109 of145 • Lesson11.7 • Chapter11: Islam’s Conflicts with Empirical Observations Understanding and Refuting Islam - Truth Booster This lesson examines Quran passages concerning water, living things, rain and the meeting of fresh and salt water. Compare the course’s reading with the passages in context and the difference between descriptive imagery and empirical claims. Presentation references: 1. Quran, Surah al-Anbiya, 21:30 (Pickthall translation) https://quranx.com/21.30 https://quran.com/21/30 2. Quran, Surah an-Nur, 24:45 (Pickthall translation) https://quranx.com/24.45 https://quran.com/24/45 3. Quran, Surah an-Nur, 24:43 (Hilali-Khan translation) https://quranx.com/24.43 https://quran.com/24/43 4. Quran, Surah al-Furqan, 25:48 (Hilali-Khan translation) https://quranx.com/25.48 https://quran.com/25/48 5. Quran, Surah al-Furqan, 25:53 (Hilali-Khan translation) https://quranx.com/25.53 https://quran.com/25/53 6. Quran, Surah ar-Rahman, 55:19-20 (Hilali-Khan translation) https://quranx.com/55.19 https://quran.com/55/19 Listen in numbered order: https://truthbooster.com AI-assisted narration/presentation.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Water is where section 11.7 begins, Muhammad on Water. We touch it every day, so claims about it are easy to test. We will look at what is said about where life comes from and about the weather, and ask whether the Quran describes the world as we actually find it. Our first slide opens with an ancient Greek idea. Now we go to something every one of us touches every day. Water. Long before Muhammad, there was a Greek philosopher named Thales, who thought that everything came from water. Years later, it seems that Allah
and Muhammad picked up on the same idea. Listen to Surah al-Anbiya, chapter 21, verse 30, in Pickthall's translation. Quote, Have not those who disbelieve known that the heavens and the earth were of one piece, then we parted them, and we made every living thing of water? Will they not then believe? End quote. And Surah An -Nur, chapter 24, verse 45, again in Pickthall, quote, Allah hath created every animal of water. Of them is a kind that goeth upon its belly,
and a kind that goeth upon two legs, and a kind that goeth upon four. Allah createth what he will. Lo, Allah is able to do all things, end quote. According to the Quran, then, everything was made from water. Yet water is only hydrogen and oxygen. And as we saw earlier, in another part of the Quran, Allah claimed he made man from clay. So which is it? Now let's see what the Quran says about the weather. This book argues that Allah is unfamiliar with how weather normally
works. In Surah an-Nur, chapter 24, verse 43, the rain comes from between the clouds, not from the clouds. And there is that part about mountains of hail in the sky. We have never seen that. Listen, in the translation of al-Hilali, and Khan. Quote, See you not that Allah drives the clouds gently, then joins them together, then makes them into a heap of layers, and you see the rain comes forth from between them. And he sends down from the sky hail like mountains,
or there are in the heaven mountains of hail from where he sends down hail, and strike therewith whom he will, and averts it from whom he wills. The vivid flash of its clouds, lightning nearly blinds the sight. End quote. And in Surah Al -Furqan, chapter 25, verse 48, the Qur'an claims that rain is pure water. In the Hilali and Khan translation, quote, and it is he who sends the winds as heralds of glad tidings, going before his mercy, rain, and we send down pure water
from the sky, end quote. The manuscript cuts that verse off here, but the point stands. In fact, rain picks up what is in the air on its way down. Now let's turn to the seas. Allah says there are two types of water that never mix. Surah al-Furqan, chapter 25, verse 53, in Hilali and Khan. And it is He who has let free the two seas, kinds of water, one palatable and sweet, and the other salt and bitter, and He has set
a barrier and a complete partition between them. And Surah ar-Rahman, chapter 55, verses 19 and 20, also in Hilali and Khan. He has let loose the two seas, the salt water and the sweet, meeting together. Between them is a barrier which none of them can transgress. Allah says there is a barrier and a complete partition between them. But this is not true. Sweet water flows into the oceans and eventually mixes. It takes a little
while, as it does for any body of liquid flowing into another. But they do mix. If they did not, the region of sweet water would continually be growing since it is continually flowing into the salty water. You can follow the discussion of Muhammad's statements about water back to its sources here. Pause the video to examine these references, also listed in the description. I provide them so you can do your own research, weigh the evidence, and reach your own conclusions. Here is the last page of references for Muhammad's
statements about water. Pause as long as you need. The description includes these sources too, giving you a way to examine the evidence yourself and form your own considered conclusions. Follow any river to the sea and ask yourself, do the waters stay apart? The Quran says, two seas never mix, and that everything was made from water. This chapter sets those claims beside a map. For every source, get the free book at www.truthbooster.com. There are free Christian
books and content in every language. Drop your questions in the comments, share this video, and like and subscribe.
145 of 145 • Course Finale: Closing Word Understanding and Refuting Islam - Truth Booster The course closes with a personal appeal to ask careful questions, listen patiently and treat Muslim neighbors, coworkers and...
144 of 145 • Chapter 4 Companion: Closing Argument Understanding and Refuting Islam - Truth Booster Return to the course’s overview of Muhammad’s life. This closing presentation gathers the author’s critical assessment...
143 of 145 • Lesson 15.3 • Appendix B: Divine Plural Language Understanding and Refuting Islam - Truth Booster This lesson sets out the royal or majestic-plural explanation and follows the course author’s proposed...
142 of 145 • Lesson 15.2 • Appendix B: Divine Plural Language Understanding and Refuting Islam - Truth Booster Compare the Arabic pronouns ana and nahnu and examine the course author’s questions about divine plural...
141 of 145 • Lesson 15.1 • Appendix B: Divine Plural Language Understanding and Refuting Islam - Truth Booster Examine the singular and plural wording in Genesis 1:26-28 and 11:6-7. This lesson presents the course’s...