S09E30: Come, Hear What We Have to Say (The Scole Experiment), 2/2
35 minAudio
The second and final part of Unexplained S09E30: Come, Hear What We Have to Say (The Scole Experiment). In October of 1993, the living members of the Scole Experiment Group had supposedly made contact with one spirit, but that was just the beginning. And what incredible sights they had to show them... Written by Neil McRobert and Richard MacLean Smith Watch/follow at youtube.com/@unexplainedpod, tiktok.com/@unexplainedpodcast, X @unexplainedpod, facebook.com/unexplainedpodcast, bsky.app/profile/unexplained.bsky.social, www.unexplainedpodcast.com
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Speaker 1Hello, and welcome to Unexplained with me your host Richard mclin smith, where each week we explore another true tale of high strangeness. If you're new here and you're a fan of expertly told atmospheric stories about the strange and unexplained, then you've come to the right place. Please subscribe to the show if you haven't already done so. I'm very excited to be taking Unexplained to the Edinburgh Fringe Festival this year. I'll be performing at the Space's Surgeon's Hall venue at ten oh five pm every night from August
Speaker 1seventh to the twenty ninth, except for the sixteenth and twenty third. You can get tickets at the Space UK dot com. Forward Slash shows, Forward Slash twenty twenty six, Forward Slash Unexplained hyphen Live. For those watching on YouTube, you can find the link below. This is the second and final part of Unexplained, Season nine, episode thirty. Come
Speaker 1hear what we have to say. The history of spiritualism is dominated by individuals. There have been many famous mediums, from Daniel Douglas Home, the nineteenth century Scottish figure known for apparent feats of levitation, to John Edward Stalwart of US late night television at the turn of the millennium, but almost all worked alone, presenting their powers as personal and private gifts. Likewise, their counterparts in the spirit realm
Speaker 1are similarly singular. Many mediums claim a connection with a particular entity, often termed their spirit control or guide. During the nineteenth century, a spirit named John King was arguably the busiest entity around. Numerous noteworthy medium claimed him as their spirit control, including the famed Mister and Missus Nelson Homes of Philadelphia and controversial Italian medium Eusapia Palladino. Even
Speaker 1the infamous theosophist Elena Blovatski was said to have worked with John King during seances in London in the eighteen fifties. King apparently served as control for Frank hearn a clairvoyant who, while allegedly under King's guidance, began to exhibit physical manifestations, including the uncanny elongation of his own body. In eighteen seventy, Hearne began to tutor a fifteen year old girl named Florence Cook, who'd recently discovered her own apparent mediumistic abilities.
Speaker 1It seems his attempt to pass the battan here on earth were also mirrored on the spirit side, as Florence soon announced that her own spirit was none other than Katie King, the daughter of Hearne's own guy. This is just one celebrated case of a close relationship between individuals on each side of the veil. One medium and one spirit is the typical dynamic that occurs in various cultures around the globe and across time. But in nineteen ninety three,
Speaker 1in the tiny English village of Skull, spiritualism was a communal effort. The Skull Experiment Group, a collective of seven amateurs, met each week in the basement of Sandra and Robin Foy's home known as Street Farmhouse. All had a level of interest or expertise and the occult, and had come together for a groundbreaking mission to prove that something of the human spirit endured after death. Rather than relying on the antiquated practices of mental mediumship with its messages and symbols,
Speaker 1the Skull Group were pursuing what they called physical psychic phenomena, the use of combined human and spiritual energy to manifest tangible evidence. But as with traditional supposed spiritual connections, it would still need both sides of the veil to make it work. In October of nineteen ninety three, the living members of the Skull Experiment group had supposedly made contact with one spirit, but that was just the beginning. When
Speaker 1we left the group in late nineteen ninety three, they'd been experimenting for the best part of a year with some apparent results. They claimed to have recorded floating orbs, temperature drops, and even the physical movement of objects in the cellar. None of it, however, could be proven to the evidential standard that the team were aiming for, and then Man Whu made contact. Man Whu claimed to be the leader of a spirit team, as man who apparently
Speaker 1explained this team was made up of spirits who were each as committed as the Skull group to proving the truth about the spirit realm and that intelligent scientific cooperation was possible across their realm and hours. In order to do this, according to the so called Manu, they would use their own energy sources called etheric energy to change things in the cellar on a molecular and atomic basis. Manu also explained that his team was only one of
Speaker 1many who worked under the direction of a higher council, and that this was far from their first attempt to make contact with the living. It was specifically because of the Skull team's particular collective energy as a group that Manu was apparently able to make contact with them. Manu's team of spirits was said to have been made up of many distinct personalities, whose number and identities would fluctuate over time. But there were corps participants, Missus Emily Bradshaw,
Speaker 1an unfailingly refined spirit of a woman who apparently died in the late nineteenth century. Patrick McKenna, an Irish priest given to a bantering tone. I was a priest in my lifetime, said the apparent Patrick when he first appeared, but not a good one. Kept getting into trouble I did. Patrick supposedly communicated through Alan Bennett, who, along with his partner Diane, had supposedly been chosen by the spirits as the conduits through which they would communicate. Patrick had apparently
Speaker 1died in nineteen forty two. Then there was Patrick's friend Raji, an Indian man who had his own assistant that he referred to as Charlie Number one, a young boy who was supposedly prone to patting the Skull Team members on the head. In addition to these, there was also an apparent spirit named Edward Matthews, a sensitive young scientist who had died in the First World War, and John Paxton, who claimed to be part of another group known as
Speaker 1the Council of Communion, who was said to exist on a more elevated spiritual plane than Manu's team. It was Paxton, more than any other, who seemingly impressed upon the Skull Group the importance of the work ahead. He arrived unannounced one afternoon, speaking in an odd, gruff tone through Diane. It is not normally possible for me to communicate directly with those on earth, he said, as Diane kept completely still save for the opening and closing of her mouth. However,
Speaker 1there has been an important decision by the Council of Communion, and we have decided that I will communicate directly with your group from time to time. The work that you do now and in the future is considered very important. The Council of Communion, he said, was made up of thirteen equally elevated souls, but was only one of many such spiritual counsels. Each of these strange individuals was supposedly equally invested from the spirit side in the skull group's
Speaker 1one key aim to facilitate contact between the living and the afterlife and to provide concrete proof of that connection. Like any team working in tandem, the spirits had their own interpersonal habits and patterns. Typically, Man Whu would open proceedings, announcing himself suddenly to the group through Diane, then he would largely disappear, ceding the floor to others. The priest
Speaker 1Patrick McKenna would often delay the experiment by bantering at the expense of Raji, who would respond good naturedly until another spirit, usually Missus Bradshaw, intervened, at which point Raji would take the lead on explaining the experiment at hand, each voice emanating solely from Diane and Allan's mouths, sometimes multiple voices jostling to get out of the same conduit. The scientist Edward Matthews would frequently interject to enthuse about
Speaker 1possible future experiments and technologies to come. John Paxton, the higher Spirit, would follow up with more specialized teaching on the nature of spirit and its relationship to the moral world, whereas Missus Bradshaw, it said, functioned primarily as an interlocutor, often rephrasing technical messages into more easily understood language. When one of the living asked her to clarify a point, she would go quiet for a moment, as if listening
Speaker 1to instruction from her sight, then begin her response with, they are telling me that, before continuing with her given explanation. As a session drew to a close, it was always Patrick McKenna, the priest, who took the lead. Then one day, as was later claimed, his voice didn't come from either Diane or Allan, but from out of one of the dark corners of the cellar. Intrigued, the Skull group are then said to have asked him to speak from a
Speaker 1different part of the room. Moments later, his voice seemed to completely switch to come from the other side. On many occasions, his closing words also seemed to be emanating from deep within the stone walls. Such became the typical Monday evening for the Skull Experiment group. Most importantly, the Spirit Team are said to have followed through with their apparent promise to provide the kind of physical evidence that the Skull Group had been yearning for. That Robin and
Speaker 1Sandra Foy had been seeking ever since they were first turned on to the concept of physical mediumship twenty five years earlier. The Holy Grail of physical psychic phenomena apports psychical objects that appear as if from nowhere. During man Who's first appearance in October nineteen ninety three, it was
Speaker 1said by the group to have gifted them an old coin, a Churchill crown that had seemingly appeared out of thin air in the basement. A week after that first meeting, on November one, all seven members of the school group were present, Sandra and Robin Foy, Diane and Alan Bennett, Mimmy Salisbury, Ken Britton, and Burnett Head. After taking their places at the table and placing the fluorescent bands on their wrists, the customary record was put on and the
Speaker 1team sang along to it softly together. Then the tape recorder was started and Robin switched off the lights. Settling back into his seat, Robin then started the proceedings. Infinite Spirit, he intoned, solemnly, Creative Source of all things, be with us this evening and guide us in our work. It wasn't long before Manu appeared again. Soon after, he made a promise to bring a collection of gifts carefully chosen
Speaker 1by his team for those present. They are brought, he said, with a tremendous amount of love and goodwill. Moments later, a rap was heard from the table as something hard dropped onto it, then another and another. When Robin finally turned on the lights, eight trinkets lay on top of the table. A silver thimble, two silver lockets, a silver bracelet, a miniature spoon, a gold medallion covered in hieroglyphics, a
Speaker 1decorative bowl bearing a French inscription, and a Saint Christopher medal. The group stared in wonder at the items and then at each other. It was as thrilling as it was unnerving. The single cellar door was locked. No one had been able to enter the room before or during the experiment, so where on Earth or elsewhere, perhaps, had these gifts come from. It was during one seance in February nineteen
Speaker 1ninety four that supposed spirit Patrick McKenna told the team to bring a camera into the cellar so that the spirit team could use it to convey a different type of information. The group eagerly agreed to the request. On the first day of the test, one of the group aimed a thirty five millimeter camera out of the farmhouse window and took a quick picture to test it out before taking downstairs to begin the experiment. With the group settled once again at the table in the dark, the
Speaker 1apparent Patrick, speaking through Alan, instructed Sandra to take the camera and be prepared to take a picture imminently. A moment later, a speckle of light is said to have begun dancing around in the dark. Now, Patrick cried suddenly from Alan's mouth, and Sandra dutifully snapped the photo. After
Speaker 1that initial flurry of excitement, Patrick is said to have suggested that Sandra use the camera as she wished throughout the remainder of the session, and so for the rest of the evening, Sandra is said to have taken various pictures in the dark of nothing in particular. However, it seemed she wasn't the only one taking pictures, as whenever she placed it down for a moment beside her, it was said that the click of the shutter could be heard operating entirely on its own. Having apparently had the
Speaker 1images developed the following day, the boys are said to have been speechless at what they got back in return taking the photos out of their pouch. The first image was one of Saint Paul's Cathedral in London during what appeared to be the blitz of World War II. Another showed the same scene from a different angle. There were also multiple images of a bus, also seemingly during the war, lying on its side in the street. Another was simply the whole front page of the British paper, The Daily Mirror,
Speaker 1dated December sixteenth, nineteen thirty six, while others depicted groups of soldiers and a wedding photograph of an unknown bride. Only then did it occur to them that each of the photos was in black and white when the film they used was color. Clearly they had been given the wrong photos. Then they turned over the last print. It was the view from the farmhouse window, the test photo that had been taken before the camera was brought into
Speaker 1the basement, and there was also said to be one image that was unclear and composed almost entirely of light. This, they assumed, was the first photo that Sandra had been instructed to take by Patrick. As the weeks and months passed, naturally, the news of the extraordinary communication apparently taking place in the Foy's farmhouse cellar escaped into the wider world. Before long, scientists, journalists, and spiritual researchers were turning up at the Skull Hole,
Speaker 1as it came to be known, to see it for themselves and to put the group through their paces. Perhaps most pertinently, they drew the attention of the Society for Psychical Research or SPR, Britain's older and most established body of paranormal study. Three official delegates were eventually sent to Skull to investigate, but none would become more invested and indeed astounded, than doctor Montague Keene and Professor Arthur Ellison.
Speaker 1Doctor Keene and Professor Ellison were deeply pragmatic, scientifically minded men. Keen was an agricultural economist and veteran investigator of the paranormal, with a track record for exposing hoaxes. Ellison was an emeritus professor of electrical engineering at London City University and a former president of the SPR. They first met with the school group in February nineteen ninety five and were impressed, if not entirely disarmed, by the group's eagerness to invite
Speaker 1scientific scrutiny. In October of that year, they began their investigation at their first formal meeting. The group watched nervously as Keen and Ellison carried out a thorough examination of the lit celler, making notes as they peered under the tables and chairs. Then they turned their attention to all the various equipment present. They inspected the tape player and the tapes, as well as the two electrical sockets, looking for any entry point or mechanism that might be utilized
Speaker 1to perform a hoax. Carefully, with much awkwardness, they inspected the attendees to satisfied there was nothing untoward in the room, the men took their places on their own seats and nodded for the Skull team to continue. Once again, a record was played and the team sang along as they always did. Then the lights were turned out, plunging them all into near darkness, and the tape recorder set to record.
Speaker 1Within minute man who seemed to emerge from the mouth of Alan Bennett. Then one by one, the other voices followed. The one identified as Missus Bradshaw was said to being especially vocal that day. Then a light appeared in the room. Though Keen and Allison couldn't quite figure out how, they felt certain that something untoward was taking place. That was until one day in June nineteen ninety six, Doctor Keene
Speaker 1was sitting in his usual place at the table when Robin announced again that he could see a light hovering in front of him. Keen, however, couldn't see anything, nor could Professor Ellison. Keen was midway through putting it down once again to Foy's imagination, when a point of light then suddenly appeared directly in front of his own face and began tracing a figure of eight in the dark. As he started to describe what was going on, Sand seated on his left said that she was watching the
Speaker 1exact same thing happening in front of her, but when Keene turned to water he saw nothing at all. Then Professor Ellison spoke a light was apparently in front of him too. Keen was close enough to feel Professor Ellison's breath, but seemed unable to see this light too. Each time, it seems as if specifically trying to break the investigator's skepticism, the apparent spirits had constructed a private light show for each individual alone. Doctor Keen would later write of that
Speaker 1strange experience with the light that it felt distinctive, purposeful, and intelligently directed. In November nineteen ninety six, Arthur Ellison's twenty third observed experiment, he hears a voice speak, not for Diana or Alan, but from directly above the table. Then he feels something touch his shoulder, a small hand, freezing cold and firm. It squeezes three times and then retracts. Later,
Speaker 1Ellison will examine the footage from the ultraviolet camera they used for their investigation. He watched astound it as the moment came and went. There was no one near him at the time. Over many subsequent meetings, doctor Keene and Professor Ellison recorded a plethora of spectacles, endless variations on the auditory, illuminatory, and physical sensations delivered by the Apparent Spirit team. Gradually they wore down the assumed skepticism of
Speaker 1both investigators and the many other specialists that accompanied them to the sessions in the Skullhole. The fact that the Apparent Spirits insisted upon complete and toe lit darkness was a continual thorn in the skull group side, as naturally, it allowed suspicious minds in the press and the public to claim that clearly they were obscuring their tricks. But in all the years of attending the seances, doctor Keene and Professor Ellison never documented anything that pointed to either
Speaker 1a hoax or an inadvertent rationale for what happened when the lights were turned off. As months went by, the healthy spr skepticism began to crumble in the face of the truly inexplicable. And there is one strand of evidence in it all that stands out above all others in its striking confrontation with the very laws of physics as we understand them, the skull photographs. When doctor Keene and
Speaker 1Professor Ellison later heard about the strange photographs that the team had apparently captured, they leapt at the chance to repeat that experiment, only this time it would be under Keen and Ellison's controlled conditions, and so in April nineteen ninety six, Keen and Ellison joined the group in the cellar once again to do just that. By then, their numbers had shrunk, as Ken, Burnett and Mimi had drifted away for various reasons. The Foys and the Bennetts had
Speaker 1always been the most committed and most essential members of the study. Anyhow, each looked on with undimmed enthusiasm when doctor Keene presented the unopened role of film that he had personally sourced, ensuring there could be no tampering. In previous sessions, the supposed spirits had spoken about simply using their etheric energy to imprint on film instead of taking photographs, and so for this experiment, doctor Keene simply signed his
Speaker 1name over the seal and placed the film back inside a canister. Then the lights were turned off and the experiment began. After apparently communicating with spirits for some time, they eventually departed and the session was brought to an end. With the lights back on, Doctor Keene eagerly unraveled the film and was astonished by what he found inside. There appeared to be a dense tangle of blue lettering scrawled all over it, cryptic in both substance and meaning. As
Speaker 1they spread the thirteen inches of film across the table, the group read first of French quote translated to it is but the first step that counts, then a single Greek word, a short poem about the Earth, moon and sun, and two signatures written in reverse. This film was named the Diotema Film in reference to that single Greek word meaning honoured by Zeus. This was just the first of many such sophisticated messages supposedly committed somehow to unopened film.
Speaker 1Future examples included substantial excerpts from the bag of bad Geeta and long messages in cursive script, such as one that said poignantly, love continues beyond all barriers. One photograph was developed to reveal an entire page of handwritten text signed by a Frederick W. H. Myert, a Cambridge University scholar and early founder of the Society for Psychical Research. Myers, who died in nineteen oh one, famously promised to try
Speaker 1and make posthumous contact with his fellow spiritual enthusiasts if such a thing proved to be possible. When doctor Keene compared the handwriting of the letter imprinted on the film with Frederick Myers's own, the match was startlingly closed. Regardless of the contents of the photographs, their very existence flouted the rules of physics. Photographic images cannot occur without photons
Speaker 1without light. For these spectral displays to occur on film still safely wrapped in the darkness of their own packaging, it was simply impossible. The apparent Spirit Team described the process as the latest step in trans dimensional communication. They also apparently admitted, however, that they themselves were no true experts on the science of it all. John Paxton, the apparent Spirit, speaking on behalf of the High Council, confessed
Speaker 1that they were working at the threshold of their own understanding, using energies outside of their conventional spectrum. All this etheric light and told the group that it was able to interact with matter in ways not yet known. It was a lot to swallow, but even Professor Arthur Ellison, a trained engineer, felt compelled to confess that the skull photographs were the result of something that we do not understand happening at the molecular level. The physical evidence that the
Speaker 1Fois and their friends had been seeking for so long was now snowballing into something truly difficult to discount. Now more than four years into the study, the group, as well as the spr investigators, were eager to forge ahead with yet more discoveries. But the Spirit Team, it seemed, had other ideas. As nineteen ninety eight waned, the Spirit seemed to grow more urgent and troubled. They spoke of negative energies in the study who were becoming barriers to communication. Finally,
Speaker 1and without any warning, on Monday, November twenty third, nineteen ninety eight, doctor Keene and Professor Ellison received a phone call from Robin Foy. He said he was calling with troubling news that the Spirit Team had announced that the project must be shut down with immediate effect. The Spirits had apparently reported with some panic that a personality from the future was interfering with the interdimensional doorway each time it was opened, and their motives were not benevolent. The team,
Speaker 1according to Robin, had been working for some time on trying to overcome the problem. They had even reached out to specialists in other times and other realms, he said, but all of it was to no avail. It was a major blow to everyone involved, the SBR, the hundreds, possibly thousands of people following the study around the world, and most of all, to the four remaining members of the SKIS group themselves. The explanation veers closer to science fiction than spiritualism, and has been wielded against the group
Speaker 1ever since as a clear sign that their presumed hopes had gone too far either way. After five years and more than five hundred experimental sessions. That dark chamber below the Fois Farmhouse that was said to have echoed week after week with the voices of the dead, returned to being just another ordinary basement. The Skull experiment was over.
Speaker 1It must be said that none of the Skull group, including Ken Burnett and Mimi, ever reneged on a single detail of the study. Dozens of technical specialists could find no explanation for the bizarre things that they witnessed in that shadowy seller, and the hundreds of hours of audio, eerie photography, and other physical evidence are fully documented in doctor Keene and Professor Ellison's extensive report published in nineteen ninety nine. Likewise, in total, the Skull group claimed to
Speaker 1receive over seventy apports in the course of their experiments. None were ever proven to have been hoaxed. As for the investigators themselves, their final conclusion was typically measured unable to detect any direct indication of fraud or deception. It reads evidence favoring the hypothesis of intelligent force, evidence pointing to survival after death inconclusive. It's a final word that's
Speaker 1perhaps anticlimactic for the believer, but which speaks to the open mindedness of their survey. In the years since, naturally, debate has continued over the authenticity of the Skull experiment. To some, it's a hoax gone madly, staggeringly overboard. For others, it's the most compelling case for the persistence of the human personality after death. But what would that continuation be like? What kind of realm was the spirit realm? According to
Speaker 1the Skull group, it's a question never satisfactorily answered, even after so many hours of apparent conversation. There are hints, however, During the height of the photographic experiments, the Spirit team announced that they had built a new device in their realm. They termed this a Spirit camera, and claimed that it could capture images from the etheric world and imprint them more directly and more clearly onto the film in the cellar. It sounded like a step too far for the investigators
Speaker 1at first, but shortly after, as nineteen ninety six rolled into ninety seven, the quality of the captured images did grow markedly clearer. More interestingly, the images themselves were less rooted in human history, and began instead to hint at other worlds beyond ours, an unrecognized galaxy with spiral arms reaching into unknown space, landscapes that looked like nowhere on Earth,
Speaker 1odd esoteric symbols belonging to no known language or runic system, and one image of a pair of planets that look like nothing in our solar system? What are these images? Where are they? One of the most famous of all skull photos, taken in September nineteen ninety eight, shows a pair of pyramids against a smeared, desert like backdrop. The sides of the pyramids are said to be too steep and angular to match anything on Earth, and that they
Speaker 1are not organic structures, but rather structures that have been built. What does this mean for our conception of life life after death? Was this evidence not only that we go on, but that we go somewhere else entirely, that death is not the end, but the beginning of a wonderful journey of miracles still yet to see that, for now, for those of us still here on Earth, at least, remains unexplained.
Speaker 1This episode was written by Neil McRobert and Richard McLain Smith. Please remember to like and subscribe if you've enjoyed the show. Unexplained is an Avy Club Productions podcast created by me Richard McLain Smith. All other elements of the podcast, including the music, are also produced by me. Unexplained. The book and audiobook is now available to buy worldwide. You can purchase from Amazon, Barnes and Noble, Waterstones and other books. Still, be sure to follow us on Instagram, TikTok and Facebook at Unexplained Podcast and on X and Blue Sky at
Speaker 1Unexplained Pod. Until next time, stay strange and dissonant.
UNEXPLAINED SEASON 10 BEGINS FRIDAY DECEMBER 4TH In the meantime we’re continuing with our look back at some of your favourite episodes from the vaults. This week we’re venturing back to the autumn of 1984, to the...
UNEXPLAINED SEASON 10 BEGINS FRIDAY DECEMBER 4TH In 1802, Prussian naturalist Alexander von Humboldt was introduced to guano, a substance made from accumulated bird and bat droppings that had been prized for centuries...
UNEXPLAINED SEASON 10 BEGINS FRIDAY DECEMBER 4TH In January 1986, a strange object was witnessed crashing into a mountain in a far eastern region of the then Soviet Union. Described by some as Russia's Roswell, analysis...
On this week's Night Tales, have we got a story for you. Back in 1975 in a quiet English town, a naked man is found wondering around the neighbourhood covered in blood. But things only get stranger from there. Pull up a...
UNEXPLAINED SEASON 10 BEGINS FRIDAY NOVEMBER 27TH Fear, it would seem, is a powerful primal emotion. So potent that it can even make us afraid of things that may not even exist. But then again, just because we can't see...