Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Vetted Conversations

Vetted Conversations artwork

Ep. 14: The importance of civilian control of the military & our Selective Service

Jul 25, 202459 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

What would happen if you didn't register for the Selective Service, aka "the draft?" In this episode, Dr. Mike O'Hanlon of the Brookings Institution joins Ellen and Joe for a quick civics lesson on why it's important to have civilian control of the military. Next, Navy veteran Joel C. Spangenberg, the acting director of the Selective Service System, discusses how his agency contributes to our national defense. Lastly, Marine Corps Combat veteran and executive director of The Mission Continues, Marybeth Bruggeman, discusses how veterans and their families can serve their communities in meaningful ways. Support the show For more, check us out at www.wetheveterans.us and at https://linktr.ee/vettedconversations

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_04Yes, you know, ultimately the goal for us is to ensure people register. That's uh that's number one. Um and you know, I I think some of the ramifications that people face if they don't register, I think come in the what we would call the benefits space or opportunity space. So for instance, if you don't register, you may not be able to get a federal job, right? That's that's a major challenge. And a number of states have very similar laws on the books where if you don't register, you may not be able to get a state job. Um, you know, and I'll talk about this hopefully a little in a little more detail later on.

SPEAKER_04But uh one of the things that happens uh at the state level too is uh there's a connection often between uh uh a man being registered and their ability to get state level uh student aid. Um so that's that that's another thing, and also U.S. citizenship. So people who are uh immigrants here, they have to register too, and uh you know it could cause delays if they fail to register. So those are some examples that we see.

SPEAKER_01Welcome back to the Vetted Conversations Podcast, where we delve into the foundations, workings, and current challenges to the American way of self-governance.

SPEAKER_03In today's confusing world, it's more important than ever to understand how our government works and how we as citizens can actively participate in the discussion to safeguard our liberties and continued freedom.

SPEAKER_01Our mission is to ensure you, our listeners, have the knowledge and insights needed to become more informed and engaged citizens and active members of your communities. So let's get into it.

SPEAKER_03Hello, listeners. Part of our mission here is to help increase our collective understanding of civics, namely our rights and perhaps more importantly, our responsibilities to each other as citizens in a free society. To do this, we're bringing in national experts on civics and our military to talk to you and answer our questions. So joining us today is Dr. Michael O'Hanlon. Dr. O'Hanlon is a senior fellow and director of research in foreign policy at the Brookings Institution, where he specializes in U.S. defense strategy, U.S. military force, and American national security policy. He's been a friend of We the Veterans of Military Families for quite some time, and we're happy to have you here today, Mike.

SPEAKER_02Hey, Joe and Ellen, nice to be with you.

SPEAKER_01Thanks so much. Well, so we're excited to ask you a few questions that I think you know all military families veterans uh really are curious about and and should understand. So the first one is why is it important to have civilian control of the military in a democracy like ours?

SPEAKER_02It's an excellent question. And it really is worth asking just that basic, straightforward way, because we get so used to saying we have it that it almost becomes instinctual or reflexive. But we should think about why. And the main reason is, of course, that military officers and enlisted personnel are professionals who are supposed to do what the nation asked them to do, but they aren't really supposed to be making decisions because they are not directly accountable to the voter.

SPEAKER_02So they are professionals. And civilian leaders are politicians who are elected by the voter and who are also directly constrained by a system of checks and balances. There is no system of checks and balances within the military. We don't have the Army fighting the Marine Corps, except maybe on the occasional softball field or gridiron and uh and in the trash talk, you know, of bars and uh and restaurants. But the the idea here is that a democracy is a system where voters select their leaders and where there is a system of protection of individual rights and checks and balances on each branch of government, and that is all handled through voting and also through a professional court system.

SPEAKER_02So, in a sense, of the three main branches of government, the military is most similar to the courts in that it's supposed to be professional and do technical things, whereas it is primarily the congressional executive branches that are accountable to the voter and therefore that have powers in the Constitution to raise and equip armies and navies and declare war. So it really comes down to the system of voting and majority rule, but with checks and balances and protection of individual rights, all that is handled outside of the uniform military, and therefore the uniform military should not be making decisions that represent the will of the voter.

SPEAKER_01All right, thank you. That was a great answer.

SPEAKER_03The word civics means a lot of different things to a lot of people. How do we define it? Well, to us, it's all about understanding our rights, and perhaps even more important, our responsibilities to each other as citizens. Democracy is not a spectator sport, and every citizen needs to do their part. That and also understanding how our government is designed to work. There are two main fundamental duties of any legitimate government, and the first is to protect the people from attack, and the second is to punish the unjust. Everything after that is negotiable. Which leads us to today's topic, the Selective Service.

SPEAKER_03The Selective Service established in 1917 has been the cornerstone of American defense strategy during times of national emergency. It's a system through which our government can conscript citizens into military service, ensuring our nation's armed forces remain ready to support and defend our Constitution and the American way of life. Conscription, otherwise known as a draft. But what exactly is a selective service and how does it work? Though the Selective Service, as we know it today, was not in use, the United States has had a system of conscription since the Revolutionary War. It was used in World War I, World War II, during the Korean War, the Cold War, and the war in Vietnam.

SPEAKER_03Registration was suspended in 1975 and the system has gone into what they call deep standby. But beginning in 1979, a series of revitalization efforts were begun to upgrade the system's capability for rapid mobilization during an emergency. Joining us today to explore this topic further is the acting director of the Selective Service, the Honorable Joel Spangenberg.

unknownMr.

SPEAKER_03Spangenberg is a U.S. Naval Academy graduate and veteran of the U.S. Navy, where he served as a surface warfare officer, deploying in support of Operation Enduring Freedom following the 9-11 terrorist attacks. He also served on the aircraft carrier of the USS Abraham Lincoln and deployed to the Western Pacific. He has a long and distinguished career in public service, and in his current role, he leads National Conscription Readiness, overseeing the National Headquarters Data Management Center, and three regional headquarters consisting of civil servants, military reservists, and over 8,000 volunteers.

SPEAKER_03Acting Director Spangenberg, welcome.

SPEAKER_04Hey, uh, good morning, and uh thank you for uh allowing me to join you today. It's a pleasure.

SPEAKER_03Absolutely. Um we're we're uh super excited to have you here today. The Selective Service, I think, is an often misunderstood uh entity within the United States government, and one of our missions is to kind of clear up some uh misconceptions people might have about it. We just had uh folks who founded the Department of Homeland Security on a few weeks back to help do some myth busting around there as well. So, what can you tell us about the Selective Service System and its makeup and mission?

SPEAKER_04Okay, well, the Selective Service System uh first off is an uh independent federal agency, and uh we believe we've been a distinguished part of our nation's history spanning eras of conflict and peace. Um, and it's important, I think, to also frame what else I'd like to share with you today in the sense that we are a readiness organization at our very core. So uh we see ourselves as a unique element of the nation's national security capabilities. We represent an additional tier of support to our all to our nation's all-volunteer force.

SPEAKER_04Um, and right now uh we actually are operating what we call an active standby status, which is our peacetime posture, with registration for young men across America being our most visible activity. Um, and just for everybody's awareness, registration is an important civic responsibility in our nation. While we hope that a return to conscription does not occur, uh you never know what the future may hold. Um state of readiness if the president and Congress reinstated a draft in response to a national emergency, such as a major conflict.

SPEAKER_01So to clarify, so we we haven't had a draft in more than 50 years, but there's still a requirement for um young men to register with the Selective Service. And by doing that, they are sort of signed up on one of these state level lists, and and the the teams that you oversee are ready to train them if needed and sort of get them um ready to serve. Is that is that the general uh overview?

SPEAKER_04So uh our um we have a board member program. I think that's what we're talking about here, and yes, we actually uh work to uh recruit them so we have enough of them in the event of uh if there was ever a return to conscription. And it's also important to note that um our board members are to reflect the composition of that community to the greatest uh extent possible. So we work to make sure that uh they reflect that community. Um, and it's important for us to continue to train them uh so that they are ready if there ever was a national emergency.

SPEAKER_04A big part of selective service system is to be as fair and equitable as possible. And even in our regulations, uh it's it's captured there that we're supposed to be working to have our boards representing uh communities nationwide. And uh, you know, we've seen that uh we have a construct where our boards would at least be at the county level, but we also have the ability to make them multi-county or have more than one board per county. Um so you know, so you can imagine a very uh large city which might also be within a county, might have multiple boards.

SPEAKER_04So uh that's how we work that construct, and we have to continuously recruit and train to make sure that that system of volunteers is always ready to go. What other top priorities do you have currently? Uh great question. So, one of the uh things that we've been looking at, especially uh since 2022, and I I joined the agency in August 2022, and I had been the chief of staff here before during the um Obama administration. But uh we made a major transition in our focus as an agency to bring us into greater alignment with the national security strategy, national defense strategy, the president's management agenda, and the congressional direction found in the fiscal year 2022 National Defense Authorization Act, in particular the requirement for the Department of Defense to include us in a recurring national mobilization exercise.

SPEAKER_04So we were uh we were looking up and out to see what we really had to make sure we would need to align to so we can operate this agency in the best way possible. Most people interact with us as customers, if you will, as it relates to registration. So we very much stay attuned to that through things like our call center and our uh online tools.

SPEAKER_03Yeah, and that's awesome. With registration, I mean, I I think one important thing for young Americans to understand is that this is a law. Like it if you don't register, it can have pretty significant limiting factors on your future. Can you tell us a little bit about that? Like um, one, it's important to comply with with the law, but like what happens if if 18-year-old Joe Plumzer decides, like, oh, I'm not gonna do this, right?

SPEAKER_04Yes, you know, ultimately the goal for us is to ensure people register. That's uh that's number one. Um and you know, I I think some of the ramifications that people face if they don't register, I think come in the what we would call the benefits space or opportunity space. So for instance, if you don't register, you may not be able to get a federal job, right? That's that's a major challenge. And a number of states have very similar laws on the books where if you don't register, you may not be able to get a state job. Um, you know, and I'll talk about this hopefully a little in a little more detail later on, but uh one of the things that happens uh at the state level too is uh there's a connection often often between uh uh a man being registered and their ability to get state level uh student aid.

SPEAKER_04Um so that's that that's another thing, and also U.S. citizenship. So people who are uh immigrants here, they have to register too. And um, you know, it could cause delays if they fail to register. So those are some examples that we see.

SPEAKER_01Okay. So so considering all of that, and and sort of, you know, you guys have modernized, you're reaching people where they are online, your systems are kind of you know getting up to date with technology, which is which is all incredible. Um, so how how what's the big picture? Like what how's registration going across America? Have you seen a dip in registration rates despite all this incredible work that you're trying to do? You know, what's what's sort of the general status of registration right now?

SPEAKER_04Okay, that that's a great uh question. And I think this is a key thing for us too, is you know, we've been focusing on readiness, but registration is definitely a foundational thing that we care quite a bit about. So we we try to keep uh registration rates as high as possible. So until uh recently, we you know we certainly were achieving around a 90% registration rate or higher, so for the aggregate 18 to 25 year old population. So uh we started to see a major challenge emerge in late 2020, and it wasn't simply COVID impacts, uh, but it was something else.

SPEAKER_04And let me tell you about that. It was the FAFSA Simplification Act of that year. Um, and that actually delinked men's eligibility to receive federal student aid from registration. In recent years, that FAFSA kind of uh side of things, that Department of Education Connection, represented approximately 20% of the annual Selective Service registration. So, you know, young men when they were filling out their FAFSA forms, they had an option to register with Selective Service. That started to go away.

SPEAKER_04Um, so this resulted in a 5% decrease in registration rates across America as we went from 89% in calendar year 2021 to 84% in 2022 for the 18 to 25 year old population. That is one of our largest decreases in our uh agencies' history. So that's uh that's been a real struggle. That had a big impact. And preliminary preliminary data for 2023 indicates we are going to have yet another decrease into the low 80% range. Wow.

SPEAKER_04This has been a dramatic but not fully unexpected decrease. Now, um that's not like we're just sitting here and watching it happen. I don't want uh you or the listeners to think that. We've actually been very active in the face of this challenge. We've expanded our public affairs and outreach efforts with federal, state, territory, tribal, and local government partners, and also several other groups, like I mentioned, those influencer type groups and associations nationwide, and we developed new marketing and digital content to reach Gen Z and their influencers.

SPEAKER_04And we're using data analytics and metrics to help identify effective ways to reach key audiences and influencers around the country.

SPEAKER_03I'm curious, like if I've got a social security number and the government knows I exist, um, why do I need to register? Like, shouldn't that be automatic? Uh could you tell us like like what's what's the rationale behind actually taking the step to register?

SPEAKER_04Yeah, so that actually goes back to the Military Selective Service Act. And um uh much of that was put together in the late 1940s. Um so there were different modes and ways of doing things back then. And uh encapsulated in that uh uh uh that Military Selective Service Act and kind of the the approach there was that men are to present themselves uh for registration. So um, you know, you can imagine a time where people would go to the post office to do it or other places.

SPEAKER_04So, but uh you're you're mentioning something that kind of does open people's eyes to like, hey, maybe there's a better way to do things in this day and age. Uh so what what you're what you've actually proposed to me, my answer is yes, there is a way to do that. Um so and I would actually kind of link to something else that I think it's important for for people to know too about registration. Because uh, so for instance, we have uh driver's license legislation which links men's registration with their obtaining a driver's license or idea as and that's actually or an ID, and that's a very successful driver of uh people getting registered.

SPEAKER_04So we have that in 45 uh states and territories, and that's that's been really successful for us. So in a number of places, it's actually an automatic linkage. Some places it's optional, whether you opt out or opt in. Uh so we see that sort of connection. Now, we've actually been thinking about how we can start to get more into this. So to counter the dramatic uh decrease in registration rates due to the FAFSA Simplification Act, um, I did ask the team to develop a legislative approach that would increase our registration rates to much higher numbers nationally, leveraging an automatic approach.

SPEAKER_04So one of our goals is to everybody who should be registered, they need to get registered. So we want to work towards that. So uh we'd love to be, you know, up close to 100%, ideally, as close as possible.

SPEAKER_01I want to go back to a quick question because you you you mentioned it. Um we were gonna ask specifically, of course, I was gonna ask specifically about sort of the you know what the Selective Service position is on um all the different legislative proposals to expand registration to women and and people of all genders. Um obviously this has been a uh you know a big debate in America, but I'm curious, you know, where are we, where are you guys as an agency and where are we as a country on the idea of opening this up to a requirement for all people?

SPEAKER_04Um that is uh a very uh important question, and that's one of the top questions we get as an agency. So thank you for bringing that up. And I and I do want to give some credit too to the uh there was a national commission uh that looked at military, national, and public service in recent years. And his report uh came out in March 2020. So does anybody recall what was happening in March 2020? Maybe not the best time for reports to come out because then we're people probably got their mail and that's about it.

SPEAKER_04Yeah, there was a lot of COVID, uh a lot of COVID concerns happening, but I think what they uh provided was very helpful, and one thing that they articulated in there was to expand the registration requirement. Um that actually I think um um you know it it was something that the Hill noticed, and I and I and I can't give you the full list of all the different amendments or legislation that was introduced, but I know there had been uh tremendous interest in the Hill about that as well. So that was really interesting to see.

SPEAKER_04But um what I would go back to is where kind of my agency is and some of our thoughts on this as well, and some of these are my my personal thoughts, but um, you know, one of the things that I think is important to know is that legislative proposal I mentioned would include all genders. And I and I believe in and I've you know going you know, going back and looking at recent legislation, particularly the uh FY 2022 National Defense Authorization Act, um this you know, it was something that was being considered in that legislation to you know to expand the registration requirement.

SPEAKER_04And the administration articulated that they supported the uh the expansion of the registration uh requirement to all Americans in a statement of administration policy. Um it's important to also emphasize. That the decision ultimately to expand registration to women is for the president and Congress to decide, and we'll execute our mission here accordingly. And we know there are differences of opinion about expanding registration. And I believe registration expanded to all genders is ultimately in the national interest.

SPEAKER_04My opinion rests on the fact that it will ensure the nation would be in the best position to increase the size of the military rapidly and thoughtfully if needed to do so. DOD would have the benefit of having a fuller and more diverse set of skills available to it. Should there ever be a return to conscription during a major conflict? Since we can't truly predict the future and know exactly what will be needed most during that emergency. So the military could need people filling a wide variety of roles.

SPEAKER_04So you know, people historically think of, oh, conscription, you know, people are being shipped overseas, uh, they're going right into the infantry. That's not always the case, really. I mean, you hear stories going back to the Vietnam era of people doing much uh different things. In World War II, certainly, people were fulfilling a lot of roles. So the nation would potentially need people serving in the military who were uh focused on IT and cyber operations, drone operations, logistics, people working as mechanics for all this equipment, uh, HR and administration, civil affairs.

SPEAKER_04So it could run the full gamut. So this would actually allow DOD to thoughtfully look at that pool of people coming in and best match them where they're needed. And I and I and I think in a large-scale society level uh conflict, we would potentially need people in a lot of different roles.

SPEAKER_03True. And I think, you know, I was in the Pentagon um from 2010 to 2015. Uh during that time, uh the the current administration uh abolished Don't Ask No Tell, right, which is a problematic law that that limited the recognition of service from many service members and put a lot of commanders in in bad spots, right? You know, for for a number of reasons. And then fairly quickly after that, after I left the Marine Corps in 2015, um they changed the policy on ground combat exclusion for women, because prior to that point, women were excluded from tanks, artillery, infantry, especially, um, and other ground combat jobs, which in the Marine Corps is the fastest track to leadership, right?

SPEAKER_03To becoming a general, to becoming, you know, and actually leading the Marine Corps. So you know, you know, there is a huge debate out there about um who owes what to the country and why. And I think, you know, personally speaking, um, you know, I think you know, we are foolish not to fully embrace 100% of the talent within the country, right? If we're only going to limit ourselves to half. And right now, I know I know you you don't make the laws and it's restricted right now to males 18 to 25, but that was a pretty hot topic of debate as well.

SPEAKER_03But what's funny is that the women that I served with in the Marine Corps for 20 years almost unanimously said, hell yes, women should be required to sign up for the selective service. So I mean, you know, it's uh, you know, I think a lot of the debate on that depends on the kind of where you sit in the society and what kind of values you're brought up with, and you know, if you're more traditional and more open-minded, um, and that's fine. But you know, that's that's an important part of the debate, and I think one that needs to kind of be be had, right? So Ellen, what would what do you think?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, I mean, as a woman who who didn't serve, um, and actually I went to college um at a at a at a university that during my time there didn't have ROTC even on campus. Um, but then my senior year was 9-11. Um, you know, I was in New York City, I went to Columbia University, 9-11 was the September of my senior year. You know, you your your feeling as a as a young person, I mean, I think a lot of people in the country had a very different perspective on what it meant to serve, um, including in the military.

SPEAKER_01So I'm all about it. I mean, I have two daughters and a son. I think they should all, you know, have to sign up and uh and I hope some of them serve regardless of their gender. Um and so I yeah, I think, I mean, I think there's a you know, we we should feel about this not as a burden, but as a privilege and a responsibility as a citizen, not you know, as a burden as a young man that that you must carry.

SPEAKER_03Yeah, and one of the things that I I really appreciated about what Director Spangenberg brought up was that, you know, there's a lot of jobs in the military that aren't infantry or artillery tanks, right? So I mean, in the Marine Corps alone, fewer than 15% of the people in uh in the Marine Corps um serve in that capacity. Uh a lot of there's a lot of other jobs in the in the in the military that don't you know assume that kind of direct contact with the enemy risk. So I mean, you know, and I get it, you know, like you know, people um typically don't like to be told what to do.

SPEAKER_03And if they have plans in life, you know, to be told that they're gonna do something other than those plans and serve in the military probably would be a fairly uh significant emotional experience. But we've had an all-volunteer force since 1973. It's been a long time since uh our our nation has um had a draft. And from from your perspective, Director Spangenberg, like what are the what are the pros of that system? Like, you know, if if we haven't used it since 1973, like what uh um why do we still have it?

SPEAKER_04I I think it all comes back down to uh we need to maintain a level of readiness as a country. Um I think that this is actually, you know, I've I've I'm very much a product of the all-volunteer force myself. Um, and I had the great privilege of serving with uh many outstanding men and women throughout my career. And uh it's it's it's great to see the service uh that they uh that they bring so proudly to the country. Um but I I think one of the things that comes back up for me quite a bit is the fact that we just cannot predict what that next conflict will be, right?

SPEAKER_04So I think that's something we have to be clear-eyed about. Um you know, things can happen. Um and I would say we are fundamentally here to backstop uh the Department of Defense if there is a major conflict. And I, in my view, there has not been what I would term, and I don't mean any offense here, but a major conflict or major war since World War II. And what I mean by that is something really requiring the society to really align to the success of the nation in that conflict, really have a sense of there might be sacrifice, there might be hardship.

SPEAKER_04Um, and I think that that's why you know things like selective service system are here, to make sure the country can ultimately be successful. Um, to build what we have from whole cloth, uh, and GAO has even looked at this before, it's not something you can just throw money at and hope it'll just be created. Because what underlies what we do is uh a sense of trust with the public.

SPEAKER_03Yeah.

SPEAKER_04If the public sees that we are here, we're well maintained, we're being fair and equitable, we're being thoughtful, we're I like the the term, and I heard uh I've heard uh General George, who's the chief of staff of the Army, use this, and I love this term. We pull preparedness forward, and that's kind of the mentality as a readiness organization. We do things ahead of time so if that moment ever comes, we can respond and respond competently and well and communicate it well. Because we know it's gonna be at a very shocking time for the country if that time ever comes, and we owe it to everybody to do the best we can now, practice hard now so we can succeed when that time comes.

SPEAKER_03Yeah, and I think, I mean, what you're describing to me, and correct me if I'm wrong, is really a literal break glass in case of war capability that our nation has, right? Like we've got this list of military age right now, men, and potentially in the future women, who can be notified, called up, and and directed towards military service in a moment's known as if um the Congress and if the president both agree, which is a big if, right? And I mean, because you're right, like World War II, existential threat to the country.

SPEAKER_03Like when we went into World War II in 1941, we didn't know um uh what America was going to look like coming out of the other side of that thing. And if if you know if Germany had had beaten Britain, um who knows what our what our country would have looked like uh if things turned the other way, or if you know the the Russians on the Eastern Front didn't uh didn't succeed as well. But the uh existential existential threat, God, that's a hard word to say, I think is an important thing for our listeners to understand. This isn't something that's undertaken lightly.

SPEAKER_03I mean, you know, the the chips really have to be on the line in a major way for uh the Congress and the President to pull the trigger on on reinstituting the draft.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, it's what we say all the time. What there's a lot of talk in America about what our rights are, and just not as much talk about what our responsibilities are of citizenship. And this is one of those very, very um, you know, sort of poignant examples of, you know, if our responsibility as citizens is in the common defense, then this is a key part of it. And so how do we make sure that this becomes something that people are proud to do and not something that they're burdened to do? Um and so we're yeah, we're we're here for that.

SPEAKER_03Yeah. And as I mean, there's a lot of benefits to the all-volunteer force, professionalism, kind of planned pipeline, you know, high quality training, uh, people that want to be there, right? You know, it's you know, I spent um two years uh over at the Marine Corps West Coast boot camp, and you know, we were talking to the troll instructors about like your training of volunteers is a very different thing than training of conscripts that your Uncle Bob went through, the Marine Corps in you know the late 60s, early 70s. Like totally different uh cultural, climate, um, motivation, and the rest of it.

SPEAKER_03And and I gotta imagine, like, you know, if if you had plans and all of a sudden you got a telegram in the mail or a letter saying, hey, you know, guess what? You're going in the Marine Corps of the Army back in 1968. You probably um, you know, there's probably a lot of uh, you know, a significant lack of motivation when you got to boot camp, right? Like, um, but you know, there are downsides to that too. The all volunteer force, I mean we've seen it in 20 years in Iraq and Afghanistan, and and Joel, you're there, you're there for you know parts of it, right? You know, and um, you know, it's you have folks going over for two, three, four, five, six.

SPEAKER_03I think the the highest number I saw somebody did 15 deployments um with special operations command during that time. And and we run the risk of really wearing people out. And um, you know, and we've seen it, and and now in the veteran space, we see kind of like the downside of of that wear and tear um on veterans, right? Um and there's a discussion to be had uh you know about like the the Sib Mill gap, right? A lot of people to cry, like, oh, you know, in the veteran space, like, you know, our public doesn't understand uh the military, they don't understand veterans.

SPEAKER_03And it's like, well, yeah, because you know, less than one half of one percent have have joined and served um since 9-11. And you know, when when we're at war and America's told, hey, go to the mall, you know, like you brought up. There's an inevitable gap that's gonna come into place. And I'm concerned about this because right now we're at 17 million veterans by 2040 uh timeframe. The VA says we're gonna be down below 14 million as the Vietnam generation dies off. As our population in our country goes from 330, 335 million now up to 405 million over the same timeframe.

SPEAKER_03So, like, you know, numbers of veterans per capita is gonna get even smaller unless, God forbid, there is a national emergency where we do have to uh resort to the selective service and conscript people again in large numbers. But you know, I think, you know, perhaps, you know, looking back over the history of the country and understanding that conscription was more the norm than the exception for most of our history in the wars that we fought. You know, greatest generation of World War II, most of those folks were conscripted, if I I check my math correctly, right?

SPEAKER_03You know, they weren't right.

SPEAKER_04I think it was about uh uh of the 16 million who served, over 10 million were conscripted. Yeah. So that's a very true statement.

SPEAKER_03Yeah, and a lot knew their number was coming up, so they volunteered anyway. So, you know, like you could probably plus up, you know, the numbers who otherwise would have been conscripted hadn't, you know, you know, it's kind of like if I know my number's coming up and I have an ability to volunteer now and choose like I'd rather go into the navy than the Marines or something like that, or or or the Army than uh it would have been the air corps back then. But um, but yeah, no, it's it's an interesting conversation to have, right? You know, because it's like there's greater philosophical questions at hand of like what's the responsible and moral way for our country to go to war.

SPEAKER_03You know, do we put it on the credit card and and not have a war tax? You know, do we have conscription or not? I mean, those are broader uh public conversations I think that that need to be had and kind of go beyond the bounds of our conversation today. But yeah. Ellen, your thoughts?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, no, I mean I this is such an important thing for people to know about. And so we're we're so grateful um to have you, you know, sort of walk through it and and for your leadership and and you know, trying to keep things with the times, which is so important. Um Yeah, I mean, I you know, I think we again, this is this is one of those things that people have like this six six-year window of time where maybe they think about it, um, or and then they have another six-year window of time when they're parents when when they're they are parents of people who are thinking about it. Um but it probably should be a much more frequent public conversation, especially um, you know, for for Joe and I, and obviously you and your family, you know, living in this in this relatively small community and knowing that, you know, of people that will serve in the future, it is likely to be, you know, I I have three kids.

SPEAKER_01My kids are far more likely to serve than everyone else in America their same age, right? And that that feels a little that feels a little weird. It feels a little um, you know, it I don't we don't think the military should just be a family business. We should find ways to to bring more people in and and make people feel proud of and connected to it. So super grateful for for you uh explaining all this to us.

SPEAKER_04Ellen, I I love your point there too, and I think that notion of service is really important, and I think that's something we should all cherish in this country. Um and I and I wanted to mention this too, and I and it, you know, this is something to think about. I mentioned that National Commission. They talked about this opportunity for federal agencies to work together to boost awareness of service, military, national, and public service. I don't necessarily see them as mutually exclusive. Um, you know, I I kind of come in, like I said, optimistically.

SPEAKER_04I think people might try to go from one to another. We see a large number of veterans serving in the federal government after you know having spent time in uniform. Um so one thing I wanted to let you guys know too, that we, you know, in that spirit of service and wanting to do more, uh we've become, we we started to partner with the MerICorps. Um we already have one MOU memorandum of understanding on uh with them, and we're on track to have another one to share between our agencies more about uh service and volunteer opportunities so more young people know about it.

SPEAKER_04It could take the form of hey, uh when a young person gets something in the mail from Selective Service, a registration acknowledgement letter, they would potentially get something from uh AmeriCorps telling them about national service. And we're looking at maybe we do some of this via mail, some maybe we do some of this electronically. Same thing with Peace Corps and maybe even public service. So we've been talking with some agencies about that. But we have a vision too that Selective Services across military, national, and public service, building on our unique capabilities to engage with young men, potentially more than young men, like we discussed, who are on the verge of choosing their path in life.

SPEAKER_04And um, I actually am a I'm a really big believer in service, as you can hear. Um, and I and I think that building service ethos is in our national interest. Um, I think that you know utilizing things like uh national automatic registration and focusing on a national call for service are transformational. They'll build up a better understanding of civic responsibility, and I think it's just really a great investment in our future. And I'd I'd love to see people who and I love community service, but let's take that community service to the next step.

SPEAKER_04Have you thought about national service, working with people who aren't like you, maybe are from a different part of the country, working on something bigger than yourself to deliver something of value to the country and building those bonds over years, I think that strengthens people's uh notion of how to interact with the government, what the government is, it's not the enemy, but that they are fundamentally stakeholders. They have a responsibility to shape the government.

SPEAKER_03Yes, yeah, absolutely. And the whole point about like there's many ways to serve our country is absolutely true. You know, our teachers, our firemen, our EMTs, our truck drivers, or farmers, like all the like everyone that kind of makes this fabric uh of America and the system work, um, you know, it's important, right? So I think you know, it's like service, national services is just not the domain of America's military veterans. So um we just wanted to uh thank you again for coming on the show today, for helping educate us about what the selective service is, how it affects Americans' lives.

SPEAKER_03Right now, we know it's males 18 to 25 have to uh register. Uh the law is not yet there for women to be required to do the same. Um and I had one last question. So if I'm 19 and I'm well past my 18th birthday and I didn't do this, am I in trouble? Or like, you know, if I show up and do it now, am I gonna, you know, is there any penalty to that? Or what's the what's the course of option for me there?

SPEAKER_04So uh men can continue to register um all the way through their final day of being 25 years old. But once they hit 26, they can no longer uh register. Uh but if uh you know if they do have concerns about, oh my goodness, I didn't register and I want a federal job, they can uh contact select a service system and they can request uh uh what's called a status information letter. And actually we move that online to help uh people who are in that uh in that category. Uh so that there is a process, but it's ultimately the benefits granting organizations that have to make the you know determinations about uh somebody's knowing and willfulness for not registering.

SPEAKER_03Okay. Yeah, no, that makes sense, and and it's it's good to know that there's a process in place for if if I you know forgot, didn't do it, whatever, had football practice that day, um, okay. It's important for people to to understand the law and and to follow it. So well, um any any final thoughts?

SPEAKER_04Uh no, Joe, this this has been a real treat to talk with both you and Alan and uh to hear your thoughts on this and uh really value the discussions that you're having and the discussion we had today. I really appreciate the time and opportunity.

SPEAKER_03Well, we really appreciate the the gift of your time and thoughts and wisdom on uh you know what I what I would say is like a little known aspect of the American government that can have profound impact on the lives of Americans and our national defense. So thank you for all you and your staff do to make sure that you know if we ever needed to uh engage in this uh uh uh conscription again, um, there's a system in place to rapidly call Americans up to uh to serve.

SPEAKER_03There are many ways to serve our country after leaving the military, and there are many great groups across our country who can use your talents and draft. There's an old saying that if you want to go fast, go alone. But if you want to go far, go together. And when we challenge ourselves in 2022 to help America close 120,000 deficit in election poll volunteers, we banded together with like minded people. Vet the vote, which was our nationwide public awareness and election poll worker recruitment campaign, to help ensure American elections are properly staffed and run. That year we built a coalition of more than 30 veteran and civic groups and asked veterans and their family members to serve again.

SPEAKER_03You know what? More than 63,500 of you responded. And today we're spotlighting the newest member of the Vet the Vote Coalition, the Mission Continues. We're super excited about this. They have a great mission, as their name would imply, and a superb reputation in the veteran and military space. And joining us today from the Mission Continues is Marine Corps Combat Veteran and President of The Mission Continues, Mary Beth Bergeman. Welcome.

SPEAKER_00Thank you. Wonderful to be here with you both. Thanks so much for having us on and for for everything you're doing every day to protect democracy.

SPEAKER_03Absolutely. And thanks for for joining us this morning on uh espresso fueled uh uh actually it's mid-morning already. Okay. Um but yeah, just before we went on, uh Mary Beth and R and I realized that we were both in Iraq together. You were MWSS 372 while I was with 1st Marine Division. Um 373. I'm sorry, that's right, 373. Um God, they screwed up already. I need more caffeine. But anyway, uh we want to get to um your mission and your organization.

SPEAKER_03So can you tell us like what does the mission continue to do?

SPEAKER_00Sure. Um well, we're a national nonprofit, and we exist to give veterans an opportunity to serve again when they leave the military. So this time we're asking them to repurpose their leadership skills and their experience back home in under-resourced communities in their own backyards and find ways to once again serve with a mission and a purpose, and we're helping point them in the right direction and linking them up with community partners who can really use their support. Um, and they are thereby fulfilled and find that sense of purpose again that so many of us lose when we leave the military and find connection with other veterans and with communities, and it's a it's a win-win.

SPEAKER_03Can you give us a few examples of things that that your organization does?

SPEAKER_00Oh, sure. I can give you hundreds of examples. Um, you know, we're we're really excited about what we're doing in San Antonio this year. We're gearing up for what we call a mass deployment, which is our once annual opportunity for um to bring veterans in from across the country and deploy them against some local work that's been taking place there for a long time. So our local platoon leader, Richard Diaz, who's a veteran himself and a volunteer, he's been stepping up and leading a service platoon in San Antonio for years now.

SPEAKER_00And he brings together veterans and non-veterans on any given Saturday throughout the year and connects with local nonprofit partners and uh, you know, puts puts everybody to work in a six or seven hour timeframe and does incredible things over the course of the day. Um, so it's really amazing to see the work that he's been doing with his partners like Democracy Prep and so many of his, he's got urban gardens and urban farms that he works with in San Antonio. He works with the San Antonio Unified School District and so many others across the city.

SPEAKER_00And so we're able now to build on that work this summer in June and deploy about 80 veterans to San Antonio to help give a real shot in the arm to the work that he and his platoon have been doing for years. That's amazing.

SPEAKER_01So, I mean, it's it's very obvious what this community, your community of veterans, is doing for these other communities, San Antonio, but all across the country, as we we well know. How do you categorize what that work does for the veterans themselves and sort of the veter, the broader veteran community?

SPEAKER_00Um, well, so I find that veterans so often miss the thing that they're missing when they leave the military. And so so many go looking for to fill a hole somehow. And it's work, it's it's having stable finances, it's all the things that we need to do when we leave the military. Um, but I meet so many veterans that tell me that what they didn't know was missing was feeling needed again. And so there's this gulf that is created when we leave the military because for so long we've been in this really mission-driven, purposeful work.

SPEAKER_00And we leave the military, we transition out, and we find so many things, we find fulfillment in so many different ways with family, with work, with our home life, whatever it is. Um, but if you don't have that feeling that somebody needs you, that you're still on someone's front lines, that you're still on that wall, um, then there's really something that can very much feel like it's missing. It's just this black hole, and so many folks just misidentify it or can't identify it at all. Um, that's one of the greatest joys is watching veterans discover organizations like The Mission Continues and the work that we do and tell us on the back end of their first service project or their first mass deployment, this is what I didn't know I was missing.

SPEAKER_00This is the thing that I didn't know I needed. Um, and so we're we are filling a purpose gap. We're filling a connection gap. It's that ability to have that really comfortable banter with military veterans that, you know, that you might miss from the military, that that feeling like you're part of a tribe again, but also recognizing that that tribe extends beyond those veterans and now includes this incredible community of non-veterans and supporters and local communities that want to create this connection with you as well and want to tap into that leadership and experience that you bring home.

SPEAKER_03That is so, so important. I mean, I remember Mary Beth, and you probably remember this too. Like when we came in the Marine Corps, General Krulak was we always talk about like the three reasons we have in Marine Corps, right? To make Marines win battles and return quality citizens to their communities. And the Marine Corps doesn't make good on that last part of that promise, right? They get you out the door. But groups like yours are the ones who are really putting that into play every day in communities all across America. You know, and I think it's important because like the veteran community is shrinking.

SPEAKER_03You know, we have like a little bit north of 17 million, I think, now last I checked, and by 2050, that's gonna go down to below 14 million while the American population grows to over 405 uh million. And so per capita, um there are fewer and fewer of us. And I think you know, when people derry that military civilian gap and America doesn't understand us and all this other other stuff, you know, one thing I tell veterans is like you gotta take that first step towards them when you go back to your communities. Like if you're waiting for somebody to reach out to you, you're gonna be waiting a long time. So I think, you know, what a great, great way to meet other people where you intend to live and and put your talents um out there in a positive direction that's gonna help the entire community.

SPEAKER_03Fantastic.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, just and just stepping up. I mean, I think it's incredible to just to see people come back to life when they start volunteering. And again, it's with us, it's with other organizations. There's so many out there. Um, I love what we do for very particular reasons. It's it's not only it's is it impactful on the veterans, but we're making a big impact in communities. Um, but again, you can find it in so many different places, but it's that feeling of like, hey, I'm needed. Somebody's asking me for my skills. Again, somebody needs me to help solve a problem. Somebody put something sticky in front of me and really needs me to get through this challenge.

SPEAKER_00Um, I love it. These service projects are challenging. I mean, we even throw things in there like, hey, you may have to do more with less. You may have to get through this without the resources you need. We may, you may not have a tool that you need, you may have a weather challenge in front of you. But that's when we find these veterans get most, you know, woken up, and that's when they get most excited because they're like, oh, wait a minute, a challenge, a hill I can climb? Yeah, I know how to do that. Um point me towards the hardest thing, and that's what I'm gonna go try to tackle. Super cool.

SPEAKER_00I love that. That's what I love most about the veteran community.

SPEAKER_03Yeah, you know, I I coach uh quite a few veterans every year. People will contact me, be like, hey, I'm I'm gonna be getting out of the military, you know. I feel like I'm jumping off a high dive. Like, what do I need to think about? And you know, like they've heard about like you need to figure out like where you're gonna live, how much you need to make, what do you want to do for an occupation? And uh, you know, they come to me with various uh aspects of that equation figured out, but really what I tell them after that is like, okay, well, how are you gonna make meaning in your life after this? You're leaving an organization with more than 240 uh years of lineage where you know your you know your rank and status within the tribe, you know, like you have a you know, something happens on CNN and you're packing your cargo bag to ship out, like what's gonna put that fire in your belly again.

SPEAKER_03And and I think you've uh landed on the secret. It's like serving other people in a meaningful way in your community.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, definitely. Yeah, yeah, finding finding the toughest challenge you can find and going after it for sure.

SPEAKER_03Love it. Yeah, absolutely. What kind of support do you does the mission continues need from our community?

SPEAKER_00Um, you know, I I really love the quote you used at the beginning. If you want to go fast, go alone, if you want to go far, go together. Um, I know we don't do enough of that. I mean, even the mission continues, we don't do enough of that. This real true collaborative work. Um, but our space is getting smaller. It's going to. Um, not only do we have fewer veterans, as you said, but there's less money out there. There are fewer resources, and um, we're all competing for the same attention, the same dollars, the same, the same little slice of everything.

SPEAKER_00And um, what we want is to be true collaborative, collaborative partners. We're all for partnership in any kind of way, whether it's transactional or not. We'll we'll partner. That's great. Um, but we're looking for real, real, true deep collaboration that, in fact, where you pull, you're like puzzle pieces working together and finding ways to pull on each other's strengths. Um, so we're we're super open to that and looking for organizations that that just want to be, want to draw from the strengths of the work that we do and believe that the strengths of the work that they do can can fit together in a really in a really positive way.

SPEAKER_00Um so that's one thing. And that's kind of that goes into sort of the mutual support category. Um, but there's also just a lot. Look, we we fill a really important void in the military and veteran support space. Um, but it is one, it is just one void that we fill, and we're very disciplined, um, more now so than ever, because of everything I just talked about. We're very disciplined about staying, sticking to filling our void. Um, but our veterans come to us with a range of challenges, desires, wants, needs, anything.

SPEAKER_00Um, and we we need partners that we can um confidently connect them with and refer them to so that they're getting all of what they need. And we we believe that this is a system and an ecosystem of support. And again, we're we're just one slice of it and good at what we do, the best at what we do, um, but all too happy to tell veterans about all the things that we don't do and all the folks that exist that that can help them in their next chapter if if what they need is not what we have, or they need something in addition to what we're we're able to give them.

SPEAKER_03Yeah, I'm here and kind of focusing on your mission and keeping the main thing the main thing, yeah. Which is kind of a a nice segue into vet the vote. Ellen, do you want to take us down that path?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, yeah. I mean, I love you you hit on you know the sort of the three key things that that we would we would say we we're really uh in total alignment with, which is you know, partnership, collaboration across the veteran and military family space, um, but also something really cool that you said about you know just sort of showing up and doing the hard things. And so um, you know, America had this challenge of poll workers, we will have this challenge again, we will continue to have this need. Um, and we see this this you know sort of coalition as a way to answer that need using this incredible community.

SPEAKER_01So can you just in your own words talk about you know why the Mission Continues um has has kind of you know joined this coalition and and what you know in this election year, um how you see uh us all working together to solve a problem for America?

SPEAKER_00Yeah, um I a couple things. I mean, one, I think it's important for me to just talk personally about the fact that I'm one of the people that answered the call. Um, when you all put out the call for poll workers and election officers, um, I am now an election officer here in Virginia. And I've only missed one election since I became an election officer, and I felt like I was missing out. I had a I had real FOMO on that day. Um, it was too much with my just where we were with with the mission continues and our operational cycle. I just couldn't, I couldn't commit to the day far enough out.

SPEAKER_00Um, but I hated missing it because when I worked that very first election, and I think that I was, I think I signed up um for the primary in the 2020 presidential election, if that sounds right to you guys, like timing-wise. So I think that's that was my first election that I worked, and then I worked the general election that year. Um, and I was fascinated by the whole experience. I was drawn to it. I really did feel like I was on the wall that day.

SPEAKER_00Like I felt like they needed me on that wall that day. And because it was something that I could see from who turned out for that, like it wasn't easy to get election officers. And I'm in a county that's pretty well resourced, so we don't have massive gaps where some other folks do. Um, but all the same, it wasn't simple to get people to sign up and do the training and be out there and be out there all day. And I was so eager to be there. And I knew as I met people um that were working that election with me, there were probably 50% of the people, at least 50% of the people at my polling station were veterans or military spouses.

SPEAKER_03Yeah.

SPEAKER_00I mean, you could just see who was eager to answer the call. So that was one. Like personally, I absolutely loved the experience. And I felt like it was um like this ironclad, like this is where this is where our bureaucracy um really does the job. Like our elections are incredibly secure. And I can say that because I've been a part of them. And so for me, I felt like I gained some credibility in being able to say, like, we I can I can tell you exactly what the process is from start to finish on a day when you work at an election like this and how your vote gets counted.

SPEAKER_00Um, and I love validating that for myself and being able to then be, you know, a trusted voice for others. Um, so that leads me to so why did the mission continue to join? I mean, part of that is like my experience does help to inform why we can say yes to things like this and partnerships. Um, and also I we have found that our our veterans want to be a part of initiatives like this. Um, again, when there is a critical gap in our country, veterans want to be called.

SPEAKER_00They want to be asked to serve, they want to be asked to join. Um, they care deeply about the outcomes for this country. They care deeply about um the our constitution and everything it takes to uphold that. Um, they do not care about politics, we find, generally speaking, as a as a rule, I would say. Um they don't care about politics and frankly don't want to be a part of it. And I think sometimes they need something that you guys are really good at. They need an education about where they can be most useful because we leave, we are in the military and even leave the military believing we should stay as far away from conversations about politics as we can.

SPEAKER_00And that can lead us to staying far away from government, period. And serving in any capacity, whether that's in government service or even as an election officer. Like I'm not allowed to be at polls because it might make people think that I'm in tune with politics. I hear that all the time from veterans. Like, ah, apolitical, apolitical, I'm non-political, that I learned that from the military, I serve the commander-in-chief. Understood, and yet you're no longer in the military, and in fact, have a really important, trusted voice and in my view, an obligation to at least be informed.

SPEAKER_00And I I care not at all how people vote. I care deeply whether they vote because I just think that it's so important to participate and for something that you fought so hard for um blood, sweat, tears, we lost friends. We lost friends so that we could have an ability to have these free and fair elections. We fought in countries and saw firsthand what it looks like when other countries do not have free and fair elections. It matters, but it takes all of us participating in that in order for it to work.

SPEAKER_00And again, um I applaud um a two-party system. I applaud everything it takes and all the conflict it takes. I think it's actually a really beautiful part of our democracy. Um, and and still I ask veterans, just be a part of it. Just participate. And if working, if being a poll worker, an election officer is something that helps give you confidence in the system, start there. Do that because it's needed. Um and I do think it makes a huge difference for veterans and military families.

SPEAKER_03We couldn't have said it better. I mean, it it does change you in a meaningful way to go and make democracy happen for Americans. I mean, I remember uh my wife and I, every time we volunteer and and uh and help run our polling station, I mean, we leave there feeling great, right? Because, you know, you see so many members of the community, a lot of people that may agree with you, a lot of people that probably don't agree with you, but they're all coming in to exercise their fundamental right to vote and choose our elected officials.

SPEAKER_03And and you know, it's just like that is a special thing that we should never take for granted. And as you mentioned, so many of our brothers and sisters have sacrificed over the years, um, going all the way back to 1775 to guarantee that right. So, um Mary Beth, like where can people go to learn more about the Mission Continues and get involved?

SPEAKER_00Uh well, we go to our website. That's the first stop, um, missioncontinues.org. And um, from there, that will get you to a get involved page where you can find out if there's a service platoon near you. And we have service platoons in 47 cities across the country. So I hope there's one near most of your listeners. And um I would just highly encourage people to take the step and come to the next service project in your community. Um there's no barrier to entry. We it's a come one, come all. We will find something for you to do that will help you feel incredibly purposeful, whether you come for a day or you stay with us for years.

SPEAKER_00Um, whether you decide to join a leadership team as a military veteran or you want to come one time with your family and um and say you did a good thing for the day. It takes all of it, it takes all. Um, and we're just really excited to continue to grow this movement of veteran-led service. Thank you so much for listening.

SPEAKER_01If you found this podcast episode interesting or useful, please share it with the people you know. This episode was co-hosted by Joe Flensler and Ellen Gustafson. The audio and video were edited by King's Collab Studios. This podcast is a production of We the Veterans and Military Families, a 501c3 not-for-profit, nonpartisan, veteran and military spouse-led organization, focused on promoting positive and patriotic civic engagement to strengthen American freedom and liberty. Find out more about us at weTheVeterans.us and follow us on social media.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Election Hero Day with League of Women Voters & Vet the Vote

    Oct 15, 202652 minAudio

    In this special episode of Vetted Conversations, we’re marking Election Hero Day, October 20, with Jeanette Seneca of the League of Women Voters and Julie Hendricks of Vet the Vote, a poll worker herself. Jeanette...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. How Sports Unites America with Jesse Iwuji, Navy Reserve Commander and NASCAR driver.

    Oct 8, 202620 minAudio

    Navy Reserve Commander, NASCAR driver, entrepreneur, and Naval Academy graduate Jesse Iwuji sat down with us at Flag Day to discuss what it means to balance military service with professional ambition. From an...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Military Influencing America to Do Better

    Sep 1, 202629 minAudio

    Air Force spouse, former special education teacher, and content creator Erin Muhlenbeck sat down with us at Flag Day to discuss what it really means to be part of the military family. From challenging the "dependa"...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Service Doesn't Stop - Veterans Uniting Americans Through Service

    Aug 19, 202626 minAudio

    Recorded at the 2026 Flag Day Convening in Washington, D.C., this episode brings together three veteran and military-connected leaders working across different organizations to discuss how they're building bridges and...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. ”What can VMF do for America?” - The 2025 VCHI and Corporate ERGs

    Aug 17, 202632 minAudio

    What does it take for veterans and military families to keep serving after leaving the uniform? Guy Kiyokawa, VP at Leidos and former Assistant Secretary of Veterans Affairs, and Leo Marin, co-founder of Beneath the...

    Credit the people on this episode