.

The idea here is that we're going to go to a non-deterministic electricity system and I think people get nervous about that because like if you don't get an email it's one thing but like power home and hearth your medical machines whatever like electricity is very important so I just think it's worth emphasizing that despite rubbing our intuitions the wrong way I think like I'm not sure our brains are naturally wired

SPEAKER_01to think non-deterministically but We have found through experience that a massive non-deterministic system can in aggregate be as reliable or more reliable than a deterministic system and can scale much faster. But anyway, this is all by way of preface. This is all by way of saying that what you're working on, what you're thinking about, similarly to what Jonas is thinking about, similarly, honestly, to what you and other electricity researchers have been beating

your heads on for

SPEAKER_01decades now, which is trying to take this unitary deterministic system, transition it to a massively coordinated networked system, and thus reap all the benefits in the electricity system that we got by the similar transition from telephone to internet, airlines all these other examples you could say so this is all part of that big transition and so your basic fundamental point and the reason we're doing this podcast and the core thing here is that your contention your

hypothesis is that if

SPEAKER_01you're going to move from a top-down to a networked system you can't have top-down coordination anymore so how do you get coordination how do you make sure all these loosely coupled systems are operating in concert to produce the desired results how do you coordinate all this stuff your contention is that prices are the only mechanism that can do that at every scale and in every context.

SPEAKER_00Exactly. I've been looking for the last 20 years for other mechanisms. I've never found another mechanism that can do that any scale at any context. And so before we jump into what that means and how you envision it working, I just want to go over what you see as a few of the high-level benefits of doing

SPEAKER_01this. Why would we want to do this? Why is it worth it? hashing through how it works and hashing through the trouble what is the point of the trouble and so that the main thing which we just mentioned is that you think it is basically like context and scale agnostic price can work for a distribution grid can work for a micro grid can work for an individual building and can work for a nano grid inside the building at every level of organization.

SPEAKER_01The coordination is being done by pricing.

SPEAKER_00Exactly. And one important point here is that I'm a buildings person. I've worked on energy to use some buildings for the last four decades. I am not a utility grid person. So I try to resist telling people how the utility grid should operate internally. But I also like utility grid people to not tell buildings people how buildings should operate internally because that's not their area of expertise.

SPEAKER_01I actually kind of appreciate that. This is like most of Volts guests are very grid centric, but your sort of take is like, I got this covered here in my building. Don't mess with me. Just give me my power. Tell me the price. You're not asking much of the grid, basically. The grid needs to tell you what the price is and supply you power. All the other work, all the flexibility work, all the coordination work is done on the consumer side. So this is very consumer-centric, distributed, building-centric view.

I like to use the word customer to make clear that this is applicable to all

SPEAKER_00customer types, whether you're a residential commercial or industrial or agricultural. Right.

SPEAKER_01Another merit of pricing. And this to me is the most compelling reason to use prices for this coordination is that it allows the customer to accrue all the benefits and the value of flexibility. If you get a VPP in there, an aggregator in there, the aggregator takes a cut to 50% around. Yes. But if the devices are simply acting flexibly on their own in

response to price

SPEAKER_01signals, all of that flexibility value stays with the customer. The customer gets all of it.

SPEAKER_00Exactly.

SPEAKER_01When people hear pricing, they think, oh, capitalism. They think exploitation. They think poor people are going to get screwed. Pricing brings up all that stuff. But it should be emphasized this is a very customer-centric view here. This is a view of the grid where customers get the value, reap the most value. Customers are in the driver's seat in this vision and are getting a higher proportion of the value than they would in any other system. exactly yes this is designed around what's best for customers

and customer devices in devices that exist today and will even more so in the future and so it's designing the relationship between the grid and the customer around what is best for the customer but also works for the grid because remember we invented the grid to serve customers we didn't invent customers to serve I think a lot of grid people

SPEAKER_00don't quite understand that the customer is supposed to be always right And then the third benefit of pricing that I just want to throw out there is, and I think people are not going to be able to really understand this until we talk

SPEAKER_01a little bit about the model and how it works, but this vision of pricing maximizes customer privacy and autonomy and cybersecurity. Because basically, we'll get into the details, but basically under your model, the customer is not sharing any information with the grid above it. And again we'll talk through how that works but the point is like in this model customer privacy is total what goes on on the customer site is

not known by anyone but the customer and it is not the business of anyone but the customer so that is as privacy maximizing as you could get there's no grid and you know third parties can do some work we'll talk about that later but there doesn't need to be any third

SPEAKER_01party looking into your customer site Your devices are doing the work themselves and they're doing it based on your preferences and nobody else needs to know or mess with that.

SPEAKER_00Yes, but the grid does continue to know what happens at the meter and they should have smart meter The grid absolutely needs to and should have that meter data and needs it to function effectively. But that's the limit of what they need to know. They think they need to know more, but they're wrong. Right and just to clarify you said this before but just to clarify for everybody just so they know we're talking about retail prices here we're

not for the moment we're just leaving the wholesale system the wholesale energy market the wholesale the transmission system we're just leaving that aside we're talking about retail systems coordinating distribution grids so let's talk about the model the core

SPEAKER_01concept here with your model is that the grid ends at the meter meaning what goes on on the consumer side of the meter is nobody's business the grid consults the meter and two bits of information are exchanged one what's the price and then two how much energy do you need that is all the grid knows about a particular customer how much energy do they need they don't

know what devices are

SPEAKER_01in there They don't know what the devices are doing. The customer is a black box to the grid.

SPEAKER_00Yes, and my physics colleagues at Lawrence Brickley Lab where I was until recently assure me that the electrons are all the same.

SPEAKER_01Yes, but this is crucial. So the grid extends to the meter and the meter tells the grid at this customer site, we need X amount of power. And that is all that the grid knows about what goes on on the customer site. The utility is not poking its nose in and controlling your water heater. All the grid knows about it is how much energy does it need?

SPEAKER_00Well, it's how much energy did you consume in the last time interval? It's after the fact. It's not before the fact. Right, right.

SPEAKER_01But it's a quantity, basically. This is the information being exchanged. Quantity. Nothing beyond that. So let's talk about what you have to have in place to make this work. So to make any of it work, you need what you call a highly dynamic price. There's been a lot of like, you know, people who discuss this a lot are familiar with like, you know, time varying prices and real time prices, a lot of other terms for this. You use the term highly dynamic price.

SPEAKER_01What are the characteristics of a highly dynamic price?

SPEAKER_00Its essence is its hourly prices that are different every day. specifically it's prices that have intervals between hourly and five minutes that brackets the range of what's reasonable you set those prices no farther advanced than the day before and the prices are different every day

SPEAKER_01Okay, let me ask a couple of questions about this. You draw the line at hourly or smaller. Do you get more benefits the smaller that increment is? Or do you think hourly is like frequent enough to do the job? The important reason to start with hourly is that that's very comfortable for

SPEAKER_00people to move into this. And the barrier here is not technology for this. We've invented all the technology we need, all the communication protocols, the price response of algorithms. The barrier here is the human beings who are fearful of using prices even though they use prices everywhere else in their life constantly You make a point of saying that the prices are different every day You just mean that they need to be

SPEAKER_01responsive to conditions every day Exactly the conditions on the grid are different every day so if the prices are not different every day they are the wrong prices and it's a basic function of any business to set the right price for their product and if they are not competent to do that they need to let someone else who is competent to run a business run the business And one other thing is that import and export prices are separate explain what that means

SPEAKER_00Yes, so I have solar panels and I have net metering and I pay almost nothing for electricity, even though I derive huge value from the grid because I overgenerate a huge amount in the summer because there's no air conditioning where I live and I import lots of electricity in the winter. I derive huge benefit from being connected to the grid, but I pay almost nothing. And so other people's bills are higher because I'm not paying enough.

SPEAKER_01This is the cost shift that everybody's always talking about. So I don't have an opinion on what the difference should be between import and export prices. But the principle that they can be different and probably should be different,

SPEAKER_00it's a very reasonable tool for grid operators to have in their and it's something that buildings can devices can readily accommodate and use and so that's not a problem but having a stream of import prices and if different a stream of export prices also if you are an exporting customer that should be 100% of the financial complexity that devices need to contemplate for deciding how to optimize. We should not have things like demand charges, which are, I would describe as evil.

SPEAKER_00They are pathological to good load optimization and to buildings. They were invented in the 19th century. We have far better tools to address the same issue that demand charges are intended to address. We should just get rid of them. They became obsolete a long time ago. How geographically granular do you envision highly dynamic pricing being? Is this just like a price for a utility area or is it gonna get

as geographically

SPEAKER_01differentiated as it is temporally differentiated?

SPEAKER_00So from the perspective of any individual customer, they actually don't care whether it's millions of people who pay the same price or dozens. Actually, it doesn't affect the customer technology The communications or the automation as to how what how locational is what I would call it so that's really for the grid operators to decide but you need to know that to set a good price right because like the whole point is that the price is a measure of the value of electricity and the value of electricity changes from time to time and place to place and can change place to place even

relatively proximate

SPEAKER_01places Theoretically, the value of electricity could be slightly different between two even relatively close places. So all I mean is like getting the geographic scale right seems important to accurately capturing value.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. And it's similar to the time interval where there's diminishing returns to getting to smaller, smaller areas. Right. And there's diminishing issues about how to treat people, you in California we are planning to have locational prices hopefully as soon as next year in fact there are some pilot tariffs from the largest and soon the second largest utility in the state that have locational prices today that are hourly and the size of the locations is several hundred thousand people

interesting and these

SPEAKER_00are areas where the distribution system load shape is is different and so that the reasons for wanting to shift load are different in

SPEAKER_01those different locations right so highly dynamic prices if you want customer sites to optimize based on highly dynamic prices you have to transmit the highly dynamic prices to the customer sites so just briefly tell us what a price server is and what role it plays and why it's necessary

SPEAKER_00Yeah, so a price server is like a web server. A web server distributes web pages to computers to show to people. A price server distributes prices to machines to use in their optimization. Now, people are free to look at prices, but we don't want to encourage them to do so because they have much better things to do with their time and they wouldn't be good at using them. but you know maybe maybe three days a year they'll want to look at the prices and the other 362 they won't and they don't need to let me just blow that out because because we need to make this point generally but all of this

all of it is meant to be automated the customer is not going to know or care what the hourly variations and prices are they're not going to be fiddling with their devices on a day-to-day basis telling their devices what to do all of this is meant to be automated and

SPEAKER_01happening in the background and you as the customer can just chill out and take your hot showers and drink your cold beers basically like I think that's implied but just to underscore it exactly but people express preferences in advance as to how they want their devices to

SPEAKER_00behave And so they can change those preferences anytime they want to.

SPEAKER_01But anyway, to return to the original point, the point of a price server is just that you ping it and it tells you the price.

SPEAKER_00Dr. Justin Marchegiani but you know it's hard to get information out of utilities a lot of time so so who has a price server is there one of these running somewhere yes the state of

California set one up several years ago called Midas and PG&E my utility has one it uses the open ADR3 protocol Southern California Edison the second largest utility

SPEAKER_00is going to use the same price server The state will convert theirs to be using that protocol. The concept of a price server dates back to at least 2006, 20 years ago. It's not a new idea because people recognized early on, if you're going to have prices to devices, you have to have a way to communicate them. So the price server is the essential part. And then you need communication protocols to move the price from points A to points B, C, and D over both the wide area network and then also inside of

buildings to

SPEAKER_00And then you need the loads, whether they're loads or batteries or EV chargers, whatever they are,

SPEAKER_01that can use the prices. So those are the three elements. There has relatively recently been developed what's called OpenADR3. which is a modern light replicable perfectly functional protocol so we know what a price server is we have a protocol to communicate these things and we know basically how to create devices that are responsive to them but as you say in your paper there's not yet a place in the world correct me if I'm

wrong where those

SPEAKER_01three pieces are in place and working together

SPEAKER_00Actually, in California, with Pacific Gas and Electric, we do have that. There is a problem with the tariff structure, which is a huge problem that's not worth our time in this podcast that makes it problematic. So we have sort of the beginnings of it, but we haven't... for various reasons, had the ability to scale it yet. We have the glimmers of it. So California is poised to be the place where this will first happen. But practically speaking, you're correct. There isn't the place. Some places have the prices.

SPEAKER_00We have the price servers, but don't have really good prices yet. Once you have them, then manufacturers will spring up and and use them because they can deliver more value to their customers and produce a higher quality product.

SPEAKER_01Right. All right. So here then we get to in my mind the really juicy interesting stuff and this is what I struggled with and this is what I kind of like had a little breakthrough about so let's talk about the building side so as we say the only interface in your system between the grid and the building is just this single point of connection and the only information being exchanged is quantity and price basically so

SPEAKER_01Here you are inside your building, your microgrid controller, your central controller of your building devices, which I guess is like a panel or I don't know what the central controller looks like. I imagine it will be different for different buildings. So then your central controller receives the grid price. And this is what's interesting to me. So the value of electricity, for that microgrid controller for that particular building

might be different than

SPEAKER_01the grid price. So why is that? What are the sort of considerations at the building level that would mean the value of electricity Differs from the grid price and you call this the value of electricity at the building level you call this the local price which could be different than the grid price so what are those considerations that would make the value of electricity different for a building than what it says on the tin at the grid level

SPEAKER_00Yeah. So new solar customers in California for the last three or four years, they may be buying electricity at 50 cents, but if they want to sell it to the grid, they're getting eight cents. So what price should the water heater be getting to decide whether it should be heating water for the next hour or not? If you're currently importing, well, presumably you should be getting 50 cents. If you're currently exporting, if it turned on, it would be consuming eight cent electricity. And so it should be getting that signal so that you consume your low cost

SPEAKER_00electricity instead of higher cost electricity. So an asymmetric tariff where the import and export are different is sort of the most obvious and widespread reason to have a different local price. And I use local as a local area network as an IT because we want to emulate IT principles and terminology as appropriate as much as possible. So whether you're currently importing or exporting will change the local value of electricity. I mean, this is where you could sort of import any sort of values that

you want.

SPEAKER_01You know what I mean? It might be I, as a customer, place a very high premium on greenhouse gases, on avoiding greenhouse gases. So I can tell my local microgrid controller to sort of adjust the grid price by X amount to reflect that. So then the value of the electricity inside my building is slightly different than the grid price.

SPEAKER_00Exactly. That's a second reason that can create a local price is taking into account the climate pollution from the greenhouse gases. You simply take that GHG signal, multiply it by the dollar per ton value that you as the customer believe is appropriate, add that to the retail price because climate change is real, and then have your devices optimized to that price. It doesn't change what you pay on your bill, but it changes how your devices shift their load.

SPEAKER_01Right, and this is key. The point of determining the local value of electricity is not that anyone's paying anybody anything inside the building. It's just to put a value on the electricity. The whole point is to channel power. to its highest value spot application within the building, right? And work down from there. So the microgrid controller, your building controller, gets a price from the grid and then translates that grid price into a local price,

SPEAKER_01right? It takes the grid price as an input and then adds whatever local considerations there are and comes up with the local price. And then it sends that local price down to these little individual nano grids that I was talking about before that are in your building. And this is the fun bit to me. So then that little nano grid controller takes the local price that it got from the

SPEAKER_01micro grid controller and does the same thing. It says, based on my hyper, hyper, hyper local considerations, right? Like you might have a nano grid that's like, and ev charger you know whatever in a washing machine but that nano grid controller will based on its hyper local considerations come up with another local price and even more local price a hyper local price and that price will be used to coordinate the behavior of the devices on that particular individual circuit

This is what I want to emphasize is this sort of cascade that's happening.

SPEAKER_01The price server is sending a price to a building. A building then recalculates to a local price, sends that down to a nanogrid, which then recalculates that to an even more local price. So basically what you're doing, what your grid controllers are doing, your microgrid controllers, your nanogrid controllers, are assessing the value of electricity at that particular level. Dr. Justin Marchegiani

SPEAKER_01In fact, the value of electricity might, not necessarily, but might differ from nanogrid to nanogrid. But the reason it unlocks something for me is that, like I said, I was getting hung up on the word price, and I just think the word value, at least for my purposes, for my brain, value... captures this better so you're trying to basically compute what is the real time geographic specific value of electricity at this particular spot and that

Calculation is happening at every individual, like everywhere at every level.

SPEAKER_01So basically at every level from the very bottom, the most specific device itself, right up to the nanogrid, to the microgrid, to the larger microgrid, the value of power is being calculated at every point in that microgrid and power is being channeled to the highest value uses. I want to get people thinking about value rather than price because the whole point of this is to make sure that the power itself goes to the

highest value uses hey there everybody don't worry I'm not going to tell you about a new mattress or push a credit card on you this isn't an ad there are no ads on Volts it is supported entirely by listeners like you if you'll indulge me for a second I'd like to ask

SPEAKER_01for your support I started Volts because we're all surrounded by depressing news about climate change and misinformation about clean energy and it's never been more important to share the stories of the real people on the ground doing the real work of transition and all the ingenuity and courage and public spirit they are bringing to it people are hungry to hear these stories to learn from and find inspiration in them I've heard from people who change majors or careers after hearing episodes of Volts People using it in classrooms,

SPEAKER_01community groups, even state legislators who have passed bills inspired by specific episodes. Sharing these stories matters. It makes a difference. If you have found value in it and want to help me continue doing it, I hope you will join the community of paid subscribers at volts.wtf. It's about the cost of a cup of coffee a month. If you don't like subscriptions, you can make a one-time contribution, leave a review on Apple or Spotify, or just tell a friend about Volts. I am grateful for any and all support. If you're already a paid subscriber, thank you.

SPEAKER_01And now back to the show. I want to get people thinking about value rather than price, because the whole point of this is to make sure that the power itself goes to the highest value uses. Yeah, so price is just the unit of measurement by which we measure value.

SPEAKER_00It's dollars per kilowatt hour, and that's what you use for any of these, so long as you're in a country that uses dollars. So it's always that same unit that you're using, no matter what the scale is. My house, where I already have several price-responsive devices, I don't yet have a local price because I have net metering and I haven't set it up to take into account the greenhouse gas. So most customers will start out with this using the straight import retail price, and that's fine.

SPEAKER_00That's the starting point. But the communications and automation technologies facilitate this more rich utilization of it. Trivially, that's just part of how it works. And so you get all that for free.

SPEAKER_01One thing I think is important to point out here is that your building is calculating the value of electricity to you individually, your considerations, your local considerations, and acting accordingly. That is something that a VPP can't do. A VPP is going to round up a bunch of devices or a bunch of houses and basically treat them as a class as all the same a VPP can't by its nature calculate

what is optimal for each individual customer right only prices can do that for you correct the VPP doesn't have access to the correct information to make the right decision but also the VPP is acting first for its own interests second for the interest of their customer which is the utility grid and only thirdly for the actual electricity

SPEAKER_00customer With price responsiveness, 100% of the value, as you mentioned, goes to the customer and 100% of the control is with the customer and the customer devices. Now, customers may choose to have a third party optimize, let's say, their thermostat. and that could be the product manufacturer, it could be someone else, it could be a non-profit, it could be the electricity retailer and that's fine and they might even pay a small subscription fee for that service but the customer is

always in control and the optimization is 100% for the value of the customer because the customer is

SPEAKER_00engaging that third party for the customer's benefit. But so the key is that if we only had VPPs as an option, I would be an enormous fan because they do deliver important value. And there are some things that VPPs do that price is not the right tool for and shouldn't be used. For example, emergency load reduction if a power plant or transmission line fails and the grid needs an immediate, you know, within one to two second drop in load. That's a great use of VPPs, and that's not something you would do with pricing.

And there are other things like that around the edge that are great uses of VPPs.

SPEAKER_00So it's not that we shouldn't use them. We should use the right tool for the job. And part of the right tool is the most cost-effective tool. Right. So here we come to a key question, which is, okay, the grid comes to my meter, tells me a price.

SPEAKER_01My building microgrid controller takes that price as an input and computes the local price and then optimizes my devices on my site, on my consumer site accordingly. So what does it pay? How does it negotiate? Do you know what I mean? If the local prices or local value is different than the grid value, what happens between the grid and the meter? There's presumably some...

So the grid only sees the meter readings and the price that the grid announces and

SPEAKER_00then computes the bill. That's how the only involvement of the grid for balancing supply and demand. Now, there is the related topic of capacity, but putting that aside, there's no negotiation and all of this local price stuff is completely invisible to the grid. So the customer side is computing based on the local value of electricity to me at this moment. Here's how much I need and here's how much I'm willing to buy at this price. Well, I mean, the optimization could be in the central controller or in the individual device.

SPEAKER_00And most buildings will use both of those or in the cloud. Well, this is something I wanted to ask, like, do you need the central controller?

SPEAKER_01Like if the devices are smart. Couldn't they just do the work? Is it necessary that you have a central controller?

SPEAKER_00It's not if the retail import price is all you need. Then you can just send that price directly to devices and they can use them. So yes, you do not need it. You will want it over time. And the transition from having no infrastructure to infrastructure devices is a common one. With cable TV, originally the cable went directly into the back of the TV and then we moved to have set-top boxes, infrastructure devices that sort of decoupled between the the two domains and then of course with dial-up modems your

computer was directly connected to the internet and then now we connect to our local area network through some switches and routers to the modem and then that connects to the wide area

SPEAKER_00network so Creating infrastructures is natural, but to your point, you don't have to have one to start using it. So long as you're just optimizing to the direct retail price, which with better prices is going to be much better than what occurs today. And so we can do this transition incrementally and organically. It doesn't have to be an all at once thing.

SPEAKER_01So say I'm in a neighborhood by nature, my neighbors will, they will be experiencing the same climate as me. the same temperature whatever they will probably be roughly comparable to me socioeconomically whatever so like our price comes to our neighborhood and then all the devices all these customer sites take in that price and then act on it but presumably they're all going to be making roughly similar calculations and they're

SPEAKER_01going to all act roughly the same way so say for instance like a cheap electricity price comes down one hour and then everybody every ev charger in the neighborhood is like hey cheap electricity let's charge our evs boom they all go start charging evs you get a massive surge and you overwhelm your neighborhood transformer in other words how can a single price that's going to a neighborhood Dr. Justin Marchegiani

SPEAKER_00Yes, several things are going on here. One is that if you have a precipitous change in price, you're likely to get a precipitous change in demand. And many utilities around the US and around the world see this with, you know, TOU timer spikes, where to your point, EV chargers are all set to start charging at midnight. And so you create this problem not only locally, but also for the macro grid. And so the answer is don't have a precipitous change in price. And if you have you know these more fine grain of hourly or half hourly prices

then you can have the price change slowly not dramatically but even within the EV chargers different cars will need to charge for different amounts of time and need to be complete at different times of the day but will they though like they're probably all going to work in the morning and they're probably most of them coming home in the evening like this is what I mean like their behavior is going to be roughly similar

SPEAKER_00Maybe one needs to charge for two hours, one for three, one for five, another for three, so that if there's a trough of low price times, then the utility needs to just set the size and shape of that trough to result in the load shape, which is best for the grid. Prices should be set based on the result that they produce for the grid, not based on the state of grid infrastructure. Mutility people commonly assume that you must set retail prices based on cost causation, which is just wrong.

SPEAKER_00They don't know that it's wrong, but it's wrong. Prices should be set to produce the right result. That's what airlines do. They don't charge prices based on the state of the infrastructure, their airplanes and their staff. They set it based on past experience with how customers buy tickets by geography and calendar etc and then set prices to maximize the most benefit for them so utilities should set prices for all of their considerations for generation costs for transmission issues distribution issues environmental goals etc produce the best

load shape both in

SPEAKER_00aggregate and also by these locational areas and that will have a loose relation to things like wholesale energy costs, but will not have a tight relation. So first, like I'm not sure everybody's gonna understand the distinction here. So the two separate questions here are how to distribute power and then what

SPEAKER_01happens if like particular circuits are overloaded? In other words, the capacity of the circuit to handle So again, like a price signal goes to the devices, devices act a certain way, they overload the circuit. What tools do you have to keep capacity in safe boundaries? Like if you charge an EV, it is a large power draw rapidly, basically like a big burst of draw in a way that like a stove or an air conditioner

SPEAKER_01or whatever is not going to be. Especially if you have like a DC fast charger with multiple stalls, like three EVs hook up all at once. All of a sudden, you got ginormous demand out of nowhere almost instantly. Or if you have a pole-mounted transformer with 10 houses, six of them have EV chargers.

SPEAKER_00and maybe one of them has two, you can easily get the same thing. So for my house on an annual basis, well, ignoring my PV panels, it uses about a kilowatt on average over the course of the year. The highest single hour was a little over four kilowatts for everything before I got an EV. And then an EV charger can be seven or even nine kilowatts all by itself. wild so running your EV charger more than doubles the previously high point of your instantaneous load yeah for the highest single hour and it

could be like eight times the typical so that's incredibly bursty right which is it makes it a new kind of thing on the grid like this is I think is also worth emphasizing like it's not

SPEAKER_01like we have a lot of The first place that this capacity issue showed up was in Australia,

SPEAKER_00which to a recent podcast of yours on rooftop PV there, they a number of years ago had an increasing number of circuits where on certain days in the afternoon, When solar production was at its peak, the transformers and wires were approaching their capacity. So they said, okay, nobody else on this circuit gets to install PV forever, unless we spend lots of money increasing the capacity of the system.

SPEAKER_01Or they can curtail, now they're writing that into the contract, that they can curtail your individual solar in these circumstances. yeah rather than saying no one else can install solar when in fact most of the time there's there's extra capacity it's only a few hours of the year what they started doing was broadcasting out interval power limits to each customer not to how much the PV can produce but to how much the customer site as a whole can export this is called dynamic operating envelopes and then they can fairly allocate the capacity

SPEAKER_00to each customer and it's different for each customer and different every day to make maximum use of the capacity that's there and guarantee that the system will not be overloaded. So that's an incredibly powerful mechanism.

SPEAKER_01So an individual customer site is told here's how much you can export this hour correct and so if it's solar is running it might take this and say okay well then instead of exporting all the solar I'm going to put it in my battery that's the kind of calculation that's going on on the consumer side of in response to this.

SPEAKER_00Correct. Anything that you might have been in danger of having to curtail, you instead put into a battery, you run the air conditioner, you heat some water, whatever it is. And we want people to shift loads those times anyways. So this mechanism just reinforces what's good for the customer and good for the grid as well. There's no financial aspect to this. It's purely a requirement for operating to make sure that we keep the system safe. And doing this kind of digital capacity management is not new.

SPEAKER_00USB, which has now been around for more than a third of a century, which I think is amazing to think about, from day one has had capacity management. You plug a device into the USB port in a computer, it can't just take power, it has to first request capacity. and so there's a negotiation about the capacity and so this is fundamentally different from the pricing where the communication is one direction for the capacity management you know when you get to things like EVs there does need to be some sort of negotiation so that the grid can allocate through

some dynamic mechanism capacity and then devices are able to reserve capacity when they need it

SPEAKER_00and plan for it and guarantee that the system will not exceed it and the details of that mechanism are still sort of being determined. People have different theories and we absolutely need to do more experimentation on that. Pacific Gas and Electric and Southern California Energy in California are doing experiments with some mechanisms. They're kind of more band-aid rather than permanent ones. The protocol you mentioned, OpenADR3, has two mechanisms for it. So this is an area that needs much more attention,

but it can be done in coordination with the customer site as a whole rather than

SPEAKER_00trying to micromanage individual devices. But what happens at the meter is the only thing that actually affects the grip. It simplifies things so much if that's the point of interaction rather than trying to work around the meter because you don't have the right arrangement of the meter.

SPEAKER_01Right. The take home here is you've got two separate mechanisms basically pricing mechanisms and capacity mechanisms and according to you once you've got those two you're mostly done you need to send out price signals and then you need to send out basically capacity envelopes that people need to stay inside but with those two bits of information What is the price and what is the hour? You know, what is the sort of capacity envelope for the hour?

That's all the information customer sites need to do their optimization and to do

SPEAKER_01collective optimization, basically.

SPEAKER_00Correct.

SPEAKER_01Yes. In this capacity, this will also be a relatively local thing, too, or... Dr. Justin Marchegiani It could be the first transformer in front of a house,

SPEAKER_00for example, or it could be a substation or the wire in between. It could occur at different points in the distribution system, depending on the details of it. That's all inside the grid. Where the constraint is doesn't matter to the customer. The customer only needs to know what's the mechanism for coordinating with the grid so that things work out the best possible for everybody, which is to use all the capacity that's there and guarantee that it's not exceeded.

SPEAKER_01Okay, so here you have, and this I think is what comes up with a lot of people when they first hear this. Here you have a system that's based almost entirely on price. Basically like, how much does it cost? Who can pay? And when people hear that, their mind goes immediately to, well, what about people who can't pay? Like, you know, how is this not sort of like rapacious capitalism, et cetera, et cetera. So I think there's a question of like, if price and capacity are your two mechanisms and your only two mechanisms, how do you... to ensure other kinds of social or political,

you know, goals or guidelines.

SPEAKER_01How do you layer other stuff in?

SPEAKER_00Yeah. So I care as much about this as anyone else does. When I started thinking about this, I started thinking about it in the context of off-grid systems and developing countries and how to make that work. And that's how I originally came to be using price. But simply changing the price does And so that has to be clear in people's minds is that dynamic pricing is about achieving lower bills. It's not about achieving higher bills.

In California, what we are doing for the near term, and what we should do forever, is that you charge an hourly price and you calculate the bill according to that and according to some TOU price and if you would have paid less under the TOU you pay that to make sure that the people who today are more expensive to serve than others continue to pay the TOU and the people who are less expensive to serve and then

SPEAKER_00also can do additional load shifting pay the hourly and and over time, more and more people will just be doing the hourly and fewer and fewer will be on this TOU backstop. And that's easy to understand and easy to implement. How do you protect low income rate payers? Because they continue to pay the TOU if they are more expensive to serve. Many low income people today are less expensive to serve and are paying more than they should because they're consuming more at the low price times. Others are the reverse.

SPEAKER_00So it's not like low income people are some monolith The current system is not fair. We have to recognize that. Current tariffs are not fair, absolutely. And if we want to make things fair, we can move in that direction and move it to it in a way which protects anybody who has non-optimal load shapes. And then we can help them change their load shapes through acquiring devices, you know, controls or new appliances like we've done with energy efficiency for decades.

SPEAKER_01Is there any functional distinction between an individual customer site, a building, say, that is its own small microgrid, and a larger microgrid in which that building is a part? To the larger grid, the microgrid is the black box, right?

SPEAKER_00That's absolutely true, and this community is essentially a single large customer from the perspective of the utility grid.

SPEAKER_01That's what I'm trying to get at. Theoretically, a whole community could be, from the grid's point of view, a single customer if they were all on the same microgrid.

SPEAKER_00Correct. And then they could calculate their local price based on their local values. But that's the retail price for that community. And that would be at best a locational retail price. It's still not a local price inside of a single customer site. So they're similar. I can see that. But you still have a utility customer relationship between the community and the final customer. And that's not a problem. That's just, that's not the same as inside of a customer site.

SPEAKER_01Right. The whole question is like, how do you allocate your power to your highest value? You know, how do you allocate power? And the way you want to allocate power is you want to put it where it's most valuable first and work down from there. And so to do that, you need to calculate, well, what is the value? And the key insight here is that the value from the grid perspective is going to be slightly different than the value from the building perspective. So value is being calculated all the way down such that when you get to the device

SPEAKER_01level, the actual device optimization is working on extremely local, very specific value information. And so you are optimizing for value at every level.

SPEAKER_00Correct.

SPEAKER_01That I think is like, that's the point here. Yeah and the water heater doesn't have to know where the price came from or why it only cares about what the price is so the grid could go down your house continues to operate as a microgrid because you've got a battery and the price may change so the water heater re-optimizes you may have a higher price or a lower price depending on what's going on and the water heater doesn't care about why it just cares what the price is so all of this topological complexity in no way affects how

SPEAKER_00devices operate Right and let's return briefly to the point about non-deterministic systems because I think now that we've sort of described how this works how price is being used as a coordination and optimization mechanism down to the device level in what sense is

SPEAKER_01this system non-deterministic so retail customers have always been non-deterministic in their consumption of electricity with I'm sure a few niche exceptions but in general you don't promise in advance to your utility grid how much electricity you're going to consume each hour for the next month or the next year you just consume whenever you want to that's always been the case about how electricity works I'm not changing that at

SPEAKER_00all we can either charge bad prices or or we can charge good prices. Now, what's a good price? A good price is a price which results in a better overall situation for the grid. The entity is setting the prices. That's their job, is to set the price which produces the best result for them. In the past, the price was just a revenue generation mechanism. That's all it was. In the present and future, the price is also a control mechanism to shift load. And so what you need to do to set retail prices in this context

is you go through

SPEAKER_00two separate calculations. One calculation occurs today, which is the revenue requirement of the utility. How much revenue do they need to collect at the end of the day, month or year? And this doesn't change that one bit, except that we will lead to needing less revenue because the system can be more efficient. And then secondly, you go through a calculation of what's the shape of the prices, you know, 24 hourly prices or 48 half hour prices. And the grid based on past experience determines what shape for

this locality will produce the best result for the grid and then shift that shape up or down so they

SPEAKER_00collect the right amount of revenue. and those are two things happen in parallel so that you meet both objectives collect the right amount of revenue and charge the right shape so that the right load shifting happens and in general the water heater because you're only shifting load you're never shedding load with your water heater only cares about the difference in prices it doesn't care about the absolute price and so these two things work seamlessly together to shape load and to collect revenue I guess I come

SPEAKER_01back again to you know how this is going to produce a more efficient system and I think one of the advantages of this is that it makes flexibility not something that you try to add on top of the system or that you try to tweak the system afterwards flexibility will just be part of normal electricity consumption exactly in this like the flexibility is part of the operation of the system not some separate thing

precisely so historically what we do is we sold electricity at the wrong price utilities got results that they didn't like for whatever reasons because it you

SPEAKER_00know to high generation costs, transmission or distribution issues. And then we created these complicated, expensive mechanisms like VPPs to account for the fact that we charge at the wrong price. And so those are expensive bandages on the system or like digital paint on the old analog system. What this is, if you charge the right price to begin with, then you get the result you wanted You don't need the band-aid You don't have a wound that you need to address Because you're not creating the wound by charging the wrong price And

in other contexts, we just charge the right price Airlines charge the right price They don't sell their tickets at a flat price And then have third parties go in and try to convince people to change their flight times To even out the supply and demand of airplane

SPEAKER_00seats They just charge the right price to begin with

SPEAKER_01This is the analogy that finally occurred to me. I was thinking about how to explain this to normal people. And this is the analogy that I think works is like, imagine if airlines sold all seats on all flights for the same flat price. They would get terrible results from that, right? Like some flights would be massively, you know, oversubscribed, some undersubscribed. So imagine a third party came along, rounded up all the ticket holders and said, Hey,

the airlines getting terrible results and it's there's some value to the airline of of you being flexible so can you move your flight like individual customers can you move your flight and then that third party rounded up all the customers took their flexibility and sold it to the airlines basically that is the VPP model exactly and

SPEAKER_01it's complicated and it's expensive what you are saying is just don't charge that dumb flat price in the first don't charge the wrong price in the first place if you charge prices that reflect temporal and geographic value you will get the results you want and then you won't have to do this ad hoc flexibility stuff afterward is that fair like the airline analogy you think that works yeah and the key difference in the last few years is that we

now have all of the technologies at very low cost often free to make the automatic control highly practical we have the communication protocol which we had communication motor protocols for pricing you know for the last 20 years but they were old and

SPEAKER_00cumbersome and difficult to deal with now we have modern simple ones We have, you know, pervasive internet connectivity so that devices can get the prices. We have extremely low cost computation on integrated circuits. The integrated circuits that go to appliances that cost four or five dollars.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, yeah. This is worth emphasizing. This is all cheap. Often free. Like the benefit of all these electronic development over the last 30 years is like this is all just basic circuits and like communication stuff that is trivially is not some big, fancy, complicated stuff we're talking about. Your water heater just needs to ping the internet and that is a solved problem. And ping your local price server in your central building device to get the price.

SPEAKER_00Who is then pinging the central price server. Yeah. So the reason so many appliances have Wi-Fi on them today, when you think, does my dishwasher need to have Wi-Fi? Well, no, it doesn't. But the microprocessors have Wi-Fi and Bluetooth on the chip, whether they are used or not. So it is literally free for them to include it. And you can't get much less expensive than free. I have three price responses. I will soon have three price responses today, covering my space heat, water heat, and EV charging.

SPEAKER_00and also my phone optimized it to a GHG. All of it through free software upgrades from the manufacturer for devices that were not grid responsive when I bought them.

SPEAKER_01No kidding. So you bought non-grid responsive appliances and it's just they had the chips in them that were capable of Wi-Fi communication because they sort of included trivially regardless. And so a software update from the manufacturer then turned on its ability to communicate with the web I should be more specific here so my space heat and hot water come from a heat pump which the heat pump can't communicate but I have a clever controller commercial product when I bought it it optimized to time of use

prices in its the manufacturer's cloud I then got the free software update where it optimizes to hourly prices in the controller in my house and it receives those prices that were open ADR 3 that was a free software update the EV charger

SPEAKER_00When I got it, it optimizes to TOU prices in the cloud, and they are working on integrating with the PG&E price server to be able to use the hourly prices and optimize in their cloud to it. And that PG&E price server uses OpenADR3. really most of what you're talking about in the system is software tweaks like there's just not a lot of hardware certainly not expensive hardware involved in any of this most of this is software correct so for any new product or any product that

you can get over the air software update an increasing number this is pretty trivial there is this long transition time where lots of people have old water heaters maybe it's an electric resistance water heater and there are commercial

SPEAKER_00products today So there's no barrier to making literally any appliance price responsive. Even if it's dumb and old, you can get a controller to attach to it to make it Well, a dumb device, generally, it only works if you can depower it. And so for a resistance water heater, you can just shut off the power to shift its load.

SPEAKER_00I'm sure there are some devices where that's not a workable option. So some devices will need replacement, but many devices can have these external controls, which do cost something. but you know doing anything costs something to have something be part of a VPP it has to be able to communicate and that's all you need for the price response so you don't need anything more for price response that you need for VPPs you just avoid a whole lot of cost and complexity let's talk about how to get

from here to there

SPEAKER_01which is part of what's broken my brain about all this like it's This is a very wholesale change in the way the electricity system works. So just to review, what we need to make this work is a central price server a protocol that helps communicate and price responsive devices yes we have price responsive devices that's a solved technical problem we have the protocol that's a solved technical problem we know how to make a price server

that's technologically trivial so technologically speaking this is all good to go yes basically so it's

SPEAKER_01not technology development that is the barrier here so I guess what is the road in this direction. Does it start with utilities changing how they charge prices just with utilities implementing more dynamic prices? Is that step one here?

SPEAKER_00That's step one. And it could be either a unitary utility either acting on its own or it could be a utility forced by a regulator such as in Illinois where the legislature passed a law saying they must offer hourly prices different every day and they've had it for 10 years and

SPEAKER_01Oh, really? So Illinois has highly dynamic prices of the type you're talking about.

SPEAKER_00Yes, but the variation over the course of the day isn't very much. So your opportunity to save is limited. It's there, but it's not that great. And they have only very limited automation. They don't have a price server in the way that we're talking about. But to your point, having the prices is sort of a prerequisite for everything else, the prices and the price server, because while it's not that difficult for manufacturers to put in the ability to be price responsive, in general, they are reluctant to spend time doing so until they have a

critical mass of

SPEAKER_00customers who could actually use them. I've had this conversation with many manufacturers over many years, and they say, well, I'm not going to innovate into a vacuum. I need to have a business case. I need to have the customers and the customers need to be able to pay the prices so everything comes down to the prices it's not a chicken and egg thing the prices have to come first Yeah, but I mean, like, skate to where the puck is going.

SPEAKER_01Like, everything's going to talk to the internet eventually. Like, just go ahead and do it.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, and then we also need to get global consensus on the maximum complexity of the tariffs as it affects device optimization. And just to be clear, you can have fixed charges which do not affect device optimization, but the parts of the tariff that affect how devices optimize to reduce bills the most are That needs to be limited to the stream of import prices and stream of export prices. And that people need to recognize needs to become the global standard so that somebody in a manufacturer in China,

the shipping products all over the world can ship products that will work all over

SPEAKER_00the world because everything works the same way.

SPEAKER_01I see. So you want to standardize price format basically to make this Dr. Justin Marchegiani And we just need to get a critical mass of organizations that operate according to these principles and that other people will see the merit of

SPEAKER_00it and then be consistent of it. So it's really the question is, how do we get to that initial critical mass? And if you take the principles that things should be simple and universal, you're 80% of the way towards having the right answer and of course some utilities will think they're special and different and of course you and I know they aren't special and they aren't different in this respect now how you calculate the price that can be different everywhere because that doesn't change the communication this is just like web browsing where you've got the web server HTML and web browsers and

HTML defines the maximum complexity of the web page this price structure defines

SPEAKER_00the maximum complexity of how prices should be done on a retail basis

SPEAKER_01Got it. But it's a high priority for you to keep this simple, to keep the pricing differentiation as simple as possible.

SPEAKER_00Exactly.

SPEAKER_01Import price, export price. But it is going to change hour to hour. So it's not simple in that respect. It's changing temporally all the time. and also you know it could be a day of the vast majority of people who pay such prices that are day ahead prices and that's absolutely the place to start but once people have the automation they'll realize that you could shift from day ahead to day out prices and the communication the automation don't change and that's going to result in a slightly lower bill this will happen later on but we just have to know that the devices don't care if it's day ahead or day off

and but the key thing

SPEAKER_00here is that we don't want to put Dr. Justin Marchegiani And then later into the utility grid, which is digitally native and networked instead of using network technology to manage our 19th century systems. so you know this is a very big set of ideas and topics a very big idea do you have

a sort of next thing that you are pushing for you know you said we can step toward these incrementally like what's next on your personal list that you would like to see happen moving in this direction aside from every electricity retailer offering

SPEAKER_01hourly prices that are different every day

SPEAKER_00or something that's beyond flexibility.

SPEAKER_01That's kind of a big step, Bruce. I mean, much more practically earthbound. Is there a particular utility you're trying to get a pilot thing started with? I mean, very practically, what needs to happen?

SPEAKER_00So PG&E offers hourly prices different every day to any customer type, today and has for more than a year. And Southern California Edison is supposed to soon. And the state of California's Energy Commission policy is that every Californian should have access to such prices in less than a year. Now, I don't think we'll make that deadline, but we are trying to get there. And that's the price server that you're talking about. Making them available to everyone is just about setting up the price server, right? It's about offering the prices and having the price server to

communicate them. Because in some places they have the prices, but they don't have the price server. let's just stipulate in our fantasies two years from now California has the dynamic prices has the server then what's left to do for Californians individual consumers is just to buy the price responsive devices right like that's everything will be in place except for the consumers in many cases people will get devices that can get software updates to do it or they can acquire a central

controller that can do it and when they replace a product they will replace with one that does this and any cloud connected device can certainly do this and just optimize in the cloud so there's lots of paths for many existing devices to become price responsive very quickly and then it will take time for most of the devices to turn over and get

SPEAKER_01replaced but long story short California is moving in this direction and there is reason to believe that in some amount of time two years five years this is how the California electricity system is going to work yes now we also plan to still have VPPs and and use them both and the you know the balance of it should be really just determined by the by the

SPEAKER_00market and the need And again, there's always going to be some, you know, we will make good use of VPPs for the foreseeable future, because we won't turn everything over instantly, that there'll be just a shift in the balance over time. And there are some limited services that VPPs are better at. So it's not that they don't have a role it'll just be changing I would I was thinking the other day that it's like hybrid cars you know we hybrid cars are sort of like VPPs and that they're kind of a band-aid solution and hybrid

cars are actually growing as I understand it even as electric vehicles are also growing but over time eventually the EVs will grow and start taking up and the hybrids will decline over

SPEAKER_00time so that's I think a very good way to think about it also the point I'm trying to make here and what I want listeners to take away is that this is not just like Bruce's elaborate fantasy that he's concocted like this is a thing that's happening in the world yes there are systems that are moving in this

SPEAKER_01direction and this is something that could actually happen Dr. Justin Marchegiani And maybe this is a hard question to answer,

SPEAKER_00but among the sort of nerds who think about stuff like this, the class of nerds in the world who are beavering away

investigating electrical

SPEAKER_01systems and thinking about how to reform them. Is there a broad consensus behind this basic vision or is it a battle? Is it a debate? Are you an outlier? Are you a minority? What's the state of opinion in electricity world about this? Are a lot of people captured by this and want to move this way or do you feel like you're sort of fighting the tide?

SPEAKER_00Well, I feel like I'm fighting the tide but there's lots of reasons to be The automation of their use people haven't kind of figured out that that's an essential part of this and the desire for privacy and autonomy certainly I think is only growing and the desire for lower bills is growing and of course both of those are facilitated by this one problem here is that there's no group of companies that

SPEAKER_00are making lots of money off of this that are a trade association lobbying for this because the customer saves the money and so there's not these companies may pulling money out that's part of why this is so good so with VPPs you've got tons of venture capital so they can have big PR budgets and get lots of attention to this whereas there's no there's no industry behind this for pricing because it's all about saving money rather than about extracting money from people yes it is a value shift in the direction of customers and sort

of like as a cynic you would sort of expect that not to be hugely popular among the entities who were

SPEAKER_00previously receiving that

SPEAKER_01What you really need is consumer groups to get behind this. This gets back to what I was saying earlier. Consumer advocates, when they hear, let's just throw everybody out on the mercy of the market and use nothing but prices, have negative connotations around that. So there's a lot of communications work to be done with the consumer field about this, about why it's consumer-friendly.

SPEAKER_00We're already at the mercy of the market. We're already paying all of the revenue requirement for utilities. All this does is reduce how much revenue they need. And it's a way path towards lower bills. It's not a path towards higher bills. that's the key I know that you know that but like I don't think ordinary people when they hear pricing necessarily think consumer first which is just to say that like there's a lot of translation and communication work to be done here to help people understand why this is a consumer friendly reform and

not like rapacious

SPEAKER_01capitalism or whatever Yeah and internet technology developed from you know researchers and academics and government labs and such it wasn't in the market where it all developed because it had sort of business backing until it reached scale and then people figured out that they could have businesses around it but the development wasn't driven by those business interests and so that's the problem here is that we don't have

Obviously like we've barely scratched the surface people can go to your website got all kinds of papers digging into this further all the ins and outs but why I guess one thing I just sort of leave listeners with is and this I think is a good provocative question you ask which is if not prices then what as you say like

SPEAKER_01VPPs are good, but customer sites are going to get very complicated. And trying to micromanage whatever, 10,000, 50,000 customer sites from a central location is just going to get impractical quickly. Like we need a coordination and optimization mechanism that can operate locally. basically that can operate at different scales that can operate

off grid or on grid, et cetera.

SPEAKER_01And I guess if not pricing, then what is that going to be?

SPEAKER_00Exactly. And I've looked for 20 years and I've never found a second mechanism. And let's suppose that the utility sees their transformers getting overloaded and wants to turn down my EV charger, but I really want to charge my EV and I've got a stationary battery I could discharge. You know, they shouldn't turn down my EV. They should just say, you can't import as much power, in which case I'll just discharge it from the battery and keep charging my EV. So all the decisions need to be made locally because the information to make the right decision is local and the customer's preferences and,

SPEAKER_00you know, economic impacts all occur locally.

SPEAKER_01Right. So the customer's in control here in the driver's seat here, getting all the value of flexibility. in control of the preferences, in control of the operation of their devices. So all of that is one thing I like about this sort of vision is that you sort of have solved the privacy problems at a stroke here and kind of the unshittification problem too, I think. This is going to avoid that too because the utilities are not capturing you.

SPEAKER_01The VPPs are not capturing you. You are...

SPEAKER_00Yeah, right. And you're not required to be part of any platform with this. It's only about technology.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. Okay. Well, I'll leave it there. Good Lord. Thank you to any listener who's still with us. Thank you, Bruce, for walking us through this. Again, people can go to brucenordman.com and learn a lot more about all this. Thanks, Bruce.

SPEAKER_00Thank you so much. And I would love to hear from other people who want to have questions or want to help out with this.

SPEAKER_01or all three.

SPEAKER_01Thanks so much and I'll see you next time.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Can a developer turn data centers’ reputation around?

    Nov 20, 20261 hr 6 minAudio

    This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit www.volts.wtf/subscribe When people push for better data centers, they picture hyperscalers - Amazon,...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. “Repowering” worn out solar fields could create gigawatts of new grid capacity, quickly

    Nov 18, 20261 hr 18 minAudio

    This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit www.volts.wtf/subscribe America’s first big wave of solar power installations, built between 15 and...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. The federal permitting bill has been updated. What changed?

    Nov 11, 20261 hr 59 minAudio

    This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit www.volts.wtf/subscribe The Senate’s bipartisan permitting bill got a manager’s amendment last week -...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. So, how about those midterm elections?

    Nov 9, 20261 hr 26 minAudio

    This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit www.volts.wtf/subscribe Last week’s election was a blue wave all the way down the ballot: Democrats...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Best of October 2026

    Nov 6, 202614 minAudio

    This is a free preview of a paid episode. To hear more, visit www.volts.wtf Volts published eight conversations in October, which is a lot for anyone to listen to. We’ve rounded up the highlights into less than an hour....

    Credit the people on this episode