Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Volts

Volts artwork

NYC's congestion pricing has been running for a year now. How's it doing?

Jan 7, 202659 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

In this episode, I’m joined by Kate Slevin of the Regional Plan Association to discuss the triumphant first year of congestion pricing in Manhattan. We explore how the program defied its critics by boosting business and pedestrian traffic while reducing gridlock, without evident traffic spillover onto adjacent streets. We also cover the money that’s been raised for public transit and what the future holds for the congestion relief zone. This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit www.volts.wtf/subscribe

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_01Greetings, everyone. This is Volts for January 7th, 2026. New York City's congestion pricing has been running for a year now. How's it doing? I'm your host, David Roberts. At the beginning of 2025, after more than 20 years of organizing and pushing by advocates, congestion pricing finally went into effect in Manhattan. It was a close call right to the end.

New York Governor Kathy Hochul delayed the program at the last minute and only

SPEAKER_01implemented it with a $9 charge rather than $15 under intense pressure. The Trump administration has also tried to kill it, an effort which is unfortunately ongoing. Despite how difficult it was to pass and implement all the ups and downs and chaos along the way, congestion pricing has proven to be an almost unalloyed triumph. Traffic is down in the congestion zone and has not risen

outside the zone to compensate.

SPEAKER_01Transit trips are up, buses are moving faster, accidents are down, noise complaints are down, business inside the congestion zone is up. Advocates said it would work, and at least so far, it is working. I wanted to talk to one of those advocates about the one-year anniversary, partly to simply wallow in a rare bit of happy news, and partly to dig a little deeper into the program's performance and future. Happily, I have with me the perfect guest,

SPEAKER_01Kate Slevin, Executive Vice President of the Regional Plan Association, a civic nonprofit that has been involved in this issue for a long, long time. We are going to talk all about the program's performance, its current political health and security, and what we can expect in its future.

SPEAKER_01With no further ado, Kate Slevin, welcome to Volts. Thank you so much for coming.

SPEAKER_00Thank you so much for having me. It's a real pleasure to be here.

SPEAKER_01It's so rare and fun and exciting for me, Kate, to be happy for a while. This is a happy hour, so I'm really relishing it. So I think the place to start is maybe, I don't want to assume people have a lot of background knowledge about this. I think people vaguely know that it happened, but insofar as you can condense the the history to a reasonable amount of time. It's a lot of history, but maybe just briefly walk us through the history of this thing,

SPEAKER_01like the five-minute version. I know there's like an hour version. There's probably like a full documentary version, but give us the five-minute version.

SPEAKER_00Sure, sure. Well, look, New York has always had a challenge in sort of how to pay for its public transit and how to address traffic congestion. This has been sort of a perpetual problem that the city has faced. It's very expensive to operate the MTA system. And over the years, traffic congestion, as the population of the city has grown and more and more people have come to the city, it's just become unbearable,

SPEAKER_00especially in our central business district. So these conversations go way back. I mean, my organization has been around over 100 years, and we found some materials from the 1940s talking about how to deal with traffic in Midtown.

SPEAKER_01No kidding. I wonder how far back the idea of congestion pricing goes. I wonder if anybody knows.

SPEAKER_00It goes way, way back. I mean, decades and decades. And they're actually, you know, when they first opened some of the East River bridges, they put fees on them for people crossing.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, I guess like any toll bridge technically is kind of a form of congestion pricing, is it not?

SPEAKER_00Yeah, it is. And, you know, a lot of things we do are more expensive during certain times and less expensive during other times. Right. So a lot of our stuff is sort of priced based on how many people are using it and at what time. Anyway, so the recent history, if you want to call it that, I think it really started in the early 2000s, I would say, because London instituted a congestion pricing program and New York really sees

SPEAKER_00itself as comparable to London. You know, our populations are similar. We're global cities. were sort of international peers. So many people in New York started thinking about how we could bring congestion pricing or something like it to the city. At that time, the person in power was Mayor Bloomberg. And a couple of years later, he hired a number of people to help him develop a

sustainability plan for the city

SPEAKER_00that was called Plan YC. And, you know, there was talk over months about what would be in that. And in 2007, the plan came out and there were 127 initiatives in that plan. And one of them got the most attention. And guess which one that is? Congestion pricing. So that sort of started the debate at that time.

SPEAKER_01Died in the legislature at the hand of Democrats.

SPEAKER_00Yep. You are right. Yep. It died in the hands of the Democrats in the state legislature who didn't even bring it to a vote. The state assembly didn't even bring it to a vote. But the transit issues and the need to manage traffic didn't go away. It continued on in New York. So a couple of years later, there was a commission that was put together and named after Dick Ravitch, who is just a wonderful public servant and leader and visionary here in New York.

SPEAKER_00called the Ravitch Commission. And they recommended a number of ways to fund transit. And one of the ways was through bridge tolls. And if you know what New York City looks like, you know that if you put fees on the bridges coming into Manhattan, you are effectively putting in a cordon fee. That part didn't make it through, but we did get at that time a thing called the payroll mobility tax authorized. And that brought a bunch of revenue into the transit system. And it's still in effect today.

SPEAKER_00And then around 2015, 2017, there was an increasing issue with traffic, not only in Midtown, but all around the city and just declining transit service. You know, people were overcrowded. There are these horrible images of people being stuck in subway cars where the doors wouldn't open, of overcrowded stations. It really felt unsafe. in a lot of ways, and so there was a lot of urgency to address the situation. And at the same time, Midtown was just crawling. I mean, it's always congested, but it just became unbearable.

So there was a couple coalitions set up, Fix the Subway and Fix Our Transit.

SPEAKER_00These were coalitions that we were part of, and we sort of set these up to advocate for congestion pricing as a solution. And we were successful. And in 2019, it was authorized by the New York State Legislature.

SPEAKER_01And this was, we should just say, a much more democratic legislature than the one that rejected the first plan. Like that democratic legislature that rejected the first one, that was the sort of famous Cuomo Democrat, but not really Democrat. I forget all the details, but it was not the same legislature, basically.

SPEAKER_00The legislature had become more progressive. I think that's fair to say. But Governor Cuomo was the one who advanced congestion pricing and who got it through and who partnered with the legislature to do that. So, you know, he since sort of changed his tune a little bit over the past couple of years, but he was a champion of it at that time. Yeah. So interesting political history. And I used to make a joke, you know, that if you oppose congestion pricing, you might end up in jail because a number of elected officials who opposed previous

SPEAKER_00iterations at the state level ended up, you know, in jail for corruption charges or other horrible things.

SPEAKER_01Correlation or causation. Who can say?

SPEAKER_00Yeah. Yeah. So anyway, then congestion pricing was a little bit delayed due to the first Trump administration and COVID and a variety of things. But eventually we got it through the environmental review process and it was authorized in 2023 by the federal government. It had to go through the federal environmental process because some of the tolls affect federal highways. So that was...

SPEAKER_00something that took a little bit of time to get it through that process. But it succeeded. We got sign off from the federal government for congestion pricing through NEPA, which is the National Environmental Protection Act. And we also got a authorization from the federal government through a specific transportation program called the Value Pricing Pilot Program. which allows states across the country to toll federal highways.

SPEAKER_00So the federal government authorized congestion pricing twice, you know, and was a lot of back and forth with the state and the city about implementing it.

SPEAKER_01And then it was all ready to go.

SPEAKER_00It was all ready to go. And then there was a little bit of a pause in June 2024 by the governor, Governor Hochul, because she had some concerns about implementing it at that time due to an election that was coming up later that year. But the election happened. And in November 2024, she unpaused the program and it went into effect in January on January 5th, 2025. And many of us were in Manhattan,

you know, watching the program go into effect.

SPEAKER_00And it was pretty, pretty wonderful. I mean, you know, there's a lot of advocates, myself included. who've worked on this a very long time. I mean, I started working on it in the early 2000s. So to see this huge environmental and transit policy actually begin, it was pretty excellent. So that's the history.

SPEAKER_01It's a lot. So I want to spend just a minute or two. This is actually the second part I've done about congestion pricing. I did it when it first passed. But in that first part, I didn't actually take much time to really look at kind of the nuts and bolts mechanics of how it works. So tell me, is this right? So there's a zone, meaning there's sort of a southernmost street and a northernmost street. And is it the full east-west breadth of Manhattan in that zone?

So it's in effect in Manhattan, south of 60th Street, actually south of 61st Street.

SPEAKER_00So 60th Street and below.

SPEAKER_01All the way down below that. Everything in Manhattan below that.

SPEAKER_00Correct. However, if you are just traveling on the highways that go on the outside of Manhattan and you don't come into the streets of the city, then you are not charged.

SPEAKER_01I see. Okay. And when you come in and are charged, presumably this is some sort of widget scanning something on your license plate. Like it's automatic, right? Like how does that?

SPEAKER_00It's automatic. It's a bunch of cameras around. It's EasyPass.

SPEAKER_01Ah, so it's based off a pass that most people had already.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, most people have EasyPass. The adoption rate is pretty high at this point. So, you know, you don't actually see anything other than your EasyPass bill being paid if you have EasyPass.

SPEAKER_01I'm sort of curious, if you don't have E-ZPass, what happens?

SPEAKER_00Then you get a bill by mail, you get a fee in the mail. And that's how it is for a lot of our tolls here, whether it's run by the MTA or by the Port Authority or the Thruway Authority. I think most of them have a similar structure at this point. So what happens if I'm on 62nd Street and I drive two blocks south into the zone

SPEAKER_01and then drive back out and then drive back in? Am I charged each time I cross that threshold?

SPEAKER_00You are only charged multiple times if you're a commercial vehicle. If you're a passenger vehicle, you only get charged once per day.

SPEAKER_01But the commercial vehicles pay each time they cross the threshold.

SPEAKER_00Correct.

SPEAKER_01And these are, I guess, all the north-south streets crossing 61st. But then south of that, it's just the bridges coming in to Manhattan, basically.

SPEAKER_00Right.

SPEAKER_01All the traffic coming into Manhattan is coming through those bridges. Right.

SPEAKER_00Right, bridges or tunnels. And I think if you're not familiar with New York City, it's kind of interesting because we have a lot of people who've always, or not always, but for decades have paid tolls to drive into Manhattan. And then there's folks who, because they're using the city bridges, who haven't ever paid anything. So that was one of the potential benefits I think a lot of people saw in congestion pricing is that a lot of people were going out of their way for a cheaper ride. And so this is intended to kind of even the traffic out a

little bit and reduce the

SPEAKER_00burden on communities that, you know, host those formerly free crossings.

SPEAKER_01Interesting.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. In the particular boundary, how was that determined and who determined it? Yeah. I mean, it's seen as our central business district. So just sort of makes sense.

SPEAKER_01That district has a set boundary, like there's a clear boundary in

SPEAKER_00Yeah, I mean, I don't really know who came up with the concept that that was our central business district. But whenever people talk about our central business district or whenever there's studies done or whenever our regional planning organization looks at our central business district, that's kind of the area they use. Now it's called the congestion relief zone, by the way. Congestion relief.

SPEAKER_01A bunch of people, when I threw this out online that I was going to talk about this, I'm sure you've heard this a trillion times. A bunch of people are like, oh, congestion pricing is the worst term for this. You need to call it congestion relief. People are always thinking of better names, better words.

SPEAKER_00I love that conversation. I mean, we've been having that conversation for 20 years. I know. And at some point, we would do these focus groups and these public opinion polls. And what would come back would be that New Yorkers just want it straight. They don't want any BS. They don't want it called something it's not. And once it started to be called congestion pricing, it was really hard to deviate from that because- Then people would think they're trying to be duped or something, right? That the government was trying to play a trick on them and call

this thing something else.

SPEAKER_00And so we kept the term congestion pricing. And in fact, the last coalition we had from the past couple of years, it's now called congestion pricing now. Forget fix our transit, fix traffic. It's just let's get congestion pricing done.

SPEAKER_01That's funny. Yeah. The price level originally was going to be $15. Hoko reduced it to nine. I'm sort of wondering how much science was involved in determining the $15 level. What sort of magic went into deciding that? And then in turn, what was the rationale for nine? Were there clear rationales for either number?

SPEAKER_00Yeah. I mean, look, we have a lot of traffic here in New York City and what they studied in the environmental review was actually between nine and fifteen dollars. Like that was part of the study. So it was within the parameters of what everyone had been talking about and we're expecting. I mean, depending on which side you're on, you could argue that it's too high. Or you could argue that it's not high enough. So I think there's a case to be made that at some point we're going to have to increase it. And that is actually the plan to increase it over the next

couple of years as

SPEAKER_00congestion grows again.

SPEAKER_01We're going to return to that. I mean, there's a certain amount of just kind of picking a number out of the air here because it's hard to know beforehand what exactly will work or what exactly the effect will be.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. Well, I do think it makes sense, though, the $9. And it is... similar somewhat to what the other crossings are. It's not astronomically more, it's less than some. And so that we already have, because we already had tolls on our, some of our crossings, you know, you could use those to kind of start to develop somewhat of a plan.

SPEAKER_01So nine is sort of in the neighborhood, at least, of other tolls. It's not some outlier. Correct. So let's then talk about the effects, how it has gone. And my first question about that is who measures how it's gone? Is the New York City government set up to count cars, measure how fast they're going, et cetera? Or is this something that outside groups have to do? Well, a lot of people have been measuring it and the MCA has been

measuring it.

SPEAKER_00The city has been measuring it. Some of the big tech firms have been measuring it. A number of external civic organizations have been measuring it.

SPEAKER_01A lot of people paying attention.

SPEAKER_00Academic institutions have been measuring it. So we have a lot of data and it's pretty positive. I mean, it's really incredible looking at the past year and to see some of the benefits.

SPEAKER_01I mean, my impression, and tell me if this is wrong, but my impression reading everything around is that even kind of the most enthusiastic proponents have been a little bit surprised at sort of how instantly it worked.

SPEAKER_00Yeah.

SPEAKER_01Like, I guess I'm so used to things going wrong in politics that I was just sort of

SPEAKER_00bracing,

SPEAKER_01I was bracing for something. But like, it really started working almost immediately. Yeah.

SPEAKER_00It did. And you know what? The MTA staff who worked on this, they did an exceptional job of implementing this program because we were sort of expecting, oh, they would get something wrong. There'd be a mix up with some cameras. There'd be this or that. There's been none of that. Interesting. And they just did an exceptional job. And, you know, Daniel Lieber is ahead of it. But Juliette Michelson, Alison De Sereno, there's John McCarthy. There's, you know, dozens of people there who've just done a really fabulous job of communicating this program and then actually doing the nuts and bolts behind the

scenes to make it

SPEAKER_00effective.

SPEAKER_01Right. So tell us what we found here.

SPEAKER_00So, I mean, it was overnight. I couldn't believe it. You know, I was at the entrance to the Holland Tunnel a couple of weeks after it went into effect and there was no traffic and I could hear myself and talk to my friend. I could hear my friend talk and I could walk across the street without having cars everywhere. So it was really visible. And people said, oh, man, like this is amazing. And even some people who were opposed started to support it because they saw the benefits. It is so rare for a public policy to work so clearly that even

normal people aren't

SPEAKER_01reading the news every day. They're not following politics. For a policy to work so well that it thrusts itself into the sort of daily experience of normal people, that is rare. Yeah.

SPEAKER_00Exactly. The funniest thing I thought was that a few weeks after the program went into effect, there was a public opinion poll done by the Partnership for New York City. And one of the things they found was that the people who supported it most were the people who were paying the toll and driving into the congestion relief zone frequently. Yeah.

SPEAKER_01Because there was less traffic inside it.

SPEAKER_00Yes. Yes, exactly. What do you know? Exactly. And the people who were the most opposed were still the people who rarely drove into the congestion relief zone. And a lot of them didn't even own a car or didn't even live in an area where they would be driving into the zone. So they're sort of either they're sitting on the subway thinking, one day I might have to pay that and I'm not going to want to pay it. Or they're somewhere else entirely.

SPEAKER_01You know, a lot of this is ideological, right? I mean, a lot of it is. I suspect the less direct experience you have with it, the more sort of ideological your opinion about it is.

SPEAKER_00Absolutely. So just in terms of the effects, the obvious thing is there are fewer cars inside the zone. I forgot to ask when I was talking about the mechanics, but this is 24 hours a day? Yeah, but it's different rates. So it goes down.

SPEAKER_01Oh, so it is dynamic.

SPEAKER_00It's dynamic. It's just a different price. It's $9 during the day. And then it goes down overnight to a couple dollars.

SPEAKER_01Interesting. Okay. But there are fewer cars in there.

SPEAKER_00Yeah.

SPEAKER_01So there's less traffic inside it. The cars that are going in, as you say, are the most enthusiastic cars. Supporters of this, because when they do go in, they are now moving faster. The buses are moving faster. Transit ridership is up, which I guess was predictable, but also, I guess I'm surprised that that effect is so clear and immediate. Did you expect that? I mean, I guess if fewer people are driving in, more people are subwaying in.

I guess it makes sense, but I guess, I don't know, I found that delightful.

SPEAKER_01Is that something people expected? Yeah.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, I think so. I mean, that's the whole purpose of it, right, is to grow transit ridership and to make transit better. But I just want to narrow in on a couple statistics here because it's just amazing. I mean, first, you have to consider that New York City, the MTA region here, has 40% of the country's transit ridership.

SPEAKER_01Yes, I know. It's crazy. Yeah.

SPEAKER_00We have to make transit work in New York. And so this affects a lot, a lot of people. And what you've seen over the past year is you've seen that transit ridership grow. You've seen over $400 million that's been raised through congestion pricing.

SPEAKER_01We're going to get to the money in a minute.

SPEAKER_00I got questions about the money. But 20 million fewer vehicles have entered the congestion relief zone than in 2024.

SPEAKER_01And that is having all the knock-on effects you would expect, which is that the people in there are going faster, buses are going faster, crashes are down, injuries and deaths are down.

SPEAKER_00I think that's really one to think about and focus on. I mean, the traffic safety has improved dramatically in the zone. That's because there's 80,000 fewer vehicles per day coming into the congestion relief zone.

SPEAKER_01I was very interested in this noise complaints are down as well. Like Manhattan is less loud.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. And they're down 45%.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. That's striking. I always think that noise pollution is kind of a, I feel like people overlook it in the pollution discussion, but like when I took some time to actually read about noise pollution, like it's really deadly. Like it causes heart disease. It causes like mental issues. Like noise is really bad. So very striking, very striking effect.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. And you can feel that physically, you know, you feel that in the zone now that it's just like I said, like that it's just quieter.

SPEAKER_01It's a lower stress response.

SPEAKER_00Totally lower. Whenever you're on a street in the city where there isn't traffic, it's just a totally different experience.

SPEAKER_01It's something that's slightly puzzling. I think a lot of people expected when traffic declined inside the zone, that it would increase a little bit on the streets outside the zone. The streets that allowed you to bypass the zone or the streets near the zone, that like a bunch of traffic would be sort of shunted to those streets. But as far as I can tell, that has not happened.

SPEAKER_00No, it hasn't. And that was actually one thing that was identified in the environmental... review documents was that the potential that traffic might go up in a couple isolated areas across the city and across the region. But, you know, we actually at our PA, my colleagues, Rachel Weinberger and Will Cow found that traffic delays are actually down 25% within the congestion relief zone. We used Waze data to look at that. And they're also down 9% region wide. Wild.

And this includes parts of New Jersey and Staten Island and the Bronx too. So it's really benefited not only the congestion relief zone, but the area surrounding it.

SPEAKER_01Right. If anything, it's lowering traffic in the zone around it, which is just like, if you're another city looking at this and thinking about it, that to me is just huge. That's a huge, incredibly significant finding because that's the thing that people wave around when they're scared about. This always, especially people who live sort of on the periphery of the zone. I'm curious, has there been any effects on housing? I thought maybe it might be sort of like too early to kind of

tell because housing

SPEAKER_01moves a little bit more slowly. But I just wonder, like, has there been any discernible effect on housing, housing density, housing prices? Yeah.

SPEAKER_00I don't know that we've looked at that. I mean, look, a lot of people have left the five boroughs of New York City, as we know, because of our lack of affordable housing, especially families, especially middle income and working families. So we have a lot of data about where people have moved to and why. And that's been a perpetual challenge in the city. But, you know, half of the households in New York don't own a car. A lot of people are on public transit anyway. So I think the priority is really getting better public transit

so you can support

SPEAKER_00more housing and support more reliable commutes for people.

SPEAKER_01I will be curious, like if this thing can run for, you know, like London's, five years, 10 years. I'd be really curious to see if there are discernible housing effects in that zone. That would be super interesting. Another thing that people worried about was people obscuring their license plate to avoid these charges. I know in New York City, this is a big thing with people doing it to avoid parking tickets and When they park in bike lanes and all this, I know there's a whole low-level guerrilla warfare in New York

City about this.

SPEAKER_01Has this increased in the wake of all this? Is that a substantial problem? Are there a substantial number of people avoiding this, or is it even possible to avoid it? There's a whole group of people who are out there who will catch you if you do this.

SPEAKER_00So for anyone listening, I would not recommend it. The fees are high. The MTA has a whole part of its organization that is focused on collecting the money from toll sheets. So not recommended for anyone listening.

SPEAKER_01Well, also, I guess just as a citizen of Manhattan, that is someone who is literally taking money out of your transit, right? So even like, I would imagine like ordinary people are not particularly sympathetic to doing

SPEAKER_00this. No, no. And it has been a problem. I don't know that I would call it a substantial problem, but the MTA has worked really hard and continues to work really hard to try and bring down the evasion rates. And, you know, so many people are using easy pass and You know, it does help. But of course, there's always going to be the people who try and cheat the system. And those folks do exist, unfortunately. Before we move on past the effects, are there any others that you'd like to sort of call out?

SPEAKER_01I mean, I know there are some weird sort of artifacts here and there. Like someone sent me a chart showing that AM rush hour traffic in the Lincoln Tunnel has slightly increased. which they had no explanation for. Like, are there any weird effects that you have taken note of or don't quite know how to explain or that puzzle you?

SPEAKER_00I don't know that there's anything that puzzles me that much. I mean, I will say some things that we didn't think about that have happened. School buses are moving 5% faster compared to last year and are on time 72% of the time versus 58% of the time last year. And bus speeds have increased within the congestion relief zone. Oh, and one other thing is that I should have mentioned this sooner, but retail sales are actually on track. There was a lot of worry that this was going to kill the

economy and stop people

SPEAKER_00from coming to New York. That has not been the case at all. And this is true, I saw also in the New York Times about pedestrian traffic in the zone.

SPEAKER_01Pedestrian traffic has not declined. Visits to businesses inside the zone have not declined. They're still as robust as ever.

SPEAKER_00Yep. As of this summer, that's right. Yep. One question I had is how to think about what's going to happen in the long term now. If you told me a story where traffic and population naturally increase over time,

SPEAKER_01and so that increase will affect the congestion zone too, and thus congestion zone revenue will increase over time, I would find that believable. But then if you told me, as people get more and more accustomed and understand that this one zone is expensive, more people will avoid it, avoid driving into it, and thus revenue will decline over time. I guess I would also believe that.

So I guess I just don't have strong priors on how we expect this to evolve over time.

SPEAKER_01I guess we can draw on experience from London somewhat for this. Like how do you absent any price increases? Let's say if we just had the same zone, same price for 10 years, how would you expect things to change over time? Hey there, everybody. Don't worry, I'm not going to tell you about a new mattress or push a credit card on you. This isn't an ad. There are no ads on Volts. It is supported entirely by listeners like you. If you'll indulge me for a second, I'd like to ask for your support.

I started Volts because we're all surrounded by depressing news about climate

SPEAKER_01change and misinformation about clean energy. And it's never been more important to share the stories of the real people on the ground doing the real work of transition and all the ingenuity and courage and public spirit they are bringing to it. People are hungry to hear these stories, to learn from and find inspiration in them. I've heard from people who change majors or careers after hearing episodes of Volts. People using it in classrooms, community groups, even state legislators who have passed bills inspired by

specific episodes.

SPEAKER_01Sharing these stories matters. It makes a difference. If you have found value in it and want to help me continue doing it, I hope you will join the community of paid subscribers at volts.wtf. It's about the cost of a cup of coffee a month. If you don't like subscriptions, you can make a one-time contribution, leave a review on Apple or Spotify, or just tell a friend about volts. I am grateful for any and all support. If you're already a paid subscriber, thank you. And now back to the show. Absent any price increases,

SPEAKER_01let's say, if we just had the same zone, same price for 10 years, how would you expect things to change over time?

SPEAKER_00Well, I will say first that the toll is supposed to go up. I think starting in a couple years, it'll slowly go up to $15. So if that's not for 2026, it'll stay the same next year. Yeah. but i think you can look at london i mean they did increase the toll over time they expanded the zone they laid over other policies like they have a low emission zone they have redesigned their streets to accommodate cycling and bus transit and done

SPEAKER_00a lot of other things to kind of continue to bring the benefits of congestion pricing to the people of London. So the next challenge for New York is, you know, now that you have less traffic, you have to maintain that and you have to continue to make the transit system better and sort of make the city more vibrant and easier to get around for New Yorkers and for everyone visiting there. That is, I think the next challenge and the challenge that the mayor, you know, has said some wonderful things about.

SPEAKER_00So we're very excited about the next couple of years in that regard.

SPEAKER_01Well, I guess what's informing my question is it seems to me there's sort of a tension or a trade-off. Like on the one hand, the goal of the program is to reduce traffic in the zone. But if you accomplish that, you thereby reduce revenue. So like the other goal of the program is to raise revenue for transit, right? So if you're succeeding in raising revenue, that means you're failing at reducing the traffic in the zone. So how do you think about that trade-off?

SPEAKER_00Look, there is this inherent tension in most transportation revenue. It's true for tolls. It's true for the gas taxes, right? It's an interesting conversation. I mean, ideally, we would have a system where... you would have more resources for public transit investment, and you wouldn't necessarily need to lean on all these outside revenue sources. But there's a real policy reason to ensure that you have a good balance in terms of

SPEAKER_00traffic on the streets. This is a scarce resource, right? Our streets in the city, they're a scarce resource. And if you have too many people trying to use them, Then it just becomes a total mess. So there is a real reason to price people driving into the city. And that's been one of the reasons we strongly supported it. But I do think this conversation around, you know, the traffic is going to start to grow at some point. And then what happens? Then you have to sort of bring the toll up. You have to try and use some other policy choices to balance it out.

What I would worry about more is traffic declining and then revenue declining. And insofar as you've made plans for MTA improvements premised on this revenue,

SPEAKER_01can you plan around it?

SPEAKER_00Yeah, I mean, look, they have been planning around it for a long time because they've had toll revenue from their bridges and tunnels for many years. The Port Authority, another transportation agency that is the one that collects the tolls on the Hudson River crossings, they also are in a similar situation where they rely very heavily on the tolls to invest in the pass system and the airports and maintaining those bridges and tunnels. And they've managed to, both agencies have managed to balance that trade-off and ensure

the toll was the

SPEAKER_00right price. And it's also New York, and there's always going to be traffic, unfortunately, for all of us who live and work here. So that's just the case.

SPEAKER_01So let's talk about the money then. The point of this is to raise money for transit. And so I guess my first question is, legally speaking, how secure is this money? How tied to transit is it? You know what I mean? Because I guess one worry, obviously, for anything that raises money like this is that some politician is going to come on at some point that's going to want to raid the money for other things. So I'm just curious, sort of in terms of the letter of the law, what does it say about the revenue?

SPEAKER_00Well, it's in the legislation that was authorized that all of the revenue coming in, which is supposed to raise $15 billion over five years, it will go to public transit. And that's written in the law. And they actually even... Not only public transit, but specifically the capital program of the MTA. And they even identified how much of that money would go to each part of the system, with 20% going to the commuter rail systems and 80% going to

the subways and buses

SPEAKER_00of New York City Transit.

SPEAKER_01You're not concerned at all about that fund getting raided. You think people can be confident that this is absolutely going to transit?

SPEAKER_00Yeah, I mean, for the time being, right? That's not on the list of worries right now.

SPEAKER_01How much has been raised and invested so far? And I know, again, we're very early in the game here, but are there visible impacts of those investments in transit? Is there something that the mayor can point to and say, this is what congestion pricing gave you? Yeah, I have to correct you there because this is a common misconception.

SPEAKER_00The MTA is controlled by the governor of New York. That is Kathy Hochul. The New York City mayor does not control the MTA. That is crazy. They can appoint a few people to the MTA board, but they do not actually control the agency. It's a state agency. And it's a state agency because it not only operates the system within the city, but it also operates the commuter rail system that goes to the Westchester and the Hudson Valley and Long Island.

SPEAKER_01Well, in that case, I mean, even more so, Hochul, who took it, you know, like, I've given her lots of guff over the years, but she did take a chance and do this. She really needs to be able to point to something and say, congestion pricing bought this. Is there sort of evidence on the ground yet?

SPEAKER_00Yes. I mean, there is. Well, first we talked about the traffic benefits and sort of the visible benefits to us all.

SPEAKER_01But specifically in transit.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. The MTA has already advanced projects, so they'll be on track to generate about $500 million in 2025. In the first year. In the first year. And then they bond that out to pay for capital projects. And capital projects, for those who aren't familiar, they're like the actual things, the physical infrastructure. So it's things like station upgrades, track maintenance, accessibility improvements, new rail cars, new buses, all that sort of physical infrastructure.

SPEAKER_00It's not going to the operating budget. It's just going to the capital improvements. But they've already bought new subway cars, the new rail cars that that you can actually see through the rail cars into the other ones, open sort of system. They've bought those. They have purchased new LIR locomotives. They are installing new signal upgrades on a number of lines so they can allow trains to run closer together.

And they've advanced those signal upgrades and they've brought ADA accessibility

SPEAKER_00upgrades to about 23 stations. And now is someone in Hochul's government being smart enough to hang some signage

SPEAKER_01next to all this saying congestion pricing did this? Is someone making sure that the public understands congestion pricing? that congestion pricing did this.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. I mean, look, the governor has been a great champion on this. He's tried to explain, you know, the benefits and what has been advanced because of congestion pricing. in terms of MTA projects and upgrades, but it's a pretty hectic and busy media scene. So I think that is a point that we all need to reiterate more and more is that the money is not just going into the general funds or a random place in the state of

SPEAKER_00New York's budget. It is all going to investing in the infrastructure that allows the city to run. So that's a point we're gonna be making over and over again.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. I'd love for somebody to put some money into – I think about federally the Inflation Reduction Act, of course, haunting me. Great piece of legislation that no one ever really found out about and no one ever knew that the benefits were the benefits. So ever since then, I've been very pounding the table about this. You've got to tell – you really have to tell people.

SPEAKER_00Absolutely.

SPEAKER_01In unmistakable terms.

SPEAKER_00Absolutely. And there are ads now and there is more visibility around this, but I couldn't agree more with you about that point.

SPEAKER_01So in terms of how this program is going to evolve, you say that the plan is to slowly raise the charge back up to the original $15. Yeah. When you say that's the plan, is that like written down somewhere, like legally part of the plan, or is that just sort of what people expect?

SPEAKER_00It's what the NCA board approved. So legally, that is the plan.

SPEAKER_01And in increments or just jump up to 15 one day?

SPEAKER_00It's a couple increments and it'll go up to 15 over several years. I think by 2031.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. You know, it's funny because someone sent me a study on public opinion on the Swedish. There are two cities in Sweden that have congestion pricing and they were showing public opinion. And it's really funny, like public opinion is negative right before you do it. Yeah. And then after you put it into place, opinion grows. Approval grows over time. But then when you change it, when you boost it, the whole cycle resets.

SPEAKER_01Opinion goes back down. Opinion goes back down and then starts creeping back up again. It really does seem like it's not so much the fee that people don't like. It's just change of any kind that bugs the public. So I wonder. It'll be very interesting to watch and see. what if any effect that has on public opinion when it when it rises yeah that moment before it goes into effect when it's a lot of negative attention a lot of people call that the valley of death yes so we went through it

and and came back

SPEAKER_00out the other side but um I'm just wondering if changes will be like little mini valleys of death along the way. Look, it's always a big discussion and public debate whenever the fares or tolls are raised. And I think that will certainly be contentious. At the same time, I think people are appreciating the traffic reduction benefits and are understanding on why we need it. And more and more people are supporting it. I think the more you can predict and provide regular,

SPEAKER_00smaller, incremental changes to tolls and to fares, rather than a big shock to the system one day, I think that's a better approach to go as a government agency than just... you know, not putting any increases in and then getting yourself in a big problem in a couple of years where you haven't been responsible. So we're very supportive of the growing it up to 15 over a number of years and we'll be publicly saying so and supporting it as that advances.

SPEAKER_01One of the sort of policy arguments you see around this, some people will point to possible benefits of more dynamic pricing. So they'll say like, you know, the charge should be higher on a particularly congested day or on a particularly bad air quality day or something like that. You know what I mean? Like the fee should change in response to... circumstances. And then of course, on the other side, you have people being like,

that's annoying as hell.

SPEAKER_01People are just going to be annoyed by that. Don't do that. Has that discussion, have you been through that discussion?

SPEAKER_00Yeah. A lot of us have debated that. I think from a policy perspective, it would be great to have dynamic pricing, but in the political realm in New York and just from a day-to-day person who travels around the city, it would cause a lot of problems, I think, to not know how much it would cost for a trip. So I think there's places to improve on in terms of maybe you want to

SPEAKER_00charge even more during the peak periods of the day, the very, very busy periods of the day and not make it $9 all the way across the entire daylight hours and going to nine o'clock actually at night. Maybe there's some room for modification there, but I do think it has to be predictable for people. I don't think we're ready for dynamic pricing on this thing yet. Yeah.

SPEAKER_01If people's reaction to Uber's dynamic pricing is any indication, I don't think people like it much.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. And also think about how much that charge would have to be. I mean, you could probably see days when it's very expensive. So I support that idea and getting there in concept someday. I don't think we're quite ready for it anytime soon. And in terms of the geography, you say the zone is going to be expanded or might be expanded.

SPEAKER_01Is that also written into the plans or...

SPEAKER_00No, there's no plans to expand the zone. I was just saying that's what London did.

SPEAKER_01Got it.

SPEAKER_00And I think, you know, I do think there's areas around the city that are very congested and there's a reason to consider that in the future, but there's no plans right now to expand the congestion pricing zone. It's in effect in Manhattan, south of 60th Street, and it will be for many years, I expect.

SPEAKER_01This is pure speculation, obviously, but if you were just purely speculating, which would you think is more likely that another different congestion zone is born somewhere in the region, like in a different congested area, or that this zone just expands?

SPEAKER_00That's a good question. I mean, I think that the big highways in our region that are very congested, they've always seemed to me like some of the places where it doesn't make any sense that we have so much congestion on them and that... you know, they're as poorly maintained as they are. So maybe it would be some of the big interstates that really run through our region and are massively congested. And a lot of them are already told, like New Jersey turnpikes are already told,

right?

SPEAKER_00The throughways are already told. So that would kind of just be an extension of a system we already have. But again, there's no plans to do any of that right now. But look, there are very congested areas in New York and the surrounding zones like Jersey City and downtown Brooklyn or Long Island City are almost as congested as Manhattan.

SPEAKER_01Well, I'm sure they're all watching. Let's talk briefly about opposition to this issue.

SPEAKER_00There's no opposition. No one's opposed.

SPEAKER_01The opposition has vanished. It vanished like a puff of smoke once they implemented it. Well, I'm sort of curious if you've seen a change in either the tone of opposition or the composition of opponents. Do you know what I mean? Over the course of this year, like, is it fair to say that opposition is, has kind of fallen off as much quieter has kind of been tamped down or is it, are all the same people still saying all the same things? What's your sort of read on the political valence of the thing

within the New York region?

SPEAKER_00Oh, it's way lower. I mean, it's just incredible how much has changed from a year ago. I mean, there's some pretty relevant points, I think, on that. You know, during the past year, one of the biggest opponents has been the state of New Jersey. The current governor opposed it.

SPEAKER_01A lot of New Jersey representatives were very

SPEAKER_00They were not happy about it. And actually the bus riders coming from New Jersey are some of the biggest beneficiaries in the entire region of congestion pricing. But that's not my point. The gubernatorial race that just happened last month, everyone thought congestion pricing would be a big issue in that race and that it would be something that every candidate would sort of weigh in on and use in their campaign. And we really didn't see that at all.

SPEAKER_01Interesting. So I think that just shows you that it was more popular than a lot of people expected it would be once it was implemented and people started seeing the

SPEAKER_00benefits. And you certainly see that in the media. It's just totally, totally shifted. And the public opinion poll's show the same thing as well. So it's a totally different environment today than it was one year ago. Way, way, way, way, way more support. And I think a lot of the opposition that we're seeing now is actually from people totally outside the region who are, as you said, like ideologically opposed.

SPEAKER_01For sure.

SPEAKER_00And so they're weighing in on that, but locally much more support.

SPEAKER_01Just curious, you do have a new mayor. Has he weighed in on this? Yeah, he's supportive. I mean, I guess as you say, he doesn't control it. So I guess it doesn't matter that much.

SPEAKER_00Well, he does have appointees on the MTA board. So that's important. But he's a supporter and I expect he will continue to be.

SPEAKER_01Well, one prominent opponent is Donald J. Trump. Bad talked it before it went into effect. Threatened, blah, blah, blah. Launched a lawsuit a while back. There was some judgment in favor of New York, but it didn't seem to really end the thing. So just how realistic of a prospect is it that Trump could actually get to this thing and hurt it?

SPEAKER_00Well, let me tell you first off that there's been 12 cases brought seeking to stop New York's congestion pricing program. And now a few of them are still pending, but not a single court has ordered the MTA to haul implementation of the program. and to do anything of that nature. So the courts have largely been on side of the MTA. There is a case right now. I mean, this was something that the older lawyers I know, I'm not a lawyer,

but older lawyers I know could not believe something that happened last year.

SPEAKER_00The federal government filed a case to stop the MTA from continuing congestion pricing, even though, as I said previously, the United States has approved congestion pricing twice. But the actual legal counsels for the USDOT leaked an internal memo by accident Stating all the reasons why the USDOT's case to stop MTA's congestion pricing program was bad. And they didn't have legal standing.

SPEAKER_00And the older lawyers I know couldn't believe that. They said, I've never seen anything like this in my life. Like, this is just ridiculous. This is a big mistake. And I'm sure they're very embarrassed. But, you know, the MTA has a very strong case. Yeah.

SPEAKER_01That's like a Tuesday. I'm sure the public is on to new screw-ups. Yeah, that's amazing. So they don't have particular faith in their case.

SPEAKER_00They don't. Well,

SPEAKER_01I mean, one thing that we all have to be scared about, I feel like, these days is something going up to the Supreme Court, and those guys don't seem to care about anything, but just giving Trump whatever he wants. Is there any?

SPEAKER_00Yeah.

SPEAKER_01Are you nervous at all about this lawsuit as it currently stands?

SPEAKER_00Well, the USDOT actually sent a letter saying that the MTA had to stop. I should correct myself that the MTA then filed the case against the USDOT for that letter. So I have to make sure I'm clear on that because it's confusing because it's actually the MTA versus Duffy is the name of the case. But I think the MTA has got a great legal argument. I mean, the judge, when he had the hearing this spring, he was very clear that the MTA was on strong legal standing.

He was not allowing any of the sort of shenanigans that the USDOT was trying to do,

SPEAKER_00like withhold federal transportation funds from New York. The judge said, absolutely not. You can't do that. We will proceed with the case, but you can't take any punitive measures against the MTA for this. So I think the MTA is on very strong legal footing in this case. Most people do. The case is still pending. We'll see what happens when a final verdict is released. But like my organization, we don't do much in terms of filing lawsuits or filing amicus briefs,

SPEAKER_00but we did in that case because it was so clear that that the MCA was in the right.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, well, this is, I mean, unfortunately, this is like a characteristic of many of these sort of Trumpian legal pursuits. It's like, no one thinks the cases are any good. It really is just like, do you find the right crazy judge? Do you find the right Trumpy judge who will do it anyway, even though the case sucks? But it sounds like... It's hard to predict these things, but it sounds like it's pretty safe. So I guess then final question,

obviously a huge piece of this is that lots of other cities in America and the

SPEAKER_01world are thinking about this. and have their eyes on this, you know, when other cities call you, what are the lessons that can be learned from New York? I mean, the obvious lesson seems like it works, you know, like it worked in London. It seems to be working in terms of reducing traffic in the affected zones, wherever it's done. But are there other lessons that you feel like other cities have can take from not just sort of the success of the program,

SPEAKER_01but the whole 20-year fight to make it happen? Like, what do you counsel other places?

SPEAKER_00Well, look, I think it shows that big policy change is still possible and it's necessary in the time we're living in. And, you know, often we, as a society, debate about some of these smaller policy changes that And if we're going to have all of these battles over a small change, you might as well go big and try to win something that's actually transformational like this is. I do think something that is less talked about in New York, and I'm obviously biased because I worked both in government and

SPEAKER_00in a civic group during the 20 years that we've been debating this, but having an outside coalition of supporters and making it a diverse coalition and ensuring that you have the government and an external group of real civic entities and community voices and business leaders who are actually working for something is really necessary. When we talk to other regions, the business communities are not coming along You think that's kind of the key pivot point here is that you

got some business on

SPEAKER_01your side in this fight? I think it made all the difference in New York to have the business community and

SPEAKER_00some of the big employers supportive of this. And in other places, when we talk to people, their business communities and business leaders are much more fearful to get involved. Transit is good for everyone. Less traffic is good for everyone. Cleaning the air is good for everyone. We didn't really talk about that, but the air quality looks like it's improving.

SPEAKER_01I forgot to even mention that bit.

SPEAKER_00Well, we need a couple more years here to ensure that it's actually an improvement, but the numbers look really good so far in terms of air quality and public health.

SPEAKER_01But I do think business not declining inside the zone is so important. I mean, this is the thing you realize when you work in urbanism and these issues for a while is that every time they sort of pedestrianize or otherwise reduce car traffic around a business, the business people have the same fear. And it never plays out, ever, ever, ever. I've never seen an instance yet where a business can come say, see, I told you this would happen.

SPEAKER_01It never happens. And yet, no accumulation of evidence seems sufficient to convince the next set of business people. It's a little wild to me. So I do think it is important that business specifically is both benefiting and supporting people.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, absolutely. And I, you know, there's a lot of lessons that we have in New York. And if anyone listening wants to reach out and talk to me or anyone else involved in this, we'd be happy to chat because I think we're excited about the possibility of these ideas and big climate and transit policies working in other places and advancing in other places. And we've taken a lot of inspiration in our work from other cities, not only in the US, but across the world as well. So happy to share with anyone who wants to talk more.

SPEAKER_01Awesome. All right. Well, we will leave it there. Thank you, Kate. This is just like a little, a little lantern in the darkness. Thank you for coming and walking, walking us through this and good luck in the next few years.

SPEAKER_00Thanks. Thanks. It was really my pleasure. And thank you so much for everything you do and for your support of this program. We really, really appreciate it. And, you know, we should talk again after the, to see what's next on the legal front. Cause I think that's the next thing.

SPEAKER_01Indeed.

SPEAKER_00Take care.

SPEAKER_01Thank you for listening to Volts. It takes a village to make this podcast work. Shout out especially to my super producer, Kyle McDonald, who makes me and my guests sound smart every week. And it is all supported entirely by listeners like you. So if you value conversations like this, please consider joining our community of paid subscribers at volts.wtf or leaving a nice review or telling a friend about volts or all three. Thanks so much.

SPEAKER_01And I'll see you next time.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Can a developer turn data centers’ reputation around?

    Nov 20, 20261 hr 6 minAudio

    This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit www.volts.wtf/subscribe When people push for better data centers, they picture hyperscalers - Amazon,...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. “Repowering” worn out solar fields could create gigawatts of new grid capacity, quickly

    Nov 18, 20261 hr 18 minAudio

    This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit www.volts.wtf/subscribe America’s first big wave of solar power installations, built between 15 and...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. The federal permitting bill has been updated. What changed?

    Nov 11, 20261 hr 59 minAudio

    This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit www.volts.wtf/subscribe The Senate’s bipartisan permitting bill got a manager’s amendment last week -...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. So, how about those midterm elections?

    Nov 9, 20261 hr 26 minAudio

    This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit www.volts.wtf/subscribe Last week’s election was a blue wave all the way down the ballot: Democrats...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Best of October 2026

    Nov 6, 202614 minAudio

    This is a free preview of a paid episode. To hear more, visit www.volts.wtf Volts published eight conversations in October, which is a lot for anyone to listen to. We’ve rounded up the highlights into less than an hour....

    Credit the people on this episode