This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit www.volts.wtf/subscribe Are data centers and electrification going to break the US power grid, or are they the secret to making it cheaper for everyone? In this episode, I talk with Pier LaFarge of Sparkfund about Minnesota’s landmark decision to let Xcel Energy deploy batteries directly into local distribution networks. We look past the politics and map out how a battery-saturated system can socialize the benefits of load growth, ushering in an era of boringly reliable, low-cost energy by 2030.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_00Greetings, salutations everyone. This is Volts for May 20th, 2026. Sooner than you think, electricity is going to be cheap, abundant, and boring. I'm your host, David Roberts. Late last year, up in Minnesota, the power utility Xcel Energy proposed a new program called Capacity Connect that would have it deploy 200 megawatts of battery storage,
SPEAKER_00not in the form of large utility-scale installations, but in smaller chunks distributed throughout the grid placed around commercial and industrial buildings like big-box stores. It didn't draw much attention outside the energy world, but my guest today believes that it augurs a fundamentally new chapter in the history of the U.S. electricity grid and for the U.S. economy more broadly.
SPEAKER_00Back in 2024, I talked with Pierre Lafarge, the founder and CEO of Sparkfund, about his vision of a utility-led distributed energy expansion. Now he's back to make an even stronger version of the case. What Minnesota foretells is that utilities are going to start deploying distributed batteries under conventional utility cost of service rules and those batteries are going to solve all our grid problems. They will help utilities better utilize their currently wildly
underutilized grids, which in turn will enable the addition of data center load that will reduce,
SPEAKER_00rather than raise, electricity prices. Over time, with the addition of these and other batteries to the system, US electricity will become cheap, abundant, and boringly reliable. It is, to say the least, a provocative case. And I have put it in maximally provocative fashion to get you all going. Lots of people object strenuously to the notion of utilities owning distributed energy.
SPEAKER_00Lots of people are skeptical that storage can really, in practice, substitute for lots more long distance transmission and generation. Lots of folks think raw materials or geopolitics will impose limitations on the number of batteries we can access lots of people think all kinds of things and I'm going to talk with Pierre about all of them today I have been looking forward to this
SPEAKER_00With no further ado, Pierre Lafarge, welcome back to Volts. David Roberts, thanks for having me. Great to be here. So, Pierre, I've been thinking about this episode for a while, thinking about how to structure it, and I think in my sort of mildly neurodivergent adjacent way, I have come up with a structure for this episode that makes sense to me may or may not make sense to anyone else, but I'm going to lay it out for you and then we're going to do it.
SPEAKER_00I can't wait. So we're going to start with just the facts of Minnesota, what's happening in Minnesota, just the structure of it. And then from there, we're going to vault all the way up into the stratosphere and talk about batteries on the grid. What are the benefits of having a crap ton of batteries on the grid during a time of load growth and electrification? And then I want to back out from that. So what are the benefits specifically of distributed batteries?
Why might we want those batteries to be distributed throughout distribution
SPEAKER_00networks rather than clumped up in large utility scale transmission based facilities? and then thirdly in so far as we do have some preference for distributed batteries why is the way Minnesota is doing it the way to do it as opposed to other alternatives so for all of those out there who have objections and complaints about this Minnesota program we're going to get to them at the end but I want to sort of
work my way backward to it so we understand what we're aiming at let's start with
SPEAKER_00Minnesota then just tell us What is the Capacity Connect program? So in Minnesota, the largest utility there is Excel Energy, as many of your listeners know.
SPEAKER_01And what Capacity Connect was, was a program brought forth by Excel and filed as part of their integrated resource plan, which is basically their plan and how they're going to grow the grid in response to load growth and grid needs. And they put an item in there called Capacity Connect. It's an idea that SparkFun helped develop and bring to market broadly as a distributed capacity procurement process. which is really pretty straightforward. It's just what it sounds like. It's a procurement of a bunch of distributed capacity because in Excel and the Commission's view, the grid can benefit from several hundred megawatts of
batteries that can charge up
SPEAKER_01when there's plenty of energy on the grid. dispatch when there's peak and constraint and in doing so actually help operate the grid more efficiently sell more electrons over that grid and make the grid stronger or reliable more capable of handling intermittent renewables and also make power cheaper if there's someone to buy it so Minnesota capacity connect was a 200 megawatt regulatory filing that was approved in I think a you know historic 5-0 vote several weeks ago at a commission hearing
SPEAKER_00That's significant, right? We should pause on that. That's not taken for granted at all. This was a long discussion.
SPEAKER_01Indeed.
SPEAKER_00And contentious.
SPEAKER_01No question. And received quite a bit of pushback from, in particular, the distributed solar industry. But at the end of the day, it was also exciting to see a commission ultimately evaluate a proposal to make batteries. Dr. Justin Marchegiani
Right and this I think is a key feature to understand here is that these are not genco right excel is a restructured utility it's only a distribution utility it doesn't own generation assets so this filing treats batteries as distribution
SPEAKER_00infrastructure the same as if they were building transformers or power lines right and Excel is going to own the batteries this is crucial so talk about the sort of financial arrangement well one one correction Excel is vertically integrated and they source their power through competitive RFPs right from the market they're part of my so which is the the regional operator power market so they are vertically integrated but it doesn't change the importance
SPEAKER_01I think the reason that this decision is historic is regardless of the regulatory structure or market structure of Minnesota. This is a commission saying quite simply that batteries fix so many of the problems on the grid. It helps us utilize it better. It makes it more reliable. It makes it better. Dr. Justin Marchegiani
SPEAKER_01There's another really interesting element of Capacity Connect, which is that instead of a complicated bill savings or a customer taking out debt, this is a model that lets customers and community groups all over Minnesota benefit from the wealth of infrastructure build that's used to support a growing grid.
SPEAKER_00So just to clarify that the utility owns these batteries. So it goes to a facility, a big box store, and basically says, can we rent your roof? Just treating the roof basically as a piece of land, just as if it went and put a field of batteries in some greenfield outside of town somewhere. The financial structure is basically the same. You're just renting a piece of land. That's right. The only financial... you know deal that the big box store owner is involved in is he just gets a check every month a rent check basically not involved with the energy
doesn't own it doesn't operate it doesn't mess with the batteries the batteries are owned and
SPEAKER_00operated and maintained by the utility That's right. And, you know, we're renting sides of parking lots, backfields, unused land.
SPEAKER_01It's a few thousand square feet. And, you know, we're giving, you know, think about a church. One of our first hosts in Minnesota is going to be a local church. and that church is going to get real money every month for 20 years ultimately to help them run their community programs and run their operations right so participating in infrastructure wealth I think always is best when it's unburdened by asking that customer who you know look this is a church yes they do a lot of things well in their community but they don't have to think about probably
SPEAKER_00Don't have an energy division. Yeah.
SPEAKER_01You know, they're not meant to be taking complicated bets on long term energy arbitrage or regulatory structures or making sure that their price of debt is covered by their revenue. Right. You know, these are people who wake up every day and participate in their community and go to their jobs and really focus on what they do best. And, you know, the utility in this case shows up, rents land, gives them money that improves their core business. And then the grid gets stronger and and more capable of supporting growth. so when we talk about chunks of batteries give the audience
some sense of scale here like how big is a typical utility scale battery field and then sort of where is the line as you go down where you sort of cross into distributed quote unquote distributed is there a line is there a an accepted threshold yeah you know most utility scale batteries which are connected to the transmission system and help
SPEAKER_01smooth out the timing of power or call it 150 megawatts to 300 megawatts but even those big utility installations are built out of a lot of the same sized one to two megawatt batteries they're in shipping containers it's all Legos yeah stacking little Legos in a field and then they inject all at once and they look like a power plant from the perspective of
SPEAKER_00the grid right
SPEAKER_01And utility scale batteries are fantastic. They are absolutely part of why batteries are going to transform the grid. So utility scale batteries are the first to scale and a critical part of what I think you're kind of framing in that. But look, these distributed batteries, they are one to three megawatts. per location as filed. They are shipping container batteries. They are prepackaged. They are engineering templatized. They're standardized. So you get a lot of the critical cost efficiencies that you get from a utility scale battery. You've just broken it into to little pieces and 200 megawatts is a substantial utility
scale contribution in
SPEAKER_01aggregate, but it's put exactly where the grid needs it most at the local level. So the utility and spark fund are working to determine where on the And when you incorporate them into the grid, and you operate them 100% for the benefit of the grid, that is just the same as a utility investing in a new substance. That ultimately delivers that value to society. And I think that's why this commission decision is so historic.
This is the first moment that hundreds of megawatts of distributed batteries are
SPEAKER_01going to be incorporated on the distribution grid Dr. Justin Marchegiani So it really is, I think, a big step. In the entire United States, last year in 2025, the country installed just shy of 200 megawatts of these sort of middle sized commercial industrial battery installations called 191 megawatts in the entire country. So to see one state Dr. Justin Marchegiani
let's talk about our I think shared vision of a grid with crap tons of batteries on it let's put aside for now the question of where the batteries are located how big the batteries are let's just talk about a grid with cumulatively a crap ton of
SPEAKER_00batteries on it why do we want to get there Well, I think the simplest way to put it is batteries are electron time machines.
SPEAKER_01And why does that matter? Why do you need an electron time machine? You know, we built our grid to peak, which means we built the grid to be big enough to handle, you know, the tightest, highest demand, 50 to 100 hours of the year. And that wasn't a mistake, right? A lot of people hear that and they're like, oh, that's, you know, you overbuilt the grid. No, no, you built the grid to be the size that gives us the economy and the society. We have the reliable power, the cheap power. So we built the grid to peak. And it's worth noting that America has the cheapest,
most reliable power in the world, right?
SPEAKER_01It's easy to forget that in these discussions. This thing works on a delivered basis and a reliability basis and a cost basis. But we built the grid to peak. And by necessity of the technology available, right, big centralized generation, transmission, distribution, that meant that for most of the hours of the year you were almost by definition not using much of the grid you just built.
SPEAKER_00Yes, a familiar problem. Same with cars, same with a lot of big systems. It's kind of something that you don't really notice until you start noticing. Like with cars, you just look around and you're like, oh, right. Like most cars are sitting most of the time. Most roads are unoccupied most of the time. Exactly.
SPEAKER_01And people buy cars so that they can go to the grocery store, but they don't go to the grocery store every hour, right? but it's very important that when you need to get somewhere that you have effective transportation and it's interesting and I might cut this because it's a real diversion but I've been kind of thinking about it it's interesting we built electricity to the peak meaning we have made a social contract saying you can use as much as you want and we will provide it period full stop right we don't do that
SPEAKER_00with like highways or healthcare or with highways, we do restrict capacity. There are going to be times when there's congestion and you can't get to your destination in your preferred amount of time. Like we do restrict supply in almost every other system in our society. So this is a unique and interesting and different kind of system where we've just pledged use as much as you want whenever you want and we'll build a
system big enough to make sure it's there when you want it that's a remarkable thing it's a historic triumph and I think it's core to this discussion and a populist thing I think this is what you're getting at but like an incredibly egalitarian and populist thing
SPEAKER_01absolutely I think it's one of the great triumphs of you know American infrastructure there's this element to this where you know there are several things in our society that we deem to be kind of to put it formally inelastic which means people deserve to use as much of them as they need and not be limited in that quantity right and water is one of those things you wouldn't have a water system that said oh sorry it's hard to you for you to have drinking water now or you just can't take showers this time of day sorry let's do pricing to make sure only rich people get the water that would
be terrible
SPEAKER_01Right. We would see that as a real political,
SPEAKER_00although that is the way it works in many places, like in many places, egalitarian that we don't do it that way.
SPEAKER_01Yes, sir. And this is, again, why I count it as a uniquely American infrastructure triumph, because we live on a big, abundant continent with a lot of resources. And we have as a society made some dramatic choices and you can code them however you want. but they are egalitarian choices to say we are going to have enough power enough water clean air right like we are going to make investments as a society with a cost to deliver things that help human flourishing and keep people safe happy and
productive so that we can achieve that national goal and power was one of the early it was before we invested nationally in our water system right we did this in the
SPEAKER_0130s and even more Then the commitment to have enough power for society's needs and growth to build a great nation. We also made an incredible decision of rural electrification that said you have an obligation to serve if you build a house or a cabin. Anywhere in the territory of a U.S. electric utility, that utility is obligated by law, chartered in public purpose, to deliver power to that cabin. String a line, cut down trees, get up the driveway. And that is just a staggering and now terrifying
One of the things I always say to people is try to imagine if we had a similar
SPEAKER_00social compact around driving. If you want to drive, you should be able to drive straight to your destination. That we would have to build to accommodate that if we just told people you can do it whenever you want and then if you did that people would immediately start thinking you know what maybe we should figure out ways of persuading people to drive at different times so
that we don't have this enormous peak and we don't have to build this elaborate
SPEAKER_00roadway structure so segueing back to electricity we've promised everyone electricity whenever they want it and consequently we have built a system that will provide the peak as you say the most anyone could want at any moment within a year we've built that much infrastructure and now we have a bunch of infrastructure that's not being utilized this gets back to the grid utilization discussion we're utilizing our grid at a rate of about 50% so about 50% of all
this money and investment we've plowed into this infrastructure is sitting idle because of this
SPEAKER_00social compact and this is where batteries come in that's right and you know we've deemed electricity to be a inelastic good a natural monopoly something that we want as much as we need for the purposes of our society we've regulated it to make sure that the way in which that's done is balancing all
SPEAKER_01Yeah, that's a great question. And maybe one final note, this social compact about electricity is
SPEAKER_00is like incredibly significant and important, but is only going to get more significant and more important as more and more of the services we use in our day-to-day life are run on electricity. And eventually as our entire economy is run on electricity, then all of a sudden you can have as much as you want whenever you want. It really starts to seem like a much bigger and more consequential pledge and then you really have to start worrying about overbuilding right like if everything is electric the amount of overbuilding you know that
you would have to do if you didn't care about peaks would just be insane so we have to start caring about peaks again this where batteries come in that's right from our daily lives to national security to critical infrastructure the grid is going to be one of the great foundational inputs of this next chapter of our economy as it was in the last
SPEAKER_01and Batteries have this really unique superpower, which, as I said before, they're electron time machines, which has one simple function, which is charge up when there's plenty in those periods of underutilization when the grid is not being stressed. You can charge a battery, you fill it with electrons, and then you can wait and move them in time until the and you discharge that battery and when that battery is in the
right place it at a physics level relieves the constraint on that grid it meets the peak in a more dynamic and locationally valuable way and there you go you can sell more electrons over the same wires yeah so let's talk about that because this is something that people break their brains on and I think it's really important to understand and
SPEAKER_00with, and this is an important caveat, with sufficient batteries in place added load can reduce rather than raise prices. Furthermore, and I'll make it more specific and more provocative, we could accommodate all these data centers and they could lower rates. That is a possible world. Explain how and why.
SPEAKER_01I think this is why the whole debate, which is now so politically hot around electricity, is going to end up being pretty boring. Because cheap batteries and data center demand happening at the same time plus some normal building out of new transmission and generation. We're going to need some of that, too. But, you know, those two things happening at the same time pretty much solve the grid. The cost of electricity is downstream of a pretty simple formula in most places, which is how much did you spend on your wires to get the power to people?
And in most cases, that's 60, 70 or even 80 plus percent of all the cost of power.
SPEAKER_01Right. Generation is actually just a smaller piece. so it's the wires simply put you spend money on the wires and then the price of electricity is how many units of your product can you sell across those wires and if you can invest in a technology like batteries that just fundamentally at a physics level lets you sell more over the grid then the only other thing you need David is someone to buy those electrons which is why data center demand and demand from electric cars and home
electrification are such good news because the more we buy over the same wires the cheaper power gets for everyone right so the premise here is and I think it's important to surface
SPEAKER_00this Additional load can bring down average prices as long as adding the additional load does not require you to add a ton of new infrastructure, right? If you're adding more load but using the same fixed infrastructure, you're spreading the cost out over a wider customer base and thus per unit costs are lower. Exactly right. If you add load and in order to meet that load,
SPEAKER_00you have to build a bunch of new wires and transmission and generators, then you don't get that effect. So this effect only is in place as if you're adding load without having to add new infrastructure to carry the load. Yeah. Or at least while you're having to, you have to do both. You're adding batteries, which are, I guess, technically the infrastructure, but they're so much cheaper than Yeah, yeah, I wanted to ask about that. So like this effect, adding load reduces prices.
SPEAKER_00presumes slack capacity on your system, right? You're adding load to soak up that slack capacity. That's what the batteries allow you to do, right? Whenever you have generation capacity, just put it in the batteries and then absorb it whenever you need it. So new load absorbing slack capacity means that you can add new load and bring down prices, right? That's correct. but the question then becomes how much of that slack capacity
you know what I mean I want to give people a sense of scale how long can you do that before you eventually have squeezed out the slack capacity and are forced to build more generators and more transmission lines because you need fundamentally more capacity so like how much runway do we have before we need to build new stuff anyway I think it's a really important question to ask for two reasons and one you know just a level set we have a grid that's about 1200 gigawatts of nameplate there are a lot of different ways to approach this and you know we've done some studies on it
utilize coalition has done some studies on it which spark funds a part of I'd say that horseshoes and grenades it's 200 to 400 gigawatts that you could get from increased utilization and you'd end up putting a couple hundred billion dollars of downward pressure on rates it's significant it's more than the very near term
SPEAKER_01So, this is just to sort of situate things. This gives us like, I don't know, call it 10 years, call it a decade. of runway where we can accommodate all this data center rush and lower prices
SPEAKER_00without building a gigantic amount of brand new infrastructure, which we can't do in the short term anyway, as we know. But the larger electrification of the economy, I mean, never mind data centers, as you say, everything's coming onto the electrical grid. We are eventually going to squeeze out that slack capacity and we are eventually going to have to build more, more, more. We are going to have to expand. And the reason I'm making this so explicit is that as you probably are following, there's a weird kind of very dumb fight happening in the green
community between
SPEAKER_00the sort of utilized people and the permitting reform people, the people who say, hey, we need to squeeze out this slack capacity and the people who say, hey, no, we need to build more, more, more. and of course if you get anyone in a room and sit them down and talk to them reasonably everyone's going to agree you need both but I just want to sort of like frame this you acknowledge we need both and you're mostly pushing this as a short to midterm strategy, right?
SPEAKER_01That's right. And it's not just eventually we'll need to build more. It's starting right now. We need to build as much transmission and as much new generation from gas to wind to solar to industrial, like geothermal. I mean, we need as much as we can. And the reason we should do that is because exactly as you said, it is hard and slow to build large centralized infrastructure projects. It takes five, seven, sometimes 10 years or longer for transmission. so utilization is a way to maximize the total energy abundance
of the US electric infrastructure today to deliver on near-term growth and do that in a way that specifically puts downward pressure on rates and makes power cheaper oh and by the way invest in a bunch of machines like batteries and grid flexibility demand response you know grid enhancing technologies that help the grid be stronger more reliable better able to resist weather and better able to deliver intermittent
SPEAKER_01resources so it's a good thing to do now it's a good thing to do as much of it as we can but we need to be in parallel building as much new American power infrastructure as we can to win the future and I'd also like to point out that the standards by which utilities determine the engineering safety and requirements of the grid actually do matter we do not want the grid to melt I often say to people before you cast shade Dr. Justin Marchegiani
SPEAKER_01And take a breath on endless optimization. Dr. Justin Marchegiani And I just want to emphasize this point one more time, which is, I know there are people who are concerned that the current focus on affordability is
among dims is pushing them toward degrowth and scarcity degrowth and scarcity coded solutions yeah and so it's important to surface what you're saying here is that you can shovel all the data centers on the grid you want and bring down rates and serve
SPEAKER_00affordability right these are not in tension as long as you have a crap ton of batteries.
SPEAKER_01That's right. That's it. Batteries and data center demand, solve it. And the tragedy, David, is not only is that politics of degrowth and scarcity toxic and tragic, it's also just wrong on the merits. And you have this opportunity to have more and make things cheaper, and we need to take it. It's responsibly managed growth.
SPEAKER_00The thing is, the Democratic Party, Pierre, it causes me such surus. They are in the right, they're on the right side of history here if they would just argue for their side. But you look out at the landscape and everything they're doing is basically, everything they're doing in the name of affordability begins by conceding the premise of Republican attacks. They're rolling back energy efficiency programs now. I was like oh we've been arguing for decades that those things
lower rates and now you're gonna concede to Republicans that they're raising consumer prices like that's your savvy affordability play it just drives me mad I can't get pulled down that road so to summarize the point you're making here when you have a crap ton of
SPEAKER_00batteries on your grid a lot of batteries it basically solves the affordability problem allows you to bring in new load in a way that uses slack capacity doesn't require a bunch of more building and reduces per unit cost reduces rates for everyone and this is the future that you're looking toward is a future where the grid is filled with batteries and consequently it's boring it just works it's cheap you get
electricity for pretty cheap you get as much as you want it works it's reliable and then hallelujah you can stop thinking about it and start thinking about other things you want to do with your life welcome to the age of boring cheap batteries data center demand and
SPEAKER_01a few other good investments in the US electric grid will bring us back to where we've been for much of the last hundred years, which is the grid is public infrastructure. We don't have to think that much about and we can go about our lives, build our economies and have our infrastructure and win the future in a way that I think is really compelling. so this is the vision of a grid with a lot of batteries on it right a grid that goes from no storage to a lot of storage fundamental change allows accommodation of a new load without raising prices allows you to bring prices
down solves these reliability issues and with smart inverters I think also you know you get your ancillary services you get your black start you get your frequency regulation you
SPEAKER_00know you have a very safe electronically software controlled stable grid when you have a crap load of batteries so the second question I want to address then is are batteries batteries is any battery on the grid as good as any other battery on the grid or is there any reason to prefer distributed batteries over utility scale
SPEAKER_01batteries that's a great question and I'll answer it in two ways One, I think it's just important to make the point that my view is that we are going to put batteries everywhere and of all sizes, big ones in fields, medium sized ones, which is what SparkFun does for a living in parking lots and in fields near churches and Walmarts and stuff like that. Then you're also going to have residential batteries in the home and garages. You're going to have embedded batteries in heating and air conditioning, right? Like what carrier is working on.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, let me put an explanation point on that because it's huge and I think a lot of
SPEAKER_00people don't see it coming, which is that ACs are going to start embedding batteries and there are a lot of AC units out there in the world. So like once your HVAC has a battery in it, your stove has a battery in it, your water heater will probably have a battery and you're going to have batteries in every device, in every appliance, in every house, in every garage, in every car, in every field, in every I would point out, David, we already have them in every pocket and on every desk.
It's not like the battery revolution we're pointing to is like some science fiction future.
SPEAKER_01We're carrying them around.
SPEAKER_00Let me ask you, why do that? Why not just put them all in utility scale installations in a big field somewhere and not mess with the rest of it? What performance or social advantage do you get from the distribution of them?
SPEAKER_01So there are two big groups of batteries. One are batteries that are big enough and have specialized telemetry that utilities can see and operate in their control room today as true grid assets. And utilities, you actually have an incredible amount of data about power plants, what a power plant is doing every second. Same with utility scale batteries. So batteries that are call it one megawatt and bigger, you can afford to build that telemetry onto them and you can show it and connect it into a utility. They can operate it in their normal course today.
SPEAKER_01That is a big part of Capacity Connect in Minnesota. These are utility controlled assets because they have the data quality and telemetry that allows a utility to integrate them into their control room. And when a utility can see a battery that clearly, it can dispatch it and it can accredit it, give it credit for the capacity it's creating on both the distribution and transmission system. It knows that it's not going to trip any thermal limits or voltage.
SPEAKER_00Right.
SPEAKER_01You can plan around it. You can rely on it because it's yours. Well, if you can't see something, you can't use it in high critical environments like the grid, right? Stuff melts, fires could create, right? So that accreditation allows utility scale batteries and the distributed capacity kind of missing middle that Sparkfund I think is helping fill with these distributed capacity procurements. Those batteries I think will go first because they're the easiest to bring into the core of grid operations as they stand today. But the batteries we're putting near buildings have a really
particular characteristic. They can be sited on the distribution grid closer to the infrastructure that needs it most. And the closer the battery is to the load that it's serving and the infrastructure
SPEAKER_01it's using, the more it can directly benefit that customer and that infrastructure. So if you have a residential neighborhood filled with houses that have EVs, electric cars, right? And a bunch of air conditioners that are now kind of Toyota Priuses, right? They're hybrids, right? They can, as they spin up and it gets cold in your house, it's coming from a battery that charged up while there was plenty. Well, think about that. It's the same metaphor. They charged up when there was plenty, when no one was using their electric appliances in that neighborhood. And then when everyone turns them on at once, they all self-serve.
SPEAKER_01So the proximity of a battery to load is, you know, in some ways a direct relationship to the value it has to alleviate that load on the grid. And that's actually why air conditioners are a great kind of way to think about this because it's like, okay, put the battery inside the air conditioner and it can directly alleviate the peak stress that that air conditioner puts on. on the grid. Same with the capacity connect batteries. You put them in a commercial industrial feeder or a part of the grid that has a bunch of coincident load and needs that stress relief.
SPEAKER_01Well, you put a battery there and when the grid gets crowded and congested, you turn the battery on and alleviate that stress at the level of that distribution node or feeder.
SPEAKER_00Right, so to rephrase this, people talk about the battery stack, the value stack of batteries, the different values they bring, the different benefits they bring. You could say that utility scale battery installation in a field somewhere has certain benefits, but if you break them apart and put them on the distribution grid, you get the same benefits and then more benefits stacked on top. You get performance benefits and resilience benefits on top of the basic battery benefits that's
right and something I think our industry needs to get more disciplined about doing and actually something we're working on I think broadly at spark fund is mapping out the distinct revenue streams or value streams right not all of them are revenue right but value streams that batteries and things like demand response and and grid
SPEAKER_01flexibility can provide and you know I'd say there's like depending on how you splice it seven or eight of them and we need to make a list and just stack up which ones each company or each type of battery thinks they provide yeah yeah I mean you think that kind of would have been somewhat formalized already but you'd think and even worse David I mean I think we're really suffering from a bunch of companies whose equipment does like one two three or four of those things Dr. Justin Marchegiani And then utilities and regulators and
legislators get a little confused and actually sometimes feel a little annoyed when they realize they're
SPEAKER_01like, wait, we've been spending a year talking about this and it doesn't do the thing that I need it to do. And they're like, well, no, of course it doesn't. But if we changed a bunch of variables and had a ton of new software, then it could in the future do it. And people are just disappointed because they're like, oh, I have a very urgent problem. Yeah, you know, I did a pod a couple of weeks ago about an attempt to do something like that for
SPEAKER_00VPPs, you know, sort of like a rating system, like how close to an actual power plant is it? And I think something like that for batteries, too, just like of the stackable value streams that batteries could potentially bring, How many are manifest in this installation? So let me ask you then, because Southern Company, listeners will be familiar, Big Utility down in Georgia, kind of notoriously vertically integrated, jealous of its territory,
SPEAKER_00unenthused by climate activism, let's say, etc. They have gotten religion on batteries, but they are not distributing them. they are clumping them up in giant utility scale installations but it sounds like they're getting a lot of the benefits out of them you know what I mean and as you mentioned you now can't sell one of your distributed capacity procurements to Southern because the amount of batteries they've already installed as
sort of as we mentioned before kind of reduce that arbitrage our opportunity to the point that you can't squeeze a lot more out with distributed batteries so talk a little bit about Southern Company their experience and then just tell me like why you know if
SPEAKER_00I'm a IOU executive like a Duke executive or something you know I'm and I'm looking at Southern Company and I was like, well, they just are building and owning large scale battery facilities and seem to be getting all the benefits they want out of that. Why should I futz about with distribution when I could just do that?
SPEAKER_01Right. And to put some numbers to it, you know, in one of their integrated resource plans, they had something like, I don't know, 50, 60 megawatts of batteries over the next bunch of years coming onto that.
SPEAKER_00That was just a few years ago.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. And then, you know, in this latest update, they signed a bunch of contracts with large load customers and data centers, which will, by the way, put billions of dollars of downward pressure on rates for everyone who lives in Georgia, right? They are making power cheaper every time they sign a new data center. That's the thing. If you just like take one thing away from this podcast, every utility, every state who signs a big data center will end up with cheaper power if that load is managed correctly.
SPEAKER_00If they've got a bunch of batteries and they manage the load correctly, which is a substantial if.
SPEAKER_01It is. But I think to your point, that's why this example with Southern is so compelling, which is this is a utility who is chartered in the public interest to spend money, to invest in the grid, to deliver the lowest cost, most reliable way to meet growth. So growth shows up. data center asks for power utility planners go to work and it turns out right now based on cost and value the answer is batteries and by the way the reason they're all utility scale is that the grid in the southeast is most constrained by transmission it is not very constrained by distribution.
SPEAKER_01So they put the batteries, like I said before, closest to the problem they have and the customer they want to serve. And batteries are just as good at charging up when there's underutilization and charging from a gas plant or a coal plant as they are from wind and solar. Batteries just smooth out electricity and time. That's why I call them time machines. And you end up getting more out of the grid you have, dividing the cost of the wires and you sell it to a data center and everything gets cheaper and better. Dr. Justin Marchegiani And Southern Company is a great example of a utility,
SPEAKER_01a large IOU that basically did this overnight. what is the latest it's six thousand five hundred six thousand eight hundred thousands right six point eight gigawatts of batteries or so yes and I forget the exact number not a small I mean that's that bespeaks someone inside that utility having a revelation of sorts right like you don't go from 50 to
6,000 it's a
SPEAKER_01hundred somebody inside the utility It's a hundred X. I mean, but this is the thing is we spend so much time in this industry, David, talking about, oh, how utility incentives are broken. The thing that was missing is load growth. Like utilities have been sitting there the whole time saying, thank you very much. I'm incentivized to spend money to build infrastructure. Dr. Justin Marchegiani And what my incentive is, is build things society needs that the regulator says is the lowest cost, most reliable way to do that. And when these machines get cheap enough,
SPEAKER_01and when load growth comes back and creates the need, a utility simply does the math and delivers the outcome.
SPEAKER_00Well, a utility, not all utilities, I guess. I mean southern company is the iconic you know what I mean like if people come up with examples of like who's going to be the last to get on something clean or something progressive or whatever they cite southern company so the fact that this revelation has happened inside southern company is quite significant should we assume that other utilities are going to be like well if southern you know what I mean like this is not excel and this is not California if Southern is doing this surely it must
be the obvious thing to do like is this going to unlock a similar 10x in other utilities age of boring David and you know I would say there are other examples like Indiana Indiana and Michigan AEP just announced that with data centers and a bunch of
SPEAKER_01flexibility and batteries, they're going to lower rates for everyone, right? PG&E said, every time we get a new gigawatt of data center load, we're going to drop power prices by one to 2%. And guess what? The ones we've already signed are making power 11% cheaper than it would have be. Now, California, you've got a lot of wildfires to pay for, so it may not get actually cheaper, but California has got its own problems.
SPEAKER_00Yes. Yes. But the data centers are pushing down prices because of the batteries. We can't say that often enough because it so bounces against people's instincts. That's right. We're getting the politics and the grid discussion of data centers impact 100% wrong.
SPEAKER_01We're getting it backwards. and every state that does not get data center growth is going to have an aging grid they have to pay to replace the cost of the wires are going to rise they're going to be divided over too little new growth and power will get more expensive power Dr. Justin Marchegiani And a big chunk of it is that some of this stuff was installed in the 60s and 70s and entropy always wins the argument and you
got to replace it and it's old it's breaking the second piece is that we've had you know a bunch of renewables come onto the grid that are cheap to generate but require the grid to
SPEAKER_01take the shock of intermittent power when it gets very windy and or very sunny. So we've made some investments in things like capacity banks to handle that. And affordable batteries at scale are a new thing.
SPEAKER_00That's right. That is a new category of distribution infrastructure that is now available to utilities. Hey there, everybody. Don't worry, I'm not gonna tell you about a new mattress or push a credit card on you. This isn't an ad. There are no ads on Volts. It is supported entirely by listeners like you. If you'll indulge me for a second, I'd like to ask for your support. I started Volts because we're all surrounded by depressing news about climate change and misinformation about clean energy.
And it's never been more important to share the stories of the real people on the ground doing the real work of transition and all the ingenuity and courage and
SPEAKER_00public spirit they are bringing to it. People are hungry to hear these stories, to learn from and find inspiration in them. I've heard from people who change majors or careers after hearing episodes of Volts. People using it in classrooms, community groups, even state legislators who have passed bills inspired by specific episodes. Sharing these stories matters. It makes a difference. If you have found value in it and want to help me continue doing it, I hope you will join the community of paid subscribers at volts.wtf it's about the
cost of a cup of coffee a month if you don't like subscriptions you can make a one-time contribution leave a review on Apple or Spotify or just tell a friend about volts I am grateful for any and all support if you're already a paid
SPEAKER_00subscriber thank you and now back to the show Affordable batteries at scale are a new thing. That is a new category of distribution infrastructure that is now available to utilities.
SPEAKER_01Batteries, because they're products, because you can put them in shipping containers and standardize the design. and build, you know, millions of inverters and cathodes and anodes and power electronics and factories. You can drive the cost way, way down, just like solar panels. The cost of a battery since 1999 has gone down by like 99.5%, right? By, you know, just in the last five years, they've come down another 85%, right?
SPEAKER_00And here we are looking at this future of massive load growth. Like forget data centers, again, forget data centers beyond that. load growth to the horizon. Transportation, heating and cooling, industry, load growth, load growth, load growth. And here we have in our hands a tool that renders load growth a mechanism of reducing rates. So here we have load growth and batteries in hand,
meaning abundant energy for cheaper.
SPEAKER_00Amen. Just gonna emphasize that one more time. All right so so we've discussed the virtues of having a crap ton of batteries on the grid and discussed a little bit when and where there are merits in distributing them versus clumping them like is your congestion in your problem on your transmission grid or is it in your distribution grids you basically want to clump the batteries near the problem and in many places the problem is distributed and so you'll clump the batteries in a distributed way so
SPEAKER_00Assuming then we want some distributed batteries, let's talk about the merits of the way it's happening in Minnesota specifically. So, you know, I guess the first thing I'd ask is how committed is Excel to this approach? I know the PUC told Excel, hey, you should also study... the VPP model that they're doing in Colorado so it doesn't like this is like one approach still among others so I guess um a lot of questions about this maybe the
first one is just like compare this to a VPP why might this be preferable to a VPP how do you sort of view this in relation to VPPs and just the distinction for
SPEAKER_00anybody who's not following it These batteries that we're talking about in Minnesota are owned and operated purely by the utility, purely for grid benefit. They are not operated for the benefit of the customer who is hosting them. I mean, except insofar as, you know, everybody on the grid benefits from grid stability, but they did get no specific benefit. Whereas a VPP is taking behind the meter, not in front of the meter, but behind the meter resources,
and doing this dance where they're primarily operated for the benefit of the
SPEAKER_00building owner and then secondarily operated for the benefit of the grid. That's kind of what a VPP is. So I'm just curious your thoughts about how these two relate and the relative merits. In the world we're talking about,
SPEAKER_01I think the best distinction is there are true grid assets, right, that are 100% operated for system benefit. Every value dollar that's created for the grid gets socialized to everyone. and then there are assets that are paid for by customers and therefore the customers have a right to get benefit from them and so those assets primarily serve the customer value but then also if they can be used for the grid then the grid should pay them And that's the difference between the AVPP program in Colorado and the Capacity Connect program in Minnesota. You know, in both cases,
this is Excel bringing an innovative proposal to their regulator and saying,
SPEAKER_01here's a thing we could try to make the grid more flexible, better utilized.
SPEAKER_00It's Excel in Colorado, too. Somehow it hadn't put together that it was the same.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, same utility. They're trying different models to learn which one delivers the best benefit. You know, look, I think that when utilities like this industry is very quick to point out when utilities don't do things that they like, but when they do things that are innovative and forward leaning, they end up attacking them anyway for it. And Excel was attacked in both states for both of these proposals. And then they were attacked comparing the two to each other. And it just it's so bad and everything is broken. And oh, you know, People say monopoly and forget to say public purpose regulated monopoly right are utilities perfect no but the regulated compact in which they
are allowed to invest private capital for public purpose to grow a grid that supports our economy is a
SPEAKER_01pretty good system that Sure, I mean that's a that's a fifth of one giant data center just tiny so we have to
remember the scale
SPEAKER_01of the grid this is a landscape scale machine And I think really the advantage of the Capacity Connect program is that it's asking the question, and hopefully if we in Excel do our job, it'll prove the point that batteries are just the next boring generation of distribution grid infrastructure. They're no different than substations, transformers, capacity banks. They just have this new superpower, which is that they can move electrons through space and time, and you can put them next to the problem and deliver the value.
SPEAKER_00But then, I would say the central objection that people have had to the Capacity Connect program is that it puts utilities in charge utilities own and have a monopoly over these battery installations and of course a lot of people which excludes the sort of private model that currently rules where private providers go house to house sell these things to homeowners etc
and so there's a real question about democracy here about energy democracy which I
SPEAKER_00would like you to address I know because we've known each other for a bit I know you to be committed to local community and local democracy specifically I know you value local democracy and a lot of people are coming to this with energy democracy with local energy democracy in their minds saying why shouldn't Dr. Justin Marchegiani I know it's a funny part of my life.
SPEAKER_01I spend much of my personal and political time advocating for locally led decentralization solutions in the abundance movement. And then, you know, in energy, I'm advocating for decentralized batteries and people are like, Oh,
SPEAKER_00like this guy likes monopolies.
SPEAKER_01You know, look, I think there's a difference between civic infrastructure for public purpose and just a generic monopoly. But look, I think that at the end of the day, the reality of of a grid is that it is public infrastructure in Minnesota. And this was very specific to the decision that the commission came down with, David, right in this five zero vote. And they put this intentionally and with great legal specificity. I encourage those among your listeners who are truly truly the most wonderful nerds to go and and look at the transcript look at the
hearing right this is public record it's a civic process and the commission said
SPEAKER_01very particularly legally speaking the grid is owned by the rate payers Grit operators just take private money Wall Street's money they build the grid and then are given a guaranteed or partially guaranteed return so that everyone can use it and they use it by paying for power and so the legal status of the grid is it's owned by the ratepayers and when a battery is installed on it the utility compact says I really do think the word infrastructure or the concept of
infrastructure is key here
SPEAKER_00because we have been, the conventional model to date is basically to treat distributed energy resources as a consumer item, as a consumer market item, right? Like we sell to the consumers who want them. That is not how we treat infrastructure financially.
SPEAKER_01And to your point, I very much support, and I think Excel supports and has a range of programs that are very specific to allow third party ownership. There's a program called Battery Connect where third parties can bring and own batteries and get paid for the value they give to the grid. But remember, all those batteries are splitting their value between the customer and the grid. This program says these batteries are just 100% dedicated to the grid because now batteries are so darn valuable to the grid in the way that we've been talking about now on this episode.
SPEAKER_01So Just to pause here, in Minnesota...
SPEAKER_00Private distributed energy resource developers still exist, can still sell their wares to customers. The PUC, the utility, is not preventing them from doing anything in particular.
SPEAKER_01No, there are many existing programs that explicitly allow, and not only allow, but are only for third-party ownership and participation. There's a huge community solar industry in law in Minnesota, right, with almost a gigawatt of third-party owned community solar. So I think frankly one of the opposition points that I found surprising and somewhat disingenuous was that this one program which is designed to test and validate the idea that batteries can become a core part of normal grid operating infrastructure Right the boring stuff on the grid was attacked on that ground
by a group of advocates who I think have gotten a little bit lost in whether or not the grid exists to let them invest in and privately profit from the ownership of their assets or whether it's public infrastructure that under certain conditions of
SPEAKER_01mutual value and coincident need those private owners can and should be allowed to apply to you know own assets and take some value if they can provide some value I mean I'm all for third-party ownership and I think the trade of value is often good for the grid and good for the private owner but it's not the point of the grid right and another objection is if we allow private actors to make these investments they then private investors
SPEAKER_00take on the risk and if the demand forecast or the economics business model, whatever it is, doesn't work out, it's private investors who lose the money. In this model, the utility takes the risks, but it's rate payers who pay if things go poorly. This is another common criticism. How do you think about that?
SPEAKER_01Well, I think it comes down to value and risk, right? When private investors build assets and apply to you know participate in the grid they take risk and they also take their opportunity for profit and upside which is totally appropriate and then the upside they create they keep the grid is operated by a regulated system right a civic compact that finds other private owners right the other weird thing about this is utilities are also private owners right it's always strange when one side says to the other you have a capital
incentive to deploy more money or have a shareholder incentive to give returns to your shareholders like do all companies not have shareholders and an incentive to grow their business I don't I've never quite understood why that's a kind of ground
SPEAKER_01for debate but one private owner the utility is the regulated grid operator who gets a fixed return and then every value dollar every dollar of value created above that return is socialized to the benefit of all ratepayers because again legally the ratepayers own the grid that the operator is chartered to deliver And so that distinction, I think, is neither one is better or worse. Both should be allowed. Both should be celebrated. Think about the beginning of our conversation when we were
talking about how one of the foundational inputs into the future of America's success as a nation is,
SPEAKER_01you know, from our daily lives to our national defense to have more electric power for more purposes. So we want all of it. This is like the grid growth version of all of the above. Like, let's go. Let's get this stuff out there. What about the idea if you're a private actor you're you're somewhat disciplined by this risk of loss whereas if you have a guaranteed high return on investment like the utilities do the criticism goes you're not gonna get spending discipline you're
SPEAKER_00gonna spend ratepayers' money profligately and without proper analysis because you're not disciplined the way the private market is. Do you think that high guaranteed return on investment removes discipline? I mean, do you buy that critique?
SPEAKER_01Well, I think the thing it misses is that the regulator exists. And something that sort of bums me out about this is there's this whole group of civic servants and a bunch of staff who spend their whole day with legal power and charter from the state making sure that the way in which these procurements are built and delivered meets a reasonable standard of prudency.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, but we know... that PUCs are of varying quality, varying levels of knowledge, varying levels of friendliness to industry. You know, these are longstanding critiques of the regulators, too.
SPEAKER_01They are. And look, I think one of my other political beliefs is the next chapter of American politics needs to fall back in love with civic engagement and civic compacts. We need to pay regulators more. We need to have more staff.
SPEAKER_00Administrative capacity. I wish I had one of those sound effect machines so that I could play some sort of whoop, whoop, whoop. I'm not just pro utility I'm pro utility regulated compact and I think that that system like you can debate the history and its individual decisions but the point I actually wanted to make which is more specific to your challenge of does a regulated system incorporate the dynamics of competitiveness and innovation and the answer is yes not because the regulator is perfect or
all-knowing or all-powerful but because the regulator can simply require as it did in this procurement that the way in which these assets are procured includes competition spark funds job in this capacity connect program is to build and manage on behalf of excel a local competitive ecosystem of vendors civil mechanical contractors
SPEAKER_01including union labor and local contractors right and we bid out and this is right in the filing. This is public information. It was in the filing every time. 80% of the value of this procurement of distributed batteries will be bid competitively in Minnesota. 80% of the value of this procurement will be bid competitively to local businesses in Minnesota. And the reason for that is that regulators and utilities build in market-based competition into these procurements.
They do it for utility-scale power with all-source RFPs when they procure wind and
SPEAKER_01solar and gas. So you end up with constant rolling market-based competitive price discovery when a utility is incorporating distributed batteries onto its grid for public purpose.
SPEAKER_00And I kind of think if you're in the DER business, I mean, they're probably going to yell at me for saying this, but like you still get to bid on the job, but what you don't get to do is go out and find and sign up customers and structure financial deals with them. But that just sounds to me like the worst part of the job, the worst and hardest and least rewarding part of the job. It kind of seems like If you're a DER person and you just get to skip straight to the part where you're
SPEAKER_01doing the job,
SPEAKER_00it kind of seems better.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, look, I think a lot of the opposition in Minnesota, frankly, was downstream of that protecting a finance business model that requires that to have that part of your business model. And this is, again, alongside other programs in Minnesota that allow for exactly that. but look the exciting part of capacity connect it is a major utility doing a very forward-looking innovative filing that says we're gonna make these machines part of the normal course of the distribution operations plan of our utility and we're
gonna do that because we think everything we said in the first half of this episode is true right they'll charge up when there's plenty they'll dispatch right like it
SPEAKER_01they agree that batteries are gonna be valuable but if this model
SPEAKER_00utility-owned distributed batteries takes off, works, they like it, they spread it, they expand it, other utilities grab onto it. It will have the effect of squeezing out business models that rely on third parties in between the utility and the customer. That includes VPP aggregators. It includes solar finance people like Sunrun.
SPEAKER_00And I think it includes Sparkfund. Do you not think that all like to the extent this model catches on and becomes standardized and becomes boring that all these third party business models all these middleman business models are going to get squeezed out over time maybe including your own. Maybe when things go to scale and become normal course in big public systems,
SPEAKER_01they tend to commodify and the value chain that delivers them changes. I think that's just true in economic history. So part of what we're debating here is not really about utilities or this filing or that filing. It's just about batteries and distributed energy having a moment where they're going to become a fundamental pillar of how we grow and manage our grid because our nation needs it. So, yes, will there be change? Absolutely. And I think in particular, consumer finance-based models that initially were about helping customers buy these machines versus the public grid are probably more at risk.
SPEAKER_00Well, let's not rush past that. Sunrun is very large, and that's its core business model. So I know they were among the entities that opposed the this in Minnesota and I will assume they're going to fight you all the way down the line on this are they not they will and they spent more money than anyone fighting this in Minnesota we were a little bit surprised in some ways but also you know when a when a grid has more batteries it also is better at handling and delivering solar energy but look people defend their business but they're pivoting to
SPEAKER_00batteries I mean they've said it a couple of times now they and they're pivoting to batteries and they're doing this finance model this finance model of selling batteries is now their core thing and this model that Excel has adopted if it became the default would shrink or eliminate that business model I think that's right and I think that's why they oppose it it is a competition of business models one in private financing and one
SPEAKER_01in public infrastructure And I also like to come back to VPPs. You made an important point. And then I also don't want to dodge the question about whether a spark fund will be necessary to the future of this.
SPEAKER_00Well, talk about VPPs first. I'm curious what role you see them playing in this battery filled future. Look,
SPEAKER_01much more durable because I think most VPPs, as you, I think, articulately defined it, which is largely, you know, behind the meter resources that in one moment serve customer value and another serve the grid. I think that that is really broadly speaking demand response and I do not mean that dismissively I think demand response assets are critical parts of relieving pressure on the grid and aggregate and I think demand response is absolutely one of we've been talking about batteries today with a lot of focus but I think that batteries are on a short list of grid flexibility creating assets including demand
response and grid enhancing technologies that really drive the future that we're
SPEAKER_00talking about I have a pod actually running, I think it'll be out by the time people hear this, wherein someone argues that what we ought to be doing is making price-responsive appliances. Everything electric, basically. All these embedded batteries, all these electric devices. Dr. Justin Marchegiani
And the benefit of this is that then all the value of the flexibility is captured
SPEAKER_00automatically by the homeowner, by the owner of the devices, rather than split 50-50 with a VPP, which is just kind of a middleman doing the same function in a slightly cruder way. It's interesting that there are other ways that you might eliminate the VPP model. And if then all the devices are immediately price responsive, Yeah, and what you're talking about there is really how much does an
aggregator get paid
SPEAKER_01as a share of revenue, which I think goes back, like that sounds like one plausible way that an aggregator could get paid less as the middleman. I think that the more important question though is will demand response be a service the grid wants and will it reach into customer devices to do that and will there be benefits for the customer and the owner and the grid I think the answer is yes and nothing about deploying a bunch of big batteries changes that they're just both filling two different parts well but why not though like if you've got enough of these one two five megawatt chunks scattered around your
distribution grid you
SPEAKER_00get your stability and you get your boringness why then do you need to go on and tackle the complexity of trying to coordinate consumer side devices is there not some possibility that this could prove so cheap and easy for utilities and so effective that it really sort of just like slightly moots the need for consumer side coordination I think there is
SPEAKER_01and the question is how much does it moot it And is it a hundred percent gone? I mean, remember we talked about the value of batteries at every scale and every size being how close you can put them to the problem and Batteries in the home and flexibility devices in the home are closer to and easier to put in wait for it homes Yes, but I guess the question is, is the sort of distribution level close enough? Yeah, it may be. And the reason, you know, someone very wise in this industry once said to me, you know, the reason the centralized planned grid has lasted for 100
years is that many of
SPEAKER_01these questions have been posed. This happened with post-war industrialization. It happened with HVAC and air conditioning. And it turns out that often the lowest cost, most reliable way to deliver these solutions is through I think that we have to remember that the grid, again, is not built for individual value to come off of it. And I would say in the world in which every homeowner can perfectly participate in these dynamic real-time pricing markets, think about
SPEAKER_01Dr. Justin Marchegiani you want to plan things to be lowest cost most reliable so that you can share the benefits with everyone whether or not they have the time or
money to think about it or not right I'm not against wealthy educated people participating in the grid it's by the way how we've invented some of these devices and scaled them that is a critical part of an innovation economy it should never be disallowed or banned or
SPEAKER_01limited I don't want to ban third-party ownership at all but it is not the point of the grid we did not build public infrastructure so that enthusiasts can take rents from it yeah and this actually brings me back to another point I wanted to make about the energy democracy thing I understand and am compelled by the merits of local ownership of energy assets and I'm compelled by
SPEAKER_00them in terms of energy democracy and in terms of local empowerment But, I think, if you're measuring that against the benefits of the same community having reliable, cheap, ubiquitous electricity, Even on the metric of local empowerment, the latter wins. Putting cheap, abundant electricity in people's hands is the most effective
economic development
SPEAKER_00tool on the planet. So every bit that you make a community's electricity cheaper and more ubiquitous and more boring and more cheap, that is economic development that is local empowerment that's not an alternative it's human flourishing I love that David I really do I mean that's a beautiful way to say that and I think it needs to be said more and it's in this really important and under discussed category in our tribe of nerds which is what is energy for what
is infrastructure for and I think you just articulated exactly what it's for it is for flourishing so well let me ask you about this do you not like one of the things you know I had Lorenzo Christophe on the pod love him and one of the you
SPEAKER_00know he's a big fan of local democracy local action local community local resilience self-sufficiency all that kind of stuff in electricity too one of the cases he makes which I've always found pretty compelling is that There are benefits to local communities being able to plan their power alongside planning local transportation policy and local building policy and local economic development policy like power shifts. Dr. Justin Marchegiani So do you not see,
are you not at all moved by the idea that local community ownership of local energy
SPEAKER_00assets carries some benefits?
SPEAKER_01First of all, Lorenzo is brilliant, and he and I have had some wonderful conversations about this. And I think we share a real passion for localism broadly as a basic idea of subsidiarity, which is push the planning and the decision making down to the lowest competent level that also can efficiently deliver the outcome. and you know his point I think one I'd break between two things where it's planned and where it's owned which are two different but related questions ownership is important but really about who receives the rents versus the
risk and the regulated compact was designed to smooth or socialize both the risk and the rents to all
SPEAKER_01participants at all scales of planning And then the next question is, when you go smaller with infrastructure, do you have the equivalent vehicles of debt, financing and capital that allow you to do that at that level of aggregation efficiently?
SPEAKER_00Right. And let me just put a finer point on that. You know, one of the things Lorenzo has envisioned, and I think they have them in the UK now, is what it's called DSOs, basically like the distribution of The TSOs at the transmission level. in the community but as you I think are getting at here you
might lose some of the financing benefits of size and scale and if you don't then I think there's a lot to like about that model and I think Lorenzo has an incredible again I really actually
SPEAKER_01like and admire how he talks about this stuff I think that the the question really is that you know if you zoom back the utility regulatory compact was designed to pull off a magic trick which is take Wall Street's money private money give them like a three and a half percent net dividend every year right every hundred bucks they put in they get three or four bucks and let a private operator who has some profit incentive build the grid which is the foundation for our economy and human flourishing as we've just discussed
and then submit to a civically accountable regulator to control every one of its
SPEAKER_01decisions, actions and profits. And so it's Wall Street's money building public infrastructure. And you don't, by the way, this is, that's easy to say. The reason that's important, David, is that you don't have to choose in a public budget, a general fund or a town's budget, between building the next rural hospital or paying teachers or repaving roads and building a substation or a new transmission line. because you got the Wall Street money. Yeah, we did it. We got private money for public purpose, regulated as best as can be done.
SPEAKER_01Is that system perfect? No. Does that system have flaws and imbalanced incentives? Yes. Can you name me a landscape scale, public regulated compact and institution that doesn't? But I'll tell you what's amazing about the utility compact is that it delivers its outcome pretty much 100% of the time, right? There are grids where the grid is only off 80 or 100 minutes a year. and in most of our state's economies at the level of aggregation of debt and planning the power is pretty cheap the capital is super efficient and what comes
out the other side of that is that in a lot of states the percentage of the economy that goes to pay for the infrastructure that lets us have as much power as we want anywhere we want it all the time is three or four percent of the total state's
SPEAKER_00economy and really and to kind of return to a point I made earlier You could compare that 3% or 4% to the market value of the assets it has purchased and is deploying, and I think that will look pretty favorable. Oh, incredibly fair. But again, the market value of the assets is a small sliver of the value you get from having ubiquitous, reliable, unlimited, cheap assets.
SPEAKER_00The second- and third-order benefits of that are vast. Then they're not captured by the value of the transformers.
SPEAKER_01Right. And not just vast, they're the rest of the economy. I think it's easier to just assume. I'm sure you could do some dumb research paper, which is like, what percent of GDP is not enabled by electricity? Who cares? And that's growing and growing and growing, as we said. Yeah, all of it and more. Uncaptured GDP. and that's exactly right that is what energy is for and the compact we have delivers it with private capital and it powers a whole economy with most people not having to think about it could a cca do this in california or wherever there are ccas i know there are several other states where they where
they in terms of distributed batteries yeah yeah and just just like implement an excel style program absolutely we're having conversations with grid operators across municipal
SPEAKER_01utilities co-ops yeah munis could do it co-ops could do it and and then I guess if a mutie was doing it you kind of moot some of the energy democracy complaints I think at least because then it really is like still locally
SPEAKER_00owned right it's still still still local batteries are going to win the future and we're going to put them everywhere because they are time machines for electrons and it's what the grid needs and so I think what we saw in Minnesota is a simple case of a threatened business model paying money to advocate to protect its business model in a moment of real transition when these assets that used to be sort of you know in their
SPEAKER_01protected market camp start to become a core part of grid infrastructure, and it freaked them out.
SPEAKER_00Well, you could also flip that around. I mean, people have objections to this that are not just generic, not just business model exceptions, but like Excel specifically. People have reasons specifically not to trust Excel. There are people who say Excel has had this distribution resources for a long time. They don't use them for public benefit. There have been a lot of price events where they could have used them for public benefit, and they didn't. they've been dragging their feet on distributed energy resources they got fined by
the PUC for dragging their feet on distributed energy resources in other words I think there are reasons to distrust the utility and to believe why should we believe that this you know when they have betrayed the public trust in the past why should we believe that this program will genuinely be run for public benefit
SPEAKER_00Definitely true.
SPEAKER_01We're in an age of distrust of institutions, and the public institution of utilities and the regulators is no exception. And I think the only solution to that is to actually deliver the value and hope that the future we're describing, the age of boring, comes true, which is that cheap batteries and data center demand happening at the same time make power cheaper, the grid more reliable, and we can go on our merry way and work on other things.
SPEAKER_00Okay, but that's not only an answer to the question. I hope they do this right I mean I guess but you can imagine why people who've been burned by Excel over and over again been fighting Excel for years and years are not do not just say like well let's see what happens do not find that particularly adequate and they also say that this first tranche of these distributed batteries are not They're not actually going to churches and hospitals and civic facilities. They're not actually being assessed and chosen based on community resilience
SPEAKER_00benefits, at least yet. Right now, they're just being placed purely for grid benefit. So again, why shouldn't locals, why shouldn't they be suspicious? And why shouldn't they look at what's happening and say, it looks like Excel is just making the macro grid better and is not Right. Well, something I think it's important to know about this one filing is it did actually
SPEAKER_01and does have a robust energy justice portion. So there is targeting of those resources we categorize by EJ. And that's why we got a lot of support from that community and from a bunch of local groups advocating, including advocates like Fresh Energy and CEE and others that really I think engaged constructively in making sure we got that portion of the filing right, they were part of the hearing. they spoke at length they offered decision options that were accepted by the commission so they got to directly modify so that the literally
just to put a point on this the social justice and the energy justice community was at the table helping to write those requirements to their standard and that's a commitment that Excel has that Sparkfund has and that the commission required so I think that you know again maybe we're going around a little bit in circles here but like the fact that that has been such a common talking point about this and it's right in the
SPEAKER_01order and the whole section is a bummer you know and it's I don't know how else to say it right like politics is a is a dirty game and there's some real misinformation that's come out around this and it's been a surprising journey but I think it landed in the right place and I think frankly the commission and It was genuinely impressive to watch Chair Sieben operate a civic compact under that type of duress and really ask questions and get stuff on
the record and challenge Excel and Spark Fund and advocates to explain and defend their position.
SPEAKER_01And, you know, no civic process is perfect. But Minnesota is, you know, Minneapolis is like Norway on the prairie, right? That civic compact is as strong and robust and, you know, chock full of civic nerds as I've ever seen. Yes we've all had occasion to celebrate Minnesota recently you have said I think maybe being slightly deliberately provocative but you have said to me and I think maybe in writing that you think it is possible that the
vertically integrated The old-fashioned vertically integrated utilities might move faster on this and
SPEAKER_00reach that exalted cheap, abundant, and boring plateau before restructured areas. Why do you think that? Well, I think that there is a U-curve of utility operator and market success.
SPEAKER_01And at one end, actually, there's kind of things that are closer to pure markets like ERCOT and Texas, and they work really well. ERCOT added a whole New York worth of electric load in just the last four years.
SPEAKER_00It's interesting. Right now, base power is down there in the ERCOT operating on the retail energy model, right? They're a retail energy provider, but they're actually going now to vertically integrated utilities. knocking on the door saying hey look we figured out how to get batteries on the grid faster than any other model wouldn't you like some of this juju that's right so and I think very interesting to see that what makes base such an interesting company is that they're not wedded to one business model they're a put batteries everywhere company batteries everywhere and I think that makes
them a really durable part of this story and they should bring it to other other markets right they're like a residential version of what we're doing in the you know larger
SPEAKER_01batteries and and I think it's great the answer to your question though is that IOUs right if you're not going to have a full connect and manage market that also and this is really critical Texas is superpowers has very very permissive local permitting you can build things really fast yeah and I almost like there's so many details about this David that you know better than I do but it's like when you talk about PJM design all this stuff If you have bad local permitting that makes it hard to build stuff, it almost doesn't matter what your ISO rules are.
You just can't build big power plants or even small ones or even batteries. The bottom of the U-curve is a restructured market that has a weird mix of esoteric rules that make it hard to participate in your market and allow rent-seeking, auctions that guarantee capacity because not enough people can participate and no
SPEAKER_01one can build things anyway. and are also still sort of highly regulated and have lots of rules and lots of laws from states that want a bunch of things. Like that is the thicket. Kind of a worst of both worlds. Yeah, that's the worst of both worlds. The heart of the U-curve, the thicket of PGM's discontent, which I should make t-shirts that say. But you'd really know who the nerds in the airport are if you walked through a terminal. But IOUs are not perfect, but they have this basic advantage in moments of great infrastructure need and
build is that they can organize capital and conduct their planning at both the
SPEAKER_01level of generation, transmission and distribution as one integrated system. And I would point out that a lot of the advocacy that you and I and many people in our tribe have been on about for years is ultimately that thinking of the grid as a system that seeing distributed assets part in that system will ultimately be a key part of growing the grid and I think what we're seeing in Capacity Connect and others is just now large vertically integrated utilities are doing the math and they're agreeing and that is not because this was the absolute first moment they could have done
that but it is
SPEAKER_01Pretty recent that these batteries got cheaper, right? So I'm not going to pretend that big utilities aren't slow. And for some good reasons in terms of safety, reliability, critical function, also, you know, some reasons of bureaucratic inertia and scale and slow regulated proceedings, right? Good and bad. but it is not very many years ago that batteries were not the cheapest way to do this I would argue that they're just barely becoming the cheapest now I think we've crossed that line permanently irrevocably right I think it's
sort of the thesis of this pod is it like welcome to the age of boring because that has happened but it
SPEAKER_01only you know as as the dude said new shit has come to light
SPEAKER_00Yes, indeed. Are you, this is totally orthogonal to our whole point here, but I just want to get you on record. Are you among those people who predict a return to vertical integration in the US? In part or in whole? Yes. I think it's important to clarify what vertical integration is today, right? Most vertically integrated utilities procure generation competitively through big
SPEAKER_01all-source RFPs from private owners and IPPs, right? So, you know, this is not your grandfather's vertical integration where a utility hires a crew and builds a power plant directly and operates it with, you know, its own union. and its own pension right this is still like I said tucking market price discovery competitive delivered advantage innovative designs and scaled private capital into a relationship with a public purpose infrastructure compact so I think there's a I think there are advantages that that type of civic compact
has in a planning level. that allow us to go faster go further and make the sort of leap you saw southern company make with those batteries when those conditions merit
the rapid scaled adoption of gigawatts and gigawatts of effective utility scale batteries is a good example of how to meet the moment when the nation needs to build data center infrastructure to fundamentally power the next chapter of the American economy so
SPEAKER_01I don't think that vertical integration has to be universal. I think ISOs and interoperable markets that expand the pools. I think IPPs will be a durable and critical part of competitively procuring, supplying and operating power. That private capital is the whole point of the utility compact, right? It's Wall Street's money for public purpose. There is no market in the United States today where a political and societal judgment does not set the rules for how electric power infrastructure forms the foundation of that state's economy.
SPEAKER_01Not Texas. ERCOT has a critical No one has ever said that in any region, in any market, anywhere in the world. No. I love talking about this for a bunch of reasons but like one of them is there are
so many things new possibilities new opportunities around the world of clean energy where I find myself kind of on the edge of my seat white knuckling it thinking God we've got to do this right it would be so easy to do this wrong and screw it up generationally but when it comes to this batteries it's like if you put a battery
SPEAKER_00on the grid it helps It almost doesn't matter who puts it or where or why or how they pay for it. It's almost impossible to do this wrong. Just put the batteries on the effing grid and they're going to improve the grid. You know what I mean? We don't have to do this exactly right. We just need to do it at scale. You know what I mean? We just need to do it big. We don't have to be precise about it. Every bit of battery helps.
SPEAKER_00You almost can't screw it up. welcome to the age of boring the age of boring okay so final question then is like right now I think probably conventional wisdom in our world is that we are currently facing a bit of a gauntlet bunch of new demand is showing up on the grid we've got these old sleepy institutions these old sleepy not fit for purpose I think you disagree.
I think you think and tell me if I'm right I want to get a date another date range from you I think you think that batteries are going to solve these problems sooner than people think they will and that the grid will get boring and reliable and abundant sooner than people think it will and I guess I would like to ask by way of
SPEAKER_00wrapping this up how soon? I think that the
SPEAKER_01The best way to answer that question is you're already seeing data center announcements, particularly in IOU territory but not exclusively, directly result in rate cases where the divided cost of energy goes down because you've divided the fixed cost of the wires by more sales and power gets cheaper. For example, give us a concrete example. PG&E, right, in California, one of the hardest places to operate a grid anywhere with wildfires and stuff, said that for every gigawatt of data center load, you get one or two percent cheaper power for everyone in their
territory.
SPEAKER_01Right. And that to date, 11 percent cheaper rates because of the data centers that have come.
SPEAKER_00Again, maybe not visible to the people in California because wildfire costs are simultaneously pushing rates up.
SPEAKER_01Right. Indiana, Michigan, AEP has actually made power cheaper. Southern Company, I believe, has actually made power cheaper. Right. I believe about one hundred dollars a year per rate payer was their public filing number. Maybe it was 80 or something. You know, but that's billions of dollars of cheaper power. And all of that was related to exactly this effect of managing the growth of large load customers to public benefit. And, you know, it's also important to say that data centers are sort of the hero of the story, right? Like it doesn't matter how much you invest in batteries or anything else. If you can't sell the extra power,
SPEAKER_01if you don't have electrification and load growth and data centers, you know, you're just spending money and you can utilize the grid better, but no one's going to buy the power. So it doesn't matter.
SPEAKER_00But what about people who would say, you know, AI is terrible and we should be electrifying transport faster? Like we should be getting that boost of demand from somewhere else. And in some sense, by data centers eating up all the available new capacity, we're delaying further electrification. You don't buy that at all. No, I'll go once more to the dude, which is that's like your opinion, man, right?
SPEAKER_01That's way outside the scope. That's way outside the normative scope. And frankly, something I don't love. There's a lot of things I think that are really wonderful about the community of climate energy nerds that we're both lucky enough to be a part of, right? These are system oriented, normatively engaged, really philosophically interesting people, right? And we care. And we've organized our careers around that. That's fantastic. and it's a great thing to be a part of. But one of our faults, I think, is sometimes we like breach the walls of the energy discussion and we imagine the grid is like this portal to just like unlimited social control and power.
SPEAKER_01And we're like, oh, let's use energy policy to determine, you know, should we have more electric cars or more data? So it's like, that's not a job for this. Just take a breath, right? This is me back to my genuine, you know, localist, decentralized, slightly grumpy, you know, it's like make less rules and trust that people can figure stuff out. And I think there's a real chance for an abundant America. And you think this phenomenon whereby data centers are going to create the new load
SPEAKER_00that takes the battery's new capacity and thereby reduces rates, all of that is going to happen quickly. automatically if they get on the grid. In other words, you don't need the extra step that a lot of people are talking about of basically making them pay extra, some extra fee to get on the grid, making them pay for some specific capacity. Maybe you still think that's a good idea, but the effect you're talking about doesn't depend on that. Yes, that's right.
SPEAKER_01I think that it's very Brian Janis cleverly said this beautifully in a LinkedIn post right around the announcement of you know all data centers will pay their fair way which is great look it's good politics it's good to make sure that we're saying that out loud It is proper regulation and political governance to say out loud in one of the largest capital events in human history, by the way, that the participants and beneficiaries of that investment must pay into a public system appropriately. I think that is good and true. But the basic Bonbright principles,
it took us this long to say Bonbright, by the way, um is inherent to utility rate making is that all participants should pay their fair share is that always perfectly arbitred no it's also complicated to get right and how you judge which cost was caused by what type of system growth and then there's a storm or a fire and then there's caught you know but what what about the idea I think a lot of people have that like we need a bunch of spending on the grid
SPEAKER_00right we have a bunch of needs right now the public's grumpy power prices are high they don't want to cough up for it along come these wildly wealthy companies that desperately need to hook up quickly why not extract more than their fair share you know what I mean like they've got money coming out their ears we need money why not Well, because it's no more fair to them than if they didn't pay their
fair share, right?
SPEAKER_01Fair share means cover the costs. And if you manage growth well with batteries and grid flexibility and other stuff, you'll actually spread the benefit of their participation to everyone. Just the fact that they're willing to buy gigawatts and gigawatts of new power over public infrastructure and participate in the grid as good grid citizens is the contribution. You do not need to penalize them. You do not need to tax them. you know I think this is a broader philosophical point but we're in this moment politically between moments we don't have a kind of political order to guide our shared agreement right neoliberalism is gone and before we
figure out what the next political order is there's this real chaotic risk of villain politics people are searching for villains and I think what we're getting wrong with data centers and utilities is we're casting them as these satisfying villain characters for the like
SPEAKER_01technocratic left and it's, we're missing the forest for the trees in it. We're getting the story wrong.
SPEAKER_00Or at the least, I think we should separate out the problem with these villain politics is that once someone gets the Scarlet V, people just displace all their complaints onto the villain. So like we need to distinguish the effects on the grid, the physical, energetic, and economic effects on the grid we need to be able to separate that in our heads from whatever you think the social impact of AI may or may not be like those are at the very least
are separable questions yeah the t-shirt I'd like to make or the sign I'd like to bring to a town hall where the community is determining whether a data center is right for them and it's like not all communities want or need a data center it's not right there should be local control and local voices but you know the sign I would bring is
SPEAKER_01this building is not a witch that's you know Don't create a parasocial category that's hard to disprove and then imagine all of your worst fears flow through this one thing like villain politics sucks and I think as Americans we should challenge ourselves to Okay, well, give me my date then.
SPEAKER_00When is U.S. electricity cheap, abundant, and boring? When am I going to look up and say, you know what, I need to figure out something else to pot about? 2030.
SPEAKER_01Just a few years. I think the narrative will be clear enough by 2030. Wow. That this trend is permanent and structural and inside the existing systems incentives, that data centers are driving most of the near-term electrification that makes it possible, that electric vehicles and heat pumps and broader electrification is coming behind it, new manufacturing.
SPEAKER_00Will average electricity rates in the US be visibly falling by 23rd? Yes, I think so. In the states that have substantial data center growth, I will make that my hottest of takes.
SPEAKER_01I think by 23rd. in 2030 in the states where there is substantial data center growth and other electrification power will become cheaper in a nominal basis again if you have a lot of wildfires if you have terrible storms there are other things that can make a landscape scale machine expensive for unrelated reasons so I'll give myself one type of contextual hedge but I do think that in many markets in many states that can get this growth moment right Power will be cheaper. The grid will be stronger and we'll be on our way to a new chapter.
that's a perfect place to leave it then that's a prediction that's gonna come up soon enough that we'll probably be able to talk about it on my pod 10 year predictions are so boring too right it's like 10 years I know I know everything's everything's possible the death of accountability bores me right in predictions right so I want to be clear I have no particular information I'm almost certainly wrong in countless ways but it's so much more fun to say at least by 2030 2030 it
SPEAKER_00is thank you as always Pierce fascinating Fascinating to see, like, with all the dysfunction around us in so many other areas, like, I really think it is important for listeners to absorb and take heart in the fact that electricity does really seem to be on a good path heading to a good place. So at least not 100% of things are awful.
SPEAKER_01Let it be abundance then. Thanks, David. thank you for listening to Volts it takes a village to make this podcast work shout out especially to my super producer Kyle McDonald who makes me and my guests sound smart every week and it is all supported entirely by listeners like you so if you value conversations like this please consider joining our community of paid subscribers at volts.wtf or leaving a nice review or telling a
friend about Volts
SPEAKER_00or all three Thanks so much and I'll see you next time.
This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit www.volts.wtf/subscribe When people push for better data centers, they picture hyperscalers - Amazon,...
This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit www.volts.wtf/subscribe America’s first big wave of solar power installations, built between 15 and...
This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit www.volts.wtf/subscribe The Senate’s bipartisan permitting bill got a manager’s amendment last week -...
This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit www.volts.wtf/subscribe Last week’s election was a blue wave all the way down the ballot: Democrats...
This is a free preview of a paid episode. To hear more, visit www.volts.wtf Volts published eight conversations in October, which is a lot for anyone to listen to. We’ve rounded up the highlights into less than an hour....