In this episode, I chat with Catalyst host Shayle Kann about the most pressing unresolved questions in the clean energy world today. We explore whether data center gigantism will break the grid, if the smart home revolution is destined for platform enshittification, whether billionaires should start testing solar geoengineering, and more. This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit www.volts.wtf/subscribe
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
greetings salutations konichiwa aloha this is volts for february 25th 2026 the volts catalyst pod crossover the biggest questions in clean energy i'm your host
SPEAKER_01david roberts Back in November of 2023, I did a crossover episode with the podcast Catalyst, hosted by cleantech investor and analyst Shail Khan. Catalyst covers many of the same issues as Volts, with an even tighter focus on technology, business models, and markets. It has been a while, so I thought it would be fun to do another one. In our previous crossover,
Shale and I shared our respective lists of the most overhyped and underhyped
SPEAKER_01technologies and trends in clean energy. This time around, I thought it would be fun for each of us to bring a short list of the biggest open questions in the world of clean energy, specifically questions we think might plausibly be answered in the next five to ten years. That proviso made this undertaking more difficult than you might think. We discuss self-driving cars, the possible and shittification of home electrification technology,
SPEAKER_01data centers, of course, and much, much more. This was a hoot. I hope you enjoy it.
SPEAKER_00David, nice to be back with you.
SPEAKER_01Awesome. Glad to be doing this again.
SPEAKER_00All right. So we gave ourselves a prompt here, which is that each of us have come prepared with three questions we are eager to see answered in the next five to 10 years. I assume we both came with backups as well in case we overlap. I bet you we're not going to overlap.
SPEAKER_01I tried not to overlap with you. So I think we will It'll be funny if we both tried so hard that we're going to leave some very obvious questions unanswered.
SPEAKER_00We probably will. I didn't try to go super esoteric.
SPEAKER_01I tried to get medium esoteric. So we'll see. We'll see. You want me to go first?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, you go first.
SPEAKER_01Okay. So just to review for listeners, the prompt here is questions, important questions. questions facing the clean energy world that you might reasonably think will get some kind of answer in the next five to 10 years. And that turned out to be really interesting, really difficult because I kept thinking of questions that I was like, well, will we really know in 10 years? There are lots of big questions where I don't think we'll
really know until like 20
SPEAKER_01or 30 years out. So that was sort of interesting as a way of bracketing thinking about this so anyway long story short my first one is so self-driving cars are here which is puzzling in itself since there was all this chatter and talk for years in anticipation of of their arrival. And then they arrived and nobody talks about it. They're operating in several cities now and nobody talks about it.
SPEAKER_01So it's a little weird. But there are lots of really, I think, interesting questions about the macro effects of self-driving vehicles that I think we will get answers to pretty soon because... Now that San Francisco has been doing it a while and it seems to be working, basically, and I think Seattle's starting a pilot, there's pilots starting in a bunch of cities, we're very close, I think, to basically widespread adoption.
SPEAKER_01And then we'll start to get answers to some of these questions like... The fear that I have, that I think a lot of people, sort of climate people have, greenies have, is that making it easier to take a car around is going to result in a lot more people taking a lot more cars around, basically, even though
SPEAKER_01even though people might not necessarily own their own vehicle, even if they're shared vehicles, just the level of use of cars is going to rise sharply when it becomes so easy and so convenient, which will translate mathematically into greater congestion. So you could see deaths going down, as I think we're already... seeing in san francisco you could see noise going down if
they're all electric you could see pollution going down if they're all electric but but on the core issue of urbanism they are going to the fear is that they are going to work against density basically they're going to make it easier to live far out they're going to make it
SPEAKER_01easier to commute like a commute you're not going to dread an hour long commute if you can just chill and like read and tap on your phone or watch a TV show or something. So that's just going to make it a lot easier to decide to live an hour outside of town. So anyway, I think within five to 10 years, we will at least see cities where these things become ubiquitous.
SPEAKER_01And then I think at the very least we'll have directionally, answers to some of these things i'm very curious shale from your perspective what your level like of anticipation versus dread versus um you know now that it's here it's just not that big of a deal either way i'm curious what your disposition is on self-driving cars
SPEAKER_00Uh, good question. And so many things to say about it. Okay. Let me offer you a few bits of exposition first. Um, so I live in the Bay area, as I think, you know, uh, I don't live in San Francisco, but I live outside the city and you've taken,
SPEAKER_01you've taken,
SPEAKER_00of course I waymo regularly. Yeah, of course. And you're right that like, it's just not a thing in San Francisco anymore. Not a thing in the sense that like one out of every three cars in the city is a Waymo and that's just how it is. And it's become pretty normalized to anybody who's not a tourist. And I agree with you, it's coming everywhere. And I think five to 10 years is also, it's kind of the right timeframe for this. My other tidbit for you, I have a four-year-old son and I've been making bets about his future with anybody who wants to take them with me since he was born.
SPEAKER_00And one of the bets is that he will never drive a car. He'll never get a driver's license. I mean, he's growing up, you know, in kind of suburban Bay Area, California. So take that into account because this is a specific bet to my son. But, you know, I think 12 years from now when it would be time for him to get his driver's license.
SPEAKER_01Oh, yeah.
SPEAKER_00he's not going to need to, right? And already lots of kids are just Ubering around.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_00That said, with your question, it's interesting the framing of it to me because I had anticipated you were going to raise a climate concern, which you're not, right?
SPEAKER_01Well, it's a second order. I think urbanism and density are climate related. I think if you lose density, even if the cars aren't polluting, you're still going to get greater pollution and greater impact? I think there are second-order climate effects.
SPEAKER_00Probably, but I would bet – I don't have data on this, but I would bet that those effects – one of the main reasons why density is lower emissions per capita is transportation. That's a big part of it.
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_00And so if it is true, the benefit of self-driving vehicles from a climate perspective is that it is, it makes a lot more sense for them to be electric, right? Like the, the, the, uh, utilization pattern.
SPEAKER_01They're all Weebo's. They're all electric. All the, all the extant, all the extant self-driving cars on the road are electric today.
SPEAKER_00They're pure EVs. And it just makes more sense, right? You, you drive high utilization, you pay back the added capex of the EV much faster. It's better for a bunch of reasons. So I think if you assume that our self-driving future actually accelerates vehicle electrification, then to a first order from a climate perspective, it's not inherently a bad thing. Now, that would be weighed against your question, which is, I think, a question of like, will there be more vehicle miles traveled total?
SPEAKER_02Yes.
SPEAKER_00And so those kind of weigh against each other to some extent. But it's not obvious to me that that a transition to autonomous vehicles is bad from a climate perspective. It might even be- No, no.
SPEAKER_01I would not. I mean, I would not have the arrogance to put my flag on either side of that. I don't think, like, I think we just genuinely don't know. I think that's right, that it's going to eliminate a huge chunk of emissions. The question is all these second-order effects and how you even really trace them. But, like, I do think that- continuing to sprawl outwards is bad for a number of reasons extraneous to climate.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I guess I don't really have an opinion on that. I'm not an urbanist, I guess I would say in that way. And so I don't have strong opinions on whether adding more sprawl is bad. I could see it happening. I actually have a friend who's a long-term real estate investor who is amassing a portfolio of land in the exurbs of certain cities under the bet that You know, under like a multi-decade bed of exactly what you're describing. So I totally could see that happening.
SPEAKER_00I guess I just don't inherently see it as a bad thing.
SPEAKER_01Well, the question of whether excerpts are bad or not. It's a large question that we don't have time to, to address here. So, you know, so, so, I mean, this, I, and I think this, I think this would just reinforce the worries of the urbanists, which is that they see the tech guys pushing this. And I don't, I don't see any sign from the tech guys that the tech guys care about this. They drive, they drive themselves everywhere. They drive themselves everywhere. They don't live in walkable places.
SPEAKER_01I don't like, And Silicon Valley, the physical form of Silicon Valley is so gross. It's so gross and deadening. But I guess that's all they know. Anyway, so, but at the very least, like, we'll be able to see if that sprawl happens. And then I guess we'll be able to, you know, answer the question of whether we like the effects or not. I think what we can measure to answer your question of what we know in five to 10 years is in the cities where there is high proliferation of
autonomous vehicles,
SPEAKER_00so San Francisco and five to 10 years from now, probably a bunch of other cities, will total VMT have gone up over that period? Yes, because they are pushing in the other direction in California with policy.
SPEAKER_01They are trying to restrain sprawl with a lot of other policies. So how will that balance out? Or it might even be more interesting to see what would happen to a city like Cleveland or whatever, if they get a bunch of AVs, because they do not have a strong overlay of other laws restraining them. So it'd be more of, I guess, like a clean like a clean experiment.
SPEAKER_00And we'll probably see something like that. Phoenix has been the test bed for autonomous vehicles.
SPEAKER_01Oh, are they a thing there now?
SPEAKER_00Oh, yeah. That's where a lot of the early testing was. In some ways, because it's obvious. Phoenix is a simple grid. It's not hilly. The weather's good. Yeah, so... It's kind of the opposite of San Francisco. San Francisco was like trial by fire for Waymo, but Phoenix is the kind of easy test.
SPEAKER_01Phoenix is already sprawling like crazy.
SPEAKER_00Well, that's my point.
SPEAKER_01So it's a little tricky to separate the signal from the noise. Yeah.
SPEAKER_00Okay. Can I give you my first question?
SPEAKER_01Let's get your first one.
SPEAKER_00Okay. So I think the obvious question that, of course, I'm going to ask, I'll try to ask a different version of. The obvious question that I'm going to ask is, how hot will data center fever get and will it break in the next five to 10 years? Five to 10 years is probably the right timeframe to ask that question. I was wondering about that. You could argue it could be sooner, but who knows, right? But within the next 10 years, we'll see some directional thing here.
But instead of asking the question of how hot will data center fever get and will it break,
SPEAKER_00I'll ask a different question, which I think is like a second order effect of that, which is how much large load goes off grid in the next five to 10 years? Because to walk through the chain of logic, The kind of going assumption right now of what's happening is that there is so much demand for a new data center capacity that we are going to be bursting at the seams on the grid in any market that has demand for data centers. We're basically going to tap out everything we could possibly do on the grid.
SPEAKER_00And so much so that maybe we need to go to space, right? Yeah. But I think before we go to space in significant volume, there would be a good chance we would go off grid. We've never seen a lot of large industrial loads go off grid apart from mining and things like that. We're starting to see glimmers of it right now in data center world.
SPEAKER_01Are we not seeing law? Someone just proposed or passed a law that basically said you have to
SPEAKER_00Josh Hawley in the Senate and somebody else, I think, introduced a bill that would essentially mandate data centers to go off grid. My presumption is that doesn't pass.
SPEAKER_01Well, like I've said several times, like there's a world of difference between bring some generation. and bring enough generation to cover yourself if you go off grid entirely. That's a very, you know what I mean?
SPEAKER_00I know, and I'm asking about that.
SPEAKER_01Hundreds of megawatts, yeah.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, yeah, yeah. I mean, what's happening now, to be clear, there's an enormous amount of bring your own generation.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_00No question about that one. That's an answered question. The question that has not been answered is, and actually to add to that, there's also an enormous number of projects that are saying, OK, we'll do bridge power. So we are going to be off grid until we get the grid connection. And that's going to be a year, three years, five years, whatever it might be. I'm saying forget the grid. How many large loads will just be fully off grid with no intent to get a grid connection? Will that happen in significant volume? That is an interesting question.
SPEAKER_01It is interesting. I'll just say my gut instinct strongly says no. I just think the arguments for a grid, a grid is handy. You know what I mean? Grids are extremely useful, and a lot of policy discussion right now is being forced into weird shapes, because it's trying to work around the fact that we can't do the obvious thing,
SPEAKER_01which is just build more grid, right? Like that would solve all the problems. That's what everybody wants. That's what everybody needs beyond data centers even, like for the future, period. We just need to do that. And we're like torn between trying to make that happen and then trying to sort of weasel our way around it. You know what I mean?
SPEAKER_00And so I guess how that question- Well, you're making the case, right? Like the fact that we're not solving that. I mean, you could make a case that we will solve it, but if we don't solve it, then what happens?
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Well, I mean, that's an interesting, even broader question. I could imagine a story where our sort of social and political dysfunction, our inability to build quickly- forces these weird around the edges solutions that end up like growing and developing in ways that we can't anticipate now and like bringing new things into the world you know what I mean like it will spawn invention and innovation I think
even though like if you had your druthers you would not choose this situation but I
SPEAKER_01do think it will it will it will force some very creative thinking
SPEAKER_00Yeah. I mean, I think to me, it really comes down to this question of, is it really true that for an extended period of time into the future, we're going to have dramatically more demand for data center capacity than we have ability to serve it on the grid with money attached to that demand that is willing to take some risks that maybe hyperscalers wouldn't have taken in the past, for example. And if those things are true, then it is kind of inevitable to me that some amount of it,
SPEAKER_00and I don't know how much, is going to take the one risk that is introduced by not being on the grid, which is largely reliability. You don't have as many nines of reliability unless you really overbuild a bunch of on-site stuff. But what you get in exchange is... You get unleashed from a sighting perspective. I mean, imagine how easy it is to sight something if you remove the constraint to the
SPEAKER_01transmission. But you are, I take it, imagining very large gas plants. I'm not imagining.
SPEAKER_00A lot of them. I'm watching them get built right now.
SPEAKER_01A lot of them. I would get out. Yeah, yeah, yeah. I have not accommodated myself to that yet. I don't want that to happen.
SPEAKER_00Oh, but that's happening, right?
SPEAKER_01I mean, maybe not the off-grid version.
SPEAKER_00And by the way, it doesn't inherently have to be gas, right? There's a good study that Paces and Scale Microgrids put out a while ago that was, can you actually run at high utilization a data center fully off-grid? With mostly solar and storage. Yeah, yeah. You generally do need a little bit of dispatchable generation. So you mix your things together and you end up with some gas. But like, you know.
SPEAKER_01It's just a microgrid, right? It's the same question. It's the same question that faces any microgrid. Like you. Yeah. Same question that faces any grid, really. Like you can do X amount with variable and you need some marginal amount of dispatchable to firm up. Like it's going to be the same in miniature. Or more batteries. That's what I want to see. Like that's what I think could straightforwardly. more straightforwardly substitute for natural gas is more in bigger batteries. But they're like, as you know, because like half of your shows and my shows are about this now,
SPEAKER_01but like this question, the way you ask it is also tied up intimately with a bunch of other super fascinating questions like, are data centers going to continue evolving in the direction of gigantism or is there a serious prospect for distributed, more modular, more grid edge data centers. That's a super interesting question. Then there's sort of just the bigger question of like, will there be radical efficiencies in chip design that mean we
don't need the sheer
SPEAKER_01quantity we think now, or will the bubble pop or something? You know what I mean? Like the question of how many data centers there will be is, is Lots of people want to know the answer to that question. Not just the power people and the grid people. But so how do you think about... And this is something I... And then we can move on to the next one. This is something I try to think about how to talk about. What I want to say... Here's another note I would put. Before they take the extraordinary step of trying to build their own...
SPEAKER_01I mean, if you've got a gigawatt... gigawatt data center and you're trying to go off grid you're basically building like a pretty large grid like you're building like a city's worth of like electrical infrastructure it's a pretty extreme step i would like to see them because they can't get nuclear plants quickly or coal plants quickly or natural gas plants quickly i would like to see them get serious about exploiting distributed capacity i think that's faster than And cheaper than on-site generation if we can get the financial
and institutional
SPEAKER_01arrangements lined up the right way.
SPEAKER_00I think this is all – the whole scenario here is all a yes and. The presumption is there will be enough demand. We're going to tap out every available possibility. We're going to do gets and we're going to get more on existing lines. We're going to do some distributed capacity aggregation, which is – all these things are starting to happen. I think they're going to continue to happen. And yet – in the absence of building out like a entirely new transmission system on top of our existing transmission system,
SPEAKER_00we're going to hit a ceiling basically, or at least we're going to hit a ceiling from a time to power perspective.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. And I guess the fact that all these forecasts are saying we're going to build more data centers than we could conceivably power, like, is just good evidence that it's not going to happen. I'm just very skeptical. I guess I would just ask you the central question. What do you think? Do you think demand is going to get even close to the sort of higher end projections or are you kind of a deflationist on this?
SPEAKER_00I don't think I am smart enough to know the answer to that question. I don't think anybody really knows the answer to that question. I do think that there is pretty universal agreement amongst people who are building these models that we're going to need, to your point on sort of the like, will it shift to the edge? Yes, inference might, and that's like an open question. There is going to be, for some period of time in the future, demand for more and more and more powerful models.
SPEAKER_00Those require the centralized, big-ass data centers. We are already starting to have a harder time to find sites on the grid to power those in the time period that people want. And so I think there's going to be some period of time where we are bursting at the seams from an electricity perspective. I don't know how long it lasts. And I don't know whether it gets to the point where Elon wants to put 100 gigawatts a year of orbital data centers in space.
SPEAKER_01Do you think there are going to be space-based data centers? You did a pod on it, didn't you?
SPEAKER_00We've talked about it a bunch. I'm doing more on it. I've spent a lot of time now understanding the economics. It's sort of, to me... Um, the answer to that question is the answer to the question you asked me, because, uh, I think that orbital data, I mean, Elon says he thinks that they will be the cheapest way to get new compute in like three to five years. I do not think that is possible. Not in that time period.
SPEAKER_01He says a lot of things.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. But, um, but if you do think that there is going to be this insatiable appetite and we're going to need to scale to hundreds of gigawatts a year, and we are not going to have the ability to do that on the grid. then I think the interesting question is, um, your options are kind of off grid or off world.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_00And, and then it's a different comparison and, you know, it's interesting to think about, we should get off of the data center thing.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. The final thing I would say about it, and this is the note I wanted to say earlier, this is just, when I talk to people who are, as you know, there's a very loud constituency to the left that hates data centers, hates AI, hates the whole discussion. All I would say as a final note is even if you think that data, short-term data center demand is, is radically overstated and that these data centers are not gonna, you're not gonna end up with as many as, as currently forecast. It is nonetheless the case that we're electrifying
transportation and we're
SPEAKER_01electrifying heat and cooling and we're electrifying industry and we're just gonna need lots lots lots more electricity and a much stronger better grid in the future regardless of what happens with data centers so i just think like that should be i don't want those two questions to start to be conflated in people's minds basically actually i okay put a pin in that when we get
SPEAKER_00back to my next question
SPEAKER_01Oh, interesting. Okay. So I'm on my second. Is that where we are? Yeah. Okay. This is another one that I sort of brought because I don't think tech people are thinking about it enough or taking it seriously.
SPEAKER_00I love that I represent tech people.
SPEAKER_01I'm sorry.
SPEAKER_00I'll take it. I'm in.
SPEAKER_01I'm sorry I've drafted you into this unenviable spokesperson job. So – Here's my thought. Basically, you and I know that the way the long-term evolution is that basically everything that is plugged in is going to become a resource eventually. The notion of DERs as a distinct category, I think, is just going to fade away because eventually everything that plugs in is going to
SPEAKER_01be managed by software and that is in communication with larger grids, basically. That's just gonna become kind of the default. On some time horizon, we can talk about how fast we think that's gonna happen, but it's gonna happen. Basically, so to me, what that means is that a lot of things that we have held as distinct from software are going to become software.
SPEAKER_01like driving and cars and living and homes. And on the one hand, I think that's immense. I think there's immense potential there as I've done a kajillion podcasts on. I think it's going to be extraordinary. It's going to have a much more stronger grid. We're going to make each electron go further. We're going to utilize our grid better. We're going to like, everything's going to, we're going to have a more small D democratic grid. For the most part, I love this trend,
SPEAKER_01and I'm very hopeful for it, the internetification of the grid. But, capital B, but, when I think about software as it exists today, it's awful. The situation... is awful. I think, and I'm, you know, I'm not far from the only person saying this, like it feels these days like tech, the tech sector, which is basically we think of as the software sector in public
is kind of
SPEAKER_01exploitative, out of touch, you know, like, kind of getting increasingly deranged, talking about their bunkers on their islands, talking about the Antichrist, like... all fucked up on ketamine, just off in la-la land. Basically, software feels exploitative these days. Almost everywhere you encounter it in shitification. You know, I did a whole pod on it in shitification.
Basically, platforms enter what seems like this inexorable cycle where they in shitify.
SPEAKER_01And so this trend of your house and your car becoming software, I don't see enough people raising red flags saying, do we want... intrusive ad-based ad-supported subscription nagging different tiers you know real-time variable pricing all these sort of exploitative things that we're running into do we want that in our cars and in our homes are we going
to end up within
SPEAKER_01shitified homes and is the promise basically of coordinated, distributed energy going to manifest in reality like just another chapter of sort of chintzy, exploitative, and shitified software that ends up exploiting the people who get stuck with it. I worry about that. And I don't hear hardly anybody else worrying about that. Do you worry about that?
SPEAKER_00Do you have a Nest thermostat?
SPEAKER_01I do not. My house is so analog and primitive, my current house.
SPEAKER_00I guess I don't see, so if I think of like, what are the things in the home that tie to electricity that have been software-ified? Thermostats are the obvious one to me via Nest and Ecobee and other companies like that. You know, people who have EVs have an EV charger, and then they have a software platform that goes on top of that. So they're EV owners. I drive an EV9. I'm sure you're an EV driver.
SPEAKER_01Oh, a Kia? The big one? Is it nice?
SPEAKER_00The big one.
SPEAKER_01Is it super nice? It's great.
SPEAKER_00It's the best. Yeah. So there's the vehicle, there's the thermostat. I mean, if you want to go newer age, I am an owner of a Quilt, which is a version of a heat pump. We're EIP as an investor, so I was actually customer number seven of Quilt.
SPEAKER_01Do you have one of the newer? Because didn't they just sort of like refresh the look of their wall units, I feel like?
SPEAKER_00They've always been super cool looking. But it is what you're saying, right? It's like softwareification. It's got an app. It's much more controllable. I mean, my personal experience with all those things is that they're better. And I don't know that anybody – I've heard anybody saying like, oh, Nest and shitified the thermostat. Or the Tesla app and shitifies my EV charging or my charging experience. If you're familiar with Corey's work, you know that always stage one on the platforms –
is that they're good to users and that they offer genuine value to users. That is step one of this process is you attract the users with genuine value and
SPEAKER_01then over time work to make leaving the platform difficult. And then when people are locked in, that's when you start exploiting them. And I will happily agree that all of this is so nascent and new and barely there that we're just on the front end of this. So a lot of this is speculative, but it sure seems like that is the direction everything travels.
SPEAKER_01And one way I think about this, and this is probably something you've heard me talk about before, one thing that I'm just waiting for is if the self-driving cars become ubiquitous, what is to stop them from offering a free tier that is ad-supported which everybody then chooses because nobody wants to pay up front. And then that's one more little area of our lives where we are constantly beset with customized advertising.
SPEAKER_01Like that's one way. Well, this is where, yeah, maybe I'm going to, okay, I'm going to own my tech bro-iness.
SPEAKER_00If I decide to choose to... take, to get free rides around in my future Waymo or whatever it is in exchange for being served ads, that's a trade I make deliberately and happily, right? And I get free rides and that's worth it to me. I don't, I don't see that as being inherently a bad thing. I mean, I think they, the, there are challenges obviously to the ad ecosystem, but you, you, You recognize in shitification as a thing that happens on other
platforms,
SPEAKER_01or are you skeptical more broadly about Corey's work?
SPEAKER_00I don't know Corey's work, so let me preface with that. But I would say I think I see what you're talking about, and I think I can come up with examples of it. I don't know that I see it as the inexorable direction of travel when things become software-y. particularly as it pertains to me it's less software than platforming it's the platforms so this is like this is why i want if you're on like
if your water heater is signed up to some vpp and your thermostat signed up to another one they're both on different platforms i want interoperability and i want the ability to move from one platform to the other without penalty basically i don't want lock-in like
SPEAKER_01that's what leads to platform and shitification as lock-in. And I think we could avoid a lot of that upfront if we just went in with some clear privacy laws and some clear rules and regulations about interoperability and transparency.
SPEAKER_00I guess I don't disagree with that. I think that's a pretty innocuous statement to make. To me, I guess at the high level, the things that I actually think about that are in our homes, I'll just focus on the home for now, that are hopefully going to be transformed such that, as you said, eventually all of them are software enabled, interact with the grid, enable them to be responsive to the needs of the grid, but also have more capabilities for the customer. Like when I think about them one by one and what I think the future of those things are going to be, I generally think it will be better.
And certainly the ones that I can think of today that have already started to be
SPEAKER_00that way feel better to me. I can see how it could go off the rails. Like I've watched Idiocracy, but as where we stand today, I don't see evidence of that.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I guess it's early enough now that I don't have a lot of concrete examples to hang this on. So mostly it is just a generalized fear. But I look at the exploitation and the crappiness around us in every other area, and I just don't want that coming into my home and hearth.
SPEAKER_00Fair enough. Okay. Can I come back to the last statement you made in the last question to ask my next question?
SPEAKER_01Yes. Segway me.
SPEAKER_00You said you didn't want to see... you wanted to be careful to separate out the, we need to improve the grid because we're going to be electrifying all these other loads from the, like, you know, some people just don't like data centers thing. And I sort of agree with that generally. But here's my question that I, here's my concerning question, I will say, that I think we may or may not have fully answered in the next five to 10 years, but we will know the direction of travel,
SPEAKER_00which is, Is electrification dead or will electrification be dead as a pathway for industrial emissions reduction? So just to walk through the logic here.
SPEAKER_01Will it be dead when, for what reason? Well, for what, when, I mean, will it, will it appear dead over the next five to 10 years? And for what reason is because you have two things happening in my mind right now
SPEAKER_00that are pushing against it. Yeah. By the way, for a long time, I've always said like to a first order, the simplest way to solve climate change is clean up electricity, electrify everything that you possibly can, and then go like fill in all the pieces of the stuff that you just can't possibly electrify. So that implies electrifying a big portion of heavy industry, for example. Yep. Okay. If you are trying to electrify something in heavy industry right now, you're trying to build, or even not something that hasn't been electrified, but is already electrified, take an aluminum smelter,
SPEAKER_00right? You just want to build new aluminum smelter, uses hundreds of megawatts of electricity. You can't find a site because every site is being taken up by a data center and your prices are higher and you're super sensitive to electricity prices.
SPEAKER_01Oh, I see where you're going with this. So the premise of industrial electrification is you get cheaper operating costs
SPEAKER_00because it is electrified. You're going to get probably higher capital costs. This is the trade with everything that you electrify. And then you save money over time because it's so much more efficient. And that is a function of the spark spread. It's the difference between the price of electricity and the price of natural gas.
SPEAKER_01And I also think less waste and less regulatory compliance and
SPEAKER_00Yeah, yeah, yeah, sure. Easier to permit. But in a world where you have a really, really hard time siting, because there are not that many places to put 100 megawatt, multi-hundred megawatt loads, and where there is inflationary price presser on electricity, which there certainly is today, that value proposition is eroded. And so I wonder what happens.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I mean, more broadly, both of us wanting to electrify everything... I think naturally leads to both of us being daunted at the fact that electricity prices are high and rising. Those are very obviously at odds on every level, industry particularly, but also residential, also transportation, also everything else, which gets us, of course, to the question of the day, the political question of the day,
SPEAKER_01of the decade, really, which is how you bring down electricity prices. while continuing to rapidly and aggressively electrify. Yeah. And another question I had about industry that I almost brought, I'll just throw in here. One is, does it in fact start electrifying in this circumstance where electricity is expensive and data centers are bullying them out of the way and grabbing all the
SPEAKER_00electricity? Yeah, yeah. And then another question is... that I have that I didn't bring today because it's definitely like a 20 year plus
SPEAKER_01question is when we say electrify everything, do we mean industry too? And by that, I mean, how much faith do we have in electrochemistry to replace? Like right now you can make steel with zero emissions electrochemically, right? wildly expensive same thing with you know the concrete or concrete you can do same thing like electrochemically you can do it with zero emissions it's just much more expensive so is electrochemistry is electrochemistry going to
come along enough fast enough that we could really electrify everything everything the reason i didn't bring that question along is that it's definitely like a 20 plus year
SPEAKER_01I think that's a 20-plus year question. But I think hope, think slash hope, let's call it a 50-50 split, that in the long, long term, I really think we're going to electrify everything. I'm an absolutist. I think once you've built a single unified system that is providing power to 98% of stuff, whatever that 2% is, The benefits of just being able to hook into that system are so
immense that it's
SPEAKER_01just going to overcome whatever barriers they are.
SPEAKER_00I mean, I think I agree with you in the long term. I mean, right now we're at 25% in the US, right? Yeah. 25% of final energy consumption is electricity. 75% is not worth remembering that.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, it's a long way to go.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, it's a long way to go. And for a long time, I think people who were seeking to electrify, particularly industry, sort of rested on this belief that the marginal price of electricity was plummeting towards zero,
SPEAKER_01right? Electrochemistry in particular very much depends on copious cheap products. Yeah.
SPEAKER_00And that is not the world we're living in right now. And it's probably not the world we're going to live in for the next few years. Now, it may turn back, right? This could be cyclical, and five years from now, it'll turn back. But the current state of affairs is electricity prices are going up, not down.
SPEAKER_01I mean, one thing that might be answered in the next 10 years is everybody's freaked out about electricity prices now, right? The entire Democratic Party is seized with this. So will we... Will we actually be able to pass policies that reduce the price of electricity in an enduring way? Like, you know, reform utilities and like infrastructural.
SPEAKER_00Permitting reform.
SPEAKER_01Permitting reform, stuff like that. Will we be able to actually, will we be able to do that? That's an open question.
SPEAKER_00Yes, I don't know. And maybe, right? And so I think five to 10 years is an interesting time frame under which to think about this question. But I could tell you, I think over the next three years, electricity prices are probably going up, not down. Yes. And that's going to just make that value proposition harder.
SPEAKER_01And that's bad. So I think everybody in our world really needs to uprate the question of making electricity cheaper. It really is kind of a pivot on which everything else turns And that alone could screw us, could screw everything else if we can't deal with it.
SPEAKER_00I agree with you. But to your point, I think actually a glimmer of hope here is that there is alignment. Everybody, everybody. The word affordability is going to be the key word in many, many, many circles for the next couple of years. It has become, as you said, a political hot button thing. It's the word of the day amongst utilities, amongst data center companies, and amongst everybody else. Like affordability is the thing. So there will be, and we, and we are in the lucky position that the kinds of energy we favor are the cheap
SPEAKER_01ones. So like, you know, like you can, you can take climate out of the, take climate out of the picture. There's still going to be a lot of moneyed interests pushing for lots more clean energy and batteries for reasons having nothing to do with the environment. Okay. Uh, so I'm on my third one. Yes. I think so. Okay. My third and final one. Um, This is something I've been thinking about. So here's how I'd phrase it. Is J.B. Straubel going to turn out to be as or more significant to the
long-term fortunes
SPEAKER_01of clean energy than Elon Musk? By which I mean, you know J.B. Straubel's set up this big recycling company, this big battery recycling company, set it up, Redwood, set it up arguably before there were...
SPEAKER_01So they had, they were like, you know, they were like scrabbling to like collect, you know, old vacuum cleaner batteries and double A's and stuff just to keep going along enough for the batteries to show up. But now I think we're just on the cusp of the first kind of wave of, of used up batteries coming in. And the reason I raise all this is that, is that, um, There's this whole question about critical minerals,
SPEAKER_01about materials, and about who dominates supply chains. As you know, everybody in the world is freaked out because China dominates all the supply chains. They mine all the critical minerals, do all the processing, et cetera. And so we're very dependent on them. And so there's been a lot of talk about how the US can sort of stand up a supply chain of its own. And so there's been lots of talk about mining and stuff like that in the US, although not a ton of action. But I think we should start viewing electronics themselves.
SPEAKER_01Clean tech itself is... as like a source to mine. Do you know what I mean? Like, if we can capture those materials and reuse them effectively infinitely, then when you buy a solar panel from China, it is as though you are both buying a solar panel and mining a certain quantity of materials that will be available after the solar panel is dead. Do you know what I mean?
SPEAKER_01So like, Recycling is a source of critical minerals, basically. It is a strategic source of critical minerals. And I think if you take the growth numbers of EVs and solar panels and all the rest of it seriously, it's going to be a very large source of minerals, a large source of raw minerals and raw materials. which means all of which is just means that I think that recycling is going to go from a sort of like environmental nice to have,
SPEAKER_01which is what, which is kind of how I think people are thinking about it now to something like a national security, energy security imperative. In other words, like if you get your hands on some of these materials, it is absolutely in your interest to make sure that you keep recycling those materials through your economy forever, basically. So I think recycling in the next five to 10 years is going to A,
SPEAKER_01take off, and B, just become much, much more, I think, viewed as much, much more strategically important. Yeah. I wonder whether you think so. I wonder whether you agree.
SPEAKER_00I do agree, generally. I mean, and I think it's not just EV batteries either, right? So Redwood is recycling EV batteries and a bunch of other old batteries and getting out of it the lithium nickel cobalt, stuff like that. We invested in a company called Cyclic Materials that's doing recycling for rare earth elements. Rare earth elements are like the least recycled critical mineral, which is crazy. Out of coal piles? No, out of end of life. No, no, no, not tailings or coal piles or anything like that. I saw a different company doing that. motors and magnets and stuff like that.
SPEAKER_00There are companies that are now doing solar panel recycling. Yeah, I mean, I think that Where I agree with you is I'm like a recycling maximalist. We should recycle all this stuff. It has high value at end of life, and we should take advantage of that value, and that should mitigate the amount of new virgin mine stuff that we need in any category where we possibly can, particularly in those where there is a geopolitical reason that we want to have our own sovereign supply. The only thing I would... push back against, I guess,
is just that the challenge, let's just take battery recycling. If you believe that we're on a steep upward trajectory of demand for new batteries, then you're forever going to be in a position where the amount of supply that you
SPEAKER_00have to recycle is the amount of demand that there was 10 years ago. Well, not forever. You're never going to catch up.
SPEAKER_01Not literally forever, but until you hit the top of the S curve, right?
SPEAKER_00That's what I mean. Right. So unless you think we're already at the top of the S curve, which I don't think either of us do think, then it will matter some, but it is not a solution to our sovereign mineral supply problems. I would just say that my, I guess my prediction would be that in 10 years, maybe, or in 20, That just a unit of critical minerals drawn from recycling will
be cheaper than a unit mined.
SPEAKER_01I think. I think. Eventually. I think it will end up being our primary and cheapest source of those. I don't think we're ever going to... Maybe you disagree, but I don't think we're ever... really going to be in a position where we're fully, like an autarky, where we fully have a contained and complete supply chain. I think mostly this is just about having a little bit of a buffer. But I just think people need to start rethinking, thinking of recycling like they think of mining, basically, as a source of,
SPEAKER_01as a large and probably the cheapest source of those materials.
SPEAKER_00Yes, I agree with that. And I think to the point on it should be cheaper. I mean, I'll give you a specific example in the rare earth context, right? Which is that there are actually 16 rare earth elements that are grouped together. We really only use four of them actually. Like we only care about four of them out of the 16. If you're doing mining, virgin mining, you get this like basket of all of them and you have to do this like complicated separations process to get the stuff that you want. If you're doing recycling, you're only getting the stuff we were using in the first place already. So you've already cut out a bunch of expensive separation steps
in the value chain there. So there's a bunch of reasons why, like fundamentally, I think it should be cheaper.
SPEAKER_01And again, I think it'll be such an economic push on that, that again, there'll be tons of innovation and we'll get something closer to an actual closed loop. We'll be moving, because this is like, to me, this is like, like 50% of the, of, of future sustainability, you know, we, we focus so much on the energy part, but also the closed physical loop, the, the reducing physical waste and physical throughput, I think is like the other half of the,
SPEAKER_01the other half of the equation. And this is, you know, so like, creating something like a closed loop of minerals where you're... Because the one thing that offsets that dynamic that you very accurately lay out, right? Like the demand is going up faster. So sort of by definition, your recycling is behind your new demand. One force does slightly offset that, which is the lithium you get out of the old batteries will go farther than... in the new batteries than it went in the old batteries,
SPEAKER_01just because batteries are always constantly improving. So you will actually get more. I don't think you'll catch up to demand, but you'll get more, let's say, than, you know, it's not a fungible.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, right. I think the place you want to end up in all these other critical minerals is kind of where we are maybe a little better than where we are today in more mature supply chains where like aluminum, copper, we actually do recycle a lot of that stuff. That doesn't mean we don't still need a lot more. So it doesn't solve your problem, but it's meaningful. All right. Can I do the last one? Yes, last one. Question to answer in the next five to 10 years? Maybe not next five to 10 years, to be honest. Maybe this is a question that gets answered in 20 years.
SPEAKER_00But nonetheless, I'm curious. Will we see a meaningful, scaled geoengineering demo? I thought you were going to say, I thought for sure you were going to go geothermal. Geothermal. That better get answered in the next five to 10 years.
SPEAKER_01I know. That one, I think, will be... I think in 10 years, we'll know whether geothermal is- Is big. Going to pay off the promise, do you think? Yeah, yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_00We'll know, we'll know, yeah. I mean, at least like traditional, it's for sure traditional hydrothermal, probably EGS- Who knows about, you know, super hot rock. Anyway, I'm not asking about geothermal. I'm asking about geoengineering. Yeah. When we see somebody go do like a big solar radiation management.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. I have a solar radiation expert coming on the pod in a couple of weeks to talk about just this. I'm so torn on this question. Like, you know, there are like a bunch of cowboy... jerk offs in Silicon Valley doing this already. Like they're doing little, I mean, I don't know what counts as like a scale test.
SPEAKER_00I just want to defend my, apparently my people in Silicon Valley. I would not say that the group you are referring to is not of Silicon Valley.
SPEAKER_01They are not. And that's just like one balloon at a time or whatever. I'm not super clear what they're, what they're doing. So I guess, I don't know if that counts as a test at scale. Like, uh, I do wonder if, I'm so torn about this and I'm so curious what your thoughts are on the moral hazard side of things. Because depending on what side of the bed I wake up, I can take different sides of this argument. Like on the one side, and this I suspect is your side and a lot of people's side, which is just...
SPEAKER_01This is pretty cheap. Somebody's going to do it. Climate change is going to get so bad. Somebody's going to do it. So we might as well do it in a conscious, planned, controlled way. The other side is just... You know, in a sense, the whole field is protected by being kind of obscure and not a lot of people know about it. Like what happens if you start doing high profile tests and experiments and make this a real thing?
Suddenly then everybody around the world is going to be told, hey, you could like, you know.
SPEAKER_01With like 150 bucks, you could go fiddle with the climate. And then you're like, got a whole Pandora's box thing going because you really, this is the scary thing about solar radiation management. You could stand up and do a reasonably large scale test on your own without a ton of money, arguably without being detected, doing so by the world. Yeah. You know what I mean? And the fact that no one's doing that yet,
I just think they don't know they can yet.
SPEAKER_01So I kind of don't want them to find out. What do you think about that aspect, the moral hazard part of it?
SPEAKER_00It's so tricky, right? I mean, to fear monger you a little bit more, I'm going to use a dirty word to you, I suspect, which is that a billionaire could probably get us half a degree C of cooling globally, personally. That's the crazy thing about SRM is that The estimates, like we don't really know, we don't exactly know efficacy, blah, blah, blah. But the rough estimates just to an order of magnitude are that, at least what I've seen, it might cost a couple billion dollars to deliver something
like a half a degree of
SPEAKER_00cooling, half a degree centigrade of cooling.
SPEAKER_01Yes, but as you know, I'm sure, if you follow the literature, the cloud of uncertainties around all of this, like unanticipated effects and second-order effects,
SPEAKER_00things could go so horribly wrong.
SPEAKER_01And that is precisely the kind of question I don't want... individual billionaires answering. You know what I mean? I totally agree. This to me argues for really wrapping our heads around it and doing it explicitly just because somebody needs to wrap their hands around it and start controlling it. It's the kind of thing where you want the equivalent of the
International Atomic Energy Agency.
SPEAKER_00You want the UN to take charge of this and say, look, for the sake of the world, we need to explore this, but it should only be done in a coordinated fashion or something.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, but think about the difficulty that nuclear arms regimes have had Ferreting out and finding out whether a country is actually doing a nuclear program, and a nuclear program is big and expensive and requires very specialized knowledge. It's very difficult to do that without being noticed, and people are pulling that off. I can't imagine an international enforcement regime. That could enforce this.
SPEAKER_01It's so easy to do. And then if a billionaire does it and another billionaire doesn't like the way the billionaire does it and decides to undo it or do it a different way or redo it, you know what I mean? Do we want billionaires getting the idea that they should be involved in this field? Yeah.
SPEAKER_00Well, yeah, I was going to trigger you with billions, but I don't know. The problem is I think the solution is not to put our heads in the sand. Because the more we collectively put our heads in the sand about it, the more likely it is that that's the way it gets developed, ultimately. yeah yeah it's yeah i mean i guess trying to do it on purpose and with eyes wide open is the best is the best we can do but boy boy am i nervous
about about how that plays out i guess there's no i mean you can't you can't not do it you can't put a lid back on it you can't unknow what we know about it now so like i guess the
SPEAKER_01only way out is through but uh Anyway, so we have three minutes left. You want to toss out one of your spares just to intrigue the audience, just titillate an audience with a question we didn't get to?
SPEAKER_00My spares weren't great, actually. Oh, I had some really good spares. Yeah, hit me with some spares. Well, one of my spares I was surprised you didn't bring up, I almost brought up, which is...
SPEAKER_01What's going to happen with permissionless DERs?
SPEAKER_00Oh, I just did an episode. I know. I listened to it.
SPEAKER_01I listened to it. And I did one on Balcony Solar not long before that. So people know this as Balcony Solar. Basically, it's any distributed generation or battery that you can plug in without getting permission from a utility or from anybody, really. You can just plug in. So, last I heard, and this literally changes week to week, but last I heard, 25 states had laws either proposed or...
SPEAKER_01announced to be proposed to legalize balcony solar. That's half the country right there. That's 25 states. That's probably pretty soon, and I'm sure many more will follow in the wake. I'm just fascinated by what effect it's going to have. I think you and I probably agree that the net megawatts Produced by this stuff is probably not going to be huge.
SPEAKER_01The question is, will the ability to put your hands on it and fiddle with it and play with it in a DIY way like Legos in your backyard, is that going to spark a kind of subculture? Is that going to spark a lot more people to care and get involved and just be aware of Just be aware of solar. I'm curious what you think the, how you think that's going to play out.
SPEAKER_00Balcony solar punk. I don't know. I need to learn more about Germany. Like I haven't spent enough time understanding like what, it's always a huge thing.
SPEAKER_01It's a gigawatt. Yeah. They got like a gigawatt. Uh, so I guess it's not that small of a, of an, of a net amount. They have like 400 million or something like, or 4 million. I shouldn't say 400 million. That's ridiculous. 4 million, something like that. systems installed from like three years of it being legalized. So clearly people like it. So I'm just curious what the sort of distributed social effects will be of that. I know both of us will be translated. And my other backup, which I thought was good,
SPEAKER_01but which you and I are probably not the people to discuss, but is... China is in a state of overproduction of batteries and solar panels, which means they're selling solar panels to their neighbors at just ludicrously low prices, which means countries like Pakistan and Vietnam are just being flooded with cheap solar. Pakistan went, I think it was like two years or three years, 40% of its total load now.
SPEAKER_01It has imported solar panels equivalent to 40% of its total load. Give that another two, three years. So I'm very curious. So we're going to see what happens when a massive, spontaneous upwelling of distributed solar energy meets rickety developing world How does that resolve itself?
What happens when Pakistan has enough solar panels that it's more than 100% of its total load?
SPEAKER_01You're going to get all these... problems that grids get with lots of solar, right? Like balance and frequency management and inertia and all this stuff. But all of this is unplanned. Like the leaders of Pakistan did not arrange this. They didn't have anything to do with it. Same. It's happening in Africa. It's happening in Vietnam. So I'm just curious, like what is the spontaneous unplanned profusion of solar at the ground level do in
SPEAKER_01to a country's electricity system physically and also just politically, like that's just a very big change happening very rapidly. We have no idea yet what's going to come out of it.
SPEAKER_00Great question. Not one we have time to answer.
SPEAKER_01Let's watch it. We'll leave you listeners to ponder what's going to happen in Vietnam.
SPEAKER_00There we go. David, this was fun. Thanks for doing it again.
SPEAKER_01Awesome. We'll do it again next year. Thank you for listening to Volts. It takes a village to make this podcast work. Shout out especially to my super producer, Kyle McDonald, who makes me and my guests sound smart every week. And it is all supported entirely by listeners like you. So if you value conversations like this, please consider joining our community of paid subscribers at volts.wtf or leaving a
SPEAKER_01nice review or telling a friend about volts or all three. Thanks so much. And I'll see you next time.
This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit www.volts.wtf/subscribe When people push for better data centers, they picture hyperscalers - Amazon,...
This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit www.volts.wtf/subscribe America’s first big wave of solar power installations, built between 15 and...
This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit www.volts.wtf/subscribe The Senate’s bipartisan permitting bill got a manager’s amendment last week -...
This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit www.volts.wtf/subscribe Last week’s election was a blue wave all the way down the ballot: Democrats...
This is a free preview of a paid episode. To hear more, visit www.volts.wtf Volts published eight conversations in October, which is a lot for anyone to listen to. We’ve rounded up the highlights into less than an hour....