Send us Fan Mail Daniel Rosenberg and Michael Dye break down the shocking hung jury outcome in the Lindsay Clancy murder trial. After 40 hours of deliberation, the jury ended in an 11-1 deadlock - with 11 jurors favoring not guilty by reason of lack of criminal responsibility/insanity, and one lone holdout for first-degree murder. Daniel and Michael dive deep into the legal realities and controversies surrounding the case. ⏰ Timestamps ⏰ 00:00:00 👋 Intro & Case Recap 6:45 ⚖️ The 11-1 Verdict Breakdown: Why the Jury Hung 14:18 📜 Legal Analysis: Massachusetts Insanity Defense Standards 17:05 🛡️ Defense Strategy Critique: Kevin Reddington's Tactics 23:30 🔄 Double Jeopardy Claims & Potential Retrial 26:15 📺 Public Reaction & Patrick Clancy's 60 Minutes Interview 37:00 🏥 Mental Health System Failures & Medical Liability 43:30 🏛️ Civil Commitment vs. Prison: What Happens Next? 48:10 🎯 Final Thoughts & Wrap Up 💬 What are your thoughts on the 11-1 hung jury outcome? Drop your take in the comments below! #LindsayClancy #PostpartumPsychosis #lawyer #Law #truecrimecommunity #criminallaw #CurrentEvents #justicesystem #Lawsuit #Mystery #justice #LegalNews #CourtCase #lawandorder #DeepDive #CourtroomDrama #CrimeDocumentary #criminaljustice #trials #LawAndOrder #realtalk #debate #TrueCrimePodcast #truecrimestories #attorney #investigations #LegalTips #LegalAnalysis #TwoTapsAndFriends 🔔 Don't forget to like, comment, and subscribe for more episodes of Two Taps and Friends! 🍻 https://youtu.be/9ntuPD0mwxU 🍻 Follow us: Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/twotapsandfriends Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/twotaps_and_friends Tiktok: https://tiktok.com@twotapsandfriends X: https://x.com/TwoTapsFriends 🎧 Listen now on: Apple: https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/two-taps-and-friends/id1793804856 Spotify: https://open.spotify.com/show/0wvjYhEX4wqbmawXRk8WTj Amazon Music: https://music.amazon.com/podcasts/5d7a4671-7ffd-49a2-9a4c-ecee6e86f6b8/two-taps-and-friends iHeart Radio: https://iheart.com/podcast/263402137 Merch Shop: https://www.redbubble.com/people/Two-Taps Don't forget to like, comment, and subscribe for more episodes of Two Taps and Friends! 🍻 Follow us: Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/twotapsandfriends Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/twotaps_and_friends Tiktok: https://tiktok.com@twotapsandfriends X: https://x.com/TwoTapsFriends 🎧 Listen now on: Apple: https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/two-taps-and-friends/id1793804856 Spotify: https://open.spotify.com/show/0wvjYhEX4wqbmawXRk8WTj Amazon Music: https://music.amazon.com/podcasts/5d7a4671-7ffd-49a2-9a4c-ecee6e86f6b8/two-taps-and-friends iHeart Radio: https://iheart.com/podcast/263402137 Merch Shop: https://www.redbubble.com/people/Two-Taps
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_01And on January 24th, 2023, her husband Patrick came home. And when he came home, he found her laying outside. She'd thrown herself out of the second story window. She had postpartum psychosis. Uh, she'd done everything you're supposed to do in society, meaning she checked herself in the hospitals multiple times. She's been on med, she talked to people.
SPEAKER_0311 people saying not guilty by essentially reason of insanity. And there was one holdout for first degree murder. Technically, if she got found not guilty by reason of insanity, whenever her next review rolls around, they could say she's good to go. Scary. So she could be out in the six months. Still young enough to get pregnant. There's actually a case that this happened before. They are vilifying Patrick Lancy. Michael, the little loan holdout juror. God bless you, sir.
SPEAKER_03You are a hero. Welcome back, Turnie Michael Dye.
SPEAKER_02Welcome to Two Taps and Friends. Grab your favorite drink. Get comfy, and let's dive into another episode of Two Taps and Friends.
SPEAKER_01Welcome back to Two Taps and Friends. I'm the host of the show, Danny Rosenberg. I have my co-host here, Michael Dye. Welcome back, Michael Dye. Nice to be back, Danny. Attorney Michael Dye. I'm sorry. Close enough. Great. So uh we we're back because we wanted to talk about um the Lindsey Clancy trial. Lindsey Clancy trial is a trial that's captured, it's captivated the country. It's unbelievable. This is the one trial. Have you noticed that when you talk to people? Like everybody's talking about this case. And I it just hits home. Clearly, I understand why. It hits home. She just to recap for people that uh have been living under a rock.
SPEAKER_01Lindsay Clancy is a, how old is she? Do you remember how old she was?
SPEAKER_03Uh I think she's in her early 40s now.
SPEAKER_01Early 40s, mom had three boys or three children. Two boys. Two boys and a girl. Uh eight-month-old Kaylin, three uh, I mean, three-year-old Dawson, five-year-old Cora. Um, and on January 24th, 2023, she uh her husband Patrick came home. And when he came home, he found her laying outside of the window on her back uh with a slit throat. She'd thrown herself out of the second story window, and then uh he waited for 911 to get there.
SPEAKER_01When they got there, he went to the basement and found his young children strangled to death with exercise bands. So clearly horrific, traumatizing, and I think that's obviously what's you know, captivating the country. Um, the background on it, like we talked about, we did a prior episode on this. If you guys want to really see the full breakdown, just gonna be a quick recap, is she had clear mental health issues. She'd been suffering with depression, and and uh the defense uh made the argument that she had postpartum psychosis. Uh, she'd done everything you're supposed to do in society, meaning she checked herself in the hospitals multiple times.
SPEAKER_01She's been on med, she'd talked to people. Short of telling people that she had ideations of murder of her children, she did everything, right? Uh the the the Patrick was aware of it, the husband. Uh so it really highlighted, I think, and what we brought out was the mental health system in this country failing that family as well. Now, in the trial, the defense claim, hey, in Massachusetts, they have a standard where if you meet a certain standard with the with the mental health that you can show they could argue that she doesn't, she lacks the ability to have criminal responsibility.
SPEAKER_01In other states, every state has a different standard for it, competency or whatever it may be. The gist of it is not understanding the gravity or the consequences due to a mental condition or state that you were in. So the trial occurred. This is Lindsay Clancy up. Uh, if you want to put a couple photos of her up for the audience, Clancy, maybe we do Clancy one and two, just show both of them. This was Lindsay Clancy at trial. Dan's gonna put it up in a second. Um, you know, she appeared in trial as a, you know, she was a crying mother. Um, she had moments, and look, that's the split.
SPEAKER_01It goes, some people say she was faking it. A lot of people say it looked authentic. Uh, I thought she she looked authentic. She was clearly upset. Um, and you know, so the the defense claimed that she lacked criminal responsibility. The state claimed that she planned it, that there was planning, meaning she'd sent Patrick out that day to go pick up a prescription for her and to get food, and she uh coordinated and and and there were searches on her computer uh regarding uh whether a narcissism was a narcissism or what was it?
SPEAKER_03I think it's like kind of sociopathic.
SPEAKER_01And all these searches that the state showed that, you know, the state was showing, hey, she's planning this. And if she's planning this, then you know, it's hard to say that she that she lacked the criminal responsibility or the criminal responsibility that she wasn't there. And you know, our arguments last episode was when you're in a mental episode, it can last. So listen, I I don't know that I'm no one here has made an opinion on to where we find. Clearly, she cannot be in society. I agree, Michael, you said that she cannot be in society, she should not be in society, and and and and your your position was, you know, I think, quote, fuck her, right?
SPEAKER_01Exactly. Put her away and put her and throw away the key. And I understand that, and I agree, and it's horrific. But, you know, the question is looking at it legally, you know, is the analysis. Now, I don't, I can't say that I don't agree she should be put away or she should definitely be away from society. I just stopped short of making strong statements when I don't see all the evidence in the case. And the jury saw the evidence in the case. Uh, can you want to want to flash, Dan? You want to go maybe to a couple a shot of her and the family, if you don't mind, just so the audience can see. This is the this is the Patrick and the children.
SPEAKER_01That's the entire family. But yeah, this is Patrick and the children. Those are the the the kids, tragically, that that are no longer with us. It's horrific. And Patrick literally came out and testified for her, right?
SPEAKER_03And he testified that he testified for the state, but he was sympathetic to the defense.
SPEAKER_01Right. But he testified the state at first for situational things, right? But he he literally, his position has been she's uh and he did a 60-minute interview, and we'll do a quick recap on that too. But uh, and then you want to show the other photo and maybe go from that to the this is the family in another outing, just so you can get context. So it looks like just a loving, you know, American family, and it's uh it's tragic that that things went this way. I think that's what hit home for everybody is that it could, you know, it literally looks like your neighbors next door, and all of a sudden this horrific thing is happening.
SPEAKER_01Uh and the judge presided over it. Can we show the judge? The judge uh I think had organization, he kept the trial under control pretty well. Sometimes you see judges let cases get out of control. He did a pretty stand-up job. And then uh the lawyer, well, first of all, let's do this. Why don't you tell everybody where we are now with the case? Because the verdict came back, and the verdict came back uh hung. So do you have a quick recap, but I'll explain that a little bit more.
SPEAKER_03All right, in uh Massachusetts, they have 12-person juries. Uh they selected uh 18 total jurors. After the evidence is done, then they narrow it down to 12. Uh the 12 that are deliberating, and then the other six just apparently hang around to see if they if if somebody gets removed from the jury or can't like get sick and can no longer serve, then somebody else substitutes in. So uh the 12 people uh were selected.
SPEAKER_03Um nine of them were women, three of them were men, eleven of them were white, one was a black man, and uh the final tally for the verdict was 11 to 1, uh, one person and 11 people saying not guilty by essentially reason of insanity, and there was one holdout for first degree murder. The one holdout for first degree murder happened to be the one black man on the jury.
SPEAKER_03And to a point that I'm gonna get at later, out of all 18 jurors, there were 17 white people, and there is one black man on the jury.
SPEAKER_01Okay. Uh, Dan, I I said that to you. Do we have that image? Can you put that up of the holdout juror? I mean, look, whether he's black or white, that's irrelevant. I don't think that's relevant. Are people making an issue of that?
SPEAKER_03And Gail King. Huh? Gail King. Oh, really? What is she saying? When she found out that the holdout juror was black, she's like, I've got to sit with that for a minute. It's like I looked at it. You know, it's like a Jesus, man. A black person, black man have his own opinion?
SPEAKER_01That's neither here nor there. It's ridiculous. I don't think that that's an issue at all. Um, so basically, for the ladies and gentlemen, what what a hung jury is, just so we can explain that and let's flush that out a little bit. So the jury has to be unanimous. I think you said that, right? It has to be unanimous. And that's what juries deliberate for hours and days and days. If one person's holding out as defense attorneys, you know, especially on a guilty when you're going for not guilties, it's great for us, right? So, but you know, it's you never know. It could be that they're, you know, a lot of times the leader of the jury, what do they call the the four person?
SPEAKER_01The four person. I always forget that name. I don't know why. You think I would know after years, I would just remember it. I just always forget the four person. We know who the four person is going to be, usually, right? Because you could pick the stronger personalities. It's always when you're doing jury selections, you're kind of carefully like this person's gonna end up the four person, and they have a lot of influence a lot of times. They're back there, they're kind of organizing. Um, and they tend to try to convince this holdout, right? Because the holdout just makes them stay back there longer, right? Day 36 hours, I think it was. Right. They deliberated for 40 hours, what they say.
SPEAKER_01So what happens is now they came back, they had a holdout, and uh that means that they're a hung jury. There's no verdict. This is the juror up here. Thanks, Dan. Good, good, quick.
SPEAKER_03I know his name's Michael.
SPEAKER_01You're getting quick, quick drama grah. But he got us up, and this is the holdout juror. And and look, black or white, it makes no damn difference. That makes no difference. That's ridiculous. So, what is the angle there? Because he's black, he felt bad for a white girl. If he's black, he wanted to hang whatever. What's the I don't even want to go down that route? It makes me mad, that kind of shit. Yeah, uh, there's no reason to do that. So he he's a juror and he had clear he wasn't able to make a determination, and that's fair. And and he's the one that's sitting there looking at all the evidence in the case, right? So what happens now, and a lot of people don't understand what happens?
SPEAKER_01Does she get off? No, she doesn't get off, right? So what happens is it's like a do-over. It's it sucks for both sides. The defense, now she's in jail still, right?
SPEAKER_03No, she's in a mental hospital.
SPEAKER_01I mean, she's in a mental hospital, but she's not getting released. It means it's as if the trial didn't even happen, is what happens, just for for you guys to understand that, right? So that means it now it goes back on the regular docket calendar of the judge, meaning it has to get scheduled with other cases. Issues that come up from trial, sometimes there's more issues now. There's maybe additional witnesses that can be brought in. But everybody got a preview of the case. So it kind of changes things a lot, and you have to do a do-over. And a lot of the times this does happen. I've been a part of hung juries before.
SPEAKER_01I've been I was in a hung jury in a murder case, and we had to do it again. There was a one, I know a case that they had like they couldn't get a verdict for 15 years. I don't know if that's gonna happen here, but and it's gonna be hard actually because it's such a publicized thing, but there's a do-over that's gonna happen now, and the whole thing has to be done again. Okay, so uh what happens a lot, and you know this, Mike, is usually the state starts to make different offers, right? Because they don't want to go through it again. Go ahead, just speak to that a little bit.
SPEAKER_03Well, the thing is, you know, especially in this case, but this case might be a little unique in that sense. Um, the state is looking there saying, okay, it's 11 to 1 for not guilty. Obviously, something that I'm trying to convey is not coming across to the jury.
SPEAKER_01So wait, the 11 to 1, let's be clear, was for not he held out saying that she was guilty. Guilty. Okay. And so now I see where the angle of the they're saying because he's black, then that's that's bullshit. It is. Come on. All right.
SPEAKER_03It's stupid. Okay. So what ends up happening is the state it can go ahead and say, hey, look, I don't think I can get a first-degree murder conviction, maybe offer a second degree murder conviction, maybe offer a manslaughter uh plea.
SPEAKER_01The problem is But all those deals are gonna have to be a mental facility. None of those deals can be able to be prison. Defense won't take that, right?
SPEAKER_03That's exactly what he said is that she's not gonna spend a day in in jail or prison. So yeah, the state's in a tough position. I think they do have to retry the case. One of the things that they do have going for them this time is well, the first off, the state did a horrible job. All right, they did not do a good job prosecuting the job. Why do you say that? They were inconsistent. All right, like at one point in time they were saying the exercise bands were tied around the neck, then they weren't tied around the neck, then they went ahead and completely said she had no mental health problems.
SPEAKER_03They were saying this was a just cold calculated planning. Uh she she was faking mental health issues. But by the end of the trial, at their closing argument, they were also saying it's clear she had mental health problems.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, like how do you make that argument? Like, there's a documentation of her health problems. So I think you don't even touch that, right? I think you concede that the question is gonna hang on the the legality, right? Yeah, and the planning. Did she have criminal responsibility? Did she know what she was doing? Did she think this out? And I think that they should have harped on that. And the fact that, but then again, you said put can you put the defense attorney up? The defense attorney is uh uh Reddington. Kevin Reddington. Kevin Reddington. And you know, I think he did a pretty masterful job on this case.
SPEAKER_01Mike thinks otherwise, this is Kevin Reddington. Okay. So tell me why Mike thinks he did a terrible job, but it's like the I'm making fun of him with a lot of my colleagues. Like, what do you mean? The guy got a hung jury. First of all, it's not exactly a win, but you tell me it was 11-1. He pretty much got a win here, right? State's worn out. I don't know, they're gonna want to do this again. They might have to do it again, but why do you think he did a bad job? This is a controversial because I layman looking at it think he's the hero of the world. And we'll get into the whole the public and the and the uh pop culture, whatever that's happened here and the opinion I'm hearing from lay people.
SPEAKER_01But lay people is not an insult, it just means non-lawyers. But go ahead.
SPEAKER_03Okay, here, let's take this case. Number one, Kevin Reddington should have won this case. All right, and here's why. All right, we're gonna start off with you've got a pretty white client who has money, who has access to the best experts available. Now you're making it racial. Why? Go ahead. All right, go ahead. Because it they identify this this was an 11-person white jury. Okay. And 17 out of 18. Pretty white client with access to you and I know that's not that's not for quite you can't go by that with juries and everything.
SPEAKER_01But get I get it, I get it. Oh, there's a long- You're pretty good with the panel.
SPEAKER_03There's a long list of things here. Okay, you did good with the panel, okay. And then on top of that, you are in the most liberal state in the nation in Massachusetts. Right. All right. And you have the most defense-friendly insanity laws in the entire country.
SPEAKER_01Explain that a little bit.
SPEAKER_03Okay, the normal law is the McNoton test. It's did you recognize right from wrong when you committed the act? Did you know recognize the criminality of your action?
SPEAKER_02Right.
SPEAKER_03In Massachusetts, even if you represent if you recognize the criminality of your action, there's a second step, which is could you control yourself? Was that's not quite the irresistible impulse test, but were you of such uh of a mental condition that you were incapable of uh conforming your behavior to the law?
SPEAKER_00They have to show both of these. The aid has to show this.
SPEAKER_03So once the defense presents the affirmative defense saying she didn't know what she was doing was illegal, and even if she did, she was unable to control herself. That leaves the prosecution with the responsibility to prove that she was not insane. And we all know you cannot prove a negative. All right. So there's there's logically almost nothing you can do to prove a negative.
SPEAKER_03So that was the position that he was in. He had it made. He got the right client with the right amount of money, he got the right jury in the right state with the right affirmative defense. All right. And then the husband doesn't want her punished. Um it just he can't.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, but you're you're neglecting a lot.
SPEAKER_03So this was a case that should the defense should have won. Here's where I don't like what Kevin Gravington did. All right. Number one, the way he cross-examines people, he beats up on witnesses unnecessarily. One of the rules of cross-examination is you don't ask a question that you don't already know the answer to. All right. So he asked a one of the psychiatrists, he said, and you never bothered to order her psych psychiatric records from her prior provider.
SPEAKER_03The girl says, No. He knew that was gonna be the answer. And then he gets, are you serious seriously? All right, stop with the theatrics. You knew the answer was gonna be no. All right, don't start beating up on this woman unnecessarily, because it turns jurors off. You're acting like an asshole. And that basically is what Kevin Ruddington did the entire trial.
SPEAKER_01But the theatrics, not to interrupt you, but the theatrics sometimes is part of it. Because listen, here's what I'll say. Like you keep you said all that, you're right, you make your case, that's why you're a good lawyer. But uh he they still have these photos of dead children, okay, brutally strangled. It's brutal. Like one, I mean, these are children. Any juror looks at that, and a lot of times emotion takes over and the legality goes out the door. You're thinking like a lawyer. So that's huge still to overcome.
SPEAKER_01And the theatrics might matter. In those moments, you need to distract, you need to make a show, you need to get the jurors to forget the fucking images that are being shown to them of these dead children, to forget the fact that these pure little souls are gone, right? So it's it's a mountain.
SPEAKER_03But here's the thing. I'm going back to other things he did wrong. His closing argument was trash. All right. Okay. It was horrible. Why? All right. He was just disjointed. He didn't, it it seems like he just got up there and winged it. He didn't have a he didn't have a coherent theme though.
SPEAKER_01Sometimes when you get too emotional, it's hard to do a good closing. That I've had that happen.
SPEAKER_03And then on top of that, at the end of the day, he still, it still required the state to prove a negative, something we know they can't do. Would you explain that a little bit, prove a negative.
unknownAll right.
SPEAKER_03There's a difference between you can prove somebody's crazy, all right. And what you can do is you can say, okay, here's the here's the direct evidence, here's the circumstantial evidence. You would think it's easy to prove it, but go ahead.
SPEAKER_01We have a tough time sometimes.
SPEAKER_03But when you're trying to prove a negative, you're trying to prove that the person is not crazy. All right. And so there's always, you know, like when you go to your kids and you you tell them, why did you do this? And they come up with every, you know, they say, well, actually, it was a man who walked in from the outdoors and touched the cookies. And there's unlimited amounts of excuses when you're trying to prove a negative.
SPEAKER_01Right.
SPEAKER_03So it's logically impossible, which is also one of the reasons that the Constitution is written in the negative. All right. You know, Congress shall not. All of the all of those initial amendments are shall nots, because they're written in the negative. All right.
SPEAKER_01Right. But by your rationale, that's a good point. But by your rationale, insanity would be a great defense to throw up every time. And it's not. It fucking doesn't work half the time, more than half the time. 90% of the time, insanity doesn't fucking work.
SPEAKER_03Right. It's hard. In this case, in this jurisdiction, with the amount of experts and the quality of experts that she could afford, all right, he was able to put up an insanity defense that was going to hold so that he would get a jury instruction on the modified McNaughton test. Once he met that threshold, he should have won the case.
SPEAKER_01I think you're tough on him.
SPEAKER_03Well, also, here's the other thing. I and I'm not saying I've never been an asshole in trial. I I'd say about like the first half of my career, I was then I became law partners with one of my friends, and she really helped me a lot with my cross-exams. And then I read a book and took a CLE on how to conduct an effective cross-exam. And it was written by, I think it's Terrence McCarthy. It's called McCarthy on Cross. Any attorney who's watching this, get McCarthy on Cross.
SPEAKER_03It's a fantastic book. It will up your level, up your game. Just you can't even believe it. It's an art. And so the one thing is that you never argue with the witnesses. All right. You go ahead. You ask questions that and your questions are short statements, right? And the answer to every question is always going to be yes. So what happens is the jury starts tuning out the yes because that's all they're hearing, and all they listen to you is your version of events.
SPEAKER_03But what he's doing by going ahead and, you know, are you serious? Oh my god, you know, he's taking away from his storytelling. Right. He's not going ahead and telling his story. He's getting dramatic. And one of the things that I don't like about this trial is they let the cameras in there. And I think that when cameras are in the courtroom, attorneys start playing for the camera instead of the case.
SPEAKER_01And so do the judges. So do the judges. Everybody does, right?
SPEAKER_03So I don't think that his theory on the case was right. I think his theme was right. I think his cross-examinations were pretty bad. And uh his closing was trash. I think if he would have gone ahead and cleaned up his cross-examinations, and I think if he would have come up with a better closing, this would have been uh done deal.
SPEAKER_01Well, legal, I mean, fair enough. Um, I don't I I'm gonna speak to that a little bit more because right now I want to stand the legal side of this, because then we'll go into the the pop, the the public side of this. And I think that has just something to do with it's gonna tie into what you're saying. But so right now, Reddington's trying to argue um that a prosecution will violate double jeopardy. Right. Stupid trial is turned without true manifest. His argument is trial was terminated without true manifest necessity. The defense defense can argue that another prosecution violates double jeopardy.
SPEAKER_01Reddington has publicly announced that he will litigate this. How where does that go? I don't even see how that is.
SPEAKER_03What he's saying is that there was that note from the four-person, which said that in the four person's opinion, the one juror was refusing to follow the law on reasonable doubt. So what?
SPEAKER_01All right, so yeah, but he's allowed to do that. Correct. And you talked about that in another episode, right? Yep. Jury nullification. Exactly.
SPEAKER_03And so what ended up happening is they have latched on to the four-person statement that he uh refused to follow the judge's instruction about reasonable doubt. However, the problem with that is the judge summoned the jury back in and individually asked them one by one, are you able to follow the law as I have read it to you? And all of them said yes. So basically what you have is you had there were nine women, three men.
SPEAKER_03You had nine, like remember the 12 angry men?
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_03All right, in this one, you had 11 angry, middle-aged wine mom Karen who's we'll get into that in a minute. We'll get into that in a minute. And look, you had nine angry women, two guys who just shut up and went along with it because they wanted to get out of there, and one guy who stuck to his guns.
SPEAKER_01Well, so but how does that how is there double jeopardy there, right?
SPEAKER_03It's not.
SPEAKER_01It's a ridiculous But he's just throwing that out because he wants the state to think twice about prosecuting again. And that's the next question. We said this earlier, we touched on this. Do they prosecute this again? 11 out of 12 jurors are are going against you? It's only gonna get worse. It's not gonna get better.
SPEAKER_03I think it is gonna get better, I'll tell you why. Because for them, yeah. Here's why.
SPEAKER_01And depending on what happens between now and the trial, it could be a lot of things happen, but go ahead.
SPEAKER_03The prosecution was horrible, right? Their theories were all over the place. The jurors, at least three of the women, four of the women now, who can't shut the fuck up, and they go out and they give interviews, and they've broken down exactly what the missing issues were. Oh, that's true. You turn around and you say, Okay, now I know I've got to address this, this, this, and this. That's true. And you fill in the gaps.
SPEAKER_01Right. But that brings us to where we are with the public. So the most trouble, and I don't think it matters. Here's why I don't think it matters. I think this woman is walking no matter what. And this is why I'll tell you when I talk to family members, the public about this, and and listening to the social media and all that, it's insane. They are vilifying Patrick, Lancy. They I literally had, and and I'm not gonna name names, but I had people come up to me and they're using a, I call it the Candace Owens argument, where they go, I don't know.
SPEAKER_01I just think that it's just weird that they didn't take her phone when they arrested her. Why would they take her phone? I'm like, what the fuck does that have to do with anything? And what does it have to do with Patrick? It's just weird. That's the argument they make. It's just that's what Candace Owens will do. She'll say, There were some people down on the ground that were weird there, and it's just weird. I'm not saying that it happened, but it's weird, and and people run with it. Like, that's the weird argument, which makes no sense. But for the public, like I think that women just came out. I'm not gonna generalize a lot of women, no, but I'm not, because I know a lot of women that don't do that.
SPEAKER_01But I I heard like that they were just you had this effect of them protecting the mother and just looking to vilify the husband. I I don't think that he killed her. I want to personally say, I don't think he killed her, but he must have been a shitty husband. Okay, so he's a shitty husband. That's well, I'm not saying he was, right? There's no evidence to say that the man was a shitty husband. Well, how come, you know, they said that he was there and and then they're mixing the facts of the case. And the problem is with social media is that people don't remember, and I'm like, that's not what they testified to.
SPEAKER_01And they're like, no, I heard it. That's what they testified to. And then they pull up a clip and they'll show me, and after they find it, well, maybe it wasn't the trial, but I saw this, and they show me some fucking random person like we are giving an opinion, right? At least we're lawyers, defense attorneys, right? And like that goes someplace in a trial uh analysis, right?
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Like people, you know, we are experts, but you have like laymen that are literally just making commentary, and we're we're layman on a lot of other issues that we cover here, right? But I uh you don't you hold my word as evidence, right? It's just ridiculous. But that's what society's been doing. So I think Kevin Renat, they made him a hero. I mean, everybody I talked to, like that lawyer's gangster. I'm like, really? Why? And they don't they don't know like the stuff you're talking about with the the cross-exam techniques, right? Yeah, they don't know what's less is more, they're not learning that. Like, and the layman thinks uh a cross-exam should be just bloody and screaming and belittling.
SPEAKER_01So when he's doing this, they're like, he's great. And defense attorney's like, why? That was unnecessary. You already proved your point, you know. So I think that that's why he's doing a lot of these theatrics and he knows he is playing to the camera. Exactly what you said. Go ahead. I didn't even know.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, here's the thing. It's like when people are selecting an attorney, they always want to say, Oh, I want the most aggressive attorney. And your clients love it when you just absolutely blast somebody on cross. Right. All right, judges don't, but you they do. Yeah, but some of my worst cross-examinations, I just tore the person to shreds. Right. All right. There's a difference between aggressive and effective. Exactly. Big difference.
SPEAKER_01And there's times you need to be aggressive to be effective. Correct.
SPEAKER_03But uh the general public usually does not realize that most of the time you don't need to be aggressive to be effective.
SPEAKER_01You the best, the best aggression is not being aggressive sometimes.
SPEAKER_03Correct. I always go ahead, I always get myself mentally prepped when I'm going for an evidentiary hearing, and I always remind myself, Michael, don't be emotional. Yeah, be the most reasonable person in the room. 100%. That's the way I want the jury to see me. I want to be the most reasonable person in the room. 100%, 100%.
SPEAKER_01Now, there's times where I've determined I need to beat this witness up. There are times like that. And I do tend to get aggressive at times, but I've had a backfire many times. You know, I've had a backfire many times where I had to get up and apologize to a jury. I've apologized to the jury where I'm like, listen, I'm sorry I got emotional, ladies and gentlemen. And they appreciate that. And it turned around and it worked out, but like you cannot let yourself get like that. But he's playing to the crowd. He's playing to the crowd, he's playing to these, and he's reading online what these people are saying, these allegations.
SPEAKER_01And what I told people is if, ladies and gentlemen, if you think there was an ounce of evidence pointing towards Patrick Clancy, do you not think this defense attorney would have brought it up? Oh, yeah. He didn't say a word about that. The whole trial was focused on her mental health because that was clearly the issue here, right? Whether you agree or not on criminal responsibility, clearly there's a mental health issue. There should never have been a moment where the state says she's completely faking it. She wasn't faking it. She might be hiding behind it to justify these horrific actions, and there might be no justification.
SPEAKER_01There is no justification for these actions. So that would be the angle. But to sit here and make the claims, like the defense would be the first to use it because we are trying to create reasonable doubt anywhere we can find it, right? Like, you know, could we're not going to just throw it out. But anyway, Patrick Clancy, just to jump to this, he did a 60-minute interview, and I have a quick recap.
SPEAKER_03Oh, dude, they need to hire a new PR person. Right. That was horrible. Did you watch it? I watched part of it. Like his wife was, I'm just a girl who met a boy. Oh, this is the new wife? So he had a new wife on there? I forgot what movie it was from. I think it had like Julia Roberts, I'm just a girl who met a boy. It's it was a movie line that they're using. And I'm like, Jesus Christ.
SPEAKER_01I mean, were they there with their does he have a lawyer? I'm sure he has a lawyer because they're suing the men, they're suing the whole mental. And they're also suing the the hospitals, they're suing everybody, right? And look, they should, because they again, we talked about the mental health system's fucked up. Yeah. The fact that this woman could come out and and still be with these minor children like that alone when she has all these problems and no one's even questioning her.
SPEAKER_03Well, they're they're gonna run into a lot of problems in uh hospitals because of course they have a lot of protections. Yeah, well, not just that, but I mean, Lindsay Clancy lied to all of her providers.
SPEAKER_01Okay, but you at some point, as a mental health professional, you gotta be able to see through that. How many times do we have people lying to our face? Every single day. And how many times do you get it wrong? With my kids, almost never. I know. But even with the clients, I know when they're lying to me for the most part. Yeah. Because I mean, maybe at my beginning of the career, because some people are good fucking liars, people don't realize there's really good liars out there. And a good liar, not a good liar, a liar that does it for his entire life believes himself or herself.
SPEAKER_01That's the issue. So when you're reading on tells, you're trying to do tells. I always watch these like body, you know, those people that go on, you know.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, the body language people.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, body language people are like, oh, when they look up to the left, like these motherfuckers believe it. If they believe it, they're not looking up to the left, they'll look you right in the eye and lie. Drug addicts, people with mental health, and people in mental health are delusional too.
SPEAKER_03I am so foot tall.
SPEAKER_01Right, exactly. But it could be Lindsay Clante at that moment believes that she doesn't have theirs. So that doesn't, you know, but still at some point as a health professional, you have to see a pattern, you have to see the records, you have to see the history, right?
SPEAKER_03I think the problem's gonna be is that she switched providers too often. She lied to every new provider.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, but you should be able to pick up on the fact that this woman's hopping different providers.
SPEAKER_03Okay. And then, but the the problem then was like the the youngest therapist, the one who'd just gotten out of med school, all right, she Lindsay Clancy made the determination that she wanted to do a telehealth visit. So she wasn't there in person. She's over Zoom. Um I think that the So there you go.
SPEAKER_01They don't think that that could be some kind of uh I don't know. You're right, but go ahead.
SPEAKER_03I mean, I I think that, you know, is there gonna be some liability? Absolutely. I think there's gonna be a settlement.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_03But I I don't think that the doctors and the providers have as much liability as people are making it out to be.
SPEAKER_01I'm looking at the notes here from the here, I'm not just holding my phone in the middle of a podcast. I'm looking at some of the notes from his interview. He said he believes her illness was quite tragically deceptive and ultimately caused the killings. He recounted finding Lindsay critically injured outside their home and discovering Corinne Dawson dead in the basement. He and uh the the Callan initially survived, giving him hope, but died in his arms four days later. That's horrible. Said Lindsay later described her memory of killing children as feeling like a dream. She never asked him to forgive her, but she publicly forgave her because he does not believe the healthy Lindsay, the wife and mother he knew, would have committed these acts.
SPEAKER_01When asked whether he failed his family, he answered, this is Patrick Clancy. He answered that he did the best he could with the knowledge that he had and now must live with the outcome. I mean, this poor guy.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_01I mean, come on. Uh and the fact that the public's attacking him makes me sick with no evidence. This is what drives me crazy about our country and now the world today. Like, you don't need evidence anymore. You just say shit and that's it. This Candace Owens, that woman should be put in prison for what she's doing. And all these other people, like Tucker Carlson, and you know what, to some extent, even Joe Rogan and all these guys. And look, we're we're a podcast too, right? But we don't sit here and like, I'm not gonna go down this rabbit.
SPEAKER_01I'm gonna tell you it's a rabbit hole if I'm doing that. I'm not gonna see here and say this is true. And these people have millions of followers. We're not anywhere near that, right?
SPEAKER_03But like there's a phenomenon right now, especially with TikTok, where you have a bunch of, you know, middle-aged wine moms, uh, the type with Xanax prescriptions who constantly get early refills that have turned this thing into a fucking Scooby-Doo mystery. And I have no idea what what the inspiration for that is. And for the the three dead kids. And, you know, I mean remember Scooby-Doo at the end, they'd always unmasked the bill.
SPEAKER_03Oh, yeah. And I wouldn't. I would have gotten away with it if it wasn't for you to do nosy trunk and that's abusing TikTok moments. Oh, yeah, exactly.
SPEAKER_01You know, they asked him. So he discussed the online conspiracy theories, accusing him of involvement, infidelity or indifference. He called them painful, dangerous, and a distraction from the genuine issue of postpartum mental illness. Agreed. He also revealed that he suffered a massive panic attack while testifying, but returned to finish his testimony. I can imagine. He said there wasn't a period where he didn't expect or care whether he lived to see 35. He moved to New York, seeking anonymity, good luck, and now speaks with children in his mind frequently. He's remarried. His wife is a fertility physician, Dr.
SPEAKER_01Rachel Dennis. She's pregnant with her first child. Um both they both brought malpractice claims. Patrick and Lindsay brought malpractice claims against medical providers involved in her psychiatric treatment. And no, it doesn't say the facilities. So it speaks to everything that we've been talking to. Like I do think that there's liability for these medical professionals. When I see the amount of times this woman came forward, it doesn't matter that she had different providers. And you know what?
SPEAKER_01It is malpractice. And look, I went in the medical profession, there are heroes in our medical field. There are genuine geniuses and heroes, and our technology is the greatest. But the practice as a whole is problematic. And look, a lot of times the people in ER and the search, they're doing the best they can do. And and and kudos to all of them and you, and we love you all. But there is a problem. When when when I I just went through my mother passing away, and and and when you have family members and you see how they like check on each other and communicate with each other, these different physicians, there's so many different doctors, they're not talking in the hospital.
SPEAKER_01They look at like a two-sentence note that's put in a computer. That's not, how am I going to tell you what is going on with a patient in two sentences? Sure, we can give a quick synopsis, but a conversation needs to be had. So if you see someone that has been through multiple providers, have been multiple, but in these medications, like we said, you mix them, they go bad quick, right? How are you not talking in person or demanding an in-person or at least uh treating a video visit much differently or analyzing it heavier? I think there's something that needs to be done.
SPEAKER_03Let's use her Lindsay Clancy's inpatient where she went into a hospital. All right. I think she went into hospital like on a Thursday or a Friday. They were recommending that she stay. She went ahead and lied and told Patrick Clancy that they were recommending that she check out. So the following day, well short of what the treatment they were recommending, she checked out of the hospital against medical advice, all right, and didn't follow through with the prescriptions or the follow-up.
SPEAKER_03So, you know, what can what can the hospital do when she hasn't been declared incompetent and she decides that I'm going to ignore your medical advice, I'm going to lie to my caregivers, and I'm going to check myself.
SPEAKER_01If they think that it's to a certain level, there are mechanisms in place that should have at least been used, like a baker act in Florida.
SPEAKER_03But this wasn't a baker act situation.
SPEAKER_01I understand, but if you that doesn't matter, and I'm using Florida's baker act, every state has a different thing. But if I if I'm a physician and I think it's dangerous for this woman to leave to herself or others, right? That's a standard here. I'll baker act her. Correct. But they don't. They sign off because it's not their liability, and she and now they're going to use that in their defense. It was against medical advice. We didn't tell her to leave, but motherfucker, it's too easy for her to leave.
SPEAKER_03That's the problem. That's a that's an issue with the laws. That's not an issue with the physicians.
SPEAKER_01And also you change the laws, you sue the fuck out of these physicians and you get around it. It takes one ruling when you should be looking at it. Get to your representatives.
SPEAKER_03I get it. Here's the issue. She admitted that she never told any of her uh treatment team that she was having thoughts of killing the children. So, but but so how are they supposed to base it?
SPEAKER_01So wait, they are they counting on those thoughts now? If you see a pattern, I'm sorry. How many people are gonna warn you that if they're gonna kill their kids? Even in delusions, okay? When clients have we talked about the client that I had to try to get him on. When he when this client thought that they were that everyone was a Satanist pedophile and that he needed to protect the world from them, he couldn't tell me what he would do at those moments. He couldn't tell me that he would kill an old woman later, or he couldn't, because it's an impulsive, spontaneous thing, right?
SPEAKER_03But when you saw him, he was clearly in a state of psychosis.
SPEAKER_01At times, yes. At times, no. I would get calls where the person sounded completely calm and like the best client you could ever have. Thank you so much, Mr. Rosberg. You were great. I really appreciate it. I'm paying, I know, I know this, and I know that. And then there was other times like you're the devil. Like it's but it takes experience and and and and expertise to see that. And if you have that, and I'm sorry, I think that the system failed this family.
SPEAKER_03Here's the thing, all right, and this is something that a lot of people don't understand about this case. It's something that they overlook. Lindsay Clancy was never diagnosed by any treatment provider as being in psychosis. The only person who ever mentioned postpartum psychosis was her attorney. Why? Because the DSM five, I think we're on the five now, the DSM five says postpartum psychosis has its onset within eight weeks of giving birth.
SPEAKER_03Lindsay Clancy's was it eight months. All right. Lindsay Clancy also never heard voices before that 15 minutes where she was told to kill her children, and she never heard voices afterwards. Psychosis.
SPEAKER_01Psychosis doesn't work that way. Look, we're making the case here. We're not both, I'm not arguing one side, I'm just giving him a pushback. But there's always a first time of you hearing the voices, okay? So you're just using it, okay, because she that doesn't mean it couldn't have happened. Does that mean it couldn't have happened? Yeah, but does that think does that mean it couldn't have happened? It's consistent with her being full of shit. That's a very cute legal statement you just made. Does that mean that it couldn't happen? Gotcha. Couldn't no.
SPEAKER_03There you go. That's the answer. Is it highly that's the problem that the state has, by the way. Right. All right, right. Couldn't ever know. Is it highly unlikely to a point where I would say it creates a reasonable doubt in my mind? No, it's not there. She did it.
SPEAKER_01There's no doubt she did it. No, and she wasn't. She knew what she was doing, and she could control herself at that moment.
SPEAKER_03Correct. Because now she's hiding behind a voice that only happened once. Psychesis doesn't work that way.
SPEAKER_01Well, 11 out of 12 jurors did not agree with you. All right. Well, they're all they're all women from Massachusetts. And what do you think that interview does for this case? What Andrew Clancy for if that tries again.
SPEAKER_03I don't think it makes a difference.
SPEAKER_01Really? No. I mean, listen, the public is looking at it. You know, the jury comes from the public. The public's watching it. I think it just adds to the defenses case, you know.
SPEAKER_03I think it's going to be different I think jury selection is going to be a nightmare. Because now you have every middle-aged TikTok mom is going to be in that area, is going to be campaigning to get on that jury.
SPEAKER_01Now, let's, I mean, do you know, and I don't know the answer to this question. In Massachusetts, if someone is put into a mental facility, what is the pathway to that person getting out?
SPEAKER_03They get I think it's every once every six months or once every year. That's what they do in Florida. Yeah, they get uh they get a review. So technically, if she got found not guilty by reason of insanity, whenever her next review rolls around, they could say she's good to go.
SPEAKER_01So the the verdict would be not guilty by reason by insanity, but she would then bec if you get that verdict, you are placed in the mental health facility. No.
SPEAKER_03Then the state has to petition for a civil commitment.
SPEAKER_01Okay. State petitioned a civil commitment. But they're going to get that, right? So then the civil commitment, though, there's a pathway. Every six months there's a chance she goes home. Correct. How soon is there is there a cap in Massachusetts where it has to go fight?
SPEAKER_03Not that I've heard of. Scary. So she could be out in the six months. Still young enough to get pregnant. There's actually a case that this happened before where a woman drowned her three kids and then they sent her to the mental hospital. She got back out, had three more kids, she drowned them too.
SPEAKER_01I mean, so that's the problem in this country. Don't you find that is a problem? We have a legislative problem to where it's either you are crazy or not. But if you're crazy, you know, we won't we only punish you minorly. Like there's a chance where you get a slap on the wrist for murdering your three kids. So you put everybody in this position, we got to pick one or the other. And then the one, they're both too excessive, right? One's excessively light and one's excessively harsh, right? And if you could say that kill, you know, life in prison for your kids getting killed is excessively harsh.
SPEAKER_01But if she really wasn't mentally there, even then, like the the the this the problem for me is that I would have to agree with you on this case that if if there's a pathway for her to get out, then I I don't see that I could come up with that verdict, you know, and forget the law and forget that for a minute. I would go with my emotion in my head, which is not what you're supposed to do.
SPEAKER_03She's proven herself to be too dangerous to let out.
SPEAKER_01That I agree with. And if there's a pathway for her to be out in six months, I would not be able, as a juror, to do that. And I would rather this woman sit in prison for the rest of her life. And I'm sorry you had your mouth. I'm sorry the system failed you, but we can't let you have access to children again or put you in that position ever again. So I think the fact that he got 11 out of 12 jurors to say, no, let's let her out or let's give her this pathway.
SPEAKER_01I think he did an astonishing job. That's why I'm trying to tell you.
SPEAKER_03Well, look, look at where he is.
SPEAKER_01He should have gotten all 12. You're tough, man. You're tough.
SPEAKER_03He he should have gotten all 12. I guarantee you. You're persuasive if I've seen you talk before. I guarantee you, if you would have had that case, you would have won it. Guarantee.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Um, yeah, I don't know. I just don't know enough, you know. I don't have the ego to say that, you know, but like I I'm pretty persuasive when I need to be, but I I don't know about that.
SPEAKER_03Some I've seen you be a dick too, but um, you know, uh generally speaking, you're not a dick, you're personable, uh, you get everybody to laugh. And so, you know, you're not you don't come across, you don't attack people when you don't need to attack people.
SPEAKER_01And that's I have at times there's been mistakes, but go ahead.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, and we all make mistakes. That's what I thought was wrong with Kevin Reddington is that he was unnecessarily aggressive. Everybody, all these witnesses agree with you. She's fucking crazy. They all agree with you. Why are you attacking them?
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Yeah. I mean, I and the holdout juror, what's going on with him?
SPEAKER_03I hear he's getting a lot of he's got a lawyer, or you know, yeah, he's got he's got a lawyer, and uh Ron DeSantis has offered him asylum in Florida, um, which he should probably take. Why? Is he getting threats? Yeah. He's getting death threats, his mother's getting death threats. Um, you know, it's Massachusetts, dude. When I when I moved to Massachusetts, I had a bumper sticker that I put in my car. I thought it would be funny. It said Ted Kennedy's about to shit on all Massachusetts.
SPEAKER_01Go ahead.
SPEAKER_03Ted Kennedy's car has killed more people than my gun. All right. One day with that bumper sticker on there, my car's covered in shaving cream, toilet paper, and eggs. Really? Yeah. One overnight. Those people that somebody from Massachusetts, they're like, what base datas? It's like, no, you're mass holes.
SPEAKER_01I was gonna, I was, I was, I was hoping you're gonna throw that out.
SPEAKER_03Massholes.
SPEAKER_01Oh, all the Massachusetts uh fans that we have out there, we love you. All right, this is just Michael being Michael. You have any final uh part, any lasting thing you want to say or last comment you want to make on this?
SPEAKER_03Uh Michael, the little lone holdout juror. God bless you, sir. You are a hero.
SPEAKER_01His name's Michael. Yes. That's right. Strong name. Strong name. Um, but listen, we're gonna be following this. Uh, we're gonna follow it. Interesting. I don't know that it's gonna be a retrial, but if it is, we'll be covering it. But Mike, thanks for coming on. And as usual, and and analyzing this with me. And ladies and gentlemen, thank you for watching. Uh thank you for watching Two Taps and Friends. We love you. Uh, please like and subscribe to the channel. Uh, if you like subscribe to the channel, we have more outreach. We're growing every day. We really love you guys and appreciate all of our fans out there, all the comments interacting, whether they're negative or not.
SPEAKER_01We appreciate the interactions and we appreciate uh you know your opinions on this. We are just giving our opinions. So if anyone taking it too personal, don't. Um, or you can, it's up to you. But please like, subscribe to the channel. We're everywhere. We're on YouTube, Instagram, Facebook. Uh, I can't name all of them. We're literally on everything. Our marketing team does a great job, our recording team does a great job. Uh, we'll see you guys on the next episode. Love you all. Goodbye. Cut
Send us Fan Mail Daniel Rosenberg sits down with criminal defense attorney Michael Dye to break down major legal shifts surrounding gun rights, the Second Amendment, and federal court rulings. From the DOJ's memo on...
Send us Fan Mail In this episode of Two Taps & Friends, Danny sits down with fan-favorite guest Olivia to tackle listener questions about growing up today versus 30 years ago. From social media pressures and AI in...
Send us Fan Mail A 16-year-old walked into Silver Rail Elementary School in Bend, Oregon with a shotgun, and an armed civilian and a brave teacher stopped it from becoming even worse. Host Danny Rosenberg and attorney...
Send us Fan Mail In this episode of Two Taps & Friends, host Daniel Rosenberg is joined once again by criminal defense attorney Michael Dye to break down major new developments in the Cornell University fraternity case....
Send us Fan Mail In this episode of Two Taps & Friends, Daniel Rosenberg is joined once again by attorney Michael Dye to break down the legal scrutiny and federal investigations surrounding Rep. Ilhan Omar - examining...