This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit www.volts.wtf/subscribe The UK has just released its seventh carbon budget, recommitting to the aggressive climate targets suggested by its nonpartisan Climate Change Committee. Can the Labour government actually hit those targets while keeping energy prices for the British people under control, even amidst a newly hostile political landscape? In this episode, I talk with the UK’s new climate minister, Katie White, about those challenges and more.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_01Hello, hello everyone. This is Volts for June 17th, 2026. Can the UK stay the course with its climate plans? I'm your host, David Roberts. By many measures, the UK is a genuine global leader on decarbonization. It passed an extremely ambitious climate change law in 2008 and has largely stuck with it since. It shut its last coal plant in 2024 making it the first G7
nation to leave coal behind entirely It has cut its greenhouse gas emissions by almost 50% from 1990 levels well ahead of some other countries one could mention But its decarbonization
SPEAKER_01push has recently hit some turbulence The cross-party consensus that held for 15 years seems to have come apart. With the Labour Party running the government, the Conservatives now want to repeal the very climate law they once championed, and Reform UK, which is leading in many national polls, is promising to scrap what they call Net Stupid Zero. To make matters worse, America's ill-conceived Iran war has gas prices spiking and
household bills heading
SPEAKER_01back up. An awkward backdrop for a government elected partly on a pledge to cut household bills by £300 by 2030. All of this agita will be on display later this month when Parliament votes on the UK's seventh carbon budget, which will give the government guidance on how and how fast As proposed by the labor government, it maintains course, but increasing concerns about industrial competitiveness and
the cost of heat pumps
SPEAKER_01and transport mandates will make this a spicier affair than past budgets. Can the government produce a credible policy package that meets the targets laid out in that budget? Now that the easiest reductions in the electricity sector are behind it, can it make similarly ambitious cuts in heating, transportation, and aviation? Can it restitch its climate consensus and restore its global leadership? Much of that effort will fall to Katie White.
SPEAKER_01For two decades, she has been a leading climate campaigner working at prominent NGOs to establish the UK's climate law and its basic policy architecture. then in July 2024 she became a member of parliament and in September of last year she was appointed the UK's climate minister it's a rather dizzying ascent into the higher reaches of government I can't wait to talk to her about how the climate effort looks from the inside and how she intends to keep the
country on track Katie White welcome to Volts thank you so much for coming thank you for having me David let's start here the most striking thing about UK climate politics at the moment from the outside perspective is that you know you were instrumental I've been working for years with NGOs were instrumental in passing the climate change
act way back in 2008 which passed on a cross partisan basis and has had majority
SPEAKER_01cross partisan support ever since up until it looks like right around 2023 when it looks like the consensus sort of fractured reform obviously is now out promising to repeal the whole thing conservatives are now following up saying they want to repeal the whole thing it really looks like that consensus kind of flew apart pretty abruptly starting in
SPEAKER_012023 and I'm just kind of curious what why do you think that happened what is your diagnosis for what happened well thanks David that's a great question and in terms of where we are and why do I think it's happened so look I don't think it's quite as broken as you might think or hear look undoubtedly there has been some fracturing and you're right that in 2008 it was
SPEAKER_00actually the conservatives under David Cameron David Cameron's leadership campaign was to call for a climate change bill and then the Labour government introduced it and they continue to deliver and in the last few years there's been some questioning about that and I very much have been taking a step back and ask what is the questioning and what do we agree on and what do we disagree on and what's the sort of problem with that and so I think look we are a place in terms of there's a few bits to this one is our energy bills I think
that's probably the main thing really and it's certainly the number one issue for voters in the UK and it's the number one priority for our department secondly is energy security and thirdly
SPEAKER_00is Dr. Anne McLeod I'm not sure we've made the case particularly well, but also
So people you know energy bills have continued to rise and so people have made a sort of equation there of hold on a second are these costs directly comparison now you know David you're an expert on this it's a very complicated picture and in the
SPEAKER_00UK what we're doing is we're moving from a a system where we've almost been renting energy and it's been a commodity based system we're buying up we have certain amount ourselves but broadly we're buying off other people be it the US or Norway or other countries we're buying oil and gas and so we're now moving to an infrastructure model that we're almost buying our own house and there was a down payment cost on that you know we have invested in terms of having wind turbines you know and actually the last government to credit to them they set a lot
SPEAKER_00of this you know in train the challenge they also didn't do the grid infrastructure which meant that we haven't been able to take advantage of some of those costs so we were at that sort of tricky point in the transition and so I think we need to be honest about that there's also people have put politics all involved in that and you know obviously this is even more so in their states you know it's very much a binary has been left and right I've never really agreed with that and I'm very much happy to call things out on the left and the right and you know people want to have an argument about whether things
have got a label or whatever I don't really care about the labels frankly I just want to make sure that we've got clean energy that is cheap good for the UK and good for the planet the other point and you might have some reflections in terms of where you think it is
SPEAKER_00from where you're sitting but I was with a group of leaders yesterday and some business leaders and some of them have been working on this for a while as well and they were saying actually a lot of this is cyclical and so there is generally cycles of support and lack of support and we are for sure at a lower ebb they were reassuring me that it was going to go up we'll see but they did say that the troughs of those peaks the trough is getting higher as the trend is going up and then I think finally I would just say is actually there's quite a lot we do agree on you know there's been a lot of
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I'm sorry. The one thing I wanted to say is I was looking at these charts and political
SPEAKER_01support has split rather abruptly, but that's not reflected in public support. Like if you poll the public, they're not as intense in their support as they used to be, but still majorities are in support. So it's really kind of an elite... Dr. Justin Marchegiani
but of course politics lives in the short term and people are facing high prices in the short term and you know originally I think labor was promising we're going to lower your household bills I think specifically by 300 pounds by 2030 that for a variety of reasons is looking quite implausible not all of which are in your control of course some of that is Iraq war pushing gas prices up etc but the
SPEAKER_01question I would just put to you is what are you going to do in the short term like what how do you propose to restrain costs between now and 2030 so look you're absolutely right we've committed to bring bills down and the bills were lower in 2025 than they were in 2024 so we were heading in the right direction but you're absolutely right you know I think everybody can see the international crisis we face and the challenges so we've done
SPEAKER_00a couple of things one is we have done targeted warm homes discount for people who are who need energy support most and we did that over the winter and we increased the distribution of that so there was more people getting access to warm homes discount we also were having so some of the costs of the renewables obligation we had on bills and we've taken those in-house to the treasury so yes the taxpayers paying but it is for families and businesses that is having a reduction in cost and that's why the price cap was
lower in April so it has gone up because of the Iran war but it hasn't gone up as
SPEAKER_00much and we were working from a lower base so we've already made a but I'll just also give you a story I was out knocking on doors because that's what we as politicians do out in the northwest the other day and came across a guy in a very modest house in a pretty not a hugely affluent area who was explaining dross
SPEAKER_00We're just trying to get the, we said we're going to introduce these plug-in solar that you get in Germany, that you can get in the middle aisle of our discount supermarkets. We're just going to get the regulation through, but we're trying to do that as quickly as possible because it there's a way that people can look to insulate themselves from bills and I say that's the number one thing I'm concerned about is how do we support consumers and use this time that we have wisely it's pretty hot here at the moment so energy demand is lower I mean obviously you know demand but in terms
of heating etc is lower but we will head into a winter where prices look like they're going to rise so how do we do everything now to be protecting consumers for that next winter
SPEAKER_01A slightly nerdy question related to that. And this is something Ed Miliband has referenced frequently. One of the reasons that household bills are going up is that gas prices are going up. And in the UK, the way the energy market is structured is gas is still the price maker the price of energy is still sort of pegged to gas so in a sense you're very stuck on this roller coaster with everybody else so I'm just curious in terms of energy markets how are you going to break
that link how are you going to stop allowing gas to establish the price of electricity in the UK I know there are market reforms in the works what's how do you want to break that link and
SPEAKER_01when might it be broken so there's two things to say one is you're absolutely right we've announced we're looking at how to break that link and how structurally we can do that so there's a review going on at the moment in terms of breaking that link and we'll be able to
SPEAKER_00tell you more in hopefully not too long a time because say we're operating within the framework where energy costs are causing a lot of challenges the other thing obviously is the more we move everybody onto that electrification piece every single solar farm offshore wind turbine that we are pulling onto the grid as quickly as we can and we might come on to clean power 30 the mission that the Secretary of State brought in you know allows us to be less exposed to those fossil fuel prices and we looked already you
know and again I give credit to the last government because actually their investment the fact that we
SPEAKER_00have got so much work We don't get any of that in the US I'm not sure what you're talking about We're approaching things rationally over here
SPEAKER_01So the seventh carbon budget was just released yesterday. We're talking on June 3rd. It was released on June 2nd. It's about the period from 2038 to 2042. It would represent an 87% cut from 1990 levels. This is what the Climate Change Committee... So it is a statement of ambition, it is a statement that you are staying on course, but the same Climate Change Committee also says that around 39%
of the cuts needed
SPEAKER_01to hit the 2030 target, which is much closer, are at risk because the grid connection queues are clogged supply chains are backed up and most of all you don't have the transmission you need and there's lots of on the ground local public opposition to building new transmission so it seems like if you want investors and others to sort of put credibility in that long-term target What are you going to do to make sure you hit the short-term target,
SPEAKER_01the 2030 target, especially since you're so far behind on transmission and transmission just takes a long time to build? How are you getting back on track for 2030? look so you're right the the climate change act which we brought in in 2008 for those five yearly budgets so we are currently in carbon budget four and we set yesterday for carbon budget seven so we can have that long-term trajectory for a couple of reasons one because it meets the climate change challenge which is what we're suffering today is what happened from our grandparents
and their grandparents
SPEAKER_00and what we're laying down today is affecting our grandchildren and grandchildren so you know it meets that we used to call it they're not in my term of office challenge which is like why would I care as a politician if it's not going to affect in my term of office well you need to create an incentive structure to do that so that was the point of the climate change act and it was also that it wasn't it was stating legal ambition but without a straight jacket the 2030 target is actually beyond so we met carbon budget one two three we're in carbon budget four the clean power 2030 mission
is not a legally binding target that is part of a way to accelerate our mission which will help meet those budgets so it's something that came in with the Labour government and the Secretary of State came in and wanted to have ambition and
SPEAKER_00wanted to be really clear because he came Dr. Anne McLean in terms of planning decisions, which he's just gone through. So yay or nay, let's move them on. He set up a control mission with a brilliant guy called Chris Stark, who he has mission control of this and he looks up everything
that is going on.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, yeah, yeah. of fault in the system so government had to intervene because actually the citizens we need to make sure we're getting that queue sorted so we've reordered the whole queue we took everybody out which you can imagine not everybody was thrilled about but at the same time we need to get the system working that is our
So we've reordered the queue so actually things are moving a lot faster so we can
SPEAKER_00take advantage of that. We've got a planning bill that has gone through the House of Commons and we're looking at whether we should do anything on top of that in terms of national education. infrastructure projects so I don't think anybody whether they're a supporter or not a supporter would say that the energy secretary didn't hit the ground running with skews upon a huge amount of energy for this agenda we have been going at it you know I mean to make sure that we are moving forward and getting things done on this so the committee on climate change brilliantly rightly comes
back and marks our
SPEAKER_00homework and says on different areas which bits we're doing and I think in terms of the grid you're right it's a big challenge we're looking at big investments and and also how we can we do need to make investments but also where there's areas we can manage that more effectively whether it's through AI or whether if there's more battery based systems will that take some of the peak load and some of the demand off so we're open to all that looking at all the options and Chris Stark has been doing this to 2030 is now looking at that, you know, how we make sure that is delivered most effectively.
SPEAKER_00Look, supply chains have been a challenge across the world. We know that since, you know, pre-COVID. And it's at each level, you know, we're moving this whole I do more visits than any other minister because I love going out and hearing from real people what they're doing and what's happening and also what's their story you know where's the gaps and I go to heat pump manufacturing and they're saying actually I've got more capacity if you can get you know if demand goes up here these are my extra lines so you know I go
to apprenticeships and they're like absolutely stacked out because they've got people who are wanting those jobs their future so there is challenges it's great for them to point that out that's inevitable when we've got such a big systems change but I guess I feel we're totally on it and I'm really grateful for anybody pointing out any gaps in
SPEAKER_00our plan because we want to fill them
SPEAKER_01Let me briefly hit an issue that's very hot in the U.S. right now. Tony Blair recently came out with a big op-ed and a couple of interviews saying that labor should scrap the net zero goal, etc., etc. I think he was... roundly mocked for that but I think one of the reasons he was saying that is he's now very big into AI and he wants he's part of a group of companies and corporations and a lot of big investors who want to build a lot of data centers in
the UK and of course those data centers are massively massively power intensive and
SPEAKER_01And so to the extent they're sucking up power, that's less power for everyone else and makes and the more of those you put online, the more difficult it is going to be to hit that 2030 target. So a lot of people just read that as we should prefer data centers and AI over our 2030 target. So I wonder if you see any conflict between data centers and your short term goals. Yeah you're right there's been a lot of commentary going on in the UK and in broad
terms look I welcome the opportunity to have a great conversation about energy the target and there's two targets there's a 2030 clean power and then we've got a 2050 net zero I've been in this for a long time up until 10 years ago I'd never even heard of net zero it wasn't even a term we were talking about actually where the
SPEAKER_00real excitement is is where's the electrification and where's the grid like what's you know what's the demand like how do we manage it and therefore what's the job and the investment opportunities and so the clean power transition call it what you flippin want like I think we we're getting caught up on something that is almost like in act seven Dr. Anneke Vandenberg
I think they're missing the point of having that argument and actually I listened and Tony Blair is a great thinker he's a great strategic thinker and I enjoyed reading the article I listened to one of his podcasts and he said actually we do
SPEAKER_00need to meet net zero I'm just not sure about the level of transition so you know is it 2048 or 2052 like listen I'm going to crack on with what I'm doing today and it's not going to make that much difference to me in terms of the transition on your sort of wider point around the data centers look we want to be in the game We are lucky enough to have great scientists here in the department as we have
who is you might not know but certainly in COVID here was one of our like national rock star heroes because he led the sort of science but I sat down with him and asked him about it and said you know AI are you excited are you worried in the
SPEAKER_00context of climate and energy and he was like listen there's as many opportunities in terms of AI using and helping us with the grid in terms of reduction as there is in terms of demand so look I'm definitely an optimist and maybe that's you know but I do think We want to go in and see how can we support this industry. We now have much more capacity and capacity challenges because we've got a lot of over capacity in some areas of the country. Is there a way of working those two things together to have a
holistic energy system?
SPEAKER_00Dr. Jennifer that effectively that's the thing about the budget the carbon budget why it's so great is choices like and it's the same with a fiscal budget you know like a politician or any person could find any which way of things they want to spend money on of course they can and it's about choices isn't it and you make those
choices and if you're going to go bigger one thing then you've got to squeeze back on the other so it just allows you to have a sensible practical way to do that Let's turn to another subject that a lot of people were pushing me to ask about. Labor's plan has this sort of a national fund now which is going to invest a lot and put a lot of money and energy into nuclear power and hydrogen and carbon
SPEAKER_01capture and sequestration. and there are a lot of people in my world who view all of those as very expensive very slow distractions basically and there's a some recent experience in the UK that would you know give them some evidence the size well see nuclear reactor ended up costing double what you thought it was the SMRs that you're ordering are best case scenario coming in mid 2030s the hydrogen for heating thing I think has kind of fallen apart
those pilots kind of fell apart no I don't think anybody's still pursuing that CCS there's not really any up and running so I guess my question is if you're behind
SPEAKER_01and if you need short-term fast reductions in cost and in emissions, why not reorient toward the things that move quickly, which is mostly electrification and batteries and the like? Why are you still chasing these white whales, I guess, is the non-flattering way of it.
SPEAKER_00So I think, yeah, definitely not flattering in terms of, look, so let's take each other because I think they're very different, aren't they? They're very different entities in terms of, look, I am genuinely excited about our nuclear program. I appreciate we have a problem in this country in terms of building things on time and on budget. We have a problem with that and, like, you know, it's across the board.
SPEAKER_01Again, I can't relate. I don't know what you're talking about. And that is something that I think our countries need to get a hell of a lot better at because there are places that can build things much more effectively and for
SPEAKER_00various different reasons and we could do a whole other podcast on this, we're not great at building things on time and on budget. and making choices that are like, you know, fiscally driven for the best return on our investment. So that is a separate thing. And we definitely need to be concerned about that. And I am concerned about that. However, I think our nuclear industry is something I am excited that we were investing in because a look, we need baseload and it does capacity in a way that our renewables doesn't do capacity. And we want to have that diversification of our energy system,
but it gives us that baseload. it also to say we have some technologies we have some technology and capability that nobody else has which is why we're working with the US frankly and I'm very keen actually to take the competitive advantage angle here like I'm not ashamed
SPEAKER_00that I want Britain to do well out of this like I want I think we should be and the SMR project is one of those and yeah you're right 20 but it's not that far in terms of we're just talking about budget 2042 you know 2038 2042 if that allows us that budget allows us that long-term framework and I guess I
mean the only
SPEAKER_00frustration in you clearly that we haven't cracked Dr. Anneke Vandenbroek
what about hydrogen there's a lot of people and I'm sure you've heard from them who think that the whole hydrogen thing is sort of a dead end there's still lots of
SPEAKER_01money in the budget for it do you still have hopes for hydrogen we're about to publish a hydrogen strategy so I shouldn't really talk so there's there is more to come on hydrogen from the UK and where we see the best role for hydrogen you know in terms of making sure we are investing wisely we've got a treasury that is very keen to make sure understandably that every one of our pounds is invested wisely but I think there is some opportunities and particularly we've also invested in communities as we'll come on on CCS where could hydrogen fill the
SPEAKER_00gap that other technologies couldn't do but We will keep each of this and that's why we also have the long-term plan allows us to see how each of these things are performing and how much we invest and where the support is needed etc. CCS again is like look if the couple of reasons why is the Committee on Climate Change would say to us each scenario requires CCS but also we do have a geological capacity because we've used a lot of our North Sea oil and gas we have that geological capacity that if we can crack it and make it you know work at commercial
SPEAKER_00scale it does look like we are going to have to look for options like that in the longer term so again it's whether we can do that so we will always keep things under review but at the moment we think those are the right choices all right let's talk about what is arguably one of the most difficult this is very much in your brief and one of the most difficult nuts to crack in the whole decarbonization thing I've done a million pods on people's various frustrations and difficulties which is the retrofitting homes retrofitting existing homes that just turns
out to be quite a riddle for everyone especially in the UK because I think heat pumps at this point have like 1% penetration almost almost all boilers almost all gas boilers and right now it's cheaper just straight up cheaper to heat your home in the UK with gas than
SPEAKER_01it is a heat pump it's like a four to one So a you have the difficulty of just the fact that all these residences and homes it's just a high touch sort of like home by home it's very difficult you have to deal with every homeowner you know every homeowner has very strong feelings about their home etc and then you have this cost imbalance this is just a difficult thing I'm curious how you're thinking about that part of your brief
SPEAKER_00Actually, I was in Sweden a few months ago, and the Swedes, which are a much colder country than Britain, and I think they've got 70% of their homes have got heat pumps. And so I said to the minister, I was like, can I, you know, and here, you know, people are like, hold on a second, is this going to work, all this kind of stuff. And I said... can I ask you how on earth did you do it you know how did you switch everyone and this guy's very sort of straightforward direct said well it was in the 1973 oil crisis and my grandmother came home and said that's it we will
never use another drop of oil on heating again and as if the whole country just switched and I was like I mean I love that level of rationality do you know what I mean that level of
SPEAKER_00rationality we can all envy I know I know I was like flippin' heck as you say people are like hold on a second it's gonna be a bit of a mess but it might you know save me so I think we definitely haven't had that level of rationality to shift towards it we are looking at a lot we've done lots of things in terms of heat pumps and there is more to do I think as it stands at the moment given we are in the Middle East crisis there is a lot of people looking and you'll see our EV sales have gone up solar panel sales have gone up people starting to ask about batteries and in
terms of heat pumps as
SPEAKER_00well slightly less sexy than an EV probably but still people are starting to go hold on a second how do I do this and once you've started on that you can move forward so we obviously we've got a boiler upgrade scheme so we're trying to incentivize people to do that but it's also as you know a lot of this is around misinformation and then also hitting some kind of tipping point so in terms of the misinformation there was lots of things going around is it does it really work you know is it also will I get a hot bath and I was like every time
I was like I am you know assured you get a very hot bath do you know what I mean so it's like is it but it's things like that that people care about you know it's like at the end of the day it's their home as you say it feel you know it's their sort of personal space and they want to make sure that they're going to feel comfortable and actually a
SPEAKER_00lot of what we're Dr. Anneke Vandenbroek and I was we were reflecting as we've done carbon budget seven
that in carbon but so when we introduced the act in 2008 we had 156 electric vehicles on UK roads like
SPEAKER_00one five six and now we've got over two million and you know you We've got figures like that on offshore wind and on solar but the shift that happens over that time so look we want to do everything we can to try and get it to be easier for people to do it we're encouraging people to do it but some of this is going to be a case of other actors within society and neighbors etc doing it and you know I was talking to someone today from the industry and they're in touch with their customers all the time and I said where are your blockages and they're like well it turns out
that at the moment unless every single room can be heated to a perfect temperature then people are saying oh my heat pump's not for you whereas actually the status quo is there's not that you know expectation for gas and the other thing and David you might have more of this I was talking to the other day I had another meeting people saying in the
SPEAKER_00states there's been a lot of shift because people don't want methane within their homes and so there's that shift as well that people are moving for other reasons because they don't you know in terms of doing that so and we've done our future home standards so we're looking as well and I think that's a big opportunity for us of how to make sure that new homes are built in the right place because we've when we lowered our future homes and but labor did have in place a mandate that no new boilers could be installed even in existing homes and they dialed back on that mandate so
clearly there's some political pressure around all this there's some adjustments being made again we go back to we've got to make sure we're meeting people we're at we're trying to encourage everybody because it's an upgraded experience and it's good for the UK and I mean that for all the reasons I've said price you know energy security and
SPEAKER_00climate but at the same time Brits probably the same way like Americans do not want to be forced to do anything so we're trying to to take a carrot approach as opposed to a stick another big part of your brief is what's called local net zero which is sort of you know a lot of these decarbonization dynamics and things that need to happen to play out at the local level the local sort of council level and housing and
SPEAKER_01transportation waste but it requires money to do this kind of thing. And local councils are sort of legendarily at the moment quite broke. And if they're going to be prioritizing things, they're going to prioritize the basic necessities above these more long-term things. So one question is, where does the money for these local councils to do local action, where is that going to come from? And the second question is, a bunch of these local councils have been taken over by reform
and reform people are just like we don't care about the mandates we don't care we're dismantling our targets we're rescinding these climate emergency declarations so I guess trying to deliver big decarbonization through a local level that is one broke and two you know in many areas sort of occupied by your opponents how does that work how are you navigating these local struggles what are you telling local people who are just telling you we don't have the money to do this hey there
everybody don't worry I'm not going to tell you about a new mattress or push a credit card on you this isn't an ad there are no ads on Volts it is supported entirely by listeners like
SPEAKER_01you if you'll indulge me for a second I'd like to ask for your support I started Volts because we're all surrounded by depressing news about climate change and misinformation about clean energy and it's never been more important to share the stories of the real people on the ground doing the real work of transition and all the ingenuity and courage and public spirit they are bringing to it people are hungry to hear these stories to learn from and find inspiration in them I've heard from people who change majors or careers after
hearing episodes of
SPEAKER_01Volts People using it in classrooms and community groups, even state legislators who have passed bills inspired by specific episodes. Sharing these stories matters. It makes a difference. If you have found value in it and want to help me continue doing it, I hope you will join the community of paid subscribers at volts.wtf. It's about the cost of a cup of coffee a month. If you don't like subscriptions, you can make a one-time contribution. Leave a review on Apple or Spotify or just tell a friend about Volts.
SPEAKER_01I am grateful for any and all support. If you're already a paid subscriber, thank you. And now, back to the show. How are you navigating these local struggles? What are you telling local people who are just telling you we don't have the money to do this? So I don't think it's quite as bleak as that in terms of look so you're absolutely
SPEAKER_00right that local authorities had a 90% reduction in places under the last government so a lot of them were hollowed out and services and as you say my council where I'm from was running a deficit and it's the first time ever they've not had to make cuts this year because we have done the biggest settlement they've had in 15 years so we're starting to build that back up so we are starting to reinvest because we see the local councils are hugely important at the front line and actually the places where we can get a lot of this done you know responsible for social housing some of the
most poorest people within our communities so we've already started to replenish that money there's no magic wand it will take time and there's a lot of investment
SPEAKER_00needs to happen roads houses schools hospitals etc and We are also working a lot more with mayors and we'll come on to the mayors of different colors so you know we're working with mayors who are looking at that much more strategically and it's really interesting actually because some of them have managed to go a lot further because they're working on bigger areas but still to having that accessibility with and so they've managed and they are managing and we're looking at actually they've got bigger low carbon funds how can they work together to get economies of scale and is it that they can be doing local heat
SPEAKER_00networks those elements that are happening across Yeah, yeah, yeah. you can come together you know as a sort of cricket club or whatever and say we want to have a wind turbine and we're all going to invest and we get the money back and the great energy so that is open now people are applying
and actually in terms of people owning their own energy it is a real game changer you then asked about like okay so fine but if you're going to climate skeptics you might get this vibe but I am a pretty positive person and I look for where we have things in common I'm not really bothered about statements you know things that people are signing up to whatever like you sort of helpful but it's sort of virtue signaling in some way you know it's not going to change what actually happens on the ground and what I've
SPEAKER_00seen is it's interesting in Hull and East Yorkshire we've got a reformer and they're very much like well I don't want this climate emergency statement and I don't want that net zero thing but I do want all these wind turbines and jobs that are behind me because actually that's massive investment and by the way you know I was at a factory the I think 75% of their jobs are within 45 minutes of the factory so they're local people it's not just people coming in it's local people's jobs so all of a sudden
you're not going to rip that out so I actually think and as I say we go back to like most people agree on electrification most people agree on that and I think it's a case of we have to be clear about why this is the right choice we're not doing this because we want to like make some statement we're doing this because it's the right thing for our country it's the right thing for the world as well but it's the right thing for our country in terms of our consumer bills in terms of
SPEAKER_00energy security and in terms of the planet in the longer term you talk about people sort of owning their own energy local energy so you have this public participation program called Energizing Britain you've said we're only going
SPEAKER_01to succeed in this larger effort if we bring people along we need people to be involved and engaged and people to play a role and this usually takes the form of what's called distributed energy rooftop solar panels batteries etc this is a real bright light in you know Australia for instance there's huge they get a huge amount of their energy from that now and it is bringing you know people are participating it's bringing people along but as I was looking at your larger plans it looks like most of the flexibility the grid flexibility you're looking into is coming
from these big grid
SPEAKER_01scale batteries I don't see any household batteries or targets or anything like that it seems like kind of the distributed energy piece is a little bit of a add-on and not a center of focus it kind of looks like you're mostly leaving that up to octopus which is you know doing amazing things but I just I wonder about that why why is there not a greater focus on trying to get batteries and solar panels and microgrids you know all these
things that are sort of bottom up local first in part as a solution for the previous problem I'm talking about you know the local the local councils and stuff you give them an immediate
SPEAKER_01benefit I'm just curious how you think about distributed energy basically I mean it's great and I think look there's so much to that and you're getting me excited David because there's so many different bits to this and this is a bit where you're like this is such a great area isn't it like there's so many different elements and so many different ways and also there's so many different actors
SPEAKER_00involved in this transition do you know there is a role for everybody if they want it do you know I mean like there is a role and actually right so the public participation plan was actually a recommendation of the climate change committee who said look if you want people to come with you you need to work with them and I'll be honest Yeah, absolutely.
SPEAKER_00drowson And then as you say, I'm really interested in actually practically what people can be doing and what is the best way of doing that and what is almost,
what's the way of making people feel involved but also their practical outcome of
SPEAKER_00reducing their business. and then hopefully the same thing but might be slightly different and it's almost like what's the gateway drug for people to get involved into this and it's interesting you say because I've had one side of people say to me that batteries are the gateway drug for people to get involved and actually I was like I don't know whether if you look at the different demographics it's different sorts of you know I was like is this a dad thing do you know like are they into the batteries because like and then I've also been told that it's EVs is the way in to have that gateway drug so We are looking at all of that and trying to because in a way
the complexity and the beauty of this system with all different areas is exciting to me but it can also be confusing and overwhelming for individuals and flipping it where do I start here so I think you know it's how to make sure it's really clear that people can get involved either as an individual getting an EV and and ultimately we've got a
SPEAKER_00vehicle to grid infrastructure that will help it taking off some of those pieces or we're doing this plug-in solar panel that will be another thing people can do for themselves they also might want to get involved in a community project as we've just said through this local power plan which is backed up by great British energy so they will be able to do that we're not opposed we guess we're trying to go as a government with all this array of opportunity where do we need to focus our time and do that and we're trying to make sure we I'm really lucky to work with
SPEAKER_00Dr. Jennifer how do we use that most effectively how do we make sure it's getting to the place how do we make sure we're remunerating that and if there's opportunities like with a lot more EVs on the road that makes different opportunities you know with AI that makes different opportunities and again how do you bring people
with you so that yes great if we've got some big players in the market who are doing fantastic things but how are we bringing communities on and giving them space to thrive
SPEAKER_00because I remember my one of my first meetings here was with a an MP in the Scottish Isles who was saying that they've got a massive big wind farm project but they've got a really tiny community wind farm that can't get onto the grid and they were like if you don't let us have this little bit they're not going to support this so like in that so there's almost sometimes you've got to make sure that you're listening to make sure that because actually that tiny connection might not make a massive impact in terms of prices and the planet but it might make in terms of how people feel and their pride and that's important
SPEAKER_01Just before we leave this, I'm curious, you said there's some public skepticism about heat pumps in part fueled by some misinformation. The UK is sort of not the sunniest place in Europe. I'm sort of curious what people think about rooftop solar and if that is catching on and beyond that, whether it works, whether it's a good investment in the UK and sort of like what the public thinks about that. As you say, these things tend to be I'm curious if that's happening with local with rooftop solar in particular just
SPEAKER_01sort of what the public mood around rooftop solar is I would say David the public mood of our rooftop solo is really positive really positive and it is catching on absolutely right look and great to have the opportunity again you know you getting it at all times in terms of of course when it's super sunny but you can pretty it's only a percentage off when it's cloudy
you're still getting a lot of the energy and in fact I was at a school the other week we were on their rooftop and all of the kids were up and it was in in Oldham
SPEAKER_00on the west coast which is pretty rainy place but and the weather kept changing and they were like at all times and then they were looking at monitoring the you know the impact of that inside which was a great educational thing as well but they've taken primarily a lot of their bills which was great so there's definitely a lot of support we've drvolts
SPEAKER_00panels, you know, factories that we've got plastered with solar panels. As the price of solar has fallen so much, it definitely makes sense and people are a lot more on board. We also had a policy before I was in office where it did have an impact. start some investment when it was more expensive and you ended up having a lot of people get on board with it so we definitely had chunks and there is a lot more support for rooftop solar I'm excited for when we get the plug-in solar for how many people get on board with that and how we can move that on
and yeah when you look at the companies who are involved are giving great statistics that increase sales over the last few months and that's great I'm really on board with that
SPEAKER_01Yeah, and just to clarify, there's a law now being discussed to legalize plug-in solar because it's not currently, can't currently do it. That's under works because it's, there's like, I think there's like 40 US states now where something like that is under discussion. So that's, we can expect that soon. soon very soon David we are breathing down the necks of our officials because it's such great I was in Germany and you're literally walking off the street and you just buy a thing like you know I was like can I carry this out okay it's a bit like carrying out a mirror you know you don't want to you know you
want to go stay but in terms of it's not like you've got to arrange a delivery or anything you can literally go pick it up take it in the back of your van or your car or whatever and plug it in so it's just a case of this obviously been happening in loads of other countries but we have health and safety regulation like everybody we want to make sure that's right but we are very keen that we get that green light so that people can start investing because say look my number one concern is making sure that
SPEAKER_00we're protecting consumers in the run-up to next winter
SPEAKER_01Another part of your brief is climate diplomacy. The current labor government is saying, we're back as an international climate leader, as a good partner. You've got these pledges, these climate budgets going far out now. You're playing a productive role in the cops again. But... I guess one question is how are and this is the irony of someone from the US asking this question believe me I'm intensely aware of it how are your
international
SPEAKER_01partners supposed to be able to to trust that you are in it for the long term when you've got the other parties saying, if we get power, we're going to scrap all this. If we get power, we're going to bail out on all this. And of course, all of international climate diplomacy depends on these long term commitments. They all depend on staying steady in the long term, being able to trust one another that we're in it for the long term. And so when you've got this political division at home,
and when if the wrong party gets in power, they might scrap the whole thing.
SPEAKER_01As we've seen here at home, I think no one... No one trusts the U.S. anymore. I mean, flatly, like on the international stage, no one trusts that the U.S. is in it for the long term anymore because we've got this massive swing back and forth in politics that makes long-term commitments almost impossible here. And it looks worryingly like the U.K. is entering a similar situation. So how do you think about that aspect of international
leadership and engagement? so look there is a certain amount of volatility within the world within political parties within societies across the whole world and that presents a number of challenges for everybody that's not to say that's you or I or this party we have a lot of volatility going on and you know social media who like there is multiple
SPEAKER_00layers to what that is our attention our frustration you There's multiple layers to what's going on with that. I hold that and I'm not going to deny the challenge of volatility. However, I started this off and I've been back to this theme again is that actually a lot of the basis of this, the grounding, the core of this makes long-term economic sense. And if someone calls it a different label, I don't really care. We're around the long-term trend on electrification.
and on the shift to clean energy I think is pretty unstoppable and I'm really keen to rebuild that consensus and actually you know the internet allows people to say something outrageous and get loads of attention and that is not representative really of the vast majority you see our public support for this agenda is huge when
SPEAKER_00we introduced the Climate Change Act in 2008 we had the support of the Confederation of British Industry all of the church and the Conservative Party and We've still got the support of the Confederation of British Industry, the church, and actually I think the faith leaders, by the way, have and will play a really important role. But also a lot of the conservatives, you know, I speak to a lot because some of them don't want to come out as much, which I understand. in terms of behind the scenes. And actually, you know, Theresa May, ex-Prime Minister, Lord Deban, who is head of the Climate Change Committee,
SPEAKER_00there's a lot of esteemed conservative ex-ministers, ex-Prime Ministers who are saying, you know, this is really important. and this is part of our legacy and they would make a different argument a different political argument that small c conservative is around conserving the planet etc in fact there's amazing quotes from Margaret Thatcher you know who talks about climate change being she was actually really So I think if you're like, if you believe in science, you know, if you believe in growth, you know,
SPEAKER_00if you believe in the economy, like these aren't left wing ideology things, they're actually just sensible common sense. I think the system that we have created and the geology in the UK means that the transition to a clean economy is pretty inevitable I'd love that to go as fast as possible because I think it's the best thing for Bill's security on the planet but I sure as hope that anybody who comes after me at any point will follow on that path because I think when you get into the nuts and bolts of it
it's the best
SPEAKER_00decision for our country but it's great to be back on the international stage and having those conversations and working with people who want to practically make progress we are in a different era but you know it's great to be working and you know we're working closely with Spain and you look at their A their deployment of renewables but B their growth rates you know for all the people who are in the who are in the treasuries yeah
SPEAKER_01Ten years ago, I heard so much skepticism about Spain's direction, you know, five years, ten years ago. And wow, look at their bets are paying off. It's a real illustration. It's great.
SPEAKER_00Exactly. So I think, I mean, look, I want to be blinded to the challenges. There is challenges. But in terms of a win-win, in terms of like an exciting transition, in terms of regenerating our countries, our economies, our communities, this is a brilliant way to do it. I'll tee up a final question and I know you're a positive person so I suspect I know how you're going to answer this but one thing that's sort of galvanizing all this making everybody at least think about this putting this on the front burner on
political news is the Iran war this sort of misbegotten ill-considered war that our country has started that is sending the price of gas and oil up it is forcing a lot
SPEAKER_01of decisions you can see the UK going two different ways one way is oh you know we need to double down on the transition transition faster do all the things we were saying we want to do even faster and more and then of course the other side is saying well this shows that we need to drill in the North Sea more we need to dig up more of our own oil we need to import more gas we need to you know in a sense we need to secure more fossil fuels and I'm
SPEAKER_01just sort of like Curious which way you think that's going to fall, which way you think that's going to play out in the public mind and in politicians' minds.
SPEAKER_00You're right. It's been a big discussion. I think, look, oil and gas has played an important role. It will continue because at the moment we don't have replacement for some things in terms of oil and gas. So it will continue to play an important role going forward. What we actually did was we issued these tiebacks. So we've got these tieback licenses. so it allows further like the exploration within the existing world so you're really making the most of it so again people want to make it a really binary thing of you're against oil and gas or you're you know you fall it's
just actually we
SPEAKER_00can't I don't want it all in that you know we want to tie backs that we've said we want to do that but at the same time there is a declining basin in the North Sea so look I can't say specifically around those planning decisions that got quashed because it's a life thing and we have specific legal requirements. I can't talk about those requirements, but what we'll say is to say that we've always said it would play a role, but electrification is where the big opportunity is because actually that's going to take over so much more of our energy economy.
SPEAKER_00So again, I get that it's a live thing and people want to know about it, but actually, as you said as well, the fossil fuel price is not going to change the fossil fuel price. And what's my number one issue is making sure that This winter, we're protecting consumers. That's our number one issue. And that's not going to make any difference because we're on the international market.
SPEAKER_01Can I stop you there? This is, to me, as someone who is immersed in energy world, is just like an obvious glaring fact that seems peculiarly to not penetrate the public dialogue, which is no matter how... How much you drill in the North Sea, it doesn't matter how much oil you get. You're not going to affect the global price. It's a global market. The global price of oil is going to be what it's going to be. You're not going to bring down your own oil prices by drilling in your own country. That's just like physics, and yet you cannot get that information out.
SPEAKER_01People seem weirdly resistant to acknowledging that. David you're right and if you find a way I had a really good conversation they were like but hold on a second wouldn't it be and they were like with somebody the other day and they said you know and then it was like you know 20 minutes in they're like oh right you know oh I see I was like but they're not going to sell it to us
SPEAKER_00Yeah, yeah but anyway the geology is in the long term the most important thing is electrification so it will perform part of our mix they're a really important community and where we're really lucky is if you go around any wind turbine wind farm
I'm in the UK you pretty much always hear a Scottish accent which is because they have come from Aberdeen and from our you know oil and gas so I think there is a once we're working really hard on that transition in terms of jobs and skills that you know is a lot of a similar and we are grateful that we have that expertise and we need to make sure we you know support it over to the new industries in which in large part is you know as I say we are hearing it and happening but we need to make
SPEAKER_00sure we do that
SPEAKER_01Yeah, if you want to just go out on, I forgot this, also alongside the new carbon budget, this report came out about the sort of effect of net zero on jobs and the economy and everything, you know. Was that also the Climate Change Committee that produced that report? I'm not sure who produced that report, but it's a big report. So this gets into the jobs and training stuff. So maybe if you just want to take us out with a little touch on that report.
SPEAKER_00You're right. The Confederation of British Industry, of which I talked about, which represents lots of business in the UK, they commissioned a report on what jobs were attached to the net zero economy, call it green, call it whatever you want. And they were saying in the UK, that's around a million jobs. Now in the US those numbers are but given our population that's a pretty significant amount of jobs they say about a third directly and two thirds through supply chain but those are a significant number of jobs as well as and these jobs are also really well paid
you know they're way above so I think the competition for getting into these industries now is great and each company I've been to and I'm sure that you know that the enthusiasm you get and also the fact that people are just not leaving you can see that you know that it's they're great jobs well-paid jobs and often in communities like the one I was in this week in Hull in East Yorkshire where they
SPEAKER_00haven't had as many economic opportunities over the last few decades so on that have a read it's great all right I'll leave you there I'll let you go catch your train thank you so much for doing this it's been really fascinating it's great to talk to you I really enjoyed it thank you David thank you for listening to Volts it takes a village to make this podcast work shout out especially to my super producer Kyle McDonald who makes me and my guests sound smart every week and it is
SPEAKER_01all supported entirely by listeners like you So if you value conversations like this, please consider joining our community of paid subscribers at volts.wtf or leaving a nice review or telling a friend about Volts or all three. Thanks so much and I'll see you next time.
This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit www.volts.wtf/subscribe When people push for better data centers, they picture hyperscalers - Amazon,...
This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit www.volts.wtf/subscribe America’s first big wave of solar power installations, built between 15 and...
This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit www.volts.wtf/subscribe The Senate’s bipartisan permitting bill got a manager’s amendment last week -...
This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit www.volts.wtf/subscribe Last week’s election was a blue wave all the way down the ballot: Democrats...
This is a free preview of a paid episode. To hear more, visit www.volts.wtf Volts published eight conversations in October, which is a lot for anyone to listen to. We’ve rounded up the highlights into less than an hour....