This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit www.volts.wtf/subscribe Why do climate funders prefer cutting checks for electric vehicles over fighting for dense, transit-oriented housing? I talk to Ben Holland, who recently interviewed major climate foundations about their anti-urbanism bias, and returning guest Caroline Spears, who is working to pass climate-friendly housing policy at the state level. We discuss why obsessing over easily quantifiable emissions reductions is blinding the movement to massive, tractable wins, and why ignoring zoning reform is no longer an option for serious climate advocates.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_02All right. Hello, everyone. Greetings. This is Volts for April 8th, 2026. Why climate funders don't fund housing policy and why they oughta. I am your host, David Roberts. Volts listeners know that housing and urban land use have become something of an obsession of mine. Over the past few years, I've done a series of episodes trying to build a case not just
that dense,
SPEAKER_02walkable urbanism is good, which it obviously is for a million reasons, but that it is good climate policy. It belongs on a podcast about decarbonization, not as a nice-to-have or as a co-benefit, but as a core part of any serious strategy for getting emissions down. I talked with experts at RMI about the quantitative case, why meeting our climate goals requires not just electrifying the vehicle fleet,
SPEAKER_02but actually reducing how much people drive. I talked with Matthew Lewis of California YIMBY about the increasing political salience of housing and the lack of understanding in the climate movement. I talked with YIMBY activists about how the movement is racking up winds from New York to Texas and learning from itself across geographies. And I talked with Montana state legislators about what bipartisan legislative success actually looks like from the inside. At least from my perspective,
SPEAKER_02the empirical case has been made, the political case has been made, and there's a growing track record of legislative success. And yet... climate funders still largely seem to be sitting this one out. Today, I want to understand why and what it would take to change it. My guests are Ben Holland of WRI's New Urban Mobility Alliance, who has been spending the last several months interviewing
climate funders about
SPEAKER_02exactly this question. And Serial Volt's guest, Caroline Spears of Climate Cabinet, who just released a major housing and climate policy platform and works with state legislators on this stuff. He is going to talk about what they are thinking. She is going to talk about what they ought to be doing.
SPEAKER_02With no further ado, Ben Holland and Carolyn Spears, welcome to Volts. Thank you so much for coming. Thanks for having us. Ben, let's start with you. So you have been... working on urbanism-ish stuff, related issues in climate world for several years now. Now you're at WRI. Before that, you were at RMI. I would just like to hear about your experiences and specifically, how did you find the reception of this work kind of upstairs,
SPEAKER_02up the ladder, at the boss level, let's say? The story I like to tell as far as how I got converted to urbanism goes back to 2017, 2018. I was living in Austin, Texas for a project that the RMI Mobility team was running down there. It was a direct partnership with the city of Austin and local stakeholders where a
SPEAKER_01lot of NGOs in the space at the time we were trying to advance electric, autonomous, shared mobility services. And really, the shiny object of those things, we were very much caught up in all of that. And I was sort of the on-the-ground government affairs person for that project and moved to Austin for that work. And over the course of a couple years there, I became really well-connected with the urbanism groups there and would find ourselves in conversations about, well, so what are you doing with regard to urban sprawl?
SPEAKER_01You know, if you think the future is autonomous vehicles, for instance, I mean, what is that going to do to vehicle miles travel, people living farther away from core destinations? And, you know, we didn't really even have a great answer for it at the time. We would have been like, well, these will be electric, you know? Did you see how shiny it is? Yeah. Yeah. It was in my time there where I really came to understand the flaws of just that vision and also just the real need for better housing policy as
well as kind of
SPEAKER_01like tried and true transportation planning policy. And came back to Colorado, continued working for RMI, and started to kind of build up what we called a climate-aligned urbanism team. Your former... guests, Rashad Nanavati and Heather House were two of my colleagues at the time, as was Zach Subin and Jackie Lombardi. But the work we were trying to do was, it came from kind of this acknowledgement that there needed to be better data on the actual impacts and benefits of land use reform.
SPEAKER_01It was kind of vibes-based, in my opinion. Like everybody kind of intuitively understands the compact connected communities are good you know some people have read the david owen book uh green metropolis you know intuitively understanding that these urban centers are on a per capita basis lower emissions but that was about the extent of it so we started to kind of try to put some real analysis that i think you talked about on that previous podcast with uh rashad and heather but i'll just say kind of bluntly
SPEAKER_01And I'll just take transportation as an example. Even under the most kind of wildly optimistic electric vehicle adoption scenarios, we are not going to be able to meet our climate goals without addressing the demand side, essentially reducing vehicle miles traveled. And within that goal of reducing vehicle miles traveled, one of the biggest, if not the biggest lever is improving the way that we build and where we build and improving our land use. And so we started over time kind of like stacking up all these
different analyses
SPEAKER_01and putting together these beautiful decks. I mean, I think you saw one of the presentations at Climate Week back in September with our event with Gell Architects. And, you know, we finally have the data. We're showing you the real potential of reducing emissions through land use. I would say over the past few years, not just in my recent conversations with climate funders, but over the past few years, I've heard a number of kind of universally held beliefs or skepticisms around the viability of land use reform or even mode shift on the
transportation side of
SPEAKER_01things as a sort of fundable strategy.
SPEAKER_02What kind of shocked me is that after that presentation, after all this extraordinary sort of empirical work that RMI did, which I thought was quite impressive and made the case in pretty clear terms that even RMI decided not to expand its urbanism work. Well, we've also seen a major shift in politics and where funding is going right now.
SPEAKER_01I think we can get into this in a little bit, but a lot of funding has moved to more international interest given the current political climate. And I can get into why that is understandable from their perspective, but also much needed to have even like a state focus here in the States. You say it's understandable. Maybe we can address it later, but I don't understand it at all. The fascists showed up and our response is like, all right, we're out later.
SPEAKER_02We're going to go spend overseas. We'll be back when the fascism is gone. I'm like, what are you guys for? Sorry, I'm yelling.
SPEAKER_00Carolyn, go ahead. I think it's an impulse to Sometimes people collapse U.S. policy discussions just into Washington, D.C., and it forgets that we have 50 other, you know, rulemaking bodies here where we can actually make progress. The no D.C., go international first impulse, I think, collapses a lot of it. It oversimplifies a policy discussion. We have states and they have budgetary power. And I had a lot of those conversations after, which was really...
folks asking questions like that and reminding people that we have states and their state budgets spend trillions of dollars a year and we actually have a lot of
SPEAKER_00opportunity.
SPEAKER_02Is part of it, I don't want to get too deep into this now, but is part of it, like when you said, Ben, that most of the urbanism work before you started digging into it with RMI was mostly vibes-based. And I get that. And I think it's worth saying also that the left funding community is full of sort of aspiring technocrats, like people who very much fashion themselves smart and empirical, et cetera, et cetera, meaning they want numbers.
SPEAKER_02They want like payback periods and deliverables and et cetera. Now, I think they want that to a fault in ways we can discuss later. But obviously, you can see why, at least before all this empirical work was done, why this was a kind of a bad fit. That's one thing, the fuzziness. And then the other thing is what Caroline brings up for me is that I think they also are all kind of They aspire to big things. They want to be big and important.
SPEAKER_02And federal government feels big and important. And international feels big and important. And to some extent, little state battles and city battles just don't feel grand enough for them. Is that a piece of it, Caroline, do you think?
SPEAKER_00Well, one thing that always shocks people to that point that I say is that Wisconsin as a state has more greenhouse gas emissions than the country of Norway. And how many times have I seen someone maybe on the internet get so excited about Norway's electric vehicle progress or something like that? I find that exciting too, but it is smaller than most of the states that we have in America.
SPEAKER_02Yes, U.S. is very big. Let's all remember, U.S. is very, very large. Okay, Ben, so you did this work at RMI. I think RMI kind of decided not to sort of blow this out and follow up on it, so you moved to WRI. Now you're doing this mobility alliance. Now you're... digging into it. You're out talking to climate funders about this now. Is this just kind of an informal thing you're doing on your own? What is the project you're working on right now? Yeah, well, let me first say that this work did continue at RMI for a bit.
SPEAKER_01And I think some of the challenges are universal across the board. What I'm about to get into, like... Yeah, I don't mean to single out RMI. Most NGOs are... If you talk to people in the kind of land use space or even just non-electric vehicle transportation people at NGOs, this is a universal challenge that they're facing. Yes. But I guess I would say you touched on some of these things, but some of the universal things I think are. Well, wait, before we get into the specific objections, just tell me about the project itself.
SPEAKER_02Like, why are you, is this all on your own initiative? Yeah, I've been doing a series of interviews with national and international. climate foundations to just better understand where they're coming from on this subject. It's part of a small project we were funded to do at WRI on the new Urban Mobility
SPEAKER_01Alliance team. It's so overdue.
SPEAKER_02I mean, the thinking of left funders is such an object of discourse. So many people are so consumed by trying to figure it out. And they're just up there. You could just go ask them. It's weird that there's not more transparency about why they do what they do.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, and I think I should caveat that, you know, we're still thinking through how we're going to publish these findings, but nothing I'm going to say here I think is going to be of any great surprise to anybody.
SPEAKER_02Yes, so what we're going to do is... So before all this started, Ben, you emailed me sort of like, I've been talking to funders about this, climate funders, and here are the things I hear about why they're not getting involved in urbanism. So what we're going to do now, I think, is just go through kind of the main objections and you heard, and obviously we don't have time here to fully address any one of them, much less all of them, but we're going to at least say a few words about why you and
Carolyn think they
SPEAKER_02are wrong. Just going to walk through them one at a time, the kinds of things you heard from funders. And it's funny, I'm not even in funding world. I'm not trying to raise money for urbanism. I'm just some schmo. And even I've heard all of these, to your point that they're sort of universal, like These are all very familiar. So let's go through them. The first is this notion that when you're doing energy policy, you have a couple of clear constituencies that you're trying to mobilize who can
SPEAKER_02get you over the finish line. And I think they have it in their heads that when it comes to urbanism, the stakeholder landscape is just too complicated. There's too many different groups who want too many different things. There's too much work trying to get all the constituencies on one page.
SPEAKER_01What do you make of that? So again, at first blush, it kind of makes sense that you have a distributed network of policy makers and stakeholders and community advocates, et cetera, that you have to bring together around one policy. It has been the belief. And I would go a step further. It's that many in the funder and NGO space worry that you have to do that city to city across hundreds to thousands of cities across the country.
SPEAKER_02That's the thing. These are sort of like bespoke and local and kind of geographically specific. Bespoke would be the word. All of these are very understandable. Like that's understandable to me to have that objection because to some extent, like the battle in Cleveland is sort of unique to Cleveland and the battle in Austin is somewhat unique to Austin and you really kind of got to go in and figure out the landscape and who's who and who's fighting for what. And you have to do that city by city. Like that makes some sense to me.
SPEAKER_02So what do you tell them about this?
SPEAKER_01Yeah. So at the risk of making it sound like one simple hack kind of thing, there are 75% of residential land around 75% across the U S is zoned to single family. And most high demand cities are where there's a very high demand for housing, there is significant need for multifamily housing near destinations, near public transit, that is currently illegal to build. So just legalizing apartment buildings in an infill environment,
SPEAKER_01near transit, near key destinations, is kind of a universal tool that you see the YIMBY movement using across the country to great success. And Caroline's going to get into that. But there are sort of dominoes falling, not just at the city level, but in a very exciting way at the state level as well. The one thing that comes to mind for me is just how many initiatives within the climate space do work at the state and city level and do require coordination and alignment among so many stakeholders.
SPEAKER_01If you're thinking about passing building electrification strategies. Yeah. Once you get in distribution grid stuff.
SPEAKER_02Yes. Right. I mean, all of that is somewhat geographic specific, somewhat bespoke. You say these dominoes are falling in Caroline. Maybe you can answer this. From the funder's perspective, another thing that makes sense to me is when I'm thinking about advocating for apartments or whatever, the big constituency that's going to benefit from apartments being built is doesn't yet exist. It is the people that will live in the apartments who don't yet know that they're part of that constituency.
SPEAKER_02So anybody who's status quo biased and fighting against change, they are all concentrated and mobilized. And the people who will benefit from change tend to be scattered and not mobilized. As an a priori fear about this, I can understand funders having that fear. But then look, it's working. It's happening. The dominoes are falling. So I guess, Caroline, my question is, who are the constituencies who are stepping up? It turns out it's not as difficult to find and mobilize
constituencies as we thought. Who are these people who are turning out to be the constituencies in question? Well, Dave, I don't know if you've heard about this, but affordability is a key theme right now.
SPEAKER_02The word is not ringing a bell. Can you
SPEAKER_00Have we had this discussion? But because of the affordability and cost of living crisis, which is primarily driven by the cost of housing, policymakers or constituents are really approaching land use in a different way than maybe they did 10, 20 or 30 years ago, which I think is when some of these priors are baked in. Costs are skyrocketing. In climate, we've had a long and detailed conversation about electricity. When you talk to policymakers, the number one cost issue for most of the people living in their district is the cost of housing.
SPEAKER_00It's the cost of putting a roof over their head. Median American family spends about $2,000 a month on housing. They spend another $1,000 more on transportation. And when you tackle that as a bucket, you can see some big cost of living and affordability wins, but also... Some big climate wins as well. So you have both of those happening at once. And I think this affordability conversation gives us new avenues and opportunities.
SPEAKER_02I want to think that young people get this.
SPEAKER_00Yes.
SPEAKER_02And are rising up. Is that accurate?
SPEAKER_00I think so. I think there's a big generational gap as well between folks who maybe bought their house in the 80s and folks who are trying to buy a house now.
SPEAKER_02Okay, so that's the first one. That's the constituencies question. And I think the answer to that is just that the cavalry has kind of arrived.
SPEAKER_00Yep.
SPEAKER_02The constituency is there. It's been demonstrated. And Ben, tell me if I'm getting out over my skis here, but it seems like having pulled those constituencies together and won, each time you do that at a new city, it's a little bit easier the next city, just because you have a little bit of better understanding of what the constituencies are and the dynamics of et cetera. Like, it's not proving to be 100% bespoke, 100% start over, right?
SPEAKER_01I mean, they've very much created a template. California Yimby has, and you're seeing that adopted state to state around the country right now with major wins happening. And you know, alongside of the state level, you also have many very successful city level campaigns like Austin, Texas gets a lot of attention in this space. It's kind of like it's becoming a standard template that I think it's fairly adaptable and not bespoke city to city or state to state.
SPEAKER_02A little bit like what happened with renewable portfolio standards, I feel like in kind of the 90s and 2000s is the first few words, a lot of work and bespoke. And then they just kind of started like going once they got established. Just to double down on that, just talk about renewable portfolio standards.
SPEAKER_00It goes state by state by state. So sure, you get people going, oh, you got to go in each state, each state, each state. By 2015, half of all renewable energy built in America was built because of a state renewable portfolio standard. So we have track record.
SPEAKER_02Right. Then you've got a case to make at the federal level, right? Your case at the federal level is much stronger if you've got a bunch of states. pulling in the right direction the second objection this one i almost think is has the most bite and this is the kind of measurement question as we said ben like all these funders or at least like their officers the people they have working with with them all fashion themselves technocrats and they all want
to be like you know how many votes will I get for this dollar of investment, you know, in the electoral system?
SPEAKER_02Like, you know, they want things quantified. And in this area, there's a pretty long causal chain between mustering the constituencies, passing the policy, having the policy work its magic for a few years. Then you see a marginal reduction of, a VMT, then you get some carbon benefits. But that's just a long chain, and it's very difficult to track. It's difficult to quantify. It's difficult to say for certain to a funder,
invest this dollar, you'll get X result.
SPEAKER_02That is understandable to me. I think they take it too far. I think they get kind of obsessive and psychotic about it. And a lot of stuff that ought to get money doesn't get money because of that weird obsession, but at its root, it makes some sense. Like they want to know, does this stuff work? So what is your answer to the kind of measurement question?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I'm going to combine this with something I think you were going to bring up a little bit later too, around VMT. First of all, yes, that is an understandable skepticism. However, there is very interesting evidence coming out around the actual VMT reductions when housing is built close to transit, close to destinations and jobs. I'll just throw out a couple. Between 2013 and 2024, housing units grew 20% in Minneapolis, while overall VMT fell 12%,
and per capita fell by 18%.
SPEAKER_01Now, most states, and Minnesota's one of them, most states that have some kind of VMT reduction goal tend to be around the 20%, they kind of top out at 20% per capita. That's pretty remarkable that they're seeing, and obviously there's other factors involved there. Well, yeah, I mean, it's the case in point, like Minneapolis has done a bunch of things
SPEAKER_02Which of those, you know, is responsible for how much of that 8%? It's very difficult to figure that out.
SPEAKER_01One of the things to kind of simplify, at least from my perspective, is that if you have sort of a suite of housing policy, policies that are being introduced at the state level, you know, there's certainly some question around like if you just do a basic kind of duplex, fourplex, broad upzoning, where is it going to be built and how much is it going to actually reduce VMT? I don't want to overestimate how easy it is to quantify those things. There is significant potential,
SPEAKER_01I think, to also support more housing near transit where if you basically have properties that cannot be developed with multifamily housing in existing low VMT areas, then people are going to build elsewhere. And when you liberalize kind of that, those properties to be developed, you're making it possible to live in a lower VMT area. There's a lot of work that Turner Center has done looking at the viability of prioritizing new housing in existing low VMT areas.
SPEAKER_02Well, like, it's easy to establish... directionally what will happen, right? Like if you up zone a bunch of single family lots around a transit station, people will build on them. You know, like that much you can say specifying how much they'll build and then further from that deriving how much greenhouse gases they will save by living there You're back in fuzzy territory. You can get directionality, but not precision, I feel like. I'm going to get probably some flack from some of my EV friends
for this following
SPEAKER_01statement, but I used to work in the EV space. There's just sort of a confidence in if we pass this EV policy or these tax credits, there's a kind of one-for-one replacement in people buying EVs. I'm not saying it's as fuzzy as land use. However, there are some kind of assumptions that go into play as far as just kind of checking that box. We have this big EV win. But, you know... Are those vehicles second or third vehicles? That is changing over time, of course.
SPEAKER_01EVs are getting cheaper. They're becoming the primary vehicle for a lot of households. How much VMT is that replacing? How many electrified miles is it creating versus ICE miles? I think just simply legalizing multifamily housing in places where it's currently illegal is for me, is enough of a level of certainty, I guess, as far as this being a production. Yeah,
SPEAKER_02I guess what I would ask is, because I think the class of policies for which you can reliably project precise effects is pretty small. Most social and political and economic policy is spirals out and has second order effects. And, you know, I mean, like it's very difficult to predict the effects of almost anything. So I guess when you talk to funders about this, what would you like to see?
Would you like to see more empirical work and measurement and precision in the urbanism world?
SPEAKER_02to mollify this concern? Or would you say to funders, you got to loosen up a little bit about this? You know what I mean? Should funders adjust what they expect?
SPEAKER_01Which side or both? I believe that the funders in the climate community writ large in the US right now needs to participate in the discussions related to housing policy where they're currently, for the most part, not participating in those discussions. As far as the flows of funding, supporting pro-housing initiatives and pro-housing in states and cities across the country would be very valuable. I've heard these numbers thrown around, and I apologize if they're not completely accurate,
but I think on average there's about $4 billion of funding committed to climate in
SPEAKER_01the U.S. Every year, the sort of pro-housing movement up until recently has had a little more than $40 million, I think, across the whole country. So even just a small amount of investment in this space... And look at the relative success,
SPEAKER_02the relative results of those two different buckets of spending.
SPEAKER_01I know that Caroline has some thoughts on this too, as far as playing a role in this conversation related to housing policy. Well, let's get to what I think is one of the other understandable objections. I think this is one that not just funders have in their head, but that a lot of ordinary people have in their head like just a lot of people I encounter online which is this like if you want to decarbonize housing and transportation just make everything electric and non-carbon just solve it with technology substitute low to
zero carbon technologies in there I think if you ask just an ordinary person like which is
SPEAKER_02faster shifting land use policies and thereby shifting development patterns and transportation patterns, or just like giving everybody who buys an EV a $10,000 check. I think a lot of people will intuitively think it's just faster to get the electric vehicles out there. It's just faster to replace a technology than it is to change social and behavioral and longstanding patterns of
SPEAKER_02how we live, basically just like a lot of funders, I think, like we have a technological lever we can pull here that's clear and easy and we know exactly where to put the money in contrast to, again, this fuzziness that you want me to get into. How do you address that objection?
SPEAKER_01I would say that that's an understandable sentiment. However, and this is going to sound a bit like a cop-out, we have to do both. You know, some of the analysis that my team, when I was at RMI did, found that to meet 2030 emissions goals, we would need something on the order of, just for the transportation sector alone, we would need to reduce emissions by 45% by 2030. What that would amount to is 70 million EVs on the road by 2030. And even under that just wildly optimistic scenario,
SPEAKER_01we would still need to reduce vehicle miles traveled by 20% per capita. And that's kind of getting close to that Minneapolis number I mentioned. We have, I think, a little over 6 million EVs on the road today in less than six years. Sorry, excuse me, less than four years till we get to 2030. Now, I know some of the goalposts are moving on this. And as far as timelines out to 2050, the EV market could potentially get there to pick up the slack.
SPEAKER_02But, you know, also worth saying that cars have their life cycle and don't turn over that often. 12, 13 years. And there's limited... public policy tools that can really hasten that cycle. So you're sort of tied to that timeline in that world.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. And meanwhile, sprawl is continuing throughout the U S and housing policies are being made that could either improve or worsen those conditions and basically locking in, you know, a hundred years of development patterns are basically into perpetuity. So I would say that, um, Yes, hypothetically, it's borne out just in the reduction of battery costs and the adoption of EVs. Technology moves fast, but not fast enough for where we need to be.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, I think that's the main thing. And that's kind of what was established in the RMI episode I did, which is just that no matter what your feelings about EVs, there's just no model. There's no prospect of getting where we need to get purely through EVs. You just can't do it. You can't hasten that cycle. And there's also, I think, a corresponding kind of intuitive sense of the slowness of urban reform that is also kind of belied by events. Things are moving pretty quickly.
SPEAKER_02Austin has changed quite a bit, pretty quick. Minneapolis has changed quite a bit, pretty quick. It's not always slow and incremental.
SPEAKER_00I mean, we have specific examples just recently about that. Since New York City put in congestion pricing, pollution has dropped 10%. There are other cities like Barcelona. In the last decade and a half, they've reduced their carbon pollution by roughly 20% in 15 years. Name another sector of climate policy where we've been able to get that emissions reduction in that short of a time. I'll weigh it. And guess what? They did it through a combination. You got EV policy in there, but a lot of it was walkability, bikeability.
You should be able to walk to your corner store and like making a livable community
SPEAKER_00that makes that a reality. And that's how they did it.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. So I think that kind of the response there is kind of twofold. One is EVs can't move as fast as you might think they could, right? They're slower than you think. And two, urban reform moves faster than you generally might think it would. Once it gets going, it moves pretty quick. And I feel like, God, having that congestion pricing example out there is really helpful. You would be challenged to find a policy that is more just evidently beneficial immediately to everyone.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_02The fifth objection, which I don't know how often or substantial this one is, but it's interesting to me is, you know, just as a little background, there's this abundance thing going on. Anybody who follows democratic politics is no doubt familiar with this hype around And, you know, the abundance people love the Yimby people. They sort of claim the Yimby people as part of their own. But a lot of how abundance has gotten press and attention is by
crapping on green groups, right?
SPEAKER_02That's kind of how they've levered their way to a high profile, which I would imagine makes some people in the green groups and in the green funding world somewhat suspicious of the abundance people, perhaps even hostile to the abundance people, which then might be putting them off Yimby because they associate it with abundance. I'm just curious what's going on there.
SPEAKER_02What are funders thinking about that specifically? Because like from a distance, you think, well, look, the abundance people love YIMBY. The climate people love YIMBY. Let's all just support YIMBY and be happy and hold hands and make good things happen. Of course, that's not how it works. Instead, everybody's at each other's throats, but I'm curious what you've heard from funders about this. Hey there, everybody. Don't worry. I'm not going to tell you about a new mattress or push a credit card on you. This isn't an ad.
SPEAKER_02There are no ads on Volts. It is supported entirely by listeners like you. If you'll indulge me for a second, I'd like to ask for your support. I started Volts because we're all surrounded by depressing news about climate change and misinformation about clean energy. And it's never been more important to share the stories of the real people on the ground doing the real work of transition and all the ingenuity and courage and public spirit they are bringing to it. People are hungry to hear these stories, to learn from and find inspiration in them.
I've heard from people who change majors or careers after hearing episodes of Volts.
SPEAKER_02People using it in classrooms, community groups, even state legislators who have passed bills inspired by specific episodes. Sharing these stories matters. It makes a difference. If you have found value in it and want to help me continue doing it, The Abundance People love Yimby.
SPEAKER_02The climate people love YIMBY. Let's all just support YIMBY and be happy and hold hands and make good things happen. Of course, that's not how it works. Instead, everybody's at each other's throats. But I'm curious what you've heard from funders about this. I was afraid you were going to bring this one up. A whole abundance debate. Can you hear the stampede in the distance? It's coming at us.
SPEAKER_00Ben, why don't you take this one? Yeah, sure.
SPEAKER_01I think that there is a concern that, especially with regard to transportation and land use, this sort of enthusiasm about reducing permitting hurdles and eliminating kind of environmental assessments necessary for projects, that that could give rise to For instance, more highways, since that, you know, basically the book focuses a great deal on why don't we have high-speed rail in California yet? And there's all myriad of different environmental regulations
and processes that
SPEAKER_01have slowed that down, which I'm very sympathetic to that argument. Many in the climate space, I think, would say the abundance movement is, you know, by supporting that... You're also potentially expanding more highways, getting more fossil fuel interests involved and things of that nature. It's kind of interesting to me because the climate space has had nothing to say basically about highway expansions or highways or transportation investment of that kind to date either.
SPEAKER_02I know. Now we don't like it?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, exactly. That would be another episode altogether, I think, around just transportation funding.
SPEAKER_02I think if I could summarize what you just said, it's that abundance, the vibe of abundance is build, build, build everything. And the vibe of climate people is, okay, fine, build, but only good stuff. And that is, I think, the source of the disagreement between them. But again, I return to the fact that they can both agree on build, build, build housing, right? Like this seems like it ought to be a site of collaboration and bridge building between these two factions, I guess is what I'm saying.
SPEAKER_02And I don't know that I'm seeing that happen.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I would agree with that. There's still a fair amount of education conversation that needs to be had on the left and within the environmental space around what we mean as far as housing abundance and how they can play a role in influencing more kind of climate aligned housing development, which is combining, you know, building decarbonization goals with pro-housing initiatives in urban centers around the country could be super powerful. I don't think that zoning is really even on the radar of most climate groups. And if you've seen a lot of skepticism online and on Twitter,
SPEAKER_01you know, there are a lot of anti-abundance kind of Twitter accounts. They don't like to even engage in the zoning discussion. It tends to just focus on corporate interests.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. Am I worried that like the abundance people introducing themselves through crapping on green groups has polarized members of the green groups against things like zoning reform. And that to me is just tragic. It's just tragic that that it's happened. I don't want, I want to stop that trend from happening. Like, How do you navigate this, Ben? I mean, I don't know to what extent you're trying to sort of be a funder whisperer and change these people's minds, but like what works on this question to get around this sensitivity?
SPEAKER_01For me, it's really focusing this subject around the sort of infill and transit-oriented development policies that could be a part of those kind of abundant, if you want to call it abundance packages. But that term is, There's some overlap with the YIMBY movement, but I will say that the YIMBY movement's done a really amazing job of creating compelling messaging and fact-based messaging around the climate benefits, and in many cases have successfully built
bridged relationships where they didn't exist like with sierra club for instance in california and in oregon and you're seeing more and more of this happen i think at really at the state level without even really any meaningful participation from kind of more national groups that's i know it's kind of sad i mean i almost think if i was in the yimby movement my attitude toward this would be look we're winning I don't want your loser coalition grabbing onto me and I don't want your loser
SPEAKER_02coalition grabbing onto me. No, thanks. We'll just remain independent and keep winning. Like, has anyone asked the YIMBY people whether they want climate showing up at the door? You know what I mean?
SPEAKER_01This is actually a fear of mine. And it's something I talked to, you know, some in the YIMBY movement. I'm a big fan of Matthew Lewis, who you interviewed. But in some places, so I'll give you an example of where additional support for pro-housing, a particular infill and kind of transit-oriented development policies would be really effective, would be in more purple and just straight-up red states. So we have some forthcoming analysis at WRI that finds significant emissions reduction potential in Texas, Arizona, North Carolina, Florida,
SPEAKER_01and places like that because people drive a lot there. There's more sprawling development patterns.
SPEAKER_02You mean just through basic upzoning and...
SPEAKER_01Yes. Yeah. And, you know, something akin to like a transit oriented development bill, like you've seen in your state of Washington or California or, or Colorado. However, I think the YIMBY movements in those places understandably would be a little cautious about the climate coming out very vocal about it. Like, would it help for the Sierra club to show up in Texas and be like, Hey, we love this too.
SPEAKER_02Like it's not clear to me. The whole thing, but I have heard it's, I've heard just different opinions on it.
SPEAKER_01Like the groups we've talked to in Texas, You know, they had to get some Democratic legislators on board to support some recent state level zoning policy wins there. Basically, they recently passed some legislation that allows by right development of housing on commercial lots, which ideally will give rise to more development in some urban centers. There are times when the climate message is really effective. I think it gets to a level of political strategy that I'm not
very adept at to
SPEAKER_01think about how much are those discussions behind closed doors? And can the climate funding space support some of these initiatives without derailing the whole thing?
SPEAKER_02Well, Caroline, let me ask you about this because you are in dialogue with state and city level politicians all the time. When I think about if you're a poster online, It helps you for abundance and climate to be fighting because, oh, the content it generates. But if you are a state politician trying to do things and pass bills, it seems like you would look at this and say,
SPEAKER_02this seems like a natural overlap. I need constituencies, right? I need popular policies that are gonna help multiple goals at once, right? This overlap seems like rich and attractive to me. So I'm just curious whether state politicians are maybe ahead of the climate funding community on this question.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I mean, just to be clear about where housing policy is in state capitals, state capitals being our only avenue for climate progress for the next three years. state and local. Just to be clear about where housing policy is, housing policy is going to pass most state legislatures. It's already hit most state legislatures the last few years. I will go on this podcast and make a public prediction that almost every state, if not 100% of them, will pass some policy to build more housing in the next session or two.
SPEAKER_02We'll see about that. We'll hold you to that.
SPEAKER_00Someone can fact check me on this. because it's the number one cost driver for people in America. Housing prices have skyrocketed. And I will just say, somewhat miraculously, to me anyway, housing seems to be...
SPEAKER_02I'm knocking on wood even as I'm saying these words, but it does seem to me, at least to date, to have avoided the absolutely chronic, crippling polarization that affects literally everything else in American public life. I don't know why that is or how long it can last, but... that's like magic dust in today's politics.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, building more housing has this bipartisan constituency, absolutely. And so I think from a climate perspective, we have two choices. Option A for housing policy is it passes and it spikes transportation pollution. Option B is it reduces transportation pollution. So there's two paths and that's like a why get involved and You can either have more costs, more traffic, more time in the car instead of time with your family, or you can create low pollution communities.
SPEAKER_00And that's kind of the choice that folks are facing. That's the choice in front of climate right now. Here are the two options. Everyone's going to pass more housing policy, but you can kind of pick option A or option B. And option B is the one in which climate gets involved a little more.
SPEAKER_02So the pitch here is housing policy is happening regardless. Is it going to be climate-friendly housing policy or climate-negative housing policy?
SPEAKER_00That's right.
SPEAKER_02That depends somewhat on whether climate groups are in the room, in the door, engaged in this area.
SPEAKER_00Exactly. Absolutely.
SPEAKER_02And do they buy that? Like, like I buy that, but of course I want to buy that. Like, I'm curious whether they buy that. Like, do they view housing as like, you know, it is still, even though it's happening everywhere, it's still kind of dangerous. It's still fraught. There's still a lot of arguing about what kind is good and et cetera. So like, do they buy the idea that like, this is the train that's moving, hop on or get run over. Is that working? I think what's challenging about it is something you and Ben talked about earlier,
SPEAKER_00which is that it's a little bit of a walk. Transportation pollution is the number one source of climate pollution in America.
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_00And right now kind of there has been this to Ben's point, the focus of transportation policy for the last at least decade and a half has been electric vehicles and specifically the California electrical vehicle standards and trying to get those into many as many states as possible. Well, then someone by the name of Donald Trump got elected, kind of threw that plan into the bonfire. So we're in a space now where we have to go a little bit back to the drawing board on transportation policy. And the question then becomes, how many options can we put on the table that are tractable,
SPEAKER_00that are doable, where we can get something done on transportation policy with the avenues that we have and the power that we have? And then housing policy starts looking like a very interesting solution.
SPEAKER_02Well, I think one of the reasons why, as I'm thinking about reasons why that hasn't happened, this raises another question, which is the generational thing, which is if I'm diagnosing, why is that the case? My suspicion is that older people in general have a much more positive view of driving and cars generally. I think to an older generation, they represented...
SPEAKER_02freedom and prosperity and et cetera, et cetera. This has all been written about to no end. So like old people like driving and they hate policies that make them drive less. And, you know, sort of legendarily older people are overrepresented in our politics in general. And in, at the municipal level in particular, like they're the ones who show up at the meetings, you know, like they're the ones who fill out the response cards and they're the ones who call the legislators. So I wonder like,
SPEAKER_02If I'm a state legislature and I think about here's, I'm going to pass a policy that with the explicit goal of having people drive less, I am in terror of organized old people in my state crucifying me. So I wonder how the generational thing is playing out on the ground, whether you or Ben have any thoughts on that.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I think the generational gap is a big part of it. I would say that our goal, right, EVs are part of the picture. So if people love driving, that part of the picture really speaks to that. And it's about transportation choices. Transportation is, again, the second largest monthly expense that the average American family faces and And it's about having options and choices about where do you want to put that? Or do you just like about 25% of all of Philadelphia actually choose to get to work
SPEAKER_00every weekday on SEPTA, the Philadelphia public transit system, zero carbon transportation system that almost got defunded last year. And it's still really struggling.
SPEAKER_02A lot of city transit systems are still in that perilous situation.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, it's about giving people choices. And if I were to tell you, hey, I have a magic bullet to convert 25% of Philadelphia's cars to EVs, I think someone would be really excited about that. And then when you peel back the curtain a little bit and say, it's the bus, sometimes folks change it. But from a climate perspective, the point is, it's the same. And it's about giving people options and choices. And EVs are part of that, but also... There's transportation. Zero carbon transit is a part of that as well.
SPEAKER_02But you know that people's views on this are so vibes-based. When people have personal experience with something, it's almost like empirical analysis goes out the window. You can throw numbers at them all day long. They're like, no, but I got uncomfortable on the bus once. But Ben, this is perhaps a slightly awkward and uncomfortable question, but the funders themselves... are those old people. By and large, the funders themselves are from an older generation that had a
different attitude
SPEAKER_02towards cars and driving. And I think very deep in their bones views, like you grow up, you get a job, you become independent, and you get a car. And if you don't, if you're still an adult stuck on public transit, it is a sign of basically failure. I think that is so deeply ingrained. And it's not coincidence that all the funders are from that generation. So I just wonder, A, is that accurate on my part?
SPEAKER_02And B, is there any kind of generational overturning, renewal happening in the funding community?
SPEAKER_01Well, I think that generalization is largely accurate. They also tend to be deeply rooted in kind of an anti-developer sentiment that goes back to the 70s, you know? Kind of your classic environmentalist. Yeah, land preservation, all that stuff. Land preservation, yeah. I've lived in Colorado and Boulder, Colorado for most of the last 20 years, and every time there's some kind of upzoning or housing... development or zoning policy that's introduced, people come out of the woodwork using climate as their excuse
for fighting it.
SPEAKER_01And that is just rampant.
SPEAKER_00That's what's so wild to me as someone who also, I love hiking, I love being outside, is I actually do care about preserving ecosystems and things like that. And I'm like, yeah, and I don't want anyone to have to super commute in two hours each way to get to a major city. And I kind of, it's so funny that that's a you know, just where we are, because I think the bridge here is that actually, we actually have a way into not paving over really nice farmland. You could be using to grow food for people.
We're down to our last kind of five, 10% of wetlands in the state of California.
SPEAKER_00Let's not go there.
SPEAKER_02Let me just tell you, having run this argument on Nextdoor, let me just tell you, they're not convinced. Yeah. It doesn't work.
SPEAKER_00You know what? I think the big generational gap, though, besides the driving, not the attitudes towards driving, I think the big generational gap is cost of housing. I think when I talk to folks who bought a house in the 80s and they tell me and I do the little inflation adjustment in my head, I'm like, are you serious? What was the cost of housing? That's incredible. The goal with housing is let's create a world in which we can do that again.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. Well, that's what I say is like, if you're to the next door people, like if you fight housing here, it's just going to go out and plant itself on the land that you say you want to preserve. So you are having perverse effects here by fighting housing, but I have not changed a single mind on, on next door yet.
SPEAKER_00On next door. Yeah. Godspeed. Yeah.
SPEAKER_01You mentioned the transit piece, and I think that's accurate as well. Probably, this is a gross generalization, but there are probably not a lot of heavy transit users as far as the big money environmental.
SPEAKER_02I think they live in suburbs and they drive. Wealthy white American people live in suburbs and drive mostly. I remember back when we had the whole shared electric autonomous initiative and
SPEAKER_01every other NGO in the space, it was almost this kind of understanding or conventional wisdom that was like, you know, the transition is not effective on a cost basis and the ridership is really weak. And that these were the just sort of firmly held beliefs among, in some of those discussions. And some people, I think their eyes glaze over when you talk about things like transit oriented development, because it's kind of like, it is sort of been a topic and well-worn territory in the planning space for so long. But yeah,
SPEAKER_02Well, it doesn't feel disruptive. Yeah, it doesn't feel disruptive. It doesn't feel techie. It doesn't feel futuristic. They all want self-driving, unmanned drone VTOLs. All these guys, they're all 12-year-old boys. And buses and trains are just kind of... boring and reliable and standard, right?
SPEAKER_01That's very true. My colleague, Justin Huckleberry, is running some analysis right now of looking at the sort of existing densities along transit lines in 70 different cities. And I think the rule of thumb is kind of like you want something north of 15 units per acre to be kind of supportive of transit operations. And I mean, the land use adjacent to transit lines in a lot of the cities we're looking at on average are just abysmal. It's wild. Five units per acre, maybe. I've heard you talk about this with regard to Seattle even,
SPEAKER_01which is, I think, surprised a lot of people.
SPEAKER_02I mean, I'm thinking like they, you know, they built this giant multi-billion dollar light rail system in Seattle, which, you know, great. But there's a station that next to the, to the interstate near my house. And I can stand in the parking lot of that light rail station, throw a rock and hit a single family home across the street or a profanity golf course, a golf course, catty corner to the transit station. Like we have dozens of golf courses, like, but you better believe the community rally to protect that
frigging golf course.
SPEAKER_02And this is baffling to me, Ben. And Caroline, maybe you have something to say about this too. Forget climate. Forget pollution. Forget everything else. Just allowing building along transit routes is a job. generator. It is a tax revenue generator. It is the most reliable growth generator that you have as an urban politician. It just seems in self-interest they would want to do at least that.
SPEAKER_00I think that's true. I think one question that people have around housing and land use is, is it tractable? Y'all talked about, is it too slow, et cetera? I mean, this is a place where Just last year, Illinois passed this incredible first piece, really cool legislation, the NETA Act, which not only dedicated over $1.5 billion a year to zero carbon transportation, $1.5 billion a year to zero carbon transportation, incredible.
SPEAKER_00It also... allowed people to build multi-unit near transit stops. And by that, I don't just mean trains, I mean buses, I mean walkability, like it really built all of this. And then building on that, that's not just then, Illinois is not stopping yet. J.B. Pritzker has introduced the build Act to Illinois this year, and that would legalize ADUs, legalize missing middle homes that are symptomatic of this larger housing affordability problem. It eliminates parking minimums, need eliminated parking minimums near transit stops.
SPEAKER_00This goes more statewide. And this is, it already passed. I have great news, y'all. All of these ideas that we're talking about, they're tractable. They're moving through states and we already have a great one out of Illinois and they're building on it.
SPEAKER_02If you're running a climate group in Illinois, wouldn't you like to be one of those people standing behind the desk when, when Jamie Pritzker signs this beautiful victory legislation, wouldn't you like to be one of the people ascribed, you know, as the person who helped get this done? Like, wouldn't you rather be on that train?
SPEAKER_00Nice. That was good. That was well done. And there's this great coalition there that got that over the finish line and is working on more. So there's even more in the future. And what I really want to see is folks kind of learning from that group that got that bill over the finish line. And how do we take this out into, we can keep going.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, yeah. I did a pod on the Illinois climate half. They're passing all kinds of stuff in Illinois. I did a pod on the climate half, but not on the transit half. But the coalition building in Illinois, I feel like it's so germane to everything we've been talking about, should be studied. I feel like I have to say, because I have not said yet in this episode, and I am going to get scolded by multiple people if I don't say it on the EV question, It's just worth throwing out there that all the research has come back that
electric bicycles are responsible for more oil demand destruction worldwide than
SPEAKER_02EVs.
SPEAKER_00Is that true?
SPEAKER_02Yes, I will be shot if I don't at least say in this episode that electric bikes, not just EVs, not just cars, electric bikes are magic in this area. They make your walk shed, your non-car shed... so much larger, so much easier. They're so good for families. They're so good for groceries, their car replacements, et cetera, et cetera. I just have to sort of like sing the praises of e-bikes here so I don't get yelled at.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I got to give a shout out to my former colleague, Bryn Grunwald. RMI has done a lot of great work in this space, developed this really fantastic e-bike environment and economics impact assessment tool, has been just kind of plugging away at this in the US context for a long time.
SPEAKER_00That's amazing.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, like even if you're a climate funder jazzed about technology, How about peeling off a little bit of your money and funding some e-bike subsidies?
SPEAKER_02That would be so cheap. It would be so cheap for a city to just do e-bike subsidies. They're doing them in Colorado, I think a couple other places. And everywhere I've seen one pop up, it is immediately oversubscribed. Immediately. So there's a lot of untapped demand for e-bikes out there, climate people. Hello. Let's just wrap up by asking, what can people... do here like yeah i'm yelling online i think that has limited
efficacy uh lots of other people are yelling online i'm not certain that even more people yelling online would substantially help things perhaps there are other things people could do like ben what would like specifically on the question of how to move climate
SPEAKER_02world on this what would you recommend that people do because I have no idea what affects funders. Like I really, like what lever of influence does anyone have over these people? They just seem kind of floating in the clouds, like on Mount Olympus and, you know, the money floats down. It is what it is. We get what we get. Like, it's just crazy. Like there doesn't seem to be any feedback mechanism. So is there any way to reach these people and affect how they think?
SPEAKER_01I mean, I think that, And this is not general public, but my peers in the climate advocacy and NGO space just need to continue kind of screaming from the rooftops about this. There's been a lot of momentum and reason to be optimistic on this front. Like this is fantastic group called the Clean Rides Network. That's a coalition of NGOs and funders that are really pushing the mode shift side of things. And we just need to keep being louder because ultimately the philanthropy NGOs in the community groups are the ones that are running the analysis and also
SPEAKER_01So seeing at the ground level successes, and I think continuing to get behind this and then informing alliances with some of the climate-aligned pro-housing groups, like your Matt Lewis from California Yimby and folks like that. But I'm just very much in the continuing to screen from the rooftops position at this point.
SPEAKER_02Well, Caroline, you're down in state politics. Obviously, people can call their state legislators and say, do something about housing. I mean, you make the point frequently that affordability, everybody's, as you noted, everybody's obsessed with affordability now. And particularly the climate energy world has become fixated on electricity affordability. And you make the point frequently that housing on an objective,
measurable basis...
SPEAKER_02Housing is a bigger cost center than electricity. Transportation is a bigger cost center than electricity. Electricity is getting more expensive. It is a problem. But if you care about affordability as such, go after the unaffordable bits, the most unaffordable bits first, right? I mean, especially if you can get some climate benefit along the way. So what... What do you want people to do and what do you want state legislators to do? Because I imagine a lot of them are like,
SPEAKER_02well, I kind of get this, but I'm, you know, like, what are the support mechanisms? What are the groups? What are the how do you how can you how can they tap into this?
SPEAKER_00Basically, we look at, you know. Four of the biggest household bills that Americans face on a month-to-month basis are things that climate has a real tangible solution for reducing costs. We're about to launch our 2026-2027 policy platform, so I'm getting a little bit ahead of this. This is a preview. It's four of the biggest household bills. And when we show up to state capitals, when we work with any type of lawmaker, and you say, I care about affordability, you got to talk about the largest source of costs for people right now.
SPEAKER_00And that's housing and transportation. Electricity is absolutely a part of that at about, you know, it tends to be about three or $400 a month for folks, but housing and transportation are about $3,000 a month for folks. And so to be able to show up and say, I have a solution on this. And by the way, it's going to make housing prices go down. It's we're going to help out with transportation prices. And by the way, we got an electricity plan as well. Lawmakers are excited about that. Like I said, it's already passing in a lot of states and we have an option
in front of us.
SPEAKER_00We can kind of push in the climate friendly direction, but there's also a risk of some of this going in a spot where we're building homes and wildfire interfaces, homes with a lot of climate risk. So there's two options in front of us and let's do it.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, I think this is such a good point. Like the climate train is not chugging along very well these days, not very healthy. The housing thing is happening. The affordability thing is happening. They could either happen in climate-friendly ways or climate-unfriendly ways. So rather than staying off in its own little corner, waiting for its perfect climate policy, I feel like the climate community and climate funders need to get involved in these other things to make sure they turn out well.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I totally agree.
SPEAKER_02All right, Ben, just to wrap up, tell me about this project you're working on now and sort of your work now at WRI. Are you working on building this empirical case, trying to bring some numbers to the game? Yeah, we are in the next couple months, we will be releasing two publications.
SPEAKER_01The first will be in the next couple of weeks, I believe, maybe by the time this airs, we'll have a piece that comes out with Pew Charitable Trust that looks at the economics of housing production, the economic benefits and the fiscal benefits of housing. Housing production in particular, infill housing production, kind of the suburban sprawl kind of Ponzi scheme thing that Strong Towns talks about time to time. We put some numbers behind that that'll come out with Pew. And then on the heels of that, we will be publishing. Wow.
Do you find that the potential is bigger in red states because they've kind of like
SPEAKER_02been more car friendly in the past?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, yeah, largely. It is because of that. And it's a lot of people moving there, places like Texas, North Carolina. in florida and i guess it's unfair to really call north carolina fully red state but um very sprawling development patterns at times and uh and dirty cars basically a lot of suvs there so anything we can do to get more people more housing available in the city centers and close to transit it's going to be a benefit emissions wise there so those things will come out in the next uh couple months so very excited
SPEAKER_01about that
SPEAKER_02Awesome. And I'll just say, um, you know, as a final word out there to anyone listening, if you are a climate funder or an officer at a climate fund, or what are those family people, the, whatever the family officers that decide how the family funds spend their money, whatever. If you're someone with your hand on a bunch of money in climate, I would love to talk to you. I'd love to hear what you're thinking. Like, what are, what are your other funders thinking? How do you cognize all this? Like get in touch. Ben. Carolyn, thank you so much.
SPEAKER_02This was delightful.
SPEAKER_00Thanks so much for having us.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, this was fun.
SPEAKER_02Thank you for listening to Volts. It takes a village to make this podcast work. Shout out especially to my super producer, Kyle McDonald, who makes me and my guests sound smart every week. And it is all supported entirely by listeners like you. So if you value conversations like this, please consider joining our community of paid subscribers at volts.wtf, or leaving a nice review, or telling a friend about Volts, or all three.
SPEAKER_02Thanks so much, and I'll see you next time.
This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit www.volts.wtf/subscribe When people push for better data centers, they picture hyperscalers - Amazon,...
This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit www.volts.wtf/subscribe America’s first big wave of solar power installations, built between 15 and...
This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit www.volts.wtf/subscribe The Senate’s bipartisan permitting bill got a manager’s amendment last week -...
This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit www.volts.wtf/subscribe Last week’s election was a blue wave all the way down the ballot: Democrats...
This is a free preview of a paid episode. To hear more, visit www.volts.wtf Volts published eight conversations in October, which is a lot for anyone to listen to. We’ve rounded up the highlights into less than an hour....