What if you invested so much in a new home that you were forced to stay, even once you realised that you might not be the only inhabitants? And what if those other, most unwelcome housemates proved to be more frightening than anything you could possibly imagine? Written by Neil McRobert and produced Richard MacLean Smith. Find us at youtube.com/@unexplainedpod, tiktok.com/@unexplainedpodcast, twitter @unexplainedpod, facebook.com/unexplainedpodcast or www.unexplainedpodcast.com for more info. Thank you for listening.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Speaker 1Hello, It's Richard mclin smith here. I just want to say a huge thank you to everyone that took part in our survey. It's been an immense help. The survey is now closed and I'll be contacting the ten winners of a signed copy of The Unexplained Book in due courts. Keep a near out for some big announcements coming in the next few months as I look to launch my new Unexplained newsletter as well as a whole new companion show where I'll be discussing all things strange with some of the leading thinkers interrogating our world and reality today, and I'll also be participating in a number of live
Speaker 1events throughout the year. On that note, I'm very excited to announce that I'll be joining this year's lineup at Crime Con Birmingham on the twenty fifth of April, and I'll be back again for Crime Con London on the third and fourth of October. Birmingham is a brand new stop for Crime Con UK and it's already shaping up to be something special. I'll be there alongside some of the most recognizable voices and experts in true crime for a full, immersive day of stories insight and conversation, and then in October we take everything to the next level
Speaker 1in London, another chance to meet, chat theories and dig deeper into the cases we cover. Whether you've been with the show for years or you've only just discovered it, I'd love for you to come and say hello at either event or both. Come and hang out with me and the rest of the true crime community at crime com Birmingham and crime Con London, partnered by True Crime Channel. The expert let True Crime Channel available wherever you listen. Just head to Crimecon dot co dot uk and use my promo code unexplained for ten percent off your ticket.
Speaker 1Two cities, two incredible events, and I can't wait to see you there. In his seminal survey of horror culture Dance maccarbough, Stephen King recounts a trip to see Stuart Rosenberg's Amateurville Horror on its release in nineteen seventy nine. While sitting in the Darkened Movie Theater watching James Brolin
Speaker 1and Margo Kidder recreate the supposed haunting of the Lutz family, King heard a voice from the row behind a woman's voice repeating the same phrase in low, urgent tones. Think of the bills, she said, over and over, with mounting anxiety. Just think of the bills. The Amateurville horror king theorizes may masquerade as a ghost story, but is in truth a nightmare of economic insecurity and domestic stress. Here is
Speaker 1a movie, he writes, for every woman who ever wept over a plugged up toilet or a spreading water stain on the ceiling, for every man whoever did a slow burn when the weight of the snow caused its gutters to give way. Beneath its ghost story exterior, the horror maestro concludes what happens to the Lutz family is really a financial demolition derby spirits, in this interpretation, are just one more potential pitfall of home ownership, an esoteric version
Speaker 1of dry rot or toxic mold, a problem to be either fixed or endured. Such prosaic worries seem at odds with our usual assumptions and conception of the supernatural. We tend to think of hauntings as binary confrontations between the human and something other, a battle for ownership of our homes and our souls. We win and stay, or we lose and leave, whether or not we can afford the
Speaker 1cost of the haunting or the leaving never really comes to mind. The Lutzes are said to have fled their Amateurville home in terror after just twenty eight nights. If their story is to be believed, the dark force that lurked in one hundred and twelve Ocean Drive had a greater claim on the property than they could ever match. They concluded it was not a fight worth continuing, regardless of how much money the Lutzes had tied up in the place. But what about those who simply can't afford
Speaker 1to cut and run? What if you invested so much in your new home that you were forced to stay even once you realized that you are not the only inhabitants. And what if those other most unwelcome housemates proved to be more frightening than anything you could possibly imagine. You're listening to Unexplained and I'm Richard McLean Smith. Jack and
Speaker 1Janet Smile moved into their new home at three hundred and twenty eight Chase Street with their two young daughters on the first of October nineteen seventy three. The property was part of a duplex alongside Number three hundred thirty owned by Jack's parents, John and Mary Smile, in the small coal belt town of West Pittston, Pennsylvania. John and Mary themselves had moved into their half of the property just a few weeks earlier, after flooding had forced them
Speaker 1from their previous home. The two property building, dating back to eighteen ninety six, was a modest, unobtrusive thing, sitting on a narrow thoroughway more alley than street. Each apartment had the same floorplan, a living room and large kitchen on the ground floor, and three bedrooms and a bathroom on the first all sandwiched between an attic and a concrete lined basement. It was a duer upper for sure, but it was the perfect starter home for a young,
Speaker 1middle class American family, a safe haven in the economic turmoil of the nineteen seventies. The address already had a reputation though whispers of strange noises heard in the early hours and figures seen through half parted curtains. Long before the Smiles took up residents, it had already become the neighborhood house that kids dared each other to approach in the dark. But if any of these murmured rumors reached
Speaker 1the smell's ears. Neither generation were dissuaded from moving in. Instead, the family approached their new home as they did most things in life, with optimism. Janet and Jack had married in nineteen sixty eight, when Janet was twenty two and Jack was twenty eight. They were a perfect match, sensible, stoic, hard working, and devout. Janet described their shared philosophy. We didn't go along with the people our age who were
Speaker 1into drugs and protesting. We wanted a family, and we both wanted to make sure that our family would be raised properly. The following year, in nineteen sixty nine, they celebrated the birth of their first daughter, Dawn, and three years later, her sister, Heather, was born. When they met, Janet and Jack worked at the same local confectionery company, but Janet resigned her position to focus on raising Dawn and Heather, while Jack progressed further up the ladder. However,
Speaker 1he hadn't always worked in the confectionery business. After graduating high school in nineteen fifty nine, Jack enlisted in the Navy, where he worked as a neuropsychiatric technician, assisting military doctors in electro shock therapy. Though The practice is controversial today and presented as brutal torture in many a horror movie. At the time, it was seen as a miracle intervention for depression, suicidal thoughts, and the emerging concept of trauma.
Speaker 1It was a well paid job that Jack took pride and interest in, and by confronting different psychiatric conditions, he became aware of the potential frailty of perception and how easily the stressed, distorted mind could begin to question what is real. This knowledge would later cloud Jack's own certainty when he himself was faced with reality bending occurrences, but all that would come later. For the first few months
Speaker 1of their life on Chay Street, the smells were a portrait of domestic bliss. Janet was heavily involved in community organization. She helped to form a local Lioness's Club and served as its first president. She led a campaign against drink driving, and both she and Jack worked together to support various youth programs and junior sports teams. Dawn and Heather were healthy, happy children who loved their parents and grandparents deeply and
Speaker 1were well nurtured. In return. Each evening, Jack would return from work kiss his wife on the porch, then sweep his daughters into a giggling embrace. By all accounts, the Smiles were very happily living their little slice of the mid century American dream, but all that was about to change. Sometime at the beginning of nineteen seventy four, Jack's mother, Mary,
Speaker 1bought a brand new rug for their apartment. When she laid it down in the quiet of her home, she noticed a large, greasy mark on the fabric. With some irritation, she set to work cleaning it up, and before long, thanks to a few products and brushes, she succeeded in getting rid of the mark. But two days later Mary and John came down to breakfast to find that the mark was back. Once more. Mary cleaned the rug, and
Speaker 1once again the mark returned. After weeks watching his wife battle the strange, recurrent stain, John finally rolled up the rug and took it to the local dump. Some time later, next door, Jack's Smile was up late watching a Western. He sat alone in the dark as the images flickered out from the screen while everyone else slept soundly in their beds. Eventually, Jack's eyes began to droop when suddenly
Speaker 1the television exploded into flame. The blaze became so intense, so fast that in the seconds it took for Jack to switch off the set, the plastic molding had melted like butter. Not long after that, the smells new Electrick stove inexplicably caught fire. So too did the wiring in Jack's car, only days after he brought it home from the showroom. Perhaps there was something defective in the way the house had been wired, wandered Jack and his father,
Speaker 1and the car was just an unfortunate coincidence. They knew that the building needed some renovation, not least of all with the plumbing, and so over the next few weeks, Jack and his father threw themselves into gaining mastery over their new home. John Smill was an experienced welder, and
Speaker 1he set about soldering the pipes with gusto. Working methodically with Jack, going through the property piece by piece, he fixed more than thirty joints of piping. Satisfied with the work, he yelled for Jack to switch the water back on. Together, they watched with alarm as the whole building began to flood. Each and every joint had failed. Grumbling, but undeterred, they switched off the water and John resoldered everything once again.
Speaker 1They stood back and waited as the water was turned on. For a moment, everything seemed fine. Then one pipe spewed out a jet of water, followed by another, and then another. In the end, according to Jack, his father reworked some of the pipes five times before they finally held water. In the meantime, Jack turned his focus to his and Janet's bathroom. He spent days fastidiously installing their new bath
Speaker 1and sink, which had cost them a considerable amount of money, and when the job was finally finished, the pair agreed that they were the per choice. Finally, bit by bit, they were making their home their own. The next day, Janet woke up and wandered sleepily into the bathroom, glad to finally have it back in use. Then she froze. The porcelain sink was covered with scratches so deep as
Speaker 1to be unrepairable. Entire chunks of it had been gouged out and lay in white crumbs on the linoleum floor. She called out to Jack, who was equally baffled to find the room in such a state. But while Jack picked at the crumbled porcelain, racking his brains to try and understand what an earth had happened. A sudden sense of dread came over Janet. It was those deep scratches on the sink that she couldn't take her eyes off.
Speaker 1To her mind, at least, they looked like the furious wipe marks of a claw. From that point on, a sense of eeriness pervaded the home. A few days later, Jack began painting the apartment skirting boards and Wayne scotting. Hours after he'd finished, he went back to inspect his work. That's weird, he thought, as he approached one section of paneling. When he left it, the finish had been smooth, but now it appeared to be covered in streak marks. Drawing closer,
Speaker 1he realized they weren't streaks at all, but gouges in the paint, again, like scratch marks. A little confused, Jack simply painted over them and tried to forget about it, but it was hard to resist the growing sense of disquiet spreading through their home, and before long the children were feeling it too. Deep. In the early hours of night,
Speaker 1all was quiet in the smell household. Janet and Jack lay peacefully in their beds, their tired unconscious minds drifting deeper and deeper into sleep, when suddenly a scream rang out, wrenching them both back into the world with a shocking jolt. It was their six year old daughter, Dawn, crying out for help. Moments later, she burst into their bedroom, crying, what is it? What's wrong? Janet asked, People are flying
Speaker 1around my room, she said, through short, urgent gasps. Janet looked to Jack, who was already up, worried they might have an intruder. Telling his wife and daughter to stay put, he slowly inched out into the hallway, listening intently for any sounds of movement, but there was only silence as he neared his daughter's bedroom, and when he stepped inside it, there was nobody there. Then a few nights later, it happened again. This time Dawn rushed into her parents bedroom,
Speaker 1claiming that people were taunting her in the darkness beyond her bed. Each time, when Jack went to investigate, he found nothing untoward. Clearly, Dawn was just experiencing a run of bad nightmares, he thought, But Janet wasn't so sure. Though Dawn was only six, she was already a sensible girl, happy but serious minded and not given to flights of childhood whimsy, and she well knew the difference between fantasy
Speaker 1and reality, and the strangeness didn't end there. Over time, more oddities creeped into their daily lives. Sometimes in the evening, Jack fancied he heard the sound of heavy footsteps moving about on the floor above when there was no one else in the house. Then a blared out one day without warning. When Jack rushed over to turn it off, he was shocked to find that it wasn't even plugged. In.
Speaker 1Grasping its straws the smells, wondered if subsidence might somehow be to blame. This was Pennsylvania, and the ground beneath many homes were a Swiss cheese of old mine shafts and unmapped excavations. However, surveyors they drafted in to investigate found nothing wrong. It was early one morning. Soon after that, Janet and Jack were woken again in the night, but this time by a strange creaking sound. When it wouldn't stop,
Speaker 1The couple drowsily got up to investigate and followed the sound to their back garden, where there in the still morning air, the chairs on their patio were gently rocking back and forth, Jack reached out and stilled them, and the creaking stopped. Another night, Jack was lying awake on his side, unable to sleep, when he felt a hand to caress his bare shoulder. He turned over, surprised to find Janet was turned away from him, fast asleep. Some
Speaker 1time later, the older Mary and John Smiles were enjoying a quiet moment together when they heard a violent barrage of foul language coming from the other apartment. Concerned that their son Jack was being abusive to his wife and kids, they confronted him about it, but both he and Janet claimed sincerely that they had no idea what they were talking about. Quietly, Janet and Jack began to wonder if they weren't entirely alone in their new home, though it
Speaker 1seemed ludicrous to admit it. As people of faith who believed in souls and the afterlife, the concept in itself wasn't utterly out of the question, but since whatever it was didn't seem malicious, over time, they made peace with the possibility, and so things continued on and off for the next few years. In early nineteen seventy seven, Janet and Jack were delighted to discover that Janet was pregnant again.
Speaker 1In September, she gave birth to a pair of twin girls, Shannon and Karen. For the next six years, the family lived fairly event free in their home, which by then they couldn't imagine swapping for anywhere else. After all, all four of their children had grown up there. But that's the thing with life. You never know what it's going to throw at you next. Sometime toward the end of nineteen eighty three, Janet made one of her routine trips
Speaker 1to the washer machine. Whenever she was alone in the house, she liked to switch on the TV for company and leave it playing wherever she was, and so it was that day. As she made her way down the steps to the basement, the sound of canned laughter echoed out from the living room behind her. Moving to the machine at the back of the room, she pulled up its door and tipped all the washing inside, with all of it deposited. She threw in some powder and switched it on,
Speaker 1and that was when she heard someone calling out her name. Janet spun round and nervously eyed the space behind her as the chatter from the TV continued to float down from above and the machine word rhythmclee. Had she misheard something, she wondered. She scanned the room again, but saw little beside the odd bag of clothes and box of Christmas decorations.
Speaker 1Then the voice came again, this time from the other direction, in the space between her and the back wall Janet. It was a feminine voice, quiet but confident, and clear as day. The hairs on Janet's neck began to stand up. For a moment, she stood perfectly still as her mind raised. Then she did the only thing she could think to do.
Speaker 1What do you want? She asked? A short, sharp laugh rang out in response. With that, Janet hurriedly backed away from the wall and walked backwards up the stairs, keeping her eyes fixed on the empty basement as she went. As soon as she was back in the kitchen, she ran to her bedroom and dug out her rosary beats. She assumed at first it was the present finally making itself known. But then another equally terrifying thought occurred to her.
Speaker 1What if some one had got into the house and was playing a trick on her? Bravely she made her way from room to room, checking closets and underneath beds, but no one was there, which, to Janet left only the one explanation. She returned to the kitchen and stared at the open basement door at the far side of it. She raised across the room and slammed it shut, then sank to her knees and prayed. And there she stayed
Speaker 1for the rest of the afternoon, praying to God for the strength to finally confront what she had believed for some time now, but there was something malignant in their home. Later that night, after the girls had gone to bed, Janet revealed all to Jack about the voices and her growing conviction that there was something very wrong with their house. Jack listened without dismissal, though he didn't quite know what to say. At the very least he could see how
Speaker 1upset Janet was. He asked her how often strange things had been occurring? Nearly every day, she replied. Jack reached out across the kitchen table and took hold of her hand. Nothing's going to run us out of here, he said, and promised that they'd find a solution over the next
Speaker 1few days. Still rattled by her basement encounter, Janet threw herself into the housework to keep her mind from wandering. A blast of winter weather had swept over the area, blanketing much of the region in heavy snow. One morning, with her daughters packed off the school and Jack out at work, Janet was tackling the ironing as the TV kept her company as usual. Just then she felt a sudden gust of chilled air. She looked up, expecting to
Speaker 1see a window blown open, snow spiraling in. What she apparently saw instead was a dark, amorphous figure standing in the corner of the room. As Janet later described it, it looked almost humanoid in shape, though nebulous and shifting as if it were made of rolling smoke. The ominous figure had no features at all, only a dark smear where a face should be, and from its back something seemed to be fluttering like a cape. It stood as
Speaker 1high as a nearby radiator that measured almost six feet. Janet would later tell investigators how she'd stayed surprisingly calm. At first, she couldn't quite get a handle on what it was she was looking at exactly. Then it started gliding toward her. Janet stood rooted to the spot. As it passed close to her, she detected a strange odour, more odd than unpleasant and felt a deep chill. Suddenly,
Speaker 1without warning, it accelerated to a hurtling rush and disappeared into the kitchen. Janet, still seemingly unable to move, followed it with her eyes until it went out of view. She later suggested that the whole experience had left her in a profound state of shock. Only after some minutes had passed did she regain control over her own body. She looked down to see the iron was still clenched tightly in her fist, Quickly returning it to its cradle,
Speaker 1she stumbled after the apparent entity and into the kitchen, but it was now nowhere to be seen. Janet is said to have rushed next door in terror, not quite sure what she was going to say to her parents in law, But when Mary answered the door, she too appeared shaken. After inviting Janet in sight, she immediately slumped into a chair and began shaking. As she explained then to Janet, only minutes before, she'd been sitting in that
Speaker 1exact spot, completing her daily prayer when she felt a change of pressure in the room. Looking up, she saw a black, smokelike vigure sliding through the wall. It paused for a moment, she said, as if noticing her presence, before gliding past her chair and disappearing out of sight. Over the next few months, things were relatively calm in
Speaker 1the respective Smell households, so much so that Janet and Jack began to wander aloud. If their time of weirdness had now passed. Perhaps the ghosts were just using their house as a motel before passing on, joked Jack. In the spring of nineteen eighty four, Janet and her by then eleven year old daughter Heather were sitting at the kitchen table putting finishing touches to the white dress that Heather was due to wear for her confirmation that evening. Meanwhile,
Speaker 1six year old Shannon was busy ransacking the fridge when a strange, grating noise was heard coming from above them. They barely had time to look up before the entire light fixture suddenly tore itself free from the ceiling. Janet had just enough time to pull Heather out of the way, but could only watch in horror as the fitting fell down with a shocking crash into the middle of the room, striking Shannon on the shoulder and knocking her violently to the ground. Jack heard the screams from upstairs and rushed
Speaker 1down to find Janet and their daughters in floods of tears, still shaking. Jack would later say that that was when he began to suspect that something truly sinister had taken hold in their home. But in an interview with Robert current author of The Haunted, the Fullest account of the Smells Torment, Jack explained that true acceptance was hard. The first thing that the average person does, he said, is reject the idea that he's dealing with the supernatural. All
Speaker 1these really incredible things happen, but your mind keeps looking for some normal explanation. He remembered his experiences working in psychiatric treatment, all the times he had seen firsthand how the stressed mind could discern patterns and meaning in random events. But as spring rolled into summer, whatever doubts the Smells still clung to were soon torn away for good. On a humid night in early June, claimed that Janet was
Speaker 1dozing on the edge of sleep when something took hold of her leg. She'd only a second to gather her senses before she was roughly yanked from the bed. Jack startled awake, by his wife's screams, was horrified to find her being seemingly dragged across their bedroom floor, one leg up in the air, as if it were in the grip of an invisible attacker. As Janet apparently fought to
Speaker 1escape her phantom assailant, Jack leaped forward and tried to grasp her outstretched hand. What followed, according to Jack, was a tug of war over Janet's body, one he was slowly losing. As he gathered his strength for a final pall, he suddenly felt himself go limp and all the strength ran out of his body. From that point on, he could only sit immobilized on the bed, unable to even speak, as Janet struggled against her attacker, clinging to the bed
Speaker 1sheets in desperation. When suddenly, according to Janet, the pressure around her leg released and Jack's paralysis broke. Just then, a series of violent loud bangs reverberated in the walls all around them. Then a thund came from outside the room, followed by the screams of one of their daughters sprinting out on to the landing. The couple looked over the banister to see the now seven year old Shannon crammed
Speaker 1awkwardly into the corner at the bottom of the stairs. What happened, they asked, rushing to her aid I don't know, she replied, before collapsing into tears. Janet and Jack looked to each other in horror. There was no doubting it now. There was something in their home that wanted to hurt them, something that wanted to hurt their children. It was time to find help. You've been listening to part one of
Speaker 1Unexplained Season nine, Episode nine, The Uninvited. The second and final part will be released next Friday, January twenty third. This episode was written by Neil McRobert and produced by me Richard mclin Smith. Neil is the creator and host of his own brilliant podcast called Talking Scared, in which he discusses the craft of horror, writing with everyone from
Speaker 1Ta Nanaeve Do to the god of horror himself, Stephen King. I can't recommend it highly enough. Thank you as ever for listening. Unexplained is an Avy Club Productions podcast created by Richard McLain Smith. All other elements of the podcast, including the music, are also produced by me Richard mc lean smith. Unexplained the book and audiobook is now available to buy worldwide. You can purchase from Amazon, Barnes and Noble, Waterstones,
Speaker 1and other bookstores. Please subscribe to and rate the show wherever you get your podcasts, and feel free to get in touch with any thoughts or ideas regarding the stories you've heard on the show. Perhaps you have an explanation or a story of your own you'd like to share. You can find out more at Unexplained podcast dot com and reach us online through X and Blue Sky at Unexplained Pod and Facebook at Facebook dot com, Forward Slash Unexplained Podcast
UNEXPLAINED SEASON 10 BEGINS FRIDAY DECEMBER 4TH In the meantime we’re continuing with our look back at some of your favourite episodes from the vaults. This week we’re venturing back to the autumn of 1984, to the...
UNEXPLAINED SEASON 10 BEGINS FRIDAY DECEMBER 4TH In 1802, Prussian naturalist Alexander von Humboldt was introduced to guano, a substance made from accumulated bird and bat droppings that had been prized for centuries...
UNEXPLAINED SEASON 10 BEGINS FRIDAY DECEMBER 4TH In January 1986, a strange object was witnessed crashing into a mountain in a far eastern region of the then Soviet Union. Described by some as Russia's Roswell, analysis...
On this week's Night Tales, have we got a story for you. Back in 1975 in a quiet English town, a naked man is found wondering around the neighbourhood covered in blood. But things only get stranger from there. Pull up a...
UNEXPLAINED SEASON 10 BEGINS FRIDAY NOVEMBER 27TH Fear, it would seem, is a powerful primal emotion. So potent that it can even make us afraid of things that may not even exist. But then again, just because we can't see...