Send us Fan Mail You can do everything right clinically and still lose a client in one conversation. We sit down with Dr. Erik Hofmeister to unpack what pet owners actually expect when a veterinary medical error happens, and the answers are more demanding than most of us assume. Many respondents say they want to be told about every error, even minor mistakes that never reach the patient, and they want that disclosure immediately. That level of transparency sounds simple until you picture a real clinic day, real caseload pressure, and real human emotion. We also dig into why expectations vary. Education level and personality traits shape how owners think about whether errors are inevitable, what an “acceptable” error rate looks like, and how much grace they extend to complex medical systems. That leads to a key veterinary practice management takeaway: understanding complexity does not automatically lower standards. Clients can believe errors happen while still expecting strong safeguards and clear accountability. Then we get practical about client communication, because the trust numbers are hard to ignore: poor communication about an error drives trust down fast, while great communication has a limited but meaningful ability to rebuild it. We talk through a concrete disclosure tool we can teach and practice in any hospital, the TEAM approach: be truthful, express empathy, apologize, and make a plan. If you care about transparency, risk management, informed consent, and long-term client relationships, this conversation gives you language you can use the next time things go wrong. Subscribe for more Veterinary Vertex conversations, share this with a colleague who trains new grads, and leave a rating and review to help other veterinary teams find the show. JAVMA article: https://doi.org/10.2460/javma.25.12.0872 INTERESTED IN SUBMITTING YOUR MANUSCRIPT TO JAVMA ® OR AJVR ®? JAVMA ®: https://avma.org/JAVMAAuthors AJVR ®: https://avma.org/AJVRAuthors FOLLOW US: JAVMA ®: Facebook: Journal of the American Veterinary Medical Association - JAVMA | Facebook Instagram: JAVMA (@avma_javma) • Instagram photos and videos Twitter: JAVMA (@AVMAJAVMA) / Twitter AJVR ®: Facebook: American Journal of Veterinary Research - AJVR | Facebook Instagram: AJVR (@ajvroa) • Instagram photos and videos Twitter: AJVR (@AJVROA) / Twitter JAVMA ® and AJVR ® LinkedIn: https://linkedin.com/company/avma-journals
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_02You show up for pets every day. It's because care is your calling and it's ours too. We know it's what drives you to make a difference in the health and well-being of every pet. That's because at Zoetis, hundreds of veterinarians are part of our team too. Working with you to provide science-backed medicines, technology, and practical support to help elevate your standard of care. Learn more at CareisYourCalling.com.
Lisa FortierWelcome to Epic Award-winning Veterinary Vertex, the AVMA's journal podcast where we delve into behind-the-scenes look with manuscript authors. I'm editor-in-chief Lisa Fortier, joined by Associate Editor Sarah Wright. Today we're discussing how pet owners expect veterinarians to disclose medical errors with our guest, Eric Hoffmeister. Thank you for joining us, Eric.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, thanks for having me. This is great.
Lisa FortierEric, this is a very unique uh aspect and a lens through which you were looking. What motivated you to study how pet owners feel about medical what motivated you to study how pet owners feel about medical error disclosure?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, so I've been interested in medical error for a while for anesthesia, you know, is kind of at the forefront of medical error kind of systems. And then my co-author is a dermatologist and teaches in the communication curriculum. And so I think we were talking one day and realizing, like, hey, we don't, you know, we have these ideas of how to communicate with clients, but we actually don't know how they want to be communicated with about these things. So maybe we should uh ask them.
Sarah WrightEric, your article has been super well received on social media, both by pet owners and veterinarians alike, and all coming to a consensus saying, yes, these are things that should definitely be disclosed. In your study, you found that nearly three-quarters of respondents wanted to know about every medical error, even minor ones. And they wanted to be told immediately. Did that level of demand for transparency surprise you?
SPEAKER_01It did. Uh I was definitely not expecting that so many people would want so much transparency. And it definitely places a large burden on us to try to achieve that level of transparency because, you know, like calculation errors happen all the time, but they're caught. And so, you know, it doesn't even get to the patient. And yet a lot of clients report that they want to know about those things. So I think that there is a disconnect between like what people say that they want and what's practically achievable, you know.
Lisa FortierYou also found links between personality and education level and the belief that errors are, I guess, inevitable. What is your read on that?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, that was really interesting. That um there were two questions, whether whether it was inevitable, and then also what they thought an acceptable error rate was. So um people with a higher education um were more understanding that errors were inevitable, but they gave a lower acceptable rate of errors. And so those two findings together are interesting because it suggests that people who are educated understand that errors are going to occur, but they expect them to be rare.
SPEAKER_01Um, and that might reflect them being in professional roles themselves, working in complex systems where errors are going to happen because errors are a result of the system, you know, that's complicated, not necessarily the individuals. And so they might understand that, but then they might also understand that there should be systems in place to minimize those errors. Um, so that was that was pretty interesting to find that education was related there. And then, yeah, there were some personality traits where um that influenced their feelings about the acceptability of medical error as well as the rate.
SPEAKER_01And I think that you know, it just speaks to the fact that that people have different orientations based on their you know level of extroversion and um those other kinds of characteristics. So um yeah, it was it was pretty uh interesting finding.
Sarah WrightA big take-home for me from your study was that communication is so very important when we're communicating with our clients. Your study found that 87% of people said poor communication about an error made them lose trust, but only 58% said good communication improved trust. What does that gap tell us about how much is writing on these conversations?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, it it's massive, I think. That um if you don't do a good job communicating, the clients are gonna be upset. Even if you do a good job communicating, they they're still gonna be upset, you know? Um but the the juxtaposition there was that you can actually improve your relationship with your clients by handling errors in a correct, effective way with clear communication, which I think is remarkable.
SPEAKER_01You know, we always assume, oh, if you tell someone there's been an error, that's gonna lead to all kinds of bad things. Um, but as you said, almost 60% reported that their trust increased in their veterinarian. And when we think about, you know, those client connections and how important they are for longevity of our practice and people continuing to bring their pets into us, anything that bolsters that feeling of trust, I think, is really uh interesting to reflect on. Um, but there is that gap, as you mentioned.
SPEAKER_01So I think that it it says, you know, if we do a good job, that that might help. Um, if we do a poor job, it's definitely gonna hurt. So it's like you, you know, you can only move the needle so far with some people. Um, but definitely doing a better job is better than doing a bad job.
Lisa FortierI love it. Yeah, it was always like if oh if a horse had a chance of improving, a 60% chance of getting better with some surgery, we were like, it's a toss of the coin.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, right, right, exactly. But if you don't do a good job, you know it's not gonna turn out well. Yeah.
Lisa FortierRight. Uh we've been kind of talking about errors as a bulk, but your study also distinguished errors in communication, diagnosis, and treatment. How did owners react differently depending on which type of error was disclosed?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, that came from we asked them to uh share a story if they had their pet experience uh a medical error. And then we did some qualitative data analysis to pick through those stories and try to classify them. So it was interesting that clients, you know, sort of fixated on one of those elements. So if there was, if there was a communication error, that was what they were centered on. If there was a diagnosis error, that was what they were centered on, et cetera.
SPEAKER_01Um, so it does suggest, first of all, how important communication is, right? Communication is right up there with diagnosis and treatment, which, you know, we always were trained as medical professionals, we're trained to do diagnosis and treatment, but realize how important communication is and the risk of poor communication leading to the perception of an error by the clients. Again, this was their reported stories. We don't know what the reality is, but they felt that there was an error if there was a communication breakdown, uh, even.
SPEAKER_01So I think for me, that highlights again how important communication is. And then, yeah, their responses to those experiences, um, they were they were basically just as upset, uh, at least according to their narrative, if there was a poor case outcome as if they were miscommunicated with, as if they missed a diagnosis or a treatment. So like they they were they were equally upset regardless of like what the error was, which was a little bit interesting because you know, you assume like, oh, if there's a poor paid case outcome, that's what people care about.
SPEAKER_01But it seems like they care about all the steps in the the medical process that we have them in our care. And so that just makes me think that we just need to to look at our systems and and see how we're making sure that we're meeting those client needs along the way.
Lisa FortierYeah, I think that's interesting because I certainly have had my share of health professionals taking care of me that I would instantly say, Hey, Eric, this person has no bedside manner, but they get it right. So I think that's interesting in your finding.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, no, that's that's it is it is uh, you know, there's this classic narrative of, you know, the human surgeon who's just like an excellent surgeon but is terrible to people. Um, but I think more and more actually in modern, you know, on the human medicine side, they're realizing that really that person probably doesn't exist. You know, that that the ability to communicate effectively is kind of part and parcel with being a good doctor. And I think that we're starting to kind of get that message in veterinary medicine as well.
Lisa FortierDid you pick on surgeons for a reason, Eric?
SPEAKER_01There's just so, you know, we all we all know, we all know. There's no secret.
Sarah WrightAs soon as he says surgeons, I looked at Lisa for her reaction. Lisa's an equine surgeon. So as veterinarians, we don't receive a lot of training in what to do when things go wrong. For a veterinarian who's never had formal training in disclosing an error, what's the most important thing to get right? And what would you tell a student dreading this conversation?
SPEAKER_01So there's two really important elements to think about. The first is um when medical errors happen, there's this historic perspective that we have about why it is, which is it's because someone messed up. And that's an outdated philosophical construct. Like nowadays, we know that errors happen because medicine is complicated, we can't see perfectly into our patient. You know, we have the environment, we have the patient, we have the client, we have our staff. There's all these variables that factor into it, that errors happen because of the system.
SPEAKER_01So I think that's one thing that I always want to make sure that my students understand is this happened because there were systems in place that resulted in it. So that encourages a no-blame culture where you realize that this is gonna happen. Let's figure out the systems and work on that. So that's kind of a foundational concept that I want to make sure everyone um begins to engage with is the errors happen because of the system. And then the communication piece specifically, we use the team acronym T-E-A-M.
SPEAKER_01So that's be truthful, express empathy, apologize, and make a plan. So when you're confronted with an error that you need to communicate with a client, be truthful, first of all. People get sued because they lie, right? That that's like the number one thing that clients will sue you about is if you start lying. So be truthful. If there's something that impacted their pet, be sure to be clear and transparent. Um, express empathy, you know, uh recognize their feelings, validate their feelings of being angry and upset.
SPEAKER_01Um, that's that's a very natural emotion to have in response to hearing, you know, bad news about what happened to your pet. Um, apologize. I think a lot of times vets feel, oh, if I apologize, that's implying blame, you know, that I'm gonna be responsible then. Um, but that's that's not necessarily how people see it. So apologize uh and then make a plan. A lot of the errors that I've been involved in where clients are upset, they are upset and you kind of get them through that emotional time. And then they want to know how is this not gonna happen to somebody else's pet?
SPEAKER_01And so coming up with that make a plan helps them feel like they're having some positive impact on the world, basically, from this, you know, if the pet died, potentially catastrophic outcome. So be truthful, empathize, apologize, and make a plan. Those four steps are what we teach as kind of routine for communicating about medical error.
Lisa FortierYeah, you kind of touched on a couple of things. Those thinking about if you, as a veterinarian, uh disclose every medical error, are you more likely to cause anxiety in a client and they're going to be mad and you have you spend more and more and more and more time trying to discuss through each of these?
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
Lisa FortierAnd is there a risk for you said no? Well, I don't think you said no, but is there a risk? Are you at risk legally? Like they're like, ooh, you made an error.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. It's a good question. I I think that the first point is, you know, the the clients say that they want to know about everything, but I'm not sure how true that is. You know, I think that that might come from a certain source of ignorance on their part. It's like, okay, you really want me to talk about all the possible things that could go wrong. And it's just like when we're consenting them for surgery, right? Am I going to talk to them about esophageal stricture that happens like one in 10,000 times or something? You know, there's only so much time in the day.
SPEAKER_01So I think that's a really good point. That even though clients, at least according to our data, say that they want to know everything, that's not very practical. And I'm not sure that that's true, even. You know, I think that that would be really interesting to follow up and be like, okay, so what this means for your day is you're going to be at the vet for four hours every time, you know? Um, so I think that there's some practicality considerations there. And then, you know, weeds, you always worry about the liability.
SPEAKER_01Um, I guess what I would say about that is that medical liability insurance for veterinarians is extremely inexpensive compared to human uh physicians. And part of that is it just doesn't get used very much. So I think that we worry about it, but on a real practical basis, it's uncommon that it, you know, results in any sort of negative outcome for us. It does happen, obviously.
SPEAKER_01If you disclose, are you more likely to have more of those incidents? I mean, just as a numbers game, it makes sense to me that that could be the case. But I think there's also something to be said for clients, you know, again, that that increasing trust if you're doing a good job communicating with them, uh, that especially if the if the medical error did result in a negative patient outcome, you know, if you're like, oh, hey, you know, just so you know, we did some math, uh, there was an error, but when we checked it, it was caught before your pet got the drug, you know.
SPEAKER_01Um, I think that that's gonna make someone feel like, oh, okay, wow, they really like telling me and making sure that I feel, you know, um a part of my pet's medical care here. So, you know, I I think it's it's worthy of consideration. I think as a numbers game, it makes sense that it might increase that likelihood of having some kind of legal action, but I'm not sure that's true. You know, I think that's that's a really interesting future study.
Lisa FortierYeah. Is there any preferred method that the client prefers for communication? Text message, email, phone call, and obviously you would document that communication, but from their perspective, was there a preferred method?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, that's a good question. I don't think that we asked that question in this uh study. Um, there's another study that I did where we looked at how clients want to be communicated with about anesthesia information. And that was primarily uh in-person. So they didn't want to like read it on a website or have a flyer handed to them or that sort of thing. They wanted either their regular veterinarian or their specialist veterinarian to be communicating with them about that. So um, so I'm not exactly sure, but I think that that's I think in-person is probably easiest as well to have a better connection with the client and to answer any questions that might come up.
SPEAKER_01And again, you could express that empathy piece, I think, a little bit more easily in person than in any other sort of communication um modalities.
Lisa FortierYeah, that tracks.
Sarah WrightEric, you shared a lot of really important information today. Now we're gonna boil it down to our take-home message. If you could get one takeaway from this study into every clinic's client communication training, what would it be?
SPEAKER_01I think it would be understand that that clients do care about this and want to know maybe more than you think that they do. And to make sure that everyone in your clinic uh knows the team approach, the truthful empathy, apologize, make a plan, and that you have systems in place to deal with it when an error occurs.
Lisa FortierYeah, really great information, Eric. Thanks so much for joining us today.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, thanks. This is great.
Lisa FortierFor our listeners and viewers, you can read Eric's article in Javma. I'm Lisa Fortier with Sarah Wright. Be sure to tune in next week for another episode of Veterinary Vertex. And don't forget to leave us a rating and review on Apple Podcasts or wherever you listen.
Send us Fan Mail A pair of suture scissors can feel like the definition of “low risk” until you look at what’s actually living on them between patients. We sit down with Kathryn P. Spivey, returning guest and AJVR...
Send us Fan Mail A calf can look “fine” and still be losing ground in the lungs and that’s exactly why BRSV keeps costing farms money. We sit down with Dr. John Ellis to unpack a rare head-to-head comparison of two...
Send us Fan Mail Dogs with chronic enteropathy can make even seasoned clinicians feel stuck: antibiotics help, symptoms fade, then everything flares the moment treatment stops. We sit down with Drs. Moshen Hanifeh and...
Send us Fan Mail Septic arthritis in a neonatal foal is one of those diagnoses that can change everything fast: the foal’s comfort today, survival to discharge, and even long-term athletic soundness once cartilage gets...
Send us Fan Mail One strange beat on a resting horse ECG can spark a surprisingly high-stakes question: are we seeing a normal sinus arrhythmia, or an atrial premature complex that changes how we think about risk and...