Why This Top Agent Threw Away His Business Cards (And Other Counterintuitive Moves)
43 minAudio
Want the best insights from this episode and more in bite-sized nuggets? Sign up for our free newsletter at https://undercontractnotes.com/ Guest Bio: Casey McCoy is a real estate team leader with Keller Williams based in Evansville, Indiana, running a five-agent team that has grown roughly 50 percent year over year for the past three years. He got his start in real estate after a rough experience buying his first house at age 20, which led him to get licensed in 2010, and he has since built a business rooted in investment income, relationship-first client acquisition, and early adoption of AI tools. Episode Summary: Casey McCoy joins Under Contract to share the winding, almost accidental path that led him from a foreclosure-threatened house hack at 20 years old into building a thriving real estate team in Evansville, Indiana. He dives into the mentorship moment that reshaped his entire business model, his relationship-first approach to lead generation and follow-up, and how he is already using AI tools like Claude to build custom real estate technology on the cheap. What's Covered: Casey recounts buying his first house at 20 with three lined-up roommates, only to end up in foreclosure and upside down on the mortgage after a botched roof repair and a market crash, which unexpectedly pushed him into getting his real estate license He credits mentor Mike McCarthy with two pivotal lessons that changed his business: hiring help early by asking 'why are you stealing someone else's joy' and building investment income so he never has to pressure a client to transact Casey explains his go-to strategy for starting over in a new city with no database, which centers on visiting locally owned coffee shops to get introductions to well-connected community members, plus working expired listings for faster results He details his personal lead sources, including ditching business cards entirely to control follow-up timing, a Zillow partnership that converts about one in five leads into referrals, and strategic Thursday open houses paired with 100-door neighborhood knocks Casey identifies follow-up in the middle of his funnel as his single biggest current business problem despite explosive top-of-funnel growth, and shares client feedback showing people actually want to be followed up with rather than feeling bothered He shares his history experimenting with AI-driven real estate technology, from a $25,000 nine-month platform build in 2014 to recreating similar functionality in a weekend for about $50 using Claude, plus his vision for a client-facing AI assistant trained on his own conversations and local market knowledge Timestamps: 00:00:39 - How Casey got into real estate after running out of college money 00:03:37 - The roof repair that never happened and led to foreclosure 00:06:03 - Getting licensed with his last $500 00:08:06 - Mentor Mike McCarthy and the turning point conversation 00:10:50 - Why are you stealing someone else's joy, the hiring lesson 00:12:46 - What Casey would do first starting over in a new city 00:17:09 - Why Casey stopped using business cards 00:19:08 - Zillow partnership and referral conversion rates 00:22:14 - Casey's follow-up philosophy and building relationships over transactions 00:26:51 - The one problem Casey would fix with a magic wand: follow-up 00:31:53 - Casey's early AI platform build in 2014 versus rebuilding it in a weekend with Claude 00:36:03 - Using AI-powered seller updates to guide price reduction conversations 00:38:04 - Casey's vision for a personal AI assistant trained on his own client conversations
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_00Uh before we jump into today's episode, I interview dozens of top producing agents every month. And I know you probably don't have the time to listen to every single conversation. So we do the listening and note taking for you. We pull out the best ideas and strategies we're hearing and regularly send you the ones we're putting to work in your business. It's completely free. Just go to undercontractnotes.com. That's undercontractnotes.com. Now let's get into today's conversation.
SPEAKER_00Hey there and welcome to undercontract, where I sit down with some of the top real estate agents and team leaders in the country to talk about how they've built their businesses, uh, what's working right now and where they see the industry going next. So today I am joined by Casey McCoy from Evansville, Indiana. Casey, thanks for coming on. I'm excited to have you.
SPEAKER_01I am Tim, appreciate you having me on. I'm excited about it.
SPEAKER_00Let's jump right into it. I'm excited as well. Um I would start with the first question, which is take me back to the beginning, right? How did you get into real estate? How did you get from there to where you are today?
SPEAKER_01Okay. Yeah, so I was uh I was uh 20 going to college and um I ran out of money for college. So I so I I joined the military and um I started looking around and I was like, well, I don't I don't really know what I want to do with my life. Um but one thing that I do know is that smart people buy real estate. And so at 20, uh I went to my mom and dad and I was like, hey, I think I'm gonna buy a house.
SPEAKER_01And they were like, I think that's a bad idea. You should just rent an apartment. Um and I was like, okay, well, uh my my three, you know, up until that point, the the three people that I knew, my grandma, my uncle, and my parents, uh all owned houses. And I said, Well, I mean, it's worked out pretty well for you guys. Um this the year is 2006, by the way. And uh so I call on a few, you know, uh uh sign calls and I get hooked up with this agent.
SPEAKER_01She just, you know, I I don't know anything. I'm the only person other than my parents and my uncle and my grandma that, you know, are is looking at houses. So um I don't know to ask anybody, you know, what to do. I just have this idea that I want to live uh not with my parents, but still not have a mortgage payment. And I said, okay, the the only way that that could happen is if I go buy a house and then I rent out the rooms. Uh this is what's now called house hacking.
SPEAKER_01Uh at the time I just was like, I'd like to party and uh not live with my parents and have some other people pay the rent. So uh I went out on search for the house. I had a couple through had three three roommates lined up. Closing took a little bit longer. You know, I got I got pre-approved back then for like$150,000. I started doing the math. I'm like, I don't make this much a month. I'm like part-time security guard going to college. So I you're like, that doesn't make any sense to me.
SPEAKER_01Like, let's back that number down a little bit, be a little conservative. And um, so I ended up buying this house, closing took a little bit longer. So the in the meantime, those people went and rented something else. And I'm like, well, uh what do I do now? Now I have this house, my plan is starting to unravel already. And um, so I found some other roommates, put them in there. I started a party business when I was in college, and we built out a big, it became a pretty large thing.
SPEAKER_01Um, but along that path, my house um uh that I purchased, it had a leak in the garage roof. It had a big four-car garage. I needed a big garage to party in. Um, so I uh uh that leak was supposed to be fixed by the time closing happened. And I don't know anything. Again, I'm 20. Um, I'm trusting the people that I've hired around me to know what the heck is going on. Um and uh we get to the close and I was like, hey, did uh all the stuff that we asked for to get repaired get done?
SPEAKER_01And they're like, yeah, this stuff did, but the roof, it's too cold outside to do it, it was a flat roof. And I was like, okay, yeah, when are they going back out there? They're like, this is November. They're like, ah, they're gonna get back out there in the spring as soon as it warms up. I'm like, cool, that sounds sounds great. That never happened. That agent got out of the business uh because 2008 happened. And uh um so along that path, I was like, I mean, this can't be that hard. Like, the to make sure that like people get pr are protected and served well, and to make sure that nothing unexpected like that happens to them can't be that difficult.
SPEAKER_01Um, I had an agent, uh buddy of mine that I met through uh our college uh parties, and uh had him come over and he was looking at my house and I was like, I don't know. We I had just had three rounds of roommates move out. And I was like, I'm tired of this cycle of getting new people in here and uh and trying to figure out the house hack thing. And uh, of course I didn't have that verbiage back then, but uh got them in, him in, he was doing evaluation, he was like, I bought the house at 10102.
SPEAKER_01Um he was like, the house is worth about 75,000. And I was like, well, I don't have$25,000, so it looks like I'm gonna try to figure this thing out. Um and I was behind on my mortgage at the time, and so my house was in foreclosure, I was upside down, and uh, and the only person that really knew uh was me. I didn't share that with anybody. Um, and as I was just talking to him, he goes, uh he was like, Well, you know, what do you think? I was like, dude, I don't know.
SPEAKER_01I don't even know what I want to do in life. And he was like, Have you thought about real estate? I was like, I well, yeah, I have. You know, my uncle was in some development stuff, he was a big state farm insurance guy. So always been, you know, I've always had that um that that viewpoint in life that like, well, life can be pretty different uh depending on the paths you take. And so I said, Yeah, but I don't know anything about it. And he was like, dude, just get license, join my team. He was like, it'll be it'll be great. And I was like, okay, well, how much does that cost?
SPEAKER_01And he was like, the class is like 500 bucks. And I go, well, I have$550 in my account. And it's like, uh, so I yeah, if that's how much it costs, like this is the only opportunity path that I see forward. Uh so I took my last 500 bucks basically, took the class, and then he didn't tell me about the licensing and the board dues and all that stuff that I figured out later that he ended up uh his mom ended up loaning me some money for, thankfully.
SPEAKER_01That's awesome. Yeah. Uh so it was this weird little randomness of uh path to get here. Luckily, that house I worked out with the bank and I sold it off in 2020. Um, and uh we did pretty well on it. But that's the reason that I ended up getting in real estate was I was, you know, at college go studying print journalism and uh and marketing, and I was like, and newspapers all around the country were going down, so I figured why not this path? I'm pretty good at talking to people and I'm pretty and I want to serve people.
SPEAKER_01So yeah, that's how I ended up here.
SPEAKER_00I love it. What a great story. Yeah, well, yeah, print journalism probably was not the ideal uh path path to take. Um okay, so that was a party, Casey. Uh 20 oh close to 20 years ago. Um here with a fast forward. Um you know, I I feel like typically someone who's uh built uh uh a business at your level there's usually like a point or two in their journey. Uh maybe it was a decision, a strategy, a hire, or maybe just a different way of thinking about the business where uh like you can point back and say that was a real turning point uh in your business.
SPEAKER_00Can you identify maybe uh one or two things that happened in your business that you can look back and say that's that's pretty crucial that that happened to get where I am right now?
SPEAKER_01Most definitely I can draw right to it. So um uh a couple things. One, I luckily um uh so I'm at Keller Williams, uh, our operating principal at the time, his coach, his name's Mike McCarthy, and uh he owns uh a couple of the Keller Williams regions. Um he he made a bet with my operating principal and he said, Hey, if you don't do these things, I'll come in and I'll teach a class for your agents for free. I'll fly in, teach a class.
SPEAKER_01Luckily, he did those things, and uh so Mike had to come in, teach a class to us. Mike's talking up on stage. This is probably 2014 or so. I've been in the business about four years. I got in in 2010. And um, you know, I'm making a ton of calls every day, expired listings for sell by owners, but you name it, I'm talking to them. And um, I'm listening to Mike on stage, and he's like, you know, I uh my wife's name's Lindsay, I own a brewery, um, I own some Keller Williams franchises and regents, and I'm like, my wife's name's Lindsay.
SPEAKER_01I'd love to own a brewery. That's being a owner in uh some brokerages sounds awesome. And so after the class, I I uh go up to him and I say, Hey Mike, um, I don't know anything about anything, but I have this call to ask you to mentor me, and I don't even know what that looks like or how that would shake out or anything. And he's Mike's like, absolutely, yeah, definitely. So he starts working with me um and shows me a different path, right?
SPEAKER_01Which is one of um your uh expenses can be paid for by the cash flow of your investments. It's the first time I'd ever heard that in my life. And I have thought to myself, back to, you know, I I want to live not at my parents' house, but also for free. I'm like, I like this idea of living for free based off of the income from things that I've invested in, where I don't have to get up every day and go to work, because that sounds like a lot. And that's I'm I'm ambitiously lazy, so that sounds like a pain in the butt.
SPEAKER_01Um so um uh along that path, I started um uh he did he taught me two real key things along there. Um I said uh he was like you need to hire somebody so that you can focus on 100% generating leads and closing contracts and meeting with clients. Um and I said, Okay, but like I, you know, I'm a pretty particular person. I like things to be done a certain way. And he goes, I totally get that.
SPEAKER_01Um, why are you stealing someone else's joy? And I thought, oh my gosh. Uh he said, Do you think somewhere someone out there, he said, let me ask you a question, do you like doing that stuff? I said, no, I like talking to people, I like meeting with people, I like helping people with their problems. He goes, someone out there hates that, but loves everything else. And I thought, wow, that's uh so I had my made my first hire after that.
SPEAKER_01And then um along the path, you know, one of the things, again, creating income from your investments. Uh, he said, he said, well, you know, from a foundation level, if you have cash flow coming in, you're not worried about each deal closing. You're not, you know, you're worried about serving the client to their best of their ability for them. And I thought to myself, that's my whole goal. That's like that's the way I think about it anyway. He said, well, if you have a base level of income from your investments, from your real estate investing, um, then you don't have to worry.
SPEAKER_01You don't need every client to transact with you. You can just show up and serve them however fits best for them. And so that idea really took hold and became the base level of uh building out the team. Um, we started investing in 2017 and then started building out the team uh about 2019.
SPEAKER_00Love it. Well, that it's amazing uh sometimes what one mentor can do for you. Um sounds like that was a a big paradigm shift for you. Now I I always like to ask this because there are some newer agents uh that are are listening to this. Um and it's a question of if I dropped you into a brand new city tomorrow with no database, no reputation, no relationships, and you had to build it all over again, what would you do first?
SPEAKER_01I'd go to a coffee shop. Okay. I'd go to a coffee shop and I'd meet whoever owns it, not Starbucks, right? Locally owned place. I'd go to a locally owned place, coffee shop first and ask that owner, who do I need to know that they know? And then from there I would meet more people and ask the same question next. Like, hey, who comes in here that's influential that you love dealing with? That especially if I like the person that owns the coffee shop, that's a clear thing there.
SPEAKER_01You know, it's like if I connect with them, the prob the person they're gonna introduce me to probably is going to be very similar. So uh, and open to introducing me to other people. So, like that's that is the way that you know when we my wife and I travel a lot. That's the one thing that we always do is go into a coffee shop and especially locally owned one, and we just support them and try their coffee. Sometimes it's great and sometimes it's not so great.
SPEAKER_01Uh but but it's all the person that's running it always has a big heart for the community. So uh that that specific business um does so, but and they're attached to everybody, especially if they're well located, they're in an area around a lot of people. Um, yeah, the the one thing I you know would do other than that is probably call expired listings for sale by owners. Um, but I've I to be honest, uh we've listed maybe 10 for sale by owners over the 16 years of my career.
SPEAKER_01I just never really could figure that out. But expired listings, I'm your guy. Like, you know, it's just like they need somebody to show up, care for them, listen to their story, and help them change something that's happening in their life. So if I needed money, that's why I would go after. Um, but if but really to rebuild uh relationships is worth uh I love that.
SPEAKER_00Uh I appreciate the sort of uh uh two-pronged approach there. It makes a lot of sense. I like the the coffee shop idea and the context is why as to why a coffee shop owner is such a great connection. Um and uh it's interesting too. I think about uh generally speaking in business, um there's a customer journey, right? There's someone that's completely like isn't even thinking about real estate to obviously a client. And what I what I do think sort of generally speaking, when I take a step back, I think about an expired listing, it's like that's someone that's further along uh the journey, right?
SPEAKER_00Like you don't have to sell you don't have to sell them on the idea that they're they want to sell for hours. Like they're already there. It's just we we might need to do a little maintenance, a little look under the hood there, but I I like that a lot because instead of just straight up cold calling people who you have no idea what their status is uh in their relate their uh real estate kind of cycle, if you will.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I mean, real estate's an event business. You know, that normally somebody has an event in their life, and that's the thing that's causing them to upend all of their normal daily crap to then go, well guys, let's pack everything up and let's move. So that timing is really important, and uh, and that event, whatever it is, can depict the timing. You know, if if if grandma falls, that event happens really fast, you know, and that and that's unfortunate when it does happen, and if they have a plan in place for that, because you know it's gonna happen to everybody eventually.
SPEAKER_02Sure.
SPEAKER_01Everybody will transact and will sell. It's just when it is, and it's yeah, like you can be prepared for it, or it can life can happen to you, you know. And I like I like our clients to be prepared more than you know surprises always suck if you're not prepared for it. It sucks way more.
SPEAKER_00Yep. Yep, 100%. So let's talk about uh client acquisition uh for just a moment. Um where are your best clients actually coming from today? And what's working now, maybe that wasn't working a few years ago?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, yeah, good question. Um so first of all, for like my personal business on the team. Yep. My my personal business is repeat referral clients. Um that that's been true for the last 10 years, probably. Um so one thing that I stopped doing about 10 years ago, I actually had somebody ask me for a business card yesterday. Uh so it's top of mind. Uh, I stopped giving out business cards. I stopped getting them printed. I don't have any, I've not had any for 10 years.
SPEAKER_01What I do though is if I meet you, Tim, and you say, Hey, do you have a business card? I go, Oh man, I don't. I'm out. Um, but what's your number? I'll text you. That puts me in the driver's seat of that relationship.
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Then a week from now, I can reach out and say, Hey, Tim, you remember we met at the coffee shop? You said that you liked popcorn. This is a link to that popcorn flavoring I was telling you about. That's a real thing that happened a week ago. Um, so it puts me in the driver's seat of creating and cultivating that relationship instead of what normally what I found out happens in the first four years, right? It's like I give uh, you know, Tim, I give you my business card, and then you at some point in time lose that business card by the time that you're wanting to make that phone call, and then you're like, Oh shit, what was that guy's name?
SPEAKER_01He was really cool. I thought he was he said a lot of stuff that really helped me out. Fuck, what was his name? And then you just don't know. So instead of that happening, stopping that, but that's again putting myself in the driver's seat of relationships. That's that's which relationships are super important to me. So um curating them has to be of importance to me. Um but so that's one thing that drive that drives most of my personal business.
SPEAKER_01Um is repeat and referral clients. Um or the agents on my team. Uh we've got a Zillow partnership. So they they drive that. Through that, though, they get uh from our numbers stance, we get about one referral per five leads that come through on Zillow side, from them introducing us to a parent, to a friend, to whatever. Um, and it's just because again, we're super relationship focused.
SPEAKER_01We're not um we're we want to make sure that we serve them for them, not so much serve them for us. Um, so that is one thing that it does make it easier, right, on the agent side to drive some of those leads forward. Those are the two things open houses when we do them strategically, which is we knock a hundred doors around the open house. And again, this all looks like work, right? So, like not everybody wants to do it because it really looks like work, because it is work.
SPEAKER_01So door knock a hundred doors around the open house, invite all the neighbors to the open house. It's not rocket science, it's just relationships. You catch in people on a Saturday morning, inviting them to a Sunday uh, you know, open house. And we've we've shifted that a little bit recently to Thursday open houses, um, because we've noticed people have been held up in their houses on Sundays. I I do the same thing myself. Like, yeah, hey, I need a day to not have to interact with people as much as I love people.
SPEAKER_01I just need a day to myself. So uh we've shifted that a little bit, but yeah, just inviting the neighbors, getting to know them. Yeah, a lot of times we get them coming over, bringing a friend over to the house. It doesn't sell the house all the time, but it gets activity in there and it gets people looking and it gets people talking about it. So you know that's the goal. Um, but you know, we use a lot of strategic open houses, so most of the time though the house sells before the open house anyway, but we still get that can connection in the community there.
SPEAKER_00I love it. And speaking of the team, uh how many people are on your team right now?
SPEAKER_01Um so we've got uh myself and four other agents. Uh and then two uh two operations side.
SPEAKER_00Got it. And uh as the Zilla partner, does does that tend to keep the team pretty busy? Um from a lead perspective?
SPEAKER_01It does, yeah. Um, so we're uh over the past three years, we've been up about 50 percent um every year. And uh this year we're just past um uh just surpassed where we were last year in November um in July. So we're gonna be up about 50 percent again this year. So yeah, it does it does.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, yeah, I I see that. Um now we we talked about lead generation. The so the next part that I see agents uh struggling with is the follow-up part, right? You can get leads, but how effective are you at follow-up? So, what is your you and your team's uh system as far as like when a lead comes in, uh what happens maybe in the first five minutes versus six months from now? Because as you pointed out, like there's a this is an event business. Just because someone raised their hand doesn't mean mean uh that they're gonna be ready to buy, buy, or sell in the first 30, 60 years.
SPEAKER_00But I think a lot of agents kind of really hone in on that and don't focus on the on the relationship. And uh so I'd love to hear your thoughts on how you guys approach that.
SPEAKER_01So I'll give you two, I'll give you two things. One, what it looked like before the team before I built the team out, and then two, what it looks like today. So before I built the team out, uh, we were generating uh 50-ish leads a month from just online uh blogs and all kinds of different stuff. And when those were coming in and I was the one in control of them, um I would go stalk their Facebook page, Adam is a friend on Facebook, uh find out anything that I could find out about them in Facebook, Instagram, whatever, not to stalk them in and be creepy, but so that I had something to talk about, right?
SPEAKER_01So, like Tim, again, back to the popcorn analogy. If I knew that you liked popcorn a lot, I would go, oh Tim, I I'd I'd randomly bring it up. Not to um, I I think about building bridges all the time. How can I build a bridge between me and you? So so that because it's never something where I'm just making stuff up. Like I wouldn't be like, Tim, hey, I saw that you're a car guy. I'm a car guy too. Yeah, yeah. I'm not a car guy, so that wouldn't be something I'd bring out.
SPEAKER_01Um, I drive a crazy car now, but that's because it it looks like a dumpster and I love it. Uh but so uh, but the um, but I there are people that are really big car guys or really, you know, most of the things though you can draw a line through the middle of. Most car guys are very particular. So I I I know to drive in on that, right? So like I'm learning their personality more than anything else, so that I know how to speak to them and so that I can communicate well with them for them, not for me.
SPEAKER_01Because for me, the easiest thing is to say the same thing over and over to you, to the next person, to the next person, to the next person. The harder thing is to do the deep dive on the relationship and get really focused and solid on who Tim is so that I can help Tim so that when he is ready to transact, Tim goes. I mean, the obvious person to call here is Casey. Right? That that's that's the whole goal. It's not to do the transaction today. It's really honestly, I use real estate as a reason to stay in relationship with people.
SPEAKER_01I mean I I love what a great pair.
SPEAKER_00I I like the way you flip that. That's uh and I I do think um real estate certainly feels like a a a relationship compounding game too. It's just like the more you actually focus on the relationship and you keep doing that and you create more relationships. My guess is that when you look up five years from now, your business is gonna look very different. If you are uh close, there's a lot of tactics you know out there that you can do, but I think at the end of the day, like if you want if you're actually genuinely want to help people and you and you have a genuine relationship without the idea in the back of your mind of how how can I get this person to transact with me?
SPEAKER_00Um a book that really was a a game changer for me like years ago was I don't know if you ever read The Go Giver. Oh yeah, oh yeah, yeah, yeah. Huge huge, huge book for me. Yeah. Huge book. And it's an easy read, by the way. Uh if you're listening to this, you haven't listened to that. Yeah, it's it and it's a great story. Like um it's just a uh basically a story. And um what I loved about about it was it's just it creates a filter that you can look at relationships through. And I'm it's crucial for my success.
SPEAKER_00It's been crucial that was a game changer for you. Sounds like it was pretty important uh for you too. So definitely uh check that one out. Um okay, so one thing I want to ask you uh you obviously you're growing 50% every year, it sounds like, which is fantastic. Um but if you could wave a magic wand and solve one problem in your business over the next 12 months, what would have the biggest impact? You can dream here a little bit.
SPEAKER_01I mean, honest, honestly, we have a really large top-end funnel, and that is a great thing, and it's also a super huge detriment because me not being at like I'm not at the helm of every person that comes in, right? Cultivating that relationship, which that is my number one skill in life is relationships. Um, by the way, the uh uh strengths finder, if you've it like for anybody that has not done that, that was huge for me.
SPEAKER_01Along I read that and go giver kind of simultaneously, and I was like, these two things go happenstantially for me, very good together. Um so uh, but that's that's the uh the winning others over for whatever reason. I've been good at it my whole life. Uh it's probably because I've always been a big ass dude. So every room I go into, people are you know, they're like, Who's that big guy? Um, so I had to, you know, be like, no, I'm cool.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, yeah, that's true. Yeah.
SPEAKER_01I'm not gonna hurt you. Yeah. Um, but so if I could wave a magic wand, and we're going through this actually right now at the moment, um, because our funnel's so big at the top, we are missing people in the middle. Our follow-up is the one thing that like, and it sounds crazy to say out loud because this would not be, you know, if if I if I had to choose my problems, you know, five years ago, this would not be one that would be on my bingo card because I'm so diligent about once somebody comes into my uh atmosphere, making sure that they stay in my atmosphere, right?
SPEAKER_01Mostly so because I know if they're in my atmosphere, I can serve them. And I'm not gonna tell them something that's self-serving to me, because I don't, I don't need to try, I don't need them to transact, right? I built the I built the foundation of my investment business so that I could serve people to the highest level, which means that if, you know, if you get if I get a phone call from somebody and we go to their house and they're like, yeah, you know, we just kind of want to move. And I'm like, okay, well, you know, what's your what's your finances look like right now?
SPEAKER_01It's an intrusive question that a lot of people think most people are totally open to share. If you if you if you're coming at it from a genuine perspective, and they're like, well, okay, so we've got like a 2. you know, 7% interest rate. I'm like, you should not sell. You should stay here. Unless there's some big thing that's moving you to do it, you should stay right here where you are. I'm happy to help you figure out how to tap some equity or whatever you, you know, it might look like. Uh if you want to, you know, do something for pay for kids' college or upgrade or whatever.
SPEAKER_01You know, wife needs a new car. Don't care what it is. But like if I don't know the whole story, I can't help you make those decisions. Um, but yeah, the the follow-up side is the one thing that I um that that honestly would be the the big driver for that. We've got a uh we just hired a new operations person about a month ago, and she's been going through helping us cultivate some of those. And uh every single day I wake up to messages, hey, we already bought a house, hey, we sold our house, we really appreciate you following up.
SPEAKER_01And by the way, that was a good recent aha for me. Literally yesterday, I saw a text come through. It said, We bought a house, but I really appreciate you following up. Like, we think we're bugging people when we're following the real reality is we're not. People want to be followed up with, they want to be reminded of the things that they set out for themselves to do in life. They just need somebody to go, hey, Tim, remember you that you remember you told me you want to do that one thing?
SPEAKER_01Just call in to see if you did that.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Oh, it's amazing.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I love it. Yeah, well, don't I would say this? I I talk to a lot of uh smart agents, and uh the follow-up is you hear that a lot, uh, especially when you're starting to do more volume, uh, like you guys are as a team. So um one thing I want to ask you, uh, because you kind of can't ignore it, uh, is is AI, right? Um a lot about it. Um I when I talk to agents, you know, some agents are really excited about certain things, uh, some think it might be a little bit of smoke and mirrors.
SPEAKER_00Um tell me about your relationship with AI right now. Uh how are you using your business? Where would you like to use your business? Where do you think maybe it's this is like a very like a four-part question here. Uh where also where uh maybe you think that you've heard uh it could be used a business where you're like, eh, I don't know that I'd I'd be down for that.
SPEAKER_01So uh I we in 2014, um a little backstory. So like 2014-ish, you know, it was like I was kind of figuring it out. I was selling, you know, 30 to 40 houses by myself a year uh in that first four-ish years. So I went, you know, started making a little bit of money, and I was like, okay, well, I started seeing this um uh this play out over and over again, where somebody would call me and say, Hey, uh, Casey, I'm moving to Las Vegas.
SPEAKER_01Um you know, do you know any good agents out there? And I'm like, okay, yeah, yeah, totally. I can get you hooked up with an agent out there. Um so I would call uh most of the time, you know, a couple market centers out there, and I would say, hey, talk to the team leader and go, hey, who do you know that I need to know? And then they'd introduce me to two or three people. I'd call those people and I'd go, okay, for that person, that person won't work. That person won't work. Ooh, this would be a really good fit, right? And it's mostly personality driven.
SPEAKER_01Because somebody that cares about details is not gonna care about this person that just told me about their dog's, you know, best friend at daycare. Like they they'll be like, okay, time out, Casey hooked me up with the wrong person. Uh, but so their ability to know themselves is high up on that list. So we built out a uh technology platform that connected buyers and sellers with agents based off their area expertise, personality, and location geography geography. Um, and it it took us about$25,000 to do.
SPEAKER_01And I went when uh ChatGPT dropped, well, when Claude dropped with the the dev capability side, I was like, I wonder how quickly and inexpensively I could build this. Because it took us about nine months to go through the whole phase back in 2014. I did it in a weekend with about$50. The whole algorithm, the whole everything. It's like, wow, that's insane.
SPEAKER_01So that trajectory and that that endeavor ended up you know failing because we figured out pretty quickly that uh we needed to spend basically about two million dollars more to attract enough people to the platform because we were onboarding agents all the time, very easily. But it was the clients side that we you know just didn't have a good lever. So uh, but fast forward since then we've been building out different tools on the back end. Like I got um um I we're a MLS provider now uh through the state of Indiana.
SPEAKER_01Um, and it's because I was like, well, hey, I need a new, I need a new MLS feed for this project I'm working on. And they're like, well, who's your tech, you know, who's your technology provider that you're working with? I was like, me and Claude, but Claude's not gonna sign anything. So how do we do this? Um, so we've been building out a bunch of different tools and stuff and really just connecting. We right now we're working on one that's uh a larger project, and I really I probably am at the point where we need to get a developer to come in and like help the last that it's like that last 10% or something that's just really hard to nail on bigger projects.
SPEAKER_01You can do a bunch of different little stuff. One of the things that um uh uh that we're that we've noticed is like every week, uh every Friday, our sellers get an update with showing feedback, any showings coming up, um pendings, actives, solds that are around them so that they see, oh, cool, like these houses are coming on the market. Also, these houses are pending. Why aren't we pending? Because maybe our price is too high. That's generally, you know, as as everybody here knows the case most of the time.
SPEAKER_01Um, but it it we found it helps them realize by the time I pick up the phone call on Tuesday, they're like, hey, Casey, what do you think about a price reduction? Like, hey, I think it's a great idea, probably based off of the market and the feedback that we're seeing. And we give them guardrails to look at from the very beginning to go, hey, you know, what we see in our market, if we go over X amount of days between showings, if we're uh this many showings with no offers, those are both really good indicators that we're probably the market is telling us we're overpriced for what we have in the location that we have in it.
SPEAKER_01So, and that's okay. We just adjust. Um, but one of that's that's a super easy tool you can build out in Claude or Perplexity or whatever you want to use with a couple of prompts. If it's not super large, it's basically a back end Excel sheet, you know. Um so that the client then just can pop on there and see that very easily. Um, everybody's a visual learner, I in my opinion. Some people aren't, but like big myself included, vast majority of the population, visual learners.
SPEAKER_01However, we can do that to where people can see it and consume the knowledge and quickly. Um, you know, that that's all stuff that we can do with AI now, you know. Yeah. So um I I'm pretty bullish on it. The thing that uh I'm uh I've not been able to figure out is how to get it to connect to uh my back end and just look at like every conversation I've ever had so that it builds out, you know, a little Casey bot that like because this is a scary, but B um can be really useful for especially that middle section of the follow-up piece because there's people they're they're all we we see it every day, they're all over the internet looking at every sort of different, you know, they're looking at um uh news and suggestions in LA when as it relates to Evansville, Indiana Real Estate.
SPEAKER_01And they're two very different markets, even Evansville and Nashville are two very different markets, or Indianapolis. So, you know, they need real estate specific local geographic knowledge, and that's what we as agents have really uh a big brain for, right? That's especially if you're paying attention in any sort certain way. So if you can compile that in a way where um the average person can log on and go, well, hey, I know it's Saturday and Casey's not gonna get back to me, but I would I got some questions for Casey Bot, right?
SPEAKER_01Like he's gonna have pretty semblance of you know of the information at least. Then they can interact with that without feeling pressured from me. Not that not that we pressure anybody, but you know, I I know myself well enough to know that like I'll go on Google before I go ask my you know exterior sighting contractor about something. Uh, because A, I don't want to look dumb once I chat with them, and I'm like, well, hey, you know, is is this color or that color or this finish or that finish?
SPEAKER_01Is that gonna be better? Like I can get a semblance of an idea through um the the tech side on AI, and then I can have a pretty good grasp of like a window, and then they can tell me, well, Casey, I wouldn't use that because we've had problems with it, or whatever, like the in the field experience. And that's what I think is in the future is a semblance of people getting more educated through the pipeline, and then when they show up, they're ready. So and they're going, hey Tim, I know this much, but I don't yep, yep.
SPEAKER_01And that's the portion that I think as humans we're they're not gonna be able to replicate. Like that, that's that's the one thing that like everybody thinks AI is gonna take all these jobs and whatever, and it is going to change things, but it's gonna change the things that we do, you know. When we when somebody calls in and says, Hey, I I I I saw this house over on the north side that you guys have listed. It's like, I don't know. We have a few listings up there. Like, what they're like, well, it's I think it was off of Browning Road, and you're like, okay, we've got a few up there.
SPEAKER_01It's like AI can go probably talking about these two houses. Yeah, yeah, yeah. It's like that that's a super easy thing. So I'm very bullish on it. I think it'll be really cool to see as it plays out.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I agree. And I agree with your sentiment uh on that it's and it's not necessarily gonna replace people, but it will change how we work, and I also think it can be an amazing tool uh done correctly. And you you just shared some really good ideas uh here. Well, uh Casey, you've been awesome, by the way. Before we wrap up, where can people learn more about you and your team?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, um, I mean, the team side, uh, best place is team-mccoy.com. That's our website. Um, get around on there. Um my easiest place to find me is on Facebook, Casey McCoy, um in Evansville. Um, I again that's something that like we don't have a great uh direct one you know pager built out to to go do because we've just been you know heads down selling real estate for for a long time.
SPEAKER_01Uh, but that is something that's on on our agendas getting a one one piece, because I I I have a uh beef with podcasts that are like, call me, text me, you know, email me. It's like I I'm not gonna look at the I don't look at my emails, so don't email me. I love it.
SPEAKER_00Okay, fair enough. Now now we know how to get a hold of you. So all right, Casey. Uh thank you again for joining me on under contract. I really enjoyed the conversation. You're awesome, man.
SPEAKER_01Appreciate you, Tim.
SPEAKER_00Thanks for listening to Under Contract. If you don't have time to catch every episode, we'll do the listening and the note taking for you. We pull out the best ideas and strategies we're hearing from top producing agents and regularly send you the ones we're putting to work in your business. Get the notes completely free at undercontract notes.com. That's undercontractnotes.com. I'll see you on the next episode.
Want the best insights from this episode and more in bite-sized nuggets? Sign up for our free newsletter at https://undercontractnotes.com/ Guest Bio: Brian Wignall leads the Wignall Group at F.C. Tucker in Carmel,...
Want the best insights from this episode and more in bite-sized nuggets? Sign up for our free newsletter at https://undercontractnotes.com/ Guest Bio: Andrew Hannan is the founder and team leader of the Hannan Team at...
Want the best insights from this episode and more in bite-sized nuggets? Sign up for our free newsletter at https://undercontractnotes.com/ Guest Bio: Mary Gilbert leads the Mary Gilbert Group, a Place-affiliated real...
Want the best insights from this episode and more in bite-sized nuggets? Sign up for our free newsletter at https://undercontractnotes.com/ Guest Bio: Krissy Mireles leads the Krissy Mireles Team at eXp Realty, serving...
Want the best insights from this episode and more in bite-sized nuggets? Sign up for our free newsletter at https://undercontractnotes.com/ Guest Bio: Tammy Hines is the owner and managing broker of Tammy Hines & Co,...