Dye & Golburgh | Afroman on Trial, Lion King Joke spills into Court: Attorneys Weigh In #64
45 minAudio
Send us Fan Mail What unfolds when a 2022 police raid on Afroman’s Ohio home - based on a tip about narcotics and a supposed “dungeon” - yields no charges, yet leaves his family shaken and cash missing? The Grammy-nominated artist responds by weaving his security camera footage into satirical music videos that roast the officers by name and moment, sparking a high-stakes civil lawsuit over defamation, emotional distress, and right of publicity. In this episode of Two Taps and Friends, attorneys Michael Dyer and Lloyd Goldberg unpack the jury’s full verdict in Afroman’s favor, the transformative-use First Amendment defense that carried the day, and why monetizing the art did not strip away its protection. They also explore a fresh $27 million lawsuit against a comedian for a viral “Look, there’s a lion” mistranslation of the Lion King’s Circle of Life chant, plus broader questions about free speech, parody, and authority in the podcast age. A story of resilience, creativity, and legal clarity that resonates far beyond the courtroom. ⏰ Timestamps ⏰ 00:00 🎬 Teaser 02:30 - 📹 From Security Footage to Viral Diss Tracks 07:15 - ⚖️ The Officers’ Lawsuit: Defamation, Likeness, and Emotional Distress Claims 11:28 - 🛡️ Transformative Art Meets the First Amendment 14:00 - 😂 Parody Precedents and the Decision to Let It Ride to Trial 17:12 - 📈 Catalog Surges Over 500% - The Power of a Legal Win 20:34 - 🦁 The $27 Million Lion King Lyrics Parody Lawsuit 30:59 - 🎙️ Free Speech, Expertise, and Podcast Responsibility 37:46 - 📰 Quick Reflections on Current Cases How broadly should the First Amendment protect artists who use real events and public officials’ likenesses in satirical or transformative content - especially when money is involved? #Afroman #LemonPoundCake #policeraid #firstamendment #Parody #CircleOfLife #comedian #SecurityFootage #johnnydepp #satire #TrueCrimePodcast #truecrimestories #legalanalysis #attorney #truecrimestory #investigations #news #podcastcommunity #lawyer #cops #lawyerlife #realtalk #CourtCase #CourtroomDrama #JusticeSystem #LawAndOrder #CriminalLaw #debate #podcast #law Don't forget to like, comment, and subscribe for more episodes of Two Taps and Friends! 🍻 Follow us: Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/twotapsandfriends Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/twotaps_and_friends Tiktok: https://tiktok.com@twotapsandfriends X: https://x.com/TwoTapsFriends 🎧 Listen now on: Apple: https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/two-taps-and-friends/id1793804856 Spotify: https://open.spotify.com/show/0wvjYhEX4wqbmawXRk8WTj Amazon Music: https://music.amazon.com/podcasts/5d7a4671-7ffd-49a2-9a4c-ecee6e86f6b8/two-taps-and-friends iHeart Radio: https://iheart.com/podcast/263402137 Merch Shop: https://www.redbubble.com/people/Two-Taps
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_00Based on the tip, they got a warrant, a search warrant for Afro Man's house. He had a large quantity of narcotics in his house and people that he had kidnapped, and he was holding them in the dungeon of his house. He starts releasing these songs, and the officers say, You're using my uh image and likeness for commercial purposes. First song was, Will you help me repair my door? Uh and then he's also, it shows them kicking down the door.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, he stops at the pancake and he's like, he does a double take at the pancake.
SPEAKER_08So, okay, go ahead.
SPEAKER_00So Afro Man makes a song. People have sent hundreds of pound cakes to my office. Randy Walters is a son of a bitch. And then he says, That's why I fucked his wife and got filthy rich. My God. And it seems like he starts getting pissed off at his wife.
SPEAKER_09And the judge rejected that argument outright by saying that emotional distress alone could not justify liability.
SPEAKER_05Grab your favorite drink, get comfy, and let's dive into another episode of Two Taps and Friends.
SPEAKER_07Welcome back to Two Taps and Friends. I'm the host of the show, Danny Roseberg. Today I have my favorite panel on attorney Michael Dye. Welcome back. Hey Danny. Attorney Lloyd Goldberg. Welcome back. We're back on today. Today we're going to cover a uh uh a case that's in the news all over the place. It's viral right now. It's the Afroman case. Um and it's it's it's making headweights all over social media, it's all over everywhere. And we, you know, we we had to cover it because it's pretty hilarious as well. So, Mike, give us, I'm gonna turn to you to give us a background on what's going on.
SPEAKER_07Well, what where did this come about? What happened here? All right, and and we'll jump in.
SPEAKER_00Several years ago, I think it was three years ago, uh Afro Man lives in Adams County, Ohio.
SPEAKER_07Okay.
SPEAKER_00And so the Adams County Sheriff's Office got a tip from a confidential informant, allegedly a reliable informant, that he had a large quantity of narcotics in his house and people that he had kidnapped, and he was holding them in the dungeon of his house. Oh my gosh.
SPEAKER_07Dan, put up a picture of just Afro Man so we can see who it is. Sorry, okay. So And they don't know who this tip was.
SPEAKER_00It was a no, no, it was a it was a confidential informant. Okay. Uh so they and they knew who it was, and based on the tip, they got a warrant, a search warrant for Afro Man's house. And they went through there uh based on the anonymous tip. Not anonymous, the con the confidential, reliable informant. Okay, so it must have been credible. So they went ahead and they broke through the the gate in the front of his yard and uh kicked down his door and uh searched his entire house.
SPEAKER_00Now, when uh the police were there, Afroman's children and ex-wife showed up at the house, and uh the police were there, you know, traumatized the kids, um, and he he was not at home, but he had a security camera inside the house. Okay, and so he has videotape of the police searching his house until such time as the police officers disconnected the cameras during the middle of the search.
SPEAKER_00Oh my god. So they seized uh money, uh, which was uh he later the count on the money, it's I think it was something like 16,000 or something. Uh and when he got the so they charged him with what they never charged, they didn't charge him with anything. All right, so just seized cash. Yes. Okay, and so when he got the envelope back, there was four hundred dollars missing from the envelope. So, of course, he accused the uh police officers of stealing the money.
SPEAKER_00Uh he then took the videos that he compiled from his house and started making music videos. Uh, I think one of the first song was Will You Help Me Repair My Door? Uh then he's also which shows them kicking down the door. Then he made uh another song called Lemon Pound Cake. Okay, because there's like a heavy set officer that like just started eyeballing the lemon pound cake.
SPEAKER_00Hold on, let me stop.
SPEAKER_07I saw this image. Dan, put up the pound cake security.
SPEAKER_08So that's pound cake right there. Yeah, and as he's walking by, he stops at the pound cake.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, he stops at the pound cake and he's like, he does a double take at the pound cake. So okay, go ahead. So Afro Man makes a song called Lemon Pound Cake and talking about, you know, it's like makes the sheriff want to put down his gun and cut him a slice. Right.
SPEAKER_09And uh so didn't we have a Sergeant Rainak like 25 years ago who was accused of like picking up a sandwich and taking a bite out of it during like a crime scene, like a murder investigation? I do not know that that is funny. That's a rumor that I heard it.
SPEAKER_00Some cake's amazing though.
SPEAKER_09Then Cranack, that's what it is.
SPEAKER_00Oh, yeah. There's another one, there's another officer where I think it's Randy Walters is a son of a bitch, is the name of the song. And uh he's like a big artist after. Yeah, yeah. I mean, he made because I got high. Okay, okay. So uh the Randy Walters is a son of a bitch, and then he says, That's why I fucked his wife and got filthy rich. Oh my god. And so he pissed off Randy Walters. Then there's a woman who was involved in the search, and uh her name is uh Officer Lisa Phillips, and so he starts calling her uh Lickum Low Lisa Phillips.
SPEAKER_00Oh god, show a picture of Lickum Low Lisa Phillips, please. And there's poor thing. Okay. And he he wrote a whole she has a she has a really deep voice, right? Okay, and so he's like he made a whole Instagram post about, you know, I was dropping my kids off of the school, and this woman has like a voice that's three octaves deeper than mine. You you know, you need to check to see if she's got a a penis down there, she knows my penis is bigger than mine, and uh so like he really just he lit into everybody, uh, called one of the cops a pedophile.
SPEAKER_00Um so what's going on with it now? Okay, so well, the the cops after they searched his house, took his property, and damaged his house in front of his children. So he wasn't charged with anything, he wasn't charged with anything. Okay, it's completely false. All right, and uh, and you think they would at least find some narcotics in Afro Man's house, but I guess they didn't.
SPEAKER_07Pound cake, pound cake and 16k.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, okay, and uh so he starts releasing these songs, and uh the officers say you're using my uh image and likeness for commercial purposes, meaning they're he they're he's making money off their image and likeness. No way, and they also said that uh he was defaming them. All right, so and just hold that thought.
SPEAKER_07Go back to the pound cake testimony or the uh the pound cake and what was the other one? Just a regular pound cake? Yeah, is that he's testifying? Go to the other one. He was testifying what tell him what they were testifying.
SPEAKER_00Okay, so he he testified that um it just in the beginning of it, he said that you know the the attorney. I don't know why I can't ever get a trial like this, but the officer's like, okay, and sir, you are who is referred to as officer pound cake, and he says, Yes, you know, your your client referred to me to that, you know, multiple times, and then he goes into why you know he's referred to as officer pound cake because he does a double take on the pound cake, and then the cop just says in there, and people have sent hundreds of pound cakes to my office.
SPEAKER_00So people are just like going on Amazon and sending this guy like lemon pound cake uh his office.
SPEAKER_08Dan, can you go through some of the other photos we haven't covered? We could talk about what's going on on those photos. This is what him and uh that's Randy Walters is a son of a bitch. He looks like a son of a bitch.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, he does, he looks mean, and he um this was this was like one of the the funniest testimony because he says that he was defamed by Afro Man because Afro Man said that he had sex with his wife, and the attorney is like, and that's clearly not true. Afroman is not having sex with your or uh Mr. Um forgot his last name.
SPEAKER_00Foreman. All right, Mr. Foreman is not having sex with your wife, and the cop goes, I don't know, is he? Ask your client. Oh my god, and it seems like he starts getting pissed off at his wife of the testimony.
SPEAKER_09And the judge rejected that argument outright uh by saying that emotional distress alone could not justify liability. Wow.
SPEAKER_07So when is this child going on now? No, it's over.
SPEAKER_00And uh Afro Man got uh there were six uh separate counts against them, and he won all six. Oh wow, so they lost. Yeah, clean sweet. Yeah, and but yeah, that that was Randy Walters is a son of a bitch, and then he uh has uh you know, starts talking about how he had sex with Randy, uh the officer's wife, and so you know, he he sued him saying that it caused tremendous emotional pain and suffering, and it defamed him because he uh, you know, accusing his wife of having sex with some or cheating on him defamed him.
SPEAKER_00It didn't make much sense. Lloyd, do you have the counts on what the lawsuits were?
SPEAKER_07Well, yeah, I can talk about the legal prison.
SPEAKER_09Yeah, I can tell you what the court uh considered. Okay. Um, first of all, he sues for what? He's suing like he said, defamation for defamation, and then use of likeness because their likenesses were used in the pursuit of making money. Yeah. So did the pound cake company sue? I don't know anything about that. All I know is so it came down to those two things. Um, you know, whether or not that that he had a First Amendment right to use their likenesses in the way that he used them. With his videotapes. Right. These were all off his videotapes.
SPEAKER_09Right. Well, I believe there was might have been a public record footage too that was adopted into his videos, but I'm not sure about that. But I mean, most of the people body cam footage. Well, either way, it would have been the same thing because they're police officers, they're on the job, so it they're it's a public job. Right. Um, they have no expectation of privacy while on the job, in uniform, and in conducting government business. So that was, you know, that was the issue with respect to the right of privacy, um, and that the videos, the, you know, his videos are his own private videos and the body cam videos are public record.
SPEAKER_09Right. But then it came down to so so, in other words, they have no official uh no privacy rights while on duty and in their official capacity. Where it turned, though, was the fact that in his favor was and this I was surprised, not that had he used straight video or just their likenesses alone, they may have had a claim, which I found very interesting. And what the court uh turned on in dismissing this entire lawsuit was um that he actually there's a transformative test that he took the videos and he he manipulated them, he cut them up and made art out of them.
SPEAKER_09So therefore he had a First Amendment right because he included their likenesses in a greater narrative. So he had a First Amendment right to create art. Wow, you you know, and disseminating that as a narrative. And then their their counter-argument was, yeah, but the minute that he started monetizing it, now he's making money off our likeness. And the court said, No, just because you monetize your art doesn't mean that you don't have the First Amendment right to continue to do it.
SPEAKER_07So he he he won everything. But that seems like a pushback could be given pretty hard. Yeah, you're like, yeah, but still, because you you're still naming likeness, right? It is public record, but now you're altering the public record. But I I don't know. I don't know. What are your thoughts on that?
SPEAKER_00I don't know. I mean, there is some stuff in there. I mean, like Officer Pound Cake, I found that hilarious. Um all of it's hilarious, yeah. And I there there are some things. I'm talking about legally I just from a legal perspective, I think he was I thought he was in the clear the whole time. Um, but like on man law, there are a couple lines he crossed. But we're not talking about man law.
SPEAKER_07I'm talking about real law, okay? Man law is real. Well, this West Virginia analysis has to go away. I want man law, not man law. Now you got me saying man law. I want regular law analysis. Yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_00I I I always thought he was in the clear. You know, when you have that um Falwell versus uh Hustler Publishing, where the Kampariad, where uh Larry Flint uh was talking about Jerry Falwell and how the first time Jerry Falwell had sex was was his mother in an outhouse. Right. I remember this. They made a movie about that, US versus Larry Flint. And so uh, you know, it's a parody, and parody is protected.
SPEAKER_00Right, right, right. So, you know, this case, I mean, it it seemed pretty clear-cut to me. I don't know how it got past summary judgment. That's what my question is. How come they didn't get this thing kicked out quick? You know, I don't know how it got past summary judgment, but it went all the way to the jury.
SPEAKER_07I bet you, I bet you Afro Man was like, let it ride. Yeah, let it ride.
SPEAKER_09Yeah, no, well, right. I guess he could have settled, but they sued him for millions of dollars and he didn't do anything wrong.
SPEAKER_07Yeah, or do you file a motion dismiss, or if you have an attorney that says, I'm gonna kick the shit out of this case, but let's let it ride a little bit, get the publicity. I don't know. You can't buy this type of publicity. This is amazing. I don't know who Afro Man is. I know that song, but I don't know who didn't even know the song, so to me, now I know who it is.
SPEAKER_09I only was interested in the legality of it. I don't know the facts of these people.
SPEAKER_07Dan, is there any other photos we didn't take get to on those? There was one more, I think.
SPEAKER_00Oh, the the I think the parody of okay, so you would think that's that's the real one. That's the rule of Phillips. The no the other one is the parody. And if you look at it, they the first one was the deposition, and it's filled, it's in the same room that he has the parody chick in. So he used the same room for the deposition as he used to be. So he made a movie or in a video, in a video, okay. So here's the thing you would think that, like, if we're representing somebody So this is the fake lickem low.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, okay. If we're going ahead and we're representing somebody and we're coming up on trial for something like this, you're gonna tell your client, you know, kind of lay low, don't don't make waves right before the trial. Right, hell no. The Afro Man goes all in like the last the the last week before trial. He comes up with this video uh called Lickum Lo Lisa, all right, and he has the the fake Lisa Phillips in there, and it it it is not a PG-rated video.
SPEAKER_00Oh my god, he's got her doing exactly what you think he she would be doing, all right, with a stripper, and then at the end of it, he's like, I'm sorry, Lisa, I didn't know I hurt you so bad. And then Afroman goes back to his house with the fake and is like having sex with her, and they're blurring out everything with marijuana leaves.
SPEAKER_07When did this go viral? This last week and why now because the trial ended, yeah. Uh Joseph Edgerson.
SPEAKER_00I mean, so like he you would think that like going into trial, you'd be like a little bit more restrained and calm, but not Afro Man.
SPEAKER_07Yeah, can you share the security video real quick, Dan? That's another one, right?
SPEAKER_09Here's Billboard magazine's uh uh headline. Afroman's catalog rises over 500% following legal victory. So, yes, it pays to go to track.
SPEAKER_07Like the Johnny Depp, like the Johnny Depp. First of all, here's a surveillance uh photo of them in his house. That's his house? Yeah, it's like a little dinky kitchen, though. I would think he had some big kitchen.
SPEAKER_08No, he he has it's a big house, but it's just a little dinky kitchen. Oh, maybe that's just some big dudes. Maybe pound cake's a big guy. Yeah, and now you see the pound cake.
SPEAKER_05I see the pound cake. The pound cakes get way more play than that.
SPEAKER_00You've got you got Officer Pound Cake all the way on the right.
SPEAKER_09Oh, poor guy.
SPEAKER_08This guy's got a career ahead of him.
SPEAKER_09No, he went home and got pound cake that day.
SPEAKER_07Yeah, he definitely did. He's got 900 deliveries of pound cake. He's probably got steady Amazon shipment to pound cake to the department.
SPEAKER_00Officer pound cake was saying that you know the stress created by this whole situation contributed to his marriage falling apart. No. So Afro Man calls his ex-wife to testify. And she's like, no, it didn't have anything to do with it.
SPEAKER_08If anything, it made him cooler, you know?
SPEAKER_07And it just made me get a lot of pound cakes in the divorce, you know.
SPEAKER_00It's like these these trials you can work in here.
SPEAKER_07I mean, look at Johnny Depp. Johnny Depp was like dead in the water when all that shit came out on him, right? Yes. And he fucking decides to go public with that trial. I thought that was suicide. But it was a stroke of genius. He's back in Disney movies, he's so good at it.
SPEAKER_08He was so good on the stand. So good.
SPEAKER_07The megapint is still one of the greatest moments in any trial history. It really is. He goes, Did you go home and have a mega pint? He goes, a megapint. He goes, Yeah, I had some beer. He goes, uh wine, a megapint of wine. He goes, Yeah, I had a glass of wine. He goes, it was a large glass. And then he felt it necessary.
SPEAKER_00It was required.
SPEAKER_07It was required.
SPEAKER_00That was awesome. What about when uh he was talking about how Amber Heard took a dump on his oh my god, that's one of my favorite things.
SPEAKER_09And he was like, You might be right. It might be I felt it necessary.
SPEAKER_08Yeah, yeah, that's what it was.
SPEAKER_00The fecal deposit.
SPEAKER_08Was that his word?
SPEAKER_07He was genius in that trial. And he lit, and that that poor guy, the poor prosecutor, or not prosecutor, the plaintiff's attorney. Oh my god. Oh, he was bad. He was he got railed up there.
SPEAKER_00He asked the question, and then Johnny Depp answers that he's like, objection, Your Honor. Here's that. She's like, You asked the question.
SPEAKER_08He objected to so much shit.
SPEAKER_09Yeah, no, so those things here really were. How did she ever think that was gonna work out? That the fecal deposit moment was ever gonna work out well for her. I don't think she wanted to be in the trial. He was the one that pushed her. No, but in the moment that she was doing that, how did she ever think that was gonna work out well for her? Uh it's drugs.
SPEAKER_00Um it has to be because I mean you you do some stupid shit when you take drugs. No pun in there. You're like, this is a good idea. Yeah, no pun.
SPEAKER_05This is a good idea.
SPEAKER_00You know, you'll sit there and you'll be like, This is a good now. I've never taken a crap on anybody's bed, but you know, I've been there and be like, this is a good idea.
SPEAKER_07I've never even thought it was a good idea. Maybe after a megapint, right? Yeah, you don't know what kind of judgment you do. Yeah, that was funny. But no, but that we'll watch how that develops. But on in another in another thing that's going on now, you guys have shown you that Lion King incident, right? Uh, where this comedian comes out. We're gonna play the video for you one second here. The video comes out of a of a comedian, and his name is he's gone viral now. Um, the comedian's name is Learn More Jonasi.
SPEAKER_07He's facing a$27 million lawsuit. We're gonna show the clip. Dan, play the clip of what this is all about. This is just a podcast appearance that he made. Go ahead, Dan.
SPEAKER_04I can do it. Do it. So let's sing it like what does it mean?
SPEAKER_03It means look, there's a lion. Oh my god. You're joking. That is not what that means. That is not what that means. That's exactly what it means. It means look, there's a lion. Oh my god.
SPEAKER_04Look, there's a lion! Oh my god, there's a lion.
SPEAKER_09So it doesn't mean his voice just sounds like a character.
SPEAKER_07So he's a so that guy is a comedian. He's a big African comedian, he's a Kenyan guy. He's hysterical, too. But I guess it's his podcast. So I saw that going around the other day, and I thought it was hysterical. I said it to everybody. Yeah, because it's ridiculous. Turns out he gets sued now. He got sued by uh Um, Libo Moraki, who's the Grammy winning South African composer behind the iconic opening channel Lion King Circle of Life. Cause of the loss to the legal battle stems from the viral 32nd Cliff, where he says, Look, there's a lion.
SPEAKER_07Oh my God. Libo's perspective is that that's completely fabricated, trivializing distortion of a serious Zulu royal praise poem that actually means, quote, all hail the king, we all bow in the presence of the king. He claims the joke mocks his 30-year-old legacy and misrepresents the cultural significance of the work and disrupts his business relationships with Disney. Claim damages,$20 million in actual damages,$7 million in punitive, accusing Janasi of defamation, trade libel, misrepresentation.
SPEAKER_07Your thoughts go, Mike, first. Uh defamation, never heard of him before. Oh, him. Yeah. Well, it doesn't mean you have to hear of him. That's not part of the defamation analysis. Uh how how does that it's damaged to reputation? How's that damage to reputation? Well, if he's in contracts, I'm just playing back. If he's got contracts with Disney and they see that and they believe that they built this whole legacy on that ridiculous fucking line, right? And he lied to them about it, it could cause a strain, you know, and maybe there's some because Africa has 57 dialects there too.
SPEAKER_07So maybe one dialect does say that. I don't know.
SPEAKER_00Well, I mean, the thing is it could have harmed if he could show it harmed his relationship. If he can show it harmed his relationship, and Disney would have a corporate representative say, look, we were gonna hire him again to do this, but he but we found out how stupid that song was. Um you know, and we're not gonna use him anymore, then he might have something. But I mean I just don't just just for getting out there and saying it and making a joke out of it, it you'd have a hard time showing damages.
SPEAKER_07And where do you think he gets to 20 million dollar? I mean, my the only thought when I hear that big number is either the guy's an idiot or the guy's in talks for a huge contract that he lost. You know what I mean?
SPEAKER_09Well, if you throw something at the wall to see what sticks. 20 million dollars? 20 million, walk away with two million to see.
SPEAKER_07Well, he's saying 20 million in actual damages, not even punitive.
SPEAKER_09Interesting.
SPEAKER_07That makes me think that he lost the contract, the guy maybe. I don't know. So actual damage to listening viewers means something that I can literally show you by numbers, a contract I lost. This is what I was supposed to get, now I don't have it. Or this is what I had, now I lost it. Punitive damage is a speculative thing, and more of a we need to punish. The court wants to just punish you and deter you from doing that behavior again, and you could get crazy numbers on on that. There's no cap or limit where actual is quantified. It's like dollar for dollar, you could show it.
SPEAKER_07So they're saying 20 million actual damage is not just punishment. So he must have had some in the works, and I don't know. And even if the lyrics aren't fake, it could be that Disney's like, look, we just we can't do it. We can't even do deals with you, dude. This is too much blowback, right?
SPEAKER_09But I don't but that wouldn't that assume that we all knew what the what the words meant anyway in the first place? You know, what the real lyrics meant. Does anybody did anybody else know that?
SPEAKER_07Well, when you grow up thinking that's some ceremonial deep words, and it's Luke, there's a lion.
SPEAKER_09Oh my god. Can you play it one more time? Sorry, play it one more time and then becomes, you know, did he really know that? Was he joking?
SPEAKER_03What is the name? Luke! There's a lion. Oh my god.
SPEAKER_09Yeah, but it's it's fucking hilarious. Now who is he? Is he a is he another?
SPEAKER_07So he's a big comedian. He's a comedian. Yes, so that's right. That's another thing. He's a comedian. It's a joke.
SPEAKER_09So right again, parody.
SPEAKER_07So there's the question. So if I get up, how many comedians get up and joke about everything? Of course. It's protected. At some point, you're protected. You're not really damaging. Does that mean that if I get up? Chris Rock gets up and makes a joke about whatever. Betty Vetter, a Pearl Jam song where Nicholas is going to get sued, right?
SPEAKER_09Like, does that mean you can, you know, get sued if you misrepresent the lyrics to a Pearl Jam song? We've all done it. Right. All right. So we all agree that that's not really going anywhere.
SPEAKER_07Now, as far as the intellectual property. Well, that I don't I don't know the law there.
SPEAKER_09That would have to be where his complaint might lie.
SPEAKER_07Well, to sue for copyright, if you're using it to monetize, but he said a funny joke about something that went viral on its own. He's not making it go viral. He hasn't made he hasn't called himself the Lying King comedian, right? I think when it gets to a point where you're using the name and likeness, he hasn't accused uh the composer of the thing. Nobody even knows this guy. Who the hell knows this guy's name? I had to look it up, you know.
SPEAKER_00Well, you know what? I mean, there there is something again, copyright's not my thing. I mean there's something called fair use, right? Where you know you're allowed to use other people's material for certain certain aspects. So I just I just don't see how I mean if if you could go ahead and sue somebody for making a joke about your song, I mean, God, I mean, a lot of people would be getting sued. Like, I mean, how I mean, how many times is like baby got back referenced and you know, on the computer?
SPEAKER_00Like, you know, it's like I I like big butts and I cannot, and then you you try to hit the button that says lie, yeah, yeah. And it just keeps going all over the place.
SPEAKER_07No, I think that um what people don't understand is you could sue for anything. Yeah, for anyone, right? But can you win in a case like that? Is the question. And then trade libel and misrepresentation. Misrepresentation's interesting, but even then it's a joke. It's a joke, yeah. Like, what like what are the elements misrepresentation? Misrepresentation is more used to induce you into some kind of an agreement with me, right?
SPEAKER_00As opposed to I think of it, it's like fraud and the inducement.
SPEAKER_07Yeah, fraud and inducement or misrepresentation on on contract talks or whatever that may be. But I just don't see that going around.
SPEAKER_09Yeah, the guy told a joke.
SPEAKER_07There's there's it's a hilarious joke, too. And I think you know that But I'm not, but it's not even really argued. I don't know that it's what he's saying is even true. Well, he's saying it's a joke. So he came out and said that I made a joke. So that's not what the lyrics mean?
SPEAKER_09Well, he said he made a joke. If it will it wouldn't have been a joke if if if he was insisting that that's what the lyrics were.
SPEAKER_07Well, that's still a bit dicey here, because you're just lying about what the translation is, you know.
SPEAKER_09I think it's I think it's still going nowhere.
SPEAKER_07Yeah.
SPEAKER_09I think it's an Afro in the Afroman's case.
SPEAKER_07But what's crazy is that it gets the headlines, you know, it get it gets publicity, the composer's name's out there now, and he's put out and he's might and he's successful in combating it now. Whereas if that joke would have just lied forever, we would have gone around saying that that's the lyrics of that song. That's true. And now we're not so sure that's a lyrics. It sounds like it's more the Hail the King thing, right?
SPEAKER_06Well, you know what?
SPEAKER_00Here's also the other thing the guy might not even be actually suing him for the purpose of trying to collect money. Like we were talking about with Afro. Maybe when you buy that psychopath publicity. So if he's getting paid by streaming services, and you're gonna have people sitting there trying to figure out which is you know, going back and forth, you know, he could pull up a lot more streams and make 12 more cents from Spotify by just going ahead and uh keeping the keeping the publicity surrounding this going.
SPEAKER_00Right, right.
SPEAKER_09So just a quick little Google search, you know, about what the legal arguments were um that his claim constitutes a fabricated trivializing distortion. I don't know if that's a a cause of action. Uh something called the Latham Act. The suit alleges that Jonassi violated the Lanham Act by misrepresenting the nature and cultural significance of the composition to his audience.
SPEAKER_09Who the hell is he? He's a comedian. Weird. The complaint asserts that Jonassi's exaggerated imitations, quote unquote, and quote unquote false statements of fact have damaged Libo M's reputation and jeopardized his economic relationship. You said that with Disney. 20 million in actual seven million in punitives. And let's see. That he put because he presented it as an authoritative fact, right, not comedy during the podcast, uh, the comments should not be protected by the First Amendment regarding parody or satire.
SPEAKER_09So we'll see. I wonder if it got by summary judgment. We should take a look.
SPEAKER_07But you know what? This brings up a big issue that I didn't even think about until now. These podcasts, and we do it here with our political arguing and we do it with our legal arguing, and these people that are otherwise not very known people now are on podcasts. Yeah, they're like us, we're not known celebrities, right? Right, right. Oh, well, you know. Right, exactly. But I'm saying we're we're known in our community, we're known in our communities, right? But like we come on here, but we're clear to say I'm not an authority on things, right? We're giving you our opinions.
SPEAKER_07But a lot of these big people on the big, they're not big people, they're shitheads, but they're on these big podcasts, they're putting themselves out, and people take it as authority. So where is the line drawn here? There's a freedom of speech, but then if you're holding yourself out as an authority, is there some kind or should there be some kind of safeguards? This guy comes out, he he he he shows that he understands the language, he says it in the perfect accent, he says the lyrics, so he looks to you like an authority, right? He's like, oh, this guy knows what this means, and then he comes out saying I'm a comedian.
SPEAKER_07It's the same thing that the shithead Dave Smith and those guys, they hide behind the cloak. No, I'm very well learned on the Middle East, so I'm very learned on this. And then whenever you attack them for making up shit, well, I'm just a comedian, right? Right? They're playing a double thing. So how do you push back on these fuckers if you don't sue? I kind of think suing, I I'm not so against it.
SPEAKER_09Yeah, I mean, if it's a misrepresentation of fact, I think that that that is a cause of action.
SPEAKER_07It is, it should be a cause of action. Like you just lied about, you know, it's a big song for people. It's part of the it's pop culture, it's part of the culture of the uh of our culture is the Lion King in that song. Everybody knows it.
SPEAKER_09I think that that may be that from what it says is they're still in the filing stages, he's raising money for his defense. Right. Um, so there's been no, it doesn't even look like there's been a response filed. So they're not at summary judgment uh stage yet. But I wouldn't be surprised if they would get by summary judgment on that issue, because I think the matter of fact for a jury to decide would be whether or not he was passing that off as fact or as a as a joke. Right. So and then that brings into all another issue is you know, is it incumbent upon us to watch the whole video, to watch the whole reel, to get all the information?
SPEAKER_09There is a lot of interesting issues that are uh coming, you know, about now from the legal perspective in terms of the technology and what's happening.
SPEAKER_07It's cool. But there is also a backdrop I think that's important too. So those guys are comedians on a comedian podcast. Yes, that's a little different. I think that they should have a little bit more leeway than a Dave Smith. And I keep naming him because I hate this fucking guy. He's a failed comedian that goes on like political talks, and he goes on like Pierce Morgan, he goes on like these bigger podcasts that are like having serious. Sometimes they have like a former prime minister or whatever, and then they have Dave Smith. And I was like, Who the fuck is this guy?
SPEAKER_07And he's this failed comedian that nobody you don't know him, but he did tries to debate, he thinks he's this amazing debate. I'll talk circles around you, dude.
SPEAKER_09And he was a very he he took a very unique position, uh, anti-semitism.
SPEAKER_07So yeah, he's he's a Jewish guy that I'm a Jew against Jews, pretty much, right?
SPEAKER_09And his claim to fame is is who pushed him? Was it was it Rogan? Who pushed him?
SPEAKER_07Oh no, Doug Murray, real bad.
SPEAKER_09Doug Murray pushed him. Uh uh, but you know, you you you pass yourself off as a an expert on the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, and he he basically acknowledged that. And then he says, Have you ever been to Israel? And he's like, No.
SPEAKER_07But he holds but he goes on as an expert, right? And he holds so but it's different. But then if if like everybody gets riled up about it, he's like, I'm just a comedian, I'm giving my opinions. Now he's just a comedian giving his opinion. So I think that if you're on a serious, if you're holding yourself out as an expert, I think you should be under a different standard than if you're sitting and talking shit with other comedians on a comedian podcast. We agree, yes, right? So what do you think of that?
SPEAKER_00I think you are held to a different standard.
SPEAKER_07You're not right now. Everybody's held to the same standard. I can go out this podcast, this isn't real media. You're not calling yourself an expert, you're just pretending like you're an expert, right? How are they held to a different standard?
SPEAKER_00Well, I I think I mean, because it's not satire, it's not humor. And if you if you're presenting things as fact, that that's different than satire, humor, and opinion. So if you're if you're, you know, but just by going ahead and saying, Well, I'm a comedian, doesn't mean that you are, you know. I mean, it's you'd have to look at the substance over the context of circumstances. Right.
SPEAKER_07But like in court, when we have to qualify an expert, yeah. I think low bar you should, but still, you have to think you should at least have to do that prior to giving if you want the protections or or you want if you know what I mean, if you're saying as an expert, you're saying you're an expert, you're holding a cell, you should be qualified. I think the podcasters should qualify their people, you know. Yeah, what's your expertise in this? Oh, I just you know, I like it. You know, okay. Well, this guy's just giving an opinion now. You know what I mean? It's not even admissible.
SPEAKER_00If I were gonna get into something really touchy, I'd always start off with, this is my opinion and my opinion only. Right. Uh you know, I wouldn't I wouldn't even go into you know, I I think in this video there's a lot of defenses.
SPEAKER_09I mean, it's show business too. How about that argument that hey, it's a show, right? There's even in this show, there's still uh a you know, a sense of show business where we're you know we're performing. And I think that that applies in those cases, you know, especially we all laughed, you know, which was the purpose there. Now we didn't necessarily laugh until the other guy sang the song. Yeah, it was funny. But can't our defendant in this case claim that the whole thing was an act?
SPEAKER_07Right. And it's interesting though, in defamation, truth is a defense, right? For sure. He doesn't claim truth, he's not claiming truth, and that could have been one of the reasons why he filed the lawsuit because he knows this guy can't say it's true. He's lying. Let me expose him to be a liar. Right. And then solves my problem. Yeah, I make up a number at 20 million, you know.
SPEAKER_00Or uh defamation, truth's not always uh an absolute defense. Not absolute, because you've got but it's a defense. Yeah, there's a uh but look, if you look at defamation, it's uh those are usually state law claims, and so Florida has it has to have a proper purpose, all right. So even if it's true, if it had an improper purpose, it's still defamation. Interesting, right?
SPEAKER_07Okay, I get what you're saying.
SPEAKER_09Yeah, but that's all analysis. I would have to read that case law.
SPEAKER_07Yeah. But I mean, what's a proper, you know, what's improper? That's the analysis you have to do now, right?
SPEAKER_09Right. Last thing ruin your reputation by telling the truth about you?
SPEAKER_07Yeah, I don't know. That's that that's open to Yeah, that's a hard one, but last few minutes on uh just the current topic, this unresolved. Anybody hear anything about Guthrie? No, she went on TV yesterday. I think she went on. Didn't say find a body? I don't know. No, there's no body, and what she came out saying was she thinks that my her mom was targeted because of her money. Because of her fame.
SPEAKER_09I don't know. The whole thing still looks I'm I'm gonna get it. I still don't know who says it just seems so performative. I don't know, man. I got a weird gut. Really? It just bothers me. Like she gets on TV and she says, If you know, this could be my fault because uh I have money, and maybe they targeted if we meant money, and if that's it, I'm so sorry. I'm so sorry. Like, unless it's weird.
SPEAKER_07What's the point of doing that in the public like that? I don't understand that either.
unknownI don't know.
SPEAKER_07Why would you want to do an interview like that? I don't know.
SPEAKER_09I tell you, I look at it and I'm just something doesn't add up. It's just a gut. I could be completely wrong.
SPEAKER_07But this girl's got like all she's so huge anyway, she doesn't need this publicity.
SPEAKER_09It's weird.
SPEAKER_07It is weird. I don't know what it is, but it is weird.
SPEAKER_09But apparently the I'm not ready, yeah.
SPEAKER_07I'm not ready to like accuse her of anything.
SPEAKER_09Yeah, they're all officially cleared, and I just in my eye had a weird feeling when I watched it. I'm like, it just seems so odd.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, you have any thoughts?
SPEAKER_09Some people are just weird, yes, of course.
SPEAKER_07Yeah, yeah. Any any do you have any thoughts or anything? I I heard that there was a body that was found.
SPEAKER_00Aliens, but they didn't know.
SPEAKER_07Oh no, they found a body, but it wasn't hers.
SPEAKER_00Okay.
SPEAKER_07We know that that broke like a little a couple not long ago, and then uh they immediately came out saying it wasn't hers. We just found a random body in the desert.
SPEAKER_09Still probably don't have time to talk about Sheridan Gorman.
SPEAKER_07What is it? Tell me.
SPEAKER_09Sheridan Gorman was the 18-year-old college student who was executed the other day by an illegal immigrant from Venezuela who, according to one local alderman, I think in Chicago, was she must have just been in the wrong place at the wrong time and startled the gunman who shot her in the back as she was running away. Where is this story?
SPEAKER_07In Chicago, you said?
SPEAKER_09No. Yes. Um Loyola?
SPEAKER_07Where's that? In Loyola at school?
SPEAKER_09Is that Chicago or is that New Orleans? Louisiana.
SPEAKER_07Loyola, I think, is in Maryland. I don't even know. I don't remember. I don't want to. Look, there's Loyola, Maryland, there's Loyola Maryland.
SPEAKER_09Okay, there were so many stories I don't want to say where it was. Huh? I don't remember. There was there's so many stories I read lately. I don't know which where this one was. Yeah. What made what made it horrible was like I said, that local politician came out and said that, you know, she was in the wrong place at the wrong time, that she might have startled the poor gunman. And the gunman was what, an immigrant? Uh yes, uh a person who was here, an undocumented uh young man from Venezuela uh who was carrying a gun and had been released um as a result of the sanctuary sanctuary city policies after being um arrested for shoplifting, and he was he had already overstayed his welcome.
SPEAKER_09And uh instead of deporting him, he they let him go.
SPEAKER_07Again, the issue there, and people are gonna say that like oh, you leave the immigrants. Nobody has a problem with immigrants, it's the bad guys. We're all immigrants, it's people that are here undocumented and that are causing problems, and the fact that it's not Chicago, it's not being differentiated, or there's no help coming from the local community with the federal government trying to round up the right people. And and you're having to do this wide sweeping stuff that's getting people caught in the middle, and then they're all surprised it's happening.
SPEAKER_09The argument is that narrow, right? You know, that when they're already in the jails because they've been arrested for a local offense, right? You you you know, and they have a detainer or they have a uh a deportation order, those people should be deported.
SPEAKER_07Just honor them. That's it. Honor that, and that's it, and the problem will be solved. Solved. We're not seeing any of these things in Florida. Texas. That's what's happening.
SPEAKER_09You know, we're not seeing in Florida, we're not seeing in Texas, you're not seeing in fucking Alabama because the people that should be getting deported are getting detained.
SPEAKER_00Well, it's also in states like Florida, you know, you don't see a lot of the bullshit that you see in like uh Washington and California. You don't see Antifa running around in Florida because we have to-cause they don't need to. Well, we have a high concealed K, right? Oh, yeah. So, I mean, if they go ahead and swing a lock and a sock at somebody, there's a good chance that they're gonna get swiss cheesed up.
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_09Well, there's not an environment in Florida of acceptance of the kind of behavior. That's why.
SPEAKER_07Well, they don't understand the conservative, you know. That's why all the notoriously law enforcement, the judiciary, it's usually conservative, right? Because that's where the safety is gonna come from, right? Laws. Yeah, laws are what keep us from you know from being, you know, wild environment. Like I just came back from El Salvador and like Bukele went down there. And I'm telling you, I used to go to El Salvador for 25 years. I've been going to El Salvador, and you could not walk around down in Salvador. It's different now. The last four years, yeah, whatever he did, he arrested anyone under age of whatever.
SPEAKER_07If you have ink on your face, you're sitting in Sikut. That like fucking, have you seen that? That prison he built. Yeah. But let me tell you something, you're walking around safe in El Salvador now. You know, yeah.
SPEAKER_09You know, my my brother's wife is from El Salvador, her whole family, obviously. And she has mixed emotions. She said, Because my wife's family. Same way. It's in other words, okay, now we have law and order and safety, but who's getting caught up in this net? And apparently, they my my sister-in-law, anyway, is of the opinion that a lot of innocent people are getting caught up in that net.
SPEAKER_07Well, a lot of people did.
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_07The funny thing is they came out and said, Yeah, we you know, it was a big sweep, okay, and they're releasing a lot. Okay. But the ones that they got in Sikut, yeah. You'll take a look at these guys, okay? They got ink all over their face and their tongues, like they're Salvatucia. They're MS-13. Like, there's no. And if not, you just got bad taste and you got wrapped up in the wrong thing. It's like if I got a tattoo of a swastika on my forehead, you belong to it. I'm not a Nazi. Like, well, don't get a fucking swastika on your fucking forehead, right? Yeah. Yeah.
SPEAKER_07There's a comment coming sometime soon, is there? No. Okay, good. All right. Well, not to judge every tattoo uh wearer by the same swastika. I knew him 30 years. Yeah, that's fine. All right. Anyone else with a parting thought?
unknownNo.
SPEAKER_07All right. We'll have you guys back on. I'm looking forward to it. And that's it. We'll be covering everything. And ladies and gentlemen, viewers and uh watch uh viewers and listeners, we'll be covering everything. Try to keep it to the minute as much as we can. But uh thank you all for watching and listening. Uh please like and subscribe to the channel. Like I say, we can keep doing these debates and have these panels on and have these guests come on. Uh, the outreach you give us with the likes and subscriptions, it helps a lot. Um, uh, we're everywhere. We're on Instagram, we're on YouTube, we're on Facebook. Our marketing team does a great job, our recording team does a great job.
SPEAKER_07Everybody here does a great job. We love you all. We look forward to next time. Thank you for watching. Thanks for listening. Love you all. See you next time. Goodbye.
Send us Fan Mail Daniel Rosenberg sits down with criminal defense attorney Michael Dye to break down major legal shifts surrounding gun rights, the Second Amendment, and federal court rulings. From the DOJ's memo on...
Send us Fan Mail In this episode of Two Taps & Friends, Danny sits down with fan-favorite guest Olivia to tackle listener questions about growing up today versus 30 years ago. From social media pressures and AI in...
Send us Fan Mail A 16-year-old walked into Silver Rail Elementary School in Bend, Oregon with a shotgun, and an armed civilian and a brave teacher stopped it from becoming even worse. Host Danny Rosenberg and attorney...
Send us Fan Mail In this episode of Two Taps & Friends, host Daniel Rosenberg is joined once again by criminal defense attorney Michael Dye to break down major new developments in the Cornell University fraternity case....
Send us Fan Mail In this episode of Two Taps & Friends, Daniel Rosenberg is joined once again by attorney Michael Dye to break down the legal scrutiny and federal investigations surrounding Rep. Ilhan Omar - examining...