Let's Not Be Trash: Cornell, Consent, and The Men in the Chat
50 minAudio
This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit www.letsnotbtrash.com/subscribe
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_00Yo, what's going on, everybody? It's me, Stanley, and the good man, Evan Mastronardi, and we're here for a quick little Let's Not Be Trash chat. Sorry, my automatic instinct is to do an introduction. So, like, the people who are jumping in, which right now, that is approximately one viewer, and that viewer, I think, is actually us, so that they know what's going on. But go ahead, Evan. Sorry about that.
SPEAKER_01It's us. Well, welcome us. And welcome to Let's Not Be Trash for those who hopefully will join. This is our second live in several months. We've been wanting to do this for a little while to check in and discuss a lot of the headlines of a lot of the topics we discuss on our website. You know, consent, masculinity, and really...
SPEAKER_01A lot of the oppression that patriarchy poses on both men and women and all genders. And I think that, of course, recently the case with the most publicity, but I don't want to look over two other ones, is the... I don't even like saying Cornell 7 because it makes it sound like boy bands. These are nasty, assaulting sailors. And the Central Park Five were people who were innocent.
SPEAKER_01So I don't like calling it Cornell 7. I call it the Cornell Rape Chat. That's what it was. So there was a chat. Sorry, I thought it paused. There was a chat of over... For those... I don't know how you don't know, but if you don't, there's a chat of over 50 men and that... I don't know how it originally started, but at some point in a frat party, several of those men posted within the chat essentially an open invitation to...
SPEAKER_01There's a lot of phrases for it, but we'll say gang rape, essentially. A... A woman who may have consented initially to a threesome, but then became incapacitated, and the men are taking advantage of her and inviting all these other men to do things to her. Ultimately, seven men were charged with and admitted to doing something, but there were 57 men in this chat. So why don't we start with the Cornell case,
SPEAKER_01and then we can, you know, there's a few others, but What were your initial thoughts with this? And what do you kind of want to get out of a conversation if we are talking to Mitt?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, sure. So first off, guys, thanks for coming. We see folks trickling into the chat. Bess Reed, William J. Armone, C.N. Clark. Appreciate you, John E. Dobbs. Thanks for coming in here. So if you have followed our newsletter, you know, Let's Not Be Trash. We talk about patriarchy, politics, and all things masculinity, and hopefully in a way that is not a TED Talk. And, you know, we were inspired by the great Let's Not Be Trash. We were inspired by the great, very smart brothers. And shout out to Damon, who's on Substack now. So if you haven't, you should follow his newsletter.
SPEAKER_00And we're talking about, like, we're really talking about assault in general, but specifically talking about the assault that happened at Cornell University with a young lady who was assaulted by several members of a fraternity and what happened afterwards. So, first of all, the fact that, like, she was assaulted. Brothers promoted that she was in a room available for people to have sex with against her will. They essentially said, free pussy. Like just to quote exactly what they said, people came in there. The folks who did not join in the assault, but saw the message in the chat on Snapchat,
SPEAKER_00didn't say anything, didn't confront them, didn't stop them. After the assault happened, the issue was not taken seriously. When she went to the officers, the officers put the entire testimony together, sent it to the DA's office. It was not moved forward. And two years later, now we're kind of reckoning with everything that's been happening. And People seem to be moving. And the question that I have for myself, Evan, is why does it always take this long?
SPEAKER_00Why did it have to come to this now where it became a viral thing, a big story for folks to take it seriously when it was very obvious what was going on back then? That's the thing that really sticks out to me. And the other thing that really sticks out to me is I thought we had made so much progress about consent and about the way that we view women. But then you got a group chat where guys are essentially saying free pussy to someone who is too drunk to consent, who's too drunk to do really anything. And people are coming in and they're coming to take advantage of that. And it makes me wonder...
SPEAKER_00What are folks thinking? And are we living in a bubble where we think that, you know, there's not this level of entitlement to women's bodies? So that's kind of where I'm at with this story. And if folks have thoughts or comments, please leave it in the chat. I mean, as you know.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, please. Engaged. It means a lot. I mean, as you know, Stanley, so many of these things and like what we talk about on the site, there's so many things that intersect, right? There's privilege. This is Cornell University. Most of these people involved are white, lighter skinned or white presenting. I'm not saying they are all Caucasian, but the majority. You know, are. What we can say presenting or of lighter complexion.
SPEAKER_01And that absolutely makes a difference. Now it doesn't mean, and I want to like, because there are many cases going around with different people and different backgrounds. It is atrocious and a problem no matter who perpetuates it. But when we look at each case, and to your point, why so long? We do have to kind of say in some part, these are privileged guys. These are privileged. Mostly white, or white, you know, in white circles, men.
SPEAKER_01And they come from privileged families. Many of them come from wealth. They go to an esteemed university that does not want its reputation ruined. And all of that, and also there is a culture within those fraternities and a culture within academia of, for a long time, not wanting these types of stories to And ironically, I think it would be much better press, actually, if schools faced it head on.
SPEAKER_01But instead, it's more, it's status quo. It's hush, like do things quietly, make them right. I don't even, you know, the essay part is like, I can barely even get into that. That's like, that's even bad for Cornell.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, real quick, Evan. Tell five of them.
SPEAKER_01Two did get expelled, but until five of them in.
SPEAKER_00Real quick, Evan, for those of you who are listening who don't know what Evan's talking about. Yeah, five of them were
SPEAKER_01asked to write a message.
SPEAKER_00When the assault happened and the complaint went through, the school decided that five of the men could write essays and they would not face any other severe penalizations. Two were expelled, but the five of them could write essays and they were able to move on with their lives. And that's been one of the big things coming up in the story where you can assault someone and the penalty can be an essay. And, you know, from my point of view, we have students who have said, you know, Palestinian people deserve to live and have gotten kicked out of school, had their careers destroyed or their budding careers destroyed, have received death threats,
SPEAKER_00have been deported, have been targeted by the federal government. But we have these young men who are committing assault and they can write an essay that they probably use chat GPT to put together for them and they can move on with their lives. So go ahead, Evan. I didn't mean to interrupt you. I just want to add some context to that. And shout out to Steve and Janae who came to the chat.
SPEAKER_01And by the way, Yeah, thanks for listening. And two of the men, I don't know if they're the same two who were expelled, fled the country and were able to do so. When people have wealth and social mobility, they literally have mobility. They can move places. Their lives are not over. So it's also amazing how many of these men, even if we see their pictures, one guy's in Dubai. He just went.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, UAE, Dubai. Just went. And another guy, I believe, went to Korea.
SPEAKER_02Now, I'm not saying they won't encounter anything. They should encounter some sort of accountants.
SPEAKER_01But again, if someone else without the social mobility, without the means, did something still equally terrible, And they did it of a different class and of a different background. We know that it probably would not be two years, right? Because you're up against an establishment. You're up against established academia. And the other reason, if you really want to know why, one of the men, I'm not saying he did all the right things, but there
SPEAKER_02is one guy who leaked the photo.
SPEAKER_01That Is one of the main reasons we even have any of this? You know when it's like people say there was police brutality, but then we get like a snippet of a video and it's like, oh shit, there was actually police brutality. And then you wonder, well, if we didn't see this video, if we didn't see the video of George Floyd, what do you think that police department would have said, right? If we didn't see a sort of chat That had something this deliberate,
SPEAKER_01who knows what we could have, it would have been even, it still would have been even worse, it would have been more swept. So many people are not being believed, and this is what it takes even to get this far. So that's part of the reason of the, that's my explanation of the two years.
SPEAKER_00So we talked about the two years and I'd love to hear from folks in the chat. So if you got something to say, put it in there. And the question that I'm asking is, we, if it was pretty clear that like we live in a country that like has a strong rape culture, we know that because Cornell, this Cornell story isn't even the freshest story. We had this story about the young woman who was raped and died at FIT after she was drugged. And according to the article that I read, the person who did it, instead of calling 911, took like, Download her nudes.
SPEAKER_00That's what he did.
SPEAKER_01The pictures.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. That was what he did and we know that sexual assaults...
SPEAKER_01He took pictures and he sent them.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. We know that sexual assaults are happening over here. And there's a rape culture that exists. But What I've experienced when I've talked to them about patriarchy, masculinity, and rape culture, right, is a level of defensiveness that can be really hard to navigate through. And I get it because no one wants to see themselves as the villain. And even the way that I write, and I think, Evan, I think I would say the same thing for you. When we write about these issues, we try to write about it from a space of empathy so it doesn't feel like an attack.
SPEAKER_00Moments like this, it feels like that's not working. So the question that I have is like, what are the things that we need to do that we can be doing to be breaking this culture apart? For me, the first thing that we can be doing is like doing some very clear education on consent. But the piece that seems to be the biggest problem is there's a level of, from my point of view, of not looking at women as whole people, of looking at them like objects, that is really, really troubling. And I don't want to talk about it from an academic sense,
SPEAKER_00I want to talk about it from personal experience. I remember growing up, my dad used to say to me, you got to get pussy. No matter how you got to get it, you got to get it. And he would joke that he learned how to speak Dutch and he learned how to speak German just so he can get some pussy. He's not lying. He was fluent in both those languages just so he could get laid. And when he talked about it, he didn't talk about women. He talked about pussy. So pardon me for the language, but that is how he described it. And I've been in conversations,
SPEAKER_00not recently, but when I was younger, of people saying, you know, if you got to cry to get it, if you got to lie to get it, if you got to be somebody you're not to get it, do that because the goal is to get it. And if that's the way we're talking to people and that's how we're talking about women and the thing that is attached to them, Is it really a surprise that we're landing in this space? So like, how do we attack that specific piece? How do we go after that in a way that doesn't just turn into preaching?
SPEAKER_01Yeah. And of course, anyone in the comments who wants to add to Stanley's question, please. I agree with you. We need education. I wrote a piece for our publication that if we can have D.A.R.E., like you remember D.A.R.E., which obviously did not work and famously wasn't effective. But if you can have a structured program that goes throughout public schools, right? We can have something that's consent education. We can have programs like that. We can have programs about educating about the manosphere and the dangers to parents.
SPEAKER_01We could do all of it. We just choose not to. It's not like we can't. This is where I disagree with some of the many opinions I've seen online that say it's not education. Men know. And they don't like it. That's not the issue. And I would say there are multiple issues. And first of all, let's remember, men start with boys. No one is born a grown, sleazy, assaulting man.
SPEAKER_01And I don't want young boys to see themselves that way. I want boys to be educated and girls. But It's especially important for young boys to be educated about touch, about consent. And if we're being honest, I think one of the reasons why is because, unfortunately, a lot of parents in this country do not want their children being,
SPEAKER_01as crazy as it sounds, indoctrinated by certain agendas. I don't To me, consent is a normal thing. It shouldn't be an agenda. But they don't want people teaching any sort of social skill. But I argue this is a health skill. This isn't a social skill, right? I mean, I guess it is, but it's a social skill that connects to one's boundaries and to harm.
SPEAKER_01And those are The types of things we should learn in school for learning not to do drugs. You know, who's to say in someone's apartment, in someone's house, you know, weed is seen as therapeutic, right? So I don't really buy that, but I do think if that's one of the reasons in between it. Now, when it comes to grown men, because who knows how long it'll take until we get that type of education, right? I don't think grown men want to be educated.
SPEAKER_01I don't think grown men want to learn. I don't think grown men want to hear, for the most part, about women's experiences. They think they're not the problem.
SPEAKER_02Wait, really?
SPEAKER_01And that's where it ends. Now I'm learning about women.
SPEAKER_02I want to interrupt you here.
SPEAKER_01And what they encounter.
SPEAKER_00So you're saying essentially that you don't think men are interested in learning and they're not interested in learning and changing.
SPEAKER_02Is that where you're at right now?
SPEAKER_01About women's experience through this world, specifically. Not about anything. And men will learn how to be double prestige and fucking Call of Duty.
SPEAKER_02I'm not saying they don't want to learn other things.
SPEAKER_01Men don't want to, like, I think, yeah, like, one in three women are sexually assaulted. If we knew that as kids, that this is the world women encounter, right? Like, because I wrote, you're not someone's friend if you don't really know about the world they encounter, so If I can't say I have friends of different backgrounds and then not care that, you know, when we had stop and frisk at its full force, and I'm sure it's still not, numbers haven't changed much, you know, over 80% of those stop and frisk were black and brown.
SPEAKER_01So I can't not care about that or not be interested, be engaged, and claim to have friends, right? And it's the same thing. I can't say, I have a woman, I have a girlfriend, I have a mom, sister. So that means no. But if you don't then care what happens when they go on the street, if you don't care about the world they encounter, you don't really care about them. That's why I wrote that and had that piece. I don't think men care about women as a gender, really.
SPEAKER_01They care about them in their relational aspect. So that's why what you're saying about education is so important because we got to get people when they're young. Because at this age, I do think most men are very, as you said, defensive. They just don't want to be the bad guy. And if they're not the bad guy, they don't see it as their problem.
SPEAKER_00Can you educate someone into
SPEAKER_02caring about women, though? I honestly think that...
SPEAKER_01I personally think that there's a lot of men... Who probably have no business being in relationships with women. Because I don't think if you, I mean, I said this in the last slide. If you don't even care about the world they encounter, I don't think you should be dating a woman. Now, it's maybe a high standard to hold, but I think we should start holding it. I don't think most men are going to change unless they see that it is not normal
SPEAKER_01for me as a man to give so little care about these issues. I think we have to denormalize that as a society. I'm not saying I know the perfect way to do it, but that's what I think.
SPEAKER_00I don't know. So I don't know that I agree with you 100%. Oh, sorry. I don't know that I agree with you. I don't think it's a case that all men are uninterested or don't care about the experiences of women, right? Like, I don't think that is necessarily the case. That is what it can feel like. But if that were the case, we wouldn't be here now having this conversation. Johnny Dobbs, who I'm assuming identifies as a male, if you don't, I apologize. He probably wouldn't be here listening to this conversation.
SPEAKER_00Steve, also, if you identify as a male, don't know for sure, just going off by your name. They wouldn't be here. So, people care, right? I think there's a level of care that does exist. The question is...
SPEAKER_02Not all men,
SPEAKER_00no. Yeah, like, not all men, but, like, the question is, why does it seem like a dominant narrative? Or, like, the people with the most impact seem to not care. And that's where I start to look at patriarchy, right? And, like, sexism and these gender norms that we have, a lot like white supremacy and racism. Because do I believe that all white people are uninterested in the experiences of black people? Absolutely not. Do I believe that all white people have some inkling of racism on them?
SPEAKER_00Absolutely I do. Do I think that makes all white people bad people? No. It's like all white people are racist. It's like all men are sexist. And this thing that exists because of the system that we live in, where that is the culture, that is the rule of law. So it is very difficult if It's the allegory of the cave. If like everyone has always spent their days looking inside of the cave, looking inside of the cave, they never turn around. It is very difficult to then be somebody who does not like have their focus solely on the inside of the cave, right?
SPEAKER_00And the people who turn around to look beyond what they've always known, they tend to be the outliers, right? Does that mean that the people who are looking inside of the cave don't care about anybody else or anything else? No, it's just all that they've known. And then the challenge that we have to face is if A world that is dominated by white supremacy, patriarchy, and sexism is all that we've ever known. And if we want to break away from that, then how do we do it? And the answer is we have to learn new tools. But before you can even learn new tools, you have to understand that the world that you're in,
SPEAKER_00the way that you think is broken. It's the same way that somebody who has an addiction, they can't get help until they acknowledge and accept that they have it and they have it challenged. And they want the help. And then they still have to do the work. And any person who has an addiction who's recovering will tell you that you don't become cured one day. Every day is a process where you're trying your best to stay like on this new path. And some days you do really well and some days you might falter. And it's being kind to yourself and holding space and you need a community around it.
SPEAKER_00And I think that we live in a world where we, the dominant worldview is Says that women aren't people, that men can take what they want, that certain groups of people have less value. And we are, these messages are reinforced all over the place, consciously and unconsciously, and we're reacting to that. So, maybe it feels like men aren't interested in what women go through.
SPEAKER_00But probably more accurately, it's like men don't even know that there's a difference. We're not experiencing the world in the same way. So how do we get us level set on the same world, the same reality?
SPEAKER_01But we can say, I would make that argument 20 years ago. Now I can't make that argument. It's all over the place. Men are seeing things. Men are seeing the Cornell cases, LSU, there's FIT, there was Harvey Weinstein. Men can't even, if they wanted to, escape that there's a prolific... Assault is prolific.
SPEAKER_01Femicide is prolific. They don't... In my opinion... They just like if you're talking about levels of care and energy and things that will take up our psyche and our time, it's just not that high on the radar. And it's because, you know, you went to the allegory of the cave. I'm just going to just something very aspect of human psychology is that a lot of
SPEAKER_01if you don't teach empathy early on and we are not an empathetic society. And we are a patriarchal society. A lot of men are just thinking, I'm not the rapist. Why do I care? Why does this affect me? It's not that they will go and assault women. Like I said in the last one we had, it's like a pie chart. The men who are actually assaulting women are few and far between. But the men who will allow it,
SPEAKER_01The men who don't think it's that big a deal. I truly believe that the majority of men, not all, again, but the majority of men are the men in that group chat. The majority. Not the seven who did it. The rest of them.
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_01I think that's the majority of men. The majority of men will say, oh, some guy's going crazy. Free pussy, what? He's going crazy. I just want to associate myself. Not thinking that, wow, someone is inviting me, unless a woman literally sent an orgy invitation to 57 men, someone is inviting me to have sex with, she's not inviting you. Someone's inviting me to have sex with someone who is ultimately incapacitated.
SPEAKER_01And your ideology is, Either, whatever, that's crazy, it's frat, boys will be boys, girls will be girls for being there in the first place. And the other half of it is, if I saw that chat two days later, I would really say, I need to rethink who the fuck my friends are. Why am I in a chat where I have never, I've been in many group chats. I'm sure you have too. Never has anything close to that ever came up.
SPEAKER_01And we've had debates about things, including You know, feminism, never. But I don't think, this is why I'm saying, like, I truly think a lot of men, a lot of men didn't look at that and say, how did 50, all these men not do something? Like, it just, most of the responses you could aggregate to, those guys are innocent.
SPEAKER_01The guys that didn't do, the guys that were in the chat and didn't do anything. Innocent's not the word I would use. And, well, she got drunk and she wanted perhaps a threesome, so come on. And a lot of other men just aren't being very outspoken about it. And I just think that it's, again, not that all men, but the majority of men,
SPEAKER_01I just don't think have that much of an interest in changing and being the vocal part of changing this culture when it's just so easy to just be that guy in the chat that does nothing.
SPEAKER_00So in that case, I was going to debate you some more, but I'll just ask a question. And then what do we do?
SPEAKER_02Is all this futile? Like, should we just give up?
SPEAKER_01No, I think you brought up some points with white folks on racism. Again, I said at the beginning of this, I don't believe nihilism is the answer either. It's not about giving up on men. It's not about saying men shouldn't be here. It's not about... I have to think that also a lot of men won't change is because we have normal, this is what I'm writing now, one of my 18 drafts in Let's Not Be Trash, is like we've normalized these men.
SPEAKER_01And if I'm being 100% honest, normalizing these men is us keeping them around. I personally wouldn't, but many men will keep them around as friends. But they're also someone's boyfriends. They're also someone's husband. They're also someone's father. It is not women's job to put patriarchy down, but they do have a role. Women have, just like non-white people have a role in deconstructing white supremacy,
SPEAKER_01women have a role too. And it's not just, if you kind of say, well, all these men shouldn't, but this guy's different. I can change him. He can be fixed. He could change. Like, no, you're actually, I think, I think you're actually normalizing someone. I don't think people should have the most intimate people who hold these views should have the most intimate access to women. So I would literally say we should rethink who our friends are and we should rethink
SPEAKER_01who our, you know, intimate partners are and I hate to make it look like it's like a tough love type of thing, but we're not going to re-educate grown-ass men. And grown-ass men are not going to suddenly have an epiphany. Most of these men, I think, unfortunately, will change when they realize they have less access and their behavior is
SPEAKER_00less normal. Or they'll get resentful and they'll lash out and they'll build power like white people have. Like, look at Donald Trump. We tried this thing, but we turned our back and we tried to ostracize folks. And we got Trump twice for it. White people watch black people get shot and killed in the streets. They saw undocumented people get treated poorly and they voted for Trump. 80% of them voted for Trump. And the reason being is because, like, that mood doesn't change anything. It just creates resentment.
SPEAKER_00And, you know, there are all, every single white person that voted for Trump, are they an evil person? No, but that's not what I'm talking about. But, like, when you're saying, so what you're saying is, like, they're not going to learn, so, like, we just got to kind of, like, you know, like, we shouldn't date them, we shouldn't be their friends, right? I don't disagree with that. But, like, they're still here. Like, they're still in society. So what happens now? Like, those same folks, we canceled all these people. Because we're talking
SPEAKER_01about different, you and I are talking about different parts of that pie chart.
SPEAKER_02Okay, go ahead.
SPEAKER_01Sorry, I know there's a delay. You're talking about people who were very far away from change from the first place. I'm not talking about those people. I'm talking about people who already think they're better and are probably the majority of men.
SPEAKER_02Mm-hmm.
SPEAKER_01And who say nothing, don't think it's that big a deal, but they're also not necessarily raging on forums. Probably don't vote for Donald Trump. I'm talking like I told you in the last one about the male moderate. The male moderate is the greatest threat. Just like in racism, I believe in sexism and patriarchy. That's the guy that can't be normalized.
SPEAKER_01Just like centrism shouldn't be normalized.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_01I don't think we can normalize this guy who's kind of neutral. Well, there's problems on both sides. There's crazy men. There's crazy women. Like that guy. That is not normalized. I want that person to at least now think one in three women are sexually assaulted. Femicide is an issue. This is a rampant issue. I want to know more about, like, I want, I don't see that energy from the vast majority of men.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, so I agree with you on that, right? And also, if we're not talking to them, or maybe it's not us, right? Maybe we don't have that energy to do it. And that's fine. If someone is not talking to them, trying to pull them in, trying to shift their mindset, the red pill bros will get to them. They already are. And that's part of the problem why some of these male moderates They are drifting over to the extremes because what a lot of us have done is said, like, you should know better. I'm not doing this with you.
SPEAKER_00I can't be your friend. I can't date you and all these other things. And then the red pills come here and they say, you can't get a job. You can't get a girl. Everyone's blaming you for things that's out of your control. It's the fault of women and trans people. And then now you have a bigger problem. So that's why I say, like, I hear you, but we still have to do something.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, but I wouldn't say necessarily the male moderate is the person who's being extricated. I actually think part of what allows for moderation, just like what allows for these 50 other men, is the other people that normalize it. So I do think... A person's social circle that does include their intimate partners, but I'm not only saying, obviously, in this case, women. Not only saying that, I'm saying your male friends.
SPEAKER_01I'm saying also your colleagues. I'm saying also people who care about you. We have to denormalize this apathy. We have to denormalize and reduce access to ourselves. How do you do that when this
SPEAKER_00apathy is a standard?
SPEAKER_01Well, right, but there's two parts. There's denormalizing it, but then as you said earlier, it can't be denormalizing it and then there's a shut door. It's like reducing normalization but saying, but I want to have this conversation and there has to be places for it. So it's parallel. It's like we have to say, I hate to put it like, Back into like when we're teaching kids, this is bad.
SPEAKER_01This isn't good. I don't want you to think this. But that doesn't mean I'm going to throw you in time out and not going to talk
SPEAKER_02to you.
SPEAKER_01Denormalization of it, I'm saying means I'm identifying this. I'm not going to tolerate this, but let's talk about. What alternatives can look like and what would mean something to me, what I would like you to do. One thing that I'm writing is when a woman tells you her experience, I think too many men, including their boyfriends, including men who are moderate, jump to you're overreacting. Jump to that's not really what happened.
SPEAKER_01It's not that serious. Why did they jump to that? I don't think men that say that are because if it's that serious, if it's really the case, there's a broader problem that I might be a small part of in some way and that's uncomfortable to me. Same thing with Well, maybe you did something that looked threatening, right?
SPEAKER_01Maybe the way you drove, are you sure? Did you have a hoodie up? And that can be someone that's your quote-unquote friend, but then it's time to say, no, this is my lived experience, and if you're my friend, you need to listen to me and care about my lived experience. So that's one tip. If we're at the part now where we're talking about things to do,
SPEAKER_01that's one tip I have for any man. Especially when women talk to you, especially if it's a partner or anyone who's talking to you about serious shit, go into it with an open mind and to learn and to believe her experience. Not jumping to overreaction isn't that serious. That's one thing I think we can do a lot better.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I hear you. So what can you and I do better? Like, how can we be better allies? Because, like, we started Let's Not Be Trash to talk to men to kind of, like, have these conversations. What I've experienced with the writing done here, I've had a great time. I love writing. I love sharing stuff on Substack and the newsletter and the email list. But at least for me, most of the people who respond to me are women. I'm not reaching the men.
SPEAKER_02So what are we doing wrong? What am I doing wrong?
SPEAKER_01I think we should reframe that. I don't think it's right or wrong. I think it's trying to make a difference in a very difficult system, like you said, that has been the norm. I don't think, I look at it more like, If we go from 75% being women to 73% being women, we actually made progress. That's how I look at it.
SPEAKER_01I don't think this is going to change anytime soon. I think we need to also acknowledge that what progress can look like. And that 2% of men... If we got 2% more men viewership and listenership, that's a big difference because who knows, and 2% of however many is more than 2, who knows what they can change. So I wouldn't be, I agree with you though. It's a, you know, but we're up against something very big.
SPEAKER_01We both have full-time jobs. We're not, we don't have all the resources.
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_01But we gotta keep having conversations like this and calling men and listening in our lives. I want to embody it too. If a woman says, this is what happened to me today and it sounds crazy, I don't want my first reaction to be, is it really? Yeah. You know?
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_01I want to, I want women, I want, I want to continue. It's a continuing process for women to feel safe around us.
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_01For women to feel heard and seen. We don't have to be yes men and say they're always right and never have an opinion. But all of those things can be present, safe, heard, and seen with women around us.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. And I try to follow a very simple philosophy, which is called Don't Be a Dick. And... I, from my white friends, I probably said this to you before too, Evan, I'm like, when you're trying to like be NC racist, sometimes like I don't need you to quote every single like James Baldwin, Malcolm X, Martin Luther King thing to me. No, it's just like in your daily interactions, don't be a dick. And sometimes you will be a dick. And that sucks, but it's like eat it, apologize, and move forward. I think so much of what we see in the pushback is people's shame.
SPEAKER_00And because they feel shameful about something and they don't want to own because they don't like that feeling, they push back, they get resentful, they get angry, they argue, right? They become the opposition. I think a lot of what you're seeing in this red pill and the pushback that men have about like when you talk about patriarchy or sexism or assault, right? Is there's that shame of like, am I really capable of this? Or is this what men are? And then that shame turns to anger. And anger is just a cloud. Like that's blocking what the real emotion is anyway.
SPEAKER_00And it goes from there. So don't be a dick. Don't get caught up in your shame. We all feel shame. I feel shame all the time. I just wrote an essay about an embarrassing moment I had and the shame that I felt in that moment where a girl that I hooked up with when I first graduated from college, I wanted to date her seriously. And she was like, I don't date men. And I tried to convince her. And then I had an open mic. And the girl's girlfriend recited a poem, essentially making fun of me. And like, that was embarrassing. There was a lot of shame there.
SPEAKER_00But also, she told me what her conditions were and what her boundaries were, and I didn't respect them. And like, it's a shame that it took that experience to kind of like, realize it. Right? But, it was a lesson to be learned. And if we can get beyond the shame, get beyond the embarrassment, get beyond the frustration of Of like feeling singled out and kind of get to the core is that like people that we care about are not safe. People are having things happen to them that we would not wish on our worst enemies.
SPEAKER_00If you do not care about the issue of femicide or a sexual assault in mass, I'm sure you don't think that it's okay for people to just be getting assaulted. I'm sure you don't think it's okay for people to be getting murdered or abused because I think you're a good person and you have good values. So if it's just that basic principle, if we can agree right there, then we can make some progress.
SPEAKER_02So that's what I'm going to focus on.
SPEAKER_01I think I agree with you. I think for the most part, if you ask people individually, and again, to like what you said about You know, I don't need you to quote Malcolm X and James Ball. I don't need you to, like, I love, I love Belle Hooks, as you know.
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_01I don't need you to always quote Belle Hooks. Yeah. You know. But you can, because
SPEAKER_02she's fire.
SPEAKER_01But the principles, don't be a dick or a racist dick. Yeah, she is. But, you know, don't be a racist dick. Don't be a sexist, you know, misogynistic, you know, Andrew Tate. I don't know. But, like, Did I tell you I call his followers Tots? But anyway, I just think it's funny because they were doing push-ups in front of his fucking thing. Jesus Christ. But I agree with you. I think, I know, I think what bothers me is that,
SPEAKER_01kind of like what you said earlier about, these people have seen, what you were talking before about, Immigrants being shot, police brutality. There's so many people who have seen this shit, right? It's not an unknown quantity and they still find excuses and reasons to not make it their problem. But this is what I'm saying. I feel the same way. The knowledge, the information, it's all there.
SPEAKER_01In fact, You could just ask a woman that you care about and don't, like, just like you shouldn't ever ask a person of color, like, tell me all your traumatic experiences. I'm listening. Like, you shouldn't just randomly fucking do that. But to someone who you have a relationship with, maybe a girlfriend, maybe a mom, a sister, like, you maybe haven't had these conversations with them. Listen to them. I...
SPEAKER_01What I will tell men is that I have hope for you. I don't think you're incapable. I believe men have a capacity. I don't believe, like we talked about earlier, male nihilism. But I also don't believe in saying all this stuff on social media and then entirely normalizing the behavior in our personal lives. I can't tell you how many... It's not fun to be the guy in the group chat that always got to talk, you know, but I do my best to be that guy even when it's annoying. And we're never going to do it perfectly.
SPEAKER_01And as we said at the beginning, it's never going to be a TED Talk. It'll be a barbershop talk sometimes, but it needs to be a talk. Just saying to a friend, that's kind of weird.
SPEAKER_02Just saying to a friend, I don't think that's right, has power. You can do a lot just by doing that.
SPEAKER_01I mean, we could go on. One of the things I'm actually writing is, like, little steps of things that people can do. The other thing, oh, this is the other thing I wrote. I, like, I do think there's a little bit of homework here. And again, like I said, if you can research fucking every Fortnite DLC, then you can do this. Like, There's different documentaries. One of the most famous ones called The Hunting Ground.
SPEAKER_01And I think it's one of the most relevant now. I think all men should watch The Hunting Ground. Also, if you're a New York Giants fan, you might see a familiar face. I'm sorry. And I am a Giants fan. And that's why Janice Winston, for those who don't know, had accusations. He's a creep.
SPEAKER_02He's a multi-time creep.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, but anyway, that one of many people, but it's about college campuses and assault on college campuses. So I recommend The Hunting Ground. I do recommend The Will to Change, but with a lot of people, I know it takes time to read books. I really think there's a lot of ways to educate yourself in ways that
SPEAKER_02aren't like through shame.
SPEAKER_01And I don't want to hear as men that they don't exist because they do. So there's some very simple things that men can do. I just sometimes feel like the men who are going to do them are already in the chat. This chat, not the other chat. And that's where I kind of lose. I guess it's kind of to your earlier point about it being mostly women. That's where I sometimes feel like
SPEAKER_01But how do you, we can end after this, but just how do we think, like, men who have been resistant, how do you think, like, we've been open to them? It's not like we're shaming, we're open, and they're still resistant. What do people do then?
SPEAKER_00So, I mean, so yeah, we should definitely close this out, but I think, and for those of you who are just jumping in, we're talking about the Cardinal sexual assault cases, and the sexual assault cases happening all over the country, and, like, what we need to be doing. So for those of you who are trying your best, keep trying your best. And like Evan said, something as simple as like when your friend says something like crazy or inappropriate, like you ain't got to make a big thing. You could just be like, bro, that's weird. Just to be the counter narrative to it. And the biggest thing that you can do that is within your spirit of control is
SPEAKER_00to check yourself. It's like to like ask yourself, how am I showing up? Ask yourself about the women in your lives. What do you know about them? What's their favorite color? What are their aspirations? What are they trying to do? And think about it. Don't think about it in a sexual context or like you're trying to date them. Just think about them as people. And make believe it's a video game and you're talking to the side characters. Just try to figure out who they are a little bit. And it doesn't have to be a whole assignment. Just pick one person.
SPEAKER_00And it's like really just try to get to know them a little bit better because I think the more we lean into relationships and we know, we understand people and how they think and like we can see beyond ourselves, the better we can be.
SPEAKER_02Evan, did I lose you? All right, I think we lost Evan. Well, folks, thanks for joining us today. It's been a great conversation and talk to you soon.
Thanks for being a subscriber to Let's Not Be Trash. If you’re new here, we (Stanley Fritz, Evan J. Mastronardi, and Karina Maria) write about patriarchy, politics, race, culture, music, and ruminations. The goal is to...
Thanks for being a subscriber to Let's Not Be Trash. If you’re new here, we (Stanley Fritz, Evan J. Mastronardi, and Karina Maria) write about patriarchy, politics, race, culture, music, and ruminations. The goal is to...
Thanks for being a subscriber to Let's Not Be Trash. If you’re new here, we (Stanley Fritz, Evan J. Mastronardi, and Karina Maria) write about patriarchy, politics, race, culture, music, and ruminations. The goal is to...