S09E25: Desert Rain Pt. 1 of 2 (The Disappearance of Daniel Robinson)
31 minAudio
In June 2021, just outside of Phoenix, Arizona, 24-year-old geologist Daniel Robinson, drove off into the desert and was never seen again. What exactly happened to him remains one of the most tragic and beguiling mysteries of recent times. Written by Diane Hope and Richard MacLean Smith. Find us at youtube.com/@unexplainedpod, tiktok.com/@unexplainedpodcast, twitter @unexplainedpod, facebook.com/unexplainedpodcast or www.unexplainedpodcast.com for more info. Thank you for listening.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Speaker 1Hello. I'm hugely excited to reveal that Unexplained will be coming to the Edinburgh Fringe Festival this August. The year is nineteen hundred three. Lighthouse keepers stand watch on a desolate island far from home, until one day they completely vanish from the face of the earth. Unexplained Life brings the haunting Flannanal's mystery to the stage in a gripping, immersive performance that plunges audiences into one of history's most chilling and enduring unsolved disappearances. I'll be performing at the Space at Surgeons Hall at ten oh five pm every
Speaker 1night from August seventh to the twenty ninth, excluding the sixteenth and twenty third. Please go to Unexplained podcast dot com Forward Slash Events for more information, or you can purchase tickets direct by going to the Space UK dot com Forward Slash Shows, Forward Slash twenty twenty six, Forward Slash Unexplained hyphen Life. I look forward to seeing you there.
Speaker 1The man rolled the window down and gazed out from the driver's seat of his suv and the wide desert vista spread out before him. Although it was only just after nine in the morning, the mercury was already well into the eighties. It might even have been hotter were it not for the scattering of clouds that had brought a recent run of much needed rain to the area. It was June twenty third, twenty twenty one, and the man Ken Elliott was waiting for a colleague to join him to inspect a borehole that had just been made
Speaker 1for a water well intended to serve a new residential development just to the west of the White Tank Mountains near Phoenix, Arizona. All Ken could see for miles ahead of him was the bare, bleached soil of the vast Sonoran Desert and its scattering of pebbles, cacti, and brittle bush. The occasional spindly pallo verde and twisted ironwood could be seen, too, stirring along the bottom of the many dry washes that traversed the undulating, desicated terrain. Ken breathed in the deep,
Speaker 1musky scent of creosoap bush as it wafted in through the window of his car. Finally, he saw a blue Jeep Renegade driving slowly toward him along the bumpy desert track. Ken climbed out of his vehicle and prepared to meet the jeep's driver as he pulled up next to him. As Daniel Robinson slid out of his jeep, Ken took in the athletic but slight twenty four year old man with his close cropped hair, blue jeans and check shirt, and orange hi Ve's vest just like his own. This
Speaker 1would be the one and only time the two men would meet. After Daniel Robinson drove off a little later that morning, he would never be seen again. You're listening to Unexplained and I'm Richard McLean Smith. As Ken and Daniel greeted each other, Ken noticed that the young man was missing the lower part of his right forearm. A native of South Carolina, Daniel Cornelius Robinson had been born
Speaker 1without a right hand and the lower part of his arm, but refused to use a prosthetic or to let it impact his life in any way. Some say it was exactly that attitude which helped him excel in athletics during his time as a student at the College of Charleston in South Carolina. Daniel would go on to graduate in twenty seventeen with a degree in geology. Described by his family as bright and adventurous, Daniel had relocated to Arizona the previous year after taking a job as a hydrogeologist
Speaker 1with a company called Matrix New World. The environmental engineering company was involved in a number of projects out west, including this one to test and develop water sources to supply the ever growing urban fringes of Phoenix. Daniel and Ken were meeting to assess a new well sight. No sooner had Daniel arrived, a heavy storm moved in. It was so intense they could feel the static in the air, so for a while, fearing an imminent lightning strike, the
Speaker 1two men sat in Ken's car as they waited for the rain to pass. Despite this being their first meeting, Ken couldn't help but think there was something off with Daniel. The men talked amiably as the heavy rain splattered the windscreen, but every so often Daniel seemed to pull back, then turned to look out at the window and stare out at the desert. It was around nine point forty five when Daniel abruptly asked Ken if he wanted to go back to Phoenix. Ken assumed he meant it in the
Speaker 1sense of whether it was worth waiting any longer for the rain to end, so He told Daniel to wait a moment as he pulled up a weather app to find out when it was due to stop, but no sooner had he done so. Without saying a word, Daniel opened the door and got out of the car. Ken watched with confusion as Daniel ambled back over to his jeep, then turned to give Ken a brief wave before climbing into his vehicle and driving off. Startled by the sudden departure,
Speaker 1Ken could only look on as the jeep made its way back down the dirt road and disappeared out of sight. Though his view of the vehicle was obscured by the terrain, Ken knew that in just two thousand feet Daniel would come to a spot where the road split. There he could either turn to the east and head back towards the city, or west and out into the wide Sonoran desert. Laughing it off, Ken called his boss to fill him in on the unexpected turn of events, then shifted his
Speaker 1car into gear and drove off himself. When Ken reached the split in the dirt road, he saw the rain had washed away all but the most recent set of tire tracks, those belonging to Daniel's jeep. Much to his surprise, they didn't turn east toward Phoenix, but west into the vast expanse of the desert. Around mid afternoon, Ken's boss
Speaker 1phone to ask if he'd spoken to Daniel at all since they last met. No one at the company had heard from him since the morning. Ken cast his mind back to their meeting earlier and how distant Daniel had seemed when they spoke. He began to get worried. A short time later, Ken was back in his truck, heading out to the well site where he and Daniel had met earlier that day. Scrambling up to a high vantage point, he stared out long and hard across the desert, but
Speaker 1saw no sign of Daniel or his vehicle. By late afternoon, Daniel's family were becoming concerned. Although Daniel was adventurous, he also kept in frequent contact with his family, typically calling or testing his father and siblings several times a day, especially his sister Davisha, who also lived in the Phoenix area. It just wasn't like him to suddenly go quiet. A little after seven that night, with no one in the
Speaker 1family having heard from Daniel in twenty four hours, his father, army veteran David Robinson phoned the Buckeye Police Department from his home in South Carolina and reported his son as missing. The police report filed that evening was characteristically blunt and to the point. Twenty four year old Daniel Robinson, it read, is black with short hair, missing his right arm and has no prosthetic, no visible tattoos, no facial hair, no
Speaker 1medical issue, but has been acting strain. The father last heard from his son yesterday. This morning, he met someone at a job site. No one has heard from him since. The police began their search by attempting to call Daniel on his cell phone, but no one picked up. Then they called his employer, Matrix New World, who yet to hear from him and had little to add to what was already known. That evening, Daniel's sister d Visha went to his apartment in Tempe in Central Phoenix, but the
Speaker 1windows were dark and there was no sign of Daniel, nor was his jeep Renegade parked outside. At that point, all the police had to go on was Ken Elliott's account from when Daniel was last seen and the coordinates to the work site where he and Daniel had met. The spot is surrounded by nothing but desert and ranchland, with the dry bed of the Hassiampa River just over a mile to the west. The nearest settlement was about eight miles further west, out in the desert, in the
Speaker 1direction that Daniel had last been seen heading. It was the fenced compound of the Our Lady of Solitude Monastery, a small, enclosed community of contemplative nuns. The same day Daniel was reported missing, two officers from the Buckeye Police Department drove out to where Daniel and Ken had met
Speaker 1that morning, as a red setting sun sent slanting rays across the desert. They drove the surrounding dirt trails for four hours until well after dark, but found no trace of Daniel or his vehicle. The following morning, the police quizzed Daniel's father, David, about his son's state of mind. David insisted there being nothing in his recent phone call with his son to suggest that he was suicidal or wanted to hurt himself. As for drug abuse or other
Speaker 1addiction issues, David said Daniel had no such problem with anything like that, but smoked marijuana from time to time, which was legal in Arizona. David Robinson did say, however, that his son had been acting a little odd lately. Daniel's shifting mood, according to his father, seemed to coincide with his meeting of a woman that he'd apparently fallen in love with, but when David questioned his son about the woman, he didn't seem to know much about her.
Speaker 1The police asked Daniel's father to check his son's social media for any clues. There, he found a link to an Instagram account of someone named Caitlin, displaying a profile picture of a young woman with straight, dark hair, smiling at the camera and holding a dog. But then David noticed something strange. Not only were there no new hosts on Daniel's account, but all the photos on his Instagram and Facebook accounts had been completely removed. About the same time,
Speaker 1police interviewed Daniel's sister, Davisha too. She conferred that Daniel had lived alone in an apartment in Tempe for the last year. When asked if there been any change in his usual character in the last few months or weeks, Davisha couldn't help reflecting on one of the last times she'd seen him, he'd asked to come to her place, but when he arrived, he just sat there for half an hour without saying anything, before simply getting up and walking out of the apartment. Her brother had told her
Speaker 1too that he'd recently met a woman and was in love with her. She couldn't confirm if they were actually in a relationship, but the way Daniel talked about her, she suggested that perhaps they were. Curiously, Daniel told his sister that the woman had introduced him to a podcast, which he claimed had profoundly changed the way he looked at life. Da Visha didn't have the woman's contact details, but remembered Daniel mentioning that she lived in Lavigne, on the west side of Phoenix. While Buckeye Police conducted a
Speaker 1ground search near the well site where Daniel was last seen, one officer checked you Connect, a vehicle tracking system that Daniel's jeep had supposedly been linked to, but the GPS coordinates for the vehicle were all set to zero. The reason for this could be due to one of three things. Either the system application had not been properly updated in the vehicle, the jeep battery had gone dead, or someone had tampered with the system. An attempt to ping Daniel's
Speaker 1cell phone for its location was also unsuccessful. Meanwhile, a separate search was initiated to try and track down the mysterious Kate Lie. Incredibly, thanks to the Arizona motor vehicle records, a woman was soon found matching her description. When the police eventually got hold of her, she was sorry to hear that Daniel was missing, but she hadn't heard from him either. Then she explained how she knew him in the first place. It was back on Saturday, June twelfth,
Speaker 1and the so called Valley of the Sun was living up to its name. There wasn't a cloud in the sky as the urban sprawl of Phoenix shimmered under a smoggy heat haze. It was the first day the city had reached one hundred and ten degrees fahrenheit that year, and an excessive heat warning had been issued by the authorities. Caitlin and a friend of hers were hanging out at Caitlyn's home in Levigne, on the western edge of the city. They were doing what many people did on days like this, staying inside with the air conditioning on, watching TV, and drinking.
Speaker 1The temperature barely dropped as darkness fell, and neither woman fell motivated to go out to eat so they ordered a takeout. About half an hour later, the doorbell rang and Caitlyn got up to answer it. She opened the door to find a smiling, friendly faced young man holding their delivery items. He told Caitlyn that his name was Daniel. He had a warm smile and a bright demeanor, so, feeling somewhat tipsy, Caitlyn invited the man to come inside and hang out with her and her friend. The three
Speaker 1shared the food and drank some more. Then, when Daniel eventually left, he and Caitlyn shared phone numbers. Sometime after two a m. Caitlyn sent Daniel a text with a link to a podcast on spirituality that she suggested he listened to. She thought no more of the encounter until a day or so later, when Daniel texted her that he'd accidentally left his shade canopy for his car at her place. He wanted to know when he could come over and get it. It was Monday, June fourteenth, the
Speaker 1day after Daniel left her apartment, that Caitlyn received the first text message, Hey, I accidentally left my canopy outside your house. Is it still there? If so, is it okay if I pick it up? Also, the podcast was great wrote Daniel. Caitlyn replied the next day, Yes, you can pick it up whenever. Daniel replied soon after that he could come over straight away to get it, or the following day if Caitlin preferred. Caitlyn hadn't yet replied
Speaker 1and was away in Flagstaff when she got an alert on her phone. Her door camera had picked up movement outside her house. Watching back the footage, she was a little surprised to see Daniel at the door. She texted him back, Hi, I saw you on the camera. I'm in Flagstaff and will be home later tonight if you want, and put it out front by the chairs before I head out for work tomorrow morning. Daniel replied an hour later with a red heart emoji, then later that night
Speaker 1with the words I'm sorry. The next day, Caitlin got another alert on her phone while she was out of the flat. It was Daniel at her door again. Feeling a little irked, Caitlyn asked later that evening that he stopped showing up at her door unannounced, to which he replied, okay, I won't ever again. Growing a little tired of the issue, Caitlyn went out to the garage to have a look for the canopy, but couldn't find it anywhere. I don't
Speaker 1see it in the garage, she texted Daniel moments later. But Daniel, it seemed, had already been in the garage and found it for himself. I already have it, he replied. I just wanted to tell you I'm sorry for disappearing the other day, he said, then with a sad face emoji. Then moments later he sent another text, I couldn't stop thinking about you. Caitlyn didn't know what to say to that. She thought perhaps not replying at all might be the
Speaker 1best thing to do, hoping that Daniel might get the message. A few days later, Daniel texted again, can we hang out? Having at first felt irritated by Daniel's unwanted advances, Caitlin was now starting to feel harassed. Having told him she wasn't free to hang out. Daniel had replied simply, okay. It seemed perhaps that that might be the end of it.
Speaker 1Then later that night, just after midnight, he sent another message, I love you, it read again. Caitlyn didn't quite know how to respond to that, so once more she opted not to reply. The following morning, Daniel sent another message to ask if Caitlyn was at home. In an effort to get him to back off, she decided to be straight with him. Honestly, you showing up at my house unannounced made me extremely uncomfortable. I don't see his hanging
Speaker 1out anytime soon, she wrote at three point thirty six pm. Later that day, Daniel wrote back, I'm outside of your place.
Speaker 2Now.
Speaker 1Feeling increasingly anxious, Caitlyn tried again to get him to back off, telling him it wasn't okay to keep turning up at her house when she expressly told him not to. Do you hate me, Daniel replied later, I don't hate you, said Caitlyn clearly at the end of her tether, but please leave me alone. There was one last text from Daniel the following day. It came on Tuesday, twenty second of June, at three oh seven pm. The world can
Speaker 1get better, but I'll have to take all the time I can, or we can, whatever to name it. I'll either see you again or never see you again. The very next day, Daniel went missing. Two days after his disappearance, on Friday, June twenty fifth, the Buckeye Police carried out another ground search around the site where Daniel had last been seen, while a police helicopter conducted a much wider search from the air, but still nothing was found. Daniel
Speaker 1Robinson had been missing for just over a week when on Wednesday, June thirtieth, a detective was finally assigned to the case. Larry Biffin was a decorated officer who'd served for many years with the Buckeye Police Department. As Biffin poured over the case notes, he couldn't help but be puzzled by the whole thing. Having seen that all Daniel's Instagram posts had been deleted, he began by making a request to the social media company to return them, and set about getting in touch with all of Daniel's contacts.
Speaker 1A friend of Daniel's name Antonio, had a seventeen minute phone call with Daniel on June sixteenth, the first day he'd gone to Caitlyn's house unannounced. Antonio said that his friend seemed more hyper than usual and talked about two girls he'd met while working as a delivery driver. Daniel said that he'd hooked up with one of the girls. Antonio commented that although very social, Daniel hadn't made many friends since moving to Arizona and could at times be
Speaker 1quite gullible, implying that Daniel may have read more into the encounter than the woman intended. Another friend, Ruben, spoke with Daniel just after he'd texted Caitlin for the last time on the twenty second. They only spoke for five minutes. Reuben, who lived in Florida, was excited about a vacation He was planning to Arizona and California and was looking forward to catching up with his friend. He was disappointed when Daniel didn't seem to want to talk about his visit.
Speaker 1He said his friend appeared to be down, preoccupied, and off somehow. After gaining access to Daniel's apartment, Detective Biffin found no obvious indications of foul play or any sign that Daniel had packed for a trip, since most of his possessions were still there. Biffin then had flyers placed at the two small local airports in the Buckeye area, asking for any crew flying in and out to keep a lookout for Daniel and his vehicle. Then he raised
Speaker 1for another air search to be conducted over the region where Daniel had last been seen. In the early morning of Friday, July ninth, It was already ninety four degrees fahrenheit when Detective Biffin strode out across the baking Aspha at the junction of some Valley Parkway and Cactus Road and shook hands with Daniel's father, David Robinson. Mister Robinson had driven all the way from South Carolina to Phoenix the day after he learned of his son's disappearance, and
Speaker 1had been there ever since. He was frantic with worry and had already undertaken several searches of the desert himself, helped by local volunteers, with no result. Daniel's father could only watch as the two search planes traversed the sky back and forth while the thermometer climbed steadily to one hundred and six fahrenheit. But the search crew found nothing, and nor did they the following day when another plane was sent up to help. It had been over two
Speaker 1weeks now and not one shred of evidence to where Daniel Robinson had gone had been found. Having grown tired of the police's seeming in ability to locate his son, David Robinson hired a private detective named Jeffrey McGrath to undertake a separate investigation on his behalf ten days later, on Monday, nineteenth of July, a rancher spotted something at
Speaker 1the bottom of a ravine on his land. Getting out of his truck to investigate further, he saw then it was a badly damaged blue jeep that had rolled on to its passenger side. When he called the police to report it, a quick check on the number plate confirmed it with Daniel's jeep. A short time later, Detective Larry Biffin was making his way out to the site with the team of officers in tow. Their route took them out beyond the urban sprawl of Phoenix and into the dusty,
Speaker 1sun bleached desert beyond. The further out they went, the smaller the roads became, until eventually they found themselves in the foothills of the White Tank Mountains, heading west along a narrow dirt track cresting the top of a rise. Biffin and his entourage finally arrived at the top of the ravine, and there at the bottom of it was Daniel's jeep. Biffin got out of his car and slipped down into the ravine to get a better look. The
Speaker 1vehicle's front bumper had crumpled where it had hit the dirt. The driver's window was shattered and the windscreen and roof were damaged to All of the interior airbags had been deployed, but there was no sign of Daniel inside. Then Biffin found something unexpected About three feet from the wreckage. Gathered in a messy pile was what he assumed to be most, if not all, the clothes Daniel had been wearing when he disappeared. It included a pair of jeans, a pair
Speaker 1of brown work boots, a faded orange high viz vest bearing the Matrix New World Company low so Go, as well as a T shirt and a pair of socks. Examining the genes, Biffin found a wallet in the back pocket. Pulling it out, he found Daniel's ID inside it, along with multiple debit and credit cards, but no cash. Despite the substantial damage the vehicle had sustained, there was nothing to indicate that the driver had been injured at all.
Speaker 1As Biffin inspected the jeep's interior more closely, he found Daniel's cell phone, the keys to the vehicle and his apartment, as well as a backpack containing his laptop and some documents. There were other miscellaneous items, two more clothing, a basketball, and quite a few unopened bottles of water. The detective straightened back up, not quite knowing what to think. It was certainly strange, he thought how they'd searched the area
Speaker 1multiple times but not spotted the jeep despite it being fairly out in the open. And something else bugged him about it too. It seemed unusually clean for a vehicle that had supposedly crashed out there almost four weeks previously. As Detective Biffin stared down at the wreckage, he was joined by the rancher who'd found the vehicle in the first place. He too was perplexed as to how the
Speaker 1jeep had lain there undetected for such a long time, and just like Detective Biffin, even with the recent monsoon rains, he couldn't, for the life of him, understand how a vehicle exposed to four weeks of desert, wind, sand and dust appeared so clean. When officers searched the area around the vehicle, there was nothing to suggest that Daniel had spent any time at the site. There were no empty water bottles, for example, and no footprints appeared to lead
Speaker 1away from the vehicle. In the end, finding Daniel's jeep seemed to only raise more questions than it had answers. Detective Biffin gazed at Daniel's upturn hard hat lying in the bottom of the ruined vehicle, now filled with rain water, then looked up and out at the vastness of the desert stretched out before him. Was Daniel Robinson dead or alive? If he was dead, why couldn't they find his body?
Speaker 1And if he was alive, then where on earth was he? You've been listening to Unexplained Season nine, episode twenty five, Desert Rain, Part one. The second and final part, will be released next Friday, June the eleventh. This episode was written by Diane Hope and Richard McLain smith. Thank you as ever for listening Unexplained as an Avy Club Productions
Speaker 1podcast created by Richard McClain smith. All other elements of the podcast, including the music, are also produced by me Richard McClain smith. Unexplained. The book and audiobook is now available to buy worldwide. You can purchase from Amazon, Barnes and Noble, Waterstones and other bookstores. Please subscribe to and rate the show wherever you get your podcasts, and feel free to get in touch with any thoughts or ideas regarding the stories you've heard on the show. Perhaps you
Speaker 1have an explanation or a story of your own you'd like to share. You can find out more at Unexplained podcast dot com and reach us online through X and Blue Sky at Unexplained Pod and Facebook at Facebook dot com. Forward Slash Unexplained Podcast.
UNEXPLAINED SEASON 10 BEGINS FRIDAY DECEMBER 4TH In the meantime we’re continuing with our look back at some of your favourite episodes from the vaults. This week we’re venturing back to the autumn of 1984, to the...
UNEXPLAINED SEASON 10 BEGINS FRIDAY DECEMBER 4TH In 1802, Prussian naturalist Alexander von Humboldt was introduced to guano, a substance made from accumulated bird and bat droppings that had been prized for centuries...
UNEXPLAINED SEASON 10 BEGINS FRIDAY DECEMBER 4TH In January 1986, a strange object was witnessed crashing into a mountain in a far eastern region of the then Soviet Union. Described by some as Russia's Roswell, analysis...
On this week's Night Tales, have we got a story for you. Back in 1975 in a quiet English town, a naked man is found wondering around the neighbourhood covered in blood. But things only get stranger from there. Pull up a...
UNEXPLAINED SEASON 10 BEGINS FRIDAY NOVEMBER 27TH Fear, it would seem, is a powerful primal emotion. So potent that it can even make us afraid of things that may not even exist. But then again, just because we can't see...