Award-winning columnist and commentator on politics, spirituality, and culture, Jonathan Merritt returns to Typology to explore the challenges of authenticity, fear and his journey towards self-compassion. Jonathan opens up about his personal experiences reconciling his identity with his upbringing, the role fear has played in his life, and how he's learning to trust and let go. We discuss his new children's book, "My Gunkle and Me," a heartwarming story that celebrates individuality and inclusivity. As Jonathan explains, "the ways in which you are different from the majority of people in this world. Those differences are not liabilities. They're your gifts to the world. They're the things that make you, you." Join us for this enlightening but deeply moving conversation, offering a powerful reminder of the transformative power of self-compassion and acceptance.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Hey, everybody, welcome back to Typology, the podcast on which we explore the mystery of the human personality and the human adventure through the lens of the Enneagram. As always, I'm joined by my dear friend, Anthony Skinner. Anthony, greetings. Hey, man, happy to be here. How you doing? Man, I am doing well, and I'm doing particularly well because we have an old friend on the show today who I cannot wait to speak to about his new book. Please welcome Enneagram 3 Jonathan
Hello. Hello. Good to be back with you again. It's been a few years since I've been on Tapology. It has been That's quite- That's it. It's pre-pandemic. It is pre-so many things. It's crazy. You have this wonderful new children's story children's book by Gunkel and me. I want to hear all about it. But first, I want to dive into some Enneagram 3 stuff with you. Can we do that? Let's do it. I want to read you a quote that I that
I love from Parker Palmer, who Yes. Parker Palmer is an Enneagram 3, friends. You heard it here first. And he he talks about his journey, and I don't know if he was thinking about the Enneagram when he wrote this, but this is what he said. He says, our deepest calling is to grow into our own authentic selfhood, whether or not it conforms to
some image of who we ought to be. As we do so, we will not only find the joy that every human being seeks, we will also find our path of authentic service in the world. How does that land with Well, I love that. I think as an Enneagram 3, and maybe this is a challenge, I mean, you're the expert more than I am, but I think one of the challenges I have is when I hear that phrase, authentic self, It feels so far
away. It feels like something that I'm constantly out of touch with. Like I'm constantly asking myself, is this who I am or is this the person that I'm trying to project to the world? And sometimes I actually don't know. So I think it connects with me because that's my constant challenge is to live out my calling as my authentic self. But man, that's a Yeah, you're so funny. One of the questions I wrote down actually, it's the first question I wrote
is, how do you tell when you are your own authentic self or when you're simply crafting an image for public consumption? And of course, when we talk about Enneagram types, these are prototypes, right? So there's a part of me that does this, Anthony that does this, right? And there are the prototype of the four, the seven or the nine, those are pieces of me as well. But I am curious, because I'm always trying to, you know, I think threes ask all the time, like, well, how do I know, right? Like, when
I am flowing in the truth of myself, and when I am merely projecting an image to win the admiration and the approval and the love of others. Does your body tell you? Is there something in you now at this age in your life where you're like, Okay. I know I'm Yes. You know, like anything, there's like the gray area in the middle where it gets really confusing, but then there are
the poles. And I'll say that there are times where I'll laugh and I'll catch myself going, that really wasn't, that wasn't a real laugh, right? Or I can tell that I'm editing something in real time, right? Like I'm editing out all of the rough parts or the embarrassing parts. And so I catch myself, I mean, this is... In some ways, it's like the gift of the Enneagram is like a greater awareness. It's not that I don't do the things, but now when I do
the things, I'm aware that I'm doing it. I can hold myself accountable and pivot away from those affectations, those personality affectations. I find that I am doing it Maybe not as much as I used to, but I'm catching myself doing it a lot when I'm interacting with friends and family members and So I have a woman I'm working with, and she's a very, very strong three. And I'm completely masking this
person's identity. But one of the things I've noticed in public settings is what I call the need to control the narrative. Oh yeah. So it's as if in real time, in a group setting where this person is a leader, she wants to make sure that the narrative is crafted all the time. The conversation is just being crafted in the way that she wants
things to be perceived and understood about herself and this situation. And it's almost like like bending reality. It's like I'm watching this person burn incredible amounts of calories trying to bend reality for everyone to see it a certain way. And Oh, 100%. And I'll tell you how, you know, maybe this even goes back to the last question you asked. Sometimes the way that I know I'm doing the thing, the shtick,
is after the encounter, after I've left the business meeting, after I've had the lunch with a friend and I begin to kind of question whether or not they bought it, right? You begin to go like, did they perceive me the way that I wanted them to perceive me? And that sort of is the tell that you're doing the thing that threes do so well. So a lot of times I'll pay attention to what I feel afterwards and then I'll become obsessive. where then, let's say for example, let's say that I'm in a
business meeting and there are three of us and two of us walk away. I'll begin to ask that second person whether they thought I presented in this way in that meeting. You can see it on people's faces because maybe they're not a three, so they're like, what are you talking? Why are we still talking about this? Why are we having a conversation about this? But I will want to kind of deconstruct the interaction to see like, hey, did I sound did I sound dumb when I said that thing? Or do you think that they thought that I was this way when I
said that thing? Right. So I will start to like deconstruct and tease apart the encounter, the meeting with the other person who was bearing witness to it. I do that all the time. Exactly right. Yeah. I mean, how does one break free of the addiction, really? And I say that not just about threes, but of all types, right? We have addictive patterns like this, right? How
does one break free of the need to control the narrative, to bend reality so that it shines on the right side of our face, our best side? How do we How And that's a good question. And you're probably the guru here, but I'll tell you something that that's really been been helpful for me and has been liberating for me. Is I always I talk about it as like reviewing the
tape. So I go back and I look at all of the times when I wasn't able to control the narrative. And it turned out okay. You know, I was, I think maybe I talked about it five years ago when I was on this podcast before, but in 2012, I was very publicly outed for being gay. And I was, I was not only was I not able to control the narrative in that situation, but
I really mangled it. I responded, you know, because I felt I felt so judged and I felt like I was failing in that moment so deeply that I began to panic and I began to kind of express like stress behavior. I began to say things that I didn't, that I didn't believe were true, but I felt like people wanted to hear even if they conflicted with other things that I was saying and I was a total mess. And now I look back on that, you know, some 12 years
ago now and I go, it's all okay. It all, it all came out in the wash. Yes, you responded in a terrible way at times. Yes, you said things that were not a reflection of your authentic self, your authentic beliefs, and it was still okay. And so I think sometimes it's reminding ourselves Of the pattern that many of us have in our lives when we weren't able to do the thing and we still survived And
we still move past it and we still move through it And so for me reminding myself that there's a pattern there That when i'm not able to control it, the stakes are not nearly as high as I assume allows me to kind of like allows my shoulders to come down from around my ears in the moment when I think that if I can't control this, then the worst possible thing, So oftentimes I think what I've seen in threes, and by
the way, I have such a strong three-wing, it's kooky. I'm a self-preservation four, which already makes me a little three-ish and seven-ish, but I have a very, very strong three-wing. So I'm resonating with everything that's being said. It seems to me that when you can't control the narrative, it's not working. It's just not working. That often what happens is we go into a tailspin. We
start the helix down. And we find ourselves lost in the room of mirrors. Because if you've been playing all these games with different people for so long, it's like, you get sort of thrust into a panic mode, and you don't know which of your true selves is the true self to put out there. It's like a vertigo-like experience. But I can't imagine Oh,
and also I'd say this, where threes and sevens are different is, in those situations, the seven might reframe this, and I've said this before on the show, but it's worth saying, whereas the three will spin it. So the seven might say, oh, this is a terrible experience, but it's really going to help me grow with blah, blah, blah. So all of a sudden the negative becomes a positive and they don't have to feel all the bad feelings associated with betrayal or being outed publicly, humiliation, embarrassment, making mistakes, et cetera. Whereas the three will
take a situation like that and spin it to make themselves look good. Do you know what I'm saying? Which is different. It's a nuanced, you're smiling a little bit for me. Is that, so it's like, how do I spin this debacle Yeah. Yeah, and I do this all the time. It's like the creative storytelling of the three. And it's like that inner, I mean, as a three, like I have a publicist that lives inside my brain.
And so I'm always trying to tell stories about the choices that I've made, the way that things have worked out. And it kind of drives me crazy because now that I have a little bit of self-awareness, I'm like, am I, is that, I don't know what's real. Is that the story that I'm telling or is that really what happened, right? Did I make that decision and it worked out this way because that's the way it was supposed to have worked out and that was the health of the whole thing? Or is that like
my post hoc rationalization of the situation so that I can make peace with it and move on? And I don't know Yeah, it's like, if you, I met a three one time, and there, they had a very public failure. And the first word, this person said, like, maybe two or three days after it hit the headlines, right? The remark was something like, well, you know, this is going to make a
New York Times bestseller. And he had already begun thinking, how can I turn this into a win, like into a win for me and for my public image and for my brand and my platform. And that's spinning versus reframing. And I always love to make that delineation for people because sometimes it looks the same, but it's not, right? Because it's all around the image and for the three. So We're
going to get to this wonderful children's book in just a moment, but I'm fascinated by this topic today. Twos, threes, and fours, the most image-conscious numbers on the Enneagram, meaning they all project an image, believing they can't be loved for who they are. So in the case of twos, but only for what they can do for others. For fours, for being special and unique. And really for threes, there's this need
to really craft an image of winning and success, because for them, there's this belief that winning and success equals love somehow. They want love and they settle for admiration. But one of the things that Beatrice Chestnut says that I find so interesting, she says for all three types, the common thread that runs through it is grief and shame. or
particularly grief and sadness, I should say. Others say shame, others say feelings, like what at the heart center, what is the emotion that they share? And it's grief and sadness for twos, threes, and fours, which you would not think for twos and threes, because twos are so likable and upbeat and cheerful and ebullient and sometimes histrionic. And then you have threes, and they're confident and blah, blah, blah, and the appearance of having it all together. What role has grief
Well, you know, so much of of what you just said around not just grief and sadness, but you also use the word shame, I feel like plays a huge role in this, because for me, the the publicist in me is aware that I'm doing it and I feel sort of embarrassed about it. I don't say that out loud. I don't speak that part out loud, but I feel sort of ashamed. Particularly, this is the hard thing, the sort of
the burden of learning a system like the Enneagram, is now you know you're doing it. And so then you're sort of aware of your inauthenticities. And so I feel a lot of shame. I think the other thing is, is that, and this is where at least for me, where grief comes into the equation, is that I realize not just the way I am, but I start to realize why I
am the way that I am. And I begin to look back in my childhood, the demands that were placed on me when I was just a little boy and I feel such a deep sense of sadness because it's like I can't, now it sort of feels fixed, right? I can't escape who I am so I have a constant reminder of these deep wounds from my childhood. And
I'm constantly having to grieve that because now that I see it, I see it everywhere and I can't get away from it. And so I do feel like constantly grieved for that kid inside me who felt that he had to become who I am in order to survive, in order to be seen, in order to be loved. And I think anybody who becomes aware of that kind of thing pain that produces the personality, feels a real, a real sadness, a real sadness that
hopefully you can like allow it to mature into self compassion, which is a little bit like softer form of grief. It's not just despair, right? It kind of falls off that cliff in one direction, it becomes despair. But if you allow it to kind of mature and blossom, it becomes self love and self compassion. I think in my best moments, that's what happens. I feel I feel a deep sense of compassion for myself and for previous iterations of myself that had to endure all the pain they endured. But in my worst moments, I
feel utter despair because this is part of my story Yeah. So I think for me, as a four in the hard triad. I think I've pretty successfully made the cross the bridge from grief and despair to self-compassion and a sense of humor too. When I catch myself in the act of doing what I do, like my things, You
know, there's a little part of me that sort of smiles at myself the way a mother smiles at a child with his hand in the cookie jar. You know what I mean? Like with a bit like, well, of course you are, you're eight years old. Kids steal cookies at eight, you know, and there's this kind of a smile. And I sort of giggle at myself a little bit, like, you know, busted. And I'm glad that, you know, but it took a minute to get there. I mean, like it, there was a long time on the grief and despair side of the bridge for sure. And and
I do think that humor is like so important, like just having a sense of humor about our particular way of being in the world is like so freaking vital. But I want to hear for people to be reminded of why, like what was the situation growing up and the pressures you felt? Because it is a compelling story. Yeah. Well, I grew up in a fundamentalist
home with a sort of famous religious leader. My dad is, to this day, a TV preacher. He was president of the Southern Baptist Convention, so it was a very pietistic household, a very high-pressure environment, an environment with a lot of anger and a lot of guilt. and a lot of fear, a lot of anger, guilt and fear. And
those things were kind of the motivating factors for conformity in our house. And so when we were able to conform to what was expected of us and to do it really, really well, then we were rewarded, or at least we weren't punished, which was its own form of reward is not being punished. Because if we all deserve punishment, not being punishment is the reward. So I
grew up kind of in that pressure cooker. And it wasn't until later on that I kind of assumed this is how everybody's house was. I went to college and I remember people saying, why do you yell all the time? And I was like, what are you talking about? What do you mean? People don't yell like you yell all the time and I realized like, you know, I grew up in this household That was that was so contentious that we were all having to
to get louder In order to be heard over everybody else and I just thought this is how people talk or we could we would judge and eviscerate each other and when I would start to do that other people people be like You can't talk to me in that way. I mean What do you mean? I'm just saying what I think is true. People don't talk to other people this way. So I had a real awakening really in college because I would
learn the sort of normal human patterns of relationship and then I would come home and I would be thrust back into this very different environment and I realized I wasn't really able to tolerate it. And so, you know, it was a multi-year journey to kind of untangling what's normal, what's not normal. And then when I began to realize what I wanted for my life, kind of a more normal
human way of relating to other people, then how would I go back and survive when I had to go home to be with my family, which is something that all of us do? And that was a multi-year journey, really, of having to sit down with my parents and my siblings and be like, guys, not only is this not normal, maybe it is, sometimes it is normal, sadly, but it's not healthy, and it's not good, and we have to find a different way of relating to each other. And, you know, I was lucky
enough that I had a family for the most part over time that So you're the son of a famous religious figure, public figure, you're a gay young man, let's say, or I'm not sure at what point in your life's journey all the dots connected for you in terms of coming to terms with your own sexual identity. Where is it now? There's
so many things I want to ask you about. Okay, so making peace with family. You have a brand new book out, My Gunkle and Me, about this young boy, Henry Higgleston, who's viewed as an oddball by the other kids at school. His wonderful gay uncle arrives for a weekend with his French bulldog in tow. He's on a mission to teach Henry that what makes us different makes us special. Okay,
so you, you know, you are a gay man in the public sphere, you are a public figure, like Well, you know, in some ways, my siblings and their kind of growing embrace transformed me. because they were like, we love you. You don't have to be something in order to be loved by us. We love you. And, you know, they began to have kids and those kids as kids do. They loved me and they
loved me because of of who I was, not because of which box I checked under sexual orientation, let's say. I think that that whole my whole imagination for what it what family could be And what it meant to live and love within the confines of family really expanded a few years ago in New York City because I moved into an old seminary property here in Manhattan
in Chelsea. And I began to live alongside a number of families. In fact, it was shortly after or right around the time, I guess that was on your show last and probably 2019, I just moved in here. And these families invited me in and they said, you have a seat at our table. And this seat is not just like any other seat. It is an honored and a celebrated seat. And we recognize that you have
gifts to give that we cannot give. And our family will be poor if you're not giving those gifts to us. And, you know, for somebody like me who grew up in in a culture that said that gay people were threatening, to families, both the lowercase F family that lives next door and the kids that exist in those households, and also the big capital F family, the traditional family, I didn't realize how ingrained that assumption had
been made in my own spirit, that I really ingested that idea and even had accepted that that I couldn't be around families and kids like this. And so it was their love for me and their embrace of me that really changed me. And it really alerted me to all of the ways that I had come to believe things about myself that were not true. And so it's been
actually living here that I think accelerated that process. So when I ended up deciding that I wanted to write a children's book, A friend of mine who lives here said, why don't you just write about what you know and write about how you've been living alongside us and the ways that you have touched our families. And so this book is kind of a composite, both of my biological nephews and nieces back home. And also, it incorporates all of these stories of the ways that I have been living here
So what would it have been like for you to have had a book like Mike Gunkel and You know, this is this is sort of the crazy thing, because and I think a lot of children's authors say this or they do this. They write the book that that they wish they would have had when they were a child. And in some ways, I guess I really I really did that. You know, I'm well aware that the kind of grown-up that a person becomes is
largely a result of the types of stories that the grown-ups in their life chose to tell them when they were children. And we can all point back to the stories that we were told for good or ill, and they weren't always written down on pages. They were the stories our families told. They were the mythologies that we were given in our families, the kinds of stories we were told, and the assumptions underneath those stories, and the films we watched, and the TV shows that we watched. And we ingested those, and we digested those, and they became sort of embedded
in our DNA. And we've lived into those assumptions, in many cases, unaware in adulthood. And I wish I had had better stories. I wish I had had stories that said, you are loved because of who you are. And God loves you because of who you are. And God made you the way you are. And that the ways in which you are different from the majority of people in this world. Those differences are not liabilities. They're your gifts to the world. They're the things that make you,
you. You know, I was, I think in some ways when people see this book, they go, you're the Gunkel, right? I can even kind of look like this, this, the way that the, the illustrator, the great illustrator, great illustrator, the way that this illustrator rendered me. And it wasn't actually until this book was published that I realized I'm also Henry. And what I think I did, maybe even on an unconscious level, was I, the future self, or I guess at this point, the
present me, almost went back in time to take a knee and to look the past me in the eyes and to say the things that needed to be said to me that were never said. And I think that's ultimately what Everybody, I'm speaking with our friend Jonathan Merritt, the author of the new children's book, My Gunkle and Me. Jonathan, what is it right now that is the frontier of
growth for you? It could be what you're dealing with in therapy or just a theme that's coming up over and over again in your life right now that Oh, this is a good one because And I can tell you, I might not have been able to tell you a year ago, but I began this like journaling practice starting last summer. And it started by doing the artist way, which I'm sure a lot of people know, where you do morning pages, you sort of write stream of consciousness in the morning. And
for me, it's become, I think, a more intentional journaling practice meets prayer practice even. And I've been able to kind of track some things going on. And I think one of the things I've realized is the ways in which fear motivates so much of my life. Fear of failure, fear of rejection, fear of insignificance, fear of irrelevance. I mean, I'm all the
time afraid Afraid of how people perceive me. I mean, even when I wrote this book, I was like, you can't write a children's book. First of all, you won't be able to do it well, and it'll be a big mess, and that'll embarrass you. And if you go out and do it, and if you do get it published, then people will think that you're unserious. You're supposed to be this columnist. You write for the New York Times. You write for the Atlantic. You write serious grown-up books with data and arguments and persuasion inside
of them. You can't write a children's book. It's silly. It's unserious. And I'm realizing all of the things that I feel called to do and compelled to do that I am held back from doing because fear has grown in my life at such a level that that's really what I feel like I need to. It's like the number one task of my life right now is digging down deep and trying to kind of chip away at the root of fear that
is so deeply ingrained in my life. Even a minute ago, you were talking about the ways in which Enneagram threes are trying to kind of control the narrative. And I have these like twin responses. I'm both trying to control the narrative and I'm telling myself I'm not doing it. I'm failing at it. And so I feel like everybody else, I'm trying to do it and I feel like everybody else must see that I'm trying to do it. And then I feel embarrassed
and ashamed that the jig is up, that everybody knows what's going on. And so I'm both trying to do something that I'm convinced I'm going to fail at. And there's a real misery. Living stuck in in that cycle and so I think that's the one thing that I'm I'm really working on right now the one thing that I hear over and over and over I have been hearing over the last year when I'm I'm having this kind of moment of prayer meditation in the morning is
you know I hear God or the universe whatever you want to call it. saying back to me, trust and let go. Trust and let go. You cannot control. And the thing that keeps me stuck as a three is trying to control what I cannot control. It's like an exercise in frustration and failure, trying to control the thing I can't control. And so I think the task for me right now is recognizing the fear that's driving that impulse
I love what you just said, the fear of not being able to control what I can't control. And I love what you said about trust and letting go. You know, in my 12-step program, we do a lot of work with what's called a fear inventory, where we actually do like as part of our fourth and fifth steps, right? You have to actually write a fear inventory. like to write down everything you're afraid of. And
one of the, you know, amazing gifts of that of that program is like I had no idea. the degree to which fear governed my life. I just, I had no idea until I sat down and really started to write stuff out. And I was like, oh my gosh, like fear dictates so much of my thinking and my feeling and my way of behaving. It's ridiculous, right? And so we go through this process and I think the Enneagram helps us, things
like the 12 steps help us, different tools that we can avail ourselves of, help us to uncover, discover, and discard those parts of ourselves that are no longer serving us. And you've done a beautiful job of just articulating, I think, You were talking about the fear of irrelevance, the fear of insignificance. This is like textbook Enneagram 3 stuff, right? The fear of worthlessness. And of course, what can we control? You
know, and realizing there are so many things I get anxious about, over which I have no control, in which the only solution is surrender and trust. You know, just perpetually reminding myself, surrender and trust. Thank you. Thank you for that. Jonathan Merritt, author of My Gunkle and Me, this marvelous new children's book. I love what Kate Bowler said about it. Every parent needs this, a story of love that teaches children that they are never, ever alone.
We all need a gunkle. And I'm glad I had a gunkle today, Anthony, and he was on our show. Jonathan, thanks for Oh, my gosh. The pleasure is all mine. Thank you May you and everyone listening have love, may you have joy, may you have peace, may you have healing, and
Have you ever felt something so deeply that you couldn't find the words to explain it? Or wondered whether your longing for God was drawing you closer to him or keeping you searching for something just out of reach?...
What happens when the person everyone sees on the outside doesn't quite match the person you know yourself to be? Award-winning singer, songwriter, and author Cindy Morgan joins me for a heartfelt conversation about...
What if shame isn't the enemy we've always thought it was? What if, instead of trying to silence it, we learned to listen for what it might be telling us? This week, I sat down with Dr. Frank Spinelli, an Enneagram...
What does it actually mean to become a person of deep character in a culture obsessed with personality, platform, and performance? On this episode of Typology, Ian Morgan Cron sits down with therapist, spiritual...
None of us becomes who we are on our own. We carry the stories, wounds, wisdom, and unfinished hopes of the people who came before us. Sometimes we recognize those inheritances; sometimes they show up in us before we...