This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit www.volts.wtf/subscribe Property taxes are two taxes stapled together: one on the land, one on whatever gets built on it. Put up an apartment building and the bill goes up. Pave the lot for parking and it stays low. It discourages building and rewards land speculation. The answer? Tax the buildings less and the land more. The idea of a “land value tax” goes back 150 years, but implementing it today involves navigating tricky constitutional issues. In this episode, I talk with Greg Miller of the Center for Land economics about the rationale for such taxes, and with Kitty Klitzke, a Spokane, Washington council member, about the difficulties of putting it in practice in a real city. Chapters: 00:00 Introduction 03:22 Henry George and the case for taxing land 08:12 How property taxes work now, and what a split rate changes 11:26 Land value taxes and upzoning as complements 15:18 The Pennsylvania record and the reassessment problem 18:51 Vancouver, and why homeowners outlast the policy 24:03 Estonia, Singapore, and the Scottish Islands 26:53 Washington's uniformity clause and the building exemption 33:18 Kitty Klitzke on twenty years of Spokane infill 43:27 What Spokane needs from the state legislature 45:25 Single family homeowners and the Division corridor 48:34 The assessor objection 52:45 What the Spokane modeling shows 59:31 The plan for next session 1:01:44 Virginia, Kentucky, and cross-partisan momentum
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
[music]
SPEAKER_01alrighty alrighty alrighty hello everyone this is volts for july 15th 2026 want less sprawl and more urban infill try a land value tax i'm your host david roberts have you ever driven through an american city and wondered why so much land near and around the urban core remains either undeveloped or covered
SPEAKER_01in low value uses like parking lots many people point reflexively to zoning and lord knows i have done many pods over the last few years on the evils of restrictive zoning but there is more to it than that you also need to look at the tax code property taxes are determined by a mix of two values the value of the land and the value of the structures on the land
SPEAKER_01one perverse outcome of this arrangement is that if you own a vacant lot and you put a building on it you raise your property taxes the higher the value of the building the more economic activity or community benefit it produces the higher your taxes in effect property taxes as currently constructed penalize building and reward leaving land underdeveloped it is perverse that's why even many cities that have reformed zoning still suffer from this problem
SPEAKER_01the obvious solution which is gaining momentum in cities and states across the country is to shift the tax burden away from the buildings to the land the total property tax bill can remain the same i.e. the reform can be revenue neutral but the resulting land value tax will penalize landowners who leave their lots empty and reward those who build it will incentivize building on the highest value land near urban cores
SPEAKER_01the idea is simple enough but the details get pretty hairy pretty quickly so we are going to dive into some of those details with me today i have Greg Miller co-founder and director of the center for land economics and a driving force behind the resurgent discourse around land value taxes and kitty klitsky a city council member who is pushing for adoption of a version of
SPEAKER_01a land value tax in spokane washington just down the street from me i'm going to talk with greg about the conceptual rationale behind land value taxes and kitty about the challenges of getting them implemented on the ground i'm super excited for this one so let's get into it all right with no further ado greg miller kitty klitsky welcome to volts thank you so much for coming thank you for having me all right greg let's start with you um in
SPEAKER_01the name of keeping my introduction tractably short i did not get into henry george why don't you briefly tell us who henry george was and what his basic insight was and why
SPEAKER_00that basic insight has come back henry george is a political philosopher a journalist whatever you want to frame him has from the 19th century and in the 1890s he lands down in san francisco and he's asking himself this question it's the industrial ages we are producing things faster than ever and this is supposed to bring about all this progress all this prosperity and he's asking himself why do i see so many people living in such terrible conditions with so much poverty and so he writes
SPEAKER_00a book called progress and poverty what he realized is with the industrial age we had discovered a new frontier that frontier is everybody moving to an urban core there's all of a sudden agglomeration effects around living near a factory and because everybody wants to live near a factory the people who own the land are the people who are able to benefit the most because they can charge increased rents and as those factories become more productive as we discover assembly lines and new methods and mechanisms to make factories more productive so too do
SPEAKER_00the profits and so too do the wages to the workers and all of that means that the rents can go up even further because now more people want to be near that factory that pays higher and we see this today right we see this in san francisco in our big cities that's where we see the highest agglomeration and the highest value of land and the highest rents that people pay for units that you know you could go into a rural area and have a house uh eight times the size of and so henry george the political philosopher who understood that land was a big deal
SPEAKER_00and he invents what he calls the land value tax why don't we tax this value this locational premium um in our cities and this wasn't a novel idea necessarily i mean adam smith thomas payne talked about variations of this policy but he really popularized and becomes one of the most notorious figures he actually runs for uh mayor in new york city marches down the streets and has a huge parade uh he ends up finishing second but uh he's this figure that has lasted and his ideas have proven themselves throughout the past century and now is
SPEAKER_00the resurgence here is his idea around land value tax that i think we're seeing right now a huge resurgence of georgism he's even got
SPEAKER_01a he's even got an ism uh named after him yeah and i think the key the key thing for people to understand there is if you are owning if you're sitting on this piece of land if you own this piece of land and people develop around it you know the factories come in and then the public invests in infrastructure and people invest in schools and libraries all that stuff raises the value of your land even though you didn't do anything you're just sitting on it and you and so basically that public investment
SPEAKER_01is going to your private profit i think that's part of what he that was part
SPEAKER_00of his insight yeah that's exactly exactly the way i understand it too right is that land it is people sometimes get confused what we what do we mean by land right what we really mean is location and right nobody creates location it's a natural resource i mean we have we have 50 trillion dollars of land in the united states that's our largest natural resource and nobody created that land and and then when we go to new york city you don't create that value everybody around you does the roads the people the schools and
SPEAKER_00so i think that's where we sometimes what we say is land value returns we're returning the value of land to the community that makes that land valuable right and and we use a tax as the mechanism via which to do that um but yeah i think that's where you sometimes hear this concept
SPEAKER_01of land value return one other thing to say is the reason a lot of economists love this even conservative economists is the sort of basic economist insight that when you tax something on the margins you get less of it if you tax income on the margins you get less income if you tax sales on the margin you get less sales if you tax carbon on the margins you get less carbon but you can't get less land right you can tax land all you want and you can't reduce
SPEAKER_01the supply of land so um milton friedman uh he was a fan even he called it the least bad the least bad tax so george wanted all taxes on land he wanted he wanted that to be the sole the sole tax i don't think anybody today is proposing that i mentioned this briefly in the intro but tell us sort of how property taxes currently work about this balance of values and how kind of how they're assessed yeah and good news
SPEAKER_00for the united states we have a property tax system uh the european nations some of them can barely relate right when we have quite robust one and a property tax includes two taxes in one we add together the
SPEAKER_00and we can decrease the building tax at a time when we're asking how can we get more development how can we help solve the housing shortage and then we can increase the land tax at a time we're asking how can we have less land speculation less vacant landowners less surface parking lots in our downtown corridors and i think that's the idea that when we're talking about land value tax nowadays it's really important to say we're talking about shifting taxes from buildings to land we're talking about decreasing the building tax we're not trying to raise taxes overall some people are some people aren't for me it's not a question of how much money the government takes in i'll let
SPEAKER_00the city government decide that or the county government decide that it's a question of how we collect that money and how we collect that money is an extremely important question for how our urban environments get built and that's why i think property taxes are very important for this conversation right
SPEAKER_01so and so like i said the basic insight is if you shift that ratio if you should reduce the building side of that tax and increase the land side of that tax you are raising the penalty for sitting on an undeveloped piece of land basically and you are reducing the penalty for building that's the idea is around
SPEAKER_00the margins you'll get more building yeah and to put this tangibly if you look at a downtown and you go drive through your downtown and you'll notice that there's either a vacant lot or a surface parking lot somewhere there and you'll notice that there might be an apartment complex and a hotel and a mixed-use apartment complex with a storefront right next to it and if you look at how much taxes the vacant lot pays today under the current property tax system it's paying usually 10 times to 20 times less than the apartment complex sitting right next door so the person who decided to you know invest in their property and build this downtown is paying 10
SPEAKER_00to 20 times more in taxes as we shift that tax burden from buildings to land we're saying these should be paying pretty similar we should stop penalizing that development so the vacant land would pay more compared to our current system um but that's just because that's the way that we set up our current system we've penalized that development um and so that's the ultimate impact of of this shift when when you look you know when you drive through your downtown that's what you should be thinking about
SPEAKER_01and i guess maybe one other thing to say is that the effect of this would be felt most intensely on the most valuable land right which which tends to be pretty mechanically the closer you are to an urban core more or less so so the natural effect of this would be to push more building toward the core precisely this is the infill development we're looking for right and so um say a brief word some of
SPEAKER_01the questions i got i threw this out online as i tend to do and got a bunch of questions and one of the questions i got is sort of how does this relate what is the sort of relationship to of land value taxes to kind of the yimby zoning up zoning all that stuff that you know i've covered on previous previous podcasts that they that the yimby's want to do up zoning around transit all that kind of stuff are they compliments do they do they need one another can they can they
SPEAKER_01stand separately how do you look at that relationship
SPEAKER_00perfect complimentary um in fact thank you to the yinbees for their past decade of activism i don't think i don't think we would see be seeing all the states considering land value taxes today without that urbanist movement and that grassroots momentum when we upzone when we make it easier to develop land becomes more valuable there's good studies on this you know when you when you do transit-oriented development upzoning you see all of that land become a lot more valuable and because it becomes more valuable folks can still sit on that land i mean we've seen this out in dc with some of
SPEAKER_00the developments in the amada i'm from the dc area and and we've seen folks just sit on vacant land why because they can wait 20 years and still double their money on that vacant plot of land and so when you do this upzoning and we do this transit investment the next question is is okay how do we ensure that this windfall that we've created this huge amount of money that we've created for private landowners
SPEAKER_01right we've created value again i just got to put an exclamation point in that when you up zone and when you develop land you're creating value right and so how do you distribute that value is the question yes yeah and and and
SPEAKER_00then how do you both distribute that value while also incentivizing the upzoning to also materialize and so i think this is that question is we've we've raised the land values but we also want to encourage this person to develop the multifamily house rather than sit on it and wait for their neighbor to develop first because then they can sell for more later right um and i think this is all about incentives and the questions around incentives and so i i view these as perfect complementary uh we work with a lot of yenby chapters a lot of um housing policy housing abundance folks and i think there's
SPEAKER_00a reason why these these are policies that go hand in hand
SPEAKER_01is there is there anything to say about the the order kind of order of operations or like if you're a city contemplating these things is there is it better to do one before the other or does that matter like do you is there a kind of a sequence is there a sequencing anything to say about sequencing
SPEAKER_00yeah there there is i i think some folks would argue you know if you implement the split rate right before and up zoning then that could be good because then you capture some of that windfall you've created right away and then are also immediately incentivizing that development but i i also think that you can up zone and then a year later pass some sort of policy of a land value tax shift and still see those good benefits and so um i think that the housing solutions is a is not a one size fits all solution and
SPEAKER_00so cities should do what's what's politically feasible but also should be working on this problem from every different angle right and a lot of our cities you know i i believe upzoning is really important a lot of our cities but a lot of our cities are asking themselves you know we have this surface parking lot downtown that technically could be developed into something but it's not so is zoning really our problem um and zoning still is you know if you universally up zone it's a good thing but a lot of our cities aren't san francisco and aren't new york city and aren't going to see all that development right away and so they we also have to ask ourselves
SPEAKER_00the incentives question so i think you know whatever the order is these are complementary policies but they're also policies that can both solve help help to get at the solution independently there are
SPEAKER_01some examples of this happening in the wild not a not a ton but some and so pennsylvania for instance let's talk just briefly about pennsylvania pennsylvania is one of the rare cases where the state their state law that basically says if cities want to do this split rate i.e increase the building or increase the land tax reduce the building tax they can so presumably have we have some examples on
SPEAKER_01the ground some experience what have we learned
SPEAKER_00from pennsylvania's uh record yeah pennsylvania has had 20 plus cities implement what we call split rate tax again taxing land more than buildings and those cities there's good economic evidence from those cities now economic evidence comes from the 1980s to the 2000s i mean the economic studies come after but this is when the implementation is so take some of this with a grain of salt but you saw the cities these post-industrial cities like pittsburgh which is the largest city to have implemented one from 1960 to 2000
SPEAKER_00really was able to continue to build and survive this post-industrial decline of a lot of neighboring cities a lot better and so the economic evidence suggests that you saw an increase in housing infill development more units per acre you saw more permitting you saw less vacancy less vacant land and you saw an overall increase in property values so this is the gist of the economic literature from the pennsylvania experiment now some people ask well pittsburgh got rid of it in 2000 the question is why and so i always have to preempt this with it's kind
SPEAKER_00of ironic that pennsylvania is the one state where this has been done because pennsylvania also has the worst some of the worst reassessment policies some of their cities right now have assessments dating back to 1960s
SPEAKER_01and when we say assessment this just means that when we talk about the value of the land and the value of the buildings somebody's got to go in and determine that that's not it's not an obvious number there's some judgment involved and some expertise involved and that's what assessors do and that is also governed in some sense in some ways by law and and procedure you know if you want
SPEAKER_00to be impressed by your local government drive around and notice how many independent properties there are and tell yourself wow the assessor assesses all of those properties pretty frequently and that's a hard task right so so the assessors have a hard task and they're oftentimes you know very low staffed to do this very very hard task but if you're pennsylvania you avoid that by just never doing it now washington state for instance does that every year right um and so pittsburgh does this huge reassessment they finally you know the first time
SPEAKER_00in 20 30 years they're like okay what is each property worth now and of course you saw massive increases and so there's a huge populist backlash against the reassessment we're seeing this today in syracuse new york they did a reassessment and they voted against their reassessed values because there was a backlash to the increase in tax burden um and the assessor's not at fault
SPEAKER_02the assessor's just telling you what the market tells you but
SPEAKER_00pittsburgh got mad they were wondering why they're doing this weird split rate system they said the skyscrapers should pay more let's get rid of this weird system we have and so it is ironic that pennsylvania is the one state with this considering they don't mandate reassessments while other states do mandate annual triennial you know once every four years once every three years once every year reassessments on all properties
SPEAKER_01yeah we're gonna we're gonna get back to assessment in a bit when we talk about spokane but one other um example that i want to briefly discuss which i found really fascinating is vancouver bc vancouver bc back in the early 20th century had like a fully georgist system they only valued land was the only thing taxed in vancouver and what you've seen in vancouver is not this sort of one one-off backlash
SPEAKER_01that got rid of it what you saw in vancouver bc is over time the land value tax got kind of whittled away the building tax grew over time and then eventually i think it was in the 80s it finally went away entirely and then ironically as anyone who lives in vancouver knows they proceeded to have a giant affordability crisis uh through lack of building but as i understand it and tell me if i'm wrong what kind of what happened
SPEAKER_01in vancouver is that homeowners the ones who um you know get penalized by this over time more and more as the cycle goes on are also an incredibly powerful political constituency and the people who benefit from this policy as is so often the case with public policies are sort of diffuse they don't really know they benefit from it some of them are future renters so they don't even know you know they're not organized etc is that accurate
SPEAKER_01about what happened in vancouver and i guess my question would be how do you how do you prevent that from happening how do you prevent sort of the people who see the penalties organizing to fight it and the people who benefit you know being diffuse and unorganized that's my understanding
SPEAKER_00of vancouver and probably the extent of my understanding of the vancouver situation is similar to the way you've described it um i will say i've had people reach out to me from vancouver recently uh trying to revive the land value tax in the same way that people are reaching out in pittsburgh and you know even the pittsburgh gazette's editors came out and said we need to revive our land value tax so um it's it's curious that these these cities are now looking back towards what they once had um of course there's winners and losers with these policies i think one of
SPEAKER_00the things we'll get into in a second with spokane is sometimes these shifts are actually beneficial you see a tax decrease for single family houses because single family houses are sometimes good uses of land in a lot of our cities for in san francisco a single family house is not a great use of land but in other parts of our cities the single family houses are decent uses of land um probably not as good as row homes right but they're not as bad as vacant land or surface parking lots all of this is relative to each other right um and so i think that there are some ways that you can get rid of some of
SPEAKER_00the boogeyman's around this policy it's like oh this of course single family homeowners are going to hate this and then you do the data analysis and you say well they decrease in taxes so why are they going to hate this and oh of course this is a progressive policy so industry would hate this but actually this is a pro development policy so why would you know development hate this and but then you do have a landed class you have landowners and those landowners want to get that money from land right and so we see this in florida with there's a huge push to abolish
SPEAKER_00property taxes that ended up just being a 250 000 exemption for homeowners why because homeowners as you said are the class of people who vote and who have political power um and they want more wealth
SPEAKER_00you know host of the charlie kirk show come out and talk about how this was a massive wealth transfer from gen z to the boomers um how this is just creating
SPEAKER_01a ton of money right and so the land and there's an element of like killing the killing the golden goose right like the reason the land is valuable in the first place is i mean this is something i i come back to again and again like city's agglomeration as you said creates value that's why the value exists that's why the land is valuable in the first place and if you kill agglomeration and you you know disincentivize building in urban cores you're killing the golden goose that gave your land the value in
SPEAKER_01the first place it's long-term self-destructive definitely and so
SPEAKER_00to answer your question there's pushback there are people who don't want this to happen but there's also reasons why there's a lot of people should support this and there's a lot of boogeyman's around the policy that i think are inaccurate um i think you get a lot of folks in support of of a revenue neutral shift
SPEAKER_01to land um final background question is just is this is there any other country are there international examples of this happening or are experiences to learn from or is this a u.s centric kind of problem
SPEAKER_00no there are estonia has a national land value tax that has been implemented for a while they just did a massive reassessment at a national scale um and so you know there's a huge a german state that just implemented a land value tax i think that there's a lot to look towards um but a land value tax is not the only way to do what we're trying to accomplish what we're saying is that the public creates value and should regain and recapture that value and then return it to the community Singapore does this through owning all of the land and having variable rate leases
SPEAKER_00and so these variable rate leases effectively operate as a land value tax and Singapore has seen tremendous prosperity and pretty good sustainable financing because they own 80 of the land and are able to do variable rate leases on top of those lands and so there are a lot of different examples of the sort that you can look at to realize that this isn't a crazy system that nobody's done um there are folks doing
SPEAKER_01so you so you lease the land it gets built up it creates public value that public value goes to the state and the state reinvests it in schools and infrastructure etc raises the value of the land more gets more revenue invest more revenue you can get a cycle going there ideally instead of the state invests raise the land value and then a bunch of landowners get rich
SPEAKER_00precisely and one of my favorite examples of this recently we have a fellow l griffin who also does a lot of her own great work she's been studying the scottish islands scottish islands bought themselves some of them and the way they were funded was through the scottish lottery the lottery had a provision that a lot of the a lot of the proceeds would go to a national land bank and so residents would come together the island of stornoway for instance they bought the island but because they own the island and there was a huge massive land trust they also had to provide for themselves and provide the businesses the the schools
SPEAKER_00the infrastructure their own housing and so they had this incentive though because they owned the trust and they benefited from the trust to also make it attractive so they built a golf course and that golf course is now part of the scottish open i believe um and so you know you create these good dynamics where cities want to improve they want to be better because the residents all gain from that the city gains from that but in this case it's a trust but you know same principle it says i find it funny that a lottery system funded this um but there's there's things to take away from that model
SPEAKER_01yeah okay let's so let's focus in a little bit on an example in washington let's talk about washington state where i live one of the barriers to this in washington state as i understand it this is true in many state constitutions the state constitution has what's called a uniformity clause which basically says that taxes on property must be uniform and that all real estate is one class so you have
SPEAKER_01to have one rate one rate on all classes so legally you cannot tax the land at one rate and buildings at a separate rate legally you cannot do a straightforward land value tax so then how do you get around that
SPEAKER_00yeah the other way of doing of shifting taxes from buildings to land what if we just exempted all buildings from taxation the only thing left to tax is land and so we actually do this in a lot of cities we have random exemptions for multifamily as washington state has a multifamily tax exemption but we're saying what if we exempted everyone from their building taxation what if when you build an adu in your backyard you're not taxed on your improvement and so the washington state constitution gives broad authority to the state legislature
SPEAKER_00to determine what property can be exempt from property taxes and so that also gives the state legislature authority to say cities can choose to exempt portions of every building from taxation so what this would look like in principle is uh is saying is the state passing this law and then a city like spokane saying we want to exempt 50 of every building from taxation and what that does is it decreases the taxable base if you otherwise had 200 million dollars in property value now you only have 150 million dollars you can tax right
SPEAKER_00but you need you still need to get 50 million dollars to fund your you know your city government and so you you raise your tax rate from one percent to 1.2 1.3 percent effectively what that's doing is that 1.3 percent is now being applied to land so this is sort of a goofy way of going about it but what we're doing is we're saying buildings are exempt from taxation or a portion of buildings are and so we're going to raise taxes the tax rate overall and that raised tax rate is mostly going to apply to the value of land
SPEAKER_00and it effectively accomplishes the same thing right
SPEAKER_01so it's revenue neutral you're still raising the same amount of tax revenue but less of the taxes applied to the buildings more of the taxes applied to the land it's sort of a backdoor backdoor land value tax one other technical detail in washington in our wisdom we have a rate cap a cap on the amount you are allowed to charge property taxes and an increase cap or a cap on
SPEAKER_01the rate that you're allowed to increase property taxes talk just a little bit about how those constrain movement here constrain what washington cities can do
SPEAKER_00yeah parcels in washington city a piece of property cannot be taxed up more than one percent of its full market value by typical means so a city council can vote in a prop who can vote among themselves for a property tax um the state has a property tax the county has a property tax that they vote for that the among themselves among the elected leaders for and uh the constitution caps the total amount of that across all of the different uh the state the county the city when you add those all together you can't go over one percent and additionally the city can't collect if
SPEAKER_00the city this year collects 50 million dollars next year it can't choose to collect 100 million dollars it could only raise its total revenue collected by one percent every year these are city-wide or district-wide restrictions it's different for listeners who know about prop 13 in california to that where that's parcel level that means that each parcel can't increase in taxes more than one percent california has it a lot worse right that's parcel level means that you'll have two properties sitting next to each other one will be taxed at two thousand dollars one will be taxed at a hundred thousand dollars
SPEAKER_00and you know they're one they're both five million dollar homes not paying their fair share because they've been owned for five decades that this is a different question um but importantly in washington state the city can vote for levies and this happens frequently oftentimes for school districts and when they vote for levies those voted levies do not apply to either of those restrictions and so there are a lot of voted levies both in seattle and in spokane that are not restricted by that and so that just means that the people who are actually residents there need to vote in favor of that levy increase
SPEAKER_00which does happen um so although it's unfortunate that you have some of these restrictions it's it's also democratic in a sense um when i talk to conservatives i say this is the most beautiful tax because you know exactly where your tax is going right and and in some states like to washington state you quite literally vote for it and so if you're gonna if you're gonna want any tax this is a great one um but yes there are restrictions in washington state but voted levies get around some of those yeah
SPEAKER_01and i guess it's good that we can get around it but i just have to say for the record that it is crazy if you have a city that experiences big rapid growth you would think what a good thing let's we can now get more tax revenue and invest more in our city and get in that virtuous loop and instead you have a city that grows really quickly and you are capped in the amount you can raise property taxes so almost
SPEAKER_01by definition you are starving the cities that are growing the fastest it's an insane an insane thing to do but that's uh constitutional i guess and very difficult to very difficult to undo but as you say if the voters levy it on themselves they can get around those caps which is like not an easy thing necessarily to get voters to vote to raise their own taxes but uh
SPEAKER_01if you can talk them into it you can you can get around these these rate caps so kitty sorry uh greg and i nerded out a little a little bit there but i want to talk to you now um you have a long background in land use work land use advocacy worked for future wise done a lot of transit campaigns etc etc but as i understand it you had not really heard about land value taxes until relatively recently until after you were on
SPEAKER_01the city council so maybe just tell us briefly about kind of your history with land use and how you came to find out about this and why it why it appealed to you hey there everybody don't worry i'm not going to tell you about a new mattress or push a credit card on you this isn't an ad there are no ads on volts it is supported entirely by listeners like you if you'll indulge me for a second i'd like to ask for your support i started volts because we're all surrounded by depressing news about climate change
SPEAKER_01and misinformation about clean energy and it's never been more important to share the stories of the real people on the ground doing the real work of transition and all the ingenuity and courage and public spirit they are bringing to it people are hungry to hear these stories to learn from and find inspiration in them i've heard from people who change majors or careers after hearing episodes of volts people using it in classrooms and community groups even state legislators who have passed bills inspired
SPEAKER_01by specific episodes sharing these stories matters it makes a difference if you have found value in it and want to help me continue doing it tell us briefly about
SPEAKER_01kind of your history with land use and how you came to find out about this and why it why it appealed
SPEAKER_02to you um yeah well that's not exactly true um it's been brewing for me for a little over 20 years um about 20 years ago i future wise is a statewide organization and i was in our seattle headquarters uh walking on capitol hill with a co-worker and we're walking by this old Scientologist church that was being renovated into condos and the developer happened to be there and very frustrated
SPEAKER_02and somehow knew who we were and he came out on the sidewalk and sort of accosted us and said look at this the seattle tax system is making it very hard for me to develop this beautiful building of lasting value and turn it into something that continues to be a lasting value meanwhile you're making it super easy for people to build these corrugated steel articulated crappy multi-family buildings that in 10 or 15 years are gonna you're gonna look at them and say oh these are
SPEAKER_02so two thousands and they're not gonna have any like lasting character or value he said your tax system is incentivizing this you want to know why no one builds with stone or brick anymore it's because you make it so expensive for us and so cheap for people to build with crap and it kind of came out of nowhere he let us tour the building it was beautiful but he was really struggling we didn't even know if he was going to be able to complete the project but it stuck with me i had no idea what to do with it um and
SPEAKER_02then over the years i had been involved in spokane in my job in participating in these kind of steering committees that were supposed to figure out infill for spokane because we outsized our urban growth boundary early on shortly after the passing of the UGA so we had this enormous urban growth boundary and a sprawl problem and an infrastructure and traffic problem and not the most affluent tax base to address all these problems so we
SPEAKER_02as a city they were deciding to try to get it together and strive for infill and try to grow up and not out and be a little more prudent protect our remaining forests and farmland all the things sounds good so we tried up zoning we tried to take advantage of every incentive the state allows us to give we did a lot of public investment in transit and streetscaping and other things and um it wasn't always manifesting in the way
SPEAKER_02that we had hoped we weren't seeing any redevelopment and we still had a ton
SPEAKER_01of vacant lots yeah i should say just i've been to spokane and even relative to other big cities you see there is a striking amount of weirdly underdeveloped land right in the middle of the city it's it's
SPEAKER_02a striking feature of spokane i think to this day yes and it's a thorn in my side and it has been for a very long time but i think so this was before you got on the city council because that was well before yes this was a 20-year process for me um but i think what i started to notice over the years is just like public policy taxes can be kind of an unintentional source of social engineering yeah and so when we we tax the value of
SPEAKER_02a building we disincentivize quality we disincentivize good materials and we disincentivize maintenance
SPEAKER_01so that's why that gets to to what the guy said to you before the reason people now are building with cheaper materials and building cheap ticky tacky buildings rather than nice quality buildings is that they get taxed more the higher the value of the building they build basically
SPEAKER_02that's surely a part of it um i think it also affects the way that things are financed we're not i don't see raising the the land value as the the thing that we tax over the building as penalizing i think what we're doing is we're actually changing the stakes when we upzone and incentivize land it increases the expectations for speculators right so that i can't tell you how many times i've gone and you know an area has been recently up zoned a landowner owns this huge piece of land
SPEAKER_02and i'm coming in and talking to them about why they need a street vacation so they can maximize the use a lot of all these stories about what they're doing and so we do the street vacation and then the land just still sits there for sale all they're trying to do is maximize the value of that lot they had no intention of developing it because developing things is a lot of work and so we're we're raising the value and keeping the stakes extremely low for someone who wants to speculate they're paying almost nothing in property taxes
SPEAKER_02but they're raised they're slowly like building the value of this piece of land by us upzoning it incentivizing it and then maybe doing a little bit of administrative work and the land just goes up
SPEAKER_01hugely in value right so spokane spokane is raising the value of the land yes
SPEAKER_02and they are benefiting from it with very little risk right and meanwhile the neighborhood's sitting there experiencing this vacant lot like on all the all the nuisances that come with that whether it's raccoons and stray cats or squatters and crime we experience all those nuisances associated with that vacant lot that is usually in a prime location and it just sits there because they're waiting for the person to pay the right price and they're doing a minimal amount of work
SPEAKER_02to get more money out of that but when you take away the risk of higher property taxes and all the things from the part of the building we're doing what we can to incentivize a higher quality building and make it easier to build that building they don't have to consider it in their finances having their property taxes go up so um i think it's kind of a virtuous cycle and like that experience in capitol hill this made it very real
SPEAKER_02for me um that these these kinds of policies decisions that are very hard to change because they involve taxes and i feel like there are a lot of boogeyman's with taxes but if we don't get serious about what we're doing wrong what we're truly incentivizing and disincentivizing with our tax system the problem is just going to continue to fester i was in peru the last few weeks and i noticed that there's a lot of unfinished looking buildings everywhere there's rebar sticking out of
SPEAKER_02the beams tops of buildings and things and someone in my bus that it was on finally asked someone why this is they don't tax buildings that are incomplete as highly as complete buildings and so people just don't complete the building you'll see the two or three story window with rebar sticking out of the top floor to imply that there's going to be another floor someday so please don't tax me and i think they were probably trying to make it easy
SPEAKER_02for developers trying to ease the burden on somebody who's trying to build their building or their house but what it's resulted across the country from lima to kuzco these weird looking unfinished substandard looking housing that might be nice inside but looks terrible from the street yeah tax policy is full
SPEAKER_01of unanticipated consequences
SPEAKER_02but i feel like we have gone as far as we can in spokane with upzoning and incentives we're trying to diversify the building types we allow we're trying to make our code more flexible we went to a form-based code a while back and it's still not resulting in the type of turnover but we have some landholders in the community that just sit on land and are happy to do that for decades or generations until the golden goose turns golden enough i guess and that's really just not great for
SPEAKER_02the community um so i've been talking about this issue for years under different names at first we started talking about it as a universal or no we first called it highest and best use and that conversation kind of got shut down like what about the vacant lot next to my house that i might someday want to build for my grandma um okay how badly do you need that and if you're serious about it why can't you pay taxes on it but um then we started talking about land value tax and the constitutional things came up and it wasn't
SPEAKER_02until i got connected with with land economics and greg and some other folks that we started thinking about this universal building exhaustion concept which has been really helpful because it was starting to seem impossible to get a policy that really reflects the goals and values of our community rather than making it harder for everybody to get there
SPEAKER_01so it's the split value thing that is somewhat new to you then so this is a proposal now that you've put on the table at the city council level it didn't get through this time what's the sort of political state of state of play of
SPEAKER_02the proposal specifically we weren't really able we don't have the statutory authority to um reform taxes at the city level for almost everything we do have to go to the state for permission even if it's something we're going to ask voters for unless it's something that the state has already carved out our ability to do we cannot
SPEAKER_01so you're pushing for a state you're pushing for a state law a state some sort
SPEAKER_02of state reform we are trying to get the authority from the states to be able to do this in our city either as a pilot project just for spokane or as we're finding there are many cities that are interested in this um as either a pilot project or just a permissive legislation for cities who want to opt into this
SPEAKER_01and so what is the state of play at the state level then it didn't it didn't get through this session is it still i mean we've had difficulty getting it drafted
SPEAKER_02because we feel that we need some cooperation from the department of revenue to do that properly and the code revisers at the state level don't necessarily have the confidence to just sit down and draft department of revenue laws without the cooperation of the department of revenue so we uh have a we have a kind of steep learning curve that we need to get folks over to understand the why and the what of this and that we're not trying to raise taxes or create any inequities we're trying to increase opportunity
SPEAKER_02and build a tax code that makes more sense for the goals of our cities
SPEAKER_01well if there's one thing i have learned about washington cities is that uh single family homeowners have a lot of power uh in them there are a lot of single family homes in them and single family homeowners homeowners have a lot of power and they tend towards nimbyism uh i'll just say as charitably as possible so what do you say to single family homeowners who say look if you're going to incentivize building that means people are going to build a bunch of big apartment buildings
SPEAKER_01in my neighborhood this is of course the terror of all single family homeowners in washington is that someone builds an apartment near them what do you say to the single family homeowners who are worried that this is going to induce a bunch of development in their neighborhoods well first of all it doesn't affect the zoning
SPEAKER_02at all so if you're not zoned for multifamily you're not going to see multifamily just because of a land value tax right in spokane we don't have any single family zoning so a fourplex could be allowed anywhere and so that could already be a fear of someone who's afraid of those types of things in their neighborhood but what i will say about this is this makes it easier for someone in your neighborhood to build another bathroom to re-roof their house if they need to upgrade their facade
SPEAKER_02to maintain the homes that they have without fear of their property taxes going up or their next door neighbor's property tax going up just because they made some improvements so and their property taxes will go down so there is some benefit to single family homes it also makes i think a person who has purchased a vacant lot and wants to build a single family home that's going to be easier for them to do because the taxes are not going to go up significantly on that lot when they build a house on it
SPEAKER_02so it's it doesn't do what people think it's going to do it's there to uh get rid of the speculation and the very woeful and obvious under development we have some huge surface lots where there should be buildings in our downtown we're about to make significant investment on our division corridor that goes through the center of the city our biggest main street for we're going to build bus rapid transit there and do station improvements
SPEAKER_02and streetscaping and all of those kinds of things in that area is just an eyesore it's full of vacant lots under block empty buildings there's only really one significant multi-story building and it just stands there by itself compared to this kind of depressing single story and vacant lot area and we don't want to make that kind of public investment it's going to be a quarter of a billion dollars of public investment and then see nothing grow out of that and that's what could continue to happen if we continue to make it incredibly cheap
SPEAKER_02for those landowners that own a ton of land on that corridor to do nothing until someone else does and makes it more profitable so getting back to
SPEAKER_01the assessment question it's kind of technical but it turns out to be like one of the real barriers here the county your county assessor called this proposal crazy because he says then you have you're running two different tax rolls you're making two separate assessments for every property the state assessors association were unanimous in opposing this it seems like that's a real barrier here so how do you how do you solve that i mean it's my inclination obviously being
SPEAKER_01the way i am is you just need to fund and staff your assessing departments adequately but like how how are you addressing that objection and that bit of resistance do you have sort of answers or proposals
SPEAKER_02to help them well i think first of all we're not asking them to change
SPEAKER_01the way they assess land or home
SPEAKER_02the value of the home and the land stays the same it's just how much of the tax burden we apply to the land part and how much tax burden we apply to the building part that's really all that's changing we're not asking land differently at all so that's kind of a misunderstanding i don't know if they saw like an early draft that could have implied that that made them think that that's where we were going but our county assessor has been on board at different times and has kind of changed his mind as he hears other voices interpreting
SPEAKER_02in different ways but i think this is there's no insuperable barrier there to getting them on board i think what they will have to do is work with their local governments and create the algorithm that works for their land base and their goals and then apply that algorithm to each property so this could be a matter of just programming and not necessarily having to hire new staff and i'll chime in here as well
SPEAKER_00because i've talked to a lot of these assessors in washington state on this and um ultimately they already valued the land and buildings separately and across the country this is true too and different counties do it differently spokane actually does a quite good job of their split between land and buildings and these counties in washington already administered the multifamily tax exemption which is an exemption on improvements and this is very similar we're not asking them to run two split roles we're asking them just to add another exemption to properties um so we don't we don't think that there's a as large of
SPEAKER_00an administrative barrier as assessors make it out to be we're working with them to figure out how we can ensure i used to work for housing development i care a lot about administration and but i also think that there's this sentiment among assessors we see nationwide when we talk about this policy some are actually very much in favor some think really like their land values but some push back a lot and i think that this sentiment imagine if today we didn't have a property tax system the idea that you'd go around each city and value each property which sounds so absurd like how how do i know that
SPEAKER_00the granite countertops worth eighty thousand dollars and the buildings depreciated twenty thousand dollars i mean yes indeed
SPEAKER_01it's something of a mystery to me how they do it how they do it now i mean
SPEAKER_00and it works right granted people push back nowadays and make this argument that oh it's an illiquid you don't know the value until it sells but it turns out that our property tax system works pretty well and so if we were in this alternative universe where we didn't have one we would hear the exact same pushback now this is an even less of a step from going from no property tax to a property tax because we already have all of the infrastructure to value land we have all the data we need now some assessors might not be paying as much attention to the land values they should be um
SPEAKER_00but they already have all the infrastructure data they need and so this to me is sometimes feels like a larger argument than it should be um because people just aren't imagining what the future could look like in terms of land value taxes um and it's not as crazy it's just as crazy as a property taxes we already do property taxes so i i think it's possible it's entirely possible
SPEAKER_01another question is just about um the size of this and the effects it will have so um and tell me if i'm wrong about this kitty so under this proposed tax split in spokane as i read the report the median tax bill of a vacant parcel will rise by something like 560 a year but these improvements you're making these investments like the like the investment
SPEAKER_01in bus rapid transit etc etc this these some of these land values could be appreciating by tens of thousands of dollars a year so so i'm sort of wondering like even if you get this passed is the scale of it sufficient really to actually induce building like what is the what is the modeling show you about whether this is actually going to induce behavioral change well i think that's
SPEAKER_02the question right there i think it depends on how we're able to apply it if we're able to make it applicable to state and local taxes um there's a lot of what ifs there that are going to be worked out through the legislature i'm obviously hoping for the maximum impact possible but it is just one tool in our toolbox to try to incentivize infill we still need good growth containment strategies we still need
SPEAKER_02economic development plans we still need to improve our zoning and our building codes all of which we are working on in spokane has been a leader
SPEAKER_01on
SPEAKER_02but this is just one more thing that slightly equitizes our tax base gives some relief to residential folks while still allowing us to pay for the infrastructure that some of these larger landowners benefit the most
SPEAKER_01from Greg maybe you could tell us briefly you did a your outfit has done analyses and reports for various cities just how this would work and what the effects would be tell us what the modeling shows in spokane like who benefits and who gets who gets penalized and i was sort of thinking about the about the people in the single-family homes i mean it just strikes me and tell me if this is correct or not that there's not one answer
SPEAKER_01for how it's going to affect people in single family home neighborhood it obviously depends on the value of the land which again depends on the proximity to the core basically so like if you are in a single family neighborhood that's very close to the urban core it probably will induce a lot more development than it would if you're in a neighborhood farther from the core and it seems to me like that's exactly what you would want to happen but but tell me what the modeling kind of shows like whose bill goes up
SPEAKER_01and down and um like who benefits and who gets who gets hurt yeah first this is
SPEAKER_00a lever that the city has and they can press on this lever as much as they want and so the modeling we do for the city is a version of the policy we you know the modeling we we published was just one version of the policy that we would propose for spokane it doesn't dial it up immediately it doesn't but it's also not completely white and so in the modeling we did there was a base exemption and then and then an exemption on buildings a percentage exemption on buildings and that modeling showed that the median single-family homeowner is going to decrease four percent but importantly
SPEAKER_01to your point david their tax the median single-family homeowners tax burden will property tax burden decline very slightly
SPEAKER_00very slightly and and and that was what i was about to say is most this large majority of single-family homes will stay within 10 of their current bill and so what this is actually doing is it's really shifting that burden from the multi-family developments the townhouses um to the vacant and surface parking lots in the downtown corridor but also for those single-family homeowners this is not dialing up a full land value tax to 100% we're you know we're far even if we did 100% building exemption far from 100% land value tax and so as
SPEAKER_00the downtown develops more which this policy would do the single family home sure their land values would increase but you profit off of that increase and so there's still profit incentive for these single family homeowners to see their city get better um at least in in my vision but this is again comes down to whether the whether this is about profit maximizing or whether this is about just keeping the character of the neighborhood right which is still undefined science i think a lot of people are starting to think the latter the latter might be guiding this a little bit more than we once previously thought right um
SPEAKER_00but the other thing i wanted to touch on in terms of projections outwards in terms of what this does to development i don't think it's been talked about we're talking about a one percent tax we're used to like eight percent sales taxes twenty percent right income taxes but that one percent tax applies annually and so this building tax is building portion if i own a plot of land and i build a million dollar apartment on it i'm taxed one percent not just this year on that one million dollar investment but every single year thereafter five years later i'm still paying one percent of that million dollars we take the net present value of that we sort of amortize that out we
SPEAKER_00say how much tax is this really in terms of today's money and it's it's can go up to 20 30 tax burden um and so so the building tax although it seems small is actually a large tax and i just want to touch on that because it's important to say that we're not talking about a small tax here this is number one source of revenue for local governments it's a huge tax um and it's not just a one-time tax so it's this is a large tax um and
SPEAKER_01a large disincentive to develop and just uh you very briefly touched on this but just to sort of pull this out taxes would go up the most for vacant lots and parking lots and would decrease the most for multifamily residences basically
SPEAKER_00yeah that's the modeling in spokane and that modeling typically holds true in a lot of the other cities that we we model now it's always true that vacant land doubles you know and service parking lot double in price and it's a little bit variable how much single family homes are impacted how much multi-families impacted but typically those are single families typically not really changing much and your multi-family is typically a median 10 percent decrease um and that's true of the spokane modeling it's true of a lot of modeling we do
SPEAKER_01all right and so kitty just one more for you just what is the plan what is the what's the plan of attack here are you going to have another go at trying to push this in the state legislature next session yes we'll be having workshops
SPEAKER_02for legislators um before the session starts do they get this do they like
SPEAKER_01in your experience do they intuitively understand this or is there a lot of education required at the at
SPEAKER_02the state legislature level i think what happens is they they get the need for it they get the idea and the concept and then they get spooked when the details come out and so that's the point where we have to compete for their attention enough to get them to understand and feel confident that what we're trying to do is possible and what we're trying to do is not burdensome to the state or local governments and
SPEAKER_02then it will be much easier because there's a ton of interest there's a ton of buzz it's something that i've been talking about for years with certain people and is starting to gain ground in more mainstream circles some folks even from counties have been interested in exploring this idea which i've never quite understood but
SPEAKER_01i'm glad they're interested and and specifically are you pushing for a pilot thing for spokane are you trying to get a bill akin to what pennsylvania has which just says that cities can do this
SPEAKER_02at their discretion i think ideally it would be permissive for any city that wants to do it but spokane is always happy to be the test kitchen rest of the state so um for me it would be enough to get it here i think the problem is pronounced enough it's very very visible and it's clear done everything we can with the other tools that we have that it would make a lot of sense to be a laboratory here but um i also don't want
SPEAKER_02to stop other cities from being able to do it
SPEAKER_01if they're interested interesting okay well we're short on time but just quickly um greg tell us a little bit about momentum here like this seems like a concept that was relatively obscure and confined to some some committed georgists not that long ago and now you know i i hear it popping up more often uh my own mayor of my own city katie wilson here in seattle mentioned briefly recently
SPEAKER_01that she would is interested in this idea is interested in possibly pursuing this idea so it seems like it's gaining momentum what is actually happening and
SPEAKER_00where it's gaining a ton of momentum um and i think it's all part of this urbanist movement i think it's part of people trying to broaden their perspectives i think three to four years ago there's maybe a couple of states considering legislation to enable cities implement this policy
SPEAKER_01and this is just to clarify enabling cities to do this split rate that is the main mechanism we're talking about that is the main thing we're trying to push through state legislatures nobody is really contemplating like a full-on full-on straightforward land value tax are they it's just it's this is the tool that we have available is that is that more or
SPEAKER_00well david if you talk to the right people you'll find somebody pushing some people pushing for federal land value tax and constitutional yeah this is the policy that i believe incrementalism i think this is you know the step in the right direction um and so this is what i'm talking about is just enabling this split rate again not even within even once it's enabled for the city you don't have to dial it up 100 the pennsylvania cities haven't done
SPEAKER_01that um you can be as incremental as incremental as you want basically once this is enabled precisely and so yeah so
SPEAKER_00you know three years ago we're looking at a couple of states now we're looking at 12 10 with introduced legislation to enable cities we're looking at two states that have passed legislation this year for the first time and probably um a couple of decades i think virginia had one bill in the 2010s and outside of that we really haven't seen movement on this who passed so virginia and kentucky passed bills um virginia enabled four additional cities uh newport news and charlottesville are like the sort of main ones and then kentucky enabled louisville to implement split rate taxes and so we think
SPEAKER_00that we're just at the beginning of this um i think the momentum's only going to continue
SPEAKER_01am i making it up there's one place where a republican legislature pushed this through over a democratic governor's veto is that is
SPEAKER_02that kentucky this is kentucky yeah so kentucky
SPEAKER_01so this is really intriguingly cross-partisan it's not a straight is not a straightforwardly partisan kind of thing yeah that's actually
SPEAKER_00a great point virginia the same month virginia and kentucky passed a bill virginia's blue they passed a bill actually pretty bipartisan anyways kentucky the split rate tax was part of a larger governance um overhaul and so it's just one component and so the republicans were pushing this through they wanted to remake the ethics committee to make it more republican in nature for for the metro councils um and they they added this in because they were really interested in this as a pro-development strategy particularly for urban areas um and and the urban area um
SPEAKER_01so we think of we think of republicans i mean i think of republicans generally as kind of hostile to cities on a general basis so what is the what is kind of the conservative rationale here what do what do republicans say uh on behalf of this policy
SPEAKER_00it's it's pro-development so senator or former senator pat toomey was once allentown pennsylvania's uh city administrator and he wrote a letter to all the nearby cities saying you guys should do split rate land value taxes this is the best tax right this is pro-development and he becomes uh republicans to senator um now running a very conservative fiscal conservative org or i think he was at one point i forget what he's up to now but in kentucky it was the same story right milton friedman loves this tax this is pro-development and and
SPEAKER_00to complete the story the republicans are then steamrolling the democrats on this urban reform to remake the ethics but there's this land value tax provision a democrat stands up like i hate this bill but i love the land value tax provision you know and so and so really we are seeing bipartisan support i think that there's something for everyone to love here um some policies sound good too good to be true land value tax um might be too good to be true but we will find out i i like to believe that it's too good to be true but
SPEAKER_00then every time i think about it further i'm like this is a great policy and that's why i focused on it so much uh and started the center for land economics
SPEAKER_01to work on it full time yeah i mean you have to tax somebody right somebody somebody's got to pay taxes if you want to have public amenities and like almost any group you can gin up some sympathy for but almost nobody really loves land speculators you know this is this is not a group of people that have a lot of like explicit defenders in uh in legislative world except themselves yes yes to the extent that they are organized they defend themselves but like
SPEAKER_01if you're looking for people who you know and if you're looking to sort of minimize again like the the second order you know negative effects of of taxing you're not going to get any less land right like you can't get rid of land by taxing it so like it seems like uh it ought to be an area of agreement okay well i've kept you all long enough uh as usual when i dig into something like this i realized you could do a million uh pods on this
SPEAKER_01and barely scratch the surface but uh i think we sort of captured the the basic idea so thank you greg uh and thank you kitty thank you thanks everybody you've been listening to volts founded and hosted by me david roberts produced by nate peavey that's how this show grows and survives through word of mouth see you next time
This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit www.volts.wtf/subscribe When people push for better data centers, they picture hyperscalers - Amazon,...
This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit www.volts.wtf/subscribe America’s first big wave of solar power installations, built between 15 and...
This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit www.volts.wtf/subscribe The Senate’s bipartisan permitting bill got a manager’s amendment last week -...
This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit www.volts.wtf/subscribe Last week’s election was a blue wave all the way down the ballot: Democrats...
This is a free preview of a paid episode. To hear more, visit www.volts.wtf Volts published eight conversations in October, which is a lot for anyone to listen to. We’ve rounded up the highlights into less than an hour....