Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Unexplained

Unexplained artwork

S09E30: Come, Hear What We Have to Say (The Scole Experiment), 1/2

Aug 7, 202630 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

In the waning years of the twentieth century, a group of researchers decided to finally tackle the great enigma. Namely, does life... do we… ever really end? This is the extraordinary story of the Scole Experiment Group. Written by Neil McRobert and Richard MacLean Smith Watch/follow at youtube.com/@unexplainedpod, tiktok.com/@unexplainedpodcast, X @unexplainedpod, facebook.com/unexplainedpodcast, bsky.app/profile/unexplained.bsky.social, www.unexplainedpodcast.com

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Speaker 1Hello, and welcome to Unexplained with me your host Richard mclin smith, where each week we explore another true tale of high strangeness. If you're new here and you're a fan of expertly told atmospheric stories about the strange and unexplained, then you've come to the right place, and please subscribe to the show if you haven't already done so. I'm very excited to be taking Unexplained to the Edinburgh Fringe Festival this year. I'll be performing at the Space's Surgeon's Hall venue at ten o five pm every night from

Speaker 1August seventh to the twenty ninth, except for the sixteenth and twenty third. You can get tickets at the Space UK dot com. Forward Slash shows Forward Slash twenty twenty six, Forward Slash Unexplained hyphen Live. For those watching on YouTube, you can find the link below. With all that out of the way, this is Unexplained, Season nine, Episode thirty, Come hear what we have to say, Part one. In

Speaker 1the late nineteenth and early twentieth century, a new phenomenon sparked across the English speaking world. Spiritualism, the belief that something of the person remains after death and more crucially still, that we the living can communicate with them. To some it was seen as a social movement. Others considered it a religion, but either way it fundamentally altered the way in which Western society reflected on humanity's place in the

Speaker 1material and immaterial world. The founding philosophies of spiritualism are commonly attributed to a pair of earlier eighteenth century theorists, a Manual Swedenborg and Franz Mesmer. Swedenborg, a Swedish polymath and expert in a wide array of natural and philosophical sciences, is perhaps best known for his book Heaven and Hell, in which he outlined his thoughts on the afterlife. For Swedenborg, when you die, you don't go straight to heaven or Hell. Instead,

Speaker 1it was his belief that you first passed through and in between plates he called the world of spirits. This is where your true character is revealed to all, or rather your hidden drive, as he put it, not the facade perhaps that you project to the world, but your most natural moralistic impulses, which, in theory, has been solidified over time through the choices you made in life. For example, in life you might have pretended to be virtuous and polite,

Speaker 1but all the while were in fact being driven by more selfish goals. Swedenborg called this hidden drive a person's ruling love. It was his belief that death strips away the body's ability to disguise, and rather than being judged by God for their worthiness to enter Heaven or be banished to Hell, individuals instead will have an instinctive feeling about where they prefer to be. In this way, as Swedenborg had it, those ruled by selfishness and greed will

Speaker 1naturally gravitate to Hell, while those ruled by love for God and others will gravitate to heaven. According to Swedenborg, this choice is also partly driven by how an individual responds to the light of divine truth that illuminates all of Heaven when they first see it. Those he would label as good feel comforted and warmed by the light, but those he would describe as evil can't stand it and naturally prefer the murky light of Hell. In Swedenborg's interpretation,

Speaker 1heaven is active and ordered, full of people with jobs, relationships, and marriages. Their happiness comes from being useful and connected to others. Hell, meanwhile, isn't all fire and brimstone, but simply a place full of selfish people, endlessly playing out the intractability of a whole society built on nothing but self interest. Swedenborg knew all this because he'd seen it in a vision. German doctor Franz Mesmer, on the other hand,

Speaker 1had no fervent belief in the hereafter, but instead contributed his practice of Mesmerism or hypnosis as it is otherwise known, which he claimed could facilitate a ready state of communication with higher spiritual planes. Together, the work of these two men built the scaffolding upon which the following century's spiritualist obsession would be staged. Unlike most organic social trends, the

Speaker 1birth of modern spiritualism can be pinpointed to a specific date and place, March thirty first, eighteen forty eight, in Hydesville, a small town in eastern upstate New York. It was there that two young girls named Kate and Margaret Fox claim to have made contact with the spirit of a murdered man, who apparently told the tale of his violent end through a sequence of rapping noises in response to the girl's yes or no questions. The story quickly spread

Speaker 1and the Fox Sisters became a sensation for decades. They toured the US and abroad, putting on shows of mediumship to rapped audiences, and though controversy and suspicion stalked their careers, and despite a short and soon retracted admission that the rappings were actually the cracking of their toes, the Fox Sisters were heralded as pioneers of the movement. Adherents of spiritualism were widespread and often prestigious. Famous mediums, including the

Speaker 1Fox Sisters, were hosted at the White House to perform seances for no less than the then President of the United States himself, Abraham Lincoln and his wife, Mary Todd. Both the President and his wife were deep in mourning over the loss of their son, and spiritualism offered a tenuous hope that perhaps their severance need not be total. That yearning for connection with the lost fueled the wholesale explosion of spiritualism in years marred by lethal conflict, the

Speaker 1American Civil War drove thousands to consult mediums in a desperate attempt to reach their lost sons, brothers, husbands, and friends. Over in Europe, the carnage of the First World war had an equal effect. By the turn of the twentieth century, its claimed that over eight million people identified as followers of them movement. Various spiritualist societies either came into being or grew in stature in the post war years, attracting

Speaker 1such luminaries as the biologist Alfred Russell Wallace, physicist William Crooks, famed inventor Thomas Edison, and Nobel laureate Pierre Curie. Perhaps the most famous pillar of rationality to be ured by the seance parlor was the writer Arthur Conan Doyle. After losing his son Kingsley to pneumonia in the final days of the First World War, Doyle threw himself zealously into spiritualist pursuits, an emotional obsession seemingly at odds with the calculated,

Speaker 1grounded shrewdness of his most famous creation, Sherlock Holmes. These men and women of reason attempted to apply the scientific method to the practices of spiritualism, investigating the many supposed manifestations of connection with the other side, from table turning to inexplicable noises and seemingly impossible knowledge, and even the emanation of ectoplasm. It all seems rather quaint now looking

Speaker 1back at those nineteenth century spiritualists caught a little off guard, perhaps by a world that began to change far more rapidly than it ever had done before, in which old grand narratives were fraying from the friction of exhilarating, terrifying modernity. Seen through this lens, spiritualism and mediumship could perhaps be dismissed as an archaic absurdity, a set of dusty eccentrics coming together to expunge their grief, or cling to the

Speaker 1numinous like a life raft, as all previous beliefs seemed to be dissolving around them. For the most part, perhaps it was merely the stuff of fiction, of bad theater and hammi Christmas ghost stories. But even as modernity reigned and technology improved, the questions underpinning spiritualism never went away. Is there such a thing as the spirit? If so, where does it go when the body dies? And is

Speaker 1it possible to bridge the divide? Thus, in the waning years of the twentieth century, in a world on the cusp of yet more radical change, a group of researchers decided to finally tackle the great enigma together they descended on a small village in the southeast of England, and over the next five years would commit to one of the most thorough and compelling studies of the boundary between our tangible, quantifiable world and whatever lies beyond it. Their

Speaker 1experiences and the apparent evidence they collected has the potential to shake the most fundamental assumption of life and consciousness, namely, does it do we ever really end? You're listening to Unexplained and I'm Richard McLean Smith. It's October nineteen ninety

Speaker 1three in Skull, a sleepy village in a southern corner of Norfolk in the southeast of England. Down in the cellar of Street Farmhouse, a room no larger than five feet by ten three people sit in darkness, huddled around a small circular table, while outside, a chill wind whistles across the low wide landscape. Robin Foy is the co owner of the property and the de facto leader of the group. Ordinarily, he would have been joined by his

Speaker 1wife Sandra, but having endured an especially uncable visit to the dentist earlier that day, she has decided to retire to bed. Diana and Alan Bennett are the other two present that day. The Bennetts are a middle aged couple who live with their four children on a farm in the depths of the Norfolk countryside. All three were bands of soft fluorescent light around their wrists, providing just enough light to illuminate the strange metal cone on the table

Speaker 1before them. It's a spirit trumpet, a device that is said to be able to amplify sounds coming from beyond the veil. Hidden in the darkness around them is also a tape recorder and two microphones angled toward the table. At Robin's nod, Diana hits record on the tape player, and then they begin Infinite Spirit. Robert in tones, creative Source of all things, be with us this evening and

Speaker 1guide us in our work. His words evaporate into the silence as the group waits expectantly in the dark. Then a low, gravelly voice is heard emanating from Diana's mouth. I am manu, it says. Robin, and Allan lean forward, aghast, staring at Diana, who remains completely still with her eyes closed. Then the strange voice comes again. Robin and Allan listen

Speaker 1in wonder as it begins to tell a story. The so called man, who claims to have once lived on earth in what is now South America. Now, however, he is part of a team of beings made up of many thousands of minds from all the realms of existence, and they want to help. We will work with you, continues the so called manu through Diana's body, to provide

Speaker 1tangible evidence of these other realms and to pioneer important methods of communication between them. Then a heavy thud is heard from the table top, as if something had just landed on it, But in the low light cast by their luminescent wristbands, neither Robin nor Allan can make out what it is. We have brought you a gift, says the gravelly voice again, and with that Diana falls silent. When Diana finally comes round from whatever trance like state

Speaker 1she had slipped into, a visibly shaken, Robin jumps up and turns on the lights. Then he stares in astonishment at the table. There lying on top of the unvarnished wood is a coin. It's a Churchill crown, says Robin, confused. Examining it closer, he sees it is in perfect mint condition. Diana and Allan seem equally astounded by its sudden appearance. Or three of them claimed to have never seen it before,

Speaker 1and all agree that it wasn't on the table before the experiment began. Moments later, Sandra Foy, having been roused from sleep by all the commotion, appears at the top of the basement stairs. When Robin shows that the coin, she too is filled with unbridled joy. After weeks and months of spiritual experimentation, they finally have the physical evidence they've been chasing, an inexplicable object and an unknown voice caught on tape. But this was just the beginning. Sandra

Speaker 1and Robin Foy had always been interested in spiritualism. In fact, the pair had even first met at a seance where a medium claiming to be channeling an enter calling itself Doctor Dunn, told them that in the future you will work in a new way, using energy, not ecdoplasm. When the couple later decided to begin trying to investigate spiritual matters together, this message became their guide. What the poise ultimately became interested in was a branch of spiritualism known

Speaker 1as physical psychic phenomena. Unlike mental mediumship, which relies heavily on thoughts, images, and messages being supposedly sent to the living. Physical mediumship is a step beyond in which spiritual forces are instead said to manifest in ways that are more tangible, visible, or audible to onlookers. Seance goers experiencing physical mediumship, for example, may feel a phantom touch. Others may smell out of

Speaker 1place odors like flowers or smoke, or hear sounds which can also be recorded on tape. For over a century, the most well known and extreme form of physical psychic phenomena was ectoplasm, a supposedly physical substance often thought to be a mixture of bodily fluids or plasma that is said to be catalyzed by spiritual energy and then apparently exuded by mediums during a seance. For the Poise, however,

Speaker 1ectoplasm was really just a relic from spiritualism's somewhat more vaudevillian days. They were far more interested in what they termed creative energy. According to the poise, this was a blend of human spirit and earth energy, which they aimed to manipulate in various experiments in order to produce physical evidence of the spirit realm. The Pois knew well that in order to prove the existence of the spirit to the scientific community, they needed to provide evidence that could

Speaker 1be held, weighed, and taken away whole for further examination. They wondered if creative energy could achieve this suitably applied in theory, it would allow for the physical manipulation of atoms and molecules, the very building blocks of what we call reality. It was a bold aim to combine the energies of the living and the spirit world to create something where nothing had been before, and it would require a laboratory. Having identified street farmhouse in the village of

Speaker 1Skull as the perfect place to begin their investigations, the fois immediately began transforming the cellar into the ideal experimental space. First, the cellar was completely light proofed and then repainted a matte navy blue in colour in order to better see the spiritual energy, which the fois believed commonly appeared as inexplicab light. The only way into the room was through a door at the bottom of a creaky wooden staircase,

Speaker 1which left no space for doubt about hidden figures or hoaxes. Breaking in all in all, it was a wholly controlled environment and by February nineteen ninety two it was ready having already established a spiritualist group of their own. The Foys then invited all the members to join them in Skull from that point on to continue their meetings. Among the members of the group was renowned local self described medium Stuart Alexander. Under Alexander's guidance, the group is said

Speaker 1to have met repeatedly for seances at the Foy's new home, where wraps and loud clicks was said to have often been heard coming from the walls. A strange whistle was also said to have been heard on numerous occasions, while strange drops in temperature were frequently reported. As the group's notoriety spread, more curious spiritualists came to the farmhouse. At one time, twenty eight people crammed into the cellar to experience the activity for themselves. But by early spring, the

Speaker 1spasm of activity was petering out, as one session after another continued without result, frustration began to settle over the group. Worse yet, tempers had begun to fray, a disastrous outcome for spiritualist pursuits, which are thought to rely heavily on positive harmony between participants. One night, Alexander even relayed an apparent message from the spirit realm, warning the group that their misaligned energies were barring contact with others in the realm.

Speaker 1One by one, members began to fall away from the group, often citing the difficulty of making the weekly trek to the village. By the end of that summer in ninety nine two, Robin and Sandra were more or less conducting their studies alone, sitting together night after night in a lightless cellar, seemingly unable to conjure even the smallest spiritual phenomena. They had no luck, no data, and no evidence of

Speaker 1any presence beyond their own. At some point, the Foys heard of a woman living in the nearby village of Diss who was looking for like minded people to begin a spiritualist circle with her. Mismy Salisbury was a French businesswoman working for a local engineering company. Bright and scientifically minded,

Speaker 1but with a deep curiosity on the subject of spiritualism. She was the ideal candidate for the Foy's rigorous approach, so the couple got in touch and invited her to join them at the farmhouse on Monday, September twenty first, nineteen ninety two, Mimi arrived at the Foy's home for their first session together. Almost immediately, things began to pick up as they settled into the basement for that first session. A short time later, when Sandra started the audio recorder,

Speaker 1it was with a greater optimism than she felt in months. The Foys believed that singing together helped to galvanize the energy required to perform, and so they began as they always did, by putting on a record. That evening's chosen music was Bring Me Sunshine by the comedy duo morcam and Wise. Then the three of them began to sing along. Almost as soon as the music started, Mimi, Robin and Sandra heard what sounded like the loud click of false teeth.

Speaker 1It came from the air between them. It was the first significant result that the Foys had experienced in months, and they all couldn't help but laugh. Eric Morecambe was famous for his use of chattery teeth in his act, so perhaps they wondered this apparent spirit had a sense of humor. But over the next few days, more serious signals came through. The phenomena seemed to quickly focus on the Foy's bedroom, where loud bangs were said to have

Speaker 1been heard coming from the wall and doors. Then, one night, the couple are said to have been jerked awake from sleep by a loud slap on their head board. Although a little unnerving, the group were keen to continue. However, each agreed that there was little more they could achieve with so few members, and so in order to expand their numbers, the Foys ran a week end retreat at the farmhouse for any one with an interest in the field.

Speaker 1One of the first people they met was Ken Britton, who worked at the headquarters of the National Union of Spiritualists, as well as Ken's friend Burnett Head, a local post office employee. It wasn't long after that when Diana and Alan Bennett came across an advertisement for one of the Foy's retreats in their local newspaper. The Bennetts had been taking part in seances and apparently making contact with the spirits since they were young. Diana and Allan both reported

Speaker 1strange events happening throughout their lives. However, when they mediated together, according to the couple, their ability to interact with the spirit realm intensified. Exponentially. The Foys thought they were perfect. On January fourth, nineteen ninety three, the Skull Experimental Group, as it would come to be known as, for the

Speaker 1first time the atmosphere was one of untrammeled excitement. Unlike the Foy's previous group, riven by frustration, this new collective seemed to fill the Foy's farmhouse cellar with beautiful, harmonious energy. After a few initial sessions to settle in, these improved vibes began to reap dividends. On April twenty sixth, the aluminum Spirit trumpet was said to be knocked from the table by an invisible force. During the following session, the

Speaker 1cellar echoed with loud raps and taps, and the temperature plummeted to what Robin Foyd described as an incredible coldness. Then the trumpet was again seemingly flung by an invisible force, right into Ken Britton's lap. The group made a habit of recording every session. When they played the tape back from this one, it was said to have been filled with white noise. The noise grew continuously louder until the precise second that the trumpet was thrown and then ceased entirely,

Speaker 1almost as if some build up of energy had suddenly been discharged. Throughout the summer of nineteen ninety three, these strange incidents in the cellar continued, with new phenomena continuously added to the mix, with each session conducted in near darkness in order to better focus the energies. As the foise had it, It was said to have been especially thrilling when the lights began to appear. Records of the experiments reference uncanny illuminations that appeared faint at first, before

Speaker 1growing brighter and brighter. Within weeks. What started as flashes of light had apparently coalesced into orbs of varying colours and luminosity. According to the group, these manifestations almost seemed to be intelligent at times, or at least under the guidance of something sentient. The group recorded how orbs would seem to respond to individuals, gliding closer when invited and moving away when asked, even changing direction as if in

Speaker 1response to some authority. On occasion, a thick mist was said to appear. Members of the group also claimed to have been splashed with freezing water, and each reported their clothes and even their bodies being tugged by unseen hands. During this heady period, the group also began to experiment in earnest with trance communication, trying to speak directly to the spirit world through Sandra, who adopted the role of lead medium. However, Sandra quickly began to feel under too

Speaker 1much pressure to perform, and so they asked the spirits to choose someone else to communicate through. It seems that whatever power was apparently present in the cellar it ultimately decided to use Diana and Alan Bennett as its conduits. The Bennetts were seen as the group's most seasoned spiritualist practitioners, but while Diana was familiar with trance mediumship, the method

Speaker 1was new to Allan. At first, he appeared to fight against the incursion as he writhed and spluttered in the dark, seemingly rejecting whatever spirit was trying to communicate through him, until finally he seemed to relax into the role. Primarily, Diana and Allan were supposedly used as vessels for simple communications, but then in October nineteen ninety three, came something else entirely that strange, gravelly voice announcing itself as Manu Manu

Speaker 1would ultimately declare himself the leader or gatekeeper, as the Skull Experiment Group would later put it, of a strange team of spirits made up of thousands of minds from all realms of existence. Together, they were determined to help the Skull Group prove the existence of these other realms. Over the coming months and years, the group would meet the rest of Manu's team. Not only that, but they would apparently work with them, converse with them, and together,

Speaker 1from each side of the veil, the two groups would offer the world some of the most startling insights into the paranormal ever recorded. You'd be listening to part one of Unexplained, Season nine, episode thirty Come Hear what we have to say. The second and final part will be released next Friday, August fourteenth. This episode was written by Neil McRobert and Richard mclin Smith. Please remember to like

Speaker 1and subscribe if you've enjoyed the show. Unexplained as an AV Club Productions podcast created by me Richard McLain Smith. All other elements of the podcast, including the music, are also produced by me. Unexplained. The book and audiobook is now available to buy worldwide. You can purchase from Amazon, Barnes and Noble, Waterstones and other bookstores. Be shorre to follow us on Instagram, TikTok and Facebook at Unexplained Podcast, and on X and Blue Sky at Unexplained Pod. Until

Speaker 1next time, stay strange and dissonant.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. S03E08: REPEAT INPUT UNTIL END - The Dodleston Messages (RERUN)

    Nov 20, 202632 minAudio

    UNEXPLAINED SEASON 10 BEGINS FRIDAY DECEMBER 4TH In the meantime we’re continuing with our look back at some of your favourite episodes from the vaults. This week we’re venturing back to the autumn of 1984, to the...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. S05E02: The Unceasing Cloud - The Mad Gasser of Botetourt (RERUN)

    Nov 13, 202637 minAudio

    UNEXPLAINED SEASON 10 BEGINS FRIDAY DECEMBER 4TH In 1802, Prussian naturalist Alexander von Humboldt was introduced to guano, a substance made from accumulated bird and bat droppings that had been prized for centuries...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. S05E15: It Came From Above - The Height 611 UFO Incident (RERUN)

    Nov 8, 202629 minAudio

    UNEXPLAINED SEASON 10 BEGINS FRIDAY DECEMBER 4TH In January 1986, a strange object was witnessed crashing into a mountain in a far eastern region of the then Soviet Union. Described by some as Russia's Roswell, analysis...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Unexplained Halloween Special: Night Tales

    Oct 31, 202632 minAudio

    On this week's Night Tales, have we got a story for you. Back in 1975 in a quiet English town, a naked man is found wondering around the neighbourhood covered in blood. But things only get stranger from there. Pull up a...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. S01E04: Where Darkness Plays - The Pontefract Poltergeist (RERUN)

    Oct 30, 202625 minAudio

    UNEXPLAINED SEASON 10 BEGINS FRIDAY NOVEMBER 27TH Fear, it would seem, is a powerful primal emotion. So potent that it can even make us afraid of things that may not even exist. But then again, just because we can't see...

    Credit the people on this episode