Has the reality of Vintage Cube been fractured? Join Team Uber Cube as we explore the state of vintage cubes and how the latest sets have impacted the landscape. In this unscripted episode we chat on our updates for a variety of cube environments and how high-powered cards have changed the boundaries of play. Thanks for listening, subscribing, 5-stars, and as always, happy cubing! Uber Bear's Powered Cube Discussed Sammich's Powered Cube Discussed The Black Parade Join the Uber Cube Discord Show Notes Anthony's Cubes May's Cubes Stu's Cubes Uber Cube is now on YouTube! MTG Cube Drafting Page Find us on Twitter @UberCubeMTGPod Find us on Bluesky@ubercubemtgpodcast.bsky.social Uber Cube YouTube Email Uber Cube: ubercubemtgpodcast@gmail.com Thanks for Listening and Happy cubing! Support the show
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_02Welcome to Uber Cube, the podcast that's hosted in Stu's new house.
SPEAKER_03Thanks. Yeah.
SPEAKER_02We don't know how the audio quality is going to be. We just did a round robbing of this room, so I may have myself an editing nightmare. So I don't know.
SPEAKER_03I don't think so.
SPEAKER_02I mean it could be I think it's gonna be pretty good. It could be crisp or it could be like a bathroom.
SPEAKER_03I mean the settings is all the same. And yeah, we did kind of have to finagle the audio dampening a little bit, but everything else is the same, same mic, same everything. Uh so we should be good.
SPEAKER_02Did you try turning it off and back on again?
SPEAKER_03I did. I had to turn it off to actually move it here. That makes sense.
SPEAKER_02Okay. And we have the lovely Christopher. Hi, Christopher. May's not with us. She's the lovely, but she's feeling a little under the weather today.
SPEAKER_04Thanks for having me. Appreciate it. Happy to be here.
SPEAKER_02Happy to help out. You'll just have to be our plan C. Who'd you invite before him? Who was that? You said Christian, right?
SPEAKER_04I don't know. I'll be happy when someone like that F. Christian, you got Chris?
SPEAKER_03Uh, you know what? I I don't think you can even make a joke that's made that's believable like that. Like, no. Good good luck. Uh I I keep saying that I was trying to get my boy Andrew from Canadia on, because he went from being like a pretty dedicated Canadian Highlander player, which makes sense, he's Canadian, to Andy and Modern.
SPEAKER_02Andy's a Highlander.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, well, he played he Modern was his thing for a long time. Then he got into Canlander, and then he's like, Man, I'm I got really nothing else to play except Commander because that's what a bunch of other people play. And now he's got like he's built a couple of cubes already, and he's got this is something else that we'll come up with. This is not a this is a future episode discussion, but basically he's setting up for his buddies a way to take it's basically a pre-con that you upgrade over time with kind of retail drafting. We'll we'll potentially go through it in a later episode, but yeah, yeah, we I think it would be fun for him to come on and talk about it.
SPEAKER_02You were talking about diversifying the podcast a little bit, anyways. You had some ideas, some plans you to kind of widen our reach a little bit. I think so. Talk about a little bit more.
SPEAKER_03The reason why I think it's a good idea now is if you remember when we first started doing this, obviously, this is now almost five years ago. There was I don't I think the 540 had gone offline at that point. Yep. And Lucky Paper, obviously, plowing the road for so many after that are either doing it now or have come before us. But nowadays there's a lot of cube content out there as far as podcasts is concerned. And there's a but you know, there's YouTube channels if you want to go and watch Vintage Cube and and whatever, but I feel like the Cube dedicated podcast space has really widened a lot over the last couple of years.
SPEAKER_02This is one of our original ideas. When we first met up to talk about doing this podcast, do and I together, you're right. The 540 had kind of just rolled off and they decided to step back, and then Lucky Paper was running it, and I wasn't I still enjoy their show, listening to it all the time. But there wasn't much in the space, so we wanted to add, you know, add some voices to the to the space, right? But I do agree with you. I'm not we're not we're gonna keep doing cube, obviously, so anybody's panicking right now. No, this is what we're gonna talk about. But I think fun, I think it'd be fun every once in a while to talk about my chili recipe, or you know, you went fishing that day or your golf game as a little kind of segue type thing.
SPEAKER_02These are fun, sometimes you can intertwine other hobbies that blend with these.
SPEAKER_03I think variety content creation is almost an inevitability, and I think it's you can kind of make your name in a single space and maybe get your name out there a little bit, but I think eventually it just gets to the point where you spend five years doing the same thing over and over again, and when you're dedicated to dropping an episode every single week, it gets challenging.
SPEAKER_02I just had a delightful experience recording on the Taylor Made podcast where we didn't talk about Cube at all. It was nice. We talked about the origin story of bourbon and Colonel E. H. Taylor and check out the Taylor Made podcast, it's really cool.
SPEAKER_03Talk about some Pappy Van Winkle.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, well, we talked about Buffalo Trace and the sag, and it's basically like an umbrella corp now, basically. But the gist was is how bourbon came to be. And it was just fun to dive into something different because I have a lot of their hobbies. I like to brew and I like to play board games, I like to bike, I like to run, I do mud runs, I don't do them anymore. But I have a lot of engineering, whatever, right? Uh there's a lot of different things we experience. So I agree with you, Stu. Sometimes you can blend in some ideas into a show, pepper it in, and it's fun. Chris, what other hobbies do you do besides just Cube?
SPEAKER_02I mean board games.
SPEAKER_03And Dungeons and Dragons.
SPEAKER_04Yeah. I like board games, I like you know, tabletop RPGs, I play video games with my wife. Uh we have a good time. And you're a bad thing.
SPEAKER_02Afficionado, things like that too, right? Uh your horror movie aficionado, collecting the city.
SPEAKER_04Oh my god, yes. Uh love me some horror movies, love me some heavy metal music, love all that. Love going to concerts, that's another favorite of mine.
SPEAKER_03Nice. You know what I you know what I got as well? I've I just set up my wife and I kind of wanted to make a bit of a retro space for our kids and not just have them glued to like YouTube and on-demand content. So in our new house, we have like a a little space upstairs for our kids that's got a TV, except instead of it being a smart TV, it's an old school kind of TV, and we've got a VHS DVD player hooked up to it with all the all the fun movies. Well, one of the things that I do have, I have Halloween 1, 2, and 4.
SPEAKER_03I have the original Star Wars trilogy on VHS.
SPEAKER_02You skip Season of the Witch, that's the best one out of the whole series.
SPEAKER_03Anyway. See, this is why you think aliens is superior to Alien. Okay, your your opinion is just I cannot take you seriously.
SPEAKER_02Oh, I love it. I love Halloween three. That's the one with the mask.
SPEAKER_03It's fine. It's fine. It's just, you know.
SPEAKER_02They made like uh, what was it? R. L. Stein did basically the mask, and it felt a lot of things. Pretty much. Yeah, pretty much. Someone stole from someone in that story. Yeah, so that we just wanted to loosen our vocal cords a little bit here. That's what we're doing. We're vibing. We haven't been around for a while. Stu hasn't. You know, Chris and I have been carrying the fort with May, pretty much keeping this podcast alive.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, we're a foursome now.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. Let's talk about our drinks before we get to our topic.
SPEAKER_03Okay, let's go. Anthony, I I ain't drinking anything special on the on the main, but you've brought a delicious side.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, I brought a Penelope bourbon. It's a straight bourbon whiskey. I it's it's good. It's affordable. Very nice, delicate palette. It's obviously oak, but some of them are weeded. I like it.
SPEAKER_03It's very nice. Chris, what about yourself?
SPEAKER_04I just finished uh a bottle of Penelope recently, but um, having some Southern Star, just another favorite of mine, a staple I keep in the house. That's out of Texas. One of my favorites. Is that out of Texas? I think it is. I can't remember. I'm not sure. I know you can get it here. I can't get it now like down in Georgia, but I know you can get it here. I think it's up this air, but I don't have the bottle with me, so I'm not sure. I've seen Southern Star.
SPEAKER_02I know you can get like TX whiskey, and all the obviously from Texas. Those are great. I'm actually trying to pick up a bottle of that next week.
SPEAKER_03Our friend Sam brought it to your place, Chris, a few months ago. The first time I had it. Yeah, it's really, really good.
SPEAKER_04Tonight it's the uh cask strength one uh that I like. It's uh it's a little I I like it. It's just uh real smooth. I really like it.
SPEAKER_02But the weeded one there, the double rye is really good as well as well. Nice. So we're gonna talk about some vintage cubes. That's what we decided we wanted to do. Oh, about time. I know. We've talked about it, yeah. We've kind of you may have heard me use the terms min-max and power, but I and maybe that I don't even love it, but you know what? It's still fun. I still curate it. I actually had a conversation with Chris recently. I I said this to you because I don't I can't remember the last time I actually played my Powered Vintage Cube. I really truly cannot remember. I'm craving it.
SPEAKER_02But I do update it all the time and I stare at it. I was I put new cards in it today. But I did ask you, I came over to your house, I dropped by for a you know cube night about three weeks ago or so, and I said, uh, why are we ordering all these damn cards for something that we don't play very often? You too. Like we don't play our powered cubes, but they're very seldom now.
SPEAKER_04Well, I we actually just played ours, mine. Not this past week, but the week before. We after I think you left, Anthony. We've got to be a good one.
SPEAKER_02I think it was after we had this conversation, though. Remember that's that that probably correlates when we said that because we just don't break them out. We play a lot of peasant. We played my horror cube recently.
SPEAKER_03Exile files.
SPEAKER_02Exile files, all the cube contesting, we kind of went through that season of getting these ready, and then we did the Uber Cube a thon. And everybody, we've been talking about that debating amongst our group. We've got the problem where instead of having a commander player that has the two suitcases of you know decks that they bring with them, and they're only going to play one anyways, and they're all, you know, they're all level ones or whatever they are. But uh instead, we've got I've lost track, I just keep putting 25 plus in our 25 lots. We have a lot. People keep adding, so and it's created a problem.
SPEAKER_04But we're we're blessed in that in that in that space. Not everybody has this.
SPEAKER_02So, you know. I think because of that, we we don't get a lot of testing.
SPEAKER_03Now, I would argue that our vintage cubes, we could say that we don't need to test them with any true level of frequency because most of it's kind of tested for us because of the nature of this type of there's a there's a lot of content, there's a lot of people out there with vintage cubes, there's a lot of discussion about vintage cube out there on the webs, obviously, as kind of I almost hate myself for saying this, but like the iconic kind of staple of cube in general, there's a lot of data that's there about it, but that doesn't lend to much when you can say, look at your guys' lists, and they're different numbers and they're very different lists, and they achieve different things, and they're focused on different kind of strengths of the history of magic.
SPEAKER_03So I I don't know if I would say that they don't need testing, I think that's but maybe they don't, maybe not.
SPEAKER_02One of the things, and we'll we'll get to some points here, but it's more of we're setting up a lot of points, is what we're doing. One of the conversations that I'd kind of briefly talk to you about, and I just talked to Chris a few minutes ago about this idea, is even in my 540, there was a period where I would say I could keep certain cards in there because it's 540, you know, as you expand a cube from that base. So pretend in a world you had a hundred and eighty cube that was the most powerful cards ever made.
SPEAKER_02360 looks foreign to it at that point. You're gonna have cards that wouldn't make the 180 list. That's the best way to call it. If you were following this maximum output efficiency model, right? And then so on and so forth. I go to 450, I'm gonna start adding cards that would not have they would be hard pressed to have made that 360 list, and then me at 540. And then I could use that as an outlier situation. We kind of talked about this a long time ago, and like I think we called it our five orbits of power or whatever, as things kind of think of a centrifuge or a center or core, and we start kind of expanding out away from the most, you know, most powerful, most egregious cards you could call them, the ones that are most broken, and then you start pushing out from this axis, going further and further out, right?
SPEAKER_02I mean, that's something you can vision, but I would say as I've been doing updates, and this is a thought that I had even today, it's getting harder for me to make that argument of I'm at 540, this card can look so far outside of that. The orbits are starting to get constricted because the cards are getting more efficient by design.
SPEAKER_03I mean the outliers at 540 become outliers to the point where they start to become non-viable, I would almost argue.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, that is what's happening, or it's amazing. One thing is they've printed so many cards recently that are just becoming a lot more efficient and better that you can run a 540 that's a really tight list now. And cube equity, as in for a 360, becomes a huge issue because you have to worry about is this card just going to be a little rinky dink little thing? I love it, but it's gonna be a rinky dink little thing and no one's ever gonna draft because there's so many much more power powerful things there. So you have to really think about that one when we even for a power cube like this, even at 540, you really have to really consider cube equity.
SPEAKER_04Is this card worth a slot? But how okay?
SPEAKER_03But Chris, we're not just talking about green cards right now, we are trying to talk about the entirety anyway. Anyway, sorry, sorry.
SPEAKER_02At this point, we've done Reality Fracture and Star Trek's coming out soon, if not in a week or so or whatever. But Reality Fracture has now entered my cube. And I put some cards in there, and it even these cards that just entered from Reality Fracture are starting to make some of the modern Horizons cards look not they're they're they look different. Like, and it's not that they're bad, and they still have a function and a form, and people will play them. This is like a mental game that I'm playing. If if I'm putting all this highly efficient interaction, is one thing that's really starting to challenge these outliers for their existence.
SPEAKER_02Now, lucky for me, I have this parachute that I made, but the parachute's even getting weird. I'm I built the Black Parade, and that's where I would take my my darlings and the cards that I loved and my pet cards, and I I was really frustrated with this idea of cards getting pushed out. So I was able to find a home for them, and I'm happy with that home. And that home really shows, I mean, it almost 100% personifies what I'm trying to say, is that the cards that now occupy the Black Parade do not look the same compared to my 440 at all.
SPEAKER_02I mean, they look completely different environments. Would you agree with that, Chris?
SPEAKER_04Oh, 100%. The cards of yesteryear, they're still fun to play, they're still good. I think the black parade is a fun cube, but it's just not the way magic is played these days. It's a memory. It's an unfortunate byproduct of power creep. Yeah. And you know, that's just how it is.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. And so as I was adding in cards from you know, Reality Fracture, which we'll talk about a few of them, it's started kind of making me look at some more displacements. Like I push this one in, it pushes that one out. That's what's really starting to happen. And I can't hardly I'm having a harder time justifying to to kind of bring your point, which you said earlier, at 540, my list is getting wildly tight. As in every one of my cards that are not going in there are starting to really fit in the same hemisphere.
SPEAKER_02There's a few of them you could say, sure, why not? And there's definitely some, and the ones that stick out look weird to me now, but everything's constricting around this idea.
SPEAKER_03I I would make the argument, and I obviously I'm someone that's familiar with your list, but as more time has gone on, I actually think that 540 was probably a much more difficult project to maintain a couple of years ago, three or four years ago, because Power Creep has really gone nuclear in the last, you want to say four or five years. I think sort of post-dominaria was really the time where that's the consensus, is that that was that's when the power creep went crazy. So all of a sudden you've got you know a lot of cards coming in that are very, very powerful, very, very efficient.
SPEAKER_03It's really starting to push out a lot of those sort of fringe-ish kind of cards. But nowadays, a 540 list has got to be a much easier number to curate just because there's been so many bonkers, powerful, and efficient cards printed.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, they they don't look so dissimilar between the 360 and 540-ish, right? I'm just have more cards.
SPEAKER_03Barrier of entry, the seat the the floor is has been raised significantly.
SPEAKER_02So what I've accepted with a 540 is a higher expense, right? More maintenance. Yeah, more maintenance.
SPEAKER_04Guess how many cards I bought from Reality Fracture with my power cube? More maintenance.
SPEAKER_02One and I was able to put some in because I still had this constant churn. We talked about this recently uh in an episode where there are cards, again, I don't get to play my 540 very often. I truly cannot remember the last time we have opened it up. It may have been a KubeCon some time ago. I'm uncertain.
SPEAKER_03We'll do a housewarming here with with uh with vintage tracks.
SPEAKER_02Cards have come out that have never even seen testing because I've got enough you know baseline standards from other content creators or Aaron, I'm staring at the Matrix, right? And I can just see this card just not what I envisioned when I first ordered it. It just you kind of get used to seeing it in the lines, right? So we'll talk about some of the cards that I've added from reality fracture.
SPEAKER_03Before we get into that, I want to make one like final point, yeah, if you will, and I'm and this is almost a question to both of you guys. Obviously, you have a lot of cubes as well as vintage cubes. I feel like maybe just because you guys have been curating cubes for so long, plus the number of cubes that you have, to me, it seems logical that because the vintage cube, the floor is so much higher. Likelihood, the likelihood is that the floor is so much higher than a lot of other cubes, there's just going to be more options for change and being able to be dynamic with your other cubes, and maybe it's just a little bit more fun to be able to look for cards in some of the other cubes and and just find more options.
SPEAKER_03I don't know if you would agree with that.
SPEAKER_02So I've got that weird doldrum, right? That spot between the Black Parade, which is basically capturing, we'll say, circa pre-fire design, magic, where a vintage cube would have been we'll say 2018-ish give or takes, right? And a little bit backwards. Titans and whatnot. But then I've got that little doldrum where now I feel this um it's perplexing that I'm updating this vintage cube, but cards are getting sorted out. What do I do with them? Well, frankly, I've just been selling them at this point, right? Like after they fall out, and if they can't go into some random commander deck, which I don't play very often, or they can't, or they're too strong to go into my artifact cube, or they don't, they're disjointed from my horror cube.
SPEAKER_02What we've been doing in our circle, and I and it's kind of happening, and it happens organically, is I got a card that just kind of whatever reason I've decided decays. Especially David does this the most. He goes, Hey, do you guys need this card? I don't need it anymore. We've got like a I don't need it, it's gonna go in a cube. Here you go, bar cube, whatever. That's actually a fix for that little dead spot, right?
SPEAKER_03Chris, for you, obviously Anthony has got his black parade, so he's got kind of a home for all these old vintage cubes, but you yourself, and I suppose you have as well, but so uh not to disparage your, but Chris, you have the exile files, and that's a very high power cube as well. So maybe because you have this combination of very high power cubes, I don't know how that's kind of looked to just a different outlook for you when the new sets are coming out.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, well, for me it's different because I'm trying to achieve different goals in like the exile files versus like the power cube. They both do very different things there and uh I have to look for specific styles of cards, cards that synergize well with the exiling and playing from anywhere. You know, I look for things where you can for that cube specifically, look for things that can cast from other places, or do you get benefits from doing it? Or does it cause you to be able to do that? But I have a lot of fun doing that, like especially for the graveyard shift, trying to find cards that really synergize the graveyard. You always get a few every set, you know, not every set gets you the best of the best, but you know, some do.
SPEAKER_04And I'll tell you, the the cube that takes the most time to curate is my freaking peasant. There's so many. I was gonna say it's gotta be peasant or pull, but yeah. That that are getting pauper doesn't get very many updates. It's peasant. They are printing so many banger uncommons that that are just really good and just really interesting. It's just a really neat design space.
SPEAKER_02It's it's even happening in the and vintage that's happening too, and it's happening in your peasant cube. And I've got this new iSpy cube that I built. And you know, at first it was kind of static. I got surveil and I got scry. I'll be damned if they haven't printed more things just in Star Trek that say the word surveil, and then the last set surveil. Yes, they do. And I don't want it to become the surveil cube, I want it to be the scry and surveil cube top deck manipulation. But but the the swath of cards coming in, I I spoiler season's getting weird with this many cubes.
SPEAKER_02It just is. The easiest one for me, period. Actually, there's two of them that are easy. One, it's the horror cube. Uh I'm looking at Salt Vampire from Star Trek, asking myself.
SPEAKER_03Thematic cubes probably stand out as they're going to be the easiest.
SPEAKER_02I was just talking to May about this. Fake Cube, it's only one in you know, one in four sets that you'll see something that makes sense. Yeah. The other one that's just easy is the Fem Cube. I look at it and I go, well, does it meet these qualifiers? And is it good enough for this cube? The rest of them, I'm like you, man. I don't know how you maintain a peasant cube when you're just a smattering half the page on a spoiler is uncommon. And you're like, well, I I mean, I'm you're keeping it at 360, right? Or are you 450? It's that's hard.
SPEAKER_04No, but I'm gonna always be 450. I like having a little bit of wiggle room. That's the biggest cube I own. Every other cube I have is 360 or smaller, and um, I like having it at that. It's it's been that's how I initially drew it up, and I just haven't wanted to cut it down. It just feels like it I like having that little bit of variance in there. For that cube, I really do enjoy the variance.
SPEAKER_03I will say I like the variance in that. I I would say I appreciate the size of that more than maybe any other cube because of how dynamic the drafting experience is. So yeah, make keep keep four fifty great.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. Yeah. We're doing this to a level of intent too, right? Like the five forty, I'm not a holdout on five forty, it's just I know five forty is far enough from. The 360 mark that our cubes can be different because we're already having a problem with cube competition in our group, anyways. It's just as a natural thing that's occurring. There is no reason for him and I to have identical cubes. Now you're making things really weird, right? I mean, like a logistical standpoint, competition. You're inviting unusual things into that circumstance. I mean, there's no reason to exist.
SPEAKER_03The easier answer is one of you has to commit and put initiative and time vault combo and just make it super. No, no. I have debated.
SPEAKER_04Just to get back to that. We have people with time vault combo in their cubes. We do. That's a tongue-in-cheek. That's my least favorite combo in magic. I cannot stand the time vault combo. Yeah.
SPEAKER_03What about Thass's Oracle? What about that one? Do you like Tancott? I don't run that either. I don't like it either. Okay, good.
SPEAKER_04If I did it, it would be tenant packed. I wouldn't run the uh the other one. The demand. I'd run 10-pact. Yeah. Yeah. No, it will leave you. I want to make you work for it. I can't. You can't be that easy.
SPEAKER_03I listen, I agree. We'll leave that. There's always some douchebag that has it in their commander deck, and we'll just leave that to that to that guy.
SPEAKER_02Well, before we've gone on forever, we've just having fun. We haven't talked to each other in a while, so we missed each other. And I'm sorry that listeners have to enjoy us just getting to know each other again. But another thing that I've been thinking about doing before I even get to reality fracture, which I've built up to for, I don't know, 20 minutes now, is I'm thinking about putting in on the vintage cube. I'm really wanting to bring back Goblin Welder again. And I've got a point to make with that idea. I love it. Because there's a revitalization. Usman and I talked about this recently where we talked about like how Parallax Wave at one point wasn't the card that it is now, or even Caracas wasn't the card that it is now.
SPEAKER_02And then Goblin Welder had unseated itself, and now Goblin Welder can come back into the business. Yeah, for for real. Because now I've got like this.
SPEAKER_04Is that what that surveillance camp surveillance can?
SPEAKER_02I've got one sitting there, so I'm gonna put that in tonight. Again, to not play this for another four years, but I'm putting it in because that creates infinite mana loop, which you can feed off into your walking ballista or whatever you're doing, right? Uh so these type of things, uh, when you've got these swaths of new cards, and Usman and I talked about this with May, you've also, while you're making cuts, you're also waking up old cards back to when I said, Well, what do you do with your cards that are pushed out? Maybe you hold on to them for a little while. And maybe because they're strong enough that you could see that someday they'll be readily supported again, which there are stark examples of that idea.
SPEAKER_02What's the one that um and I'll keep it in forever that you tap on the got the Orkish lumberjack or whatever?
SPEAKER_03Yeah, sacrifice a forest to add the insane concept.
SPEAKER_02You could argue it's tap, but it is negative. Acceleration's insane. Yeah. And if you've got a Lands Matters card in there, but at one point that would have ebbed and flowed out of a vintage cube's favor because it had the word tap on it. There was like this Baneslayer must-do something ETB conversation that was happening in that. But you've seen now that we're getting more introductions of all these external IPs and commander cards and all that are injecting themselves into these vintage cube environments. They're making it hard to defend that you can't take one turn to activate something that pulls off such a powerful effect.
SPEAKER_02Bolsa Citadel was one that was kind of drifted out and has drifted back in because it's still a great tinkerer target, great welder target now. Pull it back in. Kappa Cannoneer, in, out, drifts back, forth. These cards edge on the outer polarity, and then they pull back in because a new card wakes them up again and goes, huh. Sewer surveillance cam wakes up goblin welder again. Alright, I can justify that argument. Yes, that requires two cards. Very hard to draft both of them at 540 versus a 360 probability. Yeah, I mean computations. We can do all that.
SPEAKER_02You could argue these statements. But it's still there, and it still looks fun and still is an interesting. Alright, pack one, pick one. I know it looks weird. I'm taking goblin welder. I know I can get value out of that either way. I'm going trinkety, and then comes along the sewer surveillance camp. Alright, cool, sweet. Infinite mana. What am I gonna rock with this? Oh, I can do an Ulamaga some sort or whatever Emercole. Where I think we do weird things.
SPEAKER_03Where I think, like, and I I I agree, and I think it's it's pretty fun to see how cards have gone out and come in and gone out and come in, whatever the sort of the pattern is for all of these cards. You know, you could make the Goblin Welder argument, even things like Zurinorb being powered by Titania, so on and so forth. But there's a part of me that looks at this as kind of a dangerous element to when you're drafting a very, very high power cube or even creating one. Because, and I'll go back to the comment that I made. Time walk.
SPEAKER_02And our soundproofing has fallen.
SPEAKER_03Soundproof fell, but I'll fix that. Time walk, I'm not editing that out, and manifold key. It's still pulling back the sound. And then Thass's Oracle, demonic consultation, or tainted packets right. So you've got these all these two-card combos. Now you start thinking about a very restricted list, and especially if you're playing in paper and you've got a 360-card cube that has this number of combos that are two slash three cards, it creates such a difficult experience for the players because you know that there's these two-card combos that are out there that are ultimately very powerful.
SPEAKER_03So now you've got this dynamic while you're drafting of okay, I've opened my pack one, I've got time vault. Okay, do I take that knowing that I have a two-card combo? But someone else sitting around the table, and I I saw said saw this with Sam's cube, right? Because Sam has time vault voltage key combo in his cube. If I see time vault, I'm taking it. If I'm in pack two or three, I really need a good reason to not prioritize taking one of those cards, even though I know it's kind of it's it's a bad decision.
SPEAKER_03Ultimately, it is a bad decision, but it becomes this kind of cat and mouse of chasing these two card combos, and then are you going to end up with a good deck? You can do the same thing right now in a more traditional combo, or sorry, a more traditional cube with something like Artifacts and Talarian Academy and some of the payoffs for that. And not that I want just every cube to devolve into this mid-range versus control versus aggro, but there's such a care that needs to be taken with some of these cards. Because you look at like all these cards that we're talking about, they're all combo cards, and a lot of them involve two or maybe three cards.
SPEAKER_02I'm ready to stop, stop in here or get in here and do a little bit of disruption. I would argue, based on the other thing that I was talking about, is your interaction points, have come in tight to the center core of a vintage cube at this point, right? We already had like Inquisitions and we had all these different things. We got Tidebinder and we've got all these cards, you've got dress downs, you've got all these components that look sidebared, but they're highly disruptible, force of wills, pact and negations, all these. There's so many weapons to fight that 2A B card combo that would have existed.
SPEAKER_02Maybe maybe Sam's Cube. He he definitely has extremely high power arc, but he doesn't do powered powered max, right? He's not pushing all these other interaction points that threaten that. So they are the definitely the we'll call them the boogeyman of that idea, that environment, sure. And in while he does have all the interaction points and highly efficient cards, he does keep himself highly restricted to the idea that most of the time it has to be a uh artist proof or it has to be full text on it because read the card explains the card, right?
SPEAKER_02Yeah. So he omits cards sometimes that Chris and I are just YOLO, throw these things in. Even at the 540, I know your pattern is wider. You know, you do like a dot matrix on my cube, and the scat the smattering of points on the grid are definitely wider. Even so, just if Chris were to put time vault combo in his 360, the likelihood of someone assembling that package is definitely probability-wise higher in an eight-person draft because all the cards are seen. And yes, the tension of breaking up, you know, losing a draft pick is still very relevant in that conversation.
SPEAKER_02But simultaneously, you have to have the supplemental mana to get them both at the same time and execute. If they shine one, you have just enough time to even wreck sage at this point, right? Some basic, you know, get that card out of there, Manglehorn, whatever you're doing, right? To blow up some of these. I should hope Manglehorn is not in the middle of the city. But you the the breaking points that you it might actually be good. That's one of the cards that I think will eventually come around, but give it time. But the idea is that the disruption is there, and we you don't have to you can break these things so much cleaner in these environments.
SPEAKER_02They're almost worried about you as much as you're worried about them. I mean, they've got the two pieces in their hand, and they're fretting how do I display these two components to close out this game? Meanwhile, Chris has got pacton negations and inquisitions, and I now have to pull up, I have to basically protect my entire combo that would have been this clean sweep in an old world. Drop these two pieces, dirtle magic, I take infinite turns, you lose a game. Oh, this sucks. We're not there anymore. That's the whole point. That web that I said was going way out is coming way back in, it's contracting.
SPEAKER_02I feel like when you're saying my 540 on a pattern is getting closer to his 360, that's a sign that those two card combos are now being threatened at their interior core by all these modular cards that are now entering the game.
SPEAKER_03Very likely. And I think the fact that aggro is in such an incredibly strong place right now and has been for some time. Obviously, Boros has had just some absolutely bonkers. Let's talk about one of the segue into yeah, into reality fracture. So let's talk about a new addition. So interesting, obviously, Anthony, you like a fair amount of parody when it comes to the colours, so it makes sense. Gobble Rabble Master was the victim for this one. So this is Samut Hazaretz Champion, one and a red for a legendary creature, human warrior cleric.
SPEAKER_03Creatures you control have haste. 2-2. That's it.
SPEAKER_02That's not just an aggro piece. That is a piece that a lot of decks want to have on the battlefield. Reanimator would love for this to exist on the battlefield. I mean, this is mid-range wants this to exist on the battlefield, right? Aggro definitely 100% wants this to exist on the battlefield. It is a fervor effect that's on a stick that's also charging in.
SPEAKER_03I don't know if I would say aggro, or I would say reanimator once. I would say that it your slot equity is pretty tight, I think.
SPEAKER_02I would say that your Atraxa is really great on ETVs, but even better whenever they can attack in if you're splashing all those colors.
SPEAKER_03That's all I'm all the value from Atraxa is when it is really on the ETB. Same with the ETB. Yeah, it's that ETB. Same with our kind of cruelty. It doesn't matter for Grizzle Brand. You can draw seven cards. Uh I I mean with Atali, I think Italian is a little bit more. I would rather be Grixis out the wazo and have as many disruption counter spells, reanimate spells, entomb effect spells than ever play this.
SPEAKER_03I think this is much more of an aggro card than it ever is a utility card in other decks. Chris, I don't know. You tell me how you feel about it.
SPEAKER_04I think it's a very good card. I'm currently not running it right now, but I may. I've got my red two slots need some help, so that may be something that I might throw in just just for the heck of it. Right now, my red twos side, they could use a little work. I wouldn't mind seeing this one cut come in. It's a strong card. So yeah. Red threes are very good. If this was a three-drop, I'd say probably not gonna happen. Yeah, yeah, yeah. But being a two-drop does happen.
SPEAKER_02And I also say this is not a boring card. This card I think opens up a lot of it makes it a card that doesn't read smart, but will make plays look smart. It creates gacha moments in the game, right? Like, so I drop this worm quail engine, post this, and I just go. I mean, these are these are goofy tangential arguments, but they still think about this too hard.
SPEAKER_04I I you go turn one, you know, you play this on turn two, then on turn three, you drop your uh you drop what is it, your your goblin welder, and along with your suit your sewer valence cam, and there you go. You are off to the races because you you you weld out that mox and get back whatever the hell you discarded to your faithless looting. I don't know. You know, it's like so here you go. Agreed.
SPEAKER_02And you and I like that it just doesn't read so plainly as like what was the card? Was it wasn't just fervor, but what was the one before it where everything gets like uh concordant crossroads or whatever, everything gets haste, these type cards.
SPEAKER_04Concordant crossroads gives the entire world haste. Yeah, yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_02Nothing has been printed at this level with this efficiency on a creature to date, is my understanding. Nothing matches the speed that it's giving. Probably not.
SPEAKER_04I don't think it's I mean, there are creatures that give everything haste, but I think they cost more mana than two. Yeah, I think and they're usually multicolored. Yeah, if I remember correctly.
SPEAKER_02So I think it's a great addition. So it made me look at Rabble Master, which unfortunately already is in the Black Parade. Not sure what I'm gonna do with it. Probably gonna bark. I'm gonna barkeep.
SPEAKER_01Rabble Man hasn't cut it in here. He's so good, though. But I'm gonna barkeep.
SPEAKER_03You know what he's good with? Is Samut Hazaritz Champion? I know, I didn't know. Really good with that card.
SPEAKER_02I did actually, as dumb as that is, I didn't know.
SPEAKER_03Really, really good with that card and goblin bombardment. I mean, there's a lot of token support nowadays. Vintage cubes and and tokens are kind of a thing with things like Jack Rabbit and these other token producers. All of a sudden, you've got you know pretty pretty sweet potential out there.
SPEAKER_01It's funny that you mentioned that before it crossed my mind. Still a very good card.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, I mean, why not? You've got a token maker, a haster, and a and a pinga right there.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, yeah. It crossed my mind, which kind of leads me to the next one that I'm gonna do the same argument because I did look at that axis of like I'm cutting one card that would be great to chase this card. I I I thought about that, but I needed a cut. It was getting hard, even at 540. The next one I brought in, we kind of talked about today, was Stingcaster Mage, and I'm not gonna argue that this is Snapcaster. We kind of did that in our Discord for a little bit of fun. This is basically the card that is a 2-1 haste, does not have flash. This is Snapcaster at home, but with haste.
SPEAKER_02I added this to my vintage cube today, and I I can make a thousand arguments, but one of the things I was looking at today, I'm like, what do I cut? And I got to thinking, I'm gonna cut Young Pasy. Like it was on the cusp. The card has gotten old, but I got some sweet art. And then I looked back at this card and I go, well, this card feeds Young Pasy. Why am I cutting this card? And I literally came back on the loop myself, kind of like you did with Rabble Master. Why don't I want Rabble Master to go fast? I'm like in this little, like, I'm making my own dilemmas. Like, what would be sweet, Samuel? Rabble Master? Hell yeah, let's go. Now I'm looking at, well, Stingcaster comes in and let's go.
SPEAKER_02It'd be really great to have Young Pasy to go ahead and play that spell. I was doing all this in my mind.
SPEAKER_04Chris, you got to- Okay, I'm gonna argue against Young Power Mancer. I think Young Powermancer is not good anymore. Like I just I do not believe Young Pyro holds any holds a candle or anything anymore. I know nothing is not.
SPEAKER_02Well, so yeah, I know, because I don't have the tech. So 540 back to the stretch of the 540. I don't disagree with you. That's why I want to do it. I'm not gonna sit there and defend that card. I do love it. But then I'm looking at like dread dreadhorde arcanis.
SPEAKER_04I don't see that in your list. Oh, yeah, that is. Fear of missing the I don't see it. Are you serious? No, there's no fear of missing out on your list.
SPEAKER_02It's yeah, it is. I'm staring at it right now. Oh, that's yours. That's that's why the hell is it? It was in there. Okay, I've got a database error. It's definitely in there. I actually found one today. It's a little screen. Well, yeah, it's 100% in there. I know it is, and it is. I I I have another error, so apparently I've got to lay out my whole cube. That's another problem of 540. It's gonna be miserable. So today I also found out that I had I looked at my list and I had two molten collapses, and I'm staring. I'm like, holy shit, I only got one. And then I realized the other card that I meant to enter in CubeCobra was Mine Collapse.
SPEAKER_02That those words are Mollapse is pretty good.
SPEAKER_04Mine Collapse is pretty good.
SPEAKER_02Mine Collapse is very good. Molten Collapse is still there. I didn't cut it. It might don't look at my cube cod uh my cubecobra blog right now. It's very confusing. This is but now I do have fear of missing out on there, which I'm super confused now. We'll be thank you, Chris.
SPEAKER_03You're just gonna have to button.
SPEAKER_02That's the worst thing you can tell a person that owns a cube.
SPEAKER_03Rebuild your cube list again.
SPEAKER_02Oh my god, it's gonna be stressful. All right. So, one of the things I was gonna get back to the point of now that you've caused me a panic attack. Okay, well, let's do that then. All right, we'll go ahead and do that more loudly. Go ahead and do that more loudly, make that more pronounced.
SPEAKER_03I would I would make the argument that maybe because you've got a black parade that the Kiki stuff and Splinter Twin and that kind of stuff, birthing pot, even like that's the home for those.
SPEAKER_02Birthing pod is not even in there, it's not good enough. It was already struggling with the idea of anything to begin with. Yeah, I can see that. I can see that. It works, it's struggling in my artifact cube. It's just there for the fan.
SPEAKER_03I can see that. I can see that. But I I would say that just as you know, a fan. I think I think it's a good one.
SPEAKER_04Screaming nemesis. Screaming nemesis. Put that in our Rumper Recruiter.
SPEAKER_02What am I looking at right now? I thought I had oh my god, you guys are I knew this was gonna happen. Uh listeners enjoy the fact that I was waiting for the creature.
SPEAKER_03This is what happens when you curate a vintage cube and don't play it. Yeah, yeah. This is what happens, and database error though.
SPEAKER_02And now you've got to.
SPEAKER_03This is like Anthony's three soul rings in his commander deck story from back in the day. Three soul rings? It was three soul rings in one.
unknownYeah.
SPEAKER_04I'm not meaning to cause you a panic attack. I'm just looking at it going like you're right.
SPEAKER_02It's not in there. It's not my list, but I am certain that I have it because, anyways, panic attack listeners, enjoy the idea. So back to the outliers of the cube as I'm adding in these new cards, I'm fleshing out old cards. You're right. Imperial Recruiter is actually one I've been looking at. You mumbled that earlier. I stared at that. Another card, and then I kind of start asking myself when I own this type cube. Again, I don't get to play test it. And there's some cards like Rampaging Raptor that was pretty sweet when it first came out that I've never even seen it do anything because we haven't played it, so I don't even know if it's good.
SPEAKER_02That's where we're at with tech.
SPEAKER_03Man, the four mana haste creatures like Raptor's fine.
SPEAKER_04Nothing wrong with it. It's not bad. It's not great. It's not bad either.
SPEAKER_03But it's a vintage game. Yeah, but they this should be somewhat great. I mean, like I said, I made the joke about it, but even those four, four like hasty green creatures, they're like, they're just okay. Like Questing Beast? Yeah, like Questing Boost. It's okay. Yeah, it's a questing beast is more than okay, in my opinion. Well, I think it's okay. I think it's a lot of mana to spend on something that it's doing four mana to just do four damage instead of four mana on like a mince camboo. I don't know.
SPEAKER_04Well, but here's the thing if you can do like turn three minskamboo, turn four to turn four thing. I mean, come on. It's pretty good at that point.
SPEAKER_03It it is it it it's fine, it's not terrible, but is it is it great? Again, we're talking about Vintage. No, I I never said it was great. I just said it was okay. We need more. We need more. I'm agreeing with that. I just don't really know.
SPEAKER_02I just don't think I agree any longer with the idea that we're gonna use like Minx and Boo and Fourth Alingus and the One Ring as our baseline application. Uh even the Moxin at some point people stop talking about it. Like the idea that that is the center point, the centrifuge, the idea, the the the core of where your power is being generated from. For example, uh ancestral recall. We can all no debate the card's amazing.
SPEAKER_02We know it is. Very strong. But also unfortunately super replaceable. And I mean in the sense in the argument that, yeah, granted, it's not 100% replaceable, draw through cards. I don't mean that. I'm not trying to be ignorant. I'm saying if you pass Ancestral Recall for some other whatever reason you've decided, your draw in a vintage cube is not 100% going to be harmed by comparison. You can Xerox effect in a vintage cube still, yeah, we know it's the greatest of all time. It's the goat. I'm not arguing it's not the goat. It's up there.
SPEAKER_03I mean, it's up there with probably I mean I would you could maybe argue that Black Lotus and Time Walk are are maybe stronger cards.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, but at one point five years ago, you said Incestra was the greatest card of all time. I think times have changed.
SPEAKER_03Things changed because it's no longer but they're still on such they're still so tight as far as their power. Agreed. Agreed. I think all three of those are bunkers tight.
SPEAKER_04The way I look at those at those powerful cards, you you have to, when you're putting together the cube like this, those cards exist. You have to you have to acknowledge that they exist, and then you have to look at how does this card compete in an environment with those cards? And it's like sometimes you gotta look at it and go, mmm, it's not gonna survive very well. Some and you know, but I think a card like Rampaging Raptor, just to use an example, we were talking about that, it it is not a great card. It is not like, oh my god, I'm gonna slam this every time.
SPEAKER_04But it fills a role at 540. You have to have role players, and that's the way I look at it. So it's not terrible. Maybe you can find a better four-drop. I don't know. Take a look around, see what you find. But that might be a good, a good for good for what he's trying to achieve in the cube.
SPEAKER_02I want to I want to roll back to the Stingcaster Mage. The we'll call it the Snapcaster at home. Sure. And you it's got haste on it, it's got legs, it runs. And we were you and I were kind of doing this little bit of minor debate in our Discord talking about it's no Snapcaster, it plays different different context. You were saying it's aggro.
SPEAKER_04It's for a different deck. It's for a much different deck.
SPEAKER_02And then I and then you're did you not see my little duck pressing the uh nuclear button and watching explosion as I demonstrated you the power of price of progress with that card? Right.
SPEAKER_04I I have an argument about pro price of progress. I think I I think the card is good. The card's real good, but I think it's better in an environment with like like our our friend Thomas's uh double his uh desert cube because there's less basics, there's a lot less basics running around. I don't know. Press of progress is good, but it's not as good as as it is in there. Let's put it that way.
SPEAKER_02I let's put it this way. I'd pay two to hit you for four, six, and call it a day, and then I'll do my thing. Cast this again. I think that might be a closer. Like these type cards are the hook cards. I was looking for Ted.
SPEAKER_03I can fantasize about my opponent having having, you know, three or four or whatever. It's not that hard. Yeah.
SPEAKER_04You know, I didn't say it wasn't bad. I it wasn't I I just say it's not as slam dunk as it is another.
SPEAKER_02No, it's not slam dunk, but I think there's chair legs that'll get kicked out when people think they're okay and they're not okay. Or Christian's gonna be one of the things. It's gonna kill somebody. It will kill somebody all the non-basics.
SPEAKER_03Christian will probably beat someone with this. That's a very much Christian cause.
SPEAKER_04Or you'll be like me and play against someone who literally had no basics but never draw a price of progress. Which which happened in all three games. It was great.
SPEAKER_02Let's talk about Jace versus Jace, and there's so many Jace's, but let's talk about the dead the dead Jace versus the minus couple. Yeah, there's not a question. I'm running them side by side for the short term, and uh you're not gonna get disagreeing out disagreement out of me. They don't feel the same. We're talking about the theorist, I guess what is that Jace Bellarin. They play different, they play very different. Jace the mind sculptor is a card that for a short period of time that it's got it's lost its for me, it's lost its luster so much that I put it as a centerpiece.
SPEAKER_02In the Black Parade is a centerpiece, and also it's a centerpiece in uh I spy cube because of the you know the fate ceiling is more of the reason. That's how much by comparison that modern magic has displaced the rise of the tides, the water has come up, that now a card that was banned, was this banned and modern for so long?
SPEAKER_03Which called it so that it was banned and modern, yeah.
SPEAKER_02It was banned and modern. It was so disgusting. And now it's it's still powerful and it still has homes and cubes. But now if your cube that you're building or constructing, it it can now it can rise to the top. It's it's now it could be the cream of the cream of the crop in another cube at this point. Here, I think it started becoming a strange outlier even at 540. I can hang on to it, but I could get where you're at 360, and you decided that the theorist Bellarin is just better.
SPEAKER_04It just does more. I actually got to play with the theorist the other night, and uh I'm gonna tell you right now, it's better. It is better, it plays a lot better. It's just you you make tick up, make make a guy draw a card. Yeah, I mean, like it's crazy good, and yeah, it's it's crazy, and like I it hurt my soul to cut Jace the Mind Sculpture, okay? It really did. I I've that card's been one of the cards that's been in my my power cube since the beginning. And it's like I even had to proxy it first because I didn't own one because it was like a$200 card at that time.
SPEAKER_04It's like, you know, I was like, you know, and I finally got one. I spent way too much money on it, obviously. And uh now, of course, it's out.
SPEAKER_03It's one of those rare cards that was like just so dominant in all the 60 card constructed formats that it were anytime it was legal, right? Same with Dark Confidant. Yep. Um obviously Dark Comfidant banned in modern. Umazawa's JT was recently unbanned in Modern. I don't know if you saw that. Guess how much Umazawa's JT is doing in Modern right now?
SPEAKER_02Nothing.
SPEAKER_03Nothing. Not even a little bit.
SPEAKER_02It's just sad, and it's so good. Still love it. I think it's still I think it's still those cards are not ready to be cut. But you start looking at the even Stoneforge Mystic decks, or they're gonna exist, and I think it's Stoneforge Mystic has seen it's like it's heyday.
SPEAKER_03It's it's it's a cool card, but two mana, you play it. Yeah, okay. I agree. Turn three, you don't do anything, and then you activate at the end, and it's like, hey, I I brought an equipment to my hand, or yeah, or I put an equipment into play on Twitter. No, no, you put a Cauldra complete into play.
SPEAKER_01That's what you put.
SPEAKER_03Which is completely Cauldra complete, which is which is fine, right? But is that good enough nowadays? I don't see anyone doing that.
SPEAKER_02I don't know.
SPEAKER_04I think I think it's still okay. I think having a but you only need like four or five good equipment to make Stoneforge okay. And you need like one or two in your deck, and you're fine. Is it Cauldra though? Is that the best card? Yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_03Or is it Skull Clamp?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, yeah, Skull Clamp. But we I still is very good too.
SPEAKER_03It depends on the deck. 100% it does.
SPEAKER_02I still have some cards that are not ready to displace, like batter skulls and all that. They'll still sit there for a little bit. I'm still running batteries. They'll hang out for they'll hang out for a while. I want to go back to a card that I want to pitch to you, Chris. That I don't know if you got you told me you'd get a chance to listen to the one where Usman and May talked about this card. I didn't really show up because we would have sold you on this card. Sphinx of the false conclusions for two colors, and blue blue, you get a Sphinx illusion, flash flying. Whenever this creature attacks, draw a card, then discard a card. Whenever this creature dies, if it isn't a token, create a token that's a copy of this for a four-two.
SPEAKER_02This card's gross. We talked about this in a recent episode. Again, I haven't play tested it, but I've been watching content on it. It's one of those cards, and Usman like highly repped it and tested it and all that. But it's one of those cards that goes in and strikes, loots, and you kill it, and they gotta deal with it again. It is pretty bonkers for an unusual. Are we mid-range? Are we tempo? What are we are? What are we at right here with blue? It's got flash, it's fast. It is really neat, and I think this could get in at 360.
SPEAKER_02This card does interesting things to threaten.
SPEAKER_04You're gonna have to say the name of it again.
SPEAKER_03I don't know, Sphinx of the Conclusions. Is that right? False, false. Sorry, Sphinx of False Conclusions. Yeah. 4 2, flash flying. When it attacks, draw a card, then discard, and then when it dies, if it isn't a token, create a token of it. 4 2. I actually really like this card. I think it's very cool. Yeah, card is awesome design, first of all. And uh yeah, I think it I think it can go in a lot of different decks. So I like I like cards like that that have got good utility and are aggressive and are fun.
SPEAKER_04The only thing that gives us this thing legs is flash. Otherwise, 100%.
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_04Yeah. Um I mean you can argue because it hasn't it has no ETB. It does not bring any other value other than the fact if it dies, it gets a copy of it, which is not bad. I mean, don't get me wrong, this card's not terrible. It's just not a card that I'm not saying it's bad. I just I don't know what I'd even cut for this thing.
SPEAKER_02Uh literally put that and sandboot in and hit them for 10.
SPEAKER_03That means what? Four mana flash, block your minskamboo, hamster token, attack planeswalkers, evasion dies, it comes back in you move, go to your turn, swing, kill their minsk. You're right, it's bad.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, I get it. Or tick to monarch. I got it.
SPEAKER_04I didn't say it was bad. I just said I'm not sure what I would cut for it at 360, I'll be honest.
SPEAKER_02What do you guys think about Mole Man Morbid Master? This is a weird card. I have more of a land-centric package in my 540, although I am cle gleaning that.
SPEAKER_04I'm gonna be putting that in my cube. Card's great pretty nice. Very cool. Very, very cool card. Yeah, I I've got to replace the Ramanap excavator with that. That's what that's coming out.
SPEAKER_02Oh my god, you're still running the Ramanap excavator at 360. You peasant.
SPEAKER_04I am. I'm I'm taking this out to put the Molman in. Wow.
SPEAKER_02You can make fun of all you want. I'm just so used to getting it that I'm just giving it back now. It's my turn. It's my time, it's my time to shine.
SPEAKER_03Are you still are you running ice till as well as um I'm running ice till I'm Raminant?
SPEAKER_04Ice Till's way better. Rem Reminant, I I was talking about this the other day with some uh with with at the group. I said, my cubes, there are still cards I have blind spots for. Where it's just you look at your list and you just don't see these these weaknesses. I'm sure Anthony has the same issue.
SPEAKER_02Oh god, yes.
SPEAKER_04Anyone with a cube has this issue. You you look at it and you just don't see things that probably should leave. Either they're just not good enough or they're old, but they're just there and they've always been there. And it's like this is correct for them to be here. We could probably do a whole episode of the city. You know what I mean?
SPEAKER_02It's like so well. I I want to push back on that. I I would say that I would say that Anthony a year ago would definitely fall into that. I think these new cards are put it shining a lens on something that it's hard for me not to see now. It's just getting harder for me not to see.
SPEAKER_03You say that, that's how it is on my other two cards.
SPEAKER_02I'm looking at course of crucifix.
SPEAKER_03He says that as courser of crucifix and auger of autumn.
SPEAKER_02They need to go. Yeah, I was I was pointing at him on a reason.
SPEAKER_03These two cards. Chris just said these cards are terrible. Did you hear that?
SPEAKER_02Uh no, I agree with you. That's why literally he's cheating because I'm hovering over them, my mouse going back and forth, making them flash. So just spoiler alert, audience. But I agree with you. I was looking at them today and like I don't know what to I need that one card. Was it or a boy or whatever that thing is? Auroboroid? Aroboroid. Yeah, I want one of those. It's pretty deep.
SPEAKER_04It's a very good card.
SPEAKER_02I haven't picked one up yet. I'm looking at that. I'm not sure what to do with these two cards. I'm not ashamed to imbalance a cube.
SPEAKER_03I'll probably cut both of them at this point. Black Parade is called in for both of those bad boys.
SPEAKER_02Well, see, that's where it maybe same with Ewit. Ewit's gotta go. I was gonna ask about Ewit. Where are we at? Where are we at with Ewit this night?
SPEAKER_04No, I like Ewit. I like uh here's here's what Ewit should become. Uh the that emeritus of the Green Emeritus. Yeah, why is that so great, though?
SPEAKER_02That card cost a million.
SPEAKER_04The Green Emeritus is really good, but Ewit is there's still decks that like Ewit. The Time Walk deck loves Ewit. And and any deck that likes to recur things from the yard loves Ewit. So it's not a terrible card. It's not terrible. Yeah, but the emeritus goes infinite with time walk if you have eight lands. So there's that.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, but how often so back to the it goes. I remember a long time ago, what was that card that was the America card? It was mono-white and had blue and red, and it was in there for the sole purpose of the city. Oh, yeah.
SPEAKER_04It gave stuff lifelink. I forget what it was.
SPEAKER_02It did infinite triggers with time walk, wasn't that the case or something like that?
SPEAKER_04Yeah, it costs like a billion mana, but yeah, it would do it.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, yeah, but it see, and sometimes we kind of cling on that a little bit in these environments, I think. We look at these A-ish, B-ish combos that get decentralized at 540 a little bit, anyways. Problematic 360. But then you what do you justify the idea of keeping that card in? But now we're saying we keep this new one that has regrowth built into it because it has prepared that cost multiple turns to set up.
SPEAKER_04It's also a Vigilance 3-4 for three.
SPEAKER_02It's not terrible. There's that. But what do you do with that whenever you I guess back to your point though, how do you combat that when you how do you justify that? I mean, what do you what are you hoping for? Black lotus into this, and then what speed are you at now? Because Stu's always been our naysayer. You guys can't see I'm pointing at him. And before it was always tearing these cards out, it's not good enough, it's not good enough, it's not good enough. And you always wonder what like how many cards do I need here? Eleven cards in this cube, right? But my question is, where has your temperament changed, Stu? You're again, we're theory crafting here because none of us have played these cards, not really.
SPEAKER_03Uh again, I I think the complication is how do you fit all of these in with a 540 number, knowing again, going back to Chris's point, that your floor power level, even if you want to call it, or even if you want to call it your ceiling power level, is Black Lotus and Time Walk and Ancestral Recall, how do these cards all fit in? Like you're hovering over Vastlands Scavenger, right? It's a nuts, it's a three-mana, death touch four-four, enters prepared, which gives you five mana, bind to life, an instant, add uh mill seven cards, then put a creature card from among them onto the battlefield.
SPEAKER_03Like, how are you gonna feel about playing that card on turn three? And not hitting how you're gonna feel about not hitting it's a good, it's pretty bad, but it's a good card. How are you gonna feel about hitting and you hit a birds of paradise? Yeah, I agree with you, but some of these how are you gonna feel about hitting a vault born tyrant? You're gonna feel very good. So the question is not necessarily becoming about how do the cards look, and I don't want to say it's becoming it. This is not the case. It's not about what are the potential outcomes for this card.
SPEAKER_03It's how how much of a guarantee you have. I know what a guarantee I have when I pay four mana for minskambu that I am attacking with it, the planeswalk is getting larger, and it's a nightmare to deal with. I know what the what the outcome is, and I know what the the consequences are for my opponent. You just there's so many unknowns, and this is what you're essentially bringing in at 540 versus 360. 360, you have guarantees with what the cards are doing, every single one of them. When you expand out to 540, now even if it's not just purely at a power level perspective.
SPEAKER_03Except for Ramanap. Ramanap Excavator does a thing. And you know what's great about Ramanap Excavator.
SPEAKER_04Except about a Mole Man. It does look at it.
SPEAKER_03And and Mole Man and Crucible and Ice Tell Explorer, you know what you're getting with those cards if you are putting them in a deck, a green deck with Titania and Strip Mine and Wasteland or whatever else, right? There's a known factor about those cards, but some of those others there just isn't. And if you can't guarantee that value, especially at three mana, and certainly at four mana, justify it.
SPEAKER_02Well, I got one more question for you, Chris, and we're kind of coming to a conclusion here. We could debate all day because I would I would argue that a lot of these cards ultimately through proxy become placeholders. That's what you're trying to grab onto here, is that a certain point a new card is going to come out, and these cards are just decayed. And while you should try the idea of at the current tech, you've got a card and say, I need to get prime time out, which is on my list. It's just not as effective as it was then. There's nothing wrong with it.
SPEAKER_02But it's holding on by little strings now.
SPEAKER_03It's not even just that, it's also the excitement that is not a this is a cube agnostic concept, right? The excitement and the fun, right, is the the the one that you showed before, the three-maner and then the five-maner. There isn't a level of excitement there because there's the oh, what will I mill and will I get a big creature and so on and so forth. But I'm looking at some of these cards and they're not as exciting to me. And and as much as I hate to say this, I'm a simple person. I see Entomb and I see Reanimate and I see our kind of cruelty, and I see Grizzlebrand, or I see Black Lotus, or I see Underworld Breach, and so on and so forth.
SPEAKER_03Those cards are exciting, they're not the only exciting, there's plenty of exciting cards, but now how do you balance making it exciting, making it fun, and fitting it within this ground floor of Black Lotus and Time Vault and Time Walk and so on and so forth?
SPEAKER_02I think that through deck diversity you need these mid-range. Of course you do. You have to have them, and then the weaker cards will find synergies. I mean, it's there's there the but some of them have the synergies are kind of breaking up, right? That's just the way it's going to be. Chris, have you had a chance to test out Formidable Speaker? I remember when this card first came out.
SPEAKER_04Two colors and yeah, I've run it in a couple of cubes. I actually, formidable speaker generally, you know, the untap ability, people use it with time bolt. Let's be real. They use it with the time bolt combo thing. I'm currently running it in mine. I added it, I don't know, a while back. And it's just a neat little one shot, it can be like, you know, just a one-shot uh uh what do they call it? Survival of the fittest. So yeah, I but I think you can discard any card, right? Yeah, you can discard any card whereas survival requires a creature discard. I I've liked this card.
SPEAKER_04Uh a two-four for three that that uh tutors out a creature, pretty good. Uh it's been good for me. I've never and it's really good in my in my graveyard cube. Uh, it's a real good there. Good with library, good with Telerian Academy.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, I agree with that. Any it's it's not non-land permanent, it's any permanent, so anything that has a good tap effect. What was the card that we were talking about earlier? Little little red guy for one mana. Oh, uh welder. The little goblin welder. Like and it's this is the other thing. If you actually go back to your blog and look at the the cuts that you made, all the cuts that you made are cards that are very, very good with Goblin Welder. What was the other one that you cut that you cut? Little two-mana dreadhored Arcanist? Yeah, I don't really love that card, but I don't love it either.
SPEAKER_02I'm pretty sure I might have accidentally cut.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, you want it to be so.
SPEAKER_02You want to put a piece of equipment on it, bone splitter or whatever you want on it in order to get the effect, but it's just too much. Yeah, that that's the dream. It's never asking too much, is the problem. Yeah. And that's what's I kind of wanted to talk about. How many hoops you have to jump through matters. Exactly. So the hoops matter. Exactly. I I just believe that the resolution on this cube is getting I'm getting more clarity on the cuts because the reins are tightening in. That's the whole point I wanted to talk about. I'm not sitting here arguing like I once would have about the justification of cards that are outside the barrier.
SPEAKER_02I know that young Pyromancer is now officially a placeholder. And by the way, I got that six signed art that's going to go into the Black Parade. It'll just replace something else. And they got one coming out for the FemCube that I don't particularly care for the art, but I do love the extra life benefit, so I will be adding that to the femme cube for young PZ that I've been asking for for years. And then we also have cards like Courser, Krufix, and all that that I already I saw them today, and I'm like, what are you doing? Like they're what's really, really starting to shine a light on this is if I'm putting a card in the Black Parade, it's looking back at this cube, asking that question.
SPEAKER_02That's what's happening.
SPEAKER_04I'd be interested to see an exercise. Courser's not terrible. It hung on the longest in my cube. I I only barely cut it within the past year or two. So yeah, I just don't know what to do.
SPEAKER_02I just gotta buy some I'm buying magic cards is not fun.
SPEAKER_03And like I say, I'd be interested to see an exercise. Go through, cut the Augas and the Courses and all that kind of nonsense. I know that both of you do not have time vault combo, you don't have initiative, you don't have Thoracall, all that kind of stuff, and just see how close your lists are once you cut all of the dare I say the fluff, right? And um okay. Anthony's Anthony's showing me one. So this is how so this is from what? It's a jump start, alright. It's a jump start.
SPEAKER_02No, I'm sorry, no, no, no, no, no. That's from um oh airbender or whatever that is. The last airbender.
SPEAKER_03Oh, Avatar? Yeah. The Avatar set? Okay. My or May, Scornful Striker, one and a black for a two-two-far strike. Already rates nice. Whenever a player casts a non-creature spell, they lose two lives. Yeah, Rek Nerds.
SPEAKER_02I like this card. I like it. I like it too. I like the punishment.
SPEAKER_03I'm definitely gonna look at it for all of my black commander decks. It's oh, shut your hole.
SPEAKER_02That's such a good card.
SPEAKER_04That's such a good card. It'll be good in blue card. That'll be much better in commander, I think, than here, but it's not gonna be bad. Anytime you're relying on your opponent to do things, it's probably gonna do as much as I can.
SPEAKER_02I'm also relying on my opponents not to do things with this. This is like an anti-Thalia effect in my mind. I put it in here. I wanted to try it out. It got recommended to me. I saw it on a list. Again, that was probably so four years ago because we don't play this cube. We are doing a uh cube night at your house. You're setting this up sometime in November before Thanksgiving.
SPEAKER_03This should happen. Yeah, we should do it uh maybe uh before Thanksgiving might be tough.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, it definitely is. I just said that at chest.
SPEAKER_03It's probably something in favor. You know what? Maybe we can try and do it on the 21st.
SPEAKER_02We'll see. We'll try. We'll try. I'd like to get some power cube drafts in just to actually try them out. I'm tired of watching just content of other people doing it.
SPEAKER_03Oh, we'll put the word out. 21st. Vintage Cube, the r the reckoning.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, just nothing but power cubes at my house. One of the most mundane nights we could celebrate. Dude's doing vintage. It's happening. So we can talk about other cards that aren't great anymore, I guess. One more card that I want to talk about before we close out is Sedgmore Witch. Is that still holding its own? I don't think so.
SPEAKER_04Unless you're running combo, unless you're doing the chain of smog combo, yeah. Cut it.
SPEAKER_03Yeah.
SPEAKER_04Yeah.
SPEAKER_03I I think again it's if your cube I got it. I think if your cube has a lean and uh a sort of a desire to want to run the two-card combos, which I I don't dislike them. I think those cards and those combos can absolutely have a place. I would argue that those cards and those combos are probably very playgroup dependent. If if your playgroup once initiative, once time vault, once sedge more witch, and once you know, just anything's two-card combo, then then throw them all in there and and go nuts.
SPEAKER_03But if if that's not that it is again, you you for you, Anthony, I think you could absolutely justify putting both Sedge Morewitch and Chain of Smog in your cube at 540. Would I say that Chris, with his 360 list being much more tight and the and the equity being as tight as it is, I would say unless you really want it, probably not, but I think you could make the argument at 540.
SPEAKER_04Yeah. I oh, and Anthony, just to let you know, I did just compare a list currently. We have 337 cards that are the same. So that should tell you something right there.
SPEAKER_02Well, I'm thinking about cutting the other 200.
SPEAKER_04That's fine. If you want to cut 180 cards, that's fine.
SPEAKER_02Anthony's making a tuba. All right. Well, thank you guys for listening to us rabble on Rabblmaster about this nonsense. This has been fun. We just wanted to get together and do a little bit of vintage.
SPEAKER_03Do you even have Goblin Rabblemaster in this cube now? No. Because you just cut it today. Do you even have Goblin Bombardment in this cube? I do. I do.
SPEAKER_02You do have. Yeah, I'll keep that. That card's still good. I mean, look. Rabble Master is super quick.
SPEAKER_04Bombardment's amazing.
SPEAKER_02Don't cut that card. That card's awesome. Wasn't always amazing.
SPEAKER_03You can't tell me you're keeping uh Corser of Krufix and then cutting or not including Goblin Bob Bob and Aspie. Yeah, I mean look at Jimmy. I think JVP the Foods are going to be a good thing.
SPEAKER_02I think JVP's still holding on by a thread now. I just don't think it's hitting the mark.
SPEAKER_03I think JVP is fine, man. I think JVP's fine.
SPEAKER_02And you put it next to Bilbo, Thief in the Night, and Tameo is the first one. JVP's two mana.
SPEAKER_03And I know he obviously.
SPEAKER_04Are you talking about the two mana Jace? Yeah, the flip Jace. Yeah. He's okay. He's questionable. It's not terrible. It's not something that's I if I saw it in a pack, I wouldn't be I wouldn't like say, oh, why is this in here? I'd be like, you know, it's okay.
SPEAKER_03I think I think JVP's just fine, man.
SPEAKER_02So I'm still trying to pull off these before I except we're gonna close out for the 15th time. I'm still trying to pull off displacer kit and combos in here. They're still here.
SPEAKER_04I'll run it. I've got it in my 360.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, so I'm running stuff like this. I I guess it's Skycoach Conductor. I've got these little kind of switcheroo cards you can kind of mess around with. I want stuff like Emeritus that triggers for that. Hole breacher can probably go. Whole breacher.
SPEAKER_04I know that's you want your whole breacher for the for the uh what is it? The the draw seven combo, man. You want that for no you want to run it with your uh with your orcish bow masters and everything. It's fun stuff. Yeah, but I think there's it's other numbers, but who cares?
SPEAKER_03Yeah, I I don't know about whole breacher. I uh again I'm kind of thinking fun on the bowser. I don't dislike whole breacher. I I actually prefer, I would argue, I actually prefer shouldered and orcish bow masters.
SPEAKER_02Next thing you guys are they are better, they actually kill your opponent as fine. Listen, I got the day.
SPEAKER_04I've never cut mine, I've just got one too, man. I got one cut.
SPEAKER_03Listen, Chris will attest to this, okay? As I know we've been trying to close out for about 15 years. Chris will attest to this when we played uh at Sam's Invitational, it was last year, 2025, there were two cards, in my opinion, that were the most impactful cards. He went coast to coast with a certain mono red, absolutely brutal beatdown of a card. Do you remember what that card was, Chris?
SPEAKER_04Oh, I do. NT. I remember that being NT.
SPEAKER_03He absolutely went coast to coast in the third game, the decider. But the first game, the only reason it was no, it wasn't though. The first game, you ran away with the first game. You you won the first game. But the second game, the reason why I was able to hang was because of library and because I was able to keep keep the cards.
SPEAKER_02It was it was to put that final bow on this. I still think that yes, I've got some cards that definitely the receding has begun, right? There's some that I know have to be cut. But we are looking at them purely in a theoretical vacuum. I believe when you play the cube and you put them together and the synergies link together, it'll be like frogs in a blender at that point, right? I mean, sure, we could argue that Corsair Crucifix on the on the list doesn't do anything, but in a game, it still can do a thing until I replace it.
SPEAKER_02That's my only point. It it will hold a few.
SPEAKER_04It'll play just fine, Anthony.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, it'll play fine until it gets a replacement. That's the only argument I'm gonna make, right? It's just a holder that won't look odd on a battlefield spanned out with cards that you're only dealing with all these min-max cards, anyways. Yeah, you can go out of your nine cards you're just playing me, that one looks goofy, but I'm getting my teeth knocked in, anyways. That's okay.
SPEAKER_04It'll be a great 15th pick for somebody. It'll be awesome.
SPEAKER_02It'll it something always has to be 23. Of course!
SPEAKER_03Of course.
SPEAKER_02You know what? Okay.
SPEAKER_03We're just squeezing. Not to be completely contrarian, but I would argue you've got these three mana greens creatures. I don't see Strangle Root Geist. I don't see Colonian Tusca. I'm I'm I'm a little disappointed. Where you tell Mr. Colonial Hydra? What is it? Colonian, no, Colonian Tusca, Strangle Root Geist, you know. Let's see. Aspect of hydro no aspect of hydra. Aspect of hydra is badass. No vines of Vasswood. Actually, Berserk would be great. I was never is that too far?
SPEAKER_03Is that too far? Yeah, that was never that was never a it's a removal spell.
SPEAKER_04I I I I just cut Berserk from Peasant. I can play a pond. Let's not do anything anymore.
SPEAKER_02So good. God, mistakes are made. All right, thank you guys for watching. I needed space. I need to need a room. Oh my god, we're trying to end. All right. We love you guys. Thank you for listening. We didn't do any show notes. Uh, good luck with Skyfall and look at our socials. They'll be on this episode when they get it knocked out. We're gonna try to keep coming back for more. Quite right. Thank you guys for supporting us and listening to the show, and the numbers are still good, so Anthony's ego still feels great. And that's pretty much it. Yeah. Good times.
SPEAKER_02We get to that one episode in South Park where was it Stan got the South America? Got the one for end. South America. South America got that one for end. Yeah. I've heard it's South America now. It's South America now, not South Park. All right. Non-political blue wave. All right, guys, have a great one. And happy cubing. Happy cubing.
SPEAKER_04Happy cubing. Oh, yeah. Ramunap has been I've been meaning to get a stupid ball man forever.
During this spooky episode join Team Uber Cube as we unravel the mysteries of typal design. Traverse the dark path and hold your torch close as May and Anthony guide us through designing faction-based cubes and...
During this episode join Team Uber Cube and special guest Usman Jamil as we tackle the question "What are sleeper cards?" Tune in as we chat on cards that slipped past designer’s radars and later were discovered. Listen...
During this must listen episode we are recording live from the halls of Cube Con 2026. Join us as we capture the magic of Cube Con as we interview players, designers, and iconic cube personalities. Tune in as we chat on...
Join Team Uber Cube as we discuss the aspects of mechanical first cube design. Tune in as we road map the journey and questions presented while designing both “Eye Spy” and “The Exile Files.” We chat on applying a “Cube...
We are back! Join Team Uber Cube as we discuss the current state of equipment in cube. During this episode, the team banters on the latest equipment mechanics and how the “Living Weapon” design of modern cards can...