Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Unruly Subjects

Unruly Subjects artwork

Escaping the Fascist Imagination. An Unruly Check in with Mariame Kaba

Nov 5, 20261 hr 11 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

What can you do right where you are, with the people you already know? Organizer and educator Mariame Kaba joins Chenjerai to talk about finding your role in a movement. You might be the person who brings people together, teaches a skill, or keeps track of who needs help. Kaba tells the story of Communiversity, a community education initiative in New York City that brings people together to learn how to care for one another. Kaba shares what that looks like in practice, from workshops on first aid and herbalism to conversations about how to work through conflict. They also get into what Kaba calls “DoorDash relationships,” why movements can’t leave their biggest demands up to elected officials, and what it takes to change your mind in public. 📣 DON’T JUST LISTEN - PASS IT ON If you know someone who would appreciate this conversation, send it to them. Seriously, text them right now. Send a screen shot. Forward it in an email. Drop it in the group chat. 🚨 HELP US BUILD FULLY INDEPENDENT MEDIA! We’re up to 136 members on Patreon, including 55 paid supporters. To everyone who’s joined us: THANK YOU! 🎯 OUR GOAL: 100 paid subscribers by December 1. We’re past halfway, and we need 45 more listeners to pitch in. Your support helps us keep making the show and bring you more conversations like this one. We’re doing this work from the muscle, and if we want to keep making the show, expand our coverage, and bring you more conversations like this one, we need more of our listeners to pitch in. 🙏 If you value worker-owned, independent journalism, join our Patreon community for as little as $5/month. Help us build listener-backed media at unrulysubjectspodcast.com. Follow Chenjerai on Instagram @chenjerai and Bluesky @chenjerai.bsky.social and follow Unruly Subjects @unrulysubjectspod. Get in touch at unrulysubjects@gmail.com. Unruly Subjects is also now on YouTube! Subscribe here: https://www.youtube.com/@UnrulySubjects Production Help From Aowen Cao Unruly Subjects is created in partnership with Rowhome Productions Further reading & sources from this episode: Communiversity: A Brooklyn community education series organized by Interrupting Criminalization and hosted by Women Building Up. The 2026 series focuses on healing justice and collective care. Making a Plan: A printable workbook from Mariame Kaba and Interrupting Criminalization to help you figure out where you can contribute and turn that into a plan. “Not everyone is an organizer, but your community still needs you”: The essay by Zedé that Kaba brings up when she talks about the many roles that keep a community going. “Mariame Kaba: Everything Worthwhile Is Done With Other People”: The Adi Magazine interview with Eve L. Ewing that Chenjerai quotes, about why relationships are central to Kaba’s organizing. https://www.haymarketbooks.org/books/2876-songs-my-mother-taught-me Support the show 🙏 If you value worker-owned, independent journalism, join our Patreon community for as little as $5/month. Help us build listener-backed media at UnrulySubjectsPodcast.com. Get Your Unruly Merch Here

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_01Bro Home Production. What's up, y'all? Unruly subjects is outside. Yeah, man, we outside. Oh my god. Yeah, man. Oh, listen, listen. I'm I'm recording this Wednesday morning, the day after the midterm elections, and man, what a night.

SPEAKER_01I'm uh still recovering, honestly. Uh last night I was over at Darylisa Avila Chevalier's election night vary, so y'all already know. The energy in their room was incredible. Uh we were watching these results coming from all over the country. You know what I'm saying? New York, victories across the South, Texas, Michigan. And uh, yeah, it was just like places where people have said for years Democrats couldn't win, and we were winning. So it was amazing. And now we've got Democrats taking control of the House in the Senate.

SPEAKER_01We've got a historic wave of socialist victories, including Daria Lisa and Claire Valdez here in New York. We've got Abdul El Sayed winning his Senate race in Michigan. I was up all night on that one, man. Y'all know. And uh it means the first Muslim elected to the United States Senate. Just so satisfying. Such a satisfying win. Of course, I gotta shout out my man Donovan McKinney. I mean, there was just so many. And we were in that room last night watching these results come in, celebrating. People were hugging, dancing. It was a beautiful thing.

SPEAKER_01Now, listen, I'm not gonna even uh give y'all like a full analysis of the elections right now. Nobody needs Shinjarai's hot take on the election. I need to process everything. Uh right and look, Mississippi is still coming in as as I'm recording this. Um, we might have to do a special unruly election episode because there's a lot to talk about, including the fact that not all these results were victories, right? We got to talk about Angie Nixon in Florida and Justin J. Pearson in Tennessee. I mean, both of those campaigns showed what was possible in places where I mean, every obstacle was against these candidates.

SPEAKER_01And, you know, look, we gotta ask some real serious questions about where the Democratic establishment chose to invest resources and where it didn't. Because it damn sure didn't put the resources they should have in Florida. And one thing that I hope we're learning from this election is that people are willing to fight. And, you know, when I when I look at that, uh it makes me emotional because there's a lot of small work that people had to do to make sure all the election workers, all the people, you know, informing people about what was going on.

SPEAKER_01I mean, it was so much work in that organizing, building relationships, and making demands that people tell us are politically impossible actually is shifting the political terrain. And speaking of that, y'all know we did some incredible coverage last week of the student voting struggle in North Carolina. Shout out to those students, shout out to uh Kimani Noble and Demetrius Noble, you know what I mean, who helped make that possible. Students from North Carolina, AT, Bennett College, and UNC Greensboro were organizing to overcome barriers to earlier voting after polling prices were removed from their campuses, right?

SPEAKER_01I mean, some students were facing a trip of like 40 minutes just to get to the polls. So we got to talk to some of those leaders who were organizing their communities, getting to the polls, and refusing to accept that situation. By the way, y'all, that whole conversation is up on our Patreon right now. We might bring it down to the regular feed, but I want y'all to hear it because they are incredible. It's incredible to listen to those students. They're so sharp. And you're gonna feel inspired, especially given the results, what happened because of that, you know?

SPEAKER_01And it's um, yeah, it's just an example of the work that's behind the scenes of victories like this. Um, by the way, I, you know, I'm also on the National Council of uh AAUP. You know what I mean? American Association of University Professors. We were able to partner with our uh North Carolina chapter and help to get those students a shuttle. And, you know, they we so we we you know contributed a little something to getting people back and forth to early vote uh last Friday. But that whole conversation is on our Patreon right now.

SPEAKER_01And listen, y'all, I got some more good news about the Patreon that I want to share. We are building, we're getting more and more people, tens of thousands of people listening to unruly subjects. People stop me all the time and they're like, yo, man, I love the show. They're listening. I'm surprised with people who are who are listening, man, you know, some influential folks. But it it really warms my heart when it's regular people or people who are in the struggle listening and sharing episodes. And I appreciate every single person. But out of those tens of thousands of people, we only have uh we have 136 Patreon members, and only 55 of y'all are paid supporters.

SPEAKER_01That means you're hearing this right now. You might not be on our Patreon. You know what I mean? And we want to get to 100 paid Patreon supporters by December. That's just 45 more people, and we're so close. I know we can do it. We got a month to do it. Listen, we're making this show with a very small team. We're making it because we believe there's a need for the kind of independent political journalism and conversation and something that we can do with, you know, some energy so it just doesn't all feel like vegetables. And I, you know, I want to be able to pay everybody who contributes to this work and we want to sustain it, you know what I mean?

SPEAKER_01And listen, in addition to the stuff about the North Carolina voting and all kinds of other great stuff, I had a really great conversation with Ron Young Jr., incredible podcaster and storyteller from Wait for It and, you know, leaving the theater. And so he and I are had some hilarious conversations critiquing short form content on the internet. It's funny that you talk about these people being out of touch. I saw a clip of um Don Cheadle. Someone was asking Don Cheadle how he's avoided scandals in all his career.

SPEAKER_01Like he's like, Yeah, man, you never have popped up. Like all these other people, you know, you know, I'm saying all kinds of stuff. He said, How did you do it? And Don Cheadle was, it was the example he gave was was interesting to me because he said, he goes, you know how like you're about to send that email to co-workers, and then you're like, you know what, let me just take a minute and pause before I send this email because I'm angry. And I'm sitting there like, Don Cheeto, what you know about that, right? You made real like a big star for real my life.

SPEAKER_00Like you can relate.

SPEAKER_01It was interesting how he could relate to that moment. I'm like, what that sounds like, you know what I mean? I I mean, I guess he he still has to email people, but I'm like, the way that's close to the ground, baby.

SPEAKER_00That's regular problems. Like regular people problems.

SPEAKER_01Still, it was interesting that he went in that bag as opposed to like, you know, I feel like, you know, I'm sorry, I feel like some of these people would be like, well, you know, it's kind of like when you're, you know, a coffee is too expensive in Soho, and you're like, oh man.

SPEAKER_00It's kind of like it's kind of like when you have a booking for your helicopter and it doesn't show up on time. You know, it's like they don't have any far guis on the menu, and you're like, oh man, you know, I but I really search my inner self and I practice with breath work and meditation before I get started.

SPEAKER_01Let's talk about today's episode. I had the great pleasure of checking in with Mariam Kaba. Mariam Kaba is an organizer, educator, archivist, curator, and zine maker who's active in movements for racial, gender, and transformative justice. She co-leads Interrupting Criminalization, an organization she co-founded with Adria Ritchie in 2018. Mariam is the author of New York Times Bestseller. We do this till we free us, abolitionist organizing and transforming justice. That's a Haymarket Books Project in 2021, and the national bestseller, Let This Radicalize You Organizing and the Revolution of Reciprocal Care, co-authored with Kelly Haynes, also a Haymarket Books Project in 2023.

SPEAKER_01She's also authored and contributed to numerous other books, essays, and projects offering tools and frameworks for repair, transformation, abolition, and building a future without incarceration and policing. Her work has been recognized through numerous awards and fellowships. She's co-founded and founded a number of projects and organizations. Most recently, the For the People Leftist Library Project and the NYC Public Library Action Network. Really important stuff there. And over the years, CABA's also co-founded Project NIA, We Charged Genocide, the Chicago Freedom School, the Chicago Task Force on Violence Against Girls and Young Women, Chicago Alliance to Free Marissa Alexander, which is now called Love and Protect, Just Practice Collaborative, and Survived and Punished.

SPEAKER_01And Mariam is the co-director of Sojourners for Justice Press, an abolitionist feminist press behind the Black Zine Fair. She's taught at Northwestern University, Northeastern Illinois University, Columbia University, American University, and CUNY. So that, and you know what? That's not even all the work she does. But with that said, welcome, Mariam Kaba. Yeah. Hello. Um, when we checked in, Mariam, you told me that there's a thing happening.

SPEAKER_01Uh, yeah, could we talk about the Communiversity piece?

SPEAKER_03Yes, of course. Thanks so much for having me and for being interested in our work at Communiversity. Basically, what we are doing at Communiversity is inviting people in New York City who are interested in specifically healing justice and collective care to join us. Over the last few weeks, we've had, you know, session about collective care and healing justice that was facilitated by the amazing Cara Page and some other facilitators.

SPEAKER_03We just had a series of four different sessions about teaching people about people's first aid, teaching people about herbs and herbalism, having conversations about conflict and how we kind of mediate those conflicts so as not to find ourselves in disagreements that feel irreconcilable. So I'm really excited to be able to have young folks get together, do some things that are fun, while also being able to learn together and hopefully to make connections with each other so that we can form stronger bonds.

SPEAKER_03We're gonna really, really need each other in the next few weeks and months and years. And it's always more helpful to be in community with other people than to be isolated. And so Communiversity is a space for those connections to be built.

SPEAKER_01Absolutely. I mean, I so appreciate this. When you first told me about this and I looked at like, you know, what the schedule was, I was like, oh man, I was like, I need to sign up for the one for like seven-year-olds, because I have I got a strong seven-year-old, you know what I'm saying? Like I love Demer Warrior uh child who is I want to put into that environment. But yeah, listen, folks, everybody who's hearing this now. I want you to go into your networks, particularly with young folks. If you got young people in your life, you know, plug them into this. Um, we're definitely gonna reach out to our educative people.

SPEAKER_01But more broadly, I just want you to see the kinds of stuff that's happening with community bersity. Because again, there's lots of folks who will either tell you there's nothing we can do or that the only thing you can do is run to what is called the front lines of struggle. I mean, actually, Marian, what what do you think about that? Because there's a lot of people who I think I'm gonna be really generous here, that maybe because, you know, in the past, if you're someone who hasn't been on what you perceive to be the front lines, maybe you're maybe you're a professor or a student, or you were just where you were at, you just didn't, you know, you didn't quite understand that fascism has been here for uh more than a century.

SPEAKER_01And you were now, you're like, I want to really put myself on the line, but your understanding of that is like I'm just gonna go like yell at police at a protest or something. Yeah. I mean, how do we need to complicate our understanding of what the front lines are?

SPEAKER_03Yeah, I think it's a great question. And the front lines are gonna be different for different people. I also think I read a piece by a writer named Zede, who has a Substack blog, and they wrote something a few weeks ago, the title of which was Not Everyone is an organizer, but your community still needs you. And I think a lot of people get caught up on the word organizer and don't pay attention to all of the different kinds of roles that are needed for a community to actually run.

SPEAKER_03And this person pointed out certain roles like, you know, the connector, the host, the runner, the teacher, the steward, the keeper, you know. So like you are a person who might be keeping track of things, you know, who needs help? What is it that that person needs? You're kind of the person who might be the memory keeper in your community, in your family, on your block, in your whole workplace, right? That's a role that helps our community actually run.

SPEAKER_03And that then is your front line. You know, there are some people who, when you meet them, they make you feel like so at home. You know, they know how to host people, they know how to bring people in, and you make people feel welcome. So, like that's your role in our community is that person being the host. Take that with you wherever you are. You're making a difference, you know. Um, there are all these really useful tools that people have created that's kind of like an ecosystem model of how we do life, but also how we do care and how we do organizing.

SPEAKER_03And so I always encourage people to look up some of that work um and be able to find your lane. You don't have to be doing everything. Find your lane and like work that lane like there's nobody's business. That's what we need right now, I think. Um, I think we need less people running around like chickens with their heads cut off. We need a lot less critics. We need so many more workers. We need so many more people who are willing to be wrong.

SPEAKER_03We need so many more people who aren't afraid to just jump in where they're needed and like roll up their sleeves and dig in. And so, yeah, I feel like this is the moment for all of those things. And I would love to see folks think more about like find where you fit in and ask yourself some questions about like, what do you already know how to do? What are the things you want to learn and grow? How are you in a position where you're kind of like, you know, somebody looks at you and they're like, you know what, you're such a good blah.

SPEAKER_03It's like, okay, that's the thing to lean into that might be useful for our community. Early on in 2024, towards the end of the year, I made a zine along with my friend Eva, who designed it. It's on our website at interrupting criminalization. It's called Making a Plan. And it's a really easy-to-print off your computer workbook of like, make a plan for how you can actually take charge. Um, so the front line is everywhere. The front line is where you are. And I hope that people really take that to heart and do what you can, where you can, how you can.

SPEAKER_01I love that for so many reasons. I mean, I just want to take a moment to say that, you know, when I look at my trajectory around some of these questions, it was like I remember there was, you know, there was a period when I thought the best thing you could do was be an activist, right? Like that was the language I had learned, right? The people who were doing activism. And at the time when I was showing up to protest and stuff, I was getting a lot of credit for that, right? You get a lot of currency. They're like, oh, he's doing activism. But then as I got more into, you know, sort of more involved, more into relationship with people with experience, there was a distinction being drawn.

SPEAKER_01I remember a piece by my comrade and colleague uh Astra Taylor about the difference between organizing and activism, which and and why actually some of our opponents actually prefer activism. Yeah. In a way, because they're like, you know, if it's not connected to something that's really going to build power, bring people into deep relationship, something that maybe activism is more easily co-opted. So that made me want to turn to organizing, but what you say is absolutely right. Like, then it all of a sudden turn like everybody's an organizer.

SPEAKER_01Even I would see, you know, like, look, I'm a professor and a media maker, but I wound up seeing posters where they're like chingerized and organizer, and I was like, yo, man, the real organizers in my life are going to raise a real eyebrow at this.

SPEAKER_03Yeah. I mean, the question of organizing is always the question of who are you actually accountable to? And importantly, not just who do you think you're accountable to, but who do other people think you're accountable to? Do they think you're accountable to them? Are you accountable to each other? And by that I mean like, and I don't want to use the term accountability in the kind of colloquialism that we use it in, but rather if you make a decision, are you making that decision with other people or are you just making it with yourself?

SPEAKER_03If you're in a position where you make a decision, can other people say, well, we don't think that's a good idea? And would you then be forced to stop moving, you know, until you got everybody on the same line? Like that's the difference between activists, in my opinion, then organizers like as an activist, you can basically, yes, you could be making media stuff. You have your complete control over your whole program of what it is that you want to put out. Maybe you get some quote, you know, feedback from people or somebody gives you their opinion, but you don't have to actually take that into consideration.

SPEAKER_03You can just make your thing, right? That is activism. Organizing, you can't just do that. There are other people in it with you who are also equally invested and have a role to play. And you guys are building the ship together, right? And so I think that that really makes a huge difference. And you're not organizing by yourself, it's a collective project, always. Whereas activism isn't always a collective project.

SPEAKER_01Right. You just show up as an individual unit.

SPEAKER_03You can sort of express yourself and do something really great and you make a really excellent project, but it's all your project. Right.

SPEAKER_01That can be the ability, right? The answer ability to all kinds of folks. And what I love about what you're saying as well is that for one, it's it's empowering in the sense that it brings different people with different kinds of work, you know, because I I think this sort of insistence that everybody's an organizer has almost crowded out some work. Yes. And maybe even reproduced some of these gender problems with what work is valued and where people are putting the energy. Like it, I know that people aren't using it like this, but you and I both know there's a lot of men, and I'm implicated in this myself, who are like, oh, if the work is organizing and not something else, yeah, then that allows me to sort of be out there and not attend this other kind of reproductive labor.

SPEAKER_01You know, no, it's real sustains us.

SPEAKER_03It's real. And also, I think the other reality is like, think about the world that we're living in. People are struggling. People have been put out of work. Some people have not had work for a really long time. If everybody is supposed to be an organizer, then almost nobody will be because the world doesn't operate. We are living under capitalism at its extreme levels right now. And folks can barely get it together to like they don't have childcare, so they're working a million hours to try to be able to afford childcare, or they're taking care of elders, or they are trying to just put a roof over their heads, or whatever.

SPEAKER_03Not everybody really can be organizing, and I think that's something that maybe some people feel is like a controversial thing to say, but I think it's actually just honest. And that then means that we have to find different ways for people to contribute in the world that fit with what they can do, because we have so many really wonderful, brilliant people who could plug in, you know, they could plug into this or that. They can, you know, come in and share their like unique talents in this one way.

SPEAKER_03And that's something we should be like excited about because we need more people. We need more people doing more different kinds of things every single day. So yeah, so I think about that a lot. And I'm always trying to figure out what I can do in my seasons of life, and I'm always trying to bring more people in, you know, what can you contribute to this thing? It doesn't have to be everything. I you can your designer, I would love for you to be able to design these things that are not AI, you know, that will actually be able to support this work that other people are doing.

SPEAKER_03You know, you you're like super good with spreadsheets, you know. Like, I mean, my God, how much we need the spreadsheet people. We need the spreadsheet people. We need the people who love administration but can't attend all the meetings. We need the people who are super good with logistics, but you know, can't be at every single uh meeting. We need the people who are the communicators who can make the newsletter for the groups that are taking on. The action that is more, you know, on the organizing tip.

SPEAKER_03Like all of that is what's going to make it possible for us to sustain this kind of work and grow it in the long term. So yeah, I think we get caught up sometimes on these words and their meanings and, you know, who's doing what, when, how, where. And what I want to see is like, what can you bring to the table? What's the lane? Where do you feel like A, that you can do the most, you know, because we really need everybody to do something.

SPEAKER_01It makes me realize that the term can be a little flattening. And when we talk about the actual nature of all these parts of the work with the precision and detail that you're talking about, then we actually also see what they have to do with power, right? And how the and giving empowering us and creating leverage and all these other things. So I I appreciate that. And one other aspect I want to bring, you know, you did uh um an interview a while back with Eve U and incredible interview. Everybody should read it. Great conversation. And in it, there the topic of narrative change came up.

SPEAKER_01You know, narrative change is a big word. I mean, obviously one could argue I work in narrative change with someone about podcasts and things of that nature. There is a lot of funders who will get excited about that. Um, you know, what you said, I think is so crucial. You said that you are far more interested in our relationships with each other. I'll just quote here from the article you said, I believe that when we're in relationship with each other, we influence each other. And what matters to me as the unit of interest is relationships. Yeah. Could you say more about that?

SPEAKER_01I mean, because I think that seems to also be why we need a really good vocabulary around what is called organizing ego.

SPEAKER_03Yeah. To me, relationships are human currency. Like that's the bottom line. We as human beings are inherently social beings. The concept that there is no society is foolish, but it's been the 60-year project of the right to try to prove it to us every day that there is no society, as Thatcher said. But to me, I know that's impossible, right? The technofascists that are trying to go to the moon right now are trying to evade relationship.

SPEAKER_03To me, that is the anathema of any left project. The left project is flourishing, and flourishing can only happen in relation with others. A person on their own is a person who's quickly dying because you can't survive on your own. It's not possible. So everything that you from the beginning of the day that you open your eyes, everything that has happened in your life is because other people help to make it happen.

SPEAKER_03If you're brushing your teeth, somebody made the toothbrush. If you're using the toothpaste, somebody made that. If you are lying on sheets, those were not made by you. If they're like, you know, just you keep going through that entire list. That that is just the kind of human interconnection. And then in addition to that human interconnection is the deep need for a sustaining set of relations that allow us to be more human. There's a sociologist named Cooley who came up with a term years ago called the looking glass self.

SPEAKER_03And the looking glass self is a way of helping people to understand how we come to understand ourselves as human beings and as social beings in the world. We look to others for the cues that tell us how we are and how we should be, right? That's we mimic other people as a way to be able to figure out how to be more fully human. And you can't do that if you're not in relationship with other people, right? We're not going to win against the fascists on our own. We're only going to win collectively. So therefore, relationships are human currency.

SPEAKER_03They're the things that we need in order to be able to live a good life, to live at all. And so that's where I'm at. Like I've always been this way. This is what I very much is the core of my politics, the thing that has been constant. It's why I engage in work that has to do with conflict resolution and things like that, because I think that we're not going to make it as isolated beings. Um, we're not gonna make it. And so that's at the bottom, what fascists really want is for you to be isolated.

SPEAKER_03That's the base. I mean, everything else about being, you know, plundering, extraction, uh, outgroups, uh, domination, like all those things are, but at bottom, it's to isolate you allows them to further their project of domination, control, extraction, and plunder. So I think the way to fight that the most anti-fascist thing you can do is to like make sure you have at least four people in your life that you can count on and to also talk to all your neighbors.

SPEAKER_03Those are anti-fascist actions that we can all actually do, that we have to work towards doing. Having anxiety is not an excuse. You have to figure out how to be with other people.

SPEAKER_01And it's I'm so glad you said that because I think that's one of the hardest things. That's one of the most terrifying things about in those relationships, is even for you know, for me, like I talk all this smack and I'm out of here, but when I have to talk to my colleagues or my neighbors to make an ask, it's terrifying. And then on the other side of it, it's always at least enlightening, if not great.

SPEAKER_03It will reinvigorate you once you try. And I think that we need reinvigoration right now. And we also need to not be so afraid of friction. And what everybody's trying to do right now, it looks to me in the world, not just in the US, is to make our existence frictionless in a way that is not natural because human beings are bonkers and we are extremely difficult and we can be annoying and all that stuff, and yet we are essential to each other's survival.

SPEAKER_01Could you say more about that piece about what you mean by where they're trying to make our existence frictionless?

SPEAKER_03Yeah, frictionless is a lot of people now, and I think that the COVID pandemic is something we haven't yet been able to reckon with at all. But the COVID pandemic has dislodged something that was already happening, which is that the isolation that many people experienced during that time and the kind of overhaul of our relations to each other and to ourselves means that everybody has become more dependent on what I call the conciergification of US society.

SPEAKER_03The conciergification of US society is basically everybody placing orders on DoorDash for everything. Like we want DoorDash relationships now, too. So we want everybody to provide us as consumer all of the things and we want it with ease, we want it super fast. We're not gonna wait. We want it to our exact specifications, and if it doesn't come exactly as we want, then we're gonna go to social media, which is our new Yelp, and blast people 24-7.

SPEAKER_03If something comes back, like there was a mistake made or whatever, our tolerance level for people's failure is like zero percent now. So it's all of that has made it so that our relationships not just become like commodified or conciergified in the sense that we always just want to be delivered everything easily and without any trouble exactly to our specifications. It's part of what's making it hard for us to organize because everybody who wants to be served doesn't want to serve.

SPEAKER_01Right. And we get confused when some of the things that we actually have to struggle with, like the struggle part is what makes us stronger, makes us more in relation, makes us, but then we're like, if we perceive the struggle as exactly, I mean, look, sometimes struggle is harm and it is, but not always, right? Like conflict is not always that, right?

SPEAKER_03And not only that, and also not, it's the usual. Being in the world with other people who you don't know who are strangers to you means that you're gonna be in friction constantly because you're gonna have to learn each other. We're not the same. We don't come from the same backgrounds and cultures. We have to figure out how to be with each other across differences. And that means stuff's gonna happen. That means people aren't gonna be the way that you hope for them to be, which is why you should have the skills to be able to address conflict, because otherwise you're gonna be a person who's constantly leaving spaces, and you're also gonna be a person who's going to become what we call, I call the drive-by critiquers.

SPEAKER_03These are the people who are constantly complaining. They complain offline, they complain in real life, they complain in every part of the world. There's constant critique, but they are not stay-in-fighters, they are drive-bys, critiquers. So, oh, well, that sucked. Okay, blah, blah, blah, blah. But it's like, well, if it sucked, what is your investment in trying to make sure it doesn't suck? You know, if you think about the conciergification, you don't have to be in an argument with your DoorDash person.

SPEAKER_03You can just literally go onto the app and give them a bad review.

SPEAKER_01Right, because of the nature of what this relationship is.

SPEAKER_03Exactly.

SPEAKER_01No, I'm a consumer, which means I'm in control. It's almost like if you're experiencing the kind of friction-free existence that you're describing, you're probably talking to like an AI bot. This is gonna make it hard. And it just glazes you the whole time.

SPEAKER_03This is exactly why people are now in roads, like literally being attracted to chatbots because of all things I'm talking about, about what real relationships entail. Real relationships are always gonna have conflict. The chatbot's job is to keep you engaged. So the chatbot is gonna do absolutely everything to keep you engaged. Because once you break off the chatbot, the chatbot doesn't exist. So your bottom line is to have this chatbot be like so solicitous to you.

SPEAKER_03Oh, Chandra, you are so brilliant. You know, your ideas, my god, nobody's ever had ideas like you. Woo man, that was something I had never heard that, but you just oh, and you know what? You just talked to me about this person. You're right, you're a hundred percent correct. You can't do any wrong. Yes, you're so right, and not egging you on.

SPEAKER_01I promise you, I'm not gonna take this recording and just the phrases of your voice said that and play them over and over for my self-esteem. But I could acknowledge that I want to.

SPEAKER_03Real people aren't gonna do that for you all the time. No, no, you know, they will some will for a while. Some of your closest friends they'll say to you, you know what? That was horrible. That that happened to you. That was terrible. But you know what? I'm seeing where you had some a role in this too. Like that's just not guilty.

SPEAKER_01My friends lovingly check me all the time. All the time. And that's support. You know, they like, look, change, I don't want you out here looking raggedy, bro. You know, like this is, you know, no, you're so right. And it's, but it is. I mean, I think another thing I would say is that it's a weird world we live in where part of what sets the stage for that is that the capitalist workplace, all these ads also make people kind of thirsty for that because you're constantly being told you're not enough, right? Like you're being told at the workplace, your work isn't valuable.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, nobody's really, you know, people I think don't feel valuable. And that I see that or seen right. Now, the solution though is actually, you know, coming from this, you know, it's like the same the machine is also going to give you the solution that's the problem it created, you know.

SPEAKER_03That's exactly right. And further alienation. I mean, you know, Marx is right about being alienated from one's labor, but also being alienated from oneself, you know, under capitalism. Like, I think that that is really, really important for us to understand that like that form of alienation is actually potential violence. And I think I see this playing out in such ways. I'm concerned for the younger generation that's coming up, um, that really does not have experience.

SPEAKER_03Like, I talk to young people all the time, including children, who tell me like they don't have any friends. To me, that that is terrifying. That's terrifying. Um, you should have friends, like as a child, you know, that's like imperative because like going back to the looking glass cell, how do you know who you are? You see yourself through other people. And so I worry about this quite a bit.

SPEAKER_01I know, I really do. And I mean, we know, you know, there's like a sort of, you know, the social scientists, like we're we're in a loneliness epidemic, which I think is kind of trying to name a thing, but not actually.

SPEAKER_03It's not hitting on it.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. Getting at the dynamic. But I gotta say, the communiversity is there to put people in relationships. So if you got folks, young folks, in that in that age bracket who maybe aren't, you know, maybe they spend a lot of time in front of the screen. Yes. Get them out, get us, let's get in community, and let's do more community versities in more places. You know what I mean?

SPEAKER_03I agree. I agree. Necessary, and um, I hope people come to this one or build your own.

SPEAKER_01I guess the only other thing I want to ask, I mean, you've really you've really given us so much about how to be in this moment for us to reflect on. But, you know, is there anything you want to say about um sort of the state of things at this moment in terms of where our focus should be? I mean, there's any number of crises unfolding. Obviously, here in New York, we seem to be maybe past whatever honeymoon may have existed with the mayor related to policing and those kinds of things. Uh but there's also, you know, there's elections, there's lots.

SPEAKER_01I mean, where is Mariam Kabba's attention right now?

SPEAKER_03Yeah, as I mentioned before, I'm a person who tries to pick my lanes. You know, I'm a Jack Cornfield gal, you know, that you tend to the part of the garden you can reach. And I think for myself, I've been really, really clear on two things from like 2024 on, which was that I knew that this was a fascist. Um, I was not confused about that. I wasn't one of the people on the left who pretended that wasn't the case or that they weren't fascists.

SPEAKER_03Like I could see that. You could see it with Project 2025. It was clear to me that we were dealing with fascists. I said early on that I thought that people were delusional if they thought that you were using stupid terms like, you know, competitive authoritarianism, whatever, whatever. I'm like, no, this is full-on federal fascism. That's what we're under right now. And being clear and understanding that and being clear-eyed would help us to be able to figure out better responses. I'm also a person who actually believes that we haven't been here before.

SPEAKER_03I think we've had state-level forms of fascism in this country, but we've never had full-on federal fascism. Um, so that's new. And it's okay for things to be not like to have new things that have happened to us. That's a big one because people some people are like, this is it's always been always no, no, that's not true. I mean, it is true that fascism is differentially experienced according to your social location. So some people have been in more fascism than others, but federal fascism at this level, we've never, nobody who's alive today has really experienced that, I think, except probably people who were interned in Japanese internment camps, maybe.

SPEAKER_03But like I think that that's just something we should sit with and try to figure out our way out of because our old playbooks are probably not going to be very helpful because we haven't had to fight against federal fascism. So I think about those kinds of things right now. And so what I've been trying to really do in my own local communities has been to be part of fights that are asking us to dream about bigger things, to figure out where are the areas where we should be actually demanding more.

SPEAKER_03You know, where are the places where imagination can lead us to something stronger? So I, you know, I've been doing work on libraries and public libraries here in New York City because I think that anti-fascism means fully funded, extremely operational, expansive public libraries. You know, I think it's critical. I think it's critical. I think public goods, shared in common, distributed to everyone. That is to me, those are the things I want to be fighting for in this moment.

SPEAKER_03Um, and I want to do that with other people. So that's just one area of the focus that I've been having, but I've found it to be actually giving me some life. It's given me an opportunity to be able to talk with people about an expansive vision rather than restricting an austerity and fear. And I'm so grateful for New York City Public Library Action Network, my comrades that for the People Leftist Library Project, along with my ongoing commitment to prison industrial complex abolition, because I've known from the beginning, and I've been saying for decades now, that criminalization is the fuel of fascism.

SPEAKER_03It's the fuel for fascism. We the reason we want to interrupt it and eventually just completely dismantle criminalization is because we knew the apparatus that they were building would be turned against us under a fascist regime. And the people who kept talking to us about, well, we definitely need the jails. We definitely need now we're building concentration camps to keep immigrants in them based on that basic base that already existed that they could just reactivate as needed.

SPEAKER_03The whole concept of ICE as not policing is bonkers to me. Okay, ICE and police, they're together. Like these are not separate, distinct district. And the carceral socialists are on my fucking last nerves, you know.

SPEAKER_01I'm so glad you said this because I was about to go there. Like the development that at this moment, right? Crazy have people on the left. You have in, I'm just gonna say Jacobin magazine, you know, some people who I think in some cases are really smart folks. Ridiculous. Making absurd and very harmful authorities about concessions and sort of like we need to somehow we need policing and all this other stuff. And it's like you'll hear, I just I just actually did an interview on NPR where I tried to talk a little bit about how we got here, even with um to a point where we can't even have a conversation about funding because of a slogan.

SPEAKER_03You know, I know it's like But it wasn't a slogan though, it was a demand. Do you see? I feel really strongly about this. I think that we just have to admit certain things in life, and one of them is that a core of people do not want to take money away from policing. We don't have to go in circles around that. There are people who just don't want that. They say, well, defund was the wrong no, defund was an actual demand. That was what everybody understands what it means to defund things.

SPEAKER_03We've lived under 60 years of defunding shit on the right. Why is that like the other part of it was invest in life-affirming things. Take away from the death-making institutions, invest in the life-affirming ones. So we have to just be honest. We're not fighting over a slogan. I think that's ridiculous. And I think this whole notion of I think the people who use quote woke one unironically should be ashamed of themselves.

SPEAKER_03Okay. I agree with that. Ashamed of themselves because they do know better. And so my thing about all of this is the silliness of it, right? I would rather just people say, I just don't want to take money away from the cops. Like, just say that. It's okay. Then we have a place from which we're starting that's honest.

SPEAKER_01Right. Because in the end of the day, that's what you're arguing. I mean, I I would say I was calling it a slogan because my sense is like, you know, for those who care about polls or if they see a particular language arrangement, they don't like that, then they, you know, and this is what I talked about, you know, in this interview that came out today. But it's like, my thing is look, but let's talk about what's going on with the funding. Like, how are you gonna take the whole conversation and demand off the table at a point in all these cities? The funding continues to go up. Exactly. Funding goes toward like overtime, by the way, surveillance technology, all kinds of BS.

SPEAKER_01Thank you. You tell me nobody can like, you know, I saw Bernie on um, I think he was talking on whatever podcast, and he was like, No one I know takes that seriously. Now I was like, bro, whatever you're trying to do electorally, to say nobody serious is talking about.

SPEAKER_03Of course, people, of course, millions of people take it seriously. Millions. Just because it's not the majority doesn't mean that a lot of people don't want that to be the case, right? And this is why if there's danger of this concept of narrative building, narrative building without organizing is not useful. Because what it is is we're in a fight. We're in a fight, like we're in actual disagreement. We actually don't think that these things are the same. Some people Want more cops, some people want less.

SPEAKER_03Some people want the cops to have more money, some people want the cops to have less. Some people want more prisons, other people want none. Like, I don't understand why we're all tittoing around and pretending we're not actually in a disagreement. That's the thing I've not understood. Like, I just don't agree with you. I think it's ridiculous to keep funneling all our cash to these places while the key part not funding all the other things that are desperately needed in our communities, in our society.

SPEAKER_01Okay, but let me say this. Do you think, like, for example, if you take, I'll just say someone like Francesca Hall, right? She in her elect earlier in her career saying policing is an institution that was, you know, largely sublimacy. She's right. She said things that was facts to me.

SPEAKER_03They're facts.

SPEAKER_01I can understand, and you, you know, you get at me if you've I understand why if you're in baby poise to win a primary, you might be a little like, okay, confused about what you're allowed to say on the messaging.

SPEAKER_03I am not mad. I'm gonna tell you this. This is so important. I am not pissed off at Zara Mamdani, AOC, Francesca Hong, all the people who were on the defund line until they needed to run for office again. Because their work is different than mine. Their job is to get elected, and they're gonna try to do that by any means necessary, right? They're just gonna try to do that, and they're gonna throw away all the things that are gonna stand in their way to do like we're adults here, okay?

SPEAKER_03And some of us have been doing politics for a long time in multiple kinds of ways. So I'm not even gonna be in a fight with them about that stuff. The thing I don't appreciate is lying. I don't appreciate if you did think there was value in a concept, I don't appreciate you then turning around and pretending you don't now think there was still value in there because it's a lie. I don't believe you, right? Like, and I think that's the problem. That's the problem. You could say, I recognize that this is now something that is not as popular with regular folks in this kind of way, and so I'm just like, we're not ready for it.

SPEAKER_03And so I'm not gonna push it as a policy. Like you could do that and live in your integrity in some way, right? So I just think again, I just want us to be honest about what it is that we're demanding, what it is, what's the vision of the world we're actually fighting for? And I thankfully am not a politician, so I don't have to take anything back. I've thought the same ideas for decades, and I'm gonna keep fighting on that ground because I think I'm right.

SPEAKER_01Well, it makes no, and it's like, look, I fully I agree with you. I like that. Like we get, you know, uh politicians are doing things that they feel they have to do. But here's the thing you can't act like you mean to tell me you're gonna act like you don't even understand these remedies that you formally signed up for. You can't even disband the strategic response group. Okay, you know, you guys out here working with your NYPD, the budget's still going up. Like you don't even understand the demand at this moment, but you know who does understand it, Mariam? I went up to um Marble Hill the night when the ICE officer killed, you know, the person with his five-year-old in the backseat.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. And the community was not making any distinction between ICE and the police, and they had really questions. In fact, where I was positioned that night, it was interesting because you know, uh, Zoran came out to speak. And my understanding of his speech is that he was saying the right thing in terms of like abolish ice, and that's good.

SPEAKER_03But like No, but you believe that he's gonna like why this is the question I've been asking everybody I know, and you might answer this for me.

SPEAKER_02Yes.

SPEAKER_03Why should we believe these people about abolishing ICE now? It's there's no, there's no constituency it's up to them to convince us. There's no constituency pre-built that would sustain the attacks that are gonna come from the right wing immediately after an election in 2028, where they're gonna paint everybody who wants to quote abolish ice as soft on crime. You mean to tell me that these folks who folded so quickly on defund are serious about abolishing ice?

SPEAKER_03Come on now. Let's not pretend, let's not play this game because every time I ask the question, what does abolish ice actually mean? People say it's reform so and so. This is nonsense. This is nonsense. Okay, like we're so I don't believe people who are now on an abolish ice tip because they're going to be cross-pressured very soon to pretend they never said that they wanted to abolish ice.

SPEAKER_01Is that something that you think that through movement building, though, it is only we can change the dynamic and pressure on them, even if they don't want to? Because my thing is we gotta make these people, Zoran included, there is a world in which they have to they have to fear us or at least understand that world doesn't exist yet.

SPEAKER_03I agree, and that's the point. So my thing is always it's the people who lead. It's the people who lead, but it's also the people in this country who are deeply easily influenced and demagogued. We have a two-sided situation where people are gonna go with right now, abolish ice sounds good, and then the right, which they are masterful at being able to sabotage everything and make everything about crime, everything, all their ads, even right now, as crime is diminishing by numbers, including by their own FBI numbers.

SPEAKER_03These folks are still running ads about bail reform in New York City.

SPEAKER_01That's right.

SPEAKER_03I just saw, I just saw that's Blakeman's whole thing, is on that. They're still running those ads because they never stop. Whereas our people give up and say this is now not being able. We can't change people. Our job is to change people's minds and to hold the line, to help people hold the line. That's our work. I don't expect the politicians to lead us. I expect us to lead us, and that means that we have to get our act together on the ground.

SPEAKER_03If abolish ice is a to be a real thing, it's gonna have to be a real thing that's a people's movement. Because these people will not stand up. You've seen it, they will crumble under the quickest, shortest, not even a push. We will have silly comments like woke one was crazy. Oh, come on. How incredibly disrespectful. How disrespectful.

SPEAKER_01And I think it's it's a symbol that our movements are not strong enough that somebody feels they can say that. You know what I mean?

SPEAKER_03Um but also now don't think not only that they can feel like they can say that, but that everybody else has to be silent for it. Because the fear is that if you say anything, then you're making their lives potentially worse. And of course, there's nothing more important to quote unquote than to get let people reach the highest levels of politics, supposedly, electoral politics. To me, that's ridiculous. We have to be able to tell the truth to shame the devil. And it is not my role to pretend that talking about whoa, as though, imagine, as though people fighting for rights, as though people fighting for liberation and freedom are frivolous, ridiculous people who should have small dreams that could fit into the size of the Democratic Party as it currently is in existence.

SPEAKER_03You can't stop me from imagining an actual free world that I can live in and that the people who I love can live in, and that the people who are I'll be ancestor to can live in and flourish. I want a world of flourishing for my people. And these people, the cops are shooting people every day. The numbers have not gone down since 2020. They've gone up.

SPEAKER_01They've gone up.

SPEAKER_03So what are we doing here? What are we really talking about? I refuse. So I'm always going to be, I'm always gonna give people the benefit of the doubt. I'm always gonna try to be accommodating to the level that I can, but I'm always gonna push and I'm always gonna speak out for what is right and what is true.

SPEAKER_01So yeah, that's how I feel about the I mean, I look, I'm gonna be honest here. It's very easy for me to agree with you because it's so clear what you but I'm talking to you. But I wanna what I want to say is the reason I appreciate declared is because I think for a lot of folks it is confusing. And you're right, because and I think that this is the complication. And I don't know if I want to say danger, but it is a kind of danger and risk when you have very charming, charismatic candidates and electeds, because which I'm in some sense, look, I'm glad we have folks that might be more responsive to our movement work.

SPEAKER_01But what happens, I think, is that people get confused and they think that our movements are about good politicians. My approach to organizing and all this other stuff is not about good politicians. I'm glad we have some folks. Mine is that is what you said, people power has to move whoever.

SPEAKER_03It whoever. And my thing is, we don't have to be like again, I think that most of these people are lovely human beings. That's not the point. I just think we all have different roles to play in the world. I'm not an elected official on purpose for many reasons. I would not get elected. Number one, number two, I have no interest in it. And number three, that's not where I think I can make the most difference. But I think that I have an equally important role to play in society, as do you, as does every other person who wants to be part of a fight for justice and liberation.

SPEAKER_03And I don't think we should be cowed. And I don't think it's our job to like be sycophantic. That's the right wing. I'm not in a cult, okay? And I'm not in a cult of personality either. And I'm gonna say, I'm gonna remind people on a regular basis that we should have our eyes on a bigger goal, on a bigger goal, which is liberation for all people, not throwing some people under the bus as other people gain rights, not taking rights away from other people, not pretending that we're not seeing the same things, not supporting the premature death-making institutions that are killing our people consistently.

SPEAKER_03I'm gonna always speak to that reality. I'm always gonna speak to that reality. And I'm not, it's not like I'm an unstrategic. Of course, I'm strategic is but why does our horizon have to be limited to campaign promises? Thank you. And my horizon is not four years. My horizon is not eight years. Okay, we have to play a longer game to try to win what we want to win, which is a completely different world than the one that we are living in right now, you know, and one side understands that the fascists play the long game.

SPEAKER_03I feel extremely calm, extremely focused, extremely clear on these points. And I'm not gonna, I'm refusing. I'm you cannot, I don't care. You can make fun of me, you can put me out there, you can say I'm this or that, you can call me every name in the book. I don't care. The benefit of being a grown human being is that you get to know yourself and you can stand in the shoes of your own integrity.

SPEAKER_03So I know what I think, I know what I want, I understand what I'm trying to do. So these things aren't necessarily on the same exact page as everybody else. So we're gonna fight for what we want. We're gonna try to get what we can, and that's the bottom line. So, yeah, I don't think this is a moment for all of us to be shrinking. I just don't. I think this is a moment to be big, you know? I think this is a moment to be expansive. I think this is a moment to push for all the things that we want. We do want a free Palestine. We do want an end to police murders, and we do want an end to the caging of our people.

SPEAKER_03We absolutely do want health care for all. We absolutely do want housing as a human right. We absolutely do want public schooling that is at the level of being able to do what it needs to do to educate the future generations. You know, we do want free college, we do want no debt. Like, I don't understand why that should be treated as some sort of like thing we have to be embarrassed about. It it isn't embarrassing, it's a beautiful vision of what people need to be able to flourish and thrive in the world.

SPEAKER_03For God's sakes, people, we're living with the on in the imaginations of fascists right now. How about we live in our imagination?

SPEAKER_01Yes, this is a really good reminder. It's really good to kind of be, you know, immersed and baptized in what you're saying and reminded because it's like, you know, again, because like I say, even me, we get out here and you know we it's it the terrain sometimes can be a little confusing. There's a lot of forces trying to confuse us about things that you're laying out.

SPEAKER_03So thank you. Um they will always do that. You have to be mindful, you have to know what you think, and then you have to fight for it. Period. End of discussion. Now, these other people do that all the time too, right? Like, why are your dreams and your your desires less valid? Like, why? Let's put some steel in our backs, in our spines. Let's fight. We deserve it. I hope that people really take this moment and like realize that you know, it's okay to be afraid.

SPEAKER_03And that's why relationships matter so much, because you need other people and you are braver with other people, right? Courage, bravery is really hard to embody as a lone individual, but it's much easier to be courageous when you've got a whole crew of folks who are gonna fight alongside you. And so that's the work, that's our jobs, and like don't cower. This is a great moment to be making big friggin' asks, to be making demands that we really want and to fight for them. That's how I feel. So that's why I'm not like cowering in a corner.

SPEAKER_03It's also why I'm hardly giving any talks. You're absolutely somebody who's I appreciate and respect, and so that's why I'm on it. But like everybody asks me for talking on interviews or being on here or doing that. And like, I'm not doing that shit. And the reason I'm not doing that shit is because I'm busy, but also because like I feel in this moment that we're really in a moment where we need to buck each other up and we don't need to do that in public. We need to be in private, having conversations with each other and really pushing each other and pushing ourselves beyond this moment of just being shrunken into this fascist imagination.

SPEAKER_03Like we need a jailbreak of our imaginations, as uh Kelly and I write in our book.

SPEAKER_01So that's it. No, I um listen, listen. I I appreciate it. And um, and I just you know, I I want to say two things that in response to that. One is I am doing a lot of talks, it's usually because people couldn't get you or sorry people, not at all, and then they get the Timu version.

SPEAKER_03Not at all.

SPEAKER_01You are so smooth, and they realize they realize to their horror at the event, like, oh wait, this isn't that is not true in the least.

SPEAKER_03No, yeah, I'm I say no a lot. I say no a lot because I think it's reminder. There are other people who should be out there speaking, and I want them to be able to do that, you know, but also like I know what I think, I know what I believe, and a lot of people aren't on the same page as that, and that's okay, but I'm doing that work behind the scenes to build more people who can think about the world in ways that are expansive and that could push for that world to happen.

SPEAKER_03So we'll keep it going.

SPEAKER_01The last thing I want to say is like, in the spirit of that kind of accountability that you talked about, you know, you'll see me out here on different places on the internet's doing things. I want to just say for everybody to hear, like, I'm receptive to that. Like, if I, you know, like you might see something I've said or done, and you might be like, man, change just out here wild at a minute. Hopefully you won't. I try not to, I ain't trying to be that guy. But if you do, I'm telling you right now, I receive that. And I want to receive that in a comradely sense and be like, okay, let me take this in, let me think about it. Yeah. So I want to contribute to that, to getting sharper and not the other stuff.

SPEAKER_01So either saying it directly to you, uh you know, so we know, and I want to model this for people that this is how we gotta be, you know what I mean?

SPEAKER_03We do, and also like I also want to model that we will disagree because we do, we don't all agree. I really think this is so critical, and I think some people take it so personally when somebody's like, I just don't agree with you. I'm like, okay, you don't agree with me. Like, that's cool. Like, I'm okay. I'm okay with being disagreed with. For God's sakes, I'm a PAC abolitionist, I've been one for decades. I am used to being not popular.

unknownOkay.

SPEAKER_03Like, I am used, I've never been deluded from that. I'm used to not being a popular person, and like I'm okay with that. Like, I because I do believe that what I believe is important to be able to stand in the shoes of. And I am just gonna keep fighting on that front. And I'm gonna keep learning also. I'm gonna keep learning because I don't know everything. I changed my mind, and that is to be a human being is to change your mind. It's you're not principled to have the exact same ideas that you had 35 years ago because the world has changed, the context changed, you have changed, you've gained new knowledge and information.

SPEAKER_03Don't be afraid to change your mind, and don't be afraid to change your mind in public. Being consistent is bullshit unless it's being having integrity that is important. Being consistent and having integrity is important, but being consistent in your opinions, you should change your mind when new information comes in to shift the context. You should be thinking that this is supposed to be saying, Oh, you used to think this. I'm like, Yes, I did, but I gotta learn now.

SPEAKER_01Right. If we learn, is everybody who learns, you know, like a hipposcore or something? So no, I love you.

SPEAKER_03But in this culture, you're supposed to stick to the death with the I, you know what I mean? But like I changed my mind. Like you can say that actually if you really mean it. Not I changed my mind for political reasons. No, I just changed my mind. These were ideas that I thought were useful. Now I don't think they're useful anymore. And then it's up to you to say what is useful, what is your new idea, and get people on board with that, right?

SPEAKER_01So that's something I see um more in writing and long form. I mean, I I think all kinds of platforms and places can be useful. Yeah, social media, it feels like everybody shows up certain now, I already know you're wrong. I never I don't hear people going like I'm changing my mind. I don't hear people come out and be like, I'm not sure about this thing. You know, it doesn't reward very much a part of my life.

SPEAKER_03You know, social media does not reward you for changing your mind. Social media is not even the place where you are supposed to develop into anything. So I it's okay too. Like again, that has its place, you know. Let people do what they want to do there. I think in real life, you'll see people that you meet that you see them on social, they're one way, and you'll be you'll meet them in person, and you're like, are you the same person? You know what I mean? Like, are you really like you don't see like you're so different online, you know?

SPEAKER_03And it's like because people can be different online, they can there's a kind of an inhibition to the sometimes kind of anonymity of the screen that allows people not to be their best selves. Whereas when you're face to face to somebody, harder to not try to be your best self. First of all, you can be punched in the neck. Second of all, like you know, like there's just the vibes are different.

SPEAKER_01You could be punched. I remember one time, I'm not connected to that, but I'm just to say, I remember one time I had had George Consciously, the influencer brother, and he was telling me about some real wild stuff people were saying, lying to him, and he just was like, if you met me a person, your energy would be different.

SPEAKER_03They would not do it in person, Changerai. They would not do it in person. This is why you have to be so mindful. Again, the value of being a grown-house person is being able to know these differences. But people will say anything and lie and do all the things online that all of a sudden you meet them in person, they're like night and day. And you're like, Are you the same person who was spreading lies about me the other day? Like, what? Right? Like, so people are different in person than they are online.

SPEAKER_01Keep it in mind. I really appreciate it. Well, yo, everybody unruly subject, give it up for Mariam Kabber. Really, really help us get out of the fascist imagination into our imaginations and into the actual work in relationship to each other. So, um Yeah.

SPEAKER_03Thank you. Thanks so much for having me.

SPEAKER_01Unruly subjects. All right, I mean I always come away from these conversations with a bunch of things I really need to sit with. But one thing that's really staying with me right now, especially with after what happened in these elections, is what RM says about our political imagination, right? I mean, she talks about how our opponents have been able to get people, you know, to live inside their imagination, right? Reacting to what they want.

SPEAKER_01And, you know, this even applies to some of us who are trying to think strategically. And she asks us to imagine what it would mean to live inside our own political imaginations, to refuse to make our demands smaller just because someone else wants to tell us that it's not realistic. And I think that's just really important for us to keep the focus on and to remember that like these victories are crucial, we should celebrate them, and also they're not the end or limit of the work at all, right? And, you know, look, I also appreciated her challenge for us to all think about our roles and how we can inhabit them with our strength, and we can all grow and do things that maybe, you know, we stretch out a little bit, but also we got there should be a whole array and spectrum of ways we can bring our talents and our energy, you know, and our creativity into movement and our relationships.

SPEAKER_01We need people who can teach, host, cook, logistics, all of that. All of that matters. Because at the end of the day, um, we gotta be sustained and we gotta play a much longer game. So big shout out to Mariam Cabber for making time to come on the show and continuing to challenge all of us. Unruly Subjects is brought to you in partnership with Ro Home Productions. Boy, I'm proud of Ro Home. Ro Home is run by John Myers and Alex Lewis.

SPEAKER_01Thank y'all. You know what I mean? And our producer, Alan Sal, really uh puts a lot of work into these episodes. So, shout out to Alan. I want to give a special shout out to my man Demetrius Noble, who helped us put together that North Carolina student voting coverage on the Patreon now, maybe coming down the feed at some point. Really important work, and thanks for all the ways, brother, that you that you helped me to think through what we want to do with this show and this platform. Our artwork is by Alex Tetusian. Our music is by Axel Kakutier.

SPEAKER_01And one other thing I want to share before we get out of here. We have finally, you know, kind of like finalized some artwork with Shaintrice Black. Um, she's an incredible artist, part of a black art collective out of Kentucky. I can't wait for y'all to see how fly this merch is. It's done. We got it's just a couple more things before we put the store online, but y'all are gonna want to do this, and there's gonna be special exclusive drops for our Patreon folks. So you yeah, it's fly. I can't wait. I can't wait for y'all to see it, man. Anyway, um, take care of each other, build those relationships, find your lane, keep doing the work, and uh, we will see you soon at Unmoving Subjects, man.

SPEAKER_01Rohome Productions.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Police Sexual Violence and the Consent Loophole, with Rachel Lapointe

    Nov 19, 202657 minAudio

    What happens when the people we're told to call for protection are themselves committing sexual violence? And why aren't we hearing more about it? This week, Chenjerai talks with social worker, researcher, and writer...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Hasan Piker: Beyond the Stream - Live in NYC

    Oct 22, 202653 minAudio

    What does it mean to build an independent media platform, and what responsibilities come with it? Recorded before a live audience in New York City, Chenjerai talks with political commentator and streamer Hasan Piker...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. From Being Right to Being Powerful: Reaching Beyond a Politics of Powerlessness, with Yotam Marom

    Oct 8, 20261 hr 32 minAudio

    What does it take to move from being right about the world to actually having the power to change it? What happens within our movements and organizations and in our hearts when we stop believing that we can actually...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. A Reckoning with our Moment LIVE at the Socialism Conference

    Sep 24, 202656 minAudio

    Unruly Subjects is back in the building and back in your feed! After a long, hot summer hiatus we’re returning with a very special episode recorded live at the Socialism Conference in Chicago, featuring a conversation...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Natalie Bencivenga, Hasan Piker & UNRULY SUBJECTS Live from the Socialism Conference!

    Sep 2, 20261 minAudio

    Before we relaunch our new season later this month, we wanted to share a special update! We just dropped an interview with journalist and media producer Natalie Bencivenga for our Patreon community. [LISTEN HERE]...

    Credit the people on this episode