Hawaii Senator Brian Schatz joins me to discuss the energy policy landscape facing Democrats and how they should respond. We touch on the shift in messaging from “climate” to “affordability,” current Congressional Republican efforts on permitting reform in light of Trump’s anti-renewables crusade, the role of green groups in climate politics, and much more. This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit www.volts.wtf/subscribe
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_00Greetings, everyone. This is Volts for December 31st, 2025. Senator Brian Schatz wants permitting reform, but not like this. I'm your host, David Roberts. Hawaii's Brian Schatz has been in the U.S. Senate since 2012 and in politics since 1998. And throughout that time, he has centered his campaigns in advocacy
SPEAKER_00on climate change. Recently, however, he, like many Democrats, has pivoted to stressing energy affordability. Clean is cheap, and cheap is clean. And as part of that, pushing for permitting reform that would allow more wind and solar projects to be built in the U.S. Nonetheless, he is opposing a new Republican-sponsored permitting bill, the SPEED Act, He says it does not contain sufficient guarantees that renewables will be able to
SPEAKER_00compete on a level playing field. What with Trump and Interior Secretary Doug Burgum effectively making them illegal to permit. Anyway, there's a lot going on, and I'm very excited to have the chance to talk to the senator about permitting, data centers, the politics of the IRA, the role of the groups in climate policy, and more.
SPEAKER_00With no further ado, Senator Brian Schatz, welcome to Volts. Thank you so much for coming.
SPEAKER_01Thanks for having me.
SPEAKER_00A ton to talk about today, but I want to start here. From my perspective, in the wake of the election, it seems like the Democratic Party... establishment politicians pundits consultants everybody seemed to sort of swing like a school of fish away from climate change toward energy affordability the sort of like the word went out is we're not talking about climate change anymore we're talking about energy affordability i want to talk about energy affordability but before we get to that i just sort of want to talk to you about
how people who are
SPEAKER_00still very much concerned about climate change should feel or think about this pivot?
SPEAKER_01I think we should just be focused on winning. And I think that any argument that is both true and effective is an argument that we should be unapologetic in making. And over many, many years now, a little more than 25 years in public service of some form of fashion, I have been making the case for climate action and sometimes the electrons that are coming from clean generation are cheaper and sometimes they're not. But I've always made the case regardless because I do believe
this is a planetary emergency. But we are in a different place now in terms of just the cost of solar and wind
SPEAKER_01and battery and geothermal and nuclear energy. And so I think we should lean into that because it's an opportunity for us to flip the script. We no longer have to talk about externalities. We no longer have to make a kind of indirect argument. We can look people in the eye and say cheap is clean and clean is cheap, and that these shortages are caused by Donald Trump's national solar ban, and that's the reason your prices are starting to go up at double the rate of inflation. So I don't know.
SPEAKER_01I'd like us to win. I don't think we should say anything dishonest about climate or energy, but I do think that it is perfectly appropriate if you are in the business of trying to achieve a majority so you can enact climate legislation, that we have this incredibly powerful argument that is available to us. And we shouldn't get so fussy about the fact that, you know, look, I've run for election and reelection lots and lots of times. And as you know, David, my number one priority in my public service in my life is climate action.
SPEAKER_01But it has been very rare that the focus of my campaign communications has been exclusively climate. I talk about public education, public health, affordability, housing, Native Hawaiian issues. I talk about a lot of stuff. I also talk about climate, but the idea that because I'm a climate guy, I have to emphasize that in every moment of my life is sort of like not how people work. Right. And so the opportunity in front of us is not just about capturing a successful midterm election,
SPEAKER_01but it's bigger than that. If it is now true and now plausible to the voter that clean energy is cheap energy, that a ban on renewable energy hurts their pocketbook, that changes the politics, not just in terms of election cycles, but in terms of what's possible to enact.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, well said. I want to look forward, but briefly, let's look back, just for a few minutes. I've asked several Democratic lawmakers this question in recent months, which is, it seems like part of the political theory of the IRA, as you are well aware, you were in the trenches putting it together. Part of the sort of political thought behind it was... This is going to funnel a ton of money and investment into red states. It's all sort of industrial policy.
SPEAKER_00It's all forward-looking. We're not talking about carbon taxes. We're not taking anything away from anybody. The politics are going to be good, and red state lawmakers will see the benefit in it and will defend it from repeal. A lot of people were saying similar things. That, just like in retrospect, turned out to be wildly wrong. And I guess my question is, were you taken aback by, you know, nobody was under any illusions that this administration was going to be
SPEAKER_00pro-renewables or anti-fossil fuels, but were you surprised by the sort of ferocity, lack of nuance, you know, that this was a sledgehammer, not a scalpel? Did that surprise you that none of your colleagues, none of your Republican colleagues really stood up to try to slow this down or stop it?
SPEAKER_01It did surprise me. And I think that if we were doing their big, beautiful bill right now in the month of December, that it probably would have gone differently. I think we're smart to move at the sort of close to the peak of Donald Trump's political power. And so just nobody wanted to defy him. But I'd be lying if I didn't say that I was expecting better, more coordinated, more powerful pushback. And some of the people who made noises in the right direction
eventually ended up
SPEAKER_01collapsing in the end. And that was a surprise. But just to the kind of like architecture of the IRA and the theory behind the IRA, It's true that there were a bunch of people who thought, well, if there's a bunch of clean energy deployed in red states, that that kind of barbs the hook and makes it really difficult to repeal. And that did turn out to be wrong. But that doesn't mean the IRA wasn't the best available policy and political approach, because we were still in a place where we had to find something
that could be big and bold and sort of equal to the moment and pass muster with Joe Manchin and
SPEAKER_01and Kyrsten Sinema. And despite online people saying, just be like Lyndon Johnson and bully him, or whatever that is.
SPEAKER_00You're saying invoking Lyndon Johnson is not enough to get it done?
SPEAKER_01Yeah. I mean, look, I've read all the Robert Caro books, and I love those stories. But we are in a different era. And to get Joe Manchin to enact the biggest climate action in human history was a really big political achievement for our conference. And so that was what was available to us. I do think we kind of got high on our own supply saying, not only is this the biggest climate action ever taken, but it is unrepealable. Like, we just didn't need to say that because that turned out not to be true. But I wouldn't change what we did because I'm not sure that,
SPEAKER_01you know, look, if I were the chancellor of some sort of non-democracy, would I write a different climate bill? Sure. But this was an exercise in, as you know, driving down emissions and being kind of ruthless and scientifically rigorous about what policies would drive down emissions. But it was also an exercise in coalition management and getting to 50 votes plus one. And so there were things in the bill that drove down emissions that were kind of the engine of the IRA. And then there were some other things that were basically just to make sure that we
SPEAKER_01could hold the majority coalition together. So In retrospect, did people overcook the idea that, oh, as long as we're deploying wind in Kansas, they won't vote to repeal it? Well, that turned out to be bullshit, but I also think it's kind of not the main point at this point.
SPEAKER_00Well, two other questions about that. One specific one, I know that you personally were sort of very involved in and invested in the Greenhouse Gas Reduction Fund, the GGRF, which was a couple billion dollars, I think, of grants that were going to get handed out Specifically, I think to a lot of low income communities, hard hit communities, etc. I'll confess that there are so many battles going on that I have not been closely tracking the battle over that money as I understood it. He was trying to yank it all back.
SPEAKER_00Are you engaged in that fight? Is that fight ongoing? What has become of that money?
SPEAKER_01I'd have to check like you. I'm glad that you as an expert are not tracking it totally carefully.
SPEAKER_00I only have so many hours in the day.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. And I don't want to claim credit for that. The stuff that I was working on was the investment tax credit, the production tax credit, all the stuff that had a sort of immediate arithmetic impact on emissions. The GGRF and some of the environmental justice funds, which were largely repealed in the BBB, didn't have the big climate impact. They were more about making sure that as we move forward, that we do so in an equitable and fair fashion.
So I'm pretty sure they repealed as much as they could in that reconciliation package.
SPEAKER_00Final question on the IRA then, and this is a more general question, kind of getting at what you were just saying earlier, which is like, you know, if Democrats took power or retook power, someday say that happens you know one thing they could do is just take the ira back down off the shelf and pass it again it's already they've already had the negotiations already been the fights everybody already knows what's in it and so i'm just curious sort of like from your perspective what do you think you would do differently if you had another go at it like how much of the ira do you think holds
up and what do you think like what are the big pieces if there are any that you
SPEAKER_00think we're missing
SPEAKER_01I think the ITC and the PTC have to be reestablished for sure. I'll also say that what we did to get to passing the IRA was a couple of years worth of coalition building, coalition management, policy development. So I don't think we're ready to say, here's the program. I do think there is always going to be a place in climate policy for subsidy towards deployment and towards keeping costs down for individual consumers.
SPEAKER_01So that's going to be in there. I would say the composition of the subsidy could be dialed according to what's possible and what is necessary in the moment. That's number one. Number two, I think we have to invest in some of the tech that is potentially a game changer but not quite commercially viable yet. You know, carbon dioxide removal, The geothermal stuff, which you're covering and watching very carefully, is like really exciting. And so I do think the battery storage piece,
SPEAKER_01the carbon dioxide removal, both sort of natural systems-based CDER and other ways to do it, present incredible opportunities. And then finally, I still think we ought to consider a carbon-based border adjustment mechanism, some sort of pricing, Because the rest of the world is moving forward with this and we should be participating in these markets.
SPEAKER_00Europe's carbon border adjustment, I believe, is going into effect imminently, I think, in the next couple of weeks or months.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. And if we don't align with that, we're actually disadvantaging American manufacturers and producers and all the rest of it. So I think there's deal space there. But I really do think that we should think of climate policy like we think of other policies, which is this thing is going to take decades to fix, which means we're going to have to take multiple bites at the apple. And that as the door swings in either direction politically, that we're going to take two steps forward, one step back. And I do think the IRA should be viewed as maybe three steps forward,
SPEAKER_01one step back, because the amount of clean energy deployment that we achieved and is still, frankly, underway is pretty extraordinary. And if you had told me that we were going to pass the IRA, but it was going to be time limited to just four or five years, and then it would expire, which is sort of, in effect, what ended up happening. In the moments in that summer when the thing was dead as a doornail, I would have taken that deal in two seconds, right? So it's true that we have this open-ended way to ramp the
credits down, but it's also true that From a deployment standpoint, it was like two and a half X what was projected by CBO.
SPEAKER_01So it exceeded a lot of expectations on the front end. And then I think we didn't even meet our expectations on the back end because Trump won the trifecta and then the rest is history. One of the hot topics in the energy world right now, in front of Congress right now, is
SPEAKER_00Permitting reform. So I think there's a lot of sentiment on the Democratic side, I think, that IRA was great and IRA sort of put a rocket booster behind deployment, but at the same time, all these permitting laws and permitting regulations, et cetera, were kind of a wet blanket. On top of the rocket, I've lost track of my metaphor, but- No, I think that works. You know, the permitting was slowing things down as much as Ira was trying to speed things up. So everybody's talking now about permitting reform.
So I think you have kind of angered some far left green types by being generally
SPEAKER_00supportive of permitting reform. And then I think now you're also angering some people on the right by opposing- the permitting reform bill that is actually sponsored by Republicans and up in front of Congress right now.
SPEAKER_01So I've hit the sweet spot.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, you're nailing it. You're killing it. Everybody's mad at you. So let's start with what is wrong with the SPEED Act is the Republican-sponsored permitting bill that's up right now, which you and a couple of your colleagues have come out in opposition to. What is the problem with it?
SPEAKER_01two things, two categories, I should say. One is what's in it, and one is what's not in it. What's in it is not really National Environmental Protection Act reforms, but an effective repeal as long as any state or county or tribal agency is able to attest to the federal government that they've already conducted a review. So that's not like permitting certainty, that's not a shot clock, that's not limiting the scope of what's permissible in litigation,
which is all kind of in the deal space of how do we make this system work faster
SPEAKER_01and more fairly and more predictably. This is just like, hey, if someone else did a review, we don't need one. And that is gutting the National Environmental Protection Act. Okay. That having been said, I actually think those issues are workable because it's true that NEPA was established to protect natural resources, but it is now in some instances being weaponized against the very projects that will help us to save the planet. And so it's not that I'm closed-minded to NEPA reform,
SPEAKER_01but it has to be NEPA reform and not a gutting of bedrock environmental protections. That's what's in it. What's not in it, and this is what was kind of maddening to me, is that, first of all, there is effectively a national ban on solar energy. 90% of the projects that are stalled and in the queue our solar energy, most of those are cheaper than whatever people are paying for on the grid as we speak. And that is caused by the president's executive order and Doug Bergram and all these other executive agencies that are saying not just on federal land,
SPEAKER_01but where there is a federal nexus, they're going to sandbag these projects into oblivion.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, there's a letter to Congress, I believe, recently, right, from a bunch of solar, like a hundred and something solar companies basically saying this. Yeah, there is a ban on solar energy instituted by the president of the United States.
SPEAKER_01And until that ban is lifted, until we believe, and not just with verbal reassurances, but with ways that we can ensure that this is true, that these projects are not going to be choked off, then we're not even really reasonably at the table because then we're just making the world safe for fossil generation. And the trade in permitting reform is basically it's a bet, right? We say a couple of things. We say, first of all, there are people who think we should exclusively keep it in the
ground.
SPEAKER_01Fair enough, but that is not my view. There are other people who say, hey, the future is clean energy. The bottleneck is transmission distribution. Permitting reform will benefit some fossil projects, but if you're talking about a 90-10 split for what's about to come on the grid, You're talking about a 90-10 split in terms of the benefit of permitting reform, right? Yes, but that argument presumes that permitting reform yields an even playing field. This is the problem. And as long as Doug Burgum is scouring the Federal Register for
anything that he
SPEAKER_01might be able to slow down, then it's very hard to get to a deal. And then the second part, and you're tracking this very carefully, is is the transmission issue. FERC has done some interesting things. Obviously, Manchin Barrasso addressed transmission. And so we're not going to be able to come to a conclusion on this until we have a comprehensive deal. Do I see that the elements of a deal are possible? Yes. If the Tea Party has veto authority over what goes into a
permitting reform bill,
SPEAKER_01then it's not really permitting reform. Yeah, Chip Roy has come out against it now because it's not anti-renewables enough. Yeah, and God bless Chip Roy. I've never met him, but he does seem to really mean what he says. And he's basically saying, look, Russ Vought, look, Stephen Miller, you promised me you'd kill all this stuff. And this new statute might force the administration to do a few things. I don't want that. And by the way,
I think there are some people on the left that are never going to be able to get to
SPEAKER_01yes on permitting reform. And that's okay. Those are sincerely held views on the right and the left. But if the deal is to be made, it's going to be among climate hawks who are sort of inclined towards building, right? Like Martin Heinrich, like Sheldon Whitehouse, like myself, and the Chairman Westermans of the world who understand that, you know, energy dominance means energy dominance, right? And if we're really going to be all of the above, if we're really going to power our future, if we're really going to provide relief in terms of people's
utility bills,
SPEAKER_01then throttling solar energy, which is the cheapest and most immediate stuff you can put on the grid, is preposterous.
SPEAKER_00But on a general level, you would have taken Manchin's deal. The basic idea that fair permitting reform that does create a level playing field will benefit renewable energy, that basic theory of the case, you still hold to. And I'm wondering, you say a deal is possible, but what can the Republican Congress do to to restrain Trump and Burgum. They don't seem to care much about what Congress says. So what part of the deal could assure you that they are restraining the executive branch?
So I'll leave that to both Martin and Sheldon to negotiate the legislative details. But some of what they're doing is illegal and has been shown to be illegal.
SPEAKER_01But some of that is they do have discretion in between the lines of the statutory law. And we want to eliminate that discretion, not to say that you must approve X number of projects that are solar and X number of projects that are gas and whatever. That gets a little bit goofy. But my view is that everybody has a right to an expeditious consideration of their project Everybody has an obligation to comply with the statute. And then once the government has given you permission to move
forward, that's it.
SPEAKER_01It has to stick. And so there are a bunch of developers out there of fossil energy, clean energy, and they all are in the same position, which is, I would just like to know that we're the United States of America and that the rule of law means something, which means if I've got a 10 gigawatt solar farm and I've got many millions of dollars that I've borrowed from some bank and I think I've got permission. It can't be that actually, no, you didn't. And, um, and I think that should matter to everybody.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. I mean, it's clear that like what Trump wants is some version of a, you know, mafia state where you get favors if you are in good with him. Like that's the basic model of how he thinks.
SPEAKER_01It's Tammany Hall, right? I mean, but it is that like he, he believes in shortages. He wants shortages of workers. He wants shortages, frankly, of food. He wants shortages of healthcare. He wants shortages of electricity. And by the way, the tariffs are a perfect example because then everyone has to petition the monarch for relief.
SPEAKER_00Exactly. Exactly. An atmosphere of shortage, I think, is fertile ground for reactionaries. One more question about permitting review. So in the permitting reform bills that I've seen thrown around, you see a couple of things. You see timelines, frequently sort of imposed timelines saying the review cannot take longer than X, these sort of guarantees of review in a certain amount of time. But what I don't see,
SPEAKER_00like I was just talking to Senator Gallego about this last week, because he has a new energy plan out that has some permitting reform stuff in it. What I'm not seeing in these permitting reform deals is, from my understanding, what would be most helpful based on the literature and study, which is fully staffing and funding the organizations involved in doing the reviews. If you asked Deb Haaland when she was running BLM, she would have told you,
that's the problem.
SPEAKER_00That's why it's taking so long as staffing. We're chronically understaffed and underfunded. And yet I don't see that on the bullet point list of these plans that are flying around among Democrats. So I just wonder how you think about that aspect, whether you think that aspect is getting enough attention.
SPEAKER_01It's a fair point. And there are agencies that are basically in a backlog because they can't hire fast enough or they don't have the resources for the number of personnel they need. I'm a little cautious to invest too heavily in that policy. not because I don't think there are instances where it's important, but because we do have some experience in Hawaii around this, where the State Historic Preservation Division of the Department of Land and Natural Resources, basically,
SPEAKER_01they had a backlog, right? And they said, we're short like 12 reviewers, right? And first of all, it's very hard to hire, because if you're a person who knows how to do historic review, you're just going to make more money in the private sector preparing the application. than reviewing the application. So even when the legislature appropriated money, you just couldn't backfill the positions. And then we finally, this is like eight years of trying to solve it that way. And then what we came to was, hey, the pile's too high. There are too many things that are even subject to this kind of review.
SPEAKER_01And so, for instance, in Hawaii, the National Historic Preservation Act says, if something is, I think, 50 years or older, it may be historic. And our state law, the way we administer this, is if it's 50 years or older, it is historic. So that means that just the volume of paper on any individual reviewer's desk is completely untenable. Now, you could 10X the staff so they can process all that paper, or you could just invert the assumption and say, why don't we just make this a little bit more reasonable?
SPEAKER_01And so I think it's probably both things. Agencies need to be staffed. Civil servant experts that review these things need the resources, but they probably also just need fewer things to look at.
SPEAKER_00I just know there's some suspicion out in climate community, out in green world, that everybody's focusing on the timeline part. and very few people seem to be focusing on the staffing part. Well,
SPEAKER_01the other part of this, you know, the shot clock thing also sounds good, but what has happened sometimes in local governments is it's like with a kid, right, who's like asking for their candy before dinner, and it's like, hey, if you need to know the answer now, it's a no, right? And so if you know, okay, I've got 60 days to review this, after which it's automatically reviewed, then on day 59, you just say, no. Right. I couldn't get to it. So no.
SPEAKER_00Exactly. Exactly.
SPEAKER_01So there are developers who are like, oh, that sounds good until on the 59th day they couldn't get to it. And if you gave them another week, they could get to yes.
SPEAKER_00Or more resources or more reviewers. Exactly. Like a timeline without any additional resources seems to me like it's just going to end up with that happening.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. So this stuff is really complicated, but I think the more basic solution, right, is why don't we give them less to review? Yes. Right.
SPEAKER_00For sure. And what's happening right now is that we are evaluating environmental impacts of
SPEAKER_01things that have very little environmental impact. So there's a lot of paper flow back and forth, but nobody out in the field believes we're saving an ecosystem. We're just passing paper.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. Okay. Let's talk about another hot topic that is very much on everyone's mind these days. And I think is very interesting for a bunch of different reasons, which is data centers, AI data centers. These are sort of like, we're on no one's mind three or four years ago, and now are on everyone's mind. And I think everyone, in addition to sort of groping around trying to figure out what policy should be, I think everyone's kind of groping around trying to figure out how should we think about these things? What is the right framework to put around these things?
SPEAKER_00I think a lot of people when they see electricity bills going up and they see data centers coming in or sort of drawing the conclusion, like big energy hogs, you know, designed to do, to create silly videos of president Trump pooping on America, like, and they're just getting hostile. You know, these are like vampires, parasites sucking our energy away. And then, you know, I think some local communities see them as economic development or job development. And then of course, like electricity grid,
SPEAKER_00People have their own views. So I just said curious, sort of like how you cognize AI data centers and what do you think sort of public policy toward them should look like? Hey there, everybody. Don't worry, I'm not gonna tell you about a new mattress or push a credit card on you. This isn't an ad. There are no ads on Volts. It is supported entirely by listeners like you. If you'll indulge me for a second, I'd like to ask for your support. I started Volts because we're all surrounded by depressing news
about climate
SPEAKER_00change and misinformation about clean energy. And it's never been more important to share the stories of the real people on the ground doing the real work of transition and all the ingenuity and courage and public spirit they are bringing to it. People are hungry to hear these stories, to learn from and find inspiration in them. I've heard from people who change majors or careers after hearing episodes of Volts. People using it in classrooms, community groups, even state legislators who have passed bills inspired by
specific episodes.
SPEAKER_00Sharing these stories matters. It makes a difference. If you have found value in it and want to help me continue doing it, I hope you will join the community of paid subscribers at volts.wtf. It's about the cost of a cup of coffee a month. If you don't like subscriptions, you can make a one-time contribution, leave a review on Apple or Spotify, or just tell a friend about volts. I am grateful for any and all support. If you're already a paid subscriber, thank you. And now back to the show.
So I just said curious sort of like how you cognize AI data centers and what do you
SPEAKER_00think sort of public policy toward them should look like?
SPEAKER_01I know I'm not supposed to say this because I'm a politician, but I'll just say I don't have fully formed thoughts in this area yet.
SPEAKER_00Oh no, what?
SPEAKER_01I know I'm supposed to have a tight answer for everything, but let me just tell you some preliminary thinking about data centers. I think the first thing is just the politics of it, is that at the federal level, we tried to engage the data center coalition and a lot of the companies that are going to need this amount of electricity very, very shortly, and tried to explain to them that the repeal of portions of the IRA was going to really harm their plan, right? Because Now they're looking at a load that they may not be able to meet
the demand.
SPEAKER_01And their ramp is really steep. And without solar energy, they're a little cooked. They did not step up, frankly. I mean, they did the minimum. And so there's just part of me that's not all that sympathetic to their new problem, which is now everyone's frigging pissed at them because prices are going up. There's an electron shortage. And now they're trying to sell their projects to all these local county councils and PSCs and PUCs, and people are grouchy, right?
SPEAKER_01Now, at the kind of actual energy management level, this is where I'm a little more agnostic or unclear, which is to say, it kind of depends on where this data center is And what the actual power generation plan is and what the power purchase agreements are and all the rest of it. In some instances, they're actually capturing some of the fixed costs of the system and absorbing some of the needs for repair and recapitalization of the entire system.
SPEAKER_01grid in a region. And so on that level, because they're so profitable, they can actually defray costs for the rest of the system. There are other instances where they're just going to come in and try to get over on a community, and that'll actually raise rates. So it's very much like docket by docket. I'll just say that at the political level, that they missed an opportunity to get a bunch of clean energy on the grid. And now they're contending with what that actually means for both their local politics, but also they're just more straightforward energy needs.
So I think there is a potential alignment between the AI folks and the data center
SPEAKER_01folks and the clean energy folks, because they're the ones that are going to need all this new solar energy.
SPEAKER_00And they have all the money.
SPEAKER_01And they have the money. So, like, this seemed to me to be a simple play. I think they just felt so kind of discombobulated politically between, like, their sort of regular tax, corporate tax treatment needs. Right. They need to stay close to the Trump folks. They were officially like, hey, we like the PTC, but they didn't really throw their weight down. behind it like I had hoped. So I think the politics are swirling around and getting very, very complicated. And that if I were them, I would sort of reevaluate whether you want to cast your lot
with fossil energy and
SPEAKER_01with the Trump enterprise, which politically is sort of going in the wrong direction. And I just think they're very easy to be pissed off about because, you know, I'm a big Yimby, right? I want housing and I want energy and all the rest of it. But it is actually hard. I understand the value of AI, right, in terms of medical research and actually even scientific research related to grid and grid management, services from the government and all the rest of it. Like there is plenty of upside. in AI,
SPEAKER_01but if I'm a regular person in a regular community and it's like, they're not employment centers, right? It's just like, I'm probably gonna betray my ignorance on the technical level, but it's like a box with a bunch of server racks, right? So yeah, people work there, but it ain't like some big economic boom except for the initial CapEx and AI is starting to pop in poles in ways that I think is totally unexpected. On another level, it's tracking with the uptake rate and the extent to which it
is already causing
SPEAKER_01disruption. And so people are going, I'm sorry, what are we doing this for? So that all the jobs can be generated through, because it's not just stupid videos. It's also providing services that human beings are currently providing. So you're telling me I get to pay more for my electricity bill. in exchange for my job no longer existing, right? And I'm not saying that's an entirely fair characterization, but that is definitely the vibe out there. And so the data center folks really need to get in front of
this and have a better theory of the case than don't you think that the gross national product rising
SPEAKER_01because half of the whole economy is now CapEx for data. So isn't that great? That is great. If the only thing you care about is the Dow, But most regular people are going, I just don't I literally don't understand what's in it for me.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. Well, one thing I've been trying to put in people's ears, you know, one thing a data center could do if it needs grid capacity is to fund distributed grid capacity, which is just like funding solar and storage systems on people's houses. If they have electric resistance heating, buy them heat pumps, put batteries on their houses, all that. You could assemble that distributed grid capacity into grid capacity at scale. And like they have all the money to fund it. And that would be a great way of like investing in the community too.
SPEAKER_01100%. And by the way, to your point, these things, their basic value proposition is a non-incremental increase in productivity, which basically has a one-to-one relationship with profitability. And so if one of the externalities, I think one of the externalities is going to be a loss of employment, which is not the subject of this podcast. But the other externality is all this energy use. Well, I'm starting to do the arithmetic on the kind of carbon mitigation,
SPEAKER_01climate mitigation that currently doesn't pencil on a per kilowatt, right? Or per megawatt or per negawatt basis. Well, okay, sure. But if these guys are as profitable as they expect to be, then it'll be a rounding error for them to also set aside resources for carbon dioxide renewal, which like right now we're trying to compare to like regular businesses trying to figure out if they can pencil CDR. They definitely can't. But if you're talking about something that is more profitable
than any enterprise
SPEAKER_01in human history, it's not unreasonable to say, hey, while you're doing this, would you please do some mitigation that, yeah, of course it doesn't pencil on a pure energy basis, but neither does the thing you're doing.
SPEAKER_00And these things, when they're built and they're not hooking up to the grid, are wasting millions of dollars a day in opportunity costs. So really just that, just the money they're burning on opportunity costs, not being able to hook up to the grid, just that money alone is enough to transform a lot of these distributed energy spaces.
SPEAKER_01Yep. And to be fair, there are a lot of exciting things happening because they do feel so urgently about getting electrons that they're doing their own solar and trying to figure out if they can do SMR and whatever. So, you know, I think about AI like I think about climate in the sense that You don't get to wish it away. You can have an opinion about what we should do about it, but you don't get to have an opinion about whether or not it exists. AI is going to exist. There's no possibility of regulating them out of existence.
SPEAKER_01And so what we have to do is manage all the negative externalities, which I think are going to be numerous, and take all the opportunities provided in terms of compute and all the rest of it, I think there's a pathway here, but we have to realize that, like, we got to get to some policymaking and there has to be leadership among the data center folks to realize that, you know, don't you know this is the future is kind of like not the way to get it done.
SPEAKER_00They do seem to, for some reason, they seem really enamored with the nuclear idea, which like maybe that will turn out differently this time, but. Like if I were uniquely in a hurry to get power, that is not the place I would look for fast.
SPEAKER_01No, it's not fast. And, you know, it may end up being fast when they, like on the regulatory side and on the technical and economic side, SMR is super exciting. And by the way, so is geothermal. So there may be a point at which, oh, look, we've got these horizontal, I'm now toggling back to geothermal. We got this new horizontal drilling, you know, closed system, whatever. There's cool stuff happening everywhere. But even that is not ready next year. The only thing that's ready next year is a solar farm.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. And like, that's fine. Right. Because like solar farms work and they're cheap and they're easily deployable. They're not terribly controversial. So in the next, I would say six years, we should be focusing on the stuff that's immediately ready. And then for the 2030s to 2040, I'm all in on all of the new tech. And I don't think we know which one is going to hit and then be scalable. But let's figure that out.
SPEAKER_00Well, the other thing I would just put in your ear is that in addition to needing a lot of energy, there's also enormous uncertainty in the amount of energy that will be needed. Enormous uncertainty. And I always think in a policy environment of uncertainty, you want to make small incremental bets, not giant gambles. And you can do that with solar where you can't do it with something like nuclear or a big gas plant. You can build small increments. You can make small bets.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Like, Hey guys, we need another, we need another megawatt. Cool.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_01We have the land. Great. We can get solar panels. Bang. We're in. Let's talk about energy affordability since it is going to be the heart of the,
SPEAKER_00sort of like the Democratic pitch. Everybody's saying it was at the heart of this New Jersey governor's race, big part of the Georgia PSC races that were just over. Everybody thinks it's going to be a big part of the midterms. So I guess my main question is just like, say you are doing a town hall in Iowa for whatever reason, for whatever reason you happen to be in Iowa doing a town hall, and a constituent asks you, Just the ordinary Democrat off the street ask you, I hear you talking about energy affordability. My bills are high. I hear you talking about energy affordability.
SPEAKER_00What are you going to do? What is the answer to that question? What is the agenda?
SPEAKER_01lift the solar ban, restore the credits and do permitting reform.
SPEAKER_00Those are the big pieces in your mind?
SPEAKER_01Yeah. I mean, I, I also think like, I was having a conversation with my staff about this. Democrats are so wonky and so interested in the substance that we're already talking about exactly what we would do if we were in charge. And I have that instinct too. And don't get me wrong. Like my staff is like, as we speak, like drafting bills for the future trifecta whenever that may occur. But I do think like as a political matter that we would be wise to throttle back
SPEAKER_01and not immediately get into third and fourth gear because midterms are a referendum on the party in charge. Yes. And it is sufficient to say, have you had enough of this shit? Right? Right. And then the kind of energy and affordability agenda, I think we have to have a new sort of social contract with people as it relates to how government even functions with them. I think we need to basically promise people that whatever you need from the federal government, you should be able to get within 10 minutes.
SPEAKER_01Like if you're entitled to something, it should not take hours to get it because then you're not actually getting it. And so I just I think there's a bunch of cool stuff we should talk about in the future. But the truth is that that process is messy and contentious and is usually resolved by getting a nominee. Right. For president. And I don't want us to churn too much. against each other in a kind of competition, political competition, but also a competition of ideas, I think we should refine our pitch,
SPEAKER_01which is, if you put us in charge, we will lift the solar ban. If you put us in charge, we will make it easier to build clean energy. If you put us in charge, we'll restore the credits that we're providing some measure of relief. We don't have to have the kind of 2.0 of what we're going to do ready to roll because that gets really messy. And we could think we did it. But then once we have a nominee, that person is going to say, that's all very lovely legislators, but here's my plan.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, it's going to start from scratch regardless. Well, and I also think that all Democrats should be learning from Mamdani's success. Mamdani's three policies that he ran on, which I, a non-New Yorker, can reel off from memory— were not necessarily the big three policies that are going to be required to run New York City. All of them were on their own merits, relatively small, relatively marginal policies, but they communicated what he cared about.
SPEAKER_00That's what it was. And what kind of person he was.
SPEAKER_01I'm a huge fan of his. I've never said this publicly, only because I've never been asked. But I'm a huge fan of Mamdani. But I also agree, like, eh, freeze the rent. Like, maybe, maybe not. I don't even know the details of how the rent board works, but I'm generally a little cautious about rent control. Like, a government-provided grocery store, like, I don't have some, like, visceral aversion to it, but it didn't sound to me like that was going to, like, do the trick. I don't know what the, oh, free buses. I'm for free buses, but like also if you charged a buck, that doesn't like offend my sensibilities.
SPEAKER_01But to your point, like people understand that whatever you're proposing is going to end up in some meat grinder anyway.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, right.
SPEAKER_01And so you're just communicating, this is the stuff I'm watching. This is the stuff I care about. And I think we need to get back to that. And right now, like there is a planetary emergency and there is a cohort of voters out there who care about that. But guess what? All of them, every single one of them is going to vote for Democrats, right? The question is, how do we swing the people who were pissed off that we had an old president and prices were too high? But now they're pissed off again that we have an old president and prices are too high.
And so, you know, my good buddy, the former governor from Hawaii, Neil Abercrombie, used to say,
SPEAKER_01People vote for you for their reasons, not yours. And their reasons right now is that everything is up and the president looks like he's out to lunch. And I think we should lean into that unapologetically. It doesn't mean that we are sublimating any of our core values. It just means that we're talking to people in such a way that doesn't make us seem like we just like popped out of a salon.
SPEAKER_00Or a white paper development retreat. Yeah, or Brookings.
SPEAKER_01I was going to say Brookings, but I was like, those people are nice.
SPEAKER_00I know. We don't want to shoot a stray at Brookings. They seem fine. One other question about, and this gets back to the green groups. There's a lot of green groups that are against permitting reform. And on a larger level, there's this, I'm sure you've followed the abundance thing. And there's all the politics of that. But there's this sentiment, I think, among abundance groups. that green groups have basically evolved to the point that they are a net negative in this climate fight because they are stuck in the politics of
constraining
SPEAKER_00supply, constraints, limits, etc. And there's all this sentiment that they ought to turn and pivot and And the way this comes down to the ground level is, I think, how we should think about the role of gas and gas pipelines in, say, the next 10 to 20 years. So you got your greens who are just like, no. No fossil fuels, no. And then you got these abundance types now who are saying,
SPEAKER_00yay, more natural gas means cheaper electricity. That's the main thing right now. Shut up. Get on board. I wonder if you have thoughts about... That critique of green groups, whether that sounds accurate to you and whether that's sort of an accurate description of kind of the lay of the land. I mean, what I would do is divide it between the sort of local and the national.
SPEAKER_01Obviously, there's some division among green groups about permitting reform more generally, but I think they're developing. Some of this is just habit and how their political organizations have evolved over time and their members who probably joined their organization to stop something in their neighborhood, right? And so one of the things that I do is try to remind people like I got into the environmental movement through the Save Sandy Beach Coalition, the Save Sunset Beach Coalition. And now I see that we should still protect our precious areas
100 percent.
SPEAKER_01And I'm totally committed to that. But we are in a planetary emergency. We need to build stuff. And so what I see more often than not is that the national environmental organizations understand the need to build electricity transmission and distribution. They understand the need for permitting reform, although it makes them kind of nauseous. They still sort of get it. But I think what happens is where some of that philanthropic money and some of that political money and some of that energy manifests itself locally is kind of John
SPEAKER_01Birch society level nimbyism, where you're protecting the, you know, quote unquote, unique character of a neighborhood. And you're hiding behind some sort of conservation veneer when really you just don't want any shit blocking your view. And I think those people, frankly, do not belong in the climate coalition. I just want to be precise about that, that to the extent that we are in coalition with some like deeply right-wing people who are now weaponizing NEPA
against clean energy,
SPEAKER_01like that's not us, right? That the reason that we all got into this is that there is a planetary emergency and it's going to cause us to have to evolve over time. Like when I got in the Save Sandy Beach Coalition, I was 17 years old. That is a very, very long time ago. So of course my views have evolved because the world has evolved. And so, I just think we need to give each other a little bit of room to evolve here. And there's a little bit of a cottage industry of like, you know, attacking the abundance people, you know, the abundance people attacking leftists and like in the real world,
SPEAKER_01most people kind of understand we're going to have to build some stuff. And also we should protect ecosystems as much as we can along the way. So I just worry that some of this is just like consultants fighting for primacy rather than like humans. Do you agree with the general critique that democratic politicians are sort of
SPEAKER_00overly in hock to the groups, capital T, capital G, sort of like excessively deferential to the groups? That's sort of the larger abundance critique. Does that ring true to you?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I mean, first of all, like, I don't know, I read Abundance, and I don't remember it being like super groups oriented. But I will say that the best critique of the groups that I've heard that I agree with is that some organizations purport to represent people out there in the world, and they do not.
SPEAKER_02Mm-mm.
SPEAKER_01And so I saw this with environmental justice because there were, I mean, literally Washington, D.C. lobbyists who were sort of, I'm an EJ person. And I was like, are you? You know what I mean? And coming from Hawaii, and at the time I was the chairman of the Senate Committee on Indian Affairs, I had pretty good connectivity with people who really do experience environmental injustice and work in this space. And they were like, I don't know who that person is pretending to be like the EJ.
SPEAKER_01Right.
SPEAKER_00Well, there's no certification, right? There's no board handing out. And then I think it's definitely true that some of that stuff happened with the immigration issues where there really was a sea change among immigrant communities
SPEAKER_01about their feelings about border security and everything else. And we were still fighting fights from like a decade earlier. And so it's not that organizations shouldn't exist to influence politicians or elections or public policy. It's that those organizations should be pressure tested in a respectful way about the extent to which they are representing their constituency. That's number one. Number two is, you know, one of the things I said to a number of groups right after we got our asses kicked because there was a little bit more openness to having a conversation is,
SPEAKER_01you know, you're at the table. You're a stakeholder. Yeah. but you're not the convener. It's the people with the election certificates that do the convening, right? And that when a legislature works properly, which is usually a local legislature, not the federal one, then you convene stakeholders and you say, nope, I can't do that for you. Yes, I can do that for you. No, not this year. No, don't be greedy. And you sort it out like a real politician. And that is, I think, the model that we have to get back to as opposed to There's like an email campaign coming from an organization and
a bunch of senators
SPEAKER_01are like downstream from some demand that they've never heard about. That I think is what needed to be broken, but not the idea that groups exist or that there's a progressive ecosystem of people who give a shit about things. We need them, we love them, but we all got our ass kicked. So whether it was the campaign infrastructure, the advocacy infrastructure, my own personal office, the way I operate, like everyone needed to reevaluate how we operate it. And I think we're in the process of recalibrating that. But like,
I am not one of those people who think groups shouldn't exist because groups look,
SPEAKER_01I mean, when you want to fight against repealing the Affordable Care Act, like I know who to call, right? And they are the groups, right? It's move on and it's, you know, protect our care and it's labor. And we rely on them for politics. So we can't pretend we don't. It's just that we needed to get into a more functional space where we're actually collaborating and not just doing sort of pressure politics on each other. Yeah, it does seem like the most vicious politics in America are
intra-left politics.
SPEAKER_00One other question about national, and then we'll wrap up. I guess I'm skeptical about the ability of the Republican Congress to do anything productive... with their opponents, as long as Trump is sort of out there, you know, because he's just like this, he's a wild card, you know, there's no guarantee that he will respect the promises that Republican Congress people make or will be constrained by the laws they pass. So I just wonder, like, should people who are thinking about energy and climate
SPEAKER_00Should we just sort of write off the next two years, or do you think there's any real possibility that Congress can, even in light of Trump's erratic whatever, can make real progress or real deals?
SPEAKER_01I don't know the answer to that, but I think it's like, I mean, I'm not going to try to tell you like, don't be pessimistic. These guys are great. So, I mean, that's not the case. I would bet against them being a productive Congress. I would also say that besides appropriations, permitting reform is probably, you know, in the very top tier of the art of the possible. But we're definitely, first of all, the impediments you described are real. But also, Speaker Johnson may lose control of the House floor overall
over the next month or so.
SPEAKER_00Kind of seems like that's happening.
SPEAKER_01I would just say it's getting quite wild over there. But again, I think the deal space is there, not because I trust anybody, but because our incentives are aligned. We don't have to be in agreement or share values, but we can share interests and try to get a bill done.
SPEAKER_00All right. Okay, final question. I know you're a federal politician and your focus is on federal policy, but Hawaii, which you represent, is, in my world, in energy world, just an endless source of fascination. It is... an island, as you're probably aware, and I'm blowing your mind here. It's an island, and so it has to generate all its own energy. And if it's trying to go clean, islands have particular challenges trying to go clean.
And so I just wonder, into your day-to-day, how much do you really get to engage with Hawaii-specific energy policy and problems, because it's really a fascinating kind of puzzle.
SPEAKER_01So, I mean, it is an island chain. We do have multiple grids each by island, and that creates all these challenges. I was tasked by Governor Abercrombie with sort of supervising the Hawaii Clean Energy Initiative. So there was a point at which I was involved in every little thing. Now I'm mostly just tracking it and also using it as a sort of proof point that you really can integrate so-called intermittent energy into the grid at levels of penetration that had been previously not contemplated and that
We were kind of at the bleeding edge of like clean being cheap and cheap being clean.
SPEAKER_01And now that's true across the country. So, I mean, it is now an example. It was kind of in our mind's eye going to be this example for the rest of the world about how to do solar and battery storage, how to make a grid work. how to do all of this in light of consumers not being endlessly able to pay. And so now I monitor it, but I basically use it to prove that we can do it elsewhere.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. All right. Fair enough. Thank you, Senator. This was delightful as expected. Thanks for coming on.
SPEAKER_01Thanks, David. Take care.
SPEAKER_00Thank you for listening to Volts. It takes a village to make this podcast work. Shout out especially to my super producer, Kyle McDonald, who makes me and my guests sound smart every week. And it is all supported entirely by listeners like you. So if you value conversations like this, please consider joining our community of paid subscribers at volts.wtf or leaving a nice review or telling a friend about volts or all three.
SPEAKER_00Thanks so much. And I'll see you next time.
This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit www.volts.wtf/subscribe When people push for better data centers, they picture hyperscalers - Amazon,...
This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit www.volts.wtf/subscribe America’s first big wave of solar power installations, built between 15 and...
This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit www.volts.wtf/subscribe The Senate’s bipartisan permitting bill got a manager’s amendment last week -...
This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit www.volts.wtf/subscribe Last week’s election was a blue wave all the way down the ballot: Democrats...
This is a free preview of a paid episode. To hear more, visit www.volts.wtf Volts published eight conversations in October, which is a lot for anyone to listen to. We’ve rounded up the highlights into less than an hour....