Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Unexplained

Unexplained artwork

S0E912: Eyes that Shine a Burning Red Pt.3 of 3 (Charles Walton Murder)

Feb 27, 202631 minAudio

The third and final part of Season 09 Episode 12: Eyes that Shine a Burning Red Digging into the local history, investigators uncover strange tales of witchcraft that have plagued the area for generations, including the chilling case of Ann Tenant. But surely, it couldn't possibly have had anything to do with Charles' murder, could it? Written by Richard MacLean Smith, James Conor Patterson and Emma Dibdin. Find us at youtube.com/@unexplainedpod, tiktok.com/@unexplainedpodcast, twitter @unexplainedpod, facebook.com/unexplainedpodcast or www.unexplainedpodcast.com for more info. Thank you for listening.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Speaker 1Unexplained now has a substack page. If you enjoy Unexplained and want to go deeper into the world of the show, I've created a new space for all the bits that don't quite fit into the podcast, including the Unexplained Addendum, a weekly companion piece to each new episode. Expect essays that lean more academic and analytical explorations of folklore, psychology, and the shadowy corners of history that have shaped the stories you hear on the show. But it's also a home for something more personal, my fiction, my strange amusings, and the odd fragments that don't belong anywhere else. Search

Speaker 1for Unexplained podcast on substack or go to Unexplained podcast dot substack dot com to find out more and subscribe. If it's like a little bit more of me and Unexplained in your week, join me on substack and let's keep exploring the unknown together new writing every Monday. You're

Speaker 1listening to the third and final part of Unexplained, Season nine, episode twelve, Eyes that Shine, Burning Bread. On a mild September afternoon in eighteen seventy five in the village of long Compton, eighty year old an tenant is returning home from the Bakers when a local farm laborer named James Heywood spies her from across the road. The tired and

Speaker 1weary James, still carrying his pitchfork, has spent all day working in the field, but the sight of Anne seems to stir something animalistic inside of him. Holding his pitchfork aloft, he tears across the road and unleashes hell on the elderly woman, stabbing her first in the leg, then two more times in the body. He screams for her to leave him alone and to die. Hayward is eventually pulled off the woman and taken to the police, and Tenant

Speaker 1dies the following day from her injuries. Pressed on why on earth he attacked the poor, defenseless old woman, Hayward insisted she wasn't defenseless at all, but was in fact a witch. Not only that, but she was the head of an entire coven that had been actively cursing him since he was a young boy. Naturally, to Hayward's mind, the only way to break the hecks was to kill off the coven's leader. The plan was then to take

Speaker 1out the rest of the coven one by one until the earth was wet with their blood. After being examined by a physician, it was determined that Hayward had a quote enfeebled mind and was incapable of controlling his emotions, possibly owing to an accident he'd had as a boy when he'd been struck on the head by a falling branch. But it was also found that Heyward was not entirely alone in his suspicions about the existence of malignant witches in the area. In fact, he owed much of his

Speaker 1suspicions to the influence of his parents, who regularly complained to fellow villagers that local witches wouldn't leave their boy alone. With the same local suspicions and the use of the pitchfork, it was hard not to see the similarities between the murders of Charles Walton and Anne Tenant. Though Inspector Fabian at little time for the suggestion that Charles really was

Speaker 1a witch, was it at least possible that, much like James Heyward to Anne Tenant, his murderer believed it, could they have been so unnerved by all the strange rumors surrounding Charles, or convinced even that he'd actually put a curse on them, they killed him for it. Surely it wasn't possible in that day and age, reasoned fabian. But then the investigators did a little more digging. As it

Speaker 1turned out not only was it possible, but that small area of English countryside that Charles Walton called home, known to some as the Land of the Covens, was especially famous for it. Back in eighteen eighty, on a farm in Ilmington, four miles south of Lower Quinton, a number of cows died inexplicably. Fearing a curse had been put on them. The farmer's made cut out the heart of one of the dead cows, then stuck it with pins

Speaker 1and baked it in the farmhouse oven. As the story goes, no sooner had the flesh started to cook, a strange creature, the likes of which had never been seen before, appeared suddenly in the kitchen and made a bee line for the oven. It scratched desperately at the oven door, trying to get inside to get at the heart, but before it could, the creature was captured and killed. From that day on, the farmer's cows were apparently no longer bothered

Speaker 1by the supposed curse. On February night in eighteen eighty six in the town of fenny Compton, twenty miles east of Lower Quinton, a local police officer disappeared. A few days later, the body of twenty nine year old Constable William Hine was fished out of the local canal. An inquest found that the cause of death was due to one expertly delivered stab wound to the jugular vein. The man had, as the coroner noted, been stuck like a pig.

Speaker 1Though local poachers were suspected of the murder, others believed there was a far more strange and supernatural motive for the killing, a belief that never truly went away. There were also numerous tales of one apparent witch local to the area called Betty. It said that one evening sometime around the late eighteen hundreds, a cat appeared at a village party that Betty had not been invited to. Believing the cat was actually Betty in disguise, the host is

Speaker 1said to have chased it down and driven a pitchfork through its pow. The following day, a sheepish looking Betty was apparently seen around the village nursing a hand wound. More recently. One farmer living at Hillside Farm, not far from where Charles Wharton was murdered, was said to have been having trouble keeping its gate shut. Each morning he would awake to find them left wide open, and all his cattle missing. Even when he bought padlocks for them,

Speaker 1all still he would wake to find them all unlocked and pushed open, his cattle scattered about. He blamed. Which is and then, of course there were the roll Right Stones. Not fifteen miles south of Lower Quinton, on a scarp overlooking the village of long Compton, where Anne Tenant was murdered, resides a peculiar stone circle constructed from oulite limestone. Like

Speaker 1Edward Leeds Skalnin's Strange Coral Castle in Florida, it is composed of seventy seven stones placed in a ring about thirty meters in diameter, known as the King's Men. Beside this are four standing stones seemingly in a huddle together, known as the Whispering Knights, thought to be the remains of a burial chamber, and lastly a large solitary stone at the head of it, all known as the Kingstone. As the story goes, early one afternoon a king was

Speaker 1riding through the countryside with his army when they were accosted by a witch. She offered the king a challenge in return for which he would become king of all the land. But the king failed, so he and his men were turned to stone, where they stood in truth. The ancient ritual site was built periodically over the course of about three thousand years, with the Whispering Knights burial chamber thought to have been built some six thousand years ago.

Speaker 1The witch related origin story may be apocryphal, but the mysterious stone circles association with witches does not end there. For centuries, rumors have abounded of a coven of witches who regularly gathered for late night sabbaths in the middle of the roll ride stones. On certain nights when the moon is at its fullest or the mist at its thickest, Witnesses claimed to have seen groups of naked people cavorting inside the circle, rubbing ointments onto their bodies, and dancing

Speaker 1themselves into a state of delirium. At least one so called roll right, which is said to be executed in the seventeenth century at the hands of the infamous witch finder General Matthew Hopkins. It was said to be common knowledge to any woman struggling to get pregnant that all they had to do was ruber breast against one of the stones, and they would no longer struggle to conceive. One farmer is alleged to have tried to steal one of the stones for use in a building project, using

Speaker 1horses to pull it free, but every time he tried to attach them to the stone, the horses simply reared away in fear, it seemed witches, or at least the fear of them was still very much alive and well. In fact, there was also a rumor that at least three men and four women still met regularly at me and Hill to conduct Sabbath's One man from long Marston, another local village, claimed that he saw them eat a

Speaker 1nest of hairless mice, washing each one down with gluttonous gulps of cider. As it happened. Charles Walton was a known cider drinker, which he would always buy by the barrel to supposedly drink at home away from prying eyes. Despite the headlines being dominated by the war, it wasn't

Speaker 1long before the rumor that something truly strange had occurred in Lower Quinton began to get noticed by the wider public. Talk of black magic and witchcraft began to intensify. Though Inspector Fabian had no time for the supernatural, he also knew that it didn't matter what he believed, only what Charles's killer did. Suddenly it didn't seem so out of the question that someone might have been sufficiently rattled at the thought that Charles was a witch that they had

Speaker 1killed him for it. Mutterings intensified about rum things that happened last spring, and how the crops had been inexplicably poor despite good weather. As one man put it, something's wrong when crops go against nature. Was Charles and his natterjack toads to blame for this? They wondered? And then there was the watch. According to some, Charles's pocket watch was no ordinary timepiece, but was really used to store

Speaker 1a small black scrying mirror, which he used to predict the future and cast his spells. Is that what the murderer had been searching for all along? Despite the many peculiar theories now beginning to percolate, Inspector Fabian still had nothing solid to go on. At the heart of it all was the villager's continued refusal to name anyone to go along with their various theories about who might have done it and why. But there was one thing Fabian

Speaker 1couldn't stop thinking about, just how was it possible that no one in the village had seen Charles being attacked in broad daylight, or at least someone who would have been covered in blood fleeing the scene. In a re newed effort to get to the bottom of it, a reconnaissance plane was used to take detailed photographs of the area surrounding the murder site. From this, a detailed map was compiled, marking out all local landmarks and farms from which someone might have had a good line of sight to where

Speaker 1Charles was working when he was attacked. Anyone associated with those places was pressed again on what they'd seen that day, but all maintained their ignorance. Police also looked into the records for all the murders committed in the region over the last ten years to see if any had been linked to witchcraft or black magic, or anything else that might tie together with the Charles Walton killing, but nothing was found. After three months, it seemed that all avenues

Speaker 1to find the killer had been exhausted in all that time. Aside from the man named Smith who'd killed himself, only one other person was considered a possible suspect, a soldier who lived near the village who also dabbled in poaching rabbits. Some speculated that Charles had caught him red handed and he'd murdered him for it, but it all sounded a little far fetched to inspect a fabian, and though he had no way to prove it for him, there was

Speaker 1only one name worth considering, because when it came to murder, more often than not, the simplest answer was the right one. As it turned out, there was one person who they knew had a perfect line of sight of Charles around the time he was murdered, who also just happened to be the last known person to have seen him alive, Alfred Potter. For all his supposed alibis, there wasn't actually anyone who could confirm absolutely that Potter wasn't near me

Speaker 1and Hill when Charles was killed. For example, one local shopkeeper who Potter put forward as an alibi, confirmed that Alfred had brought pig feed from him on the day of the crime, but not at the time of the murder. Digging further into Potter's farm, Inspector Fabian learned there were rumors of financial irregularities in the family estate. Maybe he wondered Charles had found out about this and had demanded more pay in return for his silence. If Charles had

Speaker 1refused to let it go, so, perhaps Potter had just snapped and put an end to it. As a man of good standing in the community, unlike the outcast Charles who few would miss. Perhaps he reasoned that he'd get away with it, and maybe he did. Perhaps he'd even done it out of a genuine fear of Charles's supposed black magic powers, genuinely holding him responsible for the previous year's fallow harvest or ailments affecting his animals. Perhaps hearing

Speaker 1that one of his heifers was dead in a ditch had been the final straw. But in the end, just like Inspector Robert Fabian, we will never know. As summer arrived, Fabian was forced to make the tough decision to end the investigation and return to London. In the years that followed, the formal investigation into Charles Walton's murder. The esteemed Inspector

Speaker 1Fabian could never quite shake off the case, and had haunted him for the rest of his life. In his subsequent memoirs, he described it as one of the strangest of his career, and it was clear that something of the country's dark superstitions had left a permanent mark on the man, though he said little about it at the time. Reflecting on the case in nineteen seventy, Fabian is reputed to have said, I advise anybody who is tempted at any time to venture into black magic, witchcraft, shamanism, call

Speaker 1it what you will, to remember Charles Wharton and to think of his death, which was clearly the ghastly climax of a pagan rite. There is no stronger argument for keeping as far away as possible from the villains with their swords, incense and mumbo jumbo. It is prudence on which your future peace of mind and even your life could depend. Superintendent Alex Spooner from Warwickshire's CID was similarly

Speaker 1affected by it, and equally troubled by the inability to find a culprit. Every Valentine's Day for the next fifteen years, he returned to Lower Quinton and made a solitary pilgrimage to the precise spot where Charles was murdered. There at noon, precisely he could be seen keeping his own quiet vigil in Charles's memory. The idea was to send a message to the killer, if they still frequented the area, that he hadn't forgotten, in the hope that he might provoke

Speaker 1them into finally buckling under their own guilt. But no one came forward, and in time, as is often the way, the villagers came to resent his visits. They wanted to move on, so Spooner stopped coming. Somewhere along the line, it was pointed out that Charles Walton had been murdered on February fourteenth, but only according to the Gregorian calendar. If you were a pagan traditionalist, you might prefer to go by the Julian calendar, which runs thirteen days behind.

Speaker 1If so, the day Charles was murdered was actually February the first, a traditional Druidic day of sacrifice. Could it be? Some wondered that it wasn't Charles, who in fact was the witch, but his murderer. Had he actually been murdered as part of a pagan ritual using his blood to replenish the soil and keep the local crops thriving. As coroner James Webster pointed out at the inquest, the likelihood

Speaker 1was that Charles had been struck first over the head with its walking stick, then run through with the pitchfork, and only then had his throat slit. It was certainly odd the way the pitchfork seemed to have been deliberately positioned to keep the jugular angled toward the ground, which in turn would enable the most blunt to soak into the earth. A few years after Charles's murder, a mister J. F.

Speaker 1Rogers from Bambury, a town about twenty miles east of Lower Quinton, heard a rumor about a black Sabbath that was due to take place at the Rollright Stones. On May twelfth, nineteen forty nine, mister Rogers drove out to the mysterious site as a full moon shone in the sky above him. He parked his car as close as he could, then stealthily made his way up the hill toward the stones. As he drew near to them, he heard strange shrieking and whooping sounds with the ominous silhouette

Speaker 1of mean Hill rising up in the background, he saw the source of the ecstatic, a group of seven or so men and women dancing naked among the so called King's Men, one of whom he later claimed, appeared to be wearing some kind of goat mask, or perhaps it wasn't a mask at all. Not long after, a woman from Birmingham contacted the police asking for protection in return for answers. The woman claimed to have been a witch

Speaker 1who'd taken part in satanic rituals and knew the killer of Charles Walton, a fellow witch who'd supposedly been brought in from a different part of the country to conduct a fertility ritual, with Walton as the sacrifice. The police declined to investigate further. By the nineteen fifties, Charles Wharton's murder continued to cast a disturbing shadow over Lower Quinton and the wider area. Though most had tried to move on,

Speaker 1others remained determined to uncover the truth about who had been responsible. Since regular police work could failed to find the perpetrator, Bernard Payne from the Birmingham Psychic Research Society, decided to take a slightly more unorthodox approach. It was a bitterly cold night when he and fifteen others arrived at the foot of Mean Hill in late November nineteen fifty two, together with fellow society member and farmer, a man named mister Mills. Leading the way, they trudged gallantly

Speaker 1through a driving blizzard of sleet and snow, over barbed wire fences, across muddy fields, and through icy puddles as they searched for the spot where Charles had been killed. The Birmingham Psychic Research Society expedition had been six months in the making. The plan was simple. They would hold a seance at the murder sight in the hope of making contact with Charles. Perhaps then the man himself could

Speaker 1reveal who killed him. However, every medium they convinced to take part soon pulled out of the endeavor, unsettled by the thought that they too might become victims of the killer should they succeed in discovering their name. But finally one medium agreed to make the trip. The group powered on through the relentless sleep until about an hour into the mission, with the team barely able to see more than two meters in front of them, the medium called

Speaker 1out for everyone to stop. This was the place, she said. Mister Mills and Bernard Paine, shivering in the colt, looked all around and then back to each other with confusion, But before they could question it, the medium had fallen into a trance. The rest of the team gathered round as she swayed back and forth while the wind howled and whipped at their bodies. Then a strange voice emanated from her lips. It was barely audible at first through

Speaker 1the gale, but soon grew in strength. I forgive, it said, I forgive. I deserved what was coming to me, but not in such a brutal way. Then the medium became suddenly unsteady on her feet. Just as she was about to collapse, two Society members rushed in to catch her, and slowly she came round. The voice was Charles Walton, she said, she was sure of it. Just then the

Speaker 1blizzard began to ease off, and mister Mills shone his torch. About a few meters away. The light bounced back off an old white fence, the fence next to where Walton's body had been discovered. They had been in the right spot after all. With the seance complete, the team spent some time taking photos and collecting soil samples before making the long walk back to their cars. During her apparent trance,

Speaker 1the medium, supposedly channeling the voice of Charles Wharton, was said to have mentioned two names. When Bernard Payne ran them past a local detective some time later, he confirmed that both were relevant to the investigation. The detective was also disturbed by the medium's claim that Charles's apparent spirit had said he had had it coming to him. It reminded him of just how many in the force were convinced that the farm hand had been up to something strange in the lead up to his death. And as

Speaker 1for the samples of soil, from the moment mister Mills brought them home, his family was said to have been beset by constant mishaps. First, his daughter contracted pneumonia three times in quick succession. Then he broke an ankle. Not long after his son was almost killed falling through the loft floor. Later, one morning, mister Mills went into his yard to feed his sixty chickens, only to find that most of them had inexplicably died. Then the small number

Speaker 1of cattle he owned became sick, Mills was left with little doubt that something evil had tainted the soil. When he eventually decided to throw it away, his family's misfortune was said to have ended immediately. Then there were the pictures that were taken at the sight. Mister Mills developed them himself as he had stood in the dark room under that eerie crimson light. He watched patiently as one after another image appeared in the development tray. Most showed

Speaker 1little more than blurry smudges of sleet and the occasional outline of a hedgerow, just visible through the dark. Then another image emerged in the tray, and the hairs on the back of Mills's neck stood up. There was something in the hedge overlooking the precise spot where Charles was slaughtered. To Mills's mind, it looked just like the angry, scowling face of an elderly woman. Some time later, in nineteen sixty,

Speaker 1as part of a renovation of Charles's old house in Lower Quinton, the outhouse in the back garden was knocked down. As one of the builders cleared away the rubble, he spotted something silver glinting among the dust and brick, A silver pocket watch. Whether or not it was Charles Walton's missing watch has never been confirmed. Regardless, no black scrying mirror was found inside its casing. To this day, Me

Speaker 1and Hill and the Rollright Stones remain as shrouded in myth and mystery as they have ever been, while reports of phantom black hounds stalking the area continue to trickle in from time to time. As for the truth about just what exactly happened to Charles Walton, still the oldest unsolved murder in Warwickshire's constabulary records that remains to this day unexplained. This episode was written by Richard mcclin smith,

Speaker 1James Connor Patterson and Emma Dibden. Thank you as ever for listening Unexplained as an Avy Club Productions podcast created by Richard mclin Smith. All other elements of the podcast, including the music, are also produced by me Richard mclin Smith. Unexplained. The book and audiobook is now available to buy worldwide. You can purchase from Amazon, Barnes and Noble, Waterstones and other bookstores. Please subscribe to and rate the show wherever you get your podcasts, and feel free to get in

Speaker 1touch with any thoughts or ideas regarding the stories you've heard on the show. Perhaps you have an explanation or a story of your own you'd like to share. You can find out more at Unexplained podcast dot com and reach us online through X and blue Sky at Unexplained Pod and Facebook at Facebook dot com, Forward Slash Unexplained Podcast.

Speaker 2Met I d be g I d I did oh

Speaker 2h h

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. S03E08: REPEAT INPUT UNTIL END - The Dodleston Messages (RERUN)

    Nov 20, 202632 minAudio

    UNEXPLAINED SEASON 10 BEGINS FRIDAY DECEMBER 4TH In the meantime we’re continuing with our look back at some of your favourite episodes from the vaults. This week we’re venturing back to the autumn of 1984, to the...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. S05E02: The Unceasing Cloud - The Mad Gasser of Botetourt (RERUN)

    Nov 13, 202637 minAudio

    UNEXPLAINED SEASON 10 BEGINS FRIDAY DECEMBER 4TH In 1802, Prussian naturalist Alexander von Humboldt was introduced to guano, a substance made from accumulated bird and bat droppings that had been prized for centuries...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. S05E15: It Came From Above - The Height 611 UFO Incident (RERUN)

    Nov 8, 202629 minAudio

    UNEXPLAINED SEASON 10 BEGINS FRIDAY DECEMBER 4TH In January 1986, a strange object was witnessed crashing into a mountain in a far eastern region of the then Soviet Union. Described by some as Russia's Roswell, analysis...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Unexplained Halloween Special: Night Tales

    Oct 31, 202632 minAudio

    On this week's Night Tales, have we got a story for you. Back in 1975 in a quiet English town, a naked man is found wondering around the neighbourhood covered in blood. But things only get stranger from there. Pull up a...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. S01E04: Where Darkness Plays - The Pontefract Poltergeist (RERUN)

    Oct 30, 202625 minAudio

    UNEXPLAINED SEASON 10 BEGINS FRIDAY NOVEMBER 27TH Fear, it would seem, is a powerful primal emotion. So potent that it can even make us afraid of things that may not even exist. But then again, just because we can't see...

    Credit the people on this episode