Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Unexplained

Unexplained artwork

S09E25: Desert Rain Pt.2 of 2 (The Disappearance of Daniel Robinson)

Jun 12, 202632 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

The second part of Season 09 Episode 25: Desert Rain As search teams struggle to find any sign of Daniel, a private investigator uncovers a promising lead. But will it lead to any more answers or just more questions... Written by Diane Hope and produced by Richard MacLean Smith. Find us at youtube.com/@unexplainedpod, tiktok.com/@unexplainedpodcast, twitter @unexplainedpod, facebook.com/unexplainedpodcast or www.unexplainedpodcast.com for more info. Thank you for listening.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Speaker 1Hello. I'm hugely excited to reveal that Unexplained will be coming to the Edinburgh Fringe Festival this August. The year is nineteen hundred three. Lighthouse keepers stand watch on a desolate island far from home, until one day they completely vanish from the face of the earth. Unexplained Life brings the haunting Flannanal's mystery to the stage in a gripping immersive performance that plunges audiences into one of history's most chilling and enduring unsolved disappearances. I'll be performing at the Space at Surgeons Hall at ten oh five pm every

Speaker 1night from August seventh to the twenty ninth, excluding the sixteenth and twenty third. Please go to Unexplained podcast dot com Forward Slash Events for more information, or you can purchase tickets direct by going to the Space UK dot com Forward Slash Shows, Forward Slash twenty twenty six, Forward Slash Unexplained hyphen Life. I look forward to seeing you there. Hello,

Speaker 1and welcome to Unexplained with me your host Richard mclin smith, where each week we explore another true tale of high strangeness. If you're new here and atmospheric and expertly told stories of the strange and unexplained are you'll think then please consider subscribing to the show. This is the second and final part of season nine, episode twenty five, Desert Rain, the Daniel Robinson Story. Detective Larry Biffin from the Buckeye

Speaker 1Police Department stood in the ravine next to Daniel Robinson's crash cheap as the desert sun bared down upon him. He thought back to the last text that Daniel had sent Caitlin, I'll either see you again or never see you again. Everything about his behavior and food prior to his disappearance suggested the high possibility that he had meant to go missing, maybe even to kill himself. But Biffin's head was flooded with questions. Howse his vehicle not seen

Speaker 1during the numerous searches of the area in the month since the young geologist had disappeared, Why had Daniel left all his clothes at the crash site, but most of all, where was the young man? The detective began by climbing the low hill to the east. From there, he could just about make out the jeeps faint vehicle tracks showing it had driven in from an easterly direction, just as you might expect if Daniel had driven it there straight after the meeting with his colleague Ken Elliot on June

Speaker 1twenty third, almost four weeks ago. Up above, a drone buzzed as it scanned the area, taking detailed pictures of the site. Later, when Biffin examined the photographs, they seemed to show that Daniel's jep had left the dirt road south of the job site where he'd met Ken, then driven up onto a hillside before hurtling down into the ravine. It had driven over several bushes in the process that were still visibly damaged. The gearbox of the overturned vehicle

Speaker 1was still in drive when it was found. As the day progressed, officers moved in to document the scene, while search and rescue teams arrived to search the surrounding area. A helicopter was also dispatched to help, along with a pack of cadaver docks, but there was no trace of Daniel. As some of the search team inspected an area by the Hesseampa River, they soon discovered that they were not alone. A mountain lion had crested a rise and was cautiously studying them. Perhaps a lion had taken Daniel. Some of

Speaker 1them wandered. The only other information they had to go on was the data from the jeep's black box. It showed that the vehicle was moving it around thirty miles when it hit the dirt at the bottom of the ravine and the air bags deployed. The driver's seat belt was buckled when the crash occurred, and the ignition was cycled forty four times after the crash event. It suggested that Daniel had most likely deliberately driven off the dirt road in a failed attempt to drive through the ravine

Speaker 1and up the other side. The jeeps mileage and examinations of Daniel's recovered phone revealed more information. There were two photos taken of work related logs and equipment at around ten past seven that morning, with GPS coordinates showing they were taken at a work site near Varado Road, south of Interstate ten in the Buckeye area, just west of Phoenix.

Speaker 1This tallied with the mileage and a credit card purchase Daniel made at a shell station around seven a m just over a mile from the Verado job site. With so much about the crash seeming off, Biffin was beginning to wander something. Was it possible that Daniel wasn't even driving the car when it crashed? Had the whole thing been simply made to look like a crash? Now with multiple possible angles to work with, Detective Biffin got in

Speaker 1touch with some accident reconstruction experts and asked them to review the vehicle's data and the crash site. In the meantime, he turned his focus to Daniel's phone records. What he found looked, for all the world, like a young man going through a mental health crisis. After the exchange of text messages between Daniel and Caitlin, which ended with her telling him that she didn't want to see him again, on the afternoon before he went missing, Daniel had texted his sister Davisha at four twenty one with the words

Speaker 1it's an emergency. His sister called him and they spoke for over a minute. Then Daniel hung up and replied to no further messages from his sister, other family members, or friends who tried to call that evening. Next the detective found what Daniel had been googling that night. Search terms included should I call her? Love is patience? Love is something you can't explain? I'm okay to do things I hate delete Instagram account explosion. Daniel's phone also contained

Speaker 1recordings of driving directions that he'd been following the day of his disappearance. They showed that he did not go directly to meet Ken, but where he had gone exactly was a mystery. Meanwhile, private investigator Jeffrey McGrath, who'd been hired by Daniel's father David to also work on the case, had been making a few discoveries of his own. Daniel's family had given McGrath access to his apartment in Tempe,

Speaker 1and it looked to the investigator that someone had ransacked Daniel's closet and accessed his laptop before the police made their official search there. After much pleading, David Robinson convinced the Tempe Police Department to do some forensics work on Daniel's electronics, including his personal laptop and gaming system. Incredibly, they found that someone had indeed looked up Daniel's search history and been fooling around on the computer. As they put it, McGrath was also troubled by the downloaded data

Speaker 1from Daniel's jeep. He claimed to find traces of red paint from a different vehicle at one of the areas of damage on the jeep. Even more suspicious was the vehicle lock, which appeared to show that the jeep had traveled some eleven miles after an initial crash event. McGrath concluded that not all of the jeep's damage was consider distant with the crash scene, but rather pointed to the crash having been staged. Police Detective Biffin, on the other hand,

Speaker 1was adamant they needed to wait for the results of the forensic examination from crash reconstruction experts before coming to any conclusions, but he did follow up on another of the pi's suggestions that he interview a friend of Daniels called Roger, who also worked at Matrix New World. As Detective Biffin interviewed Roger, it appeared that he knew Daniel well and had been a good friend to him. As Roger explained, the geologist had stayed with him for about a month when he first moved to Phoenix. They had

Speaker 1a mutual interest in computer gaming and both loved basketball, often meeting up to watch games together. During the week before Daniel disappeared, Roger's father had died and he'd been absent from work for a few days. When he returned, he was shocked at the change that he saw in his friend. Not only had he cut his hair very short, but instead of his normally friendly, chatty manner, Daniel was curt and irritable with him. At one point, Roger suggested they go and get some food together. Over breakfast, Daniel

Speaker 1let slip that there was a problem with a girl who didn't know he existed, as Roger put it. He then asked Roger if he believed in miracles, and also said something about getting rid of his ego, because ego is bad, he said. When Roger reassured his friend that he was just confident, not egotistical, Daniel replied oddly that he had to get rid of his story. This confused Roger, since previously Daniel had been proud of who he was and where he came from. Back at work, a short

Speaker 1time later, Daniel left the office without saying goodbye. The following day, Roger and Daniel went to breakfast again. Daniel asked Roger straight out, what if there was a girl you liked but you couldn't have her. Roger said They talked about the issue some more, but he got the feeling that Daniel wasn't being wholly honest with him. He

Speaker 1seemed to believe that he had to completely change himself to get the girl again. Once back at the office, but thoroughly preoccupied, Daniel left without saying another word. After speaking to Roger, Detective Biffin remembered that Caitlin had recommended a podcast to Daniel shortly before he disappeared. Looking back into Daniel's phone records, he eventually located the link that Caitlyn had sent him for it. It took him to a podcast by the famous spiritual teacher Eckhart Toll and

Speaker 1an episode titled Transcending Our Stories. In it, Toll says we all have a tendency to manufacture stories about ourselves and others, often fueled by a desperate need to be right and to make others wrong. Toll advises that we can learn to shift our inner narrative and release the ego in order to better align ourselves with the peace of the present moment. It was clear that the message in the podcast aligned closely with things Daniel had said

Speaker 1to both Roger and his sister. But if Daniel had indeed intended to commit suicide, surely that couldn't have been enough to drive him to do it. As September twenty twenty one, rolled by police and volunteer groups led by Daniel's father continued to search for any sign of Daniel out in the desert beyond the White Tank Mountains just west of Phoenix. On the twenty eighth of September, another pack of cadaver dogs were out working by the Hessiampa River when one of them suddenly became interested in one

Speaker 1of the large bushes close to the riverbank. It appeared to pick up a scent that led it toward the middle of the dry river bed, then frustratingly lost it soon after. On hearing the news, Detective Biffin wondered if Daniel's body was somewhere out in the desert where its scent could not be detected. As it happened, there were two mine shafts about eight miles away for where Daniels crashed cheap had been found. Both were thoroughly searched for any sign of the missing man, but again the search

Speaker 1teams came up empty handed. Around the same time, a search volunteer was inspecting an area of desert just west of where the jeep crashed when they saw an odd looking stone partially buried in the dry earth. Moving closer, they realized with a jolt that it was in fact a human skull, along with some other bone fragments. However, when analyzed, they were found to belong to two other people who'd been missing for even longer than Daniel. In

Speaker 1mid October two thousand and one, Detective Larry Biffin received what he'd been waiting for from the accident investigator, a detailed record from Daniel's jeep in its final moments. It revealed that the jeep had made a series of small turns just before it drove into the ravine. Half a second before the crash. The report continued, the driver increased the accelerator pedal right before impact, which could indicate the attempt to drive up the other side of the ravine. Doing so with the wheels turned to the right could

Speaker 1be a factor in causing the jeep to roll over to the left. The jeep shows no evidence of having been involved in another collision. The apparent anomaly of eleven miles between the car's computer and the miley's display is not unusual. Such a discrepancy has been found in other crash reconstructions and is not significant in this case. Based on the available evidence, it is my opinion the jeep had been in only one recorded event. That event is the crash at the bottom of the ravine. There is

Speaker 1insufficient evidence to connect the jeep to another crash, will support a theory that the jeep crash was staged. The driver of the jeep drove it into the ravine, rolled and being unable to proceed further, abandoned the jeep as it lay. The report appeared to discredit private investigator Jeffrey McGrath's theory that the jeep had been involved in two crashes that day, making it unlikely that the crash was faked. Daniel's phone had stopped tracking at ten oh five that morning.

Speaker 1Its last recorded position was in the ravine, exactly where the jeep and phone were found. Then, in November, a new lead emerged. Private investigator McGrath told Detective Biffin that he'd been contacted by a federal worker named Billy, who claimed to have encountered Daniel with his jeep out in the desert on the morning that Daniel went missing. So Biffin gave Billy a call. The man claimed that he was an it worker for the Inter Tribal Marijuana Commission

Speaker 1and sometimes also worked in an official capacity on marijuana enforcement operations. Billy sent the detective a map and photos of the place where he claimed this encounter with Daniel had occurred. When Biffin checked the coordinates, it was half a mile from where daniels jeep was found. As Billy went on to explain to Detective Biffin, he'd been driving

Speaker 1the dirt roads looking for a place to shoot targets with his air rifle when around eleven thirty am he claimed to come upon a jeep and a man matching Daniel's description. Billy said he was wearing a bright reflective shirt and boots at the time and was in the process of moving things from his back seat to the rear hatch. Billy said he immediately noticed that the man was missing part of his arm and stopped to ask if he needed help, after which they had a brief chat.

Speaker 1Billy alleged that Daniel told him something about how he was doing some work in the area and pointed to the north. Around one pm, Billy claimed to be looking through his rifle scope further southeast along a ridge line when he saw a vehicle similar to Daniel's driving away about three miles further southwest from where he'd last seen it. Billy said he didn't watch a lot of the news and had only just heard about the search for Daniel, hence why he was getting in touch with police now.

Speaker 1Billy's story was immediately suspicious. For a start, all the available evidence pointed to Daniel's jeep having already crashed in the ravine two hours earlier that when Billy claimed to have met Daniel. Detective Biffin and a colleague drove to the site where the encounter between Billy and Daniel supposedly happened. They didn't find any indication that Daniel had been there, but what they did find was a fenced gated private property containing a number of abandoned trailers, RVs and other

Speaker 1heavy equipment within walking distance of the jeep crash site, but there was no sign of Daniel or anything to suggest that he'd ever been there. In late November, private investigator McGrath and Detective Biffin decided to pull all their information to see if they could finally crack the case together. McGrath revealed that he'd been under strict instructions from Daniel's father to not give any information that he found to the police, but now McGrath was ready to share, and

Speaker 1there were two things that jumped out at Biffin. Daniel's sister, Davisha, had told McGrath that the day before Daniel went missing, he'd said something about how the family would have to get used to him disappearing. McGrath had also learned that Daniel wasn't just a casual marijuana smoker, but a frequent user, and often made random drives to California to pick up weed. McGrath wondered if the morning that Daniel had met Ken at the job site, he had accidentally ingested PCP. PCP

Speaker 1or fen cyclidine, is a highly addictive, mind altering hallucinogen developed in the nineteen fifties. Its use as a surgical anesthetic was discontinued when it was found to cause severe postoperative delusions. Illegally sold on the streets as a powder or liquid, known variously as angel dust, rocket fuel, or embalming fluid, it's most often applied to mint leaves or marijuana and smoked with notoriously unpredictable effects, including distorted vision, hearing,

Speaker 1and time perception. It can trigger paranoia or a false sense of immense strength and invincibility, and it can cause users to feel separated from their own bodies and their surroundings. Taking PCP would go a long way to explaining why Daniel had acted so strangely in the hours prior to his disappearing, crashing his jeep then taking off his clothes in the middle of the desert. McGrath concluded that he didn't believe that Daniel was still out there chilling. He

Speaker 1thought that Daniel was in the desert, but that he was no longer alive. Just a month later, on New Year's Eve twenty twenty one, McGrath contacted Detective Biffin again. He told him that he'd resigned from the case. He felt that his client, David Robinson's insistence to not share information with the police was counterproductive to finding Daniel. It was one of multiple reasons for his decision, he said, and it had one last piece of advice for Biffin

Speaker 1to check the background of the witness, Billy. When Biffin did exactly that in twenty twenty two, he was startled by what he found. It turned out that Billy had participated in many of the volunteer searches that David Robinson had organized, and that he was not all that he claimed to be. It turned out the so called Billy had multiple felony convictions, almost all marijuana related, and he'd served time in prison. The Intertribal Marijuana Commission also revealed

Speaker 1that Billy was not an IT worker for them. He was a member of their enforcement team in Nevada and Utah, but not in Arizona. Next, some members of the volunteer search teams told Biffin they'd found Billy's behavior suspicious while out on searches. They'd noticed that whenever word went around that the police were on their way, he'd always find an excuse to suddenly leave. Detective Biffin made a note to have another chat with Billy in person. In April

Speaker 1twenty twenty two, Detective Biffin asked Daniel's father, David, for access to Daniel's personal laptop, which was now in David's possession, but Robinson refused unless the police made the investigation a criminal case and brought in the FBI, convinced that his son had been the victim of foul play. However, when Detective Biffin actually presented his findings to the FBI. They complimented him on an extremely thorough investigation, concluding that there was no reason for them to get involved. Understandably distraught

Speaker 1and frustrated with the lack of success in finding his son, David Robinson offered a ten thousand dollars reward for any information that led to Daniel being found, and, as so often happens when such rewards are promised, reports of Daniel being sighted suddenly began to flood in from California, Arizona, Albuquerque, and New Mexico, you name it. But each time when the police followed up, the person at the center of the reports was very obviously not Daniel. On the tenth

Speaker 1of June twenty twenty two, almost a year after Daniel went missing, Detective Biffin finally spoke with Billy again, this time in person at Billy's home in Surprise, a suburb on the western edge of Phoenix. Once again, Billy repeated the details of his story from the previous year, but Biffin questioned him on it, since neither his alleged midday timing of the encounter or the location tallied with police evidence, but Billy stood by his story. The detective asked Billy

Speaker 1if he might have been motivated to make up his account for the potential ward money, but Billy deflected the question. Then Biffin asked if Billy had hurt Daniel or had anything to do with him going missing or his vehicle, but Billy said no. Biffin also asked Billy if he'd ever met Daniel before his first supposed encounter with him, or whether he'd sold him weed or smoked it with him, but again Billy said no. After a while, he seemed

Speaker 1to backtrack on his original statement, suggesting he might have misremembered it slightly, but insisted that he wasn't trying to make it up. He even offered to take a lie detective test to prove it. Later that day, after Biffin had left his home, Billy emailed the detective of a trail map showing the route he'd taken that fateful morning and the alleged location where he met Daniel. No part of Billy's route came closer than half a mile to any location where Daniel's jeep had been recorded. When the

Speaker 1option to take a polygraph test came up in the end, Billy refused to do it, as the investigation into Daniel Robinson's whereabouts dragged into a second year. Detective Biffin and the Buckeye Police Department continued to follow up reported sightings of Daniel, but all were to no avail. But Biffin couldn't let go of the thought that Billy was hiding something,

Speaker 1and so on the twenty second of May twenty twenty three, perhaps sensing something dangerous about the man, Detective Biffin arranged to meet Billy again for another round of questioning, this time in a Fry's gas station parking lot in surprise for added security. Biffin also didn't go alone, but was joined by his colleague, Detective Favella, who was parked in an unmarked vehicle nearby to maintain a visual on Billy at all times. It was pushing one hundred degrees when

Speaker 1Billy slid into the passenger seat of Detective Biffin's truck. Biffin immediately sensed that the man's demeanor was apologetic. Strangely, as soon as he got into the truck, he gave the detective a mobile Wi Fi hotspot and a charger in case it might be of some use to him, perhaps looking to make some kind of amends for refusing the lie detector test. This time, when Biffin asked him again to describe his alleged encounter with Daniel, everything had changed.

Speaker 1Having initially described an up close, extended exchange, Billy now said that he'd only had a brief, passing encounter with the young man, who'd been about thirty feet away from him the whole time. Which story is true, demanded Biffin with obvious frustration. Why have you inserted yourself into my investigation? But Billy was either unwilling or unable to answer the question. All he could say was that, however, or whenever it happened,

Speaker 1he had seen Daniel out in the desert that day. For Detective Biffin, it was an agonizing dead end that only became more irritating the more he interrogated it. Why on earth, as he later pondered in his report, would Billy lie about talking to Daniel that day. Since Daniel Robinson went missing in June twenty twenty one, his devastated father has been consumed with the search for his son.

Speaker 1He's traveled repeatedly to Arizona, organized desert searches, distributed flyers, and gone seventy thousand dollars into debt in the process, all in the hope of finding a concrete answer to Daniel's whereabouts. There are still so many unanswered questions, and so far, to this day, what exactly happened to Daniel Robinson remains unexplained. If you have any evidence related to this case, please contact Buckeye Police Department on USA area

Speaker 1code six two three three four nine six' four double, one or go To Please Help Find daniel dot. Com this episode was written By Diane hope and produced by Me richard McLain. Smith thank you as ever for Listening unexplained as an Av club production podcast created By richard McLain. Smith all other elements of the, podcast including the, music

Speaker 1are also produced by Me richard McClain. Smith. Unexplained the book and audiobook is now available to buy. Worldwide you can purchase From, Amazon barnes And, Noble, waterstones and other. Bookstores please subscribe to and rate the show wherever you get your, podcasts and feel free to get in touch with any thoughts or ideas regarding the stories you've heard on the. Show perhaps you have an explanation or a story of your own you'd like to. Share you can find out more At unexplained podcast dot, com and reaches

Speaker 1online THROUGH x And Blue sky At Unexplained pod And facebook At facebook dot. Com Forward Slash Unexplained podcast AS.

Speaker 2Mu Must pass as new

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. S03E08: REPEAT INPUT UNTIL END - The Dodleston Messages (RERUN)

    Nov 20, 202632 minAudio

    UNEXPLAINED SEASON 10 BEGINS FRIDAY DECEMBER 4TH In the meantime we’re continuing with our look back at some of your favourite episodes from the vaults. This week we’re venturing back to the autumn of 1984, to the...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. S05E02: The Unceasing Cloud - The Mad Gasser of Botetourt (RERUN)

    Nov 13, 202637 minAudio

    UNEXPLAINED SEASON 10 BEGINS FRIDAY DECEMBER 4TH In 1802, Prussian naturalist Alexander von Humboldt was introduced to guano, a substance made from accumulated bird and bat droppings that had been prized for centuries...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. S05E15: It Came From Above - The Height 611 UFO Incident (RERUN)

    Nov 8, 202629 minAudio

    UNEXPLAINED SEASON 10 BEGINS FRIDAY DECEMBER 4TH In January 1986, a strange object was witnessed crashing into a mountain in a far eastern region of the then Soviet Union. Described by some as Russia's Roswell, analysis...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Unexplained Halloween Special: Night Tales

    Oct 31, 202632 minAudio

    On this week's Night Tales, have we got a story for you. Back in 1975 in a quiet English town, a naked man is found wondering around the neighbourhood covered in blood. But things only get stranger from there. Pull up a...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. S01E04: Where Darkness Plays - The Pontefract Poltergeist (RERUN)

    Oct 30, 202625 minAudio

    UNEXPLAINED SEASON 10 BEGINS FRIDAY NOVEMBER 27TH Fear, it would seem, is a powerful primal emotion. So potent that it can even make us afraid of things that may not even exist. But then again, just because we can't see...

    Credit the people on this episode