Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Volts

Volts artwork

A limited defense of Biden's everything-bagel industrial policy

May 27, 20261 hr 8 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit www.volts.wtf/subscribe Conventional punditry loves the narrative that woolly-headed progressive standards over-burdened federal climate spending and slowed everything to a crawl. In this episode, I talk with Betony Jones about her time designing labor policies at the DOE and what she learned from interviewing dozens of companies that received federal funding. We explore the difference between bad rules and weak administrative capacity, how the DOE successfully streamlined century-old Davis-Bacon compliance, and why creating high-quality jobs is essential for global competitiveness.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_00Hello and greetings, everyone. This is Volts for May 27th, 2026. A limited defense of Biden's everything bagel industrial policy. I'm your host, David Roberts. Last year, in their book, Abundance, Ezra Klein and Derek Thompson popularized an argument about the Biden administration's industrial policy that has since become something like

SPEAKER_00conventional wisdom. It goes like this. By attaching so many well-meaning progressive requirements to every tax break or grant, labor standards, community benefit standards, local hiring standards, domestic content standards, they overburdened the policy and made it slow and bureaucratic. Consequently, the money didn't get out the door fast enough, voters' lives were not changed quickly enough, Biden did not get any public or electoral credit for his policies,

SPEAKER_00and so Trump won. That, at least, is the official line. Bettany Jones ran labor and jobs policy at the Department of Energy under Biden and was responsible for developing those labor standards, which applied to thousands of projects totaling over $100 billion. You will not be surprised to hear that she has a rather different take on the subject. And she's not just drawing from her personal experience. She has spent the last year interviewing executives at a dozen

plus companies that

SPEAKER_00received federal clean energy funding to find out what happened, what really did slow things down. What she found was that the labor and community conditions were generally more welcomed than burdensome. The real bottlenecks were in implementation. She wrote up her findings in a report called The Receipts, which I find very amusing. I am excited to talk with her today about what we should and

shouldn't be learning

SPEAKER_00from the Biden industrial policy experience. With no further ado, Bettany Jones, welcome back to Volts. Thank you so much for coming.

SPEAKER_01Thank you. It's so great to be here.

SPEAKER_00I want to start with this sort of abundance critique thing. Despite my somewhat provocative title for this episode, you are not here to defend the whole bagel, the whole everything bagel. We're mainly here to focus on labor standards and community benefit standards, the sort of workforce side of things. and so the question is whether these and other workforce standards are getting in the way of the speed and scale of industrial policy that we

want so there's sort of two questions you could ask about these standards one is the empirical questions which is do they in fact slow things down did they in fact slow things down are

SPEAKER_00they in fact burdensome And then secondly, there's the political question, which is whether attaching these kind of standards makes the policy, makes the bill look more explicitly progressive, thereby polarizing it, thereby making it more difficult to pass. So there's sort of a substantive critique and a political critique. I want to take those one at a time. But before we jump into any of that, maybe let's just back up. And I just want to ask you,

you know, what was Biden's approach on workforce issues? Because, you know, this general family of issues goes way back in the Democratic coalition. I'm just curious like what was Biden's innovation what was new about the Biden administration's approach to workforce issues and how would you characterize that

SPEAKER_00approach

SPEAKER_01We can talk about Biden's approach to workforce issues. I tend to see these things through the lens of climate policy, and we tried for decades. You know, I've been working on climate policy since the Clinton administration, and there have been many, many efforts to advance climate policy through regulation, through Waxman-Markey, a lot of different efforts, a lot of thoughts around carbon taxes. Nothing got across the finish line until we had a climate policy that had a really broad agenda and had a broad political

coalition advancing it

SPEAKER_01that included left-behind communities, environmental justice communities, the labor movement included the climate advocates. And so by design, this climate policy, the set of policies, the Inflation Reduction Act, the bipartisan infrastructure law, and really the Chips and Science Act is suite of three policies to address the climate crisis was by design intended to deliver to those constituents who lent

SPEAKER_01their political muscle to getting that across the finish line. So, you know, in some ways to go back and then critique that those very things that were baked in by design and the whole reason that we have these policies to implement in the first place were responsible for their some failure like that never really made sense to me I don't want to get too off on too

SPEAKER_00much talking about the abundance stuff but like When the green movement tried to be surgical, right? And clean and only go after carbon emissions in the way that was approved by economists, right? And didn't have any of this everything bagel stuff on it. it failed and everybody yelled at the green movement oh what's this technocratic blah blah what about the ground what about the movement what about the people what about all these co-benefits and so then greens go back and they're like as always

they're ace students they're like okay we'll go back and we'll work up a big elaborate policy that has all that stuff it involves everybody it includes

SPEAKER_00everybody and then people are like Why did you include all this stuff? Why don't you be surgical? There's a real, you, this will resonate with you since you've been at this for so long. There's a real, you just can't win vibe around all this.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. People like to pretend that politics don't exist. And a lot of people aren't really in the weeds or paying attention to power or what moves it or how it plays out in how policies get crafted. but the Biden administration we were implementing what was passed we were implementing what there was political will to execute on and so it doesn't make sense to say oh all of those efforts slowed down this one aspect of the goal I mean first of all the arguments saying that they're not backed up by

any reporting or data they're just ideas so that's what I was trying to correct for but second of

SPEAKER_01all it's like what was the assignment though like let's grade ourselves based on the assignment not based on some other idea of what we think the world should be like well I mean we should say and I wanted to say this too like the critique that greens are sort of wooly headed and naive and they want paradise and they want all

SPEAKER_00these goodies and and we the level-headed reasonable centrists need to come in and discipline them and tell them how silly they are any critique that fits that basic mold people love it people buy it they don't ask for any reporting they don't ask for any data you know what I mean like they don't say prove it they're just like oh yeah that sounds right that sounds right to me that's the kind of critique that in DC just sounds right to everyone

SPEAKER_01I think it's unfortunately a bit deeper than that. I think it's a critique that aligns with a particular paradigm. It happens to align with this kind of deregulation, let's drive lowest cost solutions, this sort of free trade globalization, wherever we can get the markets to move, neoliberal paradigm. It fits into that, and that's something that people are very comfortable with, so then they like it. And you see that with abundance. I mean, not necessarily exactly what the authors intended,

but certainly the people who've picked it up and run with it and redefined it or

SPEAKER_01co-opted it in some cases to push for deregulation.

SPEAKER_00So anyway, let's get back to Biden's. So how did you try to accomplish the assignment?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, and you were asking what was different about Biden, because certainly Obama had a green jobs strategy. I think what was fundamentally different about Biden's approach is that it was more by design and sort of by necessity, it was more a demand-driven approach to pulling workers into jobs. Whereas in the Obama administration, there was a lot of funding for training, workforce education and training to sort of push workers into jobs that we hoped would manifest. So kind of the train and pray model,

like let's train everybody in solar and hope they find their way into the industry.

SPEAKER_01And that just didn't really work out in the Biden administration. The proposals around investing in workforce development and Build Back Better were sort of gutted and what we finally got across the finish line. So what we had to work with were investments in projects and we had to then ensure that those projects were making the investments in workforce development and labor standards and have the strategies to attract and retain and train the workers that they needed to get the job done.

SPEAKER_00Can I briefly ask you know maybe it's neither here nor there but what were some of the tools that got stripped out you know because this is another thing like people critique the way you do it and they're like well we had tons of better ways like you know talk to Joe Manchin we had all kinds of ideas about how to do this better right right like all of those social infrastructure things so like child care and yes you know money for training and expanding registered apprenticeships and pre-apprenticeships and

SPEAKER_01on-the-job training So all of the funding for the supportive services barrier reduction side of the workforce equation, side of the labor market, those things were stripped out

SPEAKER_00Which meant that the only tool, the only lever you had to implement the things they were telling you to do is on the project side. Like that was the reason these things got attached to project agreements is because that's what ended up in the legislation. Like it's not, you know what I mean?

SPEAKER_01And it's a good model. Like it happened, you know, because it happened, but it's also a good model because what it ensured is that the workers who were trained were actually trained to work on actual projects. They weren't just engaging in training to pull them out of the labor market. It's a longstanding critique of job training programs going way back decades.

SPEAKER_00I mean, aside from clean energy is people have always had this idea of job training as an answer to economic woes and they've never really worked out like people want and I think always the main critique has always been you're just training them and sending them out into the wilderness and what you need is a complementary demand side policy that creates the jobs that pulls them in so that when they get the trained they have jobs and that was what you were trying to do that's what we did both with the grants and loans but that's also how the IRA was

designed through the prevailing wage and apprenticeship tax credit so you got a much larger tax credit if you were using registered apprentices and what that means is that you got a larger tax credit if your project was investing in training the

SPEAKER_01next generation so there was an incentive to tie those things together I don't know if this is important but I think maybe it's just worth sort of detailing the family of tools we're talking about here these workforce standards

SPEAKER_00because they do all kind of get lumped together so I think it's worth distinguishing There's Davis Bacon, which we'll talk about a little later, which is old, goes way back, which just says you've got to pay prevailing wages. And then there's the IRA tax credit stuff, where you get a bigger tax credit, as you say, if you do prevailing wage and apprenticeship stuff. And then there was the Department of Energy Community Benefits Plans, which which was a separate thing and that was I think unique to the

Biden administration so I don't know if you want to say anything about distinguishing those tools but

SPEAKER_00like it's not all the same thing I love talking to you because you're such a good reader and I did break it down like we have these we have these different levers that we were using to advance these goals and I was looking at what did those different levers accomplish so like you said like the base the kind of standard on all federally supported construction

SPEAKER_01is Davis Bacon Davis Bacon you know it sets a wage floor so that federally funded money isn't undercutting local labor markets. And that's really important because it helps support stability in a really volatile and seasonal industry. So it helps kind of retain workers.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. And that goes back to the 30s. Yeah, yeah, it's a century old, basically, and it's worked very effectively.

SPEAKER_01People complain quite a lot about compliance. One of my goals at DOE was to streamline that to make that a lot less painful, and we were really successful in doing that. Yeah, I want to return to that whole subject in a minute and talk about that more in more depth. Yeah, but just as a further summary, the tax credits were basically about five times more. Your tax credit went up from like 6% to 30%. if you pay prevailing wage and use registered it's it's so big and it's so much more than any cost of of paying more or costs of managing the

the record keeping so it was really treated as a as a requirement because nobody wants to to give up at that level of increase the cent you know these are hundred million many multiple

SPEAKER_01hundred billion dollar projects it's a lot of money and the cost of, you know, prevailing wage relative to market wages in a tight labor market isn't, it's not that game changing. And then the community benefits plan, this was, I think, a real policy innovation, huge thanks to not just the colleagues that I, you know, we put our heads together, but also Secretary Granholm, who saw the value of doing this, but you know we were trying to get this money out quickly and deploy these

first-of-a-kind and large demonstration projects and and scale this market at a time when the labor market was really constrained unemployment was at some of the lowest levels we've ever seen yeah and so we workforce constraints labor strife

SPEAKER_01community opposition these are real execution risks And we, you know, there were the policy priorities of the administration, but there were also just the practical on the ground constraints of getting these projects built quickly. And so the community benefits plan was really designed to get firms to think really practically upfront around how they were going to think about those execution risks and mitigate them. and so aligned around labor standards and benefits to

communities and also DEI which got so politicized but is really just a critical strategy for forgetting the

SPEAKER_01workers you need in a tight labor market. So that approach of requiring these community benefits plans on all of the projects seeking funding from DOE both grants and loans was really novel. I mean its conditions on federal funding intended to distribute benefits of these taxpayer dollars more broadly but also really designed to advance projects.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. And just to spell it out for people who maybe are not familiar with this stuff, community benefits just means if you're a big developer and you want to build a big new project, instead of just saying you're going to do it and then stirring up community opposition and then fighting the community and having the lawsuits, et cetera, et cetera, you go in early, you talk to community leaders, you work out some way that the community will benefit from the project. Like you send some money to schools or you help pay for some infrastructure or or you promise to employ within the community, all these kind of things.

SPEAKER_00And the idea, always the idea with this, and this is something that I kind of want to ask you about a little bit later too, the theory of the case on this stuff is that that does not slow things down but in fact speeds things up. If you go in early and work out a community agreement, you skip the whole community fight part of things and thus get faster. So that was explicitly an effort to make things faster, not to slow things down.

just one caveat to that because what you're saying is exactly true I just want to guess and it it's about community opposition it's also about securing the workforce that you need so like that's a little bit different that saying like what are we going to need to build this project on time and on budget who can we work with to make sure that we have those workers and that we're investing in the training early or that they're investing in the trainings that in two years when we're ready to

SPEAKER_01break ground We have the workers we need. Collective bargaining agreements, project labor agreements help provide that assurance. They reduce that particular risk. So that's not just about mitigating community backlash or opposition. It's also just about a critical supply chain issue to build your project.

SPEAKER_00Okay, so you developed these standards. You implemented this stuff. It all got wiped away with OBPP. Since then, there's been this abundance critique, et cetera, et cetera. And so... You did what I think of as a very, just, I don't know, such a very characteristically democratic thing, which is like, well, I'm going to go study this. I'm going to go figure it out. I'm going to go ask people, you know, just very A student behavior. I love it. So you went and talked to the companies in question,

the ones who are receiving the grants and loans to ask them from the horse's mouth,

SPEAKER_00what happened? Like what did and didn't slow things down? And I'm so... A, it's a little maddening to me that you sitting at a think tank did this, and none of the dozens and dozens of journalists who dutifully sort of coughed up this abundance critique, you know, just dutifully replicated it, amplified it, none of them went... I'm

SPEAKER_01Yeah, I mean, I was genuinely curious and like, yes, in the interest of learning so that we can do better next time, you know, I was, I'm really interested in what the other side was experiencing. And when I was at DOE, I heard many, many comments in passing that were very appreciative and thankful, even from unexpected entities, like I was with some southern utilities, and they were just raving about the community benefits. plan and how it changed how they were thinking about community

engagement to make it more upfront and less of a tack on exercise and how that like completely has made their project implementation more efficient and they were just so grateful and I was hearing those kinds of comments really all the time and so I was surprised

SPEAKER_01you know by this critique You know, and it's not to say that you can't find people to say the opposite, but it wasn't just the chorus who was, you know, the people who've already been kind of implementing some of these practices who was, those people were appreciative that some of their efforts mattered or were like scored favorably, you know, the things they've been doing all along. there were also a lot of converts and people who were saying like wow I was really skeptical about working with you know the steel workers but they've improved our productivity and our production efficiency so much like the

next location I open I'm going to work with them from the beginning and and a lot of comments especially around working with labor where firms initially were like well I don't know why I'm supposed to avoid unions at all costs that's just always what I've been told but You're telling me maybe there's some benefits of those partnerships, so let's explore it. Yeah, you said a lot of them were, quote, labor curious, which is a phrase I love.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, and not everybody, but there was a lot of that. So when we went out to more formally interview people, I wasn't going to the people I knew, the companies that have always been supportive. It was really trying to capture some of the other firms that I hadn't really heard from. from and just understand their experience generally, you know, what were the pain points? What could we have done better? You know, a lot of what I heard was just how utterly damaging the

volatility is with the

SPEAKER_01second Trump administration and how costly that is. So most, a lot of people wanted to talk about that, but when we went back and asked about these, yeah, yeah, that's the big thing. That's the big. issue but when we went back and I said well what about these community benefits plans it was either like oh yeah I mean that we had no idea how to do that that was a steep learning curve but like we figured it out and yeah that made a lot of sense and it wasn't a problem we like brought in you know some people who actually knew

SPEAKER_01how to do that kind of thing and it was interesting or or it was like Yes that upfront engagement and securing you know thinking about the risks and thinking about the workforce we needed upfront like that was so helpful and we're doing that on all of these other projects nobody said anything about it being this insurmountable obstacle that slowed them down in some cases it was like well our project is stalled now because we don't know what the Trump administration is doing to renegotiate it so we'll see how much those things get

implemented many said yeah the Trump administration has told us we don't have to do this stuff anymore but it's baked into our project like we're we're gonna keep doing it we that's why we're off we don't want to be on the record like we don't want to get ourselves into trouble but like these are just smart practical things to do so

SPEAKER_01we're doing them anyway

SPEAKER_00And you're talking specifically about the community benefits stuff. They just sort of like going to a community beforehand and doing the work. That's what you're saying. They found that that helped and they're going to keep doing it. Yeah.

SPEAKER_01And under that umbrella, I include the labor partnerships and the labor agreements because at DOE, you know, it's all part of the same umbrella, but it was those community partnerships. You know, at DOE, what we were really pushing for is not just ideas,

SPEAKER_00but like real plans leading to real

SPEAKER_01partnerships formalized by enforceable agreements, community benefits agreements, or collective bargaining agreements, things that would really ensure that the plan was implemented as designed with those community partners. And so a lot of those partnerships are intact.

SPEAKER_00Right. And so you say a lot of these companies told you this community benefit approach worked for us and we're going to keep doing it even though we no longer have to basically yeah and I mean we've seen that so it's not just the projects that we touch there's spillover they're saying we're going to do it on other projects states have adopted similar conditions on funding opportunities like the system that we designed was pragmatic it made sense it reduced project

risks it ensures

SPEAKER_01some distribution of benefits to beneficiaries beyond the companies and their investors. There's nothing else to say. It just is working.

SPEAKER_00So what did they complain about that you all did? What did they say? I mean, pre obviously Trump effed everything up. Republicans have effed everything up since then. But before that, I'm curious where they were finding friction. What was slowing them down? What they did have to complain about? I think that inside and the outside just have such different perspectives.

SPEAKER_01I mean, the laws didn't pass early enough in the administration. So, you know, to put out hundreds of billions of dollars in competitive grants across nearly 100 different programs, many of which had to be set up through new offices that had to be set up. You know, DOE had to hire some 3,000 staff. Like, it's like... the execution on the inside it felt like a like a race you know when the infrastructure law was passed in 2021 the IRA in 2022 in any

case two and a half years or less to execute this and we were trying to follow the law you know

SPEAKER_01designing the terms getting public input like you know

SPEAKER_00Right. But this idea that you were slow and pokey is not, was not your experience.

SPEAKER_01Well, the idea that we were like obsessed with process instead of execution, just like that doesn't resonate with anything that I saw on the inside. Like, in fact, I would say this but I've heard Jigar Shah say this I've heard other people say this like the federal government was so much faster more nimble and less bureaucratic than any of us could have anticipated or really anything we've experienced in any other sector that like that critique just

doesn't match the experience on the inside like it was less bureaucratic than my son's preschool

SPEAKER_01co-op

SPEAKER_00Well, that's not a fair comparison. There's very little that's more bureaucratic than that.

SPEAKER_01That's true.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, and this is what I meant earlier when I said this notion that it's slow, process-obsessed bureaucrats just resonates with people's priors so much that they don't really ask for Evidence they don't you know they don't need it they're just like oh that sounds you know just because that just resonates with cliches that have been bouncing around in our society since freaking Reagan so everybody's like yeah that makes sense but really like nobody I've talked to on the inside who

is trying to implement these things ever felt anything like sanguine or slow or content or like

SPEAKER_00everybody I've ever talked to felt like they were at a full sprint and from the minute they entered the federal bureaucracy to the minute they exited. I've never talked to anyone who fits the cliche, I guess I would say. But just to say, there are other parts of the abundance critique. I don't want to throw the whole abundance critique overboard here. There's a lot in there and there's a lot to say about it. And some of the problems in implementation, like with permitting, for example... really are problems and really did slow some of these projects down.

SPEAKER_00Like in the implementation side, those critiques do land. There is a lot of friction on that side. Do you agree?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, I found it just so interesting talking to these people about, you know, in a bigger context than just the community benefits plans, because a lot of these are multinational corporations. They do business in a lot of countries and they had perspectives of how things work in Germany around Like, for example, Germany is how they invest in the commercialization of technology and how it's kind of bureaucratic and politically durable. It's not subject to these political wins. You know, some commentary was,

you know, we had this big industrial policy in a lot of ways. It was very comprehensive in this whole of government, like very integrated approach.

SPEAKER_01On the other hand, it wasn't integrated enough to deploy as quickly as we could have, like things that companies That's a whole different agency. Like we already talked about, there wasn't like a big pot of workforce development dollars, but it would have worked better is if you got funding for your project, then there's other funding to support some of the workforce development,

SPEAKER_01especially you know some of the things like on the job training or new apprenticeship programs like things that companies haven't had experienced before like a little bit of funding to help them do that there is a way that you could imagine an even more comprehensive and even more all of government approach to unstick some of these things or move them forward another thing was around the domestic content and it's this chicken and an egg thing you have these requirements even if the supply chain isn't

there and the process

SPEAKER_01for getting an exemption was sort of necessary because if you don't Yeah, yeah.

SPEAKER_00You know, there's a lot of infrastructure that's needed to make that kind of thing work that

SPEAKER_01just like wasn't really yet in place. But again, if you don't have this signal, you never get there. So it's like, how do you build the infrastructure as you're also trying to, you know, support the productive capacity of the US for these supply chains? every conversation I have about this about IRA about trying to pull things together and implement IRA just brings me back to the sort of heartbreaking thought of how much could have gotten done in the subsequent four years right

like the people implementing it had their eyes on these choke points they knew what was they knew what was slowing things down and in more and more you know you could have taken more legislative action more regulatory action to ease these barriers could have

SPEAKER_00done permitting reform The whole thing could have gotten running so quickly. And this is what kind of bugs me a little bit about the critique. I don't think the critique is totally wrong, but it's more complicated than it's made out to be. But this thing really was, relative to big federal programs past, really was moving quickly. There really were a lot of people moving quickly. There was a lot of things just about to happen.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, I mean, we all had our 2025 strategies and

SPEAKER_00Yeah. Well, let me ask you about a specific question. So you've had this sort of exchange going with Mike Schmidt. He was running the chips program at the Department of Commerce. And so he was trying to get chips factories built, basically. And he has said, you know, he writes this, co-writes this Substack called Factory Settings, really interesting, worth checking out. But he has said that Davis Bacon slowed him down, basically, and he has complained about Davis Bacon,

SPEAKER_00which is just, you know, he'd approach these chip makers, try to lure them to the U.S. to build factories, and then suddenly they were confronted with sort of complicated U.S. construction requirements and laws, and it baffled them, and it took them time to do compliance, it slowed the whole thing down, et cetera. your response to this was hey over at the Department of Energy we also faced Davis Bacon requirements but they didn't slow us down so tell us why

they didn't slow you down because you you built a system to do it so tell us a little bit about the specifics of that system first of all hey there everybody don't worry I'm not going to tell you about a new mattress or push a credit card on you this isn't an ad

SPEAKER_00There are no ads on Volts. It is supported entirely by listeners like you. If you'll indulge me for a second, I'd like to ask for your support. I started Volts because we're all surrounded by depressing news about climate change and misinformation about clean energy. And it's never been more important to share the stories of the real people on the ground doing the real work of transition and all the ingenuity and courage and public spirit they are bringing to it. people are hungry to hear these stories to learn from and find

inspiration in them I've heard from people who change majors or careers after hearing episodes of Volts people using it in classrooms and community groups even state legislators who have passed bills inspired by specific episodes sharing these stories matters it makes a difference if you have found value in it and want to help me continue doing it I hope you will join the community of paid subscribers at volts.wtf it's about the cost of a cup of coffee a month if you don't like subscriptions you can make a one-time contribution leave a review on Apple or Spotify or

just tell a friend about volts I am grateful for any and all support if you're already a paid

SPEAKER_00subscriber thank you and now back to the show Tell us why they didn't slow you down because you built a system to do it. So tell us a little bit about the specifics of that system, first of all.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, I felt bad for Mike. There was a point when the White House chief of staff called us both in for me to like school him on like how DOE was doing it. And he was like, but we didn't set any of this. You know, I know Davis Bacon is a challenge to implement. And I knew that it was going to be a part of these bills. so I was really proactive but that was insight that I have just to be clear it's been on the books since 1930 yeah no one didn't know that they

were gonna be right subject to these requirements right there's nothing was nothing stopping everybody else in every other department from preparing in advance to that's not a surprise to anyone that's true except that I'm a real wonk like I had unique insight into

SPEAKER_01exactly what could work better and when I went to DOE When I decided to take the job, I had basically five goals that I thought were audacious. One of them was to streamline and simplify Davis Bacon compliance, and I thought it was probably the most audacious.

SPEAKER_00So what did you do? Tell us.

SPEAKER_01And it was hard, and I'll tell you what I did. But I just want to say I felt for Chips, like just because they didn't have that foresight, which was kind of this unicorn foresight, they... It was really challenging to implement, and it's not critical of them.

SPEAKER_00What I was hoping at DOE is that we could demonstrate how to do better.

SPEAKER_01And if that we could demonstrate it at DOE that going forward, other federal agencies implementing Davis Bacon could also do that. It's easier to do something when a different agency pioneered it. So that was my goal, but that wasn't in place at the time of chips.

SPEAKER_00Yes. But again, on the books since 1930, like why, why is it only after this thing has been on the books for a century? that has occurred to someone to find a way to do it more quickly and easily to build a city. You know what I mean? Like, I mean, maybe not the other Biden appointees. They just inherited what they inherited. But it's a little crazy that this thing has been around for a century and the federal government has still not accommodated itself to it.

SPEAKER_01I know. I mean, there's an interesting story there. I mean, one, the private sector has figured out ways to help firms meet the requirements. And so there's these tools out there that we ended up contracting with. But the federal government, it was also trying to develop, like GSA was trying to develop a more streamlined inside of government system. And they finally, after wanting money to do that for a long time in partnership with DOL, finally in this period either through bill or IRA or something else got funding

to actually develop that so it's not that there wasn't the will or the interest or the talent to do it it's just that it's one of those super wonky boring bureaucratic things that is not ever going to look like a win like nobody cares right so tell us the system you

SPEAKER_00made in a way that non I will try deep inside the bureaucracy wonks can't understand it

SPEAKER_01Yeah, so what Davis Bacon requires is, and this has been in the books, you know, for 95 years, is a couple things. One, there's a wage requirement, but it's not a single wage. There's thousands of different wage determinations based on geography, based on craft and classification of the worker. So you have to first, like, figure out what is the correct wage determination, and the Department of Labor publishes these but on different timelines and they're published in PDFs and

that is the definitive that is the definitive way of wage determination is PDFs in SAM.gov that are like binary text to like sort it's very tedious first you have to figure out the right wage determination the other thing that it requires is that you have to pay workers

SPEAKER_01weekly that's just in the law you have to pay them on a weekly cadence and the third thing is that you have to report those weekly payroll records weekly to the funding agency to whoever the compliance agency and that they're like they in our case DOE is responsible for making sure that all of that is correct even in some cases doing site visits to make sure every worker is getting reported and their wage classification is correct so it's really onerous as a researcher what I've always wanted

is that weekly payroll data because you have this data that has to be reported every single week for every

SPEAKER_01single hour worked on a federally funded construction project. That gives you real-time access to job creation. What jobs are we creating? Where are they going? Who's getting them? But the problem is that that data has never been usable because that data comes in by mail, by email, by PDF, by email. excel it comes in every different way to every different person managing a grant or a contract so that data is coming in it's compliance data but

it's completely unusable in terms of metrics or tracking what's going on so my interest was how can we get this data in a usable format to both help us with compliance but also like give us a running sense of how we're doing on project implementation the data part

SPEAKER_01That was Bettany's interest. That doesn't have anything to do with reducing the compliance burden. But if we could get the data in one centralized electronic system that integrates with payroll systems, then it's reducing the burden on the outside for people to figure out what is the right wage classification and hiring their own Davis-Bacon compliance entity to help them track it. because DOE is procuring that tool on their behalf.

And then it helps on the inside because instead of charging thousands of staff who

SPEAKER_01are managing these grants or these contracts with Davis-Bacon compliance, like something they have no idea how to do or what it is, it would allow us to centralize that compliance and have real experts. reviewing the data and ensuring that workers are actually paid what they're due. So what worked on the inside, because this required a massive collaboration across all of the program offices and agencies at DOE to all chip in to create this centralized system and centralized

SPEAKER_01staffing, and the value proposition was that it would relieve them of you know staff burnout or more FTEs you know it's just more efficient so they once they realized how much it would help them on the inside they were sort of sold and then in terms of you know our efforts to streamline we're sensitive of the burden of doing business with the federal government we were all very sensitive to that anything that we could do to make it less painful on the other side for the firms

SPEAKER_01that we were working with to comply and comply effectively we're always trying to do that so there it was a real win-win and it's not that there weren't other issues that arose with Davis bacon one of them for example was with our grid grants a lot of which went to utilities and some utilities have bespoke payroll systems and they pay on a bi-weekly basis and paying a certain set of workers on a weekly basis is a huge change management

undertaking or so they

SPEAKER_00said

SPEAKER_01and that's written into the law. It's just a requirement. So navigating those things and trying to figure out ways to deal with those, we spent time on that. It's not that it was... But that's the only thing we had to spend time on. We didn't have to spend time on the supposed burden of reporting.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, and I just... I want to pound the table about this a little bit because I feel like this is a very important illustrative example of a broader point that I wanted to make in our discussion which is How much burden will a particular requirement, a particular bit of everything bagel, how much will it slow down the government and how much it will slow down the private sector is not a fixed quantity, right? Like you can make it less of a burden for the federal

government with thoughtful,

SPEAKER_00well-funded administrative capacities. you can build the administrative capacity to do it well such that it's not a burden or you can do it in a dumb way where it is a burden there's not one fixed answer to that question and it's not inherent to the requirements that they are burdensome you can do them in a way such that they aren't and I feel like you sort of implicitly made the same point on the side of the private sector with these

SPEAKER_00community benefit agreements like to a big firm who hasn't done it it might be awkward and slow the first couple of times but again they can figure out how to do it set up the capacity set up the systems and then voila it's not a burden anymore it's just a routine part of business all of which is just you know all of which is just to make the point that like you can have better or worse federal performance federal agency performance it's not a fixed quantity and this is tell me if this resonates with

you because I know you've been sort of like arguing with the abundance people I feel like if you read

SPEAKER_00the original abundance book and like the to me the heart of the critique had two halves one was about maybe some of these excessive rules but then on the other half the book was all about making government work better right that was the thrust of the book part of that is getting rid of silly or unnecessary rules but part of that the other half of that is is bulking up your administrative capacity so that you have the muscles to do the things you want to do. And I feel like that half of abundance,

SPEAKER_00which is implicit in the whole thing and is in the book, has kind of dropped out of the discussion. Like half of it is supposed to be fund and adequately staff your federal government.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, right. And I mean, you look at something like permitting that everybody complains about, and some of it is, you know, like overlapping and sometimes contradictory requirements from different permitting agencies. Like, yeah, that we should fix. But some of it is just the backlog and the understaffing of people to review it. So why is that not part of the solution here to augment government, to support government to do its job more effectively, more efficiently, more, you know, more innovatively?

SPEAKER_00Yeah, I would just love to hear more of the abundance people making that point a little more often. Hey, let's fund, let's celebrate and fund the administrators we're asking to do this competent governance, right? Let's boost that half of the abundance thing. One other quick thing about Davis-Bacon is it applies to construction workers. So if the federal government gives a grant to a developer is going to construct something they have to use it it doesn't cover factory workers and so in some cases you had these sort of

problematic instances where you're sort of paying the people who construct the factory really well and then the people who end up staffing and running it not as

SPEAKER_00well how do you think about that Yeah, there was a parallel to Davis, Bacon, Walsh, Healy that was never repealed.

SPEAKER_01It's still in the books, but it could be reinvigorated. The wages, eventually, federal minimum wage just exceeded the wages that were in there, and it kind of was eroded by the courts. but there were proposals again that didn't make it into the final versions of the bills that passed to have some labor standards and wage standards on the manufacturing side and the analysis that you know some of my friends and colleagues have looked at back of the envelope is that the tax credits

like you take the

SPEAKER_01battery production tax credit it is so generous that again More union pattern upper quintile wages could have been accommodated and would have, you know, spread the wealth of these really generous incentives to the workers actually building this. Whatever happens behind closed doors in the final negotiation of these bills that did not make the final cut and it's too bad. I'm really proud of the work at DOE to think about those

ongoing operations and manufacturing jobs and build that into this community benefits plan framework where firms were asked not just how are you going to secure and retain the workers you

SPEAKER_01need for the construction project, but also what is your long-term plan for operations and what is the quality of jobs that you're creating there? How are you going to ensure that there's advancement opportunity? for workers there and with some grants we actually suggested this upper quartile based on BLS like you know not just average but above average wages for the industry and occupation to try to nudge wages up because the

labor market's competitive and a lot of these manufacturing companies are paying less than Starbucks in a lot of cases and then they they're like well we have 30-40% turnover

SPEAKER_01and but you know we'll just go back to the fast food industry and see who else we can find and like that's not a way to build a successful globally relevant innovative industry which is what we need to do like we really need firms thinking about their workforce strategy and how to retain workers give workers a reason to make a career in these nascent and emerging industries like batteries and battery supply chains, and 30% turnover isn't going to get us there. So we really do need a plan to improve job quality and manufacturing

and make sure that this is something that workers and parents see as opportunities for their kids and that we can really kind of reinvigorate that workforce.

SPEAKER_01But the other thing is, you know, we got a lot of firms committing to either neutrality agreements or collective bargaining agreements on the production side. And I think for a policy that was agency discretion and tied to implementation, We got really, really remarkable results in terms of advancing job quality, not just on construction, but also in the long-term operations because we were asking about it and because we

SPEAKER_01were asking firms to think about it up front. I feel like out there in the American public and even somewhat in politically engaged people there's still this lingering idea that the business community is full of ruthless self-interest maximizers and rationalists and all this kind of stuff which if you believe that then anything the government comes in and tells them to do almost by definition is going to make things worse right because they've already optimized and this is like the basic conservative critique but what you

SPEAKER_00find is in practice like what you're describing is business people are human like everybody else and there's just a lot of inertia a lot of old thinking there's a lot of path dependence there's a lot of just like busyness don't have time to think about stuff and so someone coming in and nudging you to do things better can be very helpful and then you can change and do things better enduringly like you know these things are not all optimized they can get better and government can help them get better

SPEAKER_01They can get better and the government can help. I mean, just to give you one other anecdote, in the battery space, we developed at DOE this battery workforce initiative. And the very idea of it was, look, there's all of these investments in battery manufacturing in the U.S., There's no coherent, we don't have any developed pathway into those jobs. It's each company for themselves. They're competing on so many things. They're racing to get to these tax credits. They're not thinking about their medium term workforce.

Let's bring them all together let's leverage our convening power to bring all the industry players in this space together to figure out what is the common 85% of

SPEAKER_01skills that they all need not like the specialized trade secrets But how do we capture the 85% of the skills that they're going to need so that we can develop some standardized training and credentials to support this industry where we really want to develop some US competitiveness, want to and need to, for security purposes, develop this industry. And so that's a role that's really unique to government, the convening power. And it's something that the, you know, industries were at least at first tepid because they're like,

SPEAKER_01well, we're our thing is special and we don't want anybody to know what our technology is. But once they once they realize like that, yeah, like a lot of the skills are transferable across the industry. There's benefit to a more cooperative approach, thinking about workforce development and standardizing that. And the U.S. or the federal government, state government, like we're uniquely qualified. We have the technical expertise and the convening power to lean in and help there. Again, it's one of those things that helps everybody and helps our country and helps

SPEAKER_01develop this productive capacity that we need. two political questions coming at this from different sides one of the critiques you sometimes hear is like the phrase you've used to describe Biden's approach is industry-led government-enabled which I think really captures the vibe here which is that the private companies are out front doing the things government is doing

SPEAKER_00things to help them, structure their workforce, boost their workforce, subsidize their production, whatever. But almost all of that is behind the scenes. And consequently, to the public, it doesn't look like there's much government happening at all. You know what I mean? This just looks like the market. And consequently, all these good things you're doing, which I feel like I and eight other people in the world know about,

SPEAKER_00just didn't get out and didn't have any political effect. Do you think that's a... Because it seems like, substantively, that works pretty well. It seemed to work pretty well, but politically, there's questions about whether it worked. I'm just curious whether you have an opinion on that question.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, I mean, if I design... Our industrial policy in the U.S. really depends on relationships with the private sector. It goes way back to the forming of the Manhattan Project and the establishment of the National Labs, which are these public-private partnerships, really, to enlist the innovation and nimbleness of the private sector and maintain our competitive edge as a country, mostly for, you know, initially, like really for military dominance, but like to really drive continuous R&D and so we have this

dependence on the private sector and we need them to be engaged and we need them to be part of the solutions it's just how our system is set up I think we go too far in making government invisible and part of that might be by political necessity but then it's this

SPEAKER_01self-sustaining cycle and I think in the Biden administration it was You know, the attribution, the failure of getting credit for this stuff is the big lesson learned. And I think there's a lot of people who are responsible for that. Maybe we didn't do a good enough job. Maybe we should have sent letters with Biden signature to everybody who was working on these projects. Maybe, you know, the require workplace signage, like thanks to the Inflation Reduction Act. That's why we're here.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, right. I mean, I think one thing Trump has shown us is you can't be too crude about it. You know what I mean? There's nothing too crude and obvious. It works.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, but also the onus is on companies to share the credit. And at so many ribbon cuttings, they'll say in private, oh, this is such a game changer, but they won't go up and say it at the podium. and so all of this work was happening at the beginning of this call you talked about how you know voters lives didn't change that's not true voters lives did change people were employed at record numbers wages were up like there are lots of indicators real valid data that shows that people's lives were better

SPEAKER_01in communities all across the country. But it wasn't adding up to something coherent. That was a part of a coherent federal presidential strategy. And so that message just didn't get through.

SPEAKER_00People are very fond of blaming Biden for that, basically. They're like, oh, he was old. He was weak. He didn't talk to the press enough. He didn't give enough speeches. And I'm just like, he gave speeches. yeah no one paid attention like people in the administration talked about this all the time no one paid attention like at a certain point the media has to take some responsibility like you're asking the government to like deliver you a story with a bow tied on it you're supposed to be the media you're supposed to be figuring out what's happening you're supposed to tell people what's happening like You can't just sit back and say Biden didn't come to me and

personally tell me and

SPEAKER_00make me write this story like you know other people need to take some responsibility I think a lot of too much of that is pushed on to Biden as a person as opposed to structural problems I'm sure you agree

SPEAKER_01Yeah, I mean, it's tough. The media environment is tough. I mean, even if reporters did cover it more in the New York Times or the Washington Post, that's not where people are getting their news. The lived reality doesn't necessarily match the headlines.

SPEAKER_00The other political question is from the other side, which is the idea that attaching these well-meaning progressive requirements to what are otherwise fairly bipartisan policies has the effect of making them basically more, coding them as more liberal, polarizing them, destroying the bipartisan, making them more, and then thereby, and this is, I think, the substance of the critique, thereby making them more vulnerable to being overturned by the

next person.

SPEAKER_00And this critique also, I will say, I want to hear your answer, but this one bugs me a little bit too. Again, there is... there's not nothing to it but I think there's less to it than is generally made up but why don't you tell me your opinion first of this durability critique like how did the left lose the billionaires and the working class and who do and who do we want back well I would I would refer us to our previous discussion about the media that would be my first answer but there but apparently I'm

alone in that I'm the

SPEAKER_00only one who wants to talk about that um Here's one thing like with the IRA and the OVVB and the thing that stuck with bipartisan support was the prevailing wage and apprenticeship standards the underlying credits the solar tax credits you know got changed you know basically went away but the prevailing wage and apprenticeship credits like they were not repealed that's still there so where is their political support I don't think it's

SPEAKER_01for just climate I think it's for economic equity and policies that support that and so can climate fit into that that's probably the winning argument like maybe we have to just turn it on its head and look at climate benefits as ancillary and the economic benefits that people feel in their lives as the thing that's primary that is the typical dim response because you know that's like let's take the critique as though it is made in good faith and come up with a good faith response to the critique but I just

like I just don't I just don't think it's made in good faith this is the question I would pose to people making this critique what does it look like to make a policy that is resilient to a nihilist authoritarian group of morons pardon my French like look at

SPEAKER_00that party what political what magic What are you imagining that they would not destroy? What is it that you think? Where is this big bipartisan path? Look at the other side of the bipartisan aisle and tell me what can stop them from destroying things. They destroyed lots of things that they weren't legally allowed to destroy. They just destroyed them anyway. What could people have done to make those things durable? They were protected by law and they still got destroyed.

SPEAKER_00So like... what do you mean durability look at these people yeah I'm sure you're not allowed to say that no but I mean I mean I think a lot about durability and and one is like the boring bureaucratic fixes are durable they're too boring for anybody I mean look at Davis Bacon it's so boring and it's been around for 95 years right but it also has power behind it and I think some of the problems we run into as we think

SPEAKER_01of these policy solutions you know we're all the a students like you said we're crafting these policies but they're detached from any theory of power or how to shift power or how to sustain power or what new political coalitions look like like I see this in the affordability of yes the price of things is too high affordability is a crisis but some of the policy responses to affordability are decoupled completely

SPEAKER_00from any path to power

SPEAKER_01And it's very hard. If it's hard to get attribution for direct spending on projects that are improving people's lives and communities, how on earth do we capture credit for reducing the cost of milk by 10 cents?

SPEAKER_00Well, I would even go farther. Some of the responses to the affordability critique are not only politically inert. Some of them, I think, are actively politically counterproductive. They concede the premise to their opponents. like you see Democratic governors now rolling back energy efficiency programs I'm like guys we've been arguing for decades that those things lower prices for rate payers and now you're just confused conceding that point and rolling them back?

SPEAKER_00How do you expect, like, if rolling back climate policy is how you do affordability, well, why bother voting for Democrats? You've got a whole party devoted to rolling back climate policy. It's just insane. And their rolling back climate policy, their rolling back efficiency policy, they're basically, the way they want to respond to these critiques is by conceding their opponents' arguments up front, which is just... will never not drive me insane. I can't figure this party out.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. It's this relentless focus on the cost of things and not the equation that

SPEAKER_01affordability is between, you know, the cost of things and income to be able to pay for things. Yes. And, like, that's really short-sighted and dangerous as well, especially for the politics.

SPEAKER_00A final question, which is, you now have been in the trenches of this, of industrial policymaking and The point of your report, I think, is to defend a lot of what was done inside the government around Biden industrial policy. But presumably you also saw the problems and the frictions. So I guess I would just ask, like, what advice would you give in the event a friendly administration comes into power

SPEAKER_00and there is a friendly Congress in and Democrats work up the will to take another pass at industrial policy. All of those are very, very large ifs, but if all those ifs line up, what advice would you give them to improve what you did? What did you learn from your experience? I just hope that we don't reject this outright and I think this narrative that it didn't work is just the foundation for inventing something totally new we don't need to invent something totally new a lot of this is working

the fixes are in the

SPEAKER_01tweaks

SPEAKER_00At this point, we've tried everything. They keep telling us to try new things, and we try the new thing they say to try, and it doesn't work either. But this did work. If you abandon industrial policy, go back to what?

SPEAKER_01The thing is, this did work. We got firms to make irreversible investments in building clean energy supply chains in the US. They did that with hundreds of billions of dollars in those projects. The vast majority are moving forward. so it did work we created jobs we raised wages like think about climate we are so much better off today than we were six years ago still even with all of the changes

SPEAKER_01solar is cheaper this is clean energy is the norm it's the trajectory is more solidified so it did work whatever issue you care about it worked we can make it work better but like let's stick with the thing that was working and the other thing is it's not just at this stage it's not just for the sake of climate but also our energy security and our national security which people are waking up to. We need U.S. industrial policy. The energy system is changing from subsurface molecule

combustion to one that is

SPEAKER_01highly manufactured. We need to manufacture those things and get the resources that go into them in the U.S. and with our friends and security supply chains. That is an answer for our economy. It's an answer for our security. It's an answer for the climate. and I agree and I would just add on a political note I understand why liberals are so prone to self-criticism sometimes we might say edging over

into unproductive

SPEAKER_00self-loathing even so of course when this happened when the OBBB happened everybody's first thought is what did we do wrong god we screwed up again oh we suck etc etc etc But maybe the real flaw was they didn't fight hard enough for themselves and they let Trump win. Maybe the magic policy key to making the industrial policy work was not letting Trump get elected.

SPEAKER_00That seems like the most direct route to making this all work. You don't need to redo the policy from the ground up. Just don't let the guy get elected who wants to destroy it all. It seems like a much simpler... a much simpler answer like and the way to do that is to be prouder of yourself to fight harder to brag more about what you're doing not like liberals have this idea of like we just like if we just like lash ourselves and flagellate ourselves in public long enough we'll win some sort of like sympathy or I

don't know what the theory is like it'd be so fun to have a whole weekend to just rant to just continue

SPEAKER_01these rants I know I'm sorry no no I mean I just I'm like I'm like getting fired up too I'm like let's just all right I'll stop ranting but but I think I did just want to do this pod mainly to

SPEAKER_00make the point that you made very eloquently just now which is that on most fronts in most respects the industrial policy of the Biden administration was working the projects were going in they were getting built the workforce was being created the supply chain was getting stood up like it was working and we shouldn't just be like little scared fawns in the forest who heard gunfire in the distance and are gonna go sprint the other direction you know like have the courage of your convictions a little bit people

SPEAKER_01Here, here. Yes. Love it.

SPEAKER_00Thank you. All right. Thank you for coming on and joining me in this opportunity to rant. I appreciate hearing from the inside. And I really just really do appreciate and admire you being like, well, let's figure out what did happen. Let's go find out what did happen. Let's go ask people. And I would just for everyone listening in government or private industry. you should be inspired by this go out and find out what's really happening go ask people before you do takes go ask there you go I'll end there thank you so much for doing this for reading the papers love it thank you for

listening to Volts it takes a village to make this podcast work shout out especially to my super producer Kyle McDonald who makes me and my guests sound smart every week and it is all supported

SPEAKER_00entirely by listeners like you So if you value conversations like this please consider joining our community of paid subscribers at volts.wtf or leaving a nice review or telling a friend about Volts or all three. Thanks so much and I'll see you next time.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Can a developer turn data centers’ reputation around?

    Nov 20, 20261 hr 6 minAudio

    This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit www.volts.wtf/subscribe When people push for better data centers, they picture hyperscalers - Amazon,...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. “Repowering” worn out solar fields could create gigawatts of new grid capacity, quickly

    Nov 18, 20261 hr 18 minAudio

    This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit www.volts.wtf/subscribe America’s first big wave of solar power installations, built between 15 and...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. The federal permitting bill has been updated. What changed?

    Nov 11, 20261 hr 59 minAudio

    This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit www.volts.wtf/subscribe The Senate’s bipartisan permitting bill got a manager’s amendment last week -...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. So, how about those midterm elections?

    Nov 9, 20261 hr 26 minAudio

    This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit www.volts.wtf/subscribe Last week’s election was a blue wave all the way down the ballot: Democrats...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Best of October 2026

    Nov 6, 202614 minAudio

    This is a free preview of a paid episode. To hear more, visit www.volts.wtf Volts published eight conversations in October, which is a lot for anyone to listen to. We’ve rounded up the highlights into less than an hour....

    Credit the people on this episode