In 1968, Margaret O'Brien moved into a crumbling hunting lodge outside Dublin, hoping to fill it with artists. Instead she found herself at the mercy of terrifying forces beyond her control, and at the centre of it all, one strange, unnerving black cat, that some believed was not of this world... Watch/follow at youtube.com/@unexplainedpod, tiktok.com/@unexplainedpodcast, X @unexplainedpod, facebook.com/unexplainedpodcast, bsky.app/profile/unexplained.bsky.social, www.unexplainedpodcast.com
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Speaker 1Hello, and welcome to Unexplained, where each week we explore another true tale of high strangeness. With me, your host, not an AI, Richard McLean-Smith. If you're new here and you're a fan of expertly told, atmospheric stories about the strange and unexplained, then you've come to the right place. And please subscribe to the show if you haven't already done so. With the Edinburgh Festival out of the way, next up I'll be appearing at London's CrimeCon on the 3rd and 4th of October. If you haven't been, it's
Speaker 1a fantastic programme of all things true crime related, with special attention given to survivors of crime. I'll be at a table for the duration of the convention and also telling a story in the podcaster's studio. The event will take place in East London at 133 Houndsditch. That's again on October the 3rd and 4th. You can go to crimecon.co.uk to get tickets and use code unexplained for 10% off. Come along and say hello. I'd love to see you there. Now,
Speaker 1with all that out of the way, this is Unexplained, Season 9, Episode 34. Nine Lives. The Black Cat has many faces. In ancient Egypt, cats, black or otherwise... were said to have been so sacred that if a house caught fire, residents and onlookers would be more inclined to
Speaker 1form a line around the building to stop cats running into the flames instead of trying to put the fire out. In Scotland, a black cat appearing suddenly at your door was a lucky sign said to signal the imminent arrival of wealth and prosperity. While along stretches of the Yorkshire coast in England, black cats were thought to be so lucky that fishermen's wives were said to keep a black cat in the house specifically to help keep their husbands safe at sea. Meanwhile, throughout medieval mainland Europe, thanks largely
Speaker 1to a strange document that began circulating in 1233, things were a little different. Written by Pope Gregory IX, the document described a sacrilegious and salacious satanic rite that he claimed was being conducted all over the continent. At one point during the rite, the devil himself is said to appear to his followers in the shape of a black cat. In the centuries that followed, the black cat became synonymous
Speaker 1with witches and the work of the devil, the archetypal demonic familiar, where even just the ownership of one might have you condemned as a witch. It is said that Pope Gregory's decree led to the slaughter of thousands of cats across the continent by terrified acolytes, convinced they were the devil in human form. The black cat has many faces. In Japan, the black maneki neko, or welcoming cat, is
Speaker 1widely venerated and trusted to ward off evil. And yet, between 1943 to 1944, the phrase black cat simultaneously became something that struck terror into the hearts of all Japanese sailors stationed in the Pacific, During that time, the US Navy's PBY Black Cat squadrons painted black specifically to avoid detection in the night, unleashed hell on Japanese warships, killing
Speaker 1hundreds in the process. The Black Cat has many faces. In November of 1968, at just 20 years old, Fred Hampton founded the Chicago chapter of the Black Panther Party. and quickly became one of its most galvanizing voices. A young man, widely regarded by many Americans as a positive, energizing force in the righteous fight for racial equality. Just over a year later, on December 4th, 1969, a then
Speaker 121-year-old Fred Hampton was murdered in cold blood in a raid coordinated between the Chicago police and the FBI. The raid was part of a wider campaign led by J. Edgar Hoover, who was terrified of this black cat and all that he represented. The black cat has many faces. Around the same time, entirely unrelated and thousands of miles away, on the outskirts of Dublin, Ireland, a place, incidentally, that
Speaker 1is no stranger to political violence and the cause of those who some might call freedom fighters, others terrorists, Another black cat is about to make itself known. You're listening to Unexplained, and I'm Richard McLean-Smith. Margaret O'Brien was not by disposition a woman given to fancy. Her husband Nicholas
Speaker 1had spent his career as a superintendent in Ireland's police force, Garda Sheer Corner. and Margaret carried something of that same practical temperament with her. What drew the two of them to the old steward's house was not legend so much, for it was not short of those, as the building itself. It was a fifteen-room rubble stone mansion built in the 1760s. It had an open courtyard, a stable block gone soft with moss, and a small stone bell tower that had
Speaker 1long since stopped calling anyone to anything. all surrounded by a dense forest of pine, seven miles south of Dublin, in the foothills of the Wicklow Mountains. The place was called Quiller Caywk, the Blind Man's Wood, which in time would also become known as Killer Quay, and in 1968 it was still a genuinely remote stretch of country. Out there, in the rolling hedge and heather-covered hills, beyond the clutches
Speaker 1of the city, The silence at night speaks less of quietness and more of what might lay hidden in the surrounding darkness. It's the kind of landscape that people like to describe as having a memory of its own, and whether or not that means anything, given the context of all that had happened there, it wouldn't be surprising if this particular corner of it held onto something that other fields and hillsides didn't. There were of course the tangible things, like the five IRA soldiers who are said to have
Speaker 1been shot dead on the estate in the early 20th century, and how the occupiers of the estate fluctuated between those opposed to their cause and those somewhat sympathetic, and how such divisions can scar a land far deeper than any grave can be dug. But there were intangible things too, things said to be glimpsed in shadow or moving out of the corner of the eye. For the O'Briens, It was simply a question of practicality. Margaret wanted to do
Speaker 1something for the nation's artist community, who she felt lacked sufficient support from the government, and so she set about trying to find a place where painters, sculptors and musicians could all come together to create and exhibit their work. The half-ruined old steward's house was perfect. That first year, Margaret dedicated herself to bringing the place back to life.
Speaker 1Damp plaster was stripped back to stone, doors that had become swollen in their frames were replaced, and electricity coaxed into rooms that hadn't held a lightbulb in decades. But somewhere along the line, some in the surrounding community of Killikey began to mention things to her. Unspecific things at first, just a feeling they had about the place. Some pointed out how it had once been the site of an old cairn, an ancient grave, that should never have been disturbed.
Speaker 1In fact, some of its old stones had been used in the construction of the building. And then one day, someone half-jokingly mentioned the strange black cat that was said to visit from time to time. One afternoon, Margaret was alone in the garden when she noticed a shape at the edge of the undergrowth. It was quite clearly a black cat, evidently the one she'd been told about, sitting perfectly still at the end of her garden. It was
Speaker 1considerably larger than any cat she had ever seen before. The cat stared at her for a moment, then disappeared back into the ferns. A few days later, elsewhere on the estate, Val McGann stepped out of the trailer he was staying in and stretched in the crisp morning air. McGann was a former Irish pole vault and decathlon champion, but after retiring from sport, he'd become a distinguished landscape painter and had been invited by Margaret to become one
Speaker 1of the first artists to exhibit at her art centre. That morning, he was just heading out to the forest for one of his regular morning walks, when he too caught sight of that peculiar black cat. He later described it as being about the size of a biggish dog with terrible eyes. There was just something about it, he said, that seemed to cut right through you. He became so unnerved by it that he even attempted to hunt it down with a shotgun. but could never quite find it
Speaker 1whenever he went looking. One night, a man unfamiliar with Killikey was walking along a country lane around 10.45pm, having missed a lift back to the city. when that same black cat is said to have appeared suddenly from a house close to the woods. Before he knew what was happening, the cat leapt at him and with loud hisses began
Speaker 1to tear and claw at his face. The man was found shortly after by a local resident, huddled against a gate, bleeding profusely. The man later described the cat as being as big as a terrier dog and as something unnatural that was not of this world. and it seemed many people who lived nearby had their own similar stories. According to them, if you really wanted to understand what that peculiar animal was, you first had to climb Montpelier Hill
Speaker 1that overlooked Margaret's nascent art centre to the strange foreboding ruin at its summit, the other former hunting lodge on the Killarkey estate. Sometime back in the mid-18th century, a young Catholic priest was making his way through Killer Key in the midst of a terrible blizzard. When the snow finally eased, he found himself standing at the foot of a hill he didn't recognise, at the top of which lay a peculiarly squat and foreboding building, with a faint
Speaker 1light spilling from its windows. Eager to be out of the snowstorm, he hastily made his way up the hill toward the light. As he climbed higher, and the property came more clearly into view, he began to hear the sound of laughter and raucous voices coming from inside of it. Thinking only of getting out of the cold, he knocked at the door, but no sooner had his frozen hand touched the wood, the noise inside completely stopped. Then the
Speaker 1door creaked open to reveal a large atrium in which stood maybe fifteen or so men, dimly lit by flickering candlelight. dressed in long black cloaks, with what appeared to be horns fixed to their heads. The figures stood deathly still for a moment, then all suddenly pointed toward the priest and shouted, Woe unto thee, evil spirit! Before the clergyman knew what was happening, the men wrenched him inside with rough,
Speaker 1uncompromising hands and hustled him forward into a large dining hall, laid out for a sumptuous feast and pushed him down into a black wooden chair. As the clergyman struggled to get his bearings, another cloaked figure entered the room, carrying a large black cat on a cushion. The priest could only watch in confusion as the cat was placed with great ceremony at the head of the table, before being
Speaker 1served up a plate of fresh meat and some milk from a bowl. carved into the shape of a human skull. Behind it, barely visible under the flickering of candlelight, hung a huge garish portrait of what the priest then realised to his horror was the devil himself. Suddenly terrified for his life, the young man rose from the chair, seized the cat from its cushion and hurled it across the room at the painting of Satan. The animal screamed as
Speaker 1it clattered into the canvas. before falling to the floor along with the painting in an almighty crash. At this, the priest was quickly seized by the horned figures and tied up with rope. After an impromptu trial, the clergyman was quickly found guilty for the crime of abusing the group's sacred animal and sentenced to death. Unsure if this was all an elaborate game or entirely real, the priest instinctively began to utter the prayer to St Michael the Archangel,
Speaker 1the prayer of exorcism. Then from somewhere out of the shadows, the strange cat began to wail and howl as if being flayed alive, while up above, a vast candle chandelier hanging over the dining table began to sway. Then suddenly it slipped free of its fastenings and came smashing down onto the table. setting fire to the tablecloth and sending the cloaked men scattering for cover. It was then that the priest caught sight of the cat at the back
Speaker 1of the room. Then it began to rise up suddenly and morph into something quite beyond description, before it disappeared straight up through the ceiling, tearing the whole roof from the house as it went. Or so goes one of the many stories that claim to depict just another day in the life of Ireland's infamous Hellfire Club, one of several clubs that borrowed the name and libertine ethos from the original Hellfire Club established in London 17 years earlier.
Speaker 1The group, which mostly comprised of young, rakish aristocrats, gathered regularly in the late hours throughout the 18th century at that strange lodge on top of Montpelier Hill. Quite exactly what took place there has long been the subject of much speculation, and the stories that emerged after its eventual disbandment only grew darker by the year. The number one activity said to take place there, of course, was devil worship.
Speaker 1Usually when the figure of a black cat appeared in stories about the dubious activities of the Hellfire Club, It was portrayed as a proxy for the devil that was treated with great reverence by the group. However, one story tells of a black mass being held by club members in which a black cat was soaked in spirits and burned alive as an offering to the devil instead. Another story tells of a so-called half-wit and person of small
Speaker 1stature with an unusually large head who was said to have been captured by the group before being beaten and suffocated to death, then also offered up as a sacrifice to the devil. His body was said to have been buried somewhere on the estate. And then there was the cannibalism. It is said that in a later iteration of the Hellfire Club, sometime in the early 1800s, some members kidnapped a local farmer's daughter. After torturing her to death, So
Speaker 1the story goes, they cooked what remained of her and ate it among themselves. One day, that lodge on Montpelier Hill burned down. Nobody seems to know exactly how it started. In one story, the Connolly family who owned the building were so disgusted by what their tenants were using it for, they refused to renew the lease, and so the Hellfire members simply burned the building down in revenge. But there
Speaker 1is another version. It says that during a night of drinking, following another of the club's black masses, a footman serving at the table spilled wine across one especially arrogant member's coat. The offended man flew into such a rage at the sight of the stain, he then doused the servant in brandy and set him alight where he stood. The building burned down as the man screamed in agony from room to room. Whatever the truth of how the fire began,
Speaker 1that lodge on Montpelier Hill did burn down, forcing the Hellfire Club to relocate to the old Steward's House below, the same building that two centuries later would become Margaret O'Brien's art centre. According to some, that black cat that had in fact been glimpsed around Killer Key for decades before Margaret and Nicholas arrived wasn't simply an animal that had gone wild and grown large on whatever it found in the woods. It was something left over, a kind
Speaker 1of residue from what had happened on that hillside two centuries before. The enraged spirit of that black cat that had been burned alive, perhaps, or maybe even the very devil himself. For her part, Margaret was too busy with the renovations to pay any mind to the strange stories that were swirling around the estate. But that was until even stranger things began to happen. In March 1968, an
Speaker 1artist named Tom McCassey moved into the property to help Margaret fix it up. One evening, he and two other men were working in the old ballroom, with a portable gas heater by their side to keep them warm. At some point, a freezing cold gust of wind blew through the room, sending the temperature plummeting that no amount of warmth from the heater could displace. When Makassi looked out toward the hallway, he was surprised to see the front door was wide open. Makassi was certain that he'd closed
Speaker 1it when they came in and secured it tightly. with its heavy bolt lock. Then the lights in the hallway are said to have begun to flicker until finally they gave out completely. Plunged into darkness, Makassi suddenly caught sight of a tall figure that was now standing in the open entrance to the house. shrouded in shadow and with no discernible face. Assuming it was just one of the local lads having a laugh with them, Makassi called out
Speaker 1to the figure. I see you, he said. Come inside. To which the strange figure replied, You can't see me. Confused, Makassi stepped forward into the hallway and was just about to say something when the figure emitted a strange gurgling sound Now almost close enough to touch it, Makassi grabbed the front door and slammed it shut, leaving whatever was out there standing on the doorstep. Then he returned, a
Speaker 1little uneasily, to the ballroom. But no sooner had he got there, he felt another rush of cold air and turned to see the front door was open once again. And Sitting Squat, right in the middle of its frame, was a huge black cat. staring him down with bright red eyes. Macassie would later paint a portrait of that very same cat, which remained hanging in the hallway of the Arts Centre for many years, as a warning to
Speaker 1future guests. One afternoon, as work continued on the house, two workmen were entering the ballroom together, when they stopped suddenly at the sight of what they took to be a woman, with her back turned toward them. The figure, which they described as being dressed like a nun, stood eerily still. They asked if they could help her, but the figure didn't budge. The men looked to each other
Speaker 1in confusion, but when they looked back, the figure had gone. When more workers came forward with their own strange stories, Margaret said, fearing her project might capitulate before it had begun, felt she had little choice but to seek the help of the local church. Eventually, one priest agreed to exercise the building, and at first it seemed to do the trick. For the better part of a year, no more peculiar events occurred, and Margaret's art centre began to flourish, just
Speaker 1as she'd hoped. But by then, there were few who visited the centre who didn't know something of its supposedly haunted reputation. In October 1969, journalist and songwriter Shea Healy, singer Danny Doyle and comedian Noel Ginnity were staying together at the property. One night, after a few glasses of wine, one of the group suggested they try to contact whatever it was that was said to be living there. Letters
Speaker 1and numbers were hastily scrawled onto a piece of paper and then torn out and placed into a rough circle across one of the tables. Then a glass tumbler was placed upside down in the middle of it. Resting their fingers lightly on the glass, they called out to the air if any spirits wanted to communicate with them. For a while, nothing happened. But slowly, the glass began to move. first in small, hesitant arcs, as though testing the table,
Speaker 1but then more decisively, gaining speed as it went from one letter to another. A nervous laughter rippled among the group, but quickly petered out, as letter by letter, the glass spelled out a name. P-A-T-F-O-S-T-E-R. Pat Foster spelled out the glass.
Speaker 1No one in the group knew anyone by that name, but before they could ask another question, the glass began to move again. Go home. There is danger, it said. The group glanced nervously at each other. Then someone asked, what kind of danger exactly? Lights, came back the reply. Just then, all of the lights above their heads began to dim, sinking down through a slow amber fade until
Speaker 1the room was barely lit at all. Then out in the courtyard, the lights went out completely all at once. When the fuse board was checked afterward, They found nothing wrong with it. Though they never did get to the bottom of who Pat Foster was exactly, it was all undoubtedly weird. And in the months that followed, things only intensified. Lights began to switch themselves on and off through the empty rooms at night. Bells that no longer existed anywhere
Speaker 1on the property were heard ringing, sometimes all through the night. with nobody able to locate any source for the ominous sound. One afternoon, a violent shattering was heard, after which a pair of oak chairs were found completely smashed to pieces, with no obvious culprit. Some oil paintings were also found one morning, torn into long, ragged strips, and a display of pottery that had stood untouched the evening before was
Speaker 1discovered shattered across the studio floor. One day, a small knitted children's hat appeared in one of the rooms that apparently nobody had seen before. The recurring appearance of these hats, some dirty and old, others seemingly brand new, would become a regular feature of the apparent haunting. One night, with her husband Nicholas away on business, Margaret was woken in the small hours by what sounded like more furniture being
Speaker 1thrown and smashed about downstairs. Grabbing a torch, a terrified Margaret tiptoed downstairs to investigate, but found every room completely clean and intact, just as she'd left it the night before. By the spring of 1970, Margaret O'Brien estimated that over £ 100 worth of damage had been caused by the apparent poltergeist that was now terrorising her home. Thousands in today's money.
Speaker 1Too scared to continue living there, Margaret and her husband decided to move in with their son John, who lived half a mile away. In the meantime, another exorcism was conducted, along with a visit from self-described medium Sheila St Clare and an Irish television crew, who were keen to capture the activity for themselves. As they filmed St. Clair moving cautiously about the building, she claimed that numerous dark spirits were dotted about the place, but there were two in
Speaker 1particular that stood out to her. One she called Holy Mary and the other Blessed Margaret. Both, she claimed, had served at black masses held by the Hellfire Club and had been trapped at the property ever since. It was her belief that the dark energy she detected there was simply the residue of all the diabolical things said to have taken place on the estate. After that second exorcism, Margaret felt safe enough to return to the property and
Speaker 1continue her work managing the art centre, and things once again seemed to settle down. It was sometime in 1971 when a plumber working in the kitchen is said to have hauled up one of the old flagstones and only to find a small brass figurine buried in the dirt underneath it. Brushing off the mud, he saw that it was a horned devil, with its hands raised in a strange, almost inviting gesture. Thinking little of it, he put it
Speaker 1aside and continued his work, digging under the stone, when he hit something else hard, buried deep in the mud. The plumber recoiled in horror. it was a human skeleton. The skeleton was said to have been that of an adult male, far smaller in size than the average male, with a strangely enlarged skull. The remains were eventually removed and given a religious burial, and by every account that followed,
Speaker 1the strange disturbances at Killer Key all but ceased from that point on, as though whatever had been unsettled in the house had finally disappeared. after 200 years, been allowed to lie down. With the worst of it then said to have finally been over, for the next seven years, Margaret claimed not to have experienced anything more untoward, save the occasional odd sound in the night. But even now, decades on, the stories haven't entirely stopped. One later account
Speaker 1describes a man in a blood-stained shirt, still seen occasionally on that hillside, Another errant member of the Hellfire Club, it seems. thought to have been killed in a duel outside the old lodge more than 250 years ago still walking the same ground he never quite managed to leave so what then of that black cat was it the angry spirit of a tortured animal come back to settle some ancient score with the species that had burned it alive?
Speaker 1Was it, as some insisted, Satan in disguise? Or was it simply an innocent animal, oblivious to the multifaceted perceptions of human beings? And what of the Hellfire Club itself? Was it really as fiendish as the rumours made it out to be? The Irish Hellfire Club was founded by Richard Parsons, also known as the Earl of Ross, sometime
Speaker 1around 1735. Parsons was one of those peculiar so-called Irish gentry who seems by all accounts to have been almost entirely English. By the 1700s, the British Crown had already spent the better part of two centuries colonising Ireland, confiscating land from its overwhelmingly Catholic population, and handing it to families willing to help enforce that rule. Parsons, who was very much a beneficiary of that colonialisation, belonged to the
Speaker 1so-called Anglo-Irish aristocracy, Irish in name and address only. He was born in Twickenham, just outside London. His family held their Irish estate purely because an earlier generation had been dispatched from England. to help confiscate it from the people who lived on it first, and still live there. Through the 17th and 18th centuries, that same Catholic population lived under law after law, designed to keep them from the land, education,
Speaker 1and any real power over their own country. So it isn't difficult to see how a group of men, anti-Catholic, and English by blood and loyalty, gathering on a hilltop, to mock the beliefs of the people they ruled over, with their supposedly sacrilegious behaviour, came to be remembered as devil worshippers by those same people. Yes, they were no doubt obnoxious, drank, gambled and cavorted openly with women, but whether any of it involved anything truly satanic is not
Speaker 1so clear. But it was easy enough from where the Catholic Irish stood to believe it might have. And yet... that same Catholic Church would itself prove capable of horrors that might not unreasonably also be described as satanic. Between 1922 and 1998, tens of thousands of Irish women were sent by their own families, under the guise of Catholicism, into mother and baby homes run by Catholic religious orders.
Speaker 1And from there, many were passed on to Magdalene laundries, where they worked without pay, as penance for the supposed sin of having conceived a child outside of marriage. Their babies, meanwhile, were separated from them, and in institution after institution, died in numbers that the country is still coming to terms with. At one home, run by the Bon Secours sisters between 1925 and 1961, 796 children that died there, largely due to neglect, were found buried en masse in a disused
Speaker 1sewage tank. Across all the homes investigated, close to 9,000 infants and children are believed to have died. Later state inquiries, the Ferns Report, the Ryan Report, the Murphy Report and the Cloyne Report, documented decades of child sexual abuse carried out by Catholic clergy that the Church's own hierarchy were well aware of, and had even worked methodically to keep hidden.
Speaker 1So what then is the black cat? Well, that depends, it seems, entirely on who's looking at it. Because the black cat has many faces. Please remember to like and subscribe if you've enjoyed the show. Unexplained is an AV Club Productions podcast created by me, Richard McLean Smith. All other elements of the podcast, including the music, are also
Speaker 1produced by me. Unexplained, the book and audiobook, is now available to buy worldwide. You can purchase from Amazon, Barnes & Noble, Waterstones and other bookstores. Be sure to follow us on Instagram, TikTok and Facebook at Unexplained Podcast and on X and Blue Sky at Unexplained Pod. Until next time. Stay strange and dissonant.
UNEXPLAINED SEASON 10 BEGINS FRIDAY DECEMBER 4TH In the meantime we’re continuing with our look back at some of your favourite episodes from the vaults. This week we’re venturing back to the autumn of 1984, to the...
UNEXPLAINED SEASON 10 BEGINS FRIDAY DECEMBER 4TH In 1802, Prussian naturalist Alexander von Humboldt was introduced to guano, a substance made from accumulated bird and bat droppings that had been prized for centuries...
UNEXPLAINED SEASON 10 BEGINS FRIDAY DECEMBER 4TH In January 1986, a strange object was witnessed crashing into a mountain in a far eastern region of the then Soviet Union. Described by some as Russia's Roswell, analysis...
On this week's Night Tales, have we got a story for you. Back in 1975 in a quiet English town, a naked man is found wondering around the neighbourhood covered in blood. But things only get stranger from there. Pull up a...
UNEXPLAINED SEASON 10 BEGINS FRIDAY NOVEMBER 27TH Fear, it would seem, is a powerful primal emotion. So potent that it can even make us afraid of things that may not even exist. But then again, just because we can't see...