S09E27: Death in Vegas, the Ted Binion Mystery (Pt. 2 of 3)
34 minAudio
In Part 2 of Unexplained Season 09 Episode 27: Death in Vegas, the Ted Binion Mystery, we dig deeper into the controversial and complicated nature of Ted Binion's life. Meanwhile, on a night out at the famous Piero's restaurant, Ted and Sandy meet a man named Rick Tabish. Some might say, it was all down hill from there... Watch/follow at youtube.com/@unexplainedpod, tiktok.com/@unexplainedpodcast, X @unexplainedpod, facebook.com/unexplainedpodcast, bsky.app/profile/unexplained.bsky.social, www.unexplainedpodcast.com Thank you for listening.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Speaker 1Hello, and welcome to Unexplained with Me your host, Richard mclin smith, where each week we explore another true tale of high strangeness. If you're new here and you're a fan of expertly told, atmospheric stories about the strange and unexplained, then you've come to the right place, and please subscribe to the show if you haven't already done so. I mentioned last week that I'll be hosting a live stream Q and A on YouTube to discuss this case and anything else you might want to ask about me or the show after the third and final part of this
Speaker 1episode drops next Friday. This will take place at seven o'clock Eastern Time or midnight in the UK on Wednesday, twenty second of July. You can find the link in the description below, But for now, we continue our deep dive into the life and death of Ted Binyon two of Unexplained, Season nine, episode twenty seven, Death in Vegas,
Speaker 1the Ted Binyon Mystery. For all that was appealing to Sandy Murphy about life with Ted Binion, there was another side to their relationship. One night, a frightened Sandy arrived in tears at the home of Ted's sister Becky. Her face was covered in bruises. A call was made to nine to one one in which Sandy accused Ted of assaulting her, but the accusation was later retracted. It said
Speaker 1that whenever Ted beat Sandy, his way of making it up to her was just to lavish her with more gifts, including at one time giving her a black Mercedes worth about two hundred thousand dollars today. Over time, Sandy began to get an understanding of what life in Ted's orbit also entailed. She rubbed his shoulders with gangsters and politicians and watched as they all circled each other, doing whatever they needed to keep their respective wheels greased. There were
Speaker 1all the guns, too, At one point there were thought to be about three hundred of them that Ted kept stashed away at various properties. After all, for anyone involved with so much money in Vegas, the high likelihood that you were always a target for somebody was an occupational hazard, and Ted knew better than most. Back in the nineteen sixties, when Ted was twenty four, a man named Bill Wade began making it known that he had some information that
Speaker 1he wanted to get to Benny Binyon. According to Wade, an ex con named Marvin Shoemate, had concocted a plan to abduct Ted and demand ransom for his safe return. But Marvin had no intention of returning Ted at all and planned to kill him instead, believing that was the only way he could get away with the scam. Wade knew all this because at one point he'd been in on the plan, only he got cold feet when Marvin revealed that he actually wanted to kill Ted. It isn't
Speaker 1clear what became of Wade exactly once Benny heard all this, but what happened to Marvin Shumate is a little less unclear. After speaking to Benny's people, Wade arranged a meeting with Schuemate at a Vegas diner, supposedly to go over the plan once again, but when Shumate turned up to the meeting, there was no sign of Wade. Waiting for Shuemte instead were Bennie's henchmen. They asked him to take a ride with them out of the desert. Marvin wound up dead
Speaker 1in a ditch just outside of Vegas after having his chest blown apart by a shotgun blast. It wasn't just outsiders that had it in for Ted. Behind the scenes of the Binyon Horseshoe, a bit of power struggle was playing out between him, his brother Jack, and his sister Becky over who could be best trusted with the casino business. Despite regaining his gaming license in nineteen ninety two, Ted
Speaker 1standing at the Horseshoe never fully recovered. His sister Becky, who Ted seemed to have little time for and even less respect, had maneuvered herself into an effective co presidency alongside Jack. Ted still held his twenty percent, but the floor he grew up on was no longer his Sandy for a while seemed to make him happy at least, but it wasn't enough to banish the wider problem. By early nineteen ninety six, state gaming regulators were back at
Speaker 1his door. Hair sample tests returned positive results for marijuana and cocaine on three separate occasions, and his license was suspended again pending a review. The following year, Ted's world began to contract. He drank more, he used more. Things appeared to be souring with Sandy too, and though both seemed intent on sticking it out for now, things were about to get even worse. Ted Binyon's world in the
Speaker 1mid nineteen nineties wasn't just complicated by family politics and drug habits. It was ringed, as it had always been, by men whose names. If you wanted to keep your gambling license, you didn't want associated with yours. One of those names for Ted was Herbert Blitztein, or Fat Herbie as some called him. Blitztein had been a top lieutenant of Antony Spilotro until Spilotro was beaten to death by his own people for skimming from his bosses in nineteen
Speaker 1eighty six. Blitztein had survived the cull, but without steady work, had drifted into loan sharking. Since then, Ted and Blitztein, who moved in similar circles, had become friends. On the seventh of January nineteen ninety seven, police were called to Blitztein's home and found him slumped forward, head first in an armchair with a bullet hole in his head. He'd been executed on the orders of a man named Peter Caruso, whose bosses wanted in on Blitztein's loan shark operation. Ted's
Speaker 1association with Blitztein was a leading feature in the Gaming Commission's investigation into his eligibility to regain his license, But it was a whole lot more complicated than that, So here's an interesting bit of information worth keeping in mind for later. The FBI had known all about the planned assassination of Herbert Blitztein thanks to an informer named John Branco.
Speaker 1After it was carried out, Branco had another tip off. When Peter Crusoe had Blitztein murdered, items were apparently stolen from his house that turned out to belong to Ted, and Caruso wanted more of them. According to Branco, Caruso had heard that Ted was a heroin addict and so apparently hatched a plan to burgle his home after murdering him in a way that would make it look like he just overdosed on heroin. In May nineteen ninety seven,
Speaker 1no doubt influenced by all the messiness surrounding Herbert Blitstein, the Nevada Gaming Control Board suspended Ted's license again, pending a review. It was around this time that Ted and Sandy went to dinner one night at Piero's. Back in the nineteen eighties when it first opened, the Italian restaurant Piero's, with its tightly packed covers, low lights and crisp white tablecloths. Became a popular hangout for organized crime bosses, casino owners,
Speaker 1and politicians who liked to treat the place as a neutral territory, the restaurant equivalent of the Continental Hotel if you're familiar with the John Wick movies. While there, at some point, Ted went to the bathroom, whereupon he found himself standing next to a tall, dark haired man. The man introduced himself as Rick Tabish. Rick had arrived in Vegas the previous year, much like Sandy, searching for something.
Speaker 1He grew up in Missoula in Montana, and came from what papers described as a prominent family, which I assume means fairly wealthy. His father ran a petrol distribution business, and by all accounts, he and his wife provided their kids with everything they could ever need to succeed in life. But there was something underneath all that. Sometime in the early nineteen sixties, before Rick was born, his parents' second son, Patrick Tabish, wandered to the back of the family home
Speaker 1and fell into an irrigation canal and drowned. He was only fourteen months old at the time. About a year later, under what would have been an immeasurable shadow of grief. Rick was born. By all accounts, it seems that Rick was lavished with love and attention, perhaps too much, Some might say, it's easy to understand why a parent might
Speaker 1want to cling on to a child a little tight of the normal if born under such circumstances. But perhaps to a boy like Rick striving for an identity of his own, this intense love that had been sharpened so acutely by grief and the fear of loss felt less like warmth and more like a cage, And perhaps that is why he started getting mixed up in crime. Rick was smart and athletic, and would go on to play football for the University of Montana. He was handsome and
Speaker 1charming who the kind of person who could hold a room. But friends noticed early that he seemed drawn to the wrong people. The guy with the nice car who turned out to be a dealer, the older kids whose rules were different from the ones his parents espoused. Maybe it was the pull of the forbidden. Maybe it was something more specific, a need to step out of the shadow, perhaps of a brother he'd never met, but whose absence had filled every room he'd ever lived in. Whatever the
Speaker 1courts a pattern slowly began to establish itself. It started with a series of petty crimes, but quickly escalated. In nineteen eighty five, while at the home of miss soou La lawyer Milton Datzopolos, who was helping him fight a previous misdemeanor, a then twenty one year old Rick stole one of Milton's paintings. It was a work attributed to the seventeenth century French master Nicholas Poussain, believed at the time to be worth six hundred thousand dollars or just
Speaker 1under two million in today's money. The collection it came from would later turn out to be the subject of its own fraud investigation, in which valuations had been significantly inflated. But Rick wasn't to know that. Rick got a rather lenient three years probationary sentence for it, not even jail time. Then, in February nineteen eighty seven, at twenty two, he was arrested for attempting to ship a quarter pound of cocaine from Arizona to Missoula via Federal Express. The package was
Speaker 1worth about forty thousand dollars roughly one hundred and ten thousand to day the Missoula County Attorney, a man named Robert Deschamp, the third was not sympathetic. Tabish is a classic example of an arrogant rich kit he said, who's been able to commit numerous crimes with almost complete impunity because his father has been able to buy his way out. This time, Rick was sentenced to three years in prison, but served only nine months before being parolled. Every time
Speaker 1Rick Tabish was arrested, thanks to his prominent family, he managed to evade the type of punishment that others might have received for similar offenses. So, thankfully for him, when he finally decided to turn his life around, it wasn't too late. Perhaps scared by the prospect of endless years in and out of jail, Rick started to get steady employment, working in construction at first, then in the early nineties he fell in love and got married. He and his wife,
Speaker 1Mary Joe, started a trucking business together. Rick was a hard worker when he put his mind to it, and was always trying to make things happen, but nothing quite took off to the level he wanted it to. So when in nineteen ninety six a friend convinced him to try his luck in Las Vegas. Rick wasted little time in getting a license to operate his business in Nevada and quickly pivoted to hauling gravel and sand for the local construction industry. Despite all that, however, it seems, he
Speaker 1still wasn't quite fulfilled, and he still had a weakness for a certain kind of man, for the gravitational pull of a world that was bigger and more dangerous than the one his parents had built for him in Massula, which is perhaps why standing next to Ted Binion in that bathroom in Piero's restaurant that night, he couldn't help but be a little spellbound, and maybe the feeling was mutual. Rick was everything that Ted wasn't at that point in his life, young, energetic, full of forward momentum, and hungry
Speaker 1in a way that Ted had perhaps once been but had mislaid somewhere along the line. And Rick, for his part, found in Ted exactly the kind of man he'd always been drawn to. But this time it was the real thing, Old Vegas Royalty, a man who'd grown up in rooms where serious money changed hands and nobody blinked, who knew everyone worth knowing, and a few people It was better not to know, but more pertinently, he was a man
Speaker 1who could really open doors for him without having to break the law. With his wife, Mary Joe and their children back in Missoula, Rick began spending more time with Ted and Sandy over dinners and late nights. He heard the full Binyon saga about Ted's problems with the gaming board and the knotty family history, and he heard about Ted silver. In the summer of nineteen ninety seven, a
Speaker 1car cruised past Ted and Sandy's house on Palomino Lane and opened fire. Nobody he was harmed, and no culprit was ever found. Sandy later accused Becky Binyon's son Nick, of being in the car. Whether it was a warning from Becky for Ted to step away from the business once and for all, if this were true, or a genuine attempt to kill him, isn't clear in any case. In March nineteen ninety eight, Ted's license was formally revoked
Speaker 1and Becky took over the day to day running of the Binyon's Horseshoe casino. She fired staff loyal to Ted and their father, and slashed betting limits, remaking the place in an image that bore almost no resemblance to what Benny had built the old Horseshoe, the joint with the red velvet and the no limits tables. Becky was dismantling it to piece by piece, which meant that Ted could no longer keep his silver there, so he decided to bury it instead out on that vacant lot in Perump.
Speaker 1And who better to help him do it than Rick Tabish and his construction team. Now this is also something worth remembering for later on. One of Ted's lawyers would later testify that he was present when Ted told Rick Tabish that if he were to die, that Rick should retrieve the silver, to keep it away from his siblings and make sure it all got to his daughter Bonnie. Rick immediately got to work building the vault deep underground on Ted's vacant parcel of land out in Perump. Then
Speaker 1one evening in July, Rick Tabish and its crew filed into the Horseshoe Casino and piece by piece carried out Ted's forty eight thousand pound horde of silver bars and coins, placing them into the back of a large truck before driving it out to Perump. Keeping an eye on the whole operation was Ted, complete with bulletproof vest and two semi automatic holstered at his waist. Rick would later thrillingly describe taking part in the operation as having felt like
Speaker 1being a cowboy in the night, And by the end of that evening, Ted Silver was back in the ground. Three days after that, Sandy was added to Ted's will, to the tune of three hundred thousand dollars the Palomino Lane house and all its contents. Things rumbled on depressingly. Ted and Sandy now in separate bedrooms, living increasingly separate lives. Ted growing more and more listless and drifting into more
Speaker 1frequent heroin use. But he hadn't completely given up hope yet. He still had friends in high places, and he clearly had plans for the future, and Ted, it seemed, hadn't given up entirely on getting back into the game. On September fifteenth, nineteen ninety eight, Ted opened a million dollar investment account and one hundred thousand dollar checking account. We
Speaker 1don't know why. The next morning, on Wednesday the sixteenth, former Las Vegas mayor Jan Jones came to his house to pick up a forty thousand dollar campaign contribution. But let's call a spade a spade. This is Vegas, after all. I think it's reasonable to assume that Ted was hoping the money might persuade Jones to help him get his license back if she got elected. Interestingly, Jones would later say that she was struck by the tidiness of the house and by the couple's ease with each other that day.
Speaker 1Despite what many people had said of Sandy that she could only have been with Ted for his money. To Jones, at least, they seemed like a genuine couple. At eleven a m. Ted went out into the yard. His neighbor, a doctor named Enrique Leceo, was outside too, and the pair talk to each other over the fence. Lokeo would later say that Ted seemed agitated that day and angry at himself for what the heroine was doing to him. Ted asked Lokeo to write him a prescription for one
Speaker 1hundred and twenty Xanax pills. He apparently had a plan to use the xanax to wean himself off the harder stuff. Lokeo wrote it out for him, as he had done before, but never for quite that amount. Ted would go on to collect it later that afternoon. That same day, Ted also called a private investigator named Don Dibble and asked him to keep tabs on Sandy. It appeared that he'd started to become suspicious that she might be having an
Speaker 1affair with Rick Tabish, a ranch hand from Ted's Perump property. A man named Roy Price was at the Palomino Lane house that day and had seen Sandy and Rick sitting together on the sofa point he leaned into Ted as he eyed the couple and said that they seemed closer than a cheap suit. Ted seemed to have taken note. Later, between eight and nine that night, a man named Pete Sheridan,
Speaker 1Ted's dealer, arrived at the house to drop off twelve balloons of heroin, three times Ted's usual amount Sheridan would later testify that Ted was fairly drunk or high, or both when he arrived. Ted gave him some cash in return and thirty of his Sanax pills, which left ninety for Ted. On that night of Wednesday, September sixteenth, Sandy
Speaker 1went out with friends. According to her, when she came home late, the house was quiet and she went straight to bed. A few hours later, she was woken by Ted. He seemed distressed and had clearly been using it. Was terrified that he might have taken too much, and was worried that something might happen to him in his sleep. He wanted Sandy to keep an eye on him as he slept, to make sure he didn't vomit, or so she could call an ambulance if he stopped breathing for whatever reason. This is now the morning of Thursday, September seventeenth.
Speaker 1Sandy apparently lay down with Ted in the den, a kind of entertainment room that Ted had kitted out for himself. Today we might describe it as a man cave. It was the place where Ted felt safest, where he could hunker down and watch TV while keeping an eye on his many CCTV cameras, most of them, at least as it happened. The camera at the front of the house appeared to have been tampered with a few days previously and was still in the shop being repaired. Sandy stayed
Speaker 1with Ted in the den until the morning, then, once she was satisfied he was safe in his sleep, she went out again to meet some friends and run some errands. Sandy said that when she came back around three p m. Ted appeared to still just be sleeping, but a short time later she discovered that he wasn't breathing and dialed nine one one. So that's Sandy's version of events. Outside of that, this is what we know. Early in the
Speaker 1morning of Thursday the seventeenth, Ted and Sandy's housekeeper, Mary Montoya Gascoygne, receives a call from Sandy. Sandy tells her not to come to the house because Ted is feeling unwell. A little later, Ted and Sandy's gardener arrives and works for the next few hours. The gardener later said that Ted and Sandy's dogs, Pig and Princess were tethered to the back door the entire time, which was a little unusual. It was enough to make him wonder if something wrong
Speaker 1inside the house. He tried to peer through a gap in the curtains, but couldn't see anything and left around one PM. Slightly earlier, around midday, real estate agent Barbara Brown made a phone call to the house to speak to Ted to confirm some lunch plans they had for the next day, and apparently emotional, Sandy answered the phone, saying that Ted was out cold and had made a mess in the bathroom that she'd spent the whole morning cleaning up. Brown offered to come over, but Sandy told
Speaker 1her not to and that Ted didn't want to see anyone for the foreseeable future. It was twelve fifteen, just after she spoken to Barbara Brown on the phone, when Sandy went out to lunch at Cetaeus Grill. Meeting her there was Rick Tabish and a lawyer named William cu Nudson. After lunch, at three pm, she dropped a check for one hundred and fifty dollars at the Horseshoe from Ted's nephew,
Speaker 1who was repaying a small loan. Ted's assistant Kathy Rose, who Sandy gave the check to, thought it unusual for Sandy to come in like that. At three point fifty four pm, Sandy placed a call to nine one one and tells the operator that her husband isn't breathing. When first responder Kenneth Dickinson arrives three minutes later, a distressed
Speaker 1Sandy Murphy comes running out to meet him. He's not breathing, she keeps saying between sobs. Then she leads Dickinson through the house and down a flight of stairs to the den. Inside, Ted Binyon is lying on the floor on a foot on mattress with a blanket over him and his head on a pillow. He's in his briefs and an unbuttoned shirt. His skin is pale, scattered about with some lighters and cigarettes,
Speaker 1broken balloons, and a bottle of xanax. Only the day before it had ninety pills in it, now it was empty. It didn't take a professional to know that the man was dead. Riga mortis had already set in to his jaw when given the news, Sandy threw herself suddenly over Ted's body, obstructing the work of the paramedics, who in the end had to pull her away to finish their job. In the hours that followed, news spread quickly and friends
Speaker 1and family began turning up at the house. Meanwhile, Sandy became more and more despondent and seemingly distraught, to the point where more paramedics were dispatched just to treat her. When they arrived, they found her lying on her bed, seemingly in the grip of a panic attack. She was hyperventilating and incapable of answering questions. Concerned that she might go into shock. The medics decided it would be best to get her to hospital. Despite Sandy's protestations. She was
Speaker 1eventually forced onto a gurney and put into the back of an ambulance. It said that all the way to the hospital, Sandy pleaded with the paramedics to take her back to the house, terrified that Ted's family might try to stop her from returning there. Later, back at the property, what followed was a catastrophe of police procedure. Officers walked in and out without cordoning off the scene. Friends, neighbors, family members, and lawyers milled through the driveway and eventually
Speaker 1inside the house. Rick Tabish arrived too and spoke to reporters outside. He came as soon as he heard the news, he said, and what a tragedy it was. All the while, down in the den, investigators got to work examining the sun as Ted's body lay peacefully on the floor, serenaded by one after another anxious caller leaving messages on Ted's answer phone, desperate to know that the rumors weren't true.
Speaker 1All law enforcement who attended the scene of Ted Binyon's death on the afternoon of the seventeenth came to the conclusion that there didn't seem to be anything suspicious about it, believing it was simply a case of a self inflicted drug overdose. The homicide department actively declined the invitation to get involved with it. Meanwhile, at Valley Hospital, Sandy's apparent house of grief were being heard throughout the emergency room. Hearing the commotion, a nurse of twenty five years experience
Speaker 1attempted to take control of the situation. He tried to triarge her, but eventually gave up, having been unable to calm her down. The nurse would later testify that Sandy's reaction seemed theatrical and that nothing appeared to be medically wrong with her, although it should be said that her heart rate and breathing were twice the normal resting beat, so she was at the very least hyper ventilating and possibly suffering from a panic attack. Eventually, she calmed down
Speaker 1enough for a detective to conduct an interview, but became so worked up again that he was forced to abandon it after thirteen minutes. I sure can you tell her what happened up until the surfer down turn between sobs
Speaker 1and rapid breaths. She told him about how she'd been out late in the evening and then stayed up with Ted to help him sleep. She also said, seemingly with great regret, that she'd brought him the xanax and heroine when he asked for it, and if only she hadn't, then maybe Ted would still be alive. There was one strange detail, though. When police arrived at the scene, they found that Sandy's bathroom window was open and a chair had been placed underneath it. At some point between the
Speaker 1afternoon of September sixteenth and Ted being found dead in the afternoon of the seventeenth, someone had clearly used it to get into the house. Sandy claimed it was her, saying that she had put it there because when she got home late in the evening, she misplaced her keys and had to get in through the bathroom window, which she said she often left open for such circumstances, which was certainly odd given Ted's intense paranoia over people being after him and his money. Around seven pm, Sandy's friend
Speaker 1Janis Tanno went to visit her at the hospital, alarmed by the state that she was in and assuming that she wouldn't be allowed back in the house anytime soon. Janie offered Sandy a place to stay for the night. At seven thirty pm, Sandy checked out at the hospital and Julie went to stay with Janie. Janis would later say that at one point, Sandy, who was barely coherent
Speaker 1when she first saw her, said something a little odd that would stay with Janice long afterwards. I don't want to hurt Teddy, she said. On the surface of it, it was a strange thing to say about a man who was already dead. Perhaps she meant this with regards to a possible affair she was in, which case it wouldn't be so strange that someone might say this out of guilt having just received the news that their partner was dead. But maybe she was referring to something else.
Speaker 1Either way, or this would be picked apart later. But not one person at that point suspected Sandy of doing anything untoward. No one, that is, except apparently Becky Binyon, or at least that's what she told the police. Whether she believed this or this was some kind of powerplay, we could never know for sure. In any case. When Becky heard about Ted's death late in the afternoon, on that Thursday day. She immediately told the police that they
Speaker 1shouldn't be treating his death as an accidental overdose because, according to her, Ted had quite clearly been murdered. And that's where we'll leave it for now. Join me next week on Friday July seventeenth for the third and final part of season nine, episode twenty seven, Death in Vegas, The Ted Binyon Mystery. Until then, thanks so much again for listening and watching. I've been Richard mclin smith and
Speaker 1this is Unexplained. Please subscribe and rate the show If you've enjoyed it, now let me know what you think about it all in the comments below. Thank you as ever for listening Unexplained as an Avy Club production podcast created by Richard McClain Smith. All other elements of the podcast, including the music, are also produced by me Richard McClain smith. Unexplained. The book and audiobook is now available to buy worldwide.
Speaker 1You can purchase from Amazon, Barnes and Noble, Waterstones and other bookstores. Please subscribe to and rate the show wherever you get your podcasts, and feel free to get in touch with any thoughts or ideas regarding the stories you've heard. On the show. Perhaps you have an explanation or a story of your own you'd like to share. You can find out more at Unexplained podcast dot com and reaches online through X and Blue Sky That Unexplained Pod and Facebook at Facebook dot com, Forward Slash Unexplained Podcast
UNEXPLAINED SEASON 10 BEGINS FRIDAY DECEMBER 4TH In the meantime we’re continuing with our look back at some of your favourite episodes from the vaults. This week we’re venturing back to the autumn of 1984, to the...
UNEXPLAINED SEASON 10 BEGINS FRIDAY DECEMBER 4TH In 1802, Prussian naturalist Alexander von Humboldt was introduced to guano, a substance made from accumulated bird and bat droppings that had been prized for centuries...
UNEXPLAINED SEASON 10 BEGINS FRIDAY DECEMBER 4TH In January 1986, a strange object was witnessed crashing into a mountain in a far eastern region of the then Soviet Union. Described by some as Russia's Roswell, analysis...
On this week's Night Tales, have we got a story for you. Back in 1975 in a quiet English town, a naked man is found wondering around the neighbourhood covered in blood. But things only get stranger from there. Pull up a...
UNEXPLAINED SEASON 10 BEGINS FRIDAY NOVEMBER 27TH Fear, it would seem, is a powerful primal emotion. So potent that it can even make us afraid of things that may not even exist. But then again, just because we can't see...