Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Untidy Faith

Untidy Faith artwork

Celeste Irwin | Trans and Christian

Apr 23, 20261 hrAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

In this episode of the Untidy Faith Podcast, I sit down with Celeste Irwin for an honest conversation about what it’s like to be trans in Christian spaces - from childhood shame over “transy thoughts” with no language for them, to losing every friend when coming out, to discovering that transition feels like being literally raised to life. Celeste Irwin is a transgender, lesbian woman and a survivor of a spiritually abusive evangelical church network. She’s written in-depth about her experiences in that network, and she now writes and speaks about issues affecting transgender people, including queer inclusion in Christian spaces. Topics Covered * Why even as a child Celeste knew “this is the thing I can’t confess” - different from sins you talk about in small group, this was something that would “really mess stuff up” if she stared at it too long * The cost of exile like losing most friends when leaving evangelicalism, then losing the rest when coming out as trans * What churches miss without trans people: * Why queer exclusion is spiritual abuse * The three things Celeste is tired of saying but will say for us anyway: * How the movie Moana captures trans joy best Timestamps: 02:00 Primary School “Transy Thoughts” and Unconfessable Shame 10:00 The Cost of Exile: Losing 20-Year Friendships 14:00 What the Church Loses Without the Trans Limb 22:00 Names, Identity, and “Your Identity Should Be in Christ” 28:00 Three Things Celeste Is Tired of Saying (But Will Say Again) 36:00 Why Becoming Affirming Requires Actual Repentance 40:00 What Intellectual Arguments Miss: The People 46:00 Trans Joy: Skirt Go Spinny and Te Fiti’s Heart Restored 54:00 What a Church That Genuinely Welcomes Trans People Looks Like 58:00 The Pride Month Challenge: Education Work Required Links https://www.celestefinally.com https://www.youtube.com/@Celestial-Navigation https://www.notovercome.org This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit kateboyd.substack.com/subscribe

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_00You're listening to the Untidy Faith Podcast, where we have honest conversations and gentle encouragement for when following Jesus gets messy. I'm your host, Kate Boyd, author, speaker, and gentle guide for Christians who are disentangling their faith from culture and desiring to find joy in following Jesus again.

SPEAKER_01There can be life of faith after deconstruction. Let's find yours together.

SPEAKER_00Welcome back everyone to the untidy faith podcast. I'm your host Kate Boyd. And today I have with me Celeste Erwin. Hello, Celeste.

SPEAKER_01Hi, Kate. Good to be here.

SPEAKER_00Yes. I am so excited to have you. Um, you and I you're on the, you're currently on the board at the remember table, um, and have been really helpful in getting us, uh, in helping to shape spaces that are inclusive and connected and, for our people and so i'm super grateful for that but i'm also really looking forward to this conversation because i think a lot of people um this conversation about uh being trans and being a christian and how those things

can and do coexist and what it looks like in the church and and to be affected by that personally um on that side so i really appreciate you showing up and being willing to have this

SPEAKER_01conversation with me absolutely happy to be here happy to talk So I want to start with like maybe some of the beginning of your trans journey.

SPEAKER_00You were a Christian before you had language for who you were. What was it like to inhabit those spaces as a person that you didn't fully yet know or even feel comfortable showing up as?

SPEAKER_01Absolutely. My... first memory of any kind of thought that i was trans or whatever i obviously didn't have the right words for it or anything but any kind of transy thoughts we'll call them um was i was primary school age uh yeah you know no older than seven So pretty much at the start of my memories of thinking about myself.

SPEAKER_01So it was kind of always there. But I remember thinking like vivid memories of thinking I should have been a girl. Like this is wrong that I'm a boy. This is not right. You know, I remember thinking, you know, oh, there was some coin flip before I was born and it went wrong. right and that was the way i phrased it in my head was it went wrong not just like oh it could have gone a different way or or something like that it was just like this doesn't feel right and those feelings never went away um

and so as i was in the church as i was um grew up got into evangelical spaces in college and was there for most of my adult life all of those feelings were always there all of the ways that that would manifest at times either just in how i would think about myself um you know occasionally you know trying on clothes in

secret and not letting anybody know that it was the one thing in evangelical world that i never

SPEAKER_01ever ever let anybody know right um and and i say that all to say like even though i did have didn't have language it was always there and it was always a source of unbelievable shame um it was something that i knew every single time i would hear a pastor be like oh yeah and you need to confess your sins or whatever because that was the only language i'd been given for it um it was like no i can't i can't say that um and so it meant that i had to

SPEAKER_01I had to adopt kind of a life. And I've said this before of like, I couldn't live the life that I wanted. I couldn't be the person that I was. And I didn't really fully understand what that was because I had no exposure to trans people. I didn't have that. And so I just kind of had to adopt this weird view of myself of just like,

SPEAKER_01I'll be what other people want and need me to be because I can't be me. So I'll just find ways to be useful. Right. And find ways to be good for other people and things like that. And you know, this very, you know, utilitarian view of self of just like I exist for other people because that's all I can aspire to. Yeah.

SPEAKER_00So I feel like some of that is so relatable, like even in my experience, but I do find it fascinating that even then you kind of registered it as like, I can't say this is sinful, even if it was sort of a shame or even some of the things that you were thinking or working out felt shameful. Yeah. Yeah, I mean, I think I knew, to be clear, like, I think I knew that they would see it as sin.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. I think I was so scared to even look at it that long that it was like, okay, this is, yeah, their sin and the kinds of sins that we talk about when we're, you know, in small group and we're confessing our sins to our one-on-one whoever and our pastor, There's those. And then there's this. And this is the thing that I'm going to try to completely block

out and not think

SPEAKER_01about any longer than I absolutely have to. Because I think I did know at some root level that there was something... more significant there that like, okay, if I stare at this too long, it's gonna really mess stuff up.

SPEAKER_00It's gonna change everything. Yeah. I mean, I felt that way whenever I was determining whether or not to become affirming at all. It was just sort of like, I know that if I start looking at this, it's gonna change everything about how I relate to a lot of people. So like having that pressure around your own identity when it's like not even a, it's not a, it's like for me, it's almost intellectual,

SPEAKER_00right? Like it's not because I know trans people and it's very important to me like to be on their side, but that it doesn't necessarily have to affect me if I don't want it to, that privileged position. And so I can't imagine what that's like in that space too.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, absolutely. And even the question of being affirming, you know, or the phrasing that I typically like to use, but we'll use affirming here, but I typically like to use the question of, you know, walking away from queer exclusive beliefs, right? Queer excluding beliefs, right? And giving that up was also something that, you know, when I was in those evangelical spaces, I was like, okay, I I took one look at that in college briefly.

SPEAKER_01I took another one briefly in like 2011, 2012. And I remember thinking, I was like, I wish I could get to an affirming view because I hate having to be anti-gay, you know, anti-gay, anti-trans. And it was mostly the gay side of things because I really just didn't know much about trans people at the time. Yeah. And it was scary. And I think to. To, you know, I have a lot of regret about.

SPEAKER_01The. The ways that I didn't really look at that and I didn't really go find the best voices on that. And I kind of found, OK, here's some evangelicals who say this is how it is. and didn't really ever find the responses to that and didn't really you know and but it was you know that that it was a deeply unsafe thing to ask because yeah okay the moment and this is even more true today ecosystem right

like you're discouraged from looking outside of the ecosystem so you're only pointed towards the voices

SPEAKER_00that agree with the people at the top two

SPEAKER_01Absolutely. And even more so today, the evangelical church has kind of adopted this, like, being anti-queer is probably the most litmus test of litmus tests, right? It is the most strict one of the moment you say, I'm okay with gay or trans people. It's like, okay, you're out. And so, and that was true back then too, of like, okay, if I come to this view, it's going to cost me a lot. which isn't a reason not to look at it.

SPEAKER_01Right. It's just not. And you know, once I figured out who I was, it was like, okay, now this is who I am. So. Yeah.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. So I do want to talk about that cost because I think a lot of people, um, in my audience have either have watched trans friends and family members get pushed out of churches or know of people, um, in which that's happened. Some of them, you know, pushed themselves some of them walked away some of them were the push some of the people in my audience had previously been pushers of people out of those within those communities what do you want those people to understand

um about what that kind of exile actually costs the people that they exile yeah um I when I left my

SPEAKER_01evangelical church I lost most of my friends when i came out as trans i lost the rest um because even the ones that i kept were still deeply in evangelical spaces still deeply anti-queer i had friends that i knew for 20 years that i came out as trans and literally never heard from them again um like they didn't even respond to me my coming out

SPEAKER_01I had others who just sent me, you know, one nasty email and said, you know, I can't believe you're doing this. And I tried to respond and explain and again, never heard back. Others who tried to wrestle with it. I had one who I was the, you know, best. Well, I'll misgender myself briefly. You know, I was the best man in his wedding. prior to coming out. And as soon as I came out,

I think we had two conversations and that was it.

SPEAKER_01Haven't heard from him in coming up on three years. And it's deeply painful. You know, I went through a time where I had almost no in-person community. those scars of the abandonments and the betrayals of the people who had told me that they loved me who told me that they cared deeply about me

that they were you know people that i called family um who didn't even try yeah to understand right

SPEAKER_01that the fact that i was somebody that they knew. They knew my character. They knew my ways of thinking. They knew I was not an irrational person and impulsive and whatever. They knew they had good reason to believe that if I came to this conclusion, it was because I had looked at it a lot and just the deep lack of curiosity there and the very,

SPEAKER_01very fast expulsion yeah from any kind of friendship or community you know it it hurts because you lose those friendships right um you lose those parts i think it was cs lewis who talked about you know when you lose a close friend you actually do lose a part of yourself there's a part of you that dies because there's a part of you that only ever came out around that person right and that part will never exist again and i felt that

SPEAKER_01deeply But then also just the like, okay, when you lose friends that close, how do you make friends again? How do you ever trust anybody?

SPEAKER_00It's so hard as an adult anyway.

SPEAKER_01Right. And so it's taken years to get to a point where it's possible for me to even really try. Right. And that's because I had a couple people who just decided to make themselves safe people for me. Um, I'm so grateful to them. Um, but it took a long time, but it's, it's a huge cost. Um, yeah. Yeah.

SPEAKER_00I think too, the other side of this is that, um, a lot of churches don't know that not having trans people around them cost them too. I think so if someone in our audience hasn't had a meaningful relationship with a trans person, what are they missing out on? What are their environments missing out on? What is that absence of trans people costing them?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, it's huge. I like to look at, you know, you see Paul talking about the body of Christ in Corinthians and, you know, every part is different and all of them are necessary. And the language that I use, and I think it's entirely accurate, is that the church for millennia amputated a limb, right? They just cut off the queer arm or leg or whatever part of the

body queer people

SPEAKER_01are, just literally cut that off. And so the body of Christ is has a disability, right? It is disabled because it has inflicted this harm on itself and it can't function the way that it should without restoring queer people to the body and including them as full members, as needed members in the church.

SPEAKER_01Part of what that ends up looking like is you know uh from a trans perspective like okay we talk about god became man in the incarnation yeah okay well trans people have an awful lot of thinking around becoming something that too many people feels impossible right that it's like okay like which is kind of funny to me i'm always like

SPEAKER_01they're like, well, a man can never become a woman. I'm like, you believe that God can become a man. Like, how is this any more difficult? And also, I was never a man. Like, you know, right, right. Like, that's not how being trans works. Like, but like, we have so many thoughts on that. Resurrections, right? Somebody coming from death to life. So many trans people have so many stories, you know, so much to say around feeling.

SPEAKER_01Literally raised to life by our transitions, right? Like I have never been more alive than I am now post transition. It's amazing. And the church loses that they lose those perspectives on what it's like to become something different than what people thought you could what it's like to um there's a great quote and i'll forget the exact wording so i

won't get there but about you know trans people participating in the act of creation right that um you know and the the quote is you know around like similar to like god gave us wheat

SPEAKER_01not bread right yeah like and so we participate in that act of creation and we get to do that and it's cool like I don't feel sorry for myself that I'm trans like not even a little um I actually really like it I think it's a really cool way to live and I've had all these fun experiences and yes there's lots of it that are hard most of which are societal issues some of which are surgeries are painful and yeah long

time to recover and things like that but you know it's we just have so much perspective on so many different things and there's like ways that you have to read the bible if you're

SPEAKER_01not trans inclusive that don't make sense, right? Like, you know, there's the whole, like, dust up over, like, what are God's pronouns? And it's like, God is non-binary.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, God doesn't have pronouns.

SPEAKER_01Obviously non-binary. Like, clear, like, if men and women are both made in God's image, then God has to, like, has to contain both the masculine and feminine. Therefore, God cannot be binary masculine. Like, this is just, like, it's very clear. But if you don't want to go there, you have to ignore that. You have to read God wrong. You have to read God as only masculine. You have to do all these things. So there's just all kinds of

ways that people end up twisting scriptures twisting their theology to accommodate say anti-trans beliefs alone um anti-gay beliefs it's like okay so you have to put love in a box right and you have to say that love can only look this way um so there's this there's there's so many different ways which is one of the reasons i

SPEAKER_01say like churches need to put trans people in their pulpits even if those trans people don't have the seminary degree or whatever because we couldn't right like what seminary could most of us go to um and so it's like yeah okay if you're if you're a pastor and you need to let a trans you know if you need to proofread the trans person's notes before they get up and speak fine but let your church hear trans perspectives because we've just got a lot

SPEAKER_01a lot to give, um, and a lot to give to church. So I love the idea.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, go ahead. I was just going to say, I love, you were talking about creation and, and I was just thinking like how much the trans experience must be a little bit of a foretaste of like what the future is, right. This restoration of what is meant to be, um, as like, so getting to participate in an even more full and in-depth way of like your own yeah

of new creation and then also absolutely i think there's also the sense in which um i've been thinking a lot about like when churches say like you know your identity should be in christ and if it's there but like most of the time they mean a

SPEAKER_00particular set of rules for the checkboxes for what it looks like to be in Christ and have your identity there. But that like, because trans people have had to wrestle so much with what identity is and what it means that it has had to be not just inside of themselves, but outside of themselves in a spiritually healthier way or more spiritually deep way than a lot of people who already fit prescribed boxes that

maybe never have to

SPEAKER_00interrogate that.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, absolutely. And so many of the identities, you know, I've had people, you know, come at me when I was active on Twitter with like, oh, but your identity should only be in Christ. Right. And it's like, from some married guy who always wears a wedding ring or from some married woman who literally changed her last name when she got married.

SPEAKER_00And I'm like, don't try and tell me that you don't have these other identities that aren't Christ

SPEAKER_01alone. Right. Like, of course you do right you know and you'll you'll check their twitter bio right and it's you know the the classic you know father pastor yeah husband father pastor you know whatever right and it's like okay come on like right don't try and tell me like it's like you're you're only using that for me specifically um i was gonna say one really fun story the church that i go to um most frequently

actually had me

SPEAKER_01um speak one time um about names right and we see in the bible we see the importance of names and it's like well who has an awful lot of thoughts on the importance of names and what a name means and how a name can be part of your identity well trans people because we get to name ourselves right um and so like my name is you know my name celeste is deeply meaningful to me in a way that my dead name never was, right? It just didn't fit me ever.

SPEAKER_01It was always just weird to me that that was my name. Like I would have these like thought things of like, I guess that's what people call me. Sure, weird, but fine.

SPEAKER_00That's what people call me, but that's not my name.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, it's just some like syllable that somebody throws out there when they're trying to get, but it never felt like me. Once I found the name Celeste, I was like, that's it. That's who I am. So anyway, so even like perspectives like that, that just, you know, and if I could explain all of it, then people wouldn't need trans people in their church, right? It's like you need them because of the surprises for the same reason that you need anybody else in the church, because everybody's, again, it's that body of Christ.

Everybody's bringing their own perspective or gifting or whatever to the body.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. And I think one thing that I have been encouraged by after leaving evangelicalism too, and seeing the way there are certainly very unhealthy dynamics in some of the deconstruction and exvangelical spaces, but I also appreciate the their willingness to count personal experience in context and like a personal context as an appropriate thing to count towards or like to

bring into theology like that you see this with like how liberation theology has gained a lot of ground

SPEAKER_00and and is you know now multiplied into queer liberation theologies and you know latin women's theology you know and muharista theology or womanist like you get all these different intersections of what that looks like um and that's been really fascinating like i could honestly just like sit and read all that stuff all the time um but that's one thing that like and then even gives me permission to bring some of my experience in in a way um

but also like understanding and taking in these different perspectives and getting

SPEAKER_00that like diversity. And like you were saying that the fullness of the body of Christ through the different perspectives, rather than thinking of it as one thing as more of like a big, beautiful picture that we can all pull from.

SPEAKER_01Right. And I love that you brought up like, you know, queer theology or queer liberation theology, because there are kind of two

SPEAKER_00streams of queer inclusion in the church.

SPEAKER_01One is this very assimilationist, respectability, you know, whatever. It's like, okay, we'll let the queer people come to church as long as they act straight, right? And it's like, okay, you can, you know, The gay person can be here as long as they are monogamously married with kids and a dog and their life looks as straight as it possibly can.

SPEAKER_00Straight as possible.

SPEAKER_01Other than the gender of the people who are involved, whatever. Or, okay, fine, you can be trans, but you need to be binary trans. You need to be recognizably woman or man or whatever. And then you see churches that just say God's far more wild than that. right and love is far more wild than that and people are far more interesting than that and there's far more diversity in creation than that and we're here for all of it um and that's it's just far richer and it's far more when i

look at the bible and i see you know even in the new testament of god always answering the question

SPEAKER_01of like okay you know you know, who is the gospel for? And it's always like more than you've done yet. Right.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. Always know for them to keep going,

SPEAKER_01keep going, keep going, keep including the people who make you more uncomfortable. Right. Exactly.

SPEAKER_00Yeah.

SPEAKER_01And you see, I mean, Jesus, right. His entire time is all up there with the people that everybody's like, really, you're going to hang out with them. It's like, Jesus would be at pride parades, right?

SPEAKER_00Yeah.

SPEAKER_01And he'd be having a blast, right?

SPEAKER_00So much fun.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. Like Jesus would have all kinds of queer friends and it'd be amazing. So I think probably as a person in your position who does a lot of like advocacy

SPEAKER_00and education around this, that there are probably some things that you're tired of having to say. Yeah. What's something, maybe a top one or two things that you really need the church to know that you're tired of having to say, but you're willing to say for us here?

SPEAKER_01Yeah. There's a couple. I know you said one or two, but I'll probably do three. That's okay. Yeah. it's okay i like to do things in threes too so i get it um my one of my favorite thing i i have friends who used to make fun of me about i'd be like okay two things wait no three things um yeah so anyway um the first one i want to hit on is and we talked about this a little bit before i think um

SPEAKER_01For those deconstructing, you have to make sure you don't stop the deconstruction at the point where it benefits you. Yes, people are likely to deconstruct the things that impact them personally first, but once you've realized that your beliefs were wrong in ways that harmed you and you've gone through and you've done the work there, again like just for integrity purposes and out of the ability to say that you're actually loving your neighbor you have to then go say okay and

there's these other people who are also saying that various beliefs have hurt them and i need to listen to that and i need to explore that and i need to explore that by listening to the people who are saying that they are being hurt right i can't just listen to you

SPEAKER_01know what does john piper say about queer people right um i will say right now about trans people in particular it is a rare rare day when i hear a conservative or evangelical voice say something correct about trans people um when i hear them talk about trans people it's just wild to me almost every single thing they say about us

SPEAKER_01is incorrect um just factually wrong um yeah and so if you get all of your sourcing from those people like you're gonna like oftentimes it's like i'll hear them be like oh we need to stop blah blah blah blah blah blah blah and i'm like if that was happening i would agree with you yeah but it's not so What are we talking about? Right. So there's there's those sorts of things. So keep going on your deconstruction.

But like, don't go read Preston Sprinkle to decide what you think about queer and trans people.

SPEAKER_01Right. Like that's incorrect. And me and Billy Hoard have written God knows how many words at this point going through like Preston Sprinkle's anti-trans.

SPEAKER_00They're really, really long blog posts. So if you want them, definitely go see Celeste Substack. There's a ton.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, there's a lot there. And it's actually really frustrating because when I'm writing those, I'm like, could you please go one sentence without saying something that I need to respond

SPEAKER_00to? Yeah.

SPEAKER_01Right. Could you just say, just give me one sentence that's correct? Right. That I just can be like, yeah, no, that's right.

SPEAKER_00Don't just read about trans people. Read from trans people.

SPEAKER_01Exactly. So go read Austin Hartke's book. Transforming is great. Go read Brandon Robertson's book. He's a gay man. He wrote a book last year that's phenomenal. It's the book I finally I have wanted it for a long time of it is the here's why being affirming is good, actually. But it's finally by a queer author because we've had like David Gushy and Colby Martin and Bridget Eileen Rivera, who I really like her book, but some of her views on queer people I don't love.

SPEAKER_01But, you know, but Brandon Robertson's book is great queer and Christian. Check it out. It's it's good. Austin Hartke's book on trans people is phenomenal. Read my sub stack, read Billy Hoard's sub stack. It's all good, but hear from the actual people who are impact in the same way that if you're going to read about racism, you're going to want to talk, you're going to want to read Jamar Tisby or Kat Armas, or you're going to want to read from a person of color.

SPEAKER_01You don't want to read a white person talking about racism. That's a bad idea. You're going to want to read women talking about women's inclusion in the church. That's the first one. The second one, and this may be surprising to people, but I'm going to say it anyway. For those of you who are familiar with the concepts of spiritual abuse, the exclusion of queer people from the church is spiritual abuse.

SPEAKER_01And people don't often think of it that way. They see it as, oh, well, we have this difference of opinion or whatever. And it's like, but it checks all the boxes. Every definition I've ever seen of spiritual abuse, using the Bible to get people to live in a way that they wouldn't otherwise, and using the Bible in not great ways to do that. Demanding that people submit to an authority that isn't earned, isn't right for them to have to submit to.

SPEAKER_01You can go down all of the lists, but it is trying to push people using spiritual language to live their lives in a particular way that is objectively harmful to them right the deep deep deep scars that i will carry with me from having to live as the wrong gender for 40 years right um like i'll never fully recover from that ever right and people be like oh

it's no big deal you

SPEAKER_01got there it's like okay go try and live as like whatever gender you are pick another one and go try and live it live as that for one year and tell me how that feels and most people are going to recoil at that and be like oh my gosh i could never do that like right and i was forced to do it for 40. um but it is spiritual abuse um and we you know and the corollary to that is we can't fight spiritual abuse well if we protect the weapons and say well you can use these weapons

against queer people because that's right you just can't use it against other people right like that doesn't work um and then because of that the third thing i always say is churches

SPEAKER_01and christians who have been queer excluding need to go through an actual repentance process i love it when people become affirming it's great And also far too many churches and Christians will say that they are affirming as kind of a, hey, look, I made it. Isn't everybody proud of me?

SPEAKER_00Yeah.

SPEAKER_01And it's like, yes, I am.

SPEAKER_00And yeah.

SPEAKER_01And also, while you weren't, you did a lot of harm, becoming affirming is simply saying, I'm not going to harm these people anymore. Right. It's not some bonus. It's we should have always been included. Right. So it's writing a wrong. And so I always say, like, I, I want to see churches apologize. I want to see Christians apologize. I want to see that repentance work. I'll just name drop Rabbi Rutenberg's book on repentance and repair.

SPEAKER_01It's my favorite book ever. It's really good. It's so good. And people need to read it. and wrestle with what does that repentance work look like what does that repair work look like um because there are queer people that need that right and need those apologies i've had single digit numbers of people actually give me an apology right for that which is not how it should be um yeah and i've

seen far too many

SPEAKER_01People get to the, hey, look, I'm affirming, yay.

SPEAKER_00And it's like, okay, then there's some apologies in order here, right?

SPEAKER_01And I'm not trying to get my pound of flesh or anything like that. It's just like any other form of harm where like, yeah, you would expect to see that. But on this one, people just, you know, if for no other reason than if you don't do the deep work of trying to wrestle with, okay, in what ways did I harm the queer community? while i was holding this view then you're unlikely to love them while going forward because you're unlikely to fully understand what harm was done

to them what they need how to repair that how to advocate for us um things like that you're much more likely to see it as an intellectual like well i was not affirming now i'm affirming

SPEAKER_01yay yeah right and you're likely to see it as a much more you thing as opposed to like no this was real things that had real impacts on other people um you know even the church i go to sometimes you know is has been affirming for 30 years but it was a church for a century before that yeah undoubtedly there were closeted queer people in that church before that yeah right so yeah and it's and i'll just say as someone

SPEAKER_00who for, like I said earlier, for a long time, I didn't examine whether or not I wanted to be affirming or like really dig into it because I knew it would be so tough and costly and it would change a lot of things. Same. And, but like we, we got to a point where it was, it was like, you couldn't, I couldn't look away anymore. And even after that, it was, I mean, I did have to apologize to some of my queer friends and say like,

SPEAKER_00I know that this didn't, probably didn't feel like it affected our relationship that much because we are friends, but I do want you to know that I'm very sorry that there are, like, that I wasn't sure of what your place would be, you know, in different things, or I wasn't sure how you could fit or where you should be allowed to fit or whatever that was, you know? And certainly there are things from my past that, like, didn't necessarily affect them, but I was like evangelical poster child. So like, what do you, you know,

and you know, they were like, oh, it's fine.

SPEAKER_00Like it, because so much of that was behind me before I met them that like, it didn't really feel like, but it was important to me for them to hear that, like, maybe, maybe you didn't experience me this way, but this is something I was wrestling through. And I'm sorry that I even questioned any of this in the first place. Um, But it is hard and it's uncomfortable and it sucks. You know, even if people are looking at you like you're a weirdo for even saying those things, you know, it's important to to work through and figure out because

because it does affect.

SPEAKER_00I think we do think of this as an intellectual exercise. And I even think there's like a version of this conversation. um, in which we're just debating Bible passages and points, you know, that you've probably done. And so like, I'm curious what you think. Um, and, and to be clear, we both agreed that that's not what we wanted this conversation to be. Resources already exist for that. If you guys want to dig into that, a 30, 40, 50 minute conversation is not going to do what the tons of

writing that already

SPEAKER_00exists there. Um, But what does the framing of intellectual argument miss? Like whenever your life, you know, is reduced to an exercise that people can just perform in their minds.

SPEAKER_01It's such a good question. I came across just a random YouTube video last week, Trevor Noah and Malcolm Gladwell talking about trans women in sports. there's like 13 minutes and like they mostly hit the right debate points they mostly hit the right intellectual points and the whole time I'm like why don't you have a trans woman in sports there for the conversation yeah

right why don't you

SPEAKER_01have one of the people who's impacted by this and I you know there were very few names used in part because there's almost zero actual trans women in sports which is why the whole craze about oh we need to stop this is like the ncaa has said they had less than 10 out of 500 000 athletes like it's absurd um But there's been one trans woman ever in the Olympics and they've been allowed since 2006.

SPEAKER_01It's insane. But it was such a sterile conversation. It didn't have that human connection. It wasn't rooted in compassion for, hey, these trans women are just trying to live their lives.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. And they want to do sports for the same reason that anybody else who wants to do

SPEAKER_01sports does sports. They're there for the community. They're there for the competition. They're there for the physical fitness. They're there for whatever reason people do sports, because lots of people do sports for lots of different reasons. And when the conversation isn't grounded in that, you end up having these weird like, oh, we need to keep third grade trans girls out of girls sports as though The competition level demands that as though there's significant enough different physiological differences at that point.

As though third grade sports aren't just about going out and having fun, right?

SPEAKER_01And being with your friends and things like that. And so it just ends up when it's about the intellectual arguments, it just forgets that there's people, right? Which is why we see, and this is actually really good news i think is there was a stat that i came across a couple years ago that i like to share all the time it's like something like 50 of people don't know that

they know a trans person right so they think that they feel high yeah something like half of people think that they've never known a trans person right um Something like only 11% of Americans would say that they have a close relationship

SPEAKER_01with a trans person, right? Which means for most people, it is just this intellectual, I'm talking about a group of people that I have no experience with and things like that. But what we see is also when you do polling on, like, do you support trans right X, right? Do you support gender affirming care? Do you support trans women in sports? Do you support trans people being able to use the bathroom that

matches their

SPEAKER_01gender identity, which, by the way, is safer for everybody? Like, yes, I've written a blog post about that one. But like, when you talk about all of those things the people who don't know a trans person or rather the people who do tend to be something like 20 percent more supportive right it changes like 45 percent support to like 65 percent percent report just from

knowing one trans person right because as soon as you humanize it as soon as somebody knows me

SPEAKER_01it becomes a lot harder for them to see trans people as this, to borrow Janai Ahmed's word, right, to see us as the other, right? It's like, oh, Celeste is just Celeste. She's just this person that I know. And, you know, she likes Legos and math and whatever, right? Like, it becomes a lot harder to do the dehumanizing work of intellectualization right and when

they do just see it as this intellectual debate that is actually and i know it feels weird to say it but it is a form of dehumanization because it is to take the person out of it and just act like this is some opinion or some intellectual exercise that just forgets

SPEAKER_01that there's real people impacted by all this, it forgets that all the debates about gender affirming care and access to it have had the trans community in absolute terror for the last year and a half. As we're all afraid of, am I going to lose access to my hormones that changed my life? Right? Am I going to lose access to the surgeries that I need to feel at home in my body? Right?

why do these other people get to weigh in on my own medical decisions, right?

SPEAKER_01Why do they get to make medical decisions for me, right? And it just forgets all of that, right? And it doesn't let my voice be heard. It just ends up being, well, let's look at Genesis 127 and argue about whether male and female he created them means that everybody is created exactly as they appeared on the day of their birth which isn't what that verse means right like yeah um so that's it's just it's about the

people right loving your neighbor can't mean debate about some intellectual issue with the neighbor it

SPEAKER_01has to mean going and getting to know them

SPEAKER_00You just mentioned a lot of the trans struggle, but I think one thing that doesn't get as much airtime is trans joy, not survival, not resilience in the face of harm. And not that those aren't important parts of the experience, but I think, too, that what I have witnessed from the trans people in my life is this sort of genuine, full, life-giving joy. What does that look like in your life?

Trans joy has become like one of my most like one of my favorite things to see in the world.

SPEAKER_01It's absolutely beautiful. It's life giving just to see someone. It's amazing at any age, but to see people who were denied the ability to be themselves. Suddenly get to be that. um you'll see it's a little bit cringe but you'll see on like trans community boards there's a like particularly with trans women like there's just this whole meme about like skirt go spinny right of like the first time

that we get to wear a dress or a skirt and we just start twirling and twirling and twirling because we've never got the opportunity to do that before and you know it's these huge smiles and

SPEAKER_01it's just getting to be yourself and no skirts aren't what makes somebody a woman and you know don't take it that way but getting to see you know the day after I had facial feminization surgery and I got to feel where my brow bone was gone and I got to feel for the first time that just you know seamless transition whatever i just ran my

finger down my forehead and i just started crying um because i knew i was like i'm finally gonna get to see me in the mirror right which i'd never done before ever right i had stopped looking in mirrors because it was so deeply uncomfortable and now i can

SPEAKER_01look in a mirror and i can see me and i love it so much um But trans joy is powerful. It's beautiful. For those who have seen the movie Moana, it's probably the best way I have of communicating it. And this is something that I think a lot of people can relate to, especially in deconstruction spaces or survivor spaces. of seeing someone get to be themselves again.

SPEAKER_01You know, you can look at the character activity and yes, spoilers for Moana, but it's been out for 10 years now.

SPEAKER_00It's been a while. If you haven't seen Moana, I'm sorry.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, it's my favorite movie ever.

SPEAKER_00We're not required to keep it from you anymore.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, like, go watch it. It's my favorite movie ever. I have Moana Lego behind me right now, you know, because she's amazing. But The character of Te Fidi, who textually, her heart was stolen from her and taken from her and that turned her into angry and just couldn't figure out what is she supposed to be.

And she's just fighting and fighting and fighting and probably doesn't even really know why.

SPEAKER_01Right. As just like, what is going on? And my gosh, I can relate to that pre transition, pre hormone therapy, just feeling so on edge and angry all the time of like trying to live this life that just doesn't fit. Right. And there's something missing of me not getting to be who I am. And that was done to her. Right. And it was done to her by people trying to take something from her that she was just trying to give life to the world. Right. Give life and beauty and joy to the world.

SPEAKER_01And they were like, no, we're going to take that away from you. Right. And then you finally see that get restored to her and you see Moana finally see her for who she is. Right. And say, I know who you are. I see it. Right. And this is who you are. And I'm going to restore that back to you. And then you see her become, again, who she is, this beautiful, life-giving goddess in that story.

SPEAKER_01But for trans people, getting to be ourselves and put that life and joy and light into the world. If you haven't gotten to see it, get to know a trans person. Find yourself a trans friend. because it's just so much fun. I love going to queer events where I get to see so many trans people and just see them living their life. And I'm just like always just beaming the whole time because I'm just like, this is amazing getting to see these people who have reclaimed

their lives and

SPEAKER_01said, this is who I am and this is how I'm going to be in this world.

SPEAKER_00I love that. When you imagine a church that has genuinely made room for trans people, um you know not just tolerated but welcomed um and needed right not just included what does that community look like and what can it what can it do that um a church without you can't yeah um i mentioned some of that earlier around you have to get

SPEAKER_01the trans perspectives into the church you have to get you know both on identity and gender and you know the ways that that impacts a theology but also right now um even just you know churches that are seeking to be justice making churches right the trans community right now is obviously under unbelievable attack right yeah um you know i and

SPEAKER_01It's something a lot of people have been missing. But oh, my gosh, the number of ways that we have been hit over the last couple of years, you know, three or four or five years in red states, it's terrifying. You know, there are states now that I can't be in. Right. Idaho just passed a law last week. I can't go to Idaho anymore because I can't use the women's room in Idaho. By law, it would be a misdemeanor. And if I do it again, it's a felony. Right. I can go to prison for using the women's room and trans women

in men's room are deeply unsafe.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. But if you want to be about justice, trans people are right out there right now.

SPEAKER_01Um, trans women of color. Oh my gosh. Like my heroes, they are fierce. They are strong. They're incredible. Um, and so including that in the life of your church, um, But I think it looks like a church understanding that they have deficits. They have real things missing because they have left out trans

and queer people for

SPEAKER_01years, decades, millennia,

SPEAKER_00right? That they have real things and that they don't necessarily know what it's going to look like. but they know that they need to listen to the queer people in their church and be

SPEAKER_01part of restoring that. One thing it does not look like is trying to be like, okay, we're going to go try and make Christians out of queer people, right? It's like, nope, the church has not earned any kind of right to be evangelistic towards queer people. especially if you're not even apologizing when you become affirming like there's there are ways in which we could repair some of the rifts but if we're not taking

some of those base steps we're never yeah um but like i said letting us speak into

SPEAKER_01the church letting us be part of steering the church in the right directions asking us regularly how could this church be safer and more inclusive to trans people like and don't even just ask is there anything we could do because of course then we're going to be polite and be like no no no of course everything's right it's like give me one thing one thing that we can do better right okay well the bathrooms we still don't have a gender neutral bathroom right we need that that's going to be expensive right medical bills lots of churches will help

members with medical bills if they're going through something that needs to apply

SPEAKER_01to gender affirming care.

SPEAKER_00Right.

SPEAKER_01And yeah, that's going to be expensive.

SPEAKER_00Yeah.

SPEAKER_01But you do it for anybody else. And this is what we need and things like that. So also just like. If you have a trans person, you know, not everybody is as open as me, and understandably so. I find myself to be in a place of quite a bit of privilege, and so I try to be very open about my story, which is why, and I'll put this out there for your audience, find my substack, feel free to send me questions, anything. I try to answer any question that is asked in good faith,

because I want people to know. But if you have somebody like that in your church, give them an opportunity to do a, like, trans education session with the church just a trans 101 it's probably not even going to be all that theological but just helping people understand hey this is what is actually going on with trans people because so often the narratives around us are by not us yeah so that's that's a number of it but it's really just you know making sure that trans people never feel like they're second

class and to some

SPEAKER_01extent that's going to mean almost biasing the other way for a while yeah so those are some ideas so i love that thank you so much for sharing um and being so open i know that that can be hard or draining even for people like you who have a lot of practice um and so i

SPEAKER_00appreciate you showing up as your full self and giving us some of your insight today. Where can we find more to learn from you or follow along?

SPEAKER_01Yeah. And I appreciate that. My Substack is Celestefinally.com. And where else am I these days? I have a YouTube that doesn't have much on it, Celestial Navigation. I hope to do more there at some point. But for now, Celestefinally.com is probably the best way to find me. um and do go read it do go every piece i ever write there is deeply sourced and linked to other trans people and do go yeah the footnotes you

guys are outrageous so like uh in a good way i say that in a good way so like if you're looking for a real deep treatment on the issues celeste is a really great resource um if you're wrestling through that and wanting to look up close at some of this it's a good

SPEAKER_00place to start

SPEAKER_01And do remember, like, you know, we've had, you know, however long we've had today to get through it. And please, anybody who is less familiar with trans people, that's okay. You're not alone in that. But it means you do have education work to do. One challenge I will throw out there, if I may.

SPEAKER_00Yeah.

SPEAKER_01For those who, I don't know when this episode is going to go out. Me either. Okay, and that's totally fine. If it happens to go out at a place where this makes sense, a challenge I gave myself in 2022 was I said, I want to get to the end of Pride Month because I wasn't affirming yet, but I knew I wanted to figure that out. And I said, by the end of Pride Month, I want to either get to a point where I can say I'm affirming or that I really, really,

SPEAKER_01really deeply understand why I can't be. right um and that needed to mean listening to a bunch of queer authors and whatever and and once you start doing that you're gonna end up you know spoiler alert like you're gonna end up realizing that a lot of the things that you've been told were not really all that valid or justified yeah but but do that work give yourself a timeline don't just put it as a like oh i need to do that someday because queer people really are hurting right now and really do need people to come around and

SPEAKER_01quickly so

SPEAKER_00Yeah.

SPEAKER_01So anyway, do the work. You know, this is it's it's hard. But yeah.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. Well, thanks again. Thanks, everyone, for joining. And I'll talk to you next time.

SPEAKER_01All right. Sounds good. Thank you for joining us for another episode of the Untidy Faith podcast.

SPEAKER_00If you enjoyed this conversation, please consider leaving us a review on your favorite podcast player so more people can find our podcast and join the conversation. And we'd also love for you to subscribe so you never miss an episode and share your favorite takeaways on social media. I'm so grateful you're here and I'll see you next time.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Liz Daye | Why Bad Trinitarian Theology Creates Churches That Cover for Abusers

    Nov 3, 202640 minAudio

    In this episode of the Untidy Faith Podcast, I sit down with Liz Daye, author of Interwoven Discipleship, for a conversation about what happens when the Trinity gets flattened into a chain of command - and why the...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. KJ Ramsey | Joy That Doesn't Require Your Life to Get Better

    Oct 20, 202641 minAudio

    In this episode of the Untidy Faith Podcast, I sit down with KJ Ramsey, trauma therapist and author of The Place Between Our Pains, for a conversation about what happens when the faith language you’ve published books...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Kat Armas | How Colonialism Shaped What You Believe About God

    Oct 6, 202643 minAudio

    In this episode of the Untidy Faith Podcast, I sit down with Kat Armas for a conversation about what “empire” actually means once you strip away the buzzword - and why decolonizing your bookshelf and diversifying it are...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Anna Rollins | Purity Culture and Diet Culture Taught You the Same Thing

    Sep 22, 202636 minAudio

    In this episode of the Untidy Faith Podcast, I sit down with Anna Rollins, author of Famished: On Food, Sex, and Growing Up as a “Good Girl,” for a conversation about the shared script underneath purity culture and diet...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Kristin Mockler Young | Why Certainty Isn't Faith

    Sep 8, 202628 minAudio

    In this episode of the Untidy Faith Podcast, I sit down with Kristin Mockler Young, author of The Other Side of Certainty, for a conversation about what certainty is actually doing for us - and why the thing we were...

    Credit the people on this episode